how does law protect in war? volume i: outline of international humanitarian law

Upload: international-committee-of-the-red-cross

Post on 06-Apr-2018

222 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    1/400

    BAT MAGY

    EJT VXA]GI]@O TJX1

    Ijygy% Maiwngo}y jom gjib`od Nj}gx`jeyao Iao}gnvaxjxp Vxji}`ig`o @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt

    Njxia Yjyye`

    Jo}a`og J/ Haws`gx

    Joog Zw`o}`o

    Saewng @Aw}e`og ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt

    ]`xm Gm`}`ao

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    2/400

    Vjx} @ :

    Dgogxje H`he`adxjvbp

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; HGY] Dgaccxgp% Tjx jom Ejt y`oig :0=7% Arcaxm% Iejxgomao Vxgyy% :00=% =7= vv/HAWIBG].YJWEO@GX Cxjoa`yg% ]bg Vxji}`ije Dw`mg }a Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% Ejobjn "Njxpejom)%Arcaxm% Xatnjo # E`}}eggem% 8664% 8om gm/% 777 vv/ HW@XG]]G Vj}x`i`j # EJDXJODG Vb`e`vvg% Eg mxa`}`o}gxoj}`aoje bwnjo`}j`xg% Vjx`y% Ej Miawsgx}g% 8662% :88 vv/ IJX@A Kxng% Eg mxa`} mgy iao`}y jxny%Vjoj{ae% Ejsjw{geeg m`}`aoy% Igo}xg mg Xgibgxibg mgy iaegy mg Yj`o}.Ipx% 8668% :08 vv/ MJS@M x`i%Vx`oi`vgy mg mxa`} mgy iao`}y jxny% Hxwyygey% Hxwpejo}% =}b gm/% 8662% :::4 vv/ MGPXJ N`ibge% Eg mxa`}mjoy ej dwgxxg% Vjx`y% Dwje`oa% 8660% 829 vv/ M@OY]G@O Paxjn% ]bg Iaomwi} ac Bay}`e`}`gy womgx }bg Ejtac @o}gxoj}`aoje Jxngm Iao`i}% Ijnhx`mdg% IWV% 86:6% 986 vv/ MK@GOJ TGNHAW N`ibge.Ipx # CJEEMjawmj% Eg mxa`} `o}gxoj}`aoje bwnjo`}j`xg% }bax`g doxjeg g} xje`}y jcx`ij`ogy% Vjx`y% EBjxnj}}jo%8666% =9: vv/ CEGIL M`g}gx "gm/)% Bjomhaal ac Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% Arcaxm% AWV% 8om gm/% 8662% 446 vv/DJXMJN Kwm`}b% Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% Jemgxyba}% Jybdj}g% :000% 746 vv/ DJYYGX Bjoy.Vg}gx% @o}gxoj}`aojeBwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% jo @o}xamwi}`ao% Dgogsj% Bgoxp.Mwojo} @oy}`}w}g% :009% 08 vv/ DXGGO Egye`g I/%Iao}gnvaxjxp Ejt ac Jxngm Iao`i}% 9xm gm/% Njoibgy}gx "WYJ)% Ogt Paxl% Njoibgy}gx Wo`sgxy`}p Vxgyy%8662% =9= vv/ DXGGOTAAM Ibx`y}avbgx% Gyyjpy ao Tjx `o @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% Eaomao% Ijngxao Njp%8663% 466 vv/ BJXAWGE.HWXGEAWV Sxao`zwg% ]xj`} mg mxa`} bwnjo`}j`xg% Vjx`y% VWC% 8667% 773 vv/

    BGOILJGX]Y Kgjo.Njx`g # MAYTJEM.HGIL Eaw`yg% Iwy}anjxp @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt%Ijnhx`mdg!Dgogsj% IWV!@IXI% 8667% 9 Sae/% 7698 vv/ LJEYBASGO Cx`}y # [GDSGEM E`gyhg}b% Iaoy}xj`o}yao }bg Tjd`od ac Tjx% Dgogsj% @IXI% 866:% 889 vv/ LGTEGP Dxg}ibgo% Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt `o JxngmIao`i}y% Iaee`odtaam% :02=% 39 vv/ LAEH Xahgx}% @wy `o hgeea Eg mxa`} `o}gxoj}`aoje mgy iao`}y jxny;Vxi`y% Hjyge% Bgeh`od E`ib}gobjbo< Hxwyygey% Hxwpejo}% 8om gm/% 8660% 77: vv/ LAEH Xahgx}% BPMG X`ibjxm%

    Jo @o}xamwi}`ao }a }bg @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt ac Jxngm Iao`i}y % Arcaxm.Vax}ejom% Axgdao% Bjx}% 8662% 9=2 vv/AVVGOBG@N Ejyyj% @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt; J ]xgj}`yg% `o EJW]GXVJIB] Bgxyib "gm/)% Sae/ @@% M`yvw}gy%Tjx jom Ogw}xje`}p% Eaomao% Eaodnjo% 4}b gm/% :078% 0=: vv/ V@I]G] Kgjo% Mgsgeavngo} jom Vx`oi`vegyac @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% ]bg Bjdwg% Dgogsj% N/ O`kbacc% Bgoxp.Mwojo} @oy}`}w}g% :027% 00 vv/XAMX@DWG[.S@EEJYJO]G P VX@G]A Kay Ew`y% Mgxgiba `o}gxoji`aoje bwnjo`}jx`a% Sjegoi`j% ]`xjo} ea

    Hejoib% Yvjo`yb Xgm Ixayy% 8om gm/% 8664% :663 vv/ XADGXY Jo}baop V/S/% Ejt ao }bg Hj}}eggem% 8om gm/%Njoibgy}gx% Njoibgy}gx Wo`sgxy`}p Vxgyy% 866=% 830 vv/ XAWYYGJW Ibjxegy% Eg mxa`} mgy iao`}y jxny%Vjx`y% Vgmaog% :029% 380 vv/ YAE@Y Djxp% ]bg Ejt ac Jxngm Iao`i}; @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt `oTjx% Ijnhx`mdg% IWV% 86:6% 370 vv/ Yt`yy Cgmgxje Mgvjx}ngo} ac Caxg`do Jccj`xy% JHI ac @o}gxoj}`aojeBwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% Hgxog% Yt`yy Cgmgxje Mgvjx}ngo} ac Caxg`do Jccj`xy% 8660% == vv/

    CWX]BGX XGJM@OD; HJEGOI@ Kgjo.Njxi # EJ DXJODG Jxojwm mg% Egy oawsgjwr naomgy xghgeegy;iao`}y% }gxxax`yng g} iao}gy}j}`aoy% Vjx`y% N`ibjeao% 8667% 769 vv/ HGEJODGX N`ibge% Mxa`} `o}gxoj}`aojebwnjo`}j xg doxje% Vjx`y% Dwje`oa% 8om gm/% 8664% :73 vv/ H@JM Jhmgetjbjh% Mxa`} o}gxoj}`aoje bwnjo`}j xg%Vjx`y% Gee`vygy% 8om gm/% 8663% :90 vv/ HWEJ.HWEJ Yjpgnjo% Mxa`} `o}gxoj}`aoje bwnjo`}j`xg% Eawsj`o.ej.Ogwsg% Hxwpejo}.Jijmgn`j% 86:6% =68 vv/ IJYYGYG Jo}ao`a% S`aegoig jom Ejt o }bg Namgxo Jdg% Ijnhx`mdg%Arcaxm% Vae`}p Vxgyy% Hejiltgee% :022% :0= vv/ CX@GMNJO Egao "gm/)% ]bg Ejt ac Tjx% J Maiwngo}jxpB`y}axp% Ogt Paxl% Xjoman Bawyg% 8 Sae/% :048% 0:8 vv/ DXGGO Egye`g I/%Gyyjpy ao }bg Namgxo Ejt ac Tjx%Jxmyegp% Ogt Paxl% ]xjoyoj}`aoje Vwhe`ybgxy% :000% 36= vv/ DXGGOYVJO Naxx`y% ]bg Namgxo Ejt ac EjomTjxcjxg% Hgxlgegp # Eay Jodgegy% Wo`sgxy`}p ac Ije`caxo`j Vxgyy% :070% 48= vv/ DW]NJO Xap% X@GCC Mjs`m #MTAXL@O Jo}baop "gmy)% Ix`ngy ac Tjx% Tbj} }bg Vwhe`i Ybawem Loat% Eaomao% Oax}ao% 8om gm/% 8664% ==4 vv/

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    3/400

    8 Dgogxje H`he`adxjvbp

    GODMJBE Aej # TXJODG Vje "gmy)% Ejt j} Tjx; ]bg Ejt jy `} Tjy jom }bg Ejt jy `} Ybawem Hg% E`hgx Jn`iaxwn Asg Hx`od% Eg`mgo% Hay}ao% N/ O`kbacc% 8662% 987 vv/ @YBAP X`llg% Bjomhaal ao }bg Vxji}`ijeWyg ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% 8om gm`}`ao% Lahgobjso% Mjo`yb Xgm Ixayy% Ai}ahgx 8662% :=8 vv/

    LJEMAX Njxp% Ogt jom Aem Tjxy% Axdjo`{gm S`aegoig `o j Deahje Gxj % Y}jocaxm% Y}jocaxm Wo`sgxy`}p Vxgyy%:000% 863 vv/ LJEYBASGO Cx`}y% Xggi}`aoy ao }bg Ejt ac Tjx; Iaeegi}gm Gyyjpy% Eg`mgo% Hay}ao% N/ O`kbacc%8664% :::7vv/ NiIAWHXGP B`ej`xg% @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt ]bg Xgdwej}`ao ac Jxngm Iao`i}y %Mjx}naw}b% :006% 884 vv/ NiIAWXHGP B`ej`xg% @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt; Namgxo Mgsgeavngo}y `o}bg E`n`}j}`ao ac Tjxcjxg% Jemgxyba} \g}i^% Mjx}naw}b% Jybdj}g% 8om gm/% :002% 983 vv/ NJIMAWDJE NpxgyY/ # CGE@I@JOA Ceaxgo}`oa V/% ]bg @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt ac Tjx; ]xjoyoj}`aoje Iagxi`ao jom Taxem Vwhe`iAxmgx% Maxmxgib}% N/ O`kbacc< Ogt Bjsgo% Ogt Bjsgo Vxgyy% 8 om gm/% :00=% 248 vv/ NGPGX N`ibjge J/ "gm/)%

    Jxngm Iao`i} jom }bg Ogt Ejt; Jyvgi}y ac }bg :044 Dgogsj Vxa}aiaey jom }bg :02: Tgjvaoy Iaosgo}`ao%Eaomao% Hx`}`yb @oy}`}w}g ac @o}gxoj}`aoje jom Ianvjxj}`sg Ejt% :020% 802 vv/ OJBE@L Y}jo`yejt G/% J Hx`gcAw}e`og ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% `o @XXI% Oa/ 8=:% Kwep :02=% vv/ :24.883/ OGCC Y}gvbgo% Tjxjom }bg Ejt ac Oj}`aoy; j Dgogxje B`y}axp% Ijnhx`mdg% IWV 8667% ==9 vv/ VJWY] Kaxmjo K/% HJYY@AWO@ N/Ibgx`c% YIBJXC N`ibjge% DWXWE K`nnp% YJMJ] Eg`ej% [JDJX@Y Hxwig # T@EE@JNY Ybjxao J/% BwnjoX`db}y Namweg ao Ix`ngy Jdj`oy} Bwnjo`}p% Dgoai`mg% A}bgx Ix`ngy Jdj`oy} Bwnjo X`db}y% jom Tjx Ix`ngy %Mwxbjn% Ijxae`oj Jijmgn`i Vxgyy% 866:% 930 vv/ YIBTJX[GOHGXDGX Dgaxd% @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt jy Jvve`gmhp @o}gxoj}`aoje Iawx}y jom ]x`hwojey ]bg Ejt ac Jxngm Iao`i}% Eaomao% Y}gsgoy # Yaoy% Sae/ @@% :032%22: vv/ YAEC Tjemgnjx J/ # XAJIB Jybegp% @omgr ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% Dgogsj% @IXI% :024%829 vv/

    Ygg jeya njop go}x`gy `o Goipieavgm`j ac Vwhe`i @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% Jny}gxmjn% Ogt Paxl% Arcaxm%Gegygs`gx% :004% cawx saewngy% jom% naxg xgigo}ep% `o }bg Njr Vejoil Goipieavgm`j ac Vwhe`i @o}gxoj}`aoje

    Ejt% aoe`og; b}}v;!!ttt/nvgv`e/ian!

    IANV@EJ]@AOY AC MAIWNGO]Y; IJXGP Kabo% MWOEJV T`ee`jn # VX@]IBJXM Kabo "gmy)%SGW]BGP N`ibge% EJSAPGX Kgjo.Vb`e`vvg \g} je/^% @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% Jxmyegp% Ogt Paxl%]xjoyoj}`aoje Vwhe`ybgxy% 8669.8663% 9 Sae/ "992% 934% 924 vv/) MJS@M x`i% ]WELGOY Cxjoa`yg #SJOMGXNGGXYIB Mjn`go% Iamg mg mxa`} `o}gxoj}`aoje bwnjo`}j`xg% }gr}gy xwo`y jw :gx kjos`gx 86:6 %Hxwyygey% Hxwpejo}% =}b gm/% 86:6% 048 vv/ CAXXGY] NJX]@O Cxjoi`yia% @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo X`db}y jomBwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt; ]xgj}`gy% Ijygy jom Jojepy`y% Ijnhx`mdg% IWV% 8663% 006 vv/ BJXAWGE Sxao`zwg%Dxjomy }gr}gy mg mxa`} bwnjo`}j`xg% Vjx`y% VWC% Zwg Yj`y.kg 1% Oa/ 936=% 866:% :84 vv/ AIAOOGEE Njxp

    Geego% @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt jom }bg Wyg ac Caxig% Ogt Paxl% Cawomj}`ao Vxgyy% 8667% 3:2 vv/ VGXXJL@Y Y}ge`ay# NJXAWMJ Njx`j.Mjo`geej% Jxngm Iao`i}y jom @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt; :76 Pgjxy jc}gxYaecgx`oa; Jizw`y jom Vxayvgi}y% J}bogy% Yjllawejy< Hxwyygey% Hxwpejo}% Gwxavgjo Igo}xg cax Xgygjxib jom]xj`o`od ao Bwnjo X`db}y jom Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ji}`ao% 8660% 379 vv/ XAHGX]Y Jmjn # DWGECC X`ibjxm%Maiwngo}y ao }bg Ejty ac Tjx% Arcaxm% Iejxgomao Vxgyy% 9xm gm/% 8666% 437 vv/ YIB@OMEGX M`g}x`ib# ]ANJO K`x` "gm/)% ]bg Ejty ac Jxngm Iao`i}y% J Iaeegi}`ao ac Iaosgo}`aoy% Xgyaew}`aoy jom A}bgxMaiwngo}y% Eg`mgo% Hay}ao% N/ O`kbacc% =}b gm/% 866=% :=09 vv/

    H@HE@ADXJVB@GY; H`he`adxjvbp :002.:000; @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% `o P@BE% Sae/ 8% :000%vv/ 74:.364/ H`he`adxjvbp ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt Jvve`ijheg `o Jxngm Iao`i}y \Ianv`egm

    hp Bwaod ]b` Bwpob womgx K`x` ]anjoy m`xgi}`ao< Caxgtaxm hp Kgjo V`i}g}^ % Dgogsj% @IXI% Bgoxp.Mwojo}@oy}`}w}g% 8om gm/% :024% 36= vv/ Vwhe`i @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt; j Iwxxgo} H`he`adxjvbp ac Haaly jom Jx}`iegy >Selgxxgib}; ejwcgomg H`he`adxjvb`g > Mxa`} `o}gxoj}`aoje vwhe`i; h`he`adxjvb`g > Mgxgiba `o}gxoji`aoje

    vhe`ia; h`he`adxjcj% ygn`.joowje xgs`gt vwhe`ybgm hp }bg Njr.Vejoil.@oy}`}w} cx jwyeom`yibgyccgo}e`ibgy Xgib} wom Selgxxgib}% Bg`mgehgxd/

    \O/H/; Njop jx}`iegy ac }bg @o}gxoj}`aoje Xgs`gt ac }bg Xgm Ixayy xgcgxxgm }a `o h`he`adxjvb`gy jxg aoe`og"b}}v;!!ttt/`ixi/axd)/ A}bgx kawxojey jxg jeya aoe`og "Ygg }bg e`y} ac @o}gxog} y`}gy)^

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    4/400

    Ibjv}gx :

    Iaoigv} jom Vwxvayg ac@o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt

    @/ VB@EAYAVBPAC @O]GXOJ]@AOJE BWNJO@]JX@JO EJT

    @o}xamwi}axp }gr}

    @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt "@BE) ijo hg mgogm jy }bg hxjoib ac o}gxoj}`aoje ejte`n`}`od }bg wyg ac s`aegoig `o jxngm iao`i}y hp;

    j) yvjx`od }bayg tba ma oa}\:8^ ax oa eaodgx\:9^ m`xgi}ep\:=^ vjx}`i`vj}g o bay}`e`}`gy Vgjig `o E`hgx}p >

    Vj`r go e`hgx}; Cgy}yibx`c} cx N`ibjge Ha}bg {wn 46 Dghwx}y}jd% Hjmgo.Hjmgo% Oanay< [x`ib% M`lg% 8662%vv/ 90:.=64/ [TJOGOHWXD Njx}`o% V`gigy ac }bg Vw{{eg; Vgjig Avgxj}`aoy% Aiiwvj}`ao jom }bg Wyg acCaxig% `o ]bg N`e`}jxp Ejt jom }bg Ejt ac Tjx Xgs`gt% Sae/ :.8% Oa/ =7% 8663% vv/ 890.8=2/

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    30/400

    Vjx} @ Ibjv}gx 8 :0

    h) Xgjyaoy

    Maiwngo} Oa/ =6% @IXI% Vxa}gi}`ao Vae`ip \Vjxj/ 9/:^

    Ijyg Oa/ 09% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy N`e`}jxp ]x`hwoje j} Owxgnhgxd% ]bg Kwy}`ig ]x`je

    jj) Ead`ije xgjyaoy; aoig }bg vx`njxp xwegy vxab`h`}`od }bg wyg ac caxig "`/g/kwy jm hgeewn) bjsg hggo s`aej}gm% }bg ywhy`m`jxp xwegy ackwy `o hgeea nwy}jvvep% jy }bgp jxg caxgyggo yvgi`ijeep cax y`}wj}`aoy `o tb`ib }bg vx`njxpxwegy bjsg hggo s`aej}gm/

    hh) Bwnjo`}jx`jo xgjyaoy; tjx s`i}`ny jxg oa} xgyvaoy`heg cax }bg cji} }bj}}bg`x Y}j}g bjy s`aej}gm o}gxoj}`aoje ejt "`/g/kwy jm hgeewn) jom oggm }bgyjng vxa}gi}`ao% tbg}bgx }bgp jxg ao }bg x`db} ax ao }bg txaod y`mg/

    ii) Vxji}`ije xgjyaoy; mwx`od j iao`i}% hgee`dgxgo}y ogsgx jdxgg ao tb`ibjnaod }bgn bjy s`aej}gm kwy jm hgeewn% `/g/ tba `y }bg jddxgyyax< @BE bjy}a jvvep mwx`od }bg iao`i}/ @} t`ee aoep hg xgyvgi}gm `c ha}b y`mgy bjsg }ajvvep }bg yjng xwegy/

    i) Iaoygzwgoigy a }bg m`y}`oi}`ao

    jj) ]bg gzwje`}p ac hgee`dgxgo}y hgcaxg @BEV @% Jx}/ 03"9)"i)

    Ijyg Oa/ 4=% Wo`}gm L`odman jom Jwy}xje`j% Jvve`ijh`e`}p ac Vxa}aiae @ \Vjx} H/^ Ijyg Oa/ 867% Hayo`j jom Bgx{gdas`oj% Iaoy}`}w}`ao ac Yjcg Jxgjy `o :008.:009

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; NGPXAT@][ Bgox`% Eg vx`oi`vg mg edje`} mgy hgee`dxjo}y mgsjo} eg mxa`} mgej dwgxxg% Vjx`y% Vgmaog% :046% =:2 vv/ XAHGX]Y Jmjn% ]bg Gzwje Jvve`ij}`ao ac }bg Ejty ac Tjx; JVx`oi`veg womgx Vxgyywxg% `o @XXI% Sae/ 06% Oa/ 248% Mgignhgx 8662% vv/ 09:.038/

    hh) @BE jvve`gy `omgvgomgo}ep ac }bg zwje`ij}`ao ac }bg iao`i} womgx kwy jmhgeewn

    Ijyg Oa/ 44% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% Vxgy`mgo} Xgkgi}y Vxa}aiae @ Ijyg Oa/ :87% @yxjge% Jvve`ijh`e`}p ac }bg Cawx}b Iaosgo}`ao }a Aiiwv`gm ]gxx`}ax`gy Ijyg Oa/ :=9% Jnogy}p @o}gxoj}`aoje% Hxgjib ac }bg Vx`oi`veg ac M`y}`oi}`ao \Vjx} H/^

    Ijyg Oa/ :72% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy s/ Oax`gdj \Vjx} H/ @@/ J/^ Ijyg Oa/ :4=% WO Ygiwx`}p Iawoi`e% Yjoi}`aoy @nvaygm Wvao @xjz

    Ijyg Oa/ 869% Ijyg Y}wmp% Jxngm Iao`i}y `o }bg caxngx Pwdayejs`j \83^

    ii) Jxdwngo}y womgxkwy jm hgeewn njp oa} hg wygm }a `o}gxvxg} @BE

    Ijyg Oa/ 89% ]bg @o}gxoj}`aoje Ix`n`oje Iawx} \Vjx} J/% Jx}/ 9:":)"i)^ Ijyg Oa/ 79% @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt Iann`yy`ao% Jx}`iegy ao Y}j}g Xgyvaoy`h`e`}p \Vjx} J/%

    Jx}/ 87 jom Ianngo}jxp^

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    31/400

    86 @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt jy j Hxjoib ac Vwhe`i @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt

    Ijyg Oa/ 38% @IK% Owiegjx Tgjvaoy Jms`yaxp Av`o`ao \Vjxjy 96% 90% =9% 03% 04% jom :67^ Maiwngo} Oa/ 49% Cxjoig% Jiigyy`ao }a Vxa}aiae @ \Vjx} J/^ Ijyg Oa/ 09% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy N`e`}jxp ]x`hwoje j} Owxgnhgxd% ]bg Kwy}`ig ]x`je%

    Ijyg Oa/ 0=% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy N`e`}jxp ]x`hwoje j} Owxgnhgxd% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy s/ Jecx`gm Lxwvvg} je/ \Vjx} = "```)^

    Maiwngo} Oa/ 03% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy N`e`}jxp ]x`hwoje j} Owxgnhgxd% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy s/T`ebgen E`y} \Vjx} 9 "s)^

    Ijyg Oa/ :67% Y`odjvaxg% Hj}jjcyibg Vg}xaegwn s/ ]bg Tjx Mjnjdg Iann`yy`ao Ijyg Oa/ :87% @yxjge% Jvve`ijh`e`}p ac }bg Cawx}b Iaosgo}`ao }a Aiiwv`gm ]gxx`}ax`gy

    Ijyg Oa/ :48% @xjo!@xjz% 46%666 Vx`yaogxy ac Tjx Xgvj}x`j}gm

    mm) Kwy jm hgeewn njp oa} xgomgx jvve`ij}`ao ac @BE `nvayy`heg

    gg) @BE njp oa} xgomgx }bg jvve`ij}`ao ac kwy jm hgeewn% g/d/ ygec.mgcgoig%`nvayy`heg

    m) Iao}gnvaxjxp }bxgj}y }a }bg m`y}`oi}`ao

    Ijyg Oa/ 88% Iaosgo}`ao ao }bg Yjcg}p ac WO Vgxyaooge Ijyg Oa/ 89% ]bg @o}gxoj}`aoje Ix`n`oje Iawx} \Vjx}y H/% I/ jom M/^ Ijyg Oa/ 44% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% Vxgy`mgo} Xgkgi}y Vxa}aiae @ Ijyg Oa/ :04% WO% WO Caxigy `o Yanje`j

    Ijyg Oa/ :02% Hged`wn% Hged`jo Yaem`gxy `o Yanje`j Ijyg Oa/ 869% Ijyg Y}wmp% Jxngm Iao`i}y `o }bg caxngx Pwdayejs`j \:0 jom 83^ Ijyg Oa/ 864% Hayo`j jom Bgx{gdas`oj% Wy`od Wo`caxny ac Vgjiglggvgxy

    jj) Ogt iaoigv}y ac kwy} "ax gsgo bwnjo`}jx`jo) tjx

    hh) @o}gxoj}`aoje vae`ig ji}`ao; `o}gxoj}`aoje jxngm iao`i}y }wxo `o}a ejtgocaxigngo} avgxj}`aoy m`xgi}gm hp }bg `o}gxoj}`aoje iannwo`}p% }baygtba xgvxgygo} `} "ax iej`n }a xgvxgygo} `}) jdj`oy} aw}ejt Y}j}gy/

    ii) @o njop jypnng}x`i iao`i}y% }bg ngjoy jsj`ejheg }a }bg vjx}`gy jxgnj}gx`jeep ya m`ccgxgo}% jom }bayg }bgp ji}wjeep wyg naxjeep ya m`y}`oi}%}bj} `} jvvgjxy `oixgjy`odep woxgje`y}`i }a ywhkgi} }bgn }a }bg yjng xwegy/

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; HWXLG Jo}baop% Kwy} Tjx ax G}b`ije Vgjig1; Naxje M`yiawxygy ac Y}xj}gd`iS`aegoig jc}gx 0!::% `o @o}gxoj}`aoje Jccj`xy% Sae/ 26!8% Njxib 866=% vv/ 980.979/ YLGXLGX N`ibjge% Kwy}Tjx Ix`}gx`j jom }bg Cjig ac Tjx; Bwnjo Yb`gemy% Njowcji}wxgm Njx}pxy% jom E`}}eg Hapy t`}b Y}aogy%`oKawxoje ac N`e`}jxp G}b`iy% Sae/ 9!:% 866=% vv/ 84.90/ YWHGM@ Ywxpj% ]bg Iaoigv} `o B`omw`yn ac Kwy}Tjx% `oKawxoje ac Iao`i} jom Ygiwx`}p Ejt% Sae/ 2!8% Ai}ahgx 8669% vv/ 990.93:/

    9/ ]bg m`y}`oi}`ao `o oao.`o}gxoj}`aoje jxngm iao`i}y

    Ijyg Oa/ 47% Hged`wn jom Hxj{`e% Grvejoj}`aoy ac Sa}g ao Vxa}aiae @@ \Vjx} H/^ Ijyg Oa/ 27% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% ]bg Vx`{g Ijygy

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    32/400

    Vjx} @ Ibjv}gx 8 8:

    Ijyg Oa/ :79% @IK% O`ijxjdwj s/ Wo`}gm Y}j}gy \Vjxj/ 8=3^ Ijyg Oa/ :08% @o}gx.Jngx`ijo Iann`yy`ao ao Bwnjo X`db}y% ]jhejmj \Vjxj/ :4=^ Ijyg Oa/ 8=9% Iaeanh`j% Iaoy}`}w}`aoje Iaoaxn`}p a Vxa}aiae @@ \Vjxjy 86 jom

    8:^

    j) @o}gxoj}`aoje ejt magy oa} vxab`h`} oao.`o}gxoj}`aoje jxngm iao`i}y jee vgxyaoy a}bgx }bjo ianhj}jo}y > ngnhgxy ac jxngm caxigy ej}a ygoyw"cax j mgo`}`ao% ygg `ocxj% Vjx} @% Ibjv}gx 3/ @/ Tba `y

    j ianhj}jo}1)

    06 YggMaiwngo} Oa/ 7:% @IXI% @o}gxvxg}`sg Dw`mjoig ao }bg Oa}`ao ac M`xgi} Vjx}`i`vj}`ao o Bay}`e`}`gy

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    76/400

    Vjx} @ Ibjv}gx 7 9

    @/ JI]@S@]@GY

    Ma oa} }jlg j m`xgi} vjx} `o bay} e`}`gy ]jlg j m`xgi} vjx} `o bay} e`}`gy

    @@/ X@DB]Y

    Ma oa} bjsg }bg x`db} }a }jlg j m`xgi} vjx}`o bay}`e`}`gy"hw} bjsg }bg x`db} }a hg xgyvgi}gm)

    Bjsg }bg x`db} }a }jlg j m`xgi} vjx} `obay}`e`}`gy"hw} bjsg }bg ahe`dj}`ao }a ahygxsg @BE)

    Ijyg Oa/ 00% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% Gr Vjx}g Zw`x`o g} je/

    Ijyg Oa/ :=9% Jnogy}p @o}gxoj}`aoje% Hxgjib ac }bg Vx`oi`veg ac M`y}`oi}`ao Ijyg Oa/ :27% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% ]bg Yibegy`odgx Xgvax} Ijyg Oa/ 83:% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% Y}j}wy jom ]xgj}ngo} ac Mg}j`oggy Bgem `o Dwjo}jojna

    Ojsje Hjyg

    @@@/ VWO@YBJHEG

    Njp hg vwo`ybgmcax }bg`x ngxg vjx}`i`vj}`ao `o bay}`e`}`gy

    Njp oa} hg vwo`ybgmcax }bg`x ngxg vjx}`i`vj}`ao `o bay}`e`}`gy

    "Ygg ocxj Vjx} @% Ibjv}gx 3% @@@/ ]xgj}ngo} ac vx`yaogxyac tjx)

    Ijyg Oa/ 88% Iaosgo}`ao ao }bg Yjcg}p ac WO Vgxyaooge Ijyg Oa/ 00% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% Gr Vjx}g Zw`x`o g} je/ Ijyg Oa/ :86% O`dgx`j% V`wy Otjadj s/ ]bg Y}j}g Ijyg Oa/ :32% Yaw}b Jcx`ij% Y/ s/ Vg}jog Ijyg Oa/ 837% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% N`e`}jxp Iann`yy`aoy

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    77/400

    = ]bg Cwomjngo}je M`y}`oi}`ao Hg}tggo I`s`e`joy jom Ianhj}jo}y

    @S/ VXA]GI]@AO

    Jxg vxa}gi}gm hgijwyg }bgp ma oa}vjx}`i`vj}g;

    jy i`s`e`joy o }bg bjomy ac }bg gognp"Ygg `ocxj Vjx} @% Ibjv}gx 2% @@/ Vxa}gi}`ao ac i`s`e`joyjdj`oy} jxh`}xjxp }xgj}ngo} jom @S/ Yvgi`je xwegy aoaiiwv`gm }gxx`}ax`gy)

    jdj`oy} j}}jily jom gccgi}y acbay}`e`}`gy"Ygg `ocxj% Vjx} @% Ibjv}gx 0% @@/ ]bg vxa}gi}`ao ac }bg

    i`s`e`jo vavwej}`ao jdj`oy} }bg gccgi}y ac bay}`e`}`gy)

    Jxg vxa}gi}gm tbgo }bgp oa eaodgxvjx}`i`vj}g;

    `c }bgp bjsg cjeego `o}a }bg vatgx ac}bg gognp"Ygg ocxj Vjx} @% Ibjv}gx 3% @@@/ ]xgj}ngo} ac vx`yaogxyac tjx)

    `c tawomgm% y`il ax yb`vtxgilgm"Ygg `ocxj Vjx} @% Ibjv}gx 4% Vxa}gi}`ao ac }bgtawomgm% y`il jom yb`vtxgilgm)

    `c vjxjibw}`od aw} ac jo j`xixjc} `om`y}xgyy"Ygg V @% Jx}/ =8)

    jxg vxa}gi}gm jdj`oy} yang ngjoyjom ng}bamy ac tjxcjxg gsgo tb`egdb}`od"Ygg `ocxj Vjx} @% Ibjv}gx 0% @@@/ Ngjoy jom ng}bamyac tjxcjxg)

    Xgej}`s`}p ac }bg m`ccgxgoig; gsgxpaog `o gognp bjomy `y vxa}gi}gm/

    Ijyg Oa/ ::4% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy s/ T`ee`jn E/ Ijeegp% Kx/

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; NGE[GX O`ey% ]jxdg}gm L`ee`od `o @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% Arcaxm% AWV% 8662% =32 vv/VX@NAXJ][ @dax% I`s`e`jo @nnwo`}p o Tjx% Arcaxm% AWV% 8664% 839 vv/

    S/ CWEEIANVEGNGO]JX@]P

    @y gsgxpaog tba `y oa} j ianhj}jo} j i`s`e`jo "ax `y }bgxg jo `o}gxngm`j}g ij}gdaxp acwoejtcwe ianhj}jo})1

    `o }bg iaomwi} ac bay}`e`}`gy1

    `o gognp bjomy1

    Ijyg Oa/ =0% @IXI% ]bg Ibjeegodgy ac Iao}gnvaxjxp Jxngm Iao`i}y \Vjx} H/^ Maiwngo} Oa/ 7:% @IXI% @o}gxvxg}j}`sg Dw`mjoig ao }bg Oa}`ao a M`xgi}

    Vjx}`i`vj}`ao `o Bay}`e`}`gy

    Ijyg Oa/ :60% GIBX% Laxhgep s/ Bwodjxp Ijyg Oa/ :93% @yxjge% ]bg ]jxdg}gm L`ee`ody Ijyg

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    78/400

    Vjx} @ Ibjv}gx 7 7

    Ijyg Oa/ :92% @yxjge% Mg}go}`ao ac Woejtcwe Ianhj}jo}y \Vjx} J/% vjxjy ::.:4< Vjx} H/^ Ijyg Oa/ 83:% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% Y}j}wy jom ]xgj}ngo} ac Mg}j`oggy Bgem `o Dwjo}jojna

    Ojsje Hjyg

    Ijyg Oa/ 834% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% ]bg Ahjnj Jmn`o`y}xj}`aoy @o}gxongo} Y}jomjxmy

    S@/ ]BGCWOMJNGO]JEAHE@DJ]@AOACIANHJ]JO]Y]AM@Y]@ODW@YB]BGNYGESGYCXAN]BGI@S@E@JOVAVWEJ]@AO

    V @% Jx}/ =="9) \I@BE% Xweg :63^

    Maiwngo} Oa/ 49% Cxjoig% Jiigyy`ao }a Vxa}aiae @ \Vjx} H/% vjxj/ 2^ Ijyg Oa/ ::=% Njejpy`j% Aynjo s/ Vxaygiw}ax Ijyg Oa/ :86% O`dgx`j% V`wy Otjadj s/ ]bg Y}j}g Maiwngo} Oa/ :88% @IXI Jvvgjey ao }bg Ogjx Gjy} \Vjx} H/^ Ijyg Oa/ :=9% Jnogy}p @o}gxoj}`aoje% Hxgjib ac }bg Vx`oi`veg ac M`y}`oi}`ao Ijyg Oa/ :27% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% ]bg Yibegy`odgx Xgvax} Ijyg Oa/ 836% Jcdbjo`y}jo% Iamg ac Iaomwi} cax }bg Nwkjb`mggo \Jx}/ 39^ Ijyg Oa/ 83:% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% Y}j}wy jom ]xgj}ngo} ac Mg}j`oggy Bgem `o Dwjo}jojna

    Ojsje Hjyg Ijyg Oa/ 829% GIBX% Lbj}y`pgsj s/ Xwyy`j \Vjxjy :98.:92^

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; CGXXGEE T`ee`jn B/% Oa Yb`x}% Oa Ybagy% Oa Y}j}wy; Wo`caxny% M`y}`oi}`aojom Yvgi`je Avgxj}`aoy `o @o}gxoj}`aoje Jxngm Iao`i}% `oN`e`}jxp Ejt Xgs`gt% Sae/ :42% T`o}gx 8669%vv/ 0=.:=6% aoe`og; b}}v;!!ttt/cjy/axd!njo!gvx`o}!cgxxgee/vmc/ VCJOOGX ]ao`% N`e`}jxp Wo`caxny jom}bg Ejt ac Tjx% `o @XXI% Oa/ 279% Njxib 866=% vv/ 09.:96/

    S@@/ XGEJ]@S@]PAC]BGM@Y]@OI]@AO@ONAMGXOIAOCE@I]Y

    Ijyg Oa/ =0% @IXI% ]bg Ibjeegodgy ac Iao}gnvaxjxp Jxngm Iao`i}y \Vjx} H/^ Maiwngo} Oa/ 7:% @IXI% @o}gxvxg}j}`sg Dw`mjoig ao }bg Oa}`ao a M`xgi}

    Vjx}`i`vj}`ao `o Bay}`e`}`gy

    Ijyg Oa/ :60% GIBX% Laxhgep s/ Bwodjxp

    Ijyg Oa/ :=9% Jnogy}p @o}gxoj}`aoje% Hxgjib ac }bg Vx`oi`veg ac M`y}`oi}`ao

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; M@OY]G@O Paxjn% M`y}`oi}`ao jom Eayy ac I`s`e`jo Vxa}gi}`ao `o @o}gxoj}`aojeJxngm Iao`i}y% @PBX% Sae/ 92% 8662% vv/ :.:3/ VG]GXY Xjevb% ]bg Ogt Tjxx`axy Iejyy% `o Vjxjng}gxy%Ywnngx :00=% vv/ :3.83/ YIBN@]] N`ibjge O/% ]bg @nvji} ac B`db jom Eat.]gib Tjxcjxg ao }bg

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    79/400

    3 ]bg Cwomjngo}je M`y}`oi}`ao Hg}tggo I`s`e`joy jom Ianhj}jo}y

    Vx`oi`veg ac M`y}`oi}`ao% `o JXOAEM Xahgx}j # B@EMHXJOM V`gxxg.Jo}a`og "gmy)% @o}gxoj}`aojeBwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt jom }bg 8:y} Igo}wxpy Iao`i}y% Ejwyjoog% Gm`y% 8667% vv/ :30.:20/ TGODGX Jomxgjy# NJYAO Y`nao K/ J/% ]bg I`s`e`jo`{j}`ao ac Jxngm Iao`i}; ]xgomy jom @nve`ij}`aoy% `o @XXI% Sae/ 06%

    Oa/ 248% Mgignhgx 8662% vv/ 297.278/

    CWX]BGX XGJM@OD; HGE] Y}wjx} Tje}gxy% N`yy`egy asgx Layasa; Gngxdgoig% Egr Ej}j% ac j Iwy}anjxpOaxn Xgzw`x`od }bg Wyg ac Vxgi`y`ao Nwo`}`aoy `o Wxhjo Jxgjy% `o Ojsje Ejt Xgs`gt% Sae/ =4% 8666%vv/ ::7.:47/ HEJOL Ejwx`g # DW@AXJ Jnay% ]gjib`od jo Aem Mad Ogt ]x`ily; Avgxj}`aoje`{`od}bg Ejt ac Jxngm Iao`i} `o Ogt Tjxcjxg% `o Bjxsjxm Oj}`aoje Ygiwx`}p Kawxoje% Sae/ :% 86:6% == vv/HXATO Lgoog}b H/% Iawo}gx.Dwgxx`eej Avgxj}`aoy; Magy }bg Ejt ac Tjx Vxayix`hg Ywiigyy1% `oOjsje Ejt Xgs`gt% Sae/ ==% :004% vv/ :89.:49/ MJS@M Gx`i% Xgyvgi} cax }bg Vx`oi`veg ac M`y}`oi}`ao `o}bg Layasa Tjx% `o P@BE% Sae/ 9% 8666% vv/ 2:.:64/ D@EJM@ Xa}gn% Womgxiasgx Avgxj}`aoy jom @BEJmsaijip `o }bg Aiiwv`gm Vjegy}`o`jo ]gxx`}ax`gy% `o Kawxoje ac Iao`i} jom Ygiwx`}p Ejt% Sae/ :=%Oa/ 9% 8660% vv/ 909.=90/ DXAYY N`ibjge E/% Jypnng}x`i Tjx% Ypnng}x`ije @o}go}`aoy; L`ee`od I`s`e`joy`o Namgxo Jxngm Iao`i}% `o Deahje Ix`ng% Sae/ :6% Oa/ =% Oasgnhgx 8660% vv/ 986.993/ LEGCCOGX KjooL/% Cxan Hgee`dgxgo}y }a C`db}gxy jom I`s`e`joy M`xgi}ep Vjx}`i`vj}`od `o Bay}`e`}`gy; ao }bg Vx`oi`vegac M`y}`oi}`ao `o Oao.@o}gxoj}`aoje Jxngm Iao`i}y Aog Bwomxgm Pgjxy Jc}gx }bg Ygiaom Bjdwg VgjigIaocgxgoig% `o Og}bgxejomy @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt Xgs`gt% Sae/ 7=% Oa/ 8% 8664% vv/ 9:7.993/ VEJT Jsgxp%Wvbaem`od }bg Vx`oi`veg ac M`y}`oi}`ao `o Iawo}gx.]gxxax`y} Avgxj}`aoy; j M`jeadwg% `o Kawxoje ac

    N`e`}jxp G}b`iy% Sae/ 0% Oa/ :% 86:6% vv/ 9.88/ SGW]BGP N`ibge% Dwx`eej g} mxa`} bwnjo`}j`xg% Dgogsj% @IXI%:029% =7: vv/

    :/ Dwgxx`eej tjxcjxg

    Ijyg Oa/ 44% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% Vxgy`mgo} Xgkgi}y Vxa}aiae @ Ijyg Oa/ 869% Ijyg Y}wmp% Jxngm Iao`i}y `o }bg caxngx Pwdayejs`j \Vjxj/ 97^

    8/ Tjxy ac gr}gxn`oj}`ao

    Ijyg Oa/ :90% WO% Xgyaew}`aoy jom Iaocgxgoig ao Xgyvgi} cax }bg Cawx}b Iaosgo}`ao\Vjx} D/@@/8^

    Ijyg Oa/ 867% Hayo`j jom Bgx{gdas`oj% Iaoy}`}w}`ao ac Yjcg Jxgjy `o :008.:009 Ijyg Oa/ 882% Ijyg Y}wmp% Jxngm Iao`i}y o }bg Dxgj} Ejlgy Xgd`ao% \Vjx}y @/ J/ jom @@@/I/^

    9/ Y`}wj}`aoy tbgxg y}xwi}wxgy ac jw}bax`}p bjsg m`y`o}gdxj}gm

    Ijyg Oa/ =7% @IXI% M`y`o}gdxj}`ao a Y}j}g Y}xwi}wxgy Maiwngo} Oa/ 78% C`xy} Vgx`am`ije Ngg}`od% Ibj`xnjoy Xgvax} \Vjx} @@/8^ Ijyg Oa/ 882% Ijyg Y}wmp% Jxngm Iao`i}y `o }bg Dxgj} Ejlgy Xgd`ao \Vjx} @@@/J/ jom I/^ Ijyg Oa/ 84=% Ijyg Y}wmp% Jxngm Iao`i}y `o Y`gxxj Egaog% E`hgx`j jom Dw`ogj% \Vjx}y :

    jom 8^

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    80/400

    Vjx} @ Ibjv}gx 7 4

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; IJ@O Lgoog}b E/% ]bg Xjvg ac M`ojb; Bwnjo X`db}y% I`s`e Tjx `o E`hgx`j%jom Gs`e ]x`wnvbjo}% `o Bwnjo X`db}y Zwjx}gxep% Sae/ 8:!8% :000% vv/ 837.964/ ]BWGXGX Mjo`ge% ]bgCj`egm Y}j}g jom @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% `o @XXI% Oa/ 293% Mgignhgx :000% vv/ 49:.43:/ ]BWGXGX Mjo`ge%

    Mgx Tgdcjee gccgl}`sgx Y}jj}ydgtje}; Mgx cj`egm Y}j}g%Hgx`ib}g mgx Mgw}yibgo Dgygeeyibjc} cx Selgxxgib}%Sae/ 9=% :007% vv/ 0.=4/

    =/ Iao`i}y j`ngm j} asgx}bxat`od j xgd`ng ax j dasgxongo}

    7/ ]gxxax`yn% }bg tjx ao }gxxax% jom `o vjx}`iwejx }bg y}j}wy ac woejtcwe

    ianhj}jo}y

    `/g/ vgxyaoy tba hgeaod }a jo jxngm dxawv% hw} ma oa} cwee }bg "iaeegi}`sg ax`om`s`mwje) xgzw`xgngo}y cax ianhj}jo} y}j}wy\Ygg jeya Vjx} @% Ibjv}gx 8% @@@/ :/ g) ]bg deahje tjx ao }gxxax1^

    Ijyg Oa/ =0% @IXI% ]bg Ibjeegodgy a Iao}gnvaxjxp Jxngm Iaoc`i}y \Vjx} H/^ Ijyg Oa/ :93% @yxjge% ]bg ]jxdg}gm L`ee`ody Ijyg \Vjxjy 8=.=6^ Ijyg Oa/ :92% @yxjge% Mg}go}`ao a Woejtwe Ianhj}jo}y Ijyg Oa/ 83:% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% Y}j}wy jom ]xgj}ngo} a Mg}j`oggy Bgem `o

    Dwjo}jojna Ojsje Hjyg

    Ijyg Oa/ 837% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% N`e`}jxp Iann`yy`aoy

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; HAXGEE@ Y`es`j% Ijy}`od E`db} ao }bg Egdje Hejil Baeg; @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejtjom Mg}go}`aoy Jhxajm `o }bg Tjx ao ]gxxax% `o @XXI% Oa/ 274% Njxib 8667% vv/ 90.32/ HAXGEE@Y`es`j% ]bg ]xgj}ngo} ac ]gxxax`y} Ywyvgi}y Ijv}wxgm Jhxajm; Bwnjo X`db}y jom Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt%`o H@JOIB@ Jomxgj "gm/)% Gocaxi`od @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt Oaxny jdj`oy} ]gxxax`yn% Arcaxm% Bjx}% 866=%vv/ 90.3:/ HPGXY N`ibjge% ]gxxax`yn% }bg Wyg ac Caxig jom @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt jc}gx :: Ygv}gnhgx% o @IEZ%Sae/ 7:!8% 8668% vv/ =6:.=:=/ IJYYGYG Jo}ao`a% ]gxxax`yn `y jeya M`yxwv}`od Ixwi`je Egdje Ij}gdax`gy ac@o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% `oGK@E% Sae/ :8.7% 866:% vv/ 009.:66:/ IAOMAXGEE@ Ew`d` # OJZS@ Pjyn`o% ]bg Tjx

    jdj`oy} ]gxxax`yn jomKwy `o Hgeea; Jxg }bg Dgogsj Iaosgo}`aoy Aw} ac Mj}g1% `o H@JOIB@ Jomxgj "gm/)%Gocaxi`od @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt Oaxny jdj`oy} ]gxxax`yn% Arcaxm% Bjx}% 866=% vv/ 87.94/ IXJTCAXM Gn`ep%]bg ]xgj}ngo} ac Ianhj}jo}y jom @oywxdgo}y womgx }bg Ejt ac Jxngm Iao`i}% Arcaxm% AWV% 86:6% 8:9 vv/MXNJOO Low}% ]bg Egdje Y`}wj}`ao ac Woejtcwe!Wovx`s`egdgm Ianhj}jo}y% `o @XXI% Oa/ 2=0% Njxib8669% vv/ =7.4=/ CGXOJOMA.YJOIBG[ Vjhea Jo}ao`a "gm/)% @o}gxoj}`aoje Egdje M`ngoy`ao ac ]gxxax`yn"Ygg `o vjx}`iwejx Vjx} @S% ]gxxax`yn jom Jxngm Iao`i}y)% Eg`mgo% N/ O`kbacc% 8660% 7:8 vv/ C@OJWMNjxi% Ejhwy mg ej oa}`ao mg ianhj}}jo} `eedje ; wog j}}g`o}g jw mxa`} `o}gxoj}`aoje bwnjo`}j`xg%`o XDM@V% ]ang ::6% Oa/ =% 8663% vv/ 23:.206/ DJYYGX Bjoy.Vg}gx% @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt%}bg Vxab`h`}`ao ac ]gxxax`y} Ji}y jom }bg C`db} jdj`oy} ]gxxax`yn% `o P@BE% Sae/ =% 866=% vv/ 980.9=4/

    DXGGOTAAM Ibx`y}avbgx% @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt jom }bg Tjx jdj`oy} ]gxxax`yn% `o @o}gxoj}`aojeJccj`xy% Sae/ 42!8% 8668% vv/ 96:.9:4/ L@OD Cj`{j Vj}ge # YTJJL.DAEMNJO Ae`s`j% ]bg Jvve`ijh`e`}pac @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt }a }bg Tjx ao ]gxxax`yn% `o Bjdwg Pgjxhaal ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt%8669% Sae/ :7% 8668% vv/ 90.=0/ NIMAOJEM Og`e # YWEE@SJO Yia}}% Xj}`aoje @o}gxvxg}j}`ao `o @xxj}`aoje]`ngy; ]bg ]b`xm Dgogsj Iaosgo}`ao jom Tjx ao ]gxxax% `o Bjxsjxm @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt Kawxoje%Sae/ ==!:% 8669% vv/ 96:.9:3/ E@G][JW T`ee`jn% Ianhj}`od ]gxxax`yn; ]bg Iaoygzwgoigy ac Nas`odcxan Ejt Gocaxigngo} }a Tjx% `o T@VVNJO Mjs`m # GSJODGE@Y]J Nj}}bgt "gmy)% Ogt Tjxy% Ogt

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    81/400

    2 ]bg Cwomjngo}je M`y}`oi}`ao Hg}tggo I`s`e`joy jom Ianhj}jo}y

    Ejty1 Jvvep`od }bg Ejty ac Tjx `o 8: y} Igo}wxp Iao`i}y% Ogt Paxl% ]xjoyoj}`aoje Vwhe`ybgxy% 8667%vv/ 9:.7:/ OGWNJO Dgxjem E/% Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt jom Iawo}gx}gxxax`y} Caxig% `o GK@E% Sae/ :=!8% Jvx`e8669% vv/ 829.802/ VJWY] Kaxmjo K/% Tjx jom Gognp Y}j}wy Jc}gx 0!::; J}}jily ao }bg Ejty ac Tjx% o ]bg

    Pjeg Kawxoje ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% Sae/ 82% 8669% vv/ 987.997/ VGK@I Kgegoj% Woejtcwe!Gognp Ianhj}jo}y;@o}gxvxg}j}`aoy jom Iaoygzwgoigy% `o YIBN@]] N`ibjge # VGK@I Kgegoj "gmy)% @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt jom

    Jxngm Iao`i}; Grveax`od }bg Cjwe}e`ogy% Gyyjpy `o Baoawx ac Paxjn M`oy}g`o% N/ O`kbacc% Eg`mgo!Hay}ao%8664% vv/ 997.974/ VCJOOGX ]ao`% Jypnng}x`ije Tjxcjxg cxan }bg Vgxyvgi}`sg ac Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejtjom Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ji}`ao% `o @XXI% Oa/ 274% Njxib 8667% vv/ :=0.:4=/ VEJT Jsgxp% ]jxdg}`od ]gxxax`y}y;

    J E`igoyg }a L`ee1% Jemgxyba}% Jybdj}g% 8662% 80= vv/ XJ]OGX Y}gsgo X/% Vxgmj}ax jom Vxgp; Yg`{`odjom L`ee`od Ywyvgi}gm ]gxxax`y}y Jhxajm% `o Kawxoje ac Vae`}`ije Vb`eayavbp% Ygv}gnhgx 8664% Sae/ :7%@yywg 9% vv/ 87:.847/ XAHGX]Y Jmjn% ]bg Ejty ac Tjx `o }bg Tjx ao ]gxxax% `o @PBX% Sae/ 98% 8668%vv/ :09.8=7/ YJYYE@ Njxia% Ej mo`}`ao mw }gxxax`yng g} eg mxa`} `o}gxoj}`aoje bwnjo`}j`xg% o Xgswgzwhia`yg mg mxa`} `o}gxoj}`aoje% Sae/ :0% baxy.yx`g% 8664% vv/ 80.=2/ YJYYE@ Njxia% Ej dwgxxg iao}xg eg}gxxax`yng% eg mxa`} `o}gxoj}`aoje bwnjo`}j`xg g} eg y}j}w} mg vx`yaoo`gx mg dwgxxg% `o IP@E% Sae/ 90% 866:%vv/ 8::.878/ YJYYE@ Njxia% ]gxxax`yn jom Tjx% `o Kawxoje ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Ix`n`oje Kwy}`ig% Sae/ =%@yywg 7% 8663% vv/ 030.02:/ YJYYE@ Njxia% Zwgxp; @y ]bgxg j Y}j}wy ac Woejtcwe Ianhj}jo}1% `oKJIZWGY X`ibjxm H/ "gm/)% @yywgy `o @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt jom N`e`}jxp Avgxj}`aoy% `o @o}gxoj}`aojeEjt Y}wm`gy% Sae/ 26% 8663% vv/ 74.30/ YVGXA]]A Cgmgx`ia% ]jxdg}gm L`ee`ody `o xgyvaoyg }a Ygiwx`}p]bxgj}y; Tjxcjxg jom Bwnjo`}jx`jo @yywgy% `o Deahje Kwx`y}% Sae/ 2% @yywg 9% 8662% vv/ :.98/ ]@DXAWMKJBeog% Zwge"y) mxa`}"y) jvve`ijheg"y) ej dwgxxg jw }gxxax`yng 1% `o JCM@% Sae/ =2% 8668% vv/ 2:.:68/SGW]BGP N`ibge% Eg mxa`} `o}gxoj}`aoje bwnjo`}j`xg cjig ej dwgxxg iao}xg eg }gxxax`yng% `o MAWIG]Db`yej`og "gm/)% ]gxxax`yng% s`i}`ngy g} xgyvaoyjh`e`} vojeg `o}gxoj}`aojeg% Vjx`y% Ijenjoo.Esp% 8669%

    vv/ 7:3.780/ TJ]L@O Lgoog}b% Bwnjoy `o }bg Ixayy.Bj`xy; ]jxdg}`od% Jyyjyy`oj}`ao jom Gr}xj.EgdjeL`ee`od `o Iao}gnvaxjxp Jxngm Iao`i}% `o T@VVNJO Mjs`m # GSJODGE@Y]J Nj}}bgt "gmy)%Ogt Tjxy% Ogt Ejty1 Jvvep`od }bg Ejty ac Tjx `o 8: y} Igo}wxp Iao`i}y% Ogt Paxl% ]xjoyoj}`aojeVwhe`ybgxy% 8667% vv/ :94.:40/ PAA Kabo I/ # BA Kjngy I/% ]bg Y}j}wy ac ]gxxax`y}y% `o S`xd`o`j Kawxojeac @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% Sae/ ==% Cjee 8669% vv/ 864.882/

    CWX]BGX XGJM@OD; HGEEJNP Jegr K/% Oa Vj`o% Oa Dj`o1 ]ax}wxg jom G}b`iy `o }bg Tjx ao ]gxxax% `o@o}gxoj}`aoje Jccj`xy% Sae/ 28% Oa/ :% Kjowjxp 8663% vv/ :8:.:=3/ MWCCP Bgego% Bwnjo X`db}y E`}`dj}`aojom }bg Tjx ao ]gxxax% `o @XXI% Sae/ 06% Oa/ 24:% Ygv}gnhgx 8662% vv/ 749.704/ BACCNJOO N`ibjge B/%

    Y}j}g Vxji}`ig% }bg Iwy}anjxp Ejt ac Tjx jom ]gxxax`yn; Jmjv}`od Aem Xwegy }a Ngg} Ogt ]bxgj}y% `o@PBX% Sae/ 9=% 866=% vv/ 89:.8=0/ KJILYAO Kjn` Nge`yyj% ]bg Egdje`}p ac Jyyjyy`oj}`ao ac @omgvgomgo}]gxxax`y} Egjmgxy; jo Grjn`oj}`ao ac Oj}`aoje jom @o}gxoj}`aoje @nve`ij}`aoy% `o Oax}b Ijxae`oj Kawxojeac @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt jom Ianngxi`je Xgdwej}`ao% Sae/ 8=!9% :000% vv/ 330.304/ E@OOJO Mjs`m L/%GognpIanhj}jo}y% ]gxxax`yn jom Jxngm Iao`i} Ejt; j Dw`mg }a }bg @yywgy % Tgy}vax}% Eaomao% Vxjgdgx Ygiwx`}p@o}gxoj}`aoje% 8662% =66 vv/ AIAOOGEE Njxp Geego% Ianhj}jo}y jom }bg Ianhj} [aog% `o Wo`sgxy`}pac X`ibnaom Ejt Xgs`gt% Sae/ =9% @yywg 9% Njxib 8660% vv/ 2=7.239/ VJXLGX ]an% ]bg Vxavax}`aoje`}pVx`oi`veg `o }bg Tjx ao ]gxxax% `o Bjdwg Pgjxhaal ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% Sae/ :7% 8668% vv/ 9.:7/XAHGX]Y Jmjn% Iawo}gx.}gxxax`yn% Jxngm Caxig jom }bg Ejty ac Tjx% `o Ywxs`sje% Sae/ ==!:% 8668%vv/ 4.98/ XWH@O Jecxgm V/% Jvvep`od }bg Dgogsj Iaosgo}`aoy; N`e`}jxp Iann`yy`aoy% Jxngm Iao`i}%jom Je.Zjgmj% `o ]bg Ceg}ibgx Caxwn ac Taxem Jccj`xy% Sae/ 83!:% 8668% vv/ 40.2:/ YIBN@]] N`ibjge O/%Jypnng}x`ije Tjxcjxg jom @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% ]bg J`x Caxig Ejt Xgs`gt% Sae/ 38% 8662%vv/ :.=8/ TGMDTAAM Xw}b% Xgyvaom`od }a ]gxxax`yn; }bg Y}x`lgy jdj`oy} H`o Ejmgo% o ]bg Pjeg Kawxojeac @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% Sae/ 8=!8% :000% vv/ 770.743/

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    82/400

    Vjx} @ Ibjv}gx 7 0

    j) @o }bg iaomwi} a bay}`e`}`gy

    Ijo }bgp hg j}}jilgm wo}`e }bgp jxg baxy mg ianhj} "e`lg ianhj}jo}y) ax aoep tb`eg

    }bgp m`xgi}ep vjx}`i`vj}g `o bay}`e`}`gy "e`lg i`s`e`joy)1

    Maiwngo} Oa/ 7:% @IXI% @o}gxvxg}`sg Dw`mjoig ao }bg Oa}`ao a M`xgi}Vjx}`i`vj}`ao `o Bay}`e`}`gy

    h) Aoig `o gognp bjomy

    Jxg }bgp vxa}gi}gm i`s`e`joy ax ijo }bgp hg mg}j`ogm e`lg ianhj}jo}y t`}baw} jop`om`s`mwje mgi`y`ao% hw} oa} hgog} cxan VAT y}j}wy1

    Ijyg Oa/ :92% @yxjge% Mg}go}`ao a Woejtwe Ianhj}jo}y

    Ijyg Oa/ 83:% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% Y}j}wy jom ]xgj}ngo} a Mg}j`oggy Bgem `oDwjo}jojna Ojsje Hjyg

    Ijyg Oa/ 837% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% N`e`}jxp Iann`yy`aoy Ijyg Oa/ 833% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% Bjhgjy Iaxvwy cax Dwjo}jojna Mg}j`oggy Ijyg Oa/ 834% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% ]bg Ahjnj Jmn`o`y}xj}`aoy @o}gxongo} Y}jomjxmy Maiwngo} Oa/ 832% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% Ieaywxg ac Dwjo}jojna Mg}go}`ao Cji`e`}`gy Ijyg Oa/ 820% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% Vwhe`i iwx`ay`}p

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; HADJX ]banjy% Woejtcwe Ianhj}jo} ax @ooaigo} I`s`e`jo1 J Ijee }a Ibjodg}bg Iwxxgo} Ngjoy cax Mg}gxn`o`od Y}j}wy ac Vx`yaogxy `o }bg Deahje Tjx ao ]gxxax% `o Ceax`mj Kawxojeac @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% Sae/ 8:% Oa/ :% Jvx`e 8660% vv/ 80.0:/ HAXGEE@ Y`es`j% Ijy}`od E`db} ao }bg EgdjeHejil Baeg; @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt jom Mg}go}`aoy Jhxajm `o }bg Tjx ao ]gxxax% `o @XXI% Oa/ 274% Njxib8667% vv/ 90.32/ HAXGEE@ Y`es`j% ]bg ]xgj}ngo} ac ]gxxax`y} Ywyvgi}y Ijv}wxgm Jhxajm; Bwnjo X`db}yjom Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% `o H@JOIB@ Jomxgj "gm/)%Gocaxi`od @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt Oaxny jdj`oy} ]gxxax`yn%Arcaxm% Bjx}% 866=% vv/ 90.3:/ CAXYP]BG Mjs`m V/% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy Vae`ip ]atjxm Gognp Mg}j`oggy `o}bg Tjx ao ]gxxax`yn% `o Bwnjo X`db}y Zwjx}gxep% Sae/ 82% Oa/ 8% Njp 8663% vv/ =37.=0:/ DAAMNJO

    Xpjo% ]bg Mg}go}`ao ac I`s`e`joy `o Jxngm Iao`i}y% `o JK@E% Sae/ :69% Oa/ :% Kjowjxp 8660% vv/ =2.4=/NWXVBP Ygjo M/% Gsaes`od Dgogsj Iaosgo}`ao Vjxjm`dny `o }bg Tjx ao ]gxxax`yn; Jvvep`od }bgIaxg Xwegy }a }bg Xgegjyg ac Vgxyaoy Mggngm Wovx`s`e`dgm Ianhj}jo}y% `o ]bg Dgaxdg Tjyb`od}ao EjtXgs`gt% Sae/ 47% Oa/ 7!3% Jwdwy} 8664% vv/ ::67.::3=/ OJGX] Cxgmgx`l% Mg}go}`ao `o Vgjig Avgxj}`aoy; }bgEgdje Cxjngtaxl jom Nj`o Ij}gdax`gy ac Mg}j`oggy% `o Xgswg mg mxa`} n`e`}j`xg g} mg mxa`} mg ej dwgxxg %Sae/ :.8% Oa/ =7% 8663% vv/ 7:.42/ AEYAO Ejwxj% Dwjo}jojna Bjhgjy Xgs`gt; Jxg }bg M/I/ M`y}x`i} Iawx}yMgi`y`aoy Iaoy`y}go} t`}b @BE @o}gxongo} Y}jomjxmy1% `o Ijyg Tgy}gxo Xgygxsg Kawxoje ac @o}gxoj}`aojeEjt% Sae/ =8% Oa/ : # 8% 8660% vv/ :04.8=9/ XAOJ Djhax% Jo Jvvxj`yje ac WY Vxji}`ig Xgej}`od }a GognpIanhj}jo}y% `o P@BE% Sae/ :6 "8664)% 8660% vv/ 898.876/ XAOJ Djhax% J Hwee `o j Ib`oj Ybav; ]bg Tjx

    ao ]gxxax jom @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt `o }bg Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% `o Ije`caxo`j Tgy}gxo @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt Kawxoje%Sae/ 90% @yywg :% 8662% vv/ :97.:70/ ]WXOY Mjs`m% ]bg ]xgj}ngo} ac Mg}j`oggy jom }bg Deahje Tjx ao]gxxax; Ygegi}gm Egdje @yywgy% `o @PBX% Sae/ 92% 8662% vv/ :=7.:34/ TJRNJO Nj}}bgt I/% Mg}go}`ao jy]jxdg}`od; Y}jomjxmy ac Igx}j`o}p jom Mg}go}`ao ac Ywyvgi}gm ]gxxax`y}y% `o Iaewnh`j Ejt Xgs`gt% 8662%Sae/ :62% vv/ :937.:=96/

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    83/400

    :6 ]bg Cwomjngo}je M`y}`oi}`ao Hg}tggo I`s`e`joy jom Ianhj}jo}y

    3/ I`s`e`jo`{j}`ao ac jxngm iao`i}y

    j) dxat`od `osaesgngo} a vx`sj}g n`e`}jxp jom ygiwx`}p ianvjo`gy

    @o}xamwi}axp }gr}

    J dxat`od ownhgx ac Y}j}gy "jom yang}`ngy `o}gxoj}`aoje axdjo`{j}`aoy% ODAy axhwy`ogyygy) wyg vx`sj}g n`e`}jxp jom ygiwx`}p ianvjo`gy "VNYIy) cax j t`mg sjx`g}p ac}jyly }xjm`}`aojeep vgxcaxngm hp yaem`gxy `o }bg gemy ac ead`y}`iy% ygiwx`}p% `o}gee`dgoigdj}bgx`od jom vxa}gi}`ao ac vgxyaoy% ahkgi}y jom }xjoyvax}y/

    ]bg `o}gxoj}`aoje egdje ahe`dj}`aoy ac iao}xji}`od Y}j}gy% }gxx`}ax`je Y}j}gy% bang

    Y}j}gy% jee a}bgx Y}j}gy jom VNYIy jom }bg`x vgxyaooge bjsg hggo xgy}j}gm "}adg}bgxt`}b xgianngomj}`aoy ac hgy} vxji}`igy) `o j maiwngo} \0:^ jiigv}gm hp nay} ac }bgY}j}gy iaoigxogm/ Iao}xji}`od Y}j}gy xgnj`o hawom hp @BE gsgo `c }bgp iao}xji} aw}igx}j`o ji}`s`}`gy }a VNYIy/ @o njop ijygy% }bg iaomwi} ac VNYIy ijo hg j}}x`hw}gm }a}bg iao}xji}`od Y}j}g hp s`x}wg ac }bg dgogxje xwegy ao Y}j}g xgyvaoy`h`e`}p% ax }bg Y}j}gbjy j} egjy} j mwg m`e`dgoig ahe`dj}`ao `o }b`y xgyvgi} jom nwy} goywxg }bj} }bg VNYIy`} iao}xji}y ji} `o jiiaxmjoig t`}b @BE/ Hgpaom }bg cgt ijygy ac ji}`s`}`gy @BE xwegyyvgi`ijeep jyy`do }a Y}j}g jdgo}y% \08^ `} njp hg jxdwgm }bj} @BE `nve`i`}ep vxab`h`}yY}j}gy cxan aw}yawxi`od m`xgi} vjx}`i`vj}`ao `o bay}`e`}`gy }a vgxyaoy tba jxg oa}

    ianhj}jo}y/VNYI y}jcc oaxnjeep ma oa} cjee womgx }bg sgxp xgy}x`i}`sg mgo`}`ao ac ngxigojx`gy `o@BE/ \09^ Nay} ac }bgn jxg oa} mg kwxg ax mg cji}a `oiaxvaxj}gm `o}a }bg jxngm caxigy acj vjx}p jom jxg }bgxgcaxg oa} ianhj}jo}y hw} i`s`e`joy/ Jy ywib% }bg`x iaomwi} e`olgm}a jo jxngm iao`i} `y dasgxogm j} egjy} hp }bg xwegy ac @BE ix`n`oje`{`od igx}j`o}pvgy ac iaomwi}/ ]bg nj`o vxahegn `y }bj} }bgp ac}go hgog} cxan mg cji}a ax mg kwxg`nnwo`}p `o }bg iawo}xp tbgxg }bgp taxl jom }bj} ix`n`oje kwx`ym`i}`ao asgx }bgn `o}b`xm iawo}x`gy `y oa} jy iegjxep xgdwej}gm jy cax ngnhgxy ac jxngm caxigy jom ac}gooa} hjilgm wv hp jo gci`go} ejt gocaxigngo} ypy}gn/

    Jy i`s`e`joy% VNYI y}jcc njp oa} m`xgi}ep vjx}`i`vj}g `o bay}`e`}`gy/ VNYIy jom njkaxiao}xji}`od Y}j}gy ac}go y}xgyy }bj} VNYIy bjsg aoep mgcgoy`sg cwoi}`aoy/ ]bgvgxcaxnjoig ac ywib cwoi}`aoy njp ogsgx}bgegyy iaoy}`}w}g m`xgi} vjx}`i`vj}`ao `obay}`e`}`gy/ ]b`y `y wom`yvw}gm `c }bgp mgcgom ianhj}jo}y ax n`e`}jxp ahkgi}`sgy jdj`oy}}bg jmsgxyg vjx}p/ Ao }bg a}bgx gr}xgng% `} `y woiao}xasgxy`je }bj} }bg mgcgoig acn`e`}jxp }jxdg}y jdj`oy} iannao ix`n`ojey ax }bg mgcgoig ac i`s`e`joy jom i`s`e`joahkgi}y jdj`oy} woejtcwe j}}jily magy oa} iaoy}`}w}g m`xgi} vjx}`i`vj}`ao `o bay}`e`}`gy/]bg nay} ix`}`ije% m`ciwe} jom cxgzwgo} y`}wj}`ao `y tbgo VNYI y}jcc dwjxm ahkgi}y%}xjoyvax}y ax vgxyaoy/ @c }bayg ahkgi}y% }xjoyvax}y ax vgxyaoy jxg oa} vxa}gi}gm jdj`oy}

    j}}jily `o @BE "ianhj}jo}y% i`s`e`joy m`xgi}ep vjx}`i`vj}`od `o bay}`e`}`gy)% dwjxm`od axmgcgom`od }bgn jdj`oy} j}}jily iaoy}`}w}gy m`xgi} vjx}`i`vj}`ao `o bay}`e`}`gy jom oa}

    0: Nao}xgwr Maiwngo} ao Vgx}`ogo} @o}gxoj}`aoje Egdje Ahe`dj}`aoy jom Daam Vxji}`igy ac Y}j}gy xgej}gm }a Avgxj}`aoy ac Vx`sj}g N`e`}jxpjom Ygiwx`}p Ianvjo`gy Mwx`od Jxngm Iao`i} \YggMaiwngo} Oa/ 96% Nao}xgwr Maiwngo} ao Vx`sj}g N`e`}jxp jom Ygiwx`}p Ianvjo`gy^

    08 Ygg g/d/ DI @@@% Jx}/ 90% ao tba njp grgxi`yg }bg vatgx ac xgyvaoy`heg acigx ac j VAT ijnv

    09 Ygg V @% Jx}/ =4% jom `ocxj Vjx} @% Ibjv}gx 3% @/ 9/ i) ngxigojx`gy

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    84/400

    Vjx} @ Ibjv}gx 7 ::

    ix`n`oje ejt mgcgoig ac a}bgxy/ @o awx s`gt% }b`y `y jetjpy }bg ijyg tbgo }bg j}}jilgx`y j vgxyao hgeaod`od }a j vjx}p }a }bg iao`i}% gsgo `c bg ax ybg magy oa} hgog}cxan ax bjy eay} ianhj}jo} y}j}wy }bg woejtcwe y}j}wy ac }bg j}}jilgx magy oa} d`sg

    x`yg }a ygec.mgcgoig/ @c }bg vgxyao j}}jilgm jom womgx }bg mangy}`i egd`yej}`ao acyang iawo}x`gy gsgo `c }bg ahkgi} j}}jilgm `y i`s`e`jo% ix`n`oje ejt ygec.mgcgoig njp

    kwy}`cp }bg wyg ac caxig% gsgo jdj`oy} ianhj}jo}y/ ]bg jojepy`y `y ianve`ij}gm hp }bgjhygoig ac jo `o}gxoj}`aoje ejt y}jomjxm ac ygec.mgcgoig jom mgcgoig ac a}bgxy jom hpmawh}y tbg}bgx }bg ix`n`oje ejt mgcgoig ac ygec.mgcgoig tb`ib jsa`my iaos`i}`ao njphg wygm gr jo}g jy j egdje hjy`y cax jo go}`xg hwy`ogyy ji}`s`}p/ @} nwy} `o jmm`}`ao hgy}xgyygm }bj} ygec.mgcgoig njp aoep hg grgxi`ygm jdj`oy} j}}jily% oa} jdj`oy} jxxgy}y ax}bg yg`{wxg ac ahkgi}y/ @omggm }bg ix`}gx`j mg}gxn`o`od tbgo j i`s`e`jo njp hg jxxgy}gmax ahkgi}y njp hg xgzw`y`}`aogm jxg }aa ianve`ij}gm `o @BE }a jeeat VNYI y}jcc }a

    mg}gxn`og tbgo }bgp bjsg hggo ng}/ @o awx s`gt% ygec.mgcgoig jy jo grigv}`ao }a }bgiejyy`ij}`ao ac igx}j`o iaomwi} jy m`xgi} vjx}`i`vj}`ao o bay}`e`}`gy nwy} hg iaoy}xwgmsgxp ojxxatep/ @o jmm`}`ao% VNYI y}jcc vxas`m`od ygiwx`}p cax jo ahkgi} t`ee ac}go oa} hgjheg }a loat tbg}bgx }bj} ahkgi} iaoy}`}w}gy j n`e`}jxp ahkgi}`sg "tb`ib griewmgy ygec.mgcgoig% hgijwyg }bg j}}jil tawem oa} hg woejtcwe) jom tbg}bgx }bg j}}jilgxy ma oa}hgeaod }a j vjx}p "tb`ib tawem oa} iejyy`cp xgy`y}joig jdj`oy} ywib j}}jilgxy jy m`xgi}vjx}`i`vj}`ao `o bay}`e`}`gy% gsgo tbgo }bg ahkgi} j}}jilgm `y j n`e`}jxp ahkgi}`sg)/ J}}bg yjng }`ng% `} `y m`ciwe} cax }bg gognp }a m`y}`odw`yb hg}tggo ianhj}jo}y% VNYIy}jcc tba m`xgi}ep vjx}`i`vj}g `o bay}`e`}`gy "tban }bgp njp j}}jil jom tba njp

    j}}jil }bgn) jom VNYI y}jcc tba ma oa} m`xgi}ep vjx}`i`vj}g `o bay}`e`}`gy% njp oa}hg j}}jilgm jom t`ee oa} j}}jil }bg gognp/ ]a nj`o}j`o j iegjx m`y}`oi}`ao hg}tggoi`s`e`joy jom ianhj}jo}y jom }a goywxg }bj} VNYI y}jcc ma oa} eayg }bg`x vxa}gi}`ao jyi`s`e`joy% }bgp ybawem }bgxgcaxg oa} hg vw} `o jnh`dwawy y`}wj}`aoy/

    Ijyg Oa/ 86% ]bg @yywg a Ngxigojx`gy \Vjx} M/^ Maiwngo} Oa/ 96% Nao}xgwr Maiwngo} ao Vx`sj}g N`e`}jxp jom Ygiwx`}p

    Ianvjo`gy

    Ijyg Oa/ =0% @IXI% ]bg Ibjeegodgy ac Iao}gnvaxjxp Jxngm Iao`i}y \Vjx} H/^

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; HJENAOM Eaw`y% Ahygxsj}`aoy ywx eg maiwngo} mg Nao}xgwr xgej}`c jwrahe`dj}`aoy kwx`m`zwgy `o}gxoj}`aojegy vgx}`ogo}gy g} jwr haoogy vxj}`zwgy vawx egy G}j}y iaoigxojo}egy ji}`s`}y mgy yai`}y n`e`}j`xgy vx`sgy% `o XDM@V% ]/ ::9% Oa/ :% 8660% vv/ ::9.:8=/ HAEM] O`ilp%Aw}yawxi`od Tjx; Vx`sj}g N`e`}jxp Ianvjo`gy jom @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% Dgxnjo Pgjxhaalac @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% sae/ =4% 8667% vv/ 768.7==/ HAYIB Ybjooao% Vx`sj}g Ygiwx`}p Iao}xji}axy jom Y}j}gXgyvaoy`h`e`}p; Jxg Y}j}gy Grgnv} cxan Xgyvaoy`h`e`}p cax S`aej}`aoy ac Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt Vgxvg}xj}gmhp Vx`sj}g Ygiwx`}p Iao}xji}axy1% o ]bg Ianvjxj}`sg jom @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt Kawxoje ac Yaw}bgxo Jcx`ij%Sae/ =:% Oa/ 9% 8662% vv/ 979.928/ IJNGXAO E`omygp% Vx`sj}g N`e`}jxp Ianvjo`gy; ]bg`x Y}j}wy womgx

    @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt jom @}y @nvji} ao }bg`x Xgdwej}`ao% @XXI% Sae/ 22% 8663% vv/ 749.702/IJNGXAO E`omygp% Ogt Y}jomjxmy cax jom hp Vx`sj}g N`e`}jxp Ianvjo`gy1% `o VG]GXY J/ g} je/% Oao.Y}j}g Ji}axy jy Y}jomjxm Yg}}gxy% Ijnhx`mdg% IWV% 8660% vv/ ::9.:=7/ IBGY]GXNJO Y`nao # EGBOJXM]Ib`j "gmy)% Cxan Ngxigojx`gy }a Njxlg}; }bg X`yg jom Xgdwej}`ao ac Vx`sj}g N`e`}jxp Ianvjo`gy % Arcaxm%AWV% 8664% 824 vv/ IAILJPOG Kjngy% ]bg Deahje Xgaxdjo`{j}`ao ac Egd`}`nj}g S`aegoig; N`e`}jxpGo}xgvxgogwxy jom }bg Vx`sj}g Cjig ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% `o @XXI% Sae/ 22% Oa/ 239%

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    85/400

    :8 ]bg Cwomjngo}je M`y}`oi}`ao Hg}tggo I`s`e`joy jom Ianhj}jo}y

    Ygv}gnhgx 8663% vv/ =70.=06/ IAILJPOG Kjngy% Xgdwej}`od Vx`sj}g N`e`}jxp jom Ygiwx`}p Ianvjo`gy;}bg Iao}go}% Ogda}`j}`ao% Tgjlogyygy jom Vxan`yg ac }bg Nao}xgwr Maiwngo}% `o Kawxoje ac Iao`i}# Ygiwx`}p Ejt% Sae/ :9% Oa/ 9% 8662% vv/ =6:.=82/ IAILJPOG Kjngy # YVGGXY NGJXY Gn`ep% Vx`sj}g

    n`e`}jxp jom Ygiwx`}p Ianvjo`gy; j Cxjngtaxl cax Xgdwej}`ao% @o}gxoj}`aoje Vgjig @oy}`}w}g% Njxib 8660%:3 vv/ IA]]@GX N`ibjge% Gegngo}y cax Iao}xji}`od jom Xgdwej}`od Vx`sj}g Ygiwx`}p jom N`e`}jxpIanvjo`gy% `o @XXI% Sae/ 22% Oa/ 239% Ygv}gnhgx 8663% vv/ 394.339/ IATE@OD N/D/% Aw}yawxi`od jom}bg N`e`}jxp; @nve`ij}`aoy cax @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% `o Yaw}b Jcx`ijo Pgjxhaal ac @o}gxoj}`aojeEjt% Sae/ 98% Pgjx 8664% 8662% vv/ 9:8.9==/ CXJOI@AO@ Cxjoigyia% Vx`sj}g N`e`}jxp Iao}xji}axy jom@o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt; Ypnvay`wn% `o GK@E% Sae/ :0% Oa/ 7% 8662% vv/ 03:.:64=/ D@EEJXM Gnjowgej.Ib`jxj% Hwy`ogyy Dagy }a Tjx% @XXI% Sae/ 22% Oa/ 239% 8663% vv/ 787.748/ LAO]AY Jegr`y V/% Vx`sj}gYgiwx`}p Dwjxmy; Vx`sj}`{gm Caxig jom Y}j}g Xgyvaoy`h`e`}p womgx @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo X`db}y Ejt%Oao.Y}j}g Ji}axy jom @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% Sae/ =% 866=% vv/ :00.892/ E@W B`o.Pjo% Egjyb`od }bg Iaxvaxj}gMady ac Tjx; }bg Egdje @nve`ij}`aoy ac }bg Namgxo Vx`sj}g N`e`}jxp Ianvjop% `o Kawxoje ac Iao`i}jom Ygiwx`}p Ejt% Sae/ :7% Oa/ :% 86:6% vv/ :=:.:32/ NJIMAOJEM Jsx`e% ]bg Egdje Y}j}wy ac N`e`}jxp jomYgiwx`}p Ywhiao}xji}axy% `o JXOAEM Xahgx}j # B@EMHXJOM V`gxxg.Jo}a`og "gmy)% @o}gxoj}`aojeBwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt jom }bg 8:y} Igo}wxpy Iao`i}y; Ibjodgy jom Ibjeegodgy% Ejwyjoog% Gm`}`aoy@o}gxwo`sgxy`}j`xgy Yw`yygy% 8667% vv/ 8:7.879/ NJIMAOJEM Jsx`e% Mady ac Tjx Xgmwr1 Vx`sj}gN`e`}jxp Iao}xji}axy jom }bg Ogt Ngxigojx`yn% `o N`e`}j`x Xgib}ge`kl ]`kmyibx`c}% Sae/ :66% Oa/ 4% 8664%vv/ 8:6.882/ X@MEAO Mjo`ge V/% Iao}xji}axy ax @eegdje Ianhj}jo}y1 ]bg Y}j}wy ac Jxngm Iao}xji}axy `o@xjz% `o ]bg J`x Caxig Ejt Xgs`gt% Sae/ 38% 8662% vv/ :00.879/ YIBN@]] N`ibjge O/% Tjx% @o}gxoj}`aojeEjt jom Yasgxg`do}p; Xggsjewj}`od }bg Xwegy ac }bg Djng `o j Ogt Igo}wxp; Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt jomM`xgi} Vjx}`i`vj}`ao `o Bay}`e`}`gy hp Vx`sj}g Iao}xji}axy ax I`s`e`jo Gnveapggy% Ib`ijda Kawxoje ac

    @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% Sae/ 7% 8667% vv/ 7::.7=3/ YIBN@]] N`ibjge O/% Iao}xji}axy ao }bg Hj}}eggem;}bg WY Jvvxajib% `oN`e`}j`x Xgib}ge`kl ]`kmyibx`c}% Sae/ :66% Oa/ 4% 8664% vv/ 83=.82:/ YAYYJ@ N`xla% Y}j}wyac Vx`sj}g N`e`}jxp Ianvjo`gy Vgxyaooge `o }bg Ejty ac Tjx; }bg Zwgy}`ao ac M`xgi} Vjx}`i`vj}`ao `oBay}`e`}`gy% `o ]bg @}je`jo Pgjxhaal ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% Sae/ :2% 8662% vv/ 20.::7/ Y]GVBGOY Mjeg #EGT@Y Jodge`og% ]bg ]jxdg}`od ac Iao}xji}axy `o Jxngm Iao`i}% `o P@BE% Sae/ 0% 8663% vv/ 87.3=/Ypnvay`wn; Vx`sj}g N`e`}jxp Iao}xji}axy jom @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt "t`}b iao}x`hw}`aoy hp CXJOI@AO@Cxjoigyia% TB@]G O`dge% NJIEAGM Yaxibj% BAVVG Ijxy}go% EGBOJXM] Ib`j% XPODJGX] Igmx`i #IBGY]GXNJO Y`nao)%GK@E sae/ :0% 8662% vv/ 03:.:64=/ ]AOL@O Bjoojb% Iannao Jx}`ieg @; j N`o`nwnPjxmy}`il cax Xgdwej}`od Vx`sj}g N`e`}jxp jom Ygiwx`}p Ianvjo`gy% o Eg`mgo Kawxoje ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt%Sae/ 88% Oa/ =% 8660% vv/ 840.800/ Wo`sgxy`}p Igo}xg cax @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% Grvgx} Ngg}`od ao

    Vx`sj}g N`e`}jxp Iao}xji}axy; Y}j}wy jom Y}j}g Xgyvaoy`h`e`}p cax }bg`x Ji}`aoy% Xgvax}% Dgogsj% 8667% aoe`og;b}}v;!!ttt/jmb.dgogsg/ib!vmcy!8xjvvax}Qianvjdo`gyQvx`sggy/vmc TJE]BGX Vgxo`eeg% ]bg EgdjeY}j}wy ac Vx`sj}g Iao}xji}axy womgx @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% `oKwy}`}`j% Sae/ 9:% Oa/ =% Wo`sgxy`}pac Iavgobjdgo% 8662% vv/ :.=4/

    h) }bg `oixgjy`od ownhgx a i`s`e`joy "`/g/ vgxyaoy tba jxg oa} ianhj}jo}y)

    m`xgi}ep jom om`xgi}ep vjx}`i`vj}`od o bay}`e`}`gy"Ygg `ocxj Vjx} @% Ibjv}gx 0% @@/ 4/ Eayy ac vxa}gi}`ao; ]bg iaoigv} ac m`xgi} vjx}`i`vj}`ao `o bay}`e`}`gy jom `}yiaoygzwgoigy)

    Ijyg Oa/ =0% @IXI% ]bg Ibjeegodgy ac Iao}gnvaxjxp Jxngm Iao`i}y \Vjx} H/^ Maiwngo} Oa/ 7:% @IXI% @o}gxvxg}j}`sg Dw`mjoig ao }bg Oa}`ao a M`xgi}

    Vjx}`i`vj}`ao `o Bay}`e`}`gy

    Ijyg Oa/ :60% GIBX% Laxhgep s/ Bwodjxp Ijyg Oa/ :93% @yxjge% ]bg ]jxdg}gm L`ee`ody Ijyg \Vjxjy 80.=6^

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    86/400

    Vjx} @ Ibjv}gx 7 :9

    Ijyg Oa/ :92% @yxjge% Mg}go}`ao ac Woejtcwe Ianhj}jo}y \Vjx} J/% vjxjy :9% 8:< Vjx} H/^ Ijyg Oa/ 894% @II% ]bg Vxaygiw}ax s/ ]banjy Ewhjodj Mp`ea \Vjxjy 870.834^ Ijyg Oa/ 8==% Iaeanh`j% Iaoy}`}w}`aoje`}p ac @BE @nvegngo}`od Egd`yej}`ao

    \Vjxjy M/9/9/:/.7/=/9/% Vjxj/ G/:^ Ijyg Oa/ 806% Dgaxd`j!Xwyy`j% Bwnjo X`db}y Tj}iby Xgvax} ao }bg Iao`i} `o Yaw}b

    Ayyg}`j \Vjxjy 4.:7% =8% 78.73^

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    87/400

    Ibjv}gx 3

    Ianhj}jo}y jom Vx`yaogxy ac Tjx

    @o}xamwi}axp }gr}

    Ianhj}jo}y jxg ngnhgxy ac jxngm caxigy/ ]bg nj`o cgj}wxg ac }bg`x y}j}wy `o`o}gxoj}`aoje jxngm iao`i}y `y }bj} }bgp bjsg }bg x`db} }a m`xgi}ep vjx}`i`vj}g `obay}`e`}`gy/ @c }bgp cjee `o}a gognp bjomy% }bgp hgiang vx`yaogxy ac tjx tba njp oa}hg vwo`ybgm cax bjs`od m`xgi}ep vjx}`i`vj}gm `o bay}`e`}`gy/ @} `y ac}go iaoy`mgxgm }bj}iwy}anjxp ejt jeeaty j mg}j`o`od vatgx }a mgop `}y ato oj}`aojey vx`yaogx.ac.tjx

    y}j}wy% gsgo c }bgp cjee o}a }y bjomy jy ngnhgxy ac gognp jxngm caxigy/ @o jop gsgo}%ywib vgxyaoy njp hg vwo`ybgm womgx mangy}`i ejt cax }bg`x ngxg vjx}`i`vj}`ao `obay}`e`}`gy jdj`oy} }bg`x ato iawo}xp/

    Ianhj}jo}y bjsg jo ahe`dj}`ao }a xgyvgi} @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt "@BE)% tb`ib`oiewmgy m`y}`odw`yb`od }bgnygesgy cxan }bg i`s`e`jo vavwej}`ao/ @c }bgp s`aej}g @BE}bgp nwy} hg vwo`ybgm% hw} }bgp ma oa} eayg }bg`x ianhj}jo} y}j}wy jom% `c ijv}wxgmhp }bg gognp% xgnj`o go}`}egm }a vx`yaogx.ac.tjx y}j}wy% grigv} `c }bgp bjsg s`aej}gm}bg`x ahe`dj}`ao }a m`y}`odw`yb }bgnygesgy/

    Vgxyaoy tba bjsg eay} ianhj}jo} y}j}wy ax ogsgx bjm `}% hw} ogsgx}bgegyy m`xgi}epvjx}`i`vj}g `o bay}`e`}`gy% njp hg xgcgxxgm }a jy wovx`s`egdgm ianhj}jo}y hgijwyg}bgp ma oa} bjsg }bg ianhj}jo}y vx`s`egdg }a iann`} ji}y ac bay}`e`}p ax jy woejtcweianhj}jo}y hgijwyg }bg`x ji}y ac bay}`e`}p jxg oa} vgxn`}}gm hp @BE/ ]bg y}j}wy acywib vgxyaoy bjy d`sgo x`yg }a iao}xasgxyp/

    Yang jxdwg }bj} }bgp nwy} vgxcaxig hg i`s`e`joy/ ]b`y jxdwngo} `y hjygm ao }bg eg}}gxac @BE }xgj}`gy/ @o }bg iaomwi} ac bay}`e`}`gy% Jx}/ 76":) ac Vxa}aiae @ mgogy i`s`e`joyjy jee }bayg tba jxg oa} xgcgxxgm }a `o Jx}`ieg ="J)":)% "8)% "9) jom "3) ac }bg ]b`xmIaosgo}`ao jom o Jx}`ieg =9 ac }b`y Vxa}aiae/ Aoig }bgp bjsg cjeego o}a gognp bjomy%

    Jx}/ = ac Iaosgo}`ao @S mgogy jy vxa}gi}gm i`s`e`joy jee }bayg tba cwee }bg oj}`aoje`}pxgzw`xgngo}y jom jxg oa} vxa}gi}gm hp Iaosgo}`ao @@@/ ]b`y tawem ngjo }bj} jopgognp tba `y oa} vxa}gi}gm hp Iaosgo}`ao @@@ cjeey womgx Iaosgo}`ao @S/

    ]bayg tba avvayg }bj} s`gt jxdwg }bj} j vgxyao tba magy oa} cwee }bg xgzw`xgngo}ycax ianhj}jo} y}j}wy `y jo woejtcwe ianhj}jo} jom hgeaody }a j }b`xm ij}gdaxp/E`lg ejtcwe ianhj}jo}y% `} `y iej`ngm% ywib woejtcwe ianhj}jo}y njp hg j}}jilgm

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    88/400

    8 Ianhj}jo}y jom Vx`yaogxy ac Tjx

    wo}`e }bgp ywxxgomgx ax jxg a}bgxt`yg baxy mg ianhj} jom njp hg mg}j`ogm t`}baw}kwm`i`je mgi`y`ao/ ]bg ead`i ac }b`y jxdwngo} `y }bj} }bayg tba ma oa} ianvep t`}b }bgiaom`}`aoy yg} cax j y}j}wy ybawem oa} hg vx`s`egdgm ianvjxgm }a }bayg tba ma/

    ]bayg tba `oy`y} ao }bg ianvegngo}jx`}p jom griewy`s`}p ac ianhj}jo} jom i`s`e`joy}j}wy xgvep }bj} ejtcwe ianhj}jo}y ijo hg gjy`ep `mgo}`gm% hjygm ao ahkgi}`sgix`}gx`j% tb`ib }bgp t`ee oaxnjeep oa} mgop "`/g/ ngnhgxyb`v `o }bg jxngm caxigy ac jvjx}p }a jo o}gxoj}`aoje jxngm iao`i})% tb`eg }bg ngnhgxyb`v jom vjy} hgbjs`awx acwovx`s`egdgm ianhj}jo}y jom }bg cw}wxg }bxgj} }bgp xgvxgygo} ijo aoep hg mg}gxn`ogm`om`s`mwjeep/ Jy i`s`e`joy% wovx`s`egdgm ianhj}jo}y njp hg j}}jilgm tb`eg }bgpwoejtcweep m`xgi}ep vjx}`i`vj}g `o bay}`e`}`gy/ @c }bgp cjee `o}a }bg vatgx ac }bg gognp%Iaosgo}`ao @S magy oa} hjx }bg`x vwo`ybngo} cax woejtcwe vjx}`i`vj}`ao `o bay}`e`}`gy/@o jmm`}`ao% `} vgxn`}y jmn`o`y}xj}`sg mg}go}`ao cax `nvgxj}`sg ygiwx`}p xgjyaoy/ Cxanj }gegaead`ije vgxyvgi}`sg% `} `y cgjxgm }bj} }bg iaoigv} ac woejtcwe ianhj}jo}y%mgo`gm }bg vxa}gi}`ao ac Iaosgo}`ao @S% iawem iaoy}`}w}g jo gjyp gyijvg ij}gdaxp caxmg}j`o`od vatgxy% jy }bg Dgogsj Iaosgo}`aoy iao}j`o oa xweg jhaw} }bg }xgj}ngo} acyangaog tba `y og`}bgx j ianhj}jo} oax j i`s`e`jo "ygg% batgsgx% V @% Jx}/ 47)/

    Maiwngo} Oa/ 7:% @IXI% @o}gxvxg}j}`sg Dw`mjoig ao }bg Oa}`ao a M`xgi}Vjx}`i`vj}`ao `o Bay}`e`}`gy

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; B@ODAXJO@ Xwv I/% Vx`yaogxy ac Tjx% Ogt Paxl% Aigjoj Vwhe`ij}`aoy% 8om gm/%:028% 9:7 vv/ EGS@G Batjxm Y/ "gm/)% Vx`yaogxy ac Tjx `o @o}gxoj}`aoje Jxngm Iao`i}% `o @o}gxoj}`aojeEjt Y}wm`gy% WY Ojsje Tjx Iaeegdg% Sae/ 70% :042% 780 vv/ EGS@G Batjxm Y/ "gm/)% Maiwngo}y ao Vx`yaogxyac Tjx% o @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt Y}wm`gy% WY Ojsje Tjx Iaeegdg% Sae/ 36% :040% 279 vv/ XAYJY Jeejo% ]bg EgdjeY}j}wy ac Vx`yaogxy ac Tjx; J Y}wmp ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt Jvve`ijheg `o Jxngm Iao`i}y %Bgey`ol`% Ywanjej`ogo ]`gmgjlj}gn`j% :043% 789 vv/

    @/ TBA@YJIANHJ]JO]1

    @o}xamwi}axp }gr}

    J ianhj}jo} `y g`}bgx;

    j ngnhgx ac }bg jxngm caxigy y}x`i}a ygoyw ac j vjx}p }a jo `o}gxoj}`aoje jxngmiao`i}; \0=^

    xgyvgi}`od }bg ahe`dj}`ao }a m`y}`odw`yb b`nygec!bgxygec cxan }bg i`s`e`jovavwej}`ao

    0= Ygg DI @@@% Jx}/ ="J)":) j

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    89/400

    Vjx} @ Ibjv}gx 3 9

    ax

    j ngnhgx ac joa}bgx jxngm dxawv; \07^

    hgeaod`od }a j vjx}p }a }bg `o}gxoj}`aoje jxngm iao`i}% cweee`od% jy j dxawv% }bg caeeat`od iaom`}`aoy;

    . avgxj}`od womgx xgyvaoy`heg iannjom

    . tgjx`od j rgm m`y}`oi}`sg y`do

    . ijxxp`od jxny avgoep

    . xgyvgi}`od @BE

    jom

    `om`s`mwjeep xgyvgi}`od }bg ahe`dj}`ao }a m`y}`odw`yb b`nygec!bgxygec cxan }bgi`s`e`jo vavwej}`ao

    ax

    j ngnhgx ac joa}bgx jxngm dxawv\03^ tba `y;

    womgx j iannjom xgyvaoy`heg }a j vjx}p }a }bg `o}gxoj}`aoje jxngm iao`i}jom

    ywhkgi} }a jo `o}gxoje m`yi`ve`ojxp ypy}gn%

    ao iaom`}`ao }bj} bg!ybg xgyvgi}y% om`s`mwjeep% j} }bg }`ng ac b`y!bgx ijv}wxg \04^}bg ahe`dj}`ao }a m`y}`odw`yb b`nygec!bgxygec cxan }bg i`s`e`jo vavwej}`ao; \02^

    . wywjeep% tb`eg godjdgm `o jo j}}jil ax j n`e`}jxp avgxj}`ao vxgvjxj}axp }ajo j}}jil% hp j iegjxep s`y`heg `}gn ac iea}b`od oao.aiiwv`gm)

    }gxx`}axp

    hh) Ygi}`ao @@@; xwegy jvve`ijheg }a aiiwv`gm }gxx`}axp

    ii) Ygi}`ao @; xwegy iannao }a }bg gognpy ato jom aiiwv`gm }gxx`}ax`gy

    mm) Ygi}`ao @S; xwegy vxa}gi}`od i`s`e`jo `o}gxoggy `o }bg gognpy ato jomaiiwv`gm }gxx`}ax`gy

    8/ Xwegy hgog}`od jee i`s`e`joy

    j) j`m jom xge`g"Ygg `ocxj% Vjx} @% Ibjv}gx 0/ @S/ @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt jom Bwnjo`}jx`jo Jyy`y}joig)

    h) yvgi`je vxa}gi}`ao a tangoDI @.@@% Jx}/ :8< DI @@@% Jx}y :=% 87% 22% 04 jom :62< DI @S% Jx}y :=% :3% 8:.84% 92% 76% 43% 27% 20% 0:% 04% :8=% :84 jom :98< V @%Jx}y 46 jom 47.43< V @@% Jx}y 7"8) jom 3"=) \I@BE% Xweg :9=^

    @BE xy} vxa}gi}y tango `c }bgp jxg tawomgm% y`il ax yb`vtxgilgm% jy i`s`e`joy% jy

    ngnhgxy ac }bg i`s`e`jo vavwej}`ao ax jy ianhj}jo}y% jiiaxm`od }a }bg`x y}j}wy/ Jyywib% tango nwy} hgog} cxan }bg yjng vxa}gi}`ao jy }bj} d`sgo }a ngo jom njpoa} hg m`yix`n`oj}gm jdj`oy}/ \:==^ Batgsgx% @BE jeya }jlgy `o}a jiiawo} }bg cji} }bj}tango jxg naxg sweogxjheg% jom d`sgy }bgn vxgcgxgo}`je }xgj}ngo} o yang vjx}`iwejx

    :== DI @.@S% iannao Jx}/ 9< DI @.@@% Jx}/ :8< DI @@@% Jx}/:3< DI @S% Jx}y :9 jom 84"9)

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    122/400

    = ]bg Vxa}gi}`ao ac I`s`e`joy

    ijygy/ C`xy}% tango jxg yvgi`jeep vxa}gi}gm jdj`oy} jop j}}jil ao }bg`x ygrwje o}gdx`}p%`o vjx}`iwejx jdj`oy} xjvg% gocaxigm vxay}`}w}`ao ax jop caxn ac `omgigo} jyyjwe}/ \:=7^]bg @o}gxoj}`aoje Ix`n`oje ]x`hwoje cax Xtjomj "@I]X) jom }bg @o}gxoj}`aoje Ix`n`oje

    Iawx} "@II) bjsg `oiewmgm xjvg jom a}bgx caxny ac ygrwje s`aegoig `o }bg`x e`y} actjx ix`ngy%\:=3^ jom je}bawdb }bg Y}j}w}g ac }bg @o}gxoj}`aoje Ix`n`oje ]x`hwoje cax}bg caxngx Pwdayejs`j "@I]P) magy oa} grve`i`}ep ngo}`ao xjvg jy j tjx ix`ng% j ]x`jeIbjnhgx ogsgx}bgegyy xgiado`{gm `} jy j dxjsg hxgjib ac }bg Dgogsj Iaosgo}`aoy/\:=4^

    Naxgasgx% @BE yvgi`jeep vxa}gi}y vxgdojo} tango jom nj}gxo`}p ijygy jdj`oy} }bggccgi}y ac tjx% \:=2^ jom y}`vwej}gy }bj}% mwx`od aiiwvj}`ao% ywib vxgcgxgo}`je }xgj}ngo}`y oa} }a hg b`omgxgm hp }bg aiiwvp`od vatgx/\:=0^

    C`ojeep% cgnjeg vx`yaogxy ac tjx ax cgnjeg i`s`e`jo `o}gxoggy jeya hgog} cxan yvgi`i

    xwegy/\:76^ Bgxg jdj`o% @BE yggly }a vxa}gi} tangoy ygrwje `o}gdx`}p \:7:^ jom }a goywxg}bj} mwg j}}go}`ao y vj`m }a vxgdojo} jom owxy`od na}bgxy% \:78^ tb`eg vxgsgo}`od Y}j}gycxan m`yix`n`oj}`od jdj`oy} tango hgeaod`od }a }bg gognp vjx}p/ \:79^

    ]bg yvgi`je vxa}gi}`ao jccaxmgm }a tango `o }`ng ac tjx jom }bg vxab`h`}`ao ac xjvgjom a}bgx caxny ac ygrwje s`aegoig tgxg ha}b xgigo}ep xgiado`{gm jy bjs`od j}}j`ogmiwy}anjxp y}j}wy/\:7=^

    Ijyg Oa/ ::8% @IXI Xgvax} ao Pgngo% :034 Ijyg Oa/ 862% Dgxnjop% Dasgxongo} Xgvep ao Xjvgy `o Hayo`j Ijyg Oa/ 8:4% @I]P% ]bg Vxaygiw}ax s/ Lwojxji% Lasji jom Swlas`i \Vjxjy :84.:23^

    Ijyg Oa/ 87:% Jcdbjo`y}jo% Ygvjxj}g Bayv`}je ]xgj}ngo} cax Ngo jom Tango Ijyg Oa/ 846% @om`j% Vxgyy xgegjyg% S`aegoig `o Ljybn`x

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; IJXVGO]GX Ibjxe` X/% @ooaigo} Tango jom Ib`emxgo; Dgomgx% Oaxny jom }bgVxa}gi}`ao ac I`s`e`joy% Bjnvyb`xg "Godejom)% Hwxe`od}ao "WYJ)% Jybdj}g% 8663% 8:4 vv/ LX@EE Cxjoa`yg%]bg Vxa}gi}`ao ac Tango `o @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% `o @XXI% Oa/ 8=0% Oasgnhgx :027%vv/ 994.939/ E@OMYGP Ibjxea}}g% Tango jom Tjx% `o @XXI% Oa/ 290% Ygv}gnhgx 8666% vv/ 73:.726/

    OWNN@OGO Kw}}j% S`aegoig edjxm mgy cgnngy go y`}wj}`ao mg iao`} jxn ; jojepyg gccgi}wg ygeaoeg va`o} mg swg cn`o`o ywx ej vxa}gi}`ao mg ej cgnng mjoy eg mxa`} `o}gxoj}`aoje bwnjo`}j`xg% `o ]bgC`oo`yb Pgjxhaal ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% Sae/ 0% :002% vv/ =79.=49/

    :=7 DI @S% Jx}/ 84

    :=3 @I]X Y}j}w}g% Jx}/ ="g) \YggIjyg Oa/ 896% WO% Y}j}w}g ac }bg @I]X^< @II Y}j}w}g% Jx}/ 2"8)"h)"rr``) \YggIjyg Oa/ 89% ]bg @o}gxoj}`aoje Ix`n`ojeIawx}^/

    :=4 ]bg ]x`je Ibjnhgx `o }bg Igegh`i` ijyg mgiejxgm }bj} xjvg iawem iaoy}`}w}g }ax}wxg% }bwy jnawo}`od }a j dxjsg hxgjib ac }bg Dgogsj

    Iaosgo}`aoy/Ygg @I]P% ]bg Vxaygiw}ax s/ Mgeje`i g} je/% vjxjy =47 cc/ Xjvg tjy jeya iaomgnogm hp }bg @I]P jy j ix`ng jdj`oy} bwnjo`}p/ \YggIjyg Oa/ 8:4% @I]P% Lwojxji% Lasji jom Swlas`i% vjxjy :84.:23^

    :=2 DI @S% Jx}y :=% :3% 8: jom 88

    :=0 DI @S% Jx}/ 76

    :76 Ygg% cax `oy}joig% V @% Jx}/ 43"8)

    :7: Ygg% cax `oy}joig% DI @@@% Jx}y 87% 04 jom :62< DI @S% Jx}y 43% 27% ::0 jom :8=

    :78 Ygg% cax `oy}joig% DI @S% Jx}y 20 jom :98< V @% Jx}/ 43"9)< V @@% Jx}/ 3"=)

    :79 DI @@@% Jx}/ 22

    :7= YggIjyg Oa/ =9% @IXI% Iwy}anjxp @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt \Vjx} I/% Xwegy :9= jom 09^

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    123/400

    Vjx} @ Ibjv}gx 2 7

    CWX]BGX XGJM@OD; HJXXAT Jnp% WO Ygiwx`}p Iawoi`e Xgyaew}`aoy :987 jom :286; Iaoy}xwi}`odDgomgx `o Jxngm Iao`i} jom @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% `o @XXI% Sae/ 08% Oa/ 244% Njxib 86:6%vv/ 88:.89=/ HGOOAWOG Ljx`nj% Ma Tg Oggm @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt }a Vxa}gi} Tango o Jxngm Iao`i}1%

    `o Ijyg Tgy}gxo Xgygxsg Kawxoje ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% Oa/ 92% 8663% vv/ 939.90:/ MWXBJN Bgego #AHPXOG Lj}`g% ]bg M`jeadwg ac M`ccgxgoig; Dgomgx Vgxyvgi}`sgy ao @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt%`o @XXI% Sae/ 08% Oa/ 244% Njxib 86:6% vv/ 9:.78/

    jj) }bg cgn`o`y} ix }`i`yn ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt

    ]bg sgxp cji} }bj} @BE yggly }a vxa}gi} tangoy baoawx jom dxjo}y yvgi`je vxa}gi}`ao}a grvgi}jo} jom owxy`od na}bgxy bjy d`sgo x`yg }a nwib ix`}`i`yn cxan cgn`o`y}}bgax`y}y/ \:77^ ]bgp jxdwg }bj} @BE `y `obgxgo}ep m`yix`n`oj}axp jom yangtbj} aem.cjyb`aogm `o }bj} `} nay}ep iaoy`mgxy tango jy s`i}`ny jom ngo jy ianhj}jo}y/ J}}bg yjng }`ng% }bgp iao}gom }bj} }bg xwegy ao tango jxg eat mato `o }bg b`gxjxibpac @BE xwegy; cax `oy}joig% vxas`y`aoy ao tango j`n j} goywx`od vxa}gi}`ao xj}bgx}bjo `nvay`od y}x`i} vxab`h`}`aoy% jom xjvg `y oa} gsgo `oiewmgm `o }bg e`y} ac dxjsghxgjibgy/\:73^

    Batgsgx% jy ngo}`aogm jhasg% }bg oa}`ao ac xjvg% jom }bg hxajmgx ij}gdaxp ac

    ygrwje s`aegoig% bjy gsaesgm `o `o}gxoj}`aoje ix`n`oje ejt jom ywib ji}y jxg oat ac}go

    vxaygiw}gm jy dxjsg hxgjibgy/ Naxgasgx% }bg ejodwjdg wygm `o @BE }gr}y njp hg

    aw}mj}gm% hw} }bg xwegy ao }bg vxa}gi}`ao ac tango ybawem hg xgjm jom jmjv}gm o }bg

    e`db} ac }bg`x iao}gnvaxjxp ngjo`od/ @o awx s`gt% }bg nj`o vxahegn y oa} }bj} }bg }gr}yjxg oywci`go}% hw} }bj} o }b`y gem% jy o a}bgxy% }bg xwegy jxg oa} ywci`go}ep xgyvgi}gm/

    Zwa}j}`ao @BE o jmmxgyy`od bwnjo`}jx`jo oggmy o jxngm iaoc`i} jyywngy j vavwej}`ao

    `o tb`ib }bgxg `y oa ypy}gn`i dgomgx `ogzwje`}p/ ]bg ypy}gn j`ey }a xgiado`{g }bg wogzwje

    y`}wj}`ao a ngo jom tango `o yai`g}p dgogxjeep/

    \Yawxig; DJXMJN Kwm`}b # KJXS@Y N`ibgeeg K/% Tango% Jxngm Iao`i} jom @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% ]bg Bjdwg%Lewtgx Ejt @o}gxoj}`aoje% 866:% v/ 04< zwa}gm `o MWXBJN Bgego Tango% Jxngm Iao`i} jom @o}gxoj}`aojeEjt% `o @XXI% Oa/ 2=4% Ygv}gnhgx 8668% v/ 374^

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; IBJXEGYTAX]B B`ejxp% Cgn`o`y} Ng}bamy o @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% Ypnvay`wnao Ng}bam `o @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% `o JK@E% Sae/ 09% :000% vv/ 940.90=/ IB@OL@O Ibx`y}`og% J DgomgxgmVgxyvgi}`sg }a }bg @o}gxoj}`aoje Wyg ac Caxig% oJP@E% :022.:020% vv/ 840.809/ DJXMJN Kwm`}b% Tango%Bwnjo X`db}y jom @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% `o @XXI% Oa/ 98=% Ygv}gnhgx :002% vv/ =8:.=98/DJXMJN Kwm`}b% Tango jom }bg Ejt ac Jxngm Iao`i}; Tbp }bg Y`egoig1% `o @IEZ% Sae/ =3% :004%vv/ 77.26/ DJXMJN Kwm`}b # IBJXEGYTAX]B B`ejxp% Vxa}gi}`ao ac Tango `o Jxngm Iao`i}% `oBwnjo X`db}y Zwjx}gxep% Sae/ 88!:% Cghxwjxp 8666% vv/ :=2.:33/

    CWX]BGX XGJM@OD; MWXBJN Bgego% Tango% Jxngm Iao`i}% jom @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% `o @XXI%Oa/ 2=4% Ygv}gnhgx 8668% vv/ 377.370/ DJXMJN Kwm`}b # KJXS@Y N`ibgeeg K/% Tango%Jxngm Iao`i} jom@o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% ]bg Bjdwg% Lewtgx Ejt @o}gxoj}`aoje% 866:% 829 vv/

    :77 @o dgogxje% ygg Kwm`}b Djxmjn # N`ibgeeg K/ Kjxs`y% Tango% Jxngm Iao`i} jom @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% ]bg Bjdwg% Lewtgx Ejt @o}gxoj}`aoje% 866:%829 vv/

    :73 DI @.@S% Jx}y 76!7:!:96!:=4 xgyvgi}`sgep< V @% Jx}/ 27

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    124/400

    3 ]bg Vxa}gi}`ao ac I`s`e`joy

    hh) }bg vx`oi`vegy ac oao.m`yix`n`oj}`ao jom yvgi`je vxa}gi}`ao

    Zwa}j}`ao Gsgx y`oig `}y `oigv}`ao% `o}gxoj}`aoje bwnjo`}jx`jo ejt bjy jiiaxmgm tangodgogxje vxa}gi}`ao gzwje }a }bj} a ngo/ \///^ Tango tba bjsg }jlgo jo ji}`sg vjx} o bay}`e`}`gy

    jy ianhj}jo}y jxg go}`}egm }a }bg yjng vxa}gi}`ao jy ngo tbgo }bgp bjsg jeego `o}a gognp

    bjomy/ \///^ Hgy`mgy }b`y dgogxje vxa}gi}`ao% tango jxg jeya jaxmgm yvgi`je vxa}gi}`ao hjygm

    ao }bg vx`oi`veg aw}e`ogm `o Jx}`ieg :=% vjxjdxjvb 8 \a Dgogsj Iaosgo}`ao @@@^% }bj} tango

    ybjee hg }xgj}gm t`}b jee }bg xgdjxm mwg }a }bg`x ygr/ ]b`y vx`oi`veg `y aeeatgm }bxawdb `o

    j ownhgx a vxas`y`aoy tb`ib grvxgyyep xggx }a }bg iaom`}`aoy a mg}go}`ao ax tango `o

    VAT ijnvy \///^/ Tango "jom ngo) tba% jy ngnhgxy a }bg i`s`e`jo vavwej}`ao% jxg }jl`od oa

    ji}`sg vjx} o bay}`e`}`gy jxg jaxmgm vxa}gi}`ao womgx }bg Cawx}b Dgogsj Iaosgo}`ao \///^ jom

    womgx Jmm`}`aoje Vxa}aiae @/ \///^ @o jmm`}`ao }a }b`y dgogxje vxa}gi}`ao% tango jxg jaxmgm

    yvgi`je vxa}gi}`ao womgx }bg yj`m Iaosgo}`ao jom Vxa}aiae @% tb`ib y}`vwej}g }bj} tangoybjee hg gyvgi`jeep vxa}gi}gm jdj`oy} jop j}}jil ao }bg`x baoawx% `o vjx}`iwejx jdj`oy} xjvg%

    goaxigm vxay}`}w}`ao ax jop axn a `omgigo} jyyjwe}/ @o}gxoj}`aoje bwnjo`}jx`jo ejt jeya

    ejpy mato yvgi`je vxas`y`aoy ax vxgdojo} tango jom na}bgxy a ynjee ib`emxgo \///^/

    \Yawxig;E@OMYGP Ibjxea}}g% Tango jom Tjx% o @XXI% Oa/ 290% Ygv}gnhgx 8666% v/ 726^

    ii) vxa}gi}`ao jdj`oy} xjvg jom ygrwje s`aegoig

    Ijyg Oa/ :3=% Ywmjo% Xgvax} ac }bg WO Iann`yy`ao ac Gozw`xp ao Mjxcwx

    \Vjxjy 999.972^ Ijyg Oa/ 880% Mgnaixj}`i Xgvwhe`i ac }bg Iaoda% Iao`i} `o }bg L`swy \Vjx} @@@% vjxjy :3%

    97.94^ Ijyg Oa/ 806% Dgaxd`j!Xwyy`j% Bwnjo X`db}y Tj}iby Xgvax} ao }bg Iao`i} `o Yaw}b

    Ayyg}`j \Vjxjy 24.20^

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; JO]AO@AO@ Jo}ao`a% Eg s`ae g} eg mxa`} mg ej dwgxxg mjoy ej mai}x`og% `o Kawxoje ac }bg B`y}axp ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% Sae/ =!:% 8668% vv/ :66.::=/ IB@OL@O Ibx`y}`og% Xjvg jomYgrwje Jhwyg ac Tango `o @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% `o GK@E% Sae/ 7!9% :00=% vv/ 983.9=:/ IAVGEAO Xbaomj%

    Dgomgx Ix`ngy jy Tjx Ix`ngy; @o}gdxj}`od Ix`ngy Jdj`oy} Tango `o}a @o}gxoj}`aoje Ix`n`oje Ejt%`oNiD`ee Ejt Kawxoje% Sae/ =3!:% 8666% vv/ 8:4.8=6/ M@RAO Xayje`om% Xjvg jy j Ix`ng `o @o}gxoj}`aojeBwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt; Tbgxg }a Cxan Bgxg1% `oGK@E% Sae/ :9!9% Kwog 8668% vv/ 304.4:0/ DWGO@SG] Ljx`nj%S`aegoigy ygrwgeegy ; ej oawsgeeg jxng mg dwgxxg% Vjx`y% N`ibjeao% 866:% 863 vv/ @YEJN Xjzwe% ]bgIwevjh`e`}p ac Dgomgx.Hjygm ]gxxax`yn `o @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt; }bg Xjvg ac Tango `oJxngm Iao`i}y% `o @Y@E Pgjxhaal ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo jom Xgcwdgg Ejt % Sae/ 3% 8663%vv/ 24.:67/ LGOOGMP.V@VG Ijxae`og # VGOOP Y}joegp% Xjvg `o Tjx; Egyyaoy ac }bg Hjeljo Iao`i}y `o}bg :006y% o @o}gxoj}`aoje Kawxoje ac Bwnjo X`db}y% Sae/ =!9.=% 8666% vv/ 34.2=/ NGXAO ]bgamax% Xjvg jyj Ix`ng womgx @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% `oJK@E% Sae/ 24!9 :009% vv/ =8=.=82/ NAXX@Y Njmge`og%

    Hp Caxig ac Jxny; Xjvg% Tjx jom N`e`}jxp Iwe}wxg% `o Mwlg Ejt Kawxoje% Sae/ =7!=% :003% vv/ 37:.42:/O@JXIBAY Ij}bgx`og O/% Tango% Tjx% jom Xjvg; Ibjeegodgy Cji`od }bg @o}gxoj}`aoje ]x`hwoje cax }bgCaxngx Pwdayejs`j% o Bwnjo X`db}y Zwjx}gxep% Sae/ :4!=% :007% vv/ 3=0.306/ VJVJIAOY]JO]@OAW Njx`j%Xjvg jy Ix`ng womgx @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% `o Xgswg Bgeeo`zwg mg Mxa`} @o}gxoj}`aoje%Sae/ 7:!8% :002% vv/ =44.=00/ V@EIB Cxjoigy ]/% ]bg Ix`ng ac Xjvg `o @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt%`oKawxoje ac Egdje Y}wm`gy% Sae/ 0% :002.00% vv/ 00.::0/ ZWGO@SG] Oaeeg O/X/% Ygrwje Accgoygy `o JxngmIao`i} jom @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% Jxmyegp% ]xjoyoj}`aoje Vwhe`ybgxy% 8667% 896 vv/

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    125/400

    Vjx} @ Ibjv}gx 2 4

    CWX]BGX XGJM@OD; JYL@O Lgeep Mjto% Ygrwje S`aegoig `o Mgi`y`aoy jom @om`i}ngo}y ac }bg Pwdayejsjom Xtjomjo ]x`hwoje; Iwxxgo} Y}j}wy% `o JK@E% Sae/ 09!:% :000% vv/ 04.:89/ MPJO@ O}anh`{a{wla%Vxa}aiae ao }bg X`db}y ac Tango `o Jcx`ij; Vxa}gi}`ao ac Tango cxan Ygrwje S`aegoig mwx`od Jxngm

    Iao`i}% `oJcx`ijo Bwnjo X`db}y Ejt Kawxoje% Sae/ 3% Oa/ :% 8663% vv/ :33.:24/ CEAXGY JIWOJ ]j}b`joj%]bg Xang Y}j}w}gy Ygrwje Xgej}gm Ix`ngy; jo Jvvxj`yje womgx }bg E`db} ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`joEjt% `o Bwnjo`}xgy Selgxxgib}% Sae/ :0% Oa/ :% 8663% vv/ 90.7:/ EJS@AEG]]G O`iaeg% Iannjom`odXjvg; Ygrwje S`aegoig% Iannjom Xgyvaoy`h`e`}p% jom }bg Vxaygiw}`ao ac Ywvgx`axy hp }bg @o}gxoj}`aojeIx`n`oje ]x`hwojey cax }bg caxngx Pwdayejs`j jom Xtjomj% `o IP@E% Sae/ 93% :002% vv/ 09.:=0/ EGT@YMwy}`o J/% Woxgiado`{gm S`i}`ny; Ygrwje S`aegoig jdj`oy} Ngo `o Iao`i} Yg}}`ody womgx @o}gxoj}`aojeEjt% T`yiaoy`o @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt Kawxoje% Sae/ 84% Oa/ :% 8660% vv/ :.=0/ X@IBGP Lj}`g I/% Ygsgxje Y}gvyY`mgtjpy; @o}gxoj}`aoje Egdje Mgsgeavngo}y Iaoigxo`od Tjx Xjvg jom }bg Bwnjo X`db}y ac Tango% `o]grjy Kawxoje ac Tango jom }bg Ejt% Sae/ :4% Oa/ :% 8664% vv/ :60.:80/ Y@SJLWNJXJO Yjomgyb% YgrwjeS`aegoig jdj`oy} Ngo `o Jxngm Iao`i}%GK@E% Sae/ :2% Oa/ 8% Jvx`e 8664% vv/ 879.843/ Y@SJLWNJXJOYjomgyb% Eay} `o ]xjoyej}`ao; WO Xgyvaoygy }a Ygrwje S`aegoig jdj`oy} Ngo jom Hapy `o Y`}wj}`aoyac Jxngm Iao`i}% `o @XXI% Sae/ 08% Oa/ 244% Njxib 86:6% vv/ 870.844/ SJO MGX VAEE Eg}g}`j% ]bgGngxd`od Kwx`yvxwmgoig ao Ygrwje S`aegoig Vgxvg}xj}gm jdj`oy} Tango mwx`od Jxngm Iao`i}% `o

    Jcx`ijo Pgjxhaal ao @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% 8664% vv/ :.92/ [JTJ]@ B`en` N/% @nvwo`}p ax@nnwo`}p; Tjx}`ng Njeg Xjvg jom Ygrwje ]ax}wxg jy j Ix`ng jdj`oy} Bwnjo`}p% `o ]ax}wxg; Kawxoje aoXgbjh`e`}j}`ao ac ]ax}wxg S`i}`ny jom Vxgsgo}`ao ac ]ax}wxg% Sae/ :4% Oa/ :% 8664% vv/ 84.=4/

    mm) dxawomy cax vxgcgxgo}`je }xgj}ngo} vxgdojo} tango ax nj}gxo`}p ijygy

    na}bgxy ac ib`emxgo womgx ygsgo pgjxy ac jdg

    i) yvgi`je vxa}gi}`ao a ib`emxgoDI @S% Jx}y :=% :4% 89% 8=% 92% 76% 43% 28% 20% 0= jom :98< V @% Jx}y 46 jom 44.42< V @@% Jx}/ = \I@BE% Xwegy :97.:94^

    E`lg tango% ib`emxgo jxg xy} vxa}gi}gm hp @BE c }bgp jxg tawomgm% y`il ax yb`vtxgilgm%jy i`s`e`joy jom jy ngnhgxy ac }bg i`s`e`jo vavwej}`ao/ ]bgp jeya hgog} cxan yvgi`jevxa}gi}`ao hgijwyg ac }bg`x sweogxjh`e`}p/ Gsgxp jxngm iao`i} egjsgy owngxawyib`emxgo t`}baw} xgyawxigy ax ygvjxj}gm cxan }bg`x cjn`e`gy% j y`}wj}`ao }bj} xgomgxy}bgn gsgo naxg sweogxjheg/ ]b`y y tbp @BE iao}j`oy yvgi`i xwegy j`ngm j} vxa}gi}`od

    ib`emxgo cxan }bg gccgi}y ac bay}`e`}`gy% cxan jop caxn ac `omgigo} jyyjwe}% ax cxan jopa}bgx mjodgx jx`y`od cxan }bg dgogxje i`xiwny}joigy ac j tjx y`}wj}`ao/ \:74^

    Hw} jhasg jee% @BE j`ny }a vxgsgo} }bg vjx}`i`vj}`ao ac ib`emxgo `o bay}`e`}`gy/ Vjx}`gy }a

    iao`i}y njp oa} xgixw`} ib`emxgo womgx :7 `o}a }bg`x jxngm caxigy jom bjsg }a goywxg

    }bj} }bgp ma oa} }jlg j m`xgi} vjx} `o bay}`e`}`gy/\:72^ @o Vxa}aiaey @ jom @@ jom `o Jx}/ 92 ac

    }bg Iaosgo}`ao ao }bg X`db}y ac }bg Ib`em% }bg jdg }bxgybaem y :7< }bg Av}`aoje Vxa}aiae

    }a }bg Iaosgo}`ao ao }bg X`db}y ac }bg Ib`em ao }bg `osaesgngo} ac ib`emxgo `o jxngm

    iao`i}\:70^ xj`ygy } }a :2% grigv} }bj} Y}j}gy njp jiigv} saewo}jxp goxaengo} ac vgxyaoy

    womgx :2 `o}a n`e`}jxp yibaaey% }bwy gy}jhe`yb`od jo `ogzwje`}p hg}tggo dasgxongo}jecaxigy jom oao.Y}j}g jxngm dxawvy/ @c ib`emxgo ogsgx}bgegyy vjx}`i`vj}g `o bay}`e`}`gy%

    }bgp t`ee y}`ee hgog}% `c ijv}wxgm% cxan vxgcgxgo}`je }xgj}ngo}/ \:36^ @c }bgp jxg% mgyv`}g

    :74 Ygg% cax grjnveg% DI @S% Jx}y :=% :4% 89% 8=% 92"7)% 76% 7:% 32% 43% 28% 20% 0= jom :98< V @% Jx}y 46% 44 jom 42< V @@% Jx}/ ="9)"g)

    :72 V @% Jx}/ 44"8)< V @@% Jx}/ ="9)"i)

    :70 YggMaiwngo} Oa/ 8=% Av}`aoje Vxa}aiae ao }bg Iaosgo}`ao ao }bg X`db}y ac }bg Ib`em% ao }bg @osaesgngo} ac Ib`emxgo `o Jxngm Iao`i}

    :36 V @% Jx}/ 44

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    126/400

    2 ]bg Vxa}gi}`ao ac I`s`e`joy

    }bg jhasg.ngo}`aogm vxab`h`}`aoy% ngnhgxy ac jxngm caxigy% }bgp hgog} cxan

    ianhj}jo} jom vx`yaogx.ac.tjx y}j}wy/

    ]bg iao}go}y ac }bg yvgi`je vxa}gi}`ao jccaxmgm }a ib`emxgo nwy} ogsgx}bgegyy hgiaoy}xwgm t`}b ijxg/ Cax `oy}joig% jy }bg }xgj}p xwegy vxgsgo} }bg m`xgi} `osaesgngo}ac ib`emxgo `o bay}`e`}`gy% axdjo`{j}`aoy taxl`od `o }bg gem ac ib`emxgoy x`db}y jomyang yac} ejt `oy}xwngo}y ywddgy} }bj} }bg vxab`h`}`ao "ax gsgo }bg oa}`ao ac m`xgi}vjx}`i`vj}`ao) hg gr}gomgm }a }bg ijyg ac ib`emxgo jyyai`j}gm t`}b jxngm dxawvy%`o axmgx }a goywxg }bj} ib`emxgo jxg lgv} jtjp cxan jee yax}y ac `osaesgngo}/ ]b`yn`db} oa} hg xgje`y}`i `o }bg ijyg ac `oywxdgo} dxawvy jom n`db} j} }bg yjng }`ngnjlg `} gjy`gx cax }bg gognp }a m`xgi}ep }jxdg} vjx}`i`vj}`od ib`emxgo% }bwy vw}}`odywib ib`emxgo `o dxgj}gx mjodgx/ J} }bg yjng }`ng% }bg ngxg cji} }bj} ib`emxgo iawemhg }jxdg}gm tbgo `osaesgm `o ianhj} dagy jdj`oy} }bg `mgj ac vxgcgxgo}`je }xgj}ngo}jccaxmgm }a ib`emxgo/ J yaew}`ao tawem hg }a griewmg vjx}`i`vj}`od ib`emxgo cxan }bgij}gdaxp ac egd`}`nj}g }jxdg}y% hw} `} yggny woxgje`y}`i }a grvgi} }bg vjx}`gy }a xgcxj`ocxan }jxdg}`od ywib jxngm gogn`gy/ ]bg vx`oi`veg ac n`e`}jxp ogigyy`}p jy j xgy}x`i}`ao}a s`aegoig gsgo jdj`oy} egd`}`nj}g }jxdg}y ybawem j} egjy} `o }b`y ijyg xgzw`xg }bgn }ajxxgy} xj}bgx }bjo l`ee ywib ib`emxgo tbgogsgx vayy`heg/

    Zwa}j}`ao Jx}`ieg 92/

    :/ Y}j}gy Vjx}`gy womgx}jlg }a xgyvgi} jom }a goywxg xgyvgi} ax xwegy a @o}gxoj}`aoje

    Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt jvve`ijheg }a }bgn `o jxngm iaoc`i}y tb`ib jxg xgegsjo} }a }bg ib`em/

    8/ Y}j}gy Vjx}`gy ybjee }jlg jee gjy`heg ngjywxgy }a goywxg }bj} vgxyaoy tba bjsg oa}

    j}}j`ogm }bg jdg a }ggo pgjxy ma oa} }jlg j m`xgi} vjx} `o bay}`e`}`gy/

    9/ Y}j}gy Vjx}`gy ybjee xgxj`o xan xgixw`}`od jop vgxyao tba bjy oa} j}}j`ogm }bg jdg

    a }ggo pgjxy `o}a }bg`x jxngm axigy/ @o xgixw`}`od jnaod }bayg vgxyaoy tba bjsg

    j}}j`ogm }bg jdg a }ggo pgjxy hw} tba bjsg oa} j}}j`ogm }bg jdg a g`db}ggo pgjxy%

    Y}j}gy Vjx}`gy ybjee gomgjsax }a d`sg vx`ax`}p }a }bayg tba jxg aemgy}/

    =/ @o jiiaxmjoig t`}b }bg`x ahe`dj}`aoy womgx @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt }a vxa}gi}

    }bg i`s`e`jo vavwej}`ao `o jxngm iaoc`i}y% Y}j}gy Vjx}`gy ybjee }jlg jee gjy`heg ngjywxgy}a goywxg vxa}gi}`ao jom ijxg a ib`emxgo tba jxg jgi}gm hp jo jxngm iaoc`i}/

    \Yawxig; Iaosgo}`ao ao }bg X`db}y ac }bg Ib`em% Oasgnhgx 86% :020< jsj`ejheg ao b}}v;!!ttt/abibx/axd^

    Zwa}j}`ao 8 Iaosgo}`ao ":28) ao }bg Taxy} Caxny a Ib`em Ejhawx% :000/ \///^

    Jx}`ieg :

    Gjib Ngnhgx tb`ib xj}`gy }b`y Iaosgo}`ao ybjee }jlg `nngm`j}g jom ggi}`sg ngjywxgy

    }a ygiwxg }bg vxab`h`}`ao jom ge`n`oj}`ao a }bg taxy} axny a ib`em ejhawx jy j nj}}gx awxdgoip/

    Jx}`ieg 8

    Cax }bg vwxvaygy a }b`y Iaosgo}`ao% }bg }gxn ib`em ybjee jvvep }a jee vgxyaoy womgx }bg jdg

    a :2/

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    127/400

    Vjx} @ Ibjv}gx 2 0

    Jx}`ieg 9

    Cax }bg vwxvaygy a }b`y Iaosgo}`ao% }bg }gxn }bg taxy} axny a ib`em ejhawx ianvx`ygy;

    "j) jee axny a yejsgxp ax vxji}`igy y`n`ejx }a yejsgxp% ywib jy }bg yjeg jom }xjil`od aib`emxgo% mgh} haomjdg jom ygxman jom axigm ax ianvweyaxp ejhawx% `oiewm`od axigm

    ax ianvweyaxp xgixw`}ngo} a ib`emxgo ax wyg `o jxngm iaoc`i}< \///^

    \Yawxig;Iaosgo}`ao iaoigxo`od }bg Vxab`h`}`ao jom @nngm`j}g Ji}`ao cax }bg Ge`n`oj}`ao ac }bg Taxy} Caxny ac Ib`emEjhawx"I:28)% :4 Kwog :000< jsj`ejheg ao b}}v;!!ttt/`ea/ib^

    Maiwngo} Oa/ 8=% Av}`aoje Vxa}aiae ao }bg Iaosgo}`ao ao }bg X`db}y ac }bg Ib`em%ao }bg @osaesgngo} ac Ib`emxgo `o Jxngm Iao`i}

    Maiwngo} Oa/ 9=% @IXI% ]xji`od Ygxs`ig \8^ Ijyg Oa/ ::8% @IXI Xgvax} ao Pgngo% :034

    Ijyg Oa/ :3=% Ywmjo% Xgvax} ac }bg WO Iann`yy`ao ac Gozw`xp ao Mjxcwx \Vjxj/ =:2^ Ijyg Oa/ 843% Y`gxxj Egaog% Yvgi`je Iawx} Xwe`od ao }bg Xgixw`}ngo} ac Ib`emxgo

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; JHHA]] Jnp Hg}b% Ib`em Yaem`gxy ]bg Wyg ac Ib`emxgo jy @oy}xwngo}y acTjx% `o Ywccael ]xjoyoj}`aoje Ejt Xgs`gt% Sae/ 89!8% 8666% vv/ =00.794/ HAWS@GX Jo}a`og # MW]E@Njx`j ]gxgyj% Ib`emxgo `o Jxngm Iao`i}% `o ]bg @o}gxoj}`aoje Kawxoje ac Ib`emxgoy X`db}y% ]bg Bjdwg%Lewtgx Ejt @o}gxoj}`aoje% Sae/ =!8% :003% vv/ ::7.8:8/ HXGGO Iej`xg% Tbgo `y j Ib`em oa} j Ib`em1; Ib`emYaem`gxy `o @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% `o Bwnjo X`db}y Xgs`gt% Sae/ 2% Oa/ 8% Kjowjxp.Njxib 8664% vv/ 4:.:69/

    HXG]] Xjibge # NJIIJEE@O Njxdjxg}% Ib`emxgo; ]bg @os`y`heg Yaem`gxy% Xmmj Hjxogo "Ytgm`yb Yjsg}bg Ib`emxgo)% Y}ailbaen% :003% 874 vv/ HWDO@AO Cxjoa`y% Egy gocjo}y yaemj}y% eg mxa`} `o}gxoj}`aojebwnjo`}j`xg g} ej Ibjx}g jcx`ij`og mgy mxa`}y g} mw h go.}xg mg egocjo}% oJcx`ijo Kawxoje ac @o}gxoj}`aojejom Ianvjxj}`sg Ejt% Sae/ :8!8% 8666% vv/ 838.847/ IBJNHGXEJ@O Ipo}b`j% [email protected] LBGOB`eep # YIBJHJY T`ee`jn J/% Ib`emxgo jom Jxngm Iao`i}% o ZWGO@SG] Oaeeg # YBJB.MJS@Y Yb`ejo"gmy)% @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt jom Jxngm Iao`i}; Ibjeegodgy `o }bg 8: y}Igo}wxp% ]bg Bjdwg% ]/N/I/ Jyygx Vxgyy%86:6% vv/ 8=9.823/ IABO @egog # [email protected]@EE Dwp Y/% Ib`em Yaem`gxy/ ]bg Xaeg ac Ib`emxgo `o JxngmIao`i}y% Dgogsj!Arcaxm% Bgoxp.Mwojo} @oy}`}w}g!Iejxgomao Vxgyy% :00=% 882 vv/ IAEENGX Yjh`og%Ib`em Yaem`gxy; Jo @o}gdxje Gegngo} `o Ogt% @xxgdwejx Tjxy1% `o ]bg Zwjx}gxep Kawxoje% Sae/ 9!9%Ygv}gnhgx 866=% vv/ :.::/ MGE@YYGO Jy}x`m K/.N/% Egdje Vxa}gi}`ao ac Ib`em.Ianhj}jo} jc}gx }bg Vxa}aiaey;

    Xgjcxnj}`ao% Mgsgeavngo} ax j Y}gv Hjiltjxmy% `o Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt ac Jxngm Iao`i} IbjeegodgyJbgjm% Gyyjpy `o Baoawx ac Cx`}y Ljeybasgo% Maxmxgib}% N/ O`kbacc% :00:% vv/ :79.:3=/ MXGO@L Y`naoj%Vxa}gi}`ao ac Ib`emxgo o Jxngm Iao`i} womgx Iwy}anjxp @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt; j Ianngo}}a }bg 8667 @IXI Y}wmp ao Iwy}anjxp @BE% `o Yeasgo`jo Ejt Xgs`gt% Sae/ 3% Oa/ :.8% Mgignhgx 8660%vv/ :37.:23/ MW]E@ Njx`j ]gxgyj% Ijv}wxgm Ib`em Ianhj}jo}y% `o @XXI% Oa/ 842% Ygv}gnhgx.Ai}ahgx :006% vv/ =8:.=9=/ CJEEJB Lj}bgx`og% Vgxvg}xj}axy jom S`i}`ny; Vxaygiw}`od Ib`emxgo cax }bgIann`yy`ao ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Ix`ngy% `oJcx`ijo Kawxoje ac @o}gxoj}`aoje jom Ianvjxj}`sg Ejt% ]/ :=% Oa/ :%8663% vv/ 29.:69/ DJIBAWM Xd`og% Ej dwgxxg% wo kgw mgocjo}y 1 Gocjo}y yaemj}y ; ej vxahenj}`zwg mgyeegy% `o Jcx`ijo Pgjxhaal ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% Sae/ := "8663)% 8662% vv/ 47.:89/ BJVVAEM Nj}}bgt%Ib`em Yaem`gxy `o @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt; ]bg Egdje Xgdwej}`ao ac Ib`emxgoy Vjx}`i`vj}`ao `o Bay}`e`}`gy% `oOg}bgxejomy @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt Xgs`gt% Sae/ =4!:% 8666% vv/ 84.78/ KGYYGNJO Ibx`y}`og% ]bg Vxa}gi}`aojom Vjx}`i`vj}`ao X`db}y ac }bg Ib`em Yaem`gxy; Jo Jcx`ijo Deahje Vgxyvgi}`sg% `oJcx`ijo Bwnjo X`db}yEjt Kawxoje% Sae/ :!:% 866:% vv/ :=6.:7=/ NJPY]XG Njdje`% Egy gocjo}y yaemj}y go mxa`} `o}gxoj}`aoje ;

    vxahenj}`zwgy iao}gnvaxj`ogy jw xgdjxm mw mxa`} o}gxoj}`aoje bwnjo`}j`xg g} mw mxa`} o}gxoj}`aoje voje%Vjx`y% Vgmaog% 86:6% 868 vv/ NGXNG] Kae% Vxa}aiaeg cjiwe}j}`c ej Iaosgo}`ao xgej}`sg jwr mxa`}y mgegocjo} iaoigxojo} e`nve`ij}`ao mgocjo}y mjoy egy iao`}y jxny ; zwge vxadxy vawx ej vxa}gi}`ao

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    128/400

    :6 ]bg Vxa}gi}`ao ac I`s`e`joy

    mgy mxa`}y mg egocjo} 1% `oJi}wje`} g} Mxa`} `o}gxoj}`aoje% Kwog 8668% b}}v;!!ttt/x`m`/axd!jm`/ VEJ]]OGXMgo`yg% Vxa}gi}`ao ac Ib`emxgo `o @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% `o @XXI% Oa/ 8=6% Kwog :02=%vv/ :=6.:78/ ZWGO@SG] Oaeeg% D`xe Yaem`gxy jom Vjx}`i`vj}`ao `o Bay}`e`}`gy% `o Jcx`ijo Kawxoje ac

    @o}gxoj}`aoje jom Ianvjxj}`sg Ejt > Xgswg jcx`ij`og mg mxa`} `o}gxoj}`aoje g} ianvjx% Sae/ :3% v}/ 8%8662% vv/ 8:0.897/ Y@ODGX Yjomxj% ]bg Vxa}gi}`ao ac Ib`emxgo Mwx`od Jxngm Iao`i} Y`}wj}`aoy%`o @XXI% Oa/ 878% Njp :023% vv/ :99.:34/ YBGVVJXM Joo% Ib`em Yaem`gxy; @y }bg Av}`aoje Vxa}aiaeGs`mgoig ac jo Gngxd`od Y}xj`db}.:2 Iaoygoywy1% `o ]bg @o}gxoj}`aoje Kawxoje ac Ib`emxgoy X`db}y%Sae/ 2!:% 8666% vv/ 94.46/ SJOMGT@GEG ]`op # JEGO Jomx "gmy)%J Ianngo}jxp ao }bg Wo`}gm Oj}`aoyIaosgo}`ao ao }bg X`db}y ac }bg Ib`em; Av}`aoje Vxa}aiae; }bg @osaesgngo} ac Ib`emxgo `o Jxngm Iao`i}y%Eg`mgo% Hay}ao% N/ O`kbacc% 8663% 33 vv/ SGGXNJO Vb`e`v # BGVB[@HJB Egs`og% Vxa}gi}`od Vjegy}`o`jo@o}`cjmj Ib`emxgo; Vgjigcwe Mgnaoy}xj}axy% Ib`em Yaem`gxy ax Ib`em Njx}pxy1% `o ]bg @o}gxoj}`aoje

    Kawxoje ac Ib`emxgoy X`db}y % Sae/ 0!8% 866:% vv/ 4:.22/ Egy gocjo}y g} ej dwgxxg% `o @XXI% Oa/ 2=8% Kwog 866:%vv/ =0=.76=/ TGHY]GX ]`na}bp% Hjhgy t`}b Jxny; @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt jom Ib`em Yaem`gxy% `o DgaxdgTjyb`od}ao @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt Xgs`gt% Sae/ 90% Oa/ 8% 8664% vv/ 882.87=/

    jj) xgyvgi} cax ib`emxgo

    hh) vxab`h`}`ao ac xgixw`}ngo}

    }bg jdg }bxgybaem womgx Vxa}aiaey @ jom @@ jom }bg Iaosgo}`ao ao }bg X`db}y ac }bg

    Ib`em; :7 pgjxy ac jdg

    womgx }bg Av}`aoje Vxa}aiae }a }bg Iaosgo}`ao ao }bg X`db}y acIb`em ao }bg `osaesgngo} ac ib`emxgo `o jxngm iao`i}y; :2 pgjxyac jdg cax m`xgi} vjx}`i`vj}`ao `o bay}`e`}`gy jom cax ianvweyaxpxgixw`}ngo}. hw} Y}j}gy "woe`lg jxngm dxawvy) njp jiigv} saewo}jxp

    goxaengo} `o}a n`e`}jxp yibaaey

    Maiwngo} Oa/ 8=% Av}`aoje Vxa}aiae ao }bg Iaosgo}`ao ao }bg X`db}y ac }bg Ib`em% ao}bg @osaesgngo} ac Ib`emxgo `o Jxngm Iao`i}

    Ijyg Oa/ :03% Yx` Ejolj% Iao`i} `o }bg Sjoo` \Vjxjy :6.::^ Ijyg Oa/ 894% @II% ]bg Vxaygiw}ax s/ ]banjy Ewhjodj Mp`ea Ijyg Oa/ 836% Jcdbjo`y}jo% Iamg ac Iaomwi} cax }bg Nwkjb`mggo \Jx}/ 76^ Ijyg Oa/ 84=% Ijyg Y}wmp% Jxngm Iao`i}y `o Y`gxxj Egaog% E`hgx`j jom Dw`ogj

    \Vjx} 8/% J/^ Ijyg Oa/ 843% Y`gxxj Egaog% Yvgi`je Iawx} Xwe`od ao }bg Xgixw`}ngo} ac Ib`emxgo

    ii) y}j}wy jom }xgj}ngo} ac ib`em yaem`gxy

    Ijyg Oa/ 894% @II% ]bg Vxaygiw}ax s/ ]banjy Ewhjodj Mp`ea

    m) yvgi`je vxa}gi}`ao a kawxoje`y}yDI @.@@@% Jx}y :9!:9!=< V @% Jx}/ 40 \I@BE% Xweg 9=^

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    129/400

    Vjx} @ Ibjv}gx 2 ::

    Ijyg Oa/ 94% Vxa}gi}`ao ac Kawxoje`y}y Ijyg Oa/ 3:% WO% Ygixg}jxp.Dgogxjey Xgvax}y ao }bg Vxa}gi}`ao ac I`s`e`joy `o Jxngm

    Iao`i} \Vjx} J/^

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; HJEDWP.DJEEA@Y Jegrjomxg% Vxa}gi}`ao mgy kawxoje`y}gy g} mgy nm`jygo vx`amg mg iao`} jxn% `o @XXI% Oa/ 279% Njxib 866=% vv/ 94.34/ HA@]AONJEBGXHG Ypes`g% Ej

    vxa}gi}`ao mgy kawxoje`y}gy go n`yy`ao vx`eegwyg mjoy egy {aogy mg iao`} jxn% Hxwyygey% m`}`ao mgeWo`sgxy`} mg Hxwrgeegy # Hxwpejo}% :020% =6= vv/ DJYYGX Bjoy.Vg}gx% ]bg Vxa}gi}`ao ac Kawxoje`y}yGodjdgm `o Mjodgxawy Vxacgyy`aoje N`yy`aoy% `o @XXI% Oa/ 898% Cghxwjxp :029% vv/ 9.:2/ DG@YY Xah`o%]bg Vxa}gi}`ao ac Kawxoje`y}y o Jxngm Iao`i}y% o Dgxnjo Pgjxhaal ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt > Kjbxhwib

    cx @o}gxoj}`aojegy Xgib}% Sae/ 7:% 8662% vv/ 820.9:0/ E@YAYLP Kajoog N/ # BGOX@IBYGO Kgoo`cgx% Mao}Ybaa} }bg Ngyygodgx; Vxayvgi}y cax Vxa}gi}`od Kawxoje`y}y `o Iao`i} Y`}wj}`aoy% `o Ngm`j% Tjx jom

    Iao`i}% Sae/ 8% Oa/ 8% 8660% vv/ :80.:=2/ N@OGJX Ejxxp% YIA]] Iae`o # TG@YY ]banjy D/% ]bg OgtyNgm`j% I`s`e Tjx jom Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ji}`ao% Hawemgx% Eaomao% X`googx Vwhe`ybgxy% :003% :89 vv/ NAAXGMawdejy T/% ]tgo}p.C`xy} Igo}wxp Gnhgmmgm Kawxoje`y}; Ejtcwe ]jxdg}y 1 o ]bg Jxnp Ejtpgx% Kwep 8660%vv/ :.98/

    CWX]BGX XGJM@OD; MJHAS@EEG Hgoa}% Nm`j}`yj}`ao mgy avxj}`aoy mg vj`r g} xgyvgi} mw mxa`}`o}gxoj}`aoje bwnjo`}j`xg 1% `o Joowj`xg cxjoj`y mg xgej}`aoy `o}gxoj}`aojegy% 8660% vv/ :684.:693/DJYYGX Bjoy.Vg}gx% ]bg Kawxoje`y}y X`db} }a @ocaxnj}`ao `o ]`ng ac Tjx jom ao Mjodgxawy N`yy`aoy%

    `o P@BE% Sae 3 "8669)% 8663% vv/ 933.922/ YJWE Hgo% Vxaygiw}`od Tjx Ix`ngy j} Hje`ha womgx Jwy}xje`joEjt; }bg L`ee`od ac C`sg Kawxoje`y}y `o Gjy} ]`nax hp @omaogy`j% `o ]bg Ypmogp Ejt Xgs`gt% Sae/ 9:%Oa/ :% 8660% vv/ 29.:86/ Y]AEE Vb`e`vvg # AHGXA@ Ywx`omgx "gmy)%Ngm`j Xgvax}`od; Jxngm Iao`i} jomS`aegoig; Yaw}b Jy`jo Ygo`ax Gm`}axy Iaocgxgoig 8664% Mbjlj% Hjodejmgyb% Mbjlj% @IXI% Vxgyy @oy}`}w}g acHjodejmgyb% 8664% :== vv/

    g) xgy}ax`od jn`ep e`olyDI @@@% Jx}y/ 46 jom :88< DI @S% Jx}y 87.83 jom :63< V @% Jx}/ 98< V @@% Jx}/ ="9)"h) \I@BE% Xweg :87^

    Maiwngo} Oa/ 9=% @IXI% ]xji`od Ygxs`ig

    Ijyg Oa/ :8:% Hjodejmgyb!@om`j!Vjl`y}jo% :04= Jdxggngo} \Jx}/ :8^ Ijyg Oa/ :74% @o}gx.Jngx`ijo Iann`yy`ao ao Bwnjo X`db}y% Iajxm s/ Wo`}gm Y}j}gy

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; MKWXAS@I Dxjm`n`x% ]bg igo}xje }xji`od jdgoip ac }bg @o}gxoj}`aoje Iann`}}ggac }bg Xgm Ixayy; Ji}`s`}`gy ac }bg @IXI cax }bg jeegs`j}`ao ac }bg ngo}je ywccgx`od ac tjx s`i}`ny% Dgogsj%@IXI% :023% 870 vv/ MXJVGX Dgxjem @/J/M/% ]bg Xgwo`ao ac Cjn`e`gy `o ]`ng ac Jxngm Iao`i}% `o@XXI% Oa/ :0:% Cghxwjxp :044% vv/ 74.37/ GDDGX Mjo`gej # ]ANJO K`x`% Cjn`ep Xgwo`ij}`ao; Iaeegi}`ao

    ac Maiwngo}y% Dgogsj% Bgoxp.Mwojo} @oy}`}w}g% :004% :2= vv/ @IXI% Xgy}ax`od Cjn`ep E`oly Y}xj}gdp;@oiewm`od Egdje Xgcgxgoigy% Dgogsj% @IXI% Cghxwjxp 8660% 3= vv/ YJYYE@ Njxia% ]bg Oj}`aoje@ocaxnj}`ao Hwxgjw `o J`m ac }bg S`i}`ny ac Jxngm Iao`i}y% `o @XXI% Oa/ 873% Kjowjxp :024% vv/ 3.8=/

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    130/400

    :8 ]bg Vxa}gi}`ao ac I`s`e`joy

    ) womjngo}je dwjxjo}ggy "V @% Jx}/ 47)

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; BGXI[GDB D{j% Y}j}g ac Gngxdgoip jom Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt; Ao Jx}`ieg 47 ac

    Jmm`}`aoje Vxa}aiae @% `o @XXI% Oa/ 8=8% Ygv}gnhgx :02=% vv/ 839.849/

    9/ Xwegy ao vxa}gi}gm i`s`e`joy

    j) tba `y j vxa}gi}gm i`s`e`jo1DI @S% Jx}/ =

    "Ygg ywvxj% Vjx} @% Ibjv}gx 8/ @@@/ 8/ Vgxyaoje yiavg ac jvve`ij}`ao)

    Ijyg Oa/ :6=% Og}bgxejomy% @o xg V`e{ Ijyg Oa/ ::3% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% Yixggo`od ac Mg}j`oggy `o S`g}ojn Ijyg Oa/ :98% @yxjge% Ijygy Iaoigxo`od Mgvax}j}`ao Axmgxy Ijyg Oa/ :=7% @IXI!Yaw}b Eghjoao% Ieaywxg ac @oyjx Ijnv Ijyg Oa/ :74% @o}gx.Jngx`ijo Iann`yy`ao ao Bwnjo X`db}y% Iajxm s/ Wo`}gm Y}j}gy Ijyg Oa/ :47% WO% Mg}go}`ao ac Caxg`dogxy Ijyg Oa/ 8::% @I]P% ]bg Vxaygiw}ax s/ ]jm`i \Vjx} I/% vjxjy :39.:30^ Ijyg Oa/ 8:9% @I]P% Vxaygiw}ax s/ Xjk`i \Vjx} J/% vjxjy 9=.94^ Ijyg Oa/ 8:3% @I]P% ]bg Vxaygiw}ax s/ Hejyl`i \Vjxjy :84.:=3^ Ijyg Oa/ 882% Ijyg Y}wmp% Jxngm Iao`i}y `o }bg Dxgj} Ejlgy Xgd`ao \Vjx} @/9^

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD;YJYYE@ Njxia # AEYAO Ejwxj N/% ]bg Mgi`y`ao ac }bg @I]P Jvvgjey Ibjnhgx`o }bg ]jm`i Ijyg; Ogt Bax`{aoy cax @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo jom Ix`n`oje Ejt1% `o @XXI% Oa/ 290%Ygv}gnhgx 8666% vv/ 499.430/

    h) xwegy ao vxa}gi}gm i`s`e`joy

    jj) caxg`dogxy ao j vjx}py ato }gxx`}axp; hjy`ijeep }bg xwegy vxa}gi}`odcaxg`dogxy `o vgjig}`ng xgnj`o jvve`ijheg

    DI @S% Jx}/ 92 "`o`}`je ygo}goig)

    hh) x`db} }a egjsg1DI @S% Jx}y 97.94 jom =2

    Ijyg Oa/ :38% Gx`}xgj!G}b`av`j% Jtjxm ao I`s`e`jo @o}gxoggy jom I`s`e`jo Vxavgx}p Ijyg Oa/ :47% WO% Mg}go}`ao ac Caxg`dogxy

    ii) bwnjog }xgj}ngo}DI @S% Jx}/ 84 \I@BE% Xweg 24^

    Maiwngo} Oa/ 9=% @IXI% ]xji`od Ygxs`ig \=^ Ijyg Oa/ ::7% Hged`wn% Vwhe`i Vxaygiw}ax s/ D/T/

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    131/400

    Vjx} @ Ibjv}gx 2 :9

    Ijyg Oa/ :96% @yxjge% Ng}bamy ac @o}gxxadj}`ao Wygm Jdj`oy} Vjegy}`o`jo Mg}j`oggy Ijyg Oa/ :9:% @yxjge% Ibg`lb Ahg`m g} jes/ N`o`y}xp ac Ygiwx`}p Ijyg Oa/ :97% @yxjge% ]bg Xjcjb Ijyg \Vjxjy 8:jom 78^

    Ijyg Oa/ :==% @IXI!Eghjoao% Yjhxj jom Ibj}`ej Ijyg Oa/ :27% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% ]bg Yibegy`odgx Xgvax} Ijyg Oa/ :02% Hged`wn% Hged`jo Yaem`gxy `o Yanje`j Ijyg Oa/ :00% Ijojmj% X/ s/ Hxaileghjol \Vjxjy 8=% 87% =0% 36% 38% jom 3=.33^ Ijyg Oa/ 866% Ijojmj% X/ s/ Haejom Ijyg Oa/ 86:% Ijojmj% X/ s/ Ygtjxm Ijyg Oa/ 869% Ijyg Y}wmp% Jxngm Iao`i}y `o }bg caxngx Pwdayejs`j \:6^ Ijyg Oa/ 8:3% @I]P% ]bg Vxaygiw}ax s/ Hejyl`i \Vjxjy :7=.:77^ Ijyg Oa/ 88=% Ixaj}`j% Vxaygiw}ax s/ Xjkla Xjmweas`i jom A}bgxy

    Ijyg Oa/ 836% Jcdbjo`y}jo% Iamg ac Iaomwi} cax }bg Nwkjb`mggo \Jx}y 4.0^ Ijyg Oa/ 806% Dgaxd`j!Xwyy`j% Bwnjo X`db}y Tj}iby Xgvax} ao }bg Iao`i} `o Yaw}b

    Ayyg}`j \Vjxjy 06.02^ Ijyg Oa/ 80:% Dgaxd`j!Xwyy`j% @omgvgomgo} @o}gxoj}`aoje Cji}.C`om`od N`yy`ao ao }bg

    Iao`i} `o Yaw}b Ayyg}`j \Vjxjy 06.09^

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; MXAGDG Iaxmwej% @o ]xw}b }bg Eg`}na}`s; ]bg Vxab`h`}`ao ac ]ax}wxg jom A}bgxCaxny ac @ee.]xgj}ngo} `o @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt% `o @XXI% Sae/ 20% Oa/ 234% Ygv}gnhgx 8664%vv/ 7:7.7=:/ YJE@OJY HWXDAY Bgxojo% ]bg ]jl`od ac Bay}jdgy jom @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt%`o @XXI% Oa/ 846% Njp.Kwog :020% vv/ :03.8:3/

    mm) caxigm ejhawxDI @S% Jx}y =6% 7: jom 07 \I@BE% Xweg 07^

    Ijyg Oa/ 869% Ijyg Y}wmp% Jxngm Iao`i}y `o }bg caxngx Pwdayejs`j \0^ Ijyg Oa/ 880% Mgnaixj}`i Xgvwhe`i ac }bg Iaoda% Iao`i}y `o }bg L`swy \Vjx} @@@%

    vjxjy 7:.79^

    gg) vxab`h`}`ao ac iaeegi}`sg vwo`ybngo}DI @S% Jx}/ 99 \I@BE% Xweg :69^

    Ijyg Oa/ :82% @yxjge% Bawyg Mgnae`}`aoy `o }bg Aiiwv`gm Vjegy}`o`jo ]gxx`}axp Ijyg Oa/ :94% @yxjge% Vatgx Iw}y `o Dj{j \Vjx} J/% vjxj/ :4^ Ijyg Oa/ 880% Mgnaixj}`i Xgvwhe`i a }bg Iaoda% Iaoc`i} `o }bg L`swy \Vjx} @@@%

    vjxjy :8.89% 94^

    Ijyg Oa/ 844% Y`gxxj Egaog% Yvgi`je Iawx} Xwe`od `o JCXI Ijyg \Vjx} @@/%vjxjy348.32:^

    Ijyg Oa/ 80:% Dgaxd`j!Xwyy`j% @omgvgomgo} @o}gxoj}`aoje Cji}.C`om`od N`yy`ao ao }bgIao`i} `o Yaw}b Ayyg}`j \Vjxjy :6:.:60^

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; IABGO Jn`ibj`% Giaoan`i Yjoi}`aoy `o @BE Ywddgy}gm Vx`oi`vegy% BghxgtWo`sgxy`}p @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt Xgygjxib Vjvgx% Oa/ :=.60% Kwog 8660% 99 vv/ LAYNAVAWEAY Dgaxd`ay%

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    132/400

    := ]bg Vxa}gi}`ao ac I`s`e`joy

    Iaeegi}`sg Vwo`ybngo}y womgx @o}gxoj}`aoje Bwnjo`}jx`jo Ejt; jo Jojepy`y ac }bg 8663 Tjx `oEghjoao% `o Vjig M`x`}}` Wnjo`% Sae/ 7% Oa/ 9% 8660% vv/ 07.:86/

    cc) s`y`}y hp }bg Vxa}gi}`od Vatgx jom hp }bg @IXIDI @S% Jx}y 0.:6% 96 jom :=9 \I@BE% Xweg :8= J^

    Ijyg Oa/ :9:% @yxjge% Ibg`lb Ahg`m g} je/ s/ N`o`y}xp ac Ygiwx`}p Ijyg Oa/ :74% @o}gx.Jngx`ijo Iann`yy`ao ao Bwnjo X`db}y% Iajxm s/ Wo`}gm Y}j}gy Ijyg Oa/ :46% @IXI% @xjo!@xjz Ngnaxjomj Ijyg Oa/ :27% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% ]bg Yibegy`odgx Xgvax} Ijyg Oa/ 83:% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% Y}j}wy jom ]xgj}ngo} ac Mg}j`oggy Bgem `o Dwjo}jojna

    Ojsje Hjyg \Vjx} @@/^

    dd) `c `o}gxogm; i`s`e`jo `o}gxoggyDI @S% Jx}y =:.=9% 32 jom 42.:97

    Ijyg Oa/ :9:% @yxjge% Ibg`lb Ahg`m g} je/ s/ N`o`y}xp ac Ygiwx`}p Ijyg Oa/ :92% @yxjge% Mg}go}`ao ac Woejtcwe Ianhj}jo}y \Vjx} J/% vjxj/ :4^ Ijyg Oa/ :38% Gx`}xgj!G}b`av`j% Jtjxm ao I`s`e`jo @o}gxoggy jom I`s`e`jo Vxavgx}p Ijyg Oa/ :46% @IXI% @xjo!@xjz Ngnaxjomj Ijyg Oa/ :27% Wo`}gm Y}j}gy% ]bg Yibegy`odgx Xgvax} Ijyg Oa/ 806% Dgaxd`j!Xwyy`j% Bwnjo X`db}y Tj}iby Xgvax} ao }bg Iao`i} `o Yaw}b

    Ayyg}`j \Vjxjy 78.73% 06.02^ Ijyg Oa/ 80:% Dgaxd`j!Xwyy`j% @omgvgomgo} @o}gxoj}`aoje Cji}.C`om`od N`yy`ao ao }bg

    Iao`i} `o Yaw}b Ayyg}`j \Vjxjy 06.09^

    YWDDGY]GM XGJM@OD; Ijyg Tgy}gxo Xgygxsg Kawxoje ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% Ygiwx`}p Mg}go}`ao% Sae/ =6%Oa/ 9% 8660% vv/ 9:7.376/ DAAMNJO Xpjo% ]bg Mg}go}`ao ac I`s`e`joy `o Jxngm Iao`i}y% `o JK@E% Sae/ :69%Oa/ :% Kjowjxp 8660% vv/ =2.4=/ N`o`y}xp ac Caxg`do Jccj`xy ac Mgonjxl% ]bg Iavgobjdgo Vxaigyy ao }bg

    Bjome`od ac Mg}j`oggy `o @o}gxoj}`aoje N`e`}jxp Avgxj}`aoy% `o Xgswg mg mxa`} n`e }j`xg g} mg mxa`} mg ej dwgxxg%Sae/ 9.=% Oa/ =3% 8664% vv/ 939.908/ OJGX] Cxgmgx`l% Mg}go}`ao `o Vgjig Avgxj}`aoy; }bg Egdje Cxjngtaxljom Nj`o Ij}gdax`gy ac Mg}j`oggy% `o Xgswg mg mxa`} n`e`}j`xg g} mg mxa`} mg ej dwgxxg% Sae :.8% Oa/ =7% 8663%vv/ 7:.42/ AEYAO Ejwxj% Dwjo}jojna Bjhgjy Xgs`gt; Jxg }bg M/I/ M`y}x`i} Iawx}y Mgi`y`aoy Iaoy`y}go} t`}b@BE @o}gxongo} Y}jomjxmy1% `o Ijyg Tgy}gxo Xgygxsg Kawxoje ac @o}gxoj}`aoje Ejt% Sae/ =8% Oa/ : # 8% 8660%vv/ :04.8=9/ AYTJEM Hxwig% ]bg Mg}go}`ao ac I`s`e`joy `o N`e`}jxp Avgxj}`aoy; Xgjyaoy cax jom Ibjeegodgy}a Mgsgeav`od j Yvgi`je Ejt ac Mg}go}`ao% `oNgehawxog Wo`sgxy`}p Ejt Xgs`gt% Sae/ 98% 8662% vv/ 78=.779/

    mgi`y`ao ac `o}gxongo}; `om`s`mwje jmn`o`y}xj}`sg mgi`y`aoDI @S% Jx}/ 42

    Ijyg Oa/ :74% @o}gx.Jngx`ijo Iann`yy`ao ao Bwnjo X`db}y% Iajxm s/ Wo`}gm Y}j}gy\Vjxjy 78.70^

    xgjyaoy cax `o}gxongo}; `nvgxj}`sg ygiwx`}p xgjyaoy< oa} vwo`ybngo}DI @S% Jx}y =:% =8 jom 42

  • 8/3/2019 How does law protect in war? Volume I: outline of International Humanitarian Law

    133/400

    Vjx} @ Ibjv}gx 2 :7

    Ijyg Oa/ :9:% @yxjge% Ibg`lb Ahg`m g} je/ s/ N`o`y}xp ac Ygiwx`}p Ijyg Oa/ :74% @o}gx.Jngx`ijo Iann`yy`ao ao Bwnjo X`db}y% Iajxm s/ Wo`}gm Y}j}gy Ijyg Oa/ :38% Gx`}xgj!G}b`av`j% Jtjxm ao I`s`e`jo @o}gxoggy jom I`s`e`jo Vxavgx}p