february 1996 ecul' · cd changer, dual cassette deck, remote control - and our ensemble iv...
TRANSCRIPT
"Cambridge SoundWorksHome Theater For
For many speaker designers andmanufacturers, home theater is arelatively new idea. But the people whowork at Cambridge SoundWorks -
including our cofounder Henry Moss(who also founded AR, KLH andAdvent) - have been involved with theconcept of home theater from thebeginning. In 1969 (years before VCRsand cable TV), Henry Kloss foundedAdvent, the company that introducedthe first home theater audio/videosystems - complete with big -screen TVsand digital surround sound. We havehad an ongoing relationship with thepeople at Dolby Laboratories, creatorsof Dolby Surround Sound, since HenryMoss introduced the first consumerproducts withDolby noise
Our Center Channel Speakers
reduction over 20 years ago. And nowat Cambridge SoundWorks we believewe have set a new price -to -performance
*4 -
OurPopcorn
standard forhome theatercomponents.
Because wesell carefullymatched andtested hometheater speakersystems factory -direct,with no expensive middlemen,you can save hundreds of dollars. Webelieve the products on these pagesrepresent the country's best values inhigh performance home theatercomponents. Audio critics, and thou-sands of satisfied customers, agree.
Stereo Review said"CambridgeSoundWorksmanufacturesloudspeakers
that provide excep-tional sound quality at
affordable prices." Audio suggested thatwe "may have the best value in theworld."
Center Channel SpeakersCambridge SoundWorks
manufactures four speakersfor use as center channel
speakers in DolbyPro Logic hometheater systems.All four are
Our Surround Speakers
magnetically shielded so they can beplaced near a TV or computer monitor.Center/Surround IV is a compact, one-way speaker identical to our EnsemblesIV satellite speakers. $49.99. Center/Surround III is a small, affordable two-way speaker. $79.99. Center Channel isidentical to a Cambridge SoundWorksEnsemble satellite (but with magneticshielding). $159.99. Center ChannelPlus uses an ultra -low, ultra -widedesign that is ideal for placement above(or, with optional support stand, below)a TV monitor. $229.99.
Surround SpeakersCambridge SoundWorks makes two"dipole radiator" surround soundspeakers. Dolby Laboratories recom-mends dipole radiator speakers for useas surround speakers. The Surround hasa very high power handling capacityand is often selected for "high end"surround sound systems. Audio,describing a system that included TheSurround said "In many ways thesurround sensation was every bit asgood as far more expensive installa-tions." $399.99 pr. The smaller TheSurround 11 is arguably the country'sbest value in a dipole radiator speaker.$249.99 pr.
Opens The WayTo KillerAn Affordable Frice.",,,,,ew
Powered SubwoofersThe original Powered Subwoofer byCambridge SoundWorks consists of aheavy-duty 12" woofer housed in anacoustic -suspension cabinet with a 140 -watt amplifier and a built-in electroniccrossover. Stereo Review said it pro-vides "deep powerful bass...31.5 Hzbass output was obtainable at a room -shaking level... they open the way tohaving a 'killer' system for an afford-able price." $699.99.
Our Powered Subwoofers
Our Slave Subwoofer uses the samewoofer driver and cabinet, but does notinclude the amplifier or crossover. It canonly be used in conjunction with thePowered Subwoofer. $299.99. The newPowered Subwoofer II uses a120 -watt amplifier with an8" woofer. $399.99.
Home Theater Speaker Systems
We have assembled a number of hometheater speaker systems that consist of
center channel, surround andmain stereo speakers.The combination weshow here is our bestseller. It includes ourcritically acclaimedEnsemble dual sub -woofer satellite speakersystem, our CenterChannel Plus and a pairof our best surround
speakers, The Surround.You could spend hundreds
than its $1,229.97 price withoutimproving performance.
Complete Home TheaterSound Systems
We offer a range of complete hometheater surround soundsystems, ranging from$649.98 to $3,069.93.The system shown here
more
Our FeaturedHome TheaterSound System
Our Most Popular Home TheaterSpeaker System.
is incredibly easy to hook up and touse. It consists of an Aiwa center unitthat includes a Dolby Pro Logic receiver,CD changer, dual cassette deck, remotecontrol - and our Ensemble IV HomeTheater speaker system. It soundsgreat, fits into any room, and sells foran introductory price of only $899.99.
Factory -Direct SavingsThe speakers in this ad areavailable only directlyfrom CambridgeSoundWorks, and throughcost-efficient Best Buy stores - so youcan save hundreds of dollars. Orderthem, then listen in your own homes. Ifyou aren't completely satisfied, returnthem within 30 days for a full refund.
To Order Factory Direct, For aFree Catalog, Or For
The Nearest Store Location, Call
1-80;00F39#0-HIFI(1-
SCAMBRIDGESOUNDWORKS
Critically Acclaimed. Factory -Direct.311 Needham Street, Suite 102, Newton, MA 02164
lel: 1-800-367-4434 Fax: 617-332-9229Canada: 1-800-525-4434
Outside U.S. or Canada: 617-332-5936aoS Carnbndo SoundWorks Rknsemble Is a registered trademark of
Camhncte SoundWorks. Inc. KW is a trademark of KLIi. Inc AR and Advent aretradem rks of International lensen Ins Cambridge Soundhorks In nor affiliated
with KLH. Advent or All
al
FEBRUARY 1996
Cl
VOL 80, NO. 2
=""
THE EQUIPMENT AUTHORITY
IFioneer Elite
CD Recorderand BrystonAmplifier
departmentsFAST FORE -WORD Michael Riggs 4LETTERS 6WHAT'S NEW 8AUDIOCLINIC Joseph Giovanelli 12MONDO AUDIO Ken Kessler
recordings
16
CLASSICAL 76ROCK/POP 80JAll & BLUES 86
Cover Photographer: Bill Kouirinis StudioCover Equipment: Pioneer Elite PDR-99 CD recorderand Bryston 4B ST power amplifier
Audio Publishing, Editorial, and Advertising Offices,1633 Broadway, New York, N.Y. 10019
Subscription Inquiries:Phone, 303/604-1464; fax, 303/604-7455
TheAuditBureau
featuresMULTICHANNEL MUSIC RECORDING:
A VIEW FROM THE CONSOLE Daniel Sweeney 20THE AUDIO INTERVIEW:
M & K'S KEN KREISEL I)aniel Levitin 28
equipment profilesPIONEER ELITE PDR-99 CD RECORDER Edward J. Foster 36BRYSTON 4B ST AMPLIFIER i (1\%aid J. Foster 46WILSON AUDIO WATT V/PUPPY V
SPEAKER SYSTEM I) B. Keele, Jr. 50DYNACO CDV-1 CD PLAYER Bascom H. King 56
Mir/ cit.,EGGLESTONWORKS ANDRA SPEAKER A. H. Cordesman 62ANGSTROM 200 A/V PREAMP
AND PROCESSOR knthony H. Cordesman 66PASS LABORATORIES
ALEPH 1 MONO AMP Anthony H. Cordesman 72
phili)//ekPANASONIC PV -4564 VHS HI-FI VCR,
SALAMANDER DESIGNS ARCHETYPE MODULAR SHELVING,
AND B & W 803 MATRIX SERIES 2 SPEAKERS 96
Ken Kreisel,p,ige 2S
Pass LaboratoriesAleph 1 Mono Amp,page 72
We couldn't havesaidit better o elves.
- excerpts from Audio Magazine, by Anthon\ H. Cordesman
"...this is a product thatdeserves attention. yy
"You may besurprised to findout how goodyour speakers arewhen you first tryan amplifier
tyof
this qual
"This is the kind ofproduct that showsthe vest of the highend can be madetruly affordable. yy
"In short, theAdcom GFA-5800stands out even in aworld where almost /all amplifiers nowsound good. py
"It is also a little difficult tobelieve that this amplifier is inthe $1500 price range. yy
"It does everythingexceptionally well forits price, and its uppermidrange and treble andoverall musicality arehard to find in any ampli-fier not costing at leasttwice its price range. yy
"The imaging, soundstage,dynami.:s, and transparency ofthe Adcom GFA-5800 had thekind of realism and integrationI only expect to find in far moreexpensive products. yy
"Just as Adcom oncechanged the standards of thepower amplifier market withthe 555, it has introduced anew product that may similarlychange the market again. yy .
The Adcom GFA-5800 amplifier is quite possibly the best amplifier you may ever hear.We know it sounds better than others selling for more than twice its price. Delivering 250watts continuous per channel into 8 ohms between 20 Hz and 20 kHz, its circuit design andcomponent specifications are in a class by itself.
But you don't have to take our word for it. Send us your name and address and we willsend you a reprint of Audio's review as well as detailed literature. Or better yet, simply ask tolisten to the GFA-5800. Your ears will tell youall you need to know.
ADCOM®details you can hear
11 Elkins Road, East Brunswick, NJ 08816 U.S.A. (908) 390-1130.Distributed in Canada by PRO ACOUSTICS INC. Montreal, Quebec (514) 344-1226
CIRCLE NO. 1 ON READER SERVICE CARD
1=Il Send me Audio's review and detailed literature on theAdcom GFA-5800.
Name
Address
8 City State Zip
X Mail to: Adcom. 11 Elkins Road, East Brunswick, NJ 08816 U.S.A.
T
FAST
he term "surround sound" is one
we most readily associate with
movies and video. We still think of
unaccompanied audio mainly in
terms of two (probably big)
speakers in the front of the room,
forming the classic triangle with the
listener at the third vertex. We've lived with
this system for 30 years now. Modern
music recording practice is geared almost
entirely to two -channel stereo, and we're
comfortable with it. If only it worked
better!
Over the last year or so, several people in
the audio business have mentioned to me
in passing that they often prefer listening to
stereo music recordings with Dolby Pro
Logic decoding. Most discovered this
accidentally by just forgetting to turn the
decoder off. Presented with an ordinary
stereo recording, Pro Logic will direct
anything centered in the mix to the centerspeaker and any out -of -phase information
to the surround speakers. When everything
goes well, the net result is a more open,
spacious sound combined with a better
focused and more stable front stereo image,
even for listeners seated off -center.
The trouble is that Pro Logic is very
much a hit-or-miss proposition with
unencoded material: Sometimes it works
okay, other times pretty badly. And it's
never ideal. Ambience -enhancement
systems designed specifically for the
purpose can be much better-and verysatisfying-but really good ones are rare.
The best thing would be to have true
multichannel music recordings, preferably
ones that could be reproduced effectively
over the speaker setups currently being
installed at such a furious pace for A/V
surround sound. The widespread
consumer acceptance of such installations
and the development of high -density discs
that can hold many times the amount ofdata on a conventional CD are creating a
golden opportunity for the establishment
FORE -WORD
of a new and better system for
multichannel music reproduction.
But with the 20 -year -old memory of the
quadraphonic debacle still alive, will the
record industry bite? And if it does, how
will artists and producers exploit the
expanded medium? Dan Sweeney has
talked extensively with many of the
recording professionals most interested in
multichannel for music, and he reports his
findings in this issue ("Multichannel Music
Recording: A View from the Console").
Like the people Sweeney interviewed, I
hope very much that the record industry
does wake up to the potential of moving
beyond two -channel stereo and its long -
recognized inadequacies. I've been
disturbed to hear so much of the industry
discussion of a "Super CD," based on the
new high -density discs, cast in terms of
things like higher sampling rates, which
would have little or no impact on perceived
sound quality. Today, the greatest
remaining impediment to sonic realism is
the spatial distortion of two -channel
stereo; as anyone who's heard a
well -reproduced, high -quality surround
soundtrack (especially a discrete -channel
digital one) can attest, we can do a lot
better. That's what's sold home theater, and
we shouldn't let ourselves be stopped there.
AUDIOEDITOR -IN -CHIEF
Michael Riggs
ART DIRECTORCathy Cacchione
ASSOCIATE ART DIRECTORLinda Zerella
TECHNICAL EDITORIvan Berger
MANAGING EDITORKay Blumenthal
ASSOCIATE MANAGING EDITORSDouglas Hyde. Scott Van Camp
DIRECTORY EDITORTom Cannon, Jr.
ASSISTANT EDITOR/MUSICMichael Bieber
ASSISTANT EDITOR/DIRECTORYGerald F. McCarthy
SENIOR CONTRIBUTING EDITORSD. B. Keck, Jr., David Lander, Edward M. Long
CONTRIBUTING EDITORS/ARTISTSEdward Tatna11 Canby, David L Clark, Anthony H. Cordesman,
Ted Costa, John Diliberto, Frank Driggs. John Eargle,Edward I. Foster, John Gatski, Joseph Giovanelli, Dawn limier,
Ken Kessler, Bascom H. King. Robert Lone, Paul Moor,Jon W. Poses, Jon R. Sank, John Sunier, Michael Tearson,
Jon et. Sally Tiven, Michael Wright
V.P./GROUP PUBLISHERTony Catalano 212/767-6061
V.P./ASSOCIATE PUBLISHERScott Constantine 212/767-6346
GENERAL MANAGER Greg RopertiBUSINESS MANAGER Christine Z. Maillet
PRODUCTION DIRECTOR Patti BurnsPRODUCTION MANAGER Dana L. Rubin
PROMOTION COORDINATOR Dominique A. LeupiRESEARCH MANAGER Dru Ann Love
OFFICE MANAGER Aline I. PulleyOPERATIONS MANAGER Sylvia Correa
AD COORDINATOR Linda Neuweiler
ADVERTISINGREGIONAL V.P./AD DIRECTOR, EAST COAST
Charles L P Watson 212/767-6038REGIONAL ACCOUNT MANAGER
Christine B. Forhez 212/767-6025ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE Penry Price 212/767-6077MIDWEST ADVERTISING MANAGER
Jerry Stoeckigt 312/923-4804REGIONAL V.P./AD DIRECTOR, WEST COAST
Bob Meth 213/954-4831WESTERN MANAGER Paula Mayeri 213/954-4830NATIONAL RECORD LABEL SALES
MAG Inc Mitch Herskowitz 212/490-1715Steve Gross 212/490-1895
CLASSIFIED ADVERTISING 800/445-6066
twoCHAIRMAN Daniel Filipacchi
PRESIDENT, CEO, AND COO David L PeckerEXEC. V.P. AND EDIT. DIR. Jean-Louis Ginibre
PRES., HACHETTE FILIPACCHI NEW MEDIAPaul DeBenedictis
SR. V.P./GLOBAL ADV. Paul DuCharmeSR. V.P./DIR., CORP. SALES Nicholas MatarazzoSR. V.P./CFO & TREASURER John T. O'ConnorV.P., GENERAL COUNSEL Catherine Flickinger
V.P.. MFG. & DISTRIBUTION Anthony R. RomanoV.P.. CIRCULATION David W. Lecicey
V.P., RESEARCH & MKTG. SERVICES Susan SmollensV.P., COMMUNICATIONS & SPECIAL PROJECTS
Keith EstabrookV.P., MAGAZINE DEVELOPMENT Marcia SacharV.P., DIR., CREATIVE SERVICES, CORP. SALES
Lynn ChaikenCREATIVE PRODUCTION DIR., GLOBAL MKTG.
Jean Pierre LabatutSR. V.P./CORP. SALES, DETROIT H. E. (Bud) AllenV.P., FINANCIAL OPERATIONS Margaret Carroll
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 19964
1 INPL MRS TER RECORDING
CAT STEVENS THREE
$4... e.
46'
4:
'-.""--
0:101 ;
'iat,Stevens Ilirerstis,rec6rd, audi9.and hi -ft sed;aier necfe! you ?r, if zpuipridire1-
tit c
.440 ';-- :44,
! 16. 241k iireP ".'40 wP ;- .7
J6.
0:.
b e f,."'s!011inctiott)
h1F51, er
at teve411
CAT STEVENS was one of the mostpopular artists of the '70! MobileFidelity is very proud to present thisnumbered, limited edition 3 -disc setcontaining the hard -to -find "ITTSO" and
two titles exclusive from Mobi e Fidelity:
"Back To Earth" and "Numbers." Alsoexclusive to this Mobile Fidelity box set is
a personal message from the artistregarding his spiritual journey.Packaged in a custom slip case, this set
also includes a faithfully reproducedbooklet of lyrics, liner notes and artwork
from all three albums. This handsomeand extensive box set colle:tion is amust -have for all Cat Stevens fans
nw
I
105 Morris Street Sebastopol, CA 95472 800-423-5759 In Canada call 800-267-1216 WW\V URL address: http://www.mofi.com/
" -IFieLE NO. 18 ON PlEADER SERV E C
Viva Van GelderDear Editor:
I thoroughly enjoyed James Rozzi's inter-view of Rudy Van Gelder (November 1995).Rudy Van Gelder has dedicated close to 50years of his life capturing the spontaneity ofan art form labeled "jazz." Unlike chambermusic, operas, and symphonic recitals thathave been performed time and time again,jazz demands an intuitive focus on the partof the recording engineer. Along with this,Van Gelder's exquisite choice of micro-phones, and their positioning, have madehis recordings classic works of art. And it iswhy his earliest tape recordings sound sogood on CD.
A smile crossed my face when Van Gelder
stated, "I'm glad to see the LP go." Thechance of buying a "perfect" reproductionon a 12 -inch disc was worse than the oddsof winning the Florida lottery. Cutting theperfect acetate was step one, followed by the
plating, the positioning of the two stampersin the jaws of the press, and the timing cycleof the heating and cooling of the presses.And this doesn't even take into account thefact that the pressing material may have suf-fered temperature and humidity changeswhile the plant was shut down during thenight. And if the LPs weren't wrapped andshipped properly, they would arrivewarped. Among the many wonderful fea-tures of CDs is that there is no physical con-tact, plus the linearity that exists betweenthe information at the outermost and in-nermost radii.
Whatever the next accepted reproduc-tion medium is, Rudy Van Gelder's record-ings will still sound good. Keep 'em rollin',Rudy.
Tom Dowd
Tom Dowd Productions
Coconut Grove, Fla.
So Long, Vinyl?Dear Editor:
Good riddance! Thank you, Rudy VanGelder for stating what should be seen asobvious. The Van Gelder interview shouldbe required reading for anyone still clingingto the antiquated vinyl format! (Unless
you're the odd sort who doesn't feel wholewithout wow and flutter.)
Martin A. PadillaHillsboro, Ore.
Dissing the DishDear Editor:
As a subscriber for many years, I compli-ment you and the entire staff for the con-tinued excellence of Audio.
The reason for this letter, my first to you,is that I was amazed at the candor andtruthfulness of your article on RCA's Digi-tal Satellite System by Anthony H. Cordes -
man with RCA's response by James Harper("A Gourmet Dish or Pot of Trouble," Au-gust 1995).
All other material written about this sys-tem has been glowing and without criti-cism; Cordesman really told it like it is. Af-ter a major hardware purchase, expensiveinstallation, and the not -so -easy adjust-ments on the dish, there is the hiddenexpense of paying for the DTV and USSBprogramming.
I fully concur with Cordesman as to themediocrity of the picture and sound-es-pecially in the variability of quality, since itdepends not on the system itself but onthose sending material to the satellite for re-transmission to our homes. My greatest dis-appointment is the lack of constant clarityin the picture, due to the digitizationprocess-which all too frequently runs outof digits. And then there are the momentswhen the picture is lost due to heavy rain oran airplane passing by.
The criticism of the "mystery" ports forsome future use is justified because they area waste of the consumer's money. In today'svolatile market, trying to predict what portor connection will allow HDTV, computers,or other future products or formats to workis ridiculous.
This brings me to the fact that mostviewers who have seen the system do notnotice these glitches until you point themout. Then they see the downside of the dig-ital system. It's interesting to see a visualsystem running out of digits; it makes mewonder about digital sound, where it is
harder to detect the running out of digits,and how much we might be missing in CDsound due to the marginal level of theSony/Philips standard. The whole idea oftossing away information not deemed nec-essary and cramming what's left into theavailable data stream can be seen as a failurein this present Digital Satellite System. Whyare we settling for less with these new sys-tems instead of more?
Congratulations on tackling the down-side of a system that is not as good as it'sbeen made out to be and for confrontingthe manufacturer. Keep up the fine work.
John L. Dorn
Baltimore, Md.
Do Not DisturbDear Editor:
In Bascom H. King's reply to Bob Smith'sletter in the November 1995 issue about theCary Audio Design CAD -805 tube ampsounding superior to the solid-state CarverResearch Lightstar Reference, King states,"Getting people disturbed is the precursorto possibly changing their thinking." And"To be honest, though, the measurementsthat most of us reviewers make don't relatevery well to the sonic results."
"Disturbing" people should not be con-fused with an honest dialectical exchange ofideas. Disturbing people only reinforces theconclusion that the disturber wants atten-tion and seeks to annoy. Indeed, King doesnot seem "annoyed" at all that the measure-ments do not correlate to what he hears andseems somewhat complacent in continuingto use them. Instead, maybe he should be"concerned."
Now if King wants to convince or chal-lenge us gentle readers with a point of somekind, he should state what he knows. Oth-erwise, "changing their thinking" willmerely give way to further entrenchment inthe tube versus transistor debate.
King has his "feelers" out looking fornew ways to measure sonic performance.That's great. However, as a subscriber I ampaying you guys to get in the lab and active-ly find out what goes into good sonic per-formance; otherwise, I can just read the ad-vertising claims. Sitting around andlistening to the hi-fi is fine, but it's only halfthe job.
Steve Doyle
Kamuela, Hawaii
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 19966
Testing...One, Two, ThreeDear Editor:
I have some comments on Bascom H.King's response to Bob Smith's letter con-cerning amp measurements and listeningtests in the November 1995 issue.
On the subject of better tests on ampli-fiers, I recommend that amps not be loadedwith a resistor but with a loudspeaker. Al-ternatively, load the amp with a circuit thatis representative of a loudspeaker load. Thetechnical basis for this suggestion is that thecharacteristic of the load on an amp is anintegral part of its transfer function. Theperformance of an amp depends, in part,on the nature of its load. We would like itsperformance to be independent of the na-ture of its load and to be able to evaluate itsdeparture from this ideal. This can be doneby comparing its performance with a resis-tive load to that with a loudspeaker load, ora circuit that represents a loudspeaker.
Tube enthusiasts argue that traditionaltests do not reveal the true nature of ampli-fiers because they aren't evaluated with sig-nals that represent the dynamics of music.To answer this objection, I propose thatamps be tested with pink noise shaped tocorrespond to the latest IEC/DIN frequen-cy/amplitude spectrum, with gradually in-creasing levels. Better yet, modulate this sig-
nal at a random rate and at a randomintensity. Record and compare the appliedsignal to the reproduced signal.
I have one more suggestion, perhaps onlyhalf serious: Why not listen to a tube push-pull amp for reference and then pull one ofits output tubes? This should have theseemingly desired effects of reducing itspower rating, increasing its distortion, andsaturating the core of its output trans-former. Who knows, it might even exhibitadditional aberrations that used to be con-sidered undesirable!
David J. MeranerScotia, N.Y.
Author's Reply. Your suggestion of testingpower amplifiers with a loudspeaker loador a simulated loudspeaker load has cat-alyzed me to action! I will start experiment-ing with simulated loads, and I hope to beable to test with this new load in my nextamplifier review.
The idea of testing with a dynamicshaped -noise signal sounds like a good
idea. I will think about it and see if I cancome up with a way that it could be imple-mented with my Audio Precision SystemOne test instrument. One thing that mightbe promising along these lines is the newFastest DSP program, wherein lots of fre-quencies can be generated but with a gapsomewhere in the spectrum. Looking atwhat "fills in this hole" because of inter -modulation of all the frequencies presentmight prove revealing.
Finally, as to pulling out one output tubeof a push-pull pair: what a great idea! Itwould turn your old-fashioned push-pulltube amp into a modern single -ended mar-vel! One would have to crank up the platecurrent to get Class -A operation, however.This reminds me of when I first met JamesBongiorno (of GAS and Sumo fame). Hecame up with an SAE solid-state amp forme to review, and I was using a pair of fair-ly large tube power amps that had four out-put tubes per channel. When they were onand playing, I pulled one of the outputtubes. There was no ill effect, except for apop in the speaker, and I said, "Try thatwith one of your solid-state things, and seeif it still plays."-B.H.K.
Thagard Amp AvailableDear Editor:
Beginning with the January 1995 issue,Audio ran a three-part series by Dr. Nor-man E. Thagard on the design and con-struction of a 100 -watt Class -A mono am-plifier. The design philosophy was bothpragmatic and technically sound. Withouthearing the actual amp perform, I thoughtit appeared to offer a chance to indulge mylove of fine music with a piece of equip-ment otherwise beyond my financial re-sources. I have looked in vain in subsequentissues of Audio to find a supplier of either acomplete kit or a finished version of theamp.
Denis MacourtCalgary, Alberta, Canada
Editor's Reply: There is a kit (and probably a
finished product) using Dr. Thagard's de-sign in the works. Manufactured bySescom, it should be available in the nextfew months. For more information, contactSescom at 2100 Ward Dr., Henderson, Nev.89015; phone, 702/565-3400; fax, 702/565-4828.
Audio CatalogAt Cambridge SoundWorks we make unique,critically -acclaimed speakers and musicsystems designed by Henry Kloss (founder ofAR, KLH & Advent). We sell them-andcomponents from companies like Sony,Pioneer, Philips, Carver and others-factory -direct, with no expensive middlemen. Calltoday and find out why Audio magazine saidwe may have "the best value in the world." Call toll -free for factory -direct savings. Save hundreds on components and systems
from Cambridge SoundWorks, Sony, Pioneer,AIWA, Harman Kardon, Philips, Carverand more.
Audio experts will answer your questionsbefore and after you buy, 8AM-Midnight(ET), 365 days a year -even holidays.
30 -Day Total Satisfaction Guarantee on allproducts.
7 -Year Parts & Labor Speaker Warranty.
"Best Buy."PC Magazine
Add our award -winning $219.99SoundWorks systemto your computer,radio, TY or Walk-
manfor
powerful bass.
roomfillingsound and
;I
11.011 4%0
1-800-FOR-HIFICritically -Acclaimed. Factory Direct.
CAMBRIDGESOUNDWORKS
311 Needham Street, Suite 104. Newton, MA 02164Tel: 1-800-367-4434 Fax 617-332-9229
Canada: 1-800-525-4434 Outside U.S. or Canada: 617-332-5936®1 995 Cambndge SdundWorks.
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 19967
CIRCLE NO. 6 ON READER SERVICE CARD
WHAT'S NEW
DANIELS AUDIO CD PLAYERDaniels Audio's Zero -One
CD player combines a
Philips transport andsingle -bit DAC,
together with suchaudiophile niceties
as separate powersupplies for the digital and
analog sections and ananalog filter whose
PS Audio has added anHDCD decoder to itsUitralink Two D/A converter,to improve performancewith both standard andHDCD-encoded discs. AnUitraAnalog low -jitter receiverchip and 20 -bit DAC are alsoincluded. Four inputs allow
stop -band rejection isgreater than 120 dB.
The result, claims/yip_ the manufacturer,
is the kind of soundusually heard from
separate CD transportsand D/A converters. Price:
$749.95.For literature, circle No. 100
Toslink, ST optical, AES/EBU,and coaxial digitalconnections. The analogsection of the Ultralink Two isa discrete, Class -A, buffereddesign with third -order,linear -phase Bes.sel filtering.Price: $2,295.For literature, circle No. 101
The modules on
most of Transparent
Audio's latest
Transparent Cables
hold networks that
are designed to
control resonance. RF noise.
and the impedance seen by
the components the cables are
connected to. Even the cable's
length is taken into account
in the networks' design. Price:
from $45.
For literature, circle No. 02
r711917MINrrrr"PgltltPtlror]esigned for homedigital satellite
installations, Newpoint'sSatellite Smart incorporatesvoltage -surge protection,interference reduction, andsystem power control. Ifa TV is plugged intothe device's "Mover" outlet,
byremote) will control powerto other A/V componentsexcept those plugged into
the "VCR" and "AUX l'outlets. The power, sate lite,cable, and telephone linesare clamped against surges,and all three legs ofthe power line are fusec.A similar unit withoutmaster power control,the Satellite Surge,is available.Satellite Smart, $179.9`;Satellite Surge, $89.95.For literature, circle No. 103
MOSE MULTIROOM SYSTEMBose's Litestyle systems are
Known for the sleek, compactshape of their control centers,achieved by putting theamplifiers into the speakers.The new Lifestyle 20 maintainsthat design while incorporatinga six -disc CD changer along witha 30 -preset AM/FM tuner andfour inputs. The system candeliver separate signals to each
of two zones, with multiroomcontrol from a wireless remotethat uses radio, rather thaninfrared, transmission. The system's
Jewel Cube satellite speakers
measure only 4 x 2 x 3 inches;a hideaway Acoustimass bassmodule holds 200 watts' worthof amps for the Lifestyle 20.Price: approximately $2,500.For literature, circle No. 104
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 19968
IKASK .
KANSA S
:XAS
\JUST ADDIltDI
11/.
\V I S ONS I itT
y (-1
1;9
.......
ki 0 R
flAk, . 1 N\ .7-s
Bacardi. rum. Made in Puerto Rico. woo. FME BAT DEV.CE. AND TPIE rim DEvicE AFICAEGVEPED. .PORrS Mora FL 47% kC 1Y VOL
Mr( NEWPSB Mini Speaker
Smallest in PSB's Stratus line, the Stratus Mini
measures only 161/2 x 9 x 12'/2 inches. Its
61/2 -inch woofer is mounted above the
3/4 -inch tweeter to maintain spectral
balance for both seated and standing listeners.
Bass response is rated as -3 dB at 45 Hz and
-10 dB at 34 Hz. Prices: dark or black oak,
$950 per pair; gloss black, $1,050 per pair;
MS -2 stand, $179 per pair.
For literature, circle No. 105
Quinh,ssence Acousiks SpeakerDespite its name, the Stealth speaker from
Quintessence Acoustics stands 68 inches tall andweighs 300 pounds. With four 12 -inchwoofers, four 7 -inch Kevlar midrange drivers,
four 1 -inch titanium -dioxide tweeters, two1 -inch ceramic supertweeters, and 10.one 18 -inch subwoofer, the Stealthis rated to reproduce frequencies from18 Hz to 32 kHz, ±3 dB. Two activecrossovers are included. Power handis 400 watts, continuous (1,000 watts,peak). Prices: $35,000 to $40,000 perpair, depending on finish.For literature, circle No. 106
Platinum Audio, Ltd. Speaker
The Duo, from Platinum
Audio, Ltd., has dual 5 -inch
woofers plus a dome tweeter
with a damped magnet
system. All three drivers
have alloy diaphragms with
butyl rubber surrounds.
The crossover has staggered
frequency ranges for the two
woofers, with asymmetrical
slopes. The diecast aluminum
backplate includes a heat
sink for the crossover. Price:
$3,795 per pair.
For literature, circle No. 107
Canon Speaker
Among its wide -dispersionloudspeakers, Canon deems theS-25 especially suited for stereosystems and, because of itsmagnetic shielding, for center -channel use in a home theatersystem. The two-way speakercombines a 51/4 -inch woofer witha 1/4 -inch tweeter. The diffusingreflector into which the tweeterfires is said to deliver±45° dispersion horizontally and+25°, -0° vertically. Nominalimpedance is 6 ohms, thoughCanon rates "effective"impedance at 8 ohms.Bandwidth is listed as 55 Hz to22 kHz and power handling as100 watts. Matching floor standsand wall -mount brackets areavailable. Price: $299 per pair.For literature, circle No. 108
POLK BOOKSHELF SPEAKERPolk's RT series of bookshelf
speakers all use a dual -port
Acoustic Resonance Control
system with staggered tuningto suppress internal cabinetresonances. The Dynamic
Balance drivers, designed to
reduce cone resonances and
breakup, are all magneticallyshielded. In the Model RT7,those drivers include a 71/2 -inch
woofer and a 1 -inch trilaminate
dome tweeter. Rated responseis 49 Hz to 25 kHz, and
recommended amplifier poweris 20 to 150 watts. Price:
$224.95 each.For literature, circle No. 109
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199610
- .
PARADIGM BIPOLARS CANBE EXPERIENCED AT THESEFINE DEALERS:
AL: BIRMINGHAM LIKIS AUDIO HUNTSVILLEBEDDINGFIELD AV MOBILE CUSTOM AUDIO MONTGOMERY COHENS AR: FAYETTEVILLESTEREO ONE FORT SMITH STEREO ONE AZ:MESA HI FI SALES TUSCON WILSON AUDIO CA:AUBURN WOODEN SHIP STEREO BAKERSFIELDURNERS BERKELEY MUSIC LOVERS AUDIO BREAAUDIO HAVEN CHICO SOUNDS BY DAVE COSTAMESA ATLANTIC STEREO EUREKA SOUND ADVICE HOLLISTER FORTINOS INDIO SAIGON AN LOSANGELES AHEAD STEREO L A AN MENLO PARKSOUND PERFECTION REDDING CLYDES REDONDO BEACH SYSTEMS DESIGN RIVERSIDESPEAKERCRAFT SACRAMENTO PARADYLIE SANDIEGO SOUND COMPANY SAN FRANCISCOPERFORMANCE AUDIO SAN JOSE CENTURYSTEREO SAN LUIS OBISPO AUDIO ECSTASY SANMARCOS SOUND COMPANY SANTA BARBARAMISSION AUDIO SANTA CRUZ WATER STREETSTEREO SANTA MONICA SHELLEY SANTAROSA CALIFORNIA AN HOLIETECH SAUSALITOPACIFIC RIM STOCKTON GLUSKIHS VALLEJOSTEREO SHOWCASE VISALIA LEE S STEREO WALNUT CREEK SOUND DISTINCTION WOODLANDHILLS SHELLEY S CO: COLORADO SPRINGSSOUND SHOP DENVER SOUND HOUNDS FORTCOLLINS OVATION MUSIC GRAND JUNCTIONSOUND CO PUEBLO SOUND SHOP CT: NEWMAVEN TAKE 5 NEWINGTON AUDIO STORE NORWICH SOUND ONE WESTPORT SOUND ROMA
DE: WILMINGTON HI FI HOUSE FL:BLOUNTSTOWN ENCORE' HOME ENTERTAINMENT BRADENTON AUDIO WORKSHOP CLEARWATERRISING SOUNDS CORAL SPRINGS SOUNDVISIONS DESTIN PALM AN NAPLES DESIGNER AUDIO ORLANDO ELECTRONICS PLUS PENSACOLASOUTHERN HI Fl TAMPA SENSUOUS SOUND WEST PALM BEACH AUDIO ADVISORS WINTERPARK ELECTRONICS PLUS GA: ALBANY CUSTOMINC ATHENS CUSTOM INC ATLANTA AUDIOFOREST AUGUSTA CUSTOM INC BOGARTCUSTOM INC DUNWOODY AUDIO SOLUTIONS HI:HONOLULU CLASSIC AIN IA: BETTENDORFREFERENCE AV CEDAR FALLS HAWI(EYE AUDIO DES MOINES AUDIOLABS IDA GROVE BRENNER'S IOWA CITY HAWKETE AUDIO SIOUX CITY PFLANZELECTRONICS. 10: COEUR DALENE EVERYTHINGSTEREO IL: CHAMPAIGN CHAMPAGNE AUDIO CHICAGO PRO MUSICA CHRYSTAL LAKE SOUNDFORUM CLARENDON HILLS SOUNDS DELUXE FAIRVIEW HEGHTS HI FI FO TAM HOFFMANESTATES SIMPLY STEREO MORTON GROVE PROMUSICA PEORIA SOUND OF PEORIA ROCKFORDABSOLUTE AUDIO SPRINGFIELD TEAM ELEC ST CHARLES ST CHARLES AV VILLA PARKSIMPLY STEREO IN: BLOOMINGTON CAMPUSAUDIO CARMEL SOUND PRO FT WAYNELEHMAN S HUNTINGTON LEHMAN S LAFAYETTEPRO AUDIO WABASH WORLD SCAN KS: WICHITACUSTOM SOUND KY: LONDON THE SOUNDGARDEN LA: BATON ROUGE ART COLLEY S LAFAYETTE THAT S ENTERTAINMENT NEWORLEANS WILSON AUDIO MA: ARLINGTONSTEREO SHOP CAMBRIDGE 0 AUDIONORTHAMPTON TRIPOD AUDIO SUDBURYELECTRIC GRAMOPHONE WORCESTER °COINS MD: BALTIMORE COUNTY AN ME: SCARBOROUGHNEW ENGLAND HI Fl IN DEARBORN ALIAAS HN Fl DETROIT PECANS FARMINGTON HILLS ALMAS HIFI FLINT STEREO CENTER GRAND HAVENBEKINS NY GRAND RAPIDS STEREO SHOWCASE IRON MOUNTAIN SOUNDNORTH KALAMAZOOSTEREO SHOWCASE PETOSKEY. PUFFS ROYALOAK ALMAS HI FI TRAVERSE CITY SOUND ROOM TROY PECANS WI: ALEXANDRIA SOUND SHOP BEMIDOI OVERBEEK ELECTRONICS MINNEAPOLISSTEREOLAND ROCHESTER AMALGAMATED AN WILLMAR SOUND IMAGE MO: COLUMBIA D 6 MSOUND SPRINGFIELD GREYSTO(ES ST LOUIS HIFI FORUM MC STARKVILLE IDEAL ACOUSTICS VT: BILLINGS U S TECH MISSOULA STEREO PLUS NC: ASHEVILLE AV CHAMBER CHARLOTTEPREMIER AV DURHAM AUDIO VISIONSWILMINGTON AN WORLD WINSTON SALEMPLATINUM AUDIO NO: FARGO TODAYELECTRONICS MANKATO TEAM ELECTRONICS NE: GRAND ISLAND VIDEO KINGDOM OGALLALAVIDEO KINGDOM OMAHA STEREO WEST NB:NASHUA ENSEMBLE NORTH HAMPTON NEWENGLAND HI Fl NJ: BERNARDSVILLE STEVEN'SAUDIO BLOOMINGDALE SOUND CITY CHERRYHILL HI FI SALES E BRUNSWICK ATLANTICSTEREO FLEMINGTON PROFESSIONAL VIDEO &SOUND FREEHOLD ATLANTIC STEREOMiDDLETOWN STEREO DYNAMICS PARAMUSRABSONS AN POMPTON PLAINS SOUND CITY SOMERVILLE SOUND EXCIIANGE TOWACO SOUNDCITY WEST NEW YORK PARK PLACE NM:ALBUQUERQUE ABSOLUTE AUDIO LAS CRUCESDESERT SOUND NV: RENO WILD WEST NY:ALBANY ALTAIR AUDIO COMMACK SOUNDAPPROACH GREAT NECK SOUND EFFECTS HAMBURG SMITHTOWN AN ITHICA GALLAOER JOHNSON CITY OLUMS LAKE GROVE AUDIO DEN MT KISCO AUDIO OUTLET NEW YORK AUDIOSALON AN CENTER PARK AVENUE SOUND CITY PLEASANT MLLE AUDIO EXCELLENCE ROCHESTERROWE A SYRACUSE GORDON BROTHERS WATERTOWN HAPPY EAR WEST BABYLON AUDIOVISIONS ON: AKRON OHIO SOUND CANTONBELDON AUDIO CINCINNATI OHIO VALLEY AUDIO DAYTON AUDIO ETC DUBLIN AUDIO ENCOUNTERS
TOLEDO JAMIESON S STEREO OK:BARTLESVILLE SOUND STATION MIDWEST CITYAUDIO MIDWEST STILLWATER AUDIO SAY ON:BEND STEREO PLANT EUGENE ADVANCED AUDIO PORTLAND FRED'S SOUND OF MUSIC ROOMSERVICE SALEM ADVANCED AUDIO HEAR NOEVIL PA: BROOMAI I HIGH FIDELITY HOUSE CAMPHILL HI FI HOUSE CHAMBERSBURG LINCOLNLECTRONICS EPHRATA STEREO BARNGREENSBURG STEREO SHOP HARRISBURG HI FlHOUSE JENKINTOWN STEREO OUTLETJOHNSTOWN CONNECTING POINT LANCASTERGAT STEREO MCMURRAY GOOSEBUMPS MONTGOMERYVILLE WORLD WIDE PITTSBURGHAUDIO GALLERY WORLD WIDE STEREO STATECOLLEGE PAUL 6 TONY'S WHITEHALL PALMERAUDIO RE PROVIDENCE STEREO AN CENTER SC:COLUMBIA SOUND ADVICE GREENVILLEAMERICAN AUDIO HILTON HEAD ISLAND ANARCHITECTS MT PLEASANT PEACHTREE SOBROOKINGS ZEPHYR AUDIO SIOUX FALLSENTERTAINMENT DIRECT TN: JOHNSON CITY MRTOADS STEREO KINGSPORT AMERICAN VIDEO KNOXVILLE STATEMENT AN MEMPHIS MODERNMUSIC AAv TK: AMARILLO AUDIO VISIONS AUSTIN AUDIO BY DESIGN BRYAN SOUND WAVES CORPUS CHRISTI ABSOLUTE A V DALLASHILLCREST HI Fl HOUSTON ALL STAR AUDIO GROOVE AN LUBBOCK SOUND WAVE MCALLENAUDIO PLUS VIDEO MIDLAND MIDLAND SOUND SAN ANTONIO AUDIO CONCEPTS SAN MARCOSDISCOVERY AUDIO SHERMAN WORLD WIDE TYLER Say CENTER UT: PROVO AUTOSPECIALTIES VA: BLACKSBURG SCOTTYCHESAPEAKE DOMES CAXTON MUSICSCOPE VT:WILLISTON CREATIVE SOUND WA: BELLEVUEDEFINITIVE AUDIO EVERETT AUDIO WAVES KENNEWICK QUICK SILVER AUDIO PULLMANOPTIMUM SOUND SEATTLE DEFINITIVE AUDIO SPOKANE SKI INTERIORS WI: APPLETON SUESSELECTRONICS GREEN BAY HI FI HEAVEN MADISON UNIVERSITY AUDIO MILWAUKEE AUDIOEMPORIUM RACINE AL'S STEREO SHEBOYGANABSOLUTE &IV WASHBURN AUDIO WORKS WV:MORGANTOWN SOUND INVESTMENTS WY:CHEYENNE NOW HEAR THIS LARAMIE KEN'SMUSIC BOX
MUM 1/111MAIS VIMNNW OF 13111 Malk
Paradigm's Eclipse/BP
and Esprit/BP have bothreceived prestigiousGrand Prix Product of theYear Awards from Audio/Video International!With 7 new awards thisyear, Paradigm has nowreceived over 70 awardssince 1990. The critics
resoundingly agree.Paradigm is the #1 choicefor critical listeners!
"Superb!"- Stereo Review on the Export/BP
"Stoning,"- The Inner Ear Report on the Esprit/BP
"Awesome!"- Audio Ideas Guide on the Echpfe/BP
pARADIGM'S spectacular bipolar speakers are anengineering and sonic marvel! With years of design
expertise and our highly advanced R&D facility, PAFADIGM
engineers and acousticians set out to build the vv)rld's finestbipolar speakers, regardless of cost! PARADIGM Bipolar Speakers setthe highest standard of technological excellence and deliverbreathtaking performance! So don't settle for less, listen to thesesensational speakers today!
.=
I I 1Z.-amoiNtanso FOR TTTTTT SOUND
- 1w/to/Vide, International Prix
For mon- onfiwmanon on FIRADRAI 131P014125 as well as other fine Paradigm speakers
Wu: your nearest AUTHORIZED AIRADIGAI DIX FR or write:
AUDIOS! RiAlI. MPO Box 2410. Niagara Falb. NY 14302 (905) 632-0180GDRuidl: PAII4DR,A1. 101 Hanlon Rd. Woodbridge. ON L41 31'5 (905) 850-2889
CIRCLE NO. 17 ON READER SERVICE CARD
AUDIO CLINICJOSEPH GIOVANELLI
Aircraft InterferenceQLiving near an airport, I can often hear
pilots' comments loud and clearthrough my stereo system. This unwanted in-
terference occurs only when I am listening toLPs or transferring them to tape. Why do Ihear this interference, and what can I doabout it?-Name withheld
AMost likely, the cable from yourturntable to your phono input is
acting as an antenna, and some semicon-ductor in your system's phono section isrectifying these AM signals, demodulatingthem into plain audio. (Cable shielding isseldom completely effective and is likely tobe even less effective at high radio fre-quencies, such as the 118 to 136 MHz usedby aircraft.)
The simplest cure is to place some ferritebeads on the cables. Some of these beadseven let you wind a turn or two of cablethrough them, which provides some induc-tance beyond that offered by the beadsthemselves. The combined series induc-tance may be sufficient to "choke" the in-terference-hopefully eliminating it com-pletely. You should place the beads as closeto the preamplifier as practical. (RadioShack lists ferrite beads in its catalog, under"Filters-EMI/RFI Choke Cores.")
You may be able to find interconnectingcables that are better shielded than thoseyou now use. However, cables with bettershielding may have considerably more ca-pacitance than your present cables. You mayneed to compensate for this if you have amoving -magnet cartridge. Your cartridgeand preamp owner's manuals may describethe best way to do it.
Are My CDs Defective?QWith LPs, you knew on the first play if
you had a defective album, but I neverreally know when I've bought defective CDs.
Some of them cannot be played even once,and others play perfectly once or twice, afterwhich I hear dropouts, skips, and so on. Notknowing whether discs are good or not means
I'm unable to return the defective ones; toomuch time goes by between the time I take
them home and the time the trouble starts.What should I do?-David A. Taylor, Brain-tree, Mass.
AFirst, try these discs on another ma-chine. If they play properly, your
problem is probably with your own ma-chine; perhaps its optics are dirty or dusty,or maybe its tracking has become marginal.If your CDs are the problem, have you been
taking proper care of them? Are you puttingthem back in their jewel boxes betweenplays? If not, they may be picking up dust orbecoming scratched. Are there fingerprintsor dirt on the discs?
If it's the player's fault, have it fixed. If it'syour fault, buy a CD cleaning device (getone that rubs across the disc's surfacerather than around it) and reform yourhabits.
Subwoofer Crossover TypesQJohn Sehring's recent article on sub -woofer design (July 1995) talks about
crossover filters to be used in tape loops. Are
these the same as filters that I've seen used be-
tween preamps and power amps? Is such afilter better than a typical crossover networkmounted in the cabinet?-Name withheld
AThe article described a low-pass filter,used to roll off upper frequencies be-
fore they reach the subwoofer. Such filtersare usually connected between a preampand subwoofer amp, so that only the signalto that amp is filtered. Mr. Sehring put hisfilter into a tape loop only because he usedan integrated amp, not a power amp, to drivehis subwoofer. You should definitely notput the filter in your main preamp's tapeloop, or you'll roll off the highs to your en-tire system.
If you're using only one subwoofer, you'llalso need a network to add the two chan-nels together to get a mono sum signal. Ifyou put this after the low-pass filter, you'llneed one such filter for each channel. If youput it before the filter, you'll have to isolateit from the preamp, or your entire system'sstereo separation will suffer. If your preamphas a center -channel output, you can usethat to feed your subwoofer filter.
A low-pass filter is only half a completecrossover. The other half is a high-pass fil-ter, which keeps low frequencies out of thesatellite speakers and allows them to pro-duce more volume with less distortion. Thehigh-pass filter would go between your pre -amp and the amp that feed your satellitespeakers.
The crossover filters built into sub -woofers should have the right frequenciesfor those speakers, but they will vary inquality. These crossovers will also vary intype: Subwoofers having only input termi-nals but no output terminals have only low-pass filters inside; subwoofers having out-put terminals usually incorporate high-passfilters, too.
Multiple Driver ImpedancesQHow can multidriver loudspeaker sys-
tems present impedances of about 4 to8 ohms to an amplifier when each driver'simpedance is about 4 to 8 ohms?-AlanFassinger, Rochester Hills, Mich.
AIf you connected an 8 -ohm woofer,midrange, and tweeter directly to a
pair of amplifier terminals, the impedancewould not be 8 ohms. It would be muchhigher than 8 ohms if you connected themin series and much lower than that if youconnected them in parallel. But drivers arenot connected that way. There is usually apassive crossover network, which ensuresthat the amplifier is mainly feeding to thewoofer in the bass range, to the tweeter inthe treble, and to the midrange in between.(I say "mainly," because the amplifier feedstwo drivers at a time in the region aroundeach crossover frequency; this is true eventhough there's theoretically only one fre-quency per crossover at which both driversare fed equal signal levels.)
In speakers that have active crossovers,each driver is fed from a separate amplifier,with the crossover determining which fre-quencies go to each amp. Since no amplifiersees more than one driver, combined im-pedance is, again, not a factor.
If you have a problem or question about audio,write to Mr. Joseph Giovanelli at AUDIO Maga-zine, 1633 Broadway, New York, N.Y. 10019, orvia E -Mail to [email protected]. All lettersare answered. In the event that your letter is cho-sen by Mr. Giovanelli to appear in Audioclinic,please indicate if your name or address shouldbe withheld. Please enclose a stamped, self-ad-dressed envelope.
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199612
(,/F-IERE'S A SEnSE OF inDiViDUALISM,
OVERF_owinG inTELLIGErICE, -OTAL POWER,
ArlD 'r'OU HAVEKT EVErl TURrIED IT on YET.
< I 'itt -!)!, is the most innovative receiver ever
created. An audio/video receiver designed with one goal.
to giveyou the most realistic theater sound possible.With the touch of a button, your entire system comes alive
with Dolly Surround
AC -3 gives your ear the distinct pleasure of hearing
six independent digital signals. And duplicates for our
home the thrilling performance of digital surround sound
which. until now, was heard exciusively in top theaters.
The Accurate Imaging System consistently distributes
100 watts to each channel. all with discrete amplifiers.
delivering the f.11 bandwidth (20H. to 20IcH.) provided by
AC -3. And the Intelligent System Control brings the
operation of all your components. including those of other
brands. toyour fingertips.
All this at the heart ofyour audio/video system, giving
you the most uncompromising sound dualitypossible. as
you would expect only from
Elite. For the Elite deafer near-
est you. call 1-800-746-6337
LLITEBY PIONEER
01995 Pioneer Electronics (USA) Inc., Long Beach, CA. Dolby and AC -3 are tradenutios of Dolby Laboratories Licensing Lorlwntinn.
CIRCLE NO. 18 ON READER SERVICE CARD
What's "0 dB"?QTest reports and spec sheets keep refer-
ring to "0 dB," but they don't all seem
to mean the same thing. What is it?-BenShepherd, Fanwood, N.J.
ADecibels (dB, for short) are not ab-solute units like volts and ohms. In-
stead, they represent a ratio between mea-surements. We can turn decibels intoabsolute units by appending a fixed refer-ence to the "dB." Sometimes, we make thatreference explicit, as in dB SPL (sound pres-sure level in dB relative to the threshold ofhuman hearing), dBW (dB relative to1 watt), etc.; sometimes, however, the refer-ence is only implicit.
In digital audio, "0 dB" usually refers to afull-scale digital signal, the loudest signalthat can be recorded digitally. (This is notdefined in terms of volts or watts but interms of the bits involved-a "0 -dB" sig-nal's bits are all ones instead of zeros.)Audio has lately been calling this level"0 dBFS," the "FS" standing for "full-scale."
In discussing analog tape decks, the 0 -dBreference point may be the level for a signalrecorded when the deck's meter reads "0"(a level that varies between models), but itmight also be either the recording level atwhich third -harmonic distortion reaches3% or a fixed signal level of 250 nWb/m(nanowebers per meter) on the tape. It's upto the author of the article to explain which"0" he's using.
In graphs of frequency response, howev-er, 0 dB is merely a convenient temporaryreference, usually the system's output at1 kHz. A reading of +2 dB at a given fre-quency tells us that the system's output is 2dB higher at that frequency than it is at 1
kHz. The reading does not tell us what thesystem's output is, as this will depend onthe input.
Diagnosing a Dead PhonoChannel
QI have almost no output from the left
channel of my moving -coil phono car-
tridge. My balance control is centered, and Ican find no problems with any of the connec-
tions. But I did notice that the tracking forcewas 1.8 grams instead of the factory -recom-mended 1.5 grams. Could this have causedpremature failure? If so, wouldn't both chan-nels have been affected?-Stephen Bruyere,
Ottawa, Ont., Canada
ANo, that slightly high tracking forcewould not have caused the premature
failure of your cartridge. When trackingforce is too great, stylus wear increases orthe stylus bends. Your 0.3 -gram error is in-significant.
Did you check the wiring within the tone -
arm? Breaks are likely at the terminalswhere the wire connects to the turntable'soutput leads. Check all connections be-tween the phono cables and the terminallugs that attach wires to the cartridge. Youcan test this wiring by reversing the twochannels' leads to the cartridge (be carefulnot to break those delicate wires). If thesame channel stays dead, your cartridge isokay; if it isn't, you'll have to send the car-tridge back to the manufacturer or im-porter for repair.
Audio AccountabilityQI spend a lot of money on equipment,and I believe much of it is thrown away
because manufacturers do not support theirproducts. For example, in the early '80s Ibought a cutting -edge surround processorthat cost $1,300; about a year after its intro-duction, another $250 bought a modificationfor use of a remote. (By the way, the company
never did offer the remote, just the modifica-
tion for one.) The processor proved difficult to
calibrate and also leaked spurious, tweeter -damaging signals. The maker never offeredany adjustment or refund; it just took themoney and ran. I find that other companiesalso lack accountability. It's not the principle;
it's the money!-Herb Leibson, New York,N.Y.
ADid the company "take the moneyand run," or did it really take the
money and fold? I note that the maker ofyour processor is no longer listed in Audio's
Annual Equipment Directory (October1995 issue).
Many audio companies start in some-one's kitchen or garage, led by people whohave a dream, good ears, and technicalknowledge but not much capital (and, toooften, not much business knowledge). Mostof these companies want to be accountable,but some never get the chance. They may beswept away by normal business storms orlose their shirts attempting to fix problemsthey were unaware of until defective prod-ucts were returned. It might be that in deal-ing with the adjustment problems you
mention, the company used up the moneyit intended to spend on producing a remotecontrol. (Obviously, it would have been bet-ter if they'd withheld the "remote -ready"modification until they really had remotesto sell.)
I also know of firms whose productswere selling very well but whose ownerssquandered their capital while trying toproduce the perfect "whatsit." During themore than 40 years that I have followed theaudio field, many companies have comeand gone, and very few of the early, pio-neering firms remain with us today.
Despite the fact that most audio manu-facturers are ethical, there are inevitablysome cons around. So if you feel you're duemoney back and can't get it, and you sus-pect dishonesty, you should take some ac-tion-whether the firm is large or small. Ifyou believe you have a valid case, take it toyour state's attorney general, department ofconsumer protection, or perhaps even to afederal agency. Your local Better BusinessBureau can often help, as can your post-master if the company sells by mail.
Audio LeakageQ1 have recently noticed faint audioleakage in the right channel of my pre-
amplifier. When listening to the output of mytape deck through the preamp's tape monitor,
I can hear the currently selected line source in
the right channel. I can also hear it with thetape monitor out and with the volume all theway down. This happens with any source I se-
lect and with any setting of the volume andbass controls. Boosting the treble makes theleakage louder. However, when the tone con-trols are bypassed, the leakage disappears.What might be causing this?-StephenSavulak, Marlton, N.J.
AAll signs point to a deteriorating de -coupling capacitor in your preamp's
power -supply system. Since the leakage in-creases with treble boost and disappearswhen the tone -control circuits are by-passed, the decoupling capacitor associatedwith the tone -control circuit is the one toreplace. (There are probably separate. de -coupling capacitors for the left and rightchannels.) The problem capacitor will beeasier to find if you have a service manualfor your preamp. Otherwise, you may haveto tediously trace circuit -board foils or re-place a lot of your capacitors. A
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199614
GG
Matthew Polk Redefines State -Of -The -Art Again."MATTHEW POLK'S HOME THEATER SYSTEM CAN NOW BE YOURS
What started out as Matthew Polk's desire to deiigi the ultimate Lome theater
system turned into the most ambitious research p-oject in Polk's 22 year
history. The result, the Signature Reference Theater
(SRT), is a home entertainment sys-
tem of such enormous dynamic
range, accuracy, clarity and
power that listening will touch
you physically and emotionally.
Five proprietary Polk tech-
nologies, including Polk's leg-
endary SDA imaging, are com-
bined to bring you "Performance
Without Limits".
For more information
and the location of a Polk
SRT dealer near you, call
(800) 377 - POLK.
Dealer Locator Number
1-800-992-2520
ill Ad code: 20012
The SRT system consists of 35 active drive units housed in
seven enclosures (including two 300 watt powered sub -
woofers) and a Control Center with wireless remote.
Matthew PatCo-founder, Polk Audio
WARNING: THIS SYSTEM IS CAPABLE OF EXTREME SOUND PRESSURE LEVELS. SRT SYSTEMS ARE SUPPLIED WITH
A SOUND PRESSURE LEVEL METER TO HELP YOU DETERMINE SAFE LISTENING LEVELS.
PolkThe Speaker Specialists
5601 Metro Drive, Baltimore, Maryland 21215 USA (410)358-3600."Polk Audio"," The Speaker Specialists" and "Dynamic Balance" are registered trademarks of Polk Mvestment Corporation used under license by Polk Audio Incorporated.
CIRCLE NO. 19 ON READER SERVICE CARD
KEN KESSLER
DUMB AND DUMBERTraveling around the world re-veals something dark anddirty about the audio busi-ness: You learn that certaincountries have becomedumping grounds for the
home -entertainment industry andthat the various markets really aretreated differently. (And not just be-cause one country's populace hasgreater disposable income than an -other's.) So while we'd all like tothink that the world is shrinking andthat a can of Coca-Cola in Aix-en-Provence will taste exactly like oneyou'd slurp in Peoria, such consis-tency isn't always a given. Yes, you'dprobably have to be a cola maven totell Cokes bottled in different coun-tries apart, but that's an exception.The hi-fi scene is quite differentfrom the soft-drink trade.
Before you gasp at the thoughtthat a particular amplifier soundsdifferent in the Alps than it does inthe Appalachians, stop worrying:I'm not talking about sonic vari-ations but actual model avail-ability. It manifests itself indozens of ways, not justthrough counterfeiting. (Yes,there are people in this worldstupid enough to think thatthey can get real B & W, Bose, or
JBL speakers for $29 per pair.)China, as I learned about two
years ago, is the place to go if youhave the hots for something obso-lete. I found stores full of the unsolddetritus of the Hong Kong hi-fi wars,ancient models that predated theneed for an input marked "CD."Sadly, these antiques weren't collec-tors items, so please don't think for amoment that mainland China is arepository for unused Marantz Mod-el 7s or McIntosh 275s. What I saw
were late '70s Infinity speakers (mostwith dead EMITs) and Meridianamps from the "chocolate bar" era,when all Meridian products lookedlike Hershey bars. In one locale, I saw
several Musical Fidelity tuners, apair of Tangent
loudspeakers,and an SAE
preampcirca1974.
This was nomuseum,
however, nor was it a shop declaringitself to be a purveyor of pre -ownedgoods. This stuff was new, but onlyin the sense that it had never beensold before. Selling it in China wassimply a way for distributors in otherAsian territories to clear their ware-houses by exploiting an unsuspect-ing public.
Japan, too, has weird little foibles,a result of that country's obsession
with saving face. Rather than riskembarrassment by exporting an ut-ter turkey to the United States or Eu-rope, Japanese manufacturers tendto try out their most bizarre ideas onthe locals, knowing that word ofsuch strange wares is unlikely toreach Western ears.
It is therefore with deep regret thatI tell you I didn't purchase (or evenphotograph) the Panasonic combi-nation cassette/radio/electric razor Isaw in an Akihabara departmentstore. However, I remain astonishedthat one of the largest companies in
the world failed to realize (1) that'' , an electric shaver produces
an unpleasant buzzingsound that will inter-fere with the enjoy-ment of music generat-
ed by the same deviceand (2) that the actualvibration from an elec-tric shaver will have some
effect on a tape playerhoused in the same chassis.
Like, uh, wow and flutter,maybe? Even though the de-vice was a marvel of minia-turization, no bigger than anormal shaver or personal
tape player, its Jim Carrey-likedumb-and-dumberness defies allrational marketing practice.
And yet it persists. In the firstmonths of 1996, we find thatthe majors still haven't learnedtheir lessons or learned to cut
their losses. For what do we seein the United Kingdom? Yes, dearreaders on the saner side of the
pond: Sony is still beating theMiniDisc drum, while Philips refusesto bury Digital Compact Cassette.The latter is all the more surprisingbecause it was reported more than ayear ago in a major British newspa-per that the head of Philips, Jan Tim-mer, had deemed DCC, well, dead.But the company just won't give up,no doubt because it must smart towrite off millions of wasted guilders.
So when the promises of techno-logical brilliance fail to sell a newconcept, what do you do? You cut the
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199616
A bullet-proofargument for thenew B&W 600 Series.
((( ftf fr.,
Ifobal Ian grooves (C01'or Info: 212-L60.5379 faxtsraveseginrv,.a:C6S5 C011,
The use of our patented Kevlara coniesis reason enough to choose the new:B&W 600 Series.
After all, Kevlar has always beer the standardin B&W's best and mo$t expensive
loudspeakers.
KEVLAR. IS I SED IN 13
BitrOF VESTS ,%\lf HIGH -EN
13&W LOUDSPEAKERS LIKE. THE
-1NDARY B&W MATRIX 80
LSD CELEBRATED SI ,VER
SIGN %TURF. ITS MAGIC LIES IN
ITS B1LITY TO ELIMI
EFFECTS OF RESONA
ST V". DI NG WAVES. ESPECIAL'
IN CRITICAL MID -RANGE FR
III 1- NCI ES. So ALL you HEA
IS PURE, UNCOLORED II
But that's just theistart of our bullet-proof argument. Be4use B&W's top -gunengineers loaded a llarrage of technicalinnovations into an 'entire family ofaffordable, high peiformance speakers-the B&W 600 Seri4s.
Our metal dome tweeters-borrowedfrom the Matrix 401s- provide near -perfect response tib well beyond audibility.
Beveled cabinet edges and solidlybraced enclosurks minimize box
resonance and the effects of diffractionfor truly transparent sound. Gold-plated tkpeaker terminals allow forbiwiring to reduce component cross -talk.
You can chpose from a full line ofspeakers ranking from bookshelf to floorstanding, center channel to surroundsound. even an active subwoofer. Prices stOrt at just $400 a pair.
End of argument. Any questions? Fire away.
Call 1-800-370-3740.
agym--wriff
The new B&W 600 Series
B&W Loudspeakers of America,54 Concord Street. North Reading, MA 01864
tel 1-800-370-3740 fax 508-664-4109_isten and You'll See Kevlar is a registered trademark of Dupont
CIRCLE NO. 3 ON READER SERVICE CARD
Critics Rave..."...The Biggest Bargain Of All Time !'
Stu McCreary,.Positive Feedback, VAS No.3
"...One Hell Of A Buy !!"The Inner Far, July 1995
*04//e/it &-ede °shit;SE -40 Single -Ended, Pure Class A, 40+40W (80W mono) for $980.00
NEW!! SE -40 matching vaccum tube pre -amplifier, SEP-- I now available for $880.00
Call Solo Electronics at (510)887-8016 for the Golden Tube Dealers near you2462 Tripaldi Way. Hayward CA 94545. FAX 887-1657, HANDCRAFTED IN USA
CIRCLE NO 24 ON READER SERVICE CARD
It may be small. But the Bose' Acoustic Wave" music system is definitely anoverachiever. The unit holds a compact disc player (or cassette), AM/FMradio, and Bose's patented acoustic waveguide speaker technology. And pro-duces a rich, natural sound quality comparable to audio systems costing thou-sands of dollars. We know that's hard to believe. So we're ready to prove it.Call or write now for our complimentary guide to this award -winning system.Because, like the system itself, it is only available _ErArm,,direct from Bose. Better sound through research k
City
Call 1-800-898-BOSE, ext. W345.
1r leplione
State Zip
Or Mali to: Bose Corporation, The Mountain,Dept. CDD-W MS, Framingham, MA 01701-9168.
price, right? Given that the shops aren't ex-actly filled with prerecorded DCC tapes(despite a catalog of around 1,000 titles),the format's only appealing aspect is that ofa digital recorder on the cheap. And that hasbeen exploited about as far as it can go: Youcan now buy a brand -spanking -new DCCdeck-not just some piece of portable,pocket -sized junk-for £250 in the U.K.That's $375 for a real digital tape recorder.
But who wants it? Philips-the companythat co -invented CD, the first usable andcommercially viable optical playback sys-tem-continues to contradict itself by pro-moting a system launched in the 1990s thatsuffers from physical contact between ma-chine and software. The continued bleatingabout DCC's backward compatibility withexisting analog cassettes wasn't the sellingpoint the Dutch giant had hoped it wouldbe, so physical -contact heads are quite sim-ply a compromise, not a gift.
PHILIPS REFUSES
TO BURY DCC
EVEN AFTER ITS BOSS
HAS DEEMED
THE FORMAT DEAD.
On paper, though, that DCC deck lookslike it offers exceptional value for money,especially if you're one of those sad andsorry schmucks who thinks that anythingbearing the tag "digital" is automaticallywonderful. The analog cassette playback as-pects of a DCC deck (full-sized or portable)merely offer convenience. With decent -quality analog tape decks available in theU.K. for as little as the equivalent of $180(and acceptable portable players for evenless), the analog section of a DCC unit ishardly a point of great value. But for anyonewho craves a digital recording system, DCCalmost looks good, given the high prices forR-DAT machines.
Since the record industry all but killed offDAT, forcing it into the professional sector(where it serves perfectly in a number ofroles), DAT doesn't really succeed as a con-sumer rival to DCC. The tapes cost more,the hardware costs more, and there simplyare no prerecorded DAT cassettes to speakof in European shops. Maybe DCC can ex-
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199618
ploit this, but I rather doubt it. Some suck-ers, like yours truly, live in hope that CD -R
(recordable CD) might one day he afford-able. (And Pioneer is taking the lead there.)
Others realize that, for portable and car use
anyway, analog cassettes are good enough
and that CD and LP remain the primarysources for audiophiles.
So that leaves digital recording fetishists
with but one alternative, that other virtual-ly stillborn system (at least in Europe) cur-
rently undergoing another bout of feverishpromotion in the U.K. Hey, I wanted Mini -
Disc to survive because it had the makings
of being a dream all -in -one music carrier.
It's optical, so no wear and tear. The disccomes in a protective case. It's small with-out being impossible to handle (like the mi-
crocassettes in dictation machines). And itrecords. The success of MD would havemeant one size fits all: home hi-fi, carstereo, and portable. Playback and record.
Sturm and Drang. Love and marriage. Butthere was one problem: It sounded prettyaverage, certainly not as good as CD.
But, as with DCC, each generation ofMI) has brought improvement, and Sonyhas not let early disappointments in the ex-
port market halt the format's development.
(I keep hearing that MiniDisc has a greatfuture as a computer storage medium, but
the technology for bulk data storage is un-
dergoing a tumultuous revolution becauseof high -density read/write CDs, new tapeformats, etc. So I wouldn't bank on the per-
sonal computer being MD's savior.) Thelatest products are alleged to have improved
over the second -generation models asmuch as the second generation improvedover the first.
You have to hand it to Sony. It has pro-
moted MD not just through the hi-fi pressbut also in expensive, general -interest me-
dia. I've seen the ads in film magazines and
glossy lifestyle magazines. I even saw one in
Car, the U.K.'s leading automotive title.And it wasn't just any old ad but an eight -
page insert on the kind of paper stock that
you'd expect to see used for a Bentleybrochure. The ad is lavish, cool, and worthy
of the high technology it's trying to sell.The front page is black, with a half -dollar -sized opening through which you read theword "holes." Open to the first spread, and
there's a sepia -toned shot of an absolutely
wrecked music cassette. Agair, an opening
on the right-hand side reveals the word"holes," placed in the middle of the tape'sright-hand hub. Then comes the punchline: "There are no holes in our system."Which, of course, is bull, because an MD's
shell, just like a cassette's, does have a hole
in it (so the drive hub can connect to thedisc to make it spin). But that's not thepoint. Indeed, I'm ashamed that I let suchpedantry undermine the work of a brilliant
copywriter. Not.
Sony has belabored the "holes" thing so
thoroughly that you can easily find yourself
forgetting it's a premise based on a big, fat
misconception on the part of the ad writer.You get a full page about the product's ben-
efits, followed by a lavish spread showingthe various offerings: car, portable, homehi -f, plus midi -system. It's titled "The Fu-
ture of Tape," the theme recurringthroughout this campaign, that MD is thecassette of tomorrow.
And that sets up the other punch line,which the ad writer created without evenrealizing it. The very last item shown on the
page is the MHC-MD5 midi -system, which
gives you the works, including (and Iquote) "...even a twin -cassette deck." A
-7 he effect cables have on your system is like Ic oking through a window. Some cables
distort your view of the music. Others add their own reflections. Music Metre cabks open the
window,giving you the clearest view possible. In other words -remarkably natural, uncolored sound.
To get a clear view of the Music Metre line,call 1-818-242-4535 or send a fax to 1818-242-44I5.HCIRCLE NO. 15 ON READER SERVICE CARD
4A4AZ HailLINTERCONNECTS AND SPEAKER CABLES
Multichannel)uric 1 \ceerchng
By DANIEL SWEENEY
With fully discrete, dig-ital multichannel soundnow promising (eventu-ally) to supplant ma-trixed Dolby Surroundin home theater, specu-
lation has begun to grow that the time isripe for a serious reemergence of multi-channel music recording. For movie andTV sound, the standard format employs"5.1" independent channels: three full -
range front channels (left, center, andright), two full -range surround channels(left and right), and a low -frequency effects
(LFE) channel that cuts off above 125 Hz.In this country, implementation will be pri-marily, if perhaps not exclusively, by meansof Dolby AC -3 coding, which has beenadopted for laserdisc, the U.S. HDTV sys-tem, and DVD (digital videodisc) in NTSCTV markets and possibly in PAL markets aswell-we should know the answer to thatone shortly after this article goes to press.
Multichannel music recording could fol-low exactly the same path, simply exploit-ing equipment already in place for hometheater, or it could diverge in one or morerespects. The high -density discs developedfor DVD have so much capacity that datareduction (as in AC -3) would be unneces-sary for audio -only applications, yet therewould still be room for more channels andlonger word lengths (20 bits, for example,rather than the CD -standard 16), if desired,
without reducing playing time from that onconventional two -channel CDs.
Beyond the format question, though notentirely independent of it, is the more fun-damental question of whether the music in-dustry is prepared to embrace multichannelrecording again. The quadraphonic debacle
ft viewm the
console
of the '70s is still a haunting memory formany people in the music business, andthere are so many different ways of imple-menting multichannel recording and play-back that a format war like the one thathelped do in quad could easily occur again.Even if that doesn't happen, there's still thequestion of music -industry acceptance, giv-en the generally short shrift accorded theDolby Surround matrix by recording engi-neers and artists. There is a buzz in the air,however, and if nothing else the notion ofmultichannel music recording will get asecond hearing in the audio community.
In the midst of this discussion of multi-channel music software, two related ques-tions will be paramount: What use will bemade of all these channels by recording en-gineers (and to what end), and how mustthe listener configure his playback system torecover the new information most com-pletely? I'll be focusing mainly on the firstquestion here.
The Road Behind l'sThe why and how ofmultichannel sound willultimately be answeredby the recording engi-neers, not by academi-cians, and it was to the
engineers that I turned for answers aboutwhat sorts of listening experiences wemight expect from multichannel. In anyevent, no one's doing much theorizing inthe scientific publications anymore. Theseminal conceptual work was done in the'60s and '70s, and purely practical consider-ations dominate today's discussions.
But to understand current thinking, it'shelpful to know the foundations on whichit is based. Multichannel recording, as it was
first presented to the public, was an accom-paniment to wide-screen motion pictureprocesses of the 1950s. Millions of Ameri-cans thrilled to the high-fidelity multichan-nel soundtracks of such films as The Soundof Music, Oklahoma, Ben Hur, Lawrence of
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199620
ull
classic quadraphonicspeaker array, with tour identicalspeakers deployed syniniet rival habout the listening position ina rectangular preferably square.array. Ideally, die hiur speakerswould be equidistant from thelistener. As in modern surroundsound systems. the quad speakerlayout presemed compatibilit% withconventional stereo playback.
Arabia, and 2001: A Space Odyssey, but theinfluence of this kind of recording on themusic industry seems to have been mini-mal. Most of the pioneering quad mixers ofthe early '70s had no experience in filmrecording. Instead, they tended to think ofmultichannel as a fairly straightforward ex-tension of stereo music recording, thoughtheoreticians were even then propoundingmodels that were fundamentally subversiveto the familiar two -channel paradigm.
It's also interesting that at the time thequad formats were being launched, stereorecording techniques themselves were be-ginning to splinter. Relatively simple mik-ing arrangements had characterized alltypes of recording at the dawn of stereo, butduring the late '60s the advent of eight- andsixteen -track tape recorders and Dolbynoise reduction made possible the "assem-bled" stereo that has characterized popularmusic recording ever since. Minimalisttechniques became almost exclusively theprovince of purist classical and, to a lesserextent, jazz recording, where the illusion ofa real performance was sought. Thus thequad recordist, in seeking to build uponstereo, could choose either to extend thenaturalistic soundstage he was already cre-
ating with his basic stereo microphone set-up or to modify his pop studio mixdown
techniques to produce four finalchannels rather than two. In ei-ther case he was simply produc-ing, at least in his own mind,stereo squared.
In the early days, the minimal-ists seemed to have a clearer idea
where they were going in aug-menting stereo. Their goals werefairly straightforward, their toolswere relatively simple, and the
theoretical basis behind their work wasmore solid, if for no other reason than thatmost of the deep thinkers who chose towrite about quad espoused the ideal ofreplicating a performance event rather thanproducing interesting sound effects.
There were a few early theorists interest-ed in naturalistic recording, such asE. Roerback Madsen in Denmark, who ex-perimented with miking arrangements thatowed little to accepted stereo recordingpractice. However, the usual minimalisttechnique of the early '70s was to use somekind of basic stereo microphone techniqueup front, such as angled cardioids or spacedomnis, and then to employ another pair ofmikes-often omnis-well back and spacedwide apart. Some theoretically inclinedrecordists, such as John Eargle, speculatedthat a fairly dry up -front presentationshould be sought from the frontpair, with the hall sound con-signed mainly to the back chan-nels, but this notion was by nomeans universally held.
Most minimalists did choose,however, to assign nondirection-al diffuse sounds to the backchannels and to that end sought to capturean ambient sound field consisting of ran-dom -phase information, using a widelyseparated pair of microphones at the rear ofthe hall to sample the reverberant field.Both Eargle and David Haller suggestedthat cardioids rather than omnis be used inback and that the microphones be turnedtoward the orchestra if the hall seemed ex-cessively live. Eargle, seeming to anticipateTom Holman's notion of surround -channeldecorrelation, felt that the back pickupsshould be out of phase to prevent the for-mation of a rear phantom image.
An interesting variant, described in theliterature but apparently never used com-mercially, was "triphonic" recording, with a
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199622
pair of angled omnis up front and close to-gether and a pair of widely spaced figure -
eights in back (with nulls facing the orches-tra). Each rear pickup represented a puredifference signal, L -R or R - L, while thefront microphones represented a kind ofhomogenized stereo, which registeredarrival -time differences but not amplitudedifferences.
Still other minimalists sought to achievea podium perspective by using directionalpickups in all four positions and attemptingto place direct sounds beside and behindthe listener. Many of the discrete four -chan-nel reel-to-reel tape recordings featured thiskind of mid -orchestra perspective.
Finally, there was UMX, later known asAmbisonics. Basically a variant of MS(mid -side) intensity -stereo recording tech-nique, it used a three- or four -channel ma-trix with two or three bidirectional micro-phones feeding as many tracks and oneomnidirectional microphone assigned to itsown track. All microphones were disposed
Symmetrywas a jiven
in quad;in today'ssurroundsystems,
it isn't.about a single point. This technique stoodsomewhat apart from what was being soldas quad and achieved negligible success atthe time. Most of the interest in Ambisonicscame during the late '70s, when the domi-nant quadraphonic systems (SQ, QS, andCD -4) were expiring.
Interestingly, at the same time that theuncharacteristically systematic Ambisonicsapproach was attracting attention, manywriters on the subject of quadraphonic
recording began to question the ultimateresolving power of a four -channel mediumand to stress its limitations in terms of fullyre-creating the spatial cues present at a liveevent. As early as 1970, Peter Scheiber, thefather of matrix multichannel recording,had expressed the opinion that four chan-nels did not necessarily represent the opti-mum number, but only toward the end ofthe decade did the experimental evidencebegin to accumulate suggesting that agreater number of channels might be need-ed for adequate re-creation of an acousticalspace.
But four playback channels remained thenorm even for Ambisonics, though it per-mitted additional channels to be generatedfrom the matrix. Furthermore, the model offour -channel playback adopted by the con-sumer audio industry, with a square ofspeakers arranged about a central listeningposition (see Fig. 1), conditioned therecording practice of the period. It predis-posed recording engineers to favor arrange-ments in which essentially two sets of stereopickups were deployed-one fore and an-other aft-despite the lack of any firm the-oretical basis for the practice.
In fact, two of the earliest theorists ofmultichannel playback, Hafler and Madsen,both suggested different models. Madsenadvocated a system in which sum and dif-ference components defined a triangularspeaker configuration, with common infor-mation (L + R) being reproduced by a cen-ter channel and antiphase difference signals(L -R and R - L) each being assigned toside -mounted speakers along the left andright walls (Fig. 2A). Hafler also favored acenter -front L + R speaker, with side speak-
ers to the left and right of the listening posi-tion. But whereas Madsen would send dif-ference signals to the sides, Hafler wouldsend pure left and right, with an L -R dif-ference signal assigned to a fourth speakerplaced directly behind the listener (Fig. 2B).That diamond arrangement later found fa-vor with many in the Ambisonics camp, butthe demands for full compatibility withconventional two -channel stereo were toostrong, and center channels were seldomseen in dealer showrooms. Years later, whenthe center channel reappeared in A/V sys-tems, it was kept in line with the left andright speakers, reflecting the speaker layoutused in movie theaters.
Despite the chaos and controversy of thequad years and the ambivalence of therecord labels toward the whole notion ofmultichannel sound, a family of mikingtechniques for quad did begin to develop.But quad miking practice never becameanywhere nearly as systematic as its two -channel counterpart, and as with so manyother failings of the great quadraphonic ex-periment, the reasons behind the arresteddevelopment of basic recording procedureswere largely commercial. According to most
of the quad recordists I interviewed-in-cluding Dan Graveraux and John McClureof CBS Records, Larry Boden of RCA Vic-tor, and John Eargle-the great bulk of theclassical releases in quad were not specifi-cally recorded for quad playback at all, andquad miking never even entered into thepicture. Recording for good stereo playback
LR))
L -R
remained the overriding con-cern of the record labels, andstereo material was simplyremixed for quad-provided, ofcourse, that the original mastertapes were multitrack.
In popular recording quadwas, not surprisingly, viewedrather differently. Many saw it asharmonizing rather well withthe prevailing musical aesthetic,which favored layered, proc-essed, effects -laden productionsin which feedback, fuzz boxes,
flanging, and wah-wah pedals all playedtheir part in altering the contemporaryconsciousness. Nobody I know of in popu-lar music ever developed any specific mik-ing technique for quad; instead, recordingengineers attempted to implement quad atthe mixing level by means of amplitudepanning along each of the four sides (a du-bious practice, as we shall see). Those inpopular music who embraced quad, andthere were many, were often eager to exper-iment with very aggressive quad mixes withequal output levels at each speaker location,but both the nature of the formats and theexigencies of the marketplace tended to di-lute the effects of such experiments. Onlyone true discrete format, Victor's CD -4,ever won any degree of acceptance, andmost of the material released came out in-stead in SQ or QS matrix format.
Fig. 2 Madsen and I lallerprnposed alternatives tocon% entional stereo that placed
greater emphasis on reproductionof ambience. 110111 used a single
speaker centered in front Itirreproduction ofI. It signal. \ladsen required4
only t%%o additional speakers. placed
to the sides of the listeningposition. which reproduceddirliTence signals in opposite phaseL II and II L. I laller's diamondarray on the other hand, sent'owe left- and right -channel signalsto side speakers and a differencesignal 'I. II; to a speaker directlyto the rear of
1.R Ell(((
-It
11.1.11.1
The dominance of the matrix formatshad a profound impact on quad recordingand mixing practice, because these formatsdid not provide the kind of channel separa-tion all around that would enable pinpointlocalization in two dimensions. The SQmatrix maintained decent separation onlyacross the front, so pans in depth or acrossthe back were badly muddled (they tendedto be unstable even with fully discrete sys-tems), while the QS matrix had weak sepa-ration all around, denying one even a solidfrontal soundstage. Without steering -logicdecoders to enhance separation, which ap-peared only in the late '70s when quad wasdying, you just couldn't get much in theway of precise directional effects withmatrix encoding. You could spread thesound out, but you couldn't place sound
sources precisely away from the front of theroom.
And, in any event, the same imperativeobtained in pop as in classical recording:Optimize for stereo, and make damned surethe mix is completely mono compatible.Recording specifically for quad consider-ably complicated matters, so it was almostnever done.
The Road AheadWhat about today?How do recording engi-neers, drawing on 20years of additional expe-rience, propose to rein-vent multichannel?
From my interviews, I'd have to say thatmost working engineers don't yet have clear
notions as to how to record formultichannel, although it is
generally expected that what-ever is done will be based onthe 5.1 -channel layout estab-lished for soundtrack record-ing. Only a handful of engi-neers appear to have reallythought deeply on such mat-ters, and predictably they areamong those who are clamor-ing for a reintroduction ofmultichannel music software.Interestingly, most began their
IP
11
(41DU:1E10D (( (EIDDLIEDDCDEDDDDDCILICIDEDD ( (
s 1 Is)
Fig. I l'oday's surround soundlaymil devotes three speakers (left.center. and right to reproduction ofthe front stereo image. In theatersystems A . surround infiwniationis delivered by multiple speakersarrayed along the sides and hack ofthe auditorium to pros ide adequatecoverage. In phiyhack of matrixfour -channel Dolby Surround. allsurround speakers receive the samesignal: fiir the new 5.i -channeldigital s stems. the surround arra% issplit left and right:1'1w home theaterlayout II is essentialk the same.except that the smaller roomdimensions eliminate the needfor multiple surround speakers oneach side of the room.
careers during or before the quad era andworked extensively with four -channel mixes.
Those who expressed fully developedphilosophies of recording for multichannelplayback were John Eargle, renowned in-dustry consultant, engineer on hundreds ofmajor -label classical recordings, and cur-rently chief recording engineer for Delos;Tom Jung, chief recording engineer fordmp records; Brad Miller, president of Mo-bile Fidelity International (not the samecompany as the more familiar Mobile Fi-delity Sound Lab); and Tom Holman, guid-ing light of Lucasfilm's THX program andan engineer with vast experience in bothconsumer and professional audio. Thoughnot so well known as a recording engineerand with no history of involvement in mul-
tichannel music recording, Holman isknown for his championing of multichan-nel music programming and has an excep-tional grasp of the scientific literature onsound localization relating to multispeakerplayback. He and Eargle are, in fact,cochairing an Audio Engineering Societyworking group on optimum formats formultichannel music recording. His insightson 5.1 -channel recording were most valu-able. John McClure and Larry Boden proved
extraordinarily helpful, though both de-clined to discuss the theoretical aspects ofmultichannel recording at great length.
The question I asked everyone is perhapsthe most obvious: What use do we make ofthe three channels beyond the stereo pair,and how will such determinations be re-flected in recording practice?
"The most significant thing is having ahard center instead of a phantom centerchannel," asserted John Eargle.
Tom Holman concurred. "The presenceof a center stabilizes the image, though notcompletely. Five channels across the frontwould be even better-that's the key num-ber beyond which you don't get any im-provement."
Other interviewees familiar with experi-mental literature on the subject agreed. Inspite of the notion of envelopment implicitin multichannel surround sound, thefrontal presentation was deemed to beparamount and the presence of a centerchannel of crucial importance.
Nevertheless, one interviewee with con-siderable experience in recording for multi-channel playback strongly disputed the im-
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199624
portance of the center channel. Brad Millerof Mobile Fidelity International had this tosay on the matter: "I feel the quad arrange-ment of four matched loudspeakers in asquare is correct and is sufficient to re-cre-ate the original sound field if the rightrecording technique has been used. Thefifth [center] channel is valid for film andmaybe for some types of music, but I don'tthink it's generally required for music. I liketo maintain symmetry."
Miller's views touch upon a central issuein recording for multichannel playback, onethat was rarely discussed back in the '70sbecause of the overwhelming prevalence ofthe quad model of four identical loud-speakers equidistant from a central listen-ing position: What is the place of symmetryin a playback system limited to four or fiveprincipal channels? In quad, symmetry wasa given, but in today's four- and five -chan-nel A/V surround sound systems it is not.Though bilaterally symmetrical, they arenot at all symmetrical in the di-mension of depth. Just as quadwas the stepchild of two -chan-nel stereo, so A/V surround isthe stepchild of motion picturesurround, and it follows themovie theater model of threechannels of information reproduced in thefront of the room and one or two channelstoward the back. This front -to -back asym-metry is partly a reflection of the inherentfrontal bias of a film or video presentation,but it also has to do with what seems to bean asymmetry in our own mechanisms ofsound localization.
According to Eargle, who has writtenfairly extensively on the matter in his classic
text Sound Recording, and Holman, who ad-dressed the subject recently in this maga-zine ("Surround Speakers: Confusion, Dif-fusion, and Resolution," July 1995),phantom images produced by amplitude orphase panning are most stable whenformed in front of the listener, less stableand precise behind the listener, and leaststable when panned along the sides of thelistening position between front and backspeakers. If so, that would support not onlythe concept of a playback system with rela-tively nondirectional speakers aft, but also arecording technique that would not at-tempt precise localization in all directions(at least, not without more channels).
Eargle's views on the matter have under-gone some recent modification, however. "Inow believe," he said, "that it is possible toproduce stable side phantoms, but not witha normal quad panpot where you're simplygoing between a pair of speakers, front toback. You have to redefine the panningfunction by introducing signals in the otherspeakers as well, but in certain specificphase relationships. But even then thephantom would obtain only for a single
Many peoplesee 5.1
as the keyto a revival
of interestin music
playback.
listening position. What you really need aremore channels-six will do nicely. Alterna-tively, you could try a higher -order matrix,perhaps a four into six. You might not evenneed logic enhancement there; the basicseparation might be sufficient. When youget the angle between speakers down to 60°or less, you begin to get a stable sound im-age all around."
Eargle, feeling the topic was important,expanded on it without much promptingon my part. "In classical music the way isclear. For big works you want an offstage ef-fect, direct ambience. You don't want to putsound sources in the back anyway. This isfine for 5% of the music, but what are thepop/rock guys gonna do with the format?They don't have that much ambience torecord. I think they will put primary infor-mation into the rear channels, but of a veryspecial sort. I also think they'll use the rear
channels to try to widen the soundstage infront. One thing's for certain: We havemore to work with than quad did, and wecan overcome many of the problems ofquad, because every time you have a loud-speaker you have a real source, and we have
more speakers now."Against Eargle's cautious position re-
garding assignment of sources to the rearchannels, which is ultimately based on psy-choacoustical studies, are the views of BradMiller and of the Ambisonics camp. Bothinsist that with appropriate single -pointmiking techniques, one can achieve accu-rate sound -field reproduction with justfour channels. Again, Miller is unequivocal."If you sample the sound field with a point -source array and play back the recordingover four matched loudspeakers, you willbe able to reproduce the sound field. I'veclearly demonstrated this numerous times.Basically, I agree with the Ambisonics posi-
tion, except that I don't think you need toencode phase difference and I don't likethat Calrad microphone they used."
John McClure, who headed CBSRecords' classical division in the '70s,voiced an objection of a different sort to theidea of a focused sound field in front andjust ambience in back. "We did a number ofrecordings with orchestra in front, reverb inback, and they could sound very natural.When it is right, you're hardly aware of therear channels at all. The problem is thatthose kinds of recordings lack impact. Theydon't exploit the possibilities of the medi-um. Multichannel should provide a wholefresh medium for composers. In the past,everyone has been proscenium oriented.Even in the '70s some people appreciatedthat it [multichannel] could take seriousmusic in a new direction. One night I hadPinky Zukerman, Dan Barenboim, and [thelate I Jackie Du Pre over to my place, and Ihad them listen to some of my discretemasters. They were so excited that they gotup and did a ballet in my living room."
Tom Jung of dmp, who has made somesurround recordings, takes a pragmatic ap-proach to the appropriate number of chan-nels and the use that should be made of therear speakers. "I think five channels worksout pretty well. Personally, I put more am-bient information in the back. I find it dis-tracting to assign things to the rear chan-nels. At the same time, I will pan from front
a.
to back. I appreciate the academic argu-ments against panning along the sides, but Ithink they're based on the assumption ofthe head in a vise. I also think there are pos-sibilities for entirely new types of music ifyou use the rear channels to place soundsources-things like antiphonal choirs.Why limit yourself to just ambience? Wecan create ambience through processingand production. We don't have to rely onthe recording technique; we can make thedecision in software.
"I like to try different things. For in-stance, I've played around with one channelin back and two along the sides, and thatcan create a good compromise. I do thinkthat more than two channels in back isoverkill, though."
Jung is also pleased with the usual dispo-sition of the front channels in a 5.1 -channellayout. "I like the three channels across thefront. I like the standup bass in the centerchannel. In my big -band project, I put therhythm section up front, in the center, and Ihad the brass farther back, with a mike oneach side in a U shape. I do all kinds of dif-ferent stuff, though I consider myself aminimalist. On the Bob Mintzer project, Iput a Blumlein pair in the center and as-signed a separate mike to the rhythm sec-tion. I've also used the Calrad Soundfieldmike for multichannel, but at the same timeI'll use other mikes to highlight what needshighlighting."
Like Miller, Jung also expressed approvalof the Ambisonics philosophy. "Ambisonicsis very valid. I may make Ambisonics ver-sions of some of my future releases."
Holman, who has advocated the use of5.1 -channel recording for music but withthe rear channels confined to reproducingambience, did allow that more channelswould be desirable in back as well as infront. "There is a noticeable improvementgoing from two to four channels for thesurrounds. I also think that you would wantto reproduce the dimension of height.There's a high reflection off the prosceniumarch that is clearly audible." But regardingthe notion that primary sources might rou-tinely be assigned to rear channels, Holmanretains his reservations. "I think there'ssome legitimacy to having an experimentalphase to multichannel recording, but thepoint is we've been through it already in the'70s. We know what works and what does
not work, and we shouldn't be making thesame mistakes again."
Re M ultiebannelc.seorcI i lig Session
When it came to actualmicrophone techniques,my interviewees weretypically less forthcom-ing than in articulating avision of how multichan-
nel might be used, but Eargle and Holman,particularly, had interesting observationson some of the details of recording practicein the multichannel environment. Earglethinks that "a new line of second -ordermikes will have to be developed, somethingdedicated to multichannel and unlike any-thing available now. We need tighter pat-terns-a regular cardioid has too muchspill." Eargle added, "I don't think the Am-bisonics arrangement of four supercar-dioids is the answer. It's fraught with a lotof difficulties. There's too large a dimensionfrom front to back, and you can't take pat-tern control up all the way."
Holman proposes a different technique."I think that intensity stereo and single-
point Blumlein are hopeless for 5.1 -chan-nel. We should be looking at spaced omnis,something like the London tree using large -
diaphragm omnis that are deliberately di-rectional at higher frequencies. I don't real-ly disagree with John Eatgle's ideas aboutusing more directional microphones, andI'd say the corollary there is using more di-rectional loudspeakers, which is what I'vebeen advocating all along in the THX pro-gram."
But McClure, who certainly speaks fromexperience, argued against the whole no-tion of developing distinctive microphonetechniques for multichannel. "I never sawthe need for it. Most of the material weworked with was multitrack, and if you'vegot 24 tracks you can do it all in post."
I)theFutureOn.or
On the eve of the secondcoming of multichannelmusic recording, consid-erable uncertainties re-main-even among thestrongest and the most
thoughtful advocates of a multichannel re-vival. Among recording engineers and pro-
ducers with a more peripheral involvement,
and I interviewed a couple of dozen music-
industry professionals and hardware manu-facturers, the lack of clear notions as to how
recordings should be presented in 5.1 -chan-nel format is much more apparent. "Record-
ing engineers will fly guitars over the listen-er's head, and that'll be enough to sell theconcept," one pundit ventured. "It doesn'tmatter what they do, because 5.1 will sell it-self," declared another. Time will tell.
By now you may be asking yourself whyso few celebrated recording engineers orrecord producers have been quoted here.Where are the Bruce Swediens, the RudyVan Gelders, the Tony Faulkners, the Marc
Auborts? Larry Boden supplied a ready an-swer to that question. "Recording engineers
are staying away from it, because record la-bels are not convinced that there is any ad-vantage to promoting 5.1. How do theystand to benefit from it-they're not sellingaudio equipment, they're selling software.Can they charge more for it, like they didfor CD? I don't know anyone in main-stream pop who is recording for 5.1. All theactivity is in little audiophile labels. What5.1 needs to succeed is a champion who is amajor star and who is willing to throw allhis prestige behind it. I don't see anyoneyet." Boden added, "In this business, re-member, all hardware developments pro-ceed from software developments."
Holman, on the other hand, stressed thehardware side. "Multichannel movie soundsucceeds because everything is standard-ized-the levels, the playback systems,everything. The music business doesn'thave that discipline. Instead, you're going tohave all kinds of recording techniques andall kinds of speakers in all kinds of arrange-ments. Multichannel music recordingscould remain a specialty format for thatreason."
Within the hardware sector itself, espe-cially the high end of it, such cautionarynotes are seldom sounded, however. Manymanufacturers see 5.1 as the key to vastlyincreased sales and a revival of interest inmusic playback as opposed to home theater.And perhaps it will be, but in the midst ofaccolades, it might be well to continue toask what manner of experience multichan-nel is supposed to deliver. Unless clear an-swers can be communicated from the salesfloor, history could repeat itself. A
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199626
PACEMAKER.
1..+1
Sparks to move the heart. Introducing the new line up of power amplifiers from
Sonic Frontiers - headed by the Power 3 Mono Amplifier. Through progressive
and unique circuitry, these amplifiers bring tube audio amplification performance
to a new and higher level.
Resolution, the reproduction of subtle nuances that make the musical images
believable and lifelike. The Power 3 excels in this area. Through careful ports
selection, selections made through proven sonic merit - with no room given
to preconceived impressions or brand loyalties. Through innovative circuit tech-
niques, a creative approach to implementing feedback in the Power 3 reflects
Sonic Frontiers' desire to develop original circuit designs utilizing tubes. This
approach avoids the sonic downfalls that are associated with traditional feedback
designs. With these factors contributing greatly to the resoluion and detail of he
Power 3, the listener will hear and feel music exposed with incredible detail
and emotional impact.
Control, the Power 3 Amplifier has the ability to take hold of the music and loud-
speakers they are driving. Tube amps have been accused of not delivering good
low frequency performance. The lower octaves are often criticized as slow and
ill-defined, coloring the vital midrange. The Power 3 renders this to be a gross
misconception, bass performance excels and the midrange snaps into focus.
Boasting a damping factor of greater than 50, this amplifier treads on grounc
never touched by tube amplifiers. Its ability to start and stop loudspeaker drivers
is only rivaled by the very best solid state designs. Leading to a precision, liquidity
and warmth never attained by amplifier designs of the past.
Power, rated at 220 watts off the 8, 4, and 2 ohms taps, the Power 3 has the
muscle to deal with very demanding bads. Speaker selection is suddenly not a
crucial, limiting issue. The 6550 power tubes, operating in partial triode, remain
sensitive to the loads loudspeakers demand. This new Sonic Frontiers amp
responds very much like a voltage source providing greater current as load
impedance drops, or less as it rises. All these benefits can be fully experienced
through any of the Power 3's taps.
Extensively tested, including a 100 hour burn -in, repeated on and off cycling,
and conservative component ratings ensure the Power 3's reliability. A fully bal-
anced design, input through output, as well as single -ended inverting and non -
inverting inputs, permits great flexibility with corresponding preamplifiers. A
stand-by feature ensures the tubes are warm and ready to perform. A mute fea-
ture, when activated, enables easy and convenient interchange of cables and
biasing of the Power 3's 6550 power tubes.
To find out more about their notable new line up of power amplifiers,
contact Soric Frontiers. To hear life beat in your heart, audition the Power 3
Mono Amplifier today.
111110.,
SONIC FRONTIERSI NI() h I' 1: \
BREAKING THE SOUND BARRIERContact Sonic Frontiefs tar the dealer nearest you2790 Brighton Rood, Ockville, Ontario, Canada l6H 5f4 Tel (9051 829-3838 Fox: 19051 829.3033 E -Mail: SFIOsonicfrontiers.corn
CIRCLE NO. 25 ON READER SERVICE CARD
WWW- http.//www.sonicfrontiers,com
THE AUDIO INTERVIEWr
BY DANIEL LEVITIN
M&X'SKEN R REISEL
KEN KREISEL S WORKSHOP
RESEMBLES A COFFEEIMPORTER S WAREHOUSE
WITH CRATES AND BOXES
SAMPLES FROM ALL
) STACKED TO THE CEILING
BUT IN KREISEL'S CASE, THE SAMPLE BOXES
ARE FILLED WITH SPEAKER DRIVERS OF
EVERY IMAGINABLE SIZE, SHAPE, AND COM-
POSITION AMONG THE MANY RESPONSIBILI-
TIES OF RUNNING A SPEAKER COMPANY,
KREISEL PAYS EXTREMELY CLOSE ATTENTION
TO DRIVERS, HE IS A FANATIC ABOUT NOT LET-
TING ANY NEW COMPONENTS SLIP BY HIM
KREISELS CAREER. AND M & K SOUND'S
HISTORY OVER THE LAST 20 YEARS, IN MANY
WAYS PARALLELS THE MAJOR BREAK-
THROUGHS IN HIGH-PERFORMANCE AUDIO. IN
1977 KREISEL OPENED THE WORLDS FIRST
EXCLUSIVELY DIRECT -TO -DISC RECORDING
STUDIO AND ITS COMPANION COMPANY. REAL-
TIME RECORDS. THAT SAME YEAR SAW THE
INTRODUCTION OF THE VOLKSWOOFER, THE
FIRST INTERNALLY POWERED SUBWOOFER
THIS WAS FOLLOWED BY THE FIRST DIGITALLY
RECORDED DBX-ENCODED LP 11 979) THE
FIRST COMPACT DISCS RELEASED BY A U S
LABEL 11982). AND THE FIRST TRANSMIS-
SION -LINE DOME TWEETER 11992)
KREISEL S TWO PARTNERS M & K COM-
PLEMENTED HIS BACKGROUND AS ANAWARD -WINNING RECORDING ENGINEER
JONAS MILLER (THE -M OF M E. K. NOW DE-
CEASED) OWNED A RESPECTED HIGH -END
AUDIO STORE IN LOS ANGELES CHIEF SCIEN-
TIST LESTER FIELD WAS FORMERLY THE CHIEF
SCENTIST AND VICE PRESIDENT OF HUGHES
AIRCRAFT AND HAD BEEN A PROFESSOR OF
ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING AT CALTECH AND
STANFORD KREISEL DESIGNED THE FIRST
M & K SUBWOOFER TO HELP MILLER SELL
MOPE ELECTROSTATC AND PLANAR SPEAK-
ERS HE DESIGNED THE NOW -FAMOUS M 6. K
SATELLITES TO GO WITH IT WHEN HE COULDN'T
FIND A SATISFACTORY REFERENCE MONITOR
TO LSE IN THE REALTIME RECORDING STUDIOS.
KREISEL RECENTLY SPOKE WITH ME ABOUT
HIS PHILOSOPHY OF SPEAKER DESIGN AND
AUDIO IN GENERAL D. L.
Daniel Levitin studied physics at M.I.T. be-fore earning degrees in Cognitive Sciencefrom Stanford University and the Universityof Oregon. A recording engineer and produc-
er throughout the 1980s, he has also pub-lished over 200 articles on audio and musictechnology.
ing engineer makes speakers,peopir lisLen
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199629
There's one thing that has always interest-ed me about the evolution of your compa-ny. You started out as a recording engineer
and had one of the premier high-fidelitylabels in the country. And yet, you decided
your initial customer base should be con-sumers. I would have thought you'd try toget your speakers into
studios, since you had
initially developedthem for your ownstudio.
It's interesting youbrought that up. Ofcourse, before westarted making speak-ers at all, we had ahigh -end hi-fi storeand a lot of peoplefrom the recordingbusiness were cus-tomers. For a long time the audio profes-sional and the high-fidelity audiophile nev-er spoke with each other. But these differentpeople would come to our store, and theywould communicate with each other. Inthose days the monitor speakers in thestudios were very poor-you had AltecLansing 604Es, for example...
.and /BL pro monitors.
Right. And Jonas Miller was a dealer forQuad and Magneplanar. In fact, we wereone of the world's largest Quad dealers.And I had built some subwoofers to supple-ment these electrostatics. Everybody, espe-
THE AUDIO INTERVIEW
cially other dealers, thought it was amazinghow many Quads we were selling and want-ed to know how we did it. Well, it was ourcompact, single and dual 12 -inch sub -woofer designs that gave us the sales. I firstbuilt 24 -inch Hartley woofers in huge
sound of the main speakers considerably ifit's based on true biamplification with anelectronic high-pass and low-passcrossover, because then your midrangespeakers aren't trying to reproduce thelows, causing excess excursion and IM dis-tortion. And it cleans up the sound of the
amplifier, because theamp doesn't have toreproduce the lows,preventing it fromgoing into clippingduring heavy basspassages and therebydistorting the mid-range and highs.Do you rememberthe crossover fre-quency in your firstsubwoofers?
The Goliath crossed
T.) EOPLE TALK ABOUT DEPTH IN AN LP,
AND THEY SAY,
"OH -LISTEN TO THAT GREAT ROOM AMBIENCE."
WELL, A LOT OF THE "AMBIENCE"
THEY THINK THEY'RE HEARING IS GROOVE ECHO!
transmission -line cabinets (they looked likecommercial refrigerators), but the smalldual 12-inchers produced better perform-ance and were far more practical. I had alsodesigned a passive crossover and a passiveelectronic crossover, or if they wanted, wewould sell them a commercial active elec-tronic crossover.
People have been making subwoofers fora long time, but in terms of the modernthree-piece system, we were the pioneers.One of the guys from Visonik came into ourstore in the '70s, and he told us that theirDavid speakers were good for installing in
your kitchen or yourboat. I thought theysounded fantastic inthe mid and highranges. So we hookedthem up to our 12 -inchsubwoofer. I immedi-ately designed an inter-nal crossover for it andcalled it the Goliath.Overnight we built areputable, inexpensivesubwoofer. Dealers allover the country start-ed selling Goliath withall their other smallspeakers.
A sub accomplishesthree things. It extendsthe system's bass re-sponse. It cleans up the
S- 1 ( Satellite Shea c
over at 100 Hz and went down to 20 Hz. Asyou know, a sealed box speaker rolls off at12 dB per octave below its resonant fre-quency. Our other subwoofers of that sameperiod crossed over anywhere from 50 to100 Hz.
A couple of our customers were SteelyDan's Walter Becker and their recordingengineer, Roger Nichols. Walter asked me to
design a reference monitor system for them.At the time, they were out at DevonshireStudios recording Pretzel Logic.
So this must have been back around 1973Or so.
Right-it was 1973. I built a double wooferthat was similar to our push-pull, with twoopposing 12 -inch drivers mounted side-ways in a cabinet. Devonshire's controlroom was small, but I used this subwooferalong with Magneplanars for the top end.And they loved it; they had never heard aflat speaker system like that before. The stu-dio engineers went home and brought theirmaster tapes into the studio to hear themon this system. So that's what got me intospeaker manufacturing, because these sub -woofers were such a hit.
Was your subwoofer powered at this point?
It was biamped, with a separate amplifier,but at that point it wasn't our amplifier. Ithink we set them up with a big Phase Lin-ear or Crown.Roger Nichols told me that the only reasonhe and Walter Becker didn't stay with thatspeaker setup for Steely Dan's next album
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199630
KEN KREISELwas that there was always the problem ofwhere to put the subwoofer in other stu-dios. Studio control rooms aren't usuallydesigned to have subwoofers, and space isat a premium.Yes, you're absolutely right. That is thebiggest problem in most studios.
Where do you get your speaker drivers?Our midranges and tweeters are made forus mainly by Peerless in Denmark, and Em-inence makes most of our subwoofer driv-ers. All of the drivers are made to our exactspecifications. Our MX-5000THX sub -woofer driver is made for us in Japan. Ex-pensive, specialized tooling was required tosatisfy its unique design. I have dozens ofnew, lower -cost driver samples that I'mplowing through, and I'm really excitedabout some of them. I didn't want to getinto the lower end of the market, becauseit's usually a major compromise. But we areat a technological point now where we canbuild quality into a lower -priced speakersystem.What's your favorite speaker?The original Quad electrostatics. I keep apair of them hooked up, just to keep mehonest.What are the best and the worst thingsabout them?They're very accurate for tonality andimaging: You record something from a footaway, and it sounds a foot away. But theydon't have anywhere near the dynamics you
need.One of the things that has changed sinceyou started is the emergence of the CD asthe standard. Your Real Time records kept alot of audiophiles in vinyl because of theirhigh, direct -to -disc quality. Have youthought about releasing any of those onCD?
Yes, we're eventually going to release all of
the albums on CD. And I'm releasing somenew recordings on CD, too, in the near fu-ture. I've built a mastering studio at myhouse, and I'll be mastering those new re-leases and the reissues myself, using Wadia
20 -bit converters.
I'm also excited abouta new piece of testequipment I just got, theAudio Precision SystemOne Dual Domain. Ithas digital ins and outs,so you can check D/Aand A/D converters.And you can test speak-ers. It has an MLS [max-
imum -length -sequence]test, which we don't re-ally use because I have
three new DRA Labs MLSSAs [pronouncedMelissas] in three separate units.What's your opinion about vinyl versusCD?
If you listen to a phono system and itsounds more real to you, I say that's great,because it's what you want. But don't be-lieve that because it sounds more real toyou that it is more nearly perfect technical-ly, because it probably isn't. One of thebiggest revelations for me was the experi-ence of disc cutting: I realized what a limit-ed medium the LP is. People have no ideahow much intermodulation distortion is onan LP, particularly music with very heavybass-for example, organ music. You canhave tens of percent of IM distortion. Andwhen people first heard digital, many said,"Gee, it sounds like a lot of the notes aremissing." Well, there were notes missing-the IM distortion was missing!Tom Stockham said something interestingto me about this. He said if you put a groupof audiophiles in a studio control roomand ask them to choose between an analogtape and a digital tape of a performinggroup, a great many will choose the analogtape. But if you ask them to choose be-tween the tapes and then let them comparethe sound to the group performing live inthe studio, most will choose the digital. Sowithout a reference, they prefer the soundof distortion.I believe that's true with some listeners.People talk about depth in an LP, and they
say, "Oh, listen to that great room ambi-ence." Well, a lot of the room ambience LPlisteners think they are hearing is grooveecho! When you listen to an LP, you caneasily hear pre -echo right before a trackstarts and post -echo when it ends. Andthat's going on all through the LP! There'san "echo" button on cutting lathes thatspreads the grooves apart before and after atransition from a quiet passage to a loudone, to reduce the intergroove echo. Butthat uses up a lot of space. If you used thatall the time, you'd only be able to get sevenminutes on a side.
What people don't realize is that on anLP, you're constantly listening to a lot of tpre- and post -echo, conveying an artificialdepth that was never heard by the micro-phones, while intermodulation distortion isgenerating "notes" that nobody actually 'Ss'
played. Then there's harmonic distortion, ti
which can reach the tens of percent, intro- it&icing harmonics that were never pro-duced by the original instruments. (I'm notsaying it doesn't sound great, because itcan.) Then, to add insult to injury, the high -frequency response of an LP rolls off as youget farther in toward the center, not to men-tion the increase in distortion.Getting back to speaker testing, would youexplain MLSSA?MLSSA [maximum -length -sequence sys-tem analyzer] is a device developed byDoug Rife for testing speakers anechoicallyin a reverberant environment. It doeseverything. You can test frequency re-sponse, distortion, coherence, reverberationtime-you can make any kind of analysis ofa speaker or room both in the time domainand in the frequency domain. A new betasoftware version enables, for the very firsttime, accurate Dolby Surround speaker -lev-el calibration in a room, consistent with thetime -domain characteristics of the humanear! Truly a revelation.What kind of microphones do you use forspeaker testing?The B & K 4133 omni, exclusively.
You've gotten into the home theater mar-ket in a big way with Home THX speakers.What are the unique problems associatedwith designing for THX?First, there's a lot of confusion about whatTHX is. THX is not a multichannel en-code/decode system like Dolby Pro Logic or
Dolby AC -3. THX has nothing to do with
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199631
THE AUDIO INTERVIEWencoding and decoding an audio signal. It'sa set of standards originally for theatersound and is now for home theater, too. Soit is not a competitor of Dolby Surround. Itall goes back to the late 1970s and Star
Wars, directed by George Lucas. That wasone of the first films encoded with DolbySurround, which is played back in the homethrough what is called Pro Logic decoding.Before that, you had to go to a six -channel,70mm-equipped theater to hear surroundsound, and there weren't a whole lot ofthose around. But Dolby Surround gavethe more common35mm theaters achance to have sur-round sound.
Originally, thereweren't any stan-dards at all for thea-ter sound systems.Around this time,George Lucas's com-p a ny, Lucasfilm,formed a divisionthat set standards fortheater sound. Thosestandards were eventually called THX;some people say it stands for the Tom Hol-man Experiment [Tom Holman originatedthe program]. The first thing they did wasto come out with a special crossover fortheater speakers. Then they took it anotherstep: They tested a bunch of equipment-woofers, tweeters, amplifiers, sound -ab-
sorption materials-measuring distortionand frequency response and, for speakers,horizontal and vertical dispersion charac-teristics. They then came up with a blue-
print book of how to build a greattheater speaker system and im-prove acoustics. So if a theaterwants to join, they pay a fee to Lu-casfilm. Then they pick a tweeterfrom column "A," an amplifierfrom column "B," and so on. Thetheater installs the equipment inaccordance with these standards,and the THX people measure theirequipment and calibrate the the-ater to make sure the sound systemmeets these specs.
So the THX people are like inde-pendent auditors.Right. And that's what it means tohave a commercial THX theater.What they did for Home THX issimilar. They set standards forelectronics (for Dolby Pro Logicand AC -3 surround decoders/con-
trollers, internal electronic crossovers, pow-
er amplifiers, equalizers, and cables) andacoustical standards for speakers (for front -channel speakers, surround -channel speak-ers, and passive and powered subwoofers).Home THX equipment must meet or passthese standards, which call for additionalsignal processing to make the listening ex -
A Dolby Stereo movie theater, whether it'sTHX or not, at least has to meet certain cal-ibration standards; for example, the soundpressure level (SPL] is set; there's a refer-ence level throughout the film industry.Holman once said that the difference be-tween home and theater systems is that thetheater has no volume control. In the the-ater, the entire chain, from the studio to thetheater, is controlled. The average dialoghas to be at 85 dB SPL, and when they setup the theater it has to measure out at 85 dBSPL at a certain distance from the screen.That's pretty loud.That is pretty loud, actually. And dependingon whether it's an optical, a Dolby SR, or adigital print, the maximum SPL can be 20dB above that, which is 105 dB SPL.
In the home, there are different THXstandards for different components-there's a spec for the front speakers, thesubwoofer, the processor, the amplifiers, theequalizer, etc. True, a calibration engineerdoes go into the theater and not always intoyour home. But George Lucas's philosophyis that because his company itself makesmovies and because it designs, calibrates,and controls THX dubbing stages and the-aters, then it knows what the movie is sup-posed to sound like in the theater. Lucasfilmwants to get that same calibrated soundinto the consumer's house without theengineer showing up. If you purchase allTHX components-processor, amp, and
speakers-Lucassays you'll comepretty close.It seems impossible!Lucasfilm and theequipment manu-facturers have nocontrol over wheresomebody's going toput the speakers-whether they're go-ing to be on a carpet,on a stand, or hang-ing off the ceiling-
and they don't know if the room's carpetedor if it's got parallel walls. . .It just seemsimpossible, unless you can design a speakerfor which the room acoustics are relativelyunimportant.Well, that's exactly what they did. Or whatthey attempt to do. And it's actually notmuch different from what we found out
UBWOOFERS HAVE BEEN AROUND
FOR A LONG TIME, BUT AS FOR
MODERN, THREE-PIECE SYSTEMS,
WE'RE THE PIONEERS.
perience consistent with sound heard in astudio dubbing stage or THX movie theater.But it sounds like there's a huge difference.THX engineers actually go into the theaterand make sure that the acoustics of theroom conform to an exact standard. Butthey're not going into your home andchecking out your living room.
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199632
15 years ago when we were designing ourstudio monitors, and this is related to ex-periments that Tom Holman did a numberof years ago.
The idea is that you want to make aspeaker directional vertically. In many cas-es, the first reflection is going to be off theceiling or the floor, and you don't knowanything about that surface-whether itwill be carpeting, a hardwood floor, a hardceiling, a beamed ceiling, or whatever. Sohow do you make the speaker vertically di-rectional? You stack the drivers. Do you re-member our S-1 speaker from 1978?Yes. It had a pair of tweeters stacked on topof a pair of mids.Right. If you look at most THX front speak-ers, you'll see they have two or three tweet-ers on top of each other, to make them ver-tically directional. This is to achieve thedirectivity spec. Our 5-100Bs have threestacked tweeters. Two versus three tweetersaffects how the speaker lobes. The technicalreason for how you get directionality is this:When you're between the two tweeters, onaxis, the distance between the tweeters andyour ears is the same. As you move off axis,you become farther away from one tweeterthan the other. If you're half a wavelengthaway, the waves completely cancel each oth-
er out, resulting in no output at that fre-quency at that angle.So you end up with sweet or sour spots, de-pending on where you're sitting.
Right. The whole point of THX speakers isthat they're designed to be listened to exact-ly on axis, vertically, about ±5°. It doesn'tmatter what their actual height is, as long asthe drivers are pointed right at your head.
One of the things we developed here, andthe new S- IC uses this, is our unique foamtechnique. We use a very high-tech piece of
KEN KREISELV
foam. For many years I was unable to findthe correct piece of foam or felt that woulddo what I wanted. I had wanted to do thiswith the original S-ls, but I couldn't findthe material.Because the wrong foam is going to absorbtoo much?No, just the opposite. Most people thinkthat foam and felt are absorptive. Butthey're actually both reflective and absorp-tive, depending on the frequency.For some frequencies the sound isabsorbed, and for others it's likehaving a piece of wood there. Youwind up with something that'sworse than not having anything atall.
For years, wherever I've gone,when I've seen a new piece of feltor foam, I tried to take some withme to experiment with. I had theintuition that felt wasn't the rightthing. In fact, it turns out that it'stoo reflective where you don'twant it to be; most foam stuck onstudio walls is reflective at somefrequencies.Which frequencies are we talkingabout?The midrange or, sometimes, thehigh frequencies. It depends on thedensity and thickness of the material. Thefoam we're using now is the most absorp-
tive and linear thatI've found, withoutbeing reflective.On your S -ICs, whydo you place thefoam between thetweeters?When you're on axis,it doesn't make anydifference. But re-member, as youmove above or below
the axis, you can getsome very deep,
complete dips in response. With the foamin there, as you rise above axis, the foamstarts to attenuate the bottom tweeters andyou don't get the cancellation. If you havetwo drivers putting out the same signal lev-el, you can get an almost infinite cancella-tion dip. But as soon as you attenuate onedriver-it could be by as little as 3 dB-all
of a sudden you don't get that severe can-cellation. So that's what the foam does: Itcontrols the off -axis lobing.
And the foam on the sides?That just breaks up the diffraction effectsoff the edges of the cabinet.It seems to me there are two designphilosophies that are at opposite extremes.On the one hand, you could design a speak-er that is so insensitive to the room that itwill sound remarkably similar no matter
MX -200 Powered Subwoofer
where you put it. But most speakers, on theother hand, aren't like that. They aretremendously sensitive to the room'sacoustics. What are the trade-offs in thetwo designs?This has been a driving philosophy since Igot into this business, in both the record-ings and the speakers. I started recordingmusic when I was nine years old; my sisterwas a singer. I've always had a concept ofwhat recorded music should sound like. Asa listener, I've always been interested inhearing the instrument or the voice. I wantto hear the room that it was recorded in,not the room I'm playing it back in. I loveheadphones for that reason. And if you lis-ten to a pair of original Quads, they soundlike really big headphones-very direction-al
tsvertically and very transparent.
You've always tried to get away from play-back room reflections.Right, and that's how the S-1 came about. If 31you're sitting in a control room, you don't t:want much vertical dispersion.
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199633
Tr
THE AUDIO INTERVIEWBut you're still battling with a cabinet thathas a resonant frequency and a back wave,as opposed to the Quads.Well, a planar speaker has both a resonantfrequency and a back wave, too. In somecases, the resonant frequencies are not verywell damped. We always put absorptive ma-terial in our cabinets to deal with the reso-nant frequency.
The original Quads are totally differentfrom other planar speakers: They are truedipoles. For the back -wave problem, theyput a felt pad behind the tweeter andmidrange. So it's di-pole in the bass, butmost of the rearwardmids and highs areabsorbed by this feltpad.
What first got youthinking about min-imizing the reflec-tions in speakers?I first met JonasMiller in 1969, mylast year in highschool. Back then,Lester Field, who is now a partner in M & K,was the chief scientist and a vice presidentat Hughes Aircraft. His hobby wasacoustics. On one of his family vacations, Itagged along and went to Bell Labs withhim, as well as to some other importantacoustic research labs, to see what they weredoing. When Field was at Bell Labs, he co -invented the traveling -wave tube with JohnPierce, who was head of the lab at that time.
We spent a couple of days in Bell'sacoustics lab. I'll never forget one of the ex-periments; it literally changed my life andmy outlook on this whole business of roomenvironments. They had set up an array ofspeakers in an anechoic chamber. You sat ina chair, and the speakers were all at differentdistances from you, lined up in a row lead-ing away from your head. Your task was totell them which speaker was playing. Thevolume was normalized, so the levels reach-ing your ear were the same. The amazingthing was that you couldn't tell whichspeaker was playing! The recorded voice ap-peared immediately in front of my face, re-gardless of the speaker distance. I wasshocked. You take away the room reflec-tions, and you don't know how far away thespeaker is! This is what I was looking for!
Since you can't go into everybody's houseand take away the room reflections, howdo you design that quality into a speaker?The first thing you do is make it directional.
One of the reasons this doesn't work withmost speakers is because the drivers or thecrossovers are no good. So you can't accu-rately hear the room environment on therecording; you rely on reflections bouncingaround the room to enhance the "sense" ofambience. The one criticism I have of manyaudiophiles who talk about ambience is
If you design a speaker that's reasonablydirectional, and it's not right next to a sidewall, most of the audible changes in thesound as a function of the room occur be-low 500 to 800 Hz.
Years ago, at the advent of third -octaveequalizers, I took a Dayton -Wright electro-static speaker and a JBL speaker and equal-ized them for identical anechoic frequencyresponses. Lo and behold, the speakerssounded very much the same! That is 80%of the speaker's sound. At our store, yearsago, we had every top -end speaker in the
world. I realized thatthe Rogers and theSpendors, the BBCmonitors, the B & Ws,and the KEFs all hadan acoustic family re-semblance: a "British"sound, based on theiranechoic and roomfrequency response.The same was true ofGerman speakers (likethose from ADS, Vi-sonik, and Braun) and
American speakers (such as JBLs and AI-tecs). The most interesting thing was look-ing at the Fletcher -Munson curves and real-izing that these companies had optimizedtheir speakers for the different listening lev-els typical in their regions.Do you think there's a psychological effect
below the
SA LISTENER, I'VE ALWAYS BEEN INTERESTED
IN HEARING THE INSTRUMENT OR VOICE.
I WANT TO HEAR THE ROOM
THAT THE MUSIC WAS RECORDED IN,
NOT THE ROOM THAT I'M PLAYING IT BACK IN.
that they're hearing ambience not in therecorded music but in listening -room re-flections or sound bouncing around insidethe speaker cabinet. For example, somepeople say they love dipole front speakersand comment about their "wonderfully ac-curate depth." In many cases what they areactually hearing is the sound bouncingaround the room from the back of thespeaker; they're not listening to ambiencethat the microphone ever heard.What else did you learn at Bell Labs?It got me thinking about baffle coloration.How does the box color the sound? So Ithought, "Let's put the drivers in the right -sized box." And I put a lot of research intofiguring out what that was.
Recently, I listened to three top profes-sional studio engineers who were talkingabout room equalization. One was fromEngland, one was from the East Coast, andone was from the West Coast. And do youknow what they argued about? The frequen-cy above which they would not touch the EQcontrols, even though their real-time analyz-ers said the speaker response was not flat. For
one it was 600 Hz, for another 1,000...abovethat frequency, they knew that they couldnot believe what the RTA showed them.
of infrasonics, frequenciesthreshold of hearing?It couldn't hurt. Normally, our subwoofersare anechoically flat down to 15 or 18 Hz,and they roll off 12 dB per octave fromthere. We do active processing to achieveflat response down to about 15 Hz. Accord-ing to Dolby's research, there is usuallyroom gain of 12 dB per octave below about30 Hz. So actually, at 20 Hz the room gainboosts our subs by about 8 to 10 dB. Butbecause the ear isn't so sensitive in thisrange, as you can tell from the Fletcher -Munson curves, it's not bad to have itthere.This is a ittle off the topic, but everyspeaker you have here has its grille off.What percentage of your customers do youthink leave them off?Well, I would guess that if the owner is aman and he's married, he's going to leavethe grille on if he wants to stay married! A
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199634
THE HYMN ST SERIES AMPLIFIERS
Listen Past the Equipment
and Experience the Music
as Intended
Once in a while an idea
'wines along which represents
a significant step forward in
advancing the current state-
of-the-art. We feel our new
ST Series amplifiers exemplify
this unique distinction.
A new approach to low -noise,
low distortion signal -path
has produced a line of
amplifiers which is actually
quieter and more transparent
than any source material
currently available.
.4 EAR
Music
for a
Generationil
Bryston ST amplifiers, from the top: 8B ST 4 channe' 120 wpc, 5B ST 3 channel 120 apt,4B ST 250 wpc stereo, 7B ST 500 watts mono. Not shown is the 3B ST 120 wpc stereo.
The Bryston ST innovation: our
Jltra-linear "input buffer -with -
gain" substantially lowers the
distortion and inherent noise
floor - hearing is believing.
Completely separate power
ies for each channe elimi-
nate any crosstalk to enst.re firm
focus and completely accurate
imag ng of musical instruments.
Bryston Ltd, P.O. Box 2170, 677 Neal Drive, Peterborough, Cntario,Canada K9J 7Y4 Tel: (705) 742-5325 Fax: (705) 742-0882
CIRCLE NO. 4 ON READER SERVICE CARD
Switchable gold plated RICA
unbalanced and XLR-1/4 iich
balanced inputs, with ecual
gain, allows flexibility for multi-
channel sysm configurations.
EQUIPMENT PROFILEEDWARD J FOSTER
PIONEER ELITEPDR-99
CD RECORDER
Fver since the Compact Disc rocketedinto the audiophile firmament, en-thusiasts have wanted to know wherethey could get their hands on a CDrecorder. Rumors abounded, but formany years, the real McCoy existed
only in the research laboratory. Somewhatover a year ago, Pioneer introduced thePDR-09, a rather pricey $4,000 system thatreportedly was less than user-friendly. But itdid record! The company has just launchedthe PDR-99 in its Elite line, and by the time
IMEnsions: 221/2 in. W x 9% in. H x151/4 in. D (57 cm x 24.3 cm x 38.6cm).
Weight: 15.1 lbs. (6.8 kg).Price: $2,000.
Company Address: P.O. Box 1720,Long Beach, Cal. 90801; 800/746-6337.
For literature, circle No. 90
you read this, the PDR-05 should be avail-able in its regular line. Since the two arepriced similarly, $2,000 for the PDR-99 and$1,950 for the PDR-05, why not be Elitist?
Audiophile CD recorders undoubtedlygot a shot in the arm from the computer in-dustry, where CD-ROMs are the goingthing and the need for recordable massstorage is widespread. Recordable CDs foraudio and for computer use look the sameand technically are the same except for onelittle thing: Recordable CDs (CD -Rs) forcomputers can handle 74 minutes ofrecording, while blank audio discs are cur-rently limited to 60 minutes. There's notechnical reason why an audio blank can'taccommodate a maximum -length (74 -minute) CD; it's just a concession to therecord industry.
Audio CD recorders check the coding ofeach new blank and burp if you try to slipthem a computer disc. (I did manage to getthe PDR-99 to take an old computer blank,
evidently manufactured before codingcame into use, but not any of the newerones I had.) Recordable CDs are WORMdiscs, an acronym for Write Once, ReadMany. Unlike magneto -optical discs, suchas MD, which are rewritable, you get oneshot at recording these babies. As you do,the PDR-99 creates a temporary Table ofContents (TOC), which tells the systemwhere each track starts and stops, its num-ber, and so forth. You can edit the disc onlyin the sense that you can instruct the PDR-99 to skip failed recordings. Thus, you'renot erasing the recording, just telling thesystem to ignore it (so any boo-boos youmake reduce the total recording time).
When you've finished recording, you "fi-nalize" the disc, a process that takes about 4minutes on the PDR-99. During this opera-tion (which cannot be interrupted), thetemporary TOC (including skip instruc-tions) is transferred to a permanent TOCthat can be recognized by standard CDplayers. Until the disc is finalized, it can't beread by ordinary players, only by CDrecorders; once the disc is finalized, it can'tbe edited or recorded on again. Such is thepenalty for producing a universally read-able recordable CD (magneto -optical discs,which can be re-recorded, are not readableby conventional CD players).
The PDR-99 features Pioneer's StablePlatter mechanism, which supports the fulldisc instead of just its center. This is to re-duce resonance, disc sag, and vibration, allof which are thought to induce jitter andthe sonic aberrations it might cause. Thismechanism requires that the disc be placed"upside down"-that is, label side downand shiny side up. The Stable Platter system
is complemented by a chassis and mecha-nism designed to minimize resonance andvibration. A new three -beam differentialpush-pull laser pickup reads the disc. TheA/D converter is a 1 -bit "Pulseflow" designthat theoretically eliminates distortion ataxis crossings.
The PDR-99's D/A converter is matedwith a second -generation Legato -Link Scircuit, which Pioneer says "extends theCD's 'musical response' for audibly im-proved high -frequency detail and trans-parency." By applying a newly developed al-
gorithm that "psychoacoustically, and moreaccurately, restores the frequency contentlost in digital recording," this circuit is said
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199636
No matter where you are, you're there.
Musical truth.
It begins deep in the belly of the passage. Thunderous bass, so
powerful you're helpless as you're slowly taken prisoner by the music. rThe subwoofers catapult you to the furthest -eaches of the soundstage. You *IL
gain a new focus. Your world narrows down as your horizons grow.
See your Energy dealer today. And audition the new EPS- series
Subwoofers. Clean, deep undistorted
bass. Personal. Provocative.
All about you.
Energy EPS-series subwoofers
CIRCLE NO. 9 ON READER SERVICE CARD
N -c R,G)LOUDSPE AK ERS
Sound as a performance art.
O
0
1313.slowo POR-911 - Lett Normal 1.134-t-.001.18 - rrrrr ........O8
.4
0
4-120 -10 -100 -90 -80
AP
RECORDED LEVEL - d8FS
Fig. 1-Fade-to-noise test.
-70 -60
AP
120100 1 k
FREQUENCY -
Fig. 2-Record/playfrequency response, analoginput.
20
01a.
z0
001
000120
OOOOOOO Ey WEI
Ok 20k
AT 0aBF
m-am;;;;;=.==:;;;=nmaanum-a
01111=1111
1 k
FREQUENCY - /12
Fig. 3-Record/playTHD
analog input.
10k
to "mirror the characteristics found in anaturally occurring sonic event."
The recorder has one set of analog inputsand one set of fixed -level analog line out-puts on back, all with gold-plated RCAjacks. (There's a gold-plated headphonejack on the front, along with a headphonelevel control.) Optical and coaxial digitalinputs and outputs are on the back, the lat-ter using base -metal RCA jacks. (A slider on
the back switches the digital outputs off.)The active input is selected by a front -panelpad, so in theory, three sources can remainconnected. "Control In/Out" jacks enableconnection with Pioneer equipment carry-ing the "SR" mark. When this wired controlsystem is used, the PDR-99 ignores its re-mote and is operated by signals relayedthrough the cable from another Pioneercomponent.
The "REC Level" and "REC Balance"controls function only with analog sources;direct digital copying needs no level setting.For digital dubbing, the PDR-99 has a sam-pling -rate converter for transforming 32- or
20k
48 -kHz sampled data (from a DAT,
digital -radio broadcast, or whatev-er) to the 44.1 -kHz rate requiredfor CD. "REC" and "REC Mute"buttons stand to the right of the"REC Level" control and are sepa-rated by a bright "REC" LED thatilluminates when the deck is
recording. Beneath are buttons toset and clear "Skip ID" codes thatcontrol which tracks will not beplayed when the adjacent "SkipPlay" button is pressed.
Front -panel transport controlsare conventional except that thesame pads are used for both trackand manual search. Tap them light-ly to skip to the next track or backto the beginning of the currenttrack; hold either pad down tosearch the current track. (There areseparate pads for track search andmanual search on the remote con-trol, which I find more conve-nient.) On the left of the panel are"Power," "Input Selector," "DigitalSynchro," and "Finalize" buttons,along with one that chooses auto-matic or manual track numbering,one to "Write" track numbers (inthe manual mode), and another
(despite being labeled "Display Off') to cy-cle through full display, a display withoutlevel indicators, or a dark panel.
Recording is simple. When you've loadeda disc and it's recognized as an unfinalizedCD -R (this takes a few seconds, with thedisplay alternating between "CD?" and"CD -R?"), the PDR-99 reads the TOC andindicates that it's doing so. If the disc is to-tally blank, the display indicates "NewDisc." If it's been partially recorded but notfinalized, the display briefly shows the lastprogram number and time before cueing totrack 1. If the disc has been finalized, it'srecognized as a CD rather than a CD -R;further recording is not possible.
To make a digital dub of one track from aCD, DAT, MD, or DCC, you select one ofthe PDR-99's digital inputs, make sure thatthe source player is stopped or paused, andpress "Digital Synchro" once. When youstart the source player, the PDR-99 auto-matically begins recording. Don't start playuntil the PDR-99's "Sync" legend blinks, in-dicating that the PDR-99 recognizes the bit -
stream (that comes from the player evenwhen it's stopped) and is ready to go. Afteryou copy one track, recording stops. Torecord multiple tracks in succession, youfollow the same procedure except you press"Digital Synchro" twice. The display shows"AL -Sync," and recording continues untilthe last track has been recorded or until youpress "Stop."
To make an analog recording, you selectthat input, press "REC," set the recordinglevel and balance (guided by the meter'seight segments and "Over"), and press"Pause" or "Play" to start. Track numbersare written sequentially as each recordingbegins. You can also write the next tracknumber by pressing "Manual/Write." (ThePDR-99 defaults to manual numberingwhen recording from the analog input.)During digital dubbing, the track count ad-vances each time a new source track num-ber is detected. However, you can recordmanually from a digital source by pressing"REC" instead of "Digital Synchro" andfollowing the rest of the procedures forrecording from the analog input. This ishelpful when you're recording from asource that doesn't have track numbers.Note, however, that the PDR-99 will recordonly digital audio signals; you can't dub aCD-ROM.
To ward off mistakes, finalization of thedisc is a multistep procedure. When youpress "Finalize," the display asks you toconfirm ("Final?"), at which point you
THE PDR-99 COSTS
HALF AS MUCH
AS PIONEER'S FIRST
CD RECORDER AND
IS EASIER TO USE.
press it again. The recorder reads the tem-porary TOC and displays the time remain-ing on the disc. When the time appears, youcan then press "Pause" to commence actualfinalization.
Playback features are fairly standard. Youcan cue tracks by number, via the remote'skeypad, or advance through them manuallywith the program -skip buttons on the pan-el or the remote. You can elicit randomplayback via the remote or program your
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199638
ou eliminate the P
olitics.ou can review
theP
R 0 F
series.
I, Walter F
ields, President of N
I B S
Audio C
ables guarantee the P R
0 F series
are the best cable in the world, or your m
oney back.
For D
etails
Cable S
tore1-800-,v -0204.
Otherw
ise
In/Betw
een Audio -Lake O
swego, O
R (503) 638-5767
Sounds of S
ilence -Manchester, N
H (603) 625-2133
Audio C
lassics -Oklahom
a City, O
K (405) 842-3033
Audio P
erfection -Minneapolis, M
N (612) 866-0083
Front R
ow C
enter -Boca R
aton, FL (407) 241-1767
Electrical S
hack -Alham
bra, CA
(818) 585-2228S
ound by Singer -N
ew Y
ork, NY
(212) 924-8600P
recision Audio -M
oorpark, CA
(805) 523-3005O
verture -Wilm
ington, DE
(800) 838-1812International D
istribution:N
.S.W
. Australia -T
he Audio C
onnectionB
angkok, Thailand -M
aster Audio
Golden S
tring International Ltd.D
ubai-Audiotech E
lectronicsD
usseldorf, Germ
any-Impuls
Japan-Tokyo-H
.A. H
i-Fi.
Path G
roup -England
CIR
CLE
NO
. 16 ON
RE
AD
ER
SE
RV
ICE
CA
RD
z
70
-75
80
-85
90
-95
-100-100
AP
REC/PLAY, ANALOG IN
AEC/PLAT DIGITAL IN
1 t
PlAYBACy
-80 -60 -40
RECORDED LEVEL - dBFS
Fig. 4-THD + N vs. level.
60
-80
100
120
-20
0 1 YIII ATI
60+8 AAP
/I. C P.
P."
I 1 1.,.,... "/ e'.'REC/PLAY
,, 4,11C.
PVNISACK NO SIGNALdel111111
30 00 10k
FREQUENCY - Hz
Fig. 5-Spectrum analysesfor record/play (via analoginput) and for playback.
0
100k 200k
+0.8
+0.0O
0
3
1 1
PLAYEtACK
4CIT.ERKD
rr -role
RIC ZpLAY 1
-100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0
L. -TRDED LEVEL - dBFS
Fig. 6-Deviation fromlinearity for record/play(via analog input) and forplayback.
own selections with the remote's "PGM"button and its numeric keypad; the "Clear"and "Check" buttons are used to correctmistakes and confirm your selections. Youcan repeat a single track by pressing the re-mote's "Repeat" key once or repeat the en-tire disc by pressing it twice. If you're inprogrammed or random mode, pressing"Repeat" twice repeats the programmed se-
quence or yields repeated random play.Via the remote's "Time" pad, you can
choose to display the elapsed or remainingtime during recording; in playback, youcan view the elapsed track time, remain-ing track time, remaining playing time onthe disc, or the CD's total playing time.When the Elite PDR-99 is in record orrecord/pause mode, you can check the timeremaining on the disc by tapping the front -panel "Display ofr button.
The remote permits fading inand out during recording andplayback. If you press "Fader"while in record mode, recordingstops in about 5 seconds. A 3 -sec-ond fade begins automaticallywhen the available recording timeruns out. Four -second silent pas-sages can be written to the disc bypressing the "REC Mute" buttonon the panel or the remote. Like allother consumer digital audiorecorders, the PDR-99 "features"SCMS copy protection.
MeasurementsIt was difficult to stifle my cu-
riosity about the PDR-99's record-ing ability and stick to a logical se-quence by testing it first as a CDplayer. (As with any recording de-vice, playback characteristics mustbe determined before trying to in-terpret any record/play measure-ments.) Except for some effectfrom the Legato -Link S conversionsystem, I expected the PDR-99 toperform pretty much like any goodplayer. Imagine my surprise, there-fore, when I ran a frequency sweepand found an almost 1 -dB dipthroughout the octave from 7.5 to15 kHz. Hmmm! Surprising, but Iguess not all that bad.
Next, I ran a distortion test andfound that total harmonic distor-
tion plus noise (THD + N) was admirablylow in the deep bass (less than 0.004% atand below 250 Hz) but increased to 0.009%at 500 Hz, kept rising, and reached a peak of12.3% at 8 kHz. Furthermore, this was realdistortion, predominantly odd -harmonic,not the result of intermodulation with thesampling component. Above 8 kHz, oddharmonics beyond the third were reducedby my analyzer's 22 -kHz low-pass filter,which explained why the curve droppedabove that point. At 4 kHz, fifth -orderproducts also were present; in the lower -frequency region, the distortion appearedas "ringing" where the signal waveformcrossed the zero axis.
At first, I suspected my test setup, butwhen I fed the Pioneer's digital output to aD/A converter in my lab, the results werefine. A call to Pioneer revealed that Legato
Link does exhibit somewhat higher distor-tion than traditional converters (presum-ably intentional, to simulate the ultrasonicharmonics assumed lost in the recording).Still, it seemed surprisingly high, so I re-quested another machine from Pioneer. Itsdistortion results were the same as the firstunit's, so I proceeded with the first sample.
In almost every other respect, the ElitePDR-99 proved to be an exemplary ma-chine. In my playback measurements (see"Measured Data"), all made with the CBS
IT'S CLEAR THAT
THE PDR-99 CAN MAKE
AN ESSENTIALLY
PERFECT COPY
FROM A DIGITAL SOURCE.
CD -1 test disc, output level was 2 dB higherthan normal. However, this should be aconcern only if you're using a preamp (orsome other device) that has a precariouslylow input overload threshold (some DolbyPro Logic and other signal processors do).The channels were almost perfectly bal-anced; output impedance was less than 1kilohm, which suggests that interconnectcable capacitance should be of little signifi-cance. And if you're listening to the PDR-99with headphones, you'll find it has morethan adequate drive into both high- andlow -impedance sets.
Despite the higher -than -typical playback
distortion at 0 dBFS (the maximum levelrecorded on CD), THD + N at 1 kHzdropped sharply with level, so that below-30 dBFS maximum contamination wasless than -96.6 dB. That's very good perfor-mance. The -71.5 dB I measured at 0 dBFScorresponded perfectly with the 0.027%measured with the discrete -tone sequenceon the CBS test disc.
The PDR-99's Legato Link DAC had su-perb low-level linearity at 1 kHz; deviationwas no worse than 0.91 dB down to -90dBFS on the undithered tracks of the CD -1disc and no worse than 0.12 dB down to-100 dBFS on dithered recordings! The ex-ceptional linearity is apparent in Fig. 1, aplot of fade to noise. Results for the leftchannel are shown, the poorer of the two bya tiny margin.
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199640
Your
tunes.
Your
home.
Your
ears.
Your
decision.
To receive your free 1996 Reference Guide
CALL 1#8004ALIDIO4H1( That s 1 - 8 0 0 - 2 8 3 4 6 4 4 )
The brand new Legacy High Current Preamplifier with Remote Control
SERVICE: 2 1 7-5 4 4-5 2 5 2
FAX: 2 1 7- 7 4 4- 7 2 6 91 D 1 0
3021 SANGAMON AVE.SPRINGFIELD, IL 6 2 70 2
The Best Equipment. The Best Prices. The Best Service.CIRCLE NO 11 ON READER SERVICE CARD
The left channel also proved the poorerchannel vis-a-vis signal-to-noise ratio,quantization noise, and dynamic range, butthis is really splitting hairs: The A -weightedS/N of 111.4 dB on the left channel was su-perb, even if the right was 3 dB better. Inany case, conventional S/N tests on DACstell more about the analog electronics fol-lowing the DAC than about the DAC itself,which is not exercised during this test. Thedata for quantization noise is more mean-ingful, as the DAC gets a full workout. Here,too, the right channel was 1.6 dB better, buteven the left's figure represents superb per-formance. The same goes for the PDR-99'sdynamic range.
I copied several tracks from the CBS testdisc to a 60 -minute recordable CD, using
the PDR-99's optical input. One wouldhope that the copy would be identical to theoriginal; by and large, this was true. The re-sults listed in "Measured Data" for frequen-cy response, THD + N at 0 dBFS, quantiza-tion noise, and linearity error are the same,give or take a few tenths of a decibel, forCD playback and record/play. The datafor A -weighted S/N, low-level THD + N at
1 kHz, and dynamic range are slightly infe-rior on record/play (more so on the rightchannel, which heretofore had been superi-or to the left), but none is less than excel-lent. It's clear that the PDR-99 can make anessentially perfect copy of a CD or, presum-
ably, of other digital sources. I expect thatthe slight differences between playbackand record/play were due to interface jit-
-EASURED P ATA
PLAYBACK
Line Output Level, 0 dBFS: 2.52 volts.
Channel Balance: ±0.02 dB.Line Output Impedance: 915 ohms.Maximum Headphone Output Level:
4.65 volts.
Maximum Headphone Power: With600 -ohm loads, 31.0 mW; with 50 -ohm loads, 25.8 mW.
Headphone Output Impedance: 115ohms.
Frequency Response: 20 Hz to 20 kHz,+0, -0.90 dB.
THD + N at 0 dBFS: Less than 12.3%, 20Hz to 20 kHz.
THD + N at 1 kHz: From 0 to -90 dBFS,less than -71.5 dB; from -30 to -90dBFS, less than -96.6 dB.
Maximum Linearity Error to -90 dBFS:Undithered recording, 0.91 dB;dithered recording, 0.12 dB.
A -Weighted S/N (Infinity Zero re 0dBFS): 111.4 dB.
Quantization Noise: -94.9 dBFS.Dynamic Range: Unweighted, 95.9 dB;
A -weighted, 98.0 dB.
RECORD/PLAY
Analog Line Input Sensitivity: 0.29 voltfor 0 dBFS.
Analog Line Input Impedance: 33kilohms.
Analog Line Input Overload Level:More than 10 volts.
Frequency Response: Analog input at 0dBFS, 20 Hz to 20 kHz, +0, -0.92 dB;analog input at -10 dBFS, 20 Hz to20 kHz, +0, -0.52 dB; digital input at0 dBFS, 20 Hz to 20 kHz, +0, -0.90dB.
THD + N, 20 Hz to 20 kHz: Analog in-put, less than 12.7% at 0 dBFS, lessthan 5.16% at -10 dBFS, and less than1.64% at -20 dBFS; digital input, lessthan 12.3% at 0 dBFS.
THD + N at 1 kHz: Analog input, lessthan -71.5 dB from 0 to -90 dBFS andless than -89.3 dB from -30 to -90dBFS; digital input, less than -71.4 dBfrom 0 to -90 dBFS and less than -95.5dB from -30 to -90 dBFS.
Maximum Linearity Error: Analog in-put, 0.24 dB at -90 dBFS or above and0.40 dB from -90 to -100 dBFS; digitalinput, 0.84 dB at -90 dBFS or above(undithered recording).
A -Weighted S/N (Infinity Zero re 0dBFS): Analog input, 92.0 dB; digitalinput, 110.7 dB.
Quantization Noise: Analog input,-89.4 dBFS; digital input, -94.7 dBFS.
Dynamic Range: Analog input, 90.1 dBunweighted and 92.8 dB A -weighted;digital input, 96.0 dB unweighted and97.8 dB A -weighted.
Channel Separation, Analog Input:Greater than 63.9 dB, 100 Hz to 17kHz.
ter, but the effects are below the thresholdof audibility.
I next shifted my attention to recordingfrom the analog inputs. From the shape ofthe curve for distortion versus level in play-back, I suspected that the odd -order har-monics introduced by Legato Link werelevel -dependent. But there was no way toprove this by digitally copying the CBS testdisc, since it lacks low-level high -frequency
tracks. Using the analog inputs, however, Icould record at any level I wished. First, Ichecked record/play response at 0 dBFS(using a 2 -volt input signal) and then re-peated the test at -10 and -20 dBFS (Fig. 2).
At 0 dBFS, I saw about the same dip be-tween 7.5 and 15 kHz that I'd seen in play-back. But lo and behold, the dip disappearsat -10 dBFS and is replaced by a gentlerolloff beginning at about 10 kHz. (The -10dBFS record/play curve has been shifted tooverlie the 0-dBFS curve at 1 kHz. The -20dBFS record/play curve has been omitted,because it was the same as the -10 dBFScurve except for level. Only the left -channelresults are presented here and in all subse-quent graphs, since the right -channelcurves were essentially identical.)
For Fig. 3, THD + N versus frequency,the PDR-99 was playing a disc recordedfrom the analog inputs at levels of 0, -10,and -20 dBFS. From 1 to 10 kHz, the0-dBFS curves for playback of the CD -1(not shown) and for record/play matchedperfectly at every frequency on the test disc.(These occur at approximately octave inter-vals from 1 to 8 kHz, with extra spots atnominal frequencies of 10, 12.5, 16, 18, and
20 kHz.) Since there was no point in show-ing all these closely matched curves, onlythe results for record/play via the analog in-put are included. The record/play curves Iselected are probably a better indicator ofperformance, as they contain many moretest frequencies than the play -only curves.(And they differed only at intermediatepoints.)
Note how the high -frequency distortiondecreases at the lower recording levels inFig. 3. It's never really low (it still hits5.16% at -10 dBFS and 1.64% at -20dBFS), but at least it's heading in the rightdirection! In the bass and lower midrange,the curves are flat and their THD + N in-creases as the recording level drops. Thissimply represents the noise floor of the ana-
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199642
soNouotiE
BreedingTellsThe heritage of the newSonographe products isreadily apparent. Considerthese characteristic traits:
ExceptionalMusicalitySonographe componentsare engineered andmanufactured byconrad-johnson design, acompany consistentlyacclaimed for the mostmusically satisfying audiocomponents made.
TimelessStylingAccented by elegantchampagne gold Finishedpanels, these Sonographeproducts are reallydistinguished fromordinary hi-fi components.
OutstandingValueBuilt to conrad-johnson'sunmatched standards inparts quality, yetsurprisingly affordable -just 5795 for the .C25line -stage preamplifier(phono-stage optimal forS200), and 5995 for theSA250 power amplifier.
For furtherinformation,contact:conrad-johnsondesign, inc.2733 Merrilee Dr.Fairfax, VA 22031phone: 703-698-8581fax: 703-560-5360CIRCLE NO. 7 ON READER SERVICE CARE
log input electronics and is not distortionper se.
Figure 4, the THD + N versus level for a1 -kHz test tone, tells a similar story. Sincethere was a slight difference between thedata for playback of the test disc and for thedigital copy thereof, I've also included acurve obtained after I dubbed the CD -1through the optical digital interface. Therecord/play curve taken through the analoginput bottoms out at about -90 dBFS, thenoise floor of the analog input electronics.
You can also see the effect of the analoginput's noise floor in "Measured Data":Compare the record/play results via theanalog and via the digital inputs forA -weighted S/N ratio, dynamic range, andquantization noise. This effect is to be ex-pected, and the PDR-99's analog input cir-cuitry is certainly not shoddy! It's sensitive(0.29 volt will get you pretty much to 0dBFS), is immune to overload, and has adecently high input impedance. The "Over"indicator lights just at the verge of clippingthe A/D converter, although the digitalrecording level at that point is about 0.25dB below the level attainable with a digitaldub. To avoid clipping the A/D circuit, I"defined" 0 dBFS for analog recording as-0.5 dB referred to digital full scale and ad-justed the data accordingly. For normalrecording, you'll be fine as long as you don'tlet the "Over" indicator flash.
Figure 5 shows third -octave spectrumanalyses of the output for playback of thetest disc's "no -signal" (infinity -zero) trackand its 1 -kHz, -60 dBFS track; I've also in-cluded the results for record/play of equiva-lent signals via the analog input. The -60dBFS curves line up pretty well. The curvefor the "no -signal" recording made via theanalog input lies well above the curve forplayback of the test disc's "no -signal" track,as you would expect.
A trace of analog -input electronic noiseis actually beneficial, in that it "dithers"(and therefore helps linearize) the A/D con-version process. Figure 6 compares the lin-earity error for playback of undithered anddithered tracks on the test disc and forrecord/play of a comparable signal via theanalog input. (I omitted the linearity -errorcurve for record/play of the test disc's un-dithered track via digital input, as it wasnearly identical to the curve for playback ofthe test CD.) Note the improvement in low-
level linearity with the digitally ditheredtrack and the almost equally good perfor-mance for record/play via the analog input.
The crosstalk figures in "Measured Data"speak for themselves. Channel separation isbetter when a CD is played than whenyou're recording and playing your own discthrough the analog inputs. It's more thanadequate either way however.
Use and Listening Tests
The PDR-99 was a sheer delight to use,about as friendly as I expect a digitalrecorder can get. (The manual could usesome editing to clear up the Japanese con-cept of English, although its graphics weregood.) The deck's control ergonomics wereso pleasing that I had no trouble learning to
THE PDR-99 WAS A SHEER
DELIGHT TO USE,
AS USER-FRIENDLY
AS I EXPECT A DIGITAL
RECORDER CAN GET.
use it. The major oddity was having to press"Display Off" to check remaining time dur-ing a recording session.
Digital dubbing was a snap, since thePDR-99 senses the start of each new trackand starts and updates its track counter au-tomatically. You needn't worry about whereyou are on the disc; the "housekeeping" oc-curs seamlessly in the background. You justhave to be sure you don't run out of room,but even if you do, the PDR-99 gracefullyfades out the recording. Recording analogsignals is a bit dicier: You do have to set lev-
els, and an indicator that has only eight seg-ments (one of which, .0, is useless) makesthe gradations way too far apart. When the"Over" indicator comes on, you're alreadyin trouble. (Of course, the same can be saidfor some other consumer digital recorders.)
The PDR-99 did strike me as a bit slug-gish. Track access during playback wasrather slow. When a new disc was loaded,the system took its own sweet time decidingwhat type of disc it was. Disc finalizationwas so lengthy, I could have taken a coffeebreak. But, hey, this is a CD recorder, justwhat we've wanted for years. So what's afew minutes?
In my listening sessions, I dubbed CDsand DATs, using the digital hookup. ThePDR-99 recognized each unfailingly andconfirmed what they were. As far as I couldtell, the sound was equally good on the copy
as on the original, provided that the CD -Rwas "finalized" and then played on the CDplayer in my own system. That's the rub: Pi-oneer's Legato Link D/A converter has asound of its own, and it's not one I particu-larly cotton to. On the other hand, it doeshave its strong point: The bass was full andrich and tight. I particularly noticed this onpianist Andrew Rangell's recording ofBeethoven's Sonata No. 30, Op. 109 (Dori-an DOR-90158) and on Christopher Rous-set's harpsichord performance of Rameau'sPremier Livre de Pieces de Clavecin(L'Oiseau-Lyre 425886). But on both discs,the treble got edgy and hard (uncomfort-ably so on the harpsichord recording) dur-ing high-level passages. There was toomuch snap on the harpsichord attack andtoo little "puff" on the piano.
Violins fared poorly through the LegatoLink, especially "original" instrumentsplayed without vibrato. Mozart's "EineKleine Nachtmusik" by the Academy of An-cient Music under Christopher Hogwood(L'Oiseau-Lyre 411720) is a rather brightrecording to begin with; the violins sound-ed like nothing I had ever heard by the timethe PDR-99 got through with them.
The higher the level, the harder thesound got. On Wagner's "Siegfried's RhineJourney" from The "Ring" Without Words,recorded by the Berlin Philharmonic underLorin Maazel (Telarc CD -80154), the open-ing horn call and bassoon passage werenice, but the sound lost clarity in the high-level high -frequency passages. On Rodri-go's "Concierto de Aranjuez" (EMI ClassicsCDC 54665), Christopher Parkening's gui-tar fared better, yet still wasn't as smoothand natural as on my reference player. Andthe Royal Philharmonic Orchestra's violinswere steelier than they should be.
On The English Lute Song (Dorian DOR-90109), Julianne Baird sounded fine whenshe wasn't reaching, but the poor womansounded like an over -the -hill coloraturawhen she was. And Ronn McFarlane's lutecame with a bit of extra "attack" on thePDR-99 compared with the sound of myCD player.
Continued on page 58
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199644
We Get Letters...634 -34th Avenue
San Franciscc, CA 94121MLy 17, 1995
XLO Electric Company9480 Utica Avenue, Ste. 612Rancho Cucamonga, CA 91730
To Whom It May Concern;
I recently purchased a 4 -meter run of your Reference Series Type 2 inteNonnectcable. Without even breaking them in, they have to be ;he finest catles thLt, I havenever heard. (Sounds like a new slogan- "The finest cable you have never heard".)It seems as though every other cable that I have tried invariably st.ines in one ortwo areas as one runs down the usual audiophile checklist (i.e. sound staging, tonalbalance, focus, etc....), but somehow always leaves on 3 thinking that something ismissing or that there is too much 3f something. I always thought that I hadassembled a reasonably good system, but it wasn't until I inserted the Type 2 thatI realized I have never heard it the way it should sound. At times, = can actually sitback and listen to real musicians playing in real space.
I think my next move is to slowly replace all of the cable and wire in any systemwith XLO. The wire tangle presently includes Monster Cable, Straightwire, MIT, and
COS. Anyway, kudos, hosannas. yippee, and thanks for making "The Best In The World."
.8.: Present system, F.Y.I.Versa Dynamics 1.2
Immedia RPM 1Graham 1.5t
Clavis
Genesis 2000Vendetta Phono Section
Audio Research LS -2Mark Levinson 23
Apogee Duetta Signatures
44(0004666.414.44111641
XLO Electric Company. Inc. 9480 Utica Avenue, Suite 612. Rancho Cucamonga, CA 91730Phone (909) 466-0382 Fax (909) 466-3662Distributed in Canada by May Audio Marketing (514) 651-5707
Sincer3ly,
Mike Kanai
111(1 T R I(
EQUIPMENT PROFILEEDWARD J FOSTER
BRYSTON 4B STAMPLIFIER
It's been almost two years since a Bry-ston product crossed my bench. Thatone (the BP 20 preamp, Audio, July1994) was such a pleasure that I lookedforward to getting my hands on the 4BST power amplifier. Bryston's "ST" line
of power amps strikes me as quite sensible.The 4B ST is a bridgeable stereo amp deliv-ering 250 watts per channel into 8 ohms instereo or 800 watts, bridged. The 3B ST is asimilar amp, with an 8 -ohm stereo rating of120 watts per channel. The 7B ST has twoamp modules but is designed for mono-phonic use; the two modules can be"bridged" to double the output voltage intorelatively high -impedance loads (3 to 8ohms) or operated in parallel to double thecurrent into relatively low -impedance loads(1 to 3 ohms). Interesting concept. The 8BST is a four -channel amp that is otherwisesimilar to the 3B ST; it can be configured todrive four, three, or two speakers. All of
these amps are available in THX versions,which differ only in having 12 -volt triggerinputs for remote turn -on; the 4B ST that Itested was the standard version.
Technically, Bryston seems to have doneits homework. The 4B ST's topology is clas-sic, with each amplifier module builtaround eight custom output devices pow-ered by separate positive and negative 85 -volt supplies. There are two large toroidalpower transformers, one for each channel.
Both unbalanced and balanced inputsare provided, the former via gold-platedRCA phono jacks and the latter throughgold-plated connectors that can accept bothXLR and 1/4 -inch stereo phone plugs. All in-puts sport fully discrete active buffers. Aslide switch centered between the jack pairsselects balanced or unbalanced input. Theoutput terminals are gold-plated multiwaybinding posts set on standard 3/4 -inch cen-ters and outfitted with wire holes large
enough for heavy -gauge wire. Another slide
switch, between the RCA jacks and the out-put terminals, selects bridged or stereo op-eration. In bridged mode, either channel 1input is used, and the load is connected be-tween the red output terminals. (Thewiring details are clearly indicated on theback panel.) Between the output terminalsand the combination IEC line -cord jackand fuse holder is a toggle switch for lifting
the signal -ground connections to the chas-sis. Lifting the grounds breaks the hum -pickup loop that might occur through acommon power ground when you're usingmultiple amplifiers, yet it still permits thechassis to be grounded for safety. Goodthinking!
The front panel is straightforward: solidhandles near each end, a centrally locatedpower button, and two multicolor LEDsabove the power switch. The LEDs indicate
normal operation (green), the approach ofclipping in each channel (yellow), and clip-ping (red). They also flash red momentarilyon power -up and may glow red if signal ispresent as the supply voltages collapse whenpowering down; neither condition is causefor concern.
The 1/4 -inch black -anodized aluminumpanel is drilled for rack mounting. Whennot rack -mounted, the 4B ST sits on feetthat provide a bit more than 1/2 inch ofclearance above the supporting shelf. Black -
anodized heat sinks along each side provideadequate cooling without a noisy fan. Thechassis is designed so that you can tem-porarily rest this hefty amp on its backsidewithout having to disconnect the wiring.Nice thought!
MeasurementsWith continuous signals, the Bryston 4B
ST ran warm (but not dangerously hot)during my bench tests but remained a good
Rated Output: Stereo, 250 watts perchannel into 8 ohms or 400 watts perchannel into 4 ohms; bridged, 800watts into 8 ohms.
Dimensions: 19 in. W x 5% in. H x 15%in. D (48.3 cm x 13.3 cm x 39.4 cm).
Weight: 42 lbs. (19 kg).Price: $2,095; THX version, $2,295.Company Address: 29 Northfield St.,
Montpelier, Vt. 05602; 802/223-6159.For literature, circle No. 91
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199646
5e4
feiNefe10WIPt : '..41;41.4 .A;141611' '11"d" 4"ktintA;1141n.
-
-- AMC agog
it11111111111111111th
We've just released apicture that's better thananything you'd see here.
A
. . 'I . . ". . .
ies and gentlemen, you are cordially invited to the next showing of Sharp-Visicn_
Novi, thanks to our Super High Brightness, we've got a picture that combines razor -
SH A II PTISIONsharp clarity With a brightnesMat surpasses most movie tlTaters. And it's playing
in a place where the popcorn's Letter anyway... your own home. No hulky boxes.
No three beam convergence headaches. Just 40", up to a moss.ve 200", of crisp, bright picture. So if you really
want to see a memorable pictu2e, don't go to the movies. G3 to a SharpVision dealer. Call 1-800-BE-SliARP Or
visit our web site at Tittp://www.sharp-usa.com. Then sit back, relax and enjoy the show. A RpoLCD
lir1996 Siarp Electronics Cprporation.
FROM SHARP MINESCOME SHARP PRODUZTS-
CFCLE NC 23 ON READER SEPVCE CARD
tr 4111, - ,K1.111 - arm ..... Uflatenc. -
iiiiiii
F 0.0'
000100005
02
it 011
0.01
0.00100005
02
10
OUTPUT - WATTS
100
4S1 Pd.! I am. L1[6
1k
A
-1101, 4- --2"'=6;;;;;; --an--WRIIII=M : ::m:;- -201H:-1111111=M0111111=MM1111111111110111111111
- ---- ===-------------===Eiliiii===z-........,----
illinillEgiiiiiirffanillinfiliiiiii..r.;;;;;;==a::::-.=1.1:.::..-............iiiiiiMillillaillaillaiiiiiiii---,..i.-..-------- -MeiEEiEi----====zzo
0 100
OUTPUT - WATTS
B
0.1
z
F 0.0,
0.001
0000502
°.°====.
IiiiCi:::CCiiilii:Cii11l:iiiiii iiiu111111u1111110IIIIIIIII III
munnommumaiiirosoumesmanan10
OUTPUT - WATTS
Fig. 1-THD + N vs. outputin stereo with 8 -ohm loads (A),in stereo with 4 -ohmloads (B), and in bridgedmode with 8 -ohm load (C).
100
bit cooler in normal operation. Perhaps theheat was due to the high supply voltages.Theoretically, an amplifier whose powersupply delivers +85 and -85 volts could de-liver 450 watts into 8 -ohm loads, almost 2.6dB above Bryston's 250 -watt rating. Whatthe 4B ST actually delivered on the benchwas 300 watts (24.8 dBW) of continuouspower into 8 ohms at clipping and 0.1 dBmore (310 watts) with the IH F dynamic -headroom tone burst-more than it's ratedfor but still less than theory would suggest.That's not a complaint; the data simply sug-gests that Bryston uses a rather stiff powersupply, which many people consider to bean advantage.
I measured total harmonic distortionplus noise (THD + N) as a function of out-put for stereo operation with 8 -ohm loads,stereo operation with 4 -ohm loads, andbridged mono operation with an 8 -ohm
C
load (Fig. 1). The data was taken at
20 Hz, 1 kHz, and 20 kHz. I usedthe unbalanced inputs for thesemeasurements, since that is howmost people will use the 4B ST.With 8 -ohm loads, both channelsdriven, I could keep my AC line atthe standard 120 volts. With4 -ohm loads, I was unable to holdthe line at 120 volts when bothchannels were driven to rated out-put. I therefore made the 4 -ohmstereo test with only one channeldriven, justified by the fact that the4B ST has separate supplies foreach channel. Bridged operationinto 8 ohms, while technically sim-ilar to 4 -ohm stereo operation,makes it impossible to drive onlyone channel at a time. Thus, as theamplifier approached clipping inthis mode, the line dropped to ap-proximately 110 volts.
The results for dynamic outputpower and headroom listed in"Measured Data" were obtainedwith both channels driven andwith my meter reading an averageof 120 volts across the AC line (themeter fluctuates a bit while an am-plifier is being pulsed). Since the4B ST was being driven to fullpower only part of the time in thistest, I could maintain 120 volts atlower output settings of my vari-
able -voltage transformer than I had beenable to use in the sine -wave tests. Therefore,
I also took data using the same transformersettings that had been needed to maintain120 volts at the sine -wave clipping point (or
the maximum I could manage when 120volts couldn't be maintained). At these
THE SOUND
WAS EFFORTLESS
AT ALL LISTENING LEVELS,
WITH TIGHT BASS AND
BRIGHT, CLEAN TREBLE.
settings, my line meter naturally read morethan 120 volts, and the numbers came out0.5 to 1 dB better than those listed in "Mea-sured Data."
- MIS/ - 1.41NISI 4,44111111 - 0.1
T oat
0 001
0000520
020
- lin4041.0need I ..... OSL
E-E-EEE. =.2.oaal:GIIBEENERaiiiiiimm==ENRINmmommiiirmlm...M ENIIIII MMNIIIIIMIMI1111111 1111111iliiiiiii5liMer.-22!M
To" - mmirsirmmiEMPIIIIIIIIIMM -.41EI!!IIMelIMIC.in 11iimmi
="a1:::17r1/113.1.2::i.E-..-----"E=-Eiiii100 Ik
FREQUENCY - Ha
10k 20k
A
ton - 1411.11.1 41 - 4 o ..... - kw. - OSL
at
001
0001
000520
NEEKEEzisni--- :hems:IMIMINIIIIIIMEW1111111111111WEINII=IMBINI11111111MEMIIIII=ME11.110.1111.........1111
1111111 IMIIII INSOM
IIIIIII
.1.1o.--=m=o-----=Iwzi; 4 -.-za..!ia---...r.astie4..-----..-
MItrttlidligiiiINIEgg.wmumt-.i..Pattr:-:.-..nsitriviii
titill11111111111illiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiill
100 1 k
FREQUENCY - Hz
10k 20k
B
001
yln,
E=:=11111111111.-;;;;...-..-uni..-assur
-===r.::::===.7.-:::ilia
INIMIIIMIIIIIIIIMMEN11111111111011111111111 111111 MEINM
--E====s3.15-.E.e,!.,.-_,switiiiiiii--gisiii-,70Zus
11101.11111.11111.M 10 WATTIlt
"Iii°111.11111111.11.11 IIIRS.Oil".W'
===Zi:::=1.=====m100 1 k
FREQUENCY - HI
Fig. 2-THD + N vs.frequency in stereo with8 -ohm loads (A), in stereowith 4 -ohm loads (B), andin bridged mode with8 -ohm load (C).
104 20k
C
Measurements of THD + N versus fre-quency (Fig. 2) were made at output levelsof 1 watt, 10 watts, 100 watts, and ratedpower. The last, of course, varied with con-ditions: 250 watts per channel in stereowith 8 -ohm loads, 400 watts per channel instereo with 4 -ohm loads, and 800 watts forbridged operation into 8 ohms. Driving theamplifier in bridged mode to 800 wattswith an 8 -ohm load dropped the AC linewell below the 120 -volt standard. I there-fore repeated the measurement, this time at700 watts; calculations showed that the am-plifier's distortion at this power level withthe available line voltage would be the sameas its distortion at 800 watts with a true120 -volt line. The worst -case THD + N islisted in "Measured Data" for each operat-ing configuration at 10 watts and at ratedoutput. I have also reported the bridged700 -watt data, since it is probably more
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199648
Moods & Tbs IIMask*UMW Mies MMV(Manic) 06872
Heart, The Road HomeiCapto. 02967
Sheryl CrowTuesday Night Music Club
03061
Raekwon.Only Built 4 Cuban Linz(Loud Records) 00061 I
Ty England (RCA) 00070
Alaimo: In Pictures(RCA) 00063
D'Angelo: Brown Sugar(EN) 00313 0
Clueless/5db*.Cool*, Cracker. MisersICAPN0N 00341
Toni Session(team) 00420
The Very Best Of Cream-
=00468Brew
Pavarotti I Friends 2Welt Bryan Adorns, others.(Lander) OMftThe Bonnie Reit Collection(Warner Bros) 00569
Best 01 Dire Straits.Money For Nothing(Warner Bros 00713
Fleetwood Mac: Greatestkits (Warner Bros 00796
RCA Victor Greatest HitsSerks: TchalkovskyGreatest Hits (RCA 00952
Weld Groatist Hits(RCA) 00956
Fall (Bad Boy/Ansta) 00668
Nelms' W. Smith:rIllmd You Home(Reunion) NONMil Turner Simply TheB eet (Copilot) 01195
TM Bast 01 Joe CockeriCapttoi, 01336
Freedom tosave more the
longer you stay- up to 7o%.
James Brown:20 All -Time Greatest Hits(Politior) 01342
Pavarotti And Friends(London) 01451
Creedence ClearwaterRevival: Chronicle:20 Grealeet Hits(Fantasy) 01520
B lind Melon: Soup(CePtioll 01667
Gershwin Plays Cierehwin:TM Nino Rale(Elektraffikneetkh) 01675
Faith R Weer, To Me(Warner Bros.) 02110
Ae Of Bose: TM Sign(Arista) (12364
Madonna: The ImmeculeleCollection (Si.) 54164
Opere's Greatest Moments(FICA Victor Red Seel) 02561
yin IrloroLl Bonnie RainSing. others. (Atlanta) 02594
Elton John.Greatest Hits: Volume Two1P01Y000 03078
Chant: TM BenedictineMonks Of Santo Domingo deSloe (Angel) 02957
Beethoven. SymphoniesHos. 5 6 "Peolorale"
Gold, 03127 r(DG
B lackhawk: Strong Enough(Anita Hasiwde) 03113
Girth Brooks: In Pisces(LJ0owlY) 637101Medina McBride: *lidAngels (RCA) 03241 1
Ccglactive Soul: HMIs,AllegationsThings LanUnsaid (Mont) NM IJon Secede: Heart. Soul & A IYoke (Saki 03323
B lues Twofer (MM) 03396 1Kershew:i
(Mercury ) 03522
TM Lion Irang1801a.(Walt Disney) 03533
Travis DIM Grestest lets -From The(Warner Derrell 03557E dwin McCain:Manor Among Thieves(AllentsYLave) 03608
Printer The Illte 1(WBOPaisiory Park) 02228 t 1
Ace 01 Sees: The Bridge(Adele) 03913 1
Alan JacksonOmani Hits Collection(Arista flatriviliel 03915 I
=19/7 (AIM) 04393The Singles
Supertramp: Clanks (14 IGreatest Hits) (AIM) 04491 ,
Ray LynchDeepBreakfast
Zdha02634
S aws Rea: LongingIn Thar Helms(C80100 02742
Green Om: Dookie(Remise)
Frank
02753
ForVASinatra:Dusts(Captio) 03039
Elton JohnGoodbye Yellow BrickRoad(Pcin300300
76
NOW
orthepriceof
Empra Records/Sdtrk.Gin Blossom,. Cr,berries, EtterynNNW 1AMA 03457
The PoliceEver, Breath You Take,
C.....114. TM Classics(Mk 03515
Davie Bowie,The Singles 1969-1993(Ryk, disc, 01659
Nana Griffith; Flyer'Fiekrai 05982
Ehilr
ThF Tony Bennett/
(W°:Pleriall3r0e.) 02142
Bill Evans Albumpm/ (Fantasy, 00280
TlrlisuaW Cher.John:
NOTHING MORE TO BUY EVER! PC:'" 0202403077
Drearnlan31Quincy Jones: Classics (ISGres ell Ms) (UM) 04106
Rey Charles:The Beef 01 The AtlanticYews (Rhino) 06756
Brooks Dunn: Wolin' OnSundown (Anita) 06886
Amy Cart Mouse 01 Loa(AIN 06602
Jerrae Gehrer Wind OfChimp Tears M Hewer,
06660more ARCA)
Mlle Baker. Rhythm Of Love(Eleldral 05960
s 022
Incognito Positivityk!-,,, rm 02989
Norm in Brown After TheStorm 1.1 03282
g Vanessa Rubin Sings!(Novo:) 03411
Cecilia [MicaMozart Portniits
ownB oys Men: 1(Molowb
fhegillea n:The Woman In Me(Merced Pieshvils) 06935
Krems Cluerlst
06028
Prayers (Nonce t) NOMR.E.M.: Morals!Mama Bros.) 06164
B on Jowl: Cross Road(Cireratra Mb) (Mousy) ONO
May VTR The Icon ILove (.111) WIN
Pemrote: The EarlyYews, Vol. IRegarded Wel (RCAActs Gold Seal) 08200
Rod Streart TheMincury Anthology(Mrcuiy, 01161
To Petty: WildflowersWiner Bros 06260
Brandy i Atlantic! 06266
Bues Traveler Four Jasan's Lyric/Mirk. LL6M NOS Coo J, Tony1TonilTone'
Wart Msaury) 06266Fraser Sinatra: Duets I
(019131) 082NSears flirelasnd:Halo Daly0'4101 06314
Ymessa Williams:The Sweetest Days
(Mercury 06335
eledorms: Bedtime StoriesPilevencliSite 06356
The 11441 Of Nog 1964-1014: Fiala 0/ Gold(AIM) 06357
The UnximileMeeCollection,Vol. 1Paul McCattney. others(Warner 06393
Real McCoy: Another Night06500
LucianoPaverotd:Paverolli IiCeara Perk(London) NMCabala foul(Aaink) 06133
TM Chlethars: Ths LongBack Veil Footslog Sting.The Roing Stones others.(RCA Victor) 06406
TM Traub To Elvis:N's Now Or Hever MichaelBolton Tony Bennett others.
5496
Freedom to
explore all
kinds of music.k. Mug ay The MostBeautifullisei Thing in thisWorld (Jive) 06506 f
Neal McCoy: you Gotta LoveThat! (Aller,C) 06904
Stevie Wonder: Converse -non Peace (M010tan) 011069
JAll MASTERSAlex ElognonTales F on, The BrightSide 1-, 03426
Boney . ernes Seduction
Mike Baubeck QuartetLate Ni, ht BrobeckLove At She Blue Note
05665
Ella Fitzgerald The Best01 The Songbooks.The Salads . 05713
Joshua RedmanMood Swig
kill 05645
The Best of DavidSanborr Poor's', 06274George /uke. IllusionsfJner 3r., 06926
David S1 nborn Pearls08324
Herbie Fencock.Du is Di Drum
06567
The Bridges OfMadison County/S(1PB
08709
Incognito.100 Degrees And Rising
The Best 01 Miles Davis'The Capitol/Blue NoteYears r 't 7.- 11000
John ColtraneGiant Steps
34589
Kenny G BreathlessA, sl.i 54317
The George BensonCollection
016513
Joshua Redman Quartet -Sprit 01 The Moment -Live At TheVillage Vanguard!Warner Bros ) 02221 o
Sera.ILIO NIUE* IllsIVEY 4,7111.
SERVICE -
BUSINESS REPLY MAILFIRST-CLASS MAIL PERMIT NO. 5071 INDIANAPOLIS IN
POSTAGE WILL BE PAID BY ADDRESSEE
BMG MUSIC SERVICEPO BOX 91300INDIANAPOLIS IN 46209-9254
NO POSTAGENECESSARYIF MAILED
IN THEUNITED STATES
1.1..1.11 I1 111...1.1..1.1....1.1.1.1..1..11.1..1
John Michael Montgomery(Mantic) 08251
Pops Stoppers - GreatestHits of the Boston PopsOrchestra John Williams,can (Philips) 06573
The Very Best 01 ElvisCastello 8 The Attractions1E77-85 (Rykodisc) 06956
Eacomium: A Tribute To LedZeppelin Hooke 8 The Blowfish.ohers (Atlantic) 06135
Better Than Ezra: Deluxe!- 'PORI 08160
OW ISM
Freedom to
stay as long as
you want, after
you but just
one at hai price.
Mr
4. CI Mrs0 Ms.
Address
City
Phone (Area Code
Annie Lennox: Medusa03678
Matthew Sweet: 100% FunZoo Entertainment) 06166
Lorrie Morgan:
08232 InGreatest Hits
Eric Clanton:The Cream 01 Clanton(solydori 08241
Linda Ronstadt,Fens Like HometElektra) 08255
Adlna Howard:Do You Wanna Ride?!EastWest)
Madonna: The Immaculate:ollection iSirei 541
bm
The CMilberries: No Need
11111.1111111111 06251k
Robert Cray: Some l,,,466Morning (Mercury)Elton John: Med* InEngland (Rocitet/PRI) 06583Bletsid Union 01 Souls:Home (EMI) 08604
TM Infamous Mobb peep(Loud Records)
The Very But Of OtisRedding (Rhino) 08756
Monica Miss Thanes
MUSICMESERVICE a --
Neil Young: Mirror Ball08873
The Rembranclts: LPE 08897
Classic Disney60 Years 01 Musical MagicVol. I includes songs from,.The Lion King: WaryPoppins' arid others(Walt Disney) 08692
Enya: The Celts(Reprise) 08872
Jeff Foxworthy:Games Rednecks Play
irner 08877
Ail -4 -One: And The MusicSpeaks !Aiiiii- ifitr, 089171111Ork. Post E 08919
Prinr;e: The Hits 1(WEI/Paisley Park) 02228
Guru: Juzrnatazz Vol. II -TM New Reality
Boyz N Men: Cooleyhigh-harmony (Motown) 10930
Jackson Browne: RunningOn Empty Eiektra) 11066
Aaron Neville: The TattooedHeart (A8M) 16655
ST: MAT TlIKWF.RAND
' 4Dave Matthews BandUnder The Table And
Dreaming A 05998
theFor
L
NOTHING MORE TO BUY
7 + fit. +Start with Buy only 1 at lug Thee get 2 more Noy 10 CDs
7 FREE CD. the Noir Club CDs of your for 1/2 thenow price within a yew choice, FREE price of 1
A shipping and handling charge is added to each selection.
NOTHING MORE TO BUY, EVER!
Melina Etheridge: Yes IAm Island) 35501
Eric Chariton: Unplutd)(Warner Bros
James Taylor:Greatest HitsReprise) 23790
The Best Of TheBeach BoysCapitol. 23946
Foreigner:The Very Best...
And Beyond(Atlantic) 24722
Stone TemplePilots: Purple(Atlantic) 24738
Gin Blossoms:New MiserableExperience(A8M) 24884
The Greatest HitsOf Freddie Jackson
(Capitol) 25323
Cale/Cast Recording(P017331) 00071 tr
EVER! Theer GevereakIte"sletrNits 14) 74-19371899
The Best Of Arnim FranklinlAtlantic) 20078
Paul Simon: Negotiations AndLove Songs 1971-86(Warner Bros.) 20461
The Very Best 01 Yee(Atlantic) 20671
Isn't 11 Romantic: CapitolSings Rodgers & Hart(Capitol) 21102
Eagiu: Greatest Hits1971-1975 (Asylum) 234111
BrIen McKnigM(Mercury) 25453
Smokily Robinson & TheMirense: 18 Grestiet Hits(Motown) 33878
Moo* Blues: Legend OfA Bend (Greatest lilts)(Threehoid) 34264
Steve winwood: Chronicles111 34501
Bryn Adams: So Fr SoGood (MIA) 34771
Start Saving! Mail This Postage -Paid Card Today.r: the BMG Music Ser ,Iter.. agree to w, iy,$1_1 CD at
nall the regular Club once ($14.98 to $16.98) within a year. I will then receive 2 more choices FREE) That's 10 for 1/2 the once of 1 yrth 00111100 more topryer! I understand that a shipping and handling charge will be billed for each selection.
2. Rein me Uses 7 CDs sow (indicate by number):
A 2 -CO set (*) counts as 2 selections.
3. I am always free to choose hoer any category. but I am most interested in the music category checked here (check ma only)
1 0 LIGHT SOUNDS 2. 0 COUNTRY 3. 0 HARD ROCK 4 0 son ROCK 8 POP 5 0 rE 4688tAl IllMies Mar Alen Jackson Bon Joy Ban Join Lozano RIVI3t070Frank Sksies Stinis Twain Van Helen Hoot* 8 The Blowfish Evgeny Kisser
6 0 Jen 7 0 METAL 8 0 FMB/DANCE 9 0 ALTERNATIVEFlulnY Patera TLC The Garton",Dud Sartcm AC Boyz II Men Green Day
First Name Initial
State
Signature
Last Name
APt
Zlp
Instant
50%OffBonus
EMS MUSICSERVME
Free day ore, every timeyou buy a CD at theregular Club once,
you're entitled to buyanother of equal or
lesser value at hall price.
IL Menton ere croon CLASSICAL as are lame Merest all begins:sr) by Pe BMG Classcal Mien Sense. we reserve the nee to request seasonedinformelon. riled MY 114:64100(In a Canal any membership. brniteci to new members. Local IBMS, it env will be added. Offer &alai* in continental uS4and under acacia misspeak in Alaska and Hawaii Offer not eyelet* in Puerto Rico. APO or FPO. Ode, sd0 orcouct selector may vary in Canada
Carew reekleals wallMt/ to,(NAG MUSIC ServiceBM 7010misname 01115A 413
FBDAA
Bette Midler. Bette Of Roses(Atlantic) 40445
Carreras, Domingo IPavarotti: The 3 Tenors InConceit Melds conducts(London) 35078
The Best 01The Doable Brothers(Warner Bros.) 43738
Enya: Shepherd Moons(Reprise) 53190
The Temptations: 17Greatest HIP (Gordy) 53410
AP U2: The Joshua TreeIsland) 53501
Bob lawny: Legend°Mend) 53621
Munn Gaye: 15 GimiselHIM (Mom) 53634
Whitney HouMon:The Bodyguard/SentArista) 54213
Vivaldi, The Four SwoonsGil Shaham/Crpheus CharnixorOrchestra. (DG) 06093
En Vogue: Funky Divas(EastWest) 61717
Dean Martin:Capitol Collectors Series
(Capitol) 62295
Eagles: GiselestHits, Vol. 2(Asylum) 63316
Magenta,:Countdown To Extinction(Capitol) 63340
Nell Young: Unplugged(Reprise) 64125
0 i
Dire Straits: Live At TheBBC Warner Bros 02140
PM Collins: Serious Hits...Livel (Manic) 00324
YennkLive At The Acropolis(Private Music) 02477
Bryan Adams:Live! Live! Live?(A8M) 06497
Dwight Yoskam: DwightLive (Reprise) 08713
Elvis Presley: Live AtMadison Spare Garden(RCA) 30070
16 51 Motown HitsFrom The Late '60s TheSupremos, The Temptations.others. (Motown) 64334
Van Morrison: Moondenos(Warner Bros.) 64565
Elvis Presley: The NumberOne Nils (RCA) 72190
The John LennonCollection (Capitol) 73627Rod Stewart:UnpluggetL.And Seated(Warner Bros.) 73684
Zapp 8 Roger:All The Greatest Hits(Repose) 80232
Frank Sinatra: SinatraReprise: The Very GoodYears (Repose) 80304
ZZ Top: Greatest Hits(Warner Bros.) 83411
Best Of The Grateful Deed:Skeletons From The Ctoeet(Warner Bros.) 83892
ABSOLUTELY LIVEU2: Under A Blood RedSky (Live At Red Rocks)(Island! 53598
Allman Brothers Band:The Fillmore ConcertsiPolyOor 01159 tr
Van Helen: Live:Right Here, Right Now(Warner Bros) 011135 Ss
Genesis Live:The Way We Walk. Vol 1
(Atlantic) 02033
The Police: Live(651.) 06551
Mash: A Live One(Eleldra) 08922
Grateful Dead: Europe 72(Warner Bros) $3931 tr
David Bowie: David Live(Rykodisc) 64369 '
The Doors: In Concert(Elektra) 93427
Here's how your Club works:Start with our 744 hem* to introduce you to the Club...andto your savings!
CHOOSE THE MUSIC YOU LOVE. Pick 7 FREE CDs right now from the many great choices
in this ad. Roy beet 1 select, orf the regular Club price (currendy
$14.913 to S16 98 ,ear. Then ! 2 more FREE CDs. That's 10 for 1/2 the price
of 1 i-dling for each selection) with Toth
LISTEN WITH NO RISK. You may take 10 days to listen toyour introductory selections and look over the accompanyingterms of Club membership.
If you're not completely satisfied, simply return your selec-tions at our expense - with no further obligation.
SHOP FROM THE COMFORT OF HOME. Discover howconvenient it is to shop with BMG Music Service. You'll get our exclusive Club Catalog about every three weeks
(19 shopping opportunities a year), filled with hundreds ofchoices in a variety of music categones, plus music news.artist interviews and recommendations from our experts.
So easy! Every issue offers a Featured Selection in yourpreferred music category. If you want the Featured Selection.don't do a thing - you'll receive it automatically.
Your choice! If you want other hits horn the Catalog - ornone at all - lust return the Notification Card providedby the specified date. You'll have at least 10 days to decide.
No pressure! If you should have fewer than 10 days to replyand receive an unwanted Featured Selection, simply return itat our expense.
SAVE AGAIN AND AGAIN. From day one, for every selec-tion you buy at the regular Club once, you may choose anotherof equal or lesser value at 50% oft. But that's not all. The longer you remain a BMG Music Service member, the
more you save - up to 50%, 60%, even 70% - with ourspecial sales and discounts.
We're sure you'll enjoy your exclusive Club benefits. But if youever want to cancel, lust write and tell us. It's your choice
waniMirelom-BIZtek,uyQus,c buyrweaw andhalftpri; senglect. *n.
Wily
1 Mrs tway sma is Msaing please wine to:BMG Music Serves, P.O. Box 91300.
C11/4
MUSICMSERVICEM
I ',mai klmo).-Contans ai4.1 lm enig .99842110 set !counts an 2 sebedionsi
Dr( Ind nom we Vole... al Gonda Eincvc Caron,.uSA rte MG by e a tradirnark al MG Mae Ode,indsnrits wee in We eloarburrent am the pi:party dwags trademark Ewen BMG Music Serve.6550 E 3001 51 inciwn49114 IN 4621911940 1995 WAG Ned
(PLEASE PRINT)
typical of what the distortion at rated pow-er would have been had I been able tomaintain a 120 -volt line.
If you compare these distortion figureswith those of many similarly rated ampli-fiers, you'll see that Bryston has placedprime emphasis on performance. Even theworst -case THD + N is vanishingly low un-der all conditions, and the 1 -watt curves inFig. 2 (which stand above the others overmost of the frequency range) reflect resid-ual noise rather than distortion.
The noise is unusually low for an ampli-fier that combines such high power withreasonably high gain. On an A -weighted ba-sis, worst -case output noise was a minus-cule -93.6 dBW when the unbalanced in-puts were used and negligibly worse withthe balanced input. When referenced to rat-ed output power, A -weighted signal-to-noise ratios ran from 116.3 dB (balancedinput, stereo) to a whopping 123.5 dB (un-balanced input, bridged).
Figure 3 shows third -octave noise power(in dBW) versus frequency for the worst -case operating mode, 8 -ohm stereo opera-tion with balanced input. Obviously, the 4BST is outfitted with excellent power -supplyfilters: Note the relative absence of compo-nents at 120 Hz and its harmonics. The
components that do appear are basedon 60 Hz and its odd harmonics, sug-gesting that the components arecaused by minute amounts of mag-netic flux leakage from the powertransformers (even toroids aren'tperfect) or from the power -linewiring. In any event, since the veryworst noise level (channel 1 at 60 Hz)is a mere -94.3 dBW, hum shouldcertainly be inaudible. Because mysetup in the lab is designed to avoidground loops, it made little differ-ence whether I made this measure-ment with the signal ground con-nected to the chassis or lifted from it.In normal use, you may well find theability to separate the signal andchassis grounds quite beneficial.
Figure 4 shows frequency responsewith 8 -ohm loads. In stereo mode, only thechannel 1 data is shown, since the resultsfor channel 2 were identical; channel bal-ance was as near perfect as it is possible todocument. It's clear that the Bryston 4B STis a wideband design: Its high -frequency -3dB points approach 200 kHz in stereo and130 kHz in bridged operation, where therolloffs of both channels combine. At thelow end, the -3 dB point is far below 10 Hz,
MEASURED DATA 111111111=Output Power at Clipping (1% THD at 1
kHz): Into 8 ohms, 300 watts (24.8dBW) per channel, both channels driv-en; into 4 ohms, 440 watts (26.4 dBW)per channel, one channel driven (seetext); bridged, into 8 ohms, 820 watts(29.1 dBW).
Dynamic Output Power, All ChannelsDriven: Into 8 ohms, 310 watts perchannel (24.9 dBW); into 4 ohms, 525watts per channel (27.2 dBW); into 2ohms, 710 watts per channel (28.0dBW); bridged, into 8 ohms, 1,000watts (30.0 dBW).
Frequency Response: Stereo, unbalancedinput, 20 Hz to 20 kHz, +0, -0.05 dB,with -3 dB points below 10 Hz and at195 kHz; stereo, balanced input, 20 Hzto 20 kHz, +0, -0.01 dB, with -3 dBpoints below 10 Hz and at 174 kHz;bridged, 20 Hz to 20 kHz, +0, -0.1 dB,with -3 dB points below 10 Hz and at129 kHz.
Dynamic Headroom: Stereo, 0.9 dB re 8 -ohm rated power and 1.2 dB re 4 -ohmrated power; bridged mode, 1.0 dB re8 -ohm rated power.
THD + N, 20 Hz to 20 kHz, at RatedOutput: Stereo, less than 0.0053% into8 ohms aid less than 0.0158% into 4ohms; bridged, into 8 ohms, less than0.130% al rated output (see ex° andless than C.0085% at 700 watts.
THD + N, 20 Hz to 20 kHz, at 10 WattsOut: Stereo, less than 0.0035% into 8ohms and less than 0.0063% into 4ohms; bridged, less than 0.0032% into8 ohms.
Sensitivity: Stereo, unbalanced input,96.6 mV far 0-dBW output ani 1.53 Vfor rated Dutput into 8 ohms; stereo,balanced input, 193.0 mV for 0-dBWoutput and 3.05 V for rated 8 -ohm out-put; bridled, unbalanced input, 97.0mV for 0-dBW output and 2.74 V forrated 8 -ohm output.
- 40
20
1 / 3-0c la. ftot r OOOOOO 1,1
EHANNEL 2
CHANNEL t
100 1k
FREQUENCY - H,
Fig. 3-Noise spectrum,worst case (stereo mode,balanced input(.
10k
Oro.. MIST - .eiteu.nr .11.10.00 et I Nal% - w Irop.mr, 04810
ri
g V-2
3
10
1004
I dill 111 II- - - STEREO. BALANCED N- STEREO. UNBALANCED IN- - BRIDGED, UNBALANCED IN
100
Fig. 4-Frequencyresponse.
IY 10k
FREQUENCY -Hz
100k 200k
the limit of the measurement; in the mostimportant range, 20 Hz to 20 kHz, responseis dead flat.
Channel separation was a perfectly ade-quate 70 dB, in both directions, from 20 Hzto 1 kHz; it was 65 dB or better at 4 kHz andbetter than 60 dB at 8 kHz. Input/outputphase error was less than 5° at 10 kHz andless than 10° at 20 kHz. Input impedancewas relatively high for a power amp, almost50 kilohms at the unbalanced input; thisshould present no problems for any pre -amp. Damping factor was a solid 600 at 50Hz, and output impedance remained rela-tively low across the frequency band (180milliohms at 20 kHz).
Use and Listening TestsWith only one 4B ST at my disposal, I
confined my auditioning to the stereomode, using the unbalanced inputs. Myprogram sources were a variety of CDs anda few DATs that I had recorded live. Againand again, I heard an effortless quality at alllistening levels and a clean, tight bass (espe-cially noticeable in piano recordings) cou-pled with a bright high end that had nary atrace of frizziness. This is definitely a gold-en -ear amplifier at a silver -ear price. It's so
solidly built, it carries a 20 -year warranty!It's technically impressive, sonically superb,and a top value. I find it easy to recommendthe Bryston 4B ST with enthusiasm andwould love to keep it hard at work in myreference system. Pair it with a BP 20 preamp,
and you'll have a system to drool over. A
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199649
EQUIPMENT PROFILED. B. KEELE, JR.
WILSON AUDIOWATT V/PUPPY VSPEAKER SYSTEM
0ne of the very few speaker systemswith an excellent reputation inboth high -end home audio andprofessional recording is this Wil-son Audio Specialties setup-which is actually two systems. The
two-way WATT (Wilson Audio Tiny Tot)was originally designed by David Wilson asa high -accuracy portable monitor for loca-tion recording; the Puppy woofer wasadded later, to extend the WATT's bass from55 Hz down to 28 Hz. The resultingWATT/Puppy combination, now up to Se-ries V, has been widely praised and is, ac-cording to Wilson Audio, used as a record-ing monitor at Chesky Records, HarmoniaMundi U.S.A., and Lucasfilm.
Until recently, the WATT/Puppy combi-nation was Wilson Audio's least expensivefull -range system-at about $15,000 perpair! However, the WITT (essentially an all -
in -one version of the WATT/Puppy) is now
available at $8,888 per pair. Wilson also of-
fers the X-1 Grand SLAMM at $67,500 perpair and the legendary WAMM (WilsonAudio Modular Monitor) system, at$147,000 per four -piece stereo setup.
What does the WATT V/Puppy V giveyou for $15,000? Lots. Besides the attentionWilson Audio haspaid to its perform-ance, the companyoverlooks no detail ofappearance or con-struction. And yourWilson Audio dealerwill personally set upeach of these systemsin your home.
The WATT V is a modest -sized two-way
speaker with a 7 -inch woofer and a 1 -inchdome tweeter. The surprise comes whenyou first try to pick it up: It's heavy! TheWATT's cabinet is a very massive pyramid,with a very inert feel-not your conven-tional vinyl -wrapped particleboard box. A
nice touch is the tubular alloy "handle bar,"running across the bottom rear of the sys-tem, to help you lift and carry the speaker.
The WATT's sloping front panel holdsthe drivers, which are attached with ma-chine screws. The front of the cabinet iscovered with quarter -inch foam, to mini-mize diffraction. Hook -and -loop fastenerstrips at the center and periphery of thefront panel hold the grille, an unframedpiece of low -density open -cell foam, also aquarter -inch thick.
The WATT's tweeter is a much -modifiedFocal driver with an inverted titaniumdome; the long -throw woofer is ascanspeak unit with a doped -pulp cone.Both drivers have very large and heavymagnets. The WATT's cabinet is made of amineral and ceramic -filled methacrylatepolymer, a very dense and rigid material.The cabinet is cross -braced and is dampedinternally with lead -alloy blocks; a bitumi-nous surface treatment is applied to strate-gic points inside the enclosure for furtherdamping. The cabinet's vent is 1 inch in di-ameter and 1.9 inches long, with a flaredmetal end. The cabinet is said to be alignedto a QB3 (quasi -Butterworth third -order)tuning.
The WATT's crossover is encapsulatedwithin an aluminum can, bolted to the bot-tom of the enclosure. (The bottom is at-tached to the cabinet with 16 socket -headmachine screws.) As I could not examinethe encapsulated crossover and Wilson pro-vided no circuit details for it (not even thecrossover frequency), I inferred its topologythrough measurements (not shown) thatrevealed second -order high- and low-pass
filters with a crossoverfrequency of about 2.5kHz. According to aWilson Audio bro-chure, "Minimum en-ergy storage behaviorin the crossover is
achieved by using onlythe finest audio -gradepolypropylene capaci-
tors, OFC [oxygen -free copper] air -core in-ductors, and time -coherent wire. All com-ponents are matched to less than 0.1%tolerance."
All connections to the WATT's crossover,drivers, and terminals are soldered and uselarge -diameter, audiophile -grade cable. The "cf-
NO OTHER SYSTEM
I'VE TESTED HAS HAD
SUCH INERT, UNMOVING
CABINET WALLS.
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199650
Rear view of the Watt V.Note the "handle bar."
gold-plated WBT terminals can handle barewires, large spade lugs, or even the shafts ofsingle banana plugs (the spacing is incom-patible with double -banana plugs). Thesingle pair of terminals cannot be bi-wired.
The Puppy V woofer consists of two 8 -inch, long -excursion Dynaudio drivers in avented box that was designed to act as astand for the WATT as well as providinglow -frequency extension for it. The enclo-sure is tuned with a foam -lined port tube,about 21/2 inches in diameter and 61/2 inches
long, on the rear panel. (An alternative,slightly longer, vent tube is supplied. It low-ers box resonance, which effectively in -
Rated Frequency Response: 28 Hz to21 kHz, +0, -3 dB.
Recommended Minimum AmplifierPower: 10 watts per channel.
Dimensions: Overall, 39 in. H x 111/2in. W x 161/2 in. D (96.5 cm x 29.2 cm
x 41.9 cm); WATT V, 14 in. H (35.6cm); Puppy V, 24 in. H (61 cm).
Weight: Overall, 162 lbs. (73.6 kg)each; WATT V, 70 lbs. (31.8 kg) each;
Puppy V, 92 lbs. (41.8 kg) each.
Price: $14,990 for four -piece system(WATT V, $8,200 per pair; Puppy V,$6,790 per pair) in high -gloss black;other gloss colors, no charge onWATT V and $1,112 per pair addi-tional on Puppy V; wood -veneer sidepanels, $500 per pair additional onWATT V and $1,600 per pair addi-tional on Puppy V.
Company Address: 2233 MountainVista Lane, Provo, Utah 84606;801/377-2233; E-mail, [email protected]
For literature, circle No. 92
creases damping by slightly reduc-ing bass level and extending low -frequency response.) An internalcrossover provides low-pass filtra-tion for the Puppy woofers and ahigh-pass for the WATT, crossingover with a broad overlap in the re-gion from about 125 to 250 Hz. Aconcealed channel runs upwardfrom the input -terminal cup onthe bottom rear of the Puppy'scabinet to accommodate the con-nection cable between the Puppyand the WATT. The Puppy's enclo-sure, made from MDF and ma-chined high -density phenolic, isheavily cross -braced. Very large,adjustable spikes are supplied.
The Puppy's drivers have highsensitivity and high power -han-dling capacity. Each has a rigid,polymer -based cone, a long -excur-
sion voice coil (2 inches in diame-ter and 1 inch long), and a verylarge magnet coupled to a die-castmagnesium basket. Terminals areprovided on the rear of the Puppyfor connection to the input cableand the WATT. Wilson Audio rec-ommends against bi-wiring or us-ing an electronic crossover andseparate amplifiers to drive theWATT/Puppy. Like the WATT, thePuppy has an encapsulated cross-over in a metal can, premium -grade cabling and soldered connec-tions, and a frameless foam grillewith hook -and -loop fasteners.
FREQUENCY - Hz
Fig. 1-On-axis frequencyresponses.
A
0
360
-54020 100
WAVEFORM TEFPHASE
PHASE
16
FREQUENCY - Hz
Fig. 2-On-axis phaseresponse, group delay,and waveform phase.
90
80
70
60
TEF
.1.0
-0.5106 206
5002 4 6 8 10
TIME - msec
Fig. 3-Energy/timeresponse
MeasurementsThe on -axis anechoic frequency response
of the WATT/Puppy, with the WATT's grille
on and off, is shown in Fig. I. Also shownare individual response curves of the WATTand Puppy driven directly. Measurementswere taken from the front of the speakers,on the tweeter's axis, and averaged with atenth -octave filter.
The WATT/Puppy's on -axis response isexceptionally flat and smooth and fits atight, 4 -dB, window (+1, -3 dB referencedto 1 kHz) from 50 Hz to 20 kHz. Referencedto 1 kHz, the response is 6 dB down at 45Hz and 10 dB down at 37 Hz, quite re-spectable low -frequency extension. There isa slight rise in bass response between
80 and 200 Hz and a high -frequency peakat 12.6 kHz followed by a dip at 15.5 kHz (areplacement tweeter I received later exhibit-ed even smoother high -frequency re-sponse). As can be seen in Fig. 1, theWATT's grille is quite transparent acousti-cally, causing essentially no change in theon -axis response.
The response of the Puppy alone has apeaked bandpass characteristic. Its maxi-mum output is at 90 Hz; the output falls at12 dB/octave in the lower frequencies and6 dB/octave at higher frequencies. Whenthe Puppy is used alone, its internal low-pass crossover filter is still operating, thus roll-
ing off its high -frequency response. Whenthe WATT is driven directly (not through
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199651
==
10dB
200 2k
FREQUENCY-Hz
Fig. 4-Horizontal off -axisfrequency responses.
10dB
2k
FREQUENCY- Hz
Fig. 5-Vertical off -axisfrequency responses.
100
0
5 10
6 01046
100
FREQUENCY -112
Fig. 6-Impedance.
Fig. 7-Compleximpedance.
90
80
co
70B.
60
so20
20k
-0 FRONT45 OFF
90 SIDE AXIS--135 DEGREES
180 REAR
-90 BELOW45
OFF0 FRONT zoas_
45 DEGREES
90 ABOVE20k
1k
3 6 9
RESISTANCE - OHMS
100 1k
FREQUENCY - Hz
Fig. 8-Three-meter roomresponse.
10k 20k
12
10k 20k
the Puppy's crossover), its responsefalls at about 1.5 dB/octave below800 Hz and at 12 dB/octave below80 Hz.
The WATT/Puppy's sensitivityaveraged 89.8 dB from 250 Hz to 4kHz. This is about 1 dB below Wil-son's 91 -dB published rating. Be-low 10 kHz, the right and left sys-tems matched within a close ±1 dB;above 10 kHz, they matched within±2 dB, with the maximum differ-ence occurring at 20 kHz.
Figure 2 shows the phase andgroup -delay responses of theWATT/Puppy, referenced to thetweeter's arrival time, as well as thewaveform phase (which indicateswhether waveshapes will be pre-served in specific frequencyranges). The phase curve is quitewell behaved and decreases only102° between 1 and 10 kHz. Whenaveraged over the range from 800Hz to 4 kHz, the group delay's off-set is only 0.09 millisecond, withthe WATT's woofer delayed slightly
behind its tweeter. The curve ofwaveform phase indicates thatmost waveshapes will not be pre-served, because the phase does notstay at or near 0° or 180° over anysignificant bandwidth. However,the waveform phase does not rotateas rapidly as it does on most othersystems. Between 800 Hz and 6.5kHz, the waveform phase does staywithin ±60° of 0°.
Figure 3 shows the WATT/Pup-py's energy/time response. The testparameters accentuate the system'sresponse from 1 to 10 kHz, whichincludes the upper crossover re-gion. The main arrival, at 3 msec, isextremely compact but is followedby several delayed responses, down23 dB or more. Generally, thiscurve indicates very good behavior.
Figure 4 shows the combo's hor-izontal off -axis responses. (Thebold curve at the rear of the graphis the on -axis response.) The excel-
lent curve -to -curve uniformitydemonstrates very even horizontalcoverage. Some narrowing is evi-dent above 10 kHz.
Figure 5 shows the vertical off -axis re-sponses of the WATT/Puppy. (The boldcurve in the middle of the graph is on thetweeter's axis.) Although the on -axis and±5° curves are quite uniform, at greater off -
axis angles the response is depressed be-tween 2 and 6 kHz. The response is fairlysymmetrical up and down, which indicatesthat the midrange and tweeter are roughlyin phase through the crossover region. Far-ther off axis, the polar response does exhib-it some asymmetry; fortunately, the re-sponse is significantly flatter above the axisthan below it.
The WATT/Puppy's impedance magni-tude is shown in Fig. 6. Because there aretwo speakers in this system, we see twopeaks and two dips instead of the two peaks
THE WATT/PUPPY
COMBINATION'SFREQUENCY RESPONSE
WAS EXCEPTIONALLY FLAT
AND SMOOTH.
and one dip that are typical of a vented box.The 2.7 -ohm dip at 28 Hz indicates the ap-proximate location of the Puppy's vented -box tuning frequency; the dip at 90 Hz(where the impedance falls to its minimum,2.3 ohms) is due to the crossover that linksthe Puppy with the WATT. Above 200 Hz,the impedance stays within a fairly narrow,4 -ohm, range between 5.5 ohms and thesystem's 9.6 -ohm maximum impedance,which occurs at 20 kHz. The WATT/Pup-py's overall impedance variation is a mod-erate 4.2 to 1 (9.6 divided by 2.3). Cable se-ries resistance should be limited to a lowmaximum of about 0.035 ohm, to keep ca-ble -drop effects from causing responsepeaks and dips that are greater than 0.1 dB.For a typical run of about 10 feet, I recom-mend that you use 12 -gauge (or larger),low -inductance cable.
The WATT/Puppy's complex impedance,over the frequency range from 5 Hz to 30kHz, is shown in Fig. 7. The two largestloops correspond to the two low -frequencypeaks of Fig. 6. A smaller loop correspondsto the slight impedance rise between 800Hz and 2 kHz of Fig. 6; a much smallerloop occurs in the vicinity of 435 Hz.
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199652
Above 8 kHz, the impedance continues torise and heads off toward the upper right ofthe graph. The somewhat unusual curve isdue to the WATT being driven in cascadewith the Puppy's high-pass section.
Effectively no side -wall resonances were
detectable when either the WATT or thePuppy was driven by a high-level sine -wave
sweep. The sides of both systems were es-sentially inert and unmoving. No otherspeaker I have tested has passed this test sowell. Both the WATT and the Puppy always
sounded quite clean and effortless in thesine -wave test. The woofers in both systems
overloaded quite gracefully and did notgenerate any harsh sounds.
The maximum excursion of the Puppywoofers was a fairly generous 0.5 inch, peakto peak, while the maximum excursion ofthe WATT woofer was a quite respectable0.35 inch or so, peak to peak. Based on myestimate of the frequency where each cone'sexcursion reached its minimum, the vent-ed -box resonance of the Puppy was about35 Hz and that of the WATT was about 50Hz. Closing the port showed that it reducedthe Puppy's cone motion at box resonanceby a significant 70%; the WATT's motionreduction was about 50%, which is still verygood. The WATT's port reduced cone mo-tion over a wide frequency range, about 27to 78 Hz. I noted some dynamic offset onthe Puppy woofers when levels exceed-ed 14 volts rms at certain frequencies.
MAXIMUM BASS OUTPUT
WAS IN THE TOP 20%
OF ALL SYSTEMS
I'VE TESTED.
The WATT/Puppy's 3 -meter room re-sponse is shown in Fig. 8, with both rawand sixth -octave -smoothed data. Thespeakers were in the right-hand stereo posi-tion and aimed laterally at the test micro-phone, which I placed at ear height (36inches), at the listener's position on thesofa. The system was driven with a sweptsine -wave signal of 2.83 volts rms (corre-sponding to 2 watts into the rated 4 -ohmimpedance). The direct sound and 13 msecof the room's reverberation are included.
Between 800 Hz and 16 kHz, thesmoothed curve is quite flat andfits within a tight, 5 -dB, window. If
you include all peaks and dips, itstill fits a respectable 10 -dB win-dow from 100 Hz to 20 kHz. Notethe depressed region between 300and 500 Hz and the peaks at 180and 710 Hz. High -frequency undu-
lations above 10 kHz mimic theanechoic axial response.
Figure 9 shows the E1 (41.2 -Hz)
bass harmonic distortion of theWATT/Puppy. I used higher ampli-fier power than usual because ofthe speakers' very clean and effort-less sound. At 200 watts, the second
harmonic reaches only 4.9%, whilethe third rises only to 8.3%. Higher
harmonics are at 2.3% or less. (Thepeaks at low power levels, in thefront of the graph, were caused byrandom acoustic background noisein my test setup.) At a 200 -watt in-put at 41.2 Hz, the system generat-ed a healthy 105 dB SPL at 1 meter.
The similarly low A2 (110 -Hz)bass harmonic distortion is shownin Fig. 10. At 200 watts, the second
harmonic reaches 6.1%, the thirdrises only to 1.6%, and higher har-monics are negligible. The higherproportion of second harmonic inthis test was due to moderate dy-namic offset of the Puppy'swoofers, which caused an outwarddisplacement of the cone and re-sultant asymmetrical rounding ofthe output waveshape. With a 200 -watt input at 110 Hz, the systemgenerated a very strong 114 dB SPLat 1 meter.
Figure 11 shows the IM versuspower, created by tones of 440 Hz(A4) and 41.2 Hz (E1) of equal lev-el. As in the previous two distortion
tests, the WATT/Puppy soundedquite clean. Even at 200 watts, itsIM rises only to 5.6%. The wideoverlap of the lower crossover wasone reason why the Wilson combinationhad somewhat higher distortion in this testthan other three-way speakers whosecrossover frequencies are below 400 Hz.This is because the overlap lets the WATT'swoofer undergo significant displacement at
100 -
20) -
20
POWER -WATTS
2nd. 49% 3rd, 8.3%
ti
a.:
MAXIMUM POWER 200 WATTS
4th, 2.3%5th. 6% 6th, 1.0/.
so 100 150
FREQUENCY- Hz
Fig. 9-Harmonic distortionfor E, (41.2 Hz)
, 2nd 6.1%cc0
200
20
POWER -WATTS 2
3rd, 1.6%
MAXIMUM POWER 200 WATTS
= _
4 t4
' ' ,7.ri
150 250 350 450 550
FREQUENCY -44z
Fig. 10-Harmonic distortionfor A2 ( 1 10 Hz).
E -
4
2
02
12 dB
-f-
280
12 dB
1
2 20
POWER - WATTS
Fig. 11-1M distortion forA4 (440 Hz) and E1(41.2 Hz).
140.
WITH130 ROON
GAIN
120
1'0
100
90
TEF
PEAK ACOUSTIC OUTPUT
PEAK INPUT POWER
WITHOUTROOMGAIN
8020 100 1k
FREQUENCY - Hz
Fig. 12-Maximumpea input power andsound output.
10k LE
1k 2
100a.
1010k 20k
200
high power levels from a signal as low as41 Hz.
Figure 12 shows the combination'sshort-term peak -power input and outputcapabilities. The peak input power was cal-culated by assuming that the measured
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199653
peak voltage was applied across the rated 4-
ohm impedance.The peak input powerstarts at a very strong 360 watts at 20 Hz,rises to 700 watts at 40 Hz, falls somewhat(to 450 watts at 80 Hz), and then risesrapidly into the region of 5 to 6 kilowattsabove 200 Hz. In the tweeter's range, above5 kHz, the power drops somewhat (to 2,500watts).
As you can see in Fig. 12, the maximumpeak SPL with room gain starts at an im-pressive 107 dB at 20 Hz, rises rapidly to aslight plateau of 120 dB at 65 Hz, and thencontinues to rise to about 125 dB or soabove 150 Hz. The system reaches 110 dBSPL at a low 30 Hz and then rises past 120dB at an impressively low 65 Hz. These SPLthresholds place the WATT/Puppy's maxi-mum bass output in the top 20% of allloudspeakers I have tested, including sever-al that are much larger.
Two mishaps occurred to the WATT dur-ing the peak -power tests. The wooferstopped operating when the 500 -Hz burstreached a power level of nearly 7,000 watts.A call to Wilson Audio's factory revealedthat a resistive protection device in thecrossover had engaged and shut off thewoofer; after the protector was replacedwith a new device, operation was normal.The second mishap was a buzz that devel-oped in a tweeter after it was tested. A retestat lower power was accomplished withoutfurther problems. A new tweeter broughtthe WATT back to factory specifications,and the right/left match was then evenslightly better than it had been when I orig-inally measured it.
Use and Listening TestsThe Wilson speakers arrived in four
heavy wooden crates, two housing theWATTs and two housing the Puppies. Ineeded help both in unpacking them and incarrying them. (Normally, the Wilson Au-dio dealer would take care of setup.) TheWATTs are very heavy for their size; it felt as
if they were weighted with lead inside. As Ilearned later, they really do contain leadblocks, not to add weight but to mass -loadthe cabinet walls to reduce vibration!
I was immediately impressed with boththe packaging and the appearance of thesespeakers. My review systems had an attrac-tive "platinum" glossy finish that lookedlike real metal. The fact that most of the fas-
teners were socket -head machine screwscontributed to this impression. All the cabi-nets had the look of very expensive pieces ofprecision equipment.
The WATTs are normally placed on topof the Puppies, which act as optimum -
height stands. Three small bituminousdamping pads are supplied; they go be-tween the WATT andPuppy to "decouplesubtle midrange inter-face resonances." Twohalf -inch spacers areprovided, which Wil-son Audio says enablesthe speakers' height tobe adjusted for finecontrol of upper -bassand lower -midrange reflections. A set offour Puppy Paw spikes (and a socketwrench) are provided for each Puppy. Thecompany suggests finding the optimum po-sition before the spikes are attached. I con-ducted my listening tests both with andwithout the spikes.
The WATT connects to the Puppythrough a heavy-duty spade -lugged cable(called a Puppy Tail). It passes through thechannel in the rear of the Puppy's cabinetto that speaker's high-pass output termi-nals. An arrow on the cable should point to-
ward the WATT, according to Wilson, to al-low a network in the cable to terminatehigh -frequency reflections. Signals fromyour amplifier are fed to both speakersthrough input terminals on the rear of thePuppy. I could make the terminals only fin-ger -tight because of their shape; even when
the terminals seemed tight, a gentle tugwould sometimes pull the spade loose.
Separate owner's manuals are suppliedfor the WATT and the Puppy. The WATT'smanual is 26 pages long, while the Puppymanual is seven pages. Among the topics inthe WATT's manual are selection of inter-changeable tuning ports (which I did notevaluate), room acoustics, mountingheight, room placement, adding a sub-
woofer (other than the Puppy), and themagnetic field around the WATT (accom-panied by a very useful chart of the fieldshape). Confusingly, some of the state-ments seemed applicable only to bygoneversions of the WATT. Much of the manualillustrated how frequency response, "reso-lution of low-level detail," and soundstag-ing vary with location and mountingheight; the graphs of frequency responsewere quite instructive.
Wilson suggests placing the WATT/Pup-pies at least 3 feet from the wall behindthem, at least 2 feet from the side walls, andtoed in so that a seated listener can barelysee the inner side panel of the WATTs. After
some experimenting,I wound up placingthese speakers closeto my usual locations;
the toe -in matchedthe recommendationfrom Wilson Audio.
I listened with gear
that included Onkyoand Rotel CD players
and Krell's KRC preamp and KSA250 poweramp, with B & W 801 Matrix Series 3 speak-
ers used for comparison. The TransparentAudio cables and interconnects were recom-mended by Wilson Audio.
On Maceo Parker's Life on Planet Groove(Verve 314 517197-2), the WATT/Puppiessounded very dynamic and open, withsmooth and well-balanced response cou-pled with excellent bass control and exten-sion. The crowd sounds at the start of trackI were reproduced with extreme realism;the drum solo from 6:42 to 7:24 on that
THE WATT/PUPPIES
SOUNDED VERY DYNAMIC
AND OPEN, WITH SMOOTH
AND WELL-BALANCED
RESPONSE.
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199654
track was extremely effective. The Wilsonspeakers delivered a rarely matched combi-nation of clean sound and high volume.Loud rock and jazz percussion were repro-duced particularly well.
On demanding female vocals, such as myfavorite Holly Cole track on Musical Truth
(Alert Music DPRO-240, a promo CDavailable from Energy Loudspeakers), theWATT/Puppies sounded very smooth andclean, emphasizing sibilants only a bit morethan the B & W 801s. And since the 801s'high frequencies are slightly depressed, theysounded slightly dull in comparison to theWATT/Puppies. On male voice, the WilsonAudio speakers also did very well, with notubbiness or other tonal aberrations.
The WATT/Puppies are quite sensitive; Ihad to reduce my amplifier's output by 5 or6 dB to match their sound level to the levelof the 801s during my comparisons. Onclean hard -rock music (there actually issuch a thing!), the WATT/Puppies couldplay significantly louder and cleaner thanthe 801s. However, this seems mainly due to
the Wilsons' higher sensitivity and the limi-tations of the 200 -watt amp I used. Al-though the Wilson speakers were clean atlevels where the B & Ws sounded harsh andcompressed, the 801s have reproducedthese levels cleanly with other amps.
On pink noise, the WATT/Puppiessounded somewhat smoother to me thanthe 801s when I was seated but noticeablyless smooth when I stood up, because ofupper -midrange roughness and tonality.Horizontal coverage was excellent. Onthird -octave band -limited pink noise, theWilsons had some usable output at 20 Hz,more usable output at 25 Hz, and lots ofclean output at all higher frequencies. At 32Hz and above, the WATT/Puppies delivered
more clean output than the B & Ws, whoseoutput capability has been exceeded by veryfew speakers I've tested. The only problem Ifound in the Wilsons was some outward dy-namic offset at 25, 80, and 100 Hz at veryhigh levels. Port noise was significantly low-er than that of the B & Ws when played atequal levels.
On large-scale cathedral pipe organ, as inJean Guillou's very demanding recording ofMussorgsky's "Pictures at an Exhibition"(Dorian DOR-90117), the WATT/Puppiesactually delivered more clean bass outputthan the 801s at all but the very lowest fre-
quencies. The Wilson combination couldhandle the full output of the Krell amplifierwithout any problems. Only rarely was theWATT/Puppy's limit reached, and eventhen its overload behavior was very good.
On more sedate classical music, such asTelemann for Trumpet by Stephen Burns(Dorian Discovery DIS-80132), theWATT/Puppies produced a full-bodied,neutral tonality with good depth andsoundstage. Trumpet peaks were repro-duced cleanly, with no roughness. On clas-sical guitar recordings, plucked string
sound was crisp and clear. On massed or-chestral music, the WATT/Puppy's outputwas always quite clean and allowed me todelineate individual instrument sections.
The WATT/Puppy combo performedsuperbly in most of my bench and listeningtests. Its level of performance surpassedthat of most of the other speakers I haveevaluated, making it a definite contenderfor-dare I say it?-best of breed. For thosewho can afford it, this system delivers asmuch performance and pride of ownershipas a Jaguar, or perhaps even a Ferrari. A
Better AUDIO for your VIDEO !
VA\iHRSTE-
Phase-correctman speaker
"Legendaryperformanceon .5oth filmsand music."
In its pursuit of per-fection, specialtyaudio has estab-lished high-fidelitystaldards Baket onlythe best sparscan reach.
Model 1Phase -correctmain speaker
"The standardfor affordablespeakers."
\ AJ91Model 2W
Three driver,300 watt amplifiedsubwoofer
O
IIILJIIII
1
VCC Phase -correctcetter speaker
"Rocks thefoundation."
"Uftimate realism."
Model 3r. Ultra high-
performancephase -correctmain speakerThe ulitimate emboeimentof the VANDERSTEPVboxless full -range nesign.
"Incomparable detainand resolution."
VSMPhase- :affectwall-nmuntloudspeaker
"The idealsurrounispeakeA"
NON your home the3ter system can meet these standards. A VANDERSTEENphase -correct home tteater system creates a coherent and expansive sound -fieldwith exceptional detail and superior dialog intelligibiliry. You wiLl hearwhy "boxless- is definitely better as the system's incredibl3 realism he.ghtensyour emotional involrem9nt in your films.
For almost 20 years, VANDERSTEEN AUDIO has built affordable loudspeakers trueto both science and nu.sic. If you are 'ooking for a system that convincinglyreproduces every nualce of a film as easily as it conveys the essence of music,we can direct you to }.our nearest carefully selected VANDERSTEEN dealer.
1-)I\ )1Er\ lql(Thr\ I,A! -117)1T
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199655
Please write or call for a aro,:hureana the name of your nee rest dealer
116 West Fourth St, Hanford, CA 93230(209: 582-0324
CIRCLE NO 30 ON READER SERVICE CARD
EQUIPMENT PROFILEBASCOM H. KING
DYNACO CDV-1CD PLAYER
Tubes are not often found in theanalog stages of D/A convertercircuits, though the DynacoCDV-1 is not the first CD playerto use them that way. The own-er's manual says the player's two
6DJ8 tubes help it deliver "rich,soft, warm harmonics with adeep and natural bass response"
and that music will sound appre-
ciably more pleasing on the CDV-1 than on
conventional, solid-state, CD players.
Because it has a volume control, theCDV-1 would be a logical candidate for aCD -only system when used with an appro-priate power amplifier. Aside from that vol-
ume control and the window throughwhich the tubes can be seen, the CDV-1's
front panel is fairly standard. Its round but-
tons are divided into two logical groups,one for the main transport functions and
the other for up/down search and such less
essential functions as programming. Sever-
al buttons have red indicator lights, ofwhich the ones for "Play," "Program," and
"Repeat" blink or glow, depending on theoperating mode. The power on/off indica-tor is green during initial standby and turnsred once the tubes are warmed up.
The transport mechanism is one ofPhilips's latest. It has a three -beam laserpickup and a straight -line -tracking sled for
the optics. The digital audio decoder anddigital filter is a Philips SAA7345GP chip,operating in its four-times-oversamplingmode. This is an infinite -impulse -response
(IIR) design rather than the more usual fi-nite -impulse -response (FIR) type. An IIRfilter needs fewer filter sections or filtercomputations than an FIR design to achieve
a given amount of out -of -band attenuation.
However, the phase response of IIR filters is
not as linear as that of FIR filters, so IIR fil-
ters have asymmetrical transient character-
istics. Also, when normally configured (asin the CDV-1), this chip set digitally attenu-
ates the signal to both the converter and the
digital output by 0.5 dB, which will preventproper operation of an external HDCD de-
coder. (The CDV- I does not itself provideHDCD decoding.)
The Dynaco's 1 -bit DAC is a PhilipsSAA7350GP. (This chip is also used in anumber of separate D/A converters.) Itsdifferential output is converted to a single -ended signal by a Burr -Brown OPA2604op -amp. Capacitors across the appropriate
resistors in this op -amp circuit, togetherwith a two -stage passive RC filter between
the output of the op -amp and the volumecontrol, form a low-pass filter whose cutoff
frequency is about 75 kHz. The player'stube output circuit, which uses one 6DJ8twin triode per channel, is implemented as
a common -cathode amplifier and is direct -
coupled to a cathode follower. The negative
feedback loop for this stage runs from the
output coupling capacitor back to the firststage's grid.
Measurements
With the volume control fully up and asignal at digital full scale (0 dBFS), theCDV-1's output measured 3.2 and 2.98volts, respectively, for the left and right line
outputs with instrument loading. Theheadphone output delivered 2.85 volts forthe left channel and 2.66 volts for the right.
Output resistance was about 252 ohms forthe line outputs and 100 ohms for the head-
phone outputs.
Frequency response 's plotted in Fig. 1for instrument loading. (With the IHF load,the high -frequency response was the same
but the level at 10 Hz was down about 0.5
dB more.) However, the CDV-l's high -fre-quency de -emphasis overcompensates, as
shown, for the pre -emphasis used on cer-
Dimensions: 22 in. W x 7 in. H x 16 in.D (55.9 cm x 17.8 cm x 40.6 cm).
eight: 19 lbs. (8.6 kg).
cc $699.
mpany Address: 125 Cabot Court,Hauppauge, N.Y. 11788; 516/434-1200.
For literature, circle No. 93
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199656
INK LABS -C11111114hr/ 1 LIVE.(dIr) FRIWItc)
t -LEFT---RIGHT WITHOUT DE -EMPHASIS
0 -- -.- -..... ...it.....". ....-- -.....--' \ \
WITH DE -EMPHASIS N\ \
5 10 100 lk 10k 20k
/
FREQUENCY - Hz
Fig. 1-Frequencyresponse.
IIIM IJISS - Cm/
0.4 0.8 1.2
TIME - MILLISECONDS
Fig. 2-Response to a1 -kHz square wave.
1101 INS MAIO .. FAEQIItz,
- LEFT- - RIGHT
of
+ 0.1 -
0.01
80 -kHz BANDWIDTH
J
16 2.0
22-,: BANDWIDTH
10 100 Ik
FREQUENCY -Hz
Fig. 3-THD + N vs.frequency.
1M3 11111.11C4b1 Ltuatdir,-60
Z -800F -
LEFT
RIGHT-100
-100 -80 -60 -40 -20RECORDED LEVEL-dBFS
Fig. 4-THD + N vs.level.
10k 20k
tain CDs; the unit's de -emphasiserror will slightly dull the highs if adisc recorded with pre -emphasis isplayed, but such CDs are rare. Al -kHz square wave (Fig. 2) indi-cates asymmetrical ringing, causedby the IIR filter's nonlinear phaseresponse. Playback polarity wasnot inverted.
Figure 3 shows total harmonicdistortion plus noise (THD + N)versus frequency, at 0 dBFS withthe CDV-1's volume control fullyclockwise. In the curves made withmy normal measurement band-width of 22 kHz, the rise in distor-tion at the higher frequencies isdue to intermodulation and otherartifacts rather than to harmonicsof the signal frequencies, althoughthis limited bandwidth makes thatpoint unclear. With the measurement bandwidth opened up to 80kHz, which lets in more out -of -band energy, you can see an evengreater increase in non -signal ener-gy as frequency increases. This ismore representative of the signalthis player would feed to your pre -amp and amp in actual use.
At the 0-dBFS signal level, dis-tortion below about 1 kHz is gen-erated in the CDV-1's tube outputsection, and it drops with decreas-ing signal amplitude. This can beseen in Fig. 4, THD + N versusrecorded level for a 1 -kHz signal
and a measurement bandwidth of400 Hz to 22 kHz. Distortionwould also be lower if the outputvoltage were decreased by turningthe volume control down insteadof by reducing signal amplitude.
The fade -to -noise test (notshown), a measure of linearity(and, hence, distortion), yieldedquite good results that were essen-tially identical for both channels.Deviation was about -1 dB at -90dBFS, crossed through 0 dB at -100dBFS, passed through +2 dB at-105 dBFS, and climbed to +5 dBat -115 dBFS.
Interchannel crosstalk rose atthe typical rate of 6 dB per octave.Crosstalk from the left to the right
channel was -56 dB at 1 kHz and -32 dB at16 kHz but was 20 dB better in the oppositedirection.
With the transport on pause or playing asilent track, output noise level of the twochannels averaged about -85.6 dB withwideband measurement. It was -87.6 dBover the band from 22 Hz to 22 kHz andwas -97 dB from 400 Hz to 22 kHz orA -weighted. Quantization noise was -89.2dB, and dynamic range came out to about97 dB.
Volume -control tracking between chan-nels was quite good down to about -15 dB.From that point on, though, the left chan-nel's attenuation increased faster than theright channel's, creating an imbalance ofabout 3 dB at -25 dB and 8 dB at -50 dB.
As I suspected, the digital output wouldnot piss an HDCI) signal on to an external
RESULTS OF
T-IE FADE -TO -NOISE TEST
WERE QUITE GOOD AND
ESSENTIALLY IDENTICAL
FOR BOTH CHANNELS.
D/A converter with HDCD decoding. Jitterin the digital output, measured with a Meit-ner LIM jitter detector in conjunction witha Crystal 8412 input receiver, was ratherhigh. I measured nearly 10 nanoseconds,peak to peak, of signal -correlated jittercomponents for a -90 dB, 1 -kHz signal.Fortunately, the amount of jitter getting tothe CDV- l's internal DAC is not this bad, asmost of the jitter at the digital output jack isdue to a poorly designed output -isolationtransformer.
Use and Listening TestsAs my comparison CD players, I used a
Counterpoint DA -11A CD transport to drivea Museatex Bidat or a Sonic Frontiers SFD-2 MU! D/A converter. Additionally, at vari-ous times a Genesis Digital Lens anti -jitterdevice was placed between the CD trans-port and the D/A converter. A Forssell tubeline driver was used with the Sonic Fron-tiers D/A converter; other sources wentthrough a Quicksilver Audio preamp. Pow-er amplifiers on hand for the review periodwere a Crown Macro Reference, a pair of
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199657
-1W I L MI I
het Us
EntertainYou!
Moe created and produced by Media Group Marketing. Inc (t)
Theater Specialists
When you're buying audio and video components.
it's important to understand that it's not enough to
buy a good TV and VCR. Components must also be
chosen for how they sound together. PARA is a
processional association of independent specialty
audioAndeo stores who are committed to the high-
est standards in retailing.
PARA stores will take the time to ask about
what you already own and suggest home
theater components that will integrate into
your current system.
PARA home entertainment professionals are
educated to explain the newest technologies in
clear, friendly language, helping you get the
best value for your money.
Let us help you choose the system that's lust
nght for you.
CALL 1-800 4-PARA 94 to find the PARA
dealer nearest you!
ProfessionalAudioVideoRetailersAssociation
Quicksilver M135 tube units, an Arnow(7B digital switching design, and a Hafler9505. I also used a Jolida SJ 302A tube inte-
grated amp. The loudspeakers were B & W801 Matrix Series 3s, augmented from 20 to50 Hz by a subwoofer in each channel.
I first listened with the Dynaco CDV-1feeding directly into the Jolida amplifier. Iset the CDV-1's volume control up fullyand used the volume control on the amp.The sound was pretty good overall, al-though I did notice some high -frequencyirritation on loud, complex passages. Basswas robust, full, and extended. I next pairedthe Dynaco player with the Hafler amp andused the volume control on the CDV-1.Again the sound was quite good, with excel-
lent bass. However, the sense of space anddimension, and the musical believability,were not as good as with my usual listeningsetup, and I was bothered by a touch ofhigh -frequency edginess heard on someCDs. Still, I was able to get into the musiceasily enough, which is the most importantthing.
THE DYNACO CDV- 1
PRODUCED BASS
THAT WAS ROBUST,
FULL, AND EXTENDED.
111
I have couple of nits to pick. The poorvolume -control tracking below about the 9o'clock knob position was a bit bother-some, causing me to sometimes turn up thevolume more than I would have liked to geta reasonable left/right balance. Anotherthing that I consider a definite flaw in myreview sample, and a potential flaw in thedesign, was a transient noise when startingor stopping a CD. At volume settings ofabout 9 to 10 o'clock, a definite pop couldbe heard and woofer displacement was evi-dent. With the volume turned up real high,starting, stopping, or pausing a CD pro-duced a substantial transient.
Does the CDV- I live up to its promises of
delivering the fabled attributes of tubesound? Regrettably, I feel it doesn't quite.Nevertheless, I think the Dynaco gave apretty good account of itself overall, espe-cially considering its modest price. A
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199658
PIONEER, continued from page 44Pop and New Age sounded "different"
but acceptable. Some of the discs I used-Madonna's True Blue (Sire 9 25442) and Ki-
taro's Silk Road (Gramavision R2 79409)-were originally recorded on analog tape,which might have made a difference.
I SEE NO POINT
IN DESIGNING A GOODD/A CONVERTER AND
THEN PURPOSELY
ADDING DISTORTION.
Legato Link reminds me of a moving -coil phono cartridge, many of which alsostrike me as being peaky in the treble andhaving considerable tracking distortion.Perhaps "MC sound" was what Pioneersought from Legato Link. Many audiophilesdo love that kind of sound, but I'm not oneof them. To my way of thinking, LegatoLink is the PDR-99's major weakness.
I see no point in designing an essentiallydistortion -free converter and then purpose-fully introducing artifacts (ringing onmidrange axis crossings and scads of odd -order distortion on treble signals) on theassumption that they were originally in themusic but removed by the bandwidth re-strictions of 44.1 -kHz sampling. Assumingthat harmonics were lost, there's no way toknow what they were. Each instrument hasits own overtone structure that makes itssound unique. There's no such thing as a"universal fix." (Nor is it clear that there'sreally anything that needs fixing: Evidenceof human perception of sound above CD'sstandard upper -frequency limit of 20 kHzis extremely scant.)
I have no problem with a manufacturermanipulating the signal if it believes theend product sounds better. Just allow me toturn the processing off if I disagree! Unfor-tunately, with the PDR-99, you can't. If youhave a good external D/A converter, you'rein luck. Run it from the PDR-99's digitaloutput, and you'll have a CD recording sys-tem you can be proud of. Or you mightconsider spending $50 less for the PDR-05,which differs only in having a shorter war-ranty, a less fancy finish, and (Pioneer tellsme) no Legato Link. A
KlipschLUCASFILM
--..:..Ktnufafturerso1 lilipseh Audio Entertainment. Min Thea Distributed Sound Systans
NO OTHER SPEAKER
SYSTEM DELIVERS
A MORE FORCEFUL
THX° EXPERIENCE.THX criteria are demanding. Exact specifications
for efficiency, distortion, power handling, dispersion
control and frequency response must be met for a
product to earn the THX logo.
Award winning Klipsch Horn Technology is based
on the principles of physics. So Klipsch THX speak-
ers are highly efficient, deliver broad dynamics with
low levels of distortion, offer controlled directivity
and have flat frequency response. It's the sametechnology found in our full line of audio and home
theater speaker systems. And it's the same tech-nology that's made Klipsch world famous for over
50 years!
The goal of a Home THX System is for the viewer
to experience a movie soundtrack that's exciting
enough for the most demanding director and sound
engineer. Klipsch THX will deliver outstandingaudio whether you're watching "The Empire Strikes
Back" or listening to your favorite CD.
Klipsch1HX is a registered trademark of Lucasfilm Ltd All rights reserved
W#1 Photo courtesy of Lucasfilm 1985
1-800-KLIPSCH
When you've got questions about Audio and Video,
see a specialist-., Is it possible to have excellent
home theater sound and musicalreproduction in one stereo
system?
Yes and No. Most surroundreceivers and pre -amps sacrificemusical information and nuance
wi:h inadequate processing circuits andpoor preamplifier sections. However,some companies have produced surroundsound pre -amplifiers with excellentmusical characteristics and surroundsound processing that derives it's ambientcues from the actual recorded material.Some speaker systems that are designedexpressly for movie soundtrackreproduction have limited verticaldispersion to facilitate greater intelligibility.High end music speakers not only limitsound stage "height", they also exhibitexcellent front to back depth and rhythmiccoherency. We believe that there areexcellent music loudspeakers that enhancethe sound of a home theater system. Inshort, carefully chosen components cancreate superlative sound for music andvideo.
-David ReidHigh Fidelity, Inc.
Austin, Texas
High Fidelity Inc.
"ly television recently got hit bylighting. How can I protect myequipment from power surgeslike that?
BLying an A/V system is nodifferent than making any othermajor purchase. You want to
protect your equipment because it is aninvestmervt. Electrical surges can destroythe electronics in your components in aninstant. The cumulative effect of small,practically undetectable surges that comein periodically through the external wiresand into your home can actually be moredamaging :0 your components than largerisolated surges called "electrical spikes"which are caused by lightning. This dispelsthe myth that you can unplug yourcomponer ts before a storm and keepthem safe, because damage occurs atrandom intervals. It is definitely worthwhile to irvest a little extra money insurge protecting products to insure thatyour equipment will be protected. Workwith your audio/video retailer to get theproducts r ecessary to protect yourcomponents from environmentaldisturbances.
-Norman RozakColumbia Audio/Video
Highland Park, Illinois
COLUMBIAAUDIO/VIDEO
Each month, Audio Magazine's newest feature "See a Specialist", will showcase some of the Finestaudio/video dealers from across the country. The dealers, chosen as a result of recommendations fromequipment manufacturers, Audio Magazine staff and industry organizations, will exemplify the bestaudio/video dealers from New York to California. The chosen dealers will offer solutions to problemsthat can best be handled by a specialty audio/video retailer.
If you would like to submit questions to dealers in your area please write to :
See a Specialist, c/o Audio Magazine, 1633 Broadway, NY, NY 10019
If I pLrchase a home theatersystem, will it sound as good inmy home as in your shcwroom?
We do two things to make thepurcha;e of a home theater systema rewarding and successful
experience. Fi-st, we presentdemonstration venues that recreate thecustomer's own living environment. We dothis from very basic surround systems allthe way to incredibly sophisticated THXhome theaters. Second, we deliver and setup the system so that the customer'sexperience at home is at least as good as inour showroon. We accomplish -..his bycarrying "cutting edge" home theaterproducts as well as training our salespeople in system integration. Beuig anindependent specialty dealer enables us toperform the magic that provides a uniqueexperience for our customer. Thisrelationship with our customer is thedriving force i i our business now and willbe the force teat drives our business intothe next century.
-Peter CosenzaHifi House
Broomall, Pennsylvania
4
Hifi HouseHOME THEATER CENTER
How can I connect my stereosystem to my computer?
To hook up your computer to thestereo ycu will need a pazchcordwhich has a stereo mini headphone
jack (3.5mm) on one end and a Fair ofRCA jacks on th2. other end. You shouldbe able to purchase these cords at anystereo store. The mini jack plugs into thesound card on the back of the computerand the RCA jac< plugs into to an unusedinput on your re:eiver or preamp. Nowyou will be able to enjoy thesuperior sound from your stereo systemwhile playing games and using multimediaCD-ROMs.
-Todd HolcombCyclone Sterec
Ames, Iowa
CYCLONESTEREO
Presented by AUDI()
AURICLEANTHONY H. CORDESMAN
EGGLESTONWORKSANDRA SPEAKER
A
t its best, the high end is glo-rious excess. At its worst, it is
pretentious and grandiose.Happily, the Andra loud-speaker, from a new compa-ny, EgglestonWorks, is far
more glorious than grandiose. Withthe Andra, EgglestonWorks haspushed efforts to eliminate cabinetcoloration to new heights but hasnot lost sight of the need for ad-vanced design technology in otherareas. The Andra offers excellent per-
formance in virtually every aspect,and its soundstaging is among thebest of any speaker available.
Like most assaults onthe state of the art, the An-dra is expensive; it sells for$12,960 a pair. One reasontor this lies in its construc-tion. For example, howmany speakers incorpo-rate large pieces of Italianblack granite to dampcabinet resonances? Andthe Andra's laminatedwalls consist of two panelsof 5/8 -inch medium -densi-
ty fiberboard. A final layerof outer lamination is bonded by aviscoelastic damping adhesive,which EgglestonWorks claims de-creases wall -transmitted vibrationsby a factor of 10. The cabinet wallsare a minimum of 11/4 inches thick,and in the upper section of the cabi-net, the laminate is sandwiched be-tween two pieces of granite to create
Company Address: 378 SouthMain St., Memphis, Tenn.38103; phone, 901/525-1100;fax, 901/525-1050; web site,
http://www.eggworks.00m/-eggworks
For literature, circle No. 95
walls that are 21/2 inches thick. Thecabinet uses dado and biscuit join-ery, and the internal braces are rarelymore than a fewinches apart.
The Andra hasa number of oth-er features to re-duce cabinet col-oration. A nylonpolyamide loose -bulk fiber, whichdoes not requiresupport and does not settle, is usedas damping material. Simply Physicsdecouplers act as feet. The Andra's
grilles are unusually transparent anddo little to color the sound, althoughI would recommend that you useonly the tweeter guards for seriouslistening.
The Andra is a very stylish speaker
that has the finish and look you ex-pect at its price level. The speaker isvery attractive and remarkably com-pact for its 210 -pound weight. The
Andra is only 371/2 inches high andjust 151/4 inches wide versus 181/4deep, which makes it appear much
smaller than itis. Its sculpturedlook should fitcomfortably intoa great manyliving rooms,without takingon the characterof a room -domi-nating icon.
The Andra's cabinet is designed tocreate resistance behind the driversthat's as close to that of a free -air
EGGLESTONWORKS
HAS PUSHED EFFORTS
TO ELIMINATE
CABINET COLORATION
TO NEW HEIGHTS.
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199662
Today's
Air Forceoffers you powerful
tools to shape your tomorrow.The Air Force offers technical training in more
than 250 job skills. Add hands-on experience
in one of our high-tech jobs - plus educational
opportunities - and, you'll have the powerful
tools you'll need in the 2Ist Century.
Ask an Air Force Recruiter for information or call:
1 -800 -423 -USAF.
AIM HIGH-A1R-.116--FORCE-T-
suspension as possible. This ensures thateach diaphragm has roughly the same pres-sure in back of it as it does it front.
The Andra's tweeter has a large, aperiod-ic rear damping chamber to imitate infi-nite -baffle loading, and its crossover-which uses MIT capacitors and Vishayresistors-is in its own chamber. Eggleston -Works says it chose Dynaudio's EsotarT330D tweeter on the basis of its exception-al neutrality and because it is manufacturedand tested with outstanding quality control.
The Andra's two Morel MW166 6 -inchpolypropylene, double -magnet mid -bassdrivers are in independently tuned trans-mission lines. The MW166 has a large voicecoil (3 inches in diameter) and an unusual-ly rigid structure. It also has a natural rolloffcharacteristic and can be run full -range.EgglestonWorks claims that the transmis-sion lines used to load the MW166s are thefirst to incorporate the design work by Lar-ry D. Sharp, enabling the use of shortertransmission lines than previously possible.
The bass drivers are two Dynaudio30W100 12 -inch woofers. These are loadedin a pressure -driven configuration of twoparallel chambers; the rear chamber is vent-ed. The 30W100 has a very large voice coil(4 inches in diameter), a mass of only 35.2grams, a large (28 -mm) cone excursion, anunusually supple suspension, and highstructural rigidity. The pressure -drivenloading is said to minimize back pressureon the front woofer while still allowing itto produce good "slam," good definition,and low bass extension in a relatively smallcabinet.
The Andra is easy on amplifiers andspeaker cables. It has a moderate rated sen-sitivity of 87 dB, but its nominal impedanceof 6.9 ohms makes it a good match with anytop-quality amplifier capable of more than100 watts per channel. I encountered nosignificant interaction problems in usingmy reference AudioQuest, Goertz, Discov-ery, and Wireworld speaker cables with arange of different power amps.
During the last few years, the best high -end dynamic speakers have advanced to thepoint where their apparent speed andtransparency are similar to those of electro-static speakers while providing superiorbass, dynamics, upper treble, and disper-sion. The Andra's sound has all of thesecharacteristics. Like most of today's best de-
signs, it is remarkably free of the minor re-sponse irregularities and crossover col-orations audiophiles had to put up witheven a few years ago. It has a seamless trans-
parency from the upper mid -bass to at leastthe limit of my hearing.
The Andra's most striking characteristicis its exceptionally wide soundstage. At themanufacturer's suggestion, I placed the An-dras about 50% farther apart than I wouldmost speakers, with a moderate toe -in to-ward the listening position. I expected thisplacement would be so wide that it wouldproduce a "hole in the middle" effect. In-stead, center fill, left -to -right imaging, andsoundstage definition were all excellent.The Andra's only limitation was a slightloss of depth, relative to the best competingspeakers, and a bit more vertical directivityin the treble than some line -source dipoles.
The Andras provided an exceptionallywide, stable listening area-nothing antiso-cial about the dispersion characteristics ofthis speaker. You do, however, need to payattention to side -wall reflections. Much ofthe advice given audiophiles about speakerplacement now emphasizes achieving flat
THE MOST STRIKING
ASPECT OF THE ANDRA
IS ITS EXCEPTIONALLY
WIDE SOUNDSTAGE.
bass response so much that it ignores therisk of smear from reflected treble andmidrange energy. A speaker with the excel-lent dispersion characteristics of the Andrashould not be placed too near the side wallssimply to get the widest soundstage. Glori-ous as excess may be, musically natural isstill better.
The Andra's treble was excellent. Only afew ribbon drivers give more apparent de-tail and life, and this speaker's timbre waswell chosen to provide lifelike musical ener-gy and information without excess treble.The Andra did not have a euphonic high -frequency rolloff or "forgiving" upper oc-taves, but it was in no way etched, overpre-cise, or analytic.
The midrange was very neutral andsmooth. I occasionally heard a slight
amount of excess upper -midrange energy,but this seemed to be as much a matter ofthe recording as the speaker. The Andra'supper midrange was very revealing, anddid not hear any characteristic coloration ofsoprano and tenor voices, violin, or pianoin this region.
The critical lower-midrange/upper-bassregion had excellent definition and timbre.The Andra provided exceptional naturalwarmth here, an area where many speakerserr on the side of either leanness or excess.The lower midrange also had outstandingtransparency coupled with very good low-level detail and resolution. Cellos soundedexceptionally natural, as did organ andpercussion.
The mid -bass was excellent and the lowbass very good. The Andra is capable of re-producing very deep bass, but an apparentrolloff in energy began at around 35 Hz; itcannot provide the power and "slam" of alarge separate subwoofer. I'd have liked justa bit more definition in the very low bass.
Overall transparency was very good overa wide range of levels. The Andra did an ex-ceptional job of revealing low-level detailand could handle anything but insane rock -concert levels. There was no change insound character from low- to high-level dy-namics, and I experienced no problems inletting classical music "rip." I could letWagner do his worst (best?) without push-ing the Andra's dynamic limits.
The Andra is an exceptional speaker andshould provide years of listening pleasure.New manufacturers often produce interest-ing loudspeakers, but ones that tend to em-phasize some aspects of sound quality overothers. They may have important innova-tions, but once the initial favorable reviewsare over, the product is often found to lackbalance and integration. I don't believe thiswill be true of the EgglestonWorks Andra, aspeaker that is anything but a "one -trickpony." EgglestonWorks may have put spe-cial emphasis on reducing cabinet col-oration, but it has also paid proper atten-tion to driver selection, driver loading,dispersion characteristics, amplifier load-ing, and every other important design para-meter. If you are looking for a reference -quality speaker that offers a superbsoundstage and an outstanding ability tofaithfully reproduce recordings, the Andramay be your speaker of choice. A
AUDIOFEBRUARY 199664
l'11LE illOntreisAUDIO wants you to be as informed as possible when you
make your next Audio/Home Theater purchase. The Reader Inquiry
Card (opposite) will allow you to receive free information on
participating advertisers' products. Manufacturer Reader Service
numbers can be found at the bottom of their advertisement and a
complete index of advertisers is located on pace 88 .
To help us continue providing :he information ycu need,
we encourage you to fill out and return the attacl-ed card.
AURICLEANTHONY H. CORDESMAN
ANC STROM 200A/V PREAMP
AND PROCESSOR
nnovation is the essence of thehigh end, but only a few prod-ucts break new ground in qualityand function. The Angstrom 200not only addresses both, but itdoes so in an area where innova-
tion is badly needed. In one way oranother, preamps and processorshave been the weak links in bringinghigh -end sound to A/V systems. TheAngstrom 200 is the first componentI have encountered that successfullycombines advanced digital signal
Company Address: do MikeMoffat Labs, 5273 CommerceAve., #1, Moorpark, Cal. 93021;805/523-7864.
For literature, circle No. 94
processing with all of the features ofa good A/V preamp. It not only hasinputs for a wide range of videoequipment butcan accommo-date game con-soles and othercomponentsthat have oftencaused hum orpops with otherA/V preamps.Its ergonomicsmake it remarkably easy to live with.Most important, Dolby Surroundsoundtracks and music recordingsseem far more lifelike on the Ang-strom than on any other surroundprocessor I have heard.
The Angstrom 200 costs $3,495, butit is a bargain by high -end stand-ards. You get six channels of digitalsignal processing, a full -featured A/V
preamp with all -digital implementa-tion of Dolby Pro Logic, plus matrixsurround. Besides its built-in Dolbydecoding, the Angstrom can be up-graded to include decoders for twoof the digital discrete six -channel("5.1 -channel") systems now com-ing on the market. A Dolby AC -3 de-
modulator and decoder will soon beavailable for under $1,500, and you'llbe able to add another such decodingsystem (DTS, for example), if oneshould become available. In fact, theAngstrom is designed so that all ofits digital processing is upgradable.This offers an unusual degree of pro-tection against the high cost of keep-ing up with rapid changes in audiotechnology.
The Angstrom 200 has a well-bal-anced mix of A/V and control fea-tures. It provides switching for sixaudio and audio/video sources, in-cluding three digital inputs (two op-tical and one coaxial). This makes iteasy to connect the unit into a com-plicated audio/video system.
You may miss the usual welter ofnumerous (and often useless) front -panel controls and a display filledwith indicators. On the other hand, Ifound the Angstrom's combinationof front -panel controls and on-screen features to be just right. Theonly choice I would question isputting the surround delay adjust-
ment on therear panel.While I agreethat it's nor-mally best toset this controlonce and forgetit, and thatfront -panelm isadj ust men t
is a constant risk, I'd still prefer easi-er access.
The rest of the Angstrom 200's er-gonomics are very good. An on-screen display makes setup easy, theowner's manual is relatively well
THE ANGSTROM 200
SUCCESSFULLY
INTEGRATES DSP
WITH ALL THE FEATURES
OF A GOOD A/V PREAMP.
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199666
1927: Moviegoers are mesmerizedby a new technology
Gaff?" Carl Laemmle. Jr., and Sid Grauman will the Fox Movie1one dev'ce. the firstf-cdritained system for recording synchronous movie soundtra6cs.
On:e again, or4K,IC writesa new scene in:c he. hometheater script v.iti o_r remTX -3V828 receiver. is gotall ie classc 01<v°I -al narks-iiscr_=1. an-plffiercesgn for ircreclble power.
scundfe lccircJits-pli.s tie latestsurround sound r n:va-ionsdeveloped ii cpn}in:ticnviti our global tectriology3ar ners Mctorpt. (-heTX-SV828 uses the ne.v24 3it DSP ificro-:cmputer),11M_ucasfilm aid Jib?. Tiiscream team cc ribinationTia<es the TX-SA,8213 today'spreeminent how thealer-ecaiver win the ri:st3d.anced TH), rrccessingani cinema aco.st csaccomplished :c iEle.
Then we thougit aboJttonorrow.
1996:Deja Vu
-4
44-49 nfl0t.)000IL III
ONKYO
So we designed ou r ewED -901 AC -3 Processor.When you add the ED -901
to the TX-SV828 (or aiycompatible comporent). ycucreate a home theater systemfiat simply has no qual interms of performance-notonly for today. but wel intotie future. In typical ONKYOfashion, we've even inprch.edon AC -3 by incorperatingLucasfilm Cinema RE-EQprocessing into the ED -901.The result is a tonal balancefor AC -3 movies tha: matchesthe standards Lucasf irn sets/Or its theaters. ackrowledgecas the world's finest acousticvenues for motion p cures.
All of which makes fr:t aviewing experience :hat's jestas mesmerizing today as itfirst was 69 years ag:
ONKYO t.SA Corporation ?.00 Williams Drive. Ramey. NJ 07446 201-825-7E-50E --n; it at [email protected] or via the Internet at www onkyo co jp/
THX k a registered trademark of LuN shim LidRC.; f 4 k 4'
written, and much of the hookup is intu-itively obvious. The key settings are shownby LEDs on the front panel, and the controlfeatures are relatively simple and hard tomisadjust. For once, setup procedures areclearly differentiated from ordinary opera-tion, which minimizes the chance of some-one in your family accidentally fouling upyour setup adjustments. The remote con-trol is also mercifully simple.
The rear -panel layout is well arranged,with connectors placed in a logical orderand spaced so you can easily use either bun -
died or separate audio and video cables. Iwould have liked a test signal for subwooferlevel, however. (The test signal for settingfront and surround levels has no bass, perDolby standards.) Using a subwoofer-levelsignal and a sound -level meter is much eas-ier than adjusting subwoofer level by ear,particularly if you're not very familiar withsetting up A/V systems.
The decoding modes include Dolby ProLogic, "Matrix," "Plus 1," and "Plus 2." Forthe moment, the last two duplicate the ProLogic and "matrix" modes but with full-
//...one of high end's most
accomplished companies."-lom Miiller, The Audio Adventure
VI/
;Faith to right: SCS2, CS1.5, CS3.6, CS5i, CS7, a52 2, C5
Priced from $1,350 to $12,300 per pair
World-wide critical acclaim for current THIEL models include: 8 CES® Design and Engineering Awards
5 Audio Video International "Product of the Year" Awards 2 Stereo Sound (Japan) "Component of the Year" Awards
Stereophile magazine's "Loudspeaker of 1993." Runner-up '92 & '94 Six models in Stereophile's "Recommended Components"
Call or write for our 32 -page full -line brochure,review reprints, and the name of your nearest 7HIEL dealer.
THIELUltimate Performance Loudspeakers
range surround signals (and, in "Plus 1,"enhanced steering). The real purpose ofthese settings is to leave a place for the dis-crete 5.1 -channel upgrades.
Central to the design is an astonishingamount of computing power. There are twoAnalog Devices ADSP-2115 main proces-sors, for a total of over 30 MIPS (million in-
structions per second) of capability-plus asocket for a third processor for future up-grades. This enables the Angstrom to usecomplex finite -impulse -response (FIR) fil-ters in decoding Dolby Pro Logic and ma-trix sound. Angstrom claims that FIR yieldsfar more linear phase characteristics thanthe much simpler infinite -impulse -re-sponse (IIR) filters used in other digitalDolby Surround decoders. The benefits aresaid to include better directionality andimaging, wider bandwidth and better up-per -octave information, and cleaner andmore natural musical harmonics.
THE ANGSTROM CAN BE
UPGRADED TO INCLUDE
TOMORROW'S DIGITAL
SURROUND SYSTEMS.
For better sound quality, the Angstrom'sthree digital inputs are not decoded to ana-log before processing, and its video signalsare very carefully isolated. The 200 uses sep-
arate power transformers for its video, digi-tal, and analog power supplies; shieldingimproves signal isolation. The active andpassive components are of excellent quality,and the unit is solidly built, with a 3/s -inchaluminum faceplate and a 16 -gauge steelchassis. It carries a 10 -year warranty, 93/4years longer than some video componentsand about 8 years longer than most audiocomponents.
The Angstrom's specifications includeaudio frequency response within ±0.1 dBfrom 20 Hz to 20 kHz, THD of less than0.02% over the same range, more than 55dB of separation between channels, andS/N greater than 95 dB. Delay time is vari-able from 15 to 30 msec, and the subwoofercrossover frequency is 80 Hz. The outputvoltage is a nominal 2 volts, and the outputimpedance is 100 ohms.
11-11EL 102t, Nandino Boulevard, Lexington, Kentucky, 40511 Telephone. W4,254-9427AUDIO/FEBRUARY 1996
68
Audio's primary concern is sound, notimages, but I should note two things aboutpicture quality via the Angstrom 200.First, it is one of the most neutral videoswitching devices I have encountered. Sec-ond, it does not have S -video connectors.Some video buffs use such connections foreverything in sight, but I have found themto be useful only with leads less than 6 feetlong and with Super -VHS tape machines
MULTICHANNEL MUSIC
TOOK ON NEW FOCUS
AND DEFINITION, WITHVERY CLEAN SURROUND.
and a few satellite systems. I'd suggest, too,that if you want to get the best pictureavailable, you should use the video switch-ing in your monitor in preference to thatin the Angstrom. If you connect the videooutput of your satellite terminal, laserdiscplayer, or S -VHS recorder directly to themonitor, it will make A/V switching a bitmore complicated, but it also will take a lotof circuitry and cabling out of the videopath.
I used the Angstrom 200 in four differentways: To play Dolby Surround soundtracks,to play music recorded with Dolby Sur-round encoding, to play stereo CDs andDAT cassettes, and to play stereo from suchanalog sources as an FM tuner and aturntable and phono preamp. The advan-tages of the Angstrom 200 were most strik-ing when I was listening to Dolby Surroundsoundtracks and music. The sound wasmuch closer to what I have heard from dis-crete multichannel digital and analog sys-tems than from any other Dolby Surroundprocessor. It was notably cleaner and less fa-tiguing, and there were fewer random sur-round -channel artifacts.
Virtually any A/V processor can be de-scribed as dramatic if the only sonic criteri-on is how loud you can make the special ef-fects or how far you can boost the bass. Theprocessing quality of an A/V decoder andpreamp also has little meaning if you areplaying one of the many Dolby Surroundmovies whose soundtracks appear to havebeen thrown together inexpertly or even
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199669
randomly. Fortunately, you can find moreand more great surround -encoded sound-tracks, and they deserve the best decodingpossible. The Angstrom provides this. It did
an exceptional job of reproducing the forestsounds in the quiet passages of the Last ofthe Mohicans, the "arrival" scenes in Termi-nator 2, the water and ambient sounds inthe director's cut of The Abyss, and thecomplex interplay of dialog, music, andsound effects in Queen Margot. It openedup the soundtracks of spectaculars (such asthe Star Trek, Indiana Jones, and Star Wars
series) by providing cleaner low-level detailand sweeter and more realistic reproduc-tion of the music. These improvementswere particularly striking when the 200 wasset in its "Plus 1" mode.
The only drawback I found in theAngstrom's ability to reproduce sound-tracks is that the 200 doesn't have equaliza-tion adjustments. There's no easy way toroll off the highs to compensate for sound-tracks that have excessive treble. There'salso no way to add the bass boost often ap-plied in movie theaters.
/ NTRODUCING
S-960
Stereo Power Amplifier60 Watts per ChonrelRetail $1599
LS -9000
Stereo Preamplifier
Retail $1399
fff 112111111111EMLS 9E0I
Integrated Amplif er
60 Watts per Cl-tinnelRetail $1999
THE WORLD'S MOST '&31W TJBE COMPONENTS... NOW, AT AN AFFORDABLE PRICE
_A_ 041-v-0 - N - )- V -hack in U. S.
Yakov Aroiov Audio Lab, Inc.
Tel 213.653.3045 Fax 213.937.690.5
CIRCLE NO 28 ON READER SEM.ICE CARD
The Angstrom 200's sound was very im-pressive with Dolby Surround CDs. Stillvery much a mixed blessing, many of theseCDs are intrinsically awful recordings thathave all the mindless surround abuses thatcharacterized most quadraphonic record-ings produced back in the '70s. Delos, how-ever, combines surround technology withtaste, and the Angstrom 200 reproducedthat company's surround recordings withmore natural musical detail and trans-parency than any other unit I have tried.The music took on a new focus and defini-
tion, and the surround effects were muchcleaner. (Try listening to Dennis Keene'sBeyond Chant, Delos DE 3165, and GerardSchwarz conducting Mendelssohn's Sym-phony No. 2, Delos DE 3112.)
The Angstrom did a very good job in re-producing stereo CDs and DATs. The 200 isnot a rival to the finest D/A converters, butit is very good indeed. It has a very smoothoverall timbre, with no eccentricities, and asmooth transition from the deep bass to thetop octaves. It is very detailed and transpar-ent and adds no touch of digital edge to the
C a nareir
y, otiu
Get a seatbelt before youadd a TV, a subwoofer anda center channel to yourhome -theater!
For your nearest PSB dealer callToll Free 1-800-263-4641.CIRCLE NO. 20 ON READER SERVICE CARD
1 eminor
Destinies were formed with thestrike of the bow. Joy or sorrowwere transmitted by the war drumor great music. Through the PSBStratus Series of loudspeakers,with full range capability andhrute dynamic power you will beable to relive the destiny of thosewho have chosen to speakthrmigh sound.Especial rough E minor.
PSB -A UNIQUE VOICEIN THE CROWD.
upper midrange or the treble. Its bass is ex-tended, powerful, and well defined. Thesoundstage has very good imaging and left -
to -right width. The Angstrom is a bit lack-ing in depth, but it is free of the digital glazethat is present in some D/A converters cost-ing nearly as much as this entire unit.
The Angstrom 200 is also not state of theart as an analog line -stage preamp. I heard aslight loss of detail, transparency, and musi-
cal life when I compared it to top-qualitystereo preamps. I would have liked a touchmore deep bass, a bit more soundstage detail
=N. -IJ
THIS IS THE FIRST
DIGITAL A/V PREAMP
TO GET HIGH -END SOUND
FROM SURROUND
MOVIES AND MUSIC.
and depth, and a bit more upper midrangetransparency. But, its sound quality never fellbelow very good. It did not harden pure ana-
log sound. Its shortcomings lie in what itsubtracts from the sound; it adds no irritat-ing colorations. Given the 200's mix of fea-tures, it is a very good preamp for the price.
The Angstrom 200 is scarcely the firstdigital A/V preamp, and many other unitsnow provide digital Dolby Pro Logic decod-ing. Yet it is the first one I have heard that is
fully successful in getting high -end soundfrom surround soundtracks and musicrecordings. In short, I believe that theAngstrom 200 is a best buy for anyone seri-ously interested in a high -end A/V sys-tem-especially for anyone who wants tocombine home theater with a music system.Although a number of rivals are scheduledto appear in months to come, the Angstromis real, not a promise, and its upgradabilitymeans it can continue to challenge the stateof the art. In my opinion, the 200 is a trulyoutstanding audio/video component. A
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199670
ORISINIRL MISS TER RECORDING
111.1 S. I 11° f,W.- The GAIN SystEm
a
Count6.1.ie7tul hi. or( Ite.tr3
ORISSA/RI AIRSTER RECORDING
NEW RELEASE UDCD 658
NATURE'SENCOREORIGINAL MIRSFER RECOR3ING
Cat Stevensr 11 R I 1
tfrmt f UDCD 3-661
ORIGINAL MASTER RE:OLROIFG
EASE UDCC 663
BETTER SOUNDING MUSIC UPGRADE TO ULTRADISCYour favorite artists sound surprisingly better on Ultradisc Why? 6eccuse Mobile Fidelity's mastering technology is o cutabove-and you can hear the difference. As the creators of the 24k gold audiophile CD, we have developed- ma or advances suchas The GAIN System , a proprietary mastering system that uses the highest grade of digital technology aicilable. Startingwith the original master tapes, we are abe to capture every last nuance o- the original recording.What does this mean? MAI hea-music like you've never heard it before!
Ultradisc IITM The Original 24K Gold Audiophile Compact Disc.To receive o cobr catalog or The GAIN System technical paper, call 800.423.5759.
LeyrE..rnuE ndel
souni labWU. de.
105 Mcrris Street Sebastopol, CA 95472WWW URL address: http://www.mofi.com/
n Canada call 800-267-1216
CIRCLE MO. 12 ON READER SE 'VICE CARD
AURICLEANTHONY H. CORDESMAN
PASS LABORATORIESALEPH 1
MONO AMP
reviewed the Aleph 0 mono am-plifier, Nelson Pass's first prod-uct since forming Pass Labora-tories, for the September 1994issue. Its sound showed whyPass is widely regarded as one of
the world's top designers of solid-state amps. The Aleph 0 demonstrat-ed that a single -ended Class -A tran-sistor design could have virtually allthe sonic merits of a top triode tube
Company Address: 21555 Lime-stone Way, Foresthill, Cal.95631; 916/367-3690.
For literature, circle No. 96
amp and have excel-lent bass and top -oc-
tave response. PassLaboratories has nowadded the Aleph 1
amp and a matchingAleph P preamp toits line. The Aleph 1
provides more thantwice the power ofthe Aleph 0 andincorporates otheradvances in soundquality.
The Aleph 1, a sin-gle -ended Class -Amono amplifier, sellsfor $6,000 each. Likethe Aleph 0, itsstyling is strictlyfunctional: a blackblock of machinedand anodized alu-minum, with onlybasic features-apower switch andLED, balanced andunbalanced inputs
(and a switch to choose betweenthem), and a set of binding -post out-put connectors. The Aleph 1, howev-er, is nearlytwice the size ofthe Aleph 0,
and its powertransformer ismuch larger.It weighs ap-proximately120 poundsand measures161/2 inches wide, 161/2 inches deep,
and 101/2 inches high.
The Aleph l's rated impedance is10 kilohms for the unbalanced input
and 22 kilohms for the balanced in-put; gain is specified as 26 and 20 dB,
respectively. Bandwidth extends to100 kHz (the -3 dB point). Total har-
monic distortion is rated at 1%, out-put noise at 30 nanowatts (500 mi-crovolts), and common -mode re-jection at 70 dB. The DC offset is nomore than 50 millivolts. The Aleph 1
is rated to deliver 150 watts into8 ohms, 300 watts into 4 ohms, or600 watts into 2 ohms. This kind ofpower allows the amp to deal withthe most demanding speaker loads.
Perhaps the only aspects of opera-tion you need pay attention to areheat and warm-up. The Aleph 1 idlesat 500 watts to ensure full Class -Aoperation with maximum head-room. As a result, its operating tem-perature is a comparatively high122° F, so this Pass Labs amplifier re-
quires good ventilation and cabinetclearance. And it takes at least anhour to warm up to its optimumoperating condition.
The Aleph 1 shares much of its de-sign philosophy with the Aleph 0.This includes an emphasis on sim-plicity and a minimum number ofcomponents to achieve the purestpossible signal path. The Aleph 1also retains the Aleph 0's Asymmet-ric Class -A topology, which uses asingle -ended circuit rather than thenormal push-pull arrangement. PassLabs says that this sharply reducescrossover distortion, low-level non -linearity, phase problems, and odd -order harmonics.
Another holdover from the Aleph0 is an element in the output stage to
avoid clippingat negative cur-rent levels thatare greater than
the bias point.According toPass Labs, theAleph 1 canhandle 50 am-peres on both
negative and positive peaks and canoperate into impedances of less thanI ohm at any phase of reactance.Its specified slew rate of about
SINGLE -ENDED
CLASS -A CIRCUITS
DO NOT HAVE TO BE
THE EXCLUSIVE PROPERTY
OF TRIODE DESIGNS.
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199672
ADVERTISMENF
We're Taking GAIN* To New Levelsand taking YOU with us!
Enter The Mobile Fidelity ibilt4b14.; S weepstaKes to win sortof the best music you'll ever hear!
Mobile Fidelity Sound Lab is offer ng this rare opportunity for you to win some of its most technological-ly advanced recordings. As the leader in creating the ripst sonically accurate audio software it theworld, Mobile Fidelity broke new bounds in sound tachnolzgy with the revolutionary GAIN Systemand pioneered the benefits of usi lc 24 -karat gold in the Ultradisc IITTM series. Mobile Fidelity's excksivetechnology atte'npts to bring to digital sound the warmth aid ambience of the live performance.
GRAND PRIZE50 -CD Package th
FIRST PRIZE?O -CD Package (Nit,
SECOND PRIZE
CAT STEVENS 3 -CD Box Set(a Mobile Fidelity exensive)
OFFICIAL SWEEPSTAKESNo purchase necessary. On an officia' entry form or E 3" by 5" piece ofpaper, print your name. address, zip code and daytime telephone number. Nomechanical reprocuction of official entry form will be accepted. Enter asoften as you wish, but nil each entry separately. To enter. mail your entry toMobile Fidelity Music Sweepstakes. 1633 Broadway..5rc Floor. Room 5132-B.New York, NY 10019. Enries must be received by April 15. 1996. All entriesbecome the property of -lachette Filipacchi Magazines. Inc.. which reservesthe right to reprint the name, address. and photo of tie vinne- for publicitypurposes. The winner w II be selected in a random crawitg to be held no laterthan April 30, 199E, from among all entries received and under the supervi-sion of Hachette Filipacchi Magazines, Inc., whose deciaon will be final. Theprizes are: Grand Prize, 3 50 -CD Package (MoFi selected. the estimated retailvalue is 51,500: First Prize. a 20 -CD Package (MoFi selected), :he estimatedretail value is 5600; Five -Second Prize Winners will receve a Cat Stevens3 -CD Box Set (a MoFi eiclusive). the estimated retail 'al Je is S74.95 each:and Ten -Third Prize Winners receive a Sound Check )is: with an estimatedvalue of S39.95 each. The winner will be notified by -rail and may be requiredto sign an affidavit of eligibility and release of liability. If under age 18, aparent or guardian must sign. Failure to return the at idevit within 10 days willresult in an alternate wir ner being selected. Odds of winning will depend onthe number of entries received. The prize is not transferable and there is nosubstitute for the orize. The contest is open to legal residents of the continen-tal United States and Canada, except the Province cf ()Lebec. Employees ofHachette Filipacchi Magazines, Inc.. Mobile Fidelity Sound Lab, their families.affiliates, or advertising and promotion agencies are not eligible. Void whereprohibited or restricted oy law. For the winners name. send a self-add-essedstamped envelope to: Mobile Fidelity Music Sweepstakes Winner. HachetteFilipacchi Magazines. Inc.. 45rd Floor 1633 Broadway. New York. NY 10019.
THIRD PRIZE
Sound Check Disc(The Professional Audio Test Dar)
'This revolutionary new System is continually improved to Atilize the latestn technocgical advancements. Tv king The GAIN System to increasingly)rogressn.s levels ensures that you, the listener, will get as close to audio)erfectios as r s technologically possible.
mototle [Went,
sound labUr SL K.
-W-T-11-
OFFICIALOFFICIAL ENTRY FORMPlease enter me in the
Mobile Fidelity Music SweepstakesMail to: Mobile Fidelity Sweepstakes
Hachette Filipacchi Magazines, Inc.45th Floor, Room 5132-B1633 BroadwayNew York, NY 10019
Name_AddressCity State Zip
Daytime Telephone )
MI entries must be received by April 15, 1996
60 volts/pec under load is some 10 timesfaster than the fastest signal likely to be en-countered and is 100 times faster than mostmusic signals.
Asymmetric Class -A circuits need cur-rent gain that increases smoothly, so theAleph l's gain stages use MOS-FETs (whosegain tends to increase with current) ratherthan bipolar devices (whose gain drops offat higher currents). The Aleph designs alsouse the wide bandwidth and capacitance ofthe MOS-FET to roll off the amp naturally,with a simple, single -pole characteristic.
The technology in the Aleph 1 does differfrom that of the Aleph 0 in a number of im-portant ways, however. It uses larger MOS-FETs in the front end than the Aleph 0 andbiases them higher. The Aleph O's 1 -watt
devices in the initial gain stage have beenreplaced with 20 -watt devices. The 20 -wattdevices in the Aleph 0's second gain stagehave become 150 -watt devices in the Aleph1. These higher capacity transistors permitincreased idle current and a further reduc-tion in feedback, making it possible for thedesigner to use simplified input circuitrywithout low-pass input filters. The only ca-
pacitor in the input circuit is a 10-pF com-pensation device in the feedback loop.
There are major changes in the Aleph l'soutput stage. The individual power transis-tors are twice as powerful as those in theAleph 0 and have an aggregate current -dis-sipation capacity of 800 amperes. There isno protective current -limiting circuitry,and the entire output stage consists entirelyof N -channel MOS-FETs, comprising abank of followers biased by a bank formingthe constant -current source. This circuit issaid to provide up to 150 watts of Class -Apower into 8 ohms, with 300 -watt peaks.
An advantage of the output circuit in theAleph 1 is that it makes full use of all theoutput devices to dissipate the enormouspower constantly running through the am-plifier. One-third of the output stage of theAleph 0 was used only when the output wasat high negative current; it did not conductat idle. In the Aleph 1, the output devicesshare equally in the idle dissipation. (PassLaboratories says this change in the outputstage has been so successful that it has beenincorporated into all Aleph Os producedsince December 1994.)
The changes in the Aleph 1 pay off soni-cally, both in sheer power and in nuance.Like the Aleph 0, the Aleph 1 shows thatClass -A single -ended circuits do not have to
be the province of triode tube amplifiers,which often are little more than midrangeamplifiers-amps that get much of theirsweetness and distinctive sound by limitingdynamic power and rolling off the bass andtreble.
The Aleph 1 can reproduce the subtlestlow-level soundstage detail and still kick assat rock listening levels. This amplifier did asuperb job of driving Apogee StudioGrand, B & W Matrix Series 3, and ThielCS7 loudspeakers to their limits, and it didso without any change in sound characterfrom the softest to the loudest passages ofeven the most demanding recordings. Thisamp also has the nuance and delicacy to getthe best out of small mini -monitors, ribbondrivers, and electrostatics. The Aleph l'ssound has the same superb openness, air,and transparency that I vividly rememberfrom the triode power amplifiers of yore. Itis quieter than any tube amplifier I haveheard to date, however. The music emerges
"IN ACCURACY. SMOOTHNESS AND STELLAR GOOD LOOKS.THE CROWN JOULES DON'T HAVE MUCH COMPETITION."
DON KEELL. AUDIO MADALINE
I COULDN'T BELIEVE MY EARS. I WAS EXPERIENCING ONE OF THOSE AUDIO MOMENTS THAT I WILLSOMEDAY TELL MY GRANDCHILDREN ABOUT. MY EARS COULD SEE THINGS NEVER BEFORE SEEN WITHA NATURAL PRECISION I WASN'T SURE REPRODUCED MUSIC WAS CAPABLE OF. WITH LIVE RECORDINGSTHE JOULES WENT FAR BEYOND THE USUAL CROWD NOISES AND TINKLING GLASSES IT WAS AS IFI COULD HEAR THE SMOKE IN THE ROOM AND THE HUMIDITY OUTSIDE. NOT MANY SPEAKERS CANDO THIS. IN THIS REGARD, THE PERFORMANCE OF THE CROWN JOULE IS AN ALMOST SINGULAREXPERIENCE.
UNDERSTAND THIS, THE CROWN JOULE IS A 2 -WAY OF THE HIGHEST RANK, A DESIGN DESERVING THEUTMOST RESPECT. LIKE ITS MAKER, THIS SPEAKER HAS CHARACTER COMBINED WITH THE ABILITY TOGET YOUR ATTENTION AND KEEP IT. FOR THE MONEY ITS FLAT OUT EXCEPTIONAL, IT IS ONE OF THEFINEST BOOKSHELF SPEAKERS MONEY CAN BUY MAYBE THE BESTIR. AND FOR THAT REASON THECROWN JOULE IS TRULY A COMPONENT OF EXCEPTIONAL MERIT. WHERE ELSE CAN ONE FIND A BIT OFAUDIO STATE -OF -ART FOR UNDER $2,000.00.
MARTIN DE WULF, BOUND FOR SOUND
MAGIC COMES IN ALL SHAPES AND SIZES. THE CROWN JOULE WITH SUBSTRATE IS A RELATIVELYINEXPENSIVE MAGIC CARPET THAT REALLY FLIES. IF YOU LOVE MUSIC, THESE SPEAKERS WILL GIVE YOUWHAT YOU PAY FOR, MUSIC. THE CROWN JOULES WITH SUBSTRATES REMINDED ME MOST OF MY OLDAVALON ASCENTS, AND WHEN YOU CONSIDER THAT THE AVALONS WERE OVER THREE TIMES THE PRICE,THAT'S SAYING SOMETHING INDEED. MOST NOTABLY THEY OFFER AN IMAGE DENSITY ANDPALPABILITY IN THE MIDRANGE WHILE PRESENTING A DEEP AND WALL TO WALL, WIDE SOUNDSTAGE. THISIMAGE DENSITY, THIS UNETCHED BUT DETAILED SOLIDITY, IS WHAT GIVES THE JOULES WITHSUBSTRATES THEIR ABILITY TO TAKE YOU FOR A WONDERFUL MUSICAL RIDE AT A REASONABLEPRICE. BUT THE JOULE ALONE, AT IT'S PRICE, MAY BE PEERLESS. HOW MUCH DO I LIKE THESESPEAKERS? I BOUGHT A PAIR.
MICHEAL GINDI
STUNNING, GORGEOUS AND SENSUAL LOOKING. THE CROWN JOULES REALLY DID SOUND LIKE MUCHLARGER SYSTEMS, WITH BIG SPEAKER EXTENDED BASS. AT MODERATE LEVELS, THE CROWN JOULESSOUNDED SURPRISINGLY SIMILAR TO THE I38W 801 MK.III, IN BOTH VOICING AND QUANTITY OF BASSAND IN BASS EXTENSION. IT WAS HARD TO TELL THEM APART. IN ACCURACY, SMOOTHNESS ANDSTELLAR GOOD LOOKS, THE CROWN JOULES DON'T HAVE MUCH COMPETITION. I GIVE THEM A HIGHRECOMMENDATION.
DON KEELE, AUDIO MAGAZINE
SCIENTIFIC FIDELITY
9344 GLENOAKS BLVD.. SUN VALLEY. CA 91352 TELEPHONE 18181 768-5123 FAX (818) 768-8013
CROWN JOULEW f SETTING
CROWN JOULEW / SUBSTRATE
TESLA 2
CIRCLE NO 22 ON READER SERVICE CARD
from Stygian silence rather than from aslight electronic haze.
I loved the Aleph l's reproduction ofchoral music and harpsichord. One of thekey tests of an amplifier's resolution is howmuch detail you can hear in complex choralpassages without artificial etching of any el-ement. The Aleph 1 did a terrific job of re-producing the voices and musical detail inhigh -quality recordings, such as the West-minster Choir's 0 Magnum Mysterium(Chesky CD 83), the SBHS (Santa BarbaraHigh School) Madrigals' recording of EarthChants (Sheffield 10049-2-F), and the Tur-tle Creek Chorale's Postcards (ReferenceRecordings RR-61CD).
The Aleph 1 also did an excellent job ofreproducing Pomp 6. Pipes, by the DallasWind Symphony under Frederick Fennell(Reference Recordings RR-58CD). Com-pared to the Aleph 0, it had notably betterdynamics and very deep bass, as well asmore power. I had thought the Aleph 0 wasgood, but the Aleph 1 has notably superiorbass definition, "slam," and extension. Itdoesn't have the slight warmth in the deepbass that characterized the Aleph 0 but re-
tains the Aleph 0's exceptionally realistictransitions from the bass to the lower mid-range and its ability to reproduce accuratelysuch instruments as bass guitar, grand pi-ano, and cello.
The Aleph l's midrange combines sweet-ness with detail and life. Again, these are
THE CHANGES IN
THE ALEPH 1'S CIRCUITRY
PAY OFF SONICALLY,
BOTH IN SHEER POWER
AND IN NUANCE.
sound characteristics I associate with thebest triode tube amps, although there aredifferences. The Aleph 1 has slightly lesstransient and dynamic energy than mosttriode tube amps, but it is slightly cleaner inreproducing low-level midrange detail.
The upper midrange and treble of theAleph 1 also are improved. They retain theAleph 0's freedom from hardness or edgebut add a bit of energy and dynamic life. As
a result, the Aleph 1 can do an excellent jobof reproducing the top octaves of the violinand the complex "shimmer" of the cymbal.It does a superb job of revealing the differ-ent levels of upper -octave detail in record-ings, phono cartridges, and D/A converterswithout coloring them or favoring one kindof sound over another.
As you might suspect from the precedingdescription, the Aleph 1 has excellent over-all transparency and dynamics. Its resolvingpower also gives it outstanding imaging andsoundstage depth and width. This is an am-plifier that does not impose its character onthe soundstage but preserves all of the in-formation in the recording and inducesyour speakers to do their best.The Aleph 1is one of the most musically convincingamplifiers around (particularly, I feel com-pelled to add, when partnered by the AlephP preamp). With really good recordings, itsperformance is exceptionally lifelike, andno aspect of musical ambience and pres-ence is emphasized over another. Its mix ofsonic virtues comes as close to combiningthe best of both tubes and transistors as anyamplifier I have yet heard. A
\ 6 VISTA DRIVE, P.O. BOX 987, OLDIN CANADA: 221 LABROSSE AVE, POINTE-CL
CIRC
the ultimatesurround sound
Life is stressful. You cou d spend a few
thousand dollars rushing to z_ weekend getaway
at a rejuvenating retreat. You could mortgage
your home for one of those "quiet as a
recording studio" motor cars you've seen on
television Or you can keep the family fortune
and relac in the sanctity of your own home
with a pair of Seniheiser headphones.
Discover the ultimate in sarround sound...
at budget you can Easily afford.
SENINHEISERYME, PQ H9NO 22 ON REAM I
0 FAX: ZIK.34.1759013 FAX: ! 14.426.2979
ORPHEUS
HD 55HD 35
HD 44o IIHD 435
HD 340HD 320
HD 250 IIHD 25 SP
HD szo IIHD 540 IIHD 56o II
HD 58o
HE 6oHEV 20
atiscamm.:s:--;s1
CLASSICALR E CO R
Haydn: Symphony No. 12,No. 44, and No. 64
Apollo Ensemble, John HsuDORIAN DOR-90226, CD; DDD; 63:34
Sound: A, Performance: A
Haydn: Symphony No. 26,No. 30, and No. 31
Chamber Orchestra of Lausanne,Jesus Lopez-Corbos
DENON CO -78967, C:1); DDD; 53:04
Sound: A, Performance: A+
he Denon recording is part of an on-going series of early Haydn sym-phonies; the Dorian is the second inwhat I hope will be a competing se-ries. Both are utterly wonderful-but utterly different.
Denon's issue suggests modernforces scaled down to the needs ofthe music but still surrounded byplenty of air in a fine, modern con-cert hall. In keeping with the music,vibrato was minimized in the stringplaying, but the fair-sized chamberorchestra appears to be playingmodern instruments. The Lausannemusicians observe the niceties of"authentic style" without making afetish of it. The delight they seem to
D I N G
take precludes the kind of preoccu-pation with mere technique andscholarship that infests so many per-formances of this music.
The Apollo Ensemble plays periodinstruments ( John Hsu, its founder,also is known as a period -instrument
cellist) and is carefully scaled to theforces known to have been available
to Haydn when these symphonieswere first performed. On sonic evi-dence alone, I'd guess the ensembleto he no more than two-thirds thesize of the Lausanne orchestra andpossibly a good deal smaller thanthat. Despite the emphasis on schol-arship, the Apollo Ensemble does notoverlook Haydn's Dionysian side butdoes keep it in its place. Vibrato isabsent (rather than minimized), andthough the recording was made in afairly large, modern hall (Dorian'sgem in Troy, N.Y.), the pickup ismuch more intimate than Denon's.The hall's sonic bloom is there, butit's discreetly in the background.
Beyond that, the approaches actu-ally are quite similar: loving andzestful, with superb ensemble workand none of the cavalry -chargeprestos or lugubrious largos that of-ten disfigure virtuoso symphonicconcert performances. Because ofthe relatively querulous tone of vi-bratoless violins, some listeners willfavor the somewhat flashier, richerDenon sound; purists will certainlyprefer the Dorian. I must admit thatI give the edge to the Denon (al-though I was less impressed with an-other disc I sampled from Denon'sseries). Yet both approaches arevalid, and each makes a special kindof sense. I wouldn't be without a sam-pling, at least, of both. Robert Long
NI it i; : .k N 1 )
Ten pianists; Wendy Mae Chambersand Artur Geisel, conductors
NEWPORT CLASSIC NPD 85553CD ; DDD; 51:39
Sound: A, Performance: A-
Composer Wendy Mae Chambersis fascinated with sound produced bylarge numbers of the same instru-ment. She has created works for 30harps, 77 trombones, and 100 tim-pani, but her first effort in this genrewas for 10 grand pianos: "TenGrand." It grew out of her interest increating a big sound, especially withpercussion instruments, and she re-membered that the piano actually is apercussion instrument.
The suite of 22 short secticns hassimilarities to Mussorgsky's "Pictures
at an Exhibition" (which has beenrecorded in a 45 -piano version, bythe way!). Instead of paintings, thelistener visits different countries-China, Russia, Japan-and observes
descriptive subjectssuch as "PrimordialBirds," "Gamelan,"and "Chords." All 10instruments do notalways play simulta-neously, and in "Spa-
tial" they gleefully bounce a musicalfigure around the soundstage.
Chambers attracted the participa-tion of a distinguished collection ofpianists, including new -music key-board notable Ursula Oppens. Ten
Grand is a keyboard blockbuster andgreat new musical fun! John Sunier
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199676
KS/EQUALIZERS/HEADPHONES AMPLIFIERS/COMPACT DISC PLAYERS/TUNERS/RATEMS/BLANK AUDIO TAPES/AUDIO ACCESSORIES/VIDEO RECORDERS/COLOR TEL
/MONITORS/COMPUTE RS/CAR STEREOS/RAD
CD PlayersThchnic. s
Technics SL -P0450Remote CD Player
WASH 1 -bit DA converter *Edit guide Weaklevel search Random play 8 auto cue20 -track programmir T,., Fn dr Heaclohone tack
514995RCA CD -1051Mcompaci-size .
Teac CD -P26916 -bit ft sTechnics SL-PG350
Luxman D-322
Luxman D-375Superb sound from Sion
'89'59995
512996
'299"'699"
satOFF DENON
Denon DRA-835RHigh Power Stereo Receiver
nil Hroh curer
)ntroi,VireleSS re- Mb Stitt ReLL 1 5800 00
$49995Technics SA-GX190
hannel.aou
JVC RX-317tin
Teac AG-SV7150
Technics SA-GX790
Kenwood KRV-8070
'159"'174"'259"537 995
549995
41,0
Luxman M-375Power Amplifier
150 watts per crt *Hu. current design.nstanding headroom (300 watts per ci.YL A/B speaker selector Input,mtrols Mfr. Sug. Retail $999.9.5
$79995AudioSource AMP ONE '269"
$79995
'229"S79995
AudioSource TNR One
-'uwer Amp Al
Luxman A-384
AudioSource PRE ONE
Luxman C-383
Audiophile CD Player Super Special
DENON
50% OFFMfr. Sug. Befall
Denon DCD-3000 Compact Disc Player. : : : : it super lir ear
converter ,-5x ovurs3mpling Optical & coaxial output 20 -trackprogramming oRemote control
$699" tIDNIN DCD30001
Mfr. Sug. Retail $1400
PHILIPS '600 OFF&tr. Sue. Retail
Philips DCC900Digital Compact Cassette
TEAC V-375
Aiwa AD -F450
Aiwa AD -S950
Fostex XR7
TEAC V-8030
c 5799 95
$"'1V17995
'289"'529"'7999'
Aiwa LCX-70MMini Audio System
:Isc CD ptrayer with 30 -tract, programming-,-reverse cassette *25 warts per channe
AM'FM tuner with 32 presets *Super,...rrss remote
32995rAIW LCX70Mt
Sharp CDC -444M. 3 -disc CO dual cassette. If
JVC MXC33Jai A/R casse
JVC MXC55essette
Denon D-500
Denon D-700niuner
. tismn
$179"'349"S39995
$49995
'699"
Double Cassette DocksTEAC
TEAC W-5 15RDual Cassette DeckWith Auto Reverse
,Diby B Normal 8 high -weed climb,.pntinuous playback
$8995Aiwa AD-WX727
to -rev play. Dolby B. C. HX-Pn S149"JVC TOW -309
Dolby B C HX-Pm Dirt si a9"JVC TOW -709
..tikR ' Si 1995Technics RS-TR575Hl-pro*229"
.41 auto -re: rt
TEAC W -6000R
Mfr. Laf Price 5.79.00TEA keiS t51,
*429"
A
pfilokr'olllElhiliLr..J
AudioSource EGI TwelveGraphic Equalizer/Spectrum Analyzer
- J-uanos per chant 1.2aB ptdsyninusnk noise generator 8. catbrated rric for
..clse room adjustments *LED meters
519995 (ASO E012)
Target BT1Wall Speaker Br $29"Sennhelser HD414 Classic50th Ann
Terk AMFM0
Sennheiser H0580Audiophile Headphones 10. ..
Niles SVL-6Spn,H' SelEtor/Volume Controller
S7995
'279"'299"
CD Chan ers
Technics SL-PD7875 -Disc CD Changer
*Change any 4 discs while a 5th plays .1random play .32 -track programnRepeat capable for single track or wdisc *MASH 1 -bit D/A converter
$15995 t1Et
TEAC PD -D90032 track prO.,
Magnavox CDC- 745 1 7
JVC XL -F215
Technics SL-PD987Jntro
Kenwood DPR- 50 7 0Play -4 onanot-
'129'''149"519995
'199"'219"
Loudspeakers
JBL60% OFFM/r. Sug. Metal
JBL LX5003 -Way Speakers
.8' woofer Titaniurn dome tweeter Lstyled black cabinet with beveled ei,Rated power: 10-150 watts 8.mpedance Mfr. List Price $638 00
$2499$(Past)Pinnacle PN5+/Oak $99"cs
Technics SB-LX70-BK '1499'Technics SB-LX90-BK 619995Acoustic Research 570 $229"JBL 4312BK $499"
rrn m ,, rrri
ICA 68378
Evgeny Kissin
Legendary 1984 Moscow Concert
$1 4 99 $799I CD CASSETTE
Einhorn: Voices of Light, Anonymous 5SON 62006 co $11.99
Tchaikovsky: Violin CTO, Vengerov, AbbadoTLD 90881 Co $11.99
CALL TO ORDER MUSICREVIEWED IN THIS ISSUE
CALL US TOLL FREE FOR ITEMS NOT LISTED IN THIS AD SE HULA ESPANOL
SEND MONEY ORDER.CERTIFIED OR CASHIER'S CHECK. MASTERCARD. VISA. AMERICAN EXPRESS or DISCOVER CARDQnclude Interbank No. expiration date and signature) To: J8R Music World. Dept AU0296. 59-50 Queens Midtown Expwy. Maspeth,ueens. NY 11378. Personal and business checks must clear our Authorization Center before processing. Shipping, handling and
Insurance Charge (Continental US) is 5% of the total order with a $4.95 minimum for orders up to $500: 4% for orders over $500to $1000: and 3% for orders over $1000. For heavyweight/over-sized items. shipment by air, or to Canada. Hawaii. Alaska, VirginIslands 8 Puerto Rico please call for information. DO NOT SEND CASH. Sorry. no C.O.D's. NY residents please add sales tax.ORDERS SUBJECT TO VERIFICATION 8 ACCEPTANCE. NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR TYPOGRAPHICAL OR PICTORIAL ERRORS.ALL MERCHANDISE SHIPPED BRAND NEW. FACTORY FRESH AND 100% GUARANTEED. Some quantities may be limited.Copyright 1996 J8R Music World. City of NYDept. of Consumer Affairs License Numbers 0900310/0900615/0900676/0900617 NiS
visit, :' o_E&I at 23 Park Row, NY, NY'V Shop By Phone orto order a FREE CATOLOGUE24 Hours A Day, 7 Days A Week
1 -800-221-8180
Cantatas (Works of Bellinati,Madureira, Rougier, Bartok, Brouwer,
D'Angelo, Agobert, and Azuma)Cristina AZI1111(1, guitar
GSP RECORDINGS GSP 1009CD, CD; 55:42Sound: A, Performance: A
This is a singular and exquisite classical gui-tar recital, built around the performer'sawareness of rhythmic and modal similaritiesbetween music from northeastern Brazil andEurope. (The European portion of this musi-cal jaunt is primarily to eastern Europe, but italso covers Spain andItaly.) Thierry Rougier's"Three Byzantines" en-compass Bulgaria, Ru-mania, and Greece, andother works quote or areinspired by Falla andSatie. The Bela Bartok tracks are two tran-scriptions from his "Mikrokosmos." The CD'stitle is Portuguese for "contact" and suggestsexchange and reciprocity. Such elements dooccur throughout this fascinating program, asdoes Cristina Azuma's felicitous connectionwith the attentive listener. John Sunier
44,
Korngold: Violin Concerto; SinfoniettaLinke-Amnia lathe, t tolni;
Dallas Symphony, Andrew LittonDORIAN DOR-90216, CD; DDD; 70:06
Sound: A, Performance: A
As far as the concerto goes, this recordinghas formidable competition from theDeutsche Grammophon issue (DG 439 886)with Gil Shaham and the London SymphonyOrchestra under Andre Previn. And since theconcerto is the centerpiece of both discs, I fear
the DG, which went onsale earlier, will obscurethe worth of the Dorian.
Both reflect theircompanies' respectivecutting -edge technolo-gies: The DG is a 4D
recording, the Dorian a 20 -bit recording madewith fiber-optic links. There the similaritiesend. The DG reminds me of NormaDesmond's line in Sunset Boulevard: "I stillam big; it's the movies that got small." The av-erage level is perhaps 10 dB higher than that ofthe Dorian, and Shaham is presented as Su-perViolin-much larger than life. The level isachieved at the expense of dynamic range, andthe lush self-confidence of the performance isachieved at the expense of the more vulnera-ble detail that comes through touchingly inDorian's far more natural and human -scaledrecording.
To some extent, DG's movie -music ap-proach is appropriate to the concerto-whichwas written after Erich Wolfgang Korngold
HILD S REAWorks of Koppel, Holmboe, Kulesha,
Christiansen, and ArnoldMichala Petri, recorder;
English Chamber Orchestra, Okko KamuRCA VICTOR RED SEAL 09026-62543
CD; DDD; 77:49Sound: A, Performance: A+
All five recorder concertos here areworld -premiere recordings, and all are theresult of the efforts by Michala Petri, a Dan-ish recorder virtuoso. She adapts her an-cient instrument to contemporary musicrather than limiting it to adaptations ofmusic written for other instruments or onlyto early music for recorder.
While each concerto has its own style, allshare an upbeat and magical feeling, as sug-gested by the album title. Among the high-
lights is Malcolm Arnold's Concerto forRecorder and Orchestra, in which high spir-its characterize both the music and Petri's
stunning playing. Anotherstandout, Gary Kulesha'sConcerto for Recorder andSmall Orchestra, shows theinfluence of the Japaneseshakuhachi and requiresthe additional task of sing-
ing through the recorder while maintainingtuneful accessibility.
With the world's current leading per-former on the instrument, you can relax,certain that there will be no excruciating"clams." And few concert -goers ever hearsuch a perfect balance of recorder to orches-tra, made possible by the modern studiorecording session. John Sunier
had achieved star status for his film scores. Ituses material from some of them, but it was anovert and at times diffident attempt to rekin-dle the "pure music" of his youth in Vienna.Dorian's orchestral textures remind you thatMozart was among his models there, as well asMahler and Richard Strauss.
The Sinfonietta dates from the Vienna peri-od and is a very nice piece indeed. All of Korn -gold's music seems ultraconservative for a boybrought up in the Vienna of Berg and Webern,but it is beautifully made. It was precisely be-cause his music was so well made that he washailed as a prodigy from the beginning.
The Dallas sound is rather anonymous, butit does leave more air around the orchestrathan DG afforded its forces. The admittedlyslicker, more maxed-out DG obviously willappeal to some tastes, but I suspect Korngoldwould have preferred Dorian's more musi-cianly approach. Robert Long
Einhorn: Voices of LightAnonymous 4 and other soloists;
Netherlands Radio Choir and NetherlandsRadio Philharmonic, Steven Mercurio
SONY CLASSICAL SK 62006, CD; DDD; 70:40
Sound: A, Performance: A+
American composer Richard Einhorn wasinspired by Carl Dreyer's 1928 silent film clas-
sic The Passion of Joan ofArc, but Voices of Lightstands without visualimages. This oratorio is acelebration of Joan ofArc, using a mosaic ofancient sources, Joan's
own letters dictated to a scribe, and the writ-ings of such medieval female mystics as Hilde-gard von Bingen.
Musically, the oratorio has surpassinglylovely sections of ecstatic melodic invention.Philip Glass -type progressions are occasional-ly heard. Even without the libretto, the workcan be experienced as a dramatic melding ofmedieval and contemporary music. Intelligi-bility of the soloists and the chorus is excellenton this recording, probably aided by the spa-cious, though not cavernous, acoustic ambi-ence (the session took place in a studio ratherthan a cathedral). John Sunier
Rachmaninoff: Complete Songs, Vol. 1Kalevi 011i, baritone; Ulrich Koneffke, piano
FINLANDIA 4509-98615, two CDs;DDD; 1:34:04
Sound: C, Performance: A-
This set is more remarkable than my ratingsimply. Kalevi 011i appears to have an extreme-ly powerful voice (I would call him a bass -baritone rather than a baritone), and he singsthese often marvelousand seldom performedsongs in a style that isfar more operatic thanliederesque. Doubtlesswith that in mind, Fin-landia (a Finnish labelof Time Warner) abandoned the fairly inti-mate acoustics usually mandated for songrecitals in favor of a cavernous sound that Ifind distinctly off-putting, though you maynot agree. Admittedly, a conventional sonicperspective would have been disastrous: 011i'sbig voice and even bigger passion would haveseemed overbearing at the climaxes instead ofgalvanizing, as they are here. Surely a satisfy-ing middle ground could have been found.
011i manages the quieter, more lyrical songswith considerable aplomb, at times displaying
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199678
an unusual mastery of head tone. Not everydetail is perfectly managed or every song per-fectly suited to the singer, but it is a very im-pressive performance, minor flaws and all.And pianist Ulrich Koneffke matches 011ipoint for point; occasionally, however, theirloudest sounds become muddy.
For casual listening, an hour and a half of asingle singer and composer can be tiresome,but this is intended instead as a library collec-tion. I can imagine more refined readings ofsome of the quieter songs, but I know of nosinger who could bring more power to thedramatic ones and few who could projecttheir profoundly Russian character so vividly.On balance, 011i is an excellent proponent.(Full transliterated Russian texts and Englishtranslations are provided.) Robert Long
Janacek: Sinfonietta, Op. 60;Lachlan Dances; Tams Bulba
Czech State Philharmonic, Jose SerebrierREFERENCE RECORDINGS
RR-65CD, CD; 65:08Sound: A+, Performance: A
Fame came slowly to the genius LeosJanacek in his homeland, Morovia. This waspartly because of hisheterodox insoucianceabout such institutionsas marriage. But famecame to him even moreslowly abroad, as only inthe fairly recent pasthave the world's opera houses awakened tothe unique riches of his Jenufa and his otherpassionate masterpieces.
Fans of top-quality audio will revel in theextravagant brass section required by the Sin-fonietta-four horns, 14 trumpets in threekeys and ranges, four trombones, two tenortubas, and a bass tuba-all gloriously provid-ed here by a splendid brass section andrecorded with this small but trailblazing firm'sHDCD technique. Paul Moor
Swedish Orchestral Favourites (Worksof Soderman, Stenhammar, Larsson,Peterson -Berger, Alfven, and Wiren)
Helsingborg Symphony Orchestra, Okko KamuNAXOS 8.553115, CD; DDD; 68:28
Sound: A+, Performance: A+
While Hugo Alfven's familiar "Vigil" andthe single track from Dag Wiren's bouncy Ser-enade caught my eye, the rest of the sparkling
program joined thesetwo as personal favoritesafter just one listening.Never mind its cultural,historical, and biograph-ical significance; this al-bum is sure to captivate
SAW. nommus 11011.0111.
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199679
because of its plain and infectious music,loads of marvelous melody, and life -affirmingmoods. You'll want to shout "Skoal," and yourpocketbook will also be pleased with this re-lease from budget -label Naxos. John Sunier
Borodin: Prince IgorSoloists; Kirov Opera Chorus and Orchestra,
Valery Gergiev
PHILIPS 442 537, three CDs; DDD; 3:28:15Sound: B+, Performance: A
This is as close to a definitive Prince Igor asit gets: an excellent edition, admirably docu-
mented, in a typically committed, idiomatic,rich, colorful, dramatically convincing, and al-
together beautifulperformance by theKirov forces recordedin St. Petersburg'sMariinsky Theater.Philips has preservedall of the Kirov's dy-
namics, from floated off-stage pianissimo tothunderous. The thunder may get slightlycongested, and the sense of stage placementand movement might be clearer, but it's an
Robert Longadmirable job.
SONS
z
O
zrz.
ce,0.
ce
U
.7r1
O
O
c,_cc
ce
z
FO.
z NAKAMIC III Plo
PANASONIC MITSUBISHI TOSHIBA YAMAHA DENON
I
NEW YORK ;S` ORIGINAL EL TTRON CS DISCOUNTER
Phone: 1-800-978-6253 Fax: 1-212-721-7587SPEAKERS
NHT 2.5 3 -Way Tower CALL!CAMBER LS7 Bookshelf . . $449/prCELESTION FULL LINE IN STOCK CALL!BIC-VENTURI Realta 3 -Way Tower . CALL!KEF ALL MODELS CALL FOR BEST PRICE!JBL L7 lr Tower CALL!VELODYNE F1200R Powe-ed Sub $789PINNACLE AC650 Bookshelf . . BEST BUY!ADVENT CALL FOR BEST PRICESATLANTIC TECHNOLOGY ALL MODELS!
RECEIVERSYAMAHA RXV2090 AC3 CALL!YAMAHA RXV890 100Wx3 25Wx2 $726JVC RX817VTN 105Wx3 + 25Wx2 . CALL!SONY STRGX900ES 100Wx.7 + 30Wx2 . CALL!DEMON AVR1200 Best Bo/ CALL!DEMON AVR2500 80Wx3 - 25Wx2 $689ONKYO TXSV-919 THX CALL!TECHNICS CALL FOR BEST PRICE!NAD FULL LINE IN STOCK BEST PRICE!CARVER FULL LINE IN STOCK CALL!NAKAMICHI FULL LINE 811 STOCK CALL!KENWOOD FULL LINE IN STOCK CALL!
DAT DECKSJVC XPD1 PRO Portable CALL!SONY DTC790 Home DAT $659SONY DTC6OES Home DAT CALL!PANASONIC FULL LINE IN STOCK!TASCAM ALL MODELS CALL BEST PRICE!SONY MDS302 Mini Disc Recorder . CALL!
CONSUMER TAPESTDK D60 Audio CassetteMAXELL UR90 Audio Cassette . .
TDK SA60 Audio Cassette . .
SONY HF120 Audio Cassette . . .
MAX ELL XLI190 Audio Cassette . .
MAX ELL XLIISBO Audio Cassette .
TDK SAX90 Audio Cassette .
TDK T120 VHS Cassette . .
TDK T120E HG VHS Casse.teSCOTCH L750 BetaMAXELL T120HF VHS Cassette .
JVC ST120 VHS Cassette
EV Pr (hitt tz
$0.65$0.75$1.29$1.35$1.39$1.69$1.1:19$1.95$2.29$2.99$3.49$5.99
CASSETTE DECKSSONY TCWA9ES Dual Record $649YAMAHA KXW382 Dual Auto Reverse $249YAMAHA KXW952 Best Dual Deal( $599NA <AMICHI DR1 3 Head CALL!AIWA ADS -950 3 Head, Dolby "S" . . $339DEVON DRM740 3 Head $339SONY TCDD8 NEW Portable DAT CALL!WPM FULL LINE IN STOCK CALL!JVC TDW717 Dual Dec* Pitch Control . . . . CALL!
CD PLAYERSTECHNICS SLPD1010 Best Buy . . CALL!DEMON CDM560 5 Disc Carousel . . . CALL!NAD 514 . Mash 1 Bit CALL!NAKAMICHI CALL FOR FULL LINE!ONKYO DXC320 6 Disc Carousel . . . . CALL!YA NAHA CDC655 5 Disc Changer . $249SONY CDPCA9ES 5 Disc Carousel . . CALL!SONY CDPC545 5 Disc Carousel . . BEST $$$YAMAHA CDC555 5 Disc Chan,:, $199
MINI SYSTEMSSONY MHC405 100W x 2, 5 CD Changer . . $419JVC MXC550 40W, Dual Cassette, 7 CD CALL!SONY MHC-605 100W x 2, 5 CD's, 4 Spkrs. . $489DEVON D -CI Micro Syst.. 6 CD's . . $399DEMON D700 48W Dual Cassette, 3 CD . . CALL!AIWA NSX-V150 NEW, 50W 50CD . . CALL!AIWA NSX-V70 100W Dual Cassette, 3 CD . $419AIWA NSX-V90 Doulby Pro Logic 5 Spkr Syst . $519
PROFESSIONAL TAPESAMPEX 489DM126 ADAT. . $9.753M R60 DAT $4.99DIC H030 DAT $3.993M R46 DAT $4.49DIC H0120 DAT $5.49SONY DT120 DAT $7.75DIC 4-2.0GB 3 Hour $6.99AMPEX DDS490 3 Hour $10.99FUJI BCT3OM Betacam SP 521.503M BC60ML Betacam SP $28.50AMPEX 499 2" Reel $129.00MAXELL UD3590 $7.49SONY KCS3OBRS 3/4" $9.95SONY KSP60 3,4' SP $15.99
iromit 1 ...
t 72 St., New York, NY 10023Telephone: 212.721.7500
Fax: 212-721.7587Mon S.,1 1,1 3, 7 J9 Sun 11 1,
Not ream M..
ernational &Canadian Orders
Welcome!New York's LargestBlank Tape Dept.!
SCOTCH BROIHER 11 \R t \\ h \RDON
Your Heart's in Good HandsAl Green
MCA MCAD-11350,46:13Sound: A+, Performance: A
t's been more than 20 yearssince Al Green sent shivers upmy back. Of course, I still getgoose bumps every time I hear"Let's Stay Together" or "I'mStill in Love with You," his soul-
ful R&B crossover hits from1972 on the Memphis -based Hi
Records label. In subsequentyears, Green lost his hit -making
magic touch but found religion.Through the mid -'80s, Reverend Al
turned out pretty mediocre albums,some of which leaned heavily ondrum machines and cheesy arrange-
ments. But in spite of the inferiorproduction work, the voice was al-ways golden.
For Your Heart's in Good Hands,his first secular album in 18 years,Green put himself in the good hands
of producers Narada MichaelWalden, Arthur Baker, Jodeci'sDeVante, and the tag team of David
Steele and Andy Cox (both of Fine
Young Cannibals). The result is anuplifting, gospel -drenched gem thatis dripping with passion and irre-sistible grooves. Needless to say, I'm
shivering with delight.
Love is the theme of this come-back offering from the righteous rev-
erend of soul. The upbeat "OneLove," the smoldering R&B ballad"Could This Be the Love," the galva-
nizing title track, and the '70s -flavored "Keep on Pushing Love" (a
kind of '90s sequel to "Let's Stay To-
gether") address matters of the heart
while recalling the infectious grooves
of Green's glory days with Memphis
producer Willie Mitchell. The leg-endary Memphis Horns, AndrewLove and Wayne Jackson (whoplayed on Green's string of hits forHi Records), add their signaturepunch to "One Love" and "BestLove," while former Living Colourbassist Doug Wimbush groovesmightily on the anthemic "Love Is aBeautiful Thing."
Arthur Baker's remake of Smokey
Robinson's 1965 hit written for TheTemptations, "Don't Look Back,"rocks with an uncharacteristic edgefor fans of vintage Al Green. But the
reverend seems right at home withthe romantic ballad "Your Love (IsMore Than I Ever Hoped For)," abrilliant showcase for his passionate
abandon and spine -chilling falsetto.
Two pieces arranged and produced
by Steele and Cox, "What Does ItTake" and "People in the World(Keep on Loving You)," wrapGreen's sensuous singing voice in amore contemporary setting, blend-ing today's hip -hop beats with a clas-
sic '70s feel.
Regardless of the setting, it's themagic of Al Green's voice that cutsthrough on this triumphant come-back. This is pop music of the high-est order, healing music in a realsense. Bill Makowski
RoachfordEPIC EK 67343,51:07
Sound: A-, Performance: A-
Mhe British have always excelled=at taking American R&B music,putting their own spin on it, and sell-ing it back to the colonies.Although most British ex-ports of late have been de-void of soul, Roachford,along with Seal and TerenceTrent D'Arby (born inAmerica but considered aBritish artist), are U.K. soul exportswho have absorbed American R&Band made it their own. On his thirdalbum, Permanent Shade of Blue,
Roachford finally has a band worthyof his songwriting. And he comes upwith a musical approach that-though heavily influenced by Prince,Jimi Hendrix, Sly, et al.-is his own.
The Prince references are some-times too strong; "Cry for Me" and
"Lay Your Love on Me" couldpass for outtakes from the"Little Red Corvette"/"Rasp-berry Beret" periods. YetRoachford presents a widevariety of music and sings hisbutt off. "Emergency," with
its Kool and The Gang groove, seems
a natural for radio. And if there is alonging for mid -'80s funk, Roachfordis right on time. Jon er Sally Tiven
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199680
61
a
113C11. 1111111111111111
DIRECTIS BEST(
11CUT OUT THE MIDDLEMAN AND BUY DIRECT) -11-
AMAZINGLY LOW PRICESFREE 5 -YEAR WARRANTY
FREE ELECTRONICS NEWSLETTERSPf- PV"LEfFLEE p1/40° volt
ES 84 ECISCPO' cOSS IVA/4101 SVS ses
cvLD
11-C4,111
I
You won't find a better source for home electronics than USA DIRECT.._all the quality items you want, all the leading brands you want- from A to Z!
(800)959-4434JUST A SAMPLE OF THE t
RETAIL SALEAR 303A ... $1300.. S 888ADCOM... GCD 700... $ 750.. S 549BOSTON .VRS Surrounds . $ 400.. S 288CARVER ... CT281., . . . .51000.. S 759CELESTION SL6Si.. . . $1000. S 549HARMON KARDON. AVR10...$ 419.. S 275HITACHI. .VTUX605A ...$ 550.. $ 395INFINITY ...Composition System .. In StockJBL J620M $ 350 . S 159JVC 35" TV's .......From $1299KEF REFERENCE SERIES ...On SaleMARANTZ... CD17 $1200 . .5 898All Our Sale Prices Include 5 Year
Warranty & FREE Shipping
SONY. TOSHIBA YAMAHA ADVF`:1'A.)(AR's F.R harman Iardon
II I IX. oracle° polk ADCOM c Et.EsTion
lel It!
USA DIRECT
FREEMONTHLYEWSLETTER
New product reviews Inside industry news
Direct international prices Exciting special offers
Tips on getting the mostfrom your equipment
The latest, hottest newtechnology products
arran anclror by comp
'-'"vS IN THIS MO,'"-- = NEWSLETTER0 RETAIL SALE
MITSUBISHI .31" COLOR T.V. $1000 . .5 888NAD . .-New" 512 CD CALL....NAKAMIC4I DR2 750 . .5 539ONKYO . . . Receivers From S 219PANAMAK .MAX 1000+ $ 400 ..S 219PIONEER ... VSXD3S . $2000 . .$1199PIONEER H.,TECLDSS LASERS 900 ..5 625PSB ALPHA S 200..5 159SONY Mini Disc; Dat . . On SaleSONY ES. STRGX700 ES. .5 550 ..$ 419VELODYNE .VA810X $ 629..$ 419YAMAHA ...CDC 755.. $ 400..$ 289
Sale Prices Include 5 YearWarranty & FREE Shipping
J.MITSUBISHI earw.300 GO.VIDE
'NC mum mani=333
Ll
535 Midland Ave.,Garfield, NJ 07026Tel (800) 959-HIFIFax (800.411-HIFI
NAD uBL 14 psbSPEAKERS
WE OFFER MORE!FFEE 5 YR. COMBINED FACTORY
WARRANTEE & SERVICE CONTRACT
FREE Shipping & Insurance FREE Scheduled Maintenance FREE Price Protection FREE Performance Guarantee FREE Cables & Interconnects Next Day Delivery Available. And Of Course. Amazirgly
Low Prices
MasterCard, Visa. American Express. :', ,-.i,ei & .1(79 Card
am
or
CIRCLE NO. 27 ON READER SERVICE CAA
A Testimonial Dinner:A Tribute to XTC
Various ArtistsTHIRSTY EAR THI 57019-2, 48:52
Sound: B+, Performance: B+
The tribute album trend is pretty tired, butthis homage to XTC stands out as one of thegenre's better efforts. XTC inspires no smallamount of devotion from its fans, partly be-cause it hasn't toured for about 15 years, butmostly for the nonpareil songwriting of AndyPartridge and Colin Moulding.
Most of A Testimonial Dinner's interpreta-tions hew pretty close to the original, with the
notable exception ofRuben Blades' searingLatin take on "The ManWho Sailed Around HisSoul." Still, most of theparticipating artists man-age to stamp personality
into their performances. Sarah McLachlan's"Dear God," Freedy Johnston's "Earn Enoughfor Us," Spacehog's "Senses Working Over-time," Joe Jackson's "Statue of Liberty," andP. Hux's "Another Satellite" all qualify ashighlights. Unlike on most tribute albums,there isn't a really awful or boring cover to befound. Even XTC gets into the act pseu-donomously as Terry & The Lovemen, cover-ing an obscure B side from the "Mayor of Sim-pleton" single titled "The Good Things."
A Testimonial Dinner is a genuinely enter-taining album, one of the best in the crowdedfield of tribute albums. If it encourages anyfresh interest in the quirky but often brilliantXTC, so much the better. Michael Tearson
Almost SpeechlessBen Arnold
RUFFHOUSE/COLUMBIA CK 67215, 39:15Sound: B+, Performance: A-
Ben Arnold wants you to know how hefeels, and his straight -from -the -heart songs
hit their targets with un-erring precision. WhileArnold isn't a prisoner of20 -something angst, hisdeeply -felt emotions arethe glue that makes Al-most Speechless whole,
and deceptively simple arrangements leaveplenty of room for his soulful vocals.
There is so much strong material here, butthe real standout is "Be There." The song re-flects on the troubled life of a friend whosetragic death might have been averted if onlyArnold had "been there" for him. Don't besurprised if Rickie Lee Jones or Rod Stewartjumps on it, for this repentant confessionalcertainly belongs in the "most likely to be coy -
Julian pe
Julian Cope Presents 20 Mothers:Fetter To Light a Conclle
Than Tc Curse the DarknessJulian Cope
AMERICAN 9 43044-2, 71:49Sound: B+, Performance: B-
y now, there's no questioningJulian Cope's status as a gen-uine British eccentric. More than
a decade into a pro-lific solo career thatkicked in on the heelsof the short-livedbut influential The
Teardrop Explodes,"Saint" Julian forgesonward with all hisquirks intact (if "in-tact" is indeed a
word one would useto describe a chemi-cal zealot of Cope'srank). Of course, af-ter a while, musicalrenegades becomeas tiresome as conformists if they don'tcome up with the requisite good tunes.20 Mothers has a few, but it's also 70minutes long. So the question is, does ithave enough?
For passionate devotees, absolutely.For them, tossed -off asides like "TheLonely Guy" and "By the Light of the Sil-bury Moon" (at minimum) offer preciousinsight into the swarming mind of the"Arch-Drude" ("drude" is a Cope -coinedword, a combination of "druid" and
"dude") of neopsychedelia.Unconvertedskeptics, on the other hand, may findtheir minds wandering as Cope's in-sights and melodies stray far and wide."Try Try Try," "Highway to the Sun," and"Adam & Eve Hit the Road" are all rela-tively conventional rockers with wonder-fully intoxicating hooks, subject matterbe damned (they're about mom, meat -
eaters, and virtual reality, respectively,
according to Cope's loopy liner notes).Elsewhere, Cope wanders into every-thing from British folk to art -noise tosynth -pop, all designed to carry theweight of his pre -millennium fixationswith these "desperate times."
Cope seems satisfied to put out onetripped -out treatise after another, andfor those who constantly hunger for an-other dose of Cope, that's just delightful.For the rest of us, maybe we'll catch upwith you later. Steven Stolder
ered" category. On "You," Arnold uses hisGraham Parker -like voice for maximum im-pact in recalling a tale of unrequited love. Foratmosphere, a Dylanesque Hammond B-3provides the perfect accompaniment. "Soar,"Arnold's homage to Orville and WilburWright, looks back to the brothers' early un-successful attempts to defy Newton's law. Theopening line, "Wilbur, we'll try again tomor-row" serves as a reminder that we should nev-er surrender our dreams. Ben Arnold mayhave his head in the clouds, but all of thesesongs embrace some very down-to-earth hu-man feelings and concerns.
Although Almost Speechless is a consistentlymelodic and deftly conceived recording, it'seven more than that; it's an all-out aerobic ex-ercise for your emotional heart. Just press"Play." Steve Guttenberg
The Sacred Squall of NowReeves Gabrels
UPSTART 020, 50:48Sound: A, Performance: A
Guitarist Reeves Gabrels, David Bowie's ac-complice in Tin Machine and a hired gun onhis last two solo outings, is a sound alchemistwith a deconstructionist bent. In fact, theguy's just plain bent-as in sick, twisted, and
madly inspired beyondall reason. He's even gota band on the side calledThe Bentmen. I rest mycase.
On his solo debut (hecollaborated earlier in
1995 with slide -guitar god David Tronzo onNight in Amnesia, also on Upstart), Gabrels in -
00
cc
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199682
4
424
z
CL
4
z0
titter
0
I
0
cc
Cl)I
4likartio,yi4171.4e,
i...,,s....v
0*0 45 , L.71Bli
450 WATT(c" 4 -WAY SPEAKER$` From the L series by JBL.
the L-7 offers an incrediblepower handling of 450 watts
with a 4 -way design featuring a12" Aquaplas woofer. an 8" die castmidbass. 5" die cast mineral filled
midrange & a 1" titanium dome tweeter
.8C66.1
Se. Suggested f1
4O<C
Price.... $1899
OSHIBA LUXMAN ADVENT KLIPSCH
0
z1<
C.
MITSUBISHIVS -504150" STEREOREMOTEPROJEC-IONTVMitsubi4ii's SC"projectionT.V. featuringadvanced P -I -Pcombinedwith a multibrand remotefor the ultimatoviewingexperience.
PICTURE-IN-
PICTURE
0
quality cd change -s featuring:
REMOTE CD CHANGERHere's jul one of Denon's hi
8X OS. disc skip. two 20 bitD/A converters. 3 random playmodes and a remote.
95 DISC CAROUSEL
Suggested Price 5450
DENONDcm
KLIPSCH(INKY° TX-SV727 KG -5.5DOLBY®+ PRO LOGIC RECEIVER WITH 100 WATT 2 -WAYREMOTE CONTROL SPEAKERSOnkyo's TX-SV727 Pro Logic receiver offers 80 watts per Bass reflex speaken- fromchannel (front & center). 25 watts per channel (rear). Klipsch fezturing a -ented desi.five surround modes and a full function remote control. Suggeste: Price $750 with a 10" woofer a -id
a 10" passve radiabr.
PDCC RECORDER WITH REMOTEThe DCC 900 records &plays back on digitalcompact cassettes whileenabling you to still listen toyour old analog cassettes. Suggested Price..$499
IMULTI -CHANNEL POWER AMPSSTARTING AT..LARGESELECTIONIN STOCK
VELODYNEVA -1215X100 WATT POWERED SUBWOOFERVelodyne's VA -1215X will shake the walls with a 12" driver 1 )0watt built-in class A/amplifier.2' voicecoil. 56 oz.magnet.passive high passand an active lowpass crossover.
THORENTD -1803 SPEED TURNTABLEThorens TD -180 features a
with 33".45 and
belt drivensystem
78 speeds
Suggestzd Price $10CC
PairSuggested Price . _ , $1000
re Carty A he Line OL XLO Panamax Morster Cable Bell Ogg2tti Straightwiwe Audic Quest Niles Terk
4;0>
ct:vc4.
' 0.4i t;t4*0'
413+CI Nt7 bvr
NV- e,t.
0Cl)
.71
Ctoc7)
COUNTERPOINT APOGEE SHARP KENWOOD 'UP TO 40 POUNDS IN THE CONTINENTAL USA. ALL PRODUCTS ARE COVERED Bs THE MANUFACTURER'S WARRANTY OR ELECTRCNICS DEFOT'S EXCLUSIVE WARRANT'. ' CALL FOR INFORMATION
dulges in sonic mayhem with fangs bared. Theresults are positively horrific by pop musicstandards but wholly transcendent by "weirdmusic" standards.
As a songwriter, Gabrels has a knack formoody, abrasive rock with harmonic meatand savvy pop hooks ("Say That Now," "Prob-lem," and "Comeback"). His interest in Mid-dle Eastern music comes into play in the midstof the densely textured "Husnu," and he deliv-ers a touch of drama on the melancholy blueslament "B.N.Y.," with lyrics by his wife, SaraTerry. Bowie makes a guest vocal appearancealongside movie star Gary Oldman on "You'veBeen Around" ( which Bowie previouslyrecorded for his Black Tie/White Noise album)and on a thrashing -good industrial rant, "TheKing of Stamford Hill." Former Pixies front -man Frank Black sings lead on "119 YearsAgo," and Charlie Sexton joins Gabrels for anappropriately macabre rendition of CreedenceClearwater Revival's "Bad Moon Rising."
As an instrumentalist, Reeves is a revela-tion. His soaring solo on the Bowie-esque
lead-off track, "119 Years Ago," has all the epicuplift of Hendrix's levitating masterpiece"Bold As Love." His out -to -lunch solo on"Husnu" is state-of-the-art skronk, and hisbrief feedback-laden solo on "Problem" is asubversive gem. Gabrels' ethereal guitar or-chestra piece, "Thirteen," is like Glenn Brancawith a sense of humor. And the other urgentinstrumental, "Firedome," contains some ofthe most radical guitar work this side of DavidTorn and No Pussyfooting -era Robert Fripp.
Vocals and amazing, otherworldly guitarplaying haven't been so organically integratedinto the fabric of pop tunes since the heydayof Jimi Hendrix. Think of this one as ReevesGabrels' Are You Experienced. Bill Milkowski
TrustPatrick O'Hearn
DEEP CAVE RECORDS 1001-2, 45:35
Sound: A+, Performance: B+
Patrick O'Hearn used to play bass for Frank7.appa, and he spent the early '80s with a fun -
THE RENTALSReturn of the RentalsMAVERICK/REPRISE 9-46093-2, 37:02
Sound: B, Performance: B
You can't accuse The Rentals of over-
reaching; everything about this debut
murmurs a modest intent.
Essentially an outlet for Weezer bassist
Matt Sharp to develop his
frontman skills, The Rentals
mix and match '90s lo-fi and
early '80s retro aesthetics
into something that's notexactly ground -breaking but
is nevertheless satisfying. In
fact, the majority of these 10
tracks make for tasty earcandy that has all the appeal
of a New Wave compilation.
Beginning with the one-two
three combination of "The Love I'mSearching For," "Waiting," and "Friends
of R," The Rentals frugally adorn spright-
ly melodies with multiple Moog synthe-
sizers and bandied male/female vocals.
Sharp compares The Rentals to Electric
Light Orchestra on a budget, but The
Cars -meet -Pavement may be a more ac-
curate comparison. Visually, The Rentals
have opted for the East German bureau-
crat look, which MTV immediately em-
braced (maybe someone there is nostal-
gic for that bygone "all videos, all day"
age when Gary Numan and Devo ruled
the air). But the more novel aspects of
The Rentals have limited appeal; what's
attractive about this project is the fresh-
ness of its best songs.
Sharp promises that The Rentals are
not just "my little side project," whichmay prove to be unfortunate-if everthere was an instrinsic "little side pro-
ject," it's The Rentals. Just leave it at that.
Steven Stolder
ny haircut in MissingPersons. But for the lastdecade, he's been or-chestrating landscapes ofthe soul. His modusoperandi hasn't alteredmuch since his 1986 de-but album, the influential Ancient Dreams(Private Music 2002-2-P ),,with an organicmix of synthesizers, samplers, acoustic andelectric bass, and percussion. But Trust showsthat there are still landscapes to explore.
O'Hearn is a master of texture and sounddesign. There's nothing different in the equip-ment he uses, but he gets more expression outof it, yielding complex layers of synthesizersoften outlined by the rubbery melodies of hiselectric and acoustic basses. O'Hearn is helpedout by some old friends on a few tracks, in-cluding Zappa/Missing Persons mate TerryBozzio and guitarists Peter Maunu and DavidTorn. But they are only there as part of O'Hearn's
textures.After struggling through six years of neglect
at Private Music, O'Hearn is clearly emergingfrom a time of despair. On "Two Continents"and "Equinox," his mood is dark-full offoreboding and even menace. Percussiverhythms tug on the subconscious like a primalshadow, yet beneath it all is a sense of resigned
heroism that marks the difference between de-spair and affirmation. (Available from DeepCave Records, P.O. Box 290, Bat Cave, N.C.28710.) John Diliberto
Techniques of Speed HypnosisEdsel
RELATIVITY 88561-1525-2, 48:46Sound: B-, Performance: C
Unfortunately for Edsel, Techniques ofSpeed Hypnosis fails to get beyond soundinglike everything else on college radio. Theband's sense of melody comes through onmost of the cuts, reaching a plateau of ethere-al ecstasy, only to be dis-carded for something un-listenable in a perpetualsearch for the lost chord.Edsel should focus moreon the sweeping warmthof its breaks and forgetabout so-called "alternative credibility,"which is simply a trap for many up and com-ing bands. Every time 1 tapped my feet oryearned to catch the chorus and sing along, anoverzealous guitar disrupted the moment.
On stand -out tracks "Chester's Wig" and"Skin of the Bear," Edsel shows an ability tocraft pop compositions, where the vocals workwith the arrangements in self-assured ease.More songs like these, and Techniques of Speed
Hypnosis would have spent more time in myCD player. Lauren Sornerstein
llypnoyis
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199684
ss®DIGITAL SATELLITE SYSTEM
SONY AND RCASATELLITE SYSTEMS
NOW IN STOCK
Meadtown Shopping Center Route 23 5. Kinnelon, NJ 07405
No Home Theater is com-plete without the rightTV! Sound City carries alarge selection of lVs thatwill truly bring the movietheater expenence home.Choose from Sony, JVC,
Hitachi Panasonic and Many More! TV'sFrom to 100" Available!
SUPER TV SPECIALSBrand Name 27" TV Stockn11893 5469Brand Name 31" TV srakiiisoria 5399
Brand Name 35" TV Stodic13220s1299
Brand Name 52" TV Stock/047911m
CAMCORDERS
We Are AnAuthorizedDealer for AllCamcorderBrands WeCarry. All Formats SHARPAvailable From Such VIEWCAMFine Manufacturer's As: "-
We Also Carry A Full Line o:Batteries, Camcorder BagsLights, Fitters, & morel
Extended Wamntles Available
DISC notO
Stock
Brand Name trasaa
Multi -Format Laser Disc Player Time base corrected 1 bit DiA converter On -screen display Full function remote control with shuttle S -VHS output
CALL Midnight Theatermode for low listening
Panasonic LXK770Laser Disc Player w/Karaoke On -screen display S -VHS output CALL
EDITORSA Full Line ofEditors,Audio/VideoSwitchersand Titlers AreAlso Available To Give YourVideos That ProfessionalLook!
JVC JXED11 JVC JXS700JVC 1X5100 JVC JXSV55
JVC ASSOO Panasonic WJA'JE7
MI Far More Information
RINGING IN THE NEW YEAR AND BLOWING OUT THE SALE PRICES!
JVC HRVP6213U SpecialHi Fi VHS VCR Purchase VCR Plus. with "tab 4 head with built-in hiLL, -..k Jog/shuttle on front of unit Insert edit w/llying erase head TV/cable box remote oda. Super head cleaner
Solace SF 400On Wall Speakers
JI White
Philips CD921PBKSingle CD Player Limited
0 'A conversion °UM titieS
Direct play program Ong Shuffle and repeat pla, '189
Brand NameTurntable Semi -automatic Belt drive system Low mass tone arm Servo controller motor Cartridge includedSlocke3507
orkors
Philips DCC900BKDCC Deck Records and
Receiver plays back CD qua- 110W x 2 power output icy sound Surround SOW x 2 Analog. digital coax. DSP with 6 acoustic environments 8 digital optical inoutputs Dolby® Pro Logic decoding Analog cassette playback Remote control FRemote CD synchro 4 or 8 ohm operation Auto reverse and Dolby Subwooter output Stock/13/55 B/C NR for analog cassene
OrigSOD
Brand NameDSP A/V
Atlantic Technology 154SRSurroundSpeaker High performance speaker Dual 3 1'2- polypropyleneangled mounted drivers Woofers mounted diagonallyopposite on an irrinite baffle 1'0W3.. power raITG
*
Orig.'169/pr
Kenwood UD552Mini System SOW cn -disc CD Dual auto -reverse cassette 4 ed listening mode Pre -out for subwoofer Karoake (hit master) mode Full function remote control 20 random AMt:M presets Clock
Orto.,949
JBL PS120PoweredSubwoofer 12" High polymerlaminate woofer 2" voice coil.100W RMS amplifier power line level 8 speaker level inputs Fr. 30 Hz to (62-250 I -1:i'Determined by erosse
orig.699
BrandNameDATDigital Audio Tape Dec - L, , 'emote Optical analogand coaxial inputs Randomskip'repeatSteckel 5076
Infinity SSIV10Servo Sub 10. Powered Subwooter 90W Poweranmplifier built-in
Variable crossover50-200Hz Sealed cabinet 14- Cube orig.
'599
glinjNiles SPS-44 -Pair Speaker Selector Accomoaate up to 4 pair of speakers 100Wrch power handling Low profile design Accomodates up to14 AWG wire
AUDIO 71 1cherry RI We OfAudlo Al
Products
NEW 0111 DACMan D/ATry world's lowest price outboard DiA - with built-in TARA Labs cables has specsarid performance better than 5400 D/A's of three gars ago fear., r ad, -ii,Crystal Semiconductor *4330 DiA chip Stakt16096
DAC-In-The-Box D/A5129
TAlchemy's DAC-in-the-Box WIT131 has 18 -bit ladder-DAC proces,)al and optical digital inputs & outboard power supply Recommen.rer. video laser disc 8 cable DMX upgrades Stoat 116101 s177NEW DTIPlus Digital FilterDTIPlus anti -litter filter is designed for audiophiles who want advanced litter reduc-tion for CD payers,_ but don't need fancy AESIBU or AT&T ins or outs Sam,specs as the new DTlv2 0 - at 1/2 the price) Stock#16100 $249FOR INFORMATION &CUSTOMER SERVICE
201-263-6060
SPECIAL PURCHASE
JVC DR 571000Super VHS Hi-Fi VCR -Igh resolution S -OHS picture .'HS stereo with
per -bass sound Super spei ' Txrr,amcm OCRw multi -system cable bo
Menu button on VCR for
Limited a OrigQuantities '899
WE SHIP TO CANADA ilk,WE SHIP WORLDWIDE UpNo Credit Card Surcharges
Se Hable Es anal
RETAIL HOURS
Mon - Fri10am - 9pm EST
Saturday9am - 6pm EST
Ogler - MSE-88 Car Amplifier 16W/cis 2 into 4 ohm Orig Gold RCA inputs w/ad) sensitivity 129 Runs mono and stereo MOSFET output Transnova circuitry 22W x 4 into 4 ohm
Brand Name Amp 5W/ch x 2 bridgeable ORIG. '199Altec Lansing ALA200 100W/ch x 2 bridgeable Ong '300
Soundstream Granite 60.2 30W x 2 or 100Wx 1 Ong 51891131. GT0100 X 4 bridgeable car power amplifier
a/d/s/ P08.2 amplifier Ong 5229
Soundstream Granite 110.2 ,sw x 2,120 x 1 Orig $300
MAIL ORDER HOURS
Mon - Fri8am - 12pm EST
Sat gam - 6pm ESTSun 11am - 5pm EST
51195169
5CALL99
5895149
Probe:son,ALdoWlan
4srarkwar
Faloniktorged for al Pate we sit id responst,le kx ryp:gretcal eras NO mitt m WM or ter sleep mixt 14 lay Odeche exchrge bore date c1 re:eptAl reams oust be maie wen 14 lays '0030 CO merdwoseSC# AUD296& are Retied lo a restodang lee, iris rrusl be n owl cation axl leaden* Swg and twat not refutable Non-corrmssued salesman Dis and Is Idols a eau al Ile{ nwzycne Drug
JAZZ -BLUES
Makin' a MoveHenry Threadgill
COLUMBIA CK 67214,64:25
Sound: A, Performance: A+
enry Threadgill usuallyleads his group with analto saxophone hangingfrom his neck. But call-ing his music "jazz" islike dressing him in anill-fitting suit. Threadg-ill is a composer with asingular vision that de-fies familiar record -bincategories. The land-scape he covers on
Makin' a Move is, as always, full ofunpredictable twists and gloriousplays of shadow and light.
Like the best classical composers,Threadgill develops themes that ap-pear and disappear, only to reemergelater with a different voice and feel-ing. Some of Makin' a Move's cur-
rents flow directly from Threadgill's1994 album Carry the Day, whileothers date back further in his cata-
log; all of them sound fresh and un-dated. Unlike most concert -hallscores, Threadgill allows his musicalthemes to embrace influences with-out concern for their origin or con-ventional place. "Noisy Flowers" ar-rives via Myra Melford's delicate solo
piano; the next track is introducedby Pheeroan Aklaff's funk drum-ming. On "Like It Feels," Frenchhorn and tuba carry the melodywhile electric guitars provide coun-terpoint. On "Refined Poverty,"Threadgill's alto soars elegantlyabove a cello trio.
At the core of it all is Threadgill'sensemble, Very Very Circus-astrange brew of instrumental voicesanchored by twin tubas, played byEdwin Rodriguez and Marcus Rojas,and Mark Taylor's French horn. Onecould go on about the Indian influ-ence in Threadgill's use of guitars orthe superimposition of ragtime andcircus conventions over his ownthemes, but that would be missingthe forest for the trees. Though theword "soundscape" is overused thesedays, Threadgill's musical vision ispanoramic and rendered in suchgreat detail that you can live in it,which is a whole lot more fun thandefining it. Larry Blumenfeld
vin TMelvin Taylor & The Slac< Band
EVIDENCE ECD 26073-2 51:18Sound: B-, Performance B+
udged by its cover, ChicagoanMelvin Taylor's latest albumappears to be traditional elec-tric blues, on the order ofOtis Rush. But that's onlypart of the story; Taylor, like
many of his peers, is a contemporaryblues artist whose influences rangefrom T -Bone Walker and B B. Kingto blues rockers Jimi Hencrix andStevie Ray Vaughan. On his seconddomestic release, Taylor shows offformidable guitar chops ard vocalauthority.
Melvin Taylor & The Slack Band isa live -in -the -studio album, warts and
all. It has flaws (the bass guitar lacksdefinition, and Taylor leans on hiswah-wah pedal too much for thosewith "purist" tastes), but blues en-thusiasts will appreciate how genuineit is. Taylor and his Slack Band-bassist Willie Smith and drummerSteve Potts-lock together in an un-
polished, stripped -down fashion todeliver a set oforiginals and cov-ers that is hardlyoverproduced. Thebottom line on
Taylor, a better interpreter thansongwriter, is that even with hisflaws, few current or emerging bluesmusicians play with his emotion andauthenticity. fon 6. Sally Tiven
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199686
Tone Poems IIDavid Grisman and Martin TaylorACOUSTIC DISC ACD-18, 64:24
Sound: A, Performance: A+
David Grisman's second Tone Poems album
pairs the mandolin master (who additionallyplays mandola, mandocello, and guitars here)
with British jazz guitar whiz Martin Taylor.They play a diverse set of 19 period jazz tunes,
including "Swanee," "Besame Mucho,""Mairzy Doats," "My Romance," DjangoReinhardt's "Tears," and Ellington's "MoodIndigo" (a piece that has one of the sexiestmelodies ever).
The chemistry between Grisman and Tay-lor is wonderful. It's obvious from the relaxed
performances how much fun they had making
this album. Each plays as fast as the windwhen needed, but they also know how to play
slow and hot, leaving necessary spaces be-tween the notes.
Adding to the fun is how this live -in -the -
studio album showcases the nuances of thedifferent woods and de-
signs of the 41 vintageinstruments used on thealbum. The booklet in-cludes color photos ofeach instrument, an es-
say relating to its history, and who played itand made it. Whenever possible the instru-ment is used on a song that was originallyrecorded with the same (or a similar) model.
The first Tone Poems album (Acoustic Disc
ACD-10) was a similarly packaged collection
of folk songs played by Grisman and guitarist
Tony Rice, who used an equally dazzling array
of instruments. Both albums are spectacularaudio showcases for great playing and for the
finest subtleties of fine instruments. My high-
est recommendations both technically andartistically.
(Available from Acoustic Disc, Box 4143,
San Rafael, Cal. 94913.) Michael Tearson
Gunslinging BirdsMingus Big Band
DREYFUS FDM 36575-2, 71:11
Sound: B+, Performance: A
Charles Mingus is alive and well. Most of-
ten you can find him in New York's East Vil-lage, every Thursday night, in a basement club
called Fez. There, the Mingus Big Band, a 14 -
piece rotating outfit drawn from a roster of
more than 100 of New York's finest and mostfreethinking players, holds court. The brain-
child of writer and producer Sue Mingus, hiswidow, the group has parlayed a three-weekgig into one of the longest -running jazz
shows, with Europeantours and two CD releas-
es to boot.
Repertory jazz oftengets a bad rap, but theMingus Big Band suc-
ceeds in raising the weighty spirit of its name-
sake. Elegant yet vulgar, and full of defiantbeauty, Gunslinging Birds proves the band is
up to the challenge Mingus laid down: to per-
form his frustratingly difficult works, makethem swing, and, above all, keep them sound-
ing new.
There are some powerful reorchestrationsof "Started Melody" (by Gunther Schuller)and "Noon Night" (by Ronnie Cuber), bothdrawn from the masterwork Epitaph. Andwhile all in the unit deserve applause, trum-peters Randy Brecker, Philip Harper, and Ryan
Kisor command special note. Tenor saxo-phonists Chris Potter and Craig Handy engage
in a ferocious duel on "O.P.," and John Stub-blefield turns "Hog Calk' Blues" into a soul -
satisfying, tenor sax showcase.
The fire and fury of the Mingus Big Band is
admirably in the mix here; still, why notrecord it live? Larry Blumenfeld
blue sunMark Isham
COLUMBIA CK 67227, 60:59
Sound: A, Performance: A
Mark Isham's Columbia debut feels like a
descendant of two Miles Davis landmarks,Sketches of Spain and In a Silent Way. One se-
lection, "And Miles To Go...Before He Sleeps,"
even pays tribute to the legendary band leader
and horn player with its title.
On blue sun, Isham presents eight originals
and a lovely, wistful version of Duke Elling-ton's "In a SentimentalMood." Isham plays
trumpet, cornet, flugel-horn, and unidentified"electronics"; two keysoloists are Steve
Tavaglione on tenor sax and David Goldblatt
on acoustic and electric pianos. Bassist DougLunn and drummer Kurt Wortman completethe quintet.
411.,
CRUTCHFIEtti
Sony
ASSis Here!
WIN! A 15,9984"e Theater Sytt.
f4Ti.t":10PING!
OLDS MORE
CAR STEREO
FREEStereoCatalog
Get it before you chooseyour next home or car stereo
Huge selection - Hundreds of stereosto choose trom for your home and car,plus home theater systems and the newdigital satellite systems. Over 100pages of components to fit any budget!
Quality brands - Sony, Bose,Kenwood, JVC, Yamaha, Pioneer,Carver, Polk, Advent, Infinity, NHT,Mitsubishi, Panasonic, and many more
Complete information - includingunique comparison charts, helpfulbuying advice, and complete descrip-tions of features and specs. Get yourcatalog on its way today!
rCall Now!
1-800-955-90098 a.m. to Midnight (Eastern time 1. 7
On the Web - http://www.crutchtield.cornor mail this coupon
CRUTCHFIELD
1
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199687
LI Crutchfield Park. Dept. AU, Charlottesville, VA 22906i
CIRCLE NO 8 ON READER SERVICE CARD
1Though most of blue sun is still and lan-
guorous, opportunities remain for Isham and
Tavaglione to let it out and wail, particularly
on "Barcelona" and "Tour de Chance.""Barcelona" is a study in dynamics, as it opens
softly and builds to a peak before falling back
and repeating the ebb -and -flow cycle several
times. The title track throbs with a sad heat of
the tenor sax and Isham's muted cornet. The
sound, engineered and mixed by StephenKrause, drapes the music in elegance.
Isham's blue sun is an excellent album. It
has soothed more than its share of my trou-
bled late nights. Michael Tearson
InfinityMcCoy Tyner Trio
featuring Michael BreckerIMPULSE IMPD-171, 72:16
Sound: A, Performance: A
Infinity marks McCoy Tyner's return to the
reactivated Impulse label (he was one of itsfirst signings in the early '60s, as was John
Coltrane), and more significantly, it chronicles
Tyner's return to a piano, sax, bass, and drum
setup after years of using mostly trio and big -
band settings. In tow, he's got his trio mates of
nearly a decade, bass player Avery Sharpe and
drummer Aaron Scott, and a very specialguest, saxophonist Michael Brecker. Tyner,who enjoyed important formative associa-tions with Coltrane and Sonny Rollins, among
others, knows a thing or two about tenor play-
ers. Brecker proves an inspired choice; he has
been successful with a more progressivesound, and Infinity offers him the perfect op-
portunity to embrace his straight -ahead roots.
The nine -song session is nothing if nothonest and pure. Tyner's "Flying High" gets
things off to a powerful start. On "HappyDays," he begins with a relaxed descending
pattern, but within a minute, he and Brecker
are plumbing a deep blues well. Brecker tack-
les the tenor role admirably on Coltrane's
"Impressions," which Tyner and Coltranerecorded decades ago. And Brecker is at his
most urgent and affecting on Tyner's "Mellow
Minor," reeling off responses to the pianist's
lightning -quick figures. An unexpected treat,
the album concludes with Tyner, alone at the
piano, performing the ballad "Good Morning
Heartache." To quote Tyner from his linernotes, "life without a doubt goes in cycles."Without a doubt Infinity couldn't express this
better. Larry Blumenfeld
UDIimaximmunainmrn
SUBSCRIBER SERVICE
Place
labelhere
MOVING? Please give us 8weeks advance notice. Attachlabel with your old address, andwrite in new address below.
RENEWING? ( heck boxbelow and attach label with cor-rections marked, if any.
SUBSCRIBING? Checkbox and till in coupon. For gift sub-scriptions attach a separate sheet.
Send Audio for 1 year at $24.00
Li New subscription Renewal Payment enclosed Bill meCanadian orders add $8 per year.Foreign orders add $8 per year.
NAME
ADDRESS
CITY
STATE
ZIP _
1(303) 447-9330AUDIO
P.O. Box 52548BOULDER, CO 80322
AD INDEXFirm (Reader Service No.)Adcom (1)Audio Research (2)
Page3
Cover IIIB & W Loudspeakers (3) 17Bacardi 9BMG 48a&bBose/Acoustic Wave 18
Brystonvermont (4) 35Cambridge SoundWorks (5,6) Cover II & 1,7conrad-johnson (7) 43Crutchfield (8) 87Energy (9) 37
& R Music World (10) 77Klipsch 59Legacy Audio (11) 41Mobile Fidelity (12, 13) 5, 71, 73Mondial (14) Cover IVMusic Metre (15) 19NBS Cables (16) 39Onkyo (29) 67Paradigm (17) 11
Pioneer (18) 13Polk (19) 15
PSB Speakers (20) 70Scientific Fidelity (21) 74Sennheiser (22) 75Sharp (23) 47Sixth Avenue Electronics 83Solo Electronics (24) 18
Sonic Frontiers (25) 27Sound City (26) 85Thiel 68Uncle's Stereo 79U.S. Airforce 63USA Direct (27) 81XLO Electric 45Yakov Aronov (28) 69
AUDIO, February, 1996, Volume 80, Number 2.AUDIO (ISSN 0004-752X, Dewey DecimalNumber 621.381 or 778.5) is publishedmonthly by Hachette Filipacchi Magazines,Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of HachetteFilipacchi USA, Inc., at 1633 Broadway, NewYork, N.Y. 10019. Printed in U.S.A. at Dyers-burg, Tenn. Distributed by Warner PublisherServices Inc. Second class postage paid atNew York, N.Y. 10019 and additional mail-ing offices. Subscriptions in the UnitedStates, $24.00 for one year, $42.00 for twoyears, $58.00 for three years; other countriesexcept Canada, add $8.00 per year; in Cana-da, $32.00 for one year (includes 7% GST;Canadian GST registration number126018209).AUDIO0 is a registered trademark of Ha-chette Filipacchi Magazines, Inc. 01996, Ha-chette Filipacchi Magazines, Inc. All rightsreserved. The Editor assumes no responsibil-ity for manuscripts, photos, or artwork. ThePublisher, at his sole discretion, reserves theright to reject any ad copy he deems inap-propriate.Subscription Service: Postmaster, pleasesend change of address to AUDIO, P.O. Box52548, Boulder, Colo. 80321-2548. Alloweight weeks for change of address. Includeboth old and new address and a recent ad-dress label. If you have a subscription prob-lem, please write to the above address or call303/604-1464; fax, 303/604-7455.Back Issues: For information, write to P.O.Box 7085, Brick, N.J. 08723.
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199688
CD STORAGEFOR ADVERTISING INFORMATION
CONNECTIONCALL 1-800-445-6066. 9Am-5ram EST.
DEALER SHOWCASE
CALIFORNIA
America's best disc, tape andcomponent storage system
Free mailorder brochure
Per Madsen Design 0151 822 488l'(1 1;0 \ 882404. r)4188
To place a classified ad in theindustry leading titles of
Hachette FilipacchiMagazines, Inc.,
simply call Toll -Free and reserveyour space today!
1-800-445-6066 (9am-5pm EST)Fax: 212-767-5624
At lastthe perpect way to store
CD's; our CD box holds
60 CDSin light or dark oak
@ $69.00, or walnut.
@ $74.00, all plus $7.00
for shipping & handling.
Hills Products
P.O. Box 55 Candia, NH 03034 - call us at1-800-247-2018 with orders - or for a freecatalog of all our fine products!
Storage Solutions
CD, Audio and Video Storage. Fully Assembled!. 100% Solid Oak!. 30 Day Money Back
Guarantee!
Made in U.S.A.. Smoked Glass Doors. Ajustable Shelves. No Hidden Costs
Just One Low Price!Call or write for aim color brochure
AGM WoodworkingN70 Capiiolio Way #5
San Luis Obispo. Ca. 9341)118051544-1661)
4110 1-800-858-9005
CD CABINET
r
NOW a very practicalsolution to storing your large library of CDs
Our CD cabinets feature our patented EZ View "Fhp andPick" pull-out CD tray that Mk,ws you to store CDs in avertical. (we -forward posrlqn for easy viewing and selection.
Our Woes. cabinet has storage for over 1000 :Zs
Write, Call or Fax for a free brochure
NEW AGE FURNITURE2600 Fembrook Lane Minneapolis, MN 55447
(800) 767-4653 FAX: (612)553-1371
The AUDIOCD STORAGE CONNECTION
puts manufacturers of CD storage units in
touch with the ideal audience...
CD purchasers unsurpassed in size, buying
activity & the need for storage of
their ever-growing CD collections!
For advertising information call:
1.800-445-6066(Monday -Friday, 9-5 EST}
or Fax us your order at 212-767-5624
STORADISC - See why CD Review picked our LibrarySeries as their top choice-. Fine -furniture quality in a varietyof finishes and sizes. Call or write DAVIDSON-WHITEHALL.555 Whitehall Street. Atlanta. GA 30303. 1-800-848-9811.
VALUEABLEWE COMBINE EXCEPTIONAL
PRODUCTS WITH DESIGN EXPERTISETO CREATE HIGH PERFORMANCESYSTEMS OF UNUSUAL VALUE.
Factory Authorized Dealer for:Aocom Anfstrom Atlantic Technology
Apogee Audible IllusionsAudiolab Audioprism AudioQuest
DefinitiveTechnology Denon Grado Hitachi Lexicon Lovan Mc Cormack
Moc Squad M&K NAD NEAR Paradigm Parasound Pioneer Power Wedge Rotel
Bunco Stax Sumiko Sunfire Theta*Totem VAC Velodyne XLO & more!
SystemsDesign
Group
(310) 370-8575
1310 Kingsdale Ave.Redondo Bch., CA 90278
Tue-Fri 1lam-7pmSat 11am-6pm
CALIFORNIA
1/Ne don't sellperfect systems.
tiler 15 years, we've learnedno perfect system exists. It has to he built -to your specifications, within your budget
To get s s today...
182141)11j1 \ 1%). t1;111. \ 1411!40
MAINE
Acurus ...Aragon ...Audio Research... Creek ... CWD Denon Grado
Jamo JM Labs ...)olidaLexicon ... Magneplaner ... MagnumDynalab ... Mark Levinson ... NADPrometheans PSB ... Revolver ...
Rotel ... SME Sota ... Sound=onnections Stax ... Stewart ...Sumiko Symdex ... SynergisticResearch ...Thoren ...Transparent
Audio ...And Much More!
Hi Fi ExdimqcFORESIDE MALL ROUTE ONE
FALMOUTH, ME 04105
(207) 781-2326
FOR ADVERTISING INFORMATION, CALL 1-800-445-6066, 9AM-5PM EST
DEALERMASSACHUSETTS
SHOWCASEMASSACHUSETTS NEW JERSEY
The Best Values In Hi End Hi-Fi.
audio studioAuthorized sales and service for:
Audible Illusions, Audioquest, B&K.Beyerdynamic. Counterpoint, Dual.Klyne. Maplenoll, Marantz, Mirage.
Mission, Monster Cable. Morel,NAD, Nakamichi, Oideion Products.
Ortofon, Project. Proton. QUAD.Renaissance Audio, Revox,
Sennheiser. SME, Shure, Stax.Straight Wire, Sumiko, Thorens.Velodyne, VPI, and many more.
414 Harvard St., Brookline, MA 02146(617) 277-0111
FAX (617) 277-2415INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS ACCEPTED
NEW YORK
-ALPHA STEREOQuahty Components. Profesgonal Instalkm, "1 k Sert e'
NIMES INAD"We are known for thecompanies we keep"
Atlantic Technologies, Audio Control,Audioquest, Denon, JVC, KEF, Kenwood,Kinergetics, Monster Cable, NAD, Near,Nokomichi, Onkyo, Ortofon, Polk Audio,
PSB, Sennheiser, Sony, and ManyMore Products!
Northern NY's oldest & most renowned dealer
57 Smithfield Blvd., Plattsburgh, NY 12901
518-561-2822Fax: 518-561-2961
Monday -Friday IOam-Hpm. Saturday Inam-6pmMastercard, Visa, Discover, Amex
PENNSYLVANIA
Authorized Dealers For.
JVC.mtmn-sueismi
InfinityRCA
_17A7SE7 SONY
BEACH (Sorry No Catalogs)
80 VFW ParkwayRevere, MA 02151
1.800-562-9020NEW YORK
FACTORYAUTHORIZED
DEALERSspecs ut:
HOME THEATERSYSTEMS
ADS BOSE CARVER DENONINFINITY KENWOOD CAR
NAK NHT ONKYO SONANCESONY ES VELODYNE YAMAHA
The Sound Approach6067 Jen :Ho 'Nut., Commack, NY 11725
800-368-2344All returns subiect to a restocking charge.
VERMONT
PHILADELPHIA AUDIOPHILES
ACOUSTIC ENERGY
AIR TIGHT
ALON
ALPS AUDIBLE ILLUSIONS
AUDIO ALCHEMY
AUDIOtAll BENZ -MICRO
B+K COMPONENTS
CARY
CEC DIGITAL
CLASSE
COUNTERPOINT
CREEK
DYNAVECTOR
EMINENT TECH.
EPOS
FANFARE FM
GENESIS
GRADO
GRAHAM
GREEN MOUNTAIN
HARBETH
HIGHWIRE
JADIS KIMBER KABLE
KINERGETICS
KLYNE
MELOS
MERIDIAN
METAPHOR
MICROMEGA
MONITOR AUDIO
MUSE
NAD PARASOUND
PASS LABS
PRESENCE AUDIO
PS AUDIO
PSI REGA RESEARCH
ROTEl
SCI-FI
SIGNET
SOYA
SPENDOR
STAX
STRAIGHT WIRE
TARA LABS
TARGET
TOTEM
TRANSPARENT
UNITY AUDIO
VAC VPI WELL TEMPERED
WHEATON
David Lewis Audio LTD8010 Bustleton Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19152(215) 725-4080 Bank Cards Accepted
,HERE IP( YERACtrit, fiat' Dr_AtArD)
YAWE.
WE De8T WASTE WSIVIERS MoqY
Arrp inq Do THESE Fats.
krif..,n ATLANTIS 4no04.e.ST 3. Vir
liTa. &AST 6,miiTNZAI X58
Ogq. Omar -Ron Sun-Sri..Z[144 Sunlit!) TAe der
ru,rr Tioutg Wimurtou-
6 re .14,3Aiinas a.Or, Teiiiiihur
..0 rrkw rc Aoa ma
cr 14ra,
SC4E-pinri
t9rEAEOBe. 1, reu
Ile Ma.. J
TOLL- FREE
800 456 4434
BIWA as.e.to 41- or lei
1 "We Design YourSystem And
Sare You Money!"FEATURING:
HIGH END AUDIO THEATER SYSTEMS MULTI -ROOM SYSTEMS IN HOME SERVICE EXPERT ADVICE
TRADE-INS ACCEPTEDPROFESSIONAL REPAIRS
.y) It of Sales C Serf it','
201-744-0600
ADIO193 BEU.EVUE AVE., UPPER MONTCLAIR, NJ 07043
NEW YORK
I I (-,1 1...\1)
I 1%14
Serving the senous music love since 1985, wehave realized that High -End Audio hasbecome a confusing term. Random matchingof quality components. will not assure you of asystem that can reproduce music. A call or visitto Audio Outlet will. VVe specialize in productsthat offer exceptional performance and valueGive us a call, lets talkmusic. If you lust wantto know what we sell, callus and ask, or order a copyof our 96 page catalog.It's only $4.00.
jUtD10TLET Inc
914-666-0550 FAX 914-666-0544
VIRGINIA
The Best inHome Grown
Audio. Quad Spcadof Creek Alon Threshold Coda OCM Kimber Magnum MX Cardas Acrotec Epos Tam Labs JoEida
Also featuring high end usedequipment fatly guaranteed!
Hi-Fi FarmTO . NES*I 110ME GROWN AUDIO
616 Plaza, Suite 5, Moneta,Va., 24121Call For Informalion Toll Free
1.800.752.4018
VISIT THESE SPECIALTY RETAILERS FOR PROFESSIONAL CONSULTATION
WISCONSIN
1-800-906-44341 -800 -906 -HI-FI
FAX 608-255-4425Authoried Dealer For:
ADS NILES AUDI - ATLANTIC TECHNOLOGY OMNI-MOUt.' AVIA POLK AUDIO BANG 8 OLUFSEN PSB CARVER PROAC CELESTION RECOTON ENERGY GRADO HARMAN KARDON JVC
SANUS SONY DSS SONY ES SONY VIDEO
LEXICON SENNHEISER MONSTER CABLE TARGET
NAD TERKNAKAMICH THORENS
430 State Si, Madison, WI 53703608-255-2887
WISCONSIN
cAublophile'sOne of the FINEST and LARGEST.
individually owned
AUDIO/VIDEO SALONSIn the Country.
15 Private Listening Roomswith 9 Home Theatre Rooms
Custom Design and InstallationSpecialists for over 22 years.
Sales and Servicefor Wisconsin and the Nation.
2014 Main St. (Hwy.14)Cross Plains, WI 53528
(608) 798-3455
FAX (608) 798-3359
WISCONSIN
giend SellerAuthorized Dealer For:
2808 Cahill Road. P.O. Box 224Marinette. WI 54143
1-800-826-0520
PLEASE NOTE: It is impossible for us toverify all of the claims of advertisers,including product availability and exis-tence of warranties. To confirm that anadvertiser is authorized to sell a product,we suggest you contact the manufacturerdirectly. Please review our Tips for MailOrder Purchasers in this sec:ion.
AUTHORIZED
AUDIOPHILE & SCHOLARUNIVERSITY AUDIO SHOP, MADISON. WI
AUDIO RESEARCH, KRELL. Linn. YBA. Aragon. Acurus.B&K. MARTIN LOGAN. VANDERSTEEN. NHT. PARA-DIGM. Spica. NEAR, Totem. JM Labs. EAD. MicromegaCAL. Golden Tube. Fourier, Tara Labs. Lexicon (6081284-0001 SPECIALS: AMC. Spica & Audio Alchemy.
AUDIO VIDEO SPECIALTIES. Authorized dealer for AMC Arcam Elac Dynaudio Hitachi Jamo Panamax -Pioneer Platinum Proton Audio Sanus Sonographe Tributaries PH: 1414)963-9928. 3801 N. Oakland Ave..Shorewood, WI 53211.
AUDIO UNLIMITED in Colorado offers Accuphase. Acous-tic Energy. Acrotec. AirTight. Airtangent, Audio Meca byPierre Lurne. Audio Note. Basis. Benz -Micro. BitwiseChang. Chario. CODA, Zoelhecus. Day-Sequerra. Dynavec.tor. Ensemble. Graham. Harbeth. Ikeda, JM Labs. Kuzma.Magnum Dynalab. Magro. Micromega. Wilson Benesch.Morch. Musical Design. Music Metre. Muse. SymphonicLine, Onix. RoomTunes. Solid Steel. Sonoran, Sound An-chor, SOTA. Decca, Totem. Unity Audio, Vimak. WheatorTriplaner. YBA and more. .PHONE/FAX John Barnes at(303)691-3407. Audio Unlimited. 2341 West Vale AveEnglewood. CO 80110 VISA and MC accepted.
STEREO WORLD IS YOUR DIS-COUNT SOUND SOURCE DEALS ON. SONY. PYLE. DENON. PROFILE. CLARION. KENWOOD. JVC, HIFONICS.POLK. BLAUPUNKT, PIONEER. SCOSCHE EFX. CARV-ER. KITS. BASSBOXES. AND MUCH MORE, CALL ORWRITE FOR FREE SALES FLYER. FREE UPS! OUR 8THYEAR. VISA/MC: COD. P.O.BOX 596. MONROE. NY10950 19141782-6044.
FOR SALELOW PRICES!!!CALL!!! Velodyne. NHT. Snell, MK,Polk, NAD. Carver. M&K. Parasound. KEF, Nakamichi, ON-KYO, Denon, PSB. Sound Shop CALL, 360-692-8201.
HI Fl EXCHANGE. Large selection of quality USED highendcomponents at huge discounts. We buy. sell & trade. Call forinventory list. (718) 423-0400 or visit our showrooms at251-11 Northern Blvd. Little Neck, NY 11363.
CLEAN POWER, ACPEAM 951A series power line condi.honer improves Sound Image. 30 day money -back guarantyManufacturer direct. Fax or Mail for information. ACPEAMEnt. Inc 416-498-7915. Box 92215, 2900 Warden Avenue.Scarborough. Ontario M1 W3Y9 Canada.
ABARGAIN: STAX SIGN/LAMBDA $1.350: OMEGA'SRMT1 $2.900. SIGN/LAMBDA SRD/7 $499. ED -1: AUDIO-TECHNICA AT -0C9 $259: ALL UNUSED (212)966-1355.
DEMO/TRADE-IN SALE: Onkyo. Pioneer Elite. Rotel.B&K. B&W, ARC, CAL. Martin -Logan, McIntosh, SonicFrontiers. and much, much more. Call for our list of high -quality demo and trade-in components Champagne Au-dio: (2171 355-8828.
SAVE 40% ON HIGH -END home speak-ers. subwoofers. amplifiers. FREE CAT-ALOG. 3021 Sangamon Avenue. Spring-field, IL 62702. 1-800-283-4644.
AUDIO BY VAN ALSTINE FET-VALVE hybrid tube DAC,amplifiers. and preamplifiers achieve ultimate faithfulness tothe spirit of the music. f !mega III active feedback amplifiers.lull function buffered preamplifiers, and technically optimizedparallel processing DACs provide stunning clarity with eco-nomical prices, striated heatsinks, rugged engineering, andno output failures in years, New DAC-preamplifiers. basicline -headphone preamplifiers, and phase inverters or you -PAS, PAT -4, PAT -5, AND ST -70 recycled with AVA circuits(kit or wired) from $199 including new cards and precisioncontrols. Active feedback circuits for DYNACO and HAFLERAMPLIFIER chassis set new standards for transparency. dynamic range. and liquidity. Free illustrated catalog. Audio byVan Alstine. 2202 River Hills Drive. Burnsville, MN 55337(6121 890-3517. Fax (612) 894-3675 Email:avahifi,,, aol.com.
TIPS FOR MAIL ORDERPURCHASERS
It is impossible for us to verify all ofthe claims of advertisers, includingproduct availability and existence ofwarranties. Therefore, the followinginformation is provided for yourprotection.
1. Confirm price and merchandiseinformation with the seller, includingbrand, model, color or finish, acces-sories and rebates included in theprice.2. Understand the seller's returnand refund -policy, including theallowable return period, who pays thepostage for returned merchandise, andwhether there is any "restocking"charge.3. Understand the product's warran-ty. Is there a manufacturer's warranty,and if so, is it from a U.S. or foreignmanufacturer? Note that many manu-facturers assert that, even if theproduct comes with a U.S. manufac-turers warranty card, if you pur-chase from an unauthorized dealer,you are not covered by the manu-facturer's warranty. If in doubt, con-tact the manufacturer directly. Inaddition to, or instead of, the manufac-turer's warranty, the seller may offer itsown warranty. In either case, what iscovered by warranty, how long is thewarranty period, where will the productbe serviced, what do you have to do,and will the product be repaired orreplaced? You may want to receive acopy of the written warranty beforeplacing your order.4. Keep a copy of all transactions,including cancelled checks, receiptsand correspondance. For phoneorders, make a note of the orderincluding merchandise ordered, price,order date, expected delivery date andsalesperson's name.5. If the merchandise is not shippedwithin the promised time or if no timewas promised, 30 days of receipt ofthe order, you generally have the rightto cancel the order and get a refund.6. Merchandise substitution withoutyour express prior consent is notallowed.7. If you have a problem with yourorder or the merchandise, write aletter to the seller with all the pertinentinformation and keep a copy.8. If you are unable to obtain satis-faction from the seller, contact theconsumer protection agency in theseller's state or your local Post Office.
If, after following the above guide-lines, you experience a problem witha mail order advertiser that you areunable to resolve, please let us know.WRITE to Susan Ross, SpecialMarketing, 45th floor, HachetteFilipacchi Magazines, 1633 Broadway,NY, NY 10019. Be sure to includecopies of all correspondence.
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199691
FOR SALE
A NEW TONEARM IN 1995?
THE RESURGENCE IN ANALOG DESERVES THEULTIMATE IN TONEARM DESIGNS.
JMW MEMORIAL TONEARM
DESIGNED TO BE LONGER, SIMPLER, AND BETTER SOUNDINGTHAN ANY OTHER TONEARM IN THE WORLD.
VF1IND.,INC.,77CUFFWOOD AVE *3B.CLIFFW001). N.J.07721 PHONE 908-946-8606 FAX: 9C6-946-8578
AUDIO NEXUS = QUALITYFeaturing legendary VANDERSTEEN loudspeakers &ROTEL Components.
AMC Apogee Audio Alchemy Audioquest AudioSta-tic Cardas CaryCWD EAD Epos ExposureFanfare Forte Fned Golden Tube Grado JM Lab Kimber Kinergetics Lightspeed Magnum-Dynalab McCormack Melos Monarchy Nakamichi PSB Rotel Jeff Rowland Vandersleen VPI. SUMMIT, NJ(908)277-0333
Hardbound AUDIO, annual bound volume editions, )uslike the ones in the Editor -in -Chiefs office. Various yearsavailable in limited quantities. $40.00 each. Also availableHardbound October Annual Equipment Directories. Years1992, 1991, 1990, 8 1987 $15.95 each. and hardbound MayCar Stereo Directories for years 1991, 1990. 1989 and 1985.$8.00 each. All prices include postage and handling. All or-ders postpaid. Check or money order only (no credit cardorders) payable to AUDIO MAGAZINE. Send orders to AU-DIO. 1633 Broadway. New York. N.Y 10019. Attn: MichaelBieber, Or call 212/767-6301 for further information.
MUSICAL CONCEPTS CD SOUNDENIGMA. -Smooth. Transparent" $695: EPOCH. Se-ductive. Natural!" $995; Highly -Reviewed CDT -4 trans-port $695 --Musical Concepts has put the fun back intoCD playback." says The Audio Adventure. Audio Al-chemy mods. including DLC $99 -up. Marantz and Pi-oneer CD mods. Musical Concepts. 5749 Westwood DrSt. Charles, MO 63304. (314) 447-0040.
AUDIO CABLES & MORE
DON'T PAY EXORBITANT PRICES! FOR TOP QUALITY !
We have equaled the high-priced brands. Sonicequivalents at a fraction of their cost. We demysti-fy wire technology. Ask for literature.
AND MORE! DACS. Anti -Jitter Units, CDPlayers/Transports, Speaker Stands. Speakers.Home Theater, Prologic, Accessories-& MORE.Call 800.321-2108 24hrs./day for free catalog.
L A T INTERNATIONAL.Dept. A 317 Provincetown Road
Cherry Hill. NJ (181134
HYPE! HYPE! HYPE!We've delivered something different for 16 years -natural, musical results! Adcom, 138K and Haller mod-ifications, rivaling expensive components. AdcomGFA-555 Ihru 5800 mods-Adcom preamps. tuner/preampsi Powerful. transparent BSA mods. NEW! PA -2cascoded circuitry for Haller amps -budget bliss! Su-perConnect interconnect -naturalness, not hype! Mu-sical Concepts. 5749 Westwood Dr.. St. Charles. MO63304 (314) 447-0040.
ENJOY JITTER -FREE MUSIC! AT $549 FOR THE BASICPLAYER AND $649 FOR THE REFERENCE ONE TRANS-PORT. WE HAVE BROKEN THE PRICE BARRIER. ISO-LATED STABLE CLOCK MODULES AND OTHER UP-DATES STILL AVAILABLE. DEALER INQUIRIESWELCOME. G8D TRANSFORMS. (602) 650.1155
ACOUSTICS 101 teaches how to construct recording stu-dios, including matenals recommendations & diagrams. Top-res. walls, ceilings. floors. HVAC. doors 8 more. Betterbottom -line advice than you'll find anywhere else! Send$11.95 ck/mo to USAFoam, 11571 E. 126th. Fishers, IN46038 (3171842-2600
DJ & NightclubSound, Lighting & Video CATALOG
FREE 88 -Page Catalog with ahuge selection of name brandprofessional gear for DJ's.Clubs & Musicians all atdiscount prices!
Call Today800-945-9300
Mail Order Center 11711 Monarch St
Garden Grove. CA92641
Retail Super Store 13110149n
Garde, CA ,2&44 ."4
PRO SOUND OUR 20th& STAGE LIGHTING'. YEAR!
B&O B&W CARVER DENON FOSGATE H/K KEF LEXICON NAD NAKAMICHI ONKYO POLK VELODYNE 24 HOUR AU-TOMATED PRICING MANUFACTURERSWARRANTIES COURTEOUS ASSISTANCE AMERICAN THEATER SYSTEMS (904)321-0100
AVDIO CLASSICS, LTD.Buys -Sells -Trades -Repairs
I'ondcn 1128 9i Partial ListinB
. _34 Gardiner Place. PO176AAA, Walton, NY 13856
8AM-5PM Mon -Fri 607-865-7200FAX: 607-865-7222
M. Mint, EX.Excellent G.Good. F= air, P.Poor AI=As Is.BO=Best Otter : AMPLIFIERS: Accuphase P26VX1$999.Acoustat TNT120(EX) 5349 Air Tight TM2( ) $6129Aragon 2004-II(EX $699 Audio Research Corp D76A(G)5995, D100A(EX S550 $598,ST2020/BAL(N) 598 B6W MPA1 pr 98,CarverAV405(EX) $599, AV634(13 $469, SILVER -9T( X) $1499,TFM6CB(D) $361 TFMS5CB(D) $429 TFM35X(D) $699,TFM75 $1589-1759, carry CAD40M-MKII(D) $1499,CAD300B(N) S1995 CADWNEX) $4995 SLA70-MKII(N)$995 Classe DR25(EX) $2199, CM Labs 80MRM(F) $499,Conrad -Johnson MF80(D) $999 MVIEXAA718(169MV5yX $1299 Counter 2C )
( 1 96 SOLID -2(D1 $1,399, Crown$3199, PL E.X) 5595. PS200(G) 5649,PS400(EX)$799, Denon 0A5000(N) $799 Golden Tube
Audio SE N) $980, Kinergetos KBA75 51197-1495 KrellKAV500/51M $2995 KMA160CE_X $3499 KMA21:5)8rX)$4395 KSA M) 52339, KSA100 M) 53750, KSA1 EX)53039 KSA200 EX)S4595. KSA S(EX)_$5795 LazurusMARK-III-LAZ(EX 51995, McIntosh 50W2(1 5599,MACKIT(EX1 51 , MC40(EX) 5999 MC60 750-999MC225 5999-1495 MC240(EX) $1995 MC250 52-399.MC275 $2000-4995, MC502 5549-599, ki1C752(EA) .5669,MC2100 $299-449, MC2105 5399-899, MC2120 5699-799,MC2150(G) $899, MC2255(EX) $2499, MC73001EX) $9Motrf MS100(EX) $1399 Nobis CANTABILE(D) 51499, 0CMBI(EX) $349, OCM500(0) $2099. Rotel RB970BX(D) $299,Sunfire SUNFIRE(N) $2175, Threshold S500(EX) $1995.VAC PA45C(EX) 51899, V70-MKII(D) $2385 CASSETTEDECKS: Carver TD1770(N) $489, Denon DN770R(N) $699.DRS810(N) $449 DRW840(N) 5399 CD PLAYERS: CALTEMPEST-115E(Ek) $995. Carver SD/A360(0) 5396-415SDA370(D) $519, Denon DN650F(N) $869, DN961FA(D)$1499, Kinergetics KCD40(EX) $1495 Krell KPS20I(EX)$5839 McIntosh MCD7000 53-500, MCD7005(EX) $999,MCDI007 $1499, Nakamichi OMS7(EX) $299. RotelRCD96513X(D) $449 CD PROCESSORS: Ara D2A-II$999 Audio Alchemy CALL Audio M34LU ) $2700,Audio Research Corp DAC1- EX) $1 99, KrellREFERENCE-64iEX))) $7499, S Pr2X(EX) $1499STEALTH.(E_ X) 1339. STUDIO $1995-2169, MERIDIAN)203(EX) $299, roceed PDP2(EX) $899, Theta DS-PRO-PRIME(EX) $5. Wadia DIGIMASTER-64X(EX) $1799 CDTRANSPOR SBAudo Alchemy DDS-III(D) $719, CECTL1(EX) $2970, Krell MD2AC(EX) $2169. MD10(M) $3995,Proceed PDT(EX) $749 EQUALIZERS: Audio ControlCALL, McIntosh MQ101 5149-250 M0104 $99-249 M01075349-699 MXR 124(0 ) $357 Shure SR107(EX) $299.GUITAR AMPS: Ampeg GS12R(EX) 5499, ART 490(EX)$499 SWR BABY-BLUE(EX) $399 GUITARS: FenderTELECASTER(M) 51199, Rokenbacker 325JL(M) $1199HEADPHONES: Stax Grado CALL INTEGRATED AMPS:Carver CMV1185(N) $850, Marantz THIRTY(EX) $449.McIntosh MA5100 5199-499, MA6100(EX) $649 TandbergTIA3012(EX) $399 PARTS: McIntosh Thousands in stockPRE-PREAMPS: CALL PREAMPLIFIERS: Air TightATC2(D)_ $4666. Aragon 24KSP(EX) 5599, Audio ResearchCorp LS1(EX) 5995, SP3A1(EX) $999, SP EX) $550,SP14(EX) $1995, AVP2000(N) 5775 BediniBC800(EX) 5749, Cary $1350, SLP94P $1599-1799, Carver CIIN) $329 C D) 5399, C15V(0) $699
C2OV 5509-84 C4000(EX) $399, CaryCAD5 EX1 5799, Coda 01P(13.1 5_2289, Conrad -JohnsonPV5(EX) 79 Counterpoint SA1000(EX) $799, SA5000(M)$2649. SA-1(EX) $499 Golden Tube Audio SEP1(N) $889,Harman Kardon CITATION -I 5199-499, Krell KBL $1995-2669 KRC2(M) 51669, KSL2(M)..$1995 KSIAEXA $1399,KSP7B(EX) 1299. Marantz 7(EX) $3999, TT $399-499,McIntosh C8 599-250. C11 EX) $1995, C20 $750-1399 C2251495-2495, C24 5199-349, C26(EX) 5399, C27(G) S699.C28 5299-549 C29(EX) $999 C32 5799-1099 C33 1399-1499 C34V(EX.) $1499, C36(M) $999, C37 X) $1995,cup $1849, CR7LEX)1299- 99, Music and und DCC1(EX $499 Nobis PROTEUS(D) $1499_ Precision Fidet4C8( I) $349 Presence Audio LINE-STAGE-1(EX) 51920,Rotel RC980BX(DA $399, Soundstream C 10EX) $399SUMO HL1(EX) 350 Superphon REVELATION-Il$399, VAC V1NTA E-L1NE(D) 51249, VTL ULTIMATE EX$995 PROCESSORS: Audio Control CALL dbx CALL,Marantz AX1000 $1500-5995 RECEIVERS: CarverHR742(D) $519, HR895(D) $999, Denon AVR900(N) $430,McIntosh MAC4100 51099-1199 RECORD CLEANERS: VPIHW 16 5(D) $375 SPEAKER CABLES: Audioguest, CardasCALL Transparent Cable MWU8(EX) $999 SPEAKERS:AR CLASSIC -12(D) $399, Apogee CALIPER-SIG(N) $1995CENTAUR 5999-1250, CO $1169, DUETTA-StGIN)54995 IN -WALL -3(N) 51399, MINOR( $799, RIBBON-LCR(D) $669 RIBBON-MONITOR(D) $429, SLANT-6(EX)v$1589 SLANT -8 52729, STAGE 52496-3295 B8.DM640(it S899 B80 RL45 2(NOS) $299, Bose5999 zak E4000(EX) $749, Carver PLATINUM(EX$1699, Clements 107D1CD) 5339. 5474, 20801.1(N5598, RICHTER(N) $579, Energy 5 1E D) 5499, GenesisGENRE-II(D) $499_ JBL 4412A(D) $11 $1995,JM Lab $595, Joseph Audio RAPS! N $1499,KEF LS3/5A-SIG ) $1299, °RECO] $1800, ) $599,TWO(N) 52 , CORNWALL(EX1 $995,KUPSCHORN White McIntosh ML1C 5499-899ML2C 512-1800, ML4 ) $1995, XR5(EX) 5995, XR16(G$499 XR19 52995-4 XR230(M) $849 XR240($1199. MIRAGE M5(EX) $999, Ohm 4XVX $999.Platinum SOLO(D) $2495 Sound Lab PRISTINE(D)ID $2995Syntheso LM260A(D) $839, With!, Audio SIGNATURE -3(D)S599, Vandersteen 2CE(EJ, 5999. Wilson AuchoPUPPY(EX) $3475, WATT-III(E SUB -WOOFERS:BIC V12(N) 5399, Velodyne 1 N_)_ $899, F1200(EX)5799, F1200R(N) $995 F1500R(N) $1 95 ULD-15-1I $1699-1859 59, ULD-18-11(N) $2519, VA1012(D) $519, VA1215(D)$749 TAPE DECKS: Revox A77 $399-599, A700(F) 5499TEST EQUIPMENT: CALL TONER MS: CALL TUBES:CALL TUNER PREAMPS: Carver CT3(D) $379 CT6(D)McIntosh
CT7(D) 5469 CT27V(D) 5679 CT29V(0) $959,McIntosh MX110 S199-1699, MX112 5399-449_, MX113 5499-599, MX114 $399-499, MXI17(EX) 51099, RotelRTC940AX(N) $379 RTC950AX(10). _5479 TUNERS:Accuphase 7107 G) $419 T109(D) $2799, Ei&K TSI N)$398 Carver 7X110 A99-775 Day SequerraFREFERENCE((DD $4790, Jensen AVS2100(EX)$299,Ma_g_num- nalab ETUDE 5839-1299 F2051317(D)$259. FT101B1 (EX) $499 FT-R(D) $398 McIntoshMR55&A 5299-1000 MR65A&131399-999 MR66 299-799MR67 $399-799, MR71 5199-1299, MR7EX) $499, PAR7E15999-1995 MR80 V099-1599 M 500 _5549-649MR510(EX) MR7083(M) $1299 Onkyo T9090-11(0 )
$725. Perreaux TU3(EX) $499 Rotel RT950BX(N) 5299.Soundstream T 1(EX) 5299 TURNTABLES: DenonDP7F(N) $280. Sofa MOONBEAM(N) $379 VPI TNT -3(D)$4166 VIDEO EQUIPMENT: Denon LA3000(D) $360
Al 111(1 I I IIRI \Itl
FOR SALE LOUDSPEAKERS
SINGERS!REVOMCOALSVE
Unlimited. Low Cost, Instantly AvailableBackground Music from Original StandardRecordings! Does Everything Karaokedoes... /3etter and _gives you the
PmreemrZure & Demo Tape..Vocal Eliminator"'
LT Sound Dept AU -7988 LT ParkwayLithonia, GA 3005824 Hour Demo/Info Request Line ( )482.245 Eat 51When You Want Somethin Better Than Karaokel
MONEYSPENT SOUNDLYAUDIO EXCELLENCE,
TN kr Pall &VIM Emma Fri Au Pam komAcimenDEMON NASA/ANN ONKYO
SONY ES YAMAHA BOSE UPS=KEF POLK AND MORE!
SPECIALISTS IN HOME THEATRE SYSTEMS & 111611 -ENO
INC.
AUDIO
CALL Now (212) 229-1622143 West Mb Streak Now York, NY 10001All Major Credit Cards Accepted
FREE SHIPPING! PLUS:EXPERIENCED, FRIENDLY ADVICE! MIRAGE, PS,CWD, KEF, KINERGETICS, PHILIPS, AUDIOQUEST,FRIED, MONSTER, KIMBER KABLE, SPICA, CARY.STRAIGHTWIRE, QUAD. MORE! READ BROTHERS,593 KING. CHARLESTON, SC 29403. (803)723-7276.
STEVE'S CONSIGNMENTSHOP HI Fl FARM AND STEVE'S AUDIO ADVICENOW OFFERS CONSIGNMENT OPPORTUNITIES FORTHE USED AUDIO MARKET. TOP DOLLAR OFFERED.CALL FOR INFORMATION. NEW EQUIPMENT ALSO.CALL 1-800-752-4018.
FOR TWENTY YEARS WE HAVE BEEN THE SOURCEFOR ALL OF YOUR BLANK AUDIONIDEO TAPES ANDACCESSORIES, EVEN REEL-TO-REEL TAPES FOR STU-DIOS, AT DISCOUNTED PRICES. CATALOG AVAILABLE.SOUND INVESTMENT CORPORATION, 3586 PIERCEDRIVE. CHAMBLEE, GA 30341. (800) 659 -TAPE (8273), INGA (770) 458-1679. FAX: (770) 458-0276.
LOUDSPEAKERSLOUDSPEAKER COMPONENT - KITS. Audio Concepts.Dynaudio. Eclipse, Eton, LPG, Vifa. more! Crossover pans,design books & repairs. Catalog $2.00. MENISCUS. 257528th St.. S. W., Dept. A. Wyoming. MI 49509. (616)534-9121.
STATE OF THE ART CROSSOVER NETWORKS.UPGRADE ANY SPEAKER. SOFTWARE AVAILABLEFREE DESIGN GUIDE. ALLPASS TECHNOLOGIES. INC .2844 CHARMONT DR.. APOPKA. FL 32703-5972. (407)786-0623.
CUSTOM ACTIVE ELECTRONIC CROSSOVERS. 6 to 36dB/Oct. Also Snell, Magnepan versions DB SYSTEMS.POB 460, RINDGE, NH 03461. (603) 899-5121.
LOUDSPEAKER CABINETS Large selection of excellentquality loudspeaker cabinets for custom builders and deal-ers. Grenier Cabinets. 189 Jennings Road, Horseheads, N.Y.14845(607)594-3838.
D.I.V. NEW FOAM KITSFun TECHNOS AND Ti i it DoN'T KNOWS.
Ew_FOAMCALL TOLL FREE
Speaker Repair oc.. Replacement Parts A,'I\ Nationwide Service Since 1979
1 -800 -NEW -FOAM 1-800-639-3626 NATIONWIDESPEAKER REPAIR, PARTS, AND ACCESSORIES. Call uswith your speaker problems. VISA/MC/AMEX/DISC.
ROTTEN FOAM EDGES?SIMPLY SPEAKERSdoes professional foam replace-ments any size/brand. 7 Year Warranty. We sell DIYFoam Surround Kits for less! Speaker reconing. MC/VISAJDISCOVER/AME X- 1-800-767-4041.
8....cooes,t3cieS r atakOg
,SerGe'OP" fee
"...reach -out -and -touch -it realism."NY Times 800-783-1553 Ohm Acoustics Cor-poration. 241 Taafe Place. Brooklyn. NewYork 11205. FAX (718) 857-2472.0I-IMSPEAKER(a AOL.COM
TRUE SUBWOOFERWith phenomenaltrue deep bassextending below20Hz with lowdistortion at a veryaffordable price.The HRSWI2Vwill extend thebass of yourstereo or videosystem for that"air shaking allaround you"effect. HSU Research NRSW12V
Here's what experts are saying about the HRSW12V:the Hsu has to be considered an outstanding bargain
Robert Deutsch. Stereophle Guide to Home TheaterVol t No 2.1995
'Prodigious sass that shakes the walls' 'one heck of athunder buster
John E Johnson, Jr Secrets of Home These° andHigh hdelay, May 1ee5
' this woofer achieves a combination of extremely quickspeed and gut massaging bass impact that I have seldomexpenenced from any subwoofer'
Peter Michell. Stereophde Vd 18 No 1. January 1995
'has developed an enviable reputation in its few short yearsof existence'
Thomas J Wow. Sarnaiones Gad* to Hone trace Vo 1 No 1. 1495
'Hsu's HRSW12V is a wonderful subwoofer It's goodlooking and simple to use, and its performance invitesnothing less than superlatives. especially given its poop'
Torn Nousaine, Sound a Image. February Marcn +995
'The HRSW 2V is one of the most potent subwoolen we haveused Scoicall, it is all one could wish lac and the pace Is right
Aiken Hirsch. Stereo Review, December 1994
' all of the nonboomy. stomach-rnasseging Dais energy wascoming horn a single 12 -inch powered subwoolet
Peter lAtchell. Sfereophole Vol 17 No 4, April 1994
' delivered enough punch to shake the sturdiest shellBrent Butterworth, Video Magrairie, April 1994
Send for lull details on the 12V and the new 10V.Mlle [a catHSU RESEARCH14946 Shoemaker Ave Unit LSanta Fe Sonngs. CA 906701-800-554-0150 (Voice)1-310-404-3848 (Votce/Fax)
Sold factory direct with a 30 dew trial - money backguarantee 5 year manufacturer's detect warranty
HSU
Repair Foam Rot Yourself! Save hundreds of dollars %Wong kit. Kits to fit any speaker - Advent. AR.
AL. Bose. Infin EV etc Inc surrounds. adhesive 8 instructions MC / VISA / Discover No CODs Call last for Best Price Order by phone 24 hrs 704-697-9001
or call Toll Free 800-747.3692P 0 Box 1088 Flat Rock. NC 28731
STEPPAU010 TECHNOLOGIES
SOLENEUROPEAN SPEAKERDRIVER UNITS CATALOG
Nea.laawli
A
AIR t.CRNI
LA PASSION OU HAUT-PARLEURC ar.
ea, low A
WNAUDIO
1;"
peerltss
scan-speaKseas
SOLEN CROSSOVERCOMPONENTS CATALOGUES
REPTA-UTZ INDUCTORSPERFECT LAY HEXAGONALWINDING
STANDARD INDUCTORSPERFECT LAY HEXAGONALWINDING
FAST CAPACITORSMETALLIZEDPOLYPROPYLENE
SOLEN CROSSOVER &SPEAKER PARTS
SOLEN INC.4470 Ave. ThibaultSt -Hubert QC J3Y 7T9Canada
Tel: 514-656-2759Fax: 514-443-4949
Catalogue US$8.00 Refundable
(;),
<co
coin
A -I(iv -
Ooi
ejnZ
PG)
In
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199693
In
Inmu)
Z10O
(1)2)in
CrW00
cl?
CL;<
MDY-4New and improved!Audio enthusiasts have long known
that a Dynaudio two way system is aneffective way to create quality soundwithout creating significant debt. Incomparison with any system at anyprice, the combination of the Dynaudio17cm woofer with the incomparable28mm tweeter is exceptional in all ofthese areas:
Dynamic range Transient attackSmooth Reproductionresponse of the humanPhase and voicefrequency Lack offidelity compression.
To be fair, these modest drive unitscannot produce infrabass (those fre-quencies below 50 Hz), but in the other99.75% of recorded material, they equalproducts that cost 10 to 30 times asmuch.
Madisound is proud to introduce afurther refinement of this combination,the MDY-4. This quality kit uses high orderfilters to eliminate sweet spots in the off -axis response. The imaging is excep-tional, a result of precise phase and timedelay, refined in a sophisticated 14 ele-
I /WM 06 E. D-28/2
ment filter. Every part is of the highestquality; every detail is the culmination ofthree years of careful analysis.
Best of all, the MDY-4 is modestlypriced. The complete system with oakveneer cabinets in either a clear finish orblack stained finish, is $595. Cabinets arefinished, and the system can be assem-bled in one evening. Hundreds of satis-fied music lovers have built and cherishthe earlier Image Systems, and now Dy-naudio and Madisound have taken an-other step toward Audio Perfection. Isn'tit time for you to build a standard toevaluate your success as a SpeakerBuilder?
16" tall x 9" wide x IT' deep on bottom / 8.5" deep on top.- --ME111111=EN1111111111111111111111M1
ME11111=MMIIII =ER111111E111MUM 1=MOIII11111111111111111111gip! ig.1111111111MMIll
111111S11111-111111 UIIlllllll
IIMM1111111111111111111111111M1111111111111111111111111=
Madisound Speaker Components(8608 University Green)
P.O. Box 44283Madison, WI 53711 U.S.A.
Tel: 608-831-3433Fax: 608-831-3771
LOUDSPEAKERSVMPS factory assembled speakers. Lowest Prices,shipped direct to you. Free Price sheet. Arthur Morgan. 886East Charing Cross Cir . Lake Mary. FL 32746
ELECTROSTATICSPEAKER KITS. PARTS. TRADE SECRETS. SAVE MON-EY BUILDING. REPAIRING. MODIFYING. CATALOG/START-UP MANUAL -$5.00. DAVID LUCAS. DEPT. A. 924HULTON ROAD. OAKMONT, PA 15139.
$400 OFF PAIR OF JBL 4312 STUDIO MONITOR SPEAK-ERS! USED BY 70°90F ALL RECORDING STUDIOS FORMIXING AND EVALUATION. 3 -WAY WITH 12" WOOFER. 5"MIDRANGE 8 DOME TWEETER. 100 WATT CAPACITY.$499/PAIR! ORIGINAL REPRODUCTION HARTSFIELD085s 55999/PAIR. SHIPPED WORLDWIDE. VISA/MC. HALCOX, 1947. (415) 388-5711, FAX (415) 388-3359. 164 TA-MALPAIS AVENUE. MILL VALLEY. CA 94941. SAN FRAN-CISCO AREA.
CD PLAYERSDIGITAL OR ANALOG? You've invested a lot in your sys-tem-- don't let awful digital sound ruin it. Now available: thenew Daniels Audio Zero -One CD Player, "the closest thing toanalog". Stands sonically shoulder -to -shoulder with Spec-tral, Levinson and Theta, but costs only $750. Recent ravereviews in Chicago Tribune, other publications. No -obligationin -home audition. Also available: 5 -disc CD Changer, $798:phase coherent cables. Phone. FAX or write Daniels AudioCorporation. 178 North Ridgeland, Oak Park. IL 60302. FAX312/263-2335, phone 708/383-3319.
COMPACT DISCS
CD SAVER $24.95Save your scratched cd's w/CD SAVER - simple &
easy to use - save time & money - repair up to 10 cd'sTo order call 1-800-864-7357 (VISA, MC, & Discover)
or send check or money order toJ&S Company P.O. Box 2161 Opelika AL 36801-2161
'Allow 4.6 weeks for delivery/add $3 50 for 5.5H
RECORDSLV/CD/RECORD COLLECTOR'S SUPPLIES. Jewel boxes.record lockets. sleeves. storage boxes. 78 sleeves, dividers,much more! Free brochure. CABCO PRODUCTS. ROOM663, POB 8212, COLUMBUS, OH 43201. (614) 267-8468.
PRESERVE ENHANCE RESTOREWe Sell Audio Dynamite'
From Spinning 78's To The Outer Limits of Hi -Fidelity! FreeCatalog KAB Electro-Acoustics. PO. Box 2922, Plain-field. NJ 07062-0922. 908-754-1479.
HALF MILE VINYL. Large Inventory Quality Preowened LP'scleaned and graded. Send SASE for catalog to Box 98. EastWareham. MA 02538. Call 508-295-2508:
AUDIOPHILE RECORDS
Analogue ProductionsMobile Fidelity - Wilson
Reference Recording CheskySheffield Lab Rarmonia Mundi
Propnus RCA living Stereo KiwierMercury Living Presence plus Many more
in and out 01 punt recordings'
Catalog $3 In USA, $5 elsewhere refundable
visaACOUSTIC SOUNDS 1-800-525-1630
P 0 BOX 2043 SAUNA. KS 674022043MasterCard 1-913-825-8609 FAX 1113-825-0156
EST CHIPS-boards
AUDIOPHILE RECORDS
BEST VINYL RECORD SOURCE! Subscription servicewith free records -Classic Records. EMI, Decca. Sup-er Analogue. Volume discounts. monthly specials, andmore! THE VINYL VALET. DEPT. AU, 509 W. 15THSTREET. TEMPE. AZ 85281. (602)829-8537: fax (602)968-8382.
WANTED TO BUY
CASH for USED AUDIO & VIDEO EQUIP.BUYING and SELLING by PHONE. CALL forHIGHEST QUOTE. (215) 886-1650 Since1984. The Stereo Trading Outlet, 320 OldYork Road, Jenkintown, PA 19046.WANTED: WESTERN ELECTRIC. JBL. MARANTZ OLDEQUIPMENT. SUNLIGHT ENGINEERING COMPANY:310-320-7020. 22130 SOUTH VERMONT AVENUE. #A.TORRANCE. CA 90502.
MARANTZ & ALL VINTAGE EQUIPMENT, HIGH -END. Noone pays MORE. working or not! N.YS I. (718) 377-7282.2-6pm. WEEKDAYS:
Integrated buyer, David Yo, since 1977 always buying: vin-tage tube Marantz. McIntosh. ARC, Quad. Leak. Vintagespeakers. units from Western Electric. JBL. EV. Jensen. AI-tec. Tannoy. Thorens TD -124. Garrard 301. PO. Box 80371San Marino. Ca 91118-8371 Tel 818/441-3942.
WANTED, WANTED: AVID 101 SPEAKERS, DRIVERS.V.G. CONDITION? -EXCELLENT PRICE. TONY: (215)425-3260. PENNSYLVANIA. WILL DRIVE!
AUDIO CLASSICS BUYS -SELLS -TRADES -REPAIRSHigh End Audio Components. CALL for a quote. See our ad atthe beginning of the classifieds. AUDIO CLASSICS, LTD..POB 176WI3. Walton, NY 13856. Phone. 607-865-72008AM-5PM EST Mon. -Fri.. FAX: 607-865-7222.
WANT - JBL Hartsfield, EV Patrician, Brociner, Tran-scendent Singles OK. McIntosh. Marantz & other tubeequipment. Larry Dupon. 2638 W. Albion, Chicago, IL 60645.(312) 338-1042. evenings.
COLLECTOR, PAYING TOP PRICE WILL TRAVEL, to pickup, working or not. MONO/Stereo tube MARANTZ. McIn-tosh. TANNOY Spkrs, B&W, Sequerra Tuner. KRELL.Levinson, etc. (718)387-7316 or (718)383-3205. NEWYORK.
CABLE TV
LINK YOURSELF TO THE FUTURE WITH OUREXPERIENCE! CABLE TV CONVERTERS &DESCRAMBLERS. QUALITY, SERVICE &SATISFACTION GUARANTEED! VISA/MC/AMEX/C.O.D. ACCEPTED. QUANTITY DIS-COUNTS. CABLE LINX, INC., MIN-NEAPOLIS, MN: 1-800-501-0095.
A-415=311'TECHNOLOG\F_S
CABLE T V CONVERTERSDESCRAMBLE RS
all 310 500CHT -2000
MM -2000 to 2500
TO ORDER CALL 1-800-700-3947
CABLE T.V. CONVERTERS & ACCESSORIES. FairPrices, Quality Service, & 14 years Experience Gives UsThe ADVANTAGE. CALL 1-800-952-3916 Visa/MC/Amex/Disc/COD. ADVANTAGE ELECTRONICS. INC., 1125 Riv-erwood Dr., Burnsville, MN 55337. MEMBER OF NCCA.
CABLE T.V. CONVERTERS & DE -SCRAMBLERS: Replacements for mostmodels. 30 Day Trial -1 Year Warranty!Dealer Inquiries Invited. Visa/MC/Disc/Amex/COD FOR QUALITY, PRICE & SER-VICE CALL: 1-800-259-1187. Eagle Elec-tronics Inc., #1, 1301 Railhead Blvd.,Naples, FL 33963. No Florida Sales.
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199694
CABLE TV PARTS AND ACCESSORIES PUBLICATIONS
REVOLUTIONARY TECHNOLOGY. Does all Boxes - ForFree Catalog Please Call Mega Electronics 1-8001676-6342.
WE'LL BEAT ANY PRICE ON CABLE CONVERTERS &DESCRAMBLERS. SAVE ON EQUIPMENT, CABLE RENT-AL FEES, & CONNECTION CHARGES. STEALTHS, M-80,PIONEER, ETC. DEALER INQUIRES WELCOME. VISA/MASTERCARD/DISCOVER/C.O.D. QUALITY ENTER-TAINMENT 1(800) -72 -BOXES.
CABLE TV CONVERTERS & DE -SCRAMBLERS. SAVE MONEY! CALL USLAST FOR THE BEST PRICES!! ALLBRANDS. 24 HOUR SHIPPING. VISA/MC/AMEX/C.O.D. QUANTITY DISCOUNTS. VID-EO CONNECTIONS INC. 1-800-677-0321.
CABLE TV MEDESCRAMBLERS Best Buys
IINTELESTAR W t
BFeuslit SarerarynICye
800-835-2330SERVICES
ACCUPHASEAUTHORIZED SERVICE AND PARTS for all Accuphaseproducts. Contact: ACCUTECH, 206 E. Star of India Lane,Carson, CA 90746. TEL. (310) 324-7406, FAX (310)324-7422. Hours: 9am-4pm Pacific Time.
Amplifier Maintenance Specialists. All manufacturersFlat rate repairs and preventive maintenance on Dynaco.Haller and Phase Linear. Midwest Power, FAX/Phone614-351-0895. CompuServe 102461 3601
Audio Equipment Built, Repaired, Modified and Restoredby Richard Modafferi. independent consultant to Audio Clas-sics. Ltd., inventor, and former Senior Engineer at McIntosh.AUDIO CLASSICS, LTD. POB 176RTM. Walton. NY 13856Phone: 607-865-7200 8AM-5PM EST Mon -Fri . FAX:607-865-7222
TUBE COMPONENTS
SOUND VALVESAFFORDABLE TUBE COMPONENTS! (Seeour display ad October AUDIO.) Quality 100%Made -in -USA designs by Harry Klaus. Pre -amps $699 -up; Amplifiers $899 -up. MO-SFET: Amplifiers $499 -up. Factory -directsales welcomed! UPS COD. 30 -day satisfac-tion guarantee. Sound Valves, 185 North YaleAvenue, Columbus, Ohio 43222-1146. Pho-ne:61 4-2 79-23 83, 10-4 EST; Fax:614-279-0368.
Premium Grade PartsDon't Pay More!
Absolutely the best selection of audiophile grade pat fair prices Extensive deep in Stock inventfeaturing these vendors and many more. Free cat.,MIT MULTICAP, WONDER CAP, SoLEN, SCR, REL.,NICHICON MUSE, BLACK GATE, CADDOCK, VISHAY, M.HOLCO, Resis-rs, TDK, ALPS, NOBLE, EAR, DEFIER PvC.ARDAS, KB-1BU, ACROTECH, & pure silver chassis v.!'HIDCFRED diodes, Sow foil inductors, all types ofconnectors, silver contact toggle & rotary swit.stepped attenuator kits, hospital grade plugs, to!tools, IC's, super selection of damping materials 8:IntemationaVoverseas orders are especially weld !'Phone (415) 6(9-7181 or fax ( ' - '.69-7558 for a caul, ,f.tMichael Percy, Box 528. I i s erness, CA 94937
5
w
...audible results with the finestin connecting components!
SOUND C ONNECTIONS INTERNATIONAL INC203 Flagship Dr -Lutz, FL USA ::-3549
PH 813-948-2707 Fax: 813-944-2907
WhenPigs fly.
TheParts Connection Catalog 8 ResourceGuide. Volume 2
No n.iityr r just a parts cataiog. out an usst.,'t a.resource guile for those DIY projects We rave adder:whole slew of new products. an expanded selection atpremium tubes from Golden Dragon, Audio Glassic andSovtek plus directly heated triodes like the newly manu-factured Western Electric 300B and the Vaic ValveW308 More transformers l'or^ Magnequest. Plitron andHammon. Js cable and moofrom all t.. ..ss
T The Parts Connection Catalog 8Resource Guide. Volume 2 , scow
Sena $10 dlang wilt your rIci ' g doct,c, L.credit card information
THE PARTSCONNECTION' POMPOM OP SONIC PPOPPPOPIO
TG Pro. Order Line
(4
1-800-769-0747,5..c.-y,2790 Brighton Road. Oakville. Ontario. Canada L6H 5T4Telephone 19051829.5858 Facsimile (9051 P29-5388a -mad TPG0sonictronters cornWWW htlp /nwiw.sonicfronbers com/TPC
Build a better loudspeaker...than anything you can buy!
Speaker Builder can show you how.Fax your request for a FREE ISSUE to
603-924-9467 orwrite to: PO Box 494 Dept AU6,
Peterborough, NH 03458-0494 USA
BLANK TAPES
1 -800 -TAPE WORLD or 1-800-245-600095 SHIPPING FREE CAT.
DAT-1 2) 599DAT-60 40CDAT-12...c ,T -120V
1.15081F -GCDR -71/ P I 'I
VX1.11-90 1 5;YLH-S 90 19s
! '20 HGX 2 4:21 69c
- 5.947.9c
9C
'DK FUJI-1)HQ 2.79S-1120 6.49
-81160 8.99-'20 599
TAPE WORLD no WING St BMA PA IMO Oa 1221.112911'4E9ENT SAME DAY SHIPPING M -F
BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIESMAKE YOUR DREAM COME TRUE. EARN $90.000 YEAR-LY REPAIRING. NOT REPLACING, LARGE CRACKS INWINDSHIELDS. TOLL FREE 1 800 826-8523 (U.SCanada). WRITE: GLASS MECHANI X, 4555 NM. 103 AVE.SUITE 105 FT. LAUDERDALE, FL 33351.
MAIL ORDERSPY EQUIPMENT. MINIATURE CAMERAS, HIDDEN MI-CROPHONES. 155 PRODUCTS. FREE LISTING MES-SAGE 310-784-4545. CATALOG $5. BUYRIGHT DISTRIB-UTORS PO BOX 1388-Z, LOMITA. CA 90717.
ATTENTIONADVERTISERSReach proven mail orderbuyers! They turn to uswhen they are looking forpurchasing information andadvise. Advertise yourproducts and services in alow-cost environmentthat sells.
Millions of your primeprospects can be found inthe industry leading titlesof Hachette FilipacchiMagazines, Inc.
To place a classified ad,simply call us Toll -Freeand reserve your spacetoday!
1-800-445-6066(9am- 5pm EST)
orFax us your order at
212-767-5624
:
0:0<o 111
9 XlA
01
-0 -(D Zcn
(0
O
Pi
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199695
Panasonic PU-4564 UHS Hi-Fi UCHPanasonic's PV -4564 gives you plenty of space, whether or
not you have a home theater. Its Spatializer Audio Processorchip, developed by Desper Products, accents spatial cues in thesignal. This results in a more lifelike sound field, wider anddeeper than conventional stereo. Spatializer (the latest in along chain of stereo sound -field enhancers, ranging fromCarver's Sonic Holography to Hughes' SRS) provides awide "sweet spot" and subtly effective processing.Panasonic provides a switch for two degrees of processing,as well as defeat.
I used the PV -4564 with a 27 -inch TV and front -firingstereo speakers. Voices stayed centered on the screen,while sound effects and music spread out to the sides ofthe picture and in frontof it. Spatializer addedlittle in the way ofnoticeable twang orcoloration. Sitting closerto the TV enhanced theeffect. The Spatializer
GRADE: A
circuit might be considered just a desirablegimmick if not for the overall outstandingrecording performance of the $430 PV -4564itself. Besides enhancing acoustic space, thecompact size of this VCR saves considerablephysical space. Rich Warren
For literature, circle No. 120
changetoms
h
0
cas p
shewaswith
SALAMANDER DESIGNSARCHETYPE
1\1 OD ULAR SHELVINGAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAular shelving units from Salamander Designs can beo accommodate varying component ensembles. Thanks
that employs hexagonal nuts on solid -steel rods, shelfatter of choice. Units can be placed side by side or atop
er anded by
idgingprenesand-
betw n metalones to damp vibra-
tion, while mountingoptions include wheels,rubber feet, or heavymetal spikes (the lastnearly a half pound each).
My 36 -inch -high, five -shelf, natural cherry Arche-type 5.0 came with adequateillustrated instructions and
both a level and a wrenchthe only other tool re-quired was a tape meas-ure. The 90 -minute as-sembly was simple buttedious, since I quickly tired of spinning nutsdown threaded rods to their appropriate height.Others may finish more quickly, depending onhow critical they are about spacing.
I very much like the Archetype's appearance;its black -oxide gunbarrel-finish hardware
contrasts strikingly with the warm grain of the solid hardwood shelves. Prices forfive -shelf units range from $249.95 to $379.95. Two- and three -shelf units (20 and28 inches, respectively) are available, and other finishes include classic oak, hazelnut,black lacquer, and a black lacquer/cherry combination. David Lander
For literature, circle No. 121
GRA A
B & W 803 MATRIX SERIES 2 SPEAKERS+ + + + + + :0 + + + + + + + 0:0
I could tell from their looks and sound that the 803s were B & W products. Their highswere clean and natural, even on sharp -edged soprano voices. Overall balance was good,distortion was generally low, and there were no colorations. I've heard more spaciousness,but the soundstaging was broad and natural; small groups (such as William Bolcom andJoan Morris) sounded as if they were right there in the room. Bass extended down to 18 Hz,was more audible at 28 Hz, and then came in solidly at about 33 Hz-but the deep bassseet to lack some power and authority. On dense material like the Berlioz Requiem(Tell), there was either a bit of high -end rolloff or some mushiness at high volume levels.
speakers' size (40 x 11 x 14 inches) let them fit unobtrusively into my average -sizedIiSom, and their $1,500 -apiece price makes them affordable. Overall, the sound wasclear and neutral, and I found myself appreciating previously unheard subtleties in long-
familiar recordings. There was nothing to dislike in the sound, yetI could not quite bring myself to love it-I found it just a littleuninvolving. Ivan BergerGRADE: A-
AUDIO/FEBRUARY 199696
For literature, circle No. 122
5740 Green C
ircle Drive / M
in."" .nka. Minnesota 55343-4424 / Phone:
CIR
CLE
NO
2 ON
RE
AD
ER
SE
RV
ICE
CA
RD
39-0500 FAX
: 612-939-0634
Acurus Rated Number One
ACURUS vs THEM
In a twelve amplifier comparison test Video Magazine ranked she Acurus A150 amplifier number one. The Acurus
received an A g-cde in both Sound Quality and Construction! 'More importantly, th's amp delivered tons of
punch-significantly more than I expected from c '150 -watt amp. The sound nad outstanding dynamic outlines
and impact, trap drums and big bass events were impressively rendered. There was also an open, highly
aetailed, but neve- harsh character to the sound, with notable depth and 'space'.' Dan Kumin, Video Magazine
To prove to yourself that the U.S. made Acurus is superior to the foreign made Sony, Rotel, NAD, Pioneer,
Parasound, Carver, Adcom, etc. go to your nearest Acurus dealer fo- a demonstration.
VIDEOBESTOF 1996
MONDIAL DESIGNS LIMITED20 Livingstone Ave., Cobbs Ferry. NY 10522 914-693-8008 Fax 914-693-7199
CIRCLE NO 14 ON READER SERVICE CARD