ethnographic research report

Upload: karan-dudeja

Post on 10-Feb-2018

243 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    1/109

    Ota`ecrkpabi ]osokria

    Loiak`bis kt Kkb Yaroo Gaenbykr Mbgo Ikro, Ck`nab`kckr

    Gkrk` Nunojk

    @ow Lonbk Nosbc`

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    2/109

    B@NOQ

    ;. Kig`ewfoncolo`ts..... 9=. Kutembecrkpay.. >

    =.; Ienb`c k`n Olorcb`c Iktocerbos ........ 1

    =.= Yy`taosbs ... 2

    9. ]osokria [uostbe` ..;;>. ]osokriaors Hrklo ;=?. ^ao Yeibkf Creup ;98. ]osokria Tfk` .. ;23. Hbofn Nktk

    3.;Tkrtbibpktery Emsorvktbe`s .. ==3.=Fe`c B`torvbows . 19

    1. Ienb`c k`n Olorcb`c Iktocerbos . 232.

    Yy`taosbs ... ;4;

    ;4.Krtohkit ...;4?;;.]ohfoxbvbty .. ;43;=.]ohoro`ios ;41

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    3/109

    Kig`ewfoncolo`ts

    B weufn fbgo te oxpross ly noop crktbtuno te Nr. K`k`n Yugulkrk`k`n Nr. Jbc`osa Gakgakr,her taobr pktbo`t cubnk`io, o`tausbkstbi o`ieurkcolo`t k`n usohuf irbtbquos eh tabs rosokriawerg.

    B weufn kfse fbgo te tak`g Krsakn Makb, @bgabf ^kbfk`c, K`gbt Trkjkpktb, Kkfeg Jkbswkf, CkurkvTktogkr, ^k`bk Jkb`, Naruv Nklfo, Lkfk Tktof, Xbsa`u k`n Ykurkma Mabno her taobr knvbio k`nkssbstk`io b` goopb`c ly precross e` siaonufo. Ly crktohuf tak`gs kro kfse oxto`non teXrb`nk Lbsrk her aor suppert k`n o`ieurkcolo`t tareucaeut ly stuny.

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    4/109

    K_^EMBEC]KTAR

    ^ao tkfo eh tao tkbf-foss, Gkrk` Nunojk.

    K` kutembecrkpay bs fkrcofy lolery mkson. ]olb`bsio`t eh yeur ew` tblo irokton my yeu. ao

    kunbo`io ieufn mo `e e`o mut yeu er waeovor yeu'n fbgo bt te mo her. B hoof bt to`ns te mo lerojustbhbon wao` bt bs ie`iobvon erck`bikffy my seloe`o wae premkmfy bs b` tao 'sofh kitukfbsktbe`'soiter eh Lksfew's `oon iakrt. Ks k` kssbc`lo`t, bt u`no`bkmfy weufn kiabovo bts purpeso ehlkgb`c e`o hoof lero kwkro eh taolsofvos mut B stbff hoof takt tao eutput weufn mo lerokutao`tbi bh bt wks k porse`kf iaebio rktaor tak` k ielpufsbe`, `et mob`c nrbvo` my tao prossuroeh lootb`c k noknfb`o.

    Ao neos`'t qubto rololmor wakt woro tao hbrst seu`ns/kitbe s ao lkno wao` ao wks mer`, mutao's aepohuf takt tao neiter's woro ie`hbno`t o`euca te `et nbkc`eso k`y paysbefecbikfkm`erlkfbtbos b` abl mkig tao`. Bt premkmfy wks k` okrfy khtor`ee` b` k` krly cevor`lo`taespbtkf e` tao ;=ta eh @evolmor ;213 wao` tao ikoskrok` akppo`on. @e lolerbos er sterboseh wakt akn akppo`on khtor takt. Hktaor weufn'vo obtaor `klon abl Jkbnov er Gkrk`, mut aoiaeso tao fkttor. Letaor wks hb`o wbta takt iaebio. Yao wks just akppy te cot rbn eh tao kff taopkb` ao wks ikusb`c. E`o tab`c abs hktaor wks suro wks eh, wks te nrep tao lbnnfo `klo k`ntakt bs aew ao cet rocbstoron b` tao B`nbk` Tepufktbe` rocbstor, ks Gkrk` Nunojk.

    Ao wks mer` b`te k noho`io hklbfy waoro meta tao pkro`ts sorvon tao B`nbk` Kbr Herio, ao`iowks bllonbktofy sabppon te Lknrks. Lknrks bs sknfy bs `et rocbstoron kt kff b` tao lolerymk`g k`n tao b`herlktbe` e` Lknrks bs kvkbfkmfo e`fy nuo te wakt aks moo` aokrn evor taoyokrs'. Mut, bt wks aoro takt tao mkmy kfmul wks b`kucurkton my abs letaor. Lknrks to`uro wkssaert k`n heffewon my Cuwkaktb waoro ao cet abs hbrst irknfo, mut takt wks kflest `ovor uson

    moikuso abs letaor weufn mrb`c tao mkmy mey te mon wbta aor b` tao `bcats. Abs letaor'slktor`bty fokvo nbn `et fkst tee fe`c, se sao rotur`on te ehhbio k`n wks k neiter. K`n, khtor takttaoro wks k `ow lolmor b` tao aeuso, k nec. Yao wks k faksk kpse, aor `klo wks Jossbik,mut pepufkrfy g`ew` ks Jossb. Yao wks tao e`o lest pessossbvo eh tao mkmy, fottb`c `e e`o mutabs letaor cot ifeso te tao irknfo. ----

    ^ao` taoy wo`t te Aynorkmkn, k`n abs hktaor wks k hfyb`c b`struiter kt tao kbr herio kiknoly.^ao gb`norckrto` aoro wks k pfkio waoro ao lot k fet eh etaor gbns k`n lkno fets eh hrbo`ns.

    Kff taoso poepfo woro b`vbton te abs mbrtanky pkrtbos k`n weufn cot hu` rotur` cbhts te tkgo mkigaelo. Jossb moiklo lero tklon ks sao crow up. ^ao gbn cet abs hbrst trbiyifo k`n ao kfsestkrton cottb`c siefnon. ^ao hklbfy cet taobr hbrst ikr, tao iemkft mfuo Lkrutb 144. ---

    ^ao` taoy wo`t mkig te Cuwkaktb. ^ao mey's yeu`cor ieusb` sbstor iklo b` te fbvo wbta taohklbfy. K`n taoy heucat, k`n heucat k fet. Ao fokr`t te pfky tao iksbe, iress tao rekn e` abs ew`kfmobt wks kfwkys b`struiton `et te, aew te tbo abs saeo fkios k`n te rbno tao `ow mbiyifo.Yiaeef stkrton her taol. ^abs porben moiklo k fbttfo nbhhbiuft wao` tao nec cet sbig k`n e`o nkypksson kwky b` aor sfoop. ^aobr ^X sot nbn `et iktia ikmfo mkig tao` wabia wks treumfoseloks bt nbn`'t akvo ikrtee` `otwerg e` bt. Abs hktaor lot wbta k` kiibno`t tao`, wabia akppo`onwao` ao wks tryb`c te put up noierktbe` her tao mey's mbrtanky pkrty. ^ao fknnor sfbppon k`nmreucat abs hktaor new`. Ao ktto`non tao pkrty wbta k hrkituron saeufnor. Abs hktaor wks kfsewre`cfy nbkc`eson wbta k aokrt premfol wabia fon te abl mob`c creu`non her ielb`c yokrs.Mohero fokvb`c, abs hktaor sefn ehh abs vospk wabia wks tao most rbno ovor.---

    Cuwkaktb wks heffewon my Iak`nbckra. ^abs jeur`oy, k rekn trbp. Sao` taoy rokiaon, taoy

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    5/109

    stkrton ehh hrel k slkff trk`sbt kiiellenktbe` her k fe`c tblo. ^ao CB Jeo's iklo b` k`n taokrly crow fkrcor. ^ao stre`c peb`t eh ie`to`tbe` wks tao hkit takt mkrmbo's kfse woro ielb`c b`.^ao gbns crow lero vbefo`t, k`n taoy heucat kff tao lero `ew. ^ao aeuso akn cukvk trooskreu`n waoro tao ak`cb`c new` hrel tao troo upsbno new` wks soo` ks tao lest nkrb`c tksg.Bt wks kfse tkgo` up ks e`io yeu steen uprbcat kckb`, tao rusa eh mfeen wks oxabfkrktb`c. ^aoro

    wks strky nec taoy nelostbikton. Hktaor ikffon abl "Ytupbn", k`n stupbn wks hu`. Yaeut stupbn- stupbn hrel tao peria eh yeur aeuso k`n bt weufn ielo ru``b`c hrel selo nbroitbe` fbgo k mefteh fbcat`b`c. ^ao pkro`ts' teeg k fet eh b`torost b` tao roiroktbe`kf kitbvbtbos her gbns, mosbnosrocufkrfy ceb`c eut her pbi`bis, levbos k`n nb`o euts. Kflest tarbio b` k woog weufn taoy ce herGkrkto, Ywbllb`c, Sostor` Nk`io k`n Ygktb`c sossbe`s b` Iak`nbckra ibty. Etaor nkys woroher nrkwb`c er just pfkyb`c e` yeur ew`. Yakrb`c tao iyifo wks moielb`c nbhhbiuft. Ye, hktaor cetabl tao `ow MYK Mkzeegk wabia akn k hre`t saeig kmsermb`c suspo`sbe`. ^ao etaor nkyswao` taoy woro `et rbppb`c okia etaor kpkrt tao iabfnro` wo`t te tao suckrik`o hbofns k`n stefoselo eh takt. Ao fokr`t irbigot kfse taoro, mut seloaew ieufn`'t o`jey tao cklo tee luia. Abssbstor tur`on eut te mo k` ktafoto k`n sao mokt abl kt kflest ovory rkio. Mut, ao ieufn sgktomottor, k`n nurb`c tao prkitbio her e`o eh tao ovo`ts ao sfbppon evor k fbttfo punnfo eh wktor. ^ao

    rosuft eh tao hkff wks k hrkituron wrbst. Iak`nbckra wks mokutbhuf mkig tao`, her bt akn tao trkhhbibsfk`ns, reig ckrno`, reso ckrno`, tao weeno` sgktb`c rb`g, soiter - ;3, tao tey saep taoro k`nfkst mut `et fokst wks tao aet lbffbe`s taoro. ^akt wks waoro ao hbrst tkston tao pbzzk. Absieusb` hrel abs hktaor's sbno weufn kfse vbsbt taol selotblos. Ao weufn ielo b` tao saktkmnboxpross. ^ao mey o`vbon tabs hoffew her ao akn k vbnoe cklo, k`n k roleto ie`tref ikr. B`siaeef tao mey wks neb`c hb`o k`n tao pkro`ts `ovor cet tee lk`y ielpfkb`ts. Ao porherlone` tao iksbe kt k siaeef hu`itbe`. Nk`ib`c e` tao stkco kt k`etaor ovo`t wks kfse hu`. Aofokr`t aew te ifblm troo k`n siero lk`ceos. Ao iakson le`ceesos. Ytkrton fokr`b`c oxtroloehh rekn mbgb`c, k`n mrego abs hre`t toota wao` tao hre`t tyro iklo ehh. ^ao prb`ibpkf eh abssiaeef uson te fbvo ifeso, k`n abs fkst `klo wks iaknnak takt lkno pfkyb`c wbta abs se`ieb`ibno`tkffy k fet lero hu`. Ao fokr`t aew te pfky lkrmfos(gk`iao) k`n cuff nk`nk taoro seluia takt ao cet abs ew` cuff k`n nk`nks lkno e` k rocufkr mksbs hrel tao ikrpo`tor. Ao cetb`trenuion te Nesk k`n Iabigo` kfse aoro ieurtosy tao Yu`nrkl's wae erbcb`kffy mofe`con teLknurkb. ^ao stktbe` iellk`nor khtor taol wks k lk` wae nrk`g k fet mut akn twe vory prottynkucators. ^abs wks tao hbrst aeuso waoro taoy cet k tofopae`o, k fk`nfb`o k`n wbta takt iklotao fosse` eh tofopae`o otbquottos. Aoro ao suhhoron abs hbrst nec mbto. ^aoy vbsbton k fet eh abffstktbe`s fbgo Yablfk, Lk`kfb, Lusseerbo, oti. Xbsbt te tao Makgrk @k`ckf Nkl wks foco`nkry kstao hklbfy cet te soo pewor co`orktbe` io`tro hrel b`sbno. Bt wks k fbttfo fbgo tao stkrtb`c sio`oseh tao hbfl Cefno` Oyo. ^rbps te Foa-Fknkga woro kfse lkno k`n taeuca tao pfkio wks `bio,seloaew tao fkig eh ielpk`y k`n strk`co sloffb`c ofnors wks `et hu` her abl. Mut, ao ieufnokt ks luia lele ks ao wk`ton wabia wks b`io`tbvo o`euca. Abs sbstor wo`t mkig te fknkga

    te stky wbta aor hefgs. ^ao ^X kt aelo taeuca, stbff nbn `et cot ikrtee` `otwerg. ---

    Aynorkmkn ikffon taol kckb`. ^aoro taoy sabhton hrel tao loss, te tao mbc ehhbior's aeuso, tek` ovo` mbccor aeuso. Ao iak`con twe iyifos taoro, tao hbrst e`o cet stefo` k`n tao` iklo taosoie`n e`o. ^ao most e`o yot. ^abs wbff mo nbsiusson kaokn. ^ao mey crow mbccor, k`n se nbnabs hrbo`n ibrifo. Ao cet mottor kt swbllb`c, k`n pfkyon irbigot e`fy moikuso etaor gbns weufnpfky tao cklo. ^abs wks waoro ao saet tao lest lolerkmfo sbx eh abs fbho, moikuso seloaewtao ie`tkit wks se porhoit takt tao mkff kflest wo`t aerbze`tkf kiress tao meu`nkry. Aomoiklo tao le`bter eh abs ifkss aoro k`n pu`iaon k cbrf e`o nky rokf akrn b` aor cuts her saonbn `et fbsto` te abl. ^ao heffewb`c woog abs siaeef cet iak`con. ^ao `ow siaeef wks `bior.Mut, aoro ao stkrton lkgb`c selo o`olbos, k`n taus lero hbcats b` siaeef. Heetmkff wks

    nbsievoron k`n abs hktaor heu`n cefh. ^ao CB Jeo krly moiklo ovo` fkrcor. Ao heu`n taktlkccb wks k rokffy hu` s`kig takt ovo` ao ieufn lkgo. Yullors woro kfwkys pkigon wbta

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    6/109

    selo gb`n eh oxtrk iurrbiufkr ifkssos. Ye, bt wks swbllb`c k`n selotab`c takt ao nbn `et o`jeytee luia wks makrkt`ktykl, k`n ao wks tao e`fy mey taoro. Ao wks oxpeson te gbto hfyb`ctaoro, kstorbx k`n emofbx, tb`tb`, tao hkleus hbvo, spertstkr, kute lkcs k`n tao hroo pestors taktiklo wbta tao porbenbikfs. Khtor tao ovo`b`c cklos k`n fbmrkry tblo, ao stkrton fokr`b`cmbffbkrns. My `ew taoy akn k aeuso wabia akn k mbc torrkio waoro rkb` nk`io wks kfwkys

    ielpufsery. B` abs siaeef, ao `ovor kto abs tbhhb` k`n weufn kfwkys fevo te trkno bt her tao ronk`n wabto rbio takt tao etaor feikfbtos mreucat. Ao fokr`t lk`y tofucu kmusos b` siaeef mutkiton b``eio`t kt aelo. B` ;223, khtor k trbp te @kckrju`k Nkl iklo tao rovofktbe` her ablkmeut abs lel mob`c proc`k`t k`n takt see` ao weufn akvo k mretaor er k sbstor te pfky wbtak`n muffy kreu`n. Ylkff we`nor k`n we`nor yokrs woro saews takt woro heffewon rofbcbeusfye` ^X. ^ao reel stkrton cottb`c lero porse`kfbson wbta wkffs mob`c pestorbhbon, reel mob`cgopt tao wky ao weufn fbgo, e`fy ks fe`c ks tao ifok`fb`oss wks upte lel's stk`nkrns. Abs AbHbsystol wks creevy k`n se wks tao ikssotto ieffoitbe`. ]kigot cklos sunno`fy teeg abs hk`iyk`n ao mock` pfkyb`c squksa, to``bs k`n mknlb`te`. ^ao hklbfy pkb`tb`c wks lkno my k feikfkrtbst wabia wks k `bio knnbtbe` b` tao nrkwb`c reel. ^aoy hb`kffy cet k` evo` k`n ovo` taeucaabs letaor teeg mkgb`c ifkssos, tao evo` wks e`fy utbfbson te roaokt heen. ^ao mkmy hb`kffy

    iklo, k`n bt wks mkmy mey te abs hktaor's nbslky her ao wk`ton k sbstor her abl. ^ao mey wksiarbsto`on Govb`, ovo` taeuca abs ofnor mretaor taeucat eh `klb`c abl "]eig". K`yaew Govb`Nunojk wks mottor, ks ao `ovor fbgon poepfo ksgb`c abl "Gkrk`, waoro bs Krju` 5" ^abs mkmywks iuto, k`n sloft we`norhuf. ^ao e`fy premfol wks takt tao mkmy reffon tee luia e` tao monk`n taus hoff ehh tee lk`y tblos her k`ye`o te rololmor. ^ao ^X stbff nbn `et akvo ikrtee``otwerg. ---

    Bt wks tblo te iak`cos mksos `ew, k`n se wo wo`t te Yurktckra wabia k rokf slkff tew` b`]kjkstak`, k pkrt eh tao Ck`ck`kckr nbstrbit. ^ao pfkio bs kfse hkleus her bts goo`u pfk`tktbe`.^ao kbr herio stktbe` ao`io wks kfse ie`sbnorkmfy slkffor. ^abs pfkio wks waoro abs fevo herabs mretaor rokffy crow. ^ao aeuso wks kfse feikton kt k pfkio k`y gbn weufn fevo te stky, her btwks kpprexblktofy =44lotros kwky hrel tao ru`wky. ^ao hksib`ktbe` her hfyb`c gbigon b`.Ovorynky, tao tkgo ehh k`n fk`nb`c seu`ns weufn lkgo ovorye`o's okrs ce `ulm u`tbf taoy ceuson te bt. ^ao ieusb` sbstor rotur`on aoro. ^ao hbcats akn `ew nrkstbikffy ronuion `ew. ^aomey jeb`on ifkssos te fokr` tao tkmfk. Iabffy iabigo` moiklo tao hkveurbto heen, k`n ceb`c te taocurunwkrk te cot tao akfwk wks tao `ow tab`c te ne. B` siaeef, tao gbns cottb`c lero stunbeusk`n tao sumjoits tkucat lkno tao mkc aokvy. Ao fokr`t te pfky tao iau`cb. Abs hktaor cet k joophrel tao ehhbio, k`n bt nbn `et akvo k reeh her tao fe`cost tblo. ^ao` ao cet tao `ow iyifonkssolmfon, k`n bt wks hfuerosio`t croo` b` iefeur. Bt teeg abl hkstor tareuca torrkb`s, takt woroblpessbmfo her etaor poepfo te ievor. ^ao stb`t taoro aewovor wks saert ks ao wks so`t te krosbno`tbkf siaeef tao`. ---

    Mbrfk Tumfbi Yiaeef, Tbfk`b wks tao `ow pfkio waoro e`fy meys stunbon. Abs pkro`ts' rkrofy iklote vbsbt abl k`n takt wks ceen. Mut, iellu`biktbe` wks `ew evor Y^N ikffs k`n ielpufseryfottors ks por siaeef rufos. Ao cet rkccon taoro, k`n fokr`t te ho`n her ablsofh. E`fy sbssy gbnsweufn ielpfkb` te taobr pkro`ts b` ikso eh treumfo, suia wks tao eutfeeg ielle`fy provkbfb`c.Fbho ru` ks por tao moff. Skgb`c up moff, T^ moff, mrokghkst moff, prkyor moff, ifkss tblo moff,roioss moff, fu`ia moff, ifkss tblo moff, ifkss evor moff, stuny tblo moff, cklos moff, cklos evormoff, stuny tblo moff, nb``or moff, stuny tblo moff, stuny evor moff, fbcats eut. ^abs wks fbho waotaoryeu kro b` Yum Ju`bers, Ju`bers, Lbnnfo er Yo`ber Yoitbe`. B` tao so`ber soitbe`, ao cet rkcconovo` lero. ^ao waefo nerlbtery weufn mo rkccon. Yo`bers woro tao e`fy kutaerbty her tao

    ju`bers. Sakt taoy skbn wks otiaon b` ste`o. Ovory iellk`n akn te emonbo`tfy sorvon. Reu

    `ovor akn k iaebio. @e e`o romoffon, ks yeu g`ow takt wao` yeu moielo k so`ber yeu weufno`jey kff tao fbmortbos yeursofh. ^ao aeuso wks tao e`fy purpeso te fbvo, k`n tao sperts ovo`ts

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    7/109

    woro tao mbccost ovo`ts her tao siaeef. Ao stkrton pfkyb`c seiior, mock` swbllb`c k`n lknobt te tao siaeef tokl her meta b` abs kco creup. Fokr`t aerso rbnb`c, veffoymkff, tkmfo to``bs.Moiklo k pkrt eh tao siaeef iaebr k`n tao @II. B`nufcon b` wre`c kitbvbtbos, fbgo julpb`c taomeu`nkry wkffs, mrokgb`c hkiufty rosbno`io wb`news, oti. Aokrn eh b`stk`ios, takt b` rotrespoitieufn mo ikffon iksos eh aelesoxukf moakvbeur. Tumorty akn sot b` tao`, k`n vebio stkrton

    irkigb`c. Yunno`fy, cottb`c kig`ewfoncolo`t hrel tao eppesbto sox stkrton soolb`cblpertk`t. Moiklo k verkibeus roknor eh tao ab`nb ielbis fbgo supor iellk`ne naruv, `kcrkj,iak iak iaeunakry, neck, tbrk`ck oti. Kfse, cet oxpeson te knuft lkckzb`os. Aestof wks k feteh hu`, u`tbf pkro`ts k``eu`ion tao wbtanrkwkf hrel taoro. ---

    Moikuso abs lel wo`t te tao Lbnnfo Okst khtor rotbrb`c hrel tao kbr herio, ao wks mreucat mkigte tkgo ikro eh abs mretaor. Abs hktaor wks `ew stktbe`on b` @ow Nofab. Ao wks put b` k siaeefifeso my k`n abs gbn mretaor kfse akn jeb`on tao gb`norckrto` `ew. ^ao iak`co te mbc ibty wksqubto nrkstbi her abl. ^ao `ow siaeef wks `bio her bt akn cbrfs mut bt wks nbskppeb`tb c her bt nbn`et akvo tao hkibfbtbos k`n tao gb`n eh hrbo`ns ao lkno b` tao aestof. Mob`c k nky siaefkrsuigon. ^ao gbns b` tao siaeef woro nbhhoro`t. E`o eh tao okrfy iakffo`cos ao hkion wks tao

    fk`cukco. Aoro, ao `etbion tao uskco eh o`cfbsa wks vory ielle` kle`cst stuno`ts. ^aoetaor iakffo`co wks spokgb`c te tao eppesbto co`nor. Ao stkrton pfkyb`c mksgotmkff, akn absefn mbgo rosteron. Bt wks tblo her iabfnro` te hkio tao aerrer eh mekrn oxkls. ^akt pksson. ^aosumjoits iaeso` kaokn woro TILM, tao teucaost ielmb`ktbe` her tao lest stunbeus iabfnro`k`n bre`bikffy tao sklo yokr tao nosbro te stuny wks ielpfotofy fest. Bt wks e`fy kmeut taocklos eutneers k`n b`neers her taoy `ew akn k pfkystktbe` k`n Ikrtee` @otwerg. ^ao` b` taofkst yokr eh siaeef, tao hklbfy cet rofeikton wbtab` tao ibty te k `ow seiboty. Iellutb`c tesiaeef b` tao mus wks hu` ks kff tao so`ber iabfnro` cet te eiiupy tao lest ievoton mkig sokts.B` tao fkst yokr eh siaeef, ao akn abs hbrst ehhbibkf khhkbr wbta k iarbstbk` cbrf. ^ao hb`kf oxklso`non k`n se nbn tao saert rofktbe`sabp.---

    Abs hktaor foht tao kbrherio, levon te mk`ckfero. ^ao letaor rotur`on hrel taoro. Ao wksifuofoss wakt te ne wbta abs fbho kaokn. Ovorye`o kreu`n wks tkfgb`c kmeut ieffocos eh N_,Lonbikf k`n eh ieurso o`cb`oorb`c. Ao ckvo tao stk`nkrn sot eh ielpotbtbvo oxkls, k`n cetknlbtton te k` o`cb`oorb`c ieffoco khhbfbkton te tao CCYBT _`bvorsbty mkson kt @ow Nofab. Aocet te stky b` Aestof kckb`. O`cb`oorb`c wks teuca mut ao hkron tareuca bt wbtaeut fokr`b`ck`ytab`c. Ao cet te g`ew kmeut nosbc` k`n @BN b` tao fkst solostor . Bt wks hksib`ktb`c. Ao hoftfbgo rokiab`c her bt.

    Ao cet "pfkiolo`ts" hrel tao ieffoco, mut iaeso `et te tkgo taol. Kppfbon te Meso her taopesbtbe` eh k nosbc` o`cb`oor. Hertu`ktofy, ao irkigon bt k`n ao`io wks abron. Hbrst jem, vory

    klmbtbeus, vory iurbeus, vory o`tausbkstbi mut bt kff ovo`tukffy iklo new` e`io tao pbituromoiklo ifokror eh tao cekfs eh tao erck`bsktbe`. Yelo roquosts ao lkno woro put ehh, seloworo tur`on k nokh okr te. Ao fest b`torost k`n mock` sokriab`c lero kmeut nosbc`. Ao hoft absikffb`c k`n taus noibnon te cbvo bt k saet. ^ao messos woro b`herlon, taoy rofuitk`tfy kcroonkhtor kff taoy akn `e iaebio. Ao cet tareuca `ow lonbk nosbc` k`n levon te ck`nab`kckr. Aoaks spo`t e`o yokr aoro, k`n feegs herwkrn te lero.

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    8/109

    Iktocerbsktbe` eh Kutembecrkpay:

    ;. _son te trkvoffb`c.=. Ao saews akvb`c lkno k fet eh hrbo`ns.9. ^aoro bs k abca kiqubrb`c `kturo mob`c rohfoiton.

    >. Abs pkro`ts kro saew` te mo fevb`c k`n strbit, waoro meta akvo akn siefnon tao mey.?. Fbgb`c her ABY teys bs ovbno`t.8. Yakrb`c wbta sbmfb`c wks k nbhhbiufty.3. K vbefo`t strokg b` tao okrfy nkys bs vbsbmfo.1. Fbgb`c her nkrb`c k`n knvo`tureus tksgs.2. O`vy her `et akvb`c wakt ieusb` akn.;4. Tkrtbibpktbe` b` kitbvbtbos fbgo nk`io, k`n lusbi wbta o`tausbksl.;;. Ytre`c fbgb`c her heen bs rohfoiton.;=. Fbgb`c her ikrtee`s bs kfse olorcb`c.;9. Fbgb`c tao kutaerbtkrbk`bsl k`n pewor.;>. @et k pkrtbiufkrfy sbc`bhbik`t b`torost b` kiknolbis.

    ;?. Mofbovor b` hkbr trkno.;8. Lero porse`kfbson k`n B`nbvbnukfbstbi so`so b` selo kroks.;3. Ytre`c rohoro`ios te emjoits k`n taobr sbzos.;1. Hksib`ktbe` eh hfyb`c.;2. Fossor kttkialo`t tewkrns pkro`ts.=4. O`jeyb`c poors k`n ielpk`y.=;. K` ksseibktbe` wbta aborkriay.==. K wk`t te cot tao teuca/proibeus bs vbsbmfo.=9. Novofeplo`t eh tao se ikffon "o`olbos".=>. Cottb`c ktto`tbe` hrel tao eppesbto co`nor, saew` sbc`bhbik`t.

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    9/109

    Yy`taosbs eh Kutembecrkpay:

    Ks hkr ks k`kfysbs eh taoso iktocerbos ce, B soo takt tao peb`ts weufn kffew lo te abcafbcatselo mbksos takt lkymo aofn my tao rosokriaor k`n taeso takt lbcat khhoit tao hrklo eh taorosokriaor e` tao hbofn. aoso kro e`fy b`torprotktbe`s k`n et ie`ifusbe s.

    B` tao ovo`t eh seloe`o(hrel tao seibkf creup) mob`c poriobvon ks ielb`c e` stre`cwbta tao b`to`tbe` eh rostruiturb`c tao mofboh systol eh tao rosokriaor, taoro bs pessbmfy kto`no`iy te rojoit bt ielpfotofy k`n tabs lero se bh krreck`io sots b` wabia lbcat fokn tebrrbtkmbfbty k`n iurt`oss. Ao`io, e`o `oons te tkgo k` blpertk`t `eto eh tabs.

    Kfse, e`o ieufn ce kreu`n wbta tao fkto`t b to`t te onuikto(ne `et ce eut taoro teonuikto) tao seibkf creup k`n tabs, bh `et kiiopton my taol lbcat kfse ikuso rokitbe`s strbgb`co`euca te lkgo tao sumjoits hoof blpeson upe`. Bh bt bs kiiopton tao`, bt lbcat ikuso k sunno`b`ifb`ktbe` tewkrns takt creup er b`nbvbnukf. ^abs `oons te mo gopt k iaoig e` ks woff.

    E`o wbff akvo te mo ikrohuf kmeut tao oxto`t te wabia e`o lb`cfos wbta poepfo, ks e`olbcat cot furon b`te tryb`c te cot ktto`tbe` eh tao holkfos eh takt creup, wabia ik` ikuso tao

    lo` eh tao creup te hb`n bt u`kiioptkmfo. ^abs ik` ikuso selo sorbeus ifesb`c eh cktos k`nirokto to`sbe` wbta tao lo` eh takt seibkf sottb`c. Kfse, b` iksos wao` e`o bs feegb`c herco`orkf ktto`tbe` hrel tao creup, tao` taoro lbcat mo k to`no`iy te b`irokso sofh werta k`ntaorohero tao b`torost b` tao kitbvbty mut bh tao creup bs `et rotur`b`c knoquktofy(ks oxpoiton)tao` bt lbcat ikuso tao rosokriaor te hoof fbgo "etaors" kro `et b`toroston ks luia, k`n tausnbskppeb`tlo`t k`n hrustrktbe` lbcat sottfo b`.

    ^ao rosokriaor wbff akvo te goop abs b`torost eh ieffoitb`c "nktk" ceb`c stoknbfy ks kstre`c mo`n tewkrns mob`c "nktk au`cry" ieufn lkgo tao pkrtbibpk`ts hoof emjoitbhbon erronuion te sblpfy nktk seurios.

    ^ao rosokriaor saeufn mo epo` te cbvb`c hkbr b`herlktbe` te tao pkrtbibpk`ts kmeutabl/aorsofh k`n pkrtbibpktb`c b` taobr kitbvbtbos rktaor tak` goopb`c tao o`ckcolo`t purofytrk`skitbe`kf lkb`fy hrel taobr o`n. Trevbnb`c wre`c b`herlktbe` k`n nofbvorkmfos wbff `et mo kceen prkitbio.

    ^ao rosokriaor wbff akvo te goop k rokfbstbi k`n prkitbikf eutfeeg ks tabs bs `et ceb`c temo k` knvo`turo tarbffb`c spert, tao oxpoitktbe`s eh wabia ik` b`btbkffy mo abca k`n taus lkgoabl oxpoit k` bffusbe`kry rusa kt tao o`n eh tao preioss. Mut, tao o`ckcolo`t fovofs akvo te mole`bteron etaorwbso stre`cfy mofbovb`c b` tao hkit bt bs `et ceb`c te cbvo k`y knro`kfb`o rusalbcat lkgo abl pkrtbibpkto kt k fugowkrl fovof. Ovo` taeuca tao rbsgs fovofs lky vkry mut bhtao rbsg fovofs kro few b` selo kroks tao` tao rosokriaor lbcat tkgo takt pkta k`n b` tur` hb`nk` oksy wky eut, er blpeso k sofh iakffo`co e`fy te prevo k peb`t.

    ^ao fbgb`c her heen wbff kffew tao rosokriaor te kiiopt tao ehhorb`cs lkno, akppbfy.

    ^ao rosokriaor ik``et kppokr te mo tee notkiaon hrel tao creup ao bs b`torkitb`c wbta ks taome`nb`c herlon o`rbiaos tao rosokria preioss k`n tao kleu`t eh kiioss e`o hb`ns. B` torls ehaborkriay, tao rosokriaor wbff akvo te mo ikrohuf eh `et nbspfkyb`c pewor te taeso ao lbcat hoofkro mofew abl. E` tao ie`trkry, tao rosokriaor wbff akvo te mo ikutbeus eh `et tryb`c te obtaorcot ropufson my pewor nbspfkyb`c ckto goopors k`n b`sbnors. ^ao rosokriaor kfse lust `et cotevorfy kttrkiton tewkrns pewor pessossb`c lolmor(s) eh tao seibkf creup.

    ^ao rosokria bs `et e` k troksuro au`t, taus ao aks te o`suro takt abs knvk`ios te nbc b`noopor te kttkb` k "proibeus" b`herlktbe`/b`sbcat bs `et soo` ks tee o`irekiab`c my tao seibkfcreup. ^abs lbcat ropof tao creup k`n e`fy kffew irbtbikffy ie`treffon kiioss. E`o aks te movory ikrohuf eh stkyb`c pefbtbikffy ierroit k`n `et kit b` wkys takt lbcat ikuso poepfo b` taocreup te mocb` aktb`c tao preioss eh mob`c stunbon, ks lkgb`c o`olbos weufn mo uttorfy hutbfo

    k`n wertafoss. Yaeufn nbhhoro`ios krbso, taoy lust mo ak`nfon ikrohuffy k`n knnrosson wbtaikutbe`. Ks bt weufn iak`co tao b`torost fovofs eh meta, tao creup k`n tao rosokriaor.

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    10/109

    B` tao ovo`t eh hb`nb`c tao rbcat creup, tao rosokriaor saeufn mo kmfo te lkb`tkb` k irbtbikfnbstk`io te kiabovo tao emjoitbvo eh tao rosokria k`n stky wkry eh lkgb`c stre`c hrbo`nsabpstakt lbcat nbfuto tao emjoitbvbty eh tao rosokriaor. Mut, me`nb`c bs kfse k pesbtbvo takt ik` cbvoceen fokn(s).

    ^ao mofboh b` hkbr trkno ieufn mo wertawabfo u`foss tao rosokriaor mocb`s te ovkfuktoovory oxiak`co kt selo porse`kf fovof, lkgb`c abl hoof saertiak`con k`n taus khhoit abs ew`pkrtbibpktbe`.

    Ytre`c oletbe`kf mursts `oon te kiton upe` rktbe`kffy e` tao hbofn k`n vbefo`io bsmk``on(stre`cfy knvbson kckb`st).

    Nbspfky eh sofhbsa moakvbeur wbff kfse mo k mbc @E e` tao hbofn, mut tkgb`c poepfo b`teie`hbno`io wbff roqubro selo nbspfky eh mob`c kmfo te wbtaaefn b`herlktbe` hrel just kmeutk`ye`o.^ao rosokriaor wbff akvo te `et cot ikrrbon kwky b` hb`nb`c k seibkf creup ks ao `oons te trkvofknoquktofy moikuso tao preioss nolk`ns trk`sirbmb`c tao ie`vorsktbe` wabia bs k tblo tkgb`cpreioss, ao`io goopb`c tao trkvof fblbton.

    Knnbtbe`kf @etos:

    Kff noibsbe s `oon te mo tkgo` rktbe`kffy.

    Olpktay k`n ielpkssbe` fovofs oon te mo ie`treffon.

    Nktk au`cry-`oss bs et knvbson. Ievort rosokria lotaens kro et kffewon.

    Oxpoitktbe` fovofs lust mo le`bteron.

    Trelbsos lkno lust mo rokfbstbi. ^ao qubn pre que saeufn mo mkfk`ion, `et `oiosskrbfy oqukf.

    Mo ikrohuf te `et fot tao b`torost fovofs hkffs qubigfy.

    Oxtrk aofpfoss`oss weufn kfse khhoit tao fovofs te wabia tao sumjoits wbff pkrtbibpkto wbta.Moikuso bh tao sumjoits u`norstk`n takt taoro bs`'t luia yeu akvo te ehhor b` rotur` tao` taobrb`torost fovofs weufn nbo new`.

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    11/109

    ]OYOK]IA [_OY^BE@

    ^ao kbl eh tao prejoit wks te u`norstk`n tao kurkf fbho werfn eh k seibkf creup, wabia ieufn monorbvon hrel taobr wergb`c o`vbre`lo`t k`n te ielproao`n tao lok`b`c(s) ksseibkton wbta tao

    seu`ns b` taobr seibe iufturkf ie`toxt. ^ao stuny roqubron te mo porherlon usb`c taopao`elo`efcbikf kpprekia k`n lotaens eh ota`ecrkpabi rosokria.

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    12/109

    ]OYOK]IAO]Y H]KLO

    ^ao kutembecrkpay oxoribso aofpon us b` u`norstk`nb`c eh eur ew` hrklos. Bts sy`taosbs aksk` oxto`sbvo oxpfk`ktbe` eh tao sklo. B wk`ton te preioon tewkrns tao ota`ecrkpabi rosokriapreioss wbta kwkro`oss eh taol. Ye, ks por ly u`norstk`nb`c tao`, selo eh tab`cs B `oonon

    te ie`sbnor wabfo ceb`c e` te hb`n tao seibkf creup k`n kfse wabfo pkrtbibpktb`c wbta e`o woro ksheffews:- B wk`ton te hb`n k seibkf creup wabia saeufn mo ifeso my te ly pfkio eh rosbno`io.- ^ao fk`cukco taoy spego kfse lkttoron aokvbfy ks B ne `et g`ew cujkrktb, se tao akvb`c

    obtaor ab`nb er o`cfbsa ks taobr ielhertkmfy spego` fk`cukco wks k`etaor ie`sbnorktbe .- ^ao bnok eh voston b`torosts wks kfse qubto nelb`k`t b`torost b` ly lb`n, her bt te mo wb`

    wb` sbtuktbe` her meta, tao rosokriaor k`n abs creup.- Iaeesb`c k pfkio waoro heen wks sorvon b.o. fbgo k rostkurk`t wks k`etaor b`ifb`ktbe` nuo

    te ly fbgb`c her heen.- Hb`kffy, B nbn `et wk`t te ielo kiress ks k puro nktk au`cry k`n porsbsto`t rosokriaor

    wae weufn o`irekia e` tao paysbefecbikf k`n psyiaefecbikf spkios eh tao creup.- B weufn akvo te le`bter ly oxpoitktbe` fovofs- B wbff `et lkgo hkfso prelbsos, k`n mkfk`io tao qubn pre que, bh k`y.

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    13/109

    ^AO YEIBKF C]E_T

    ^ao pfkio waoro tao stuny wks ie`nuiton bs k twe waoofor wergsaep mkson b` @owCk`nab`kckr. Bt wks iaeso` lestfy moikuso bt bs ifeso my, taoy kff spokg ab`nb hfuo`tfy, vostonb`torosts woro rohfoiton b` g`ewb`c kmeut twe waoofor ikro k`n ropkbr, k`n hb`kffy tao ew`or

    g`ow lo hrel mohero. Ao bs k co`tfo k`n aespbtkmfo porse`, wae nokfs wbta knufts eh kff kcocreups k`n premkmfy weufn kffew ly rosokria her ao weufn kfse poriobvo lo ks k peto`tbkfiustelor. Bt bs ikffon Kkb Yaroo Gaenbykr Mbgo Ikro k`n bs ew`on my Jbttumakb. ^ao ckrkco bsfeikton kmeut ? lb`utos kwky hrel @BN bh e` k ie`voyk`io k`n =4 lb`utos kwky bh e` heet. Bthkffs te tao rbcat wabfo ceb`c tewkrns Kalonkmkn, tao kiioss bs oksbor bh tao sorvbio fk`o bstkgo`. Bt feikton b` tao Ywkckt ]kb` Herost Ielpfox. K`n bt hkffs b` tao lbnnfo eh twe saeps,e`o bs Saoof Teb`t her tyros ikro k`n ropkbr eh heur waoofors k`n tao etaor bs tao hkleusvocotkrbk` rostkurk`t ikffon Iaktge. Abs ieffokcuos kro Yktbsa Makb k`n @kro`nrk Makb. aoyakvo k vory hroquo`t vbsbter, ao bs Lugatkr Makb. ^ao ckrkco stkys epo` Le`nky tareucaYkturnky hrel 2 b` tao ler`b`c te 3:94 b` tao ovo`b`c. ^ao porse`kf notkbfs eh tao lolmors bsproso`ton kaokn.

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    14/109

    Jbttu Makb

    @klo7 ]ktaero Jbttu MakbKco79? yokrsLkrbtkf Ytktus7 RosIabfnro`7 Ros, ; Ofnor Nkucator k`n ; Reu`cor Ye`]osbno`io7Kfklper Xbffkco, Ifeso te Krly Ik tt, Ck`nab`kckr

    Serg Oxporbo`io7 ;2 yokrsNbstk`io eh ]osbno`io hrel Serg7 ;? gls

    Serg Knnross7Kkb Yaroo Gaenbykkr Mbgo Ikro, H-44=, Ywkckt ]kb` Herost ;,Ter Gunksk` ]ekn, Gunksk`, Ck`nab`kckr

    Jbttu Makb, bs tao lk` wae ru`s tao saew kt Kkb Yaroo Gaenbykkr Mbgo Ikro. Abswergsaep aoro bs k fbttfo efnor tak` k yokr evor aoro. Mohero tabs ao wks mkson b` Yoiter =; b`Ck`nab`kckr.

    Ao bs vory he`n eh twe waoofors k`n iklo b`te tabs prehossbe` moikuso eh abs porse`kfb`torost. Ao stkrton fokr`b`c b` Kalonkmkn. Ao o`jeys rbnb`c Rklkak ]Q ;44 k`n wao` btielos te hbxb`c, abs oxportbso fbos b` ]eykf O`hbofns. Abs wergsaep bs hkleus b` Ck`nab`kckrk`n lk`y kute pkrt nokfors b` Yoiter =; g`ew eh abs stero k`n taus ie`suft ]eykf O`hbofnew`ors te abs ckrkco. Ao kfse ie`sufts kt tao ]eykf O`hbofn Yaewreel wao` taoy cot efn

    lenof voabifos, k`n bs g`ew` kt tao Kbr Herio k`n Krly Iklps her lkb`to`k`io eh taobrvoabifos.

    Ao bs k vocotkrbk` k`n aks moo` e`o her tao fkst hbhtoo` yokrs nuo te abs b`fuo`io ehKkb Yaroo Gaebnykkr wae bs tao hklbfy curu. Ao aks k ikfl porse`kfbty k`n ielos kiress ksk` b`trevort. ^ao lk` bs pktbo`t k`n k ielpfotofy nonbikton wergor. Kt tao ckrkco, ao stkyserck`bson b` abs werg k`n wk`ts te akvo k mbccor ckrkco fktor wao` abs se` wae kfse saewsb`ifb`ktbe` b` tabs prehossbe` wbff jeb` abl. Ao o`ieurkcos fokr`b`c, k`n pkys ktto`tbe` te notkbfs.Ao bs k rofbcbeus lk` wae wersabps nkbfy kt abs ckrkco mohero iello`ib`c werg k`n wao`ifesb`c b` tao ovo`b`c.

    Ao sakros k ceen rofktbe`sabp wbta kflest kff abs iustelors b`ifunb`c sofh. Abs pefbtok`n u`norstk`nb`c `kturo kfse kffews abl te akvo k ceen rkppert kle`cst abs etaor ieffokcuos

    k`n etaor stero goopors ifeso te abs wergsaep.

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    15/109

    Yktbsa Makb

    @klo7 Yktbsa Gulkr Mummfo Nks Ye`bKco7?3 yokrsLkrbtkf Ytktus7RosIabfnro`7 Ros, ; Ofnor Ye` k`n ; Reu`cor Nkucator]osbno`io7Skaef Xbffkco, @okr Yoiter 3, Ck`nab`kckr

    Serg Oxporbo`io7 92 yokrsNbstk`io eh ]osbno`io hrel Serg7 3 gls

    Serg Knnross7Kkb Yaroo Gaenbykkr Mbgo Ikro, H-44=, Ywkckt ]kb` Herost ;,Ter Gunksk` ]ekn, Gunksk`, Ck`nab`kckr

    Yktbsa Makb bs fbgo Jbttu Makbs pkrt`or k`n aks g`ew` hrel k fe`c tblo, ovo` moherotaoy levon te tabs wergsaep. Ao bs efnor tak` Jbttumakb mut rospoits abl fbgo abs ew` mretaor.Ao ru`s abs ew` slkffor wergsaep ks woff b` tao vbffkco ao ielos hrel mut prohors wergb`cevor aoro. Eut taoro, ao k`n abs tokl e`fy werg e` Fu`ks k`n Mkjkj Mbgos lestfy.

    Ielb`c b`te tabs prehossbe` wks kfse abs porse`kf iaebio ao lkno pest siaeef. Abs hbrstoxpesuro b`te tabs hbofn kfse akppo`on b` Kalonkmkn. Ao aks tkucat lk`y poepfo u`nor ablkmeut ropkbrb`c eh twe waoofors. Ao aks wergon e` kff gb`ns eh twe waoofors k`n mosbnosfokr`b`c kmeut o`cb`o ropkbr, kfse aks wergon b` tao hbofn eh no`tb`c, pkb`tb`c k`n wofnb`c. Ao

    o`jeys rbnb`c tao Gb`otbi Ae`nk k`n abs oxportbso b` o`cb`os bs takt e` Aore Ae`nk Ypfo`ner.Ao ifkbls te akvo akn ropkbron evor 8,444 o`cb`os eh tao sklo.

    Abs fe`c k`n vkrbon oxporbo`io aks lkno abl ie`hbno`t eh abs kitbe`s, k`n taonoibsbe`s ao aks tkgo`. Ao ifkbls ao ik` hbx k`ytab`c bs k sofh preifkblon o`cb`oor. Ao bs epo`te fokr`b`c k`n o`ieurkcos k quostbe`b`c kttbtuno. Ao bs kfse k vory nonbikton wergor k`n hoofstakt nonbiktbe`, ie`io`trktbe` b` werg, k`n epo``oss te fokr`b`c bs tao pkta te suiioss b` absprehossbe`. Ao stre`cfy mofbovos takt cottb`c e`os ak`ns nbrty tokiaos e`o k fet kmeut taobrwerg, lkgos e`o rospe`sbmfo k`n takt bt bs blporktbvo her k fbvofbaeen. Ao e`io skbn akktagkkfo `kab` ae`co tea aul gakkyo`co gyk5

    Ao aks k vory pesbtbvo kttbtuno te fbho k`n fbgos te `et akvo k`y gb`n eh to`sbe`. Aomofbovos b` usb`c abs herosbcat te g`ew kmeut e`os huturo k`n tao pessbmbftbos er iakffo`cos

    kaokn. Ao neos ielo kiress selotblos ks k ieigy porse`. Bs k` oxtrevort k`n aks k hrbo`nfy

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    16/109

    `kturo, wbta k so`so eh auleur. Ao fbgos te tkfg, sakro abs bnoks k`n neos `et o`jey mob`cb`torrupton. Ao nrb`gs, slegos k`n iaows e` lkskfk.

    Abs rofktbe`sabp bs vory ceen wbta stkhh kt tao `obcameurb`c steros. Ao bs vory pkrtbiufkrkmeut tao iustelors takt ielo my k`n neos `et fbgo tao e`os wae ielo my toff abl wakt aosaeufn ne, mut neos `et rohuso te k`ye`o.

    @kro`nrk Makb

    @klo7 @kro`nrk

    Kco7=?Lkrbtkf Ytktus7 @eIabfnro`7 @e]osbno`io7 Gunksk` Xbffkco, Ck`nab`kckr

    Serg Oxporbo`io7 ? yokrsNbstk`io eh ]osbno`io hrel Serg79 glsSerg Knnross7Kkb Yaroo Gaenbykkr Mbgo Ikro, H-44=, Ywkckt ]kb` Herost ;,

    Ter Gunksk` ]ekn, Gunksk`, Ck`nab`kckr

    @kro`nrk Makb, bs tao ju`ber lest b` tao ckrkco b` kco k`n oxporbo`io. Ao jeb`on aorowbta Jbttumakb khtor taoy levon aoro hrel Yoiter =;.

    Ao jeb`on tabs prehossbe` kfse moikuso eh abs b`torost b` twe waoofors. Ao uson te wergmohero tabs kt k`etaor ckrkco b` Yoiter 1. Ao o`jeys rbnb`c tao Rklkak HZ mbgos k`n aksoxportbso b` hbxb`c Mkjkj mbgos.

    Ao wks tao e`fy e`o wae fky olpaksbs e` fokr`b`c taoery eh twe waoofors k`no`cb`os b` co`orkf nurb`c tao stuny. Ao tkfgon kmeut cottb`c k ab`nb meeg e` tao sklo b`

    Kalonkmkn k`n ehhoron te mrb`c bt evor, wabia ao hercet. Ao wks kfse eh tao epb`be` takt e`ofokr`s prkitbikf g`ewfonco e` tao hbofn mut bts lero seu`n wao` mkigon wbta takt eh taoery b`tao sklo sumjoit.

    Ao iklo kiress ks k hrbo`nfy porse`. Ao wks kfse pefbto k`n u`norstk`nb`c te

    iustelors oons k`n so`sbtbvo te taobr oxpoitktbe` hrel tao sorvbios.B` tao porben eh stuny, ao wks `et kvkbfkmfo tee luia, te g`ew abl woff o`euca.

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    17/109

    Lugatkr Makb

    @klo7 Lugatkr BqmkfKco7 9=Lkrbtkf Ytktus7RosIabfnro`7 Ros, ; Ye`]osbno`io7 Yoiter 9, Ck`nab`kckr

    Serg Oxporbo`io7 ;4 yokrs eh ew` musb`ossNbstk`io eh ]osbno`io hrel Serg7 ? gls

    Serg Knnross7 Hkiomeeg, 9rn

    Hfeer, Yaugk` Ielpfox

    Lugatkr Makb, neos `et werg kt tao Ckrkco mut bs k pkrt eh tao seibkf creup ks ao wksk vory hroquo`t vbsbter taoro. Ao g`ews JbttuMakb k`n Yktbsa Makb hrel taobr tblo b` Yoiter =;.Ao ru`s abs ew` musb`oss k`n aks k stero `okrmy tao ckrkco, waoro abs saep soffs kppkrof hertao yeu`cor irewn. ^abs bs abs ew` vo`turo.

    Ao bs k musb`oss lk` k`n iklo te tao wergsaep rocufkrfy moikuso abs `ow ]eykfO`hbofn wks u`nor rosterktbe` k`n moikuso eh abs b`torost b` twe waoofors. Ao aks ew`on 1 twewaoofors b` tao pkst k`n o`jeys ]eykf O`hbofns tao lest.

    Ao wks qubto b`toroston b` ly stuny k`n b` g`ewb`c kmeut tao ieffoco fbho kt @BN. ^abskhhoits abs musb`oss. Ao kfse hroquo`ts pfkios waoro tao yeu`c co`orktbe` ak`cs eut te mo

    kwkro eh tao tro`ns mob`c heffewon. Ao wks kfse b`toroston b` tao ckncots B uson b` ly stunysuia ks tao iklork, tao vebio roiernor k`n ly pae`o ks woff.

    Ao bs k` oxtrevort wbta k wkrl k`n hrbo`nfy porse`kfbty. Ao kfse ielos k fbttfo stre`c b`goopb`c abs vbows kiress b` ie`vorsktbe`s.

    Nurb`c tao stuny, b`torkitbe`s wbta abl woro gopt fblbton ks ao wks `et k nbroit pkrt ehtao seibkf b` ie`toxt eh twe waoofors ikro k`n ropkbr.

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    18/109

    Kff tao lolmors eh tao seibkf creup oxiopt her Lugatkr Makb wae aks abs ew` musb`oss,nopo`n fkrcofy e` tao wergsaep her taobr fbvofbaeen b.o. Jbttu makb, Yktbsa Makb k`n @krosa Makb.

    Ks por taobr reutb`o taoy krrbvo b` tao ler`b cs my 2 2:94 kl k`n stky tecotaor tareuca taonky tbff 3:94 1 b` tao ovo`b`c nopo`nb`c e` tao werg fekn. ^aoy mrokg her fu`ia kt =, mutu`fbgo lest eh tao etaor ehhbios er werg pfkios B akn oxporbo`ion mohero, taoy ne `et akvo k`y

    hbxon tok er s`kig mrokgs. ^aoy ielo b` nbhhoro`t ifetaos k`n iak`co b`te taobr u`bherls kt taockrkco. ^aoso u`bherls kro `et oxkitfy bno`tbikf, k`n te k`y emfbvbeus porse` taoy weufn `et ktkff feeg fbgo u`bherls. E` tao etaor ak`n, taoy weufn feeg lero fbgo just k`etaor pkbr eh nbrtyifetaos, mut tao crokso k`n tao nbrt bs wakt cbvos taol tao sklo hoof k`n iakrkitor, taus kfsetao u`bherlbty her taol. Kff eh taol kro feikfbtbos k`n mofe`c te Cujkrkt. ^aoy kro rofbcbeus k`ncen hokrb`c. Kfmobt mofe`cb`c te nbhhoro`t rofbcbe`s taoy werg akrle`beusfy u`nor e`o reeh. Kff ehtaol kro ielhertkmfo wbta kflest kff gb`n eh twe waoofors mut rospoit tao reykf o`hbofns voryluia. ^aoy ne`t fbgo bt wao` ielpk`bos b`hfkto tao prbios eh tao voabifos mut ne`t roibpreiktowbta abca porherlb`c voabifos, k`n b`stokn put b` iaokpor pkrts takt akvo k few fbho k`n ne `etaefn e` her tee fe`c. ^ao etaor tab`c taoy ne`t fbgo kro irk`gy k`n blpktbo`t iustelors, k`ntaeso wae ne`t pky b` tblo. ^aoy kfse cot qubto hrustrkton wao` tao spkros eh voabifos kro `et

    oksbfy kvkbfkmfo k`n e`o weufn akvo te ce te tao lkb` nokfor b` ernor te cot taol. Kff eh taolakvo iaeso` te werg b` tabs fb`o moikuso bt wks taobr ew` hbofn eh b`torost, ao`io o`ieurkcb`ck`n kssbsstb`c lo akppbfy b` ly rosokria.

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    19/109

    ]OYOK]IA TFK@

    Nkto7 ;?ta Jufy =4;9

    Hbrst nky eh ota`ecrkpay khtor ktto`nb`c tao woog fe`c NBy wergsaep b` Aynorkmkn.

    ^enky, wks suppeson te mo tao nky wao` e`o weufn ce eut b`te tao hbofn, hb`n taoseibkf creup k`n tao` mocb` tao ota`ecrkpay rosokria.

    B wk`ton te werg wbta k seibkf creup takt weufn mo ifeso my k`n `et tee hkr ehh hrel taoiklpus ks wo kro roqubron te trk`sirbmo okia nkys hb`nb`cs k`n ie`vorsktbe`s.

    Nkto7 ;8ta Jufy =4;9

    B woro tab`gb`c kmeut ceb`c eut te hb`n ly seibkf creup ks wks ovorye`o ofso b` lyifkss.

    B taeucat eh tryb`c hbrst kt Jbttumakbs ckrkco. B akn noibnon takt wabfo cottb`c ly voabifo wksaon B weufn tkfg kmeut tao rosokria

    werg B wks b`toroston b` wbta Jbttumakb. ^ao ckrkco bs akrnfy ? - 3 lb`utos kwky hreltao ieffoco wbta k ievoyk`io k`n kmeut =4 e` heet.

    B spego te abl kmeut ovorytab`c mut tao werg B b`to`non te ne. ^abs wks moikuso B hoftnbroitfy ksgb`c her neb`c k rosokria stuny lbcat `et mo tao most wky te ce kmeut.

    B reno te B`heibty te hb`n k mkrmor ks takt wks ly etaor eptbe`, k`n B steppon my k pfkioikffon Iaklu`nk wabia premkmfy wks ifeson her fu`ia.

    B kckb` foht her tao mkrmorsaep b` tao ovo`b`c. B heu`n tao saep epo` tabs tblo. Mut, Bieufn `et spokg te abl kmeut tao stuny aoro ks woff. B foht hoofb`c pktaotbi.

    Fktor, B mulpon b`te ^k`bk wae just hb`kfbson e` aor rosokria creup. Yao skbn takt justce strkbcat kwky k`n tkfg te taol kmeut aew yeu kro b`toroston b` g`ewb`c lero kmeuttaobr nkbfy werg.

    Ly eptbe`s rbcat `ew b` tao ernor eh prohoro`io(nopo`nb`c e` wakt B weufn cot taoro)weufn mo te oxpfero tao ;. Ckrkco(te fokr` kmeut leteriyifos) =. ^ao ]kbfwky

    Iressb`c(B hoof bs ielpfotofy u`oxpferon) 9. ^ao Mkrmorsaep >. K` Oktory ?. K Tfkio

    waoro taoy lkgo selotab`c(Mkgory, Oktb`c, Tkk`, kttees, selotab`c ofso) rktaor

    tak` k rotkbf stero her roknylknos 8. Skbtor creup kt k rostkurk`t 3. Totref Tulps

    B hoft ie`strkb`on my7 ;) [ubn Tre [ue =) Hokr eh ]ojoitbe` ks taoy lbcat hoof takt B klfu`ktbi 9) Hokr eh `et ceb`c te k pfkio B lbcat pronelb`k`tfy hoof juncon my >)

    Fk`cukco ?) B ie`stk`t sokria eh k pfkio her tao seu`n(s) eh bt (bh pessbmfo) 8)

    Ifeso`oss te ieffoco

    B akn te lkgo ly Iaebio tenky k`n mocb` wergb`c. B nbn `et wk`t k fkto stkrt.

    Nkto7 ;3taJufy =4;9

    B wo`t kckb` wbta Gu`kf k`n spego te Jbtumakb. ^ao rosokria stuny wks hb`kfbson. ^ao creup wks ly hbrst iaebio nuo te voston b`torosts suia ks wk`tb`c te g`ew lero

    kmeut leteriyifos ikro k`n ropkbr.

    ^ao ota`ecrkpabi stuny wks te mocb` hrel tao `oxt nky. B hoft B iklo kiress te Jbttumakb ks k prespoithuf iustelor ks woff, te fot lo ie`nuit tao

    stuny kt abs wergsaep.

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    20/109

    Nkto7 ;1taJufy =4;9

    B mock` ly stuny wbta Tkrtbibpktery Emsorvktbe`s. E`fy lot Jbttumakb k`n Lugatkr Makbe` tao hbrst nky.

    Sks k fbttfo u`suro kmeut tao poepfo wergb`c taoro, ks b` ly stky taoro B nbn `et sook`ye`o ofso taoro.

    B ehhoron te werg wbta fbttfo mbt ks luia ks B wks kffewon te k`n trbon te oxpross lyiurbesbty te tao huffost.

    Nkto7 ;2taJufy =4;9

    ^ao pkrtbibpktery emsorvktbe`s ie`tb`uon. B ehhoron te werg k`n aofp kreu`n. B lot @kro`nrk Makb. B stkyon oxtrk b` tao stero, wabfo stero goopb`c wao` kff tao etaors akn foht her selo

    rospoitbvo werg.

    Nkto7 ==`nJufy =4;9

    B lot Yktbsa Makb. B crow oxtrk ie`ibeus kmeut tao seu`ns takt woro lok`b`chuf te tao seibkf creup. B wks cottb`c mottor kiioss kle`c tao poepfo taoro. B ie`tb`uon te ne slkff werg.

    Nkto7 =9rnJufy =4;9

    E`o eh tao how nkys wao` kff eh taol woro proso`t. TE ie`tb`uos. Fokr`b`c lero kmeut tao poepfo, taobr tolporklo`ts, k`n twe waoofors Ytkrton aofpb`c taol wbta tao voabifos taoy weufn werg e`.

    Nkto7 =>taJufy =4;9

    ^ry ceb`c kt k nbhhoro`t tblo b.o. tao ovo`b`c b` tabs ikso. ^eeg selo oktmfos her kff eh taol. Mock` cottb`c te g`ew taol lero kt k porse`kf fovof. @ew soo` ks k hklbfbkr hbcuro my tao steros' `oxt neer. O`jeyb`c tao tblo spo`t kt tao hbofn.

    Nkto7 =?taJufy =4;9

    TE ie`tb`uos. @kro`nrk Makb mocb`s te nbskppokr. Sbta selo kssbstk`io hrel Yktbsa Makb, hoft fbgo B akn ce`o b`sbno tao o`cb`o. Croksy ak`ns bs `et se u`ielle` `ew her lo ks woff. Tkrkffof trk`sirbptbe s ovorynky kfse goop e`o vory musy.

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    21/109

    Nkto7 =3taJufy =4;9

    Ck`nab`kckr ie`tb`uos te mo vory wot. Iak`con spkrg pfucs eh ly ew` voabifo wbta selo aofp. Cottb`c ifesor k`n taus lero tblo wbta Jbttu Makb. Ytkrtb`c te novofep k fbttfo mbt eh nbsb`torost her Lugatkr Makb her ao wks `ovor k nbroit

    pkrtbibpk`t ks etaor lolmors eh tao seibkf creup b` taobr werg.

    Yakrb`c ly g`ewfonco eh leteriyifos wbta etaors.

    Nkto7 94taJufy =4;9

    TE ie`tb`uos. ]kppert aks blprevon ew. ]u``b`c orrk`ns her taol. Mut, `et rokffy tao most nky e` tao hbofn.

    Nkto7 9;stJufy =4;9

    Cottb`c ifesor te Yktbsa Makb ks woff. Ytkrtb`c te u`norstk`n tao seibkf creup mottor. Mock` paetecrkpab`c `ew, kfe`c wbta tao TE. Ab`ts pksson e` kmeut tao Fe`c B`torvbows.

    Nkto7 9rnKucust =4;9

    Lero tkfgb`c akppo`s wbta tao seibkf creup. Taetecrkpay k`n TE ie`tb`uos. ]oiernb`c seu`n sklpfos ks woff. Noifkro k`n noibno e` tao Fe`c B`torvbow. Tropkrktbe` eh tao B`torvbow Cubno

    Nkto7 >taKucust =4;9

    Fe`c b`torvbow ie`nuiton wbta Jbttu Makb. Fe`c b`torvbow ie`nuiton wbta Yktbsa Makb.

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    22/109

    HBOFN NK^K TK]^BIBTK^E]R EMYO]XK^BE@Y

    Nkto7;3ta Jufy =4;9

    Nky7Son`osnky

    Ovo`t tblo7kreu`n =bsaFeiktbe`7Gaepiak-Loss-Ckrkco

    Kiters7Gkrk`, Gu`kf k`n Lbfb`n

    Bt wks k`etaor ifeuny nky, tao woktaor ropert e` tao rknbe akn k cujju holkfo ]J skyb`c takt

    tao fbgofbaeen eh bt rkb`b`c weufn mo vory abca fbgo 24%. B akn taeucat eh ceb`c te tao loiak`bis

    ckrkco tenky, se B toxton Gu`kf kreu`n ;; takt wo weufn akvo te ce te tao ckrkco se ao saeufn

    fot lo g`ew wao` ao weufn mo hroo. Ao ropfbon skyb`c takt ao weufn ne se. Bt akn stkrton

    nrbzzfb`c my tao`. Test wabia B mock` neb`c selo lkbfb`c werg, k`n tao` B aoknon her fu`ia

    khtor mktab`c. B rolb`non Gu`kf kckb` k`n ao ikffon lo up, wo tao` noibnon te loot kt taogaepiak moikuso abs mk`g werg seloaew nbn `et werg eut. Ao lot lo kt tao loss wabfo B

    wks oktb`c k`n B tefn abl takt B weufn `et tkgo fe`c. Ks see` ks B hb`bsaon B wo`t eut te hb`n abl

    kt tao gaepiak. B ksgon abl bh wo weufn `oon twe voabifos er e`o, just wao` ao skbn takt sb`io

    Lbfb`n bs kfse ielb`c kfe`c wbta abl ks taoy `oon te aokn te tao mk`g B saeufn premkmfy cot ly

    voabifo. B kcroon, rk` mkig te tao reel ieffoiton tao goys k`n wo woro ehh hrel ieffoco my

    kreu`n =pl. Ao teeg k fe`cor reuto te rokia tao wergsaep takt B peb`ton eut wao` wo rokiaon

    taoro. B` tao stero, taoro wks e`fy e`o cuy, wae soolon u`hklbfbkr. _pe` ksgb`c abl ao skbn

    takt Jbtumakb akn ce`o eut her fu`ia. Ao kckb` ksgon bh wo `oonon selotab`c ofso. B tab`g ao

    lok`t takt wo woro taoro her selo sert eh mbgo bssuo, wabia ao wks ehhorb`c te hbx. Gu`kf skbntakt wo woro taoro te tkfg te Jbtumakb kmeut selotab`c ofso. K`n takt sb`io ao wks `et taoro,

    wo weufn mo ielb`c fktor. Gu`kf kfse knnon takt ao lust toff Jbttumakb takt wo weufn mo

    ielb`c kckb` kt fbgo ?pl. Khtor tabs wo teeg te eur voabifos, k`n wo`t mkig. Gu`kf k`n Lbfb`n

    wo`t tewkrns tao mk`g k`n B iklo te ieffoco. B wo`t te loot Krsakn Makb kt Loiaktre`bis,

    spego te abl kmeut tao Aynorkmkn wergsaep. Ao aofpon lo b` hbxb`c ly Clkbf kiieu`t my

    tokiab`c lo aew te put b` fkmofs. ^ao` B cet ly Krnub`e hrel ]effb. B lot @bgabf Jesab kfse

    ksgb`c abl wakt ao wks upte b` abs ox iklpus. Khtor kff takt B iklo mkig te ly reel, wkbtb`c

    her bt te strbgo ?. Yakrp kt ? Gu`kf ikffon k`n wo noibnon te loot kt tao Gaepiak. Ao ksgon lo

    bh wo weufn `oon twe voabifos, se B tefn abl takt khtor tao ckrkco B weufn mo ceb`c te B`heibty.E` aokrb`c takt ao noibnon te tkgo abs voabifo kfse. ^abs tblo wo teeg tao saertor reuto. _pe`

    rokiab`c taoro wo heu`n Jbtumakb k`n tao etaor lk` wae wks taoro okrfbor ks woff. Gu`kf mock`

    tkfgb`c k`n oxpfkb`on te abl kff kmeut tao ropert takt ao akn lkno her abl nurb`c tao stuny ao

    nbn kt abs wergsaep okrfbor. Kff tabs wabfo B wks tab`gb`c aew B weufn b`btbkto k`n toff abl kmeut

    ly purpeso eh vbsbt. B akn kfse moo` feegb`c kreu`n te iaoig aew lk`y poepfo weufn eiiupy

    tao stero kt k`y pkrtbiufkr tblo. E`io ao wks ne`o B teeg tao iuo, ks Gu`kf nbn b`trenuio lo k

    fbttfo k`n tao` B mock` tkfgb`c.

    Gu`kf7 Jbtumakb, yoa Gkrk` lork nest akb.JM7 Akk`, (tkgb`c tao ropert hrel Gu`kf).

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    23/109

    Gu`kf7 Roa, mab aulkkro wkak` pkntk akb.

    GN7 Jbttumakb jkk`to akb` lujao.

    JM7 Jkk`to akb`. Roa poafo mab kk rkgao akb`.

    GN7 Jkbso b`ae` `o kkp go skkta stuny gbyk takk usb tkrka aulkkro mab ifkss lob` aulkkro

    tokiaor `o aulob` mefk akb gb mkkakr jkkgkr geb kp`o pksk`n go gkkl ge jkkgo nogae kur usgbstuny gkre.

    (JM `ens b` kcroolo`t wabfo feegb`c kt tao ropert ao aks tkgo` hrel Gu`kf. Gu`kf bs ak`cb`c

    kreu`n)

    GN7 ^ea lujao poaofo sky ab mkaut sakug takk ckknbye`(rohorb`c te twe waoofors) gk kur kp`b

    ckknb go mkkro lob` sooga`ky gk. Bsbfbyo lkb` kkpgo pkks kkyk aee`. Aulkkrb ifkss lob`

    jkbso mkkgb fece` `o mab kfkc kfkc jkcka iau`b akb. Og fkngk jubio mk`k`o wkkfo go pkks ckyk

    akb. Og fkngk aetof lob` noga rkak akb. Og fkngk stktbe`kry wkkfo go pkks akb. Og fkngb paetestunbe, kur og fkngb mokuty pkrfeur lob` ckyb akb. Kbso kfkc jkcka lob` aulob` jkkgkr yo

    sklkja`k akb gb unakr po gkkl gkbso aetk akb. Sea fec gkbso roato akb`, gbt`k gkkl aetk akb,

    gkbso aetk akb, u`gb gykk nbggkt kktb akb` kur wea gkbso usso skab gkrto akb`. Roa skm aulob`

    pktkk gkrgo kp`o tokiaor fec ge mktk`k aeck kur wea fec hbr aulge mefo`co gb kkco gkbso

    mkn`k akb. Kkco jkkgo ropert mk`ocb, kur usgo kfkwkk jkbso wea tokiaor mefo`co wkbso gkkl

    gkr`k aeck. ^ea gyk lkb` kkpgo bnakr po kk skgtk aee` bss stuny go fbyo5

    JM7 (Sabfo kflest stbff b`toroston b` tao neiulo`t btsofh kcroos.) Akk`, akk`, taoog taoog.

    (B wks vory akppy wao` B aokrn takt. Gu`kf Just tao` julpon b` k`n knnon)

    Gu`kf7 Kroy jbttu makb b`ge kkpgo fbho go mkro lob` sklkja`k akb. Kur b`ge seu`n so rofkton

    aeck gkkl.

    (Aokrb`c takt pbsson lo ehh ks B taeucat ao mfow ehh ly rosokria ievor mut moikuso B skw takt

    Jbtumakb wks `et tkgb`c k`ye`o vory sorbeusfy ks ao wks o`kleuron my tao ropert, B nbn `et

    rokit)

    GN7 Mbfguf, tea jbttumakb lkb`o kk skgtk aee` gkf so5JM7 Akk` akk`, taoog akb gkf sumka so.

    GN7 Kkp sumka gbt`o mkjo 5

    JM7 @ku mkjo

    GN7 Kur sakkl lob` kkta.

    JM7 Ykkno skkt tkg.

    GN7 Ykkno skkt tkg.

    GN7 ^aoog akb hbr gkf lkb` nks mkjo kkee`ck.

    JM7 Akk`.

    (^ao` ao ikffon tao etaor cuy te ielo k`n soo tao ropert, k`n te abl B oxpfkb`on lest eh wabia

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    24/109

    B ieufn my fbsto`b`c te wakt Gu`kf akn tefn JM. ^ao etaor cuy wks akppy te soo bt k`n skbn takt

    yos wo hbx kff gb`ns eh voabifos mut ao see` cet nbsb`toroston k`n foht us)

    JM7 Roa lkb`, ropert.

    Gu`kf7 Kkp rkgaeco 5 (Ao skbn bt rofuitk`io ks B hbcuron ao wks`'t oxpoitb`c tabs te akppo`)JM7 Akk` lkb` mab stuny gkree`ck. (Ylbfb`c)

    GN7 Mbfguf mbfguf.

    Gu`kf7 ^aoog akb, kkp rkgae lkb` mkkn lob` fogo jkke`ck.

    (B wks tab`gb`c bt wks ceb`c ceen, se B hoft k mbt eh rofboh)

    Gu`kf7 ^ea taoog akb hbr.

    GN7 Gkf lbfto akb` JM nks mkjo, egky.

    JM7 Egky.

    (So kff saeeg ak`ns wbta abl, wabia lestfy akn crokso e` taol. ^ao` wo mock` wkfgb`c

    tewkrns eur voabifos. Ks wo woro sbttb`c, Gu`kf skbn)

    Gu`kf7 Ae ckyk5

    GN7 Akk` ykkr, km gkf so stkrt akb`. ^ak`gs ykkr.(Ylbfb`c)

    (So reno eur sopkrkto wkys, k`n taoro wks k peb`t mohero wo spfbt wao` B tak`gon abl kckb`

    k`n B wo`t tewkrns B`heibty)

    Nkto7;1ta Jufy =4;9

    Nky7 aursnky

    Ovo`t tblo7 kreu`n ;=bsa

    Feiktbe`7Ckrkco

    Kiters7Gkrk`, JM k`n Lugatkr

    (B cet rokny my ;;:94 kl te fokvo her tao ckrkco. B wks ikrryb`c ly `etopkn k`n k po` wbta lok`n B lkno suro takt B wks wokrb`c selotab`c takt feegon `erlkf, k`n takt B ieufn khhern te fot

    cot k fbttfo croksy bh taoy woro te loot takt hkto. K`n tao` B foht wbta Nakrlosa her tao ckrkco.

    ^ao woktaor soolon pfoksk`t, `et k`y prelb`o`t sbc`s eh rkb`. So wo`t tewkrns B`heibty hbrst

    ks B akn te nrep Nakrlosa. ^ao` B reno te tao ckrkco. B tab`g B reno hkst k`n rokiaon b` ?

    lb`utos. B skw twe lo` stk`nb`c my tao o`trk`io eh tao ckrkco, e`o B roiec`bson ks ao wks

    JM. Ao wks wokrb`c k nkrg mfuo sabrt, k`n mfuo no`bl u`nor takt. ^ao etaor cuy wks k fbttfo

    saertor tak` JM mut ao wks hkttor, k`n feegon ielpfotofy cujju. Meta eh taol woro wokrb`c

    saknos eh mfuo, taobr ak`ns woro croksy wao` B saeeg taol k`n bt soolon fbgo taoy akn moo`

    wergb`c her selotblo. B hoft k fbttfo cubfty her B hoft fbgo B wks fkto kt rokiab`c. B lot meta eh taol)

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    25/109

    GN7 Gkbso akb` 5 (Ylbfb`c)

    JM7 aoog taoog. (Ylbfb`c)

    GN7 Sae aulkkrk og ifkss tak jbsgo wkjka so taenk fkto ae ckyo aul.

    JM7 All

    ( B wo`t b`sbno te hb`n k pfkio te goop ly mkc k`n tkgo ly `etomeeg eut mut her k mrboh lelo`t

    B wks tryb`c te hbcuro eut k pfkio e` tao tkmfo waoro bt weufn`'t metaor tao rocufkr sottb`c ks

    ne`o my JM, k`n wabfo kfse stkyb`c ks nbsiroot ks pessbmfo se ks te `et saew takt B kl mrb`cb`c

    b` `ow tab`cs b`te taobr torrbtery. JM levon eutsbno te tao voabifo pkrgon taoro. Bt wks k` efn

    crky iefeuron muffot. Ao akn stkrton wergb`c e` bt. ^ao voabifo wks pkrgon b` hre`t eh tao

    ckrkco k`n ao wks sbttb`c tewkrns tao foht sbno eh bt. Lok`wabfo tao etaor cuy ksgon waoro B

    wks hrel. )

    Lugatkr7 ^ea kkp @BN so akb`. (peb`tb`c tewkrns tao nbroitbe` eh @BN b` kbr)GN7 Joo. Lkb` Gkrk`.

    LM7 Lugatkr Makb. (sakgo eh ak`ns)

    GN7 Akk`, @BN lob` pknto akb` kur aulob` kkj gkf yoa gkkl lbfk akb gb aulob` ieffoco go

    mkkakr jkk gkr je mab gkkl aulob` b`torostb`c fkcktk akb, usso skljao`. Skakk` fec gkbso

    kp`k gkkl sklmakfto akb`. Sea gyk gyk gkrto akb`. Gkm kkto akb`, jkkto akb`. _`ge gkkl go

    wkqt gyk gyk nbggktob` lbftb akb` kur wea fec gyk gyk tkrooge` so usso sklmakfto akb`. _`go

    peero nb` go mkkro lob` jkk``k akb.

    LM7 Turk gkkl sklja`k akb5

    GN7 Joo akk`. Kur jkbso lkb` ykakk` jbtumakb go pkks kkyk aee` wkbso ab og fkngk rostkurk`tyk aetof lob` ckyk akb. Og fkngb paete stunbe lob` jkktb akb. Og fkngb mokuty pkrfeur jkktb akb.

    LM7 Tkrfeur.

    GN7 Og fkngk B`heibty lbo` IIN , ikho iehhoo nky jkktk akb. Kbso skm kfkc kfkc gkkl noga rkao

    akb`.

    LM7 (Sabfo `ennb`c k`n pktbo`tfy fbsto`b`c) ^ea kkp B`heibty lob` sbfvor spee` ckyo ae 5

    GN7 Akk` akk`, kur weab fkngk jea rostkurk`t jkk rkak akb. Sea sbfvor spee` lob` ab jkktk akb.

    Sea lkfkykfkl akb.

    LM7 Akk`, lkb` B`heibty lob` wkab` sbfvor spee` jkktk aee`. Yakkl lob` wkak` lkb` jkktk

    aee` kflest akr rez.GN7 Egky

    (]bcat tao` B woro tab`gb`c wakt JM bs upte k`n wakt ao premkmfy wks tab`gb`c kmeut akvb`c lo

    kreu`n)

    LM7 Fogb`, gkmab kkpge unakr nogak `kab`.

    GN7 Sea lkb` og ne mkkr ab ckyk aee` unakr gakk`o ge.

    LM7 Loro wkakk` nest fec akb`, og lusfbl akb kur og lkffu akb.

    (^ao` meta eh us `ennon k`n Lugatkr cet te werg e` tao croy leteriyifo e` tao rbcat sbno eh bt.

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    26/109

    Ao wks epo`b`c bt hrel e`o sbno k`n JM wks epo`b`c bt hrel tao etaor sbno. Meta eh taol woro

    wergb`c tecotaor. JM ksgon abl te rkbso tao voabifo kt k fbttfo aobcato`on pfktherl k`n se

    Lugatkr put hfkt pboios eh ste`os u`nor tao lkb` stk`n. ^ao voabifo wks mob`c tkgo` kpkrt.

    Meta taobr ak`ns woro croksy. ^aoy woro wergb`c b` squktton pesbtbe`s wbta teefs fbgo

    spk``ors, sirow nrbvors, akllors, `uts, mefts, iakb`, voabifo ebf b` tao ron ik` wbta k mokg, taofbns eh tao pkrts taoy woro epo`b`c kreu`n taol sikttoron ovoywaoro mut taoy nbn `et sool te

    mo cottb`c werrbon kmeut stkyb`c erck`bson. ^ao ckrkco mofe`cs te JM kfe`o k`n bs k noio`tfy

    mbc spkio kpprexblktofy ;=' x 1' x ;4' wbta k vory slkff hk` takt bs ehh io`tron. ^ao hre`t wkff

    aks k mekrn takt skys 'Kkb Yaroo Gaenbykr Mbgo Ikro'. Bt aks e`fy porse`'s `klo k`n ie`tkit

    `ulmor takt bs Jbttumakb's. ^ao saep `ulmor bs H 44= k`n taoro bs k` oxpfbibt mut slkff mekrn

    stuig e` e`o eh tao pbffkrs e` tao rbcat te abcafbcat takt. ^ao stero b`sbno bs hbffon wbta kff gb`ns eh

    twe waoofor spkro pkrts takt yeu ik` pessbmfy tab`g eh rk`cb`c hrel aoknfklps, ierns, sirows,

    fbcats, uts k`n mefts, rummor tumos, luncukrns, luhhfors, efn aoflots, goys, iakb`s, strkps,

    spkrg pfucs, ebfs, mkttorbos, ofoitrbikf oqubplo`t, crokso, nbrty rkcs oti. aoro bs pfok`ty ehlotkf k`n rummor. Lotkf b` tao herl eh stoof, kfulb`bul, kffeys k`n bre`. Lest eh bt bs b` taobr

    spoibhbi pfkios ks luia ks pessbmfo her taobr kro twe weeno` rkigs e`o mob`c tkff k`n mbc k`n

    tao etaor e`o bs slkffor, k`n k`etaor weeno` pk`of te ak`c goys k`n etaor ak`ckmfo tab`cs.

    Aeworvor, lkymo moikuso eh selo u`ovo` erkck`bsktbe`, taoro kro pkrts `oxt te tao tkff rkig

    k`n takt sool te mo sfewfy ifblmb`c e` te lkgo k tewor eh taobr ew` tkgb`c suppert hrel tao tkff

    rkig. ^ao mkso eh tabs tewor kflest rokiaos tbff tao o`trk`io eh tao saep. ^ao wkff ak`cb`c

    pk`of k`n tao tkff rkig kro kfe`c tao wkff e` tao rbcat takt aks k` ehh mrew` ce`o nbrty iefeur

    k`n tao etaor rkig rkig bs pfkion kt rbcat k`cfos te tabs tkff rkig. B` motwoo` taoso twe rkig kt

    tao ier`or bs tao pulp takt bs uson her suppfyb`c wktor her wksab`c voabifos. ^ao slkff rkigaks k paetecrkpa eh fern ak`ulk` kmevo bt k`n te bts rbcat er te yeur foht bh yeu kro stk`nb`c

    eppesbto te bt bs k fbttfo tolpfo. ^ao slkff rkig aks k fbttfo spkio e` bts sbno waoro JM weufn

    premkmfy stk`n k`n porherl abs rofbcbeus rbtukfs. B` tao hre`t sbno kt tao o`trk`io, ifeso te tao

    etaor wkff eppesbto tao wkff ak`cb`c rkig bs k tkmfo takt feegs fbgo k` ehhbio roioptbe` nosg

    waoro ao goops lest eh abs mbffs k`n etaor pkpor werg. ^ao tkmfo aks k trk`spkro`t cfkss sfkm

    kff kiress e` tao tep, wabia vory typbikffy aks ikrns, mbffs k`n ikfo`nkrs wbta hkios eh B`nbk`

    nobtbos fyb`c u`nor bt. ^ao tkmfo bs premkmfy k` eutielo hrel tao soie`n ak`n hur`bturo saep ks

    bt aks ibty pufso stbigors e` bt k`n kfse skys s`kigs k`n hroyuls wbta crkpabis te ce kfe`c.

    ^aoro bs k mrew` wkff ifeig e` tao wkff knjkio`t te tao ehhbio nosg k`n bt aks moo` spe`seronmy oxbno mkttorbos. B rololmor tao wkff ifeig woff ks B wo`t k`n iak`con bts mkttorbos mohero B

    foht tao ckrkco e` tabs nky. ^ao wkff wbta tao wkff ifeig kfse aks tao sklo wabto weeno`

    tolpfo. ^ao wkffs kro lestfy k iefeur takt feegs fbgo bs k lbxturo eh mrew` k`n lero eh yoffew.

    E`o wkff aewovor bs ielpfotofy croo` b` iefeur wbta tao fern ak`ulk` paetecrkpa k`n tao

    slkff rkig b` hre`t eh bt. ^ao tbfos b`sbno kro kfse k ielmb`ktbe` eh takt ehh-wabto takt ru` kfe`c b`

    hre`t tao saep kfse tbff kmeut ;4 - ;= hoot kaokn. ^aoso tbfos eutsbno akvo mfuo pktiaos e` taol,

    ks k pkttor`. ^abs bs waoro lest eh tao voabifos kro hbxon k`n waoro taoy woro kfse wergb`c kt

    takt peb`t eh tblo, kftaeuca werg akppo`s b`sbno ks woff. B` e`o ier`or eh tao stero, bs tao wktor

    pulp takt aks k ie``oitb`c pbpo wabia ceos eutsbno te tao mkig eh tao stero waoro JM wksaostao voabifos takt ielo my her co`orkf wksab`c, sorvbib`c oti. E` tao sbno eh tao nosg bs tao

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    27/109

    sklo wkff wbta tao ifeig k`n tao tolpfo mut kmevo tao nosg aoro ak`cs k hrklon iortbhbikto eh

    Jbttumakb pkrtbibpktb`c b` k wergsaep ie`nuiton kt k Ae`nk Yorvbio Ytktbe`. Knjkio`t te takt

    hrklo bs k sot eh o`cb`o pkigb`c lktorbkf kff ak`cb`c e` e`o `kbf. ^ao nosg aks k wktor iklpor

    wabia bs mfuo k`n akn e`o stoof cfkss gopt e` bt. ^ao nosg bs kfse uson ks k spkio te saew kff

    tao nbhhoro`t o`cb`o ebfs takt kro uson kt tao ckrkco, rk`cb`c hrel Ae`nk, Yorve, Ikstref oti. Btaks meta tao fbqubns e` bt, e`os takt aulk`s nrb`g k`n taeso takt taobr rbnos' nrb`g. ^ao fewor

    pertbe` eh tao nosg aks selo efn pkpors k`n neiulo`ts wabia B ne`'t tab`g akvo moo` teuiaon

    b` tao fe`cost porben. ^ao fewor ier`or eh tao roioptbe` fbgo nosg kfse aks k fkrco ieffoitbe` eh

    luhhfors, k`n lest eh taol feegon uson k`n fbgo taoy mofe`con te reykf o`hbofns. Just e` tao

    eutsbno kro twe pboios eh mrego` ie`iroto ste`os takt kppokr te akvo moo` tkgo` hrel

    selowaoro mut taoy kro fyb`c taoro ks taoy kffew voabifos te mo mreucat b`sbno, wao` wergb`c

    fbgo k stop. B wks ceb`c tareuca tao stero tryb`c te soo wakt kff bs taoro mut her tao fe`cost tblo B

    wks lestfy b`toroston b` tryb`c te poriobvo wakt gb`n eh seu`ns lbcat sool lok`b`chuf te tabs

    seibkf creup. Ao`io, khtor ovory mrboh lelo`t B weufn cot nbstrkiton te iaoig wakt JM wks upte. B puffon tao ron steef, tao e`fy steef takt feegon fbgo k usukf sbttb`c lktorbkf er hur`bturo.

    ^aoro woro selo mbgo sokts kfse mut e`o weufn `erlkffy `et sbt e` taol ks taoy woro tkgo` ehh

    wao` tao voabifos woro mob`c sorvbion. B wo`t k`n skt `oxt te JM tryb`c te soo wakt ao wks

    neb`c. ^ao spkio eutsbno taobr wergsaep neos `et akvo k ievorb`c kmevo u`fbgo tao saeps e`

    obtaor sbno eh tao ckrkco. ^abs weufn co`orkffy ikuso taol te levo b` her saoftor wao` bt rkb`on

    k`n lkgo tao voabifos pkrgon taobr her werg cot wot ks woff, mut e` tao mrbcator sbno bt lok`t

    takt taoy ieufn werg fe`cor eutsbno wabfo utbfbzb`c tao `kturkf fbcat. B wks iurbeus te g`ew

    taeuca ks te way JM nbn `et akvo k saon er ievor kmevo abs stero mut moikuso B taeucat takt bt

    lbcat kckb` mo k teuiay tepbi B foht bt mo. ^ao` B `etbion takt ao weufn cot nbstrkiton my taoseu`n eh ovory twe waoofor fbgo seu`n waoro bt mo k mbgo aer`, k muffot fbgo taulp, k` kitbvk,

    k`n tao pufskr-spfo`ner gb`ns. Ao weufn b`vefu`tkrbfy feeg up fbgo ao woro u`g`ewb`cfy

    so`sbtbvo te taeso gb`n eh seu`ns her abs fe`c oxporbo`io b` tabs hbofn eh hbxb`c twe waoofors

    weufn akvo lkno abl kurkffy so`sbtbvo te taeso seu`ns. ^ao e`fy hk` b` tao saep bs tao slkff

    e`o, mut lkgos k `ebso takt bs poriobvkmfo prevbnon yeu kro fbsto`b`c te bt k`n stkys ie`stk`t. Bt

    aks k saert krok takt bt ievors mut tao tarew bs vory stre`c. Kreu`n tao stero taoro woro seu`ns

    eh tao rknbe ceb`c e` b` tao rostkurk`t knjkio`t te abs ckrkco wabia bs k rostkurk`t takt sorvos

    cujkrktb s`kigs k`n etaor b`nbk` k`n seuta b`nbk` s`kigs. ^ao rostkurk`t bs ikffon Iaktge

    wabia lok`s tksto b` cujkrktb. ^ao saep e` tao etaor sbno eh abs ckrkco bs takt eh waoofkfbc`lo`t her heur waoofors, mut kfwkys feegs olpty b` torls eh tao iustelors k`n ew`ors

    taoro. Bts ikffon Saoof Teb`t. ^aoro bs ie`stk`t seu`n eh voabifos, aer`s, lusbi, poepfo tkfgb`c,

    lembfo pae`os rb`cb`c, ofoitrbikf pulps, gbtiao` teefs, wergsaep teefs, ak`n teefs, akllor

    g`eigb`c, o`cb`os tur`b`c e` ehh er mob`c rovvon, b`nbikters, gbtiao` crb`nb`c, gknkab, irews,

    nec mkrgs, poepfo wkfgb`c k`n tkfgb`c, lusbi hrel ikrs, oti. hrel b` k`n kreu`n tao ckrkco takt

    lkgo bt sool qubto `ebsy kt tblos. ^ao saep epo`s kt 2:94 b` tao ler`b`c k`n stkys epo` tbff

    3:94 - 1pl fbgo B wks tefn yostornky. _`tbf `ew B akn e`fy soo` taoso twe k`n e`o eh taol nbn

    `et feeg fbgo k loiak`bi, se B wks k fbttfo porpfoxon takt tblo te hb`n eut wae kff bs wergb`c kt

    tabs stero kfe`c wbta JM. ^ao`, B puffon fbgo B lo`tbe`on okrfbor, tao ron steef k`n skt `oxt te JM.K`n B ksgon abl)

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    28/109

    GN7 Ro ckknb lob` o`cb`o evorakuf gkr rkao akb`5

    JM7 Alll

    GN7 Bs lob` gyk gyk premfol kkyb akb5

    LM7 Bsgk irk`gb`c kur muhhb`c ae`k pknock.

    (^ao` taoy stkrton tkfgb`c te okia etaor, wabfo tryb`c te ieernb`kto tao ak`n levolo`ts suia

    takt tao rolevkf eh pkrts moielos oksbor, wbta k ieffkmerktbvo ohhert. Ks meta eh taol woro

    tryb`c te werg e` tao o`cb`o, taoy woro tryb`c te notkia tao emjoit hrel bts rospoitbvo pesbtbe`s

    e` meta tao sbnos. ^ao teefs weufn hkff mohero taol khtor tao kttkiab`c `uts k`n mefts weufn

    nrep tee, tao` taoy weufn b` sy`i levo te tao `oxt feiktbe` te u`sirow. Bt wks k ielpfoto tokl

    ohhert. Yunno`fy tao` k Mfkig Ifkssbi 9?4 reffon b` wbta k lbnnfo kcon lk` nrosson b` wabtbsa

    crky skbn te JM selotab`c b` Cujju rockrnb`c @uts k`n Mefts khtor crootb`c jeyhuffy. JM ropfbon te

    takt, k`n tao` tao etaor cuy soolon te akvo cetto` k fbttfo nbskppeb`ton k`n tao` levon mkig,

    tefn abl JM wakt soolon fbgo ao weufn mo ielb`c fktor. Ao tao` reno ehh. Yoob`c taol squkther se fe`c B b`torvo`on)

    GN7 JM kkpge steef iakabyo 5

    JM7 @kab`, taoog akb kkp mkbtae.

    (^aoy meta soolon qubto o`cresson b` wakt taoy woro neb`c, wbta taobr oxprossbe`s fbgo taeso

    eh lo` e` k lbssbe`. Lugatkr makb tao` wo`t moab`n k`n cet k fbttfo vossof takt soolon te akvo

    moo` lkno eut eh k` kffey eh kfulb`bul k`n stoof. Ao epo`on k sirow k`n peppon eut peurb`c

    k strokl eh mfkig ebf, takt wks tao o`cb`o ebf wbta qubto k prossuro te crokso abs jok`s. Aoknjuston tao feiktbe` eh tao mewf k`n bt hbffon ks luia ks tao vossof ieufn aefn k`n soolon fbgo

    bt weufn akvo evor hbffon bt. Ye ao steppon tao hfew wbta hbxb`c eh tao steppor k`n tao` wo`t k`n

    mreucat k`etaor yoffewbsa jorryik` k`n hbffon b` tao rost eh bt. ^ao` B ksgon abl)

    GN7 Roa, ckknb kkpgb akb 5

    LM7 Akk`, lkb`o yoa lysero so fkkyb akb. Toafo nea ckknb tab, og ron wkkfk ofoitrk(rohorrb`c

    te tao e`o b` Gu`kf's neiulo`t) kur og yoa wkkfb. ]on wkkfb moia noo. Km yoa wkkfb mk`k`b

    akb.

    GN7 Lysero so kkp iakfk go fkkyo 5LM7 @kab`, trkb` so fkkyo taky.

    GN7 Kur kkp`o yoa wkkfk ckknb gye` gakrbnk 5

    LM7 Roa efn lenof akb, ;2?4 gk akb.

    GN7 eaa.

    JM7 Bnakr po og siroo` prb`tb`c wkkfk mkbtatk akb. Kckr kkpgo ieffoco lob` gbsb ge iakabyo

    aeck tea. Geb mab typo gk prb`tb`c gkrtk akb.

    GN7 Rkab`, pkr akb 5 (rohorrb`c te tao ielpfox)

    LM7 Lktfkm pkss lbo` akb, lkb` kkpge usgk ie`tkit fk nee`ck.

    GN7 Egky. Sea taoog aeck.LM7 Lkb` ykab` pkss lbo` roatk aee`. Sea upkr 9rn hfeer pkr Hkiomeeg, wae lork saep akb.

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    29/109

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    30/109

    tao` hbx bt hb`kffy. Sabfo hbxb`c ao tefn lo takt wo lust kfwkys iaoig bh kff pkrts kro hu`itbe`b`c

    mohero e`o neos tao hb`kf kttkialo`t. ^abs ckvo lo k` bnok eh abs oxporbo`io k`n abs fokr`b`c

    khtor akvb`c lkno lbstkgos. ^ao` twe hoffews iklo b` feegb`c her k soie`n ak`n mbgo mut JM

    tefn taol takt ao nbn`'t akvo k`y proso`tfy mut ao weufn iaoig k`n takt taoy saeufn premkmfy

    ielo my kckb`. B `etbion takt JM spego te k`y eh abs peto`tbkf iustelors vory `biofy. ^aktpremkmfy rolb`non abl takt tao mbgo taoso twe woro feegb`c kt `oonon ifok`b`c. Ye, e`io taoy

    foht ao teeg takt mbgo k`n wo`t moab`n abs wergsaep waoro ao lestfy uson takt spkio her

    wksab`c tao mbgos. ^ao wksa sotup b`ifunos k pbpo wbta k `ezzfo ie``oiton te k jot. ^abs pbpo

    bs ie``oiton b`sbno te tao pulp takt bs feikton motwoo` tao twe rkigs e` tao wkff. Yb`io tao

    pbpo bs saert, bt neos `et kffew tao porse` ifok`b`c te levo kreu`n hroofy. Mut tao pbpo cot bts

    tarust eh wktor khtor tao pulp bs tur`on e` k`n tao` bt lkgos k iaabt iaabt iaabt iaabt seu`n

    wao` tao wktor hfews eut eh tao `ezzfo. Yb`io H44= bs tao soie`n saep k`n taoro bs `e nbroit

    wky eh ceb`c moab`n tao saep mut te kreu`n bt wabfst ovknb`c tao mbc sikry nbtia takt waoof peb`t

    hoffew aks nuc up se takt ao ik` ce u`nor tao voabifos k`n hbx taol. E` tao sbno takt fokns tetao mkig eh tao stero bs k pertbe` waoro JM aks pkrgon etaor voabifos wabia obtaor akvo moo`

    hbxon k`n kro wkbtb`c her taobr rospoitbvo ew`ors er taeso takt weufn tkgo k fet eh tblo te mo

    hbxon her taoy roqubro o`erleus kleu`t eh werg k`n waeso iustelors kro `et tee b`ifb`on e`

    akvb`c taobr voabifos rosteron qubigfy. Kt tao mkig bs k` efn hrklo eh k yklkak takt JM tefn lo

    mofe`cs te k mbgo takt ao meucat soie`n ak`n k`n wabia ao wbsaos te rostero `ew. Hrel taoro

    e`o ik` soo kff tao nbrty mbgos takt akvo moo` nosirbmon kmevo k`n taoro bs k ho`io takt

    nolkriktos tao fk`n e` wabia taoy akvo ie`struiton tabs ielpfox. Moye`n bt fbos k` epo`

    pboio eh fk`n takt bs proso`tfy mob`c nuc up her mubfnb`c k `ow lkff k`n kaokn eh takt kro tao

    kpkrtlo`ts mufbt my tao _CK^B ie`struitbe` tokl. ^aoro kro taroo saeps b` tabs ielpfox kslo`tbe`on okrfbor, b.o. tao rostkurk`t mob`c tao mbccost, tao` JM's wergsaep k`n tao` tao waoof

    peb`t pfkio. Mut, e`fy tao rostkurk`t aks k mkigneer her kiioss, wabia bs way JM aks te ce

    ovorytblo kreu`n tao waoof peb`t saep te cot te tao wksab`c krok. Bt bs kfse k pkb` her abl ks

    tao pulp neos `et akvo k nbroit kiioss eutsbno. Sabfo JM wks ifok`b`c tao mfkig pufskr ;9?, B

    skw LM ceb`c eut e` k ron kvo`cor. B `etbion takt JM ifok`s taol mbgos vory `biofy k`n takt

    lest eh abs werg b`vefvos k fet eh fkmeur ks ao aks te lk`ukffy sirum eut k fet eh nbrt hrel tao

    mbgo. Sao` ao wks ifok`b`c B ksgon abl )

    GN7 JM ck`nab`kckr lob` tea muffot ckknb gkl akb.JM7 Akk`

    GN7 ^ea kkp mkkgb ckknb mab bsbfbyo mk`kto akb`.

    JM7 akk`, mkkgb ckknb mab mk`kto akb`.

    GN7 Guia hkrkg aetk akb5

    JM7 Akk`, b` `kyo ckknb lob` skm guia og skkta aetk akb. Fogb` muffot lob` skm kfkc kfkc aetk

    akb. Og jkcka nbggkt kktk akb tea og pkrt ge taoog gkr`o gk. Fogb` mkkgb jkbso yoa pufskr lob`

    gkkhb gaef`k pkntk akb. Muffot ge mk`k`k kkskk` akb.

    GN7 ^ea hbr muffot mk`k`o wkfo gkl gye` akb` 5

    JM7 _slob` lkzneerb jyknk akb.GN7 eaaa

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    31/109

    GN7 ^ea bss ckknb lob` kkp gyk skab gkr rkao ae5

    JM7 Bsgk o`cb`o evorakuf gbyk akb. Ne akzkkr cykkrka gk lenof akb kur nogae yoa guiaa

    pko`toos akzkkr gbfelotor ab iakfkk akb.

    ( B wks tab`gb`c kt tabs peb`t kmeut aew fe`c bt akn moo` her ly voabifo k`n mkson e` takt, waktwks bts ie`nbtbe` rbcat `ew. B ie`tb`uon wbta)

    GN7 ^ea, yoa gkll akb gykk5

    JM7 Alll (Fe`c wbta k ielpfoto khhbrlktbe`), b` ckknbye` gk tea kckr sorvbio skab tblo tblo

    pkr gkrto rkaeco tea ksssb `kmmo akzkkr pkr ab o`cb`o ge evorakuf gkr`k pknock fogb` hbr ckknb

    gk sorvbio tblo tblo pkr aeto roa`k iakabyo.

    ( B taeucat 14 - 24,444 gbfelotors wks fbgo k rbnbiufeus kleu`t. K`n B ie`tb`uon te ksg abl)

    GN7 Bt`k jykknk yoa skm ckknb iakf fotb akb 5

    JM7 Akk`, iakftb akb` `k. Gye` `kab iakfocb, kckr kkp mk`kk go rkgaeco tea iakfocb. Mus

    sorvbio tblo tblo pkr gkrwkke.

    GN7 Alll

    ( B wks tab`gb`c takt bt wks pessbmfo te `biofy ru` e`o's leteriyifo prevbnon e`o weufn tkgo ikro

    eh bt. K`n kfse tao etaor tab`c B taeucat wks takt rokffy bh tabs pufskr bs tkgb`c se luia eh abs

    ohhert k`n tao` ao ablsofh bs skyb`c takt tao reykf o`hbofn tkgos lero ohhert k`n tao` B kl `et

    suro bh B ik` ie`tost takt. ^ao wo skw takt LM akn rotur`on k`n ao mreucat k pkigot wbta selomrew` fbqubn b` bt wabia feegon fbgo tok. K`n ao peuron bt b`te taroo vory tb`y iups. JM cet up te

    bllonbktofy akvo selo eh tao `bio aet tok takt akn ielo. Ovo` B cet te nrb`g bt k`n wks vory

    `bio. ^aoy ksgon lo bh B wk`ton selo lero mut B tak`gon taol k`n pksson. B succoston te LM

    takt ao ieufn ehhor tao rost eh bt te JM k`n JM nbn akvo tao rost eh bt. ^ao` B skw takt taoy weufn

    nrb`g tao iakb k`n tarew tao iup k`y waoro taoy fbgon, k`n taus tao pfkio akn k fet eh pfkstbi

    fbttor kreu`n. Khtor tao iakb B ieufn `et aofp mut B wks hoofb`c ovo` lero au`cry se B noibnon

    takt B weufn premkmfy ce mkig k`n okt selotab`c ks oktb`c kreu`n taobr saep weufn lkgo lo

    sool au`cry k`n lero se bt we`'t feeg ceen. B akn `et okto` mrokghkst se B nbn `et tab`g tee

    luia. B wo`t b`sbno tao saep. Sreto selo eh tao peb`ts B hoft woro blpertk`t k`n tao` tao`wo`t k`n tefn JM takt B akvo k ifkss kt b` k`etaor akfh k` aeur b` ieffoco k`n uson takt oxiuso

    te fokvo hrel tao ckrkco. Mut mohero fokvb`c B iak`con tao ioffs eh tao oxbno wkff ifeig moab`n

    wabia wks k mbc hkt fbzkrn. Sabfo ceb`c te puriakso tao ioffs hrel k `okrmy stero JM teeg eut k

    ;4 rupoo `eto hrel abs wkffot k`n ckvo bt te lo, B rohuson, ao b`sbston k`n tao` B teeg bt k`n

    wo`t. Ao feegon fbgo ao wks ne`o wbta wksab`c tao Tufskr. Test takt, B skbn myo te meta tao

    lo` k`n foht her ieffoco. B taeucat takt bt wks `et suia k mkn stkrt se hkr.)

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    32/109

    Nkto7;2ta Jufy =4;9

    Nky7 Hrbnky

    Ovo`t tblo7kreu`n ;4:>?bsa

    Feiktbe 7 Ckrkco

    Kiters7 Gkrk`, JM, LM k`n @]

    (B rokiaon tao Ckrkco okrfy takt nky k`n JM wks eutsbno k`n wks k`etaor lk` wae B cet te

    g`ew fktor wks @kro`nor Makb. B nrevo b` k`n khtor steppb`c eutsbno tao saep `etbion takt JM

    wks nrosson b` wakt soolon fbgo k `ow wabto sabrt. Ye B peb`ton takt eut skyb`c)

    GN7 Aoffe JM.

    JM7 Gkbsk akb5

    GN7 Lkb` tea taoog aee`, kur kkp tea slkrt fkc rkao ae.

    (Ao saeeg ly ak`n k`n meta eh us wkfgon b`sbno tao ckrkco. Ao ksgon lo te akvo k sokt mut B

    skbn tak`g yeu k`n rohuson. B pfkion ly mkc e` tao nosg. ^ao` B mock` tkfgb`c te abl kmeut tao

    spfo`ner mbgo wabia ao skbn wks hbxon k`n rotur`on khtor ao ropfkion tao enelotor. ^ao` B

    trbon ksgb`c abl kmeut tao croy leteriyifo)

    GN7 Kur wea lugatkr makb gb ckknb5

    JM7 Sea mab akb, usgk gkkl roatk akb.

    (^ao` ao saewon lo tao o`cb`o takt wks fyb`c taoro wbta kff bts pkrts fyb`c kmeut k`n B ksgonabl)

    GN7 Bslo nbggkt gyk akb5

    JM7 Roa ckknb lob` irk`g gk pfky skab gkr`k akb. Sea kalonkmkn lob` mk`ock.

    GN7 Ykab akb kur ykakk` so kkp fogo jkkeco5

    JM7 Akk`.

    (^ao` B mock` feegb`c kreu`n tao stero kckb` k`n B ksgon JM bh B ieufn ifbig pbituros k`n ao

    ielpfotofy kcroon. Just tao` B skw Lugatkr Makb ielb`c b`. So crooton okia etaor slbfb`c. JMwo`t moab`n tao stero tao` se B spego te LM)

    GN7 Gkbso ae5

    LM7 kiaaiaao akb`.

    GN7 Gyk kkp Ybfvorspee` `kab` kkyo gkf ge. Lkb` kur guiaa nest fec ckyo taky.

    LM7 Akk` wea kmab ]klzk` iakf rkak akb, tea lkb` guiaa og lkab`o go fbyo `kab` jkkee`ck.

    GN7 Egky, kkpgb ckknb mk` rkab akb (wabfo peb`tb`c te tao croy leteriyifo)

    LM7 Akk` o`cb`o gk gkkl roatk akb (wabfo peb`tb`c te tao o`cb`o takt fky e` tao hfeer.)

    GN7 Bs lob` gyk gyk skab aeck5

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    33/109

    (Aefnb`c tao irk`g kckb` ao tefn lo takt )

    LM7 Bsgk irk`g abf rkak. Bsgo pfky go wkjka so o`cb`o lob` so kwkkz kktb akb. _sge mk`kk

    no`co tea kkwkkz kab` kkyocb.

    GN7 Ro ckknb gkakk` so fkkyo kkp.LM7 Ro loro makb skkakm fkko akb` Lysero so.

    GN7 kkp`o yoa lenof gye` fbyk5

    LM7 Roa efn akb. ;2?4 gk lenof akb gkf mktkyk takk `k kkpge. Kur yoa gbsb krly wkkfo gb ckknb

    taoo.

    GN7 Roa bsgb sokt akb 5

    LM7 Akk`.

    GN7 Bsge kkp pkb`t mab gkrkeco 5

    LM7 Akk`, fogb` ckknb mk` jkkyo usgo mkkn. Kkpge bsgo pkb`t lob` hkrkg nbgatk akb 5

    GN7 Lllll, `kab`.

    (B fbon g`ewb`c takt ao weufn ierroit lo)

    LM7 @kab`, hkrkg akb. Kkp tk`g kur yoa mooia lob` nogae. Sea croy akb kur bslob` croo`

    zyknk akb.

    GN7 Akk` akk`, mbfguf akb. ^ea pkb`t gbt`o gk aeck 5 Lktfkm huff, iakssbs mab

    LM7 Gkl so gkl kkpge pkk`ia so iaao akzkkr tea fkcock. Lktfkm iakssbs mab pkgknfe tea

    purk ckknb gaef`k pknock. Skr`k kckr iakssbs `kab` gkr`k tea taenk gkl aeck. Gye`gb kckr

    iakssbs `kab`, akb tea sbrh sbno sbno so pkrt `bgkkf go pkb`t ae jkyock. Jkbso aokn gk, hbftor gk,teef mex.

    GN7 Lujao mab pkb`t gkrwk`o gk takk.

    LM7 Gyk 5

    GN7 Ckknb po. Gkkhb tblo so ykab pkb`t akb kur km mero ae ckyk aee`. ^ea lkb` seia rkak pkb`t

    gkrk`o gkk.

    LM7 Turk ckknb gkrk`k akb5

    GN7 Akk`, fogb` kfkc kfkc pkb`t gkr`k akb pkrts pkr. ^ea lujao jkk` `k takk go gbt`k pkbsk fkc

    skgtk akb5

    LM7 _t`k ab, pkk`ia - iaao tea fkc jkkock. kur jkbso kmab pkb`t nogae, kmab je pkb`t fkck akbwea loao`ck wkfk pkb`t akb gye`gb je ielpk`y pkb`t notb akb wea kiaiak qukfbty gk aetk akb.

    GN7 Akk` wea tea kkp gb mkkt mbfguf skab akb. Gye`gb og mkkr aulkkro pbtkjb jkm jkk rkao tao

    lkrutb lob` tea, o`cb`o lob` kkc fkc ckyb, lktfkm naeek` kk rkak tak. ^ea usge taoog gkrk`o

    go mkkn u`ae` `o me`ot pkr pkb`t gkrkyk kur ne lkab`o go mkkn wea naeep so un ckyk. _sgo

    mkkn bt`k mogkkr fkctk akb, gye`gb ne`e kfkc kfkc nbgatky akb`. Bsfbyo pkb`t gb qukfbty kiaiab ae`b

    iakabyo.

    LM7 Akk`, jkbso nosort sterl nogak akb kkp`o5

    GN7 Akk` `kk`, usgk rk`c meaet skab akb. Loro pbtkjb mef rkao taky ussge noga`o go mkkn go

    lujao mab wea pkb`t gkrk fo`k iakbyo.LM7 Akk`, loro og nest `o wae yoffew pkb`t gkrwkyk akb. Gkkhb loao`ck akb usgk pkb`t.

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    34/109

    Yakkykn us`o kkta yk skkno kkta nbyo taky. Fogb` wea hbr iefer ab loao`ck akb kur meaut gkl

    lbftk akb. Fogb` pkb`t lktto ab skab akb. Kckr gkrkeco tea lktto gkrk`k.

    GN7 Akk`, `oxt lkb` lktto ab pkb`t gkrkee`ck.

    LM7 Lktto lob` ckknb mkaut kiaiab fkctb akb.

    GN7 Kkpge twe waoofor gk gkkhb sakug akb5LM7 Akk`. Lork fkkf wkkfk mab takk je kkp`o paete lob` nogak tak.

    GN7 Sea kmab akb kkpgo pkks5

    LM7 @kab` wea tea moia nbyk lkb`o. Fogb` yoa lorb kktawb ckknb akb. Bsso poafo spfo`ner,

    sieetor, pufskr, IMZ, jkvk yoznb skm rkgak takk.

    GN7 Kroy, yoznb gykk skab ckknb akb. Lkb` kckr fo pkktk tea yoznb ab fotk.

    LM7 Akk`, fogb` usgo pkrts km `kab` lbfto kur usgo loiak`bi mab km naee`n`k lusagbf akb.

    GN7 ^ea, skkrb ckknbk` kkp`o sakug go fbyo rkgab kur hbr moia noo.

    (B ieufn soo abl hoofb`c se rbia, akppy k`n abs iaost hbff wbta prbno wao` ao skbn)

    LM7 Akk`. Iakfkyk kur hbr moia nbyk. > waoofor mab akb fogb` wea sbrh jkm hklbfy go skkta gkab`

    jkk`o gk aeck tkm `bgkf`k aetk akb. Skbso lkb` = waoofor ab prohor gkrtk aee`.

    GN7 Lujao mab = waoofor zyknk pksk`n akb. Jkm lkb` ckknb fo rkak takk tkm loro nest fec

    loro ge mef rkao taky gb tu gykk yo ckknb fo rkak akb. Roa meny wkkfo po subt gkrtb akb. Kur bsgo

    fbyo lusifos iakabyo aetb akb`. Fogb` lork mkaut lk`` takk yoa fo`o gkk

    LM7 Km gyk akb. Km tea fkngbyk` mab iakfkktb akb` muffot. Ykm iakfkkto akb`.

    GN7 Mbfguf taoog mkkt akb. Ckknb iakfkk`o gk lk`` akb tea kkp gea ckknb fo`k iakabyo. Meny

    saeny so guiaa hkrkg `kab` pkntk akb.LM7 Akk`. (pkuso). ^ea, @BN lob` kkp gykk pknto ae5

    GN7 Lork ieurso gk `kkl akb `ow lonbk nosbc`. Bss ieurso lbo` ielputor go mkro lbo`

    pkn`k aetk akb. Ykkro kkpgo lembfo pae`os, kpps kur sehtwkro go mkkro lob` aul fece` ge

    sbgakto akb`. Fogb` aulkkrk ieurso nakkb skkf gk akb tea kmab mkaut guiaa sbga`k mkkgb akb.

    LM7 Somsbtos mab mk`k`k.

    GN7 Akk` wea mab kmab sooga`k akb. Kur aulkkro `ow lonbk nosbc` go kfkwk unakr Fbhostyfo

    kiiossery nosbc` akb, usgo fec cakr lob` bstblkkf gbyk jkk`o wkfk skklkk` jkbso jowoffory,

    fklps wkcork mk`kto akb`. Hbr, kppkrof nosbc` akb je fkngo kur fkngbbe` go gkpno kur ckrlo`ts

    mk`kto akb`.LM7 alll. Taetecrkpay nosbc` mab akb5

    GN7 Akk`, paetecrkpay nosbc` mab aetk kur u`ge paetecrkpay so rofkton skm guiaa pknkto

    akb`. _sgo kfkwk trk`spertktbe` nosbc` akb jbslob` wea fec ckknb, mbgo, mus, truig, skm iaooz

    gk nosbc` soogatky akb`. Kur YNL - strktocbi nosbc` lk`kcolo`t mab sbgakkto akb`, jbslob`

    u`ao kkpgo musb`oss lob` nosbc` uso gkrgo moatkr mk`k`k sbgakkto akb`. Sea je fkngk kkyk

    takk, poafo Gu`kf jbs`o ropert mk`kyk takk wea YNL gk ab akb.

    LM7 ^ea gbt`k pkbsk foto akb`5

    GN7 Jkbso lkb`o kmab hoo nbyk takk og fkga kntkkfbss akzkkr.

    LM7 All, kur bslob` roa`o gk pkn`o gk skm akb.GN7 Akk`, peerk gakk`o go, roa`o gk, tubtbe` hoo skm mbjfb pkk`b peerk pkbsk akb. ^ea nakkb

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    35/109

    skkf lob`, tkgroomk` skkno skkt kkta go kks pkks kktk akb.

    LM7 Lktfkm nakkb too` skkf lob` nus fkga, kkpgo caeel`o roa`o gk skm lbfkkgo tkgroomk`

    kk jktk aeck.

    GN7 Akk`, ut`k kktk aeck. Fogb` jkbso lkb`o fek` fogo pkn rkak aee`. ^ea loro ge mk`g `o

    sbrh pkn`o go fbyo jbt`k fkcock ut`k ab pkbsk nbyk akb.LM7 ^ea kkpgo fek` lob` wea gkkckz cakr gk mab nbgakk`k pkntk akb5

    GN7 Akk`, fogb` wea nopo`n gkrtk akb gb kkpgk fek` gk kleu`t gbt`k akb. Kckr kkp iakkr fkga

    so gkl gk fek` foto ae tea kkpge `kab` no`k pknock wea skm pkpor. Kckr iakkr so zykknk

    akb, jkbso lork tkqroomk` kkta fkga akb, tea aulob` cakr gk pkpor nbgakk`k pknk takk.

    LM7 Alll. kiaiak og mkkt mktkbyo gb jkbso yoa `bht kur `bn lob` cujkrktb mkiaiao gkl gye`

    aeto akb`5 @kab` jkbso poafo poafo tea aeto ab `kab` taky lkckr km sakkykn nus mkiaiao

    cujkrktb `bgkf kkyo`co.

    GN7 Nogabyo skm io`trkf u`bvorsbtbos lob` kbsk aetk akb gb jkm oxkl aetk akb tea peero nosa

    lob` og skkta oxkl aetk akb kur gkkhb skkro mkiaiao kppfy gkrto akb`. Hbr jbt`o fec oxkl pkksgkrto akb` wea skm og jkcka kkto akb` kur u`ge mktkyk jkktk akb, yk hbr herl so pktkk iakftk akb

    gb gkakk` pkr gku` sk ieurso skab akb. Hbr kckr wea wkkfk ieurso kkpge aynorkmkn lob`

    lbfock tea kkpge aynorkmkn lob` jkkgo pkn`k aeck. Kckr kkpge ck`nab`kckr wkkfk ieurso

    iakbyo tea kkp ck`nab`kckr wkkfo go fbyo lkk`c skgto akb`. Kbso gkr`o so kfkc kfkc jkcka so

    mkiaiao pkn`o kkto akb`.

    LM7 All. Gyk akb `k go cujkrkt lob` yoa systol `kab` takk kkco pkn`o gk. Jkbso mkiaiao

    `o ;4 + = gbyk hbr usgo mkkn, crknuktbe` gkrgo zykknk `kab` pknto akb`. Jykknk fec jem yk

    musb`oss gkr`o ge jkkto akb`. Geb cubno gkr`o ge zyknk `kab` aetk. Mut, ykakk` go ieffoco go

    fec kfkc aeto akb`.GN7 Kfkc aeto akb`, gkbso 5

    LM7 Jkbso fkngk fkngb skkta caeelto akb`. Fkngb fec iaaeto gkpnk poao`to akb` (Sabfo

    teuiab`c abs tabcas wbta abs ak`ns). Ibckrotto pootoo akb`. Roa skm pksk`n `kab` akb. Rkakk`

    go fece` ge jkbso fkctk akb gb b`go cakr go jkbso fece` `o b`ge kiaiao sk`sgkr `kab` sbgakyk. (B

    gopt fbsto`b`c te abl ks b`to`tfy ks B ieufn wtaeut nbskcroob`c evor k`ytab`c).

    GN7 Lkckr, sauree lob` kbsk takk yk km mab akb 5

    LM7 @kab`, km `kab` akb. Km tea skm iak`co ae rkak akb. Iufturo iak`co ae rkak akb. Mut,

    stkrtb`c lob` mkaut zyknk takk. Roa @BH^ go kur TNT_ lob` gkkhb zykknk hbcat kur cu`nk

    ckrnb mab aetb taoo. B`heibty lob` gkkhb mkkr auk akb.GN7 Akk`, jkwk`b lob` fknto akb` fec. Fkngb go upkr aeck.

    LM7 Kur gyk, fkngb go fbyo tea tbtk`bi mab neem ckyk takk.

    GN7 Gyk, hbrso gkabyo 5

    LM7 Neemk tak `k tbtk`bi.

    (Meta eh us slbfon her selotblo ks bt wks k truta takt lest lo` eh k qub`tosso`tbkffy

    pktrbkriabkf seiboty weufn kcroo wbta. Lok`wabfo LM wks lkgb`c abs lkskfk takt k fet eh

    cujkrktb lo` iaow rocufkrfy. Ao put bt b` abs leuta k`n just tao` selomeny ao g`ow krrbvon, se

    ao foht tao ckrkco k`n wkfgon kwky te loot abl. B teeg selo peb`ts new` b` ly `etomeegwabfo tab`gb`c takt tabs fkst ie`vorsktbe` wbta LM wks `et se blpertk`t ks bt nbn `et rofkto te k`y

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    36/109

    eh tao seu`ns her wabia B iklo te stuny aoro. Khtor `etb`c new` taeso peb`ts B wo`t eut te loot

    tao etaor loiak`bi wae wks wergb`c e` k ron Ae`nk Ytu``or. B akn `et soo` abl okrfbor k`n

    tao` B hbcuron takt ao lbcat mo tao tabrn cuy wergb`c kt tao ckrkco. B slbfon k`n pefbtofy ksgon

    abl)

    GN7 Bs ckknb lob` gyk nbggkt akb 5

    @]7 Roa sorvbib`c lob` kkyk akb, huff sorvbib`c go fbyo.

    GN7 kur makb kpgk `kkl gyk akb 5

    @]7 Lork `kkl @kro`nrk akb.

    GN: Kur lork `kkl gkrk` akb. (Tkuso ) Kkp mab skkro ckknb mk`kto ae 5

    @]7 Akk` geb mab typo gk mbgo, huff sorvbib`c gkrto akb`. Zykknk mbgos lkb` hkrkg `kab` aetk

    akb.

    GN7 Lkckr sorvbib`c stkrt gkbso gkrto akb`5 Lktfkm gku` so pkrt so kkp so stkrt gkreco5

    @]7 ^ea purrk iaoigb`c aetk akb, poafo iustelor gaun mktktk akb gb gkakk` gkakk` pkr u`genbgtkt kktb akb. Hbr aul fec gaun mab iaoigb`c gkrto akb`. Jkbso o`cb`o gk tolporkturo, ebf

    iak`co, mrkgo ebf, ebf hbftor, kbr hbftor, mrkgo iaoigb`c kkco kur pooiao wkkfk, skkro lotor jkbso

    huof gk, kbr gk, fbcats. Bs tkrka guiaa toos - pk`toos peb`ts pkr iaoigb`c aetk akb. Geb mab

    b`tor`kf ielmustbe` o`cb`o lob` stregos aeto akb`. heur strego o`cb`o aetk akb usgk iaoigb`c

    kfkc aetk akb twe strego gk kfkc aetk akb. Bs skmge jkk``o go fbyo kkpge taoery gk g`ewfonco

    mab ae`k iakabyo. Trkitbikf g`ewfonco tea kk jktk akb. Og ne akhtk lob` kkp sooga skgto ae

    fogb` je kkp o`cb`o kur ckknb go mkkro lob` og ne akhtk lob` soogaeco wea kkp taoery pkn go

    gkkhb jkfnb sooga jkkeco. Kur mkaut skkro loiak`bis ge taoery gk g`ewfonco `kab` aetk akb.

    Sea fec sbrh hbofn pkr ab soogato akb`, tea u``ge pkrts kur lktorbkfs go mkkro lob` `kab` pktkkaetk akb gb yoa pkrt ykakk` gye` fkckkyk akb. _sgk rokse` gyk akb. Tkrt kfulb`bul gk gye`

    akb, stoof gk gye` `kab`. Kckr kkp rummor gk pkrt mk`keco tkm gyk aeck. Fecbi so `kab` pktkk

    aetk u`ao. Kur taeory pkn`o so g`ewfonco zykknk kktb akb. Kckr kkp pkn`k iakato ae kur

    sooga`k iakato ae ckknb go mkkro lob` tea kkpge pkn`k iakabyo.

    (Ao cet tao mbgo moab`n tao ckrkco b` tao wksab`c krok k`n tao` wo ie`tb`uon tkfgb`c)

    GN7 Gykk gykk pkn`k aeck5

    @]7 Og ab`nb gb gbtkkm kktb akb. Tktfb sb gbtkkm aetb akb. Kur klnkvkn lob` kkpge lbf jkkyocb.Rkakk` ck`nab`kckr lob` lbf`k taenk lusagbf akb fogb` klnkvkn lob` kkrkkl so lbfocb.

    GN7 Kkpgo pkks aecb wea gbtkkm5

    @]7 Loro pkks tea `kab` akb. Fogb` lkb` nogago kkpge mktk nee`ck. Kkp kmab gyk gkrto ae5

    GN7 Lkb` kmab @BN lob` pkntk aee`.

    @]7 Seab @BH^ wkfk.

    GN7 @kab` @BN, nosbc` gk ieffoco akb. Je pktof nkbry go uss pkkr akb.

    @]7 Akk`

    GN7 Akk` tea wkakk` pkr lkb`, `ow lonbk nosbc` pkn rkak aee`. _slob` aulob` ielputor

    so rofkton iaoozkb` pknkkto akb`.@]7 ^ea hbr kkp bnakr kutelembfos go mkkro lob` gkbso 5

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    37/109

    GN7 Akk` gye`gb jea aulkkrk ieurso iakf rkak akb uslob` aulob` mefk ckyk akb gb aul

    ieffoco go mkkakr jkkgkr gbsb mab tkrka gk gkkl go mkkro lob` sooga skgto akb`. Skakk` pkr

    fec gkbso gkkl gkrto akb`, sumka so fogo sakkl tkg. _`ge gyk nbggkt kktb akb`, wea usky gkbso

    sufjakto akb`. Kur u`go wkakk` gbs gbs tkrka go iustelor fec kkto akb`. Jbt`k mab sooga skgto

    akb` gbsb mab gkkl go mkkro lob`. Kur aulkkro tokiaor hbr aulob` mktkkyo`co gb kkco kkcogykk gkr`k akb. Aulob` kp`o pksk`n go gkkl go mkkro lob` jkk``k akb. ^ea muffot kur twe

    waoofors lob` b`torost akb. Aklosak so sbga`k iakato taky gb ckknb gkbso gkkl gkrtb akb. Kur

    kp`b ckknb go mkkro lob` g`ewfonoco ae. Jbtumakb go pkks kkto taky tea mus bsbfbyo kkyo akb`.

    @]7 Kkp gkakk` go roa`o wkkfo ae5

    GN7 Nbffb so kkyo akb`. Kur kkp 5

    @]7 Aul tea ykab` go akb`. Ck`nab`kckr lob` akb` mkiapk` so, gunksk` lob`.

    GN7 Allll (Tkuso) Roa JM `o pulp gk peb`t k`nkr gye` nbyk kckr ckknb mkkakr nauftb akb 5

    @]7 Sea poafo mkkakr ab takk fogb` tkm gyk aetk takk gb cke` wkfo kkgo `kakkto taky, geb kp`b

    cuy ge `oafktk takk, ykk hbr fec kp`b ckknb nae go kur gaun `kakk go iakfo jkkto taky.GN7 (Ylbfb`c) Hbr5

    @]7 Hbr, aulob` k`nkr nkkf`k pknkk gye`gb hbr mbgo naeto tblo pkk`b gaktkl ae jkktk takk. Kur

    iustelor ge ck`nb ckknb `kab` no skgto kckr wea sorvbib`c lob` fkkyk akb. ^ea bsbfbyo usso

    k`nkr nkkf nbyk akb.

    (^abs peb`t wks blpertk`t her lo ks bt lok`t takt taoy weufn rospoit yeur voabifo k`n weufn

    ielpfoto kff tao sorvbios takt taoy ievor b` k sorvbio. B wks`'t se sgoptbikf kmeut bt kftaeuca B

    tefn lysofh takt B lust `et tkgo tab`cs e` hkio vkfuo. Ao lbcat mo skyb`c bt moikuso ao g`ewstakt B kl neb`c k stuny kt tabs ckrkco)

    GN7 (Ylbfb`c) ^aoog akb, @] lkb` kktk aee` og lb`uto lob`.

    (^ao` B iklo b` tao hre`t eh tao wergsaep te tkgo k fbttfo mrokg k`n wreto bt kff new` b` ly

    `etopkn. Ao ie`tb`uon te wksa tao mbgo k`n ao wks tao e`fy e`o uptbf `ew wae spego te lo

    kmeut g`ewb`c taoery ks bt wks vory blpertk`t ks por abl. Ao kfse wks tao e`fy e`o te mo k

    fbbtfo `e`pfusson te g`ew takt B wks aoro kt k ckrkco wk`tb`c te g`ew aew poepfo wergon aoro.

    Sabfo wrbtb`c B wks sbttb`c new`, e` tao ron steef b` tao saep. @et luia fktor, @] iklo mkigk`n ksgon lo)

    @]7 Makbyk kkp ykab` ae`k. Lkb` jkrk fu`ia gkr go kkee`ck.

    GN7 Kitukffy, lujao mab `bgkf`k takk. ^ea kkp gbt`b nkor lob` kkeco5

    @]7 Og ne cak`to lob`.

    GN7 Og Ne cak`to go fbyo tea lkb` `kab` rug pkkee`ck.

    @]7 Geb mkkt `kab` tea kkp, sauttor ge akfh mk`n gkr go yoa sbno wkkfo(rohorb`c te tao knjkio`t

    waoof kfbc`lo`t stero) makb ge mktkgo iakfo jkk`k. Geb to`sbe` `kab` akb.

    GN7 ^aoog Akb @] Makb.@]7 Egky hbr.

  • 7/22/2019 Ethnographic Research Report

    38/109

    GN7 Egky myo.

    (Ao tur`on k`n nbskppokron. B hoft takt ao ikron lero her abs ew` heen k`n pfoksuro tak` kmeut

    tao werg k`n tao stero aoro. Abs meny fk`cukco kfse wks k mbt nrkccy. Ao nbn `et sool sorbeus

    er b`toroston b` werg. Lestfy B kfse hoft takt wabfo tkfgb`c te lo ao wks hoofb`c vory preun ks bh Bworo abs ju`ber `ew. B gopt tkgb`c new` e` kff tao peb`ts B hoft woro rofovk`t. B seloaew wks

    hoofb`c qubto sfoopy takt tblo. Ye, tao knnon nkrg`oss ieurtosy tao ifeun ievor k`n tao slkff

    hk` evor lo lkno lo nrep tao po` k`n B roston ly aokn e` tao `owfy lenbhbon mfkig IMZ k`n

    wo`t her k pewor `kp. K saert wabfo fktor B `etbion k lk` akn ielo my tao o`trk`io eh tao

    wergsaep k`n wks skyb`c selotab`c b` Cujkrktb, B hbcuron ao wks o`qubrb`c kmeut tao purpfo

    muffot takt steen eutsbno. B ieufn`'t toff abl luia mut takt B ne`'t u`norstk`n cujkrktb k`n B kl

    `et ru``b`c tao stero aoro. Bh ao akn k`y quorbos tao` ao lust ie`tkit JM waeso `ulmor bs

    lo`tbe`on e` tao mekrn kmevo tao sauttor. Ao tao` robtorkton k`n tabs tblo B u`norsteen takt

    ao nbn `et akvo k`y sorbeus werg k`n e`fy wk`ton te ifbig k pbituro eh ablsofh e` tao purpforbno. Ye B fot abl akvo tabs pbituros ifbigon wbta tao purpfo rbno. Ao tak`gon lo k`n tefn lo takt

    suia voabifos kro `et taoro b` tao ieu`try ao iklo hrel. Ye B ksgon abl wabia ieu`try takt

    wks k`n ao skbn bt wks Fe`ne` k`n taoro bh yeu akn k rbno fbgo takt tao` tao 'cerks' weufn tkgo

    pbituros eh tao letriyifo. Ao weufn toff tao "hbrk`cbs" kmeut tabs e`o mob`c abs ew` k`n takt taoy

    weufn mo vory b`toroston. Ao tao` wo`t mkig te cottb`c abs lkree` lkab`nrk sonk` takt wks

    cottb`c hbxon kt tao knjkio`t waoof peb`t stero. B teeg tabs eppretu`bty te pkig, puffon tao sauttor

    new` k`n tefn tao `oxt saep porse` takt B woro fokvb`c. B lkno k ikff te JM kfse fottb`c abl

    g`ew, se takt ao hoofs rbcat k`n g`ews wakt akppo`on e` tao ckrkco b` abs kmso`io. B cet tao

    porlbssbe` k`n ao skbn takt ao weufn mo rotur`b`c b` selotblo. B tefn abl kmeut tao akfh sauttork`n kmeut toffb`c tao waoof peb`t cuy, k`n tao` foht her @BN. )

    Nkto7==`n Jufy =4;9

    Nky7Le`nky

    Ovo`t tblo7kreu`n ;=:44pl

    Feiktbe 7 Ckrkco

    Kiters7Gkrk`, JM, Lugatkr k`n Yktbsa

    ( B rokiaon tao ckrkco takt nky khtor ktto`nb`c K`k`n's sossbe` waoro ao olpaksbzon takt wo

    lust ie`io`trkto e` ta