errors in non-gynecological cytopathology and pathology ... · pdf fileerrors in...

46
Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System Failures than System SuccessesWalid E. Khalbuss, Sara E. Monaco, & Liron Pantanowitz University of Pittsburgh Medical Center ASC 58th Annual Scientific Meeting

Upload: vumien

Post on 13-Feb-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology:

“There is More to Learn from System Failures than System Successes”

Walid E. Khalbuss, Sara E. Monaco, & Liron PantanowitzUniversity of Pittsburgh Medical CenterASC 58

th Ann

ual S

cienti

fic M

eetin

g

Page 2: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Notice of Faculty Disclosure

• In accordance with the ACCME guidelines, any individual in a position to influence and/or control the content of this ASCP CME activity has disclosed all relevant financial relationships within the past 12 months with commercial interests that provide products and/or services related to the content of this CME activity.

• The individual below has responded that he/she has no relevant financial relationship with commercial interest to disclose:

– Walid E. Khalbuss– Sara E. Monaco– Liron Pantanowitz

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 3: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Error reduction is an important aspect of continuous quality improvement. Error reduction and patient safety in healthcare has recently come to the forefront of medical practice. Follow-up is the great teacher in cytopathology. Cytopathology laboratories are required to perform cytology-histology correlation to improve their diagnostic practice and reduce errors in cytopathology. This seminar will review and discuss selected short and long cases that reveal errors at some stages prior to signing out or upon follow-up. Selected images from each case will be presented, followed by an interactive discussion between the instructors and the audience. The cases will highlight the diagnostic dilemmas and pitfalls including screening errors, interpretation errors, difficulties in well-differentiated neoplasms, benign entities the mimics malignancies, malignant entities with bland cytology, and coincident lesions and malignancies. Selected cases with errors in surgical pathology cases that were discovered through cytological diagnoses will also be presented.

Introduction

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 4: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Upon completion of this workshop you will be able to:1. Identify the common types of errors in non-gynecological

cytopathology and analyze root cause of cytopathology errors and how to reduce or prevent them..

2. Recognize the importance of cytology-histology correlation and that follow-up is the best teacher in cytopathology.

3. Understand that errors also occur in surgical pathology and that cytopathology can be QA for surgical pathology.

4. Experience practical examples of cases with errors in diagnoses and how we can develop a plan to deal with such cases in order to improve the overall quality of patient management.

GOALS

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 5: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

None-GYN Types of Cytology Specimens

• Aspiration Cytology (FNA):• By pathologist• By image-guidance

• Exfoliative Cytology:• Body Cavity Fluid Cytology• Washings

• Touch Prep/Imprint Cytology• Intraoperative or Bench top• Evaluation of Core Biopsies

• Metastatic Disease:• Lymph Node Metastases• Solid Organ Metastases: Liver FNA, Lung FNA• Body Cavity Fluids: Pleural, Peritoneal, CSF

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 6: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Non-GYN Types of Cytology Errors: Overview

Pre analytic Errors:Inexperienced aspirator/performerPoor PreparationScant cellularityInappropriate or Lack of triage (without ROSE)

Analytic Errors:Misleading immunostain (IHC) resultsOverinterpretation /FPPoor Sampling /FNContamination vs. Lesional cells

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 7: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Pitfalls of Contamination

• Lung– Reactive Bronchial Cells– Hepatocytes (RLL)– Mesothelial cells– Cartilage (from ribs)

• Lymph Node/Soft tissue– Seminal vesicle sampling (perirectal)

• Thyroid– Parathyroid sampling– Ciliated respiratory epithelium– Skeletal Muscle– Gel, plateletsASC 58

th Ann

ual S

cienti

fic M

eetin

g

Page 8: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Pitfalls of Respiratory Cytology

• Reactive/metaplastic changes• Germinal center cells, large lymphocytes, and

macrophages• Granulomatous inflammation• Lymphoid cells vs. SCLC• SCLC vs. NSCLC• Single, dyscohesive malignant cells• Non-pulmonary metastases• Bland neoplasms• LymphomaASC 58

th Ann

ual S

cienti

fic M

eetin

g

Page 9: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

• Inadequate sampling• Bland appearing neoplasms in the lung• Atypia of alveolar, bronchial, metaplastic or

mesothelial cells– Examples: infarct, asthma, bronchitis, pneumonia,

granulomas, therapy-related effects, etc– Reserve cell hyperplasia can mimic small cell

carcinoma• Mesothelioma versus Adenocarcinoma in

pleural-based lesions

Pitfalls of Transthoracic Lung FNA

FalseNegatives

FalsePositives

Inaccurate Classification or Subtyping

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 10: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

DD/Pitfalls of Granulomatous Inflammation

• Granulomatous Inflammation– Necrotizing- infection (TB), other– Non-necrotizing- sarcoidosis, other– Granulomas associated with malignancy

– Lymphoma, Seminoma, Metastatic Carcinoma

• Lymphohistiocytic aggregates in Reactive Lymphoid Hyperplasia

• Non-small cell carcinoma– Lung origin– Non-pulmonary origin- bland metastatic neoplasmsASC 58

th Ann

ual S

cienti

fic M

eetin

g

Page 11: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

DD/Pitfalls of Met NSCLC in EBUS/EUS FNA

• Reactive epithelial cells (bronchial, squamous)– Treatment-related atypia (chemo/radiation)

• Other: Viral pneumonitis, Pulmonary infarct• Features favoring benign:

– Cilia, terminal bars, uniformity, absence of mitoses, no abnormal nucleoli

• Metaplastic cells• Metastatic carcinoma

– Pulmonary vs. Non-pulmonary origin• Granulomatous inflammation• Germinal center cells

Crapanzano JP & Saqi A, Diagn Cytopathol 2010Monaco SE et al, Cytojournal 2010

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 12: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Bland Neoplasms in the Lung

• Primary Neoplasms– Carcinoid– BAC- nonmucinous &

mucinous– Signet-ring tumors

• Metastatic Neoplasms– RCC– Mesenchymal

neoplasms• Giant cell tumor of

bone• Benign

Metastasizing Leiomyoma

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 13: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

DD/Pitfalls of Single Atypical Cells in Lung/EBUS

• Benign Metaplastic Cells• Signet ring adenocarcinoma• Squamous cell carcinoma, keratinizing type• Seminoma• Melanoma• Mesenchymal lesions- spindle cell lesions• Small cell carcinoma• Lymphoma

Monaco SE et al, Cytojournal 2010ASC 58

th Ann

ual S

cienti

fic M

eetin

g

Page 14: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

DD/Pitfalls of NE Tumors in Lung/EBUS

• Reserve cell hyperplasia• Benign lymphoid cells• Small cell carcinoma• Non-small cell carcinoma

– With neuroendocrine features/LCNEC– Basaloid carcinoma

• Lymphoma• Small round blue cell tumors

Crapanzano JP & Saqi A, Diagn Cytopathol 2010Monaco SE et al, Cytojournal 2010

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 15: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Monaco SE et al, Cytojournal 2010

Pitfalls of NE Tumors & Mimics

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 16: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

• Tigroid-like Background– Seminoma– Glycogenated tumors

• Mucinous Background– NonDx vs. Dx– Don’t overcall Mucinous Ca

• Necrotic Background– Benign vs. Tumor

• Lymphoid Background– Adequacy– Crushed lymphocytes– Lymphoma– SCLC/SRBCT

EBUS & Background Material

Beware of Mismatch

Bkgd vs Cells

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 17: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Pitfalls of Background Material

Monaco SE et al, Cytojournal 2010ASC 58

th Ann

ual S

cienti

fic M

eetin

g

Page 18: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

DD/Pitfalls of Lymphoma in EBUS/EUS FNA

• Benign lymphoid cells– Background: LGBs– Dyscohesive

• Lymphoma– Background: LGBs– Dyscohesive

• Small cell carcinoma– Background: apoptotic debris– Some cohesion, moldingASC 58

th Ann

ual S

cienti

fic M

eetin

g

Page 19: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Spindle cell lesions in the mediastinum

• Difficult– Better to be called Spindle cell lesion or tumor

• DDx/Pitfalls of Spindle cell Lesions:– Thymomas- spindle cell type– Neurogenic tumors– Metastasis: spindle cell melanoma, sarcomatoid

carcinoma– Soft tissue neoplasms: schwannoma; inflammatory

pseudotumor, etc– Benign Mimics: granuloma, fibrosis/scarASC 58

th Ann

ual S

cienti

fic M

eetin

g

Page 20: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Pitfalls of Lymph Node FNA

• Subtyping Lymphomas can be difficult• Heterogeneous Aspirates are not always benign

– Mixed cell populations can occur in NHL, Hodgkin’s lymphoma, and cases with partial LN involvement

– Low grade lymphomas (marginal zone lymphomas, follicular lymphomas) can mimic reactive lymphoid hyperplasia

• Small cell carcinoma & Neuroendocrine Carcinomas• Myeloid (granulocytic) sarcoma/Chloroma• Dyscohesive Non-lymphoid Large cell Malignancies• Mimics of lymphoglandular bodies

– Platelets, necrotic debris

Kishimoto et al, Diag Cytopath 2005

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 21: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

• Cases with extensive necrosis– Benign LN conditions with necrosis:

inflammation/lymphadenitis, vasculitis, trauma/prior FNAB, autoimmune conditions (SLE), other

– Malignant LN conditions with necrosis: metastatic carcinoma (colon, small cell, etc), NHL (Burkitt, DLBCL), HL

Pitfalls of Lymph Node FNA

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 22: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

DD & Pitfalls of Necrosis

• Usual:• Reactive (Inflammatory/Infectious) Lesions:

Abscess/fat necrosis/infection (fungal, other)

• Tumor Necrosis: Primary vs Metastatic carcinoma, lymphoma, other tumors

• Unusual:• Ischemic necrosis/infarction:

Infarcted Papillary lesions, Pulmonary infarct, Post-FNA, others

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 23: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

• Plasma cell neoplasms– Can mimic non-lymphoid conditions:

melanoma, mesothelial cells, mesothelioma, carcinoma with plasmacytic differentiation

– Usually CD45 and CD20 negative– IHC pattern: -CD20, -CD19, -CD45/LCA,

+CD79a, +CD138, +CD56, +kappa/lambda

Pitfalls of Lymph Node FNA

Lymphoid cells are usually vimentin positive, so in the absence of doing a panel of lymphoid markers, one may misdiagnose lymphoid lesions (particularly plasma cell neoplasms because LCA- & CD20-) as sarcomas.

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 24: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Pitfalls/Diff Dx:-Subtyping Lymphoma-Reactive lymphoid hyperplasia -Small cell carcinoma & Neuroendocrine Carcinomas-Myeloid (granulocytic) sarcoma

SmallCells

MediumCells

LargeCells

Chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL/SLL)Mantle cell lymphoma (MCL)Follicular lymphoma (FL)Marginal zone lymphoma (MZL)Lymphoplasmacytic lymphoma (LPL)

Lymphoblastic LymphomaBurkitt Lymphoma

Diffuse Large B cell Lymphoma (DLBCL)Other Large cell lymphomas

Pitfalls/Diff Dx:-Hodgkin Lymphoma-Non-lymphoid large cell malignancies

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 25: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Difficulties in FNAB Diagnosis of Lymphoma

• Lack of architecture • Heterogeneous lymphomas• Dyscohesive neoplasms in the

differential• Need for enough material for ancillary

studies– Difficult cases with fibrosis, necrosis or

extensive cellular damage

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 26: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Difficulties in FNAB Diagnosis of Hodgkin Lymphoma

• Heterogeneous Background– Mimic of Reactive Lymphoid Hyperplasia

• Scant cellularity– Particularly in cases of nodular sclerosing HL– May benefit from concurrent core biopsy

• Need for enough material for ancillary studies– To exclude other Large cell lymphomas (ALCL,

TCRBCL)– To exclude other possibilities, such as viral

infection (EBV or HSV)Das DK et al, Diagn Cytopathol 2009

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 27: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

• Lymphoma– NHL– HL

• Plasma cell neoplasms• Poorly-differentiated carcinoma• Sarcoma• Seminoma• Melanoma

Large Cell Malignancies

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 28: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

• Granulation tissue can mimic spindle cell neoplasms• Adipocytic Tumors

– Largest group of mesenchymal tumors– Mature adipocytes from lipoma vs soft tissue around lesion

• The diagnosis of “Lipoma” requires clinical +/- radiologic correlation

– Pseudolipoblasts can be seen in other conditions• Metastatic melanoma and metastatic carcinomas with

sarcomatoid features• Large Cell Lymphomas

– Remember that vimentin positivity is very non-specificLymphomas are vimentin+, and in the context of an incomplete immunohistochemical profile may lead you falsely interpret a lesion as mesenchymal

Singh et al, Adv Anat Path, 2004

Pitfalls in Soft tissue/Bone FNA

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 29: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Pitfalls of Thyroid FNA

• Hyperplastic Nodules

• Parathyroid Sampling mimics FL/FN

• Suboptimal/Less than optimal cases– Inadequate sampling is a major cause of FNs

• Cystic lesions with no follicular cells

• Always look for any cytologic atypiaor malignant features

– Papillary Thyroid Carcinoma– Metastatic neoplasmsASC 58

th Ann

ual S

cienti

fic M

eetin

g

Page 30: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Pitfalls Of Serous Effusion

• Reactive mesothelial cells

• Histiocytic Hyperplasia

• Atypical mesothelial proliferation

• Mesothelioma:

•Well-differentiated, uncommon variants

•Mesothelioma vs. reactive mesothelial cells

•Mesothelioma vs. adenocarcinoma

• Mucinous tumors vs. mucinous carcinomas

• Serous tumors vs. serous carcinoma

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 31: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

• Lymphocyte-rich effusions

• Hematopoietic malignancies

• Epithelial malignancies: small cell ca, small round blue cell tumors

• Metastatic ductal carcinoma (elderly patients)

• Ductal carcinoma with a prominent plasmacytoid appearance

• Small-cell carcinoma of the lung

• Non-Hodgkin lymphoma

• Neuroendocrine carcinoma

• Lobular and ductal carcinoma of the breast

• Gastric adenocarcinoma

• Ewing's sarcoma/SRBCT

Pitfalls Of Effusion with Small Cell Pattern

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 32: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Pitfalls Of Effusion with Large Cell Pattern

• Adenocarcinoma (breast, lung,..). • Poorly differentiated adenocarcinoma• Malignant melanoma• Hepatocellular carcinoma• Malignant mesothelioma• Squamous cell carcinoma of the lung• Renal cell carcinoma• Malignant melanoma• Adrenal cortical carcinoma• Reactive mesothelial cells• Rheumatic effusion

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 33: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Pitfalls Of Effusion with Acinar /Clustering Cell Patterns

ACINAR

• Colonic adenocarcinoma• Cholangiocarcinoma• Ovarian epithelial neoplasms• Lung adenocarcinoma• Pseudomyxoma peritonei• Mesothelial hyperplasia• Endometriosis• Endosalpingiosis

Clustering

•Adenocarcinoma•Squamous cell carcinoma•Small cell carcinoma.•Neuroendocrine carcinoma•Mesothelioma•Mesothelial hyperplasia•Pelvic effusion clustering•Endometriosis•Endosalpingiosis

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 34: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

• Cells with Degenerative mesothelial vacuoles vs. mucin containing vacuoles• Most common: degenerative changes in mesothelial cells and non-mucinous malignancies. • Non-mucinous tumors: serous carcinoma, mesothelioma, squamous cell carcinoma, lymphoma• Other/Mimics: LE cells in lupus effusions

Pitfalls Of Effusion with Intracytoplasmic Vacuoles/Signet-Ring Cells

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 35: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

1. Viral Infection: HPV; Polyoma; Herpes2. Neobladder & Degenerative Changes 3. Calculi/Urolithiasis/ Instrumentation Atypia.4. Reactive & Reparative Changes, and Necrosis 5. Chemotherapy/Radiotherapy/BCG Tx6. Contamination: endometrial cells; Seminal Vesicle Cells

7. Cystitis Glandularis8. Pitfalls of Necrosis

Sources of Errors & Atypia in Urine Cytology

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 36: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

• Normal Specimen• Acellular or paucicellular with a few lymphocytes and monocytes.

• Any other marked cellularity suggests malignancy.• The danger of false positive diagnoses of malignancy is very great.

Pitfalls Of CSF

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 37: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

• Normal specimen– Acellular or paucicellular with a few lymphocytes and monocytes. 

• Any other marked cellularity suggests malignancy.

• The danger of false positive diagnoses of malignancy is very great.

Pitfalls Of CSF

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 38: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

• Sources of contamination. • Staining options must be considered: DQ & Pap stains.• Background renders "foreign" cells: ? malignancy:• Ependymal and choroid plexus cells, • Peripheral blood components,• Fragments of CNS tissue & bone marrow (megakaryocytes) • Chondrocytes, skin, muscle, or adipose tissue.• Fluids from fracture: bacteria, fungi (Candida), or ciliated reparatory cells

• Ventricular or reservoir samples often contain brain tissue. • Talc particles and corpora amalacea may be mistaken for fungi. • Primitive (blast‐like) cells can be seen in CSF of neonates (hemorrhage or hydrocephalus.

• Mollaret meningitis (recurrent aseptic meningitis)

Pitfalls Of CSF

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 39: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

• Secondary CNS malignancy will have a previous history of cancer or a synchronous manifestation of their neoplasm in some other site. • Occult carcinomas with leptomeningeal manifestations usually originate in the lung or the stomach. • Breast carcinoma commonly involves the CSF, but is clinically apparent prior to meningeal spread in most instances. • Hematopoietic malignancies uncommonly present as occult malignancy.• CSF lymphocytosis may shows striking reactive patterns and it may cause false positive diagnoses of lymphoma. Repeat lumbar punctures may not improve the situation, as the procedure itself can give rise to reactive lymphocytes that may resemble leukemic blasts or the cells of malignant lymphoma.

Pitfalls Of CSF

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 40: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

•The 1985 Rome Conference on Poor-Prognosis ALL defined extramedullary disease in the CNS at diagnosis as more than 5 leukocytes per micro liter and "morphologically unequivocal blasts from a cytocentrifuged sample." This problem is periodically revisited as our ability to detect very low levels of involvement based on immunostains for cell surface markers and TdT improves. While the significance of some developments is not yet clear, a few patients with low cell counts and rare blasts will experience CNS relapse.

Pitfalls Of CSF

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 41: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

• Special training and experience are required

• Many breast masses are more deeply situated than

the fingertips would suggest.

• Masses that are small, mobile, or cystic are common

(technical difficulties).

• The yield of FNA declines for lesions <1cm or >4 cm.

• The overall yield of FNA increases with even a fourth

or fifth puncture.

Pitfalls Of Breast FNA-Technical Issues

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 42: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Pitfalls Of Breast FNAs

• Cellular alterations due to inflammation or degeneration (mimicker of ca)

• Cellular changes of fibroadenoma, or gynecomastia.

• Male breast ca vs. gynecomastia.

• Papillary lesions vs. mimickers (fibroadenoma, met papillary ca.)

• Proliferative lesions of ductal epithelium;

• Masses with growth of spindle cells

• Problems related to uncommon carcinomas and their mimics.

• Myxoid changes: fibroadenoma vs. mucinous carcinoma.

• Lactational change and false positive.

• Granular cell tumors can mimic carcinoma clinically & radiographically.

• Apocrine carcinoma (contrasted with benign apocrine cells)

• Tubular carcinoma (contrasted with tubular adenoma)

• Metaplastic carcinoma with squamous differentiation vs. metastatic ca.

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 43: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

• Uncommon examples of ductal ca with acute inflammation • Lymphocytic infiltration with ductal ca of the usual types• Lymphocytic infiltration with medullary carcinoma• Lymphocytic infiltration when the masses represent LN met.• Lymphocytic infiltrate vs. lymphoma.• FAT necrosis.• Necrosis and regenerative atypia in infarction in fibroadenomas• Necrosis and regenerative atypia in infarction in a papillary lesion• Squamous or apocrine metaplasia in fibroadenomas• Proliferative ductal epithelium with a cribriform architecture • Proliferative ductal epithelium with a micropapillary architecture • Proliferative ductal epithelium with collagenous spherulosis • Necrosis of comedo DCIS,

Pitfalls Of Breast FNAs

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 44: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

Pitfalls In Liver FNA

3 main areas:• Not recognizing lesions with normal liver

components• Misinterpretation of well differentiated

hepatocellular carcinoma• Failure to differentiae poorly

differentiated hepatocellular carcinoma from metastatic tumors

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 45: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

1. Courtade-Saïdi M, Aziza J, Collin L, d'Aure D. Urine cytology pitfalls due to Polyomaviruses. Ann Pathol.. 2010 Jun;30(3):176-81.

2. Crapanzano JP, Saqi A. Pitfalls in pulmonary cytopathology. Diagn Cytopathol.. 2010 Jul 6. 3. Monaco SE, Schuchert MJ, Khalbuss WE.. Diagnostic difficulties and pitfalls in rapid on-site evaluation of

endobronchial ultrasound guided fine needle aspiration. Cytojournal. 2010 Jun 14;7:9.4. Idowu MO, Powers CN. Lung cancer cytology: potential pitfalls and mimics - a review. Int J Clin Exp Pathol. 2010

Mar 25;3(4):367-85.5. Saad RS, Silverman JF. Respiratory cytology: differential diagnosis and pitfalls. Diagn Cytopathol. 2010

Apr;38(4):297-307.6. Knezević-Obad A, Tomić-Brzac H, Zarković K, Dodig D, Stromar IK. Diagnostic pitfalls in parathyroid gland

cytology. Coll Antropol. 2010 Mar;34(1):25-97. Somma J, Schlecht NF, Fink D, Khader SN, Smith RV, Cajigas A. Thyroid fine needle aspiration cytology:

follicular lesions and the gray zone. Acta Cytol. 2010 Mar-Apr;54(2):123-318. Khalbuss WE, Teot LA, Monaco SE. Diagnostic accuracy and limitations of fine-needle aspiration cytology of

bone and soft tissue lesions: a review of 1114 cases with cytological-histological correlation. Cancer Cytopathol. 2010 Feb 25;118(1):24-32

9. Kawahara A, Harada H, Mihashi H, Akiba J, Kage M. Cytological features of cystadenocarcinoma in cyst fluid of the parotid gland: Diagnostic pitfalls and literature review. Diagn Cytopathol. 2010 May;38(5):377-81. Review.

10. Das DK, Janardan C, Pathan SK, George SS, Sheikh ZA. Infarction in a thyroid nodule after fine needle aspiration: report of 2 cases with a discussion of the cause of pitfalls in the histopathologic diagnosis of papillary thyroid carcinoma. Acta Cytol. 2009 Sep-Oct;53(5):571-5

11. Cobb CJ, Greaves TS, Raza AS. Fine needle aspiration cytology and diagnostic pitfalls in Warthin's tumor with necrotizing granulomatous inflammation and facial nerve paralysis: a case report. Acta Cytol. 2009 Jul-Aug;53(4):431-4.

12. . Monaco SE, Schuchert MJ, Khalbuss WE. Diagnostic difficulties and pitfalls in rapid on-site evaluation of endobronchial ultrasound guided fine needle aspiration. Cytojournal. 2010 Jun 14;7:9.

REFERENCES

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting

Page 46: Errors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology ... · PDF fileErrors in Non-Gynecological Cytopathology and Pathology: “There is More to Learn from System ... • Lymph

13. Penault-Llorca F, Mishellany F. Diagnostic pitfalls in mammary pathology. Case 7. Spindle-cell carcinoma of the breast or metaplastic carcinoma] Ann Pathol. 2009 Jun;29(3):223-7. Epub 2009.

14. Murali R, Loughman NT, McKenzie PR, Watson GF, Thompson JF, Scolyer RA. Cytological features of melanoma in exfoliative fluid specimens. J Clin Pathol. 2009 Jul;62(7):638-43

15. Daneshbod Y, Daneshbod K, Khademi B. Diagnostic difficulties in the interpretation of fine needle aspirate samples in salivary lesions: diagnostic pitfalls revisited. Acta Cytol. 2009 Jan-Feb;53(1):53-70.

16. Sangoi AR, Rogers WM, Longacre TA, Montoya JG, Baron EJ, Banaei N. Challenges and pitfalls of morphologic identification of fungal infections in histologic and cytologic specimens: a ten-year retrospective review at a single institution. Am J Clin Pathol. 2009 Mar;131(3):364-75.

17. Imaoka H, Yamao K, Bhatia V, Shimizu Y, Yatabe Y, Koshikawa T, Kinoshita Y. Rare pancreatic neoplasms: the utility of endoscopic ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration-a large single center study. J Gastroenterol. 2009;44(2):146-53.

18. Simsir A, Rapkiewicz A, Cangiarella J. Current utilization of breast FNA in a cytology practice. Diagn Cytopathol. 2009;37(2):140-2.

19. Handa U, Dhingra N, Chopra R, Mohan H. Pleomorphic adenoma: Cytologic variations and potential diagnostic pitfalls. Diagn Cytopathol. 2009;37(1):11-5

20. Kumar R, Sidhu H, Mistry R, Shet T. Primary pulmonary Hodgkin's lymphoma: a rare pitfall in transthoracic fine needle aspiration cytology. Diagn Cytopathol. 2008;36(9):666-9.

21. Akerman M. Fine-needle aspiration cytology of soft tissue sarcoma: benefits and limitations. Sarcoma. 1998;2(3-4):155-61.

22. Rosenberg AE. Pseudosarcomas of soft tissue. Arch Pathol Lab Med. 2008 Apr;132(4):579-86. Review.23. Pohar-Marinsek Z. Difficulties in diagnosing small round cell tumours of childhood from fine needle aspiration

cytology samples. Cytopathology. 2008 Apr;19(2):67-79.

REFERENCES

ASC 58th

Annua

l Scie

ntific

Mee

ting