frank r. leslie, b. s. e. e., m. s. space technology, ls ieee 4/22/2010, rev. 2.0.1 fleslie...
TRANSCRIPT
Frank R. Leslie, B. S. E. E., M. S. Space Technology, LS IEEE
4/22/2010, Rev. 2.0.1
fleslie @fit.edu; (321) 674-7377
www.fit.edu/~fleslie
24 Future Trends in Renewable Energy
Crude Oil $65.71 on 4/25/07$117 on 4/24/08$50 on 4/23/09$82 on 4/22/10
CNNMoney.com
Happy Earth Day!
Some Energy News
Google has been granted utility status to buy and sell electricityhttp://www.google.org/egs/ has more info
DOE funds data center efficiency research
100419
24.I Introduction
Sustainable energy comes from the sun or from tidal forces of the moon and sun; usually implies not using it faster than can be replenished
Since fossil fuels represent millions of years of “stored sunlight”, they are not sustainable
Future predictions are predicated upon uncertain trends with a lot of “noise”
The future is ill-defined!
100422
1 The Age of Cheap Energy is Nearly Over!
“Hubbert’s Peak” indicates US oil production peaked about 1970; World peak may be 2007
Oil prices are volatile, but the long term trend is up as extraction becomes more expensive
Volatile gasoline and diesel prices are increasing in the long term!
Natural gas prices are rising and massive hydrogen production will speed that trendHydrogen will be made from natural gas
first, then coal, then possibly through nuclear thermal conversion or electrolysis from wind or sun
100422
24.1.1 Fossil Fuels
Renewable energy is sustainable indefinitely, unlike long-stored energy from fossil fuels that will be depleted
As easy-to-get fuel is extracted, costs will rise in getting the more-difficult resources; drill oil at 20,000 feet?
Fuels must be transported from farther away, thus increasing total costs of it and what’s made with it
080424
24.1.2 Energy Dependence upon Foreign Countries
Our dependency on cheap oil has led to a slavish relationship to the oil dealers(Like dependency on cheap drugs has led to a
slavish relationship to the drug dealers)
So do we need a “12-step way” to free us from our oil addiction?
100422
Is it best to use all our oil first so we can be at the mercy of outside despots? Should we use imported oil first to save our US oil for hard times later?
24.1.3 “But Wait! There’s More!”
We could break away from conventional fuels to use renewable energy or increase efficient useWind, solar, hydro, ocean tides and waves, geothermalMost/much oil is consumed in transportation; efficiency
needed
The eventual energy changeover will be based more upon relative price as fossil fuels become more expensive compared to renewables
These energies are diffuse compared to fossil fuels, so collection requires a large area converter
Fossil fuels have been so cheap that any tending towards “normal” is alleged to be price-gouging, and people demand that the government hold prices down
100422
24.2 Surfeit and Waste: What about Our Grandchildren?
Consider the ethics of using up resources that our children and grandchildren, etc. may need They might not live long enough to discover substitutes
If we waste resources, we unnecessarily use what might bridge the gap to a sustainable society
If bountiful fossil fuels are required to make renewable energy converters, burning them now will mean new RE converters must be made using RE Can you imagine smelting iron using RE? Perhaps solar thermal melt systems?
100422
24.2.1 The Bountiful Life
We have become conditioned to lives filled with the joys of cheap energy and little manual labor
Microwave ovens are more efficient cookers than electric range “eyes”, yet they were developed to just save time
Multiple family cars are the norm to allow independent travel of the family members
Vehicles enable greater “urban sprawl”Living farther away from work requires more energy-
consuming travel to get thereWhy should a business be located “downtown”?A clean industry like Harris Corporation is essentially
located in a residential area where workers can live nearby
100422
24.2.2 Conspicuous Consumption
Some objects are more for show than utilityV-12, 1200 hp Cadillac engine touted in ads12,000 square foot homesExpensive imported foods; 1500-mile saladLong-distance air travel for an hour meeting“Business” meetings at golf & ski resorts
Birthday party in Sardinia for Tyco exec Kozlowski’s wife$56,000 Hummers suitable for war support on our highways
Potential for a stylish new model with welded, inoperable 0.50 caliber machine gun on roof for show?
Unimog military SUVs now available (upper right) Driven to a renewable energy fair by an RE fan!
Conversely, if someone wants to pay for something wasteful, shouldn’t they be allowed to buy it?
080424
http://www.unimog.net/
24.2.3 Is Saving Your Own Money a “Cool” Thing to Do?
Saving energy isn’t seen as important, but not “being taken” is! Don’t be a gullible chump!
A change of viewpoint can persuade people to change what they buy“Core values” (deeply held) aren’t easily changed by
ranting
Most people don’t think about energy costs until it’s a problemHigh gasoline prices are changing that viewpointLife cycle costing is unknown to most people
New cars are advertised by monthly payments, not price!
Conservation is only a “virtue” according to Vice Pres. Dick Cheney -- What do we know?
080424
24.3 Cornucopians vs. Cassandras
Cornucopians believe that “needs” and “wants” will always be provided for Just in time, a technical breakthrough will allow us to get
more for less, and we want more, more, more!The “Horn of Plenty” is always full to overflowing!“Don’t worry, be happy!”“If it feels good, do it!” --- Nike trademark
080424 http://desktoppub.about.com/
24.3 Cornucopians vs. Cassandras
Cornucopians believe that needs will always be provided for Just in time, a technical breakthrough will allow us to get
more for less, and we want more, more, more!
Cassandras shout that “We are doomed, doomed, doomed”, and no one will listen to them!Cassandra (mythic legend) was loved by Apollo (sun god)
but she spurned him; he punished her by making her unbelievable to everyone
No matter how we try, we can’t fight these oncoming events that will be our undoing and yet no one believes us
“Woe is me!”“We’ve told you for years that you’re doing the wrong
thing!”“What should we do instead?” No answer . . .
080424
24.3 Cornucopians vs. Cassandras
Cornucopians believe that needs will always be provided for Just in time, a technical breakthrough will allow us to get
more for less, and we want more, more, more!
Cassandras believe that we are doomed, doomed, doomed!No matter how we try, we can’t fight these oncoming
events that will be our undoing
We don’t have to choose one of these
philosophies!
040419
24.3.1 “The Horn of Plenty” Shall Always Provide
As European civilization expanded to North America, necessity led to inventions that preserved life or made it easier or betterSteam train, steam engines, windmills, waterpower,
electric lights, telegraph, repeating rifle, automobiles, etc.
New needs led to solutions; what worked evolved into better approaches
070425
http://desktoppub.about.com/
24.3.2 “The Sky is Falling”: What Shall We Do?What Shall We Do?
The Malthusian Theory held that the increase in population would swamp limited resourcesDeath, famine, war, and pestilence would result
An apocalyptic result (It’s been postponed so far!)
Scary movie: “No Blade of Grass”A group of economists, scientists,
and doomsayers examine the outlookRunningOnEmpty.comDieOff.comCaution: these sites may not be suitable
for children or adults!Still, there is great emphasis on self-sufficiency
080424 http://www.postermaniacs.com/originals/onesheets/no_blade_of_grass.jpg
24.4 Energy Information Sources and Beliefs
Information sources should be skeptically analyzed Whose info is it? What or who do they represent? What do
they really want? What’s their agenda?Sometimes animal rights organizations push vegan diets for
good health, but they really want no animals killed for foodPETA now pressing for cloned synthetic chicken so real
chickens won’t be killed
Beliefs of an organization may taint or slant dataNonconforming info is ignored as it doesn’t match their
dogmaThey take surveys of their members (0.5% of population)
and contend that represents the Nation as a wholeSometimes pure hatred of the opposition overwhelms the
group and taints every viewpoint
080424
24.4.1 How Much Info Trust is Demanded?
Is information available to us accurate and complete?
How does the information provider make money?Their existence depends upon public hysteria?
Does the cash flow diminish if the truth is told?When polio was conquered, “March of Dimes” switched to
another childhood disease to support the organization staff
US Energy Information Agency is a USA official sourceDetailed info considered, validated, and publishedDelayed about 2-3 years sometimes
Commercial industry sourcesPlattsAmerican Wind Energy Association
100422
24.4.2 Agendas, Slants, & Scams
Agendas (often are hidden)Wants dam removal for river rafting; argues fish are being
killedLikes yachting in Narragansett Bay; argues wind farms
interfere with navigation (in shallow water yet)Wants next-door forest to remain; they plant endangered
species to “be discovered” --- can’t clear this!
SlantsCarefully selects info to push the “message”; rejects
opposite view; “framing” dominates the informationSelects minor views of opponents and trumpets them
ScamsVenture capital gatherers with wistful, visionary “products”Donation of solicitations with 70% going to staff salariesCentral issue changes to protect organization staff jobs
100422
24.4.3 Direct Effects Upon Consumers
High energy bills strain budgets as prices riseElectricity (and affects those bought from)Gasoline (and affects those bought from)Natural Gas (and affects those bought from)
High gasoline pricesToo high if majority buys fuel efficient vehicles; but not high
if majority buys poor efficiency vehicles (like 12-16 mph SUVs)
The “Time” magazine effect: Whenever a subject is so trendy that editors put it on the front cover of Time magazine, the trend may be overMisleads public to think this is “coming issue” when it’s past“Smart money” is bailing out; don’t rush in to investAvoid investing in something that will occur 20 years in
future
100422
24.5 What Does the Future Hold for Our Children Now?
People that we know, children and grandchildren, will suffer from increased fossil fuel prices (perhaps taxes)
Those that we don’t know, greatgreatgrandchildren may have it even worse; for great7grandchildren, worse yet
What we do today affects future generations --- shouldn’t we care?
(Is it really “All about MEME! MEME! MEME!”)A surging world population will fight to get or control
energy sources, leading to wars far worse than IraqPeople of Third-World countries will crave to live as those do in
the highly over-consuming U.S. and marketeers will ensure thisEffect of global TV influences and makes people aware of
distant consumption trends; “I want to live like those people in those TV shows!” Major cause of Watts, CA riots in 1965
100422
24.5.1 My Energy Costs ForecastCrude Oil
Prices become extremely volatile, destabilizing the market
GasolinePrices rise to $6-10 per gallon (CPI-adjusted) within your
lifetimes, and taxes will be extra!
ElectricityComes from more diverse sources, with growing renewables
used as fossil fuel, becomes more expensive by twice
Public TransportationAircraft: Oil costs may preclude, or use of gases may require,
frequent landing to refuel limited energy storage tanksTrains: Take over some air traffic, but tracks are vulnerable to
easy terrorist attack because they are accessible for milesTrucking Industry: Expands to carry more people in posh cargo
containers similar to Victorian train cars -- a specially bus
100422
24.5.2 Energy Shortages
In 1973, Arabian oil countries embargoed oil shipments to the United States because we had supported Israel in the Six-Day War against EgyptGasoline shortages across the US led to long lines of cars at
gasoline pumps, and angry drivers assaulting each otherPrices did not really soar, but gas fill-ups were often limited
to so many dollars or gallons (rationing); even-or-odd fill-up days
Trans-Alaska Pipeline approved in 1973 (with early enviro protest similarity to ANWR)
Through many contentious issues, California had an electricity crisis that was responsible for replacing Governor Davis with a popular actor, Arnold SchwarzeneggerBlackouts get the voters’ attention!Shortages or total outages are received very differently by the
public than blackouts from equipment failures100422
24.5.3 Lifestyle Changes Needed!
Practice energy conservation and save your money for “fun” purchases (and investments for retirement)
Increase energy efficiency to save even more money for needed/wanted uses
Think of the marginal utility of “supersizing” your lifeLess quantity or fewer features may be acceptable and allow
your money to be used for other things you really wantWould you rather eat a slice of watermelon or a whole
watermelon? Isn’t there a limit to “wants”?
Your time may be far more valuable than your moneyLive close to where you work so you don’t waste your life
stuck in trafficWork at what you would do for free, but don’t tell your boss!
100422
24.5.4.1 Green Energy Cities: US
Chicago, IL Goal: 20% RE by 2006; now 15% Solar on all municipal buildings RFP issued: Solargenix won 2010: 25% RE; 28% energy mgm’t; 22% distributed
generation;25% cogeneration
Sacramento, CA Goal: 10% nonhydro by 2006; 20% by 2011 ~60% RE now; among top ten US cities supplying RE
Portland, OR Goal: new wind farm; green buildings; 100% RE by 2010 10% RE now; 1 million kWh waste methane fuel cells; green
tags
Austin, TX “Goal” 35% RE and Efficiency by 2020; solar initiative 100MW
by 2020
050426
24.5.4.2 Green Energy Cities: International
Reykjavik, Iceland (geothermal and hydro) Goal: World’s first hydrogen city; whole country by 2050 Shell Hydrogen: electrolysis hydrogen for local buses
Vancouver, Canada (hydro plus gas) Goal: emissions reduced by 20% compared to 1999 emissions 90% RE now’ has 100-year plan” Grand Prize for Urban
Sustainability
Barcelona, Spain (nuclear is now 49%) Goal: reduce emissions by 20% compared to 1999 by
increasing solar panel installations
Sydney, Australia (coal, solar) Goals: Reduce coal use from 43% and oil use from 35% of
total usage 500MW Singleton Solar Farms
050426
24.6 International: Price Upsets
Taliban takes over Pakistan government and controls nuclear weapon missiles?
Many countries within reach of those missiles
If Israel is threatened, will they attack Pakistan first?
India has no policy plan to fight the Taliban!What would Iran (close to nuclear weapons
for their missiles) do in support of other Islamic nations?
International instability will immediately cause oil future prices to surge higher
100422
24.C Conclusion
Fossil fuel pollution may increase “Green House Effect”
Humans must have air, water, food, and energyFuture cars will be plug-in hybrids running
occasionally on bioethanol or biodiesel for long tripsTrains will replace aircraft for civilian long tripsRenewable energy offers a long-term, sustainable
approach to the World’s energy needsRequires substantial converter building to increase supply
Economics drives the selection process and short-term (first cost) thinking leads to disregard of long-term, overall cost
100422
25.C Conclusion
Fossil fuel pollution may increase “Green House Effect”Humans must have air, water, food, and energyRenewable energy offers a long-term, sustainable
approach to the World’s energy needsEconomics drives the selection process and short-term
(first cost) thinking leads to disregard of long-term overall cost
Increasing oil, gas, and coal prices will ensure that the transition to renewable energy will occur ―
How will we choose to do it?
050426
080710
Thank you!
Questions? ? ?My website: my.fit.edu/~fleslie
for presentations
Roberts Hall weather and energy data: my.fit.edu/wx_fit/roberts/RH.htm
DMES Meteorology Webpage: my.fit.edu/wx_fit/?q=obs/realtime/roberts
References: Books
Brower, Michael. Cool Energy. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press, 1992. 0-262-02349-0, TJ807.9.U6B76, 333.79’4’0973.
Duffie, John and William A. Beckman. Solar Engineering of Thermal Processes. NY: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 920 pp., 1991
Gipe, Paul. Wind Energy for Home & Business. White River Junction, VT: Chelsea Green Pub. Co., 1993. 0-930031-64-4, TJ820.G57, 621.4’5
Patel, Mukund R. Wind and Solar Power Systems. Boca Raton: CRC Press, 1999, 351 pp. ISBN 0-8493-1605-7, TK1541.P38 1999, 621.31’2136
Sørensen, Bent. Renewable Energy, Second Edition. San Diego: Academic Press, 2000, 911 pp. ISBN 0-12-656152-4.
Aubrecht, Gordon J. Energy, Second Edition. NJ: Upper Saddle River, Prentice-Hall, Inc., 668 pp., 1995. 0-02-304601-5. TJ163.2.A88.
040409
References: Websites, etc.
[email protected]. Wind Energy [email protected]. Wind energy home powersite elistgeothermal.marin.org/ on geothermal energymailto:[email protected] rredc.nrel.gov/wind/pubs/atlas/maps/chap2/2-01m.html PNNL wind energy
map of CONUS [email protected]. Elist for wind energy experimenters
www.dieoff.org. Site devoted to the decline of energy and effects upon population
www.ferc.gov/ Federal Energy Regulatory Commissionwww.hawaii.gov/dbedt/ert/otec_hi.html#anchor349152 on OTEC systemstelosnet.com/wind/20th.htmlwww.google.com/search?q=%22renewable+energy+course%22solstice.crest.org/dataweb.usbr.gov/html/powerplant_selection.htmlhttp://cr.middlebury.edu/es/altenergylife/70's.htmhttp://www.barcelonaenergia.com/eng/observatory/bcnenergy3.htm
050426