TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS
DEBT HAPPENS:
how to get out of debt, live debt-free, and never look back
Stephen T. CraigBankruptcy AttorneyProfessional Debt Negotiator
303-520-3414www.boulderbankruptcy.comwww.tridentdebtsolutions.com
Copyright © 2012 Trident Debt Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS2
Introduction
My law practice has been limited to debt counseling and debt relief since 1994.
I have represented more than 3,000 individuals and small businesses in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court.
I founded Trident Debt Solutions, Inc., in 2000 in order to help individuals achieve debt relief through non-bankruptcy means.
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS3
Overview
The goals of this class are to:
Explain all of the different options for getting out of debt and the pros and cons of each option
Discuss the most common money mistakes people make — and how to avoid them
Teach you how to turn the tables and go from debt to prosperity
In addition, you can also sign up for a free consultation on how to create your personal strategy for becoming debt-free.
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS4
Definitions
Unsecured Debt: Debt that has no collateral associated with it. Examples include credit card debt, medical bills, and bounced checks.
Secured Debt: Debt that is secured by collateral. Examples include mortgages, home equity loans, and car loans.
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS5
Buying on Credit
Interest rates and monthly payment amounts matter $10,000 at 19.99%
Monthly payment of 3% ($300): you’ll pay a total of $14,715 ($4,715 in interest), and it will take 4.2 years to pay off.
Monthly payment of 2% ($200): you’ll pay a total of $21,681 ($11,681 in interest), and it will take about 9 years to pay off.
$10,000 at 28.99%
Monthly payment of 3% ($300): you’ll pay a total of $20,563 ($10,563 in interest), and it will take 5.7 years to pay off.
Monthly payment of 2% ($200): won’t even cover the interest — you’ll never be able to pay this off!
Bottom Line: Pay at least 3% and call your credit card companies to get rates lowered. Threaten to close the account if they will not
reduce the rates; transfer balances to cards with lower interest rates.
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS6
Sizing Up the ProblemThere’s a couple ways to look at it:
Can you pay back 3% of your debt per month?
Another way to look at it: Need to understand the relationship between total amount of unsecured debt and your income
The tipping point: Approximate point at which total debt exceeds annual income (e.g., annual salary of $40,000, credit card balances of $40,000)
If you are beyond the tipping point, look at bankruptcy options
If you are not at the tipping point, let’s look at budgeting and improving your ability to accelerate the repayment of debt
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS7
The Tipping Point: Example Calvin
Income: $40,000
Credit card debt: $40,000
Take-home pay: $2,300/month (estimated)
3% payment: $1,200/month
Calvin has reached the tipping point and should seriously consider bankruptcy options.
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS8
The Tipping Point: Example Hobbes
Income: $50,000
Credit card debt: $35,000
Take-home pay: $2,900/month (estimated)
3% payment: $1,050/month
Hobbes hasn’t reached the tipping point and can look at ways to adjust his budget and accelerate
repayment of debt.
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS9
Knowledge Is PowerWhere Does the Money Go?
You have no control over your finances until you know where your money goes
Keep track of every dollar spent for two months — cash, checks, online bill-pay, debit cards — everything!
Don’t leave anything out, no matter how small
Rule of thumb: Combined cost of mortgage/rent and car payment should not exceed 40% of net monthly income
Nothing happens without a plan
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS10
Knowledge Is Power
Finding the “Latte Factor”
Coffee shop/snacks Eating out Magazines Gifts Lottery tickets Parking Cash-register impulse buys ATM fees Bank fees/late charges Bottled water Cigarettes
What seems like “just a couple bucks”
here and there can add up to more than you
think!
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS11 11
Little Things Mean a Lot
• Skip the $5 latte three times a week: save $15/week — $780 a year
Coffee Shop
• Skip eating out $15 twice a week: save $30/week — $1,560 a year
Diner
• Resist the urge to buy a paperback in the grocery store checkout: save $8/week — $420/year
Check-Out
Just by cutting down a little bit on your Starbucks habit, taking your lunch to work a couple days a week, and
dusting off your library card, you can save almost $2,800 a year!
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS12
Reducing Your Monthly Overhead Keep monthly recurring expenses as low as possible
Insurance
Rent
Premium cable
Phone bills
Car payment and related auto insurance
Taxes: increase your exemptions if you usually get a refund — get more cash on your paycheck
Don’t be “house poor” — reduce these payments if you can
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS14 14
Non-Bankruptcy Options
Consumer Credit Counseling
The “Snowball” Method
Debt Settlement
1
2
3
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS15
Consumer Credit Counseling
“Non-profit” agency works out an agreement with your creditors to lower your interest rate.
CCCS consolidates your debt, and you make one monthly payment to them.
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS16
Consumer Credit Counseling
Pros
Lower interest rate
Lower payments
One monthly payment
Cons
The non-profit myth
3–7 year plan
110–140% payback
Credit is damaged
Not all debt is eligible: payday loans and student loans aren’t eligible. Broken leases, repossessed vehicles, and bounced-check fees are usually not eligible
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS17
Optimal Candidate for CCC
Almost no one, but it can be okay for someone who…
Makes an average income
Has credit card or medical debt of less than $20,000
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS18
The “Snowball” Method*
A debt-reduction strategy that involves systematically paying off debts by attacking the smallest ones first.
Each month, make your minimum payments on larger debts and make as large a payment as you can on the smallest debt. Because it’s smaller, it will be paid off quickly.
When that debt is paid off, take the money you had been using to pay it off and add it to your monthly payment on what is now the smallest debt. Continue in this fashion until all your debts are paid.
* Coin phrased by Dave Ramsey, see www.daveramsey.com for more infoA related method is to systematically pay off your debts
beginning with the one with the highest interest rate first. When that card is paid off, take the money you had been using
on that debt and apply it to the debt with what is now the highest interest rate, and so on. (All while continuing to make your minimum monthly payments on all your other debts.)
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS19
The “Snowball” Method
Pros
Relatively rapid debt reduction
Allows you to focus on one debt at a time
Can be psychologically empowering to see your list of debts get shorter, quickly
Works with income you already make
Improves your credit rating
Cons
Requires strict adherence to budget — discipline
Pay off the full amount owed (no discounts)
Comment
Paying off debts with the highest interest rates first can save you money in the long run but it can be harder to
remain motivated.
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS20
The “Snowball” Method
Optimal Candidate for the Snowball Method: Someone Who… Has a lot of discipline
Is determined to keep a good credit rating
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS21
Debt Settlement
Also referred to as debt negotiation, debt settlement is the art of negotiating with your creditors so they will accept less than the full amount of the debt owed to them, generally 50–65 cents on the dollar, in full satisfaction of the debt.
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS22
Debt Settlement: What’s Involved
Trust Account• Instead of continuing to make payments
to your creditors, you fund this account with either a lump sum of money, monthly payments of at least 3% of your total debt, or a combination of both.
Negotiation• With the funds in your trust account as
leverage, your debt settlement attorney negotiates with your creditors to get them to accept less than the total amount they are owed.
Lump-Sum Payment• Once a settlement agreement is
reached with your creditors, the funds in your trust account are used to pay the agreed-upon amounts in a lump sum.
1
2
3
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS23
Debt Settlement
Pros
Compromise with creditors
Repay only 50–60 cents on the dollar
Rapid debt reduction (24 months or less)
No bankruptcy notation on your credit report
Cons
Damages credit — may take up to 2 years after being debt-free for credit rating to bounce back
No court protection against potential creditor lawsuits (although an attorney can prioritize which debts to settle first to minimize risk of lawsuits)
Possible tax consequences
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS24
Debt Settlement
Optimal Candidate for Debt Settlement: Someone Who… Has primarily unsecured debt such as credit card debt
and unsecured lines of credit
Does not want to file bankruptcy — it’s typically used by people who have a lot of debt but make too much money or have too many assets to file bankruptcy
Wants to achieve debt relief rapidly (24 months or less)
Can raise 50% of the total amount of credit card debt within 24 months (in either a lump sum, monthly payments equal to 2–3% of the debt amount, or some combination of the two)
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS25
Debt Settlement Example
Hobbes Hobbes has $40,000 of credit card debt.
He has a lump sum of money available and gives $24,000 to his attorney to deposit in his trust account.
Within six months, his attorney has completed negotiations with all of Hobbes’ creditors, settling the debts for $22,500 — a savings of nearly 44%!
Hobbes is now out of debt and receives a refund of $1,500 from his attorney.
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS26
Debt Settlement Example
Calvin Calvin has $80,000 of debt consisting of credit cards
and unsecured lines of credit.
He does not have a lump sum of money available but can put $2,000/month in his trust account if he stops making his regular credit card payments.
Calvin makes 23 monthly payments and is out of debt for $46,000.
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS27
What If You Do Nothing?
Understanding the Collection Process Consider the stress of hiding from creditors
May be advisable if the statute of limitations on the debt is nearly up (varies by state: in Colorado, it’s 6 years)
Can use Cease Communications letter to stop creditor calls (doesn’t stop collection process)
Wage garnishment in Colorado: 25% of net income
Social Security income cannot be garnished
No one can garnish your wages without a court order
If court issues a judgment against you, creditor can garnish not only your wages but also your bank account, and can put a lien on any real estate you own
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS29
Chapter 7 Bankruptcy: Overview
Also referred to as a “liquidation” bankruptcy, Chapter 7 bankruptcy involves filing a petition asking the court to discharge your unsecured debts.
Chapter 7 bankruptcy is usually a good option for people who have high debt and limited income or assets.
It is intended to give individuals a fresh start.
“Exempt assets” — you can keep limited assets when their value falls below pre-established thresholds.*
“Non-exempt assets” — assets that exceed the allowed values — are sold, and the proceeds are distributed to creditors.
Any debts that remain after the assets are liquidated and creditors paid are then discharged by the court.
IRAs are exempt and cannot be attached by creditors.
* http://www.thebankruptcysite.org/exemptions/colorado.html
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS30
Chapter 7 Bankruptcy: Process
After meeting with your attorney, you stop making your unsecured payments.
You attorney gives you a packet to fill out, which will detail your income, expenses, assets, and liabilities.
From this packet, a Voluntary Petition is filed with the U.S. Bankruptcy Court.
6 weeks later you have a short hearing with the court-appointed Bankruptcy Trustee.
60 days later you receive a discharge order relieving you of your unsecured debts.
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS31
Chapter 7 Bankruptcy
Pros
Receive a “fresh start”
All unsecured debt is wiped out completely
Emotional weight is lifted quickly
Immediately stops all collection activity against you
Can usually keep home, car and other assets
Cons
Will remain on your credit for 10 years, but the practical effect is more like 3 years
You surrender non-exempt assets, if any
You must come to grips with it emotionally
Student loans, most taxes are non-dischargeable
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS32
Chapter 7 Bankruptcy
Optimal Candidate for Chapter 7 Bankruptcy: Someone Who… Has below-median income (varies by state*).
(Gross monthly income is calculated by taking your income for the six months prior to filing, doubling it, and dividing by 12)
Has a high amount of debt (more than $20,000) and no reasonable expectation of ability to pay
Has no significant assets other than those allowed by state exemptions
* http://www.justice.gov/ust/eo/bapcpa/20111101/bci_data/median_income_table.htm
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS33
Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Example
Dilbert
Dilbert has $32,000 of credit card and other unsecured debt.
He has a car worth $15,000 with a $12,000 loan against it. He also has a house worth $260,000 and a mortgage of $200,000.
He earns $40,000 per year and has no children or spouse.
Dilbert also has a 401(k) worth $14,000.
Dilbert files bankruptcy, keeps his house, his car, and his 401(k).
Dilbert discharges (eliminates) all of his unsecured debt.
Dilbert has a “fresh start.”
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS34
Chapter 13 Bankruptcy: Overview Often referred to as “reorganization” or “repayment”
bankruptcy, Chapter 13 bankruptcy is a federal court process in which individuals are able to repay all or some of their debts through an interest-free payment plan over a three- or five-year period.
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS35
Chapter 13 Bankruptcy
Pros
Forces a repayment plan on creditors
You are not asked to surrender any assets — can work to save a home in foreclosure
Can work well if you have IRS tax debt
You may get a discount on your payback to unsecured debts
In some cases, you may be able to discharge an unsecured second mortgage (e.g., fair market value $200K, first mortgage $210K, second mortgage $50K)
Cons
On your credit report for 10 years (same as Chapter 7), but harder to rebuild good credit than after Chapter 7
Unlikely to succeed It is a “ramen noodle”
plan — requires strict discipline
Comment
Other (non-bankruptcy) methods work as well as or
better than Chapter 13
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS36
Chapter 13 Bankruptcy
Optimal Candidate for Chapter 13 Bankruptcy: Someone Who… Has high income (above median)
and/or
Has significant assets whose value exceeds Chapter 7 exemptions (and might be liquidated in a Chapter 7)
and/or
Owes back taxes to the IRS
and/or
Owns property and is trying to stop a foreclosure
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS38
Debt: Avoid It Like the Plague
This should be your mantra
Live simply and your wealth will grow
If you can’t pay for it in cash don’t buy it
Don’t borrow to look rich
Example: $2,000 TV – financed at 29.9% interest at $60/month — really costs you $4,300
Compare that to a craigslist purchase
Use student loans with caution
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS39
Psychology of Spending
Thinking it through: avoid the “sugar high” of impulse purchases 24-hour rule: If you see something you want to buy,
wait 24 hours. If you still feel a need for the item, then buy it.
Don’t use credit to buy something you won’t have when you get the bill (e.g., eating out, movies, concert tickets)
Reduce trips to places like the mall, Costco, Target, etc. (where you go in for one thing and come out with five)
Resist the urge to buy something you see at the check-out stand — point-of-purchase impulse buying
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS40
Psychology of Spending
Intention — Ask yourself these questions: Do I need this? Or do I want this?
Who am I trying to impress? (“keeping up with Joneses”)
Will this purchase improve the quality of my life?
Can I buy this used for half-price?
Am I paying for form over function?
Develop a “frugal is good” mindset versus need for instant gratification —
be “value conscious”!
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS41
Marginal Utility Theory
The most important rule of spending! It’s about the amount of benefit or value derived from
consuming one additional unit of a product or service – in other words, whether the relative benefit or value of spending more for something is proportionate to the increased cost
Illustration: Is a $20,000 car twice as useful as a $10,000 car? Is an $80,000 car four times as useful?
Illustration: Does music sound three times better out of $900 speakers than out of $300 speakers? Will you get three times as much enjoyment from the $900 speakers?
This bears repeating: Be “value conscious”!
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS42
Pay For Cars With Cash
Don’t be “car poor” Using cash to buy cars is a common denominator
among wealthy people Having a high car payment is a common denominator
among people filing for bankruptcy Depreciating assets (cars, mobile/motor homes, boats,
ATVs, etc.) are not “investments”: by the time they are paid off, they have lost a large portion of their original value
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS43
Using Credit: Basics
If you must have a credit card, never have more than three
Avoid approaching the credit limit on your credit card or line of credit
Pay the full balance every month
Dispute any item you do not agree with
Must dispute with all three credit-reporting bureaus
Experian
TransUnion
Equifax
Focusing on FICO score: the old way of thinking
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS44
Money Mistakes to Avoid
Refinancing your home to pull out cash
Asking someone to co-sign a loan; being a co-signor on a loan
Getting friends involved in your finances (borrowing money from them, loaning money to them)
Cashing-out your IRA — consult an attorney and/or CPA first
Taking advice from a commissioned sales person
“Investing” in depreciating assets such as mobile homes and cars
Owing the IRS
Taking out a “payday loan”
Assuming spouse debt
Maintaining an “overdraft” line of credit
Having more than three credit cards
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS46
Pay Yourself First
Developing a Savings Plan Save 10% of everything you earn
Make savings automatic
Squirrel money away where you can’t get to it easily
Annually compounded interest dramatically increases the value of your savings.
Example: $10/day for 20 years, 10% return = $227,881!
Rule of 72 (72 divided by rate of return = # of years it will take to double money)
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS47
IRAs and 401(k)
Invest the maximum amount allowed by law, every year
Employer-matched 401(k): it’s a “no-brainer”
Do not cash them in to pay off credit cards
Tax consequences of early withdrawals
The amazing one-person 401(k) for self-employed
Don’t put more than 20% of your 401(k) in your employer’s company stock
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS48
Understanding Mortgages
Good strategies Fixed-rate mortgages
Short-term mortgages
Income tax deductions
Paying extra on your mortgage
Bi-weekly payment plan
Paying your mortgage off
Not-so-good strategies Variable-rate mortgages
Long-term (40- or 50-year) mortgages
Interest-only mortgages
Mortgage insurance
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS49
Habits of Financially Savvy People Pay for cars with cash Pay yourself first Have two to three sources of income (look for “passive”
income) Make additional payments on mortgage principal Invest in education, other ways to increase earning
capacity Reinvest profits Get paid for results not by the hour Think long-term rather than short-term Keep monthly overhead low — watch small expenses Avoid debt like the plague!
TRIDENT DEBT SOLUTIONS50
A Word on Greed
Revisiting the theory of marginal utility Money has its own diminishing returns
More is not necessarily better
Strive for simplicity
Frugal is good
Be value-conscious