Download - PRS-Analysis & PTDR Vol 2
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 1
PRS-Analysis & PTDR Vol 2
Albert De RoeckCPT AR 20/6
Vol II
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 2
Analysis PRS Groups
Deliverables: PTDR & Tools
Vol 2.1 First run plans Physics up to 1 fb-1
Vol 2.2 Full analyses: from raw data to Physics /Detector PRS driven
Vol 2.3 The physics of the 10 and 30 fb-
and asymptotic 300 fb-1
Submit April 2006 (depending on Cosmic Challenge time schedule)
New group: Generator Tools
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 3
1. Standard Model
Precision measurements of Standard Model processes and parameters
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 4
General:- good progress since spring this year as DSTs became available- started to work on early measurements and first 1 fb-1 physics (topics for Vol. II.1) - Comparisons of FAMOS with detailed simulation/reconstruction
Most topics reasonably well covered by active people except- QCD & jet physics (action being taken to improve on this)- Also still room for specific topics such as
-tt+ (top quark charge)-Top decays into particles-W/Z production & derivation of PDFs, ZZ final states in TGC
Problems:- MC production: some analyses not yet started because of missing signal MC e.g. ttbar J/Psi +X, spin correlation in ttbar, ...- Data access of large SM samples (FNAL...) still not smooth
Standard Model GroupJ. Mnich
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 5
good
bad
After our LR selection
event NOT weighted with its purity
mt(GeV)
top mass
Optimized selelectionTop mass fits• simple fit on this spectrum(the full sample)• ideogram technique(event-by-event)
J. d‘Hondt et al.
Top Mass
Mt
(input 175 GeV)
With PU
With Radiation
(nominal)
No PU
With Radiation
With PU
No Radiation
No PU
No Radiation
‘simple’ 172.4 ± 0.5 169.4 ± 0.4 179.2 ± 0.6 -
‘ideogram’ OSCAR
175.0 ± 0.5 172.4 ± 0.4 177.0 ± 0.4 -
‘ideogram’ FAMOS
- 177.2 ± 0.3 - 178.1 ± 0.2
Mass differences Mreduced by factor 3with new method
Affects systematicsuncertainty~20% of M
Full systematics under study
~1.6 fb-1all these numbers are correlated, hence differences are significant
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 6
A. Kyriakis, A.Giammanc
Leads to a limit of 410-3 in 10 fb-1 (20 times better than LEP)Improvements in progress (ttbar rejection)FAMOS analysis for high luminosity reach ongoing
FCNC: tZq Decay
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 7
S. Chatterji, H. Heath
Probe of the gluon structure at lower x and higher Q2 than before
Direct Photons
Analysis under way!This is first days physics!!
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 8
V. Andreev
•Event selection establishedThen:•Muon PT w.r.t. the B tagged jet to extract b events fraction•Fit procedure•Increase statistics•Electrons
Inclusive b-productionNew: First study on inclusive b-production started (b)
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 9
K. Mackay et al, A. Oh, V. Brigljevice.g. status W analysis
signal MC
Background:
Di-Boson production and TGCs
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 10
Forward physics and Diffraction
CMS+TOTEM prepare a LOI on diffraction, due for the LHCC of Nov 06 Forward detectors used: region 5<|| <7 calo+ tracker and TOTEM roman pots
Physics topics - Hard (& soft) diffraction, QCD and EWSB (Higgs), New Physics - Low-x dynamics and proton structure - Two-photon physics: QCD and New Physics - Special exotics (centauro’s, DCC’s in the forward region) - Cosmic Rays…
Example: di-jets in Double Pomeron Exchange ( < 0.1, H1 structure function) LHC pt> 10 GeV pt> 100 GeV pt > 500 GeV 1.2 106 pb 0.9 pb 5 10-4 pb Tevatron 1.3 105 pb
DiffractiveW Exclusive
Higgsproduction
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 11
2. Higgs Physics
H HZZ
What is the origin of Electro-weak Symmetry Breaking? If Higgs field at least one new scalar particle should exist: The Higgs One of the main missions of CMS: discover the Higgs for mH< 1 TeV
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 12
A few key results since last review
• Publications – A. Nikitenko, R. Kinnunen. S. Lehti, F. Moortgat, M. Spira,
“Measurement of the H/A-> cross section and possible constraint on tan()” CMS Note 2004/027, hep-ph/0503075.
– D. Dominici, G. Dewhirst, S. Gennai, L. Fano, A. Nikitenko, “Search for radion decays into Higgs boson pairs”, CMS Note 2005/007
– R. Kinnunen, S. Lehti, A. Nikitenko and P. Salmi, “On the discovery potential of the lightest MSSM Higgs Boson at LHC”, J. Phys. G: Nucl. Part. Phys. 31 (2005) 71-88.
• Very successful participation and collaboration with theorists in Les Houches 2005 meeting 2-20 May– H->WW group. A.-S. Giolo, G. Davatz, M. Zanetti, A. Nikitenko– Higgs with b quarks group, A. Kalinowski, S. Lehti, A. Nikitenko – VBF Higgs group, A. Nikitenko + M. Takahashi – tth group, S. Gascon– V. Drollinger (b fragmentation), A. Drozdetski (H->ZZ->4)
A. Nikitenko
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 13
General flow of progress
• HiggsAnalysis subsystem in ORCA is enlarged to 10 packages corresponding to individual channels
• Most of the datasets for PTDR have been requested
• First usage of ME+PS with ALPGEN2 for mass production: Z+2(3)j as bkg. to VBF Higgs. In collab. with M. Mangano and F. Piccinini
• Experimental and theor. systematics, generator uncertainties issues are being addressed for “hottest” channels
• Higgs boson cross sections and Brs to be used for PTDR are fixed together with scale and pdf uncertainties (with M. Spira, A. Djouadi, S. Heinemeyer)
• All important analyses well covered except • Heavy Higgses e.g. Zll or ll jetjet
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 14
General flow of progress
• Intensive use of LO ME generators for PTDR (ALPGEN, MadGraph, CompHEP); no MC@NLO datasets for PTDR but intensive generator level studies, comparison with PYTHIA and HERWIG to be prepared for “post PTDR production”
• Good collaboration with det. PRS (esp. with JetMET) • Most advanced channels
– SM H->ZZ(*)->2e2 D. Futyan, D. Giordano– SM H->WW(*)->2l, A.-S. Giolo, G. Davatz, M. Zanetti– MSSM H+ in tt~ M. Hashemi– MSSM H+ in gb->tH+, R. Kinnunen– MSSM A/H->, G. Masetti– MSSM A/H->->ll, S. Lehti
• Request still a few small number of missing datasets • Prepare first PTDR analyses for approval on September CMS week
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 15
Higgs Example: H->ZZ(*)->2e2
Beforeoffline selection
Afteroffline selection
mH=130 GeV mH=200 GeV
= 0 ± stat ± syst ± lum ± B
cross section measurement accuracy
Systematics and background being evaluated
D. Futyan and D. Giordano
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 16
Examples of Ongoing Studies
Exploring Zll+X using as a benchmark for A
ggbbA, ABackground fitted outside the region
S. LehtiG. Masetti
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 17
3. Beyond the SM
Supersymmetry Extra dimensions
New physics expected around the TeV scale Stabelize Higgs mass, Hierarchy problem, Unification of gauge couplings, CDM,…
+…
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 18
• Considerable progress since last AR– Better coverage of physics topics– Many signal samples have been produced– Will need larger + improved (NLO) SM bkgd samples – …and improved data access
• Many new results forthcoming– All based on OSCAR/ORCA and FAMOS
• CMS Notes and approved analyses– CMS Note 2004/024, 2005-002, CMS AN 2004/003, 2005/003 – CMS IN 2004-037, 2004-056, 2005-XXX (UED)
• Span many search areas:– SUSY, Z’, ED, Little Higgs, Technicolour, …– Still some weakly covered in GMSB, RPV, Little Higgs,
Technicolour• See SUSY/BSM group web page for topics + groups involved more information/updates @SUSYBSM web and http://cmsdoc.cern.ch/cms/PRS/susybsm/
L. Pape, M. Spiropulu
SUSY/BSM updateSUSY/BSM Update
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 19
• Only few highlights are listed here– See also the topics on the web
• Inclusive SS analysis approved
– Reach m1/2 > 500 GeV with 10 fb-1
– Continuing to extend analysis to larger m0
• Common test points have been defined– Cover various signatures, – Primarily for exclusive analyses– Low mass (LM) early discovery– High mass (HM) ultimate reach– Currently concentrate on LM
points
New SUSY Results
21H
21Z
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 20
• Final states with di-leptons (LM1) 0
2 ~l l l l 01 from
cascades– Required e± clean-up– Now e-e and - eff. mass– Start combining with jets
reconstruct all masses
02 ±
1 to trileptons (LM9)
• Direct 3-body 02 l l 0
1
• Will also study cascades
New SUSY Results
Opposite sign-same flavourdilepton edge for variousbenchmark points
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 21
• Final states with di-taus (LM2) s are soft: small (M-M0
1)
– Use hadronic decays– Important for Dark Matter studies
• Final states with Z0 ll (LM4)– Efficient rejection of bkgd, signal
easy to see
– Significance for 02 Z0 0
1 is 22 for 10 fb-1
• GMSB with heavy stable stau– Previous analysis with TOF
from muon DT being redone– New: measure dE/dx with ECAL
(FAMOS)
Signal event (opposite sign tau’s)Signal event (same sign tau’s)lm2 bkg (opposite sign tau’s)lm2 bkg (same sign tau’s)
M()
New SUSY Results
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 22
• High mass resonances into ee – Saturation in ECAL– Example: reach in RS model– Approved analysis
• Also RS graviton to – Reach ~4 TeV for c=0.1 at 30 fb-1
• High mass resonances into – Example: reach for Z’ models– Also performed analysis of
angular distributions (on peak only)
– Approved analyses
Z’ Resonances and Extra Dimensions
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 23
• Other final final states– Example: reach for ADD models
for effective Planck scale
( ploted results from virtual exchange)
• But many other searches for high mass resonances are ongoing– See topics on web page
• Search for UED– Parton level study completed– Now started full sim analysis
Z’ Resonances and Extra Dimensions
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 24
• Little Higgs– T t Z0, W leptonically or
hadronically– But small number of events
• Technicolour T W Z 3l
• Reach depends on T mass
T T
• Clear T peak
• Need to reconstruct T
T
Other BSM Channels
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 25
4. Heavy Ions
The quark-gluon plasma and more…
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 26
Heavy Ions Analyses
• Two analyses selected for Physics TDR– Quarkonium cross section (Bedjidian, Kodolova)
• High statistics “fast” simulation almost complete. Preliminary “mass spectra” using full detector acceptance, updated efficiency and resolutions available
• Full simulation background estimate simulation in progress, first results expected this week
– Jets rates and jet modification (C.Roland, + students: Lopez-Mateos, Platt)
• Tuning of a new generator complete– Careful centrality-dependent multiplicity and hard-collision
generation– Correct accounting of all produced particles
• All previous HI software issues are resolved – Pilot jobs of 2k Central and 10k min. bias PbPb events have been
generated and successfully reconstructed– These samples are used for PTDR Vol 1 performance studies
• Currently the generators are fine tuned for large scale production to study physics performance
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 27
%
Point 1: Both muons have 3 GeV<p<5 GeVPoint 2: Both muons have 5 GeV<p<10 GeVPoint 3: Both muons have 10 GeV<p<15 GeVPoint 4: Both muons have 10 GeV<p<15 GeV Both muons are in ||<0.7
Muon pair
Muon pair from B
Muon pair from K
Muon pair from
%
%
%
1
1
1
1
2
2
2
2
3
3
3
3
4
4
4
4
efficiency
purity
Efficiency and purityfor the
Reconstruction efficiency of muon pairs for different originFull simulation, including trigger efficiency
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 28
Quarkonium mass plots in Pb+Pb, “fast simulation”
Acceptance= 1.3%
S/B= 0.45
~120000 J/ /month
Acceptance= 27%
S/B= 0.09
~20000 /month
ORCA/OSCAR resolution ~ 85 MeV
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 29
Jet Simulation• The goal is to study parton energy loss in nuclear matter
• Channels under investigation:1. Charged particle spectra vs. collisions centrality 2. Jet spectra3. Fragmentation functions and Jet profiles
• Example Studies have been completed on generator level• Will be repeated on the full detector simulation once it is
completed• While the simulation is running (~2 month) the analysis will be
further optimized to increase sensitivity
1) 3)2)
Tuning of a new generator complete (Lokhtin, Snigirev, Petrushanko)
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 30
5. Generator Tools
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 31
New Group: MC Generator Tools
Deliverables:• Interfacing generators and generator tools with CMS software
– Documentation– Example jobs
• Cross section tables for processes (generator manual)• Including GENSER (LCG AA project generator library)• Replacing CMKIN “CMKIN++”• Introducing HepMC as MC event structure• LHAPDF for the proton structure function + uncertainties• Generator tuning subproject (P. Bartalini)
– In particular tuning/study of the systematics of the underlying event.
F. Moortgat, S. Slabospitsky
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 32
Event Generators
S. Slabospitsky et al.in preparation
New generator group web page
http://cmsdoc.cern.ch/cms/PRS/gentools/
Web pages for the differentgenerators used in CMS
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 33
Generator Tools
Transition HEPEVT to HepMC: (Weng, Stavrianakou)• HepMCInterface in COBRA • HepMC output implemented in CMKIN++• reading of HepMC input implemented in OSCAR• reading of HepMC input in FAMOS ongoing• HepMC interface in EDM being implemented
CMKIN++ : the C++ successor of CMKIN (Cuevas, Naves)• prototype CMKINInterface in COBRA• using GENSER (LCG) generator libraries• several output formats implemented (a.o. POOL)• optimizing interface with new EDM
Collaboration with LCG Generator Project :
• common forum for LHC Physics Generator related issues • GENSER (LCG generator library): interface with CMKIN tested;full deployment waiting for SCRAMv1• collaboration for development of generator level production framework
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 34
Generator Tools
C++ generators : • providing feedback from the experimental community to the authorsof the next generation Monte Carlo generators that are now being developed, e.g. PYTHIA8
Interfaces between various generator tools: • validation of SUSY Les Houches Accord & feedback• requests for new tools needed by the PRS-Analysis groups• requests for more compatibility between tools e.g. Les Houches workshop 2005
Tuning of multiple interactions and underl. event: (Bartalini et al)
• study/tuning of the systematics of the underlying event• proposal being discussed
• modifications to CMKIN to ensure consistent parameter use• testing of new PYTHIA6.3 UE model
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 35
Generator Tools
Dedicated generation of complex final state samples: Consistency/coherence; usable by many analysis groups
multi-jet final states (W/Z+ N jets, Njets, … N<=6) using state-of-the-art ALPGEN and ME/PS matching with PYTHIA (Cucciarelli, Ambroglini)
• new ALPGEN2.0 has been interfaced to CMKIN
• generation of samples is ongoing (CPU-time consuming)
W+Njets, N=0,1,2,3,4,5,6+
Z+Njets, N=0,1,2,3,4,5,6+
Njets, N=4,5,6+
tt+Njets, N=0,1,2+
bb+Njets, N=0,1,2,3,4,5,6+
WW,WZ,ZZ+Njets, N=0,1,2,3,4+
Z/W bb + Njets, N=0,1,2,3,4+
Z+Mc+Njets, M=2, N=0,1,2
bbbb +Njets, N=0,1,2,3,4+
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 36
The Physics TDR
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 37
Vol 2.1: Startup and first physics Startup scenarios and physics with up to 1 fb-1 with the startup detector
Proposed outline of Vol 2.1 • The Startup Landscape * The LHC startup * The startup detector• The Cosmic Challenge * Description of detector components * Commissioning, operation and results• From Pilot Run to Physics Startup * Startup calibration, Allignment and Reconstruction * Trigger commissioning * Basic startup measurements• Physics reach with 1 fb-1
* Standard Model * Physics Beyond the Standard Model * The Early Higgs Boson Search
P. Janot
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 38
Vol2.2 Full analyses
• ECAL/egamma– H Photon id; ultimate ECAL resolution– HZZ(*) Electron reco: golden, silver, bronze…
• Muons– HZZ(*)4 Muon id: golden, silver, bronze– HWW(*) High-stats dimuons; jet veto– Z’ High-PT muons
• HCAL/JetMET– SUSY (0.5 TeV) Jets, missing Et; at the Tevatron limit– qqH Forward jets; triggering– Z’jet-jet High-pt jets; dijet mass
• Tracker/btau– ttH B tagging; top reconstruction…– A/Htau-tau Tau tagging; trigger; backgrounds/eff– BS J/ Vertexing; low-pt tracking
• Heavy Ions– Quarkonia – Jet quenching effects
CMS physics object driven (photons, electrons, muons, etc..) Imitate “real life” to the greatest possible extend (allignement/calibration)
P. Sphicas
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 39
Vol2.3: Physics Reach
Outline of vol2.3• Standard model chapters
– Physics of Strong Interactions: QCD, B-physics and diffraction– Physics of Top Quarks– Electroweak Physics
• Higgs chapters– Standard Model Higgs Bosons– MSSM Higgs Bosons– Search for Higgs bosons in non-SUSY models
• SUSYBSM chapters – Supersymmetry– Extra Dimensions and New Vector Boson High Mass States– Selection of other BSM signatures
Physics reach with 30 fb-1 (10/100/300 fb-1)
ADR
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 40
Vol-II Progress
• PTDR Vol2 layout committed to CVS repository
• Timeline (basically take PTDR Vol1 and add 4 months)– Version of the layout ready 15/6 presentation to CMS
during the June CMS week– First draft to the collaboration 21 October (Friday) – Present to the collaboration during November CPT
week– Final Draft for March 2006 CMS meeting (cosmic
challenge?)– Submit in April 2006
• Addendum to the PTDR for Heavy Ion program – Submit end of 2006
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 41
Ongoing Projects for the PTDR
• Common significance/confidence limits– Brainstorm meeting led proposal/being circulated (use “LEP” CL
technique) • Systematic uncertainties
– On PDFs: use CTEQ6 error band prescription– Common numbers from detectors (Energy scales, …) being prepared– B-fragmen., Initial/final state radiation, Higher orders, EW
constants…• Since December 2004, discussion among the physics groups to align
requests from the working groups (signal, background) to give these datasets wider use and publicity
» MC production master in place
• LHC startup scenario specification – CMS agreed upon interpretation being worked out
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 42
Some Observations
• FAMOS used more widely in the last few months – But it needs to be completed (e.g with pile-up, further tuning..)– PRS-analysis: take responsibilities/compare results full versus fast
• Reported Problems with the data file access using grid tools– Has improved since FNAL meeting but still a problem– We need to think of a replica strategy
• Production team does a great job, but sometimes production capacity gets saturated/long waits for “validating” new production chains– Delays in getting samples to users– Legalizing existing private samples/being investigated
• Most analysis for Vol 2 will be done with the present software– Maintenance/support must be guaranteed until at least TDR is out
• More work on Vol2.1 needed: – Starting in earnest now
• PRS-analysis contributors should also contribute to PRS detector or SW (e.g. analysis software). – Works to some level must still be improved
Albert De Roeck (CERN) 43
Summary• The Physics TDR is well under way• Plenty of activity in the PRS-analysis groups/significant progress
since last AR/ So far on track for the PTDR• Good training, uncovering of probs for the real thing starting in 2007• Still a lot of work to be done within the next 10 months
SUSY events (LM4 point: leptons, missing ET)
SUSY events (LM1 point: jets missing ET)
Micro-Black Hole