economic freedom of the arab world 2012 annual report

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    1/74

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    2/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f` }dh Kzkj Q`zgm

    :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    ^kghf Jhb Bk~~hz Kg C~fkcgs' Kyykb Kg&Jx~kcmc'

    Fcaxhg Nhzukb}h~ % Ezhm FnFkd`b

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c b `z Gcjhz}s

    Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b @fkb

    Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    :?;:

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    3/74

    cc / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    N`pszca :?;: js h Ezk~hz Cb~cxh" Kgg zca~ zh~hzuhm" B` pkz ` c~ j``l fks jh zhpz`mxnhm cb

    kbs fkbbhz qk~`huhz qc`x qzchb phzfc~~c`b htnhp cb h nk~h ` jzch {x`kc`b~ hfj`mchm cb

    nzccnkg kzcngh~ kbm zhuchq~"

    ]h kx`z~ ` c~ j``l kuh q`zlhm cbmhphbmhbgs kbm `pcbc`b~ htpzh~~hm js hf kzh' hzh`zh' hcz

    `qb' kbm m` b` bhnh~~kzcgs zhhn h p`~cc`b ` h Ezk~hz Cb~cxh' `z h uchq~ ` h ~xpp`zhz~'

    zx~hh~' `z ~k ` h Ezk~hz Cb~cxh" ]c~ pxjgcnkc`b cb b` qks cfpgch~ k h Ezk~hz Cb~cxh' c~

    ~xpp`zhz~' zx~hh~' `z ~k kzh cb ku`z `' `z `pp`~h h pk~~kah `' kbs jcgg< `z k hs ~xpp`z `z `p&

    p`~h kbs pkzcnxgkz p`gccnkg pkzs `z nkbmcmkh"

    ]h pzcbncpkg kx`z ` c~ pxjgcnkc`b' ^kghf Jhb Bk~~hz Kg C~fkcgs' c~ pz`h~~c`bkggs cbu`guhm cb h

    pz`f`c`b ` cbuh~fhb cb @fkb" ]hzh`zh' ` ku`cm k n`bcn ` cbhzh~' h htnx~hm cf~hg z`f

    nkgnxgkcba h cbmht `xa h xbmhz``l h jxgl ` h kbkgs~c~"

    Mkh ` c~~xh9 B`uhfjhz :?;:

    N`uhz mh~cab js Jcgg Zks

    _xjgc~hz9 Kg&Fkz`~k `z _xjgc~cba' _zh~~ ^hzucnh~' kbm Cb`zfkc`b

    Kmmzh~~9 Jg`nl 1>33' ^zhh :4 jzkbncba z`f ^zhh 3' Fxllkkf' Nkcz`' Hasp

    H&fkcg9 fkdz`~kOfkdz`~k"n`f

    Nc}h }dc~ pxjgcnk}c`b

    Kx`z~9 ^kghf Jhb Bk~~hz Kg C~fkcgs' Kyykb Kg&Jx~kcmc' Fcaxhg Nhzukbh~' kbm Ezhm FnFk`b

    cgh9Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    _xjgc~hz9 Ezk~hz Cb~cxh

    Mkh ` pxjgcnkc`b9 :?;:

    Mcackg n`ps kukcgkjgh z`f 7d}}p9//qqq"zhh}dhq`zgm"n`f2 kbm 7d}}p9//qqq"zk~hzcb~}c}x}h"`za2"

    Nk}kg`axcba Cb`zfk}c`b

    Jhb Bk~~hz Kg C~fkcgs' ^kghf' ;384

    Hn`b`fcn zhhm`f ` h Kzkj q`zgm9 :?;: kbbxkg zhp`z / ^kghf Jhb Bk~~hz Kg C~fkcgs'

    Kyykb Kg&Jx~kcmc' Fcaxhg Nhzukbh~' kbm Ezhm FnFk`b

    C^JB 314&?&44318&:5?&>$:?;: hmcc`b#

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    4/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / ccc

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    N`b}hb}~

    Kj`x} }dh Kx}d`z~ / cu

    Knlb`qghmafhb}~ / uc

    Kj`x} }dh N`&pxjgc~dhz~ / ucc

    Cb}z`mxn}c`b / ;

    Zh~hkznd b hn`b`fcn zhhm`f / =

    N`xb}zs ~xffkzch~ / 1

    ]dh cbmht ` Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f cb }dh Kzkj Q`zgm / ;5

    Mk}k }kjgh~ / :;

    Kpphbmct9 Htpgkbk}`zs b`}h~ kbm mk}k ~`xznh~ / =5

    Zhhzhbnh~ / 81

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    5/74

    cu / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Kj`x} }dh kx}d`z~

    ^kghf Jhb Bk~~hz Kg C~fkcgs^kghf Jhb Bk~~hz Kg C~fkcgs `gm~ mhazhh~ cb hghn`ffxbcnkc`b~' Gcjhzkg

    Kz~' Cbmx~zckg Hbacbhhzcba' Jx~cbh~~ Kmfcbc~zkc`b' Fkbkahfhb kbm

    _cg`~`ps z`f xbcuhz~cch~ cb Xbchm Lcbam`f kbm h Xbchm ^kh~" Kg

    C~fkcgs q`zlhm k h _xjgcn H~kjgc~fhb `z Cbmx~zckg H~kh~ $_HCH# z`f

    ;34= ` ;335 k~ h Fkbkacba Mczhn`z" Cb ;335' h qk~ kpp`cbhm k~ hMhpxs Nkczfkb kbm Hthnxcuh _zh~cmhb h @fkbc Nhbzh `z Cbuh~fhb

    _z`f`c`b kbm Htp`z Mhuhg`pfhb qhzh h n`bcbxh~ ` ~hzuh cb h ~kfh

    nkpkncs" Dh c~ h `xbmhz kbm nkczfkb Cbhzbkc`bkg Zh~hkzn E`xbmkc`b

    kbm k fhfjhz ` h Ezk~hz Cb~cxh~ J`kzm ` Mczhn`z~" Kg C~fkcgs k~ pxj&

    gc~hm ~huhzkg pkphz~ `b h ~xjihn ` nz`~~ nxgxzh' fkbkahfhb' kbm h

    hn`b`fs' cbngxmcba q` j``l~ `b n`zp`zkh nxgxzh" Dh kg~` ~hzuh~ k~ k j`kzm

    fhfjhz fkbs pzcukh n`fpkbch~ cb h hgm bkbnckg ~hzucnh~ kbm hbhzas

    `b c~ phz~`bkg nkpkncs"

    ^kghf Jhb Bk~~hz Kg C~fkcgs c~ pz`h~~c`bkggs cbu`guhm cb h pz`f`c`b

    ` cbuh~fhb cb @fkb" ]hzh`zh' ` ku`cm k n`bcn ` cbhzh~' h htnx~hm

    cf~hg z`f nkgnxgkcba h cbmht `xa h xbmhz``l h jxgl h kbkgs~c~"

    Kyykb jcb [k~~cf Kg&Jx~kcmcKyykb jcb [k~~cf Kg&Jx~kcmc' q`zlhm k~ kb hn`b`fc~ k ~huhzkg mhpkzfhb~

    zhghukb ` zh~hkzn' cbuh~fhb~' kbm fkzlhcba cb @fkb' k~ qhgg k~ q`zlcba k~

    h NH@ h Cbhzbkc`bkg Zh~hkzn E`xbmkc`b cb @fkb' qcn c~ kb cbmhphb&

    mhb' b`b&pz` cbl kbl" Dh `gm~ k mhazhh cb Hn`b`fcn~ z`f xgkb [kj``~

    Xbcuhz~cs cb @fkb kbm kb FJK z`f h Xbcuhz~cs ` ^zkngsmh cb ^n`gkbm"

    Fcaxhg Nhzukb}h~Fcaxhg Kbahg Nhzukbh~ c~ kb hn`b`fc~ q` xbmhzklh~ cbhzbkc`bkg zh~hkzn

    `z h Ezk~hz Cb~cxh" Dh `gm~ Jknhg`z~ kbm Fk~hz~ mhazhh~ cb Hn`b`fcn~

    z`f h Xbcuhz~cs ` htk~ k Hg _k~` kbm k~ ghnxzhm k Ukbchz N`gghah< h

    nxzzhbgs ghnxzh~ k DHN F`bzhkg Jx~cbh~~ ^n``g" Dh qk~ h n`&`zmcbk`z

    ` h :??4/:??3' :??3/:?;?' :?;?/:?;;' kbm :?;;/:?;: hmcc`b~ ` hEzk~hz

    Cb~}c}x}h Kbbxkg ^xzuhs ` Fcbcba N`fpkbch~< h :??3' :?;?' :?;;' kbm :?;:

    hmcc`b~ ` hEzk~hz Cb~}c}x}h Ag`jkg _h}z`ghxf ^xzuhs< kbm ` h :?;? kbm

    :?;; hmcc`b~ `Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f ` }dh Kzkj Q zgm"

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    6/74

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    7/74

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    8/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / ucc

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Kj`x} }dh n`&pxjgc~dhz~

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b `z Gcjhz}s

    ]h Ezchmzcn Bkxfkbb E`xbmkc`b `z Gcjhzs $EBE# c~ kb cbmhphbmhb' b`b&

    pz`' b`ba`uhzbfhbkg `zakbcykc`b k c~ n`ffchm ` pz`f`cba gcjhzkg

    p`gcns kbm p`gccn~" E`xbmhm cb Ahzfkbs cb ;384' h E`xbmkc`b k~ q`b k

    zhpxkc`b `z pz`f`cba zhhm`f q`zgmqcmh" nzhkh kb `phb ~`nchs' EBE c~ axcmhm js h pzcbncpgh~ ` Gcjhzkgc~f

    kbm c~ fh~~kah fxxkg `ghzkbnh kbm knnhpkbnh mcuhz~cs" C~ n`zh n`bnhp~

    ~xn k~ h pz`hnc`b xfkb zca~' h kppgcnkc`b h zxgh gkq' gcjhzkg

    mhf`nzkns' kbm k zhh&fkzlh hn`b`fs kuh pz`uhb z`xa`x h nhbxzch~

    k Gcjhzkgc~f `hz~ kppz`pzckh ~`gxc`b~ `z h pzh~hb kbm h xxzh cb

    pxjgcn kbm phz~`bkg gch" @xz cbhb~cuh q`zl cb p`gccnkg hmxnkc`b' p`gccnkg n`b&

    ~xgkbns' zkcbcba' kbm mckg`axh c~ nkzzchm x cb Ahzfkbs kbm xz enh~ cb `uhz

    8? n`xbzch~ q`zgmqcmh"

    Qhj~ch9 7d}}p9// qqq"zhcdhc}"`za2"

    Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b

    ]h Cbhzbkc`bkg Zh~hkzn E`xbmkc`b $CZE#' ^xgkbkh ` @fkb' qk~ h~kj&

    gc~hm cb :??8 k~ k b`b&a`uhzbfhbkg' cbmhphbmhb' b`b&pz` cbl kbl

    jk~hm cb @fkb ` n`bmxn zh~hkzn `b m`fh~cn kbm cbhzbkc`bkg hn`b`fcn

    c~~xh~ qc hfpk~c~ b h Kzkj Q`zgm" ]h CZE k~ ~h c~ zh~hkzn kbm pxjgcn&

    kkcz~ kahbmk `b k n`gghackg jk~c~' zhgscba `b h cbpx ` c~ zh~hkznhz ~k' c~

    hmc`zckg j`kzm' kbm c~ hbc`z Ehgg`q~" C fkcbkcb~ k q`zlcba kzzkbahfhb qc

    a`uhzbfhbkg kbm b`b&a`uhzbfhbkg zakbcykc`b~ cb h zhac`b kbm hz pkz~

    ` h q`zgm" ]h CZE c~ h zhac`bkg fhfjhz h Ezk~hz Cb~cxh~ Hn`b`fcnEzhhm`f Bhq`zl"

    ]h uc~c`b ` CZE c~ ` nzhkh qhkg kbm i`j~ z`xa pz`f`c`b ` hn`&

    b`fcn zhhm`f" C~ fc~~c`b c~ ` fhk~xzh' zh~hkzn' kbm n`ffxbcnkh ` k ag`jkg

    kxmchbnh h cfpkn n`fphccuh fkzlh~ qc zhh hn`b`fcn p`gcnch~ b h

    qhgkzh cbmcucmxkg~"

    ]h J`kzm ` zx~hh~ ` h CZE n`b~c~~ ` ca&pz`gh pzcukh&~hn`z

    fhfjhz~ z`f mchzhb zakbcykc`b~" ]h CZE k~ cbcckhm h h~kjgc~fhb

    k bhq`zl ` knkmhfcn zh~hkznhz~ ` kncgckh zh~hkzn pz`ihn~' qcn qcgg hgp

    cb c~ hbmhku`z ` zh~hkzn hn`b`fcn c~~xh~ khncba h mkcgs gch cbmcucmxkg~"

    Qhj~ch9 7d}}p9//qqq"cz`fkb"`za/2"

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    9/74

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    10/74

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / ;

    Cb}z`mxn}c`b

    Hn`b`fcn zhhm`f c~ h hthb ` qcn `bh nkb pxz~xh hn`b`fcn kncucs qc&

    `x cbhzhzhbnh z`f a`uhzbfhb" Hn`b`fcn zhhm`f c~ jxcg xp`b phz~`bkg

    n`cnh' u`gxbkzs htnkbah' h zca ` lhhp qk s`x hkzb' kbm h ~hnxzcs `

    `bh~ pz`phzs zca~" ]h fhnkbcn~ ` hn`b`fcn zhhm`f kzh hk~s ` xbmhz&

    ~kbm" Kbs zkb~knc`b zhhgs hbhzhm cb` fx~ jhbh j` pkzch~" Kbs zkb~kn&

    c`b k m`h~ b` jhbh j` pkzch~ q`xgm jh zhihnhm js h pkzs k q`xgmn`fh xp ~`z" ]c~ k~ n`b~h{xhbnh~ z`xa`x h hn`b`fs" N`b~xfhz~

    q` kzh zhh ` n``~h qcgg `bgs jh kzknhm js ~xphzc`z {xkgcs kbm pzcnh" K

    pz`mxnhz fx~ n`b~kbgs cfpz`uh h pzcnh kbm {xkgcs htc~cba pz`mxn~ z

    cbuhb bhq pz`mxn~" Qc`x c~' nx~`fhz~ qcgg b` zhhgs hbhz cb` zkb~kn&

    c`b~ qc h pz`mxnhz" Fkbs jcggc`b~ fxxkggs jhbhnckg zkb~knc`b~ nnxz

    huhzs mks' p`qhzcba h msbkfcn k ~pxz~ cbnzhk~hm pz`mxncucs kbm pz`~phz&

    cs z`xa`x h hn`b`fs"

    ]c~ c~ h bcb zhp`z b hn`b`fcn zhhm`f cb h Kzkj q`zgm" ]h z~

    qk~ pxjgc~hm js h ~kfh kx`z~ cb h Kzkj Q`zgm N`fph}c}cuhbh~~ Zhp`z}

    :??8 $G`phy&Ngkz`~ kbm ^nqkj' :??8#" ]h ~hn`bm kbm ~xj~h{xhb hmcc`b~

    qhzh pxjgc~hm js h Cbhzbkc`bkg Zh~hkzn E`xbmkc`b $CZE# @fkb kbm h

    Ezk~hz Cb~cxh" Cb :??4' h Ezchmzcn Bkxfkbb E`xbmkc`b `z Gcjhzs' Nkcz`

    `enh' kg~` jhnkfh k n`&pxjgc~hz"

    ]h cbmht cb c~ hmcc`b kmm~ mkk `z :?;?' h f`~ zhnhb shkz `z

    qcn mkk kzh kukcgkjgh" K~ qhgg' h ~n`zh~ `z pzhuc`x~ shkz~ kuh jhhb zh&

    nkgnxgkhm x~cba zhuc~hm mkk z`f h Q`zgm Jkbl `z c~ M`cba Jx~cbh~~

    kbm Q`zgm Mhuhg`pfhb} Cbmcnk}`z~ mkkjk~h~" Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f ` }dh Kzkj

    Q`zgmc~ f`mhghm `b h kbbxkg zhp`z~ cb h ~hzch~'Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f ` }dh

    Q`zgm$Aqkzbhs kbm Gkq~`b' :??=:??3< Aqkzbhs' Dkgg' kbm Gkq~`b' :?;?< M`xn`xgcka`~ kbm Xgxjk~`agx' :??5< kbm Aqkzbhs' Gkq~`b' kbm Dkgg'

    :?;;9 ;="

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    14/74

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    15/74

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    16/74

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / 1

    N`xb}zs ~xffkzch~

    Cb h `gg`qcba ~hnc`b' qh g``l k `q hkn n`xbzs c~ ~n`zcba c~ shkz cb

    n`fpkzc~`b qc pzhuc`x~ shkz~" Qh kg~` g``l k h mkk k kzh kukcgkjgh `z

    :?;; ` ah kb cbmcnkc`b ` qk xxzh ~n`zh~ fca jh"

    ]h Kzkj ~pzcba k~ sh ` khn hn`b`fcn p`gcns mhhpgs cb f`~ bkc`b~'

    `xa c~ c~ lhs ` fhhcba h k~pczkc`b~ `z k jhhz gch knz`~~ h Kzkj

    q`zgm" E`z cb~kbnh' kg`xa h `uhzkgg ~n`zh `z Hasp' h gkzah~ ` Kzkjbkc`b~' zhfkcbhm xbnkbahm c~ shkz' mkk `z :?;; ~xaah~ k hzh qcgg jh

    k mhhzc`zkc`b cb c~ hn`b`fcn p`gcns" Lxqkc~ ~n`zh c~ kg~` gclhgs ` mhngcbh

    qcgh `b&a`cba n`bcn cb ^szck zhmxnh~ h ~pknh kbm ~khs `z zhh hn`b`fcn

    htnkbah qcgh xbmhzfcbcba h zxgh ` gkq" D`qhuhz' ~`fh bkc`b~ kzh gclhgs

    ` ~`q ~gca cfpz`uhfhb~ cb p`gcns' qc h ~cxkc`b cb F`z`nn`' xbc~ck'

    kbm Kgahzck ~`qcba pkzcnxgkz pz`fc~h' `xa' pkzcnxgkzgs cb Kgahzck' z`f

    ~fkgg hn`b`fcn jk~h~"

    ^xffkzs Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f Zk}cba~ e`z :?;? e Zkblhm N`xb}zch~ cb }dh Kzkj Q`zgm

    ? : = 5 4 ;?

    Kgahzck ;1

    Fkxzc}kbck ;5

    ^szckb Kzkj Zhpxjgcn ;8

    F`z`nn` ;=

    Micj`x}c ;>

    Hasp}' Kzkj Zhpxjgcn ;:

    ]xbc~ck ;?

    N`f`z`~ ;?

    Shfhb' Zhpxjgcn 3

    ^kxmc Kzkjck 4

    [k}kz 1

    @fkb 8

    Ghjkb`b 8

    Lxqkc} =

    I`zmkb >

    Xbc}hm Kzkj Hfczk}h~ ;

    Jkdzkcb ; 4";

    4";

    1"3

    1"4

    1"5

    1"5

    1"=

    1">

    1":

    5"4

    5"4

    5"1

    5"5

    5"8

    5":

    5"?

    8"1

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    17/74

    4 / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    ; JkdzkcbJkzkcb lhp c~ zkbl' n`fcba z~ cb c~ shkz~ zhp`z qc k `kg ~n`zh 4";' k

    ~gca cfpz`uhfhb ?"; p`cb n`fpkzcba qc c~ ~n`zh cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z" C

    fkcbkcbhm c~ ~n`zh cb h ~cyh ` a`uhzbfhb k 5"5 jx mz`pphm cb zkbl z`f

    3 pgknh cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z" C~ ~n`zh mcm b` nkbah cb ghakg ~zxnxzh kbm ~hnx&

    zcs ` pz`phzs zca~ hchz' qc k `kg ~n`zh ` 1": pgkncba c cb 3 pgknh" C~

    p`~cc`b k~ k bkbnckg xj cb h zhac`b qk~ ~zhbahbhm js c~ cfpz`uhfhb cb

    h knnh~~ ` ~`xbm f`bhs kzhk' n`fcba z~ cb zkbl qc k ~n`zh ` 3"> p`cb~'

    n`fpkzhm ` 3"; kbm czm pgknh cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z" Cb h kzhk ` zhhm`f `

    zkmh cbhzbkc`bkggs' Jkzkcb f`uhm ` h `p ` h cbmht' xp `bh pgknh n`f&

    pkzhm ` gk~ shkz' qc h ~kfh ~n`zh ` 4"= p`cb~" Ecbkggs' cb h zhaxgkc`b `

    gkj`z' nzhmc' kbm jx~cbh~~ hzh k~ jhhb kb cfpz`uhfhb ` ?"; p`cb lhhpcba

    Jkzkcb cb h z~ pgknh n`fpkzhm ` h zh~ ` h Kzkj q`zgm"

    g``lcbae`zqkzm gcgh nkbah< pzhgcfcbkzs mkk `z :?;; ~xaah~~ k Jkzkcb~

    `uhzkgg ~n`zh qcgg gclhgs zhfkcb k kj`x h ~kfh ghuhg"

    : Xbc}hm Kzkj Hfczk}h~]h Xbchm Kzkj Hfczkh~ $XKH# f`uhm xp h gc~ khz c~ `uhzkgg ~n`zh

    cfpz`uhm js ?": p`cb `uhz c~ ~n`zh cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z ` 4";" ]h ~n`zh cb h

    kzhk ` ~cyh ` a`uhzbfhb k~ cfpz`uhm js ?"8 p`cb' lhhpcba c cb czm pgknh'

    k~ c qk~ gk~ shkz" ]h ~n`zh kbm zkbl zhfkcbhm h ~kfh cb ghakg ~zxnxzh kbm

    ~hnxzcs ` pz`phzs zca~ k 1"1 p`cb~' pgkncba h XKH cb `xz pgknh" ]h

    phz`zfkbnh cb h knnh~~ ` ~`xbm f`bhs kzhk k~ cfpz`uhm js ?"; p`cb' gccba

    c~ zkbl z`f 3 ` 1 cb c~ shkz~ zhp`z" ]h XKH nkfh cb czm khz Jkzkcb

    kbm Shfhb `z zkmcba qc h q`zgm9 c lhp c~ zkbl qc kb cfpz`uhfhb `

    ?"; p`cb' n`fpkzhm ` gk~ shkz~ ~n`zh" Cb hzf~ zhaxgkc`b jx~cbh~~' gkj`z

    kbm nzhmc h ~n`zh cfpz`uhm js ?"; p`cb' zhhncba k f`uh ` q` pgknh~ cb

    h cbmht z`f 4 ` 5"

    g``lcbae`zqkzm gcgh nkbah< pzhgcfcbkzs mkk ~xaah~~ gcgh nkbah `z h

    XKH a`cba `zqkzm"

    > I`zmkbI`zmkb k~ htphzchbnhm k jca cfpz`uhfhb cb c~ `uhzkgg ~n`zh cb c~ shkz~

    zhp`z khz ~n`zcba 1"3' fklcba c h czm f`~ hn`b`fcnkggs zhh bkc`b cb

    h Kzkj q`zgm' n`fpkzhm qc k ~n`zh ` 1"= kbm k zkbl ` 4

    cb gk~ shkz~zhp`z" Cb h ~cyh ` a`uhzbfhb kzhk' I`zmkb fkmh kb cfpz`uhfhb ` :"8

    p`cb~ xp ` 1"8' zkblcba cb = pgknh n`fpkzhm ` ;5 pgknh gk~ shkz" Bhchz

    h zkbl b`z h ~n`zh nkbahm cb h ghakg ~zxnxzh kbm ~hnxzcs ` pz`phzs

    zca~ kzhk k 1"= kbm h 1 pgknh" Cb hzf~ knnh~~ ` ~`xbm f`bhs' h ~n`zh

    zhfkcbhm k 3"? p`cb~ jx I`zmkb f`uhm xp q` pgknh~ ` czm n`fpkzhm qc

    c~ zkbl gk~ shkz" ]hzh qk~ b` nkbah cb h zhhm`f ` zkmh cbhzbkc`bkggs

    kzhk< c zkblhm 8 qc k ~n`zh ` 1"3" Ecbkggs' h ~n`zh cb h jx~cbh~~' gkj`z

    kbm nzhmc kzhk cfpz`uhm js ?"; p`cb k 1"1' f`ucba c~ zkbl z`f 1 ` 8 cb

    c~ zhp`z"

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    18/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / 3

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    g``lcbae`zqkzm fcthm< pzhgcfcbkzs hucmhbnh ~xaah~~ k I`zmkb fks jh zhcb&

    cba cb ~`fh a`uhzbfhb ~phbmcba' nzhkcba f`zh ~pknh `z zhh hn`b`fcn kncucs'

    jx hzh c~ kg~` hucmhbnh mhhzc`zkc`b cb h zxgh gkq k~ k zh~xg fcgckzs

    cbhzhzhbnh"

    = Lxqkc}Lxqkc f`uhm m`qb `bh pgknh z`f c~ zkbl ` czm gk~ shkz' qc h ~kfh

    ~n`zh ` 1"4 p`cb~" C~ zkbl cb h ~cyh ` a`uhzbfhb kzhk mz`pphm q` pgknh~'

    cb ~pch ` c~ kucba h ~kfh ~n`zh ` 5"1 p`cb~' z`f 1 cb h :??3 mkk `

    3 cb c~ shkz~ zhp`z" Bhchz h ~n`zh b`z h zkbl cb h kzhk ` ghakg ~zxn&

    xzh kbm ~hnxzcs ` pz`phzs zca~1"4 p`cb~ kbm czm pgknhkuh nkbahm

    n`fpkzhm ` gk~ shkz~ zhp`z" Lxqkc ~kzhm h `p pgknh `z knnh~~ ` ~`xbm

    f`bhs qc Jkzkcb' ~n`zcba 3"> p`cb~ qc b` nkbah n`fpkzhm ` gk~ shkz'

    jx f`uhm xp `bh pgknh cb h zhhm`f ` zkmh cbhzbkc`bkggs z`f 4 ` 1

    qc kb cfpz`uhfhb ?"; p`cb ` k ~n`zh 1"1" Lxqkc~ ~n`zh `z zhaxgkc`b

    ` jx~cbh~~' nzhmc kbm gkj`z qhb m`qb js ?"8 p`cb cb n`fpkzc~`b ` gk~ shkz'qcn px~hm c~ zkbl m`qb ` 1 z`f 8 cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z"

    {g``lcbae`zqkzm m`qb9 _zhgcfcbkzs hucmhbnh ~xaah~~ k Lxqkc c~ cbnzhk~&

    cba c~ ~cyh ` a`uhzbfhb kbm c~ kgg`qcba f`bhs az`q ` knnhghzkh"

    8 Ghjkb`b^kzcba 8 pgknh cb c~ shkz~ zhp`z qc @fkb' Ghjkb`b~ ~n`zh cfpz`uhm js ?";

    p`cb z`f 1"8 p`cb~ cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z" C qk~ h jh~ phz`zfhz cb h Kzkj

    q`zgm cb hzf~ ~cyh a`uhzbfhb c~ shkz qc kb cfpz`uhm ~n`zh ?"5 p`cb

    xp z`f 4": ` 4"4' `xa c km k zkhz g`q ~n`zh ` 5"; cb h ghakg ~zxnxzh

    kzhk' n`fcba cb ;> pgknh' `bh pgknh jhhz kb gk~ shkz~ zkbl" C g`~ ?": p`cb

    cb h knnh~~ ` ~`xbm f`bhs qc k ~n`zh ` 3"?' qcn n`bzcjxhm ` c~ zkbl

    a`cba m`qb ` czm cb n`fpkzc~`b ` ~hn`bm cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z" Cb h kzhk `

    zhhm`f ` zkmh cbhzbkc`bkggs' c fkbkahm ` cbnzhk~h c~ ~n`zh js ?": p`cb xp

    ` 5": jx c~ mcm b` khn c~ zkbl ;8 z`f gk~ shkz< kbm cb h kzhk zhaxgk&

    c`b jx~cbh~~' nzhmc kbm gkj`z h ~n`zh cfpz`uhm js ?"; p`cb xp ` 4"; qc kb

    cfpz`uhfhb zkbl ` czm n`fpkzhm js 4"? p`cb~ kbm k zkbl = cb gk~ shkz"

    g``lcbae`zqkzm gcgh nkbah< pzhgcfcbkzs mkk `z :?;; ~xaah~ k Ghjkb`b~

    ~n`zh qcgg zhfkcb kczgs n`b~kb"

    5 @fkb@fkb ~kzhm 8 pgknh qc Ghjkb`b cb c~ shkz~ zhp`z khz lhhpcba k ~n`zh

    1"5 p`cb~ jx mz`ppcba z`f = pgknh cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z" ]h ~cyh ` a`uhzb&

    fhb c~ @fkb~ fkcb qhklbh~~ kbm jzcba~ m`qb c~ `uhzkgg ~n`zh `z c~ kzhk9

    c km h ~kfh ~n`zh k~ gk~ shkz' 8"= p`cb~' kbm mz`pphm `bh zkbl ` ;8 pgknh"

    Ghakg ~zxnxzh kbm ~hnxzcs pz`phzs zca~ c~ kb kzhk qhzh @fkb phz`zf~

    qhgg' fkcbkcbcba k ~n`zh 4"? p`cb~' qc`x k nkbah' kbm zkblcba cb ~hn`bm

    pgknh" ]h ~n`zh `z knnh~~ ` ~`xbm f`bhs cfpz`uhm js ?"; p`cb xp ` 4"= ~`

    c lhp c~ zkbl ` ;? cb h cbmht" Bhchz h ~n`zh b`z h zkbl k~ nkbahm

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    19/74

    ;? / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    `z zhhm`f ` zkmh cbhzbkc`bkggs1"3 p`cb~ kbm 8 zkblqhzhk~ c~ ~n`zh

    cfpz`uhm cb h zhaxgkc`b ` jx~cbh~~' nzhmc kbm gkj`z js ?"; p`cb xp ` 4">'

    gccba c~ zkbl ` ~hn`bm' n`fpkzhm ` czm pgknh cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z"

    g``lcbae`zqkzm gcgh nkbah< pzhgcfcbkzs mkk ~xaah~~ @fkb~ ~n`zh qcgg jh

    gcgh nkbahm cb :?;;"

    1 [k}kz[kkz nkfh cb 1}d cb h `uhzkgg zkblcba qc k ~n`zh 1"= p`cb~" ]h ~cyh `

    a`uhzbfhb kzhk cfpz`uhm ~gcags js ?"; p`cb `z k `kg ~n`zh ` 5"= p`cb~'

    f`ucba c~ zkbl `bh pgknh cahz kb gk~ shkz k ;:}d< c~ ~n`zh cb h kzhk `

    ghakg ~zxnxzh cfpz`uhm k~ qhgg js ?"; p`cb ` 1"5 p`cb~' cbnzhk~cba c~ zkbl js

    `bh pgknh xp ` 8}d" [kkz htphzchbnhm k ~gca mhhzc`zkc`b ` ?": p`cb cb h

    knnh~~ ` ~`xbm f`bhs kzhk ` ~n`zh 4"=' f`ucba c~ zkbl bh pgknh m`qb ` ;?}d"

    ]h zhhm`f ` zkmh cbhzbkc`bkggs kzhk mz`pphm js ?"= p`cb ` 1"8' f`ucba c~

    zkbl m`qb zhh pgknh~ ` 4}d cb n`fpkzc~`b ` gk~ shkz< c~ ~n`zh `z zhaxgkc`b` jx~cbh~~' nzhmc kbm gkj`z kg~` mz`pphm js ?"= p`cb ` 1">' px~cba c~ zkbl

    m`qb ~gcags js `bh pgknh ` 1}d n`fpkzhm ` c~ zkbl ` 5}d cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z"

    pg``lcbae`zqkzm xp ~gcags< [kkz fks kuh k ~gcags cfpz`uhm ~n`zh cb :?;;

    mxh ` akcb~ cb ~`xbm f`bhs"

    4 ^kxmc Kzkjck^kxmc Kzkjck~ `uhzkgg zkbl ~kshm k 4}d cb c~ shkz~ zhp`z khz c km ~n`zhm

    1"> p`cb~ n`fpkzhm ` 1"= p`cb~ cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z" Cb ~pch ` fkcbkcbcba k

    ~n`zh ` 8"? p`cb~ cb h ~cyh ` a`uhzbfhb kzhk' c~ zkbl hgg js q` pgknh~ `

    ;4 cb h Kzkj q`zgm' qcn ~xaah~~ k c c~ `bh ` h p``zh~ phz`zfhz~

    cb c~ kzhk" @b h `hz kbm' ^kxmc Kzkjck c~ h jh~ phz`zfhz cb h ghakg

    zca~ kzhk' fkcbkcbcba c~ ~n`zh 4": p`cb~ k~ cb gk~ shkz~ zh~xg~" ]h knnh~~

    ` ~`xbm f`bhs qk~ kb`hz kzhk qhzh ~n`zh kbm zkbl ~kshm h ~kfh k~ gk~

    shkz k 4"4 p`cb~ kbm 5 pgknh" ^kxmc Kzkjck~ ~n`zh `z zhhm`f ` zkmh qk~

    xbnkbahm k 5"5 p`cb~ jx h zkbl mz`pphm m`qb `bh pgknh z`f k ` gk~

    shkz ` ;>" Ecbkggs' h zhaxgkc`b ` jx~cbh~~' nzhmc kbm gkj`z kzhk ~kq k mz`p

    cb ~n`zh ` ?": p`cb n`fpkzhm ` gk~ shkz~ zh~xg ` 4">' qcn f`uhm ^kxmck

    Kzkjck~ zkbl m`qb ` czm z`f ~hn`bm"

    g``lcbae`zqkzm gcgh nkbah< pzhgcfcbkzs mkk `z kxmc Kzkjck ~xaah~~ gcgh

    nkbah a`cba `zqkzm"

    3 ShfhbShfhb zkblhm cb 5 pgknh cb h uhzkgg zkbl khz g`~cba ?"> p`cb `z k ~n`zh

    1":< c f`uhm m`qb zhh pgknh~ cb h uhzkgg zkblcba z`f gk~ shkz" Cb h ~cyh

    ` a`uhzbfhb kzhk' h ~n`zh q`z~hbhm js ?"4 p`cb m`qb ` 5"=' f`ucba c~

    zkbl ~ct pgknh~ m`qb z`f 8 gk~ shkz ` ;;' qcgh c fkcbkcbhm c~ ~n`zh 5"8

    p`cb~ k ;; pgknh cb h ghakg ~zxnxzh kzhk" Cb h knnh~~ ` ~`xbm f`bhs' c

    fkcbkcbhm c~ zkbl k 4 pgknh mh~pch g`~cba ?": p`cb `z k ~n`zh ` 4"8 p`cb~"

    Kg`xa c g`~ ?"> p`cb cb h zhhm`f ` zkmh kzhk' Shfhb fkcbkcbhm c~

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    20/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / ;;

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    z~ pgknh cb c~ kzhk qc k `kg ~n`zh ` 4"= p`cb~" ]h kzhk ` zhaxgkc`b `

    jx~cbh~~' nzhmc kbm gkj`z ~kq k ~cabcnkb mz`p ` ?"5 p`cb m`qb ` 5"; qcn

    px~hm Shfhb~ zkbl m`qb `xz pgknh~ ` ;8"

    g``lcbae`zqkzm fcthm< Shfhb c~ mhnzhk~cba h fktcfxf kt zkh z`f >8(

    ` ;8( `z g`nkg zh~cmhb~' kbm :?( `z b`b&zh~cmhb~' acucba c kb cfpz`uhm

    ~n`zh cb ~cyh ` a`uhzbfhb" D`qhuhz' c~ ~n`zh qcgg gclhgs mhnzhk~h `z fcgckzs

    cbhzhzhbnh kbm c~ fcthm xbmhz ~`xbm f`bhs"

    ;? N`f`z`~]h N`f`z`~ fkcbkcbhm c~ zkbl k ;? pgknh cb c~ shkz~ zhp`z' lhhpcba kb

    `uhzkgg ~n`zh ` 5"4 p`cb~" ]h ~cyh ` a`uhzbfhb kzhk kpphkz~ ` jh h kzhk

    k gchm c~ `uhzkgg ~n`zh ~cabcnkbgs9 c knchuhm k `kg ~n`zh ` 4"? p`cb~

    cb c~ kzhk' qc`x kbs nkbah n`fpkzhm ` gk~ shkz~ ~n`zh' kbm lhp ~hn`bm

    pgknh" ]h ~n`zh cb h ghakg ~zxnxzh kzhk cfpz`uhm js ?"; p`cb ` 5"= jx k ;:

    pgknh hzh qk~ b` nkbah cb zkbl `uhz gk~ shkz< qhzhk~ c~ ~n`zh q`z~hbhm cbh knnh~~ ` ~`xbm f`bhs kzhk khz c g`~ ?": p`cb m`qb ` 5"5 p`cb~' zkbl&

    cba c ;4 kf`ba h Kzkj q`zgm kbm fklcba c bh h ghk~ zhh cb h zhac`b"

    ]h `xz kzhk htphzchbnhm k ~cabcnkb cfpz`uhfhb z`f 5"1 ` 1"> p`cb~'

    px~cba c~ zkbl xp `bh pgknh ` 3 ' qhzhk~ c~ ~n`zh mz`pphm js ?"8 p`cb cb

    h gk~ kzhk m`qb ` 8"5 p`cb~' zkblcba c ;4 kbm ~xaah~cba k c c~ `bh `

    h ghk~ zhh cb hzf~ ` zhaxgkc`b ` jx~cbh~~' nzhmc kbm gkj`z"

    pg``lcbae`zqkzm xp ~gcags< h N`f`z`~ fks akcb ~gcags cb :?;; mxh `

    zhmxnhm f`bhs az`q"

    ;; ]xbc~ckxbc~ck ~kzhm h ;? pgknh qc h N`f`z`~ khz b` nkbah ``l pgknh cb

    c~ `uhzkgg ~n`zh ` 5"4 p`cb~ cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z" ]h ~cyh ` a`uhzbfhb ~n`zh

    zhfkcbhm xbnkbahm k 1"= p`cb~ jx c~ zkbl hgg js zhh pgknh~ m`qb ` 8 ` ;=" Ecbkggs' c~ ~n`zh q`z~hbhm cb h

    kzhk zhaxgkc`b jx~cbh~~' nzhmc kbm gkj`z js ?"8 p`cb' kggcba ` 8"8 p`cb~

    kbm f`ucba Hasp~ zkbl m`qb q` pgknh~ z`f ;1 ` ;3' fklcba c `bh ` h

    ghk~ zhh cb h Kzkj q`zgm `z c~ kzhk"

    {g``lcba e`zqkzm m`qb< Hasp c~ gclhgs hkmhm `z k mhngcbh cb c~ ~n`zh"

    _zhgcfcbkzs mkk ~xaah~ cbnzhk~h~ cb a`uhzbfhb ~phbmcba pgx~ mhhzc`zkc`b

    cb zxgh gkq' pkzcnxgkzgs z`f fcgckzs cbhzhzhbnh kbm k mhngcbh cb h cbhazcs

    ` h ghakg ~s~hf"

    ;> Micj`x}c

    Micj`xc nkfh cb ;> c~ shkz khz c g`~ ?"; p`cb cb c~ uhzkgg ~n`zh mz`ppcbac~ zkbl `bh pgknh n`fpkzhm ` gk~ shkz~ zhp`z" C fkcbkcbhm k g`q ~n`zh cb

    h ~cyh a`uhzbfhb kzhk 8"> jx sh g`~ q` pgknh~ cb zkbl m`qb ` ;1 cb

    n`fpkzc~`b ` gk~ shkz" Cb kmmcc`b' c~ ~n`zh cb h kzhk ` ghakg ~zxnxzh hgg ?"=

    p`cb m`qb ` 8": p`cb~' px~cba c~ zkbl m`qb js bh pgknh ` ;3' ~xaah~cba

    c c~ k h j``f cb h Kzkj q`zgm cb c~ zhakzm" Cb h knnh~~ ` ~`xbm f`bhs

    kzhk' c g`~ ?"> p`cb `z k ~n`zh ` 4"8' pxggcba c~ zkbl m`qb q` pgknh~ ` 4 3 > " ;8 4" >

    Fkxzc}kbck " ;8 " ;4 " :? " ;8 " ;:

    F`z`nn` " ;= " 1 ;8 " ;4 " ;:

    @fkb " ;8 4 : 4" ;? "3 8 4" :

    [k}kz " ;; " 8 4" ;? " 4 " 1

    ^kxmc Kzkjck ;4 4" ; 4"4 5 " ;> 4" >

    ^szckb Kzkj Zhpxjgcn 4 " ;1 " ;4 " ;1 " ;;

    ]xbc~ck " 8 " 8 "4 ;1 ;3 " 3

    Xbc}hm Kzkj Hfczk}h~ "3 > " = 4" 1 4" > " 5

    Shfhb' Zhpxjgcn " ;; " ;; 4" 4 4" ; " ;8

    N`xb}zch~ xbzkblhm jhnkx~h mk}k xbkukcgkjgh

    Czk{ " :; " :; 4" = "4 ;1

    Gcjsk " ;; "4 ;5 " ;= " ;?

    _kgh~}cbckb ]hzzc} zch~ " 5 " ;? 3 > " ;:

    ^`fkgck " :: ;3

    ^xmkb " :? ;8 ;; " :?

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    32/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / :>

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    @uhzkgg Zk}cba kbm Zkbl< ]zhbm

    N`fp`bhb}~ Kzhk @uhzkgg

    Zk}cba $Zkbl#

    ]zhbm)

    K

    Nzhmc} Fkzlh}

    Zhaxgk}c`b~

    J

    Gkj`xz Fkzlh}

    Zhaxgk}c`b~

    N

    Jx~cbh~~

    Zhaxgk}c`b~

    Zk}cba Zkbl Zk}cba Zkbl Zk}cba Zkbl Zk}cba Zkbl

    Kgahzck " ;3 " ;5 " 4 " ;1 p

    Jkdzkcb 4" > ?"? ; 4" ; 4" ;

    N`f`z`~ " ;> "3 ;: "3 ;4 "4 ;? p

    Micj`x}c "4 ;? 4" 1 " ;5 " ;> p

    Hasp}' Kzkj Zhpxjgcn " ;= " :? " ;> " ;: {

    I`zmkb " ;; 3"? = " ;? "3 >

    Lxqkc} " 3 " ;? " ;; "4 = {

    Ghjkb`b 4" ; 4" 5 " ;: " 8

    Fkxzc}kbck " 4 " ;8 " ;8 "? ;5

    F`z`nn` " ;; "4 ;4 4"? = " ;= p

    @fkb " 8 3" : "3 8 " 8

    [k}kz " ;8 "3 4 "3 5 " 1 p

    ^kxmc Kzkjck 4" : " 3 4" > " 4

    ^szckb Kzkj Zhpxjgcn " ;4 " ;= " 3 " ;8 {

    ]xbc~ck " 1 " ;> 4" : "4 ;? p

    Xbc}hm Kzkj Hfczk}h~ " 5 3" > " ;= 4" ;

    Shfhb' Zhpxjgcn "3 ;5 " ;1 "4 1 " 3

    Czk{ " :? 4" 8 " :?

    Gcjsk "? :;

    _kgh~}cbckb ]hzzc} zch~ " = " ;; "3 ;3

    ^`fkgck

    ^xmkb "3 ;1 " ;3 " ;1

    ) ]zhbm c~ jk~hm b pzhgcfcbkzs mk}k `z ?' b } pk~} phz`zfkbnh" ]zhbm c~ b`} cbmcnk}hm

    `z bk}c`b~ }dk} nkbb`} jh zkblhm mxh }` gknl ` mk}k"p 6 xp

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    33/74

    := / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Kgahzck 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# " $;8# " $;=# " $;8# "1 $;=# "1 $;=# "5 $;8# " $;1# " $;1# "1 $;1#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} "1 " " " " " " " "

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c b ~phbmcba " $"# "3 $"# "? $"# " $"# " $"# "? $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah AM_ 4"? $"# "4 $"# "4 $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $# 4"? $"# 4" $"# 4" $"#

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} "? "? "? "? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h "? $# "? $# "? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ " " "1 "1 "1 "1 "1 "3 "3

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ ?"? ?"? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf " " "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 " "

    c" Bxfjhz pz`nhmxzh~ " " " " " "? "

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# " " " " " " "

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "?

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 5"5 5"5 5" 5"5 5" 5" 5" 5" 1"5

    K" F`bhs az`q}d " $"# "4 $"# "? $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $"# 4"3 $"# 3" $"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? "?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs "1 "3 " " 5" "4 "1 " "4

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh " "3 " "? "3 "3 "3 "? "?

    c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z# "? $"# " $"# " $"# 4" $"# 4" $# 4" $# " $"# "4 $"# "4 $"#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h " $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ " $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# "4 $"# "4 $"# "4 $"# "4 $"# "4 $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 3"? 4" " 4" 4"

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"3 " " ?"4 ?"4 ?"?

    " Zhaxgk}c`b "3 "3 "3 "3 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " " " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " " " " " "

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht "4 "4 "4 " " " " "3 "3

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht " " " " " " " "

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 4"4

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3"4 3"4 3"3 3"4 3"4 3"3 3"3 3"4

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ " " " " " " " " "

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " " " " " " " "

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    34/74

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    35/74

    :5 / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    N`f`z`~ 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 5"1 $;:# 5"4 $;?# 5"4 $;?#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} 4" 4" 4"

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba "3 $"# " $"# "3 $# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4"? $"# 4" $"# 4" $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah ` AM_

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb}

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h 4"? $# 4"? $# 4"? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ " "

    J" Cb}hazc}s ` }dh ghakg ~s~}hf "? "?

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? 4"

    c" Bxfjhz ` pz`nhmxzh~ 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# " " " " "

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " "

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# " " " " "

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 5" 5" 5" 5"4 1" 1" 5"3 5"4 5"5

    K" F`bhs az`q}d " $"# " $"# " $"# 4" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4"4 $"# 4" $"# " $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $# 3" $"# 3"4 $"# 3"4 $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $"# 3" $"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs 5" 5" 5" 5" "1 "3 5"1 5"1 1"

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh "? "? " " "

    c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ "4 $"# "4 $"# " $# " $# " $#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ " " " " "? "4 " " "

    " Zhaxgk}c`b " " "1 " " " "1 5" "5

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " "4 " " " "4 " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ 4"? 4"?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ 3"? 3"? ?"? 3"? 3"? 3"? ?"? 3"? 3"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " " " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " 4" "3

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht " " " " " " " "? "

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht " " " " " " " "

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# " " " " " " " " "?

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "3 "3 "3 "3

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ " " " " " " " " "4

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " "

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# 3"? 3"? 3"? 4"3 4"3

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# " " " "4 "3

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    k" ]cfh $shkz~#

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h#

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    36/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / :1

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Micj`x}c 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 5"5 $;># 5"1 $;:# 5"5 $;>#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} " " "

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba "? $"# " $"# "4 $"# "? $"# " $"# " $# " $# " $# " $#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah ` AM_

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb}

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h 4"? $# 4"? $# 4"? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" "5 "

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ "4 "?

    J" Cb}hazc}s ` }dh ghakg ~s~}hf " "

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz ` pz`nhmxzh~ "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# " " " " "

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " "

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 3"1 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 4" 4"4 4"

    K" F`bhs az`q}d 3" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# "3 $"# " $# "4 $"# "4 $"# " $"# " $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# 4" $# 4" $#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3"3 $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $# " $# 3" $"# 3" $#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs 5" 5" 5" 5" 1" 5"3 1" 5"1 5"1

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh "4 "4 "4 "4 " " " " "

    c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h "4 $"# "4 $"# "4 $"# "4 $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# "3 $"# "3 $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ " " " " " " " "4 "4

    " Zhaxgk}c`b 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"3 1"

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " "4 "4

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ ?"? ?"?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " " " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " " " "

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ 4" 4" 4" 4" " " " " 4"

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht " " " " " " " " "

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht 4" 4" 4" " " " " "

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? 4"?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# " " " " " " " " "

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" ?"?

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ " " " " " " " " "

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " "

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# " " " " 4"?

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 4"3 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# " " " " " " " "

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# " " " " " " " "

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " " " " " " " "

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    37/74

    :4 / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Hasp}' Kzkj Zhpxjgcn 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 5" $;># 5" $;># 5" $;;# 5"1 $;?# 5"4 $;?# 1" $;?# 5"4 $;?# 5"1 $;:# 5"1 $;:#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} "1 "1 "5 "4 5" 1" 1" 5" 1"

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# "3 $"# "3 $# "3 $#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah AM_ 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# "? $"# " $"# "? $"# " $"# "3 $#

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? "? "? "? "? "?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h "? $# "? $# "? $# 4"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf " " " " " "4 "4 "4 "4

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s " " " " " 4" 4" 4" 4"

    c" Bxfjhz ` pz`nhmxzh~ "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 3" 3" 3"

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# "4 "4 "3 3" 3" 3" 3"4

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " "3 "3

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 3" 3" 4"1 4"3 4"1 4" 4" 4" 4"

    K" F`bhs az`q}d 3"? $"# 4"3 $"# 4" $"# 4"? $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    J" }k bmk zm mh uck }c b cb k}c` b 3"4 $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4"4 $"# 4"? $"# 4"? $"# 4" $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3" $"# 3" $"# " $"# 3"? $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs " " 5"1 1" 1" 1" 1" 5" 5"

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh " " " "3 "4 " "3 "3 "4

    c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z# "3 $"# " $"# "4 $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4"? $"# "3 $"#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $# " $# " $#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ " " ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ " " " " " " " " "

    " Zhaxgk}c`b " " " " " "4 "3 5" "

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? 3"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " "4 " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " " " 4" ?"? ?"?

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht " " " " " " " " "

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# " " " " " " " " "

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# " " " " " " " " ?"?

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " "? " " "

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ " " " "3 4" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# 4" 4" 3"? 3" 3" 3"4 3"4 3"4

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3" 3" 4" 3" 3" 3"4 3"4 3"3

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 4" 4" 4" 4" ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# "? "? "? "? "? "? " "?

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# " " " " " " " "

    n"Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " " " "4 "4 "4 "4 "3

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    38/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / :3

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    I`zmkb 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 1"5 $1# 1"5 $1# 1"5 $1# 1"1 $8# 1"5 $8# 1"5 $=# 1" $># 1" 4"? 1"3 $>#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} "3 "4 "4 5"1 5" 5"5 5" " 1"

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c b ~phbmcba " $"# "? $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $# "4 $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah AM_ 3" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $# " $"# 4" $"#

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} "? "? "? "? "? "? "? ?"? "?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# ?"? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1"

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf " " " " " " " " "

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s " " " " " " " 4" 4"

    c" Bxfjhz p z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " "? "?

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# " " " " " " "

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"4

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 3"1 3" 3" 3" 4"3 3" 4" 3" 3"

    K" F`bhs az`q}d 3" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# "3 $"# " $"# "3 $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 3" $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 3" $# 3"4 $"# 3" $# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# " $"# "4 $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# 4"3 $"# "? $"# 3"3 $&"# 3"? $#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs 1"3 4" 4" 4" 1"3 1"3 4" 1"3 1"3

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh " " " " " "4 "? "4 "3

    c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z# "4 $"# 4"? $# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# 4"3 $"#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h "4 $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# "4 $"# 4"? $"# 4"? $#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ "4 $"# "4 $"# "4 $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# "? $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ " " " " "3 "3 "3 "3 "3

    " Zhaxgk}c`b 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1"5 1"1

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ "3 "3 "3 " " " " " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? 3"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " " " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " " " " " "

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"3 3"?

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? " 4"?

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? ?"? ?"?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 ?"?

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " "4 "3 "? " " "

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ " " " " "4 4" 4" 4"4 4"4

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ "3 " " " " " " "

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# " 4" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 4"4 4"4 3"? 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# " "4 4"? 4" 4" ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ "3 "3 "3 "? "? "? "3 "3 "3

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# "3 "4 "? "? "? "3 "3 "3

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    39/74

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    40/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / >;

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Ghjkb`b 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 1"1 $5# 1"1 $5# 1"1 $8# 1" $1# 1" $1# 1"5 $=# 1" $1# 1" $5# 1"5 $8#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"4

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba " $"# "3 $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $# " $# " $"# "4 $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah AM_ 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# "4 $"# " $# " $"# " $# " $"# " $"#

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} ?"?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ " " " " " " " " "

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf " " " " " " " " "

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    c" Bxfjhz p z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " "

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 3"5 3" 3" 3"5 3" 3" 4"4 3" 3"

    K" F`bhs az`q}d 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $# 3" $"# 3"? $# 4"3 $"# 4" $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"3 $&"# 4"3 $"# 3" $"# "4 $"# 3"4 $"# 3" $#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs 1" 1" 5"3 "3 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh "3 4" 4" " " " " " "?

    c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z# " $# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ "4 $"# "4 $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ "4 "4 " " " " " " "

    " Zhaxgk}c`b 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1"3 4" 4" 4"

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b 4"? 4"? 4"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"?

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} "4 "4 "4 "4 " " " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " 4" 4" 4" 4"

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht " " " " " " " " "

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht " " " " " " " "

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" ?"?

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b "? "? "? "? "? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " "4 "4 "3 "3 " " "

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 3" 3" 3"

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " 4" 4" 4"

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 3" 3" 3"

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 4" 4" 4" 4"3 4"3 3"? 3" 3"

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3"4 3"4 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ " " " " " " " " "

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# " " " " " " " "

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# " " " " " " " "

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " "4 "? " " " " "

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    41/74

    >: / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Fkxzc}kbck 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 5" $;?# 5" $;?# 5" $;;# 5" $;;# 5" $;># 5" $;:# 5" $;=# 5" $;8# 5" $;5#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} "1 5" 5" 5" "3 5" 5"5 5" "

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba " $"# "? $"# " $"# "3 $# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# " $"# " $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah ` AM_

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? "? 4"? 4"? 4"? "?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 1"5 1"5 1"5 1"5 1"5 1"1 1"1 " "

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ " "

    J" Cb}hazc}s ` }dh ghakg ~s~}hf " "

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"4

    c" Bxfjhz pz`nhmxzh~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# "4 "4 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 4" 4" 4"ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 1" 1" 1" 5"3 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"

    K" F`bhs az`q}d " $# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $# 4"? $"# " $"# "3 $"#

    J" }k bmk zm mh uck }c b cb k}c` b 3" $"# 3" $"# 4"3 $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4"4 $"# 3"? $"# 4" $"# 3" $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3" $"# 3"? $"# "3 $"# " $"# 4"4 $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ "? "? "? "? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh " " " " " " " " "

    c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h "3 $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# 4" $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $# " $# " $# " $#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 " " "? "? "?

    " Zhaxgk}c`b " " " " " "5 "4 5" 5"

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ ?"? ?"?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 4"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " " " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " " " " " "

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ "4 "4 "4 " " " " " "

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht "? "? "? " " " " " "

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht " " " " " " " "

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? 4"? 4"?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# " " " " " " " " "

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" "

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ "4 "4 "4 "4 "? " 4" 4" 4"

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " "3 "3 "3

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# "? "? "? "? "3 3" 3" 3"

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 4" 4" 4" 4" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 4" 4" 4" 4"4 3"? 3" 3" 3"

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ "? "? " "? "? "? "3 "3 "?

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# " " " " " " " "

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# ?"4 "4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?" ?" "

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    42/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / >>

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    F`z`nn` 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 5" $;?# 5" $;;# 5"5 $;?# 5" $;;# 5" $;:# 5" $;:# 5" $;8# 5" $;=# 5" $;=#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} 5" 5" 5"1 5"1 5"1 5"4 5"1 5" 5"

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba " $# " $# " $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# " $"# " $"# "3 $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah ` AM_ 4" $"# 3"? $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# " $"# 4" $"# 4" $"#

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} 4"? 4"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? 4"? 4"?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 1"3 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1"

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ " " " " " " " " "

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf ?"? 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"?

    c" Bxfjhz p z`nhmxzh~ 4"? 4"? 4"? " " " "

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# "3 " 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " " " " "?ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 1" 1" 1" 1" 5"4 5"4 5"1 5"3 1"

    K" F`bhs az`q}d 3" $"# 3" $# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# 4"? $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3" $"# 3"4 $"# 3" $"# 3"4 $# 3" $"# 3" $# 3" $"# 3"4 $# 3"4 $#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs "5 "5 "3 " "1 " " " "

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh " " " " " "4 " " "

    c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z# " $"# "? $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# 4"? $# 4" $"# "3 $"# 4" $"#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ "4 $"# "4 $"# "4 $"# ?" $"# ?" $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# "4 $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ "3 "3 3" 3" 4" ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ " " ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"? ?"4 ?"4

    " Zhaxgk}c`b 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " "4 "4 "4 "? " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ "? "? "? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b 4"? 4"? 4"? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ 3"? 3"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " " " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " " " " 4" 4"

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht "? "? "? " " " " "? "

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? " "

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? 4"?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# " " " " " " " " "

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# 4" 4" 4" " " " " " "3

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " "4 "4 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ "4 "4 4"3 4"3 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# 4" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3" 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"3 3"3 3"4 3"4

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 4" 4" 4" 3"3 3"3 3"3 ?"? ?"?

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ " " " " " " " " "4

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# " " " " " " " "

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " " "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    43/74

    >= / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    @fkb 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 1"4 $=# 1"4 $># 1"4 $># 1"5 $5# 1"1 $># 1" $1# 1" $># 1"5 $=# 1"5 $8#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} "3 " " "3 " " " " "

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba ?"? $"# ?"4 $"# ?" $"# ?"? $"# ?" $"# "? $"# " $"# " $# " $#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah AM_ 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    c" Bxfjhz ` pz`nhmxzh~ 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"?

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 3"1 3"5 3" 3" 3" 4" 1"3 4" 4"

    K" F`bhs az`q}d 3" $"# 4" $"# 4" $# " $"# 4" $"# " $# "4 $"# " $"# " $"#

    J" }k bmk zm mh uck }c b cb k}c` b 3" $# 3" $# 3" $# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# 4" $# 4" $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3"3 $&"# ?"? $"# 3"4 $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4"4 $# " $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs 4"5 4"5 4"5 4" 4" 4" 4" 1"3 1"3

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh 3" 3" 3" " " 4" "4 "3 "3

    c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h 4" $# 4" $# 4" $# 3" $"# 4"3 $"# 4"3 $"# 4"3 $"# 4"3 $"# 4"3 $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# " $# " $# "3 $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ " " " " "3 "3 " "4 "4

    " Zhaxgk}c`b 4" 4" 4" 1"5 1"3 1"3 1"3 4" 4"

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ "3 "3 "3 " " " " " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b 4"? 4"? 4"? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? 3"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " " " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " " " " " "

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"3 4"3 4"3 3" 3"

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht " " " " " " " 4" ?"?

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht " " " " " " ?"? ?"?

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? ?"?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 ?"?

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " "3 "3

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"3 3" 3"

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " 4" 4"

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 3" 3" 3"

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 ?"? ?"? ?"?

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 4" 4" 4" 4"3 4"3 3" 3" 3"

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ " " " " " " " " "

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# " " " " " " " "

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " " " "4 "4 "4 "4 "4

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    44/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / >8

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    [k}kz 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 4 $:# 4 $;# 1"3 $;# 1"3 $;# 1"5 $8# 1"5 $=# 1" $># 1"5 $=# 1" $1#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah ` AM_ 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"4 $"# 3" $"# 3"3 $"# 3"4 $"# 3"? $"# 3" $"#

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb}

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1"5

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ " " " " " " " " "

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"3

    c" Bxfjhz p z`nhmxzh~ " " " "?

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"3

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " "

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 3" 3" 3" 3"

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 3"3 3"1 3" 4"3 4"5 4" 4" 4"5 4"

    K" F`bhs az`q}d "4 $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 3" $# 3" $"# 3"? $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# "4 $"# " $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz ?"? $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# " $"# " $"# "? $"# 3"? $&"# 3" $&"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs 3" 3" 3" 3" 4" 4" 1"4 1"3 1"

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh 3" 3" 3" 3" 4" 4" 4" 4" "3

    $c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $"# 3"? $"# 3"? $# 3"? $# 3"? $#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ "? $"# "3 $"# "? $# " $"# " $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ " " " " " " " " "

    " Zhaxgk}c`b 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1"1 1"

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? 3"? 3"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " " " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " " "

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"3 "3

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht " " " " " " " 4" 3"

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? 4"? 4"?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? ?"?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs#

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" "

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4" "3

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 4"3

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " "

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3"4 3"3 3"3 3"4

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# " " " "

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# " " " "

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " " " "

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    45/74

    >5 / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    ^kxmc Kzkjck 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 1" $4# 1" $4# 1" $4# 1" $4# 1" $3# 1" $3# 1" $1# 1" $4# 1" $4#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} " " " " " " " " "

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $# ?"? $"# ?" $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah ` AM_

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb}

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"4 3"4 3"4

    c" Bxfjhz ` pz`nhmxzh~ 4" 4" 4" 3" 3" 3"

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"?

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 3"5 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 4"5 4"4 4"4

    K" F`bhs az`q}d 4"4 $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# " $"# " $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4"3 $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz ?"? $"# 3"3 $"# 3"3 $"# 3"3 $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4"? $"# 3"? $"# 4"3 $"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs 1" 1" 1" 5"3 "3 "4 5" 5"5 5"5

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh 4" 4" 4" 3" " "3 "3 4" 4"

    $c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $"# 3"? $"# 3"? $"# 3"? $"# 3"? $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ " $# "4 $# "4 $"# " $"# " $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ " " " " " " " " "

    " Zhaxgk}c`b 1" 1" 1" 1"1 1"4 4" 4" 4" 4"

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ "? "? "? 4"? 4"? 4" 4" 4" 4"

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} "? "? "? " " "? "? " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht ?"? 4" 4" ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"4 4" 4" 4" "

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 4" 4" 4" ?"?

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? "? "? "? ?"?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "?

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " "3 4" 4"

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ " " " "4 " 3"? 3" 3" 3"

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " 4"4 4"4

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# " " "3 4" 3" 3" 3"3 3"3

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"4 3"3 3"3

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# "? "? " "3 ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ "3 "3 " "3 "3 "? " " "

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# " " " " " 4"3 4"3 4"3

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# " " " " " " " "

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " " " "3 " "? " "?

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    46/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / >1

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    ^szckb Kzkj Zhpxjgcn 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# " $;=# " $;=# "5 $;=# "5 $;8# "5 $;8# 5 $;=# "3 $;5# 5" $;5# 5" $;8#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} "3 "4 " "5 " 5" 1" 5"1 1"

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba " $"# " $"# "? $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# "3 $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah AM_ 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $"# 3"? $"#

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} ?"? ?"? "? "? ?"? "? "? "? "?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h 4"? $"# 4"? $"# 4"? $"# 4"? $"# 4"? $"# 4"? $"# ?"? $# 3"? $# 3"? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ "5 "5 "5 "5 "1 "1 "1 "1 "1

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ " " " " " " " " "

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz p z`nhmxzh~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"4 3"4 3"4

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# ?"? ?"? ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ ?" ?" ?" ?" ?" ?" ?" ?"

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 1"4 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"3 5" 5"5 5"5

    K" F`bhs az`q}d " $"# "3 $"# " $"# " $"# 4" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 4"3 $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4"3 $"# 4" $"# 3"? $"# 4" $"# "3 $"# "4 $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz ?"? $&"# 4"4 $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# 4"? $# 3" $"# "3 $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ "? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs " " " " " "5 " " "5

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh " " " " " " " " "?

    $c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ "3 $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# " $# " $#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ " " ?"? ?"? 3" ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ ?"? ?"? "? "? " " ?"4 ?"4 ?"4

    " Zhaxgk}c`b " " " " " " " 5" 5"

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " "4 "4 " "4 " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ "? "?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? 3"? 3"? ?"? 3"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} ?" ?" ?" ?" ?" ?" ?" ?" "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? "

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht "? "? "? " "? " " 4"? "?

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht ?"? ?"? 4"3 ?"? "4 4"3 4"3 "

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? ?"? "?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 ?"?

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " "? "? " " "

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ " " " " "3 "3 " 4" 4"4

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 3" 3" 3"

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"4 3" 3"

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# ?"? ?" ?"? " "4 " 4"? 3"

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ "? "? "? "? " " " " "?

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# " " " " " " " "

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " " " " " " " "?

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    47/74

    >4 / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    ]xbc~ck 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 5" $;?# 5" $;;# 5" $;># 5" $;;# 5"4 $;?# 5"4 $;;# 5"4 $;?# 5"4 $;?# 5"4 $;?#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} "5 " " " 1" 1" 1" 1" 1"

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah AM_ 4" $"# " $# " $# " $# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# "? $"# "? $"#

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} "? "? "? "? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 1"5 1"5 1"5 1"5 1"5 1"5 1"5 1"5 1"5

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ " " " " " " " " "

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    c" Bxfjhz ` pz`nhmxzh~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 5"3 5"4 5"4 5"4

    K" F`bhs az`q}d 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4"4 $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $#

    J" } kbmk zm mh uck }c b cb k} c b 3"4 $"# 3"3 $"# 3"4 $"# 3" $"# 3" $# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs "1 "4 " " "4 "3 "3 " "

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh " "4 " " " " "3 "4 "

    $c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4"4 $"# 4"3 $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h "? $"# "? $"# "3 $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ "? $"# "? $"# "? $"# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# " $"# " $"# " $#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ "4 "4 3" 3" 3" 3" 4" 4" "

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4

    " Zhaxgk}c`b 5"3 5"3 5"5 5"3 5"3 1" 1" 1" 1"

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " "4 " " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " "? " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " " "? 4" 4" 4"

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 " "

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht " " " " " " " "? "

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht " " " " " " " 4"

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? 4" ?"?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 4"4

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ 4" 4" " 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3" 3" 3"3 3"3 ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ "3 "3 " "3 "3 "3 4"? 4"? "3

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " ?"? " " " " " "

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    48/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / >3

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Xbc}hm Kzkj Hfczk}h~ 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 1"4 $=# 1"4 $># 1"1 $8# 1"4 $># 1"4 $:# 1"1 $># 1"1 $:# 1"3 $:# 4" $;#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} 1" 1" 1" 1"5 1"5 1"1 1"1 1" 1"3

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4"3 $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4"? $"# 4" $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah ` AM_ 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} ?"? ?"? ?"? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1"1 1"1

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf " " " " " " " " "

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"4 3"4

    c" Bxfjhz p z`nhmxzh~ 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? ?"? ?"?

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 ?"? ?"?

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " "? "?

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "? "?

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " " " "4 "4ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 3" 3" 4"1 4" 4" 1"4 1"3 4"5 4"1

    K" F`bhs az`q}d 4" $"# "3 $"# " $"# "? $"# " $"# "4 $"# " $# " $"# " $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 3"? $"# 3"? $"# 3"? $"# 3"? $"# 3"? $"# 4" $"# 4"4 $"# 4" $"# "4 $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $# 4"4 $"# 4" $"# "4 $"# " $"# 3" $"# 3"4 $"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4" 4" 4" 4"

    $c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h 3" $# 3" $# 3" $# 3"? $"# 3"? $# 3"? $# 3"? $# 3"? $"# 3"? $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# " $"# "? $"# "? $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ " " " " " " "4 "4 "

    " Zhaxgk}c`b 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1"5

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " " " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " " " 4" 4" 4"

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 3"

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 3" 4"

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? 4"? "?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# " " " " " " " " "

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# " " " " " " " " ?"?

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"3 4"3

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"4 3"3 3"3

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" ?"? ?"?

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ " " "4 " " " " " "

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# " " " " " " " "

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# " " " " " " " "

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " ?"? " " " " " "

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    49/74

    =? / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Shfhb' Zhpxjgcn 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 1" $3# 1" $4# 1" $3# 1" $4# 1" $1# 1" $4# 1" $1# 1" $5# 1" $3#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} 5"1 5"3 1" 1" 5"3 5"4 1" 1" 5"

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c b ~phbmcba " $"# "4 $# " $"# " $# "3 $"# " $"# " $# " $# 4" $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah ` AM_

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} "?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ " " " " " " " " "

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf " " " " " " " " "

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    c" Bxfjhz ` pz`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " "

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"4 4"4 4"4

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "? "?

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 4"5 4"1 4"5 3" 4"3 4"3 4" 4"1 4"

    K" F`bhs az`q}d 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4"? $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# 4"? $"# 4" $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# "3 $"# 4"? $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz " $"# "4 $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# 4" $"# " $# 4"3 $"# "4 $"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs 4" 4" 4" 4"4 4"1 4"1 4"5 4"1 4"

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    $c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"