fiscal plan
TRANSCRIPT
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 1/26
How to do Financial PlanningWhat is Financial Planning ?
Financial planning a process where you plan your Investments in such a way which meets your
financial goals over time.
You must be very disciplined when you do this , you must know from where you the money is
going to come to you and how are you going to save or invest it , and in future how are you goingto achieve your goals.
What are the Steps in Financial Planning
1. List down your Goals
Prepare a list of financial goals. It can be any requirement like Buying Home , Car , Child
Education , Child Marriage , Vacation , Retirement etc . Along with this there must be a very clear
timeline associated with the Goal. Something like "I want to buy a Car after 3 years , which will
cost 50,000 at that time" .
2. List down Your Cash Flows and Cash Inflow
Prepare the list of your cash flows , cash flow means , how money is coming and going ? Any
money coming in is Cash inflow and Any Expenses is Cash outflow.
It will help you in understanding how money is coming to you and how is is utilized and how
much is remaining for investing purpose. By Doing this , you can get very clear of how you are
going to get money and how you are going to spend it, and how much you are left with to spend.
. Understand and figure out your Risk-appetite
This is a very important part of financial Planning, Risk appetite is the amount of risk a person
can take while investing. How much money you can afford to loose in order to earn high returns
defines your risk taking ability.
For Example:
if you are ready to loose 60% of your money , your risk appetite is high
If you are ready to loose 25% of your money , your risk appetite is moderate
If not at all ready to loose your money even 1% , you are not at all a risk taker.
It depends on you which category you belong in. it depends on individuals Physcology , Family
Conditions , Attitude etc
Generally people in there early age have more risk appetite as they have less responsibilities
and more freedom to invest . Later when they get married and have responsibilities , they cant
risk money to loose.
4. List down your Financial Goals
At this point , you must be clear with your goals. Financial goals are the list of things for which
you need money and you must have a predefined target time.
Example:
Manish earns 3,00,000 per year with 1,00,000 left for investment, he has moderate risk appetite.
Goals:
1. Buy a Car within 2 years worth 5,00,000.
2. Vacations in New Zealand worth 8,00,000 within 4 yrs.
3. Buy home worth 40,00,000 in 10 years.
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 2/26
Here, Goals are not compatible with amount invested per year and with that kind of risk-appetite.
Therefore , Goals must be realistic and achievable , it must not look totally irrelevant.
5. Make sure your Goals are realistic
At this point you must make sure that your goals do not look unrealistic and unachievable . If they
do , then you must either lower your goals or increase risk appetite or increase the investible
amount per year. This gist of the matter is , Be Realistic !!!
6. Make the Plan
Once you are done with all these steps , Its the time for the planning.
For each goal you must devise a systematic investment plan , by choosing the correct
investment instrument. For example: For your child Education make sure you invest in something
which is not very risky for the time period you are going to invest in that. You can invest in
equities for that , as Equities are not risky in very long term and generate great return.
But for a short term goal like vacation in 1-2 yrs , don't invest in equities , rather go for a debt
fund or a fixed deposit. In this way , you have to be clear how you are going to invest for
achieving your goals.
7. Review and Take advice Revise your steps and make sure everything is correct. If you are unclear about anything meet
some one who is more knowledgeable than you , See a financial planner or a knowledgeable
friend.
8. Take Action and keep Reviewing
The last step is to take Action and start executing the plan with discipline and make sure you
change you goals , r isk appetite as time passes and these things change over time.
I would be happy to read your comments or disagreement on any topic. Please leave a
comment.
Detail
8 easy steps to financial planning
We all know that making a financial plan plays an important role in wealth generation. However, for some
reason or the other we find excuses for not making one. If you have not yet made a financial plan that charts your
future earnings, expenses and returns from your investments then perhaps it's about time you made one.
Here are eight easy steps that will help you make your financial plan.
1. Identify and list down your future needs/ objectives
Each individual aspires to lead a better and a happier life. To lead such a life there are some needs and somewishes that need to be fulfilled. Money is a medium through which such needs and wishes are fulfilled. Some of
the common needs that most individuals would have are: creating enough financial resources to lead a
comfortable retired life, providing for a child's education and marriage, buying a dream home, providing for
medical emergencies, etc.
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 3/26
The first step in a making a financial plan is to identify the goals which have to be met. These goals are the needs
and the objectives of the individual. Clarity in this respect would be the starting point to help an individual work
out the journey on the financial road which needs to be followed.
Disclaimer: The explanation in this article is directed to help a person understand in a broad sense the financial
planning process. Specific skills and knowledge other than discussed above maybe needed in creating a financialplan. The approach may vary based on the unique circumstances specific to different individuals.
2. Converting needs into financial goals
Once the needs/ objectives have been identified, they need to be converted into financial goals.
But how do we convert the needs into financial goals?
Two components go into converting the needs into financial goals. First is to evaluate and find out when you
need to make withdrawals from your investments for each of the needs/ objectives. Then you should estimate the
amount of money needed in current value to meet the objective/ need today. Then by using a suitable inflation
factor you can project what would be the amount of money needed to meet the objective/ need in future.
For example, let us consider the need to create an education fund for your child which is needed 15 years from
now. Let us assume that the current cost of education today would work out to around Rs 4 lakh. We can project
what is the amount needed after 15 years for your child by applying a suitable inflation factor to the current cost
of education assumed as Rs 4 lakh.
Assuming that cost of education would rise at 7 per cent per annum over the next 15 years, the total amount
required after 15 years would work out to Rs 11.03 lakh.
Similarly you need to estimate the amount of money needed to meet all such objectives/ needs. Once you have
all the values you need to plot it against a timeline.
This is very easily done by using spreadsheets. It will give you a broad idea about when and how much money
you would need during your life in future.
3. Getting a grip of your current financial state
To get clarity on your current financial state, it is necessary to create a family budget. As part of this budget, you
need to list down your income and expenses.
y Income should include the husband and wife's income as well as rental income if any y The expenses part should be split under monthly expenses and annual expenses
y Under monthly expenses you should list down the regular monthly expenses like groceries, phone bills,electricity, petrol, etc
y Under the annual expenses you need to include non-regular expenses like school fees, car insurance,
vacation, etc
This enables you to get an idea of the pattern of cash outflows (expenses) during the year. Accordingly you can
plan to keep adequate money liquid for the necessary expenses during the course of the year. All Loan EMIs
(equated monthly installments) paid should be kept separate under the monthly expenses head, as after a finite
number of years they will no longer be part of your regular living expenses.
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 4/26
The most important information that you get from the above study is your current annual cost of living (that part of
expenses which supports your current lifestyle).
An analysis of the above figures would enable you to understand the amount of savings (income less expenses)
that you are left with on an average. This in turn will give you an idea of surplus regular money available for
investment. This is the savings that will take care of you and your family when income from your work stops.
Hence it is extremely important to understand what is happening to your savings. A strategy to invest
the savings in the most appropriate way is critical for you to meet your financial goals.
4. Stage I of the financial plan: Risk planning
The first component of the financial plan would cover the aspect of risk planning. The two major risks are that of
illness and death. The role of insurance is to cover risk (in financial terms only). A suitable health insurance cover is worked out after taking into account the situation of the family and information about the availability of anycover from the employer.
The next step is to estimate the amount of life insurance cover required. Loss of income in case of death of an
earning member may put the rest of the family into financial discomfort (especially where he/ she may be the
primary bread winner).
The role of insurance is to take care of this financial discomfort. The most suitable life Insurance cover for this is
a term cover. Information on financial goals and your current financial state, when suitably modified, becomes a
base from which to work towards estimating the amount of life insurance and the tenure of the cover.
Once the risk planning is in place the cash flows for long term financial planning is worked out.
5. Stage II of financial plan: Core cash flow study
You now have the basic inputs needed to work on your financial plan. The needs/ objectives have been
converted into financial goals. You know the amount of money and the time when it is required for each of your financial goals. These financial goals will be met through creating financial resources by investing your savings.
You have a basic understanding of your current cash flow (income and expenses statement) through creating a
family budget. From this you can get an idea of your potential savings. By projecting your income and expenses
into the future you can get an idea of the kind of savings you can have each year.
By assuming that savings grow at different rates you would get an idea of how your investment pool would grow
into the future. You will have to work out at what rate of growth of your savings would all your financial goals be
met. If the rate needed is very high then it gives you an idea that you may have to save and invest more or
alternatively sacrifice some financial goals.
In case the return needed is very low, you can explore the possibility of achieving financial freedom
earlier in life. You can mix and match and work out different scenarios and then finalise a plan that suits you
most. As this is a part that involves a lot of number crunching, spread sheets make it easier to work
6.Determining a suitable asset allocation strategyBased on a projection of the estimates of long term cash flows done you know the rate at which you
need to grow your investments. The financial plan thus lays the broad investment parameters in terms of an
asset allocation strategy.
Different assets classes like debt, equity, real estate, etc. grow at certain natural growth rates over the long term.
You have to work out an investment strategy to invest the saving across various asset classes in a suitable ratio
so that you meet the targeted return as per the financial plan.
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 5/26
If a higher return is needed then accordingly a higher exposure to higher growth assets like equities isneeded. Discipline in maintaining the asset allocation is the key to achieving success in the long term
7. Product selection and plan execution
Only after the asset allocation strategy as per the financial plan is in place does the question of product
selection and execution arise.
This strategy guides us on the allocation of money to various asset classes (example: debt, equity, gold, etc). For
each of the asset classes, suitable investment options are evaluated. A thorough understanding of how different
products work and the costs associated with them is critical for this evaluation. The most suitable product which
will help you meet the expected returns as estimated in the financial plan is selected.
By growing the money at the expected rate you would be able to build enough financial resources to fulfill your
objectives and needs in life. A lot of individuals invest into an investment option without understanding its overall
long term impact on their lives. Due to this reason they may find out that they are left with inadequate financial
resources during their later years.
They generally have to depend on someone (like their children) or have to drastically reduce their lifestyle to lead a financially viable life. Hence it is extremely important for people to evaluate beforehand, the amount of financial resources they need to accumulate, in order to lead a comfortable life posttheir working years.
8. Monitoring and evaluating your financial plan
The success in financial planning is achieved only when all the financial goals are met. Hence financial
planning does not end as soon as investments are made. It is a continuous process where regular monitoring
and periodic evaluation is necessary to ensure that things are happening as per the plan. It is essential to ensure
that planned contributions from your savings are happening towards your investments.
In addition to this the returns being generated by the investments should be monitored and rebalancing of
investments should be made as per the asset allocation strategy. Based on the above evaluation the financial
plan should be fine tuned if necessary.
Adjustments to the financial plan maybe needed in certain scenarios. Any permanent change in lifestyleover and above the estimated level would impact on your long term financial situation . Similarly anymajor change in your existing situation -- new member added in the family or reduction in income due toone member of the family taking time off from work to raise children -- would require a reworking of thefinancial plan.
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 6/26
Zero-based budgeting
Zero-based budgeting is an approach to planning and decision-making which reverses the working
process of traditional budgeting. In traditional incremental budgeting, departmental managers justify
only variances versus past years, based on the assumption that the "baseline" is automatically
approved. By contrast, in zero-based budgeting, every line item of the budget must be approved,
rather than only changes.[1]
During the review process, no reference is made to the previous level of
expenditure. Zero-based budgeting requires the budget request be re-evaluated thoroughly, starting
from the zero-base. This process is independent on whether the total budget or specific line items are
increasing or decreasing.
The term "zero-based budgeting" is sometimes used in personal finance to describe "zero-sum
budgeting", the practice of budgeting every dollar of income received, and then adjusting some part of
the budget downward for every other part that needs to be adjusted upward.
Zero based budgeting also refers to the identification of a task or tasks and then funding resources tocomplete the task independent of current resourcing.
Advantages of zero-based budgeting
1. Efficient allocation of resources, as it is based on needs and benefits rather than history.
2. Drives managers to find cost effective ways to improve operations.
3. Detects inflated budgets.
4. Increases staff motivation by providing greater initiative and responsibility in decision-making.
5. Increases communication and coordination within the organization.
6. Identifies and eliminates wasteful and obsolete operations.
7. Identifies opportunities for outsourcing.
8. Forces cost centers to identify their mission and their relationship to overall goals.
9. It helps in identifying areas of wasteful expenditure and, if desired, it can also be used for
suggesting alternative courses of action.
[edit]Disadvantages of zero-based budgeting
1. More time-consuming than incremental budgeting.
2. Justifying every line item can be problematic for departments with intangible outputs.
3. Requires specific training, due to increased complexity vs. incremental budgeting.
4. In a large organization, the amount of information backing up the budgeting process may be
overwhelming
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 7/26
Revised Estimates, Indian Revised BudgetEstimates 2008-2009, RE 2008-09
The Indian Budget Estimate for 2008 -09 was initially expected to be
Rs.7,50,884 crore in total expenditure.
Following the announcement of the Indian Interim Budget 2009, this has now been
revised to Rs.900,953 crore, with an increase of Rs.1,50,069 crore. That represents
a pretty significant Budget Estimate increase of 19.9 per cent.
The Plan Expenditure for 2008-09 was initially placed at Rs.2,43,386 crore in the
Budget Estimate. It has now gone up to Rs.2,82,957 crore in the Revised Estimate
presented as part of the Interim Budget - a 16.4 per cent increase.
The additional plan spending of Rs.39,571 crore is due to an increase in the Central
Plan by Rs.24,174 crore and an increase of Rs.15,397 crore in the Central
Assistance to State and UT Plans.
Central Plan Expenditure has increased for Rural Development, Atomic Energy,
Telecommunications, Textiles, Urban Development, Youth Affairs & Sports and
Railways.
The increase in Central Assistance for State and UT Plans is on account of
additional Central Assistance for Externally Aided Projects, Accelerated Irrigation
Benefit Programme, Roads and Bridges, National Social Assistance Programme,
Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission and Tsunami Rehabilitation.
Non-Plan items have grown Rs.1,10,498 crore in the Revised Estimates through an
increase in expenditure of Rs.44,863 crore on fertilizer subsidy, Rs.10,960 crore on
food subsidy, Rs.15,000 crore on Agricultural Debt Waiv er and Debt Relief Scheme,
Rs.7,605 crore on Pensions, and Rs.5,149 crore on Police.
An additional amount of Rs.9,000 crore has also been pro vided for Defence
expenditure.
Non-Tax Revenues are a key component of IndianGovernment receipts. As against
the Budget Estimates of Rs.95,785 crore for 2008-09, the Revised Estimates for the
Non-Tax Revenues are Rs.96,203 crore, a slight increase.
Actual tax collections during 2007-08 exceeded the Revised Estimates for 2007-08,
both for Direct and Indirect Taxes.
However, for 2008-09, the RE of tax collection is projected at Rs.6,27,949 crore as
against the BE of Rs.6,87,715 crore. This shortfall is due to Indian Government fisc al
measures initiated to counter the impact of global slowdown on the Indian economy,
as part of its stimulus packages.
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 8/26
A relief program of about Rs.40,000 crore has been extended through tax cuts,
including a fairly steep across the board reduction in Central Excise rates in
December, 2008.
Despite this, it is expected that the tax collection in 2008 -09 will still exceed last
year¶s collection.
In summaiton of the variations in receipts and expenditure, the current year is
expected to end with aRevenue Deficit of Rs.2,41,273 crore as against the Budgeted
Figure of Rs.55,184 crore.
The revised Revenue Deficit stands at 4.4 per cent of GDP in the revised Budget
Estimate, against the 1.0 per cent Revenue Deficit in the original Budget Estimates.
The fiscal deficit for 2008-09 has gone up from Rs.1,33,287 crore in the Budget
Estimate to Rs.3,26,515 crore in the Revised Estimate, a very significant 144.9 per
cent increase.
The revised fiscal deficit is estimated at 6 per cent of the GDP as against the
budgeted figure of 2.5 per cent. This is a massive increase rep resenting 3.5 per cent,
and it may lead to a downgrading of India's soveriegn debt.
Public Sector Budget - Indian Interim BudgetEstimates 2009, Public Sector Enterprises
India has created a strong public sector which has evolved in response to the
nation¶s needs and provided stability in development. The Indian Government has
noted that turnover of Central Public Sector Enterprises (CPSEs) in 2003 -04 wasRs.5 lakh 87 thousand crore which has grown by 84 per cent to Rs.10 lakh 81
thousand crore in 2007-08. During the same period, profitsof CPSEs have increased
by 72 per cent from Rs.53 thousand crore to Rs.91 thousand crore.
The contribution of CPSEs to the Central Exchequer by way of dividend, interest and
taxes and duties has recorded an increase of 86 per cent. The number of loss
making enterprises has come down from 73 in 2003-04 to 55 in 2007-08 and the
number of profit making enterprises has gone up from 143 to 158 during the same
period.
In order to maintain ethics and probity in the functioning of CPSEs, the Governmenthas approved the implementation of Guidelines on Corporate Governance in CPSEs
in June, 2007.
In November 2007, Government constituted the National Investment Fund into which
the proceeds from disinvestment of Government equity in Central Public Sector
Enterprises (CPSEs) are deposited. Three-quarters of annual income of the Fund
will be used to finance select social sector schemes which promote education, health
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 9/26
and employment. The residual 25 per cent annual income of the Fund will be used to
meet the capital investment requirements of profitable and revivable CPSEs. As on
December 31, 2008, the corpus of the Fund was about Rs.1815 crore
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 10/26
Financial audit
A financial audit, or more accurately, an audit of financial statements, is the verification of the
financial statements of a legal entity, with a view to express an audit opinion. The audit opinion is a
reasonable assurance that the financial statements are presented fairly, in all material respects, or
give a true and fair view in accordance with the financial reporting framework. The purpose of an audit
is to enhance the degree of confidence of intended users in the financial statements.
Financial audits are typically performed by firms of practising accountants who are experts in financial
reporting. The financial audit is one of manyassurance functions provided by accounting firms. Many
organisations separately employ or hire internal auditors, who do not attest to financial reports but
focus mainly on the internal controls of the organization. External auditors may choose to place
limited reliance on the work of internal auditors.
Internationally, the International Standards on Auditing (ISA) issued by the International Auditing and
Assurance Standards Board (IAASB) is considered as the benchmark for audit process. Almost all
jurisdictions require auditors to follow the ISA or a local variation of the ISA.
Purpose
Financial audits exist to add credibility to the implied assertion by an
organization's management that its financial statements fairly
represent the organization's position and performance to the firm's
stakeholders. The principal stakeholders of a company are typically its
shareholders, but other parties such as tax authorities, banks,regulators, suppliers, customers and employees may also have an
interest in ensuring that the financial statements are accurate. The
audit is designed to increase the possibility that a material
misstatement is detected by audit procedures. A misstatement is
defined as false or missing information, whether caused by fraud
(including deliberate misstatement) or error. "Material" is very broadly
defined as being large enough or important enough to cause
stakeholders to alter their decisions. Audits exist because they add
value through easing the cost of information asymmetry, not becausethey are required by law (note: audits are obligatory in njln;l
Audit of government expenditure
The earliest surviving mention of a public official charged with auditing government expenditure is a
reference to the Auditor of the Exchequer in England in 1314. The Auditors of the Imprest were
established under Queen Elizabeth I in 1559 with formal responsibility for auditing Exchequer
payments. This system gradually lapsed and in 1780, Commissioners for Auditing the Public
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 11/26
Accounts were appointed by statute. From 1834, the Commissioners worked in tandem with the
Comptroller of the Exchequer, who was charged with controlling the issue of funds to the government.
As Chancellor of the Exchequer , William Ewart Gladstone initiated major reforms of public finance
and Parliamentary accountability. His 1866 Exchequer and Audit Departments Act required all
departments, for the first time, to produce annual accounts, known as appropriation accounts. The Act
also established the position of Comptroller and Auditor General (C&AG) and an Exchequer and Audit
Department (E&AD) to provide supporting staff from within the civil service. The C&AG was given two
main functions ± to authorise the issue of public money to government from the Bank of England,
having satisfied himself that this was within the limits Parliament had voted ± and to audit the
accounts of all Government departments and report to Parliament accordingly.
Auditing of UK government expenditure is now carried out by the National Audit Office. Sing industry
(acting through various organisations throughout the years) as to the accounting standards for
financial reporting, and the U.S. Congress has deferred to the SEC.
This is also typically the case in other developed economies. In the UK, auditing guidelines are set by
the institutes (including ACCA, ICAEW, ICAS and ICAI) of which auditing firms and individual auditors
are members.
Accordingly, financial auditing standards and methods have tended to change significantly only after
auditing failures. The most recent and familiar case is that of Enron. The company succeeded in
hiding some important facts, such as off-book liabilities, from banks and shareholders. Eventually,
Enron filed for bankruptcy, and (as of 2006) is in the process of being dissolved. One result of this
scandal was that Arthur Andersen, then one of the five largest accountancy firms worldwide, lost their
ability to audit public companies, essentially killing off the firm.
A recent trend in audits (spurred on by such accounting scandals as Enron and Worldcom) has been
an increased focus on internal control procedures, which aim to ensure the completeness, accuracy
and validity of items in the accounts, and restricted access to financial systems. This emphasis on the
internal control environment is now a mandatory part of the audit of SEC-listed companies, under the
auditing standards of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) set up by
the Sarbanes-Oxley Act.
Governance and Oversight
Many countries have government sponsored or mandated organizations who develop and maintain auditing
standards, commonly referred to generally accepted auditing
standards or GAAS. These standards prescribe different aspects of
auditing such as the opinion, stages of an audit, and controls over
work product (i.e., working papers).
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 12/26
Some oversight organizations require auditors and audit firms to
undergo a third-party quality review periodically to ensure the
applicable GAAS is followed.
Stages of an audit
A financial audit is performed before the release of the financial statements (typically on an annual
basis), and will overlap the year-end (the date which the financial statements relate to).
The following are the stages of a typical audit:[c it ati on needed ]
[edit]Planning and risk assessment
Timing: before year-end
Purpose:...
To understand the business of the company and the environment in which it operates.
What should auditors understand?[1]
The relevant industry, regulatory, and other external factors including the applicable
financial reporting framework
The nature of the entity
The entity¶s selection and application of accounting policies
The entity¶s objectives and strategies, and the related business risks that may result in
material misstatement of the financial statements
The measurement and review of the entity¶s financial performance
Internal control relevant to the audit
To determine the major audit risks (i.e. the chance that the auditor will issue the wrong opinion).
For example, if sales representatives stand to gain bonuses based on their sales, and they
account for the sales they generate, they have both the incentive and the ability to overstate their
sales figures, thus leading to overstated revenue. In response, the auditor would typically plan to
increase the rigour of their procedures for checking the sales figures.
[edit]Internal controls testing
Timing: before and/or after year-end
Purpose:
To assess the operating effectiveness of internal controls (e.g. authorisation of transactions,
account reconciliations, segregation of duties) including IT General Controls. If internal controls
are assessed as effective, this will reduce (but not entirely eliminate) the amount of 'substantive'
work the auditor needs to do (see below).
Notes:
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 13/26
In some cases an auditor may not perform any internal controls testing, because he/she does not
expect internal controls to be reliable. When no i nt ernal c ont rols testing is performed, the audit is
said to follow a substantive approach.
This test determines the amount of work to be performed i.e. substantive testing or test of
details.
[c it ati on needed ]
[edit]Substantive procedures
Timing: after year-end (see note regarding hard/fast close below)
Purpose:
to collect audit evidence that the management assertions (actual figures and disclosures) made in
the Financial Statements are reliable and in accordance with required standards and legislation.
Methods:
where internal controls are strong, auditors typically rely more on Substantive Analytical
Procedures (the comparison of sets of financial information, and financial with non-financial
information, to see if the numbers 'make sense' and that unexpected movements can be
explained)
where internal controls are weak, auditors typically rely more on Substantive Tests of
Detail (selecting a sample of items from the major account balances, and finding hard evidence
(e.g. invoices, bank statements) for those items)
Notes:
Some audits involve a 'hard close' or 'fast close' whereby certain substantive procedures can be
performed before year-end. For example, if the year-end is 31 December, the hard close may
provide the auditors with figures as at 30 November. The auditors would audit income/expense
movements between 1 January and 30 November, so that after year end, it is only necessary for
them to audit the December income/expense movements and the 31st December balance sheet.
In some countries and accountancy firms these are known as 'rollforward' procedures.
[edit]Finalization
Timing: at the end of the audit
Purpose:
To compile a report to management regarding any important matters that came to the auditor's
attention during performance of the audit,
To evaluate and review the audit evidence obtained, ensuring sufficient appropriate evidence was
obtained for every material assertion and
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 14/26
To consider the type of audit opinion that should be reported based on the audit evidence
obtained.
[edit]Commercial relationships versus objectivity
One of the major issues faced by private auditing firms is the need to provide independent auditing
services while maintaining a business relationship with the audited company.
The auditing firm's responsibility to check and confirm the reliability of financial statements may be
limited by pressure from the audited company, who pays the auditing firm for the service. The auditing
firm's need to maintain a viable business through auditing revenue may be weighed against its duty to
examine and verify the accuracy, relevancy, and completeness of the company's financial statements.
Numerous proposals are made to revise the current system to provide better economic incentives to
auditors to perform the auditing function without having their commercial interests compromised by
client relationships. Examples are more direct incentive compensation awards and financial statement
insurance approaches. See, respectively, Incentive Systems to Promote Capital Market Gatekeeper
Effectiveness and Financial Statement Insurance
Or
2.0 AUDIT OBJECTIVES AND SCOPE
2.1 Audit Objectives
The following were the objectives for this audit of financial planning, budgeting and
monitoring:
y To provide assurance that CSC¶s financial management framework is adequate,and effectively supports relevant and timely financial planning, budgeting and
monitoring activities.
y To assess the adequacy of the process used to develop annual budgets (i.e.ARLU, NCAOP, Main Estimates) which appropriately reflect CSC¶s
strategic/business priorities and financial requirements.
y To assess the adequacy of the process in place at the National and Regional levelsto allocate resources in a consistent, timely and transparent manner, and aligned
with strategic priorities.
y To assess the adequacy of the financial monitoring process at the National andRegional levels to support timely decision-making on financial matters, including
resource reallocation and other corrective actions.
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 15/26
The specific criteria used for the audit can be found in Annex A.
2.2 Audit Scope
The audit encompassed the financial planning, budgeting (which includes identifying
resource requirements, budget preparation and resource allocation), and monitoringprocesses.
Financial Planning and Budgeting
Internal Audit reviewed the processes which form part of the development of budget
activities to obtain funding to meet CSC¶s resource needs. The audit did not assess the
appropriateness of NCAOP resource standards and indicators, as a review of theresourcing standards is currently being conducted by CSC.
The audit focused on the resource allocation process (including assessing the adequacy
of guidelines, tools, systems and data).
Financial Monitoring
The focus of the audit with respect to the monitoring process was on the preparation and
reporting of forecasts and variance analysis, as well as corrective actions taken whereappropriate.
The audit was national in scope and included visits to NHQ, all regions and selected
institutions/sites/branches (see Annex B). Along with the assessment of the objectives
and criteria noted above, the audit attempted to identify opportunities for improvement,including the potential for CSC to harness best practices that are implemented in specific
regions or institutions.
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 16/26
Employee healthcare reforms in India
Ever since the process of economic reforms was launched in India in
1991, employee healthcare reforms became a part of the government¶s national socio-economic
agenda. In addition to the involvement of the public and private sector corporations, various
government, international and multi-lateral health agencies, and other private stakeholders such as
private health insurers got involved in the reform process.
Particularly, during the middle of the tenth five year plan (2004-05 onwards) the
employee healthcare reforms received a very high priority from the government of India. Now,
the health sector has become one of the key areas, with a major focus on providing
primary health care services. The Employee State Insurance Corporation runs a scheme called ESI,
which provides six social security benefits to employees: Medical benefit, sickness benefit, maternity
benefit, disablement benefit, dependant¶s benefit and funeral expenses. (1)
However, till today one of the handicaps faced in the path of employee healthcare reforms has been
the lack of sufficient evidence based information about, and the impact-assessment of various
initiatives (such as Balika Samriddhi Yojana, Nutrition Program for Adolescent Girls,
Maternal Health Program, etc.) undertaken as part of the reform process. Looking into this weakness,
the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare in conjunction with the World Health Organization (WHO)
Country Office has undertaken a review and documentation of these initiatives in India. This is an
ongoing review process that was started in the year 2004.
The initiatives that are under review are in the area of
employee health care financing, health insurance, healthsystem organization, delivery and
management, public-private partnerships, and reforms related to human resource management in
public and private sector organizations. (2)
As part of the reform process, the government of India is also increasingly adopting alternative means
of financing such as seeking loans from the World Bank and other international financing institutions
to upgrade and manage the labour welfare and health programs (such as National Family Welfare
Program and Employee State Health Insurance Scheme) in the country. At the same time, the
government has encouraged the establishment of corporate hospitals in order to improve the quality
of healthcare. These corporate hospitals have tie-ups with most insurance companies and large
business organizations to provide superior healthcare for the employees. Apollo Hospital chain,
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 17/26
Escorts Hospital, Tata Memorial Hospital, Max Healthcare, and Fortis Hospital chain from Ranbaxy,
are some of the premier corporate hospitals operating across India at present. (3)
At the grassroots level, the government of India has encouraged NGOs to play a pivotal role in
deliveringhealthcare services to the working population. The reforms have been initiated to create aPublic Health and Panchayat system collaboration, special funds have been allocated
for health policy research, and there is a thrust on improving the health dynamics of the working
women. (4)
However, in comparison to the developed economies of the western world, India has a long way to go
in terms of employee healthcare. There are various inherent weaknesses in the national health policy.
For instance, providing employee health insurance cover is not a mandatory requirement in the
private sector in India till now. This is a fundamental weakness of the healthcare system in India that
needs to be addressed urgently. Reforms in this area will pick up more pace when the government
provides incentives and imposes stricter regulations on the employers in both public and private
sectors in India.
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 18/26
Health economics
Health economics is a branch of economics concerned with issues related to scarcity in the
allocation of health and health care. In broad terms, health economists study the functioning of the
health care system and the private and social causes of health-affecting behaviors such as smoking.
A seminal 1963 article by Kenneth Arrow, often credited with giving rise to the health economics as a
discipline, drew conceptual distinctions between health and other goals.[1]
Factors that distinguish
health economics from other areas include extensive government intervention,
intractable uncertainty in several dimensions,asymmetric information, and externalities.[2]
Governments tend to regulate the health care industry heavily and also tend to be the largest payer
within the market. Uncertainty is intrinsic to health, both in patient outcomes and financial concerns.
The knowledge gap that exists between a physician and a patient creates a situation of distinct
advantage for the physician, which is called asymmetric information.
Externalities arise frequently when considering health and health care, notably in the context of
infectious disease. For example, making an effort to avoid catching the common cold affects people
other than the decision maker
Scope
The scope of health economics is neatly encapsulated by Alan Williams' "plumbing
diagram"[7]
dividing the discipline into eight distinct topics:
What influences health? (other than health care)
What is health and what is its value
The demand for health care
The supply of health care
Micro-economic evaluation at treatment level
Market equilibrium
Evaluation at whole system level; and,
Planning, budgeting and monitoring mechanisms.
Health care demand
The demand for health care is a derived demand from the demand for health. Health care is
demanded as a means for consumers to achieve a larger stock of "health capital." The demand for
health is unlike most other goods because individuals allocate resources in order to both consume
and produce health.
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 19/26
The
¡
¢ £
e ¤
escr i¥ ti
¢
¦
§ i
£
es three roles of ¥ ersons in health economics. The ̈
or l
¤
© ealth
epor t
p.
states that people take f our roles in the health care:
.
ontr i¡
utors
.
iti
ens
stewardship)
.
Providers
.
onsumers
ichael
! rossman's
" # model of health production[
$
] has ¡
een extremel%
influential in this field of
study and has several uni & ue elements that make it notable. ! rossman's model views each individual
as both a producer and a consumer of health.© ealth is treated as a stock which degrades over time
in the absence of '
investments" in health, so that health is viewed as a sor t of capital. The model
acknowledges that health care is both a consumption good that yields direct satisf action and utility,
and an investment good, which yields satisf action to consumers indirectly through increased
productivity, f ewer sick days, and higher wages. Investment in health is costly as consumers must
trade off time and resources devoted to health, such as exercising at a local gym, against other goals.
These f actors are used to determine the optimal level of health that an individual willdemand. The
model makes predictions over the eff ects of changes in pr ices of health care and other goods, labour
market outcomes such as employment and wages, and technological changes. These predictions and
other predictions f rom models extending ! rossman's
" # paper f orm the basis of much of the
econometr ic research conducted by health economists.
In ! rossman's model, the optimal level of investment in health occurs where themarginal cost of
health capital is equal to the marginal benefit. ̈
ith the passing of time, health depreciates at some
rate . The interest rate f aced by the consumer is denoted by r . The marginal cost of health capital
can be f ound by adding these var iables: . The marginal benefit of health capital
is the rate of return f rom this capital in both market and non-market sectors. In this model, the optimal
health stock can be impacted by f actors like age, wages and education. As an example, increases
with age, so it becomes more and more costly to attain the same level of health capital or health stock
as one ages. Age also decreases the marginal benefit of health stock. The optimal health stock will
theref ore decrease as one ages.
Beyond issues of the f undamental, "real" demand f or medical care der ived f rom the desire to have
good health
and thus influenced by the production f unction f or health) is the impor tant distinction
between the "marginal benefit" of medical care
which is always associated with this "real demand"
curve based on der ived demand), and a separate "eff ective demand" curve, which summar i
es the
amount of medical care demanded at par ticular market pr ices. Because most medical care is not
purchased f rom providers directly, but is rather obtained at subsidi
ed pr ices due to insurance, the
out-of -pocket pr ices f aced by consumers are typically much lower than the market pr ice. The
consumer sets
B=
out of pocket, and so the "eff ective demand" will have a separate relationship
between pr ice and quantity than will the "marginal benefit curve" or real demand relationship. This
distinction is often descr ibed under the rubr ic of "ex-post moral hazard"
which is again distinct f rom
ex-ante moral hazard, which is f ound in any type of market with insurance).
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 20/26
Health insurance
Health insurance is insurance against the risk of incurring medical expenses among
individuals. By estimating the overall risk of health care expenses among a targeted group, an insurer
can develop a routine finance structure, such as a monthly premium or payroll tax, to ensure that
money is available to pay for the health care benefits specified in the insurance agreement. The
benefit is administered by a central organization such as a government agency, private business, or
not-for-profit entity
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 21/26
Critical Pathways
A Review
Nathan R. Every, MD, MPH; Judith Hochman, MD; Richard Becker,
MD; Steve Kopecky, MD; Christopher P. Cannon, MD;for the Committee on AcuteCardiac Care, Council on Clinical Cardiology, American Heart Association
Key Words: AHA Scientific Statements � critical pathways � clinical protocols
Critical pathways, also known as critical paths, clinical pathways, or care paths, are
management plans that display goals for patients and provide the sequence and
timing of actions necessary to achieve these goals with optimal efficiency.
1As
competition in the healthcare industry has increased, managers have embraced
critical pathways as a method to reduce variation in care, decreaseresource utilization, and potentially improve healthcare quality.
Cardiovascular medicine in particular is an area in which critical pathways have
been embraced. This is due in part to the high volume and high cost associated with
cardiovascular diseases and procedures. In addition, the relatively mature guideline
process has alsocontributed to the growth in use of critical pathways in cardiology.
Although anchored in clinical guidelines, the critical pathway is a distinct tool that
details processes of care and highlights inefficiencies regardless of whether there is
evidence to warrant changes in those processes. Clinical guidelines, on the other
hand, are consensus statements that are systematically developed to assist
practitioners in making patient management decisions related to specific
clinical circumstances.
2Although clinical guidelines can and should
be used in
pathway development, the majority of processes included in a pathway have not
been rigorously tested and are generally not addressed in guidelines. Another term
that should also be distinguished from critical pathways is clinical
protocols.Protocols are treatment recommendations that are often based
on guidelines. Like the critical pathway, the goal of the clinical protocol
may be to
decrease treatment variation. However, protocols are most often focused on
guideline compliance rather than the identification of rate-limiting steps in the
patient care process. In further contrast to critical pathways, protocols may or may
not include a continuous monitoring and data-evaluation component.
Critical pathway techniques were first developed for use in industry as a tool to
identify and manage the rate-limiting steps in production processes.
3 4 5 6
In
industry, any variation in production process is suboptimal. Thus, by defining the
processes and timing of these processes, managers could target areas that were
critical, measure variation, and try to make improvements. Once steps were taken
to improve the process, there would be a remeasurement. In time, variation would
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 22/26
decrease, the time it took to complete the pathway would decrease, costs
would decrease, and quality of production would improve.
When applied to health care, the technique of critical pathways has obvious
concerns. First, unlike in manufacturing, not all variation in patient care is
negative. Individual patient factors
may contribute to variation that cannot andshould not be controlled by the system. For example, if postoperative extubation
occurred within a prespecified time period based on a pathway, there
would be
early extubations with potential for harm. Also unlike in manufacturing, in which
the products are standardized, patients are different and may not fit within a
pathway. Second, there exists concern that streamlining care may have a negative
impact on patient outcomes. For example, if a care pathway suggests a 2-day stay
in the cardiac care unit, a provider may alter care against his or her best judgment
to stay within the plan. Finally, physicians have objected to "cookbook medicine"
and have felt an erosion of professional autonomy with the critical
pathways. Without physician support of the pathway, it is unlikely to achieve
any
of the stated cost-saving or quality goals.
Despite these obvious limitations, the use of critical pathways is being embraced in
many systems. Although designed as a tool for both cost savings and improved
quality of care, it is the former that has been emphasized by managers. Interest in
critical pathways has increased because anecdotal reports of cost savings
have been
disseminated. These reports are best described as case studies and in general have
not followed careful studydesigns. Implementation of the care pathways has not
been tested in a scientific or controlled fashion.7 8 9 No controlled study has shown
a critical pathway to reduce length of stay, decrease resource use, or improve
patient satisfaction. Most importantly,
no controlled study has shownimprovements in patient outcome.3
Lack of careful evaluation has not limited the dev elopment and implementation of
critical pathways in multiple healthcare settings. It is important for cardiovascular
practitioners to understand the goals, development, and implementation of critical
pathways. In addition, physicians must take an active ro le in the development of
critical pathways. By understanding the strengths and limitations of the critical
pathway process, physicians and other practitioners can ensure appropriate use of
these methods. In a review of critical pathways, Pearson et al
1examined the goals
of critical pathways, optimal pathway development, and implementation strategies
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 23/26
Performance-based budgeting
Today, when the management of money is more important than ever for public and private entities,
budgeting plays an enormous role in controlling operations efficiently and effectively. Budgeting in
itself is a familiar process to even the smallest economic unit ± the household - but it needs to be
divided into two different classes: budgeting for public entities and private entities.
This differentiation is important because public bodies need to go through many processes before
moving into the budget execution phase and post-execution analyses; furthermore, the entire process
involves the collaboration of different bodies throughout the government. This collaboration is not only
for budget preparation, negotiation and approval processes, but also for the spending approval after
the whole budget allocation is finalized. Compared to private sector, it is cumbersome.
Another factor is the increasing awareness of the policies of the World Bank in pursuit of restructuring
the budgeting and spending processes of developing nations via the World Bank Treasury Reference
Model. This new model has led the public sector to understand, digest and adopt a new style.
According to this new budgeting methodology, traditional methods of analyzing and utilizing budget
figures are insufficient. In traditional terms, organizations start building up their long-term plans and
break those plans into annual budgets that are formed as forecasts. At the end of the year, budget
figures are compared with actual results and a simple actual-budget variance comparison is
calculated. Since the analysis is simple, this analysis lacks any sophistication in terms of adjusting
similar budget items for forthcoming periods by increasing or decreasing the expenditure estimates.
Basically, variance results are generally used for revising monetary amounts for the next planning and
budgeting cycle, and also for very simple departmental performance tracking.
This new approach to budget analysis and utilization is many steps ahead of traditional methods. As
an example, a governmental project to enhance the social welfare of children in a remote area can
help explain the performance-oriented approach. For such projects, which are generally composed of
long-term plans, governments decide on objectives and the activities that are required to be
accomplished to achieve them. Practical ways of enhancing social welfare of children in a rural area
might include increasing the job skills of parents in the area.
In order to achieve such an objective, the government may plan to establish schooling infrastructures
in various locations, complete with the necessary equipment, and further plan to assign trainers to
those schools for implementing the educational programs. All these activities have a cost aspect and,
at this point, long-term plans are broken down into annual budgets that incorporate the monetary
figures. Once the long-term plans are accomplished, the traditional way to gauge the effectiveness of
this whole project would be to assess the gap between the budget and the actual money spent.
However, with the new budgeting approach, the questions to answer are tougher:
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 24/26
Did we really succeed in enhancing the social welfare of children?
Did this project cost what we expected?
Have we done what we should have done in enhancing the social welfare of children?
Peter van der Knaap from the Ministry of Finance in the Netherlands[4]
suggests: ³The general
purpose of the proposals is to make budget documents and, hence, the budgetary process more
policy-oriented by presenting information on (intended and achieved) policy objectives, policy
measures or instruments, and their costs.´ Furthermore, van der Knaap explains that this type of
budgeting has the following major performance indicators:
(the quantity, quality, and costs of) products and services (output) produced by
government or government services in order to achieve certain effects, and;
the intended effects of those measures (outcome).
Within this kind of a planning and budgeting setup, the lack of reliable information on the
effects of policies emerges as a serious issue. Therefore, it is important to approach the
planning and budgeting cycle in a holistic and integrated way, with collaboration across the
areas of policy design, performance measures definition and policy evaluation.
[edit]Performance-based budgeting (PBB)
This whole framework points us to a newer way of budgeting, the so-called Performance-
Based Budgeting.
As explained by Carter [5]
(as quoted in )[6]
³Performance budgets use statements of
missions, goals and objectives to explain why the money is being spent. It is a way to
allocate resources to achieve specific objectives based on program goals and measured
results.´ The key to understanding performance-based budgeting lies beneath the word
³result´. In this method, the entire planning and budgeting framework is result oriented.
There are objectives and activities to achieve these objectives and these form the
foundation of the overall evaluation.
According to the more comprehensive definition of Segal and Summers[7]
, performance
budgeting comprises three elements:
the result (final outcome)
the strategy (different ways to achieve the final outcome)
activity/outputs (what is actually done to achieve the final outcome)
Segal and Summers point out that within this framework, a connection exists between
the rationales for specific activities and the end results and the result is not excluded,
while individual activities or outputs are. With this information, it is possible to
understand which activities are cost-effective in terms of achieving the desired result.
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 25/26
As can be seen from some of the definitions used here, Performance-Based
Budgeting is a way to allocate resources for achieving certain objectives[8]
,
Harrison[9]
elaborates: ³PBB sets a goal, or a set of goals, to which monies are
³connected´ (i.e. allocated). From these goals, specific objectives are delineated and
funds are then subdivided among them.´
[edit] Achieving PBB
For this type of advanced budgeting, which requires the definition of Key
Performance Indicators (KPIs) at the outset, linking these performance indicators to
resources becomes the vital part of the entire setup. This is similar to the Corporate
Performance Management (CPM) framework, which is ³where strategy and planning
meet execution and measurement´, according to John Hagerty from AMR Research.
This is a sort of a Balanced Scorecard approach in which KPIs are defined and
linkages are built between causes and effects in a tree-model on top of a budgeting
system which should be integrated with the transactional system, in which financial,
procurement, sales and similar types of transactions are tracked. Moreover, linking
resources with results provides information on how much it costs to provide a given
level of outcome. Many public bodies fail to figure out how much it costs to deliver an
output, primarily due to problems with indirect cost allocation. This puts the Activity-
Based Costing framework into the picture..
Both the concepts of scorecards, as first introduced by Kaplan and Norton, and
activity-based costing are today well-known concepts in the private sector, but much
less so for the public-sector bodies«until the advent of Performance-Based
Budgeting! Another conceptual framework that has gained ground is the relatively
recently introduced CPM, again more popular in the private sector. The point is that
the CPM framework has not much touched on the topic of Performance-Based
Budgeting, although the similarities in policies offered by these frameworks are worth
a deeper look. The technical foundation that the CPM framework puts on the table
may well be a perfect means to rationalize the somewhat tougher budgeting
approach, not only for the public sector but also for commercial companies..
[edit]The way to CPM and PBB
Leading companies are integrating various business intelligence applications and
processes in order to achieve corporate performance management. The first step is
for senior management to formulate the organization¶s strategy and to articulate
specific strategic objectives supported by key financial and non-financial metrics.
8/6/2019 Fiscal Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fiscal-plan 26/26
These metrics and targets feed the next step in the process, Planning and Budgeting,
and are eventually communicated to the front-line employees that will carry out the
day-to-day activities. Targets and thresholds are loaded from the planning systems
into a Business Activity Monitoring engine that will automatically notify responsible
persons of potential problems in real time. The status of the business is reviewedregularly and re-forecast and, if necessary, budget changes are made. If the business
performance is significantly off plan, executives may need to re-evaluate the strategy
as some of the original assumptions may have changed. Optionally, activity-based
costing efforts can enhance the strategic planning process ± deciding to outsource
key activities, for example. ABC can also facilitate improved budgeting and controls
through Activity-Based Budgeting which helps coordinate operational and financial
planning.
The ability to establish CPM to enhance control on budget depends first upon
achieving a better understanding of the business through unified, consistent data to
provide the basis for a 360-degree view of the organization. The unified data model
allows you to establish a single repository of information where users can quickly
access consistent information related to both financial and management reporting,
easily move between reporting the past and projecting the future, and drill to detailed
information.
By then, you are ready to plug in - on the unified data - the applications that support
consolidations, reporting, analysis, budgeting, planning, forecasting, activity-based
costing, and profitability measurement. The applications are then integrated with the
single repository of information and are delivered with a set of tools that allow users
to follow the assessment path from strategy, to plans and budgets and to the
supporting transactional data.
CPM and the adoption of more public-sector oriented PBB are not easy to tackle, but
in the ever-changing business and political climate they are definitely worth a closer
look