exposure0of0fish0in0the0athabasca0and0slave0rivers0to0meta ... · lesions and deformities in fishes...

1
RESEARCH POSTER PRESENTATION DESIGN © 2012 www.PosterPresentations.com Sample Collection: Fish were collected in the summer fall and winter of 2011 and the spring of 2012 from 8 sites along the Athabasca Slave and Peace Rivers. Target sample size for each site was 30 individuals of each of 5 species (Goldeye - Hiodon alosoides, Whitefish - Coregonus clupeaformis, Northern Pike - Esox lucius, Walleye - Sander vitreus, Burbot - Lota lota). A total of 1498 fish were collected during these samplings. Each fish was examined externally and internally. Muscle, liver, bile, and blood plasma samples were taken for further analysis of indicators of condition and health. Introduc4on Metal Site BB Mean ± SE (n) * pvalue GE Mean ± SE (n)* pvalue JF Mean ± SE (n)* pvalue WE Mean ± SE (n)* pvalue WF Mean ±SE (n)* pvalue Hg FMU 540±81 (3) 0.712 1251±252 (11) A 0.678 1416±256 (10) A 0.240 2475±733 (12) A <0.001 514±134 (10) A <0.001 FM 691±162 (2) 1022±95 (20) A 1397±371 (19) A 1309±139 (20) A 179±21 (20) C FC 340±24 (4) 952±102 (19) A 1294±158 (20) A 811±78 (15) B 190±38 (20) C FS 734±114 (8) A 973±125 (20) A 1427±311 (21) X 0.010 1813±264 (20) A 216±32 (18) B FR 839±116 (30) A 1241±188 (12) A 1031±190 (21) A 1399±306 (10) A 353±44 (20) A Se FMU 1848±166 (3) 0.308 3060±340 (11) AB 0.005 1205±106 (13) B <0.001 1717±146 (13) BC <0.001 1612±133 (10) BC <0.001 FM 1476±121 (2) 2397±205 (20) B 843±118 (19) C 1432±137 (20) C 1546±78 (19) C FC 2282±164 (4) 3262±216 (19) AB 1639±105 (20) A 2041±106 (15) AB 1509±105 (20) C FS 1984±201 (8) A 3549±353 (20) A 1879±80 (21) A 2338±108 (20) A 2069±136 (18) AB FR 1806±71 (30) A 4053±456 (12) A 1869±94 (21) A 2303±94 (10) AB 2233±89 (20) A Tl FMU 8.94±0.42 (3) 0.003 11.51±1.50 (11) A 0.234 14.45±2.36 (13) B <0.001 20.94±3.61 (13) C <0.001 6.75±1.51 (10) B <0.001 FM 0.05 (2) 9.26±1.28 (20) A 8.02±1.32 (19) B 19.96±3.10 (20) C 6.32±0.70 (20) B FC 8.88±3.38 (4) 12.04±2.13 (19) A 16.84±2.22 (20) B 37.4±2.00 (15) B 6.85±1.26 (20) B FS 8.43±1.36 (8) B 13.70±1.82 (20) A 32.82±4.00 (21) A 66.16±6.97 (20) A 20.30±2.70 (18) A FR 15.99±1.53 (30) A 15.44±2.98 (12) A 47.72±5.41 (21) A 78.54±7.96 (10) A 17.59±1.19 (20) A V FMU 46.6±2.0 (3) 0.031 22.3±5.4 (11) A 0.141 22.3±4.4 (13) A 0.208 25.3±5.8 (13) A 0.265 35.7±8.0 (10) A 0.096 FM 20.5±2.1 (2) 20.9±3.4 (20) A 16.3±2.8 (19) A 16.8±3.6 (20) A 18.8±3.4 (20) A FC 12.7±3.2 (4) 18.5±3.8 (19) A 23.7±5.1 (20) A 25.5±8.0 (15) A 37.0±5.6 (20) A FS 66.3±16.4 (8) A 35.6±8.7 (20) A 25.0±5.7 (21) A 34.1±6.4 (20) A 40.7±8.4 (18) A FR 28.8±3.6 (30) B 36.0±4.2 (12) A 14.0±4.0 (21) A 17.7±5.7 (10) A 49.2±16.5 (20) A Objec4ves Much of the current open-pit mining activities in the Alberta oilsand are adjacent to the Athabasca River. Contaminants associated with oilsands include metals, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), and naphthenic acids, some of which are persistent, toxic, mutagenic and potentially carcinogenic. Concerns have been expressed about the potential effects of emissions on the environment and human health by communities in the Athabasca River basin as well as by communities in the downstream Slave and Mackenzie river basins. Local communities have also reported an increase in the occurrence of lesions and deformities in fishes which has raised their concerns These concerns have been heightened by uncertainties concerning the origin of contaminants, natural or anthropogenic, and magnitudes of exposure. Methods Conclusions Concentrations of Se were different in summer and fall. The increased concentration in summer could be caused by the influx of contaminants after snow melt. Thallium, but not V or Se appear to biomagnify, since fishes of higher trophic levels have equal or higher concentrations than those at lower trophic levels. V and Tl have been previously associated with discharges from petroleum based activities, including oil sands activities. Greater concentrations of metals along the Slave River are potentially due to upstream activities. Increases in V and Tl at the downstream sites pose interesting questions of bioaccumulation and chemodynamics, further research is planned. Spring sampling has been completed and metals are being quantified to better understand spatial and temporal distribution of their concentrations. Two sites were added downstream of Athabasca Basin for the spring sampling (FF, PP) to better understand metal distribution. Acknowledgements This project would not have been possible without the assistance provided by First Nations and Métis communities of Ft Resolution, Ft Smith, Ft Chipewyan, Ft MacKay and Ft McMurray and by numerous Provincial and Federal agencies. Funding was provided by the Boreal Songbird Initiative (BSI), Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Canada (AANDC) and the Government of the Northwest Territories, which supported sampling in the NWT. Tim Barrett (UNB) provided assistance with statistical analysis. This research was conducted to describe spatial and temporal distributions of metals in tissues of fishes from selected locations along the Athabasca and Slave Rivers. Most of the metals analysed showed little or no location associated variability for the summer and fall samplings. Thallium(Tl), Vanadium(V), Selenium(Se), and Mercury(Hg) did show location associated variability. Se concentrations varied little among sites in summer, but in the fall were greater on the Slave River. A steady increase in the concentration of thallium in fish muscle was noted at sites proceeding down the Athabasca/Slave system. Thallium also showed a relationship between concentration and trophic level as the higher trophic level JF and WE had greater concentrations. Results Summer B. Tendler 1 , E. Ohiozebau ,2 A. Hill 1 , G. Codling 2 , J.P. Giesy 1,3,4 , E. Kelly 5 , P. Hodson 6 , J. Short 7 , P.D. Jones 1,2 1.Toxicology Centre, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Canada 2.School of Environment & Sustainability, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Canada 3. Dept. of Biomedical Veterinary Sciences, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Canada 4. Dept. of Biology and Chemistry, City University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, SAR, China 5. Environment and Natural Resources, Government of the Northwest Territories, Canada 6. Department of Biology, Queens University, Kingston ON, Canada 7. DJWS Consul.ng LLC, Juneau AK, USA Exposure of Fish in the Athabasca and Slave Rivers to Metals Poten4ally Derived from Oilsands Opera4ons Quantification of Metals: Approximately 0.1 g of dry muscle was added to a 15 mL Teflon vial and digested in concentrated nitric acid (69%) and hydrogen peroxide (30%). Digests were evaporated until dry at approximately 70ᴼC. 5 mL of 2% nitric acid was added to dried digest which was then filtered (0.45 micrometre pore size) and transferred into 8 mL HDPE vial for storage and analysis. Concentrations of 20 metals were measured by ICP-MS. Methods Pike or Jackfish (Esox lucius) JF Loche Mariah, Burbot (Lota lota) BB Goldeye (Hiodon alosoides) GE Whitefish (Coregonus clupeaformis) WF Walleye or Pickeral (Sander vitreus) WE Figure 3. Concentrations of metals by species and site. Summary statistics (means, SE = standard error of the mean; n = sample size). Sites sharing a letter (A,B,C), within a metal/species grouping are not significantly different at α = 0.05 (Tukey family-wise error rate for multiple comparisons). Hypothesis tests conducted using ANOVA after data transformation (rank, log base 10, or power). Hg analyses conducted using ANCOVA with log base 10 transformed data (response and covariate) using length or weight as a covariate). X = significant interaction in ANCOVA (p = 0.05). Text in red addresses to subjectively assess trends across species. Fall BB GE JF WE WF decrease downriver Hg increase at FS Se increase at FR Tl increase downriver V increase at FS, not high upstream Athabasca Results Figure 1. Metal Concentration trends for metals of interest. Figure 2. Metal concentrations (V, Tl, Se) for all Species by Season. Concentrations of Vanadium (V) were significantly (p<0.05) greater at Fort Resolution and Fort Smith on the Slave River than those in fish from sites on the Athabasca River. Concentrations of Selenium (Se) varied little among locations during summer. During the fall, selenium concentrations were greater in Slave River than Athabasca River. Concentrations of Mercury (Hg) were greater in JF and WE on the Slave River. Results

Upload: hoangnguyet

Post on 27-Jul-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

QUICK DESIGN GUIDE (--THIS SECTION DOES NOT PRINT--)

This PowerPoint 2007 template produces a 36”x72” professional poster. It will save you valuable time placing titles, subtitles, text, and graphics. Use it to create your presentation. Then send it to PosterPresentations.com for premium quality, same day affordable printing. We provide a series of online tutorials that will guide you through the poster design process and answer your poster production questions. View our online tutorials at: http://bit.ly/Poster_creation_help (copy and paste the link into your web browser). For assistance and to order your printed poster call PosterPresentations.com at 1.866.649.3004

Object Placeholders

Use the placeholders provided below to add new elements to your poster: Drag a placeholder onto the poster area, size it, and click it to edit. Section Header placeholder Use section headers to separate topics or concepts within your presentation. Text placeholder Move this preformatted text placeholder to the poster to add a new body of text. Picture placeholder Move this graphic placeholder onto your poster, size it first, and then click it to add a picture to the poster.

RESEARCH POSTER PRESENTATION DESIGN © 2012

www.PosterPresentations.com

QUICK TIPS (--THIS SECTION DOES NOT PRINT--)

This PowerPoint template requires basic PowerPoint (version 2007 or newer) skills. Below is a list of commonly asked questions specific to this template. If you are using an older version of PowerPoint some template features may not work properly.

Using the template

Verifying the quality of your graphics Go to the VIEW menu and click on ZOOM to set your preferred magnification. This template is at 50% the size of the final poster. All text and graphics will be printed at 200% their size. To see what your poster will look like when printed, set the zoom to 200% and evaluate the quality of all your graphics before you submit your poster for printing. Using the placeholders To add text to this template click inside a placeholder and type in or paste your text. To move a placeholder, click on it once (to select it), place your cursor on its frame and your cursor will change to this symbol: Then, click once and drag it to its new location where you can resize it as needed. Additional placeholders can be found on the left side of this template. Modifying the layout This template has four different column layouts. Right-click your mouse on the background and click on “Layout” to see the layout options. The columns in the provided layouts are fixed and cannot be moved but advanced users can modify any layout by going to VIEW and then SLIDE MASTER. Importing text and graphics from external sources TEXT: Paste or type your text into a pre-existing placeholder or drag in a new placeholder from the left side of the template. Move it anywhere as needed. PHOTOS: Drag in a picture placeholder, size it first, click in it and insert a photo from the menu. TABLES: You can copy and paste a table from an external document onto this poster template. To make the text fit better in the cells of an imported table, right-click on the table, click FORMAT SHAPE then click on TEXT BOX and change the INTERNAL MARGIN values to 0.25 Modifying the color scheme To change the color scheme of this template go to the “Design” menu and click on “Colors”. You can choose from the provide color combinations or you can create your own.

©  2012  PosterPresenta.ons.com          2117  Fourth  Street  ,  Unit  C          Berkeley    CA    94710          [email protected]  

Student discounts are available on our Facebook page. Go to PosterPresentations.com and click on the FB icon.

Sample Collection: • Fish were collected in the summer fall and winter of 2011 and the spring of 2012 from 8 sites along the Athabasca Slave and Peace Rivers. • Target sample size for each site was 30 individuals of each of 5 species (Goldeye - Hiodon alosoides, Whitefish - Coregonus clupeaformis, Northern Pike - Esox lucius, Walleye - Sander vitreus, Burbot - Lota lota). • A total of 1498 fish were collected during these samplings. • Each fish was examined externally and internally. • Muscle, liver, bile, and blood plasma samples were taken for further analysis of indicators of condition and health.

Introduc4on  Metal   Site   BB  Mean  ±  SE  (n)  *   p-­‐value   GE    Mean  ±  SE  (n)*   p-­‐value   JF    Mean  ±  SE  (n)*   p-­‐value   WE    Mean  ±  SE  (n)*   p-­‐value   WF    Mean  ±SE  (n)*   p-­‐value  Hg   FMU   540±81  (3)     0.712   1251±252  (11)  A   0.678   1416±256  (10)  A   0.240   2475±733  (12)  A   <0.001   514±134  (10)  A   <0.001  

FM   691±162  (2)     1022±95  (20)  A   1397±371  (19)  A   1309±139  (20)  A   179±21  (20)  C  FC   340±24  (4)     952±102  (19)  A   1294±158  (20)  A   811±78  (15)  B   190±38  (20)  C  FS   734±114  (8)  A   973±125  (20)  A   1427±311  (21)  X   0.010   1813±264  (20)  A   216±32  (18)  B  FR   839±116  (30)  A   1241±188  (12)  A   1031±190  (21)  A   1399±306  (10)  A   353±44  (20)  A  

Se   FMU   1848±166  (3)     0.308   3060±340  (11)  AB   0.005   1205±106  (13)  B   <0.001   1717±146  (13)  BC   <0.001   1612±133  (10)  BC   <0.001  FM   1476±121  (2)     2397±205  (20)  B   843±118  (19)  C   1432±137  (20)  C   1546±78  (19)  C  FC   2282±164  (4)     3262±216  (19)  AB   1639±105  (20)  A   2041±106  (15)  AB   1509±105  (20)  C  FS   1984±201  (8)  A   3549±353  (20)  A   1879±80  (21)  A   2338±108  (20)  A   2069±136  (18)  AB  FR   1806±71  (30)  A   4053±456  (12)  A   1869±94  (21)  A   2303±94  (10)  AB   2233±89  (20)  A  

Tl   FMU   8.94±0.42  (3)     0.003   11.51±1.50  (11)  A   0.234   14.45±2.36  (13)  B   <0.001   20.94±3.61  (13)  C   <0.001   6.75±1.51  (10)  B   <0.001  FM   0.05  (2)     9.26±1.28  (20)  A   8.02±1.32  (19)  B   19.96±3.10  (20)  C   6.32±0.70  (20)  B  FC   8.88±3.38  (4)     12.04±2.13  (19)  A   16.84±2.22  (20)  B   37.4±2.00  (15)  B   6.85±1.26  (20)  B  FS   8.43±1.36  (8)  B   13.70±1.82  (20)  A   32.82±4.00  (21)  A   66.16±6.97  (20)  A   20.30±2.70  (18)  A  FR   15.99±1.53  (30)  A   15.44±2.98  (12)  A   47.72±5.41  (21)  A   78.54±7.96  (10)  A   17.59±1.19  (20)  A  

V   FMU   46.6±2.0  (3)     0.031   22.3±5.4  (11)  A   0.141   22.3±4.4  (13)  A   0.208   25.3±5.8  (13)  A   0.265   35.7±8.0  (10)  A   0.096  FM   20.5±2.1  (2)     20.9±3.4  (20)  A   16.3±2.8  (19)  A   16.8±3.6  (20)  A   18.8±3.4  (20)  A  FC   12.7±3.2  (4)     18.5±3.8  (19)  A   23.7±5.1  (20)  A   25.5±8.0  (15)  A   37.0±5.6  (20)  A  FS   66.3±16.4  (8)  A   35.6±8.7  (20)  A   25.0±5.7  (21)  A   34.1±6.4  (20)  A   40.7±8.4  (18)  A  FR   28.8±3.6  (30)  B   36.0±4.2  (12)  A   14.0±4.0  (21)  A   17.7±5.7  (10)  A   49.2±16.5  (20)  A  

Objec4ves  

• Much of the current open-pit mining activities in the Alberta oilsand are adjacent to the Athabasca River. •  Contaminants associated with oilsands include metals, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), and naphthenic acids, some of which are persistent, toxic, mutagenic and potentially carcinogenic. • Concerns have been expressed about the potential effects of emissions on the environment and human health by communities in the Athabasca River basin as well as by communities in the downstream Slave and Mackenzie river basins. • Local communities have also reported an increase in the occurrence of lesions and deformities in fishes which has raised their concerns • These concerns have been heightened by uncertainties concerning the origin of contaminants, natural or anthropogenic, and magnitudes of exposure.

Methods  

Conclusions  •  Concentrations of Se were different in summer and fall. The increased

concentration in summer could be caused by the influx of contaminants after snow melt.

•  Thallium, but not V or Se appear to biomagnify, since fishes of higher trophic levels have equal or higher concentrations than those at lower trophic levels.

•  V and Tl have been previously associated with discharges from petroleum based activities, including oil sands activities.

•  Greater concentrations of metals along the Slave River are potentially due to upstream activities.

•  Increases in V and Tl at the downstream sites pose interesting questions of bioaccumulation and chemodynamics, further research is planned.

•  Spring sampling has been completed and metals are being quantified to better understand spatial and temporal distribution of their concentrations.

•  Two sites were added downstream of Athabasca Basin for the spring sampling (FF, PP) to better understand metal distribution.

Acknowledgements  This project would not have been possible without the assistance provided by First Nations and Métis communities of Ft Resolution, Ft Smith, Ft Chipewyan, Ft MacKay and Ft McMurray and by numerous Provincial and Federal agencies. Funding was provided by the Boreal Songbird Initiative (BSI), Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Canada (AANDC) and the Government of the Northwest Territories, which supported sampling in the NWT. Tim Barrett (UNB) provided assistance with statistical analysis.

This research was conducted to describe spatial and temporal distributions of metals in tissues of fishes from selected locations along the Athabasca and Slave Rivers.

• Most of the metals analysed showed little or no location associated variability for the summer and fall samplings. • Thallium(Tl), Vanadium(V), Selenium(Se), and Mercury(Hg) did show location associated variability. • Se concentrations varied little among sites in summer, but in the fall were greater on the Slave River. • A steady increase in the concentration of thallium in fish muscle was noted at sites proceeding down the Athabasca/Slave system. • Thallium also showed a relationship between concentration and trophic level as the higher trophic level JF and WE had greater concentrations.

Results  

Summer  

B.  Tendler1,  E.  Ohiozebau,2  A.  Hill1,  G.  Codling2,  J.P.  Giesy1,3,4,  E.  Kelly5,  P.  Hodson6,  J.  Short7,  P.D.  Jones1,2    1.Toxicology  Centre,  University  of  Saskatchewan,  Saskatoon,  Canada          2.School  of  Environment  &  Sustainability,  University  of  Saskatchewan,  Saskatoon,  Canada          3.  Dept.  of  Biomedical  Veterinary  Sciences,  University  of  Saskatchewan,  Saskatoon,  Canada      

   4.  Dept.  of  Biology  and  Chemistry,  City  University  of  Hong  Kong,  Hong  Kong,  SAR,  China          5.  Environment  and  Natural  Resources,  Government  of  the  Northwest  Territories,  Canada  6.  Department  of  Biology,  Queens  University,  Kingston  ON,  Canada          7.  DJWS  Consul.ng  LLC,  Juneau  AK,  USA  

 

Exposure  of  Fish  in  the  Athabasca  and  Slave  Rivers  to  Metals  Poten4ally  Derived  from  Oilsands  Opera4ons  

Quantification of Metals: • Approximately 0.1 g of dry muscle was added to a 15 mL Teflon vial and digested in concentrated nitric acid (69%) and hydrogen peroxide (30%). • Digests were evaporated until dry at approximately 70ᴼC.  • 5 mL of 2% nitric acid was added to dried digest which was then filtered (0.45 micrometre pore size) and transferred into 8 mL HDPE vial for storage and analysis. • Concentrations of 20 metals were measured by ICP-MS.

Methods  

Pike  or  Jackfish  (Esox  lucius)    JF  

Loche  Mariah,  Burbot  (Lota  lota)  BB  

Goldeye  (Hiodon  alosoides)  GE  

Whitefish  (Coregonus  clupeaformis)  WF  

Walleye  or  Pickeral  (Sander  vitreus)  WE  

Figure 3. Concentrations of metals by species and site. Summary statistics (means, SE = standard error of the mean; n = sample size). Sites sharing a letter (A,B,C), within a metal/species grouping are not significantly different at α = 0.05 (Tukey family-wise error rate for multiple comparisons). Hypothesis tests conducted using ANOVA after data transformation (rank, log base 10, or power). Hg analyses conducted using ANCOVA with log base 10 transformed data (response and covariate) using length or weight as a covariate). X = significant interaction in ANCOVA (p = 0.05). Text in red addresses to subjectively assess trends across species.

Fall  

    BB   GE   JF   WE   WF        decrease  downriver  

Hg                            increase  at  FS  

Se                            increase  at  FR  

Tl                            increase  downriver  

V                            increase  at  FS,  not  high  upstream  Athabasca  

Results  

Figure 1. Metal Concentration trends for metals of interest. Figure 2. Metal concentrations (V, Tl, Se) for all Species by Season.

• Concentrations of Vanadium (V) were significantly (p<0.05) greater at Fort Resolution and Fort Smith on the Slave River than those in fish from sites on the Athabasca River. • Concentrations of Selenium (Se) varied little among locations during summer. During the fall, selenium concentrations were greater in Slave River than Athabasca River. • Concentrations of Mercury (Hg) were greater in JF and WE on the Slave River.

Results