Download - Strategic Lean Six Sigma
Strategic Lean Six Sigma
Colin SmartVice President Business Excellence & Six Sigma
28th June 2006
© TRW Automotive Inc. 20062
TRW Automotive - Profile
• Headquartered in Livonia, Michigan• 63,000+ employees worldwide• More than 200 facilities in 25 countries• Serves all major OEM vehicle manufacturers worldwide and their
suppliers• Leading developer and supplier of active and passive safety
systems
© TRW Automotive Inc. 20063
Supporting Customers Globally
(1) Manufacturing facilities includes majority-owned joint-venture facilities (as of December 31, 2005)(2) Total headcount includes only active employees (as of December 31, 2005)(3) Primarily South America
Asia-PacificROW (3)
• 2005 Sales $0.4B• 8 Mfg. Facilities(1)
• 4,400 Employees(2)
• 3 Joint Ventures• Primarily Chassis and Aftermarket
• 2005 Sales of $7.0B• 77 Mfg. Facilities(1)
• 33,800 Employees(2)
• 1 Joint Venture• All products and Aftermarket
• 2005 Sales of $0.7B• 20 Mfg. Facilities(1)
• 3,600 Employees(2)
• 14 Joint Ventures• All products and Aftermarket
Europe• 2005 Sales of $4.6B• 40 mfg. facilities(1)
• 21,300 employees(2)
• 3 Joint Ventures• All products and Aftermarket
North America
36%
3%
55%6%
TRW OPERATIONS COVER EVERY MAJOR VEHICLE PRODUCING REGION AND ARE GROWING AT A PACE THAT MATCHES THE FUTURE NEEDS OF
OUR CUSTOMERS
© TRW Automotive Inc. 20064
TRW Automotive - Advanced TechnologiesActive Safety
Steering Wheel SystemsTouch Sensor in Steering Wheel RimVibrating Steering WheelIllumination TechnologyContactless Horn SystemPath-free use of Horn
Linkage & Suspension SystemsActive Dynamic ControlControl ArmsBall JointsStabilizer LinksTie RodsModules
Braking SystemsAnti-Lock Braking (ABS)Traction ControlElectronic Stability Control (ESC)Electric Park BrakeIntegrated Park BrakeCalipersActive Hydraulic BoostActuation
Driver Assist SystemsAdaptive Cruise Control Lane Guide SystemsCollision Warning
Steering SystemsHybrid EnablingActive SteeringElectrically Powered Hydraulic SteeringRack and Pinion SteeringElectrically Powered Steering Belt DriveElectrically Powered Steering Column DriveSpeed Proportional Steering
© TRW Automotive Inc. 20065
TRW Automotive - Advanced TechnologiesPassive Safety
Steering Wheel SystemsSteering Wheel with Integrated MicrophoneElectrical ConnectionsFixed Driver Airbag Module
AirbagsDriver AirbagsPassenger AirbagsSelf Adapting VentActive VentingLow Risk DeploymentKnee AirbagsSide AirbagsCurtain/Rollover Airbags
Seat Belt SystemsActive Control RetractorSeat Belt RetractorsLoad LimitersBuckle Pretensioners
EnTire SolutionDirect Tire Pressure Monitoring• Products from JV with Michelin
Safety ElectronicsECU and Remote SensorsVision SystemPedestrian ProtectionWeight Sensing System
© TRW Automotive Inc. 20067
Ford16%
DaimlerChrysler14%
General Motors11%
Other 16%
2005 Sales by Customer - $12.6 Billion
Volkswagen 14%
Renault/Nissan9%
BMW 4%
PSA 4%
Fiat 4%
Toyota 3%
Honda 3%
Hyundai 2%
TRW Automotive Worldwide Sales
© TRW Automotive Inc. 20068
TRW Automotive Global Market PresenceAcura Passenger Cars TSX
Alfa Romeo Passenger Cars 147, 156, 166 Spider Sprint GTV AM General Utility Hummer Audi Passenger Cars A8, A6, A4, A3, A2, TT Cabrio AutoAlliance (See Mazda) Beijing Jeep Corp. Sport Utilities Cherokee Bentley Passenger Cars GT BMW Passenger Cars 1 series 3 series 5 series 7 series Sport Utilities X3, X5 Citroën Passenger Cars Pluriel Berlingo Xsara C2, C3, C6 Vans C8 Picasso Jumpy Daewoo Magnus Lacetti Matiz Kalos Rezzo
DaimlerChrysler Passenger Cars Neon Stratus Sebring Concorede Viper Prowler
300N Vans Pacifica
Magnum Sport Wagon Caravan Voyager Town & Country Ram Van Sport Utilities Wrangler Liberty Grand Cherokee Durango Trucks Dakota Pickup Ram Pickup PT Cruiser
FAW Passenger Cars Mingshi Century Star FAW/VW Passenger Cars Jetta King Audi A6 Golf Bora Ferrari Passenger Cars F355 456 G Fiat Passenger Cars Punto Bravo/Brava Barchetta Multipla Panda Seicento Palio Stilo Uno B-MPV Albea Siena Vans Daily Doblo Strada Ulysse Ducato Trucks Scudo Ford Passenger Cars Amazon Focus Tracer Mustang
Taurus Cougar Town Car Sable Ka Fiesta Mondeo LS Thunderbird Crown Vic Grand Marquis Vans Windstar/Freestar Econoline Galaxy Sport Utilities Excursion Explorer Mountaineer Expedition Navigator Transit Trucks Ranger F-150 F-250 F-350 F-450 General Motors Passenger Cars Corvette Cavalier Impala LeSabre
Monte Carlo Bonneville Grand Prix Century Regal Ion XLR Celta CTS
Vans Aztek Safari Astro Express Compact Van Luxury Van Venture Silhouette Montana Savana Rendezvous
Sport Utilities Envoy Trailblazer Rainier SSR H2
Escalade Blazer Jimmy Suburban Tahoe Yukon Bravada
Trucks Avalanche S-10 Sonoma Sierra
Silverado Topkick Honda Passenger Cars
Civic Fit Inspire TL Accord
Sport Utilities Pilot MDX
Vans Odyssey CR-V
Hyundai Trajet XG Tuscani Small SUV EF Sonata Santa Fe ATOZ Click
Isuzu Sport Utilities
Axiom DMAX
Jaguar S-Type XJ8 X Type XK8
Jinbei Auto Passenger Cars
Zhonghua Kia Passenger Cars
ATOZ Sorento Frontier Spectra Carnival Optima Rio
Vans Bongo Pregio
Sport Utilities Carens Sportage
Lamborghini Passenger Cars
GTR Lancia Passenger Cars Aenea Lancia Y Lybra Thesis Vans
Phedra Land Rover Sport Utilities
Discovery Freelander Defender Range Rover
Lotus Passenger Cars Elise Maserati Quattro Mazda Passenger Cars Bongo Eunos Roadster Atenza Familia Friendly Millenia Premacy Titan RX-8 6 Sport Utilities MPV Tribute Mercedes-Benz Passenger Cars A-Class C-Class E-Class S-Class CL CLK Maybach SL, SLR, SLK G-Wagon Vaneo Vans Sprinter Evobus M-Class
Mitsubishi Passenger Cars Spacestar Colt Smart +4 MGX Eclipse Seabring Minicar Roadster Navistar Medium Truck NEDCAR Passenger Car V-40 Nissan Passenger Cars Micra March Almera Primera Sport Utilities Frontier Terrano Serena Primestar Trucks Compact Pickups Vans Trade Vannette Primestar NUMMI Passenger Cars Vibe Opel Passenger Cars Catera Agila Meriva Vectra Astra Zafira Corsa Signum Sport Utilities
Frontera Combo
Vans Vivaro Perodua Kancili Kelisa Peugeot Passenger Cars
107 206 307
406/407 607
Vans 807 Boxer Partner Expert
Porsche Passenger Cars
911 Boxster GT3
Proton Passenger Cars
Waja Wira Sutera
Trucks Pickup
Renault Passenger Cars
B Car B-MPV Laguna Clio Mégane Scenic Twingo
Vans Espace Master Trafic Kangoo
Saab Passenger Cars
9-3, 9-5 SAIC-Chery Passenger Cars A11, B11, T11 Samsung
EX SM3 SM5
SEAT Passenger Cars
Ibiza Leon Cordoba Toledo Alhambra Arosa
Shanghai-W Passat B5 Gol Polo Touran
SKODA Passenger Cars
Octavia Superb Fabia
Smart Minicar Roadster
Ssangyong Istana, Musso
Suzuki Sport Utilities
Jimny Toyota Passenger Cars
Avensis Avalon Camry Spacio Corolla Yaris
Trucks Tundra Tacoma
Vans Matrix Hilux Sienna Sport Rider
Volkswagen Passenger Cars
Beetle Bora Parati Phaeton Lupo Touran Cabriolet Polo GOL Golf/Vento/Jetta Passat
Sport Utilities Sharan
Vans Kombi Transporter Caddy Van
Volvo Passenger Cars
S50/V50 S40/V40 V70, S80
© TRW Automotive Inc. 20069
• Effectively integrating strategy-focused Lean/ Six Sigma - Aligning your program with your company strategy.
• The practicalities of moving from a tactical to a strategic perspective.
• Linkage of continuous improvement to strategic planning to support the long-term objectives of the business
Purpose
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200610
• Effectively integrating strategy-focused Lean/ Six Sigma - Aligning your program with your company strategy.
Making Sure You Are Part of the Solution
• The practicalities of moving from a tactical to a strategic perspective.
Getting Your Head out of the statistics
• Linkage of continuous improvement to strategic planning to support the long-term objectives of the business
Making sure everyone knows what they are trying to achieve
Purpose
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200611
• Define– Why it is so difficult to be Lean /Six Sigma
• Measure– Understanding that “They” don’t care about “p values”
• Analyse– How you make change happen
• Implement– What can you set up to get the results
• Control– How you keep it going
Agenda
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200612
• Thousands of Books• Hundreds of Consultants• Plenty of Ex Toyota Experts• Plenty of Ex Toyota Employees
Why is it so difficult?
Toyota Production System
• Tens of thousands of Books• Thousands of Consultants• Plenty of Ex GE/ Motorola Experts• Plenty of Ex GE/Motorola Employees
Six Sigma
So …… Why is it so difficult?........ Are we all just “Stupid”?
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200613
Brief History of Lean
• The Toyota Production System (TPS) is still unrivaled
• Toyota have recreated process throughout world• Toyota people have been recruited by “Followers”• Every Consultancy on earth does a Lean program
So what are we missing?
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200614
Brief History of Lean
• What you see is the finished product
• What you can analyze is the ingredients
• What you cannot see is the recipe
Problem :
Unlike Coca Cola …. Most practitioners have forgotten the recipe
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200615
Brief History of Lean
• Analogy: Knowledge Of Calculus
– One problem or knowledge of Calculus?
• Competency is knowing how to handle “Things gone wrong”
Basic Thing to do: Recreate the Learning of Lean
Education not Training
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200616
Brief History of Lean
• But there is More:
– The skills are linked… you have to learn them in a particular sequence …
- Addition, Subtraction, Multiplication, Division, Algebra, Geometry, Trigonometry, Then Calculus
Basic Thing to do: Recreate the Learning of Lean
You can customize the process …but if you change it too much…
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200617
• Define– Why it is so difficult to be Lean /Six Sigma
• Measure– Understanding that “They” don’t care about “p values”
• Analyse– How you make change happen
• Implement– What can you set up to get the results
• Control– How you keep it going
Agenda
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200618
Lean Six Sigma as a Strategy
• Hard truth is this:– Shareholders don’t really care if you are Lean or not
- If you are 6 sigma or 2 sigma
• So stop seeing Lean Six Sigma as an overarching strategy– Its in the Toolbox– It’s the way to get the strategy done
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200619
So what do they care about?
• Company strategy– Growth– Profit
…… Basically delivering value..
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200620
TRW Business Environment
Customer Priority
COST1
COST2
COST3
COST4
COST5
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200621
TRW Business Environment
Customer Expectation
1. Increasing Quality (with reducing COST)
2. Better Technology (with reducing COST)
3. Global Reach (with reducing COST)
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200622
TRW Business Environment
To Survive …. need to growTo Grow …. need to give customer what they need
Business Requirement
QUALITYQUALITY
COSTCOST
GLOBAL REACHGLOBAL REACH
INNOVATIONINNOVATION
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200623
Business Strategy
“TRW Automotive has its strategic Vision and Objectives, and anything that we do should be focussed on helping us in delivering the objectives and bringing us closer to the Vision.”
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200624
How it Fits at TRW
Objectives /PrioritiesVision
Global Leader in
Automotive Safety
Best Quality
Lowest Cost
Global Reach
Innovative Technology
Processes
Contract Acquisition
Launch
Order Fulfilment
Methods
BE Roadmap
6 Sigma Lean
Workshops
Hard Work
Leadership LearningCulture:
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200625
• Define– Why it is so difficult to be Lean /Six Sigma
• Measure– Understanding that “They” don’t care about “p values”
• Analyse– How you make change happen
• Implement– What can you set up to get the results
• Control– How you keep it going
Agenda
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200626
Why Change is hard
• Organisations find it difficult to change
Because you run into the “Machiavelli effect”
“There is nothing more difficult to take in hand, more perilous to conduct, or more uncertain in its success, than to take the lead in the introduction of a new order of things. Because the innovator has for enemies all those who have done well under the old conditions, and lukewarm (indifferent, uninterested) defenders in those who may do well under the new.”
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200627
• People Don’t Like Change
– If it’s not their idea!
– If they don’t understand why
– If they don’t see the value
– If they can’t see the whole picture
Why Change is hard
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200628
How to make change Happen
• Where are we going
• Where are we Now
• What do we need to change (next)
• How do we change it
• Commitment to see it through
Only Five Requirements for change:
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200629
Breaking down the barriers to change
Clear Vision• Make it visible, clear & logical
Logical Steps• Meaningful and Long term• Straightforward Plan
Involved Planning• Make the people Architects not victims• Don’t be afraid to talk about the need to make/ save money
Methodical Implementation• Measure Improvement objectively• Measure it consistently• Be open
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200630
• Define– Why it is so difficult to be Lean /Six Sigma
• Measure– Understanding that “They” don’t care about “p values”
• Analyse– How you make change happen
• Implement– What can you set up to get the results
• Control– How you keep it going
Agenda
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200631
Quick Recap of Lessons so far:
1. It’s not an “initiative” thing
2. It’s the Company strategy that’s important not your tool
3. The 5 Change enablers
• Clear Vision
• Honest Assessment of where we are
• Understanding of what has to change next
• Knowledge of how to make change
• Desire to get it done
4. Need to learn as we go
(Don’t teach Calculus to kindergarten)
5. People as architects and builders not as victims
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200632
Roadmap Principles
• Can’t get to world class in one step
• There is a logical path to follow
• We are not all starting from the same place
• We are not creating anything new, others have been there before us
• Uses all the ideas we discussed before
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200633
Business Excellence Development @ TRW
To make effective changes you cannot do everything at once
We needed to have a long term plan, that builds up our ability to handle the changes.
We started back in 1999.Operations Excellence was the first phase.
We are not at the end.We are progressing at a rate based on our ability to absorb the change.
Note:OE – Operations ExcellenceOF – Order FulfilmentBE – Business Excellence
BEEmbedding
Contract AcquisitionRoadmap Development
Launch RoadmapEmbedding
Sales & Business Development
Strategy Training
Launch Deployment& Integration
Launch RoadmapDevelopment
OF RoadmapEmbedding
DFSS Awareness& Training
OF Deployment& Integration
OF RoadmapDevelopment
OE RoadmapEmbedding
6 Sigma Awareness& Training
OEDevelopment
Phase 1
Phase 2
Phase 3
Phase 4
Phase 5
Phase 6
Phase 7
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200634
How Roadmaps Work at TRW
Business Excellence
Realization of “Zero”- Incidents- Defects- Waste
Productionat pace and sequenceof the customer
Operations Excellence Roadmap
Pro c
ess
Maturity
FundamentalsPursue
PerfectionProduct Cells Improvement Pull
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200635
Business Excellence Roadmap
Primary Roadmap
Functional Process Roadmaps - Business Management - Customer Management - Financial Excellence - HR & Development - Information Systems - Operations - Quality Excellence - Supply Chain
“One Company, One Process, One Standard”
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200636
Not enough to have pretty pictures
• Actions need to happenActions need to be seen to happen
• Benefits need to be forthcomingBenefits need to be seen to be forthcoming
• Benefits need to be realBenefits need to be seen to be real
If I can’t see it…. It didn’t happen
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200637
“Devil is in the Detail”
Roadmap: Phase Descriptions
Phase: Step NarrativeElement DescriptionSupporting Materials
Step Plan: Specific ActionsAssessment Criteria
Implementation : Metrics and Audits
Business Excellence Roadmap
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200638
Infrastructure
• Infrastructure is a “Necessary Evil”– Any business of more than 150 people needs infrastructure– Sharing across large numbers of people is key challenge– Issue relates to basic “Human nature”
• Why would I put in effort to benefit someone I don’t know?
• Why would I take “advice” from someone I don’t know?• Infrastructure needs to have minimal input and maximum
output…– Need to get out more than I put in!
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200639
Business Excellence Web Site
This site provides access to:• BE Notifications and Updates• The BE Materials Library• The Roadmaps• BE Glossary• Forums• BE System / e-QOS• Business Manual• Summary of Implementation Progress
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200640
Business Excellence Web Site / “BE Status”
Web based packs allow online…
• Activity planning and implementation• Recording of sub actions (optional)• Provide targets and actuals for velocity
metrics• Deployment of change – message
within packs• Access to supporting materials via
linked actions• Modification time, date stamp• Auto step plan forecast creation• RST Acceptance recording• System automatically takes a ‘capture’
status of businesses every 6 months
2003
2003
2003
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200641
Web Site / “On Line reporting within System”
Utility ReportAllows access to various planning and
Implementation reports
Recording of Audits
Access to Checklist Library
User Account reports
Pack and Checklist Implementation
Metrics
Velocity metrics and compliance metrics
BE Data View allows graphical view of Businesses Excellence Implementation
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200642
Basic Metrics
• Basic Metrics− Std 13 Metrics
• All Plants− All same measures− Visible
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200644
Basic Metrics
Note: Dummy Information, For Training purposes only
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200646
Actions speak louder than words
• Delivering value is the key• DWYSYWD
• Planning should be like making a promise• You Keep promises
• Setting the expectation forces better planning
• Making the plan visible makes it harder to “walk away”
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200648
What Am I Promising to deliver ?
Note: Dummy Information , For Training purposes only
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200649
What Am I Promising to Deliver ?
Note: Dummy Information , For Training purposes only
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200650
• Define– Why it is so difficult to be Lean /Six Sigma
• Measure– Understanding that “They” don’t care about “p values”
• Analyse– How you make change happen
• Implement– What can you set up to get the results
• Control– How you keep it going
Agenda
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200651
Measuring the “Money”
• Clear Deliverables– Targets & action Plans– Implementation requirements – Expectations
• Clear Rules for Measurement– Project Benefit validation– Roadmap Status validation– Velocity Metrics– Audits & assessments
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200654
Measurement Hard Points
• Individual Task Achievement– Single repository– Consistent definition of improvement
- Hard/Soft/Enabler- Moneybelt validation (Named/formal)
• Measure Annualised Saving and Impact Date– Drives implementation speed– Reinforces time value– Simple
• Financial Accounting Reconciliation– Validated projects drive reconciliation
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200655
Individual Project Measurement
CISDatabase
OPOPPlanning Process
eQOSDatabase
Project /Workshop
Activity
VerifiedBenefits
VarianceAnalysis
OP Plan Reconciliation
Detailed Planningand Forecasting
Benefits Verified as Achieved
Monthly Variance to OP
Monthly Snapshot for Comparison
to OP
Reconciled & Agreed OP Plan
PlanningActuals
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200656
Are my actions working? - Projects
Note: Dummy Information , For Training purposes only
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200657
Create the cycle
Good planning & execution
Excellent visible results
Buy in and desire to excel
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200658
What we have now
• Structured Change Program – 97 Roadmap Step plans – 68 Roadmap Step plans documented– 1300 Roadmap implementation actions documented– Supporting training and education– Supporting materials and stds
• Discipline & Drive– 1700+ Roadmap steps planned for completion in 2006– 7000+ implementation actions planned in 2006
For Our Order Fulfilment Process
Similar level of activity for the Launch Process
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200659
What do we put in to it
• Dedicated Specialist Resources– Approx 400 Full Time Change Agents– Approx 200 Roadmap Subject Matter Experts– 9000 part time Green Belts– High participation in Lean Workshop events
• Discipline & Drive– Over 4k activities each year– Planning 6-12 months ahead– Tactics & Strategy
•
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200660
Business Excellence
Change needs :
A Consistent platform – BE & The Roadmaps
Processes & Tools - Lean, Six Sigma
Practitioners – LPO’s BB’s
Believers – Plant Managers, Ops Directors, VP’s , COO & CEO
What makes change at TRW happen
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200661
What do we get out of it
• Drives Behaviours
• Focuses on doing
• Improving not posing
• Best expected to provide leadership for others
•
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200663
Conclusion
• Business Excellence provides a methodology for improvement in each of our key processes.
• Due to BE new ideas and concepts were introduced as we move forward and have capacity to absorb.
• The overall direction of how we create and manage change has been thought out and has a plan.One Company, One Process, One Standard
• Visible Change lets you see the money!
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200664
• Effectively integrating strategy-focused Lean/ Six Sigma - Aligning your program with your company strategy
Don’t try and create a strategy for Lean Six Sigma. Find out what the Strategy is and work out how you can help.
• The practicalities of moving from a tactical to a strategic perspective
Stop looking for problems that fit your tool. Build the framework to apply the right tool to the problem.
• Linkage of continuous improvement to strategic planning to support the long-term objectives of the business
Make Lean Six Sigma the way we solve our problems and the way we achieve our strategic actions.
Conclusion
© TRW Automotive Inc. 200665
Q & A