hepatitis c virus genotype: is it an independent predictor of progression of liver disease?

1
406 Hepatitis C virus genotype: is it an independent predictor of progression of liver disease? Sanjay Agrawal 1 *, Savant Mehta 1 , Qin Liu 2 , Chung C Hseih 2 , Herbert L Bonkovsky 1 and Raymond S Koff 1 . 1 Gastroenterology, Liver-Biliary- Pancreas Center, University of Massachusetts Medical School, Worcester, MA, United States USA; and 2 UMASS Cancer Center. Purpose: We performed a retrospective analysis to assess the relationship between HCV genotypes and progression of liver disease. Methods: Patients referred to the hepatology and liver transplant clinic between 7/99 and 4/01 had HCV ELISA confirmed by RIBA. Sero-positive patients had a HCV PCR for viral load and genotype. A multivariate analysis of age, sex and genotype comparing the two sets of patients was performed to determine their relationship to progression of liver disease. Results: Of 242 patients referred for transplant evaluation 89 were positive for anti-HCV of which 74 patients had HCV genotype determination (5 were HCV PCR -ve, 1 not typable, 9 genotype not available). Genotype was available in 343 patients in the non-transplant group (controls). Of the 74 transplant patients, 60 (81%) had genotype 1/4 (1 or 4) with a mean age of 50.25 6.75 yrs, and a M:F ratio of 4:1; 14 patients (19%) had genotypes 2/3 with a mean age of 50.14 5.57 yrs and a M:F ratio of 2.5:1. The overall mean age in this group was 50.24 6.55 yrs with a M:F ratio of 4:1. Among the 339 controls 238 patients (67.3%) were genotype 1/4 with a mean age of 43.56 9.36 years and a M:F ratio of 1.8 :1 and 101 patients (32.8%) were genotype 2/3 with a mean age of 44.39 8.04 and a M:F ratio of 1.6:1. The overall mean age in this group was 43.81 8.98 years with a M:F ratio of 1.8:1. Patients evaluated for transplant were older than the control group (50.24 vs 43.81 yrs; p 0.05 students t-test) and the M:F ratio was higher ( 2 test p 0.05). Genotypes 1/4 were more common in the transplant group ( 2 test p 0.05). On multivariate regression analysis age and sex were independently correlated with increased likelihood of being referred for liver transplant evaluation, a surrogate marker for advanced liver disease (p 0.0001 for age, p 0.03 for sex respectively). Genotypes 1/4 showed a strong trend towards being more common in the transplant group but did not reach statistical significance in the multivariate analysis (p 0.07). Overall the mean ages and M:F ratio of genotypes 1/4 were comparable to genotypes 2/3 (44.88 vs 45.09 yrs; 2 0.41 NS). Conclusions: HCV genotype does not seem to be a strong independent correlate of being referred for liver transplant evaluation, a surrogate marker for decompensated liver disease. Genotypes 1/4 are however more common in patients referred for liver transplant. Older age and male sex correlated with more advanced liver disease. Overall, the age of patients with genotype 1/4 is comparable to that of genotype 2/3. Effective treat- ments for genotype 2/3 would thus tend to significantly lower the burden of patients requiring OLT. 407 Value of AST and AST/ALT ratio in predicting histologic grade in chronic hepatitis C (HCV) Frank M Moix, MD 1 and Jean-Pierre Raufman, MD, FACG 1 *. 1 Division of Gastroenterology, University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences, Little Rock, AR, United States. Purpose: To assess the value of AST and AST/ALT ratio in predicting the degree of fibrosis in patients with HCV. Methods: Between 1996 –99, 35 serial patients with HCV and nl ALT (1.4 50 IU/L) within 6 mos of liver biopsy were identified. During the same interval, 35 patients with elev. ALT (1.4 50 IU/L) within 6 mos of biopsy were also identified. After analysis, no significant correlation between ALT and histological grade was demonstrated (Am J Med 2000; 109:62). The present study represents a reanalysis of these 70 patients focusing on AST and AST/ALT ratio. Patients were reassigned to 2 groups based on AST values. 39 patients had nl AST (1.4 40 IU/L). The remaining 31 patients had elev. AST (1.4 40 IU/L). Demographic data were compared using a two-tailed t-test. Liver biopsies were graded by a blinded pathologist. The extent of periportal necrosis, intralobular degen- eration/focal necrosis, portal inflammation, and bridging fibrosis or cirrho- sis was scored. The total score represents the Histological Activity Index (HAI). Correlations between AST and HAI as well as AST/ALT ratio and HAI were made by simple linear regression. Results: After regrouping, it was noted that patients with elev. AST were older than those with nl AST (48.0 8.3 vs. 43.7 8.7 yrs, mean SD, P .035). There were no differences in sex, race, EtOH use, or risk factors for hepatitis. As expected, AST levels in the 2 groups were different (33.5 10 vs 100.1 40 IU/L, P 0.001). AST/ALT ratios were not different (.95 .43 vs .92 .44, P .753). Mean HAI scores were 4.4 2 in patients with nl AST vs. 6.8 3 in patients with elev. AST (P 0.001). Among patients with nl AST, 5 (12.8%) had bridging fibrosis and 4 (10.3%) had cirrhosis. Among patients with elev. AST, 12 (38.7%) had bridging fibrosis and 7 (22.6%) had cirrhosis. Mean AST and AST/ALT ratio were 86 47 and .93 .43 in patients with advanced disease (bridging fibrosis/cirrhosis) as compared with 45 30 (P .001) and .95 .43 (P .84) in those with less advanced disease. Subgroup analysis of EtOH use in patients with advanced disease did not reveal a difference from those with less advanced disease (P .94). Overall, a modest positive correlation (r .50, P 0.001) was noted between AST and HAI. However, AST/ALT ratio did not correlate with HAI (r .008, P .94) Conclusions: AST is more predictive of fibrosis in patients with HCV than either ALT or AST/ALT ratio. Nevertheless, a normal AST does not exclude advanced liver disease. 408 Rebetron for HCV in US veterans: Success or failure? Joseph Morelli 1 , Anthony Balistreri 1 , Chris Kim 1 and Ira Willner 1 *. 1 Division of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, SC, United States. Purpose: Hepatitis C in the veteran population has a reported prevalence of about 8%. We report our experience at the VA with combination therapy (Interferon plus Ribavirin) in a non-study environment. Methods: Medically and psychologically fit patients who had a liver biopsy and offered therapy were studied. They were 88 patients (85 males and 3 females) of which 51 (58%) were Caucasian (CA), 35 (40%) were African American (AA), and 2 (2%) were Hispanic Americans (HA). 13 had cirrhosis (11CA, and 2AA); 10 had stage 3 disease (5 CA, and 5 AA); 45 had stage 2 disease (24 CA, 19 AA, 2 HA); 16 had stage 1 disease (9 CA, 7 AA); 2 had stage 0 disease (1 CA, 1 AA). The population was predominately genotype 1a/b 76 (86%) (43 CA, 33 AA); genotype 2a/b 4 (4.5%) (2 CA, 1AA, 1HA); genotype 3a 4 (4.5%) (2 CA, 1 AA, 1HA). In 4 the genotype was not available. Results: 84/88 initiated treatment. 4 declined treatment. At the time of this review, 16/84 were active in therapy. 72/88 patients were no longer in treatment. 46 patients completed therapy. 12 patients discontinued therapy secondary to anemia, renal insufficiency, or persistent flu like symptoms. 14 patients who started therapy missed more than 3 consecutive appoint- ments and were discontinued. 8/46 (2 genotype 1a/b, 1 genotype 2a/b, 2 genotype 3a, 3 genotype unknown) had an end of treatment response. Nine with genotype 1 had a negative PCR after 6 months of therapy, but only 2/9 had a negative PCR at completion. One patient relapsed at 6 months. 3/13 with cirrhosis had viral clearance after 6 months of therapy, but at the end of treatment were positive. Conclusions: 8/46 (17%) of patients completing treatment including all genotypes had an end of treatment response (ETR). However, ETR in the African American population was 0%. We did not achieve a sustained response in 13 cirrhotic patients regardless of genotype. 2/8 who had ETR relapsed 6 months post treatment. 26/84 (31%) of our unselected popula- tion were either unable to tolerate treatment or lost to follow up. Using an intention to treat analysis only 11% had end of treatment response. Given these findings, a more effective treatment in this population needs to be S130 Abstracts AJG – Vol. 96, No. 9, Suppl., 2001

Upload: sanjay-agrawal

Post on 01-Dec-2016

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

406

Hepatitis C virus genotype: is it an independent predictor ofprogression of liver disease?Sanjay Agrawal1*, Savant Mehta1, Qin Liu2, Chung C Hseih2, Herbert LBonkovsky1 and Raymond S Koff1. 1Gastroenterology, Liver-Biliary-Pancreas Center, University of Massachusetts Medical School,Worcester, MA, United States USA; and 2UMASS Cancer Center.

Purpose: We performed a retrospective analysis to assess the relationshipbetween HCV genotypes and progression of liver disease.Methods: Patients referred to the hepatology and liver transplant clinicbetween 7/99 and 4/01 had HCV ELISA confirmed by RIBA. Sero-positivepatients had a HCV PCR for viral load and genotype. A multivariateanalysis of age, sex and genotype comparing the two sets of patients wasperformed to determine their relationship to progression of liver disease.Results: Of 242 patients referred for transplant evaluation 89 were positivefor anti-HCV of which 74 patients had HCV genotype determination (5were HCV PCR -ve, 1 not typable, 9 genotype not available). Genotypewas available in 343 patients in the non-transplant group (controls). Of the74 transplant patients, 60 (81%) had genotype 1/4 (1 or 4) with a mean ageof 50.25 � 6.75 yrs, and a M:F ratio of 4:1; 14 patients (19%) hadgenotypes 2/3 with a mean age of 50.14 � 5.57 yrs and a M:F ratio of 2.5:1.The overall mean age in this group was 50.24 � 6.55 yrs with a M:F ratioof 4:1. Among the 339 controls 238 patients (67.3%) were genotype 1/4with a mean age of 43.56 � 9.36 years and a M:F ratio of 1.8 :1 and 101patients (32.8%) were genotype 2/3 with a mean age of 44.39 � 8.04 anda M:F ratio of 1.6:1. The overall mean age in this group was 43.81 � 8.98years with a M:F ratio of 1.8:1.

Patients evaluated for transplant were older than the control group (50.24vs 43.81 yrs; p � 0.05 students t-test) and the M:F ratio was higher (�2testp � 0.05). Genotypes 1/4 were more common in the transplant group (�2

test p � 0.05). On multivariate regression analysis age and sex wereindependently correlated with increased likelihood of being referred forliver transplant evaluation, a surrogate marker for advanced liver disease(p � 0.0001 for age, p � 0.03 for sex respectively). Genotypes 1/4 showeda strong trend towards being more common in the transplant group but didnot reach statistical significance in the multivariate analysis (p � 0.07).Overall the mean ages and M:F ratio of genotypes 1/4 were comparable togenotypes 2/3 (44.88 vs 45.09 yrs; �2 � 0.41 NS).Conclusions: HCV genotype does not seem to be a strong independentcorrelate of being referred for liver transplant evaluation, a surrogatemarker for decompensated liver disease. Genotypes 1/4 are however morecommon in patients referred for liver transplant. Older age and male sexcorrelated with more advanced liver disease. Overall, the age of patientswith genotype 1/4 is comparable to that of genotype 2/3. Effective treat-ments for genotype 2/3 would thus tend to significantly lower the burdenof patients requiring OLT.

407

Value of AST and AST/ALT ratio in predicting histologic grade inchronic hepatitis C (HCV)Frank M Moix, MD1 and Jean-Pierre Raufman, MD, FACG1*.1Division of Gastroenterology, University of Arkansas for MedicalSciences, Little Rock, AR, United States.

Purpose: To assess the value of AST and AST/ALT ratio in predicting thedegree of fibrosis in patients with HCV.Methods: Between 1996–99, 35 serial patients with HCV and nl ALT(�1.4 � 50 IU/L) within 6 mos of liver biopsy were identified. During thesame interval, 35 patients with elev. ALT (�1.4 � 50 IU/L) within 6 mosof biopsy were also identified. After analysis, no significant correlationbetween ALT and histological grade was demonstrated (Am J Med 2000;109:62). The present study represents a reanalysis of these 70 patientsfocusing on AST and AST/ALT ratio. Patients were reassigned to 2 groupsbased on AST values. 39 patients had nl AST (�1.4 � 40 IU/L). Theremaining 31 patients had elev. AST (�1.4 � 40 IU/L). Demographic data

were compared using a two-tailed t-test. Liver biopsies were graded by ablinded pathologist. The extent of periportal necrosis, intralobular degen-eration/focal necrosis, portal inflammation, and bridging fibrosis or cirrho-sis was scored. The total score represents the Histological Activity Index(HAI). Correlations between AST and HAI as well as AST/ALT ratio andHAI were made by simple linear regression.Results: After regrouping, it was noted that patients with elev. AST wereolder than those with nl AST (48.0 � 8.3 vs. 43.7 � 8.7 yrs, mean � SD,P � .035). There were no differences in sex, race, EtOH use, or risk factorsfor hepatitis. As expected, AST levels in the 2 groups were different(33.5 � 10 vs 100.1 � 40 IU/L, P � 0.001). AST/ALT ratios were notdifferent (.95 � .43 vs .92 � .44, P � .753). Mean HAI scores were 4.4 �2 in patients with nl AST vs. 6.8 � 3 in patients with elev. AST (P �0.001). Among patients with nl AST, 5 (12.8%) had bridging fibrosis and4 (10.3%) had cirrhosis. Among patients with elev. AST, 12 (38.7%) hadbridging fibrosis and 7 (22.6%) had cirrhosis. Mean AST and AST/ALTratio were 86 � 47 and .93 � .43 in patients with advanced disease(bridging fibrosis/cirrhosis) as compared with 45 � 30 (P �.001) and .95 �.43 (P � .84) in those with less advanced disease. Subgroup analysis ofEtOH use in patients with advanced disease did not reveal a difference fromthose with less advanced disease (P � .94). Overall, a modest positivecorrelation (r � .50, P � 0.001) was noted between AST and HAI.However, AST/ALT ratio did not correlate with HAI (r � .008, P � .94)Conclusions: AST is more predictive of fibrosis in patients with HCV thaneither ALT or AST/ALT ratio. Nevertheless, a normal AST does notexclude advanced liver disease.

408

Rebetron for HCV in US veterans: Success or failure?Joseph Morelli1, Anthony Balistreri1, Chris Kim1 and Ira Willner1*.1Division of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, Medical University ofSouth Carolina, Charleston, SC, United States.

Purpose: Hepatitis C in the veteran population has a reported prevalenceof about 8%. We report our experience at the VA with combination therapy(Interferon plus Ribavirin) in a non-study environment.Methods: Medically and psychologically fit patients who had a liverbiopsy and offered therapy were studied. They were 88 patients (85 malesand 3 females) of which 51 (58%) were Caucasian (CA), 35 (40%) wereAfrican American (AA), and 2 (2%) were Hispanic Americans (HA). 13had cirrhosis (11CA, and 2AA); 10 had stage 3 disease (5 CA, and 5 AA);45 had stage 2 disease (24 CA, 19 AA, 2 HA); 16 had stage 1 disease (9CA, 7 AA); 2 had stage 0 disease (1 CA, 1 AA). The population waspredominately genotype 1a/b 76 (86%) (43 CA, 33 AA); genotype 2a/b 4(4.5%) (2 CA, 1AA, 1HA); genotype 3a 4 (4.5%) (2 CA, 1 AA, 1HA). In4 the genotype was not available.Results: 84/88 initiated treatment. 4 declined treatment. At the time of thisreview, 16/84 were active in therapy. 72/88 patients were no longer intreatment. 46 patients completed therapy. 12 patients discontinued therapysecondary to anemia, renal insufficiency, or persistent flu like symptoms.14 patients who started therapy missed more than 3 consecutive appoint-ments and were discontinued. 8/46 (2 genotype 1a/b, 1 genotype 2a/b, 2genotype 3a, 3 genotype unknown) had an end of treatment response. Ninewith genotype 1 had a negative PCR after 6 months of therapy, but only 2/9had a negative PCR at completion. One patient relapsed at 6 months. 3/13with cirrhosis had viral clearance after 6 months of therapy, but at the endof treatment were positive.Conclusions: 8/46 (17%) of patients completing treatment including allgenotypes had an end of treatment response (ETR). However, ETR in theAfrican American population was 0%. We did not achieve a sustainedresponse in 13 cirrhotic patients regardless of genotype. 2/8 who had ETRrelapsed 6 months post treatment. 26/84 (31%) of our unselected popula-tion were either unable to tolerate treatment or lost to follow up. Using anintention to treat analysis only 11% had end of treatment response. Giventhese findings, a more effective treatment in this population needs to be

S130 Abstracts AJG – Vol. 96, No. 9, Suppl., 2001