eight-mile channel clean-up · 8-mile channel remediation background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 –...

53
8-Mile Channel Remediation Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan / Oct. – Dec. ’07 In-channel works / Jan. – Mar. ’08 Borrow material / Feb. ’08 Single use treatment cell / Jan. ’08 to present October 15, 2009

Upload: others

Post on 16-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

8-Mile ChannelRemediationRemediation

Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07

Remediation work plan / Oct. – Dec. ’07 In-channel works / Jan. – Mar. ’08

Borrow material / Feb. ’08Single use treatment cell / Jan. ’08 to present

October 15, 2009

Page 2: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Background

88--MILE MILE CHANNELCHANNEL

WinnipegWinnipeg

Norway HouseNorway House

Nelson RiverNelson River

Page 3: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Background

• Constructed in early-to mid-1970s

• Substandard clean-up• Debris and petroleum

(PHC) contamination left at channel

• Contractor now defunct

Highway 373Highway 373

Page 4: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Background

Page 5: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Background

Page 6: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Background

• Debris clean-up: 2004 through 2006

• Employed local Cree Nation Contractor

• Coordination with Cree Nation

• EM surveys & soil sampling programs

• Now complete

Page 7: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

PHC DiscoverySEPTEMBER 2006SEPTEMBER 2006

• Final inspection with Norway House Cree Nation

• Evidence of PHC contamination at shoreline• Soil grab sample analyses confirmed

contamination

Page 8: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

PHC Discovery

Airstrip

Page 9: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

PHC Discovery

• North side of 8-Mile Channel• Inlet to channel at Playgreen Lake• Straddling shoreline

Page 10: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

PHC DiscoveryINVESTIGATIONINVESTIGATION

• Conducted in March 2007• Compared to CCME Tier 1 parkland criteria• Established horizontal and vertical limits of

contamination:– V ≈ 4000 m3

– A ≈ 1800 m2

– Max. depth ≈ 4 m– Approx. 50% below summer water level (by vol.)– Approx. 25% below winter water level (by vol.)

Page 11: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

PHC Discovery

AREA OF AREA OF INVESTIGATIONINVESTIGATION

AREA OF AREA OF IMPACTIMPACT

Page 12: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

PHC Discovery

Page 13: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Remediation Work Plan

• Wet (e.g., dredge) or Dry (e.g., cofferdams)? • Dry:

– Reduced impact on channel and downstream waters– Greater control over excavation incl. sampling– Less water mixed with contaminated soil– Increased precision during backfilling

Page 14: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

• Summer or Winter? • Winter:

– Eliminate wave action– Able to work from ice– Easier access to work site– Frost would provide additional stability

Remediation Work Plan

Page 15: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

• Means of isolation? • Aqua Dams:

– Minimal disturbance of bottom sediments– More easily installed than sheet piling or cofferdams– Already successfully utilized in northern MB– Readily available

Remediation Work Plan

Page 16: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Remediation Work Plan

Page 17: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Remediation Work Plan

• 9:1 excavation slopes• 9 m setback from toe of slope to aqua dam• Dewatering well network inside setback

Page 18: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

• Proposed re-use of previously disturbed areas• Consulted with local resource management

board for approval• Applied for and acquired MB Conservation and

DFO permits between October and end of December 2007!

Remediation Work Plan

Page 19: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Access RoadsAccess Roads

Remediation Work Plan

Page 20: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Remediation Work Plan

Page 21: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Remediation Work Plan

Page 22: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

In-Channel Works

Page 23: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Welcome to Welcome to Northern Manitoba!Northern Manitoba!

In-Channel Works

Page 24: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

In-Channel Works

Page 25: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

In-Channel Works

Page 26: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

In-Channel Works

Page 27: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

In-Channel Works

Page 28: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

In-Channel Works

Page 29: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

• Seepage under the dam at SE corner• Shored dam using silty backfill dike along inner

face• Dewatering successful, though continuous

In-Channel Works

Page 30: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Earthen DikeEarthen Dike

In-Channel Works

Page 31: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

• All pump intakes were fitted with fish screen structures

• A fish biologist conducted the salvage operation• 248 fish were salvaged with 97 mortalities

In-Channel Works

Page 32: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

In-Channel Works

Page 33: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

In-Channel Works

Page 34: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

In-Channel Works

Page 35: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

In-Channel Works

Page 36: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

In-Channel Works

Page 37: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

In-Channel Works

Page 38: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

In-Channel Works

Page 39: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

• Inner earth dyke was removed and used as backfill

• Aqua dams were removed by first allowing controlled flooding of isolated work area

• Dams were pulled from channel using cables manipulated by backhoes

• Destroyed dam material and silt curtain hauled to Jenpeg landfill

In-Channel Works

Page 40: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

In-Channel Works

Page 41: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

4:1 shoreline 4:1 shoreline slopeslope

In-Channel Works

Page 42: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

In-Channel Works

Page 43: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Borrow Material

• Texture consistent with channel bottom material• Initial samples showed no contamination• Discovered limited debris and evidence of PHC

impact during final removal of borrow

Page 44: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Borrow Material

• Potentially contaminated material was disposed of in treatment cell

• Debris was removed by hand to maximum extent and diverted to Norway House in solid waste stream

• Test pitting determined contamination was very limited (< 20 m3) and debris was isolated

Page 45: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Borrow Material

Page 46: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Treatment CellProposed cell area: > 7500 m2

Page 47: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Treatment Cell

Page 48: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Treatment Cell

Page 49: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Treatment Cell

Page 50: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Treatment Cell• Actual combined volume of material placed in

both cells:

7000 m3

• Demobilization from site completed by late March 2008

Page 51: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Treatment Cell• Returned to treatment cell in September 2008• Turned soils and collected soil samples• Results: 13 of 32 soil samples exceeded• One ‘hot spot’• Turned and sampled again in September 2009• Results are pending

Page 52: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

Acknowledgements

Page 53: Eight-Mile Channel Clean-up · 8-Mile Channel Remediation Background / 1973 – ’77 / ’04 – ‘06 Discovery of contamination / Sep. ’06 – Mar. ‘07 Remediation work plan

THANK YOUTHANK YOU

QUESTIONS?QUESTIONS?