evaluation of a novel pcr technology for the ... c9orf72 - poster (2).pdf · report accurate size...

1
SUMMARY • A (G 4 C 2 ) n hexanucleotide repeat expansion in the noncoding region of the C9orf72 gene represents the first genetic link between amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) and frontotemporal dementia (FTD). We developed highly sensitive and robust, single-tube, 3-primer C9orf72 PCR reagents that can flag all expanded samples irrespective of length and provide accurate sizing up to ~145 repeat units using capillary electrophoresis. • A gene-specific, 2-primer configuration of this PCR can detect low-level mosaicism and reproducibly generate products with up to ~800 repeats from expanded samples. Assay performance was evaluated across two sites including Asuragen, Inc. and the University of Pennsylvania. EVALUATION OF A NOVEL PCR TECHNOLOGY FOR THE QUANTIFICATION OF C9orf72 HEXANUCLEOTIDE REPEAT EXPANSIONS Eran Bram 1 , Kristen Culp 1 , Julie Thibert 1 , Nathan Nevitt 1 , Kimberly Nicholson 1 , Jon Kemppainen 1 , EunRan Suh 2 , Kaitlyn Grando 2 , Vivianna M Van Deerlin 2 and Gary J Latham 1 1 Asuragen, Inc., Austin, TX USA; 2 Dept. of Pathology and Lab Medicine, Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA USA INTRODUCTION Hexanucleotide repeat expansions in the noncoding region of the C9orf72 gene are present in ~7% of all clinical cases of ALS and FTD. These expansions are of considerable interest for both clinical research and potential diagnostic and screening applications. The GC-rich repeat element is recalcitrant to PCR and consequently, a combination of multiple PCR assays and Southern blot (SB) are used to profile this region. Here we describe the performance of an innovative PCR technology with capabilities that exceed current amplification assays. METHODS PCR reagents were optimized for the amplification of G 4 C 2 hexanucleotide repeats (AmplideX ® PCR/CE C9orf72 Kit, Asuragen, Inc.). Amplicons were sized using capillary electrophoresis (CE) on a 3500xL/3130xL Genetic Analyzer (Thermo Fisher) or agarose gel electrophoresis (AGE; Lonza). A total of 101 genomic DNA samples from the Coriell ALS sample repository (30 unexpanded and 71 expanded) were assessed at Asuragen. The assay was also independently evaluated at the University of Pennsylvania (UPenn) using a subset of these samples as well as residual patient specimens. RESULTS Across both lab sites, repeat values were resolved consistent with previous annotations 1 for all unexpanded samples and up to 145 repeats for all expanded samples (limited only by the sizing range of CE). Expanded samples, irrespective of repeat size, were categorically identified in each case within the same PCR reaction. AGE further confirmed these expansions, resolving high molecular weight products consistent with up to ~800 repeats along with extensive size mosaicism. Heterogeneity in expanded repeat lengths could be detected below a 5% mass fraction. The assay was robust over a 2-log range of inputs and provided clear indication when 3’ indels were present. References 1. Rutherford N.J., et al., C9orf72 hexanucleotide repeat expansions in patients with ALS from the Coriell Cell Repository. Neurology, 2012. 31;79(5):482-3. 2. Rollinson S., et al., A small deletion in C9orf72 hides a proportion of expansion carriers in FTLD, Neurobiol Aging. 2015 Mar; 36(3): 1601.e1–1601.e5. CONCLUSIONS • This novel PCR technology can amplify repeat expansions that are more than 10-fold larger than conventional assays. A 3-primer RP-PCR design provides robust performance, high sensitivity and accuracy up to 145 repeats on CE, and clear indication of both size mosaicism and 3’ sequence variations. • A gene-specific, 2-primer PCR format identified known C9orf72-expanded samples and produced amplicons consistent with up to at least ~800 hexanucleotide repeats. • This simple, single-tube PCR technology has potential to advance clinical research and emerging diagnostic, therapeutic, and screening applications for the C9orf72 marker in the context of ALS, FTD and other age-onset neurodegenerative disorders. Figure 2. Assay design enables complementary repeat sizing methods (A) A mix of cell-line DNA can be used to generate a size calibration curve (inset) that converts size (in bp) to repeat number and corrects for differential mobility of GC-rich DNA on CE. (B) Sizing by direct counting of repeat peaks. (C) An Excel macro was developed to support automation of the calibration curve approach, producing a genotype report (D). Figure 3. Performance characteristics of the AmplideX PCR/CE C9orf72 Kit. (A) Accurate sizing of up to 145 repeats (RP) with a distinct RP profile for expanded samples, which enables zygosity resolution (B). (C) Unique low-level minor alleles are detected in the 2-primer assay configuration on both CE and AGE (inset), consistent with as low as 5% mass fraction in the background of 95% normal alleles (D). (E) PCR demonstrates robust performance across a 200-fold gDNA input range down to 1 ng/reaction and also provides clear indication for the presence of 3’ indels 2 in a representative patient sample (F). Figure 4. A 2-site comparison of the 2-primer C9orf72 PCR/AGE assay for detection of expanded alleles of up to ~800 repeats. A modified PCR profile was used for PCR amplification of large repeat fragments (up to ~5kb) in Coriell ALS gDNA samples using Asurgen’s C9orf72 PCR reagents, at both Asuragen (A) and UPenn (B). Note several samples carry multiple bands at variable intensities. ND09188 is a normal (non-expanded) sample. Table 1. Genotyping of 101 Coriell NINDS ALS samples. (A) Genotype concordance across 101 samples from the Coriell NINDS ALS collection. (B) Full genotype (in RP units) for tested 101 samples. Samples in bold were genotyped at both Asuragen and UPenn. Samples with + had a 3’-deletion in expanded alleles. Last 6 samples lack reference genotype for normal allele. Figure 1. A novel PCR for the amplification of a hexanucleotide (G 4 C 2 ) n repeat element in the C9orf72 gene. (A) Schematic representation of the C9orf72 gene structure denoting predicted 11 exons (boxes) and location of the intronic hexanucleotide repeat expansion (vertical lines). (B) A 2-primer (left) or 3-primer (right) FAM-labeled PCR design, with representative CE profiles with either gene-specific (GS) peaks only or GS peaks overlaid with a consistent repeat (RP) profile (Coriell sample ND06769). The 2-primer PCR products can also be resolved by AGE (left inset). (C) A modular design can accommodate both PCR/CE and PCR/ AGE assays, requiring ~6 hr or ~9.5 hr to complete, respectively, with less than 1.5 hours of hands-on-time per 24 sample batch. (D) A simpler and more informative C9orf72 sample analysis workflow incorporating PCR technology. Research Use Only – Not For Use In Diagnostic Procedures Preliminary research data. The full performance characteristics of this assay have not yet been established. Presented at ICFTD 2016 1A 1B 1C 2A gDNA Isolation PCR Prep Step PCR CE/AGE Prep CE/AGE Run Data Analysis Pre-process 30 mins Time 3.5/5 hrs 30 mins 1/3 hrs 30 mins AmplideX® C9orf72 Workflow AmplideX C9orf72 Report accurate size Report expansion; Perform Southern blot if needed < 145 repeats > 145 repeats Analyze results Report accurate size Report expansion; Perform Southern blot if needed < 30 repeats > 30 repeats All Samples All Samples RP PCR Amplicon length PCR Traditional Workflow* 2B 2D 2C 3B 3D 3F 3A 4A A B 3C 4B 3E Reported genotype 1 Asuragen PCR Normal (0-19) Intermediate (20-29) Expansion (>30) Normal (0-19) 24 0 0 Intermediate (20-29) 0 6 0 Expansion (>30) 0 0 71 Sample ID Allele 1 Allele 2 Category ND07738 2 2 Normal ND07995 2 2 Normal ND08470 2 2 Normal ND08987 2 2 Normal ND09487 2 4 Normal ND10209 2 4 Normal ND04055 2 5 Normal ND06176 2 5 Normal ND10767 2 6 Normal ND06186 2 7 Normal ND10802 2 7 Normal ND04051 2 8 Normal ND12094 2 11 Normal ND10710 2 16 Normal ND09191 2 19 Normal ND04052 4 5 Normal ND07475 5 6 Normal ND09694 5 7 Normal ND10937 5 10 Normal ND06177 6 8 Normal ND08619 7 7 Normal ND14685 7 13 Normal ND12120 8 12 Normal ND09188 12 14 Normal ND12070 2 21 Intermediate ND06593 2 24 Intermediate ND11382 2 25 Intermediate ND09180 11 24 Intermediate ND12028 11 28 Intermediate ND10518 14 23 Intermediate +ND07489 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND07669 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND09204 2 Expanded repeat Expanded +ND09375 2 Expanded repeat Expanded +ND09407 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND09492 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND09508 2 Expanded repeat Expanded +ND09576 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND09607 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND09996 2 Expanded repeat Expanded +ND10284 2 Expanded repeat Expanded +ND10773 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND10905 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND11081 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND11252 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND11548 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND11554 2 Expanded repeat Expanded +ND11583 2 Expanded repeat Expanded +ND11668 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND11749 2 Expanded repeat Expanded +ND11755 2 Expanded repeat Expanded Sample ID Allele 1 Allele 2 Category ND11933 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND12099 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND12100 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND12277 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND12402 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND12438 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND12455 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND12754 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND12909 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND13216 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND13682 2 Expanded repeat Expanded +ND13803 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND13939 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND14186 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND14442 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND14596 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND14954 2 Expanded repeat Expanded +ND08957 4 Expanded repeat Expanded +ND10023 5 Expanded repeat Expanded ND10689 5 Expanded repeat Expanded ND10808 5 Expanded repeat (minor allele @ 86) Expanded ND11680 5 Expanded repeat Expanded ND11917 5 Expanded repeat Expanded +ND12200 5 Expanded repeat Expanded +ND13828 5 Expanded repeat Expanded ND13944 5 Expanded repeat Expanded +ND14339 5 Expanded repeat Expanded ND14911 5 Expanded repeat Expanded +ND08078 6 Expanded repeat Expanded ND12089 6 Expanded repeat Expanded ND12161 6 Expanded repeat Expanded +ND12199 6 Expanded repeat (minor allele @ 46) Expanded ND12904 6 Expanded repeat Expanded ND12102 7 Expanded repeat Expanded ND06751 8 Expanded repeat Expanded ND10101 8 Expanded repeat Expanded +ND11374 8 Expanded repeat Expanded ND11494 8 Expanded repeat Expanded ND11836 8 Expanded repeat Expanded ND10966 9 Expanded repeat Expanded ND10973 9 Expanded repeat Expanded ND09373 10 Expanded repeat Expanded ND10000 10 Expanded repeat Expanded ND09438 11 Expanded repeat Expanded ND06769 13 Expanded repeat Expanded ND08544/A 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND08544/B 2 Expanded repeat Expanded +ND15362 8 Expanded repeat Expanded +ND15686 2 Expanded repeat Expanded ND15814 2 Expanded repeat Expanded +ND20142 2 Expanded repeat Expanded 1D

Upload: others

Post on 19-Mar-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: EVALUATION OF A NOVEL PCR TECHNOLOGY FOR THE ... C9ORF72 - Poster (2).pdf · Report accurate size Report expansion; Perform Southern blot if needed < 145 repeats > 145 repeats

SUMMARY• A (G4C2)n hexanucleotide repeat expansion in the noncoding region of the C9orf72 gene

represents the first genetic link between amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) and frontotemporal dementia (FTD).

• We developed highly sensitive and robust, single-tube, 3-primer C9orf72 PCR reagents that can flag all expanded samples irrespective of length and provide accurate sizing up to ~145 repeat units using capillary electrophoresis.

• A gene-specific, 2-primer configuration of this PCR can detect low-level mosaicism and reproducibly generate products with up to ~800 repeats from expanded samples.

• Assay performance was evaluated across two sites including Asuragen, Inc. and the University of Pennsylvania.

EVALUATION OF A NOVEL PCR TECHNOLOGY FOR THE QUANTIFICATION OF C9orf72 HEXANUCLEOTIDE REPEAT EXPANSIONSEran Bram1, Kristen Culp1, Julie Thibert1, Nathan Nevitt1, Kimberly Nicholson1, Jon Kemppainen1, EunRan Suh2, Kaitlyn Grando2, Vivianna M Van Deerlin2 and Gary J Latham1

1Asuragen, Inc., Austin, TX USA; 2Dept. of Pathology and Lab Medicine, Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA USA

INTRODUCTIONHexanucleotide repeat expansions in the noncoding region of the C9orf72 gene are present in ~7% of all clinical cases of ALS and FTD. These expansions are of considerable interest for both clinical research and potential diagnostic and screening applications. The GC-rich repeat element is recalcitrant to PCR and consequently, a combination of multiple PCR assays and Southern blot (SB) are used to profile this region. Here we describe the performance of an innovative PCR technology with capabilities that exceed current amplification assays.

METHODSPCR reagents were optimized for the amplification of G4C2 hexanucleotide repeats (AmplideX® PCR/CE C9orf72 Kit, Asuragen, Inc.). Amplicons were sized using capillary electrophoresis (CE) on a 3500xL/3130xL Genetic Analyzer (Thermo Fisher) or agarose gel electrophoresis (AGE; Lonza). A total of 101 genomic DNA samples from the Coriell ALS sample repository (30 unexpanded and 71 expanded) were assessed at Asuragen. The assay was also independently evaluated at the University of Pennsylvania (UPenn) using a subset of these samples as well as residual patient specimens.

RESULTSAcross both lab sites, repeat values were resolved consistent with previous annotations1 for all unexpanded samples and up to 145 repeats for all expanded samples (limited only by the sizing range of CE). Expanded samples, irrespective of repeat size, were categorically identified in each case within the same PCR reaction. AGE further confirmed these expansions, resolving high molecular weight products consistent with up to ~800 repeats along with extensive size mosaicism. Heterogeneity in expanded repeat lengths could be detected below a 5% mass fraction. The assay was robust over a 2-log range of inputs and provided clear indication when 3’ indels were present.

References1. Rutherford N.J., et al., C9orf72 hexanucleotide repeat expansions in patients with ALS from the Coriell Cell Repository. Neurology, 2012. 31;79(5):482-3. 2. Rollinson S., et al., A small deletion in C9orf72 hides a proportion of expansion carriers in FTLD, Neurobiol Aging. 2015 Mar; 36(3): 1601.e1–1601.e5.

CONCLUSIONS• This novel PCR technology can amplify repeat expansions that are more than 10-fold larger

than conventional assays.• A 3-primer RP-PCR design provides robust performance, high sensitivity and accuracy up to

145 repeats on CE, and clear indication of both size mosaicism and 3’ sequence variations.• A gene-specific, 2-primer PCR format identified known C9orf72-expanded samples and

produced amplicons consistent with up to at least ~800 hexanucleotide repeats. • This simple, single-tube PCR technology has potential to advance clinical research and

emerging diagnostic, therapeutic, and screening applications for the C9orf72 marker in the context of ALS, FTD and other age-onset neurodegenerative disorders.

Figure 2. Assay design enables complementary repeat sizing methods (A) A mix of cell-line DNA can be used to generate a size calibration curve (inset) that converts size (in bp) to repeat number and corrects for differential mobility of GC-rich DNA on CE. (B) Sizing by direct counting of repeat peaks. (C) An Excel macro was developed to support automation of the calibration curve approach, producing a genotype report (D).

Figure 3. Performance characteristics of the AmplideX PCR/CE C9orf72 Kit. (A) Accurate sizing of up to 145 repeats (RP) with a distinct RP profile for expanded samples, which enables zygosity resolution (B). (C) Unique low-level minor alleles are detected in the 2-primer assay configuration on both CE and AGE (inset), consistent with as low as 5% mass fraction in the background of 95% normal alleles (D). (E) PCR demonstrates robust performance across a 200-fold gDNA input range down to 1 ng/reaction and also provides clear indication for the presence of 3’ indels2 in a representative patient sample (F).

Figure 4. A 2-site comparison of the 2-primer C9orf72 PCR/AGE assay for detection of expanded alleles of up to ~800 repeats. A modified PCR profile was used for PCR amplification of large repeat fragments (up to ~5kb) in Coriell ALS gDNA samples using Asurgen’s C9orf72 PCR reagents, at both Asuragen (A) and UPenn (B). Note several samples carry multiple bands at variable intensities. ND09188 is a normal (non-expanded) sample.

Table 1. Genotyping of 101 Coriell NINDS ALS samples. (A) Genotype concordance across 101 samples from the Coriell NINDS ALS collection. (B) Full genotype (in RP units) for tested 101 samples. Samples in bold were genotyped at both Asuragen and UPenn. Samples with + had a 3’-deletion in expanded alleles. Last 6 samples lack reference genotype for normal allele.

Figure 1. A novel PCR for the amplification of a hexanucleotide (G4C2)n repeat element in the C9orf72 gene. (A) Schematic representation of the C9orf72 gene structure denoting predicted 11 exons (boxes) and location of the intronic hexanucleotide repeat expansion (vertical lines). (B) A 2-primer (left) or 3-primer (right) FAM-labeled PCR design, with representative CE profiles with either gene-specific (GS) peaks only or GS peaks overlaid with a consistent repeat (RP) profile (Coriell sample ND06769). The 2-primer PCR products can also be resolved by AGE (left inset). (C) A modular design can accommodate both PCR/CE and PCR/AGE assays, requiring ~6 hr or ~9.5 hr to complete, respectively, with less than 1.5 hours of hands-on-time per 24 sample batch. (D) A simpler and more informative C9orf72 sample analysis workflow incorporating PCR technology.

Research Use Only – Not For Use In Diagnostic ProceduresPreliminary research data. The full performance characteristics of this assay have not yet been established.Presented at ICFTD 2016

1A

1B

1C

2A

gDNA Isolation

PCR Prep

Step

PCR

CE/AGE Prep

CE/AGE Run

Data Analysis

Pre-process

30 mins

Time

3.5/5 hrs

30 mins

1/3 hrs

30 mins

AmplideX® C9orf72 Work�ow

AmplideXC9orf72

Report accurate size

Report expansion; Perform Southern blot

if needed

< 145 repeats

> 145 repeats

Analyzeresults

Report accurate size

Report expansion; Perform Southern blot

if needed

< 30 repeats

> 30 repeats

All Samples

All Samples

RP PCR

Ampliconlength PCR

Traditional Work�ow*

2B

2D2C

3B

3D

3F

3A

4A

A

B

3C

4B

3E

Reported genotype1

Asu

rag

en P

CR Normal (0-19) Intermediate (20-29) Expansion (>30)

Normal (0-19) 24 0 0

Intermediate (20-29) 0 6 0

Expansion (>30) 0 0 71

Sample ID Allele 1 Allele 2 CategoryND07738 2 2 NormalND07995 2 2 NormalND08470 2 2 NormalND08987 2 2 NormalND09487 2 4 NormalND10209 2 4 NormalND04055 2 5 NormalND06176 2 5 NormalND10767 2 6 NormalND06186 2 7 NormalND10802 2 7 NormalND04051 2 8 NormalND12094 2 11 NormalND10710 2 16 NormalND09191 2 19 NormalND04052 4 5 NormalND07475 5 6 NormalND09694 5 7 NormalND10937 5 10 NormalND06177 6 8 NormalND08619 7 7 NormalND14685 7 13 NormalND12120 8 12 NormalND09188 12 14 NormalND12070 2 21 IntermediateND06593 2 24 IntermediateND11382 2 25 IntermediateND09180 11 24 IntermediateND12028 11 28 IntermediateND10518 14 23 Intermediate+ND07489 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND07669 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND09204 2 Expanded repeat Expanded+ND09375 2 Expanded repeat Expanded+ND09407 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND09492 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND09508 2 Expanded repeat Expanded

+ND09576 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND09607 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND09996 2 Expanded repeat Expanded

+ND10284 2 Expanded repeat Expanded+ND10773 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND10905 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND11081 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND11252 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND11548 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND11554 2 Expanded repeat Expanded

+ND11583 2 Expanded repeat Expanded+ND11668 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND11749 2 Expanded repeat Expanded+ND11755 2 Expanded repeat Expanded

Sample ID Allele 1 Allele 2 CategoryND11933 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND12099 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND12100 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND12277 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND12402 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND12438 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND12455 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND12754 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND12909 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND13216 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND13682 2 Expanded repeat Expanded

+ND13803 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND13939 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND14186 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND14442 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND14596 2 Expanded repeat ExpandedND14954 2 Expanded repeat Expanded

+ND08957 4 Expanded repeat Expanded+ND10023 5 Expanded repeat ExpandedND10689 5 Expanded repeat ExpandedND10808 5 Expanded repeat (minor allele @ 86) ExpandedND11680 5 Expanded repeat ExpandedND11917 5 Expanded repeat Expanded

+ND12200 5 Expanded repeat Expanded+ND13828 5 Expanded repeat ExpandedND13944 5 Expanded repeat Expanded

+ND14339 5 Expanded repeat ExpandedND14911 5 Expanded repeat Expanded+ND08078 6 Expanded repeat ExpandedND12089 6 Expanded repeat ExpandedND12161 6 Expanded repeat Expanded+ND12199 6 Expanded repeat (minor allele @ 46) ExpandedND12904 6 Expanded repeat ExpandedND12102 7 Expanded repeat ExpandedND06751 8 Expanded repeat ExpandedND10101 8 Expanded repeat Expanded+ND11374 8 Expanded repeat ExpandedND11494 8 Expanded repeat ExpandedND11836 8 Expanded repeat ExpandedND10966 9 Expanded repeat ExpandedND10973 9 Expanded repeat ExpandedND09373 10 Expanded repeat ExpandedND10000 10 Expanded repeat ExpandedND09438 11 Expanded repeat ExpandedND06769 13 Expanded repeat Expanded

ND08544/A 2 Expanded repeat  ExpandedND08544/B 2 Expanded repeat  Expanded+ND15362 8 Expanded repeat  Expanded+ND15686 2 Expanded repeat  ExpandedND15814 2 Expanded repeat  Expanded

+ND20142 2 Expanded repeat  Expanded

1D