fuzziness and the sorites paradox. from degrees to contradiction

7/31/2019 Fuzziness and the Sorites Paradox. From Degrees to Contradiction

1/173

FUZZINESS AND THE SORITES PARADOX

From Degrees to Contradictions

By

Marcelo Vsconez

Cuenca (Ecuador)2007


2/173

!

"

#

$%

&&&&&

' ' (

')('(

!'((

*(

( ( (

+,-./01102 "(34567(%,389:;


3/173

1

81=,'>?88=,?8

=@("+AB?0=*,7%C?D=6(E,A?F=*E!?,-@,

G)?*(%6?9= ,>*(*+?81

0=G$,!?80

H=6,E?80=6AE?80=6E?8:

5 '!?8D5 AC?8,?D0= ?D:

=C?DD= GCG?DD

= G%?D?F:

=$?FD

0=+?FF=E?FF

= 6,*?FF= +=6*?F9= GE%,7+A!?F9

=LK+?F;=$+?


5/173

3

= $?811= +K6?810

F=@%6%?81:KC?80F= C?809

!8H18=6++$?8H10=6C6?8H0

H='6,!?8H0:=6$(?8HHD=6,?8HH

= $6?8HH= BC?8HD

F=C-?8H +K ) ((M'

()

$>+30118?8


7/173

ii

$(>+38;;:8;;F53011D?0:95

')O6P%36?01D(5%6?O(((

()@P38;;:?8;56%)+()

$)('(,' ( ' ( )B ' '((('(4''

'(')$=

E'()((E,,"I()6",R()(I()(6L%+"-I%7)-*)( ( $E , ,

%

6))())()=

C375@


8/173

1

8$!()(

$%&'()*)+,-.'(&/+,0*(1/2**)*+&02

6()4((A(((

C(6 = 3C" ( 5 A

(=('((()$I()C"= ('"#C")8(C"'("#C"A6(

)C"(A(C"( J (

6(()@-(' ) ( )((((($

6)=

&*34.4,+&4*)

AE')"'('(KKKK$')=


9/173

2

+5*&54*6(1/2*(740+38)/*./(9*)*-

6()$C6G$(

((=

6",R/8;;82/8;;H2A"#'((C")(KSKKK$(

6(

A35"(()"

E"()'TUT6UKIKK"KTUKIK(K"KVIVVV(V"VVVVV6((?

W"WX8WWY11(

WIWX8WWX81(

+(C()VV

+')((?KSKKZK6==()G(KSKKKK$!K)(KZK(KKKK(6VSV)8(VV1)1((VZV8VV6((

Z S " I

[8 1 1 8 8

\] ^ 1 8 1

\_ _ 1 8 1

\^ ] 1 8 1

1 8 8 1 1


10/173

3

6K[KKK K\K3535'=(CFFF=1=8

')((K

()3566KK(((A((KK$ (()(()K'K'()A'?K'K@@(=$=)6((=

'(CFF(((

6()' ) KK=

''(()6(())()=

6(`"`(KKKZKKSKTU(TUTUTU6(

+%/(3(78: ; C5

@((!AI+6+,C6(((((=M((6KK$

+++3'C@5,+3$>C5+6


27/173

20

KK(++$6 6

E+AA

, ++ Z Z

A))((>( ( 6"G(+?I(++M(3$>C5$+(

>+M(,((6+)(?M+?6((66N

GE6((E

+C"()6KZK

)VZV$+(VV3"ZI5'()VV6()(?====?ISBTU ((((=?dZ6!3G8;;:?8:0ML0111?095A()!(((=?dZ

+("((

$ 0( 1()M0M1=M $7 01(

=)016 ( (8

(1$)()176($(


28/173

21

(A1a(((

=45A(&4/*)%)0*'/4=434/8

$()

6($%(6(%(((+( ./6'((%80((%KA(

==;DI(((E(

G)G(A:+()

>( =M MM(

02*3*/240/+/%)(1%??8*,/*,0*)

6?(A(((EKKK6K()(@()

6(,AKK6E6>)3,A5)((KK$KK(81(6)>+6G

@KK)(

E=KK81 (G)_(,A=_(

$KK?


29/173

22

F$(==

+KK(?85KK(M05MH5M:5'

2*(&4/*)+&+-(>

"((EKK-)((6((KK((KK6((

$KK FC=((((3((5?

6 ()?6( 6(G(CDQ0

+&474,)

$)( (7%$AC6?!(!!

6(?(((!G)(7K(,((('7(),e7

=,1(&.+3/&%0/%&*(1/2*&7%.*,/

6)(((

56,I35

E? e%? 6)((

(C?

56,A,3)5?

E? $%? 6


30/173

23


31/173

24

9

> =(1(=(

'6(A((' $3%,5M()3+5

?1

M(@ = E ( (3:5

'((

4A(,-4/4(,+3+B(&&*.4)*

E,? 0%,? './

C? 1>? %,?

44A.'340+/4(,+3+B(&&*.4)*

E,? 0%,? 6./C? 1>? %,?

444A4)B%,0/45*+B(&&*.4)*64/2*+@*7+/4(,

E,? 0%,? 7./C? 1>? +?Z

6./$( (((%,+A('

G(!6((((6')=''()$(=9()M' (


32/173

25

'()

-2*(&4/40+3*&4*)

6++(2'2(

'( = M (0 ( (1(='M(($7((./ 2'2 ()((./6./

' ' (A'( "'KK(('2(?@MB(((((

((((( ./(

$)

3+,5 ./ZZ./3C,5 Z3Z./53,,5 Z./3,,5 ./

53+,5?

(

6(=6)(A./6(?

6((

E ( 3+,5 63+,5?VV

53C,5?

((


33/173

26

6('(3C,5( =(./$?))'2./

53,,5?

(

53,,5?

()

@(3535C">3,,5? VV VSV '

3,,5()+353563+,5

3C,53,,5(6(3,,5(6(6(3,,5(((

-3,,5(3,,5$( )(?((!C3(()5!'()

B 3,,5 =?3,,5'(1*/1A1A1*/(36(G)(1*/1?1*/=1'1*/1,'C=@$1*/$>C56K1*/1K(6

6((()3+,53C,53,,56( (

3+,5C" ./SS./3C,5C" S3S./53,,5C" S./

6)S3S./5'(WWX118(W./WX1(8)(1186=1

6(C"G(C"


34/173

27

6C"

I()((()(+(()6+

*(&4/*)1(&+,,=(%,-*-&('*&/8A((( 1G(K!K)"(K$K6(K$K6e($G(A$($(A'$A'C$!G))=?

A$CA===================C$

6($($$'(76('6,3-= C5? 23$5

3$5@C$A'($CCU$((+C$

'(?CC$M$$($(CM$6$((7EAe($4e($6 $eI$A(KK=(((

'(M(6((=(8

'()?((E:(

1*,4+3)(1/2*+B(&&*.4)*


35/173

28

"((((3(5G" ( ( ( ' ()

((('(,3-=C5'( 2$(%(3C,53,,5?

36&5 ./3IS./5

( = G ( K K

KK365(

C,,./3./5./3"S./5(

(E($(M(7''((6'(

6),3-=C56

( 2==66((2(,3-=C5,3-=C5=)()'I(('( 3-= C5 A ( 3-=C5,)G 2

736&5'(./=%((6( ( 6) G()!$(+890DG(6((6

(6


36/173

29

$(

6(()'(./6('

)(G ) = (A((('./)6

C(6()")A

6(=(

()=(?)6)('(()6('()EC"((

G (G6G

(()'((( ='?

./3Z./5

G( ./()+

72**1%)+3(1/2*34''*&83('*

"(((:'(?(M'((((

+A$CA(C$B('(( $ (

(A"('(A


37/173

30

$(C'$($A$G(K!K'?

6(A-6L66(6(%-K3 @($?

"!?

E"!#(?

I

E(A (6 ( VV 4'($(+(A(

' $(

6 ('((@(811a(6C$(A6(K$KC$6(?=6

$(()'G+(++,(('@(( 3 ( 5 ( $

$ )(=)( (+>(A>((A(6(?

KK


38/173

31

A(

+( G ( ( ( (?

X K K

A @ ()? 6 ( E( ( E89K89'

KKX K2

6A(((()

6(G

4($

&!(6((G6(C7E($)$(+('$.'().$6(()$(((((

6()(($

GCFF

2*+)@)(1+2*(&8(1%??4,*))

G(((((()(()

8= '=!0= G!

H= G!


39/173

32

'(()G()(((A'((6'$

>L)38;5((

C%..+&8

G=)'('(

,,

6((E=)($,7%=A,7%'=

C((?-=C,E,@35=

35(G((?()$(=?

G(('0=D((CF((


40/173

33

/(2+'/*&

*7&**)+,-''()4/*)4,,04*,/243()('28

((((('((=

'(%I,$,$() 6 ' ( ) (

*&+034/%)+,-/2*,4/8(1''()4/*)

E'()IK(G(?3535

'(

E?

AD


41/173

34

(VV3A8;


42/173

35

,+>+7(&+)+,-/2*&4,04'3*(1,45*&)+34>/%&*

((6()$'81)?

I(((!

3A?0D;5

6(,$K((('((3+?;H881=805M3-8;F;?0


43/173

36

=E 3'f3D9D=5

(

+

OPOPOP

3,89;0?0;?08=HFFMCG?8:D8F18


44/173

37

( =P 3C A)? FF5 + (

" ( 33:C3$>C5?

(()3''81?88DH5


45/173

38

'((3(5I(?(+(((+

((

6( K(3KK5(3KK5M(((KK?KK&&((==(==52%''


46/173

39

H5(( ?(M:5M$>?MD5(((MF5?M


47/173

40

'((=G((6G>+6( G @ J %

D%4,*

G((()J("/8;F12VG,A!V/8;982')J(OP380D56

KK((((6 ( 6 (6( 6 (39D56((((

J(38095

@JK/8;982)(,AI,AOP3;85C)(('((OP3;:56,A(=J=4((

6 ( 3;8=;05'J$C"6 ./3S./5"G)(6,A

'KK(((G3;:5

6,AG)KKKKJ6(

((3'


48/173

41

(J5'((((6((KK?(

@J(((OP3;05(6(EKK81111K'((E)')

I((((O/2P3;:5'

((6)

+5+3%+/4(,

JK(,AG,A(6G)I($(6(,A(A(

(),A@('()./*/ ?

"))

3CC8Q:56(($KK(((A(((>

E(JUC"

%..*//5)/&(,7945+3*,0*

()),A%/8;;D2bA*c(=

6?KK&(=C(

3,A5)


49/173

42

)(=()

7 ( ( ?385 35(305(3H5@

"((6(KK

6(

,(

'((M( ( (

6$($(

+(=GE((?(=(()()('

@ $$@KK(30195'(+(((

G,A!$(?

7M30885

A(,A6(K

('(

30195A 308D5 6


50/173

43

8B(H /8;;:2

(4(E?K$(-!K(MKWfK630815)

I((( ( KK (

6U('('(6(I('))EM(()4()

(("(6()

")?

(M(()) ( 308F5

4334+.)(,E)7,()/404).

6G((((+)((GG(()(G((A

+9+)40*,*/)

GK(C " 6 , /8;;:2?

6)?=358

$'?O6)$P3H5


51/173

44

IC"6,A?EC"((G)389F5+C",A

G(=

@,A38;;0?8:D5'Z66ZZ(66ZM6E38;;:?8


52/173

45

)((KK

$KK&(KK()TU6(KKKK KK30H


53/173

46

0 , % /8;;92 ) %7, )(EGU/01112

)(G)(" =()(E)A)'")(G "))((( "'

)(M)((%8:;;)'H111))(M0D11A8D11)()()(L()+( = ( ' )(M)((()(((

G()(

3%75M(( ("(M(( " )(')(L()'(()((()((6)(KG K 6)(%7)(

(A()(((=(=((

G'3%7,(5)(0

4G=(KKKK6%7,6?

'! )(!38;;0?8F85

( = 6 %7, 300


54/173

47

6(KK(((30H05?

K)K)(K =8)K'(?3N5 '()()=8)

6G(?

3%7,5L6K

(KLKK)(KVKVVVK6K(((

'3%7,5)(')( S=8()(6(KLK

(%7,LK=8K(A(TS=8K((()()((30HHM8;;F?:15

@4)(=38;9=018M8;;)((

2((A((


55/173

48

(8

$ 35 " ((MM301FM8;;F?

HH1=H85I((A)(G((30H8M8;;0?8F15(()30HFM8;;:?89F5

,()7KK'(()7KKE()(

6=30885

G($((( (('(KK(((G=&!301;5E

((E(O'=P38;;:?89D5

042*4)0%))4(,(,/2**/*&.4,+/4(,(1*+,4,7

G((GK6((

@A.7C6'@8G/8;;:2=EG6==89A()((KK!GK38;;:?89H5GG(I((KK89!$)$G=EG()(KK ( ) A )((


56/173

49

$+G7>G/8;;F2=GG(((

EGK()(((+(

@A.7C6'@0+/8;;G/8;;


57/173

50

( ( $=I(% K('=(

$+G7>G/01102=G4 ( ( =(=U'!((? ((

@A.7C6'@:%/8;;92=G(

6)KK%K1K==9160H((91[10H6E /=882( 1EG)KK 6KK()((4)(I(()!6

$+G7>G=GGK=((+%

@A.7C6'@D+/8;;02/8;;F2=+)$((((6GK)=($+?O'((P38;;0?8FG/8;;02=C)(G(((

'(((( )

)((KKG=


58/173

51

38;;:?89H535KK6(>((G(

>L/01112( 6 GK + ( ( 39056)G()((((3


59/173

52

H + /8;;02 GU ( ((TU

315 385 35305 3H5 3:5 353D5

3F5

II>$$3651%3X%,53E51%,80H+3X+5:%3X%5

8=D>$$

'385(3,A533155G385%M"3F5(

-46(*+-4,7)(1/2*&((1

A )GK''(GK

=GH'(()=(KKKKKK'(KK)()KK KK I(EKKKK81+)GU

C'

3,A5C" WWX8WWX1365C" WWX83E5C" WWX1S

315 385 S3WWX8WWX15305 WWX83H5 WWX1S3:5 S3S53D5 SSS3F5 WWX8WWX1

II>$$?365C"1%,3E5C"1%,80H+:%8=D>$$

6(((63D5((385

I(365C"EK6K638;:=F5+


60/173

53

KK KK 365 6(365 C"KK 6 ( 365C" ?

36&5C" WWX8

636&5C"((A(3D5?

3D5 SSS

63D5((VV(V V$(G'(=(38;:5?

A()!(!

GI(?

3%5

3C8;;;?80;M8;;:?8


61/173

54

G(=6K[K(K =K

%=*'

3,A5%*" WWX[WWX=

365%*" WWX[

3E5%*" WWX=Z

315 385 S3WWX[WWX=5305 WWX[WWX=3H5 3853053:5 SS3WWX[WWX=5

II>$$?!3,A5%*"1%,80$3X$58=H>$$

((3H5=

)385?G(>=()4(GI6$(3,A5%*"

'GK( 8 1 ( (

$=()'(GK('(A)

-444)0%))4(,

GK'

@A.7C6'@G/8;;:2=GGK G38HD5

$VVVVG(GVVVVGG(VV$$1 G 38:D5


62/173

55

: I( G 38;9 G /8;;F2= C G)

G(@(((((AG()GGD

6 VVG(=KK

*(,/4,%4,7/2**=+/*

G(((G'(((((G(E(-/01102%-=6


63/173

56

)(GK/01102)

*44/2&4)'4,&472/

'(GG/8;;:2(((?5=M5)(

M5"AGKG

E((G)=(6(>G385 ( 6((>((+((

'(GK

I KK ( (((I?

))38D85

+(()(=G G )()((E

8F018 ( ( ')((8


64/173

57

(

$()((G8


65/173

58

F+38;;;?:9D5gg8

Y

Y(Kg8YKK

K=+g8Y

*4444/2/*'2*,02411*&

++3/8;;


66/173

59

KKA,($I)(@(()((IJ76)()(

( ( ( 356 2?I 2M . )( I2M223562H9H0K356IH9H8$35KK2-(.)((H9H0.)(IG'()()(KK2G(()(M()(( KK

6)

E(((GK7K'('(KK M ( )(

G/8;;


67/173

60

)((38;;:?89H56((G ( E O)KP3011H?+I(7''()%/01182

$(G

()((+

EGK+ ( ? 6 M(+GK(((38


68/173

61

S=8)()()=8=

@) 38


69/173

62

P381956 (+()$=3095

" 6 ('>

)

+))*)).*,/

6 ( (A( (I((+(M(

A()

( ( ) ' ' (6=+)(=()(A($+K)= + ( ( ())-

,K@ + '(()

+K)(((')(3C81


70/173

63

EC(( $('=)6

')')')6(E(%LK + :1a 811a ( E63L)898=89()A()(),A)( (

6E3815C( 6 U C"3,A5)G@(=((

635(EKK4(M

@ J G 3011H?


71/173

64

'(

(() ( G (A>%6==LE>L

%))*33

A>8;0HI( ( 6 ) VV

($7(6(()VVVV((VVVV3F:=FD5

>)((6(=(E((('=3CI8;;05

6>( * ( I(((

G>K)(('(((!&$(()(I>K

(((3F05

G) $$$M(@='=((E)M6>K6(=(=(-'D1a6>K

)


72/173

65

( >(I)(35I)=,=OPI?O'/K,K2(P3FH535>

$35)((3F05((''(>())$("(

'35)(((E((A(((

((E(('>,((((?O(P35

$(35(%()(TUTU>K,7%M,7%OP3FH5(TUOP3FD56=

(A,7%(?("

"35()>K=6')-=C,=3C,5=(I('( ((($(@( ? VV(

+))*)).*,/

6'(>K('(E>K((((

+(>K((((C,$('(='('(

CFQF=6


73/173

66

8+)

(G(%)C/0118?;D9L

+4,*

LEK/8;


74/173

67

6 E $ KK $ 6$ == (

@'3( 5 %$!%??3=56(

$(E!%?? 35 (KK$(+!%?

M'?35M35(KK $3%?((30

"(E((("$ E )KKK)KKKKK6 KK KK K K K)KKK(KK'())) ) G , 7%A)30


75/173

68

6E$!?

IXSSS

6( II&'

'O IP30995E='(

'E ( (((((

+44%'*&&%/2+,-+34-4/8'6 ( )

$30


76/173

69

'6 ((((

+)G

" ( ( ( E

6=(6(($=309


77/173

70

( (? M6(M 6 3S./5

S./6(((I(bS./V

I()())()$ 6 AS3S./53535$S./(

@A.7C6'@H=+)((35KKK)K35KKKKKK6=735KKKKKK+6)

6((M

('= 3017,"4=635=353KK)(5((EKK?

3K5 KKK./K

?

3V5 S./

$KK?

3K5 KKKSK


78/173

71

(3K53K5KK>3K53K5(M)($"3U5'

$)E A +KK()K K$( ( 6( 6 ( G)'(K

K'(((6

@A.7C6'@:=6KKK((KK!'(((3CA8;;8?F;5

>7,"4='

I( 6 6(

@A.7C6'@D=+$365?KK@ 365 ( (($(+KK6KKKKKKI365?KK365

>7,"4=4365'KKKK((KK6?KKKKKKMKKKK+(365365 E 365 E 365((?KK

L


79/173

72

36&5 KKMKK

+36&5

0))*))4,7%'*&5+3%+/4(,4).

@(=

6((*G)(E=C"()

I ( ()(()C"

E'"E)66 G + ( ( KIKKK((6 KK=6(6(3+8;99?H8MA*E?8H95'

E)(4"G

(LE38;


80/173

73

($$(()OP($38;;:?8H5$>>)*3F


81/173

74

7(./)./)(()(./6(

6L

'7((6')(

E(=',7%A

(TU6,7%6))6U

$=( 6)

402+*38*E),-*/*&.4,4).

'@

%6((@

6LK=6 K'K ? (()(()K'K(6'(#*!66=6K

6 ( LK ( E VV(VV6(VV)L()G VZV $ VZVG(VV


82/173

75

8 ] _ ^ 1

8 8 ] _ ^ 1

] 8 ] _ ^ ^

_ 8 ] _ _ _

^ 8 ] ] ] ]

1 8 8 8 8 8

(VV=VV=VZV6)('KKKKKZK38;;:?090=9H5

+2*&*)(*/*&.4,+/*+0/(1/2*+//*&+=(%/62*/2*&4)"((+ $ A ((638;;:?895,V(VKKKK$K$K+$=(.$6K$K.

.6('.$K.M.)+.K$K38;;:?05

E((%*=E? $

76)M)7M(((76@(((=(KK6A)+=

6')6KKK)(KK)(K6KK


83/173

76

KKM

G ()A6?638;;:?895

6G

=,-*14,4/*&*.4)*)+,-472*&&-*&+7%*,*))

A6K(((('(./'(((./6( ( I KK 6 ( A@

6()(6'638;;:?8D5I(?O+P35+(%(6((

$6?./'A)

Z3

Z./53Z./5+?K

!K($

(6K K($./)./K./K(CK./K(

I?A(&$6?(38;;:?09HH5$((

'6(K KK./K4(

6K$ GK

K 3,7E56K I'


84/173

77

(6,7E((A,7E(+(K ./KKK'(6=6U(=

(((7(+$( 6 (

0&4/404).

6K(I( (3(

5VZVE(((

E6I(VVVV)==&?('(VV>'( VV 6((?VVM

MVV),())'(+38;;0?8985(C(638;;:?8


85/173

78

.$$(.I.$6)G($=(.($.(.6'(A30111?DH5(VVVV

(VVVV66

'(K./K!'(?A6(I((./(6)KK(K./K

E(()(((@(K KK

]K3?9F=


86/173

79

'(())=

G(>7K6(()-")( N%K ( +K ( 7 (G$((

,7*3

>7/8;9;2)

''((())

+2*&*&*&+-%+3&('*&/4*)

7)(((((')(((6$G((((((+

(()(('KK

( (''

@(?%?=J

6((+(()6((('(G(%( G (

6 + (6


87/173

80

0",C?) &$'(((

/7KKh23>8;;8?(,( ( $ ( ()6)(?


88/173

81

( ( @K

6((=E(((

6(((( ) (

(G6 ()CK K$KK(@(

(7%*,

6(( .$ -/8;F9=F;2 ' ' ( -K(

"-K+K+f+f66+6((=='

385 '35=35g81=H++f

(f E,(8


89/173

82

H 6( 3HFD5 8(3HH85

/182')/182,(8


90/173

83

8 ] _ ^ 1

8 8 ] _ ^ 1

] 8 8 1

_ 8 8 8 _ 1

^ 8 8 8 8 1

1 8 8 8 8 8

'(WWgWW(G 8 1 ('WW(WWWWCM((

WWgWW(+(C-KKSK

X16KK3HD9=;HF05E)-

KK3H:


91/173

84

8;;;1118 8111(11181KK+KK==811118;;;$,)'(

W+1WX8W+8WX1;;;(((

WWWW6

W+1+8WX1;;;i8X1;;;

C(?

W+8+0WX1;;9i1;;;X1;;9(K;;9K

$7A((?

W+;;9+;;;WX1118i1110X1D

6 ( 6 ( ,3011H?HF


92/173

85

('-K"((')(6(6(

*? $ %, *,

+1 8+1+8 ;;;+8 ;;; 8+8+0 ;;9;;9;;+0 ;;9 8+0+H ;;9;;


93/173

86

+[8(?

18W180W80HW0Hj;;9;;;W;;9;;;8111W;;;

GC(?

80Hj;;;8111

A8(8111I=6-K(8

%-K==)=

>)(

EC8QQ:FMCFQF

*(,03%)4(,

' ( -K (? $ ( ((('(((($

$ ( 6

)I( ( (

()35

+@(11

-")/8;((==I)EKK(?WW))W

WE")(+)

'6 11!

kgl E35Ym(KlE35K(6lEK


94/173

87

(6l E?lEX3l-8l-)56K&&K7l-KK

@")C6($"))(3:D95$

(('

I 8F 8FD 8< 8


95/173

88

VZV'VZV135%")KK83:


96/173

89

EH

")eK$6

=))*)).*,/

G")$'(A)KK

('$KK(()

()")K E C 8 Q F CFQF

+024,+

L%='/8;


97/173

90

I((%(6)66(

385KK)305KK

3H5KKKK3:5

'6)C6

3853053H5+

6(3853:5((30538546)C 6 3


98/173

91

(A)

$K'VVVV6VV??

(3D;5

$ ) .K I ?

=2*(740(1+7%*,*))

@ %6E$?(

)M6 $ = )

A( ZZ3Z5!!6 6(D1a'('((,CGKK(1D=

KZK

Z1D='D1a D1a D1a'$M

B6VZV8VV+WZWX8=WW$ 3D


99/173

92

VV$(

WWX8WWYWW8=WW[WWWWWW

$

8 ] _ ^ 1

8 8 ] _ ^ 1

] 8 8 ] _ ^

_ 8 8 8 ] _

^ 8 8 8 8 ]

1 8 8 8 8 8

6)?WWXWW

$(%K ( >&$$(VVVV'? WWWW6/2(

%V$#V/182G('VVVV886668 (VV(VV$VVVVVV(VV8=E1;(1861H10AVVVV

$3WW=WW538=5VVVVWW=WW'VVVV

VVVV &VVVV3


100/173

93

('( %(/1823FD5

6KKKK)(

KK

0>'3+4,4,7/2*3+%)4=434/8(1/2*(&4/*)

((("'((KKMK%KMKAKMKKI

385

305 3A53H5 A3:5 3%AA53D5 3%A53:5 3%AA53F5 3%%A53:5 3%AA53


101/173

94

'3:5(?

395%AA

%%

IK%K8EW395WWAAW%395()E(IKAKKAKWA AWX8(395$(%)6(KAK((KAK3


102/173

95

6%K(8= '?WW1(KK?88=8=08=H6 6 8=$(

3:5=3H53D5(83


103/173

96

OP3


104/173

97

:$738895)6$*3011H?HD5?

:?( ( ' A()6')

6 6 (A 6 ( (

%? 'KKKK

*C6*/KKK*/K('((

KK(K*/K$CC(KKK*/K( */=+KKKK((

C ' KKKK(38


105/173

98

6+K')'>(=>+

O P 38


106/173

99

(((KK6VVVZV6(+K

8 ] _ ^ 1

8 8 ] _ ^ 1

] 8 ] _ ^ ^

_ 8 ] _ _ _

^ 8 ] ] ] ]

1 8 8 8 8 8

0&+-%+3+34-4/8

A( &!+38;08;D5

I(6VVD1aVV(VV$$1D+(1D

+ (D1a6(D1a$

D1a(D1a6(

6"? ,

YD1aYD1aD1aD1a

C

D1agD1aD1agD1a

*!

444

-2*(&4/*)> ((1DE=1D')==((81D'(818((1DZ:;ZD1ZD1ZD8+ ( 1D1D


107/173

100

*))*)).*,/

B+KCI=6+K ) I( C"(

C"=(+K

@)E(/182(((+' ((6($

($)) ( ( %+(

$EGVV ! ' + (O)P+)(38;F5

+(( )( = = ( '=2E(AA)AKCI=)=)('((A(A(A(,A(('2('(( (('()(()'(+QF

'

+6)3011:?0815?O(K K


108/173

101

D$C,=+>?A35

PI(66)(((('6)?

3->65KK

G 213! +3011:?8F989H53->65(=((6((?/182$(3->65 /182KAKAKKAK G+K+K+))+KA3->653->65

((E

31D1D5D1a6(D' $(

$(+KWWWZW(()6

)"+K''$?

"?

AKK1:;6KK+1:;D1a67,)'(+KW3+CFQF5

E C )(A'(4+OP30118?


109/173

102

35(

I

1.4/2E)*1*,0*(1*7&**)(1&%/2

((+30118QHF5

= ) G(

=,/2*5*&84-*+(1+-*7&**(1/&%/2 =E) n )

$+$ ' (K K'

=6(3011D?8


110/173

103

6AAKA@G3011H?G((( ( (=B(((

= 2* +)/ 9+3- +,= $ (

'((8


111/173

104

./(8$(8(KKK./K

+(KK8K./K1;;;(C?

-==

=&%/21%,0/4(,+34/8=$(('VVVZV(VZV ( 6 6G38;;:?8HF5?

KI()K

' KI KK

'+( D1 a A ( ( ) @ E(((39F5'

()((3


112/173

105

EOP(A((!6(((

I(()$6()3Io?H8:5OP3B?09F0;85

IK )6=)()3")?:F0:985M3-?HH05M(3%8;


113/173

106

)E(

GG!6()((()(%

()(G)((G

E()KK()((EM()(M(++(KK=((6D116

()(((

@I((()(()((()()(')(()(M()(=(I($(K$K?)6

4()(

",4334+.)(,E)=B*0/4(,)7+4,)/+,8+3%*-(740)

6G=I())=6()(3CG0110?D05

'()KZK=KK3(?WZWX8=WWWWXkWWWWm5(KK()?WWXWZWXWZWX_CG$)=OI(1!P38;;:?8HF=8H


114/173

107

A(=)(K,K8 ( M (3$$$5G ? 1 35M 8356(

,7% ( (3G!()5A

E((M(,7%((A())+(,7%

G + (('(KK(=

==(/8;;:?80F=80


115/173

108

-=)((()M3C56VV(6(C

=(A?

G(6)(=

))=)3(=M((==5 @((

( 6GK


116/173

109

$=(I(G())6?

&472/E),/%4/4(,4).

CG((H8;


117/173

110

(@(()G((A(

38;9


118/173

111

G38;9


119/173

112

A3$-[5VV)((VV6()VV)((((

+KK(35) (

( > 6)OP3011H?;:5,(()

6()

6( )

(('(M ( ( 3


120/173

113

02*,/%4/4(,4)/(3%/4(,/(/2*(&4/*)

G6./'(?SS3S./5I((./G(((?

3B75 3S./5

63B75SS3S./56G=(*S3S./53011H?;;56(39:5$3./56MVSVVSV?E$!

3915G(6G(38;9;?8H1=H85

G 3B75 ( ( 3B75)(39H::5A((3B75

()(39H5

*3B75IGK(?

'3S./5KK

6+3OP5('=

'3B75

-3()4,7(..*,/+&8

6((G'= ( = )3EGK'C8Q85I(VSVVSVE($$$$

=KM30118?D:815


121/173

114

(3ECFQF56'(Q:@EC8@')G')GK6G?

(38;;:?8D85

$ ' ( ) "?

=((35$(38;;:?8H;5

'(GU(I=I((I

'(=(((38; ) ( '(

42434).

-)$ + G((?,B6I

+,7*&

,B/8;


122/173

115

3?8


123/173

116

'B($$ ( E KK((6B*(7B

=@2(6'3?8DH;5

'(B()((6663?0:DM?8HF5

G ?($

B((IM ' M 6 '(((AB(

6(B(E((3? 8:95 ' )?KKKKKK

%VV6+)(6(((3?8:;5

+4&4/404).

'())BKE((B

(?E6B= 6 ( G(((G

I((6(B)I3?8:15I$?MM(4(


124/173

117

8$&(M((

7=8

G(('(VV=VV)EM=

G3?8H156VV6"

B(E(($G3?8098HH5I(A('*/M./+')

(,,3,,5?*/

'%,((B4 ' (G!$( ( ' A(?6G((6(((

6M7BB

? () 6,,Z./,,Z./6)B()()6((((

+((')!()((=(=66

'(()@BK $6'(?

OP)KKKKKKOP3?8


125/173

118

MOP3?0:;5

A+(

"B=(

' (KK((6+M(@ 26(-= C,$((6GB((3-=C5

=(&7+,

6IK'(()?I

&$(6,( 6) =( = =%('KK"

II

B ( ! GM((I)6(6?38;;:?8


126/173

119

0$((

)A ( I 6

CI(@0'())

((6('OP(N38;;:?8FD56')IAK$$$K6(A(!G(=(

@IK(( I)( (==A6,A=(?+MII)> KK

I (38;;:?8FH56

=4&4/404).

6IK)EIK'

((B'(6((A( !E MI=?+(

I((=G'(')(((+


127/173

120

H ' ) ?

MK K(KK*?*011HMA+G011H?(K$3? 38;;:? 81FM 8;;9? H8:5 + I )('I(IIA)()')$('()38;;:?88H5(6')+'IK()

6(=I@=


128/173

121

EVVV./V(A=6KKTU(('TU3)

5(= 6 6 ATUT./K6((('

+&+0(,)4)/*,/''&(+02*)

6((

?E(M$)>L30111?8;


129/173

122

:%&O(P3F:


130/173

123

=6(7KK?V V6(

I$'(

=*3*5+,/4).

6'((>+I/8;;H26= = $ )('%S3S5SSSM=

S++I(((,((%)'A = =

E('+I( =( =(

C

(((C"I(A('6)D1a)D1a(%ME,R/8;;F2

+I=KK(38:5A(=6)

K$K

'()

KK

( )

E


131/173

124

K%EKE

36KK()5A()='(

(6(KK)(6

E

A,(((%VV)'6(()KK=A+I

$ M

KK6(()?G($(=(=!.(()( ( ?

Z[8

641(M1?

S31Z5

6$'(?

E1E1E8E=8EE

A$$((&!M?(VV(VVVV6$

6$66($$()==C"6


132/173

125

$(

0+7%*,*))-+'/45*(740

6'(=-*)A*L)

6(=)A-3A5+')AKA

6((C"6()(('!*&'$"'$"((

(A(>(M(VSVM$ VV(M ($'()$3B""5 $3"""5(

(''$""""#bSc"""'($"B""("""'((

' () *)*L))6==(6(((?

.M

.%%

"((KK K K ( ( A)()M(((+(?

3/""Y>$37$


133/173

126

3'KgKKYK56?%M%,M,6?

37$$Y>38

$G()>>[8((

+$G(?VVM

E( &*& 3*$"5()G('?S3>>[856B""$I

&&&&&('(

@)(KK

G(,%('. 8%0,H(KK((=')='(01$*$"=6((

6'$"((

I((("#' (

(((()6(((

+11.+,E)(,/*>/%+34).

'/8;;:2/8;;F2>G

>K ?($!ED1I()=(=!6$ '=(A(6OP()((KK+

(,(>


134/173

127

)( 38;;:?D154('= 6 ? O ( ) !(P38;;F?8 (

)38;;:?D


135/173

128

E)90


136/173

129

?G(>$"A/8;;82(3::5?bcbc3F85$((

38HD5 ' )(M$))3-8;99?:D056($?M3%D%?:1F=


137/173

130

!

''+66(

2*(&4/40+3*&4*)7+4,

"((

66

('818``?350M35/00M35(./)(?

3C,5 Z3Z[/5

"(35K%:'0

(./$)((MG3C,5(./

6A3C,5

3,,5 !?Z[/

3+,5 $!?[/ZZ[/

3+,5(./=?I(3+,5((`"`3+,53C,5' ( 35 3+,53C,56(()

()+(3,,5(

3,,5 &?./


138/173

131

(44/00'(F44118K44K118MK/00K44/00E'()3,,5$3C,53+,5((KZKKSK)6

3C,5 3+,5 3,,5 ((@3,,5(

'((()(((C")(6()6()G(C"(((A((C"()+')((

(+( 0

/00( (3C,53+,5G)3C,53+,5(./M(

)((K2KG2E

M ( M (M((M(6(2(((0/00

6(E3C,53+,5( C G 38; ( 2(((I(E(3+,5(./I(2C"=

+((KKKK3535$3,,5

'!G(((' E)'))G((


139/173

132

2*+/%&*+,-/2*+%)*(1/2*&+,)4/4(,

%)+38;;0?8


140/173

133

/003C,53+,5G!

2*42434)/,)6*&

'()(),B+G%)I

(M()E/00((A=(/00(6( 6

G!G((('?NEG38;


141/173

134

I(((((K)!K?

365 3S./5

IKSK365KZK3C,563C,5`

`365?)('( %(./6(365

'(36544(/00'36544M((44(0M(A;;/00(

M( 365 ' ) KIK365E365?

36&5 3IS./5"K)$K(

7((6

@(I!'

GJ80('(VV6 = ? ( ( @)(?$7(>((=6=((A7( (636&5(

6( ((+38;


142/173

135

``(( E(``6+($((

K(('((('((((($#M6)(

B()46

"-()(+((6-663,8;;9?:8D5A'( $( = E K 63C,5;0

$3C,5( 36&54 Q H N$>30118?;5

%(()C"(6Z./0/003A?HHF57()3>7?H


143/173

136

(+((./)N

A)(--)$?O')((=

P3L+?D;5G26((./$(KK((N62./(2(6./)$(M(

+(6(./6(E(

4 G 2(6(226M'(

I(!@('()MKKA(26)(2W='W=(2

$( 22+3011:?8FF5'2$((2M2=A

$(A () ('( (( ( A M())("-30111?838;;:?DH56()($((

62(2W==


144/173

137

((+)(2A(./=8!6'2)? 22$`` 2

'(6

G8;;:38;;:?01H5M?

OP2

6($A(G(($:;;;;AD1111($( A D1111 +

36&

54G30110?DH5M?

)(

IA)C(%A30H95?

2

((3C,5?./(( 2M(

6( 62MA=

!(,/&+-40/(&4+3&+-%+34).

'M('()((?

!+%??4,*))

G!E(( " (E60/00 $ ( (

3I(0111?995E(/44A((


145/173

138

(63>0118?


146/173

139

('()((6(FC:

!=*7&**)(1&('*&/4*)

+=)(3+qG?:


147/173

140

8+*,R/8;;F2

((6'3$#,R01185

G3CL8;;;?65

6(3>65

3>6&5 6KK

>8'(KKKKKKKK'VVVVAVVVVVV

@((3>6&5>(3>6&5(()(3>6&5(=3>6&5+3>6&5?A(M3>6&5A63>6&56


148/173

141

0 C %- %" 8;;:? 0H;

=

@(?()(6)(>=76((

63>6&56($(($()6$((`(()`3>6&5()%$CC66)KA()+

G(3>6&5=

?(KK(I

3->65 6KK

(()3-8;;65KK3-?HH8

HHHM")8;


149/173

142

HG38;;:?8:D5G

6((M(((

!-4,4.+34).5)+>4.+34).

G(

)((-3->65( (>)?((G ( >((/2

A$$$(($13?

3%>5? VVVV

$$$$'(VVM(

+((8!+(%((((

$ 6( A> CGI >3F05?

((

G38;93D05

G 3 0F05 O ( ( (PH%("


150/173

143

=C((!=C((3"5

E

(M(63C+85

%38;L30111?0


151/173

144

:6" = $ > ? 1 3, HF0M 7( 0F:M ,R 8;;H? 90M > DD9M > 8;F


152/173

145

DC%-%"8;;:?08D085 ( 1(6('$#3?=M

3$>5 VVVVM

6((-,3011H?8F5(?OE=PD

63$>5) ? 'VV(VV(+VVVV( ) I?VVVVVV35

'()3$>5'(((3$>5

!*&(.*7&**)/((,/&+-40/4(,)

G((()G(3%8;8;;D?8


153/173

146

" C?M)M)'(G)((!AG(!A(

(GK'(3L)?9D5'(+(((

((3$>5EM 6

'()A()=

?)('

!1&+-%+3&+,)4/4(,

I( !'(G((02K)(/;;a8a$($(;0)( A((;/()

(((;/D8a= :;a=C=I((,=?(I(()

6;0;/'!'((=A;0=;/+=6./ZZ*./ M``1D1;;GZ3 Z./5!''Z3;0Z;/5V;0V1DV;/V1:;VZ;/V1D81D()+3C,5D1aMA3C,5($44/001;;

G3A)8;FH?8156@3C?0F8MI?801M+=e?


154/173

147

6)((0G!2

"(,03%)4(,

$'(?((!'H'((:D((((((()@/2)6(=(

@(

(@(()(3CAI?:5


155/173

148

"

6'$(

(G'=')==@''(((($'() A8F

C8(

'"#

()(+"#C"

@((&'( ( I(()()'(

'8H(

)(=G((()G ) +( + %) I >((I((((6(G((E(G(') ' ( (

C(E((( A( ,7%G(,7'+3,7'+5( ( () ( EVZVVSV(VV+()

$((


156/173

149

6((((('()((=(%((

OP((( 6 ()6((

' (E)) ( ) 3(5$VV

)(((((2(3-=C,5

'(GK$K

6(+()(I(+( +(

6

C8((' $$$( 6'

E((I,$,$6)'('()()?

60D? = '(G(?GJG+>EL6>7-")%+GBI+I*)>

C0(()((

G( JK ( ( $ (


157/173

150

6(6G=?3535)((35G() (''(

$3()5( 3 5 G G)( (KA(((E(V(V

C +( ((%+

((@((

E'G+35(35

CH('

'K K

KKM6((')=(6($=( + ( ()6)

" ( ( 6K )

6(( ( = )(=6(VV(VV(((

C:=(' ( > 7K

I C ( (

,7K"K!


158/173

151

(G(

-((/182

")((6( $ ") ) KK

I(-")(

6(%K((I

G( (81

6((+(?(KKKK$6$@+

$" +K (6(( (

(%+(((

CD((G(CGK('G $?()$GK((I(= '

,BK6IK(AKK?6EB()$I ' (

(A(


159/173

152

B((6)(I((((I= 3 5

(+ ( ?

+K IK - *)K $ 6('() ? (

E>K(6(A)A

((

$CF(?(6( ? I( (3%5!6(=(385=C,=305?((ENG(385305=

(

((E($( ? ( 26()N6(

$('%)3(56( ( $((?6 6(((66"

$

(')((


160/173

153

) 6 N % ( E


161/173

154

#

$)%q6G/01102V6EACV09?088=::

$%/8;;35*8CGA,7A'32*95

=====/8;G(A)(4)@B,

$#E",R/01182V",6V


162/173

155

A , $ I /8;;92 V' $ ,CV,A$I353%*0>)3-!$!$%-,+L($,8=;

An 6 ' A 6r)p /01112 V% % E?67G)V,358;D=0H1

A6A+/01182V-,*VCGA+35$(!$!$ (4)$C%,H1;=08

A) % /8;H /8;


163/173

156

=====/011D2VC"CCV+%$+35,',"X?WWWW0110WW=W

% /8;;F2 %$ ( + $ $=$CCB,

G@(I,/01112VE?IV,3508=80:

I,/8;;11!(3%'5L($,

%/8;


164/173

157

=====/011D2VG*CV80D?035/8;992=1=)%=1:I3-5@=G

-%E-35/01182> =07*0L($,

-J/8;;92'L($,

- A + /8;;12 V$ - '? 6 V!@9D?H;8=:8F

-%/011H2V$6=*-V.CA358D8=8;:

-=G A /8;;12 V+V $h . '!A #-&*''?=#)h+$60,,BE0:0


165/173

158

-G/8;;*E%+,V.76 35 = = $ >( , C &9?8D;=99

=====/8;;:2V6?$*V?!HH3+5?;V=#!8H


166/173

159

LCI/8;$(CCB,

L>/01112CCB,

L>q+,35/8;;3.5,I,6>

L)A/8;;:211!6+11!="IC,

"G/8;G+35+!!1'G-(B,H:1=H


167/173

160

%L/8;


168/173

161

=====/8;;12V,6E%?6$C"V&H


169/173

162

>+/8;;D2=@@B,

=====/011H2V6+,VC9,"B+$(

>En/8;;H2)3$=@A)(

,

> /8;D92 V$ > K 6KV ! $38;?0:8=0:D

=====/8;;822=1:!$7+,B,,

=====/011823,3,3C@C

> $ /8;F 7 /8;;;2 V$ * 6V + 88

:8=FDG,I(B>"?g?WWW't88W88Y

>.A)/8;G-/8;F02:='$!CB,

>A/8;0H2V*VL+35F8=F9

+=e L /01182 V6 E >? - $GV08?8=0D

+%)/8;992C?CB,C0?V*?6,IV0D=:;

+%)/8;;82VCGAV$LKC " F8;;1 LKC ",

=====/8;;02 V+ , 6 JV 08?8


170/173

163

+>%6G/8;;


171/173

164

+./011H2VC'=>+V!FH?0F;=91

+)%/8;;12%@C,

+>I/8;;H2VB*(7?35V!81?6EVI.+)35>

6$/8;9:2V6+,V!@F8?H;8=:08

6%/8;;:2V+,+*VLq+/8;;


172/173

165

**/8;;92V*C+,V $%"?g?WW(((WWW8;;9tHW1;Y

*-/8;DD2V@IV-* 2! *'G-,3.5,B,80;=8D1

=====/8;FD2V>,V*/8;


173/173

166

=====/8;

fuzziness and the sorites paradox. from degrees to contradiction

Documents