varttikaPV212,213
vyavahara
15
()
()
PV212
ran rig pa, svasamvedana()
PV214
Mal

16
PVP
buddhi(15)
MAK16-18TS1999-


17
karmakartrsakarajnanavada
PV212-213




alka
-
,ses bya nan gi yin par smra ba(25)


MAK52,59
19


MAK46-51
MAV ad MAV16
vedyavedakavittibheda
harupatva
MAK16-18TS 1999-2001




>(29)PV

-

>

21
mukhyagauna
ajadarupa,


ajnanarupa


svakaranirbhasajnanotpadanam
gaunam samvedanam





asiddha
viruddha
upacarita


asattvad
anaikantika
mukhyaajadarupaMAK16TS1999

--
jadarupatva (33)
22
TS2004
(35)



sa-



23

atas ca sahasamvittir nabhedan nlataddhiyoh //(39)

BASK66TSP


anaikantavisayavis
ayibhava
grahaka

grahya
ekasamagr
saha



(40)

PVTSad PV217
saha
ekaasiddha

ekenaivopalambha,gcig kho nas dmigs pa

(42)
>
kalaekatva

nanatva
cittacaitanam saty api sahopalambhe nai-
katvam, TSP p.692,20-21anaikantika


>(46)

TSP pp.692,23-693,3


(49)
BASK66,68
pp.694,21-695,5ad TS2031vyatirikta
pratibandha
tadatmya
BASK68

nanyo ’pi

anyaprthaktva
svasthapi

anaikanti-
ka(50)
30
PV
TS, TSP
c.740-795c.800



BASKSubhaguputa,Bahyarthasiddhikarika
MAK, MAV, MAPSantaraksita, Madhyamakalam kara-karika, MA-vrtti, Kamalasla, MA-
panjika ed.by M.Ichigo,1985
PVTSSakyabuddhi,Pramanavarttika-tka P No.5718,D No.4220
TSSantaraksita,Tattvasam graha
13
141967
1979)1985
Hattori Masaaki1960Bahyarthasiddhikarika of Subhaguputa,JIBS,-1
Matsumoto Shiro1980Sahopalambha-niyama12
1986 Bahyarthasiddhikarika429
1988a1
Moriyama Seitetsu1984aThe Yogacara-madhyamika Refutation of the Position of the
Satyakara and Alkakara-vadins of the Yogacara School,Part 1:A Translation of Portions
of Haribhadra’s Abhisamayalam karaloka Prajnaparamitavyakhya, 12
1984bPart2
29
2009asvasam vedana
932009b
svasam vedana
15
1975
(11cc.11

2008pp.26-28 cf1979p.312fn.(50)
PV 213
tasmat tad eva tasyapi tattvam ya dvayasunyata//

cf1979p.313
PVTSP251b5-252a 2,D204a-7hosi ad PV212-213
2009app.37-42
2008pp.26-28
2008p.27
cf2008pp.27-28
rig pa,svasamvedana,atmasamvedana


byed pa po, karaka, kartrlas, kriya, kar-
man
PV213cdrtogs pa’i no bo, bodhar-
upa
-1,
30
cf TSP p.682,21ad TS1999

-1

15cd

cf1975pp.241-243
iyam evatmasamvittir asya ya’jadarupata//1999//
kriyakarakabhavena na svasamvittir asya tu/
ekasyanamsarupasya trairupyanupapattitah//2000//
parasya tv artharupasya tena samvedanam katham//2001//



k.7ab
cf
1975p.250 k.7bcf TSP ad TS2081-
2083p.710, 21-23 atha va saktyarpanat kramenapi so’rthavabhasah svanurupakar-
yotpattaye saktim vijnanacaram karotty avirodhah k.6
2008p.40fn.108

AAA p.630,1-15MAP p.149,12-153,5
tatha hi dvividham samvedanam mukhyam gaunam ca.tatra mukhyam yad ajadarupam
sa ca jnanasyaivasadharanah svatmabhuto dharmah katham asata akarasya syat.tatha
hi yad ajnanarupam na tasya mukhyam samvedanam asti yathakasanalinasya.ajnanar-
upas casattvenopagata nladaya akara iti vyapakaviruddhopalambhih.gaunam api na
31
casatah sarvasamarthya sunyasya turagavisanasyevayuktam sarvasamarthyavivekalaks-
anatvad asattvasya.tatha hi asamartham na tasya gaunam
samvedanam yatha turagavis-
anasya. asamarthas casattvenabhimata nladaya akara iti vyapakaviruddhopalabdnih.
akaranam alkatvan nasiddho hetuh.sapakse bhavan na viruddhah tad evam muk-
hyopacaritabhyam anyonyapariharasthitalaksanabhyam samvedanasya vyaptatvat.tasya
ca vyapakasya nivrtteh samvedanasyapi tad vyaptasya nivrttir eveti nasattvad ity asya hetoh samvedane ’vakaso nastti nanaikantikatvam.cf Moriyama(1984)pp.21-23110)-
(114
gaunabhakta,amukhya,upacarita
ajnanatajadarupatvam TSP ad TS2038,TSP p.691,10-11 ad TS2025-2027 yat svato na siddham tasya ghatadivajjadarupataya jnanatvam eva hyeteti badhakam
pramanam

jadarupata
jadaMAv p.191, 15 gzugs ni bem po yin no snam du bsams pa’o//PrasP pp.74, 9-75, 1 pancanam
indriyavijnananam jadatvapratipadakatvac ca. jadatva

MAK16
ktaamukhyaupacarita
arthakaroparagena viyogac ca na bhaktitah//



691,23-25
TSP D122a7-b1,P161b2
’dzin byed ses bya las gshan med//dban blo yul med de//
de lta yin dan lhag cig rig //sno dan de blo gcig ma yin//
1967Matsumoto1980p.
TSP p.694,9-16ad TS2031
syad etat yady api vipakse sattvam na niscitam, sandhigdham tu, tatas canaikanta eva
hetuh sandigdhavipaksavyavrttikatvat/tatha hi visayavisayibhavena niyatatvad anyath-
api sahopalambhaniyamah sambhavaty eva yato jnanasya grahaka eva svabhavah, vis-
ayagrahanadharmakatvat tasya/visayasyapi tadgrahya eva svabhavah,tayos caikasama-
gryadhnatvan nityam saha bhavita /na ca sahotpadavisese’pi caksuradnam visayatva-
32
manarupo janitah, na caksuradir iti/
cf1981pp.155-156
TSP p.692,11-13ad TS2029-30
punah sa evaha yadi sahasabda ekarthah, tada hetur asiddhah /tatha hi natacandramal-
lapreksasu na hy ekenaivopalambho nladeh /napi nlatadupalambhayor ekenaivopalam-
bhah /tatha hi nlopalambhe’pi tadupalambhanam anyasantanagatanam anupalambhat /
cp.(46)cf Hattori1960p.(13),Shastri1967p.19,Matsumoto1980p.29,22

nirakarajnanavadin
yatha kila buddhasya bhavagato yad vijneyam santanantaracittam tasya buddhajnanasya
ca sahopalambhaniyamo’py asty eva ca nanatvam tatha cittacaitanam saty api sa-
hopalambhe naikatvam ity ato’naikantiko hetuh iti/
PVP P276a8-277a3,D234a4-b4





anaikantika

gcig tu dmigs pa’i nes pa

bhinnayor nlaptayoh PV388d
ekakaladus gcig tu dmigs pa
gcig, ekagcig tu dmigs pa
vaidharmyavat


33
ABAB


1985p.72fn(69)
TSP p.692,23ad TS 2029-30
jnanajneyeyoh parasparam eka evopalambhah,na prthag iti cf PV389 n.(46)
TSP pp.692,23-693,3
ya eva hi jnanopalambhah sa eva jneyasya,ya eva jneyasya sa eva jnanasyeti yavat /na ca natacandramallapreksasu kascij jnanopalambho ’sti yo na jneyopalambhakah, jneyo-
palambho va na jnanopalambhaka iti kuto’siddata/cf PV389 n.(46)
TSP p.694,3-8ad TS2029-2030
santanagatacittopalambhah napy anyasantanagatacittopalambha eva bhagavajjnanopa-
lambhah api tv anyo’pi prthaktvasya svasthapi cittasya sam vedanat /ata eva na rupalo-
kair vyabhicarah kevalasyapy alokadarsanat / rupasyapy alokarahitasya kaiscit pran-
ivisesair upalambhat / tasmad vipakse bhavasambhavan nanaikantiko hetuh//cf PV
388cd