determining appropriate locations for potential nursing homes … · 2017. 6. 26. · to determine...

1
Each year, the population of the state of Maine grows older as the baby boomer generation reaches retirement age. Based on U.S. Census Bureau figures, Maine is the oldest state based on median age (43.5 years) and the second-oldest based on the proportion of people aged 65 and older (17 percent)(Graham 2015). It is projected that 25 percent of Mainers will be over the age of 65 by 2030. This rise in the age of the population will require serious efforts to accommodate more seniors in nursing homes across the state. This project presents one model that considers three fac- tors to help determine the most appropriate locations for new nursing homes across the state: 1) proximity to established nursing homes; 2) proximity to hospitals; and 3) proximity to seniors who live alone. A sec- ond model includes an additional factor: proximity to areas with higher rates of poverty among seniors. Pop- ulation density in the surrounding area will be calculated first to deter- mine the areas under consideration (the areas with the lowest population densities will not be considered). To determine potential nursing home locations, this project utilizes the following data. Population density of Maine by block (2010) to rule out areas in the state with extremely low population density as potential locations for new nurs- ing homes. Locations of current nursing homes (2013) to place greater weight on lo- cations that currently do not have easy access to nursing homes. Locations of hospitals (2016) to place greater weight on locations in the proximity of hospitals to allow hospitals more efficient discharge of pa- tients who need long-term care. Populations of people 65 years and older who live alone by block group (2014) to place greater weight on areas where more elderly people live alone, as they are more likely to need nursing home care than those who live with family members. Populations of people 65 years and older who live under the poverty line by block group (2014) (secondary model) to place greater weight on areas where more of elderly people live under the poverty line, as they are often more likely to be denied access to nursing home care due to an inability to pay or a reliance on Maine Care. A series of models transformed each of these datasets into raster layers in ArcMap. Each of these layers were then combined to give recommenda- tions for the placement of future nursing homes. The portions of the state where the population density is greater than .001 residents per hectare were selected and used to create a new layer. The Polygon to Rastertool was used to transform this layer into a raster, and the Reclassifytool was used to give this area full weight in the final models. The Euclidean Distancetool was used to create raster layers around the preexisting nursing homes and the hospitals. These layers were then re- classified into four classes to give greater weight to locations near hospi- tals and to locations further from nursing homes. The Polygon to Rastertool transformed block groups with data concerning the senior population that lives alone and the data concerning the senior population living under the poverty line into raster layers. The Reclassifytool gave higher weights to the block groups that contained more seniors in each of these categories. Finally, the Raster Calculatortool combined the previous layers into the final two models, which consider the weights of each loca- tion within the study area based on the four factors (or three for Model 1). Model 1, which includes data concerning locations of preexisting nursing homes, hospitals, and the 65 and older population who lives alone in the study area, suggests two locations for a new nursing home, with many others that could be appropriate. The following chart provides context for making a final decision: Model 2, which includes the same data as Model 1 with the addition of data concerning the 65 and older population that lives under the poverty level, suggests a number of locations that could be appropriate for a new nursing home. The following chart provides context for two of the loca- tions with the most potential: These two models provide a starting point for selecting locations for fu- ture nursing homes in Maine. The variables that are included are im- portant factors for determining where a new nursing home would be in high demand, but there are several other considerations to be made. Some of these include the following: the availability of real estate to house a nursing home, the potential funding from private or government sources, the desirability of locations for senior populations, the availability of staff or potential for recruitment to the area, etc. Introduction Data and Methodology Results, Analysis, Limitations Future Use Sources Determining Appropriate Locations for Potential Nursing Homes in Maine Allison Brown, NUTR 231: Fundamentals of GIS, Fall 2016 Location Nearest Preexist- ing Nursing Home Population (including 3 nearest towns) (US 2010 Census) Calais 44.3 km (Eastport Memorial Nursing Home) 4,186 (Calais, Robbin- ston, Charlotte, Med- dybemps) Fort Fairfield 30.9 km (Aroostook Health Center) 23,691 (Fort Fairfield, Presque Isle, Caribou, Limestone) Top: Downtown Calais, ME Bottom: Downtown Fort Fairfield, ME Source: Google Street View, accessed 21 December 2016. Location Nearest Preexisting Nursing Home Population (including 3 nearest towns) (US 2010 Census) Etna 33.3 km (Bangor Nursing and Rehabili- tation Center) 8,695 (Etna, Newport, Carmel, Plymouth) Warren 15.61 km (Knox Cen- ter for Long Term Care) 14,141 (Warren, Waldoboro, Thomas- ton, Cushing) Top: Downtown Etna, ME Bottom: Downtown Warren, ME Source: Google Street View, accessed 21 December 2016. Population per Hectare by Block > .001 Census of Population and Housing – Blocks 2010, US Census Bureau, http://www.census.gov/data.html, accessed 11 November 2016. Nursing Homes, 2 August 2013, MEGIS, http://www.maine.gov/megis/catalog/metadata/nursing_homes.html, accessed 11 November 2016. Hospitals, 6 May 2016, MEGIS, http://www.maine.gov/megis/catalog/metadata/hospitals.html, accessed 11 November 2016. ACS Block Group 5-Year Estimates, 2010-2014, Relationship by Household Type (Including Living Alone) for the Population 65 Years and Over, US Census Bu- reau, http://factfinder.census.gov/faces/tableservices/jsf/pages/productview.xhtml?pid=ACS_15_5YR_B09020&prodType=table, accessed 14 November 2016. ACS Block Group 5-Year Estimates, 2010-2014, Poverty Status in the Past 12 Months by Household Type by Age of Householder, http://factfinder.census.gov/ faces/tableservices/jsf/pages/productview.xhtml?pid=ACS_14_5YR_B17017&prodType=table, accessed 14 November 2016. Graham, Gillian, "Maine Summit on Aging tackles issues facing state as population ages," Maine Center for Economic Policy, 15 September 2015, http:// www.mecep.org/maine-summit-on-aging-tackles-issues-facing-state-as-population-ages/, accessed November 17, 2016. Photos: Pixabay, https://pixabay.com/p-1095124/?no_redirect, accessed 21 December 2016; Street View, Map Data: Google 2016, accessed 21 December 2016. Projection: Maine East State Plane Projection

Upload: others

Post on 20-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Determining Appropriate Locations for Potential Nursing Homes … · 2017. 6. 26. · To determine potential nursing home locations, this project utilizes the following data. Population

Each year, the population of the state of Maine grows older as the baby

boomer generation reaches retirement age. Based on U.S. Census Bureau

figures, “Maine is the oldest state based on median age (43.5 years) and

the second-oldest based on the proportion of people aged 65 and older (17

percent)” (Graham 2015). It is projected that 25 percent of Mainers will

be over the age of 65 by 2030. This rise in the age of the population will

require serious efforts to accommodate more seniors in nursing homes

across the state. This project presents one model that considers three fac-

tors to help determine the most appropriate locations for new nursing

homes across the state: 1) proximity to established nursing homes; 2)

proximity to hospitals; and 3) proximity to seniors who live alone. A sec-

ond model includes an additional factor: proximity to areas with higher

rates of poverty among seniors. Pop-

ulation density in the surrounding

area will be calculated first to deter-

mine the areas under consideration

(the areas with the lowest population

densities will not be considered).

To determine potential nursing home

locations, this project utilizes the

following data.

Population density of Maine by block (2010) to rule out areas in the state

with extremely low population density as potential locations for new nurs-

ing homes.

Locations of current nursing homes (2013) to place greater weight on lo-

cations that currently do not have easy access to nursing homes.

Locations of hospitals (2016) to place greater weight on locations in the

proximity of hospitals to allow hospitals more efficient discharge of pa-

tients who need long-term care.

Populations of people 65 years and older who live alone by block group

(2014) to place greater weight on areas where more elderly people live

alone, as they are more likely to need nursing home care than those who

live with family members.

Populations of people 65 years and older who live under the poverty line

by block group (2014) (secondary model) to place greater weight on areas

where more of elderly people live under the poverty line, as they are often

more likely to be denied access to nursing home care due to an inability to

pay or a reliance on Maine Care.

A series of models transformed each of these datasets into raster layers in

ArcMap. Each of these layers were then combined to give recommenda-

tions for the placement of future nursing homes. The portions of the state

where the population density is greater than .001 residents per hectare

were selected and used to create a new layer. The “Polygon to Raster”

tool was used to transform this layer into a raster, and the “Reclassify”

tool was used to give this area full weight in the final models. The

“Euclidean Distance” tool was used to create raster layers around the

preexisting nursing homes and the hospitals. These layers were then re-

classified into four classes to give greater weight to locations near hospi-

tals and to locations further from nursing homes. The “Polygon to Raster”

tool transformed block groups with data concerning the senior population

that lives alone and the data concerning the senior population living under

the poverty line into raster layers. The “Reclassify” tool gave higher

weights to the block groups that contained more seniors in each of these

categories. Finally, the “Raster Calculator” tool combined the previous

layers into the final two models, which consider the weights of each loca-

tion within the study area based on the four factors (or three for Model 1).

Model 1, which includes data concerning locations of preexisting nursing

homes, hospitals, and the 65 and older population who lives alone in the

study area, suggests two locations for a new nursing home, with many

others that could be appropriate. The following chart provides context for

making a final decision:

Model 2, which includes the same data as Model 1 with the addition of

data concerning the 65 and older population that lives under the poverty

level, suggests a number of locations that could be appropriate for a new

nursing home. The following chart provides context for two of the loca-

tions with the most potential:

These two models provide a starting point for selecting locations for fu-ture nursing homes in Maine. The variables that are included are im-portant factors for determining where a new nursing home would be in high demand, but there are several other considerations to be made. Some of these include the following: the availability of real estate to house a nursing home, the potential funding from private or government sources, the desirability of locations for senior populations, the availability of staff or potential for recruitment to the area, etc.

Introduction

Data and Methodology

Results, Analysis, Limitations

Future Use

Sources

Determining Appropriate Locations

for Potential Nursing Homes in Maine

Allison Brown, NUTR 231: Fundamentals of GIS, Fall 2016

Location Nearest Preexist-ing Nursing Home

Population (including 3 nearest towns) (US

2010 Census)

Calais 44.3 km (Eastport Memorial Nursing

Home)

4,186 (Calais, Robbin-ston, Charlotte, Med-

dybemps)

Fort Fairfield 30.9 km

(Aroostook Health Center)

23,691 (Fort Fairfield, Presque Isle, Caribou,

Limestone)

Top:

Downtown

Calais, ME

Bottom:

Downtown

Fort Fairfield,

ME

Source:

Google Street

View,

accessed 21

December

2016.

Location Nearest Preexisting

Nursing Home

Population (including 3 nearest

towns) (US 2010 Census)

Etna 33.3 km (Bangor

Nursing and Rehabili-tation Center)

8,695 (Etna, Newport, Carmel, Plymouth)

Warren 15.61 km (Knox Cen-

ter for Long Term Care)

14,141 (Warren, Waldoboro, Thomas-

ton, Cushing)

Top:

Downtown

Etna, ME

Bottom:

Downtown

Warren, ME

Source:

Google Street

View,

accessed 21

December

2016.

Population per Hectare by

Block > .001

Census of Population and Housing – Blocks 2010, US Census Bureau, http://www.census.gov/data.html, accessed 11 November 2016.

Nursing Homes, 2 August 2013, MEGIS, http://www.maine.gov/megis/catalog/metadata/nursing_homes.html, accessed 11 November 2016.

Hospitals, 6 May 2016, MEGIS, http://www.maine.gov/megis/catalog/metadata/hospitals.html, accessed 11 November 2016.

ACS Block Group 5-Year Estimates, 2010-2014, Relationship by Household Type (Including Living Alone) for the Population 65 Years and Over, US Census Bu-

reau, http://factfinder.census.gov/faces/tableservices/jsf/pages/productview.xhtml?pid=ACS_15_5YR_B09020&prodType=table, accessed 14 November 2016.

ACS Block Group 5-Year Estimates, 2010-2014, Poverty Status in the Past 12 Months by Household Type by Age of Householder, http://factfinder.census.gov/

faces/tableservices/jsf/pages/productview.xhtml?pid=ACS_14_5YR_B17017&prodType=table, accessed 14 November 2016.

Graham, Gillian, "Maine Summit on Aging tackles issues facing state as population ages," Maine Center for Economic Policy, 15 September 2015, http://

www.mecep.org/maine-summit-on-aging-tackles-issues-facing-state-as-population-ages/, accessed November 17, 2016.

Photos: Pixabay, https://pixabay.com/p-1095124/?no_redirect, accessed 21 December 2016; Street View, Map Data: Google 2016, accessed 21 December 2016.

Projection: Maine East State Plane Projection