digital social and new tv luiss2016

41
NIELSEN @NielsenItaly [email protected] @Stefarusso New metrics to represent a new scenario Roma, marzo 2016

Upload: stefano-russo

Post on 16-Apr-2017

249 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

NIELSEN

@NielsenItaly

[email protected]

@Stefarusso

New metrics to represent a new scenario

Roma, marzo 2016

Page 2: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

AGENDA

NIELSEN

FOOTPRINT AND SOLUTIONS

SOCIAL TV

DEFINITIONS, PLAYERS, METRICS, BEST PRACTICES

SOCIAL CONTER RATINGS

THE FIRST HOLISTIC SOLUTION FOR SOCIAL TV

SCENARIO

BIG DATA AND FRAGMENTATION

Page 3: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

4 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

3I valori riportati si riferiscono a dati Nielsen Company con range temporale dal 11 gennaio al 17 gennaio 2016 (Nielsen Linear Time).

NIELSEN FOOTPRINT AND MISSION

Founded in 1923, today in +100 countries around the wrold

…We study consumers in more than 100

countries to give you the most complete

view of trends and habits worldwide.

… we’re constantly evolving, not only in terms

of where we measure, or who we measure,

but in how our insights can help you drive

profitable growth.

Page 4: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

4 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

4I valori riportati si riferiscono a dati Nielsen Company con range temporale dal 11 gennaio al 17 gennaio 2016 (Nielsen Linear Time).

ConsumerResearch

Consumer & Retail Tracking

Bases(Innovation Development)

TV Audience Measurement

WATCH BUY

In StoreObservation

Online Measurement

(Web/Mobile Media Tracking Reach cross platform)

Advertising Intelligence

NIELSEN SOLUTIONS AVAILABLE IN ITALY

Data Fusion – Integration – Ad Hoc Analysis

Social Tv Measurement

Media Analytcs

And cross platform

Page 5: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

THE MARKETPLACE IS INCREASINGLY COMPLEX

Linear vs non linear

Fragmentation

Real Time

Always On

ROPORTBSocial Media

THE HUMAN FACE OF BIG DATA

Page 6: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

DRIVERS OF CHANGE OVER THE LAST 20 YEARS

Technology/Digital

Economy

Globalization

Page 7: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

4 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

7I valori riportati si riferiscono a dati Nielsen Company con range temporale dal 11 gennaio al 17 gennaio 2016 (Nielsen Linear Time).

PEOPLE ARE MULTITASKING

OF

SMARTPHONE

OWNERS USE

DEVICE WHILE

WATCHING TV

OF TABLET OWNERS USE DEVICE WHILE

WATCHING TV

TIME SPENT ON WATCHING VIDEO ONLINE &

MOBILE (OF TOTAL WATCHING TIME)

OWN A SMARTPHONE

OWN A

TABLET24%

64%

49%

40%

1%

Page 8: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

PRE-STORE IN-STORE PURCHASEDEMAND/NEEDS LOYALTY

THE NEW PATH TO PURCHASE

Page 9: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

4 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

9I valori riportati si riferiscono a dati Nielsen Company con range temporale dal 11 gennaio al 17 gennaio 2016 (Nielsen Linear Time).

0

2.000.000

4.000.000

6.000.000

8.000.000

10.000.000

12.000.000

1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015

valori nominali valori a prezzi 1990

‘92-’00 ‘00-’08 ‘08-’15

Fattori economici e spinta tecnologica hanno determinato un assestamento

su una nuova dimensione di investimento.

INVESTIMENTI PUBBLICITARI DAGLI ANNI 90 (X1.000€)

Stima AdEx del mercato pubblicitario – incluse tutte le tipologie pubblicitarie

WWW SEARCH

SUBPRIMEBolla Internet

+11/9

Page 10: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

4 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

10

LA DISTRIBUZIONE DELL’ADVERTISING FRA I MEDIA

DAGLI ANNI 90

Adv per mezzo 1990

2%

5%25%

18%

50%

TV RADIO QUOTIDIANI

PERIODICI AFFISSIONI

Adv per mezzo 2000

5%

18%

3%17%

57%

TV RADIO QUOTIDIANI

PERIODICI AFFISSIONE

3,2 miliardi di € 7,0 miliardi di €

Fonte: BD AdEx, Nielsen. Investimenti in commerciale nazionale

90=>2000 €X2

Page 11: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

4 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

11I valori riportati si riferiscono a dati Nielsen Company con range temporale dal 11 gennaio al 17 gennaio 2016 (Nielsen Linear Time).

LE QUOTE DEI MEZZI 2015

Nota: Digital Advertising dati Nielsen - Stima Nielsen 2015 del digitale + FCP

46,1%

4,7%15,6%

3,0%

26,6%

4,0%

TV

Radio

Stampa

Altri Mezzi

Digital

Direct Mail

(*)

Due terzi degli investimenti si concentrano su Tv e Digital

7.912 milioni di €

Page 12: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

2 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

12

2,5

-7,6

7,4

45,8

13,3

8,5

16,6%

10,7%

34,3%7,4%

31,0%

LA QUOTA DEI DIVERSI WEB CHANNEL E IL LORO ANDAMENTO

Quota investimenti

pubblicitari sul totale digital

2.104 M€

26.6%

Nielsen Digital Survey 2015 – 2015 vs 2014

-1.8 pti

-1.3 pti

-0.4 pti

+2.7 pti

+0.7 pti

+1.8 pti

Video

Social

Search

Classified

Display

Totale digital

variazione % 2015 vs 2014

Nel corso del 2015 In forte crescita il Social

Page 13: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

SOCIAL CONTENT RATINGS

Page 14: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3

Th

e N

iels

en

Co

mp

an

y.

Co

nfi

de

nti

al

an

d p

rop

rie

tary

.

14

TOWARDS THE TOTAL AUDIENCE MEASUREMENT

http://sites.nielsen.com/totalaudience/

Page 15: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3

Th

e N

iels

en

Co

mp

an

y.

Co

nfi

de

nti

al

an

d p

rop

rie

tary

.

15

SOMETHING HAS CHANGED...

Second screen and social network changed the way we watch television from

familiar to social

Television mantains it’s relevance, but we changed how we interact with it

Page 16: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3

Th

e N

iels

en

Co

mp

an

y.

Co

nfi

de

nti

al

an

d p

rop

rie

tary

.

16

SOCIAL TV IS LIKE AN EXTENDED COUCH

Jared Goldsmith, VP marketing at NBC

Page 17: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3

Th

e N

iels

en

Co

mp

an

y.

Co

nfi

de

nti

al

an

d p

rop

rie

tary

.

17

4h22mper day

95%

Source: Nielsen on Auditel and Audiweb, 2015

ITALY: THE PASSION FOR TV AND SOCIAL MEDIA

Average time of Tv

viewing per day

....among MILLENNIALS?• 69% is multiscreen (surf the web while watching Tv)

• 72% are Social Networks users

26 Mn

Italians on Social Media

Every month

% of social network users

among mobile internet users

Page 18: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

4 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

18

NIELSEN SOCIAL: AN HOLISTIC APPROACH TO SOCIAL TV

Tracking of the mentions for +500 Brands in Italy:

Overlap Brand/Program Authors - Social Effect Reports

Real time monitoring:

Real Time Engagement

Top Metrics, tweets, authors, mentions, affinity among programs and

brands… Data available overnight:

+ 10.000 progams e 230.000 episodes per year

120 networks + Netflix

COMING SOON: Metrics about Instagram and Facebook as well.

Different social media platforms measured with a consistent approach

Social Content Ratings

Available in US, Italy, Australia, Mexico

Page 19: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

19

NIELSEN SOCIAL: HOW IT WORKS

NIELSEN SOCIAL AD HOC

SCR

BIG DATA CLASSIFICATION MEASURED STREAMS SOLUTIONS

SOCIAL CONTENT RATINGS

AD HOC SOLUTIONS

SOCIALGUIDE INTELLIGENCE

NIELSEN SOCIAL AD HOC

SCR

BIG DATA CLASSIFICATION MEASURED STREAMS SOLUTIONS

SOCIAL CONTENT RATINGS

AD HOC SOLUTIONS

SOCIALGUIDE INTELLIGENCE

SCHEDULING:

Daily updates for all the networks

we’re tracking

Page 20: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

20

SOCIAL CONTENT RATINGS FRAMEWORKClarification of activity into original content creation and engagement.

Activity

Authorship Engagement Reach

ORIGINAL CONTENT AMPLIFICATION AUDIENCE

Adhering to the Social Media Measurement Guidelines created by

the MRC with sponsorship and input from 4A’s, IAB & WOMMA.

Page 21: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3

Th

e N

iels

en

Co

mp

an

y.

Co

nfi

de

nti

al

an

d p

rop

rie

tary

.

21

SOCIAL CONTENT RATINGS IN CLIENT PLATFORM

METRICS REPORTS TIMEFRAMESCAPTURE

WINDOWSHISTORICAL

Ratings

Network

Program

Episode

Insights

Authorship

Engagement

Activity

Reach

Demographics

Daily

Weekly

Monthly

Quarterly

Yearly

Custom Date Range

Linear

Reporting

24/7 Reporting

SCR from

date of launch

forward

Existing

Historical Data

will Remain

Page 22: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

6 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

22

CROSS-PLATFORMFACEBOOK, INSTAGRAM, TWITTER

EARNED ACTVITY AND

OWNED ENGAGEMENTMEASUREMENT OF ACTIVITY BETWEEN

FRIENDS AND FAMILY* AND PUBLICLY

ENGAGEMENT TOOLSREAL-TIME ENGAGMENT

SOLUTIONS FOR TWITTER

REPORTING & APISSYNDICATED, ON-DEMAND,

AND CUSTOM DATA SETS

RESEARCHADVANCED REPORTING

AND THOUGHT LEADERSHIP

SOCIAL TV TOP FIVE CHARTS

POWERED BY NIELSEN

SOCIAL SEGMENTSCUSTOM SOCIAL TV SEGMENTS

FOR SOCIAL AD BUYING

EFFECTFOR POST-CAMPAIGN REPORTING :

MEASURE EARNED MEDIA ON TWITTER

DRIVEN BY TV STRATEGIES.

TV MEASUREMENT AD SOLUTIONS

AFFINITYFOR PLANNING & BUYING: FIND TV AUDIENCES

LIKELY TO AMPLIFY BRAND MESSAGES ON TWITTER

ONE SOLUTION FOR SOCIAL TV MEASUREMENT

*Excluding messenger

Page 23: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

6 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

23

THE SOCIAL TV ECOSYSTEM

TV CONTENT

AGENCIES

M.agencies (€€€ allocation)

Content Agencies

+ Sport teams and federations, associations, Content producers, bloggers.....

Page 24: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

24

SOCIAL TV: THE VALUE FOR BROADCASTERS

• REPORTING AND COMPETITIVE ANALYSIS

• MARKETING AND COMMUNICATION

• ENGAGEMENT IN REAL TIME AND PRE/POST

• MONETIZATION (SALES HOUES)

Why measuring Social Tv is so relevant

Page 25: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

25

SOCIAL TV: THE VALUE FOR ADVERTISERS/AGENCIES

• REPORTING AND MARKETING ANALYSIS

• ANALYSIS FOR PLANNING AND POST EVALUATIONS

• SOCIAL/TV CAMPAIGN MEASUREMENT

(SOCIAL EFFECT)

• REAL TIME ENGAGEMENT

Why measuring Social Tv is so relevant

BRANDING IN THE AGE OF SOCIAL MEDIA – HBR MARCH 2016

Page 26: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

26

SOCIAL TV IN ITALY: KEY LEARNINGS 2015

Key Figures

The social media presence in programs

Marketing and Communications

Advertising cross between social and Tv

Research and Intelligence

Some evidence from the italian Marketplace

Page 27: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

27

SOCIAL TV IN 2015: TRENDS AND GENRES

Note Metodologiche:

Tweet relativi ai programmi postati durante la finestra temporale Linear (+/- 3 ore rispetto al programma on AIR). Specials: ES.

Sanremo, MTV EMA, Miss Italia *Altri generi include: serie Tv, cinema, intrattenimento, factual.

Q42015 vs Q42014:Authors and Audience flat. Tweets (+20%) and Impressions (+10%).

30%

19%26%

14%

9%

Talent/Reality

Specials

Sport Live Events

Talk/News

Altri generi*

% of tweets per Genres

In 2015 44 Million Tweets, 2.3 billion impressions

Page 28: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

28

SOCIAL TV: THE SEASONALITY

3,4

6,4

4,33,6

4,9

3,4

1,6 1,4

3,4

5,5

3,62,8

Gen Feb Mar Apr Mag Giu Lug Ago Sett Ott Nov Dic

Millions of Tweets per month

293.000

382.200334.000

302.000353.000

275.300

179.000 177300

275.800303.100 294.600

228.500

Feb Mar Apr Mag Giu Lug Ago Sett Ott Nov Dic

Unique Author per month

Page 29: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3

Th

e N

iels

en

Co

mp

an

y.

Co

nfi

de

nti

al

an

d p

rop

rie

tary

.

29

TWEETS PER BROADCASTER IN 2015

Tweets per Publishers in Italy

Pub A Pub B Pub C Pub D Pub E Others

Page 30: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

30

SOCIAL MEDIA IN THE TV PROGRAMS STORYTELLING

....new opportunities for brands

...Stimulating conversations ...become content

...Aggregate communities

Page 31: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

31

SOCIAL TV RATINGS FOR MKTG PURPOSES

Page 32: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

32

SENTIMENT ANALYSIS. WHAT DO PEOPLE SAY?

Are comments positive, negative, neutral? What about brands or talent?

Page 33: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

33

THE REAL TIME OPPORUNITY

Social Media Allows real time conversations: this brings risks and opportunities

Page 34: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3

Th

e N

iels

en

Co

mp

an

y.

Co

nfi

de

nti

al

an

d p

rop

rie

tary

.

34

CALCULATING AFFINITY AMONG DIFFERENT PROGRAMS

OR NETWORKS

Mapping the viewing beaviours among different networks/programs

Page 35: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

35

GOLDEN TV AUTHORS: WHY THEY ARE SO RELEVANT

X 2.8Tweet per episode

+50%Followers

X 3.8Tweets about brands

Compared to a simple program author, a Golden TV author generates...

Source Nielsen Social: data related to 34 Tv programs on air in Italy between Sept 2014 to June 2015

Definitions Caratheristics

Program Authors Authors who tweeted at least on 2 episodes of a program over the entire season

Frequent Authors Authors who tweeted at least on 3 episodes of a program over the entire season

Loyal Authors Authors who tweeted at least on the 25% of episodes of a program over the entire season

Golden Authors Authors who tweeted at least on the 33% of episodes of a program over the entire season

Page 36: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3

Th

e N

iels

en

Co

mp

an

y.

Co

nfi

de

nti

al

an

d p

rop

rie

tary

.

36

SOCIAL TV AND ADVERTISERS

61% Twitter TV Authors: 1,1 Million

Twitter Brand Authors: 818k

Twitter Brand/TV Authors: 500k

Fonte: Nielsen Social, dati relativi al 2015

www.nielsensocial.com

500.000 people - 61% of authors who

tweeted about the brands, wrote about

television programs during 2015

Page 37: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

37

NUMBER OF TWEETS PER DAY. …..3

1/0

8/2

01

5

02

/09

/20

15

04

/09

/20

15

06

/09

/20

15

08

/09

/20

15

10

/09

/20

15

12

/09

/20

15

14

/09

/20

15

16

/09

/20

15

18

/09

/20

15

20

/09

/20

15

22

/09

/20

15

24

/09

/20

15

26

/09

/20

15

28

/09

/20

15

30

/09

/20

15

02

/10

/20

15

04

/10

/20

15

06

/10

/20

15

08

/10

/20

15

10

/10

/20

15

12

/10

/20

15

14

/10

/20

15

16

/10

/20

15

18

/10

/20

15

20

/10

/20

15

22

/10

/20

15

24

/10

/20

15

26

/10

/20

15

28

/10

/20

15

30

/10

/20

15

01

/11

/20

15

03

/11

/20

15

05

/11

/20

15

07

/11

/20

15

09

/11

/20

15

11

/11

/20

15

13

/11

/20

15

15

/11

/20

15

17

/11

/20

15

19

/11

/20

15

21

/11

/20

15

23

/11

/20

15

25

/11

/20

15

27

/11

/20

15

29

/11

/20

15

01

/12

/20

15

03

/12

/20

15

05

/12

/20

15

07

/12

/20

15

09

/12

/20

15

11

/12

/20

15

73% of the Tweets

mentioning Enel posted

by Brand&program

Authors between Dec

10 to Dec. 12

Split between Brand&Program Authors vs Brand Authors

Brand And Program Authors Brand Authors

PRE-CAMPAIGN CAMPAIGN

2.630 Tweets (out of 3.588) between Dec 10 to Dec 12 posted by

Brand&programs Authors

Page 38: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

@NielsenItaly

[email protected]

@Stefarusso

Page 39: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

6 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

39

THE PATH TO PERFORMANCEFaster, smarter more confident decisions to improve performance

SALES

EFFECTIVENESS:

Achieve better

financial

performance

through superior

plan activation

and sales

execution

MARKETING

EFFECTIVENESS:

Engage

consumers

through effective

and efficient

marketing

CONSUMERIZATION:

Organize around

consumers; build

proprietary

understanding about

your most profitable

consumer – then

activate the entire

organization.

INNOVATION:

Improve how

companies

innovate;

integrated from

white space to

launch support

Page 40: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

6 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

40

GAIN A DEEPER UNDERSTANDING OF YOUR

ADVERTISING INVESTMENTS OR MEDIA PERFORMANCE

Advertising Effectiveness

OUTCOME:

Higher overall

media ROI

How did it

change

behavior?

REACTION

How did it change attitudes ?

RESONANCE

What audience

did I reach?

REACH

MARKETING EFFECTIVENESS |

A huge portfolio of solutions for Advertisers, media owners, agencies

Page 41: Digital Social and new TV LUISS2016

Co

py

rig

ht

©2

01

3 T

he

Nie

lse

n C

om

pa

ny

. C

on

fid

en

tia

l a

nd

pro

pri

eta

ry.

41

0,0%

20,0%

40,0%

60,0%

80,0%

100,0%

120,0%

EACH AUTHORS HAS A DIFFERENT VALUE

645 2.059Nr of authors

(% on authors)

......

12% of authors generated 80% of impressions on twitter for the program...

(4%) (12%)

Quantile Nr of auhtors

1 33

2 149

3 463

4 1.443

5 14.133

Who are the most influencing among my program-authors?