faculty of cognitive sciences and human development...faculty of cognitive sciences and human...
TRANSCRIPT
Faculty of Cognitive Sciences and Human Development
EXAMIlING G ENERATIONAL DlFFERElCES BETWEEN BABY
BOOMER AND GENERATION XS WORK ATTITUDES OF
AUTHENTICITY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE
A CASE STUDY OF LECTURER IN A
MALAYSIAN P BLIe INSTIT T E
OF HIGHER EDUCATION
Farrah oorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfa sn i
HF 5549 5 J6 Bachelor of Science wllh HonoursF239
(Human Re ourc e Developmeol) 2() II
2011
BORANG PENGESAHAN STATUS TESIS I Gred j1 i
JUDUL EXAMINING GENERATIONAL DIFFERENCES BFTWEEN BABY BOOMERS AND G ENERATION XS WORK ATTITUDES OF AUTIlENTICITY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE STUDY OF LECTURERS IN A MALAYSIAN PUBLIC INSTlTUlF OF HIGHER EDUCA TlON
SESI PENGAJIAN 2 20102011
Saya FARRAH NOORNAJWA BT MOHAMAD ALFASNI
mengaku membenarkan tesis bull ini disimpan di Pusat Khidmat Maklumat Akademik Universiti Malaysia Sarawak dengan syarat-syarat kegunaan sepeni berikut
I Tesis adalah hakmilik Universiti Malaysia Sarawak 2 Pusat Khidmat Maklumat Akademik Universiti Malaysia Sarawak dibenarkan
membuat salinan untuk tujuan pengajian sahaja 3 Pusat Khidmat Maklumat Akademik Universiti Malaysia Sarawak dibenarkan
membuat pendigitan untuk membangunkan Pangkalan Data Kandun an Tempatan 4 Pusat Khidmat Maklumat Akademik Universiti Malaysia Sarawak dibenarkan
membuat salinan tesis ini sebagai bahan penukaran antara institus i pengajian tinggi
bullbull sila tandakan ( )
o (Mengandungi maklumat yang berdarjah keselamatan atau SULIT
kepentingan sepel1i termaktub di dalam AKTA RAHSIA RASMI 1972)
(Mengandungi maklumat Terhad yang telah ditentukan oleh [] TERHAD organisasibadan di mana penyelidikan dijalankan)
yen c~
(FARioABT ABDUL HALIM)
Alamat Tetap LOT 489 HILIR MASJID KAMPUNG PI NTU GENG 15100 KOTA BHARU KELANTAN
Y--_t--f_01 _Tarikh q1l ~lqX ull Tarikh __ _ 1 _ _
Catalan ~ Tests dimaksudkan sebagat (eSlS bagi IJazah Doktor Fslsltl fh SlUJ3n3 dan SarJana Muda middotJtka teStS ina SUUT atau TERHAD sila lilmprtnn sural da npada pthak berkuasalorgan lsasi berkenaan dengan menyatakan sekali sebab dan lempoh teStS ini perlu dkelaskan sebagl l TERHAD
Statement of O riginality
The work described in this Final Year ProJect entitled Exam ining genera tional diffe rences between Baby Boomers and Generational Xs work
ttitudes of Autlent icity Balance and Cballenge A case study of lecturers in a Malaysi Public I nstitute of Higher Education
is to the best of the authors knowledge that of the author except where due reference is made
(Date subm ined) (Student s signature) Farrah NoorNajwa bt Mohamad Alfsn 20953
PKH10MAT MAKLUMAT AKAOEMIK Pual Khdmal Ma~ Iwo ~ I I~ I UNIHISITI MALAYSI tK
III 1II IIimII 11111 1111 1000224362
EXAMINING GENERATIO AL DlFFERENCES BETWEEN BABY BOOMERS AND GENERATION XS WORK ATTITUDES OF
AUTHENTICITY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE STUDY OF LECTURERS IN A MALAYSIAN PUBLIC L~STITUTE OF roGHER
EDUCATION
FARRAH NOORNAJW A BT MOHAMAD ALFASN I
This project is submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for a Bachelor of Sc ience with Honours (Human Resou rce Development)
Facu lty of Cognitive Sciences and Human Development UNIVERSITI lvlALAYSIA SARAW AK
(2011)
The project entitled Examining generational differences between baby boomers and generation XS work attitudes of authenticity balance and challenge a case of lecturers in a Malaysian Public [nsitute of Higher Education was prepared by Farrah NoorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfasni and submitted to the Faculty of Cognitive Sciences and Human Development in partial fulfillment of the requirements for a Bachelor of Science with Honours (Human Resource Development)
Received for examination by
(FA
Date
4 5 ~)(T11 -------------- ---~-------- -----------
Gred
11
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First of all I am grateful to God for the blessings and grace this project can be completed successfully
J would like to ex press my appreciation to my supportive supervisor Madam Farida bt Abdul Halim on her guidance time advice and constructive critics through out this project
A big ap preciation is also given to a ll the faculties at the University Malaysia Sarawak and Un iversi ti Teknologi Mara Kota Samarahan for giving me permission to conduct a study on the faculty Special thanks given to the Department of Statistics of Sarawak for thei r cooperation and permission in obtaining some information for this project Not fo rgetting the De partment of Human Resources of University Ma laysia Sarawak espec ially to Miss Masni Masri who have been involved and cooperate in the process of co llecting data for sampling I al so would like to say thank you to Encik Moham ad from Universiti Teknologi Mara Kota Samarahan who gave me guidance and sacrificed his precious time when I was at the data collection stage
Great thanks to friends of the many colleagues who helped provide informa tion and guidance to ensure that the project is carried out properl y It is bliss for knowi ng all of you and be part of my life Special appreciation goes to my mentor Encik Abg lzhar a ll lectu rers and staffs of Facul ty of Cogn itive Sciences and Human Development and others who direc tl y and indirectl y ass ist me throughout the preparation and completion of this project Thank you very much
Finally a specia l appreciation and thanks to my loved ones especia lly to my mother and father brothers and sister who giv es me a lot of encouragement and en thusiasm for thi s project Thank you for your prayer love care an d unstoppab le support
For all those involved directly and indirectly in this project thank you aga in and may God Almighty always bless you
iii
~1 Khidmut 1a~lumnt Akacl middot1
SITJ M l IV Mi ltAr
TABLE OF CO TENTS
Acknowledgements Table of Contents List ofTables List of Figures Abstract Abstrak
CHAPTER 1 - INTROD
Page
Ul
VI
viii Xl
xu XUI
CTION
10 Introduclion I ll Background of the study 2 l2 Problem statement 2 13 Research questions 5 14 Obj ectives of the study 5
14 1 General objective 5 14 2 Specific objectives 5
15 Conceptual framework 6 16 Hypothesis 6 17 Definition of tenns 7
17 1 Work attitude 7 17 11 Authenticity 7 1712 Balance 8 1713 Challenge 8
l8 Significance of the study 8 18 1 Theoritical contribution 8 182 Robustness of research methodology 8 l8 3 Practical contribution 9
l9 Limitation of study 10 110 Conclusion 10
CHAPTER 2 - LITERATURE REVIEW
20 Introduction II 21 Context for the study (Empirical study) 12
2 11 Baby Boomers Generation 12 212 Generation Xs 13 213 Employment situasion in Malaysia 14
IV
22
23
24
CHAPTER 3
30 31 32 33
34
35 36 37
38
Review of related theories 221 Generational theories 222 Kaleidoscope career model 223 Generational research
2231 Baby Boomer 2231 Generation X
Generational differences in work attitude 231 Previous research on generational differences
An examination of work values and generational gaps in the hospitality workforce
232 Previous research on generational differences Revisiting generational work va lues for the new millennium 2321 The relationship between age and wo rk values and
work attitude Conclusion
- METHODOLOGY
Introduction Research des ign Population and sample Instrument development 331 Section A 33 2 Section B Validity 341 Reliab ility Actual survey Data collection Data Analysis Technique 371 Descrip tive statistics 372 Inferential statistics
3721 Data Screening 3722 Pearson Correlation Anal ys is 3723 Spearman Correlation 3724 Independent sample T-test 3725 Mann-Whitney U-test
Swnmary
v
15 15 17 18 18 20 21 21
22
23
24
2S 26 27 31 31 32 33 33 34 34 35 3S 35 36 36 36 37 38 38
CHAPTER 4 - FINDINGS
40 Introduction 40 41 Demographic Characteri st ics 41
411 Gender 41 412 Generational Differences 42 413 Highest Education level 43 414 Percentage of time in using computer at work 44
42 Data Screening Test Results 46 43 Reliability Test Results 48 44 Research Question Testing 49
441 Authenticity 49 442 Balance 50 443 Challenge 51
45 Hypotheses Testing Using Mann-Whitney U-test 52 451 Authenticity 52 452 Balance S3
46 Hypothesis Testing Using Independent sample T- test 55 46 1 Challenge 55
47 Summary of the findings in the study 58 48 Conclusion 59
CHAPTER 5 - SUMMARY DISCttSSION IMPLI CATION RECOMMENDATlOl( AND CONCLUSION
50 51 52
53
54
55
APPENDIX
Introducti on 60 Summary of the research 61 Discussions 63 521 Authenticity 63 522 Balance 63 523 Challenge 65 Implications of the study 66 531 Implications to theory 66 532 Implications to Human Resource Practiti oners 66 Recommendations 65 54 1 Human Resource Practitioners 67 542 Future Researchers 69 Conclusion 70
References 71 Appendix 76
Vj
LIST OF TABLES
Table 321
Number of lecturers according to the generational differences
(Universiti Malaysia Sarawak) 28
Table 322
Number oflecturers according to the generational differences
(Universiti Teknologi Mara) 29
Table 332
Likert-Scale 30
Table 3723
Description of PearsonSpearman Correlation Value 37
Table 3725
Classifications of effect s ize value r 38
Table 381
The summary table of types of statistical analysis used to analyzed each variable 39
Table 382
The summary table of types of statistical analysis used to analyzed each
hypothesis 39
Table 411
Distribution of respondents by gender 41
vl
Table 4111
Distribution of respondents by Gender according two different generation 42
Table 412
Distribut ion of respondents by Generational Differences 43
Ta ble 413
Distribution of respondents by their Highest Education Level 43
Table 4131
Distribution of respondents by Generational Differences according to their
Highest Education Level 44
Table 414
Distribution of respondents by Pe(centage of time in using computer at
work according to Generational Differences 45
Table 42
Data Screening test result 46
Table 421
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 422
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 43
Lists of Reliability test result 48
Vlll
49
Result of Spearman Correlation for the Relationship between Baby Boomers
and Generation Xs work amptitude in dimension of Authenticity
Result ofSpeannan Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Balance 50
Result of Pearson Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Challenge 5
Result of Mann-Whitney U-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Authenticity 52
Statistics for Authenticity
Result of Mann-Whitney C-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Balance 53
Statistics for Balance 54
Result of Independent sample Tmiddottest for the Difference between
IX
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Challenge 5S
Table 4611
Result of Independent sample T -test for Differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for challenge 56
Table 471
Summary of findings 58
Table 472
Summary of hypotheses result testing 59
x
6
LIST OF FIGURE
Figure 10
The direct effect relationships between selective demographic factors
towards perceived on their own working attitude
Xl
ABSTRACT
EXAMINING GENERATIONAL DlFFERE CES BETWEEN
BABY BOOMERS Al1D GENERATIO N XS WORK ATTITUDES OF
AUTHE TIClTY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE OF LECTURERS
IN A MALA YSIAN PUBLIC INSTITuTE OF HIGHER EDUCATION
Farrah NoorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfasn
This study aims to identify the generational differences betw~cn Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitudes by using the Kaleidoscope Career
Model in the d imensions of au thenticity balance and cha llenge among lec turers in
a Malays ian Public Inst itute of Higher Educat ion A quantitati ve descriptive
research was adopted and used as a tool to co llect the data The in strument used
was the self-administered questionnaire that was adopted from the previous
researchers Prior to the actual data the validated questionnaires were then
distributed to the actu a l respondents which were the lecturers in the entire faculty
in Universiti Malaysia Sarawak and Universiti Teknologi Mara The sample of
this study was 270 To answer the first re search question the researcher used
Pearson and spea rman corre lation The analysis of mann-whitney u-test and
independent samples t-test was perfonning to compare the means of Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs by using the software Statistica l Package for Social
Sciences (SPSS) 170 version A significance difference was found in th e
comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving their own needs of
authenticity and ba lance in work attitude But it was that there was no significance
difference in the comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving
their own needs of cha llenge in work attitude
xi i
ABSTRAK
MENGENALPASTI PERBEZAAN ANTARA GENERASI BABY BOOMER
DAN GENERASI X BERKAlTAN SIKAP KERJA DARl DIMENSI KEASLlAN
KESEIMBANGAN DAN CABARAN KAJIAN MENGENAI PENSYARAH DI
PUSAT PENGAJIAN TINGGI AWAM DI MALAYSIA
Farrah NoorNajwa Be Mohamad Afasni
Penyelidikan ini berlujuan untuk mengenalpasti perbezaan generasi anara Baby
Boomer dan Gfnerasi X dengan menggunakan Model Kerjaya Kaleidoskop dalam
dimensi keaslian keseimbangan dan cabaran diantara pensyarah di Intilut
Pengajian Tinggi Awam di Malaysia Sebuah kajian deskriptif kuantitatf
diadaptasikan dan digunakan sebagai medium untuk mengumpul data Medium
yang digunakan adalah sel[administered questionnaire yang diodapcosikan dari
pengkaji yang sebelumnya Bag data sebenar soalan kajian kemudian diagihkan
kepada respondent iaitu pensyarah di selunch fakulti di Unversit Malaysia
Sarawak dan Unive rsiti Teknologi Mara Sample kajian ini adalah sebanyak 270
Untuk menjawab soalan kajian yang pertama penyelidik menggunakan Korelasi
Pearson dan Korelasi Spearman Analisis Mann-Whitney U-test dan Independent
Sample T-test digunakan untuk membandingkan sikap kerja dianara Generasi
Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dengan menggunakan Software Statistical Package
Sosial (SPSS) versi 170 Satu perbezaan yang signifikan ditemui pada
perbandingan Generas Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dalam keaslian dan
keseimbangan dalam sikap kerfa Namun tiada perbezaan yang signifikan
dikenalpasti diantara Baby Boomers dan Generasi X dalam cabaran dalam
keperluan sikap kerjo mereka
xiii
CHAJTER 1
I NTRODD CTI ON
10 introd uc tion
This chapter describes the background of the study statement of problem
general and specific objecti ves the conceptual framework used and th e
significance of the study This chapter also gives more detail s about the
limitations and the scope of this stud y for theoretical and contributions The
definitions of terms are al so covered to give clear information and deepen the
understanding of readers in this research
1
11 Background of study
Current career patterns are still influenced by the traditional career model
whi ch limit many women and force them to adapt to thi s model T he result of
such approach is the unequal access of women towards development of their
career when compared to men This has its implicat ions in pers istence o f the
sectora l and occ upational separation
M uch has been written in the popular press about the clash between Baby
Boome rs and members of Generation X For instance Business Week has
featured sto ries such as The reasons why Generat ion X a re unhappy at work
which suggests that Boomer managers do not understand what motivates their
Generation X employees (Erickson 2005) Fortune has reported on how
Generation X feel cannot get ahead because of the grey ceiling created by
Boomers who will not retire (Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Time magazine
fea tured a cover story about Generation X that lamen ted they just wont up
(Grossman L 2005) while illustrating also that the generation gap is not just a
western phenomenon with its story on Chinas me generati on (Simon 2007)
Soc iety for Human Resource Management in the year of 2004 stated that s imilar
reports of how the generation gap between Baby Boomers and Generation X has
caused inc reased workplace conflict
There is a potential difference in the ca reer needs o f Baby Boomers and
Gene rati on X the two generations that dominate todays western wo rkp lace
(S ulli van 1999) It has been suggested that the root of the conflic ts between Baby
Boomers and Generation X is that these two generations differed in th e ir atti tudes
toward s work-non-work balance the desire for challenging work and differences
in the meaning of work (CalJanan and Greenhaus 2008 Hankin 2004) Bahy
Boomers are often viewed as workaholics wh o thrive on increas in g work
chall enge whereby Generation X are seen as placing a high er va lue on balance to
the po int of being perceived as slackers While popular press has devoted
considerable attention to how the interaction of members from these different
2
ge nerations may have important implicati ons for current workplace dynamics and
practices (Zemke et a l 2000)
12 Problem statement
Today the workforce is dominated by two generat ions which are the Baby
Boomers born between 1945 and 1964 and the Generation X born betwee n year
1965 and J979 (Loomis 2000) A third generation is entering the workforce
Genera tion Y or the Internet Generation the eldest of whom just turned 26
For many managing an emerging work force containing re tirin g Roomers
Gene rati on X and newly entering Generation Y wiiJ be a cha llenge About 76
million Americans were born between 1946 and 1964 (Rakoff 200 1) In 2010 the
youngest of Baby Boomers is 27 and the oldest 45 years old By their sheer size
th ese Baby Boomers defined and redefined work for the last quarter of the 20th
century (Joyner 2000) As the oldest Baby Boomers retire it affects the di versity
of the labour force overall econom y certain occupations and indus tri es Th is has
a direct impact on th e economys capacity to produce goods and services
Understanding mOre fully what traits or behaviours seem to be associated with
how each baby boo mers and Generation X perce ives effective leadership will onl y
be beneficial eas ing the trans ition as one group leaves and the othe r re places it
(Miller 2005)
The work characteristics of Baby Boomers and Generation X are different
in many respects and this difference can be ex plained by many factors such as the
differences in li ving environments when the va lues of these ge nerations were
form ed The most consistent finding in th e literature when comparisons of work
charac teristics are made between Generation X and Baby Boomers is that each
ge nerational group exh ibits a different mixture o f lifesty lc values a nd work ethics
T he Baby Boomers tend to work hard and are genera lly loya l to the ir employer In
contrast work values for the Generation X emphasise personal sati sfaction rather
than just working hard
3
Beside the ir work values Shu ( 1998) indicated that Generation X has
broke n the traditi onal Mas low hi erarchy needs rule and cha ll enged indi vidual
development progress Baby Boomers have te nded to fo llow their indi vidual
development progress starting from education ca reer marr iage promoti on and
this has moved the m towards selfmiddot achievement Generation X squeezes the
process together They need self achi evement from their job and bas ic needs at the
same time and they do not want the ir work to impac t negative ly on their quality of
life Baby Boomers have had to work in a ll three phases of a progressive economy
and therefore have had to adapt from be in g predominantly indust rial workers that
is undertaking predominantl y industr ia l work to service workers and now to
know ledge workers On the other hand Generat ion X entered the workforce
around 1985 ass umin g that they commenced employme nt in their late teens and
have onl y ever experi enced a predominan tly service economy with training
prog rams during the ir careers orie nted to deli ver the skills
The big worry here is Erickson (2005) stated that most of Generation X
were unhappy at wo rk beca use of the ir Boomer manage rs do not understand what
motivates their Gene ration X employees Generation X also felt that they cannot
get ahead because of the grey ce il ing c reated by Boomer who will not retire
(Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Em ployers have been unable to determine whether
generational membership directly im pacts career moti vation and caree r decision s
So it is crucial to study the differences of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs work
attitude for Human Resource Person in orde r to understand the ir beha viour and
avo id contli ct in each and every organisat ion
T hi s lack of understanding has presented some c ha llenges for bus iness
leaders to meet the needs o f a multigenerational workforce The re fo re the
problem is that while continued generational di vers ity is obvious in workforce
there is insufficient knowledge ab out di ffe rences in career motivation and work
attitude between the cohorts Addressing this problem may increase organiza tional
leaders generational competence as they fonnulate recruitment and retention
strategies that support generation differences As the previous study was
4
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
BORANG PENGESAHAN STATUS TESIS I Gred j1 i
JUDUL EXAMINING GENERATIONAL DIFFERENCES BFTWEEN BABY BOOMERS AND G ENERATION XS WORK ATTITUDES OF AUTIlENTICITY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE STUDY OF LECTURERS IN A MALAYSIAN PUBLIC INSTlTUlF OF HIGHER EDUCA TlON
SESI PENGAJIAN 2 20102011
Saya FARRAH NOORNAJWA BT MOHAMAD ALFASNI
mengaku membenarkan tesis bull ini disimpan di Pusat Khidmat Maklumat Akademik Universiti Malaysia Sarawak dengan syarat-syarat kegunaan sepeni berikut
I Tesis adalah hakmilik Universiti Malaysia Sarawak 2 Pusat Khidmat Maklumat Akademik Universiti Malaysia Sarawak dibenarkan
membuat salinan untuk tujuan pengajian sahaja 3 Pusat Khidmat Maklumat Akademik Universiti Malaysia Sarawak dibenarkan
membuat pendigitan untuk membangunkan Pangkalan Data Kandun an Tempatan 4 Pusat Khidmat Maklumat Akademik Universiti Malaysia Sarawak dibenarkan
membuat salinan tesis ini sebagai bahan penukaran antara institus i pengajian tinggi
bullbull sila tandakan ( )
o (Mengandungi maklumat yang berdarjah keselamatan atau SULIT
kepentingan sepel1i termaktub di dalam AKTA RAHSIA RASMI 1972)
(Mengandungi maklumat Terhad yang telah ditentukan oleh [] TERHAD organisasibadan di mana penyelidikan dijalankan)
yen c~
(FARioABT ABDUL HALIM)
Alamat Tetap LOT 489 HILIR MASJID KAMPUNG PI NTU GENG 15100 KOTA BHARU KELANTAN
Y--_t--f_01 _Tarikh q1l ~lqX ull Tarikh __ _ 1 _ _
Catalan ~ Tests dimaksudkan sebagat (eSlS bagi IJazah Doktor Fslsltl fh SlUJ3n3 dan SarJana Muda middotJtka teStS ina SUUT atau TERHAD sila lilmprtnn sural da npada pthak berkuasalorgan lsasi berkenaan dengan menyatakan sekali sebab dan lempoh teStS ini perlu dkelaskan sebagl l TERHAD
Statement of O riginality
The work described in this Final Year ProJect entitled Exam ining genera tional diffe rences between Baby Boomers and Generational Xs work
ttitudes of Autlent icity Balance and Cballenge A case study of lecturers in a Malaysi Public I nstitute of Higher Education
is to the best of the authors knowledge that of the author except where due reference is made
(Date subm ined) (Student s signature) Farrah NoorNajwa bt Mohamad Alfsn 20953
PKH10MAT MAKLUMAT AKAOEMIK Pual Khdmal Ma~ Iwo ~ I I~ I UNIHISITI MALAYSI tK
III 1II IIimII 11111 1111 1000224362
EXAMINING GENERATIO AL DlFFERENCES BETWEEN BABY BOOMERS AND GENERATION XS WORK ATTITUDES OF
AUTHENTICITY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE STUDY OF LECTURERS IN A MALAYSIAN PUBLIC L~STITUTE OF roGHER
EDUCATION
FARRAH NOORNAJW A BT MOHAMAD ALFASN I
This project is submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for a Bachelor of Sc ience with Honours (Human Resou rce Development)
Facu lty of Cognitive Sciences and Human Development UNIVERSITI lvlALAYSIA SARAW AK
(2011)
The project entitled Examining generational differences between baby boomers and generation XS work attitudes of authenticity balance and challenge a case of lecturers in a Malaysian Public [nsitute of Higher Education was prepared by Farrah NoorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfasni and submitted to the Faculty of Cognitive Sciences and Human Development in partial fulfillment of the requirements for a Bachelor of Science with Honours (Human Resource Development)
Received for examination by
(FA
Date
4 5 ~)(T11 -------------- ---~-------- -----------
Gred
11
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First of all I am grateful to God for the blessings and grace this project can be completed successfully
J would like to ex press my appreciation to my supportive supervisor Madam Farida bt Abdul Halim on her guidance time advice and constructive critics through out this project
A big ap preciation is also given to a ll the faculties at the University Malaysia Sarawak and Un iversi ti Teknologi Mara Kota Samarahan for giving me permission to conduct a study on the faculty Special thanks given to the Department of Statistics of Sarawak for thei r cooperation and permission in obtaining some information for this project Not fo rgetting the De partment of Human Resources of University Ma laysia Sarawak espec ially to Miss Masni Masri who have been involved and cooperate in the process of co llecting data for sampling I al so would like to say thank you to Encik Moham ad from Universiti Teknologi Mara Kota Samarahan who gave me guidance and sacrificed his precious time when I was at the data collection stage
Great thanks to friends of the many colleagues who helped provide informa tion and guidance to ensure that the project is carried out properl y It is bliss for knowi ng all of you and be part of my life Special appreciation goes to my mentor Encik Abg lzhar a ll lectu rers and staffs of Facul ty of Cogn itive Sciences and Human Development and others who direc tl y and indirectl y ass ist me throughout the preparation and completion of this project Thank you very much
Finally a specia l appreciation and thanks to my loved ones especia lly to my mother and father brothers and sister who giv es me a lot of encouragement and en thusiasm for thi s project Thank you for your prayer love care an d unstoppab le support
For all those involved directly and indirectly in this project thank you aga in and may God Almighty always bless you
iii
~1 Khidmut 1a~lumnt Akacl middot1
SITJ M l IV Mi ltAr
TABLE OF CO TENTS
Acknowledgements Table of Contents List ofTables List of Figures Abstract Abstrak
CHAPTER 1 - INTROD
Page
Ul
VI
viii Xl
xu XUI
CTION
10 Introduclion I ll Background of the study 2 l2 Problem statement 2 13 Research questions 5 14 Obj ectives of the study 5
14 1 General objective 5 14 2 Specific objectives 5
15 Conceptual framework 6 16 Hypothesis 6 17 Definition of tenns 7
17 1 Work attitude 7 17 11 Authenticity 7 1712 Balance 8 1713 Challenge 8
l8 Significance of the study 8 18 1 Theoritical contribution 8 182 Robustness of research methodology 8 l8 3 Practical contribution 9
l9 Limitation of study 10 110 Conclusion 10
CHAPTER 2 - LITERATURE REVIEW
20 Introduction II 21 Context for the study (Empirical study) 12
2 11 Baby Boomers Generation 12 212 Generation Xs 13 213 Employment situasion in Malaysia 14
IV
22
23
24
CHAPTER 3
30 31 32 33
34
35 36 37
38
Review of related theories 221 Generational theories 222 Kaleidoscope career model 223 Generational research
2231 Baby Boomer 2231 Generation X
Generational differences in work attitude 231 Previous research on generational differences
An examination of work values and generational gaps in the hospitality workforce
232 Previous research on generational differences Revisiting generational work va lues for the new millennium 2321 The relationship between age and wo rk values and
work attitude Conclusion
- METHODOLOGY
Introduction Research des ign Population and sample Instrument development 331 Section A 33 2 Section B Validity 341 Reliab ility Actual survey Data collection Data Analysis Technique 371 Descrip tive statistics 372 Inferential statistics
3721 Data Screening 3722 Pearson Correlation Anal ys is 3723 Spearman Correlation 3724 Independent sample T-test 3725 Mann-Whitney U-test
Swnmary
v
15 15 17 18 18 20 21 21
22
23
24
2S 26 27 31 31 32 33 33 34 34 35 3S 35 36 36 36 37 38 38
CHAPTER 4 - FINDINGS
40 Introduction 40 41 Demographic Characteri st ics 41
411 Gender 41 412 Generational Differences 42 413 Highest Education level 43 414 Percentage of time in using computer at work 44
42 Data Screening Test Results 46 43 Reliability Test Results 48 44 Research Question Testing 49
441 Authenticity 49 442 Balance 50 443 Challenge 51
45 Hypotheses Testing Using Mann-Whitney U-test 52 451 Authenticity 52 452 Balance S3
46 Hypothesis Testing Using Independent sample T- test 55 46 1 Challenge 55
47 Summary of the findings in the study 58 48 Conclusion 59
CHAPTER 5 - SUMMARY DISCttSSION IMPLI CATION RECOMMENDATlOl( AND CONCLUSION
50 51 52
53
54
55
APPENDIX
Introducti on 60 Summary of the research 61 Discussions 63 521 Authenticity 63 522 Balance 63 523 Challenge 65 Implications of the study 66 531 Implications to theory 66 532 Implications to Human Resource Practiti oners 66 Recommendations 65 54 1 Human Resource Practitioners 67 542 Future Researchers 69 Conclusion 70
References 71 Appendix 76
Vj
LIST OF TABLES
Table 321
Number of lecturers according to the generational differences
(Universiti Malaysia Sarawak) 28
Table 322
Number oflecturers according to the generational differences
(Universiti Teknologi Mara) 29
Table 332
Likert-Scale 30
Table 3723
Description of PearsonSpearman Correlation Value 37
Table 3725
Classifications of effect s ize value r 38
Table 381
The summary table of types of statistical analysis used to analyzed each variable 39
Table 382
The summary table of types of statistical analysis used to analyzed each
hypothesis 39
Table 411
Distribution of respondents by gender 41
vl
Table 4111
Distribution of respondents by Gender according two different generation 42
Table 412
Distribut ion of respondents by Generational Differences 43
Ta ble 413
Distribution of respondents by their Highest Education Level 43
Table 4131
Distribution of respondents by Generational Differences according to their
Highest Education Level 44
Table 414
Distribution of respondents by Pe(centage of time in using computer at
work according to Generational Differences 45
Table 42
Data Screening test result 46
Table 421
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 422
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 43
Lists of Reliability test result 48
Vlll
49
Result of Spearman Correlation for the Relationship between Baby Boomers
and Generation Xs work amptitude in dimension of Authenticity
Result ofSpeannan Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Balance 50
Result of Pearson Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Challenge 5
Result of Mann-Whitney U-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Authenticity 52
Statistics for Authenticity
Result of Mann-Whitney C-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Balance 53
Statistics for Balance 54
Result of Independent sample Tmiddottest for the Difference between
IX
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Challenge 5S
Table 4611
Result of Independent sample T -test for Differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for challenge 56
Table 471
Summary of findings 58
Table 472
Summary of hypotheses result testing 59
x
6
LIST OF FIGURE
Figure 10
The direct effect relationships between selective demographic factors
towards perceived on their own working attitude
Xl
ABSTRACT
EXAMINING GENERATIONAL DlFFERE CES BETWEEN
BABY BOOMERS Al1D GENERATIO N XS WORK ATTITUDES OF
AUTHE TIClTY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE OF LECTURERS
IN A MALA YSIAN PUBLIC INSTITuTE OF HIGHER EDUCATION
Farrah NoorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfasn
This study aims to identify the generational differences betw~cn Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitudes by using the Kaleidoscope Career
Model in the d imensions of au thenticity balance and cha llenge among lec turers in
a Malays ian Public Inst itute of Higher Educat ion A quantitati ve descriptive
research was adopted and used as a tool to co llect the data The in strument used
was the self-administered questionnaire that was adopted from the previous
researchers Prior to the actual data the validated questionnaires were then
distributed to the actu a l respondents which were the lecturers in the entire faculty
in Universiti Malaysia Sarawak and Universiti Teknologi Mara The sample of
this study was 270 To answer the first re search question the researcher used
Pearson and spea rman corre lation The analysis of mann-whitney u-test and
independent samples t-test was perfonning to compare the means of Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs by using the software Statistica l Package for Social
Sciences (SPSS) 170 version A significance difference was found in th e
comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving their own needs of
authenticity and ba lance in work attitude But it was that there was no significance
difference in the comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving
their own needs of cha llenge in work attitude
xi i
ABSTRAK
MENGENALPASTI PERBEZAAN ANTARA GENERASI BABY BOOMER
DAN GENERASI X BERKAlTAN SIKAP KERJA DARl DIMENSI KEASLlAN
KESEIMBANGAN DAN CABARAN KAJIAN MENGENAI PENSYARAH DI
PUSAT PENGAJIAN TINGGI AWAM DI MALAYSIA
Farrah NoorNajwa Be Mohamad Afasni
Penyelidikan ini berlujuan untuk mengenalpasti perbezaan generasi anara Baby
Boomer dan Gfnerasi X dengan menggunakan Model Kerjaya Kaleidoskop dalam
dimensi keaslian keseimbangan dan cabaran diantara pensyarah di Intilut
Pengajian Tinggi Awam di Malaysia Sebuah kajian deskriptif kuantitatf
diadaptasikan dan digunakan sebagai medium untuk mengumpul data Medium
yang digunakan adalah sel[administered questionnaire yang diodapcosikan dari
pengkaji yang sebelumnya Bag data sebenar soalan kajian kemudian diagihkan
kepada respondent iaitu pensyarah di selunch fakulti di Unversit Malaysia
Sarawak dan Unive rsiti Teknologi Mara Sample kajian ini adalah sebanyak 270
Untuk menjawab soalan kajian yang pertama penyelidik menggunakan Korelasi
Pearson dan Korelasi Spearman Analisis Mann-Whitney U-test dan Independent
Sample T-test digunakan untuk membandingkan sikap kerja dianara Generasi
Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dengan menggunakan Software Statistical Package
Sosial (SPSS) versi 170 Satu perbezaan yang signifikan ditemui pada
perbandingan Generas Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dalam keaslian dan
keseimbangan dalam sikap kerfa Namun tiada perbezaan yang signifikan
dikenalpasti diantara Baby Boomers dan Generasi X dalam cabaran dalam
keperluan sikap kerjo mereka
xiii
CHAJTER 1
I NTRODD CTI ON
10 introd uc tion
This chapter describes the background of the study statement of problem
general and specific objecti ves the conceptual framework used and th e
significance of the study This chapter also gives more detail s about the
limitations and the scope of this stud y for theoretical and contributions The
definitions of terms are al so covered to give clear information and deepen the
understanding of readers in this research
1
11 Background of study
Current career patterns are still influenced by the traditional career model
whi ch limit many women and force them to adapt to thi s model T he result of
such approach is the unequal access of women towards development of their
career when compared to men This has its implicat ions in pers istence o f the
sectora l and occ upational separation
M uch has been written in the popular press about the clash between Baby
Boome rs and members of Generation X For instance Business Week has
featured sto ries such as The reasons why Generat ion X a re unhappy at work
which suggests that Boomer managers do not understand what motivates their
Generation X employees (Erickson 2005) Fortune has reported on how
Generation X feel cannot get ahead because of the grey ceiling created by
Boomers who will not retire (Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Time magazine
fea tured a cover story about Generation X that lamen ted they just wont up
(Grossman L 2005) while illustrating also that the generation gap is not just a
western phenomenon with its story on Chinas me generati on (Simon 2007)
Soc iety for Human Resource Management in the year of 2004 stated that s imilar
reports of how the generation gap between Baby Boomers and Generation X has
caused inc reased workplace conflict
There is a potential difference in the ca reer needs o f Baby Boomers and
Gene rati on X the two generations that dominate todays western wo rkp lace
(S ulli van 1999) It has been suggested that the root of the conflic ts between Baby
Boomers and Generation X is that these two generations differed in th e ir atti tudes
toward s work-non-work balance the desire for challenging work and differences
in the meaning of work (CalJanan and Greenhaus 2008 Hankin 2004) Bahy
Boomers are often viewed as workaholics wh o thrive on increas in g work
chall enge whereby Generation X are seen as placing a high er va lue on balance to
the po int of being perceived as slackers While popular press has devoted
considerable attention to how the interaction of members from these different
2
ge nerations may have important implicati ons for current workplace dynamics and
practices (Zemke et a l 2000)
12 Problem statement
Today the workforce is dominated by two generat ions which are the Baby
Boomers born between 1945 and 1964 and the Generation X born betwee n year
1965 and J979 (Loomis 2000) A third generation is entering the workforce
Genera tion Y or the Internet Generation the eldest of whom just turned 26
For many managing an emerging work force containing re tirin g Roomers
Gene rati on X and newly entering Generation Y wiiJ be a cha llenge About 76
million Americans were born between 1946 and 1964 (Rakoff 200 1) In 2010 the
youngest of Baby Boomers is 27 and the oldest 45 years old By their sheer size
th ese Baby Boomers defined and redefined work for the last quarter of the 20th
century (Joyner 2000) As the oldest Baby Boomers retire it affects the di versity
of the labour force overall econom y certain occupations and indus tri es Th is has
a direct impact on th e economys capacity to produce goods and services
Understanding mOre fully what traits or behaviours seem to be associated with
how each baby boo mers and Generation X perce ives effective leadership will onl y
be beneficial eas ing the trans ition as one group leaves and the othe r re places it
(Miller 2005)
The work characteristics of Baby Boomers and Generation X are different
in many respects and this difference can be ex plained by many factors such as the
differences in li ving environments when the va lues of these ge nerations were
form ed The most consistent finding in th e literature when comparisons of work
charac teristics are made between Generation X and Baby Boomers is that each
ge nerational group exh ibits a different mixture o f lifesty lc values a nd work ethics
T he Baby Boomers tend to work hard and are genera lly loya l to the ir employer In
contrast work values for the Generation X emphasise personal sati sfaction rather
than just working hard
3
Beside the ir work values Shu ( 1998) indicated that Generation X has
broke n the traditi onal Mas low hi erarchy needs rule and cha ll enged indi vidual
development progress Baby Boomers have te nded to fo llow their indi vidual
development progress starting from education ca reer marr iage promoti on and
this has moved the m towards selfmiddot achievement Generation X squeezes the
process together They need self achi evement from their job and bas ic needs at the
same time and they do not want the ir work to impac t negative ly on their quality of
life Baby Boomers have had to work in a ll three phases of a progressive economy
and therefore have had to adapt from be in g predominantly indust rial workers that
is undertaking predominantl y industr ia l work to service workers and now to
know ledge workers On the other hand Generat ion X entered the workforce
around 1985 ass umin g that they commenced employme nt in their late teens and
have onl y ever experi enced a predominan tly service economy with training
prog rams during the ir careers orie nted to deli ver the skills
The big worry here is Erickson (2005) stated that most of Generation X
were unhappy at wo rk beca use of the ir Boomer manage rs do not understand what
motivates their Gene ration X employees Generation X also felt that they cannot
get ahead because of the grey ce il ing c reated by Boomer who will not retire
(Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Em ployers have been unable to determine whether
generational membership directly im pacts career moti vation and caree r decision s
So it is crucial to study the differences of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs work
attitude for Human Resource Person in orde r to understand the ir beha viour and
avo id contli ct in each and every organisat ion
T hi s lack of understanding has presented some c ha llenges for bus iness
leaders to meet the needs o f a multigenerational workforce The re fo re the
problem is that while continued generational di vers ity is obvious in workforce
there is insufficient knowledge ab out di ffe rences in career motivation and work
attitude between the cohorts Addressing this problem may increase organiza tional
leaders generational competence as they fonnulate recruitment and retention
strategies that support generation differences As the previous study was
4
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
Statement of O riginality
The work described in this Final Year ProJect entitled Exam ining genera tional diffe rences between Baby Boomers and Generational Xs work
ttitudes of Autlent icity Balance and Cballenge A case study of lecturers in a Malaysi Public I nstitute of Higher Education
is to the best of the authors knowledge that of the author except where due reference is made
(Date subm ined) (Student s signature) Farrah NoorNajwa bt Mohamad Alfsn 20953
PKH10MAT MAKLUMAT AKAOEMIK Pual Khdmal Ma~ Iwo ~ I I~ I UNIHISITI MALAYSI tK
III 1II IIimII 11111 1111 1000224362
EXAMINING GENERATIO AL DlFFERENCES BETWEEN BABY BOOMERS AND GENERATION XS WORK ATTITUDES OF
AUTHENTICITY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE STUDY OF LECTURERS IN A MALAYSIAN PUBLIC L~STITUTE OF roGHER
EDUCATION
FARRAH NOORNAJW A BT MOHAMAD ALFASN I
This project is submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for a Bachelor of Sc ience with Honours (Human Resou rce Development)
Facu lty of Cognitive Sciences and Human Development UNIVERSITI lvlALAYSIA SARAW AK
(2011)
The project entitled Examining generational differences between baby boomers and generation XS work attitudes of authenticity balance and challenge a case of lecturers in a Malaysian Public [nsitute of Higher Education was prepared by Farrah NoorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfasni and submitted to the Faculty of Cognitive Sciences and Human Development in partial fulfillment of the requirements for a Bachelor of Science with Honours (Human Resource Development)
Received for examination by
(FA
Date
4 5 ~)(T11 -------------- ---~-------- -----------
Gred
11
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First of all I am grateful to God for the blessings and grace this project can be completed successfully
J would like to ex press my appreciation to my supportive supervisor Madam Farida bt Abdul Halim on her guidance time advice and constructive critics through out this project
A big ap preciation is also given to a ll the faculties at the University Malaysia Sarawak and Un iversi ti Teknologi Mara Kota Samarahan for giving me permission to conduct a study on the faculty Special thanks given to the Department of Statistics of Sarawak for thei r cooperation and permission in obtaining some information for this project Not fo rgetting the De partment of Human Resources of University Ma laysia Sarawak espec ially to Miss Masni Masri who have been involved and cooperate in the process of co llecting data for sampling I al so would like to say thank you to Encik Moham ad from Universiti Teknologi Mara Kota Samarahan who gave me guidance and sacrificed his precious time when I was at the data collection stage
Great thanks to friends of the many colleagues who helped provide informa tion and guidance to ensure that the project is carried out properl y It is bliss for knowi ng all of you and be part of my life Special appreciation goes to my mentor Encik Abg lzhar a ll lectu rers and staffs of Facul ty of Cogn itive Sciences and Human Development and others who direc tl y and indirectl y ass ist me throughout the preparation and completion of this project Thank you very much
Finally a specia l appreciation and thanks to my loved ones especia lly to my mother and father brothers and sister who giv es me a lot of encouragement and en thusiasm for thi s project Thank you for your prayer love care an d unstoppab le support
For all those involved directly and indirectly in this project thank you aga in and may God Almighty always bless you
iii
~1 Khidmut 1a~lumnt Akacl middot1
SITJ M l IV Mi ltAr
TABLE OF CO TENTS
Acknowledgements Table of Contents List ofTables List of Figures Abstract Abstrak
CHAPTER 1 - INTROD
Page
Ul
VI
viii Xl
xu XUI
CTION
10 Introduclion I ll Background of the study 2 l2 Problem statement 2 13 Research questions 5 14 Obj ectives of the study 5
14 1 General objective 5 14 2 Specific objectives 5
15 Conceptual framework 6 16 Hypothesis 6 17 Definition of tenns 7
17 1 Work attitude 7 17 11 Authenticity 7 1712 Balance 8 1713 Challenge 8
l8 Significance of the study 8 18 1 Theoritical contribution 8 182 Robustness of research methodology 8 l8 3 Practical contribution 9
l9 Limitation of study 10 110 Conclusion 10
CHAPTER 2 - LITERATURE REVIEW
20 Introduction II 21 Context for the study (Empirical study) 12
2 11 Baby Boomers Generation 12 212 Generation Xs 13 213 Employment situasion in Malaysia 14
IV
22
23
24
CHAPTER 3
30 31 32 33
34
35 36 37
38
Review of related theories 221 Generational theories 222 Kaleidoscope career model 223 Generational research
2231 Baby Boomer 2231 Generation X
Generational differences in work attitude 231 Previous research on generational differences
An examination of work values and generational gaps in the hospitality workforce
232 Previous research on generational differences Revisiting generational work va lues for the new millennium 2321 The relationship between age and wo rk values and
work attitude Conclusion
- METHODOLOGY
Introduction Research des ign Population and sample Instrument development 331 Section A 33 2 Section B Validity 341 Reliab ility Actual survey Data collection Data Analysis Technique 371 Descrip tive statistics 372 Inferential statistics
3721 Data Screening 3722 Pearson Correlation Anal ys is 3723 Spearman Correlation 3724 Independent sample T-test 3725 Mann-Whitney U-test
Swnmary
v
15 15 17 18 18 20 21 21
22
23
24
2S 26 27 31 31 32 33 33 34 34 35 3S 35 36 36 36 37 38 38
CHAPTER 4 - FINDINGS
40 Introduction 40 41 Demographic Characteri st ics 41
411 Gender 41 412 Generational Differences 42 413 Highest Education level 43 414 Percentage of time in using computer at work 44
42 Data Screening Test Results 46 43 Reliability Test Results 48 44 Research Question Testing 49
441 Authenticity 49 442 Balance 50 443 Challenge 51
45 Hypotheses Testing Using Mann-Whitney U-test 52 451 Authenticity 52 452 Balance S3
46 Hypothesis Testing Using Independent sample T- test 55 46 1 Challenge 55
47 Summary of the findings in the study 58 48 Conclusion 59
CHAPTER 5 - SUMMARY DISCttSSION IMPLI CATION RECOMMENDATlOl( AND CONCLUSION
50 51 52
53
54
55
APPENDIX
Introducti on 60 Summary of the research 61 Discussions 63 521 Authenticity 63 522 Balance 63 523 Challenge 65 Implications of the study 66 531 Implications to theory 66 532 Implications to Human Resource Practiti oners 66 Recommendations 65 54 1 Human Resource Practitioners 67 542 Future Researchers 69 Conclusion 70
References 71 Appendix 76
Vj
LIST OF TABLES
Table 321
Number of lecturers according to the generational differences
(Universiti Malaysia Sarawak) 28
Table 322
Number oflecturers according to the generational differences
(Universiti Teknologi Mara) 29
Table 332
Likert-Scale 30
Table 3723
Description of PearsonSpearman Correlation Value 37
Table 3725
Classifications of effect s ize value r 38
Table 381
The summary table of types of statistical analysis used to analyzed each variable 39
Table 382
The summary table of types of statistical analysis used to analyzed each
hypothesis 39
Table 411
Distribution of respondents by gender 41
vl
Table 4111
Distribution of respondents by Gender according two different generation 42
Table 412
Distribut ion of respondents by Generational Differences 43
Ta ble 413
Distribution of respondents by their Highest Education Level 43
Table 4131
Distribution of respondents by Generational Differences according to their
Highest Education Level 44
Table 414
Distribution of respondents by Pe(centage of time in using computer at
work according to Generational Differences 45
Table 42
Data Screening test result 46
Table 421
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 422
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 43
Lists of Reliability test result 48
Vlll
49
Result of Spearman Correlation for the Relationship between Baby Boomers
and Generation Xs work amptitude in dimension of Authenticity
Result ofSpeannan Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Balance 50
Result of Pearson Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Challenge 5
Result of Mann-Whitney U-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Authenticity 52
Statistics for Authenticity
Result of Mann-Whitney C-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Balance 53
Statistics for Balance 54
Result of Independent sample Tmiddottest for the Difference between
IX
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Challenge 5S
Table 4611
Result of Independent sample T -test for Differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for challenge 56
Table 471
Summary of findings 58
Table 472
Summary of hypotheses result testing 59
x
6
LIST OF FIGURE
Figure 10
The direct effect relationships between selective demographic factors
towards perceived on their own working attitude
Xl
ABSTRACT
EXAMINING GENERATIONAL DlFFERE CES BETWEEN
BABY BOOMERS Al1D GENERATIO N XS WORK ATTITUDES OF
AUTHE TIClTY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE OF LECTURERS
IN A MALA YSIAN PUBLIC INSTITuTE OF HIGHER EDUCATION
Farrah NoorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfasn
This study aims to identify the generational differences betw~cn Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitudes by using the Kaleidoscope Career
Model in the d imensions of au thenticity balance and cha llenge among lec turers in
a Malays ian Public Inst itute of Higher Educat ion A quantitati ve descriptive
research was adopted and used as a tool to co llect the data The in strument used
was the self-administered questionnaire that was adopted from the previous
researchers Prior to the actual data the validated questionnaires were then
distributed to the actu a l respondents which were the lecturers in the entire faculty
in Universiti Malaysia Sarawak and Universiti Teknologi Mara The sample of
this study was 270 To answer the first re search question the researcher used
Pearson and spea rman corre lation The analysis of mann-whitney u-test and
independent samples t-test was perfonning to compare the means of Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs by using the software Statistica l Package for Social
Sciences (SPSS) 170 version A significance difference was found in th e
comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving their own needs of
authenticity and ba lance in work attitude But it was that there was no significance
difference in the comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving
their own needs of cha llenge in work attitude
xi i
ABSTRAK
MENGENALPASTI PERBEZAAN ANTARA GENERASI BABY BOOMER
DAN GENERASI X BERKAlTAN SIKAP KERJA DARl DIMENSI KEASLlAN
KESEIMBANGAN DAN CABARAN KAJIAN MENGENAI PENSYARAH DI
PUSAT PENGAJIAN TINGGI AWAM DI MALAYSIA
Farrah NoorNajwa Be Mohamad Afasni
Penyelidikan ini berlujuan untuk mengenalpasti perbezaan generasi anara Baby
Boomer dan Gfnerasi X dengan menggunakan Model Kerjaya Kaleidoskop dalam
dimensi keaslian keseimbangan dan cabaran diantara pensyarah di Intilut
Pengajian Tinggi Awam di Malaysia Sebuah kajian deskriptif kuantitatf
diadaptasikan dan digunakan sebagai medium untuk mengumpul data Medium
yang digunakan adalah sel[administered questionnaire yang diodapcosikan dari
pengkaji yang sebelumnya Bag data sebenar soalan kajian kemudian diagihkan
kepada respondent iaitu pensyarah di selunch fakulti di Unversit Malaysia
Sarawak dan Unive rsiti Teknologi Mara Sample kajian ini adalah sebanyak 270
Untuk menjawab soalan kajian yang pertama penyelidik menggunakan Korelasi
Pearson dan Korelasi Spearman Analisis Mann-Whitney U-test dan Independent
Sample T-test digunakan untuk membandingkan sikap kerja dianara Generasi
Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dengan menggunakan Software Statistical Package
Sosial (SPSS) versi 170 Satu perbezaan yang signifikan ditemui pada
perbandingan Generas Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dalam keaslian dan
keseimbangan dalam sikap kerfa Namun tiada perbezaan yang signifikan
dikenalpasti diantara Baby Boomers dan Generasi X dalam cabaran dalam
keperluan sikap kerjo mereka
xiii
CHAJTER 1
I NTRODD CTI ON
10 introd uc tion
This chapter describes the background of the study statement of problem
general and specific objecti ves the conceptual framework used and th e
significance of the study This chapter also gives more detail s about the
limitations and the scope of this stud y for theoretical and contributions The
definitions of terms are al so covered to give clear information and deepen the
understanding of readers in this research
1
11 Background of study
Current career patterns are still influenced by the traditional career model
whi ch limit many women and force them to adapt to thi s model T he result of
such approach is the unequal access of women towards development of their
career when compared to men This has its implicat ions in pers istence o f the
sectora l and occ upational separation
M uch has been written in the popular press about the clash between Baby
Boome rs and members of Generation X For instance Business Week has
featured sto ries such as The reasons why Generat ion X a re unhappy at work
which suggests that Boomer managers do not understand what motivates their
Generation X employees (Erickson 2005) Fortune has reported on how
Generation X feel cannot get ahead because of the grey ceiling created by
Boomers who will not retire (Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Time magazine
fea tured a cover story about Generation X that lamen ted they just wont up
(Grossman L 2005) while illustrating also that the generation gap is not just a
western phenomenon with its story on Chinas me generati on (Simon 2007)
Soc iety for Human Resource Management in the year of 2004 stated that s imilar
reports of how the generation gap between Baby Boomers and Generation X has
caused inc reased workplace conflict
There is a potential difference in the ca reer needs o f Baby Boomers and
Gene rati on X the two generations that dominate todays western wo rkp lace
(S ulli van 1999) It has been suggested that the root of the conflic ts between Baby
Boomers and Generation X is that these two generations differed in th e ir atti tudes
toward s work-non-work balance the desire for challenging work and differences
in the meaning of work (CalJanan and Greenhaus 2008 Hankin 2004) Bahy
Boomers are often viewed as workaholics wh o thrive on increas in g work
chall enge whereby Generation X are seen as placing a high er va lue on balance to
the po int of being perceived as slackers While popular press has devoted
considerable attention to how the interaction of members from these different
2
ge nerations may have important implicati ons for current workplace dynamics and
practices (Zemke et a l 2000)
12 Problem statement
Today the workforce is dominated by two generat ions which are the Baby
Boomers born between 1945 and 1964 and the Generation X born betwee n year
1965 and J979 (Loomis 2000) A third generation is entering the workforce
Genera tion Y or the Internet Generation the eldest of whom just turned 26
For many managing an emerging work force containing re tirin g Roomers
Gene rati on X and newly entering Generation Y wiiJ be a cha llenge About 76
million Americans were born between 1946 and 1964 (Rakoff 200 1) In 2010 the
youngest of Baby Boomers is 27 and the oldest 45 years old By their sheer size
th ese Baby Boomers defined and redefined work for the last quarter of the 20th
century (Joyner 2000) As the oldest Baby Boomers retire it affects the di versity
of the labour force overall econom y certain occupations and indus tri es Th is has
a direct impact on th e economys capacity to produce goods and services
Understanding mOre fully what traits or behaviours seem to be associated with
how each baby boo mers and Generation X perce ives effective leadership will onl y
be beneficial eas ing the trans ition as one group leaves and the othe r re places it
(Miller 2005)
The work characteristics of Baby Boomers and Generation X are different
in many respects and this difference can be ex plained by many factors such as the
differences in li ving environments when the va lues of these ge nerations were
form ed The most consistent finding in th e literature when comparisons of work
charac teristics are made between Generation X and Baby Boomers is that each
ge nerational group exh ibits a different mixture o f lifesty lc values a nd work ethics
T he Baby Boomers tend to work hard and are genera lly loya l to the ir employer In
contrast work values for the Generation X emphasise personal sati sfaction rather
than just working hard
3
Beside the ir work values Shu ( 1998) indicated that Generation X has
broke n the traditi onal Mas low hi erarchy needs rule and cha ll enged indi vidual
development progress Baby Boomers have te nded to fo llow their indi vidual
development progress starting from education ca reer marr iage promoti on and
this has moved the m towards selfmiddot achievement Generation X squeezes the
process together They need self achi evement from their job and bas ic needs at the
same time and they do not want the ir work to impac t negative ly on their quality of
life Baby Boomers have had to work in a ll three phases of a progressive economy
and therefore have had to adapt from be in g predominantly indust rial workers that
is undertaking predominantl y industr ia l work to service workers and now to
know ledge workers On the other hand Generat ion X entered the workforce
around 1985 ass umin g that they commenced employme nt in their late teens and
have onl y ever experi enced a predominan tly service economy with training
prog rams during the ir careers orie nted to deli ver the skills
The big worry here is Erickson (2005) stated that most of Generation X
were unhappy at wo rk beca use of the ir Boomer manage rs do not understand what
motivates their Gene ration X employees Generation X also felt that they cannot
get ahead because of the grey ce il ing c reated by Boomer who will not retire
(Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Em ployers have been unable to determine whether
generational membership directly im pacts career moti vation and caree r decision s
So it is crucial to study the differences of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs work
attitude for Human Resource Person in orde r to understand the ir beha viour and
avo id contli ct in each and every organisat ion
T hi s lack of understanding has presented some c ha llenges for bus iness
leaders to meet the needs o f a multigenerational workforce The re fo re the
problem is that while continued generational di vers ity is obvious in workforce
there is insufficient knowledge ab out di ffe rences in career motivation and work
attitude between the cohorts Addressing this problem may increase organiza tional
leaders generational competence as they fonnulate recruitment and retention
strategies that support generation differences As the previous study was
4
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
PKH10MAT MAKLUMAT AKAOEMIK Pual Khdmal Ma~ Iwo ~ I I~ I UNIHISITI MALAYSI tK
III 1II IIimII 11111 1111 1000224362
EXAMINING GENERATIO AL DlFFERENCES BETWEEN BABY BOOMERS AND GENERATION XS WORK ATTITUDES OF
AUTHENTICITY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE STUDY OF LECTURERS IN A MALAYSIAN PUBLIC L~STITUTE OF roGHER
EDUCATION
FARRAH NOORNAJW A BT MOHAMAD ALFASN I
This project is submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for a Bachelor of Sc ience with Honours (Human Resou rce Development)
Facu lty of Cognitive Sciences and Human Development UNIVERSITI lvlALAYSIA SARAW AK
(2011)
The project entitled Examining generational differences between baby boomers and generation XS work attitudes of authenticity balance and challenge a case of lecturers in a Malaysian Public [nsitute of Higher Education was prepared by Farrah NoorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfasni and submitted to the Faculty of Cognitive Sciences and Human Development in partial fulfillment of the requirements for a Bachelor of Science with Honours (Human Resource Development)
Received for examination by
(FA
Date
4 5 ~)(T11 -------------- ---~-------- -----------
Gred
11
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First of all I am grateful to God for the blessings and grace this project can be completed successfully
J would like to ex press my appreciation to my supportive supervisor Madam Farida bt Abdul Halim on her guidance time advice and constructive critics through out this project
A big ap preciation is also given to a ll the faculties at the University Malaysia Sarawak and Un iversi ti Teknologi Mara Kota Samarahan for giving me permission to conduct a study on the faculty Special thanks given to the Department of Statistics of Sarawak for thei r cooperation and permission in obtaining some information for this project Not fo rgetting the De partment of Human Resources of University Ma laysia Sarawak espec ially to Miss Masni Masri who have been involved and cooperate in the process of co llecting data for sampling I al so would like to say thank you to Encik Moham ad from Universiti Teknologi Mara Kota Samarahan who gave me guidance and sacrificed his precious time when I was at the data collection stage
Great thanks to friends of the many colleagues who helped provide informa tion and guidance to ensure that the project is carried out properl y It is bliss for knowi ng all of you and be part of my life Special appreciation goes to my mentor Encik Abg lzhar a ll lectu rers and staffs of Facul ty of Cogn itive Sciences and Human Development and others who direc tl y and indirectl y ass ist me throughout the preparation and completion of this project Thank you very much
Finally a specia l appreciation and thanks to my loved ones especia lly to my mother and father brothers and sister who giv es me a lot of encouragement and en thusiasm for thi s project Thank you for your prayer love care an d unstoppab le support
For all those involved directly and indirectly in this project thank you aga in and may God Almighty always bless you
iii
~1 Khidmut 1a~lumnt Akacl middot1
SITJ M l IV Mi ltAr
TABLE OF CO TENTS
Acknowledgements Table of Contents List ofTables List of Figures Abstract Abstrak
CHAPTER 1 - INTROD
Page
Ul
VI
viii Xl
xu XUI
CTION
10 Introduclion I ll Background of the study 2 l2 Problem statement 2 13 Research questions 5 14 Obj ectives of the study 5
14 1 General objective 5 14 2 Specific objectives 5
15 Conceptual framework 6 16 Hypothesis 6 17 Definition of tenns 7
17 1 Work attitude 7 17 11 Authenticity 7 1712 Balance 8 1713 Challenge 8
l8 Significance of the study 8 18 1 Theoritical contribution 8 182 Robustness of research methodology 8 l8 3 Practical contribution 9
l9 Limitation of study 10 110 Conclusion 10
CHAPTER 2 - LITERATURE REVIEW
20 Introduction II 21 Context for the study (Empirical study) 12
2 11 Baby Boomers Generation 12 212 Generation Xs 13 213 Employment situasion in Malaysia 14
IV
22
23
24
CHAPTER 3
30 31 32 33
34
35 36 37
38
Review of related theories 221 Generational theories 222 Kaleidoscope career model 223 Generational research
2231 Baby Boomer 2231 Generation X
Generational differences in work attitude 231 Previous research on generational differences
An examination of work values and generational gaps in the hospitality workforce
232 Previous research on generational differences Revisiting generational work va lues for the new millennium 2321 The relationship between age and wo rk values and
work attitude Conclusion
- METHODOLOGY
Introduction Research des ign Population and sample Instrument development 331 Section A 33 2 Section B Validity 341 Reliab ility Actual survey Data collection Data Analysis Technique 371 Descrip tive statistics 372 Inferential statistics
3721 Data Screening 3722 Pearson Correlation Anal ys is 3723 Spearman Correlation 3724 Independent sample T-test 3725 Mann-Whitney U-test
Swnmary
v
15 15 17 18 18 20 21 21
22
23
24
2S 26 27 31 31 32 33 33 34 34 35 3S 35 36 36 36 37 38 38
CHAPTER 4 - FINDINGS
40 Introduction 40 41 Demographic Characteri st ics 41
411 Gender 41 412 Generational Differences 42 413 Highest Education level 43 414 Percentage of time in using computer at work 44
42 Data Screening Test Results 46 43 Reliability Test Results 48 44 Research Question Testing 49
441 Authenticity 49 442 Balance 50 443 Challenge 51
45 Hypotheses Testing Using Mann-Whitney U-test 52 451 Authenticity 52 452 Balance S3
46 Hypothesis Testing Using Independent sample T- test 55 46 1 Challenge 55
47 Summary of the findings in the study 58 48 Conclusion 59
CHAPTER 5 - SUMMARY DISCttSSION IMPLI CATION RECOMMENDATlOl( AND CONCLUSION
50 51 52
53
54
55
APPENDIX
Introducti on 60 Summary of the research 61 Discussions 63 521 Authenticity 63 522 Balance 63 523 Challenge 65 Implications of the study 66 531 Implications to theory 66 532 Implications to Human Resource Practiti oners 66 Recommendations 65 54 1 Human Resource Practitioners 67 542 Future Researchers 69 Conclusion 70
References 71 Appendix 76
Vj
LIST OF TABLES
Table 321
Number of lecturers according to the generational differences
(Universiti Malaysia Sarawak) 28
Table 322
Number oflecturers according to the generational differences
(Universiti Teknologi Mara) 29
Table 332
Likert-Scale 30
Table 3723
Description of PearsonSpearman Correlation Value 37
Table 3725
Classifications of effect s ize value r 38
Table 381
The summary table of types of statistical analysis used to analyzed each variable 39
Table 382
The summary table of types of statistical analysis used to analyzed each
hypothesis 39
Table 411
Distribution of respondents by gender 41
vl
Table 4111
Distribution of respondents by Gender according two different generation 42
Table 412
Distribut ion of respondents by Generational Differences 43
Ta ble 413
Distribution of respondents by their Highest Education Level 43
Table 4131
Distribution of respondents by Generational Differences according to their
Highest Education Level 44
Table 414
Distribution of respondents by Pe(centage of time in using computer at
work according to Generational Differences 45
Table 42
Data Screening test result 46
Table 421
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 422
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 43
Lists of Reliability test result 48
Vlll
49
Result of Spearman Correlation for the Relationship between Baby Boomers
and Generation Xs work amptitude in dimension of Authenticity
Result ofSpeannan Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Balance 50
Result of Pearson Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Challenge 5
Result of Mann-Whitney U-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Authenticity 52
Statistics for Authenticity
Result of Mann-Whitney C-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Balance 53
Statistics for Balance 54
Result of Independent sample Tmiddottest for the Difference between
IX
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Challenge 5S
Table 4611
Result of Independent sample T -test for Differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for challenge 56
Table 471
Summary of findings 58
Table 472
Summary of hypotheses result testing 59
x
6
LIST OF FIGURE
Figure 10
The direct effect relationships between selective demographic factors
towards perceived on their own working attitude
Xl
ABSTRACT
EXAMINING GENERATIONAL DlFFERE CES BETWEEN
BABY BOOMERS Al1D GENERATIO N XS WORK ATTITUDES OF
AUTHE TIClTY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE OF LECTURERS
IN A MALA YSIAN PUBLIC INSTITuTE OF HIGHER EDUCATION
Farrah NoorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfasn
This study aims to identify the generational differences betw~cn Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitudes by using the Kaleidoscope Career
Model in the d imensions of au thenticity balance and cha llenge among lec turers in
a Malays ian Public Inst itute of Higher Educat ion A quantitati ve descriptive
research was adopted and used as a tool to co llect the data The in strument used
was the self-administered questionnaire that was adopted from the previous
researchers Prior to the actual data the validated questionnaires were then
distributed to the actu a l respondents which were the lecturers in the entire faculty
in Universiti Malaysia Sarawak and Universiti Teknologi Mara The sample of
this study was 270 To answer the first re search question the researcher used
Pearson and spea rman corre lation The analysis of mann-whitney u-test and
independent samples t-test was perfonning to compare the means of Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs by using the software Statistica l Package for Social
Sciences (SPSS) 170 version A significance difference was found in th e
comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving their own needs of
authenticity and ba lance in work attitude But it was that there was no significance
difference in the comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving
their own needs of cha llenge in work attitude
xi i
ABSTRAK
MENGENALPASTI PERBEZAAN ANTARA GENERASI BABY BOOMER
DAN GENERASI X BERKAlTAN SIKAP KERJA DARl DIMENSI KEASLlAN
KESEIMBANGAN DAN CABARAN KAJIAN MENGENAI PENSYARAH DI
PUSAT PENGAJIAN TINGGI AWAM DI MALAYSIA
Farrah NoorNajwa Be Mohamad Afasni
Penyelidikan ini berlujuan untuk mengenalpasti perbezaan generasi anara Baby
Boomer dan Gfnerasi X dengan menggunakan Model Kerjaya Kaleidoskop dalam
dimensi keaslian keseimbangan dan cabaran diantara pensyarah di Intilut
Pengajian Tinggi Awam di Malaysia Sebuah kajian deskriptif kuantitatf
diadaptasikan dan digunakan sebagai medium untuk mengumpul data Medium
yang digunakan adalah sel[administered questionnaire yang diodapcosikan dari
pengkaji yang sebelumnya Bag data sebenar soalan kajian kemudian diagihkan
kepada respondent iaitu pensyarah di selunch fakulti di Unversit Malaysia
Sarawak dan Unive rsiti Teknologi Mara Sample kajian ini adalah sebanyak 270
Untuk menjawab soalan kajian yang pertama penyelidik menggunakan Korelasi
Pearson dan Korelasi Spearman Analisis Mann-Whitney U-test dan Independent
Sample T-test digunakan untuk membandingkan sikap kerja dianara Generasi
Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dengan menggunakan Software Statistical Package
Sosial (SPSS) versi 170 Satu perbezaan yang signifikan ditemui pada
perbandingan Generas Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dalam keaslian dan
keseimbangan dalam sikap kerfa Namun tiada perbezaan yang signifikan
dikenalpasti diantara Baby Boomers dan Generasi X dalam cabaran dalam
keperluan sikap kerjo mereka
xiii
CHAJTER 1
I NTRODD CTI ON
10 introd uc tion
This chapter describes the background of the study statement of problem
general and specific objecti ves the conceptual framework used and th e
significance of the study This chapter also gives more detail s about the
limitations and the scope of this stud y for theoretical and contributions The
definitions of terms are al so covered to give clear information and deepen the
understanding of readers in this research
1
11 Background of study
Current career patterns are still influenced by the traditional career model
whi ch limit many women and force them to adapt to thi s model T he result of
such approach is the unequal access of women towards development of their
career when compared to men This has its implicat ions in pers istence o f the
sectora l and occ upational separation
M uch has been written in the popular press about the clash between Baby
Boome rs and members of Generation X For instance Business Week has
featured sto ries such as The reasons why Generat ion X a re unhappy at work
which suggests that Boomer managers do not understand what motivates their
Generation X employees (Erickson 2005) Fortune has reported on how
Generation X feel cannot get ahead because of the grey ceiling created by
Boomers who will not retire (Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Time magazine
fea tured a cover story about Generation X that lamen ted they just wont up
(Grossman L 2005) while illustrating also that the generation gap is not just a
western phenomenon with its story on Chinas me generati on (Simon 2007)
Soc iety for Human Resource Management in the year of 2004 stated that s imilar
reports of how the generation gap between Baby Boomers and Generation X has
caused inc reased workplace conflict
There is a potential difference in the ca reer needs o f Baby Boomers and
Gene rati on X the two generations that dominate todays western wo rkp lace
(S ulli van 1999) It has been suggested that the root of the conflic ts between Baby
Boomers and Generation X is that these two generations differed in th e ir atti tudes
toward s work-non-work balance the desire for challenging work and differences
in the meaning of work (CalJanan and Greenhaus 2008 Hankin 2004) Bahy
Boomers are often viewed as workaholics wh o thrive on increas in g work
chall enge whereby Generation X are seen as placing a high er va lue on balance to
the po int of being perceived as slackers While popular press has devoted
considerable attention to how the interaction of members from these different
2
ge nerations may have important implicati ons for current workplace dynamics and
practices (Zemke et a l 2000)
12 Problem statement
Today the workforce is dominated by two generat ions which are the Baby
Boomers born between 1945 and 1964 and the Generation X born betwee n year
1965 and J979 (Loomis 2000) A third generation is entering the workforce
Genera tion Y or the Internet Generation the eldest of whom just turned 26
For many managing an emerging work force containing re tirin g Roomers
Gene rati on X and newly entering Generation Y wiiJ be a cha llenge About 76
million Americans were born between 1946 and 1964 (Rakoff 200 1) In 2010 the
youngest of Baby Boomers is 27 and the oldest 45 years old By their sheer size
th ese Baby Boomers defined and redefined work for the last quarter of the 20th
century (Joyner 2000) As the oldest Baby Boomers retire it affects the di versity
of the labour force overall econom y certain occupations and indus tri es Th is has
a direct impact on th e economys capacity to produce goods and services
Understanding mOre fully what traits or behaviours seem to be associated with
how each baby boo mers and Generation X perce ives effective leadership will onl y
be beneficial eas ing the trans ition as one group leaves and the othe r re places it
(Miller 2005)
The work characteristics of Baby Boomers and Generation X are different
in many respects and this difference can be ex plained by many factors such as the
differences in li ving environments when the va lues of these ge nerations were
form ed The most consistent finding in th e literature when comparisons of work
charac teristics are made between Generation X and Baby Boomers is that each
ge nerational group exh ibits a different mixture o f lifesty lc values a nd work ethics
T he Baby Boomers tend to work hard and are genera lly loya l to the ir employer In
contrast work values for the Generation X emphasise personal sati sfaction rather
than just working hard
3
Beside the ir work values Shu ( 1998) indicated that Generation X has
broke n the traditi onal Mas low hi erarchy needs rule and cha ll enged indi vidual
development progress Baby Boomers have te nded to fo llow their indi vidual
development progress starting from education ca reer marr iage promoti on and
this has moved the m towards selfmiddot achievement Generation X squeezes the
process together They need self achi evement from their job and bas ic needs at the
same time and they do not want the ir work to impac t negative ly on their quality of
life Baby Boomers have had to work in a ll three phases of a progressive economy
and therefore have had to adapt from be in g predominantly indust rial workers that
is undertaking predominantl y industr ia l work to service workers and now to
know ledge workers On the other hand Generat ion X entered the workforce
around 1985 ass umin g that they commenced employme nt in their late teens and
have onl y ever experi enced a predominan tly service economy with training
prog rams during the ir careers orie nted to deli ver the skills
The big worry here is Erickson (2005) stated that most of Generation X
were unhappy at wo rk beca use of the ir Boomer manage rs do not understand what
motivates their Gene ration X employees Generation X also felt that they cannot
get ahead because of the grey ce il ing c reated by Boomer who will not retire
(Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Em ployers have been unable to determine whether
generational membership directly im pacts career moti vation and caree r decision s
So it is crucial to study the differences of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs work
attitude for Human Resource Person in orde r to understand the ir beha viour and
avo id contli ct in each and every organisat ion
T hi s lack of understanding has presented some c ha llenges for bus iness
leaders to meet the needs o f a multigenerational workforce The re fo re the
problem is that while continued generational di vers ity is obvious in workforce
there is insufficient knowledge ab out di ffe rences in career motivation and work
attitude between the cohorts Addressing this problem may increase organiza tional
leaders generational competence as they fonnulate recruitment and retention
strategies that support generation differences As the previous study was
4
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
The project entitled Examining generational differences between baby boomers and generation XS work attitudes of authenticity balance and challenge a case of lecturers in a Malaysian Public [nsitute of Higher Education was prepared by Farrah NoorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfasni and submitted to the Faculty of Cognitive Sciences and Human Development in partial fulfillment of the requirements for a Bachelor of Science with Honours (Human Resource Development)
Received for examination by
(FA
Date
4 5 ~)(T11 -------------- ---~-------- -----------
Gred
11
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First of all I am grateful to God for the blessings and grace this project can be completed successfully
J would like to ex press my appreciation to my supportive supervisor Madam Farida bt Abdul Halim on her guidance time advice and constructive critics through out this project
A big ap preciation is also given to a ll the faculties at the University Malaysia Sarawak and Un iversi ti Teknologi Mara Kota Samarahan for giving me permission to conduct a study on the faculty Special thanks given to the Department of Statistics of Sarawak for thei r cooperation and permission in obtaining some information for this project Not fo rgetting the De partment of Human Resources of University Ma laysia Sarawak espec ially to Miss Masni Masri who have been involved and cooperate in the process of co llecting data for sampling I al so would like to say thank you to Encik Moham ad from Universiti Teknologi Mara Kota Samarahan who gave me guidance and sacrificed his precious time when I was at the data collection stage
Great thanks to friends of the many colleagues who helped provide informa tion and guidance to ensure that the project is carried out properl y It is bliss for knowi ng all of you and be part of my life Special appreciation goes to my mentor Encik Abg lzhar a ll lectu rers and staffs of Facul ty of Cogn itive Sciences and Human Development and others who direc tl y and indirectl y ass ist me throughout the preparation and completion of this project Thank you very much
Finally a specia l appreciation and thanks to my loved ones especia lly to my mother and father brothers and sister who giv es me a lot of encouragement and en thusiasm for thi s project Thank you for your prayer love care an d unstoppab le support
For all those involved directly and indirectly in this project thank you aga in and may God Almighty always bless you
iii
~1 Khidmut 1a~lumnt Akacl middot1
SITJ M l IV Mi ltAr
TABLE OF CO TENTS
Acknowledgements Table of Contents List ofTables List of Figures Abstract Abstrak
CHAPTER 1 - INTROD
Page
Ul
VI
viii Xl
xu XUI
CTION
10 Introduclion I ll Background of the study 2 l2 Problem statement 2 13 Research questions 5 14 Obj ectives of the study 5
14 1 General objective 5 14 2 Specific objectives 5
15 Conceptual framework 6 16 Hypothesis 6 17 Definition of tenns 7
17 1 Work attitude 7 17 11 Authenticity 7 1712 Balance 8 1713 Challenge 8
l8 Significance of the study 8 18 1 Theoritical contribution 8 182 Robustness of research methodology 8 l8 3 Practical contribution 9
l9 Limitation of study 10 110 Conclusion 10
CHAPTER 2 - LITERATURE REVIEW
20 Introduction II 21 Context for the study (Empirical study) 12
2 11 Baby Boomers Generation 12 212 Generation Xs 13 213 Employment situasion in Malaysia 14
IV
22
23
24
CHAPTER 3
30 31 32 33
34
35 36 37
38
Review of related theories 221 Generational theories 222 Kaleidoscope career model 223 Generational research
2231 Baby Boomer 2231 Generation X
Generational differences in work attitude 231 Previous research on generational differences
An examination of work values and generational gaps in the hospitality workforce
232 Previous research on generational differences Revisiting generational work va lues for the new millennium 2321 The relationship between age and wo rk values and
work attitude Conclusion
- METHODOLOGY
Introduction Research des ign Population and sample Instrument development 331 Section A 33 2 Section B Validity 341 Reliab ility Actual survey Data collection Data Analysis Technique 371 Descrip tive statistics 372 Inferential statistics
3721 Data Screening 3722 Pearson Correlation Anal ys is 3723 Spearman Correlation 3724 Independent sample T-test 3725 Mann-Whitney U-test
Swnmary
v
15 15 17 18 18 20 21 21
22
23
24
2S 26 27 31 31 32 33 33 34 34 35 3S 35 36 36 36 37 38 38
CHAPTER 4 - FINDINGS
40 Introduction 40 41 Demographic Characteri st ics 41
411 Gender 41 412 Generational Differences 42 413 Highest Education level 43 414 Percentage of time in using computer at work 44
42 Data Screening Test Results 46 43 Reliability Test Results 48 44 Research Question Testing 49
441 Authenticity 49 442 Balance 50 443 Challenge 51
45 Hypotheses Testing Using Mann-Whitney U-test 52 451 Authenticity 52 452 Balance S3
46 Hypothesis Testing Using Independent sample T- test 55 46 1 Challenge 55
47 Summary of the findings in the study 58 48 Conclusion 59
CHAPTER 5 - SUMMARY DISCttSSION IMPLI CATION RECOMMENDATlOl( AND CONCLUSION
50 51 52
53
54
55
APPENDIX
Introducti on 60 Summary of the research 61 Discussions 63 521 Authenticity 63 522 Balance 63 523 Challenge 65 Implications of the study 66 531 Implications to theory 66 532 Implications to Human Resource Practiti oners 66 Recommendations 65 54 1 Human Resource Practitioners 67 542 Future Researchers 69 Conclusion 70
References 71 Appendix 76
Vj
LIST OF TABLES
Table 321
Number of lecturers according to the generational differences
(Universiti Malaysia Sarawak) 28
Table 322
Number oflecturers according to the generational differences
(Universiti Teknologi Mara) 29
Table 332
Likert-Scale 30
Table 3723
Description of PearsonSpearman Correlation Value 37
Table 3725
Classifications of effect s ize value r 38
Table 381
The summary table of types of statistical analysis used to analyzed each variable 39
Table 382
The summary table of types of statistical analysis used to analyzed each
hypothesis 39
Table 411
Distribution of respondents by gender 41
vl
Table 4111
Distribution of respondents by Gender according two different generation 42
Table 412
Distribut ion of respondents by Generational Differences 43
Ta ble 413
Distribution of respondents by their Highest Education Level 43
Table 4131
Distribution of respondents by Generational Differences according to their
Highest Education Level 44
Table 414
Distribution of respondents by Pe(centage of time in using computer at
work according to Generational Differences 45
Table 42
Data Screening test result 46
Table 421
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 422
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 43
Lists of Reliability test result 48
Vlll
49
Result of Spearman Correlation for the Relationship between Baby Boomers
and Generation Xs work amptitude in dimension of Authenticity
Result ofSpeannan Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Balance 50
Result of Pearson Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Challenge 5
Result of Mann-Whitney U-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Authenticity 52
Statistics for Authenticity
Result of Mann-Whitney C-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Balance 53
Statistics for Balance 54
Result of Independent sample Tmiddottest for the Difference between
IX
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Challenge 5S
Table 4611
Result of Independent sample T -test for Differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for challenge 56
Table 471
Summary of findings 58
Table 472
Summary of hypotheses result testing 59
x
6
LIST OF FIGURE
Figure 10
The direct effect relationships between selective demographic factors
towards perceived on their own working attitude
Xl
ABSTRACT
EXAMINING GENERATIONAL DlFFERE CES BETWEEN
BABY BOOMERS Al1D GENERATIO N XS WORK ATTITUDES OF
AUTHE TIClTY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE OF LECTURERS
IN A MALA YSIAN PUBLIC INSTITuTE OF HIGHER EDUCATION
Farrah NoorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfasn
This study aims to identify the generational differences betw~cn Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitudes by using the Kaleidoscope Career
Model in the d imensions of au thenticity balance and cha llenge among lec turers in
a Malays ian Public Inst itute of Higher Educat ion A quantitati ve descriptive
research was adopted and used as a tool to co llect the data The in strument used
was the self-administered questionnaire that was adopted from the previous
researchers Prior to the actual data the validated questionnaires were then
distributed to the actu a l respondents which were the lecturers in the entire faculty
in Universiti Malaysia Sarawak and Universiti Teknologi Mara The sample of
this study was 270 To answer the first re search question the researcher used
Pearson and spea rman corre lation The analysis of mann-whitney u-test and
independent samples t-test was perfonning to compare the means of Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs by using the software Statistica l Package for Social
Sciences (SPSS) 170 version A significance difference was found in th e
comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving their own needs of
authenticity and ba lance in work attitude But it was that there was no significance
difference in the comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving
their own needs of cha llenge in work attitude
xi i
ABSTRAK
MENGENALPASTI PERBEZAAN ANTARA GENERASI BABY BOOMER
DAN GENERASI X BERKAlTAN SIKAP KERJA DARl DIMENSI KEASLlAN
KESEIMBANGAN DAN CABARAN KAJIAN MENGENAI PENSYARAH DI
PUSAT PENGAJIAN TINGGI AWAM DI MALAYSIA
Farrah NoorNajwa Be Mohamad Afasni
Penyelidikan ini berlujuan untuk mengenalpasti perbezaan generasi anara Baby
Boomer dan Gfnerasi X dengan menggunakan Model Kerjaya Kaleidoskop dalam
dimensi keaslian keseimbangan dan cabaran diantara pensyarah di Intilut
Pengajian Tinggi Awam di Malaysia Sebuah kajian deskriptif kuantitatf
diadaptasikan dan digunakan sebagai medium untuk mengumpul data Medium
yang digunakan adalah sel[administered questionnaire yang diodapcosikan dari
pengkaji yang sebelumnya Bag data sebenar soalan kajian kemudian diagihkan
kepada respondent iaitu pensyarah di selunch fakulti di Unversit Malaysia
Sarawak dan Unive rsiti Teknologi Mara Sample kajian ini adalah sebanyak 270
Untuk menjawab soalan kajian yang pertama penyelidik menggunakan Korelasi
Pearson dan Korelasi Spearman Analisis Mann-Whitney U-test dan Independent
Sample T-test digunakan untuk membandingkan sikap kerja dianara Generasi
Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dengan menggunakan Software Statistical Package
Sosial (SPSS) versi 170 Satu perbezaan yang signifikan ditemui pada
perbandingan Generas Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dalam keaslian dan
keseimbangan dalam sikap kerfa Namun tiada perbezaan yang signifikan
dikenalpasti diantara Baby Boomers dan Generasi X dalam cabaran dalam
keperluan sikap kerjo mereka
xiii
CHAJTER 1
I NTRODD CTI ON
10 introd uc tion
This chapter describes the background of the study statement of problem
general and specific objecti ves the conceptual framework used and th e
significance of the study This chapter also gives more detail s about the
limitations and the scope of this stud y for theoretical and contributions The
definitions of terms are al so covered to give clear information and deepen the
understanding of readers in this research
1
11 Background of study
Current career patterns are still influenced by the traditional career model
whi ch limit many women and force them to adapt to thi s model T he result of
such approach is the unequal access of women towards development of their
career when compared to men This has its implicat ions in pers istence o f the
sectora l and occ upational separation
M uch has been written in the popular press about the clash between Baby
Boome rs and members of Generation X For instance Business Week has
featured sto ries such as The reasons why Generat ion X a re unhappy at work
which suggests that Boomer managers do not understand what motivates their
Generation X employees (Erickson 2005) Fortune has reported on how
Generation X feel cannot get ahead because of the grey ceiling created by
Boomers who will not retire (Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Time magazine
fea tured a cover story about Generation X that lamen ted they just wont up
(Grossman L 2005) while illustrating also that the generation gap is not just a
western phenomenon with its story on Chinas me generati on (Simon 2007)
Soc iety for Human Resource Management in the year of 2004 stated that s imilar
reports of how the generation gap between Baby Boomers and Generation X has
caused inc reased workplace conflict
There is a potential difference in the ca reer needs o f Baby Boomers and
Gene rati on X the two generations that dominate todays western wo rkp lace
(S ulli van 1999) It has been suggested that the root of the conflic ts between Baby
Boomers and Generation X is that these two generations differed in th e ir atti tudes
toward s work-non-work balance the desire for challenging work and differences
in the meaning of work (CalJanan and Greenhaus 2008 Hankin 2004) Bahy
Boomers are often viewed as workaholics wh o thrive on increas in g work
chall enge whereby Generation X are seen as placing a high er va lue on balance to
the po int of being perceived as slackers While popular press has devoted
considerable attention to how the interaction of members from these different
2
ge nerations may have important implicati ons for current workplace dynamics and
practices (Zemke et a l 2000)
12 Problem statement
Today the workforce is dominated by two generat ions which are the Baby
Boomers born between 1945 and 1964 and the Generation X born betwee n year
1965 and J979 (Loomis 2000) A third generation is entering the workforce
Genera tion Y or the Internet Generation the eldest of whom just turned 26
For many managing an emerging work force containing re tirin g Roomers
Gene rati on X and newly entering Generation Y wiiJ be a cha llenge About 76
million Americans were born between 1946 and 1964 (Rakoff 200 1) In 2010 the
youngest of Baby Boomers is 27 and the oldest 45 years old By their sheer size
th ese Baby Boomers defined and redefined work for the last quarter of the 20th
century (Joyner 2000) As the oldest Baby Boomers retire it affects the di versity
of the labour force overall econom y certain occupations and indus tri es Th is has
a direct impact on th e economys capacity to produce goods and services
Understanding mOre fully what traits or behaviours seem to be associated with
how each baby boo mers and Generation X perce ives effective leadership will onl y
be beneficial eas ing the trans ition as one group leaves and the othe r re places it
(Miller 2005)
The work characteristics of Baby Boomers and Generation X are different
in many respects and this difference can be ex plained by many factors such as the
differences in li ving environments when the va lues of these ge nerations were
form ed The most consistent finding in th e literature when comparisons of work
charac teristics are made between Generation X and Baby Boomers is that each
ge nerational group exh ibits a different mixture o f lifesty lc values a nd work ethics
T he Baby Boomers tend to work hard and are genera lly loya l to the ir employer In
contrast work values for the Generation X emphasise personal sati sfaction rather
than just working hard
3
Beside the ir work values Shu ( 1998) indicated that Generation X has
broke n the traditi onal Mas low hi erarchy needs rule and cha ll enged indi vidual
development progress Baby Boomers have te nded to fo llow their indi vidual
development progress starting from education ca reer marr iage promoti on and
this has moved the m towards selfmiddot achievement Generation X squeezes the
process together They need self achi evement from their job and bas ic needs at the
same time and they do not want the ir work to impac t negative ly on their quality of
life Baby Boomers have had to work in a ll three phases of a progressive economy
and therefore have had to adapt from be in g predominantly indust rial workers that
is undertaking predominantl y industr ia l work to service workers and now to
know ledge workers On the other hand Generat ion X entered the workforce
around 1985 ass umin g that they commenced employme nt in their late teens and
have onl y ever experi enced a predominan tly service economy with training
prog rams during the ir careers orie nted to deli ver the skills
The big worry here is Erickson (2005) stated that most of Generation X
were unhappy at wo rk beca use of the ir Boomer manage rs do not understand what
motivates their Gene ration X employees Generation X also felt that they cannot
get ahead because of the grey ce il ing c reated by Boomer who will not retire
(Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Em ployers have been unable to determine whether
generational membership directly im pacts career moti vation and caree r decision s
So it is crucial to study the differences of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs work
attitude for Human Resource Person in orde r to understand the ir beha viour and
avo id contli ct in each and every organisat ion
T hi s lack of understanding has presented some c ha llenges for bus iness
leaders to meet the needs o f a multigenerational workforce The re fo re the
problem is that while continued generational di vers ity is obvious in workforce
there is insufficient knowledge ab out di ffe rences in career motivation and work
attitude between the cohorts Addressing this problem may increase organiza tional
leaders generational competence as they fonnulate recruitment and retention
strategies that support generation differences As the previous study was
4
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First of all I am grateful to God for the blessings and grace this project can be completed successfully
J would like to ex press my appreciation to my supportive supervisor Madam Farida bt Abdul Halim on her guidance time advice and constructive critics through out this project
A big ap preciation is also given to a ll the faculties at the University Malaysia Sarawak and Un iversi ti Teknologi Mara Kota Samarahan for giving me permission to conduct a study on the faculty Special thanks given to the Department of Statistics of Sarawak for thei r cooperation and permission in obtaining some information for this project Not fo rgetting the De partment of Human Resources of University Ma laysia Sarawak espec ially to Miss Masni Masri who have been involved and cooperate in the process of co llecting data for sampling I al so would like to say thank you to Encik Moham ad from Universiti Teknologi Mara Kota Samarahan who gave me guidance and sacrificed his precious time when I was at the data collection stage
Great thanks to friends of the many colleagues who helped provide informa tion and guidance to ensure that the project is carried out properl y It is bliss for knowi ng all of you and be part of my life Special appreciation goes to my mentor Encik Abg lzhar a ll lectu rers and staffs of Facul ty of Cogn itive Sciences and Human Development and others who direc tl y and indirectl y ass ist me throughout the preparation and completion of this project Thank you very much
Finally a specia l appreciation and thanks to my loved ones especia lly to my mother and father brothers and sister who giv es me a lot of encouragement and en thusiasm for thi s project Thank you for your prayer love care an d unstoppab le support
For all those involved directly and indirectly in this project thank you aga in and may God Almighty always bless you
iii
~1 Khidmut 1a~lumnt Akacl middot1
SITJ M l IV Mi ltAr
TABLE OF CO TENTS
Acknowledgements Table of Contents List ofTables List of Figures Abstract Abstrak
CHAPTER 1 - INTROD
Page
Ul
VI
viii Xl
xu XUI
CTION
10 Introduclion I ll Background of the study 2 l2 Problem statement 2 13 Research questions 5 14 Obj ectives of the study 5
14 1 General objective 5 14 2 Specific objectives 5
15 Conceptual framework 6 16 Hypothesis 6 17 Definition of tenns 7
17 1 Work attitude 7 17 11 Authenticity 7 1712 Balance 8 1713 Challenge 8
l8 Significance of the study 8 18 1 Theoritical contribution 8 182 Robustness of research methodology 8 l8 3 Practical contribution 9
l9 Limitation of study 10 110 Conclusion 10
CHAPTER 2 - LITERATURE REVIEW
20 Introduction II 21 Context for the study (Empirical study) 12
2 11 Baby Boomers Generation 12 212 Generation Xs 13 213 Employment situasion in Malaysia 14
IV
22
23
24
CHAPTER 3
30 31 32 33
34
35 36 37
38
Review of related theories 221 Generational theories 222 Kaleidoscope career model 223 Generational research
2231 Baby Boomer 2231 Generation X
Generational differences in work attitude 231 Previous research on generational differences
An examination of work values and generational gaps in the hospitality workforce
232 Previous research on generational differences Revisiting generational work va lues for the new millennium 2321 The relationship between age and wo rk values and
work attitude Conclusion
- METHODOLOGY
Introduction Research des ign Population and sample Instrument development 331 Section A 33 2 Section B Validity 341 Reliab ility Actual survey Data collection Data Analysis Technique 371 Descrip tive statistics 372 Inferential statistics
3721 Data Screening 3722 Pearson Correlation Anal ys is 3723 Spearman Correlation 3724 Independent sample T-test 3725 Mann-Whitney U-test
Swnmary
v
15 15 17 18 18 20 21 21
22
23
24
2S 26 27 31 31 32 33 33 34 34 35 3S 35 36 36 36 37 38 38
CHAPTER 4 - FINDINGS
40 Introduction 40 41 Demographic Characteri st ics 41
411 Gender 41 412 Generational Differences 42 413 Highest Education level 43 414 Percentage of time in using computer at work 44
42 Data Screening Test Results 46 43 Reliability Test Results 48 44 Research Question Testing 49
441 Authenticity 49 442 Balance 50 443 Challenge 51
45 Hypotheses Testing Using Mann-Whitney U-test 52 451 Authenticity 52 452 Balance S3
46 Hypothesis Testing Using Independent sample T- test 55 46 1 Challenge 55
47 Summary of the findings in the study 58 48 Conclusion 59
CHAPTER 5 - SUMMARY DISCttSSION IMPLI CATION RECOMMENDATlOl( AND CONCLUSION
50 51 52
53
54
55
APPENDIX
Introducti on 60 Summary of the research 61 Discussions 63 521 Authenticity 63 522 Balance 63 523 Challenge 65 Implications of the study 66 531 Implications to theory 66 532 Implications to Human Resource Practiti oners 66 Recommendations 65 54 1 Human Resource Practitioners 67 542 Future Researchers 69 Conclusion 70
References 71 Appendix 76
Vj
LIST OF TABLES
Table 321
Number of lecturers according to the generational differences
(Universiti Malaysia Sarawak) 28
Table 322
Number oflecturers according to the generational differences
(Universiti Teknologi Mara) 29
Table 332
Likert-Scale 30
Table 3723
Description of PearsonSpearman Correlation Value 37
Table 3725
Classifications of effect s ize value r 38
Table 381
The summary table of types of statistical analysis used to analyzed each variable 39
Table 382
The summary table of types of statistical analysis used to analyzed each
hypothesis 39
Table 411
Distribution of respondents by gender 41
vl
Table 4111
Distribution of respondents by Gender according two different generation 42
Table 412
Distribut ion of respondents by Generational Differences 43
Ta ble 413
Distribution of respondents by their Highest Education Level 43
Table 4131
Distribution of respondents by Generational Differences according to their
Highest Education Level 44
Table 414
Distribution of respondents by Pe(centage of time in using computer at
work according to Generational Differences 45
Table 42
Data Screening test result 46
Table 421
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 422
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 43
Lists of Reliability test result 48
Vlll
49
Result of Spearman Correlation for the Relationship between Baby Boomers
and Generation Xs work amptitude in dimension of Authenticity
Result ofSpeannan Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Balance 50
Result of Pearson Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Challenge 5
Result of Mann-Whitney U-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Authenticity 52
Statistics for Authenticity
Result of Mann-Whitney C-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Balance 53
Statistics for Balance 54
Result of Independent sample Tmiddottest for the Difference between
IX
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Challenge 5S
Table 4611
Result of Independent sample T -test for Differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for challenge 56
Table 471
Summary of findings 58
Table 472
Summary of hypotheses result testing 59
x
6
LIST OF FIGURE
Figure 10
The direct effect relationships between selective demographic factors
towards perceived on their own working attitude
Xl
ABSTRACT
EXAMINING GENERATIONAL DlFFERE CES BETWEEN
BABY BOOMERS Al1D GENERATIO N XS WORK ATTITUDES OF
AUTHE TIClTY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE OF LECTURERS
IN A MALA YSIAN PUBLIC INSTITuTE OF HIGHER EDUCATION
Farrah NoorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfasn
This study aims to identify the generational differences betw~cn Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitudes by using the Kaleidoscope Career
Model in the d imensions of au thenticity balance and cha llenge among lec turers in
a Malays ian Public Inst itute of Higher Educat ion A quantitati ve descriptive
research was adopted and used as a tool to co llect the data The in strument used
was the self-administered questionnaire that was adopted from the previous
researchers Prior to the actual data the validated questionnaires were then
distributed to the actu a l respondents which were the lecturers in the entire faculty
in Universiti Malaysia Sarawak and Universiti Teknologi Mara The sample of
this study was 270 To answer the first re search question the researcher used
Pearson and spea rman corre lation The analysis of mann-whitney u-test and
independent samples t-test was perfonning to compare the means of Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs by using the software Statistica l Package for Social
Sciences (SPSS) 170 version A significance difference was found in th e
comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving their own needs of
authenticity and ba lance in work attitude But it was that there was no significance
difference in the comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving
their own needs of cha llenge in work attitude
xi i
ABSTRAK
MENGENALPASTI PERBEZAAN ANTARA GENERASI BABY BOOMER
DAN GENERASI X BERKAlTAN SIKAP KERJA DARl DIMENSI KEASLlAN
KESEIMBANGAN DAN CABARAN KAJIAN MENGENAI PENSYARAH DI
PUSAT PENGAJIAN TINGGI AWAM DI MALAYSIA
Farrah NoorNajwa Be Mohamad Afasni
Penyelidikan ini berlujuan untuk mengenalpasti perbezaan generasi anara Baby
Boomer dan Gfnerasi X dengan menggunakan Model Kerjaya Kaleidoskop dalam
dimensi keaslian keseimbangan dan cabaran diantara pensyarah di Intilut
Pengajian Tinggi Awam di Malaysia Sebuah kajian deskriptif kuantitatf
diadaptasikan dan digunakan sebagai medium untuk mengumpul data Medium
yang digunakan adalah sel[administered questionnaire yang diodapcosikan dari
pengkaji yang sebelumnya Bag data sebenar soalan kajian kemudian diagihkan
kepada respondent iaitu pensyarah di selunch fakulti di Unversit Malaysia
Sarawak dan Unive rsiti Teknologi Mara Sample kajian ini adalah sebanyak 270
Untuk menjawab soalan kajian yang pertama penyelidik menggunakan Korelasi
Pearson dan Korelasi Spearman Analisis Mann-Whitney U-test dan Independent
Sample T-test digunakan untuk membandingkan sikap kerja dianara Generasi
Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dengan menggunakan Software Statistical Package
Sosial (SPSS) versi 170 Satu perbezaan yang signifikan ditemui pada
perbandingan Generas Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dalam keaslian dan
keseimbangan dalam sikap kerfa Namun tiada perbezaan yang signifikan
dikenalpasti diantara Baby Boomers dan Generasi X dalam cabaran dalam
keperluan sikap kerjo mereka
xiii
CHAJTER 1
I NTRODD CTI ON
10 introd uc tion
This chapter describes the background of the study statement of problem
general and specific objecti ves the conceptual framework used and th e
significance of the study This chapter also gives more detail s about the
limitations and the scope of this stud y for theoretical and contributions The
definitions of terms are al so covered to give clear information and deepen the
understanding of readers in this research
1
11 Background of study
Current career patterns are still influenced by the traditional career model
whi ch limit many women and force them to adapt to thi s model T he result of
such approach is the unequal access of women towards development of their
career when compared to men This has its implicat ions in pers istence o f the
sectora l and occ upational separation
M uch has been written in the popular press about the clash between Baby
Boome rs and members of Generation X For instance Business Week has
featured sto ries such as The reasons why Generat ion X a re unhappy at work
which suggests that Boomer managers do not understand what motivates their
Generation X employees (Erickson 2005) Fortune has reported on how
Generation X feel cannot get ahead because of the grey ceiling created by
Boomers who will not retire (Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Time magazine
fea tured a cover story about Generation X that lamen ted they just wont up
(Grossman L 2005) while illustrating also that the generation gap is not just a
western phenomenon with its story on Chinas me generati on (Simon 2007)
Soc iety for Human Resource Management in the year of 2004 stated that s imilar
reports of how the generation gap between Baby Boomers and Generation X has
caused inc reased workplace conflict
There is a potential difference in the ca reer needs o f Baby Boomers and
Gene rati on X the two generations that dominate todays western wo rkp lace
(S ulli van 1999) It has been suggested that the root of the conflic ts between Baby
Boomers and Generation X is that these two generations differed in th e ir atti tudes
toward s work-non-work balance the desire for challenging work and differences
in the meaning of work (CalJanan and Greenhaus 2008 Hankin 2004) Bahy
Boomers are often viewed as workaholics wh o thrive on increas in g work
chall enge whereby Generation X are seen as placing a high er va lue on balance to
the po int of being perceived as slackers While popular press has devoted
considerable attention to how the interaction of members from these different
2
ge nerations may have important implicati ons for current workplace dynamics and
practices (Zemke et a l 2000)
12 Problem statement
Today the workforce is dominated by two generat ions which are the Baby
Boomers born between 1945 and 1964 and the Generation X born betwee n year
1965 and J979 (Loomis 2000) A third generation is entering the workforce
Genera tion Y or the Internet Generation the eldest of whom just turned 26
For many managing an emerging work force containing re tirin g Roomers
Gene rati on X and newly entering Generation Y wiiJ be a cha llenge About 76
million Americans were born between 1946 and 1964 (Rakoff 200 1) In 2010 the
youngest of Baby Boomers is 27 and the oldest 45 years old By their sheer size
th ese Baby Boomers defined and redefined work for the last quarter of the 20th
century (Joyner 2000) As the oldest Baby Boomers retire it affects the di versity
of the labour force overall econom y certain occupations and indus tri es Th is has
a direct impact on th e economys capacity to produce goods and services
Understanding mOre fully what traits or behaviours seem to be associated with
how each baby boo mers and Generation X perce ives effective leadership will onl y
be beneficial eas ing the trans ition as one group leaves and the othe r re places it
(Miller 2005)
The work characteristics of Baby Boomers and Generation X are different
in many respects and this difference can be ex plained by many factors such as the
differences in li ving environments when the va lues of these ge nerations were
form ed The most consistent finding in th e literature when comparisons of work
charac teristics are made between Generation X and Baby Boomers is that each
ge nerational group exh ibits a different mixture o f lifesty lc values a nd work ethics
T he Baby Boomers tend to work hard and are genera lly loya l to the ir employer In
contrast work values for the Generation X emphasise personal sati sfaction rather
than just working hard
3
Beside the ir work values Shu ( 1998) indicated that Generation X has
broke n the traditi onal Mas low hi erarchy needs rule and cha ll enged indi vidual
development progress Baby Boomers have te nded to fo llow their indi vidual
development progress starting from education ca reer marr iage promoti on and
this has moved the m towards selfmiddot achievement Generation X squeezes the
process together They need self achi evement from their job and bas ic needs at the
same time and they do not want the ir work to impac t negative ly on their quality of
life Baby Boomers have had to work in a ll three phases of a progressive economy
and therefore have had to adapt from be in g predominantly indust rial workers that
is undertaking predominantl y industr ia l work to service workers and now to
know ledge workers On the other hand Generat ion X entered the workforce
around 1985 ass umin g that they commenced employme nt in their late teens and
have onl y ever experi enced a predominan tly service economy with training
prog rams during the ir careers orie nted to deli ver the skills
The big worry here is Erickson (2005) stated that most of Generation X
were unhappy at wo rk beca use of the ir Boomer manage rs do not understand what
motivates their Gene ration X employees Generation X also felt that they cannot
get ahead because of the grey ce il ing c reated by Boomer who will not retire
(Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Em ployers have been unable to determine whether
generational membership directly im pacts career moti vation and caree r decision s
So it is crucial to study the differences of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs work
attitude for Human Resource Person in orde r to understand the ir beha viour and
avo id contli ct in each and every organisat ion
T hi s lack of understanding has presented some c ha llenges for bus iness
leaders to meet the needs o f a multigenerational workforce The re fo re the
problem is that while continued generational di vers ity is obvious in workforce
there is insufficient knowledge ab out di ffe rences in career motivation and work
attitude between the cohorts Addressing this problem may increase organiza tional
leaders generational competence as they fonnulate recruitment and retention
strategies that support generation differences As the previous study was
4
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
~1 Khidmut 1a~lumnt Akacl middot1
SITJ M l IV Mi ltAr
TABLE OF CO TENTS
Acknowledgements Table of Contents List ofTables List of Figures Abstract Abstrak
CHAPTER 1 - INTROD
Page
Ul
VI
viii Xl
xu XUI
CTION
10 Introduclion I ll Background of the study 2 l2 Problem statement 2 13 Research questions 5 14 Obj ectives of the study 5
14 1 General objective 5 14 2 Specific objectives 5
15 Conceptual framework 6 16 Hypothesis 6 17 Definition of tenns 7
17 1 Work attitude 7 17 11 Authenticity 7 1712 Balance 8 1713 Challenge 8
l8 Significance of the study 8 18 1 Theoritical contribution 8 182 Robustness of research methodology 8 l8 3 Practical contribution 9
l9 Limitation of study 10 110 Conclusion 10
CHAPTER 2 - LITERATURE REVIEW
20 Introduction II 21 Context for the study (Empirical study) 12
2 11 Baby Boomers Generation 12 212 Generation Xs 13 213 Employment situasion in Malaysia 14
IV
22
23
24
CHAPTER 3
30 31 32 33
34
35 36 37
38
Review of related theories 221 Generational theories 222 Kaleidoscope career model 223 Generational research
2231 Baby Boomer 2231 Generation X
Generational differences in work attitude 231 Previous research on generational differences
An examination of work values and generational gaps in the hospitality workforce
232 Previous research on generational differences Revisiting generational work va lues for the new millennium 2321 The relationship between age and wo rk values and
work attitude Conclusion
- METHODOLOGY
Introduction Research des ign Population and sample Instrument development 331 Section A 33 2 Section B Validity 341 Reliab ility Actual survey Data collection Data Analysis Technique 371 Descrip tive statistics 372 Inferential statistics
3721 Data Screening 3722 Pearson Correlation Anal ys is 3723 Spearman Correlation 3724 Independent sample T-test 3725 Mann-Whitney U-test
Swnmary
v
15 15 17 18 18 20 21 21
22
23
24
2S 26 27 31 31 32 33 33 34 34 35 3S 35 36 36 36 37 38 38
CHAPTER 4 - FINDINGS
40 Introduction 40 41 Demographic Characteri st ics 41
411 Gender 41 412 Generational Differences 42 413 Highest Education level 43 414 Percentage of time in using computer at work 44
42 Data Screening Test Results 46 43 Reliability Test Results 48 44 Research Question Testing 49
441 Authenticity 49 442 Balance 50 443 Challenge 51
45 Hypotheses Testing Using Mann-Whitney U-test 52 451 Authenticity 52 452 Balance S3
46 Hypothesis Testing Using Independent sample T- test 55 46 1 Challenge 55
47 Summary of the findings in the study 58 48 Conclusion 59
CHAPTER 5 - SUMMARY DISCttSSION IMPLI CATION RECOMMENDATlOl( AND CONCLUSION
50 51 52
53
54
55
APPENDIX
Introducti on 60 Summary of the research 61 Discussions 63 521 Authenticity 63 522 Balance 63 523 Challenge 65 Implications of the study 66 531 Implications to theory 66 532 Implications to Human Resource Practiti oners 66 Recommendations 65 54 1 Human Resource Practitioners 67 542 Future Researchers 69 Conclusion 70
References 71 Appendix 76
Vj
LIST OF TABLES
Table 321
Number of lecturers according to the generational differences
(Universiti Malaysia Sarawak) 28
Table 322
Number oflecturers according to the generational differences
(Universiti Teknologi Mara) 29
Table 332
Likert-Scale 30
Table 3723
Description of PearsonSpearman Correlation Value 37
Table 3725
Classifications of effect s ize value r 38
Table 381
The summary table of types of statistical analysis used to analyzed each variable 39
Table 382
The summary table of types of statistical analysis used to analyzed each
hypothesis 39
Table 411
Distribution of respondents by gender 41
vl
Table 4111
Distribution of respondents by Gender according two different generation 42
Table 412
Distribut ion of respondents by Generational Differences 43
Ta ble 413
Distribution of respondents by their Highest Education Level 43
Table 4131
Distribution of respondents by Generational Differences according to their
Highest Education Level 44
Table 414
Distribution of respondents by Pe(centage of time in using computer at
work according to Generational Differences 45
Table 42
Data Screening test result 46
Table 421
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 422
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 43
Lists of Reliability test result 48
Vlll
49
Result of Spearman Correlation for the Relationship between Baby Boomers
and Generation Xs work amptitude in dimension of Authenticity
Result ofSpeannan Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Balance 50
Result of Pearson Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Challenge 5
Result of Mann-Whitney U-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Authenticity 52
Statistics for Authenticity
Result of Mann-Whitney C-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Balance 53
Statistics for Balance 54
Result of Independent sample Tmiddottest for the Difference between
IX
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Challenge 5S
Table 4611
Result of Independent sample T -test for Differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for challenge 56
Table 471
Summary of findings 58
Table 472
Summary of hypotheses result testing 59
x
6
LIST OF FIGURE
Figure 10
The direct effect relationships between selective demographic factors
towards perceived on their own working attitude
Xl
ABSTRACT
EXAMINING GENERATIONAL DlFFERE CES BETWEEN
BABY BOOMERS Al1D GENERATIO N XS WORK ATTITUDES OF
AUTHE TIClTY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE OF LECTURERS
IN A MALA YSIAN PUBLIC INSTITuTE OF HIGHER EDUCATION
Farrah NoorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfasn
This study aims to identify the generational differences betw~cn Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitudes by using the Kaleidoscope Career
Model in the d imensions of au thenticity balance and cha llenge among lec turers in
a Malays ian Public Inst itute of Higher Educat ion A quantitati ve descriptive
research was adopted and used as a tool to co llect the data The in strument used
was the self-administered questionnaire that was adopted from the previous
researchers Prior to the actual data the validated questionnaires were then
distributed to the actu a l respondents which were the lecturers in the entire faculty
in Universiti Malaysia Sarawak and Universiti Teknologi Mara The sample of
this study was 270 To answer the first re search question the researcher used
Pearson and spea rman corre lation The analysis of mann-whitney u-test and
independent samples t-test was perfonning to compare the means of Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs by using the software Statistica l Package for Social
Sciences (SPSS) 170 version A significance difference was found in th e
comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving their own needs of
authenticity and ba lance in work attitude But it was that there was no significance
difference in the comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving
their own needs of cha llenge in work attitude
xi i
ABSTRAK
MENGENALPASTI PERBEZAAN ANTARA GENERASI BABY BOOMER
DAN GENERASI X BERKAlTAN SIKAP KERJA DARl DIMENSI KEASLlAN
KESEIMBANGAN DAN CABARAN KAJIAN MENGENAI PENSYARAH DI
PUSAT PENGAJIAN TINGGI AWAM DI MALAYSIA
Farrah NoorNajwa Be Mohamad Afasni
Penyelidikan ini berlujuan untuk mengenalpasti perbezaan generasi anara Baby
Boomer dan Gfnerasi X dengan menggunakan Model Kerjaya Kaleidoskop dalam
dimensi keaslian keseimbangan dan cabaran diantara pensyarah di Intilut
Pengajian Tinggi Awam di Malaysia Sebuah kajian deskriptif kuantitatf
diadaptasikan dan digunakan sebagai medium untuk mengumpul data Medium
yang digunakan adalah sel[administered questionnaire yang diodapcosikan dari
pengkaji yang sebelumnya Bag data sebenar soalan kajian kemudian diagihkan
kepada respondent iaitu pensyarah di selunch fakulti di Unversit Malaysia
Sarawak dan Unive rsiti Teknologi Mara Sample kajian ini adalah sebanyak 270
Untuk menjawab soalan kajian yang pertama penyelidik menggunakan Korelasi
Pearson dan Korelasi Spearman Analisis Mann-Whitney U-test dan Independent
Sample T-test digunakan untuk membandingkan sikap kerja dianara Generasi
Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dengan menggunakan Software Statistical Package
Sosial (SPSS) versi 170 Satu perbezaan yang signifikan ditemui pada
perbandingan Generas Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dalam keaslian dan
keseimbangan dalam sikap kerfa Namun tiada perbezaan yang signifikan
dikenalpasti diantara Baby Boomers dan Generasi X dalam cabaran dalam
keperluan sikap kerjo mereka
xiii
CHAJTER 1
I NTRODD CTI ON
10 introd uc tion
This chapter describes the background of the study statement of problem
general and specific objecti ves the conceptual framework used and th e
significance of the study This chapter also gives more detail s about the
limitations and the scope of this stud y for theoretical and contributions The
definitions of terms are al so covered to give clear information and deepen the
understanding of readers in this research
1
11 Background of study
Current career patterns are still influenced by the traditional career model
whi ch limit many women and force them to adapt to thi s model T he result of
such approach is the unequal access of women towards development of their
career when compared to men This has its implicat ions in pers istence o f the
sectora l and occ upational separation
M uch has been written in the popular press about the clash between Baby
Boome rs and members of Generation X For instance Business Week has
featured sto ries such as The reasons why Generat ion X a re unhappy at work
which suggests that Boomer managers do not understand what motivates their
Generation X employees (Erickson 2005) Fortune has reported on how
Generation X feel cannot get ahead because of the grey ceiling created by
Boomers who will not retire (Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Time magazine
fea tured a cover story about Generation X that lamen ted they just wont up
(Grossman L 2005) while illustrating also that the generation gap is not just a
western phenomenon with its story on Chinas me generati on (Simon 2007)
Soc iety for Human Resource Management in the year of 2004 stated that s imilar
reports of how the generation gap between Baby Boomers and Generation X has
caused inc reased workplace conflict
There is a potential difference in the ca reer needs o f Baby Boomers and
Gene rati on X the two generations that dominate todays western wo rkp lace
(S ulli van 1999) It has been suggested that the root of the conflic ts between Baby
Boomers and Generation X is that these two generations differed in th e ir atti tudes
toward s work-non-work balance the desire for challenging work and differences
in the meaning of work (CalJanan and Greenhaus 2008 Hankin 2004) Bahy
Boomers are often viewed as workaholics wh o thrive on increas in g work
chall enge whereby Generation X are seen as placing a high er va lue on balance to
the po int of being perceived as slackers While popular press has devoted
considerable attention to how the interaction of members from these different
2
ge nerations may have important implicati ons for current workplace dynamics and
practices (Zemke et a l 2000)
12 Problem statement
Today the workforce is dominated by two generat ions which are the Baby
Boomers born between 1945 and 1964 and the Generation X born betwee n year
1965 and J979 (Loomis 2000) A third generation is entering the workforce
Genera tion Y or the Internet Generation the eldest of whom just turned 26
For many managing an emerging work force containing re tirin g Roomers
Gene rati on X and newly entering Generation Y wiiJ be a cha llenge About 76
million Americans were born between 1946 and 1964 (Rakoff 200 1) In 2010 the
youngest of Baby Boomers is 27 and the oldest 45 years old By their sheer size
th ese Baby Boomers defined and redefined work for the last quarter of the 20th
century (Joyner 2000) As the oldest Baby Boomers retire it affects the di versity
of the labour force overall econom y certain occupations and indus tri es Th is has
a direct impact on th e economys capacity to produce goods and services
Understanding mOre fully what traits or behaviours seem to be associated with
how each baby boo mers and Generation X perce ives effective leadership will onl y
be beneficial eas ing the trans ition as one group leaves and the othe r re places it
(Miller 2005)
The work characteristics of Baby Boomers and Generation X are different
in many respects and this difference can be ex plained by many factors such as the
differences in li ving environments when the va lues of these ge nerations were
form ed The most consistent finding in th e literature when comparisons of work
charac teristics are made between Generation X and Baby Boomers is that each
ge nerational group exh ibits a different mixture o f lifesty lc values a nd work ethics
T he Baby Boomers tend to work hard and are genera lly loya l to the ir employer In
contrast work values for the Generation X emphasise personal sati sfaction rather
than just working hard
3
Beside the ir work values Shu ( 1998) indicated that Generation X has
broke n the traditi onal Mas low hi erarchy needs rule and cha ll enged indi vidual
development progress Baby Boomers have te nded to fo llow their indi vidual
development progress starting from education ca reer marr iage promoti on and
this has moved the m towards selfmiddot achievement Generation X squeezes the
process together They need self achi evement from their job and bas ic needs at the
same time and they do not want the ir work to impac t negative ly on their quality of
life Baby Boomers have had to work in a ll three phases of a progressive economy
and therefore have had to adapt from be in g predominantly indust rial workers that
is undertaking predominantl y industr ia l work to service workers and now to
know ledge workers On the other hand Generat ion X entered the workforce
around 1985 ass umin g that they commenced employme nt in their late teens and
have onl y ever experi enced a predominan tly service economy with training
prog rams during the ir careers orie nted to deli ver the skills
The big worry here is Erickson (2005) stated that most of Generation X
were unhappy at wo rk beca use of the ir Boomer manage rs do not understand what
motivates their Gene ration X employees Generation X also felt that they cannot
get ahead because of the grey ce il ing c reated by Boomer who will not retire
(Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Em ployers have been unable to determine whether
generational membership directly im pacts career moti vation and caree r decision s
So it is crucial to study the differences of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs work
attitude for Human Resource Person in orde r to understand the ir beha viour and
avo id contli ct in each and every organisat ion
T hi s lack of understanding has presented some c ha llenges for bus iness
leaders to meet the needs o f a multigenerational workforce The re fo re the
problem is that while continued generational di vers ity is obvious in workforce
there is insufficient knowledge ab out di ffe rences in career motivation and work
attitude between the cohorts Addressing this problem may increase organiza tional
leaders generational competence as they fonnulate recruitment and retention
strategies that support generation differences As the previous study was
4
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
22
23
24
CHAPTER 3
30 31 32 33
34
35 36 37
38
Review of related theories 221 Generational theories 222 Kaleidoscope career model 223 Generational research
2231 Baby Boomer 2231 Generation X
Generational differences in work attitude 231 Previous research on generational differences
An examination of work values and generational gaps in the hospitality workforce
232 Previous research on generational differences Revisiting generational work va lues for the new millennium 2321 The relationship between age and wo rk values and
work attitude Conclusion
- METHODOLOGY
Introduction Research des ign Population and sample Instrument development 331 Section A 33 2 Section B Validity 341 Reliab ility Actual survey Data collection Data Analysis Technique 371 Descrip tive statistics 372 Inferential statistics
3721 Data Screening 3722 Pearson Correlation Anal ys is 3723 Spearman Correlation 3724 Independent sample T-test 3725 Mann-Whitney U-test
Swnmary
v
15 15 17 18 18 20 21 21
22
23
24
2S 26 27 31 31 32 33 33 34 34 35 3S 35 36 36 36 37 38 38
CHAPTER 4 - FINDINGS
40 Introduction 40 41 Demographic Characteri st ics 41
411 Gender 41 412 Generational Differences 42 413 Highest Education level 43 414 Percentage of time in using computer at work 44
42 Data Screening Test Results 46 43 Reliability Test Results 48 44 Research Question Testing 49
441 Authenticity 49 442 Balance 50 443 Challenge 51
45 Hypotheses Testing Using Mann-Whitney U-test 52 451 Authenticity 52 452 Balance S3
46 Hypothesis Testing Using Independent sample T- test 55 46 1 Challenge 55
47 Summary of the findings in the study 58 48 Conclusion 59
CHAPTER 5 - SUMMARY DISCttSSION IMPLI CATION RECOMMENDATlOl( AND CONCLUSION
50 51 52
53
54
55
APPENDIX
Introducti on 60 Summary of the research 61 Discussions 63 521 Authenticity 63 522 Balance 63 523 Challenge 65 Implications of the study 66 531 Implications to theory 66 532 Implications to Human Resource Practiti oners 66 Recommendations 65 54 1 Human Resource Practitioners 67 542 Future Researchers 69 Conclusion 70
References 71 Appendix 76
Vj
LIST OF TABLES
Table 321
Number of lecturers according to the generational differences
(Universiti Malaysia Sarawak) 28
Table 322
Number oflecturers according to the generational differences
(Universiti Teknologi Mara) 29
Table 332
Likert-Scale 30
Table 3723
Description of PearsonSpearman Correlation Value 37
Table 3725
Classifications of effect s ize value r 38
Table 381
The summary table of types of statistical analysis used to analyzed each variable 39
Table 382
The summary table of types of statistical analysis used to analyzed each
hypothesis 39
Table 411
Distribution of respondents by gender 41
vl
Table 4111
Distribution of respondents by Gender according two different generation 42
Table 412
Distribut ion of respondents by Generational Differences 43
Ta ble 413
Distribution of respondents by their Highest Education Level 43
Table 4131
Distribution of respondents by Generational Differences according to their
Highest Education Level 44
Table 414
Distribution of respondents by Pe(centage of time in using computer at
work according to Generational Differences 45
Table 42
Data Screening test result 46
Table 421
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 422
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 43
Lists of Reliability test result 48
Vlll
49
Result of Spearman Correlation for the Relationship between Baby Boomers
and Generation Xs work amptitude in dimension of Authenticity
Result ofSpeannan Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Balance 50
Result of Pearson Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Challenge 5
Result of Mann-Whitney U-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Authenticity 52
Statistics for Authenticity
Result of Mann-Whitney C-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Balance 53
Statistics for Balance 54
Result of Independent sample Tmiddottest for the Difference between
IX
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Challenge 5S
Table 4611
Result of Independent sample T -test for Differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for challenge 56
Table 471
Summary of findings 58
Table 472
Summary of hypotheses result testing 59
x
6
LIST OF FIGURE
Figure 10
The direct effect relationships between selective demographic factors
towards perceived on their own working attitude
Xl
ABSTRACT
EXAMINING GENERATIONAL DlFFERE CES BETWEEN
BABY BOOMERS Al1D GENERATIO N XS WORK ATTITUDES OF
AUTHE TIClTY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE OF LECTURERS
IN A MALA YSIAN PUBLIC INSTITuTE OF HIGHER EDUCATION
Farrah NoorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfasn
This study aims to identify the generational differences betw~cn Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitudes by using the Kaleidoscope Career
Model in the d imensions of au thenticity balance and cha llenge among lec turers in
a Malays ian Public Inst itute of Higher Educat ion A quantitati ve descriptive
research was adopted and used as a tool to co llect the data The in strument used
was the self-administered questionnaire that was adopted from the previous
researchers Prior to the actual data the validated questionnaires were then
distributed to the actu a l respondents which were the lecturers in the entire faculty
in Universiti Malaysia Sarawak and Universiti Teknologi Mara The sample of
this study was 270 To answer the first re search question the researcher used
Pearson and spea rman corre lation The analysis of mann-whitney u-test and
independent samples t-test was perfonning to compare the means of Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs by using the software Statistica l Package for Social
Sciences (SPSS) 170 version A significance difference was found in th e
comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving their own needs of
authenticity and ba lance in work attitude But it was that there was no significance
difference in the comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving
their own needs of cha llenge in work attitude
xi i
ABSTRAK
MENGENALPASTI PERBEZAAN ANTARA GENERASI BABY BOOMER
DAN GENERASI X BERKAlTAN SIKAP KERJA DARl DIMENSI KEASLlAN
KESEIMBANGAN DAN CABARAN KAJIAN MENGENAI PENSYARAH DI
PUSAT PENGAJIAN TINGGI AWAM DI MALAYSIA
Farrah NoorNajwa Be Mohamad Afasni
Penyelidikan ini berlujuan untuk mengenalpasti perbezaan generasi anara Baby
Boomer dan Gfnerasi X dengan menggunakan Model Kerjaya Kaleidoskop dalam
dimensi keaslian keseimbangan dan cabaran diantara pensyarah di Intilut
Pengajian Tinggi Awam di Malaysia Sebuah kajian deskriptif kuantitatf
diadaptasikan dan digunakan sebagai medium untuk mengumpul data Medium
yang digunakan adalah sel[administered questionnaire yang diodapcosikan dari
pengkaji yang sebelumnya Bag data sebenar soalan kajian kemudian diagihkan
kepada respondent iaitu pensyarah di selunch fakulti di Unversit Malaysia
Sarawak dan Unive rsiti Teknologi Mara Sample kajian ini adalah sebanyak 270
Untuk menjawab soalan kajian yang pertama penyelidik menggunakan Korelasi
Pearson dan Korelasi Spearman Analisis Mann-Whitney U-test dan Independent
Sample T-test digunakan untuk membandingkan sikap kerja dianara Generasi
Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dengan menggunakan Software Statistical Package
Sosial (SPSS) versi 170 Satu perbezaan yang signifikan ditemui pada
perbandingan Generas Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dalam keaslian dan
keseimbangan dalam sikap kerfa Namun tiada perbezaan yang signifikan
dikenalpasti diantara Baby Boomers dan Generasi X dalam cabaran dalam
keperluan sikap kerjo mereka
xiii
CHAJTER 1
I NTRODD CTI ON
10 introd uc tion
This chapter describes the background of the study statement of problem
general and specific objecti ves the conceptual framework used and th e
significance of the study This chapter also gives more detail s about the
limitations and the scope of this stud y for theoretical and contributions The
definitions of terms are al so covered to give clear information and deepen the
understanding of readers in this research
1
11 Background of study
Current career patterns are still influenced by the traditional career model
whi ch limit many women and force them to adapt to thi s model T he result of
such approach is the unequal access of women towards development of their
career when compared to men This has its implicat ions in pers istence o f the
sectora l and occ upational separation
M uch has been written in the popular press about the clash between Baby
Boome rs and members of Generation X For instance Business Week has
featured sto ries such as The reasons why Generat ion X a re unhappy at work
which suggests that Boomer managers do not understand what motivates their
Generation X employees (Erickson 2005) Fortune has reported on how
Generation X feel cannot get ahead because of the grey ceiling created by
Boomers who will not retire (Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Time magazine
fea tured a cover story about Generation X that lamen ted they just wont up
(Grossman L 2005) while illustrating also that the generation gap is not just a
western phenomenon with its story on Chinas me generati on (Simon 2007)
Soc iety for Human Resource Management in the year of 2004 stated that s imilar
reports of how the generation gap between Baby Boomers and Generation X has
caused inc reased workplace conflict
There is a potential difference in the ca reer needs o f Baby Boomers and
Gene rati on X the two generations that dominate todays western wo rkp lace
(S ulli van 1999) It has been suggested that the root of the conflic ts between Baby
Boomers and Generation X is that these two generations differed in th e ir atti tudes
toward s work-non-work balance the desire for challenging work and differences
in the meaning of work (CalJanan and Greenhaus 2008 Hankin 2004) Bahy
Boomers are often viewed as workaholics wh o thrive on increas in g work
chall enge whereby Generation X are seen as placing a high er va lue on balance to
the po int of being perceived as slackers While popular press has devoted
considerable attention to how the interaction of members from these different
2
ge nerations may have important implicati ons for current workplace dynamics and
practices (Zemke et a l 2000)
12 Problem statement
Today the workforce is dominated by two generat ions which are the Baby
Boomers born between 1945 and 1964 and the Generation X born betwee n year
1965 and J979 (Loomis 2000) A third generation is entering the workforce
Genera tion Y or the Internet Generation the eldest of whom just turned 26
For many managing an emerging work force containing re tirin g Roomers
Gene rati on X and newly entering Generation Y wiiJ be a cha llenge About 76
million Americans were born between 1946 and 1964 (Rakoff 200 1) In 2010 the
youngest of Baby Boomers is 27 and the oldest 45 years old By their sheer size
th ese Baby Boomers defined and redefined work for the last quarter of the 20th
century (Joyner 2000) As the oldest Baby Boomers retire it affects the di versity
of the labour force overall econom y certain occupations and indus tri es Th is has
a direct impact on th e economys capacity to produce goods and services
Understanding mOre fully what traits or behaviours seem to be associated with
how each baby boo mers and Generation X perce ives effective leadership will onl y
be beneficial eas ing the trans ition as one group leaves and the othe r re places it
(Miller 2005)
The work characteristics of Baby Boomers and Generation X are different
in many respects and this difference can be ex plained by many factors such as the
differences in li ving environments when the va lues of these ge nerations were
form ed The most consistent finding in th e literature when comparisons of work
charac teristics are made between Generation X and Baby Boomers is that each
ge nerational group exh ibits a different mixture o f lifesty lc values a nd work ethics
T he Baby Boomers tend to work hard and are genera lly loya l to the ir employer In
contrast work values for the Generation X emphasise personal sati sfaction rather
than just working hard
3
Beside the ir work values Shu ( 1998) indicated that Generation X has
broke n the traditi onal Mas low hi erarchy needs rule and cha ll enged indi vidual
development progress Baby Boomers have te nded to fo llow their indi vidual
development progress starting from education ca reer marr iage promoti on and
this has moved the m towards selfmiddot achievement Generation X squeezes the
process together They need self achi evement from their job and bas ic needs at the
same time and they do not want the ir work to impac t negative ly on their quality of
life Baby Boomers have had to work in a ll three phases of a progressive economy
and therefore have had to adapt from be in g predominantly indust rial workers that
is undertaking predominantl y industr ia l work to service workers and now to
know ledge workers On the other hand Generat ion X entered the workforce
around 1985 ass umin g that they commenced employme nt in their late teens and
have onl y ever experi enced a predominan tly service economy with training
prog rams during the ir careers orie nted to deli ver the skills
The big worry here is Erickson (2005) stated that most of Generation X
were unhappy at wo rk beca use of the ir Boomer manage rs do not understand what
motivates their Gene ration X employees Generation X also felt that they cannot
get ahead because of the grey ce il ing c reated by Boomer who will not retire
(Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Em ployers have been unable to determine whether
generational membership directly im pacts career moti vation and caree r decision s
So it is crucial to study the differences of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs work
attitude for Human Resource Person in orde r to understand the ir beha viour and
avo id contli ct in each and every organisat ion
T hi s lack of understanding has presented some c ha llenges for bus iness
leaders to meet the needs o f a multigenerational workforce The re fo re the
problem is that while continued generational di vers ity is obvious in workforce
there is insufficient knowledge ab out di ffe rences in career motivation and work
attitude between the cohorts Addressing this problem may increase organiza tional
leaders generational competence as they fonnulate recruitment and retention
strategies that support generation differences As the previous study was
4
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
CHAPTER 4 - FINDINGS
40 Introduction 40 41 Demographic Characteri st ics 41
411 Gender 41 412 Generational Differences 42 413 Highest Education level 43 414 Percentage of time in using computer at work 44
42 Data Screening Test Results 46 43 Reliability Test Results 48 44 Research Question Testing 49
441 Authenticity 49 442 Balance 50 443 Challenge 51
45 Hypotheses Testing Using Mann-Whitney U-test 52 451 Authenticity 52 452 Balance S3
46 Hypothesis Testing Using Independent sample T- test 55 46 1 Challenge 55
47 Summary of the findings in the study 58 48 Conclusion 59
CHAPTER 5 - SUMMARY DISCttSSION IMPLI CATION RECOMMENDATlOl( AND CONCLUSION
50 51 52
53
54
55
APPENDIX
Introducti on 60 Summary of the research 61 Discussions 63 521 Authenticity 63 522 Balance 63 523 Challenge 65 Implications of the study 66 531 Implications to theory 66 532 Implications to Human Resource Practiti oners 66 Recommendations 65 54 1 Human Resource Practitioners 67 542 Future Researchers 69 Conclusion 70
References 71 Appendix 76
Vj
LIST OF TABLES
Table 321
Number of lecturers according to the generational differences
(Universiti Malaysia Sarawak) 28
Table 322
Number oflecturers according to the generational differences
(Universiti Teknologi Mara) 29
Table 332
Likert-Scale 30
Table 3723
Description of PearsonSpearman Correlation Value 37
Table 3725
Classifications of effect s ize value r 38
Table 381
The summary table of types of statistical analysis used to analyzed each variable 39
Table 382
The summary table of types of statistical analysis used to analyzed each
hypothesis 39
Table 411
Distribution of respondents by gender 41
vl
Table 4111
Distribution of respondents by Gender according two different generation 42
Table 412
Distribut ion of respondents by Generational Differences 43
Ta ble 413
Distribution of respondents by their Highest Education Level 43
Table 4131
Distribution of respondents by Generational Differences according to their
Highest Education Level 44
Table 414
Distribution of respondents by Pe(centage of time in using computer at
work according to Generational Differences 45
Table 42
Data Screening test result 46
Table 421
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 422
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 43
Lists of Reliability test result 48
Vlll
49
Result of Spearman Correlation for the Relationship between Baby Boomers
and Generation Xs work amptitude in dimension of Authenticity
Result ofSpeannan Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Balance 50
Result of Pearson Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Challenge 5
Result of Mann-Whitney U-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Authenticity 52
Statistics for Authenticity
Result of Mann-Whitney C-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Balance 53
Statistics for Balance 54
Result of Independent sample Tmiddottest for the Difference between
IX
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Challenge 5S
Table 4611
Result of Independent sample T -test for Differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for challenge 56
Table 471
Summary of findings 58
Table 472
Summary of hypotheses result testing 59
x
6
LIST OF FIGURE
Figure 10
The direct effect relationships between selective demographic factors
towards perceived on their own working attitude
Xl
ABSTRACT
EXAMINING GENERATIONAL DlFFERE CES BETWEEN
BABY BOOMERS Al1D GENERATIO N XS WORK ATTITUDES OF
AUTHE TIClTY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE OF LECTURERS
IN A MALA YSIAN PUBLIC INSTITuTE OF HIGHER EDUCATION
Farrah NoorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfasn
This study aims to identify the generational differences betw~cn Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitudes by using the Kaleidoscope Career
Model in the d imensions of au thenticity balance and cha llenge among lec turers in
a Malays ian Public Inst itute of Higher Educat ion A quantitati ve descriptive
research was adopted and used as a tool to co llect the data The in strument used
was the self-administered questionnaire that was adopted from the previous
researchers Prior to the actual data the validated questionnaires were then
distributed to the actu a l respondents which were the lecturers in the entire faculty
in Universiti Malaysia Sarawak and Universiti Teknologi Mara The sample of
this study was 270 To answer the first re search question the researcher used
Pearson and spea rman corre lation The analysis of mann-whitney u-test and
independent samples t-test was perfonning to compare the means of Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs by using the software Statistica l Package for Social
Sciences (SPSS) 170 version A significance difference was found in th e
comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving their own needs of
authenticity and ba lance in work attitude But it was that there was no significance
difference in the comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving
their own needs of cha llenge in work attitude
xi i
ABSTRAK
MENGENALPASTI PERBEZAAN ANTARA GENERASI BABY BOOMER
DAN GENERASI X BERKAlTAN SIKAP KERJA DARl DIMENSI KEASLlAN
KESEIMBANGAN DAN CABARAN KAJIAN MENGENAI PENSYARAH DI
PUSAT PENGAJIAN TINGGI AWAM DI MALAYSIA
Farrah NoorNajwa Be Mohamad Afasni
Penyelidikan ini berlujuan untuk mengenalpasti perbezaan generasi anara Baby
Boomer dan Gfnerasi X dengan menggunakan Model Kerjaya Kaleidoskop dalam
dimensi keaslian keseimbangan dan cabaran diantara pensyarah di Intilut
Pengajian Tinggi Awam di Malaysia Sebuah kajian deskriptif kuantitatf
diadaptasikan dan digunakan sebagai medium untuk mengumpul data Medium
yang digunakan adalah sel[administered questionnaire yang diodapcosikan dari
pengkaji yang sebelumnya Bag data sebenar soalan kajian kemudian diagihkan
kepada respondent iaitu pensyarah di selunch fakulti di Unversit Malaysia
Sarawak dan Unive rsiti Teknologi Mara Sample kajian ini adalah sebanyak 270
Untuk menjawab soalan kajian yang pertama penyelidik menggunakan Korelasi
Pearson dan Korelasi Spearman Analisis Mann-Whitney U-test dan Independent
Sample T-test digunakan untuk membandingkan sikap kerja dianara Generasi
Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dengan menggunakan Software Statistical Package
Sosial (SPSS) versi 170 Satu perbezaan yang signifikan ditemui pada
perbandingan Generas Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dalam keaslian dan
keseimbangan dalam sikap kerfa Namun tiada perbezaan yang signifikan
dikenalpasti diantara Baby Boomers dan Generasi X dalam cabaran dalam
keperluan sikap kerjo mereka
xiii
CHAJTER 1
I NTRODD CTI ON
10 introd uc tion
This chapter describes the background of the study statement of problem
general and specific objecti ves the conceptual framework used and th e
significance of the study This chapter also gives more detail s about the
limitations and the scope of this stud y for theoretical and contributions The
definitions of terms are al so covered to give clear information and deepen the
understanding of readers in this research
1
11 Background of study
Current career patterns are still influenced by the traditional career model
whi ch limit many women and force them to adapt to thi s model T he result of
such approach is the unequal access of women towards development of their
career when compared to men This has its implicat ions in pers istence o f the
sectora l and occ upational separation
M uch has been written in the popular press about the clash between Baby
Boome rs and members of Generation X For instance Business Week has
featured sto ries such as The reasons why Generat ion X a re unhappy at work
which suggests that Boomer managers do not understand what motivates their
Generation X employees (Erickson 2005) Fortune has reported on how
Generation X feel cannot get ahead because of the grey ceiling created by
Boomers who will not retire (Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Time magazine
fea tured a cover story about Generation X that lamen ted they just wont up
(Grossman L 2005) while illustrating also that the generation gap is not just a
western phenomenon with its story on Chinas me generati on (Simon 2007)
Soc iety for Human Resource Management in the year of 2004 stated that s imilar
reports of how the generation gap between Baby Boomers and Generation X has
caused inc reased workplace conflict
There is a potential difference in the ca reer needs o f Baby Boomers and
Gene rati on X the two generations that dominate todays western wo rkp lace
(S ulli van 1999) It has been suggested that the root of the conflic ts between Baby
Boomers and Generation X is that these two generations differed in th e ir atti tudes
toward s work-non-work balance the desire for challenging work and differences
in the meaning of work (CalJanan and Greenhaus 2008 Hankin 2004) Bahy
Boomers are often viewed as workaholics wh o thrive on increas in g work
chall enge whereby Generation X are seen as placing a high er va lue on balance to
the po int of being perceived as slackers While popular press has devoted
considerable attention to how the interaction of members from these different
2
ge nerations may have important implicati ons for current workplace dynamics and
practices (Zemke et a l 2000)
12 Problem statement
Today the workforce is dominated by two generat ions which are the Baby
Boomers born between 1945 and 1964 and the Generation X born betwee n year
1965 and J979 (Loomis 2000) A third generation is entering the workforce
Genera tion Y or the Internet Generation the eldest of whom just turned 26
For many managing an emerging work force containing re tirin g Roomers
Gene rati on X and newly entering Generation Y wiiJ be a cha llenge About 76
million Americans were born between 1946 and 1964 (Rakoff 200 1) In 2010 the
youngest of Baby Boomers is 27 and the oldest 45 years old By their sheer size
th ese Baby Boomers defined and redefined work for the last quarter of the 20th
century (Joyner 2000) As the oldest Baby Boomers retire it affects the di versity
of the labour force overall econom y certain occupations and indus tri es Th is has
a direct impact on th e economys capacity to produce goods and services
Understanding mOre fully what traits or behaviours seem to be associated with
how each baby boo mers and Generation X perce ives effective leadership will onl y
be beneficial eas ing the trans ition as one group leaves and the othe r re places it
(Miller 2005)
The work characteristics of Baby Boomers and Generation X are different
in many respects and this difference can be ex plained by many factors such as the
differences in li ving environments when the va lues of these ge nerations were
form ed The most consistent finding in th e literature when comparisons of work
charac teristics are made between Generation X and Baby Boomers is that each
ge nerational group exh ibits a different mixture o f lifesty lc values a nd work ethics
T he Baby Boomers tend to work hard and are genera lly loya l to the ir employer In
contrast work values for the Generation X emphasise personal sati sfaction rather
than just working hard
3
Beside the ir work values Shu ( 1998) indicated that Generation X has
broke n the traditi onal Mas low hi erarchy needs rule and cha ll enged indi vidual
development progress Baby Boomers have te nded to fo llow their indi vidual
development progress starting from education ca reer marr iage promoti on and
this has moved the m towards selfmiddot achievement Generation X squeezes the
process together They need self achi evement from their job and bas ic needs at the
same time and they do not want the ir work to impac t negative ly on their quality of
life Baby Boomers have had to work in a ll three phases of a progressive economy
and therefore have had to adapt from be in g predominantly indust rial workers that
is undertaking predominantl y industr ia l work to service workers and now to
know ledge workers On the other hand Generat ion X entered the workforce
around 1985 ass umin g that they commenced employme nt in their late teens and
have onl y ever experi enced a predominan tly service economy with training
prog rams during the ir careers orie nted to deli ver the skills
The big worry here is Erickson (2005) stated that most of Generation X
were unhappy at wo rk beca use of the ir Boomer manage rs do not understand what
motivates their Gene ration X employees Generation X also felt that they cannot
get ahead because of the grey ce il ing c reated by Boomer who will not retire
(Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Em ployers have been unable to determine whether
generational membership directly im pacts career moti vation and caree r decision s
So it is crucial to study the differences of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs work
attitude for Human Resource Person in orde r to understand the ir beha viour and
avo id contli ct in each and every organisat ion
T hi s lack of understanding has presented some c ha llenges for bus iness
leaders to meet the needs o f a multigenerational workforce The re fo re the
problem is that while continued generational di vers ity is obvious in workforce
there is insufficient knowledge ab out di ffe rences in career motivation and work
attitude between the cohorts Addressing this problem may increase organiza tional
leaders generational competence as they fonnulate recruitment and retention
strategies that support generation differences As the previous study was
4
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
LIST OF TABLES
Table 321
Number of lecturers according to the generational differences
(Universiti Malaysia Sarawak) 28
Table 322
Number oflecturers according to the generational differences
(Universiti Teknologi Mara) 29
Table 332
Likert-Scale 30
Table 3723
Description of PearsonSpearman Correlation Value 37
Table 3725
Classifications of effect s ize value r 38
Table 381
The summary table of types of statistical analysis used to analyzed each variable 39
Table 382
The summary table of types of statistical analysis used to analyzed each
hypothesis 39
Table 411
Distribution of respondents by gender 41
vl
Table 4111
Distribution of respondents by Gender according two different generation 42
Table 412
Distribut ion of respondents by Generational Differences 43
Ta ble 413
Distribution of respondents by their Highest Education Level 43
Table 4131
Distribution of respondents by Generational Differences according to their
Highest Education Level 44
Table 414
Distribution of respondents by Pe(centage of time in using computer at
work according to Generational Differences 45
Table 42
Data Screening test result 46
Table 421
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 422
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 43
Lists of Reliability test result 48
Vlll
49
Result of Spearman Correlation for the Relationship between Baby Boomers
and Generation Xs work amptitude in dimension of Authenticity
Result ofSpeannan Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Balance 50
Result of Pearson Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Challenge 5
Result of Mann-Whitney U-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Authenticity 52
Statistics for Authenticity
Result of Mann-Whitney C-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Balance 53
Statistics for Balance 54
Result of Independent sample Tmiddottest for the Difference between
IX
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Challenge 5S
Table 4611
Result of Independent sample T -test for Differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for challenge 56
Table 471
Summary of findings 58
Table 472
Summary of hypotheses result testing 59
x
6
LIST OF FIGURE
Figure 10
The direct effect relationships between selective demographic factors
towards perceived on their own working attitude
Xl
ABSTRACT
EXAMINING GENERATIONAL DlFFERE CES BETWEEN
BABY BOOMERS Al1D GENERATIO N XS WORK ATTITUDES OF
AUTHE TIClTY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE OF LECTURERS
IN A MALA YSIAN PUBLIC INSTITuTE OF HIGHER EDUCATION
Farrah NoorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfasn
This study aims to identify the generational differences betw~cn Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitudes by using the Kaleidoscope Career
Model in the d imensions of au thenticity balance and cha llenge among lec turers in
a Malays ian Public Inst itute of Higher Educat ion A quantitati ve descriptive
research was adopted and used as a tool to co llect the data The in strument used
was the self-administered questionnaire that was adopted from the previous
researchers Prior to the actual data the validated questionnaires were then
distributed to the actu a l respondents which were the lecturers in the entire faculty
in Universiti Malaysia Sarawak and Universiti Teknologi Mara The sample of
this study was 270 To answer the first re search question the researcher used
Pearson and spea rman corre lation The analysis of mann-whitney u-test and
independent samples t-test was perfonning to compare the means of Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs by using the software Statistica l Package for Social
Sciences (SPSS) 170 version A significance difference was found in th e
comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving their own needs of
authenticity and ba lance in work attitude But it was that there was no significance
difference in the comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving
their own needs of cha llenge in work attitude
xi i
ABSTRAK
MENGENALPASTI PERBEZAAN ANTARA GENERASI BABY BOOMER
DAN GENERASI X BERKAlTAN SIKAP KERJA DARl DIMENSI KEASLlAN
KESEIMBANGAN DAN CABARAN KAJIAN MENGENAI PENSYARAH DI
PUSAT PENGAJIAN TINGGI AWAM DI MALAYSIA
Farrah NoorNajwa Be Mohamad Afasni
Penyelidikan ini berlujuan untuk mengenalpasti perbezaan generasi anara Baby
Boomer dan Gfnerasi X dengan menggunakan Model Kerjaya Kaleidoskop dalam
dimensi keaslian keseimbangan dan cabaran diantara pensyarah di Intilut
Pengajian Tinggi Awam di Malaysia Sebuah kajian deskriptif kuantitatf
diadaptasikan dan digunakan sebagai medium untuk mengumpul data Medium
yang digunakan adalah sel[administered questionnaire yang diodapcosikan dari
pengkaji yang sebelumnya Bag data sebenar soalan kajian kemudian diagihkan
kepada respondent iaitu pensyarah di selunch fakulti di Unversit Malaysia
Sarawak dan Unive rsiti Teknologi Mara Sample kajian ini adalah sebanyak 270
Untuk menjawab soalan kajian yang pertama penyelidik menggunakan Korelasi
Pearson dan Korelasi Spearman Analisis Mann-Whitney U-test dan Independent
Sample T-test digunakan untuk membandingkan sikap kerja dianara Generasi
Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dengan menggunakan Software Statistical Package
Sosial (SPSS) versi 170 Satu perbezaan yang signifikan ditemui pada
perbandingan Generas Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dalam keaslian dan
keseimbangan dalam sikap kerfa Namun tiada perbezaan yang signifikan
dikenalpasti diantara Baby Boomers dan Generasi X dalam cabaran dalam
keperluan sikap kerjo mereka
xiii
CHAJTER 1
I NTRODD CTI ON
10 introd uc tion
This chapter describes the background of the study statement of problem
general and specific objecti ves the conceptual framework used and th e
significance of the study This chapter also gives more detail s about the
limitations and the scope of this stud y for theoretical and contributions The
definitions of terms are al so covered to give clear information and deepen the
understanding of readers in this research
1
11 Background of study
Current career patterns are still influenced by the traditional career model
whi ch limit many women and force them to adapt to thi s model T he result of
such approach is the unequal access of women towards development of their
career when compared to men This has its implicat ions in pers istence o f the
sectora l and occ upational separation
M uch has been written in the popular press about the clash between Baby
Boome rs and members of Generation X For instance Business Week has
featured sto ries such as The reasons why Generat ion X a re unhappy at work
which suggests that Boomer managers do not understand what motivates their
Generation X employees (Erickson 2005) Fortune has reported on how
Generation X feel cannot get ahead because of the grey ceiling created by
Boomers who will not retire (Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Time magazine
fea tured a cover story about Generation X that lamen ted they just wont up
(Grossman L 2005) while illustrating also that the generation gap is not just a
western phenomenon with its story on Chinas me generati on (Simon 2007)
Soc iety for Human Resource Management in the year of 2004 stated that s imilar
reports of how the generation gap between Baby Boomers and Generation X has
caused inc reased workplace conflict
There is a potential difference in the ca reer needs o f Baby Boomers and
Gene rati on X the two generations that dominate todays western wo rkp lace
(S ulli van 1999) It has been suggested that the root of the conflic ts between Baby
Boomers and Generation X is that these two generations differed in th e ir atti tudes
toward s work-non-work balance the desire for challenging work and differences
in the meaning of work (CalJanan and Greenhaus 2008 Hankin 2004) Bahy
Boomers are often viewed as workaholics wh o thrive on increas in g work
chall enge whereby Generation X are seen as placing a high er va lue on balance to
the po int of being perceived as slackers While popular press has devoted
considerable attention to how the interaction of members from these different
2
ge nerations may have important implicati ons for current workplace dynamics and
practices (Zemke et a l 2000)
12 Problem statement
Today the workforce is dominated by two generat ions which are the Baby
Boomers born between 1945 and 1964 and the Generation X born betwee n year
1965 and J979 (Loomis 2000) A third generation is entering the workforce
Genera tion Y or the Internet Generation the eldest of whom just turned 26
For many managing an emerging work force containing re tirin g Roomers
Gene rati on X and newly entering Generation Y wiiJ be a cha llenge About 76
million Americans were born between 1946 and 1964 (Rakoff 200 1) In 2010 the
youngest of Baby Boomers is 27 and the oldest 45 years old By their sheer size
th ese Baby Boomers defined and redefined work for the last quarter of the 20th
century (Joyner 2000) As the oldest Baby Boomers retire it affects the di versity
of the labour force overall econom y certain occupations and indus tri es Th is has
a direct impact on th e economys capacity to produce goods and services
Understanding mOre fully what traits or behaviours seem to be associated with
how each baby boo mers and Generation X perce ives effective leadership will onl y
be beneficial eas ing the trans ition as one group leaves and the othe r re places it
(Miller 2005)
The work characteristics of Baby Boomers and Generation X are different
in many respects and this difference can be ex plained by many factors such as the
differences in li ving environments when the va lues of these ge nerations were
form ed The most consistent finding in th e literature when comparisons of work
charac teristics are made between Generation X and Baby Boomers is that each
ge nerational group exh ibits a different mixture o f lifesty lc values a nd work ethics
T he Baby Boomers tend to work hard and are genera lly loya l to the ir employer In
contrast work values for the Generation X emphasise personal sati sfaction rather
than just working hard
3
Beside the ir work values Shu ( 1998) indicated that Generation X has
broke n the traditi onal Mas low hi erarchy needs rule and cha ll enged indi vidual
development progress Baby Boomers have te nded to fo llow their indi vidual
development progress starting from education ca reer marr iage promoti on and
this has moved the m towards selfmiddot achievement Generation X squeezes the
process together They need self achi evement from their job and bas ic needs at the
same time and they do not want the ir work to impac t negative ly on their quality of
life Baby Boomers have had to work in a ll three phases of a progressive economy
and therefore have had to adapt from be in g predominantly indust rial workers that
is undertaking predominantl y industr ia l work to service workers and now to
know ledge workers On the other hand Generat ion X entered the workforce
around 1985 ass umin g that they commenced employme nt in their late teens and
have onl y ever experi enced a predominan tly service economy with training
prog rams during the ir careers orie nted to deli ver the skills
The big worry here is Erickson (2005) stated that most of Generation X
were unhappy at wo rk beca use of the ir Boomer manage rs do not understand what
motivates their Gene ration X employees Generation X also felt that they cannot
get ahead because of the grey ce il ing c reated by Boomer who will not retire
(Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Em ployers have been unable to determine whether
generational membership directly im pacts career moti vation and caree r decision s
So it is crucial to study the differences of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs work
attitude for Human Resource Person in orde r to understand the ir beha viour and
avo id contli ct in each and every organisat ion
T hi s lack of understanding has presented some c ha llenges for bus iness
leaders to meet the needs o f a multigenerational workforce The re fo re the
problem is that while continued generational di vers ity is obvious in workforce
there is insufficient knowledge ab out di ffe rences in career motivation and work
attitude between the cohorts Addressing this problem may increase organiza tional
leaders generational competence as they fonnulate recruitment and retention
strategies that support generation differences As the previous study was
4
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
Table 4111
Distribution of respondents by Gender according two different generation 42
Table 412
Distribut ion of respondents by Generational Differences 43
Ta ble 413
Distribution of respondents by their Highest Education Level 43
Table 4131
Distribution of respondents by Generational Differences according to their
Highest Education Level 44
Table 414
Distribution of respondents by Pe(centage of time in using computer at
work according to Generational Differences 45
Table 42
Data Screening test result 46
Table 421
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 422
Lists of appropriate test for each variable 47
Table 43
Lists of Reliability test result 48
Vlll
49
Result of Spearman Correlation for the Relationship between Baby Boomers
and Generation Xs work amptitude in dimension of Authenticity
Result ofSpeannan Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Balance 50
Result of Pearson Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Challenge 5
Result of Mann-Whitney U-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Authenticity 52
Statistics for Authenticity
Result of Mann-Whitney C-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Balance 53
Statistics for Balance 54
Result of Independent sample Tmiddottest for the Difference between
IX
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Challenge 5S
Table 4611
Result of Independent sample T -test for Differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for challenge 56
Table 471
Summary of findings 58
Table 472
Summary of hypotheses result testing 59
x
6
LIST OF FIGURE
Figure 10
The direct effect relationships between selective demographic factors
towards perceived on their own working attitude
Xl
ABSTRACT
EXAMINING GENERATIONAL DlFFERE CES BETWEEN
BABY BOOMERS Al1D GENERATIO N XS WORK ATTITUDES OF
AUTHE TIClTY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE OF LECTURERS
IN A MALA YSIAN PUBLIC INSTITuTE OF HIGHER EDUCATION
Farrah NoorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfasn
This study aims to identify the generational differences betw~cn Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitudes by using the Kaleidoscope Career
Model in the d imensions of au thenticity balance and cha llenge among lec turers in
a Malays ian Public Inst itute of Higher Educat ion A quantitati ve descriptive
research was adopted and used as a tool to co llect the data The in strument used
was the self-administered questionnaire that was adopted from the previous
researchers Prior to the actual data the validated questionnaires were then
distributed to the actu a l respondents which were the lecturers in the entire faculty
in Universiti Malaysia Sarawak and Universiti Teknologi Mara The sample of
this study was 270 To answer the first re search question the researcher used
Pearson and spea rman corre lation The analysis of mann-whitney u-test and
independent samples t-test was perfonning to compare the means of Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs by using the software Statistica l Package for Social
Sciences (SPSS) 170 version A significance difference was found in th e
comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving their own needs of
authenticity and ba lance in work attitude But it was that there was no significance
difference in the comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving
their own needs of cha llenge in work attitude
xi i
ABSTRAK
MENGENALPASTI PERBEZAAN ANTARA GENERASI BABY BOOMER
DAN GENERASI X BERKAlTAN SIKAP KERJA DARl DIMENSI KEASLlAN
KESEIMBANGAN DAN CABARAN KAJIAN MENGENAI PENSYARAH DI
PUSAT PENGAJIAN TINGGI AWAM DI MALAYSIA
Farrah NoorNajwa Be Mohamad Afasni
Penyelidikan ini berlujuan untuk mengenalpasti perbezaan generasi anara Baby
Boomer dan Gfnerasi X dengan menggunakan Model Kerjaya Kaleidoskop dalam
dimensi keaslian keseimbangan dan cabaran diantara pensyarah di Intilut
Pengajian Tinggi Awam di Malaysia Sebuah kajian deskriptif kuantitatf
diadaptasikan dan digunakan sebagai medium untuk mengumpul data Medium
yang digunakan adalah sel[administered questionnaire yang diodapcosikan dari
pengkaji yang sebelumnya Bag data sebenar soalan kajian kemudian diagihkan
kepada respondent iaitu pensyarah di selunch fakulti di Unversit Malaysia
Sarawak dan Unive rsiti Teknologi Mara Sample kajian ini adalah sebanyak 270
Untuk menjawab soalan kajian yang pertama penyelidik menggunakan Korelasi
Pearson dan Korelasi Spearman Analisis Mann-Whitney U-test dan Independent
Sample T-test digunakan untuk membandingkan sikap kerja dianara Generasi
Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dengan menggunakan Software Statistical Package
Sosial (SPSS) versi 170 Satu perbezaan yang signifikan ditemui pada
perbandingan Generas Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dalam keaslian dan
keseimbangan dalam sikap kerfa Namun tiada perbezaan yang signifikan
dikenalpasti diantara Baby Boomers dan Generasi X dalam cabaran dalam
keperluan sikap kerjo mereka
xiii
CHAJTER 1
I NTRODD CTI ON
10 introd uc tion
This chapter describes the background of the study statement of problem
general and specific objecti ves the conceptual framework used and th e
significance of the study This chapter also gives more detail s about the
limitations and the scope of this stud y for theoretical and contributions The
definitions of terms are al so covered to give clear information and deepen the
understanding of readers in this research
1
11 Background of study
Current career patterns are still influenced by the traditional career model
whi ch limit many women and force them to adapt to thi s model T he result of
such approach is the unequal access of women towards development of their
career when compared to men This has its implicat ions in pers istence o f the
sectora l and occ upational separation
M uch has been written in the popular press about the clash between Baby
Boome rs and members of Generation X For instance Business Week has
featured sto ries such as The reasons why Generat ion X a re unhappy at work
which suggests that Boomer managers do not understand what motivates their
Generation X employees (Erickson 2005) Fortune has reported on how
Generation X feel cannot get ahead because of the grey ceiling created by
Boomers who will not retire (Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Time magazine
fea tured a cover story about Generation X that lamen ted they just wont up
(Grossman L 2005) while illustrating also that the generation gap is not just a
western phenomenon with its story on Chinas me generati on (Simon 2007)
Soc iety for Human Resource Management in the year of 2004 stated that s imilar
reports of how the generation gap between Baby Boomers and Generation X has
caused inc reased workplace conflict
There is a potential difference in the ca reer needs o f Baby Boomers and
Gene rati on X the two generations that dominate todays western wo rkp lace
(S ulli van 1999) It has been suggested that the root of the conflic ts between Baby
Boomers and Generation X is that these two generations differed in th e ir atti tudes
toward s work-non-work balance the desire for challenging work and differences
in the meaning of work (CalJanan and Greenhaus 2008 Hankin 2004) Bahy
Boomers are often viewed as workaholics wh o thrive on increas in g work
chall enge whereby Generation X are seen as placing a high er va lue on balance to
the po int of being perceived as slackers While popular press has devoted
considerable attention to how the interaction of members from these different
2
ge nerations may have important implicati ons for current workplace dynamics and
practices (Zemke et a l 2000)
12 Problem statement
Today the workforce is dominated by two generat ions which are the Baby
Boomers born between 1945 and 1964 and the Generation X born betwee n year
1965 and J979 (Loomis 2000) A third generation is entering the workforce
Genera tion Y or the Internet Generation the eldest of whom just turned 26
For many managing an emerging work force containing re tirin g Roomers
Gene rati on X and newly entering Generation Y wiiJ be a cha llenge About 76
million Americans were born between 1946 and 1964 (Rakoff 200 1) In 2010 the
youngest of Baby Boomers is 27 and the oldest 45 years old By their sheer size
th ese Baby Boomers defined and redefined work for the last quarter of the 20th
century (Joyner 2000) As the oldest Baby Boomers retire it affects the di versity
of the labour force overall econom y certain occupations and indus tri es Th is has
a direct impact on th e economys capacity to produce goods and services
Understanding mOre fully what traits or behaviours seem to be associated with
how each baby boo mers and Generation X perce ives effective leadership will onl y
be beneficial eas ing the trans ition as one group leaves and the othe r re places it
(Miller 2005)
The work characteristics of Baby Boomers and Generation X are different
in many respects and this difference can be ex plained by many factors such as the
differences in li ving environments when the va lues of these ge nerations were
form ed The most consistent finding in th e literature when comparisons of work
charac teristics are made between Generation X and Baby Boomers is that each
ge nerational group exh ibits a different mixture o f lifesty lc values a nd work ethics
T he Baby Boomers tend to work hard and are genera lly loya l to the ir employer In
contrast work values for the Generation X emphasise personal sati sfaction rather
than just working hard
3
Beside the ir work values Shu ( 1998) indicated that Generation X has
broke n the traditi onal Mas low hi erarchy needs rule and cha ll enged indi vidual
development progress Baby Boomers have te nded to fo llow their indi vidual
development progress starting from education ca reer marr iage promoti on and
this has moved the m towards selfmiddot achievement Generation X squeezes the
process together They need self achi evement from their job and bas ic needs at the
same time and they do not want the ir work to impac t negative ly on their quality of
life Baby Boomers have had to work in a ll three phases of a progressive economy
and therefore have had to adapt from be in g predominantly indust rial workers that
is undertaking predominantl y industr ia l work to service workers and now to
know ledge workers On the other hand Generat ion X entered the workforce
around 1985 ass umin g that they commenced employme nt in their late teens and
have onl y ever experi enced a predominan tly service economy with training
prog rams during the ir careers orie nted to deli ver the skills
The big worry here is Erickson (2005) stated that most of Generation X
were unhappy at wo rk beca use of the ir Boomer manage rs do not understand what
motivates their Gene ration X employees Generation X also felt that they cannot
get ahead because of the grey ce il ing c reated by Boomer who will not retire
(Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Em ployers have been unable to determine whether
generational membership directly im pacts career moti vation and caree r decision s
So it is crucial to study the differences of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs work
attitude for Human Resource Person in orde r to understand the ir beha viour and
avo id contli ct in each and every organisat ion
T hi s lack of understanding has presented some c ha llenges for bus iness
leaders to meet the needs o f a multigenerational workforce The re fo re the
problem is that while continued generational di vers ity is obvious in workforce
there is insufficient knowledge ab out di ffe rences in career motivation and work
attitude between the cohorts Addressing this problem may increase organiza tional
leaders generational competence as they fonnulate recruitment and retention
strategies that support generation differences As the previous study was
4
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
49
Result of Spearman Correlation for the Relationship between Baby Boomers
and Generation Xs work amptitude in dimension of Authenticity
Result ofSpeannan Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Balance 50
Result of Pearson Correlation for the Relationship between Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitude in dimension of Challenge 5
Result of Mann-Whitney U-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Authenticity 52
Statistics for Authenticity
Result of Mann-Whitney C-test for the Difference between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Balance 53
Statistics for Balance 54
Result of Independent sample Tmiddottest for the Difference between
IX
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Challenge 5S
Table 4611
Result of Independent sample T -test for Differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for challenge 56
Table 471
Summary of findings 58
Table 472
Summary of hypotheses result testing 59
x
6
LIST OF FIGURE
Figure 10
The direct effect relationships between selective demographic factors
towards perceived on their own working attitude
Xl
ABSTRACT
EXAMINING GENERATIONAL DlFFERE CES BETWEEN
BABY BOOMERS Al1D GENERATIO N XS WORK ATTITUDES OF
AUTHE TIClTY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE OF LECTURERS
IN A MALA YSIAN PUBLIC INSTITuTE OF HIGHER EDUCATION
Farrah NoorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfasn
This study aims to identify the generational differences betw~cn Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitudes by using the Kaleidoscope Career
Model in the d imensions of au thenticity balance and cha llenge among lec turers in
a Malays ian Public Inst itute of Higher Educat ion A quantitati ve descriptive
research was adopted and used as a tool to co llect the data The in strument used
was the self-administered questionnaire that was adopted from the previous
researchers Prior to the actual data the validated questionnaires were then
distributed to the actu a l respondents which were the lecturers in the entire faculty
in Universiti Malaysia Sarawak and Universiti Teknologi Mara The sample of
this study was 270 To answer the first re search question the researcher used
Pearson and spea rman corre lation The analysis of mann-whitney u-test and
independent samples t-test was perfonning to compare the means of Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs by using the software Statistica l Package for Social
Sciences (SPSS) 170 version A significance difference was found in th e
comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving their own needs of
authenticity and ba lance in work attitude But it was that there was no significance
difference in the comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving
their own needs of cha llenge in work attitude
xi i
ABSTRAK
MENGENALPASTI PERBEZAAN ANTARA GENERASI BABY BOOMER
DAN GENERASI X BERKAlTAN SIKAP KERJA DARl DIMENSI KEASLlAN
KESEIMBANGAN DAN CABARAN KAJIAN MENGENAI PENSYARAH DI
PUSAT PENGAJIAN TINGGI AWAM DI MALAYSIA
Farrah NoorNajwa Be Mohamad Afasni
Penyelidikan ini berlujuan untuk mengenalpasti perbezaan generasi anara Baby
Boomer dan Gfnerasi X dengan menggunakan Model Kerjaya Kaleidoskop dalam
dimensi keaslian keseimbangan dan cabaran diantara pensyarah di Intilut
Pengajian Tinggi Awam di Malaysia Sebuah kajian deskriptif kuantitatf
diadaptasikan dan digunakan sebagai medium untuk mengumpul data Medium
yang digunakan adalah sel[administered questionnaire yang diodapcosikan dari
pengkaji yang sebelumnya Bag data sebenar soalan kajian kemudian diagihkan
kepada respondent iaitu pensyarah di selunch fakulti di Unversit Malaysia
Sarawak dan Unive rsiti Teknologi Mara Sample kajian ini adalah sebanyak 270
Untuk menjawab soalan kajian yang pertama penyelidik menggunakan Korelasi
Pearson dan Korelasi Spearman Analisis Mann-Whitney U-test dan Independent
Sample T-test digunakan untuk membandingkan sikap kerja dianara Generasi
Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dengan menggunakan Software Statistical Package
Sosial (SPSS) versi 170 Satu perbezaan yang signifikan ditemui pada
perbandingan Generas Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dalam keaslian dan
keseimbangan dalam sikap kerfa Namun tiada perbezaan yang signifikan
dikenalpasti diantara Baby Boomers dan Generasi X dalam cabaran dalam
keperluan sikap kerjo mereka
xiii
CHAJTER 1
I NTRODD CTI ON
10 introd uc tion
This chapter describes the background of the study statement of problem
general and specific objecti ves the conceptual framework used and th e
significance of the study This chapter also gives more detail s about the
limitations and the scope of this stud y for theoretical and contributions The
definitions of terms are al so covered to give clear information and deepen the
understanding of readers in this research
1
11 Background of study
Current career patterns are still influenced by the traditional career model
whi ch limit many women and force them to adapt to thi s model T he result of
such approach is the unequal access of women towards development of their
career when compared to men This has its implicat ions in pers istence o f the
sectora l and occ upational separation
M uch has been written in the popular press about the clash between Baby
Boome rs and members of Generation X For instance Business Week has
featured sto ries such as The reasons why Generat ion X a re unhappy at work
which suggests that Boomer managers do not understand what motivates their
Generation X employees (Erickson 2005) Fortune has reported on how
Generation X feel cannot get ahead because of the grey ceiling created by
Boomers who will not retire (Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Time magazine
fea tured a cover story about Generation X that lamen ted they just wont up
(Grossman L 2005) while illustrating also that the generation gap is not just a
western phenomenon with its story on Chinas me generati on (Simon 2007)
Soc iety for Human Resource Management in the year of 2004 stated that s imilar
reports of how the generation gap between Baby Boomers and Generation X has
caused inc reased workplace conflict
There is a potential difference in the ca reer needs o f Baby Boomers and
Gene rati on X the two generations that dominate todays western wo rkp lace
(S ulli van 1999) It has been suggested that the root of the conflic ts between Baby
Boomers and Generation X is that these two generations differed in th e ir atti tudes
toward s work-non-work balance the desire for challenging work and differences
in the meaning of work (CalJanan and Greenhaus 2008 Hankin 2004) Bahy
Boomers are often viewed as workaholics wh o thrive on increas in g work
chall enge whereby Generation X are seen as placing a high er va lue on balance to
the po int of being perceived as slackers While popular press has devoted
considerable attention to how the interaction of members from these different
2
ge nerations may have important implicati ons for current workplace dynamics and
practices (Zemke et a l 2000)
12 Problem statement
Today the workforce is dominated by two generat ions which are the Baby
Boomers born between 1945 and 1964 and the Generation X born betwee n year
1965 and J979 (Loomis 2000) A third generation is entering the workforce
Genera tion Y or the Internet Generation the eldest of whom just turned 26
For many managing an emerging work force containing re tirin g Roomers
Gene rati on X and newly entering Generation Y wiiJ be a cha llenge About 76
million Americans were born between 1946 and 1964 (Rakoff 200 1) In 2010 the
youngest of Baby Boomers is 27 and the oldest 45 years old By their sheer size
th ese Baby Boomers defined and redefined work for the last quarter of the 20th
century (Joyner 2000) As the oldest Baby Boomers retire it affects the di versity
of the labour force overall econom y certain occupations and indus tri es Th is has
a direct impact on th e economys capacity to produce goods and services
Understanding mOre fully what traits or behaviours seem to be associated with
how each baby boo mers and Generation X perce ives effective leadership will onl y
be beneficial eas ing the trans ition as one group leaves and the othe r re places it
(Miller 2005)
The work characteristics of Baby Boomers and Generation X are different
in many respects and this difference can be ex plained by many factors such as the
differences in li ving environments when the va lues of these ge nerations were
form ed The most consistent finding in th e literature when comparisons of work
charac teristics are made between Generation X and Baby Boomers is that each
ge nerational group exh ibits a different mixture o f lifesty lc values a nd work ethics
T he Baby Boomers tend to work hard and are genera lly loya l to the ir employer In
contrast work values for the Generation X emphasise personal sati sfaction rather
than just working hard
3
Beside the ir work values Shu ( 1998) indicated that Generation X has
broke n the traditi onal Mas low hi erarchy needs rule and cha ll enged indi vidual
development progress Baby Boomers have te nded to fo llow their indi vidual
development progress starting from education ca reer marr iage promoti on and
this has moved the m towards selfmiddot achievement Generation X squeezes the
process together They need self achi evement from their job and bas ic needs at the
same time and they do not want the ir work to impac t negative ly on their quality of
life Baby Boomers have had to work in a ll three phases of a progressive economy
and therefore have had to adapt from be in g predominantly indust rial workers that
is undertaking predominantl y industr ia l work to service workers and now to
know ledge workers On the other hand Generat ion X entered the workforce
around 1985 ass umin g that they commenced employme nt in their late teens and
have onl y ever experi enced a predominan tly service economy with training
prog rams during the ir careers orie nted to deli ver the skills
The big worry here is Erickson (2005) stated that most of Generation X
were unhappy at wo rk beca use of the ir Boomer manage rs do not understand what
motivates their Gene ration X employees Generation X also felt that they cannot
get ahead because of the grey ce il ing c reated by Boomer who will not retire
(Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Em ployers have been unable to determine whether
generational membership directly im pacts career moti vation and caree r decision s
So it is crucial to study the differences of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs work
attitude for Human Resource Person in orde r to understand the ir beha viour and
avo id contli ct in each and every organisat ion
T hi s lack of understanding has presented some c ha llenges for bus iness
leaders to meet the needs o f a multigenerational workforce The re fo re the
problem is that while continued generational di vers ity is obvious in workforce
there is insufficient knowledge ab out di ffe rences in career motivation and work
attitude between the cohorts Addressing this problem may increase organiza tional
leaders generational competence as they fonnulate recruitment and retention
strategies that support generation differences As the previous study was
4
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for Challenge 5S
Table 4611
Result of Independent sample T -test for Differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need for challenge 56
Table 471
Summary of findings 58
Table 472
Summary of hypotheses result testing 59
x
6
LIST OF FIGURE
Figure 10
The direct effect relationships between selective demographic factors
towards perceived on their own working attitude
Xl
ABSTRACT
EXAMINING GENERATIONAL DlFFERE CES BETWEEN
BABY BOOMERS Al1D GENERATIO N XS WORK ATTITUDES OF
AUTHE TIClTY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE OF LECTURERS
IN A MALA YSIAN PUBLIC INSTITuTE OF HIGHER EDUCATION
Farrah NoorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfasn
This study aims to identify the generational differences betw~cn Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitudes by using the Kaleidoscope Career
Model in the d imensions of au thenticity balance and cha llenge among lec turers in
a Malays ian Public Inst itute of Higher Educat ion A quantitati ve descriptive
research was adopted and used as a tool to co llect the data The in strument used
was the self-administered questionnaire that was adopted from the previous
researchers Prior to the actual data the validated questionnaires were then
distributed to the actu a l respondents which were the lecturers in the entire faculty
in Universiti Malaysia Sarawak and Universiti Teknologi Mara The sample of
this study was 270 To answer the first re search question the researcher used
Pearson and spea rman corre lation The analysis of mann-whitney u-test and
independent samples t-test was perfonning to compare the means of Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs by using the software Statistica l Package for Social
Sciences (SPSS) 170 version A significance difference was found in th e
comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving their own needs of
authenticity and ba lance in work attitude But it was that there was no significance
difference in the comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving
their own needs of cha llenge in work attitude
xi i
ABSTRAK
MENGENALPASTI PERBEZAAN ANTARA GENERASI BABY BOOMER
DAN GENERASI X BERKAlTAN SIKAP KERJA DARl DIMENSI KEASLlAN
KESEIMBANGAN DAN CABARAN KAJIAN MENGENAI PENSYARAH DI
PUSAT PENGAJIAN TINGGI AWAM DI MALAYSIA
Farrah NoorNajwa Be Mohamad Afasni
Penyelidikan ini berlujuan untuk mengenalpasti perbezaan generasi anara Baby
Boomer dan Gfnerasi X dengan menggunakan Model Kerjaya Kaleidoskop dalam
dimensi keaslian keseimbangan dan cabaran diantara pensyarah di Intilut
Pengajian Tinggi Awam di Malaysia Sebuah kajian deskriptif kuantitatf
diadaptasikan dan digunakan sebagai medium untuk mengumpul data Medium
yang digunakan adalah sel[administered questionnaire yang diodapcosikan dari
pengkaji yang sebelumnya Bag data sebenar soalan kajian kemudian diagihkan
kepada respondent iaitu pensyarah di selunch fakulti di Unversit Malaysia
Sarawak dan Unive rsiti Teknologi Mara Sample kajian ini adalah sebanyak 270
Untuk menjawab soalan kajian yang pertama penyelidik menggunakan Korelasi
Pearson dan Korelasi Spearman Analisis Mann-Whitney U-test dan Independent
Sample T-test digunakan untuk membandingkan sikap kerja dianara Generasi
Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dengan menggunakan Software Statistical Package
Sosial (SPSS) versi 170 Satu perbezaan yang signifikan ditemui pada
perbandingan Generas Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dalam keaslian dan
keseimbangan dalam sikap kerfa Namun tiada perbezaan yang signifikan
dikenalpasti diantara Baby Boomers dan Generasi X dalam cabaran dalam
keperluan sikap kerjo mereka
xiii
CHAJTER 1
I NTRODD CTI ON
10 introd uc tion
This chapter describes the background of the study statement of problem
general and specific objecti ves the conceptual framework used and th e
significance of the study This chapter also gives more detail s about the
limitations and the scope of this stud y for theoretical and contributions The
definitions of terms are al so covered to give clear information and deepen the
understanding of readers in this research
1
11 Background of study
Current career patterns are still influenced by the traditional career model
whi ch limit many women and force them to adapt to thi s model T he result of
such approach is the unequal access of women towards development of their
career when compared to men This has its implicat ions in pers istence o f the
sectora l and occ upational separation
M uch has been written in the popular press about the clash between Baby
Boome rs and members of Generation X For instance Business Week has
featured sto ries such as The reasons why Generat ion X a re unhappy at work
which suggests that Boomer managers do not understand what motivates their
Generation X employees (Erickson 2005) Fortune has reported on how
Generation X feel cannot get ahead because of the grey ceiling created by
Boomers who will not retire (Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Time magazine
fea tured a cover story about Generation X that lamen ted they just wont up
(Grossman L 2005) while illustrating also that the generation gap is not just a
western phenomenon with its story on Chinas me generati on (Simon 2007)
Soc iety for Human Resource Management in the year of 2004 stated that s imilar
reports of how the generation gap between Baby Boomers and Generation X has
caused inc reased workplace conflict
There is a potential difference in the ca reer needs o f Baby Boomers and
Gene rati on X the two generations that dominate todays western wo rkp lace
(S ulli van 1999) It has been suggested that the root of the conflic ts between Baby
Boomers and Generation X is that these two generations differed in th e ir atti tudes
toward s work-non-work balance the desire for challenging work and differences
in the meaning of work (CalJanan and Greenhaus 2008 Hankin 2004) Bahy
Boomers are often viewed as workaholics wh o thrive on increas in g work
chall enge whereby Generation X are seen as placing a high er va lue on balance to
the po int of being perceived as slackers While popular press has devoted
considerable attention to how the interaction of members from these different
2
ge nerations may have important implicati ons for current workplace dynamics and
practices (Zemke et a l 2000)
12 Problem statement
Today the workforce is dominated by two generat ions which are the Baby
Boomers born between 1945 and 1964 and the Generation X born betwee n year
1965 and J979 (Loomis 2000) A third generation is entering the workforce
Genera tion Y or the Internet Generation the eldest of whom just turned 26
For many managing an emerging work force containing re tirin g Roomers
Gene rati on X and newly entering Generation Y wiiJ be a cha llenge About 76
million Americans were born between 1946 and 1964 (Rakoff 200 1) In 2010 the
youngest of Baby Boomers is 27 and the oldest 45 years old By their sheer size
th ese Baby Boomers defined and redefined work for the last quarter of the 20th
century (Joyner 2000) As the oldest Baby Boomers retire it affects the di versity
of the labour force overall econom y certain occupations and indus tri es Th is has
a direct impact on th e economys capacity to produce goods and services
Understanding mOre fully what traits or behaviours seem to be associated with
how each baby boo mers and Generation X perce ives effective leadership will onl y
be beneficial eas ing the trans ition as one group leaves and the othe r re places it
(Miller 2005)
The work characteristics of Baby Boomers and Generation X are different
in many respects and this difference can be ex plained by many factors such as the
differences in li ving environments when the va lues of these ge nerations were
form ed The most consistent finding in th e literature when comparisons of work
charac teristics are made between Generation X and Baby Boomers is that each
ge nerational group exh ibits a different mixture o f lifesty lc values a nd work ethics
T he Baby Boomers tend to work hard and are genera lly loya l to the ir employer In
contrast work values for the Generation X emphasise personal sati sfaction rather
than just working hard
3
Beside the ir work values Shu ( 1998) indicated that Generation X has
broke n the traditi onal Mas low hi erarchy needs rule and cha ll enged indi vidual
development progress Baby Boomers have te nded to fo llow their indi vidual
development progress starting from education ca reer marr iage promoti on and
this has moved the m towards selfmiddot achievement Generation X squeezes the
process together They need self achi evement from their job and bas ic needs at the
same time and they do not want the ir work to impac t negative ly on their quality of
life Baby Boomers have had to work in a ll three phases of a progressive economy
and therefore have had to adapt from be in g predominantly indust rial workers that
is undertaking predominantl y industr ia l work to service workers and now to
know ledge workers On the other hand Generat ion X entered the workforce
around 1985 ass umin g that they commenced employme nt in their late teens and
have onl y ever experi enced a predominan tly service economy with training
prog rams during the ir careers orie nted to deli ver the skills
The big worry here is Erickson (2005) stated that most of Generation X
were unhappy at wo rk beca use of the ir Boomer manage rs do not understand what
motivates their Gene ration X employees Generation X also felt that they cannot
get ahead because of the grey ce il ing c reated by Boomer who will not retire
(Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Em ployers have been unable to determine whether
generational membership directly im pacts career moti vation and caree r decision s
So it is crucial to study the differences of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs work
attitude for Human Resource Person in orde r to understand the ir beha viour and
avo id contli ct in each and every organisat ion
T hi s lack of understanding has presented some c ha llenges for bus iness
leaders to meet the needs o f a multigenerational workforce The re fo re the
problem is that while continued generational di vers ity is obvious in workforce
there is insufficient knowledge ab out di ffe rences in career motivation and work
attitude between the cohorts Addressing this problem may increase organiza tional
leaders generational competence as they fonnulate recruitment and retention
strategies that support generation differences As the previous study was
4
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
6
LIST OF FIGURE
Figure 10
The direct effect relationships between selective demographic factors
towards perceived on their own working attitude
Xl
ABSTRACT
EXAMINING GENERATIONAL DlFFERE CES BETWEEN
BABY BOOMERS Al1D GENERATIO N XS WORK ATTITUDES OF
AUTHE TIClTY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE OF LECTURERS
IN A MALA YSIAN PUBLIC INSTITuTE OF HIGHER EDUCATION
Farrah NoorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfasn
This study aims to identify the generational differences betw~cn Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitudes by using the Kaleidoscope Career
Model in the d imensions of au thenticity balance and cha llenge among lec turers in
a Malays ian Public Inst itute of Higher Educat ion A quantitati ve descriptive
research was adopted and used as a tool to co llect the data The in strument used
was the self-administered questionnaire that was adopted from the previous
researchers Prior to the actual data the validated questionnaires were then
distributed to the actu a l respondents which were the lecturers in the entire faculty
in Universiti Malaysia Sarawak and Universiti Teknologi Mara The sample of
this study was 270 To answer the first re search question the researcher used
Pearson and spea rman corre lation The analysis of mann-whitney u-test and
independent samples t-test was perfonning to compare the means of Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs by using the software Statistica l Package for Social
Sciences (SPSS) 170 version A significance difference was found in th e
comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving their own needs of
authenticity and ba lance in work attitude But it was that there was no significance
difference in the comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving
their own needs of cha llenge in work attitude
xi i
ABSTRAK
MENGENALPASTI PERBEZAAN ANTARA GENERASI BABY BOOMER
DAN GENERASI X BERKAlTAN SIKAP KERJA DARl DIMENSI KEASLlAN
KESEIMBANGAN DAN CABARAN KAJIAN MENGENAI PENSYARAH DI
PUSAT PENGAJIAN TINGGI AWAM DI MALAYSIA
Farrah NoorNajwa Be Mohamad Afasni
Penyelidikan ini berlujuan untuk mengenalpasti perbezaan generasi anara Baby
Boomer dan Gfnerasi X dengan menggunakan Model Kerjaya Kaleidoskop dalam
dimensi keaslian keseimbangan dan cabaran diantara pensyarah di Intilut
Pengajian Tinggi Awam di Malaysia Sebuah kajian deskriptif kuantitatf
diadaptasikan dan digunakan sebagai medium untuk mengumpul data Medium
yang digunakan adalah sel[administered questionnaire yang diodapcosikan dari
pengkaji yang sebelumnya Bag data sebenar soalan kajian kemudian diagihkan
kepada respondent iaitu pensyarah di selunch fakulti di Unversit Malaysia
Sarawak dan Unive rsiti Teknologi Mara Sample kajian ini adalah sebanyak 270
Untuk menjawab soalan kajian yang pertama penyelidik menggunakan Korelasi
Pearson dan Korelasi Spearman Analisis Mann-Whitney U-test dan Independent
Sample T-test digunakan untuk membandingkan sikap kerja dianara Generasi
Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dengan menggunakan Software Statistical Package
Sosial (SPSS) versi 170 Satu perbezaan yang signifikan ditemui pada
perbandingan Generas Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dalam keaslian dan
keseimbangan dalam sikap kerfa Namun tiada perbezaan yang signifikan
dikenalpasti diantara Baby Boomers dan Generasi X dalam cabaran dalam
keperluan sikap kerjo mereka
xiii
CHAJTER 1
I NTRODD CTI ON
10 introd uc tion
This chapter describes the background of the study statement of problem
general and specific objecti ves the conceptual framework used and th e
significance of the study This chapter also gives more detail s about the
limitations and the scope of this stud y for theoretical and contributions The
definitions of terms are al so covered to give clear information and deepen the
understanding of readers in this research
1
11 Background of study
Current career patterns are still influenced by the traditional career model
whi ch limit many women and force them to adapt to thi s model T he result of
such approach is the unequal access of women towards development of their
career when compared to men This has its implicat ions in pers istence o f the
sectora l and occ upational separation
M uch has been written in the popular press about the clash between Baby
Boome rs and members of Generation X For instance Business Week has
featured sto ries such as The reasons why Generat ion X a re unhappy at work
which suggests that Boomer managers do not understand what motivates their
Generation X employees (Erickson 2005) Fortune has reported on how
Generation X feel cannot get ahead because of the grey ceiling created by
Boomers who will not retire (Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Time magazine
fea tured a cover story about Generation X that lamen ted they just wont up
(Grossman L 2005) while illustrating also that the generation gap is not just a
western phenomenon with its story on Chinas me generati on (Simon 2007)
Soc iety for Human Resource Management in the year of 2004 stated that s imilar
reports of how the generation gap between Baby Boomers and Generation X has
caused inc reased workplace conflict
There is a potential difference in the ca reer needs o f Baby Boomers and
Gene rati on X the two generations that dominate todays western wo rkp lace
(S ulli van 1999) It has been suggested that the root of the conflic ts between Baby
Boomers and Generation X is that these two generations differed in th e ir atti tudes
toward s work-non-work balance the desire for challenging work and differences
in the meaning of work (CalJanan and Greenhaus 2008 Hankin 2004) Bahy
Boomers are often viewed as workaholics wh o thrive on increas in g work
chall enge whereby Generation X are seen as placing a high er va lue on balance to
the po int of being perceived as slackers While popular press has devoted
considerable attention to how the interaction of members from these different
2
ge nerations may have important implicati ons for current workplace dynamics and
practices (Zemke et a l 2000)
12 Problem statement
Today the workforce is dominated by two generat ions which are the Baby
Boomers born between 1945 and 1964 and the Generation X born betwee n year
1965 and J979 (Loomis 2000) A third generation is entering the workforce
Genera tion Y or the Internet Generation the eldest of whom just turned 26
For many managing an emerging work force containing re tirin g Roomers
Gene rati on X and newly entering Generation Y wiiJ be a cha llenge About 76
million Americans were born between 1946 and 1964 (Rakoff 200 1) In 2010 the
youngest of Baby Boomers is 27 and the oldest 45 years old By their sheer size
th ese Baby Boomers defined and redefined work for the last quarter of the 20th
century (Joyner 2000) As the oldest Baby Boomers retire it affects the di versity
of the labour force overall econom y certain occupations and indus tri es Th is has
a direct impact on th e economys capacity to produce goods and services
Understanding mOre fully what traits or behaviours seem to be associated with
how each baby boo mers and Generation X perce ives effective leadership will onl y
be beneficial eas ing the trans ition as one group leaves and the othe r re places it
(Miller 2005)
The work characteristics of Baby Boomers and Generation X are different
in many respects and this difference can be ex plained by many factors such as the
differences in li ving environments when the va lues of these ge nerations were
form ed The most consistent finding in th e literature when comparisons of work
charac teristics are made between Generation X and Baby Boomers is that each
ge nerational group exh ibits a different mixture o f lifesty lc values a nd work ethics
T he Baby Boomers tend to work hard and are genera lly loya l to the ir employer In
contrast work values for the Generation X emphasise personal sati sfaction rather
than just working hard
3
Beside the ir work values Shu ( 1998) indicated that Generation X has
broke n the traditi onal Mas low hi erarchy needs rule and cha ll enged indi vidual
development progress Baby Boomers have te nded to fo llow their indi vidual
development progress starting from education ca reer marr iage promoti on and
this has moved the m towards selfmiddot achievement Generation X squeezes the
process together They need self achi evement from their job and bas ic needs at the
same time and they do not want the ir work to impac t negative ly on their quality of
life Baby Boomers have had to work in a ll three phases of a progressive economy
and therefore have had to adapt from be in g predominantly indust rial workers that
is undertaking predominantl y industr ia l work to service workers and now to
know ledge workers On the other hand Generat ion X entered the workforce
around 1985 ass umin g that they commenced employme nt in their late teens and
have onl y ever experi enced a predominan tly service economy with training
prog rams during the ir careers orie nted to deli ver the skills
The big worry here is Erickson (2005) stated that most of Generation X
were unhappy at wo rk beca use of the ir Boomer manage rs do not understand what
motivates their Gene ration X employees Generation X also felt that they cannot
get ahead because of the grey ce il ing c reated by Boomer who will not retire
(Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Em ployers have been unable to determine whether
generational membership directly im pacts career moti vation and caree r decision s
So it is crucial to study the differences of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs work
attitude for Human Resource Person in orde r to understand the ir beha viour and
avo id contli ct in each and every organisat ion
T hi s lack of understanding has presented some c ha llenges for bus iness
leaders to meet the needs o f a multigenerational workforce The re fo re the
problem is that while continued generational di vers ity is obvious in workforce
there is insufficient knowledge ab out di ffe rences in career motivation and work
attitude between the cohorts Addressing this problem may increase organiza tional
leaders generational competence as they fonnulate recruitment and retention
strategies that support generation differences As the previous study was
4
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
ABSTRACT
EXAMINING GENERATIONAL DlFFERE CES BETWEEN
BABY BOOMERS Al1D GENERATIO N XS WORK ATTITUDES OF
AUTHE TIClTY BALANCE AND CHALLENGE A CASE OF LECTURERS
IN A MALA YSIAN PUBLIC INSTITuTE OF HIGHER EDUCATION
Farrah NoorNajwa Bt Mohamad Alfasn
This study aims to identify the generational differences betw~cn Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs work attitudes by using the Kaleidoscope Career
Model in the d imensions of au thenticity balance and cha llenge among lec turers in
a Malays ian Public Inst itute of Higher Educat ion A quantitati ve descriptive
research was adopted and used as a tool to co llect the data The in strument used
was the self-administered questionnaire that was adopted from the previous
researchers Prior to the actual data the validated questionnaires were then
distributed to the actu a l respondents which were the lecturers in the entire faculty
in Universiti Malaysia Sarawak and Universiti Teknologi Mara The sample of
this study was 270 To answer the first re search question the researcher used
Pearson and spea rman corre lation The analysis of mann-whitney u-test and
independent samples t-test was perfonning to compare the means of Baby
Boomers and Generation Xs by using the software Statistica l Package for Social
Sciences (SPSS) 170 version A significance difference was found in th e
comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving their own needs of
authenticity and ba lance in work attitude But it was that there was no significance
difference in the comparison of Baby Boomers and Generation Xs in perceiving
their own needs of cha llenge in work attitude
xi i
ABSTRAK
MENGENALPASTI PERBEZAAN ANTARA GENERASI BABY BOOMER
DAN GENERASI X BERKAlTAN SIKAP KERJA DARl DIMENSI KEASLlAN
KESEIMBANGAN DAN CABARAN KAJIAN MENGENAI PENSYARAH DI
PUSAT PENGAJIAN TINGGI AWAM DI MALAYSIA
Farrah NoorNajwa Be Mohamad Afasni
Penyelidikan ini berlujuan untuk mengenalpasti perbezaan generasi anara Baby
Boomer dan Gfnerasi X dengan menggunakan Model Kerjaya Kaleidoskop dalam
dimensi keaslian keseimbangan dan cabaran diantara pensyarah di Intilut
Pengajian Tinggi Awam di Malaysia Sebuah kajian deskriptif kuantitatf
diadaptasikan dan digunakan sebagai medium untuk mengumpul data Medium
yang digunakan adalah sel[administered questionnaire yang diodapcosikan dari
pengkaji yang sebelumnya Bag data sebenar soalan kajian kemudian diagihkan
kepada respondent iaitu pensyarah di selunch fakulti di Unversit Malaysia
Sarawak dan Unive rsiti Teknologi Mara Sample kajian ini adalah sebanyak 270
Untuk menjawab soalan kajian yang pertama penyelidik menggunakan Korelasi
Pearson dan Korelasi Spearman Analisis Mann-Whitney U-test dan Independent
Sample T-test digunakan untuk membandingkan sikap kerja dianara Generasi
Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dengan menggunakan Software Statistical Package
Sosial (SPSS) versi 170 Satu perbezaan yang signifikan ditemui pada
perbandingan Generas Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dalam keaslian dan
keseimbangan dalam sikap kerfa Namun tiada perbezaan yang signifikan
dikenalpasti diantara Baby Boomers dan Generasi X dalam cabaran dalam
keperluan sikap kerjo mereka
xiii
CHAJTER 1
I NTRODD CTI ON
10 introd uc tion
This chapter describes the background of the study statement of problem
general and specific objecti ves the conceptual framework used and th e
significance of the study This chapter also gives more detail s about the
limitations and the scope of this stud y for theoretical and contributions The
definitions of terms are al so covered to give clear information and deepen the
understanding of readers in this research
1
11 Background of study
Current career patterns are still influenced by the traditional career model
whi ch limit many women and force them to adapt to thi s model T he result of
such approach is the unequal access of women towards development of their
career when compared to men This has its implicat ions in pers istence o f the
sectora l and occ upational separation
M uch has been written in the popular press about the clash between Baby
Boome rs and members of Generation X For instance Business Week has
featured sto ries such as The reasons why Generat ion X a re unhappy at work
which suggests that Boomer managers do not understand what motivates their
Generation X employees (Erickson 2005) Fortune has reported on how
Generation X feel cannot get ahead because of the grey ceiling created by
Boomers who will not retire (Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Time magazine
fea tured a cover story about Generation X that lamen ted they just wont up
(Grossman L 2005) while illustrating also that the generation gap is not just a
western phenomenon with its story on Chinas me generati on (Simon 2007)
Soc iety for Human Resource Management in the year of 2004 stated that s imilar
reports of how the generation gap between Baby Boomers and Generation X has
caused inc reased workplace conflict
There is a potential difference in the ca reer needs o f Baby Boomers and
Gene rati on X the two generations that dominate todays western wo rkp lace
(S ulli van 1999) It has been suggested that the root of the conflic ts between Baby
Boomers and Generation X is that these two generations differed in th e ir atti tudes
toward s work-non-work balance the desire for challenging work and differences
in the meaning of work (CalJanan and Greenhaus 2008 Hankin 2004) Bahy
Boomers are often viewed as workaholics wh o thrive on increas in g work
chall enge whereby Generation X are seen as placing a high er va lue on balance to
the po int of being perceived as slackers While popular press has devoted
considerable attention to how the interaction of members from these different
2
ge nerations may have important implicati ons for current workplace dynamics and
practices (Zemke et a l 2000)
12 Problem statement
Today the workforce is dominated by two generat ions which are the Baby
Boomers born between 1945 and 1964 and the Generation X born betwee n year
1965 and J979 (Loomis 2000) A third generation is entering the workforce
Genera tion Y or the Internet Generation the eldest of whom just turned 26
For many managing an emerging work force containing re tirin g Roomers
Gene rati on X and newly entering Generation Y wiiJ be a cha llenge About 76
million Americans were born between 1946 and 1964 (Rakoff 200 1) In 2010 the
youngest of Baby Boomers is 27 and the oldest 45 years old By their sheer size
th ese Baby Boomers defined and redefined work for the last quarter of the 20th
century (Joyner 2000) As the oldest Baby Boomers retire it affects the di versity
of the labour force overall econom y certain occupations and indus tri es Th is has
a direct impact on th e economys capacity to produce goods and services
Understanding mOre fully what traits or behaviours seem to be associated with
how each baby boo mers and Generation X perce ives effective leadership will onl y
be beneficial eas ing the trans ition as one group leaves and the othe r re places it
(Miller 2005)
The work characteristics of Baby Boomers and Generation X are different
in many respects and this difference can be ex plained by many factors such as the
differences in li ving environments when the va lues of these ge nerations were
form ed The most consistent finding in th e literature when comparisons of work
charac teristics are made between Generation X and Baby Boomers is that each
ge nerational group exh ibits a different mixture o f lifesty lc values a nd work ethics
T he Baby Boomers tend to work hard and are genera lly loya l to the ir employer In
contrast work values for the Generation X emphasise personal sati sfaction rather
than just working hard
3
Beside the ir work values Shu ( 1998) indicated that Generation X has
broke n the traditi onal Mas low hi erarchy needs rule and cha ll enged indi vidual
development progress Baby Boomers have te nded to fo llow their indi vidual
development progress starting from education ca reer marr iage promoti on and
this has moved the m towards selfmiddot achievement Generation X squeezes the
process together They need self achi evement from their job and bas ic needs at the
same time and they do not want the ir work to impac t negative ly on their quality of
life Baby Boomers have had to work in a ll three phases of a progressive economy
and therefore have had to adapt from be in g predominantly indust rial workers that
is undertaking predominantl y industr ia l work to service workers and now to
know ledge workers On the other hand Generat ion X entered the workforce
around 1985 ass umin g that they commenced employme nt in their late teens and
have onl y ever experi enced a predominan tly service economy with training
prog rams during the ir careers orie nted to deli ver the skills
The big worry here is Erickson (2005) stated that most of Generation X
were unhappy at wo rk beca use of the ir Boomer manage rs do not understand what
motivates their Gene ration X employees Generation X also felt that they cannot
get ahead because of the grey ce il ing c reated by Boomer who will not retire
(Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Em ployers have been unable to determine whether
generational membership directly im pacts career moti vation and caree r decision s
So it is crucial to study the differences of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs work
attitude for Human Resource Person in orde r to understand the ir beha viour and
avo id contli ct in each and every organisat ion
T hi s lack of understanding has presented some c ha llenges for bus iness
leaders to meet the needs o f a multigenerational workforce The re fo re the
problem is that while continued generational di vers ity is obvious in workforce
there is insufficient knowledge ab out di ffe rences in career motivation and work
attitude between the cohorts Addressing this problem may increase organiza tional
leaders generational competence as they fonnulate recruitment and retention
strategies that support generation differences As the previous study was
4
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
ABSTRAK
MENGENALPASTI PERBEZAAN ANTARA GENERASI BABY BOOMER
DAN GENERASI X BERKAlTAN SIKAP KERJA DARl DIMENSI KEASLlAN
KESEIMBANGAN DAN CABARAN KAJIAN MENGENAI PENSYARAH DI
PUSAT PENGAJIAN TINGGI AWAM DI MALAYSIA
Farrah NoorNajwa Be Mohamad Afasni
Penyelidikan ini berlujuan untuk mengenalpasti perbezaan generasi anara Baby
Boomer dan Gfnerasi X dengan menggunakan Model Kerjaya Kaleidoskop dalam
dimensi keaslian keseimbangan dan cabaran diantara pensyarah di Intilut
Pengajian Tinggi Awam di Malaysia Sebuah kajian deskriptif kuantitatf
diadaptasikan dan digunakan sebagai medium untuk mengumpul data Medium
yang digunakan adalah sel[administered questionnaire yang diodapcosikan dari
pengkaji yang sebelumnya Bag data sebenar soalan kajian kemudian diagihkan
kepada respondent iaitu pensyarah di selunch fakulti di Unversit Malaysia
Sarawak dan Unive rsiti Teknologi Mara Sample kajian ini adalah sebanyak 270
Untuk menjawab soalan kajian yang pertama penyelidik menggunakan Korelasi
Pearson dan Korelasi Spearman Analisis Mann-Whitney U-test dan Independent
Sample T-test digunakan untuk membandingkan sikap kerja dianara Generasi
Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dengan menggunakan Software Statistical Package
Sosial (SPSS) versi 170 Satu perbezaan yang signifikan ditemui pada
perbandingan Generas Baby Boomer dan Generasi X dalam keaslian dan
keseimbangan dalam sikap kerfa Namun tiada perbezaan yang signifikan
dikenalpasti diantara Baby Boomers dan Generasi X dalam cabaran dalam
keperluan sikap kerjo mereka
xiii
CHAJTER 1
I NTRODD CTI ON
10 introd uc tion
This chapter describes the background of the study statement of problem
general and specific objecti ves the conceptual framework used and th e
significance of the study This chapter also gives more detail s about the
limitations and the scope of this stud y for theoretical and contributions The
definitions of terms are al so covered to give clear information and deepen the
understanding of readers in this research
1
11 Background of study
Current career patterns are still influenced by the traditional career model
whi ch limit many women and force them to adapt to thi s model T he result of
such approach is the unequal access of women towards development of their
career when compared to men This has its implicat ions in pers istence o f the
sectora l and occ upational separation
M uch has been written in the popular press about the clash between Baby
Boome rs and members of Generation X For instance Business Week has
featured sto ries such as The reasons why Generat ion X a re unhappy at work
which suggests that Boomer managers do not understand what motivates their
Generation X employees (Erickson 2005) Fortune has reported on how
Generation X feel cannot get ahead because of the grey ceiling created by
Boomers who will not retire (Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Time magazine
fea tured a cover story about Generation X that lamen ted they just wont up
(Grossman L 2005) while illustrating also that the generation gap is not just a
western phenomenon with its story on Chinas me generati on (Simon 2007)
Soc iety for Human Resource Management in the year of 2004 stated that s imilar
reports of how the generation gap between Baby Boomers and Generation X has
caused inc reased workplace conflict
There is a potential difference in the ca reer needs o f Baby Boomers and
Gene rati on X the two generations that dominate todays western wo rkp lace
(S ulli van 1999) It has been suggested that the root of the conflic ts between Baby
Boomers and Generation X is that these two generations differed in th e ir atti tudes
toward s work-non-work balance the desire for challenging work and differences
in the meaning of work (CalJanan and Greenhaus 2008 Hankin 2004) Bahy
Boomers are often viewed as workaholics wh o thrive on increas in g work
chall enge whereby Generation X are seen as placing a high er va lue on balance to
the po int of being perceived as slackers While popular press has devoted
considerable attention to how the interaction of members from these different
2
ge nerations may have important implicati ons for current workplace dynamics and
practices (Zemke et a l 2000)
12 Problem statement
Today the workforce is dominated by two generat ions which are the Baby
Boomers born between 1945 and 1964 and the Generation X born betwee n year
1965 and J979 (Loomis 2000) A third generation is entering the workforce
Genera tion Y or the Internet Generation the eldest of whom just turned 26
For many managing an emerging work force containing re tirin g Roomers
Gene rati on X and newly entering Generation Y wiiJ be a cha llenge About 76
million Americans were born between 1946 and 1964 (Rakoff 200 1) In 2010 the
youngest of Baby Boomers is 27 and the oldest 45 years old By their sheer size
th ese Baby Boomers defined and redefined work for the last quarter of the 20th
century (Joyner 2000) As the oldest Baby Boomers retire it affects the di versity
of the labour force overall econom y certain occupations and indus tri es Th is has
a direct impact on th e economys capacity to produce goods and services
Understanding mOre fully what traits or behaviours seem to be associated with
how each baby boo mers and Generation X perce ives effective leadership will onl y
be beneficial eas ing the trans ition as one group leaves and the othe r re places it
(Miller 2005)
The work characteristics of Baby Boomers and Generation X are different
in many respects and this difference can be ex plained by many factors such as the
differences in li ving environments when the va lues of these ge nerations were
form ed The most consistent finding in th e literature when comparisons of work
charac teristics are made between Generation X and Baby Boomers is that each
ge nerational group exh ibits a different mixture o f lifesty lc values a nd work ethics
T he Baby Boomers tend to work hard and are genera lly loya l to the ir employer In
contrast work values for the Generation X emphasise personal sati sfaction rather
than just working hard
3
Beside the ir work values Shu ( 1998) indicated that Generation X has
broke n the traditi onal Mas low hi erarchy needs rule and cha ll enged indi vidual
development progress Baby Boomers have te nded to fo llow their indi vidual
development progress starting from education ca reer marr iage promoti on and
this has moved the m towards selfmiddot achievement Generation X squeezes the
process together They need self achi evement from their job and bas ic needs at the
same time and they do not want the ir work to impac t negative ly on their quality of
life Baby Boomers have had to work in a ll three phases of a progressive economy
and therefore have had to adapt from be in g predominantly indust rial workers that
is undertaking predominantl y industr ia l work to service workers and now to
know ledge workers On the other hand Generat ion X entered the workforce
around 1985 ass umin g that they commenced employme nt in their late teens and
have onl y ever experi enced a predominan tly service economy with training
prog rams during the ir careers orie nted to deli ver the skills
The big worry here is Erickson (2005) stated that most of Generation X
were unhappy at wo rk beca use of the ir Boomer manage rs do not understand what
motivates their Gene ration X employees Generation X also felt that they cannot
get ahead because of the grey ce il ing c reated by Boomer who will not retire
(Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Em ployers have been unable to determine whether
generational membership directly im pacts career moti vation and caree r decision s
So it is crucial to study the differences of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs work
attitude for Human Resource Person in orde r to understand the ir beha viour and
avo id contli ct in each and every organisat ion
T hi s lack of understanding has presented some c ha llenges for bus iness
leaders to meet the needs o f a multigenerational workforce The re fo re the
problem is that while continued generational di vers ity is obvious in workforce
there is insufficient knowledge ab out di ffe rences in career motivation and work
attitude between the cohorts Addressing this problem may increase organiza tional
leaders generational competence as they fonnulate recruitment and retention
strategies that support generation differences As the previous study was
4
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
CHAJTER 1
I NTRODD CTI ON
10 introd uc tion
This chapter describes the background of the study statement of problem
general and specific objecti ves the conceptual framework used and th e
significance of the study This chapter also gives more detail s about the
limitations and the scope of this stud y for theoretical and contributions The
definitions of terms are al so covered to give clear information and deepen the
understanding of readers in this research
1
11 Background of study
Current career patterns are still influenced by the traditional career model
whi ch limit many women and force them to adapt to thi s model T he result of
such approach is the unequal access of women towards development of their
career when compared to men This has its implicat ions in pers istence o f the
sectora l and occ upational separation
M uch has been written in the popular press about the clash between Baby
Boome rs and members of Generation X For instance Business Week has
featured sto ries such as The reasons why Generat ion X a re unhappy at work
which suggests that Boomer managers do not understand what motivates their
Generation X employees (Erickson 2005) Fortune has reported on how
Generation X feel cannot get ahead because of the grey ceiling created by
Boomers who will not retire (Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Time magazine
fea tured a cover story about Generation X that lamen ted they just wont up
(Grossman L 2005) while illustrating also that the generation gap is not just a
western phenomenon with its story on Chinas me generati on (Simon 2007)
Soc iety for Human Resource Management in the year of 2004 stated that s imilar
reports of how the generation gap between Baby Boomers and Generation X has
caused inc reased workplace conflict
There is a potential difference in the ca reer needs o f Baby Boomers and
Gene rati on X the two generations that dominate todays western wo rkp lace
(S ulli van 1999) It has been suggested that the root of the conflic ts between Baby
Boomers and Generation X is that these two generations differed in th e ir atti tudes
toward s work-non-work balance the desire for challenging work and differences
in the meaning of work (CalJanan and Greenhaus 2008 Hankin 2004) Bahy
Boomers are often viewed as workaholics wh o thrive on increas in g work
chall enge whereby Generation X are seen as placing a high er va lue on balance to
the po int of being perceived as slackers While popular press has devoted
considerable attention to how the interaction of members from these different
2
ge nerations may have important implicati ons for current workplace dynamics and
practices (Zemke et a l 2000)
12 Problem statement
Today the workforce is dominated by two generat ions which are the Baby
Boomers born between 1945 and 1964 and the Generation X born betwee n year
1965 and J979 (Loomis 2000) A third generation is entering the workforce
Genera tion Y or the Internet Generation the eldest of whom just turned 26
For many managing an emerging work force containing re tirin g Roomers
Gene rati on X and newly entering Generation Y wiiJ be a cha llenge About 76
million Americans were born between 1946 and 1964 (Rakoff 200 1) In 2010 the
youngest of Baby Boomers is 27 and the oldest 45 years old By their sheer size
th ese Baby Boomers defined and redefined work for the last quarter of the 20th
century (Joyner 2000) As the oldest Baby Boomers retire it affects the di versity
of the labour force overall econom y certain occupations and indus tri es Th is has
a direct impact on th e economys capacity to produce goods and services
Understanding mOre fully what traits or behaviours seem to be associated with
how each baby boo mers and Generation X perce ives effective leadership will onl y
be beneficial eas ing the trans ition as one group leaves and the othe r re places it
(Miller 2005)
The work characteristics of Baby Boomers and Generation X are different
in many respects and this difference can be ex plained by many factors such as the
differences in li ving environments when the va lues of these ge nerations were
form ed The most consistent finding in th e literature when comparisons of work
charac teristics are made between Generation X and Baby Boomers is that each
ge nerational group exh ibits a different mixture o f lifesty lc values a nd work ethics
T he Baby Boomers tend to work hard and are genera lly loya l to the ir employer In
contrast work values for the Generation X emphasise personal sati sfaction rather
than just working hard
3
Beside the ir work values Shu ( 1998) indicated that Generation X has
broke n the traditi onal Mas low hi erarchy needs rule and cha ll enged indi vidual
development progress Baby Boomers have te nded to fo llow their indi vidual
development progress starting from education ca reer marr iage promoti on and
this has moved the m towards selfmiddot achievement Generation X squeezes the
process together They need self achi evement from their job and bas ic needs at the
same time and they do not want the ir work to impac t negative ly on their quality of
life Baby Boomers have had to work in a ll three phases of a progressive economy
and therefore have had to adapt from be in g predominantly indust rial workers that
is undertaking predominantl y industr ia l work to service workers and now to
know ledge workers On the other hand Generat ion X entered the workforce
around 1985 ass umin g that they commenced employme nt in their late teens and
have onl y ever experi enced a predominan tly service economy with training
prog rams during the ir careers orie nted to deli ver the skills
The big worry here is Erickson (2005) stated that most of Generation X
were unhappy at wo rk beca use of the ir Boomer manage rs do not understand what
motivates their Gene ration X employees Generation X also felt that they cannot
get ahead because of the grey ce il ing c reated by Boomer who will not retire
(Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Em ployers have been unable to determine whether
generational membership directly im pacts career moti vation and caree r decision s
So it is crucial to study the differences of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs work
attitude for Human Resource Person in orde r to understand the ir beha viour and
avo id contli ct in each and every organisat ion
T hi s lack of understanding has presented some c ha llenges for bus iness
leaders to meet the needs o f a multigenerational workforce The re fo re the
problem is that while continued generational di vers ity is obvious in workforce
there is insufficient knowledge ab out di ffe rences in career motivation and work
attitude between the cohorts Addressing this problem may increase organiza tional
leaders generational competence as they fonnulate recruitment and retention
strategies that support generation differences As the previous study was
4
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
11 Background of study
Current career patterns are still influenced by the traditional career model
whi ch limit many women and force them to adapt to thi s model T he result of
such approach is the unequal access of women towards development of their
career when compared to men This has its implicat ions in pers istence o f the
sectora l and occ upational separation
M uch has been written in the popular press about the clash between Baby
Boome rs and members of Generation X For instance Business Week has
featured sto ries such as The reasons why Generat ion X a re unhappy at work
which suggests that Boomer managers do not understand what motivates their
Generation X employees (Erickson 2005) Fortune has reported on how
Generation X feel cannot get ahead because of the grey ceiling created by
Boomers who will not retire (Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Time magazine
fea tured a cover story about Generation X that lamen ted they just wont up
(Grossman L 2005) while illustrating also that the generation gap is not just a
western phenomenon with its story on Chinas me generati on (Simon 2007)
Soc iety for Human Resource Management in the year of 2004 stated that s imilar
reports of how the generation gap between Baby Boomers and Generation X has
caused inc reased workplace conflict
There is a potential difference in the ca reer needs o f Baby Boomers and
Gene rati on X the two generations that dominate todays western wo rkp lace
(S ulli van 1999) It has been suggested that the root of the conflic ts between Baby
Boomers and Generation X is that these two generations differed in th e ir atti tudes
toward s work-non-work balance the desire for challenging work and differences
in the meaning of work (CalJanan and Greenhaus 2008 Hankin 2004) Bahy
Boomers are often viewed as workaholics wh o thrive on increas in g work
chall enge whereby Generation X are seen as placing a high er va lue on balance to
the po int of being perceived as slackers While popular press has devoted
considerable attention to how the interaction of members from these different
2
ge nerations may have important implicati ons for current workplace dynamics and
practices (Zemke et a l 2000)
12 Problem statement
Today the workforce is dominated by two generat ions which are the Baby
Boomers born between 1945 and 1964 and the Generation X born betwee n year
1965 and J979 (Loomis 2000) A third generation is entering the workforce
Genera tion Y or the Internet Generation the eldest of whom just turned 26
For many managing an emerging work force containing re tirin g Roomers
Gene rati on X and newly entering Generation Y wiiJ be a cha llenge About 76
million Americans were born between 1946 and 1964 (Rakoff 200 1) In 2010 the
youngest of Baby Boomers is 27 and the oldest 45 years old By their sheer size
th ese Baby Boomers defined and redefined work for the last quarter of the 20th
century (Joyner 2000) As the oldest Baby Boomers retire it affects the di versity
of the labour force overall econom y certain occupations and indus tri es Th is has
a direct impact on th e economys capacity to produce goods and services
Understanding mOre fully what traits or behaviours seem to be associated with
how each baby boo mers and Generation X perce ives effective leadership will onl y
be beneficial eas ing the trans ition as one group leaves and the othe r re places it
(Miller 2005)
The work characteristics of Baby Boomers and Generation X are different
in many respects and this difference can be ex plained by many factors such as the
differences in li ving environments when the va lues of these ge nerations were
form ed The most consistent finding in th e literature when comparisons of work
charac teristics are made between Generation X and Baby Boomers is that each
ge nerational group exh ibits a different mixture o f lifesty lc values a nd work ethics
T he Baby Boomers tend to work hard and are genera lly loya l to the ir employer In
contrast work values for the Generation X emphasise personal sati sfaction rather
than just working hard
3
Beside the ir work values Shu ( 1998) indicated that Generation X has
broke n the traditi onal Mas low hi erarchy needs rule and cha ll enged indi vidual
development progress Baby Boomers have te nded to fo llow their indi vidual
development progress starting from education ca reer marr iage promoti on and
this has moved the m towards selfmiddot achievement Generation X squeezes the
process together They need self achi evement from their job and bas ic needs at the
same time and they do not want the ir work to impac t negative ly on their quality of
life Baby Boomers have had to work in a ll three phases of a progressive economy
and therefore have had to adapt from be in g predominantly indust rial workers that
is undertaking predominantl y industr ia l work to service workers and now to
know ledge workers On the other hand Generat ion X entered the workforce
around 1985 ass umin g that they commenced employme nt in their late teens and
have onl y ever experi enced a predominan tly service economy with training
prog rams during the ir careers orie nted to deli ver the skills
The big worry here is Erickson (2005) stated that most of Generation X
were unhappy at wo rk beca use of the ir Boomer manage rs do not understand what
motivates their Gene ration X employees Generation X also felt that they cannot
get ahead because of the grey ce il ing c reated by Boomer who will not retire
(Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Em ployers have been unable to determine whether
generational membership directly im pacts career moti vation and caree r decision s
So it is crucial to study the differences of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs work
attitude for Human Resource Person in orde r to understand the ir beha viour and
avo id contli ct in each and every organisat ion
T hi s lack of understanding has presented some c ha llenges for bus iness
leaders to meet the needs o f a multigenerational workforce The re fo re the
problem is that while continued generational di vers ity is obvious in workforce
there is insufficient knowledge ab out di ffe rences in career motivation and work
attitude between the cohorts Addressing this problem may increase organiza tional
leaders generational competence as they fonnulate recruitment and retention
strategies that support generation differences As the previous study was
4
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
ge nerations may have important implicati ons for current workplace dynamics and
practices (Zemke et a l 2000)
12 Problem statement
Today the workforce is dominated by two generat ions which are the Baby
Boomers born between 1945 and 1964 and the Generation X born betwee n year
1965 and J979 (Loomis 2000) A third generation is entering the workforce
Genera tion Y or the Internet Generation the eldest of whom just turned 26
For many managing an emerging work force containing re tirin g Roomers
Gene rati on X and newly entering Generation Y wiiJ be a cha llenge About 76
million Americans were born between 1946 and 1964 (Rakoff 200 1) In 2010 the
youngest of Baby Boomers is 27 and the oldest 45 years old By their sheer size
th ese Baby Boomers defined and redefined work for the last quarter of the 20th
century (Joyner 2000) As the oldest Baby Boomers retire it affects the di versity
of the labour force overall econom y certain occupations and indus tri es Th is has
a direct impact on th e economys capacity to produce goods and services
Understanding mOre fully what traits or behaviours seem to be associated with
how each baby boo mers and Generation X perce ives effective leadership will onl y
be beneficial eas ing the trans ition as one group leaves and the othe r re places it
(Miller 2005)
The work characteristics of Baby Boomers and Generation X are different
in many respects and this difference can be ex plained by many factors such as the
differences in li ving environments when the va lues of these ge nerations were
form ed The most consistent finding in th e literature when comparisons of work
charac teristics are made between Generation X and Baby Boomers is that each
ge nerational group exh ibits a different mixture o f lifesty lc values a nd work ethics
T he Baby Boomers tend to work hard and are genera lly loya l to the ir employer In
contrast work values for the Generation X emphasise personal sati sfaction rather
than just working hard
3
Beside the ir work values Shu ( 1998) indicated that Generation X has
broke n the traditi onal Mas low hi erarchy needs rule and cha ll enged indi vidual
development progress Baby Boomers have te nded to fo llow their indi vidual
development progress starting from education ca reer marr iage promoti on and
this has moved the m towards selfmiddot achievement Generation X squeezes the
process together They need self achi evement from their job and bas ic needs at the
same time and they do not want the ir work to impac t negative ly on their quality of
life Baby Boomers have had to work in a ll three phases of a progressive economy
and therefore have had to adapt from be in g predominantly indust rial workers that
is undertaking predominantl y industr ia l work to service workers and now to
know ledge workers On the other hand Generat ion X entered the workforce
around 1985 ass umin g that they commenced employme nt in their late teens and
have onl y ever experi enced a predominan tly service economy with training
prog rams during the ir careers orie nted to deli ver the skills
The big worry here is Erickson (2005) stated that most of Generation X
were unhappy at wo rk beca use of the ir Boomer manage rs do not understand what
motivates their Gene ration X employees Generation X also felt that they cannot
get ahead because of the grey ce il ing c reated by Boomer who will not retire
(Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Em ployers have been unable to determine whether
generational membership directly im pacts career moti vation and caree r decision s
So it is crucial to study the differences of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs work
attitude for Human Resource Person in orde r to understand the ir beha viour and
avo id contli ct in each and every organisat ion
T hi s lack of understanding has presented some c ha llenges for bus iness
leaders to meet the needs o f a multigenerational workforce The re fo re the
problem is that while continued generational di vers ity is obvious in workforce
there is insufficient knowledge ab out di ffe rences in career motivation and work
attitude between the cohorts Addressing this problem may increase organiza tional
leaders generational competence as they fonnulate recruitment and retention
strategies that support generation differences As the previous study was
4
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
Beside the ir work values Shu ( 1998) indicated that Generation X has
broke n the traditi onal Mas low hi erarchy needs rule and cha ll enged indi vidual
development progress Baby Boomers have te nded to fo llow their indi vidual
development progress starting from education ca reer marr iage promoti on and
this has moved the m towards selfmiddot achievement Generation X squeezes the
process together They need self achi evement from their job and bas ic needs at the
same time and they do not want the ir work to impac t negative ly on their quality of
life Baby Boomers have had to work in a ll three phases of a progressive economy
and therefore have had to adapt from be in g predominantly indust rial workers that
is undertaking predominantl y industr ia l work to service workers and now to
know ledge workers On the other hand Generat ion X entered the workforce
around 1985 ass umin g that they commenced employme nt in their late teens and
have onl y ever experi enced a predominan tly service economy with training
prog rams during the ir careers orie nted to deli ver the skills
The big worry here is Erickson (2005) stated that most of Generation X
were unhappy at wo rk beca use of the ir Boomer manage rs do not understand what
motivates their Gene ration X employees Generation X also felt that they cannot
get ahead because of the grey ce il ing c reated by Boomer who will not retire
(Fisher and Bonamici 2006) Em ployers have been unable to determine whether
generational membership directly im pacts career moti vation and caree r decision s
So it is crucial to study the differences of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs work
attitude for Human Resource Person in orde r to understand the ir beha viour and
avo id contli ct in each and every organisat ion
T hi s lack of understanding has presented some c ha llenges for bus iness
leaders to meet the needs o f a multigenerational workforce The re fo re the
problem is that while continued generational di vers ity is obvious in workforce
there is insufficient knowledge ab out di ffe rences in career motivation and work
attitude between the cohorts Addressing this problem may increase organiza tional
leaders generational competence as they fonnulate recruitment and retention
strategies that support generation differences As the previous study was
4
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
Pusal Khidmal Ma~lum bullbull A bull rmik illll V~K)ITI MALAYS wAK
conducted in western country the result may indicate whether Malaysia hav~
similar situat ion compare to the western country Malaysia is a deve lopi ng
country which may face the sim ilar issues that happen in western co untry Thus
this study shows how th e development of different country may affect the
generational differences of work attitude by using kaleidoscope career model as
the indicator Al so thi s study will indicate whether the existence of generational
differences in Malaysia as similar to previous research that was conducted in
western country
13 Research Questions
I Is there any difference in Baby Boomer and Generati on Xs work a[lilude
2 Do Baby Boomers generation and Generation X differ in the ir needs for
all thenti city balance and challenge
11 Objectives orlhe study
141 General objective
Generally this stud y is done to examine generational differences between
Baby Boomers and Generation X in work attitudes by using Kaleidoscope Career
Model underlying authenticity balance and challenge
142 Specific Objecthcs
I To ident ify the differences between Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for authenticity
2 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for balance
3 To identify the differences between of Baby Boomer and Generation Xs
need for challenge
5
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
15 Conceptual Framework
Demographic Work Att itudes Gene ration
bull Authef1ti city
bull Balancebull Baby Boomers
bull Challenge bull Ge neration X
Figure 10 The direct effect relatio DshillS between selective
demographic factors towards perceived 00 their ow n working attitu de
This direct effect model illustrates that the demographic facto rs are
assessed in three main sub-dimensi ons All dimensions that have been accepted as
the elements of working attitude are authenticity balance and challenge
Whereby demographic factors are Baby Boomer who was born in 1945 until
1964 and Generati on X who was born in 1965 until 1985 infiuenced the perce ived
of their own working attitude The researcher chose this characteristic as the
conceptual framework as a guideli ne for this study
16 Hypol hesis
Hypotheses for this study are
Ha I There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Generat ion Xs need for
authenticity
Ha2 There is a differcnce between Baby Boomers and Generation Xs need fo r
ba lance
H a3 There is a difference between Baby Boomers and Gene rali on Xs need for
cha llenge
6
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
I7 Definition of term
17 1 Work Altitude
I7 11 Autheoticity
Accordi ng to Mainiero amp Sullivan (2000) authenticity is the parameter to
measure the work attitude of the workers in identifying the ind ividua ls internal
va lues w hether it is align with his or her external behaviours and the values o f the
employing organizati on Authentic ity is referring to the qua lity of be ing real and
true Accord ing to Bi limoria (2005) women posit that issues of authenti city and
being true to oneself will be paramount in late career Authenticity also can be
defined as the quali ty or condition of be ing trustworthy or genuine For example
the employees who are frustrated in their attempts to express their authenticity
may experience the negative work outcomes such as reduc ing the ir job
satisfacti on and commi tment Some workers choose to pick out later in the ir li ves
to pursue long-forgonen dreams whic h arc their need for authenticity may not be
me t Thus they are making a career transition in order to fi nd more meilni ng in
their lives and re-establish their need in authentic ity
17 12 Balance
Accordi ng to Ma inie ro and Su ll ivan (2009) balance refers to the
individual s strives to reach an equili brium between work and non-work such as
fa mily [riends elderly re latives and persona l interest Most of the orgiln iSiltions
do not offer a cu lture or the resources necessary for workin g women to balance all
o f he r responsibilities (Baruch amp Sulli van 2006) According 10 Bili moria (2005)
wome n pos it that issues o f balance between ca reer and re la ti ona l concerns will
more likely manifest in mid career Balance is a state where things are of eq ua l
we ight or force means in a position where you will stand without fa ll ing to e ither
side or to put someth ing in this pos ition For example to ba lance the workers
need for balance the organizat ion policies need to be created to a llowing for on
7
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-
and ofT ramps for those seeking to devote time to child rea ring and caring lo r
famil y members while still remaining connected to the organization
1 71 3 Challenge
According to Main iero and Sulli van (2009) cha ll enge de fines as the
individual s need fo r stimulating work such as responsi bility and auto nomy as
we ll as career advancement According to Bilimoria (2005) women engaging in
challenging work will be the primary foc us of women in ea rl y career phases
Challenge is sOIIl eth ing needing great menta l or physical effort in orde r to be done
success fully and which therefore tests a pe rsons ability For example by ho lding
th e senior managers responsible for the achievement o f current goals the
organizations are likely can fulfil th e workers need for chall enge
IS Significance of study
181 Theoretical contribu tion
This study contributes to the previous literature on work attitudes of Baby
Boomers and Generation X which most ly co nducted in various western countri es
in the context o f Malays ian employees [t is also contributes to the validi ty of
Kale idoscope Career Mode l in the context o f Malays ian workers as previous
studied done in overseas With the research obtained it hoped th at this research
served a greater purpose to strengthen early theories and mode ls
1 82 Robustness of Research Methodology
This research will conduct a quantitative research to deeper explore into
the generational di ffere nces in work attitudes This study hopes th at the findings
of this study enab le to assist the organ izatio ns in dec ision making s ituation by
im prov in g the unde rstanding of working a ttitude o f Baby Boome rs and
Gene rati on X so that (he confl ic t in o rga nization call be avoided and increas in g
8
-