humanitarian engineering: the r t less-d c · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction...

22
EFFECTIVELY ADAPTING & ADOPTING RISK REDUCTION TECHNOLOGIES IN EMERGING COMMUNITIES: EXAMPLE IN WEST SUMATRA, INDONESIA VERÓNICA CEDILLOS, P.E. | ASSOCIATE DIRECTOR OF PROJECTS APPLIED TECHNOLOGY COUNCIL HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R OLE OF ENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGY IN LESS-DEVELOPED COMMUNITIES

Upload: others

Post on 18-Jul-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

EFFECTIVELY ADAPTING & ADOPTING RISK REDUCTIONTECHNOLOGIES IN EMERGING COMMUNITIES:

EXAMPLE IN WEST SUMATRA, INDONESIA

VERÓNICA CEDILLOS, P.E. | ASSOCIATE DIRECTOR OF PROJECTS APPLIED TECHNOLOGY COUNCIL

HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE ROLE OFENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGY IN

LESS-DEVELOPED COMMUNITIES

Page 2: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

Difficult to achieve lasting impact and long-term local adoption of technologies

Page 3: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

Key Aspects

• What are the existing conditions, limitations, and opportunities?

• What does the community value?• How do we ensure local ownership?

Page 4: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

Key Aspects

• What are the existing conditions, limitations, and opportunities?

• What does the community value?• How do we ensure local ownership?

Page 5: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

1833

1797

1935

1861

1907

2000

2002

2004

2005

2008

2007

Padang

6 Source: Abdul Muhari

Page 6: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,
Page 7: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

Tsunami Inundation Map & Evacuation Models

LegendInundation Depth

Schlurmann et al. (2010)

Page 8: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

2007 earthquake

2009 Earthquake

Photo Credits: Abdul Muhari9

Page 9: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

Other countries face similar problems….

What strategies have they used to overcome them?

Page 10: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

Source: Muhari FEMA 646

Page 11: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

Challenges to implementation

Need to develop locally-appropriate solutions

Page 12: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

Photo Credit: Walter Mooney, USGS

Photo Credit: Walter Mooney, USGS

Other more pressing needs…

Page 13: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

How will you ever get people to care?

Page 14: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

Inadequate construction quality…

Page 15: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

Key Aspects

• What are the existing conditions, limitations, and opportunities?

• What does the community value?• How do we ensure local ownership?

Page 16: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

Image Credits: http://simbi.bimasislam.com/

> 40 million USDFunded by West Sumatra Province

Page 17: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

Performance of mosques during 2004 Great Indian Ocean Tsunami

http://bangladesh2000.com/blog//blog4.php/a-mosque-masjid-save-after-tsunami#.VIHs9WTF_pA

Page 18: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

Design Mosques for Vertical Evacuation

• Well-distributed • Typical design:

– symmetric layout– redundant structures – large open prayer areas– egress designed for large numbers

of people– construction quality relatively

better than other structures• Maintenance not an issue• Vital role in education, awareness

FEMA P-646

Page 19: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

Key Aspects

• What are the existing conditions, limitations, and opportunities?

• What does the community value?• How do we ensure local ownership?

Page 20: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

Progress from Local Efforts

• Mosques being built for vertical evacuation• Several major roads widened• Additional bridges leading to high ground

constructed• Local government offices and EOC relocated

outside tsunami inundation area• Plans to move commercial center, as well

Page 21: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

Photo Credit: GeoHazards International

Page 22: HUMANITARIAN ENGINEERING: THE R T LESS-D C · effectively adapting& adopting risk reduction technologies in emerging communities: example in west sumatra, indonesia verÓnica cedillos,

Thank you!