eu procurement for non procurement professionals
TRANSCRIPT
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 2
Introductions
Introductions
Who?
What?
EU tendering experience?
Expectations from the day?
Housekeeping
Timescales
Information packs
Themis
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 3
Programme
Introduction to sources of law Reasons why we have them
Treaty Principles
Key risks
Specifications
Selection of quotations/suppliers
Assessing the bid
Frameworks
How do we communicate with suppliers
Remedies – what happens when suppliers challenge?
New Directives
Questions and answers
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 4
Setting the scene
Current climate
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 6
Sources of Law - Hierarchy
Treaty Principles
EU Directives
UK legislation
Courts will review cases
under the UK legislation
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 7
What are the ‘EU’ rules?
Principles and detailed procedures to be applied by ‘contracting authorities’
(e.g. local government) and certain ‘utilities’ such as transport companies
Reflecting the risk that such companies might favour national/local suppliers
in their procurement
Such preferences breach the EU Treaty obligations of free movement of
goods, services, people and capital (‘the four freedoms’)
EU Directives set out the procedures and set the framework of the rules,
legislation implemented the UK, courts will review the legislation, court
cases and Treaty principles
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 8
Aims and Principles
The EU Directive and the Treaty aim to open up supplier opportunities
Principles (often applied by the courts)
Equal treatment
Non-discrimination
Mutual recognition
Proportionality
Transparency
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 9
Requirement for competition
Importance of competition
Limited scope for no competition
Who makes this decision?
Who can take part?
What must we consider for less regulated procurement?
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 11
Financial thresholds 2014-2015
What are the EU thresholds and why do you need to know?
How do they work?
Supplies and services
£172,514 - Public Sector
£345,028 - Utilities
Works
£4,322,012
Changed 1st January 2014
Every 2 years
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 12
Valuing the requirement
How do we determine the value of a contract?
The requirement not the contract
Lots and options
Aggregation
Extension of contracts
Frameworks
How much discretion do we have?
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 14
Definition
What is a Specification ?
A specification is the key part of the Tender documentation, it should be
clear, accurate, and give a complete description of the supplies, services or
works required.
The Specification defines the requirements to fulfil the contract.
A poor description of the requirement may mean that the product or service
is not delivered to the standards required, and later changes to the
requirements may result in a ‘material change’ and abortive costs.
Preparing a specification requires in-depth research and accuracy.
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 15
Pre-market engagement
Research the market by talking to suppliers, other purchasers, industry
associations, etc. to identify possible solutions, indicative costs and delivery
time-scales
Look for diversity and Innervation from possible new entrants
New Directive now provides for Pre-market engagement.
Be mindful of issues regarding discrimination
Use of Prior Information Notice – manage risk
Identify the scope of the contract and the range of goods, services or works
that the supplier will be asked to deliver
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 16
Stakeholder Engagement
Who should produce the specification ?
Procurement ?
The end user / stakeholder ?
The persons who knows the most about the needed commodity or service
Ensure that there is a clear understanding of what is required.
If producing a specification for another party, identify and agree the
stakeholders requirements and again, ensure that they are fully understood
May work with the market
conflicts of interest
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 17
Specifications and Standards
Technical specification must not lead to discrimination
Where relevant EU standard exists, must refer to it or to
performance/functional specification – cannot mandate the standard
Bespoke specifications must not be discriminatory
• E.G Built around a particular supplier’s approach
Trade names can only be used where absolutely necessary, and
accompanied by the words ‘or equivalent’
The contract notice must contain the scope of the notice and this will often
necessitate understanding the specification
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 19
Selection criteria principles
Selection criteria
To assess supplier capacity not the offer it might make
Information usually obtained using PQQ
Disclosure of criteria
All suppliers assessed equally
How should the criteria be set out?
Relevant to the contract
Proportionate
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 20
Award criteria
The evaluation criteria that will be used to assess the bids should be
developed at the same time as the specification. The evaluation criteria
must link to the subject matter of the contract.
Therefore the specification must be correct, if not the criteria will be flawed
resulting in deficient outcomes
Can not have random criteria it must be relevant, quantifiably measurable,
proportionate, linked to the specification.
If the bid received does not meet the specification it can not be accepted –
even if it offers great innovation and VFM
Post tender negotiation?
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 21
Award criteria principles
Applied to tenders and any subsequent negotiations – Procurement
responsible?
Most economically advantageous tender (MEAT) or lowest price
Criteria must be
Relevant to the contract
Measureable
Assessed professionally
Assessed equally
Disclosed to suppliers before
they tender
West Coast Trains – lessons learnt?
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 22
The distinction between selection and award criteria
Supplier’s capacity v supplier’s offer
Why it matters
Who does what in the tender?
Timescales for the competitive process
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 24
What are frameworks?
A framework is a form of ‘quasi-contract’ which is ‘awarded’ in the same way
as a ‘proper’ contract
Are not a supply contract, a works contract or a service contract in
themselves
Can be between one or more contracting authority or entity and one or more
economic operators
Which establish the terms (in particular the terms as to price and where
appropriate, quality)
Under which the economic operator will enter into one or more contracts
with an authority in the period during which the framework agreement
applies
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 25
Who can use a framework?
Transparency requires disclosure of the contracting authority or authorities
that may use the framework
At least generic reference (provided adequately detailed e.g. updated list of
central government departments as shown in a maintained list)
To allow immediate identification of user authorities
If users known they should be disclosed
Note need to identify expected maximum expenditure under the framework
in the notice
See OGC PPN 15-10
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 26
Key rules
Framework duration limited to 4 years normally
“save in exceptional circumstances, in particular circumstances relating
to the subject of the framework agreement” (Reg 19(10))
Minimum 3 providers – multi supplier framework
Where 3 or more meet selection/award requirements (Regulation 19 (6))
Prohibition of ‘improper use’ and use of framework in such a way to ‘hinder,
prevent, limit or distort competition’
Translation: “anything we have not thought about that the courts might think
is a breach of the rules is also forbidden”?
E.g. a framework which effectively allows single tender purchase from a
multi-supplier framework based on preference or non-objective criteria
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 27
Awarding contract under framework agreements
Where framework includes sufficient information (single supplier and some
multi supplier)
By applying the terms in the framework
Possible methods of awarding the contract:
“Cascade” (ranking)
Virtual catalogue
Rotation?
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 28
Awarding contract under framework agreements
Where framework does not include sufficient information to determine the
winning supplier the contract should be awarded by ‘mini competition’
All capable providers invited
Framework documents should make it clear which firms are qualified for
which type of order
Bids in writing including electronic methods (no explicit timescales)
Bids must not be opened until all received (no faxed tenders)
Contract must be awarded on the basis of application of the criteria set out
in the contract documents based on those in framework agreement.
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 30
Supplier notification
Notification at selection stage
Pre-qualification
Non-compliant bids
Award decision notification to tenderers and concerned candidates (those
not already notified)
Standstill (cooling off) period of 10 or 15 days
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 31
Supplier notification
How much information is enough and how should we respond to debriefing
requests? Who would deal with this?
Mermec UK v Network Rail Infrastructure
How are your comments useful?
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 33
Deciding not to hold a call for competition
When can we directly award contracts?
Extending contracts – what does this mean?
How much scope do we have to change contracts?
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 34
Changes to contracts post award
Applies where a contract has been changed to such an extent that a new
contract arises – from pressetext case
Risk of ineffectiveness arises from the failure to advertise this “new”
contract
New directive makes clear the indicators in that case and provides some
comfort as to changes that would not lead to a new contract arising
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 35
When does modification lead to new contract?
Modification is substantial where it renders the agreement materially
different from the original
New conditions would have allowed for selection of different candidates
or acceptance of different offer or would have attracted additional
participants
The modification changes the economic balance in favour of the
contractor
The modification extends the scope considerably
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 37
How does a legal challenge arise?
Any decision can be challenged by supplier with ‘standing’ in the UK courts
In most cases (except for ineffectiveness) supplier must start proceedings
within 30 days from date of knowledge of the breach
i.e. the date on which the supplier first knew or ought to have known
that grounds for proceedings had arisen
Court has discretion to extend up to a total of 3 months from date of
knowledge
Effect of CJEU cases
Challenge often follows supplier notification and largest volume of
complaints about selection and award criteria – West Coast Trains
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 38
Remedies regime
Suspension
Set aside
Damages
Ineffectiveness (for certain breaches)
Civil financial penalties (have to accompany ineffectiveness)
Penalties must be ‘effective, proportionate and dissuasive’
Contract shortening
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 39
Ineffectiveness
Provides for termination of a contract on application by a supplier
Applies only to certain breaches
Illegal direct award of a contract (‘single tender’)
Failure to observe standstill requirements (if accompanied by a
breach of other rules that might damage supplier’ rights)
Illegal award of a contract under a framework
Applies only prospectively – any rights or obligations from the contract prior
to the order unaffected
Ineffectiveness must be accompanied by a ‘civil penalty’ (determined by the
courts - “proportionate and dissuasive”)
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 40
When would the court waive ineffectiveness?
The court would only waive ineffectiveness in exceptional cases
In general the court has a duty to make a contract ineffective if the grounds
arise
There is an exception where ‘overriding reasons in general interest’ require
waiver
However economic reasons would only be accepted in exceptional
circumstances
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 41
When would the court waive ineffectiveness?
Specifically not allowed would be costs of:
Delay
New procedures
A change in supplier
Any legal obligations on the purchaser
Even where ineffectiveness were waived court would still be required to
shorten the contract, impose a civil penalty or both
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 42
Time limits for ineffectiveness
Default is 6 months from award
Can remove threat altogether with a Voluntary Ex Ante Transparency
(VEAT) notice after 10 days from date of publication (for direct award)
30 days from publication of contract award notice (for direct award)
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 44
Part B Services
Abolition of Part B services
No longer two separate ‘types’ of service
Residual services to fall under full coverage of the directives
Majority now have cross- border interest
Certain exemptions remain
Recognition that some services will require national delivery
E.g. Health and Social care
Specific rules surround their award
Specific thresholds for these categories - €750,000
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 45
Contracting Authorities ‘encouraged’ to break high value contracts (>
€500,000) into lots
Where not divided into lots – justification to be given in notice
Turnover requirements explicitly limited to 2x contract value
Proportionality
Exception for duly justified cases relating to special risks
Must accept self-declarations of status relating to exclusions and
financial/technical position at the time of making a request to participate or
submitting a tender
Increase support for involvement of SME’s
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 46
Changes
More relaxed view of justifications for competitive dialogue and competitive
negotiated procedures
Innovation Partnerships – phased approach to buying product
developments
Shorter minimum timescales
Sub-central bodies able to use the Prior Information Notice as a call for
competition
Abnormally low tenders defined and obligation to exclude tender if low due
to non-compliance with EU law (social, environmental etc.)
Life cycle costs can include environmental impact of product creation
provided it can be monetised and monitored
Separate Directive on works and services concessions
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 47
Clarifications
Pre-market/Pre-procurement engagement expressly provided for- subject to
protection of competition
Award criteria can include whole lifecycle costs and the merits of staff
assigned to the contract (experience issue)
Exclusion and selection criteria clarified
Evidence of poor past experience as an exclusion ground
Material Change defined
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 49
Achilles EU Team
Liz Wilson-Lamb EU Services Manager
Debbie Metcalfe EU Procurement Advisor and Trainer
Kate Pucci EU Procurement Advisor and Trainer
Emily Strange THEMiS Product Manager
Daniel Bremner Sector Account Manager
Sally Griffin Sector Account Manager
Jayne Wellman Administrator
Associates
Professor Sue Arrowsmith Legal Expert
Susie Smith Lawyer and Consultant
Steve Kay EU Advisor
© 2013 Achilles Group Limited Confidential 50
Thank you.
Achilles.com/LinkedIn Twitter.com/Achillesltd
www.achilles.com
Contact details:
T: +44 (0)1235 838115
Achilles Information Limited