i %$ b bp ]ysbr ]b88zt${s $bt ak ias{3, ]bt bj bp 7k8abj...

17

Upload: others

Post on 25-Mar-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: i %$ b BP ]YsBR ]B88Zt${s $Bt Ak IAs{3, ]Bt Bj BP 7k8ABj ...ebollt/papers/ieee-transactions-controlofsymboldynamics.pdf3 ((I (3 3 / / I $ Y stI R" ts $8$ j X Y t sI$ j Bj A 8 k R s

i�%$�b BP ]YsBR ]B88Zt${s�$Bt

Ak

3��IAs{, ]Bt��Bj BP 7k8ABj${ *kts8${R

e�$, �� Bjj�

*�}s��8�t� BP �s�Y�8s�${R� x�1 <BjjBbsk iI�� =�7� Ws%sj V{sI�8k� Vtts}Bj$R� �* 1d;(1Tx((1�

3�A�Zs�k dx� 1((d

VAR��s{�

qY$R }s}�� $R 8�st� �B R��%� sR s �Z�B�$sj I�R{�$A$t� �Y� j$t, A��b��t Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R sR s I�R{�$}�$Bt BP s

{YsB�${ s���s{�B�� stI YBb �B ZR� {Bt��Bj BP {YsBR �B 8st$}Zjs�� �Y� {B���R}BtI$t� Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R �B ��stR8$�

st $tPB�8s�$Bt A�s�$t� R$�tsj� G� ZR� �Y� NB��t9 s���s{�B�� $t �Y� PB�8 BP �Y� I$R{���� RZ{{�RR$%� 8s-$8s 8s} BP

�Y� FT%s�$sAj� �$8�TR��$�R� sR BZ� 8s$t �-s8}j�� 3B� �Y� h�R� �$8�� Y���� b� ZR� �Y$R BR{$jjs�B� sR s {YsB�${ R$�tsj{s��$��� G� ��%$�b �Y� 8stk }��%$BZRjk I�%�jB}�I $RRZ�R t�{�RRs�k �B {��s�� s bB�,$t� {Bt��Bj BP Rk8ABj Ikts8${RRkR��8� qY�R� $t{jZI� s A$��P ��%$�b BP �Y� �Y�B�k BP Rk8ABj Ikts8${R� stI YBb �Y�k s�$R� P�B8 �Y� 4Bb BP sI$&���t�$sj �JZs�$Bt� G� sjRB I$R{ZRR �Y� �Bj� BP �Y� wRk8ABj Ikts8${RD ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt� �Y� I$^{Zj�k BP htI$t�RZ{Y }s��$�$BtR� bY${Y $R st B}�t }�BAj�8 PB� 8BR� Ikts8${sj RkR��8R� stI s t�bjk I�%�jB}�I sj�B�$�Y8 �B htI�Y� ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt bY${Y ��j$�R `ZR� Bt ,tBb$t� s js��� R�� BP }��$BI${ B�A$�R� G� sjRB I$R{ZRR �Y� $8}B��st{�BP ZR$t� s ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt $t ���8R BP {BtR$I��$t� �Y� }BRR$A$j$�k BP ZR$t� RB8� B�Y�� s�A$��s�k }s��$�$Bt� b$�YI$R{ZRR$Bt BP {BtR�JZ�t{�R AB�Y ��t��sjjk �B {Ys�s{���$9$t� �Y� RkR��8� stI sjRB R}�{$h{sjjk �B {B88Zt${s�$t� Bt{YsB�${ R$�tsj {s��$��R� VjRB� BP }�s{�${sj $8}B��st{�� b� ��%$�b �Y� t�{�RRs�k P��IAs{,T{Bt��Bj $RRZ�R �B PB�{� �Y�4Bb BP s {YsB�${ I$&���t�$sj �JZs�$Bt �B {s��k s I�R$��I 8�RRs���

d yt��BIZ{�$Bt

qY� h�jI BP {Bt��Bjj$t� {YsBR bsR jsZt{Y�I b$�Y �Y� R$8}j� X!pO" sj�B�$�Y8 }ZAj$RY�I $t d��( Ak !��� p��AB�$� stIOB�,� >dH� qY� $I�s $R �Ys� st ZtR�sAj� }��$BI${ B�A$� {st A� R�sA$j$9�I Ak }s�s8���${ P��IAs{, {Bt��Bj Bt{� ���BI${$�kYsR {sZR�I s �stIB8jk {YBR�t $t$�$sj {BtI$�$Bt �B bstI�� {jBR� �tBZ�Y �B �Y� }��$BI${$�k �Ys� j$t�s� {Bt��Bj �Y�B�ks}}j$�R >dH� V ���8�tIBZR 4BBI BP �Y�B���${sj stI �-}��$8�t�sj ��R�s�{Y YsR PBjjBb�I �Y$R R�8$tsj bB�,� RB8� BP bY${Y�-��tIR �Y� B�$�$tsj !pO ��{Yt$JZ�R� stI RB8� BP bY${Y Btjk YsR $t {B88Bt b$�Y !pO �Y� R$8}j� ��sj$9s�$Bt �Ys� s{YsB�${ BR{$jjs�B� $R �R}�{$sjjk 4�-$Aj� stI �Y���PB�� sjjBbR PB� %��k R�tR$�$%� R�j�{�$Bt A��b��t s b$I� �st�� BP }BRR$Aj�A�Ys%$B�R�

]B88Zt${s�$Bt b$�Y {YsB�${ R$�tsj {s��$��R YsR �bB 8s`B� R{YBBjR� qY�R� s�� dD 7kt{Y�Bt$9s�$Bt� stI 1D 3��IAs{,{Bt��Bj BP Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R� qY� RZA`�{� BP �Y$R }s}�� {Bt{��tR �Y� P��IAs{, {Bt��Bj Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R s}}�Bs{Y�AZ� b� 8�t�$Bt Rkt{Y�Bt$9s�$Bt PB� {Bt��sR� �B �Y� B�Y�� R{YBBj BP 8��YBIR bY${Y s�� �-}�{��I �B s}}�s� Y���� qY�Rkt{Y�Bt$9s�$Bt BP {YsB�${ BR{$jjs�B�R }Y�tB8�tBt bsR h�R� I$R{B%���I $t �Y� �s�jk stI 8$ITd�M(:R Ak >xH stI �Y�t >EH��Y�t $t d��( Ak _�{B�sT]s��Bjj �Y� jsR� BP bY${Y R�s���I st s%sjst{Y� BP ��R�s�{Y� 7kt{YBt$9s�$Bt $R tBb ,tBbt �B Ys%�PZtIs8�t�sj $8}j${s�$BtR $t ts�Z�� b�jj A�kBtI �Y� }�s{�${sj �t�$t���$t� s}}j${s�$Bt BP {B88Zt${s�$Bt� qB BZ� $t����R�Y���� $� bsR RYBbt %��k �s�jk Bt >�� �H �Ys� ZR$t� Rkt{Y�Bt$9s�$Bt sjjBbR s {YsB�${ R$�tsj {s��$�� �B ��stR8$� s 8�RRs���7�� >MH PB� st �-{�jj�t� ��%$�b� stI sjRB j$,�jk s��${j�R $t �Y$R $RRZ� PB� �Y� {Z���t� R�s�� BP �Y$R s���

!t �Y� B�Y�� YstI� {Bt��Bj BP Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R ��j$�R Bt s PZtIs8�t�sj I�R{�$}�$Bt BP s {YsB�${ BR{$jjs�B� Ak {Yst��BP {BB�I$ts��R �Ys� A�$t�R s I$R{���� �$8� 8s} wbY${Y 8sk s�$R� Ak s 4Bb 8s}}$t� A��b��t _B$t{s��: RZ�Ps{�RD Bt $�R

�8s$jU ABjj�otsIt�ts%k�8$j� b�AU Y��}U\\8s�Yb�A�8s�YR{$�ZRts��IZ\Ps{Zj�k\ABjj��8\

d

Page 2: i %$ b BP ]YsBR ]B88Zt${s $Bt Ak IAs{3, ]Bt Bj BP 7k8ABj ...ebollt/papers/ieee-transactions-controlofsymboldynamics.pdf3 ((I (3 3 / / I $ Y stI R" ts $8$ j X Y t sI$ j Bj A 8 k R s

}YsR� R}s{� �B st sAR��s{� ��tBZjj$ RY$P� 8s} Bt RB8� RZARY$P� R}s{�� qY� PZtIs8�t�sj j$t, A��b��t {YsB�${ BR{$jjs�B�RstI Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R bsR h�R� $t��BIZ{�I Ak 7� 78sj� >d;H� yt d��n� 7� <sk�R ��� sj >1� nH RYBb�I �Ys� P��IAs{, {Bt��BjBP {YsB�${ ��s`�{�B�$�R �B���Y�� b$�Y R�tR$�$%� I�}�tI�t{� stI �Y� Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${sj I�R{�$}�$Bt BP {YsB�${ ��s`�{�B�$�R{st A� ZR�I �B PB�{� s {YsB�${ BR{$jjs�B� �B {s��k $tPB�8s�$Bt� 78sjj }s�s8����${ P��IAs{, {Bt��Bj R�tR$�$%�jk sj���R s{YsB�${ ��s`�{�B�k stI Y�t{� Rs$I {Yst�� BP {BB�I$ts��R R��%�R sR s {BI$t� PZt{�$Bt �B ��stRPB�8 �Y� Rk8ABj${ R�JZ�t{�{B���R}BtI$t� �B �Y� B�$�$tsj {YsB�${ ��s`�{�B�k� $t�B RB8� B�Y�� Rk8ABj${ R�JZ�t{� {B���R}BtI$t� �B s I�R$��I 8�RRs���

GY$j� �Y$R }s}�� $R 8�st� �B R��%� sR s �Z�B�$sj� sR BZ� 8s$t �-s8}j�� b� b$jj RYBb PB� �Y� h�R� �$8� YBb NB��t9:RRZ{{�RR$%� 8s-$8s 8s} R��%�R sR s �BBI $tPB�8s�$Bt {s��k$t� I�%${�� yt BZ� }��%$BZR bB�, �Y� sZ�YB� stI *Bjt$, >1;� 1xH{BtR$I���I s {Y�8${sj RkR��8� 7$t{� $� YsR A��t RYBbt �Ys� �Y� NB��t9 �JZs�$BtR {st A� �sR$jk ��sj$9�I $t {$�{Z$��k>�H� $� PBjjBbR �Ys� RZ{Y s RkR��8 {BZjI $t }�$t{$}j� A� AZ$j�� yt 7�{�$Bt 1� b� ��%$�b �Y� NB��t9 RkR��8 stI s���s{�B��bY${Y b$jj R��%� sR BZ� 8s$t {Bt{���� �-s8}j�� stI b� I$R{ZRR YBb �Y� RZ{{�RR$%� 8s-$8s 8s} k$�jIR s Bt�TYZ8}�I8s}� PB� bY${Y �Y� Rk8ABj Ikts8${R s�� I�ht�I� G� ��%$�b $t 7�{�$Bt n �Y� t�{�RRs�k Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R� AB�Y PB���t��sj I$&�B8B�}Y$R8R BP �Y� }jst�� stI PB� �Y� R$8}j�� {YsBR BP Bt�TI$8�tR$Btsj 8stkT�BTBt� 8s}R� BP bY${Y �Y� �Y�RZ{{�RR$%� 8s-$8s 8s} BP �Y� NB��t9 4Bb $R st �-s8}j�� qY�t $t 7�{�$Bt ;� b� I$R{ZRR AB�Y �Y� �Bj� stI $8}B��st{�BP ZR$t� s ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt� G� sjRB I$R{ZRR �Y� {BtR�JZ�t{�R BP ZR$t� s tBt��t��s�$t� ws�A$��s�kD }s��$�$Bt� AB�Y$t I�R{�$A$t� �Y� RkR��8� stI sjRB R}�{$h{sjjk �Y� {BtR�JZ�t{�R �B {B88Zt${s�$t� b$�Y {YsBR� G� A�$�4k ��%$�b st�b sj�B�$�Y8 �B ZR� {Bjj�{�$BtR BP ZtR�sAj� }��$BI${ B�A$�R �B ��%�sj �Y� ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt� yt 7�{�$Bt x� b� ��{sjjs ��{Yt$JZ�� {BTI�%�jB}�I Ak �Y� sZ�YB� >1�� 1M� 1�H� bY���Ak s ���s� I�sj BP {Ystt�j tB$R� ��R$R�st{� {st A� sII�I�B �Y� RkR��8� stI {BR�$t� Btjk s 8$tB� jBRR BP {Ystt�j {s}s{$�k� R$8}jk Ak ��R��${�$t� ��s`�{�B�$�R �B sjbskR s%B$I st�$�YAB�YBBI BP �Y� ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt� !Z� P��IAs{, {Bt��Bj ��{Yt$JZ�R I$R{ZRR�I $t 7�{�$Bt E b$jj PBjjBb �Y� 8��YBIR{BTI�%�jB}�I Ak �Y� sZ�YB� $t >1xH� $t bY${Y b� RYBb�I sjjBbR PB� sjj t�{�RRs�k $tPB�8s�$Bt �B A� j�s�t�I }Z��jk AkBAR��%s�$Bt stI 8�sRZ��8�t�� $t �Y� R���$t� BP s jsAB�s�B�k �-}��$8�t�� stI $t �Y� sAR�t{� BP s {jBR�I PB�8 I$&���t�$sj�JZs�$Bt 8BI�j BP �Y� Ikts8${sj RkR��8�

1 NB��t9 *$&���t�$sj eJZs�$BtR stI 7Z{{�RR$%� �s-$8s �s}

G� {BtR$I�� �Y� NB��t9 RkR��8 >;H�

�? ) d(wr � ?D,

�r ) ?w1M� FD� r,

�F ) ?r � wMbnDF, wdD

AB�Y A�{sZR� $� $R s A�t{Y8s�, �-s8}j� BP {YsB�${ BR{$jjs�$BtR� stI A�{sZR� $� {st A� }YkR${sjjk ��sj$9�I Ak st �j�{��Bt${

{$�{Z$� >�H� N$,�b$R� �YBR� $t����R��I $t B}�${sj ��stR8$RR$Bt {s��$��R 8sk ��{sjj �Y� NB��t9Tj$,� $tP�s��I W<n jsR�� Is�s

>n(H� e� NB��t9 RYBb�I �Ys� Y$R �JZs�$BtR Ys%� �Y� }�B}���k �Ys� �Y� RZ{{�RR$%� jB{sj 8s-$8s {st A� I�R{�$A�I Ak s

Bt�TI$8�tR$Btsj� Bt�TYZ8} 8s}�

FzLd ) WwF

zD, w1D

bY��� b� j�� Fz A� �Y� z�Y jB{sj 8s-$8Z8 BP �Y� R�s�� %s�$sAj� Fw0D� qY� {YsB�${ s���s{�B� $t �Y� }YsR� R}s{�w?w0D, rw0D, Fw0DD RYBbt $t 3$�� d {B���R}BtIR �B s Bt�TI$8�tR$Btsj {YsB�${ s���s{�B� $t �Y� }YsR� R}s{� BP �Y� I$R{����

8s} WwFD� stI Y�t{� �Y� Rk8ABj Ikts8${R s�� }s��${Zjs�jk R$8}j� �B stsjk9�� 7�� 3$�� 1� qY� ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt PB�

I�ht$t� s �BBI Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R $R �Y� {�$�${sj }B$t� F� BP �Y� WwFD PZt{�$Bt� V ��s`�{�B�k }B$t� b$�Y

F c F�wF k F

�D A�s�R �Y� Rk8ABj ( wdD� wnD

qY� }s��$�$Bt BP �Y$R Bt�TI$8�tR$Btsj 8s}� BP RZ{{�RR$%� Fw0D 8s-$8s {B���R}BtIR �B s ��sI$�$Btsj _B$t{s��: RZ�Ps{�

8s}}$t�� sR �Y� �bB j�s%�R BP �Y� RZ�Ps{� BP R�{�$Bt {st A� R��t $t 3$�� d� es{Y A$� �BZ�Yjk {B���R}BtIR �B s �B�s�$Bt BP�Y� w?w0D, rw0D, Fw0DD 4Bb s�BZtI �Y� j�P� B� �Y� �$�Y� jBA�R BP �Y� NB��t9 AZ����4kTRYs}�I s���s{�B�� <Bb�%��� �Y� NB��t9

s���s{�B� IB�R tB� sjjBb s�A$��s�k }��8Z�s�$BtR BP �B�s�$BtR s�BZtI Bt� stI �Y�t �Y� B�Y�� jBA�� �Y� {B���R}BtI$t�

Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R YsR s RB8�bYs� ��R��${��I ��s88s� bY${Y 8ZR� A� j�s�t�I� qY� ��s88s� BP �Y� {B���R}BtI$t�

Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R {B8}j���jk {Ys�s{���$9�R �Y� sjjBb�I ��s`�{�B�$�R� 7$t{� �Y� }Z�}BR� BP �Y$R }s}�� $R �B RYBb YBb s

{YsB�${ BR{$jjs�B� {st A� PB�{�I �B {s��k s 8�RRs�� $t $�R Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R� b� I�%�jB} PZ��Y�� �Y�R� tB�$BtR $t �Y�t�-� R�{�$Bt�

n 7k8ABj${ *kts8${R

yt �Y$R R�{�$Bt� b� ��%$�b �Y� 8s�Y�8s�${sj {Yst�� BP {BB�I$ts��R bY${Y sjjBbR ��s`�{�B�$�R BP s I$R{���� Ikts8${sj

RkR��8 �B A� �JZ$%sj�t�jk I�R{�$A�I sR $tht$�� A$� R���s8R� 7Z{Y Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${sj I�R{�$}�$BtR BP {YsBR b��� $t$�$sjjk

1

Page 3: i %$ b BP ]YsBR ]B88Zt${s $Bt Ak IAs{3, ]Bt Bj BP 7k8ABj ...ebollt/papers/ieee-transactions-controlofsymboldynamics.pdf3 ((I (3 3 / / I $ Y stI R" ts $8$ j X Y t sI$ j Bj A 8 k R s

3$�Z�� dU 7Z{{�RR$%� 8s-$8s 8s} BP �Y� 8�sRZ�� Fw0D %s�$sAj�� BP �Y� NB��t9 4Bb w?w0D, rw0D, Fw0DD P�B8 eJR� wdD�

3$�Z�� 1U NB��t9:R AZ����4k s���s{�B�� qY$R }s��${Zjs�X�k}${sj" ��s`�{�B�k BP eJR� wdD �$%�R �Y� 8�RRs�� X �s� V�8k�"bY�t $t���}����I ��js�$%� �B �Y� ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt eJ� wnD BP �Y� Bt�TI$8�tR$Btsj RZ{{�RR$%� 8s-$8s 8s} eJ� w1DRYBbt $t 3$�� 1�

n

Page 4: i %$ b BP ]YsBR ]B88Zt${s $Bt Ak IAs{3, ]Bt Bj BP 7k8ABj ...ebollt/papers/ieee-transactions-controlofsymboldynamics.pdf3 ((I (3 3 / / I $ Y stI R" ts $8$ j X Y t sI$ j Bj A 8 k R s

$t%�t��I sR s R$8}j$Pk$t� {Yst�� BP {BB�I$ts��R� $t bY${Y �Y� }�BBPR BP 8stk �Y�B��8R A�{B8� R$8}j� >d(H� ytI��I� 8BR�BP �Y� Ikts8${sj RkR��8R PB� bY${Y 8s�Y�8s�${sjjk �$�B�BZR }�BBP �-$R�R {Bt{��t$t� �Y�$� {YsB�${ }�B}���$�R s�� }��{$R�jk�YBR� PB� bY${Y s {Bt`Z�s{k �B RB8� Rk8ABj${ RY$P� �-$R�R wR�� �-s8}j�R $t >d(� ddHD� 3B� BZ� }Z�}BR�R $t {B88Zt${s�$BtRI�R{�$A$t� {Bt��Bjj�I ��s`�{�B�$�R sR 8�RRs��R $t%Bj%�R {Bt%��R$Bt �B s A$� R���s8 sR s {�Z{$sj R��}�

n�d !t� *$8�tR$Btsj �s}R G$�Y V 7$t�j� ]�$�${sj _B$t�

3$�R� b� {BtR$I�� s Bt�TYZ8}�I $t���%sj 8s}� RZ{Y sR �Y� R$�Zs�$Bt BP NB��t9:R RZ{{�RR$%� 8s-$8s 8s}�

W U >y, KH� >y, KH3 w;D

7Z{Y s 8s} XYsR" Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R >d1� dnH ��js�$%� �B s }s��$�$Bt s� �Y� {�$�${sj }B$t� ?�� ]YBBR$t� s �bB Rk8ABj

}s��$�$Bt� jsA�j�I x)\(,di� ts8$t� $���s��R BP st $t$�$sj {BtI$�$Bt ?( s{{B�I$t� �B�

�7w?(D )

w( $P W 7w?(D c ?

d $P W 7w?(D k ?�

W3 wxD

qY� PZt{�$Bt _ bY${Y jsA�jR �s{Y $t$�$sj {BtI$�$Bt ?( stI {B���R}BtI$t� B�A$� \?(, ?d, ?1, 33i Ak st $tht$�� Rk8ABj

R�JZ�t{��

_w?(D # �w?(D ) �(w?(D3�dw?(D�1w?(D333 wED

*�ht$t� �Y� XPZjjRY$P�" 1 ) \� ) �(3�d�1333 bY��� �( ) ( B� di �B A� �Y� R�� BP sjj }BRR$Aj� $tht$�� Rk8ABj${ R��$t�R BP

(IX stI dI

X� �Y�t stk �$%�t $tht$�� Rk8ABj${ R�JZ�t{� $R s R$t�j��Bt ws }B$t�D $t �Y� PZjjRY$P� R}s{�� �w?(D ; 1� qY�

ZRZsj �B}BjB�k BP B}�t R��R $t �Y� RY$P� R}s{� 1 PBjjBbR �Y� 8���${�

Q3w�, �D )

3

7)(

/�7 � �7/

17, w�D

bY${Y I�ht�R �bB Rk8ABj R�JZ�t{�R �B A� {jBR� $P �Y�k s���� $t �Y� h�R� R�%��sj A$�R� eJ� wxD $R s �BBI X{Yst�� BP

{BB�I$ts��R�" B� 8B�� }��{$R�jk s YB8�B8B�}Y$R8�d

_ U >y, KH�� 7)(

W�7w?�D� I

1, wMD

ZtI�� {BtI$�$BtR Bt W � RZ{Y sR }$�{�b$R� /W I/ k d�1 qY� ��tBZjj$ RY$P� 8s} 8B%�R �Y� I�{$8sj }B$t� $t eJ� wED �B �Y�

�$�Y�� stI X�j$8$ts��R" �Y� j�sI$t� Rk8ABj�

Xw�7D ) �7Ld3 w�D

Vjj BP �YBR� $�$t��s�$�R P�B8 �Y� 8s} W � eJ� w;D Ak eJ� wxD� {B���R}BtI �B �Y� ��tBZjj$ RY$P� 8s} ��R��${��I �B s

RZARY$P��n X U I

1� I

1� 3Z��Y��8B��� �Y� {Yst�� BP {BB�I$tIs��R _ ��R}�{�R �Y� s{�$Bt BP �Y� 8s}� $� {B88Z��R� stI $�R

s {Bt`Z�s{k;�yt RZ88s�k� �Y� }��%$BZR }s�s��s}Y R$8}jk RskR �Ys� {B���R}BtI$t� �B �Y� B�A$� BP �s{Y $t$�$sj {BtI$�$Bt BP �Y�

8s} eJ� w;D� �Y��� $R st $tht$�� $�$t��s�k BP (IX stI dIX� I�R{�$A$t� �s{Y $���s��:R }BR$�$Bt ��js�$%� �Y� }s��$�$Bt $t s

ts�Z�sj bsk bY${Y s{�R j$,� s {Yst�� BP {BB�I$ts��R RZ{Y �Ys� �Y� Ikts8${sj I�R{�$}�$Bt $R �JZ$%sj�t�� 3B� BZ� }Z�}BR�R�

{Bt��Bjj$t� B�A$�R BP �Y� 8s} W $t }YsR� R}s{� bY${Y $R st $t���%sj {B���R}BtIR sjRB �B {Bt��Bjj$t� $�$t��s�$�R $t Rk8ABj

R}s{�� qY� {Bt��Bj B%�� ? {B8}BR�I b$�Y �Y� {Yst�� BP {BB�I$ts��R _ {st �RR�t�$sjjk A� {BtR$I���I �B A� s {BI$t�

sj�B�$�Y8�

dV YB8�B8B�}Y$R8 A��b��t �bB �B}BjB�${sj R}s{�R \ stI 4 $R s Bt�TBt� stI Bt�B {Bt�$tZBZR PZt{�$Bt _ U \� 4� bY${Y 8sk A� I�R{�$A�I

jBBR�jk sR �B}BjB�${sj �JZ$%sj�t{��1WB�� �Ys� }��T$8s��R BP �Y� {�$�${sj }B$t� s�� ��8B%�I P�B8 >y, KH PB� �Y� YB8�B8B�}Y$R8� qY$R j�s%�R s ]st�B� RZAR�� BP �Y� $t���%sj

>y, KH� qY$R $R t�{�RRs�k R$t{� s RY$P� R}s{� $R sjRB {jBR�I stI }��P�{�� bY���sR �Y� ��sj j$t� $R s {Bt�$tZZ8� qY$R $R st BP��t B%��TjBB,�I

��{Yt${sj$�k� bY${Y $R s{�Zsjjk R$8$js� �B �Y� b�jj ,tBbt }�BAj�8 bY�t {BtR��Z{�$t� �Y� ��sj j$t� $t �Y� I�{$8sj RkR��8 w�Y� ��tTRY$P� d(D

bY${Y ��JZ$��R $I�t�$Pk$t� ��}�s�$t� I�{$8sj �-}stR$BtR BP ��}�s�$t� �:R RZ{Y sR PB� �-s8}j� dbx ) (3d�� # (31� qY� {B���R}BtI$t� B}��s�$Bt

�B �Y� RY$P� 8s}R >ddH $R �B $I�t�$Pk �Y� ��}�s�$t� A$ts�k �-}��RR$BtR �( 3�d33�z(dd # �(3�d 33�zddd� �YZR X{jBR$t� �Y� YBj�R" BP �Y� RY$P� R}s{�

]st�B� R���nV RZARY$P� I

1$R s {jBR�I stI ��tBZjj$ RY$P� 8s} $t%s�$st� RZAR�� BP �Y� PZjjRY$P�� I

12 1 �

;V {Bt`Z�s{k $R s YB8�B8B�}Y$R8 _ A��b��t �B}BjB�${sj R}s{�R \ stI 4 � bY${Y {B88Z��R 8s}R Bt �YBR� �bB R}s{�R� U \ � \�

# U 4 � 4� �Y�t _ H ) # H _�

;

Page 5: i %$ b BP ]YsBR ]B88Zt${s $Bt Ak IAs{3, ]Bt Bj BP 7k8ABj ...ebollt/papers/ieee-transactions-controlofsymboldynamics.pdf3 ((I (3 3 / / I $ Y stI R" ts $8$ j X Y t sI$ j Bj A 8 k R s

n�1 N�s�t$t� �Y� p�s88s� $t _�s{�${�

!t� 8$�Y� sR, bYs� �Y� I$R{���� 8s�Y�8s�${sj tB�$BtR BP ��s88s� stI RZARY$P�R Ys%� �B IB b$�Y s 4Bb RZ{Y sR �Y�NB��t9 �JZs�$BtR� eJ� wdD� yt ���8R BP �Y� NB��t9 AZ����4k� stI {B���R}BtI$t� Bt�TI$8�tR$Btsj 8s} eJ� w;D� $P s X("A$� ��}��R�t�R s 4$�Y� s�BZtI Bt� BP �Y� �bB AZ����4k b$t�R� stI s Xd" ��}��R�t�R s 4$�Y� s�BZtI �Y� B�Y�� b$t�� A�PB��}$��{$t� �Y� _B$t{s��: RZ�Ps{�� �Y�t s R}�{$h{ $tht$�� R��$t� BP �Y�R� Rk8ABjR $tI${s��R s {B���R}BtI$t� ��s`�{�B�k 4$�Y�s�BZtI �Y� s���s{�B�� !t �Y� B�Y�� YstI� RZ}}BR� �Y��� $R s s 8$RR$t� bB�I� 3B� �-s8}j�� RZ}}BR� tB $tht$�� bB�I YsR�Y� R��$t� X((" $t $�� qY$R bBZjI $tI${s�� �Ys� tB $t$�$sj {BtI$�$Bt w?w(D, rw(D, Fw(DD BP �Y� NB��t9 �JZs�$BtR �-$R�R bY${Y

8s,�R �bB RZ{{�RR$%� js}R s�BZtI �Y� j�P� b$t�� yt Ps{�� Bt �Y� NB��t9 s���s{�B� {B���R}BtI$t� �B R�stIs�I }s�s8����

%sjZ�R �( ) wd(, 1M, MbnD� �Y��� IB �-$R� $t$�$sj {BtI$�$BtR bY${Y }��8$� AB�Y s X((" R��$t� stI s Xdd" R��$t�� AZ� $t Ps{�

tB� sjj ht$�� j�t��Y R��$t�R IB B{{Z�� qY� 8$RR$t� 8$t$8sj PB�A$II�t bB�IR ��tI �B A� RB8�bYs� jBt��� �Yst �bB A$�R�

G� �-}�{� s XRZARY$P�" BP �Y� PZjjRY$P� BP sjj }BRR$Aj� bB�IR�

yt s }YkR${sj �-}��$8�t�� {B���R}BtI$t� �B �Y� Bt�TI$8�tR$Btsj 8s} RZ{Y sR eJ� w;D� $� $R }BRR$Aj� �B s}}�B-$8s��jkI�IZ{� �Y� ��s88s� BP �Y� {B���R}BtI$t� Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R Ak RkR��8s�${ ��{B�I$t� BP �Y� 8�sRZ��I %s�$sAj�R� 3$�R�tB�� �Ys� stk ��sj 8�sRZ��8�t� BP st �-}��$8�t� {BtR$R�R BP s t�{�RRs�$jk ht$�� Is�s R��� qY���PB��� $t }�s{�${�� $� {stA� s��Z�I �Ys� �Y��� $R tB RZ{Y �Y$t� sR s ��s88s� BP $tht$�� �k}� $t �Y� jsAB�s�B�k�x 7B b$�YBZ� jBRR BP ��t��sj$�k� b�8sk {BtR$I�� Btjk ��s88s�R BP ht$�� �k}� PB� BZ� }Z�}BR�R� 7Z{Y s RZARY$P� $R s R}�{$sj {sR� BP s RB}Y${ RY$P� >nd� n1H�yt B�Y�� bB�IR� �Y��� �-$R�R s ht$�� I$��s}Y bY${Y {B8}j���jk I�R{�$A�R �Y� ��s88s�� Vjj sjjBb�I bB�IR BP �Y� RZARY$P��I {B���R}BtI$t� �B $�$t��s�$�R BP B�A$�R BP �Y� 8s} {B���R}BtI �B RB8� bsj, �Y�BZ�Y �Y� ��s}Y�

3B� �-s8}j�� �Y� PZjj 1TRY$P� RY$P� $R ��t��s��I Ak �Y� ��s}Y $t 3$�� ns wAZ� �Y$R $R tB� �Y� 8$t$8sj ��s}Y ��t��s�$t�

1D� N$,�b$R�� �Y� XWB �bB 9��B:R $t s �Bb" RZARY$P� I

1$R ��t��s��I Ak sjj }BRR$Aj� $tht$�� bsj,R �Y�BZ�Y �Y� I$��s}Y $t

3$�� nA� $t bY${Y �Y� Btjk �bB %���${�R {B���R}BtI$t� �B X((" bB�IR Ys%� A��t �j$8$ts��I� �B���Y�� b$�Y �Y�$� $t}Z� stI

BZ�}Z� �I��R� p$%�t s ht$�� 8�sRZ��I Is�s R�� \?7i]7)(� R$8}jk Ak ��{B�I$t� sjj BAR��%�I bB�IR BP j�t��Y z {B���R}BtI$t�

3$�Z�� nU qY� PZjj 1TRY$P� 1 $R ��t��s��I Ak sjj }BRR$Aj� $tht$�� bsj,R �Y�BZ�Y �Y� $t sD sAB%� I$��s}Y� AD qY� XWB �bB9��B:R $t s �Bb" RZARY$P� ��s88s� I

1$R ��t��s��I Ak sjj }BRR$Aj� $tht$�� bsj,R �Y�BZ�Y �Y� sAB%� I$��s}Y� $t bY${Y �Y�

Btjk �bB %���${�R {B���R}BtI$t� �B X((" bB�IR Ys%� A��t �j$8$ts��I� �B���Y�� b$�Y �Y�$� $t}Z� stI BZ�}Z� �I��R�

�B BAR��%�I B�A$�R� stI ��{B�I$t� �Y$R j$R� s8Bt�R� sjj }BRR$Aj� 1z RZ{Y bB�IR� �Y� s}}�B}�$s�� I$��s}Y {st A� {BtR��Z{��I

sR $t 3$�� n� !t� RYBZjI {YBBR� z �B A� �Y� j�t��Y BP �Y� BAR��%�I 8$t$8sj PB�A$II�t bB�I� 7B8��$8�R� z $R �sRk �B

I�IZ{� Ak $tR}�{�$Bt sR bBZjI A� �Y� {sR� $P $� b��� X((" sR $t 3$�� nA� AZ� I$^{Zj� �B I�IZ{� PB� js���� z� qY��� �-$R�

8B�� RkR��8s�${ sj�B�$�Y8R �B I�IZ{� �Y� 8$t$8sj PB�A$II�t bB�I j�t��Y� RZ{Y sR �Y� RZA��BZ} {BtR��Z{�$Bt I�%�jB}�I

$t Bjj�� 7�stPB�I� ��� sj >nn� n;H ��js��I �B �Y� XPBjjBb��TR��" {BtR��Z{�$Bt >nd� n1H�7$t{�� �Y� Is�s R�� \?7i]7)( $R ht$��� �Y�t $P �Y� ��Z� 8$t$8sj PB�A$II�t bB�I {B���R}BtI$t� �B �Y� Ikts8${sj RkR��8

$R jBt��� �Yst Is�s Rs8}j� R$9�� z k ] � Btjk st s}}�B-$8s�$Bt BP �Y� ��s88s� $R }BRR$Aj�� qY���PB�� �Y� {B���R}BtI$t�BAR��%�I RZARY$P� $R �-}�{��I �B A� s RZAR�� BP bYs��%�� 8$�Y� A� �Y� ��Z� RZARY$P� BP �Y� 8BI�j 8s} eJ� w;D B��-}��$8�t�� qY$R $R ��t��sjjk tB� s R��$BZR }�BAj�8 PB� BZ� }Z�}BR�R R$t{� RB8� {BZ�R�T��s$t$t� sjbskR ��RZj�R $t st�-}��$8�t�� stI �Y$R RB�� BP ���B� b$jj A� R8sjj sR jBt� sR �Y� bB�I j�t��Y $R {YBR�t �B A� ��sRBtsAjk js��� b$�YBZ� stkBAR��%�I $t{BtR$R��t{$�R� VR s ��{Yt${sj tB�� BP }�s{�${sj $8}B��st{�� b� Ys%� PBZtI j$t,Tj$R�R �B A� �Y� 8BR� �^{$�t�8��YBI �B ��{B�I s I$��{��I ��s}Y �B���Y�� b$�Y $�R sjjBb�I ��stR$�$BtR�

yt 7�{�$Bt x� b� I$R{ZRR YBb �Y� ��s88s� {st A� I�j$A��s��jk ��R��${��I �B B&�� $8}�B%�I {Ystt�j tB$R� ��R$R��t{��

xy� {BZjI A� PZ��Y��8B�� s��Z�I �Ys� �Y��� $R tB RZ{Y �Y$t� sR 8�sRZ�$t� {YsBR $t �Y� jsAB�s�B�k� R$t{� 8BR� }B}Zjs� I�ht$�$BtR BP {YsBR

>ddH s�� sRk8}�B�${ ��JZ$�$t� R�tR$�$%� I�}�tIst{� stI �B}BjB�${sj ��stR$�$%$�k� AB�Y BP bY${Y bBZjI ��JZ$�� �$8� �B$t� �B $tht$�k �B {Bth�8�

x

Page 6: i %$ b BP ]YsBR ]B88Zt${s $Bt Ak IAs{3, ]Bt Bj BP 7k8ABj ...ebollt/papers/ieee-transactions-controlofsymboldynamics.pdf3 ((I (3 3 / / I $ Y stI R" ts $8$ j X Y t sI$ j Bj A 8 k R s

n�n !t� *$8�tR$Btsj �s}R G$�Y 7�%��sj ]�$�${sj _B$t�R

yt ��t��sj� st $t���%sj 8s} eJ� w;D 8sk Ys%� z {�$�${sj }B$t�R ?�,i � i ) d, 1, 33, z� stI Y�t{� �Y��� 8sk A� }B$t�R ? ; >y, KH

b$�Y Z} �B zLdT}��$8s��R� qY���PB��� �Y� Rk8ABj Ikts8${R $R ts�Z�sjjk ��t��sj$9�I >n1H Ak �-}stI$t� �Y� Rk8ABj R��

x)\(, d, 33, zi �B I�ht� �Y� RY$P� R}s{� zLd� qY� RZARY$P� I

zLd 2 zLd BP $�$t��s�$�R {B���R}BtI$t� �B B�A$�R BP �Y�

8s} eJ� w;D PBjjBbR �Y� BA%$BZR ��t��sj$9s�$Bt BP eJ� wxD� �7w?(D ) i $P ?�,i c W 7w?(D c ?�,iLd� i ) (,d, 33, z L d� stI

�s,$t� ?�,( ) y stI ?�,zLd ) K� qY� {Ys�s{���$9s�$Bt BP �Y� ��s88s� BP �Y� ��RZj�$t� RZARY$P� I

zLd {B���R}BtI$t� �B s

8s} b$�Y zT�Z�t$t� }B$t�R $R b�jj I�%�jB}�I PBjjBb$t� �Y� ,t�sI$t� �Y�B�k BP �$jtB� stI qYZ�R�Bt >d1H� 7�� sjRB >dnH�

n�; �B�� �Yst !t� *$8�tR$Bt stI 7k8ABj${ *kts8${R BP *$&�B8B�}Y$R8R

*$&�B8B�}Y$R8R s�$R� ts�Z�sjjk Ak _B$t{s��: 8s}}$t� BP s 4Bb� yt ��t��sj� s I$&�B8B�}Y$R8 W U- �- $R �-}�{��I

PB� st ] � d 8st$PBjI - bY${Y $R ��stR%��R� �B s 4Bb $t i] �

7k8ABj${ Ikts8${R BP Y$�Y�� I$8�tR$Btsj RkR��8R $R R�$jj s Y$�Yjk s{�$%� ��R�s�{Y s��s stI I��s$jR Y��� s�� t�{�RRs�$jk

Rj$�Y�� yt }s��${Zjs�� b� ��P�� �Y� ��sI�� �B R�� >;1� ;n� ;;H� qY� PZtIs8�t�sj I$&���t{� BP I$8�tR$Btsj$�k $R �Ys� $t%���$Aj�

8s}R stI Y�t{� I$&�B8B�}Y$R8R s�� t�{�RRs�$jk R$8}j� $t �Y� $t���%sj� bY���sR $t 8B�� �Yst Bt� I$8�tR$Bt� �Y��� 8sk

A� {YsBR� yt �Y� $t���%sj� Btjk s 8stkT�BTBt� 8s} sjjBbR PB� �Y� PBjI$t� }�B}���k bY${Y $R st $t���I$�t� BP {YsBR�

<Bb�%��� 7� 78sj� >d;H RYBb�I �Ys� �Y� PBjI$t� 8�{Yst$R8 BP s YB�R�RYB� sjjBbR PB� {YsBR $t s }jsts� I$&�B8B�}Y$R8�

yt �Y� I�%�jB}8�t� $t �Y� }��%$BZR RZAR�{�$BtR� �Y� Bt�TR$I�I RY$P�R ��4�{� �Y� tBt$t%���$Aj� ts�Z�� BP �Y� {B���T

R}BtI$t� $t���%sj 8s}R eJ� w;D� qY� ��t��sj$9s�$Bt BP Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R PB� $t%���$Aj� 8s}R ��JZ$��R A$T$tht$�� Rk8ABj

R�JZ�t{�R�

1 ) \� ) 333��1��d�(3�d�1333 bY��� �( ) ( B� di3 wd(D

qY� 8s$t ��{Yt${sj I$^{Zj�k BP Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R PB� s 8s} b$�Y s 8B�� �Yst Bt�TI$8�tRBtsj IB8s$t $R b�jj I�ht$t�

s }s��$�$Bt� V tB�$Bt BP �s�,B% }s��$�$BtR $R b�jj I�ht�IE PB� V-$B8 V I$&�B8B�}Y$R8R >dxH� AZ� RZ{Y 8s}R s�� tB�

�-}�{��I �B A� ��t��${� qY� 8B�� ��t��sj tB�$Bt BP s ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt >dEH $R sjRB b�jj I�ht�I�� AZ� }s��${Zjs�jk $t

�Y� {sR� BP s tBtZt$PB�8jk Yk}��ABj${ Ikts8${sj RkR��8 >d�H {BtR��Z{�$Bt BP �Y� ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt $R st B}�t }�BAj�8

PB� 8BR� 8s}R� V b�jj ���s�I�I {Bt`�{�Z�� PB� }jsts� I$&�B8B�}Y$R8R� RZ{Y sR �Y� <�tBt 8s} >dM� d�H� $R �Ys� �Y�

��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt RYBZjI A� s {Z�%� �Ys� {Btt�{�R sjj X}�$8s�k" YB8B{j$t{ �st��t{$�R� 7�� sjRB >1(� 1d� 11H�

V 8s$t P�s�Z�� $t �Y� I�ht$�$Bt BP s ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt $R �Ys� Rk8ABj${ $�$t��s�$�R Zt$JZ�jk I�ht� ��s`�{�B�$�R BP

�Y� 8s}�

; qY� iBj� BP qY� _s��$�$Bt�

V� �Y� �tI BP �Y� }��%$BZR R�{�$Bt� b� 8�t�$Bt�I �Y� I$^{Zj�k $t htI$t� s ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt BP �Y� Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R

PB� Ikts8${sj RkR��8R $t 8B�� �Yst Bt� I$8�tR$Bt $t }�s{�${�� stI $t }s��${Zjs�� $t �Y� RB��R BP Ikts8${sj RkR��8R bY${Y

8$�Y� s�$R� P�B8 s }YkR${sj s}}j${s�$Bt� yt �Y$R R�{�$Bt� b� 8�t�$Bt �bB bskR �B sII��RR �Y$R PZtIs8�t�sj BAR�s{j� �B

{Bt��Bjj$t� Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R�

;�d yR s p�t��s�$t� _s��$�$Bt i�sjjk W�{�RRs�k2

yt >n;H� b� R�ZI$�I $t �$�B�BZR 8s�Y�8s�${sj I��s$j �Y� {BtR�JZ�t{�R BP ZR$t� st s�A$��s�$jk {YBR�t }s��$�$Bt� bY${Y $R

��t��sjjk tB� ��t��s�$t�� !Z� }��%$BZR bB�, {$��I >nnH bsR 8B�$%s��I Ak �Y� 8stk ��{�t� �-}��$8�t�sj$R�R: R�ZI$�R� bYB

b$�Y 8�sRZ��I �$8�TR��$�R Is�s $t YstI� AZ� $t �Y� sAR�t{� BP s �Y�B�k j�sI$t� �B s ,tBbt ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt� R$8}jk

{YBBR� s �Y��RYBjI {�BRR$t� %sjZ� BP �Y� �$8�TR��$�R �B R��%� sR s }s��$�$Bt BP �Y� }YsR� R}s{��

!t �Y� �-}��$8�t�sj R$I�� �Y��� s}}�s�R st $t{��sR$t� $t����R� $t {YsB�${ Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R >;E� ;�H� V {B88Bt}�s{�${� $R �B s}}jk �Y� �Y��RYBjIT{�BRR$t� 8��YBI� 73�3� �B I�ht� s �s�Y�� s�A$��s�k }s��$�$Bt� RB �Ys� I$R�$t{� Rk8ABjR

{st A� I�ht�I P�B8 8�sRZ��I �$8� R��$�R >;EH� qY��� s�� �bB ��sRBtR PB� �Y� }B}Zjs�$�k BP �Y� �Y��RYBjIT{�BRR$t� 8��YBIU

Ei� Bb�t >nx� nEH� I�ht�I {BtI$�$BtR PB� s }s��$�$Bt BP X��{�st�j�R" �B A� �s�,B%� V �B}BjB�${sj }s��$�$Bt \<7i BP B}�t ��{�st�j�R $R

�s�,B% $P� \<7i Ys%� tBtB%��js}}$t� $t���$B�R� RZ{Y �Ys� bY�t Ww<7D �<i W) !� �Y�t Ww<7D R����{Y�R s{�BRR <i � $t �Ys� R����{Y$t� I$��{�$BtR

s�� 8s}}�I �B R����{Y$t� I$��{�$BtR stI {Bt��s{�$t� I$��{�$BtR s�� 8s}}�I �B {Bt��s{�$t� I$��{�$BtR� 7s$I 8B�� {s��PZjjk� b� ��JZ$�� �Ys�

P`wWzwFD,<7D 2 WzwP`wF,<7D stI WzwP XwF,<7D 2 P XwWzwFD,<7D��p$%�t s Ikts8${sj RkR��8 W U - � - � s ht$�� {Bjj�{�$Bt BP I$R`B$t� B}�t R��R� \4>i

>)d� 4> � 4i ) ! w> W) iD� $R I�ht�I �B A� s

�B}BjB�${sj }s��$�$Bt $P �Y� Zt$Bt BP �Y�$� {jBRZ��R �-s{�jk {B%��R- U - ) ��

>)d4>� >n1H� qY� R�� BP $t���R�{�$Bt BP �Y� $8s��R stI }��T$8s��R

BP �Y�R� �j�8�t�R �z

7)�zP w�7Dw4-7D $R $t ��t��sj B}�t� 3B� s Ps$�YPZj Rk8ABj${ ��}��R�t�s�$Bt BP �Y� Ikts8${R� �Y� j$8$� �

z)(�z

7)�zP w�7D

w4-7D

RYBZjI A� s R$t�j� }B$t� $P tBt�8}�k� p$%�t s Ikts8${sj RkR��8 P U&�& Bt s 8�sRZ�� R}s{� w&, B, D� s ht$�� }s��$�$Bt h ) \4>i�

>)d

$R ��t��s�$t� $P �Y� Zt$Bt BP sjj $8s��R stI }��$8s��R BP h �$%�R �Y� R�� BP sjj T8�sRZ�sAj� R��R B � yt B�Y�� bB�IR� �Y� Xts�Z�sj" ���� BP

}s��$�$BtRU ` 7)�

P7wh D� sjbskR ��t��s��R RB8� RZAT�Tsj��A�s� AZ� $P $� �$%�R �Y� PZjj �Tsj��A�s BP sjj 8�sRZ�sAj� R��R 3� �Y�t h $R {sjj�I

��t��s�$t� >dEH

E

Page 7: i %$ b BP ]YsBR ]B88Zt${s $Bt Ak IAs{3, ]Bt Bj BP 7k8ABj ...ebollt/papers/ieee-transactions-controlofsymboldynamics.pdf3 ((I (3 3 / / I $ Y stI R" ts $8$ j X Y t sI$ j Bj A 8 k R s

wdD $� $R �-���8�jk I$^{Zj� �B jB{s�� �Y� ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt P�B8 {YsB�${ Is�s� stI w1D �Y��RYBjIT{�BRR$t� $R s }YkR${sjjk

$t�Z$�$%� stI ts�Z�sj $I�s� ]BtR$I��� PB� $tR�st{�� s �$8� R��$�R BP ��8}��s�Z�� x w0D ��{B�I�I P�B8 s �Z�AZj�t� 4Bb� k��}js{$t� �Y� ��sjT%sjZ�I Is�s b$�Y Rk8ABj${ Is�s ��js�$%� �B RB8� �Y��RYBjI x

�� Rsk s ( $P x w0D c x

�stI s d $P x w0D k x

��

�Y� }�BAj�8 BP Is�s stsjkR$R {st A� R$8}j$h�I� V b�jj {YBR�t }s��$�$Bt $R {j�s�jk $8}B��st�U PB� $tR�st{�� x� {sttB� A�BZ�R$I� �Y� �st�� BP x w0D A�{sZR�� B�Y��b$R�� �Y� Rk8ABj${ R�JZ�t{� b$jj A� ��$%$sj stI {s��k tB $tPB�8s�$Bt sABZ� �Y�ZtI��jk$t� Ikts8${R� y� $R �YZR BP }s�s8BZt� $t����R�� P�B8 AB�Y �Y� �Y�B���${sj stI �-}��$8�t�sj }B$t�R BP %$�b� �BZtI��R�stI YBb 8$R}js{�I }s��$�$BtR s&�{� �Y� �BBIt�RR BP �Y� Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R RZ{Y sR �Y� s8BZt� BP $tPB�8s�$Bt�Ys� {st A� �-��s{��I P�B8 �Y� Is�s�

VR s 8BI�j }�BAj�8� b� {YBR� �B stsjk9� �Y� ��t� 8s}

W U >(,dH� >(, dH,?� d� 1/?� db1/, wddD

PB� bY${Y 8BR� BP BZ� }�BBPR s}}j$�I� !Z� tZ8��${sj �-}��$8�t�R $tI${s��I �Ys� �Y� ��RZj�R b��� $tI${s�$%� BP s 8Z{Y

b$I�� {jsRR BP Ikts8${sj RkR��8R� $t{jZI$t� �Y� Y�tBt 8s}� stI �-}��$8�t�sj Is�s P�B8 s {Y�8${sj ��s{�$Bt�

qY� ��t� 8s} $R s Bt�TYZ8}�I 8s}� stI $� $R ,tBbt �Ys� �Y� Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R $tI${s��I Ak �Y� ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt

s� ?� ) db1� Ak eJ� wxD �$%�R �Y� PZjj 1TRY$P� 1� Bt Rk8ABjR \(,di� qY� �B}BjB�${sj �t��B}k BP \(,di1

$R jt 1� WBb

3$�Z�� ;U q�t� 8s} stI s 8$R}js{�I }s��$�$Bt s� ? ) ��

8$R}js{� �Y� }s��$�$Bt s�

� ) ?� L Q, bY��� Q ; >�db1, db1H, wd1D

$R �Y� 8$R}js{�8�t� }s�s8����� yt �Y$R {sR�� �Y� Rk8ABj${ R�JZ�t{� {B���R}BtI$t� �B s }B$t� ? ; >(,dH A�{B8�RU

* ) *(3*d*1 3 3 3 , bY��� *7w?D ) swAD $P W 7w?D c �wk �D, wdnD

sR RYBbt $t 3$�� ;� qY� RY$P� RB BA�s$t�IU \s,Ai1

� b$jj tB jBt��� A� s PZjj RY$P� A�{sZR� tB� �%��k A$ts�k Rk8ABj${

R�JZ�t{� $R }BRR$Aj�� qYZR� \s,Ai1

b$jj A� s RZARY$P� Bt �bB Rk8ABjR s stI A bY�t Q W) ( w� W) ?�D� qY� �B}BjB�${sj

�t��B}k BP �Y� RZARY$P� \s,Ai1

� I�tB��I Ak _x wQD� b$jj �k}${sjjk A� j�RR �Yst _x w(D ) jt 1� WZ8��${sjjk� _x wQD {st A�

{B8}Z��I Ak ZR$t� �Y� PB�8Zjs >d(HU

_x wQD ) j$8z�

X`�jt]z

z, wd;D

bY��� ]z � 1z$R �Y� tZ8A�� BP ws,AD A$ts�k R�JZ�t{�R wbB�IRD BP j�t��Y z� yt BZ� {B8}Z�s�$Bt� b� {YBBR� d(1; %sjZ�R

BP Q Zt$PB�8jk $t �Y� $t���%sj >�db1,db1H� 3B� �s{Y %sjZ� BP Q� b� {BZt� ]z $t �Y� �st�� ; � z � dM P�B8 s ��s`�{�B�k

BP 11( }B$t�R ��t��s��I Ak �Y� ��t� 8s}� qY� RjB}�R BP �Y� }jB�R BP jt]z %��RZR z s}}�B-$8s��R _x � 3$�� x RYBbR _x wQD%��RZR Q PB� �Y� ��t� 8s}� bY��� b� BAR��%� s {B8}j${s��I� I�%$j:R R�s$�{sR�Tj$,�� AZ� {j�s�jk tBt8BtB�Bt� A�Ys%$B�� 3B�

Page 8: i %$ b BP ]YsBR ]B88Zt${s $Bt Ak IAs{3, ]Bt Bj BP 7k8ABj ...ebollt/papers/ieee-transactions-controlofsymboldynamics.pdf3 ((I (3 3 / / I $ Y stI R" ts $8$ j X Y t sI$ j Bj A 8 k R s

3$�Z�� xU 3B� �Y� ��t� 8s}U tZ8��${sjjk {B8}Z��I _x wQD PZt{�$Bt Ak PBjjBb$t� R�JZ�t{�R BP s {YsB�${ B�A$��

Q ) (� b� Ys%� _x w(D � jt 1� sR �-}�{��I� 3B� Q ) �db1 wdb1D� P�B8 3$�� ;� b� R�� �Ys� �Y� ��s88s� PB�A$IR �Y� j�����

s wAD stI� Y�t{�� \s,Ai1

w�db1D >\s,Ai1

wdb1DH YsR Btjk Bt� R�JZ�t{�U * ) A3A�A w* ) s3s�sD� <�t{�� _x w�db1D ) (�

�stk BP BZ� ��{Yt$JZ�R b��� RB8�bYs� {B8A$ts�B�$sj� ��jk$t� Bt s R$8}j� $I�s �Y� s I�tR� R�� BP 8$R}js{�8�t�

%sjZ�R w$t }s��${Zjs� $P Q $R XIksI${"� BP �Y� PB�8 Q ) �b1zD� sjjBbR ZR �B R�ZIk �Y� ��js��I }�BAj�8 BP {BZt�$t� I$R�$t{�jk

{BjB��I }s�YR �Y�BZ�Y st s}}�B}�$s�� ��s}Y${ }��R�t�s�$Bt BP �Y� RY$P�� $t bY${Y %���${�R Ys%� A��t ��jsA�j�I s{{B�I$t�

�B bY��� �Y� 8$R}js{�8�t� B{{Z�R� 7�� 3$�� E

3$�Z�� EU p�s}Y${ }��R�t�s�$Bt PB� �Y� ��tBZjj$ PZjjRY$P� stI RB8� IksI${ 8$R}js{�8�t�R

!t� BP BZ� }�$t{$}sj ��RZj�R bsR s �$�B�BZR }�BBP �Ys� �Y� �t��B}k {st A� s tBt8BtB�Bt� stI I�%$j:R R�s$�{sR�Tj$,�

PZt{�$Bt BP �Y� 8$R}js{�8�t� }s�s8����� VR RZ{Y� �Y� {BtR�JZ�t{� BP s 8$R}js{�I }s��$�$Bt {st A� R�%���� $t{jZI$t�

R$�t$h{st�jk ��IZ{�I �B}BjB�${sj �t��B}$�R stI s Y$�Y I����� BP tBtZt$JZ�t�RR� !P $8}B��st{� �B �Y� �-}��$8�t�sj$R�

bYB b$RY�R �B {Ys�s{���$9� s Ikts8${sj RkR��8 Ak BAR��%s�$Bt BP s A$� R���s8 ��t��s��I P�B8 �Y� 8�sRZ��I �$8�TR��$�R�

b� RYBb�I �Ys� $t���}���$t� stk ��RZj�R BA�s$t�I P�B8 �Y��RYBjIT{�BRR$t� �k}� BP stsjkR$R RYBZjI A� �-��{$R�I b$�Y

�-���8� {sZ�$Bt�

7}�{$h{sjjk� b� }�B%�I �Ys� �Y� R}j$��$t� }�B}���$�R BP s ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt s�� jBR� $t s R�%��� bsk� G� I�ht�I s

}B$t� ? �B A� �TZtI$R�$t�Z$RY�I $P �Y��� �-$R�R s }B$t� r W) ? RZ{Y �Ys� �Y� �Tts8�I y � K bB�I s{{B�I$t� �B eJ� wdnD

IB�R tB� I$R�$t�Z$RY �Y� }B$t�R� *w?D ) *wrD� G� I�ht�I s }B$t� ? �B A� Zt{BZt�sAjk �TZtI$R�$t�Z$RY�I� $P �Y��� �-$R�R

Zt{BZt�sAj� 8stk RZ{Y r� G� }�B%�I s �Y�B��8 $t >n;H �Ys� R�s��R �Ys� $P � ) Rb1z W) db1� �Y�t �Y� R�� BP Zt{BZt�sAjk

�TZtI$R�$t�Z$RY�I $t$�$sj {BtI$�$BtR $R I�tR� $t >(, dH� yt B�Y�� bB�IR� �Y� $tsA$j$�k BP Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R P�B8 �Y� XAsI"tBt��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt �B I$R�$t�Z$RY �Y� Ikts8${R BP }B$t�R $R R�%���� G� I�R{�$A�I �Y� R$�Zs�$Bt sR A�$t� R$8$js� �B

�Ys� BP ��k$t� �B $t���}��� �Y� �Y� Ikts8${sj RkR��8 Ak bs�{Y$t� s }�B`�{�$Bt BP �Y� ��Z� Ikts8${sj RkR��8� yt �Y$R

R�t��$B� RB8� XRYsIBb�" B� }�B`�{�$Bt BP �Y� }B$t�R {B���R}BtI �B Zt{BZt�sAjk 8stk RZR}�tR$Bt }B$t�R� yt BZ� R�ZI$�R�

M

Page 9: i %$ b BP ]YsBR ]B88Zt${s $Bt Ak IAs{3, ]Bt Bj BP 7k8ABj ...ebollt/papers/ieee-transactions-controlofsymboldynamics.pdf3 ((I (3 3 / / I $ Y stI R" ts $8$ j X Y t sI$ j Bj A 8 k R s

>nn� n;H b� sjRB �s%� 8stk PZ��Y�� ��RZj�R AB�Y I�R{�$A$t� �Y� 8�{Yst$R8 A�Y$tI �Y� $tI$R�$t�Z$RYsA$j$�k� stI PZ��Y��

�jZ{$Is�$t� �Y� }�BAj�8�WBb b� ���Z�t �B �Y� }�BAj�8 BP {B88Zt${s�$t� b$�Y {YsBR� yR $� }BRR$Aj� �B ��stR8$� s 8�RRs�� Bt s {YsB�${ {s��$��

I�R}$�� ZR$t� B�Y�� �Yst �Y� ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt2 yt eJR� wxDTwED b� I�R{�$A� �Y� PZt{�$Bt� � U >(,dH � \(,di1

stI $t

eJ� wdnD� �Y� PZt{�$Bt * U >(,dH� \s,Ai1

� <�t{�� b� $8}jk s PZt{�$Bt � U \(,di1

� \s,Ai1

bY${Y $R Zt{BZt�sAjkT8stkT�BTBt� s� RB8� }B$t�R� WBt��Y�j�RR� �s{Y $t$�$sj {BtI$�$Bt ? ; >(, dH YsR st y�K R�JZ�t{�� stI $P b� ,tBb YBb �B {Bt��Bj

s�A$��s�$jk w�Y� (� d {B���R}BtI$t� R�JZ�t{�D �Y� B�A$� BP - Ak P��IAs{, {Bt��Bj� b� s�� {B���R}BtI$t�jk {Bt��Bjj$t� $�Ry�K R�JZ�t{�� GY$j� �s{Y ? YsR Bt� {B���R}BtI$t� {BI�T$8s�� *w?D� R$t{� * $R s b�jj I�ht�I PZt{�$Bt� $� $R tB� t�{�RRs�$jks }�BAj�8 PB� �Y� }Z�}BR� BP {B88Zt${s�$Bt �Ys� *w?D {st A� Zt{BZt�sAjkT8stkT�BTBt�� 7B $t �Y� R$�Zs�$Bt �Ys� �Y���stR8$���� }jst� ,tBbR �Y� Ikts8${sj RkR��8 %��k b�jj� 8�st$t� YBb �B {Bt��Bj ��s`�{�B�$�R s�A$��s�$jk w,tBb$t� YBb

�B {Bt��Bj $�R ��Z� ZtI��jk$t� \(,di1

Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${RD �B $tht$�� }��{$R$Bt �Y�t �Y� ��stR8$���� $R sjRB {Bt��Bjj$t� �Y�

{B���R}BtI$t� \s,Ai1

Rk8ABj Ikts8${R� qY� ��{�$%�� t��I Btjk ,tBb �Y� ,�k� bY${Y ��JZ$��R ,tBb$t� �Y� }s��$�$Bt �

$t eJ� wdnD� yP Bt �Y� B�Y�� YstI� �Y� ��stR8$���� IB�R tB� ,tBb �Y� ZtI��jk$t� ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt� �Y�t �Y� }BB�{Bt�$tZ$�k }�B}���$�R BP �Y� * PZt{�$Bt 8s,� �Y� R$�Zs�$Bt $8}�s{�${sj� �B Rsk �Y� j�sR�� !P {BZ�R�� �Y� sRRZ8}�$Bt BP$tht$�� }��{$R$Bt $R �$I${ZjBZR PB� st �-}��$8�t�� y� �Z�tR BZ� �Ys� $P s R8sjj {Ystt�j ���B� B{{Z�R� �Y�t ��stR8$RR$Bt���B�R {st B{{Z�� qY� RBjZ�$Bt PB� �Y� ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt I$R{ZRR�I $t 7�{�$Bt x $R sjRB 8Z{Y 8B�� I$^{Zj� bY�ttB� ZR$t� �Y� ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt� V htsj {BtR�JZ�t{� BP ��k$t� �B ZR� s tBt��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt bBZjI A� ��IZ{�I�B}BjB�${sj �t��B}k� stI Y�t{� ��IZ{�I {Ystt�j {s}s{$�k� bY${Y $R st $RRZ� sjRB PZ��Y�� I$R{ZRR�I $t 7�{�$Bt x�

yt Ps{�� s ��{�t� s}}j${s�$Bt $t {YsB�${ {�k}�B��s}Yk 8s,�R ZR� BP X8$R}js{$t�" �Y� }s��$�$Bt I�j$A��s��jk sR s {�k}�${

,�k >;MH�

;�1 qY� 7,�j��Bt BP _��$BI${ !�A$�R stI p�t��s�$t� _s��$�$BtR

i� *s%$I{Ys{,� ��� sj >n�H Ys%� ��{�t�jk RYBbt �Ys� Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R {st A� j�s�t�I RBj�k Ak BAR��%s�$Bt BP s js���

{Bjj�{�$Bt BP �Y� ZtR�sAj� }��$BI${ B�A$�R BP �Y� Ikts8${sj RkR��8� y� YsR A��t Rs$I Ak _� ]%$�stB%${ >;1� ;n� ;;H

�Ys� }��$BI${ B�A$�R s�� �Y� XR,�j��Bt" BP {YsBR� 8�st$t� �Ys� �Y� {B8}j��� {Bjj�{�$Bt BP }��$BI${ B�A$�R ��%�sjR �Y�

���BI${ }�B}���$�R BP s Ikts8${sj RkR��8�

qY��� s�� R�%��sj ��{�t� sI%st{�8�t�R AB�Y $t {B8}Z��� Ys�Ibs��� stI ��t��sj sj�B�$�Y8R >nM� n�� ;(� ;dH �Ys� 8s,�

$� ��sRBtsAj� �B {Bjj�{� �Y� YZtI��IR BP �YBZRstIR BP }��$BI${ B�A$�R BP }��$BIR Z} �B Rsk 1( �B 1x PB� b�jj ,tBbt 8s}R

RZ{Y sR <�tBt B� y,�Is� b$�Y s {���s$t s8BZt� BP {BthI�t{� �Ys� sjj Ys%� A��t {Bjj�{��I� 7$t{� �Y� I�ht$�$Bt BP s

��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt ��JZ$��R �Ys� �%��k $t$�$sj {BtI$�$Bt A� ts8�I Zt$JZ�jk Ak �Y� Rk8ABj Ikts8${R� $t }s��${Zjs� s

b�jj I�ht�I }s��$�$Bt 8ZR� jsA�j �s{Y BP �Y�R� tZ8��${sjjk {Bjj�{��I }��$BI${ B�A$�R Zt$JZ�jk� qY$R $R �Y� {Bt{�}� BP

R}j$��$t� bY${Y $R t�{�RRs�k �B b�jj I�ht� s ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt� yt >n�H� b� I�%$R�I s RBT{sjj�I X}�B-$8$�k" PZt{�$Bt

�B {��s�� s R$8}j� sj�B�$�Y8 bY���Ak �Y� X{B8}j���" j$R� BP {Bjj�{��I B�A$�R {BZjI A� {Y�{,�I s�s$tR� s }�B}BR�I ��$sj

}s��$�$Bt� bY${Y $R �Y�t ��ht�I $t s RkR��8s�${ stI I�{��sR$t� bsk ��js�$%� �B �Y� }�B-$8$�k PZt{�$Bt bY${Y 8B%�R �Y�

}s��$�$Bt sR j$��j� sR }BRR$Aj� Bt �s{Y ��$sj� k {��s�$t� }s��$�$BtR bY${Y s�� {BtR$R��t� PB� sjj }��$BI${ B�A$�R �Y�BZ�Y

}��$BIT8� Rsk� �Y�t Bt �s{Y ��ht�8�t� �B �Y� t�-� B�I�� }��$BI� E L d� b� htI �Ys� �Y� {B���{�$BtR �B �Y� }s��$�$Bt

}BR$�$Bt A�{B8� $t{��sR$t�jk R8sjj� yt }s��${Zjs�� R�� >n�H PB� s {BjB� }${�Z�� BP �Y� y,�Is 8s} }s��$�$Bt� h�R� PBZtI

Ak �Y$R 8��YBI� _��Ys}R �Y� 8BR� $t����R�$t� P�s�Z�� BP �Y$R ��{Yt$JZ�� $R �Ys� Bt{� j$R�R BP }��$BI${ B�A$�R YsR A��t

{Bjj�{��I� �Y� ��{Yt$JZ� $R �RR�t�$sjjk I$8�tR$Bt $tI�}�tI�t�� R$t{� Bt� $R R$8}jk X}s$t�$t�" stI �Y�t X��}s$t�$t�" j$R�R

BP tZ8A��R $t s R}�{$h�I B�I��� qY� $t����R��I ��sI�� RYBZjI $t%�R�$�s�� st sj���ts�$%� sj�B�$�Y8 Ak N�3�st{� BZjst��

��� sj� >;xH �B htI �Y� ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt� sjRB Ak ZR$t� }��$BI${ B�A$�R� AZ� Ak 8��YBIR bY${Y s�� �Y�B���${sjjk I��}jk

�BB��I $t �Y� �Y�B�k BP ��8}js��R stI �Y� ,tB���I R��Z{�Z�� BP }��$BI${ B�A$�R BP 4BbR $t �Y��� I$8�tR$BtR�

x *�sj$t� G$�Y WB$R� k ]BI� i�R��${�$BtR

y� $R tB RZ�}�$R� �Ys� {Ystt�j tB$R� {st I$R�Z}� s R$�tsj ��stR8$RR$Bt� AZ� Zt{Y�{,�I� {Bt��Bjj�I Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R

bBZjI A� }s��${Zjs�jk RZR�}�$Aj� �B A$� ���B�R �%�t b$�Y R8sjj s8}j$�ZI� {Ystt�j tB$R�� y� �Z�tR BZ� �Ys� �Y��� $R s %��k

R$8}j� bsk �B ���s�jk ��IZ{� �Y� %Zjt��sA$j$�k BP s ��stR8$���I R$�tsj �B 8$R$t���}���s�$Bt IZ� �B {Ystt�j tB$R�� Ak s

��{Yt$JZ� I�%�jB}�I Ak �Y� sZ�YB� stI {Bjj�s�Z�R >1�� 1M� 1�H�

yP �Y� 8�sRZ��I %s�$sAj� ? $R �s�����I �B s }B$t� t�s� �Y� ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt s� ?�� �Y�t s R8sjj tB$R� s8}j$�ZI� $t

�Y$R 8�sRZ��8�t� {st P��JZ�t�jk {sZR� �Y� B}}BR$�� A$� �Yst �Y� $t��tI�I ��stR8$RR$Bt �B A� $t���}����I Ak �Y� ��{�$%���

3B� �-s8}j�� $t 3$�� 1� $P Fw0D $R {Bt��Bjj�I �B `ZR� �B �Y� j�P� BP �Y� }s��$�$Bt j$t�� s� s}}�B-$8s��jk F� � nM3x�x;� �Y�t

�%�t s R8sjj tB$R� s8}j$�ZI� 8sk {sZR� �Ys� 8�sRZ��8�t� �B A� 8$R$t���}����I sR A�$t� �B �Y� �$�Y� BP �Y� }s��$�$Bt�

Page 10: i %$ b BP ]YsBR ]B88Zt${s $Bt Ak IAs{3, ]Bt Bj BP 7k8ABj ...ebollt/papers/ieee-transactions-controlofsymboldynamics.pdf3 ((I (3 3 / / I $ Y stI R" ts $8$ j X Y t sI$ j Bj A 8 k R s

x�d yt��BIZ{$t� s ]BI� i�R��${�$Bt T ]B88Zt${s�$t� Bt =tR�sAj� ]YsB�${ 7sIIj�R

qY� RBjZ�$Bt �B s%B$I {Ystt�j tB$R� $R R$8}j�U s%B$I �s����$t� s t�$�YAB�YBBI BP �Y� }s��$�$Bt� 7Z}}BR� ?( $R �s�����I

�B ?d ) ?� L 6 �B $t}Z�� Rsk� s Xd"TA$� $t�B �Y� A$� ���$R���� �Y�t s {Ystt�j tB$R� BP s8}j$�ZI� 6 {st }ZRY ?d A�jBb ?��

stI �Y� ��{�$%�� $t���}���R s X("TA$�� 7$8}jk t�%�� �s����$t� s �s} w?� � 6, ?� L 6D }��%�t�R �Y$R }�BAj�8� Z� �Y�t $t

Ikts8${sj RkR��8R� $� $R tB� }BRR$Aj� �B R$8}jk ��8B%� s ���$Bt P�B8 �Y� }YsR� R}s{�� $� $R t�{�RRs�k �B Ikts8${sjjk

��8B%� �Y� ���$Bt Ak ��8B%$t� $� stI sjj BP $�R }��T$8s��R� qY� ��8s$t$t� R���

-w6D ) >(,dH�� 7)(

W�7ww?� � 6, ?� L 6DD, 6 k (, wdxD

j�s%�R s ]st�B� R��� bY${Y PB� 8stk Bt�TYZ8}�I 8s}R� $t{jZI$t� �Ys� $t 3$�� 1� $R tBt�8}�k PB� R8sjj �tBZ�Y 6� 7��3$�� �� 7Z{Y $t%s�$st� R��R s�� {sjj�I ZtR�sAj� {YsB�${ RsIIj�R �8A�II�I $t �Y� PZjj $t���%sj $t%s�$st� R��� G� Ys%� PBZtI�Ys� �Y�k s�� Y$�Yjk ZR�PZj PB� {B88Zt${s�$t� b$�Y {YsBR� R$t{� �Y�k s�� tB$R� ��R$R��t�� �sRk �B R�sA$j$9�� stI {BR� Btjks ��js�$%�jk R8sjj s8BZt� BP {Ystt�j {s}s{$�k� sR b� I$R{ZRR A�jBb� VjRB $8}B��st�� $R �Y� Ps{� �Ys� �Y�R� R��R {st A�{Ys�s{���$9�I sR s RZARY$P� �8A�II�I $t �Y� RZARY$P� BP �Y� PZjj $t���%sj� stI Y�t{� �Y�k {st A� R}�{$h�I Ak s R$8}j�{BI� ��R��${�$Bt�

3$�Z�� �U Vt ZtR�sAj� {YsB�${ RsIIj� -wXD ��8s$tR sP��� s �s} $R ��8B%�I s�BZtI �Y� ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt� sR }��eJ� wdxD� qY$R ]st�B� R�� YsR Ps%B�sAj� {Ystt�j tB$R� ��R$R��t{� }�B}���$�R sR s 8�RRs�� {s��$��� AZ� {BR�R Btjk Rj$�Y�jk�Y� {Ystt�j {s}s{$�k� sR RYBbt $t 3$�� M

V R$8}j� Ps{� P�B8 �Y� ,t�sI$t� �Y�B�k >d1H }�B%$I�R �Ys� �Y� {BI�R BP �Y� Zt$� $t���%sj s�� B�I���I 8BtB�Bt${sjjk$t �Y� Zt$� $t���%sj bY�t {YBBR$t� �Y� Xp��kT]BI�" B�I�� ]� qYs� $R ? c r $8}j$�R �w?D O �wrD� yt 3$�� ns� �Y� ;TA$�

bB�IR s�� s��st��I j�P� �B �$�Y� s{{B�I$t� �B X]�" qY���PB��� st 6Tt�$�YAB�YBBI BP ?� {st A� {Ys�s{���$9�I Ak s �st��

BP {BI�R� stI s}}�B-$8s��I Ak RB8� zTA$� {BI� ��R��${�$Bt� 3B� �-s8}j�� �Y� NB��t9 8s} sjjBbR �Y� ;TA$� bB�IR (3d((

stI d3d((� bY${Y b� {st R�� $t 3$�� ns� I�ht�R st 6Tt�$�YAB�YBBI BP ?�� w?� � 6, ?� L 6D� qB s%B$I �Y$R t�$�YAB�YBBI�$� $R t�{�RRs�k �B t�%�� ��stR8$� �Y� }Y�sR�� Xd" PBjjBb�I Ak X(("� sR {st A� I�IZ{�I $t 3$�� nA� qY$R }s��${Zjs� {BI�

��R��${�$Bt R�sA$j$9�R �Y� {YsB�${ RsIIj� bYBR� RZARY$P� $R ��t��s��I Ak 3$�� nA�

qB �$%� RB8� $jjZR��s�$%� �-s8}j�R BP �t{BI$t� 8�RRs�� $t �Y� ��R��${��I {YsB�${ R$�tsjR� Rsk b� b$RY �B {B88Zt${s��

�Y� PBjjBb$t� 8�RRs�� X eVq Vi�O�" $t V7]yy PB�8s� Ak ZR$t� �Y� NB��t9 s���s{�B�U

4

� 1� ,

d((((d(

o

� 1� ,

dd((d(d

\

� 1� ,

dd((((d

x

� 1� ,

ddd(d((

R}s{�� 1� ,

(d(((((

\

� 1� ,

d(((((d

p

� 1� ,

ddd((d(

-

� 1� ,

dd(dd(d

V

� 1� ,

dddd((d

�� 1� ,

(d((((d 3 wdED

qB ��stR8$� �Y� 8�RRs�� RZA`�{� �B �Y� XtB PBZ� 9��B:R $t s �Bb" {BI�� s R$8}j� bsk $R PB� �Y� ��stR8$���� �B $tR��� s

AZ&�� A$� Xd" sP��� �Y��� 9��B:R $t s �Bb� ���s�Ij�RR BP �Y� 8�RRs�� A$� �Ys� PBjjBbR� qYZR� �Y� �t{BI�I 8�RRs�� A�{B8�R�

4

� 1� ,

d(((d(d(

o

� 1� ,

dd((d(d

\

� 1� ,

dd(((d(d

x

� 1� ,

ddd(d((

R}s{�� 1� ,

(d(((d((

\

� 1� ,

d(((d((d

p

� 1� ,

ddd((d(

-

� 1� ,

dd(dd(d

V

� 1� ,

dddd((d

�� 1� ,

(d(((d(d 3 wd�D

3Z��Y��8B��� $P �Y� B�$�$tsj 8�RRs�� {Bt�s$tR �Y� AjB{, (((d� b$�Y �Y��� 9��B:R $t s �Bb� �Y� 8BI$h�I AjB{, $R (((dd�qYZR� �Y� ��{�$%�� {st ��{B%�� �Y� B�$�$tsj 8�RRs�� R$8}jk Ak R��$}}$t� s Bt� sP��� �%��k AjB{, BP �Y��� 9��B:R� 7$t{� PB�

d(

Page 11: i %$ b BP ]YsBR ]B88Zt${s $Bt Ak IAs{3, ]Bt Bj BP 7k8ABj ...ebollt/papers/ieee-transactions-controlofsymboldynamics.pdf3 ((I (3 3 / / I $ Y stI R" ts $8$ j X Y t sI$ j Bj A 8 k R s

�Y� NB��t9 s���s{�B�� $�R $t��$tR${ ��s88s� $R sj��sIk $t{jZI�I $t �Y� �Zj� XtB PBZ� 9��B:R $t s �Bb�" �Y� 8�RRs�� X eVqVi�O�" {st tBb A� ��stR8$���I ZR$t� �Y� NB��t9 {$�{Z$� >�H Ak Z�$j$9$t� R8sjj {Bt��Bj 8��YBIR BZ�j$t�I $t i�P� >1H�!t� 8sk sjRB {BtR$I�� s 8B�� R�%��� ��R��${�$Bt RZ{Y sR XtB �Y��� 9��B:R $t s �Bb�" bY${Y {B���R}BtIR �B s js���� �s}s{�BRR �Y� }s��$�$Bt j$t�� yt �Y$R {sR�� �Y� �t{BI�I A$ts�k R�JZ�t{� jBB,R j$,��

4

� 1� ,

d((d((dd(

o

� 1� ,

dd((dd(d

\

� 1� ,

dd((d((dd

x

� 1� ,

ddd(d((d

R}s{�� 1� ,

(d((d((d(

\

� 1� ,

d((d((d(d

p

� 1� ,

ddd((dd(

-

� 1� ,

dd(dd(d

V

� 1� ,

dddd((dd

�� 1� ,

(d((d((dd 3 wdMD

]BZt�$t� �Y� tZ8A�� BP A$�R $t �Y� sAB%� �Y��� ��stR8$RR$BtRU �Y� R��s$�Y� V7]yy 8�RRs�� $t eJ� wdED ��JZ$��R �(TA$�R��Y� XtB ((((" AZ&���I 8�RRs�� $t eJ� wd�D ��JZ$��R �x A$�R� stI �Y� XtB (((" AZ&���I 8�RRs�� $t eJ� wdMD ��JZ$��R M;

A$�R� 7$t{� 8B�� AZ&�� A$�R s�� t��I�I PB� 8B�� ��R��${�$%� {BI�R� �Y� ��stR8$RR$Bt �s�� b$jj A� RjBb��� AZ� �Y� {BI� $R

8B�� $88Zt� �B tB$R� sR �Y� tB$R�T��R$R�$t� �s} $R b$I���

k B%�� ��R��${�$t� �Y� {BI�� Bt� IB�R tB� �s,� PZjj sI%st�s�� BP �Y� ts�Z�sj {YsB�${ Ikts8${R }�BIZ{�I Ak �Y�

BR{$jjs�B�� ��RZj�$t� $t s {B88Zt${s�$Bt RkR��8 b$�Y ��IZ{�I {Ystt�j {s}s{$�k� *kts8${sjjk� �Y� {Ystt�j {s}s{$�k $R

JZst�$h�I Ak �Y� �B}BjB�${sj �t��B}k BP �Y� $t%s�$st� R�� $t bY${Y �Y� 8�RRs��T{s��k$t� ��s`�{�B�k j$�R� qY� $tPB�8s�$Bt�Y�B�k }B$t� BP %$�b $R �Ys� �B}BjB�${sj �t��B}k $R �Y� �s�� s� bY${Y $tPB�8s�$Bt $R ��t��s��I bY�t Bt� BAR��%�R �Y�

RkR��8� yt {B88Zt${s�$Bt� �Y� �B}BjB�${sj �t��B}k $R �Y� {Ystt�j {s}s{$�k A�{sZR� �Y$R �t��B}k I�ht�R �Y� Xs8BZt�"

BP $tPB�8s�$Bt �Ys� {st A� ��stR8$���I �Y�BZ�Y s {B88Zt${s�$Bt {Ystt�j >;�H� qYZR� $t B�I�� �B B}�$8$9� �Y� {Ystt�j

{s}s{$�k� Bt� 8ZR� I�R$�t s {BI� �Ys� 8s-$8$9�R �Y� �B}BjB�${sj �t��B}k� 7$t{� s {YsB�${ RsIIj� $R st $t%s�$st� RZAR��

�8A�II�I $t �Y� B�$�$tsj {YsB�${ s���s{�B�� �Y� �B}BjB�${sj �t��B}k BP �Y� RsIIj� $R ��t��sjjk R8sjj�� �Yst �Ys� BP�Y� s���s{�B�� GY$j� s js���� R$9� BP �Y� tB$R�T�s} sABZ� �Y� }s��$�$Bt ��tI��R �Y� Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R 8B�� �BAZR�

s�s$tR� tB$R�� �Y� ��RZj�$t� {YsB�${ RsIIj� }BRR�RR�R R8sjj�� �B}BjB�${sj �t��B}k� qY$R $R IZ� �B �Y� Ps{� �Ys� b$I�t$t�

�Y� tB$R�T�s} {B���R}BtIR �B $t{��sR$t� �Y� ��s88s�${sj ��R��${�$BtR Bt �Y� }��8$RR$Aj� {BI�R $t �Y� Rk8ABj Ikts8${R

��}��R�t�s�$Bt�

qY� �B}BjB�${sj �t��B}k BP s �s�,B% RZARY$P� I

1$R �JZ$%sj�t� �B�

_x wI

1D ) jtw'w\DD, wd�D

bY��� \ $R �Y� ��stR$�$Bt 8s��$- BP $�R �$�Y�T��RBj%$t� }��R�t�s�$Bt wbY�t $� �-$R�RD� stI 'w\D $R $�R R}�{��sj �sI$ZR

>n1� ndH� qY���PB��� {YBBR$t� s js��� bB�I j�t��Y� z ) d; sjjBbR 1d; }BRR$Aj� }��8Z�s�$BtR BP zTA$� bB�IR� stI ��JZ$��R

s 1d; 1d;

��stR$�$Bt 8s��$- \� 7Z{{�RR$%�jk {st{�j$t� BZ� �Y� {B���R}BtI$t� %���${�R sR $t 3$�� nA $R �JZ$%sj�t� �B9��BT$t� �Y� R$8$js�jk $tI�-�I �BbR stI {BjZ8tR BP \� ]B8}Z�$t� jtw'w\DD sjjBbR ZR �B }�BIZ{� 3$�� M RYBb$t� _x wI

1D

sR s PZt{�$Bt BP �s} b$I�Y 6�

3$�Z�� MU qB}BjB�${sj �t��B}k _x wXD sR s PZt{�$Bt BP tB$R� �s} X� V� �s{Y h-�I %sjZ� BP X� �Y� �B}BjB�${sj �t��B}k BP�Y� ZtR�sAj� {YsB�${ RsIIj�R -wXD $t eJ� wdxD s�� RYBbt� Bt� BP bY${Y $R I�}${��I $t 3$�� �� WB�${� �Ys� $t$�$sjjk� �%�ts Ps$�jk js��� tB$R� �s} X {BR�R Btjk s 8BI�R� I�{��sR� $t _x wXD� ��js�$%� �B 8s-$8sj s� X ) (�

dd

Page 12: i %$ b BP ]YsBR ]B88Zt${s $Bt Ak IAs{3, ]Bt Bj BP 7k8ABj ...ebollt/papers/ieee-transactions-controlofsymboldynamics.pdf3 ((I (3 3 / / I $ Y stI R" ts $8$ j X Y t sI$ j Bj A 8 k R s

x�1 qY� *�%$j:R 7�s$�{sR� qB}BjB�${sj et��B}k z��RZR WB$R�Tps} 3Zt{�$Bt

G� �-}�{� �B}BjB�${sj �t��B}k �B A� s 8BtB�Bt${sjjk tBtT$t{��sR$t� PZt{�$Bt BP >� yt{��sR�I ��R��${�$BtR Bt �Y� ��s88s�

j�sI �B I�{��sR�I {Ystt�j {s}s{$�k� yt{��sR$t� z� �Y� bB�I R$9� {BtR$I���I� A����� s}}�B-$8s��R �Y� �&�{� BP {Bt�$tZBZRjk

$t{��sR$t� �Y� �s} R$9� X P�B8 X ) (� s R8sjj $t{��sR� $t X ��JZ$��R z js��� �B s{{BZt� PB� s bYBj� wR8sjjD A$t bY${Y $R

�j$8$ts��I� 3$�� M ��%�sjR s I�%$j:R R�s$�{sR�Tj$,� PZt{�$Bt _x wXD PB� z ) d;� VR z $R $t{��sR�I� 8B�� {BtR�st� $t���%sjR�

B� X4s� R}B�R�" s�� ��%�sj�I� qY�R� 4s� R}B�R 8$�Y� R��8 RZ�}�$R$t� �$%�t �Y�$� B�$�$t Ak �Y� sAB%� R�JZ�t{� BP R}�{��sjT

�sI$ZR {sj{Zjs�$BtR� �Y� �-}jsts�$Bt j$�R $t �Y� Ps{� �Ys� $t%s�$st{� BP �Y� RZARY$P� YsR ��JZ$��I ZR �B �j$8$ts�� sjj��stR$�$BtR sbsk P�B8 st �j$8$ts��I tBI�� stI BP��t �Y$R 8sk �&�{�$%�jk �j$8$ts�� B�Y�� t�s�Ak tBI�R Ak {Z��$t�TB&s{{�RR �B �Y�R� tBI�R� yt RZ{Y s {sR�� PZ��Y�� b$I�t$t� BP �Y� �s}� stI Y�t{� �j$8$ts�$Bt BP �Y� �Y� t�-� tBI� $t �Y�p�sk B�I��$t�� {sZR�R tB {Yst�� A�{sZR� �Ys� tBI� 8sk Ys%� sj��sIk A��t Ikts8${sjjk �j$8$ts��I $t s }��%$BZR R��}�qY� I�%$j:R R�s$�{sR� R��Z{�Z�� s�$R�R P�B8 �Y� Ps{� �Ys� �Y$R 8�{Yst$R8 B{{Z�R Bt sjj R{sj�R� �B 1z tBI� I$��{��I ��s}Y��}��R�t�s�$BtR BP �Y� Rk8ABj Ikts8${R BP �Y� {YsB�${ RsIIj�R -wXD� PB� sjj z� stI �Y� js���� �Y� zTA$� bB�I R$9� h�R��j$8$ts��I� �Y� R8sjj�� b$jj A� �Y� 4s� R}B��

qY� Ps{� �Ys� �Y� �B}BjB�${sj �t��B}k BP �Y� {YsB�${ RsIIj� I�{��sR�R Btjk Rj$�Y�jk $t s �st�� BP �s} R$9�R w(,�XDYsR $8}B��st� }�s{�${sj $8}j${s�$BtR� 7sk �Y� tB$R� s8}j$�ZI� $R �Xbd(� qY�t �Y� {YsB�${ RsIIj�R b$�Y �s} R$9�R$t w�Xbd(,�XD s�� $88Zt� �B tB$R�� k�� �Y�$� {Ystt�j {s}s{$�k $R Btjk Rj$�Y�jk j�RR �Yst �Ys� BP �Y� B�$�$tsj {YsB�${s���s{�B�� qY��� s�� st $tht$�� tZ8A�� BP {BI�R �Ys� {st ��t��s�� {YsB�${ RsIIj�R b$�Y �s} R$9�R $t w�Xbd(,�XD� 3�B8�Y� R�stI }B$t� BP {Ystt�j {s}s{$�k stI tB$R� ��R$R�st{�� �Y�R� {BI�R s�� �Y���PB�� B}�$8sj� 7$8$js� ��RZj�R s}}�s� �BYBjI PB� Y$�YTI$8�tR$Btsj {YsB�${ RkR��8R >1�H�

E 3��IAs{, ]Bt��Bj BP �Y� 7Z{{�RR$%� �s-$8s �s}

7Z}}BR� �Ys� b� Ys%� s {YsB�${ s���s{�B� BP s 4Bb� qY� $I�s BP {Bt��Bjj$t� {YsBR Ak R�sk$t� b$�Y$t �Y� {YsB�${ s���s{�B�:R

ts�Z�sj A�Ys%$B� Ak ZR$t� Btjk R8sjj P��IAs{, {Bt��BjR bsR s ts�Z�sj AZ� A�$jj$st� �}$}Ystk >dH� ZR$t� R�tR$�$%� I�}�tIst{�

�B $t$�$sj {BtI$�$Bt �B BZ� sI%st�s���

3��IAs{, {Bt��Bj BP s {YsB�${ ��s`�{�B�k 8sk A� ��sj$9�I Ak R8sjj }s�s8���� %s�$s�$BtR� 3B� �-s8}j�� �$%�t s 4Bb

BP ?w0D ; i] bY��� b� �-}j${$�jk b�$�� �Y� }s�s8���� I�}�tI�t{� � ; iz�

�? ) B w?, �D, w1(D

w�s,� �Y� NB��t9 �JZs�$BtR PB� �-s8}j�� eJ� wdDD� Bt� {st YB}� �B �&�{� �Y� ��s`�{�B�k $t s }��I${�sAj� 8stt�� $t �Y�RYB�� �Zt� yt }s��${Zjs�� $P �Y� I�R$��I RYB��T���8 ��R}BtR� $R R8sjj� s N$}R{Y$�9 {Bt�$tZBZR �$�Y� YstI R$I� B }�B%$I�R

�Ys� R8sjj }s�s8���� %s�$s�$BtR RYBZjI RZ^{�� 3Z��Y��8B�� PB� R8sjj �tBZ�Y I�R$��I RYB�� ���8 ��R}BtR�R� �Y� ��JZ$��I

}s�s8���� %s�$s�$Bt {st A� ZR�PZjjk stI �sR$jk PBZtI Ak I$��{�jk RBj%$t� s �bBT}B$t�TABZtIs�kT%sjZ�T}�BAj�8 wq_ z_D�

�B�� R}�{$h{sjjk� RZ}}BR� �Ys� Bt RZ�Ps{� BP R�{�$Bt - � �Y� $t$�$sj {BtI$�$Bt ?( ; - 4BbR PB�bs�I ZtI�� eJ� w1(D �B?d ;-� ?( ) Ww?(D ) 0w?(D w0 $R �Y� �$8� BP 4$�Y� BP �Y� 8s}}$t�� bY${Y $R ��t��sjjk tB� Zt$PB�8 b$�Y ��R}�{� �B ?�stI �Y$R $R tB� s {Bt{��t �B ZR Y���D s� t�-� _B$t{s��: RZ�Ps{� }$��{$t�� ZtI�� s tB8$tsj\Zt{Bt��Bjj�I }s�s8���� %sjZ��(� qY� _B$t{s��: 8s}}$t� b� tBb I�tB���

Ww?, �D U - �-, w1dD

�B �8}YsR$9� s Ps8$jk BP 8s}}$t�R }s�s8����$9�I Ak s{{�RR$Aj� }s�s8���� �� yP b� }��P�� �Y� t�-� $���s�� �B A� ?I�R$��I

�Y�t �Y� t�-� {Bt��Bjj�I ��R}BtR�� $R s RBjZ�$Bt �B �Y� �JZs�$Bt�

?I�R$��I

) Ww?(,�dD w11D

bYBR� RBjZ�$Bt $R PB�8sjjk s q_ z_ BP �Y� 4Bb eJ� w1(D� bY��� �d $R �Y� Zt,tBbt $t �Y� �JZs�$Bt �B A� PBZtI� ZRZsjjk

Ak RYBB�$t� >x(H� 3B� jBt� �$8� BP 4$�Y�� �Y� ��t��sj q_ z_ $R �-}�{� �B A� tZ8��${sjjk Zt��sRBtsAj� �B RBj%�� <Bb�%���R$t{� b� sRRZ8� ,?I�R$��I�?(,1 c 6 PB� s R8sjj 6 k (� stI {Bt�$tZ$�k BP �Y� 4Bb b$�Y ��R}�{� �B }s�s8���� stI R}s{$sj

%s�$s�$BtR� b� �-}�{� �Ys� ,�d � �(,1 b$jj A� j$,�b$R� R8sjj� yt RZ{Y {sR�� s R�stIs�I RYBB�$t� sj�B�$�Y8� AsR�I BtW�b�Bt:R 8��YBI ��t��sjjk bB�,R b�jj >xdHD� {YBBR$t� � ) �( sR �Y� $t$�$sj R��I� V RBjZ�$Bt �-$R�R PB� R8sjj �tBZ�Y6 k (� stI tBtR$t�Zjs� Fs{BA$st I��$%s�$%�� Ak {Bt�$tZs�$Bt BP �Y� ��$%$sj RBjZ�$Bt ?d ) Ww?(, �(D sjBt� s }s�s8����$9�I

RBjZ�$Bt 8st$PBjI� &�w?D� stI ? ) Ww?(, �( L &�w?DD� bY${Y $R st s}}j${s�$Bt BP �Y� $8}j${$� PZt{�$Bt �Y�B��8� yt Ps{��

�Y� j$t�s�$9�I �JZs�$BtR BP %s�$s�$Bt� �&? ) (B(?

w?, �D N &?L (B(�

w?, �D N &�� {st BP��t A� ZR�I �B I$��{�jk RBj%� PB� �d� �B �BBI

s}}�B-$8s�$Bt� bY��� (B(?

stI (B(�

s�� ��R}�{�$%�jk �Y� Fs{BA$st 8s��${�R BP ? stI � %s�$s�$BtR� 7Z{Y ��t��sj$9�R �Y�

8s$t $I�s A�Y$tI �Y� R}�{$sj {sR� BP �Y� !pO ��{Yt$JZ� >dH� $t bY${Y ?I�R$��I $R {YBR�t �B j$� Bt �Y� R�sAj� 8st$PBjI

BP st ZtR�sAj� }��$BI${ }B$t�� qY� }Bj�T}js{�8�t� %��R$Bt BP !pO bsR b�$���t sABZ� $t s ��t��sj Y$�Y�� I$8�tR$Btsj

PB�8 $t >1nH� WB�� �Ys� }s�s8����${ {Bt��Bj bB�,R }s��${Zjs�jk b�jj bY�t {Bt��Bjj$t� ZtR�sAj� }��$BI${ B�A$�R R$t{� �Y���JZ$��I }s�s8���${ %s�$s�$BtR JZ${,jk A�{B8� t��j$�sAj��

d1

Page 13: i %$ b BP ]YsBR ]B88Zt${s $Bt Ak IAs{3, ]Bt Bj BP 7k8ABj ...ebollt/papers/ieee-transactions-controlofsymboldynamics.pdf3 ((I (3 3 / / I $ Y stI R" ts $8$ j X Y t sI$ j Bj A 8 k R s

V R$�t$h{st� ��{Yt${sj I$^{Zj�k �B BZ� }Z�}BR�R $R �Ys� Bt{� �Y� }s�s8����R Ys%� A��t %s�$�I� �%�t Rj$�Y�jk �B Rsk

�( L &�� �Y� 4Bb $R }ZRY�I sbsk P�B8 �Y� tB8$tsj s���s{�B� BP �(� yP �Y� }���Z�As�$Bt $R R8sjj� stI �Y� t��s�$%�

Nks}ZtB% �-}Bt�t�R BP �Y� tB8$tsj �( s���s{�B� s�� js���� �Y�t �Y� �-}�{�s�$Bt $R �Ys� �Y� ��s`�{�B�k b$jj JZ${,jk R���j�

As{, �Bbs�IR �Y� tB8$tsj s���s{�B�� !t �Y� B�Y�� YstI� $P �Y� }s�s8����R b��� j�P� s� �Y� t�b }���Z�A�I %sjZ�R �(L&��

�Y�t �Y� 4Bb {BZjI R���j� �B s t�b stI Rj$�Y�jk I�PB�8�I %��R$Bt BP �Y� s���s{�B� $P �Y� s���s{�B� $R �BAZR�� iBAZR�t�RR

BP s {YsB�${ $R ZRZsjjk �s,�t PB� ��st��I� AZ� �%�t PB� �Y� 8BR� Ps8BZR NB��t9 s���s{�B�� s �$�B�BZR 8s�Y�8s�${sj }�BBP

�Y$R }�B}���k bsR Btjk ��{�t�jk �$%�t >x1H� <Bb�%��� PB� BZ� }Z�}BR�R BP }ZRY$t� st s�A$��s�k A$� $t�B �Y� RY$P� ���$R�s�

IZ�$t� �s{Y RZ{{�RR$%� $���s�$Bt BP �Y� 8s}� }s�s8����${ %s�$s�$BtR 8ZR� A� s}}j$�I s� �s{Y R��}� <�t{�� bY$j� BZ�

}s�s8���� %s�$s�$BtR s�� �-}�{��I �B ��8s$t R8sjj� �Y�k s�� tB� �-}�{��I �B A�{B8� t��j$�Aj� sR $t !pO� qY���PB�� b�

8ZR� {B���{� �Y� 8s}TAsR�I }��I${�$Bt BP j$t�s� ��R}BtR��

G� I$R{ZRR A�jBb s Ajs{,TAB- s}}�Bs{Y� bY���Ak sjj BP �Y� t�{�RRs�k ��8}B�sj stI }s�s8���${ %s�$s�$Bt ��R}BtR�R

{st A� j�s�t�I P�B8 st �-}��$8�t� �Ztt$t� Bt �Y� 4k� RZ{Y sR bsR $t��BIZ{�I $t >1xH�

yt }s��${Zjs�� b� I�R{�$A� Y��� �Y� }s�s8����${ P��IAs{, �Zj�R PB� �Y� RZ{{�RR$%� 8s-$8s 8s} sR $P �Y� 4Bb A�Ys%�I

sR s ��Z�jk Bt� I$8�tR$Btsj 8s}� qY�t b� 8s,� {B���{�$BtR �B sjjBb PB� �Y� Ps{� �Ys� b� %s�k �Y� }s�s8����R s� �s{Y

R��}� �Y���PB�� t�%�� sjjBb$t� �Y� ��R}BtR� ��s`�{�B�k �B R���j� As{, �B �Y� s���s{�B�� 7Z}}BR� b� Ys%� st $t���%sj 8s}�

W� U >y, KH � >y, KH RZ{Y sR s}}�B-$8s��jk �$%�t Ak �Y� NB��t9 RZ{{�RR$%� 8s-$8s 8s}� eJ� w1D stI h-�I }s�s8����

%sjZ�R wRsk �Y� tB8$tsj }s�s8���� %sjZ� $R �( ) wd(,1M,MbnDD� 7Z}}BR� W�+w?D RY$P�R s ( $t�B �Y� {B���R}BtI$t� A$�

���$R�s�� AZ� b� t��I s d wB� %${�T%��RsD� 3B� �-s8}j�� RZ}}BR� �w?D ) (3(d(d(d333 �B �TA$� }��{$R$Bt� stI RZ}}BR� �Ys�

Xw�w?DD ) �wW�+w?DD ) (3d(d(d((333� AZ� b� }��P�� �wW�w?DD ) (3d(d(d(d333� qY�t Ak {Bt�$tZ$�k BP �Y� YB8�B8B�}Y$R8

eJ� wMD stI �Y� 8���${ $t �Y� Rk8ABj R}s{� eJ� w�D� Btjk s R8sjj ��8}B�sj %s�$s�$Bt $R t��I�I T �Y� 8B�� A$�R ZR�I PB�

�Y� ���$R���� �Y� R8sjj�� �Y� ��8}B�sj %s�$s�$Bt� N��

�Ww?D ) WQ�Xw?D � Ww?D, w1nD

bY${Y $R R8sjj� PB� stk {Bt��Bjj�I $���s�$Bt ? ) ?z� bY��� Ww?D $R �Y� Zt{Bt��Bjj�I ��R}BtR�� stI WQ�Xw?D }Z�R �Y� ��JZ$��I

A$� $t �Y� A$� ���$R�s�� qY� 8s}TAsR�I stsjkR$R }��PB�8�I $t >1;� 1EH PBjjBbR �Y� j$t�s�$9s�$Bt BP W b$�Y ��R}�{� �B ��

�Ww?D �(Wd

(�/w�+,?D&�, B� &� �

�Ww?D(We

(�/w�+,?D

3 w1;D

qY� }s��$sj I��$%s�$%�R (Wdb(� ��}��R�t� �Y� XIkts8${ RY$P�" BP �Y� Bt�TI$8�tR$Btsj 8s} IZ� �B }s�s8���� %s�$s�$BtR� �{sZR� �Y� PZjj Ikts8${R B{{Z�R sR s 4Bb BP �Y� I$&���t�$sj �JZs�$BtR� s R8sjj }s�s8���� %s�$s�$Bt IB�R tB� ��t��sjjk

B{{Z� sR }��I${��I Ak �Y� Bt�TI$8�tR$Btsj 8s} ��}��R�t�s�$Bt Bt �Y� RZ�Ps{� BP R�{�$Bt� qY� Ikts8${ RY$P� I�ht�R �Y�

BAR��%�I $���s�$%� %s�$s�$Bt BP �Y� 8s} $88�I$s��jk sP��� �Y� {Bt��Bj }s�s8���� $R %s�$�I�

qY� Ps{� �Ys� st s�A$��s�k 8�RRs�� ��JZ$��R {Bt��Bjj$t� }s�s8���� }���Z�As�$BtR IZ�$t� �%��k $���s�$Bt $R st $8}B��st�

��{Yt${sj $RRZ� bY${Y }��%�t�R ZR P�B8 ���Z�t$t� �B �Y� tB8$tsj }s�s8���� %sjZ� �(� ytR��sI� �Y� zLd0_ XZt{Bt��Bjj�IX

$���s�$Bt BP ? sRRZ8�R �Ys� �Y� }s�s8���� P�B8 z0_ $���s�$Bt �z $R Zt{Yst��I� qY���PB��� $tR��sI BP �Y� tB8$tsj dT*

8s} W�+w?D� �Y� �R�$8s�� BP Ww?D $t eJ� w1nD ZR�R �Y� 8s} W�z w?D bY${Y {B���R}BtIR �B �Y� }s�s8���� �z�

Ww?D ) W�zw?zD3 w1xD

G� �R�$8s�� W�z w?zD Ak j$t�s�$9s�$Bt s�BZtI �Y� tB8$tsj 8s} W�+w?DU

W�zw?zD ) W�+w?zD L w�z� �(D

(W

(�/w?z,�+D3 w1ED

]B8A$t$t� eJR� w1nDTw1ED b� BA�s$t �Y� ��JZ$��I }s�s8���� }���Z�As�$Bt &>zLd�

&�zLd ) �zLd � �z )

WQ�Xw?zD� W�+w?zD� w�z � �(D(W(�

/w?z,�+D

(We

(�/w?z ,�+D

3 w1�D

qY� I��$%s�$%� (Wb( {Ys�s{���$9�R �Y� �s�� BP �Y� R�s�${ 8s} %s�$s�$BtR� qB �R�$8s�� �Y$R JZst�$�k� Bt� 8ZR�

�-}��$8�t�sjjk X$���s��" �Y� Bt�TI$8�tR$Btsj 8s}R BA�s$t�I PB� R�%��sj RZ{{�RR$%� _B$t{s�?� R�{�$BtR� PB� �Y��� %sjZ�R BP

�Y� h-�I sI`ZR�sAj� }s�s8���� �� es{Y �$8� s R$8Zjs�$Bt b$�Y s t�b %sjZ� BP � $R R�s���I� �Y� h�R� $t���R�{�$Bt b$�Y

_B$t{s�?� RZ�Ps{� $R t��j�{��I� A�{sZR� $� $R tB� }s�� BP R�s�${ dT* 8s}� yt BZ� }��%$BZR {Y�8${sj ��s{�$Bt s}}j${s�$Bt

>1xH� b� Ys%� I�sj� b$�Y Zts%B$IsAj� tB$R� 4Z{�Zs�$BtR� Ak s}}j${s�$Bt BP {ZA${ R8BB�Y$t� R}j$t� h�R >xnH� G� �R�$8s��

�Y� I��$%s�$%�R (Wb( P�B8 �Y� �JZs�$Bt�

(W

(�/w?,+D )

W�L6w?D� W�+w?D

63 w1MD

dn

Page 14: i %$ b BP ]YsBR ]B88Zt${s $Bt Ak IAs{3, ]Bt Bj BP 7k8ABj ...ebollt/papers/ieee-transactions-controlofsymboldynamics.pdf3 ((I (3 3 / / I $ Y stI R" ts $8$ j X Y t sI$ j Bj A 8 k R s

*$��{� s}}j${s�$Bt BP �Y� sAB%� PB�8ZjsR bBZjI ��JZ$�� �stIB8 s{{�RR �B $t$�$sj {BtI$�$BtR� bY${Y $R ��t��sjjk tB�

}BRR$Aj� $t j�s�t$t� �Y� ��sj }YkR${sj �-}��$8�t�� G� }�B}BR�I s 8��YBI >1xH BP j�s�t$t� �Y�R� JZst�$�$�R BtT�Y�T4kAk s}}�B}�$s�� 8st$}Zjs�$BtR BP s �Ztt$t� �-}��$8�t�� qY� Ikts8${ �s�� BP 8s} %s�$s�$BtR� (Wdb(�� {st A� j�s�t�I

�-}��$8�t�sjjk� VR I�R{�$A�I $t h�Z��R $t 8B�� I��s$j $t >1xH� b� bs$� PB� �bB $���s��R s� �Y� tB8$tsj %sjZ� �(� A��b��t�-}��$8�t�sj }s�s8���� %s�$s�$BtR� �B 8s,� RZ�� �Ys� �Y� ��stR$�t�R R���j� Bt�B �Y� dT* s���s{�B�� �B s Y$�Y I����� BP

s{{Z�s{k� qY� BAR��%�I t�-� }$��{$t� BP �Y� _B$t{s�?� RZ�Ps{�� sP��� s }s�s8���� %s�$s�$Bt� $R �Y� Ikts8${ ��R}BtR�

Wdw?D� es{Y �bBT$���s��T�$8� $t���%sj BP h-�I �w0D ) �( s�� PBjjBb�I Ak s Bt� X$���s��" �$8� $t���%sj BP �w0D ) �( � 6�

qY� ��R}BtR� PZt{�$Bt ?w0D 8ZR� A� ��sI s{{B�I$t�jk� VP��� Rs8}j$t� �Y$R Ikts8${ ��R}BtR� %sjZ� Wdw?D� b� ��R�� �Y�4Bb �s�� As{, �B �Y� tB8$tsj %sjZ� PB� �bB ��P���t{� �%�t�R� qY$R }�B{�IZ�� {st A� ��}�s��I� B� s }���Z�As�$Bt b$�Y �Y�

Rs8� s8}j$�ZI� AZ� BP B}}BR$�� R$�t {st A� s}}j$�I� k }��$BI${sjjk ��}�s�$t� �Y$R }�B{�RR b$�Y }BR$�$%� stI t��s�$%�

}���Z�As�$BtR� b� j�s�t Ikts8${ ��R}BtR�R Wd�+�6

w?D PB� %sjZ�R BP ? ���BI${sjjk R{s�����I �Y�BZ�YBZ� �Y� $t���%sj� qY�I��$%s�$%� (Wdb(� $R �R�$8s��I R$8$js�jk �B �Y� I��$%s�$%� (Wb(�� P�B8 �Y� I$&���t{� JZB�$�t�U

(Wd

(�/w?,�+D )

Wd�+L6

w?D� W�+w?D

6

3 w1�D

�B�� I��s$jR s�� �$%�t $t >1xH {Bt{��t$t� �Y�R� t�{�RRs�k ��{Yt${sj {BtR$I��s�$BtR �B {Bt��Bj s Bt�TI$8�tR$Btsj 8s}

I��$%�I Ak RZ{{�RR$%� 8s-$8s BP s 8�sRZ��I �$8�TR��$�R BP s I$&���t�$sj �JZs�$Bt� B� ��sj �-}��$8�t�� G� {Bt{jZI� �Y$RR�{�$Bt Ak }��R�t�$t� PB� �Y� h�R� �$8� s }jB� $t 3$�� � BP s {Bt��Bjj�I ��s`�{�B�k BP �Y� NB��t9 �JZs�$BtR bY${Y Ys%�A��t PB�{�I �B PBjjBb s }s�Y bYBR� Fw0D �$8�TR��$�R {B���R}BtIR �B s }B}Zjs� 8�RRs�� s� �Y� sZ�YB�:R YB8� $tR�$�Z�$Bt�

3$�Z�� �U qY� Fw0D �$8�TR��$�R P�B8 �Y� NB��t9 eJZs�$BtR� eJR� wdD� {st A� {Bt��Bjj�I �B stk I�R$��I 8�RRs��� bY�tRZ{{�RR$%� 8s-$8s s�� ��sI ��js�$%� �B �Y� ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt� bY${Y $R �Y� YB�$9Bt�sj j$t�� qY$R }s��${Zjs� Fw0D �$8�TR��$�R $R P�B8 �Y� w?w0D, rw0D, Fw0DD ��s`�{�B�k RYBbt $t 3$�� d� qY� ZtI��j$t�I A$�R I�tB�� tBtT$tPB�8s�$Bt A�s�$t� AZ&��A$�R bY${Y s�� t�{�RRs�k �$�Y�� IZ� �B tBt8s-$8sj �B}BjB�${sj �t��B}k BP �Y� ZtI��jk$t� s���s{�B�� B� PZ��Y�� {BI���R��${�$BtR bY${Y b��� sII�I PB� tB$R� ��R$R�st{�� sR I$R{ZRR�I $t 7�{� x� qY� {BI� ZR�I bsR �Y� XtBT�bB 9��B:R $t s �Bb"�Zj�� bY${Y ��JZ$��R s AZ&�� Xd"TA$� A� $tR����I sP��� �%��k X("TA$� s}}�s�R� qY� 8�RRs�� $R �t{BI�I $t R�stIs�I V7]yy�stI ��JZ$��R EnTA$�R� AZ� b$�Y �Y� �-��s nn AZ&�� A$�R� �Y� �B�sj ��stR8$RR$Bt $R RjBb�I �B �ETA$�R� qY$R }s��${Zjs�jk

��R��${�$%� {BI� YsR s �B}BjB�${sj �t��B}k BP _x ) jtwdL$x

1D � (3;Md1� AZ� �$%�R s }s��${Zjs�jk b$I� tB$R� �s}�

V{,tBbj�I�8�t�R

qY� sZ�YB� bsR RZ}}B���I Ak �Y� W73 ZtI�� p�st� WB� *�7T��(;En� IZ�$t� d���T1(((� stI {Z���t�jk ZtI�� WB� *�7T

((�dnd;� y bBZjI j$,� �B �Yst,� O$t�T]Y�t� Ns$� �$jBR *Bjt$,� ]�jRB p��AB�$� �s�Bj ��k{9,BbR,$� q�I 7�stPB�I� iZRjst

*s%$I{Ys{,� �Z,�RY *Ys8sjs� e�${ �BR��j${Y� F$8 ��$RR� stI Vs�Bt �j�AstB&� b$�Y bYB8 y Ys%� YsI �Y� }j�sRZ�� �B

bB�, Bt ��R�s�{Y $t �Y� s��sR BP {B88Zt${s�$Bt b$�Y {YsBR� B� Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R� B� {Bt��Bj BP {YsBR� stI RB8� BP �Y$R

��R�s�{Y $R ��%$�b�I Y����

d;

Page 15: i %$ b BP ]YsBR ]B88Zt${s $Bt Ak IAs{3, ]Bt Bj BP 7k8ABj ...ebollt/papers/ieee-transactions-controlofsymboldynamics.pdf3 ((I (3 3 / / I $ Y stI R" ts $8$ j X Y t sI$ j Bj A 8 k R s

i�P���t{�R

>dH e� !��� ]� p��AB�$� F�V� OB�,�� X]Bt��Bjj$t� ]YsBR�" _YkR� i�%� N����� E; dd�ETdd�� wd��(D�

>1H 7� <sk�R� ]� p��AB�$� stI e� !��� _YkR� i�%� N���� �(� n(nd wd��nD�

>nH 7� <sk�R� ]� p��AB�$� e� !��� stI V� �s�,� _YkR� i�%� N���� �n� d�Md wd��;D�

>;H e� W� NB��t�9� F� V�8BR� 7{$� 1(� dn( wd�EnD�

>xH q� Os8sIs� <� 3Z`$Rs,s� X7�sA$j$�k �Y�B�k BP Rkt{Y�Bt$9�I 8B�$Bt $t {BZ}j�ITBR{$jjs�B� RkR��8R� yy�"

_�B��� qY�B�� _YkR� �( d1;( wd�MnD� q� Os8sIs� <� 3Z`$Rs,s� X7�sA$j$�k �Y�B�k BP Rkt{Y�Bt$9�I 8B�$Bt $t {BZ}j�ITBR{$jjs�B� RkR��8R� yyy�" _�B��� qY�B�� _YkR� �1 MMx wd�M;D�

>EH z�7� VP�s$8B%${Y� W� W� z��${Y�%� �� y� isA$tB%${Y� 7�B{YsR�${ Rkt{Y�Bt$9s�$Bt BP BR{$jjs�$BtR $t I$RR$}s�$%� RkR��8R�"

yt%� z=� isR$Bh9� i_+Ve] 1� ��xTM(n wd�MED�

>�H N� �� _�{B�s� q� N� ]s��Bjj� X7kt{Y�Bt$9s�$Bt $t {YsB�${ RkR��8R�" _YkR� i�%� N���� E; M1d wd��(D�

>MH N� �� _�{B�s� q� N� ]s��Bjj� p� V� FBYtRBt� *� F� �s�� X3ZtIs8�t�sjR BP Rkt{Y�Bt$9s�$Bt $t {YsB�${ RkR��8R�{Bt{�}�R� stI s}}j${s�$BtR�" ]YsBR � x1(Tx;n wd���D�

>�H �� ]ZB8B stI V� z� !}}�tY�$8� _YkR� i�%� N���� �d� Ex wd��nD�

>d(H ]� iBA$tRBt� *kts8${sj 7kR��8RU 7�sA$j$�k� 7k8ABj *kts8${R� stI ]YsBR� w]i] _��RR� Vtt V�AB� d��xD�

>ddH i� N� *�%st�k� Vt yt��BIZ{�$Bt �B ]YsB�${ *kts8${sj 7kR��8R� 1tI �I$�$Bt� i�IbBBI ]$�k� ]VU VII$RBt G�Rj�k

d�M��

>d1H F� �$jtB� stI G� qYZ�R�Bt� !t $���s��I 8s}R BP �Y� $t���%sj y stI yy _�$t{��Bt =t$%��R$�k _��RR w_�$t{��Bt� d���D�

>dnH G� I� ��jB� 7� %st 7���$t� !t�T*$8�tR$Btsj *kts8${R� W�b OB�,� WOU 7}�$t���Tz��js� d��1�

>d;H 7� 78sj�� X*$&���t�$sAj� *kts8${sj 7kR��8R�" Zjj V�7� �n� �;� wd�E�D�

>dxH i� Bb�t� eJZ$j$A�$Z8 7�s��R stI �Y� e��BI${ qY�B�k BP VtBRB% *$&�B8B�}Y$R8R� 7}�$t���Tz��js�� ��j$t d��x�

>dEH *�F� iZIBj}Y� 3ZtIs8�t�sjR BP ��sRZ�sAj� *kts8${R� e��BI${ qY�B�k Bt N�A�R�Z� 7}s{�R� ]js��tIBt _��RR w!-T

PB�I� d��(D�

>d�H N�T7� OBZt�� Xe��BI${ qY�B�k BP *$&���t�$sAj� *kts8${sj 7kR��8R�" }��}�$t��

>dMH _� ]%$�stB%${� p� pZts�s�t�� stI y� _�B{s{{$s� _YkR� i�%� V nM� dx(n wd�MMD�

>d�H _� ]%$�stB%${� X_��$BI${ B�A$�R sR �Y� R,�j��Bt BP {jsRR${sj stI JZst�Z8 {YsBR�" _YkR${s * xd� dnM wd��dD�

>1(H _� p�sRRA������ <� �st�9 stI =� �B�t$�� F� _YkR� V 11� x1d� wd�M�D�

>1dH 3� ]Y�$R�$stR�t� V� _Bj$�$� XpZ$Ij$t�R PB� �Y� {BtR��Z{�$Bt BP s ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$Bt $t �Y� R�stIs�I 8s}�" _YkR${s

* d(�� n1 wd���D� 3� ]Y�$R�$stR�t� V� _Bj$�$� X7k8ABj${ �t{BI$t� $t Rk8}j�{�${ 8s}R�" WBtj$t�s�$�k �� dE1n wd��ED�

>11H �� <stR�t� X7k8ABj${ Ikts8${RU !� 3$t$�� I$R}��R$%� A$jj$s�IR�" WBtj$t�s�$�k E� �xn wd��nD� �� <stR�t� X_�Zt$t�

BP B�A$�R $t PBZ�TI$R, stI Yk}��ABjs A$jj$s�IR�" ]<V!7 1� �d wd��1D�

>1nH 3� iB8��$sR� ]� p��AB�$� e� !�� stI G� *sksbstRs� X]Bt�Bjj$t� {YsB�${ Ikts8${sj RkR��8R"� _YkR${s * xM wd((1D

dExTd�1 wd��1D�

>1;H e� Bjj�� �� *Bjt$,� "et{BI$t� ytPB�8s�$Bt $t ]Y�8${sj ]YsBR Ak ]Bt��Bjj$t� 7k8ABj${ *kts8${R�" _YkR� i�%� e�xx E E;(;TE;dn� wd���D�

>1xH �� *Bjt$,� e� Bjj�� "]B88Zt${s�$Bt b$�Y ]Y�8${sj ]YsBR $t �Y� _��R�t{� BP WB$R��" ]YsBR M n� �(1T�d(� wd��MD�

>1EH e� Bjj�� X]Bt��Bjj$t� �Y� ]YsB�${ NB�$R�${ �s}�" _iy�=7 zyy d� dTdM� wd���D�

>1�H e�$, Bjj�� O$t�T]Y�t� Ns$� ]�jRB p��AB�$� "VtsjkR$R BP �Y� qB}BjB�${sj et��B}k %��RZR WB$R� i�R$R�st{� q�sI�T!&

bY�t ]B88Zt${s�$t� b$�Y ]YsBR�" _YkR${sj i�%$�b N�����R� �� d� n�M�Tn��(� d����

dx

Page 16: i %$ b BP ]YsBR ]B88Zt${s $Bt Ak IAs{3, ]Bt Bj BP 7k8ABj ...ebollt/papers/ieee-transactions-controlofsymboldynamics.pdf3 ((I (3 3 / / I $ Y stI R" ts $8$ j X Y t sI$ j Bj A 8 k R s

>1MH e�$, Bjj�� O$t�T]Y�t� Ns$� "*kts8${R BP {BI$t� $t {B88Zt${s�$t� b$�Y {YsBR�"_YkR${sj i�%$�b e� xM 1 d�1;Td�nE�

d��M�

>1�H OT] Ns$� e� Bjj�� ]� p��AB�$� "]B88Zt${s�$t� b$�Y {YsBR ZR$t� Y$�YTI$8�tR$Btsj Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R�" _YkR${R

N�����R V 1xx wdT1D wd���D �x�

>n(H =� <Z�At��� W� � VA�sYs8� stI ]� !� G�$RRU X*$8�tR$BtR stI �t��B}$�R BP {YsB�${ $t��tR$�k }ZjRs�$BtR $t s

R$t�j�T8BI� Ps�T$tP�s��I W<n jsR���" _YkR� i�%� V ;(� }� Enx; wd�M�D

>ndH �_� �$�{Y�tR� 7k8ABj${ *kts8${R� !t�TR$I�I� qbBTR$I�I stI ]BZt�sAj� 7�s�� �s�,B% 7Y$P�R� 7}�$t��� wW�b OB�,�

d��MD�

>n1H *� N$tI stI � �s�{ZR� Vt yt��BIZ{�$Bt �B 7k8ABj${ *kts8${R stI ]BI$t�� ]s8A�$I�� =t$%� _��RR wW�b OB�,�

d��xD�

>nnH e� Bjj�� q�7�stPB�I� OT]� Ns$� �� �k{9,BbR,$� Xzsj$I$�k BP �Y��RYBjIT{�BRR$t� stsjkR$R BP Rk8ABj${ Ikts8${R P�B8

{YsB�${ �$8� R��$�R�" _YkR� i�%� N���� Mx dE nx1;Tnx1�

>n;H e� Bjj�� q�7�stPB�I� OT]� Ns$� �� �k{9,BbR,$� XGYs� 7k8ABj${ *kts8${R *B G� p�� G$�Y V �$R}js{�I _s��$�$Bt2

!t �Y� zsj$I$�k BP qY��RYBjI ]�BRR$t�R VtsjkR$R BP ]YsB�${ q$8�T7��$�R�" }��}�$t� RZA8$���I �B _YkR${s *�

>nxH i� Bb�t� X�s�,B% _s��$�$BtR PB� V-$B8 V *$&�B8B�}Y$R8R�" V8� F� �s�Y �1� �1xT�;� wd��(D�

>nEH i� Bb�t� eJZ$j$A�$Z8 7�s��R stI �Y� e��BI${ qY�B�k BP VtBRB% *$&�B8B�}Y$R8R� 7}�$t���Tz��js�� ��j$t wd��xD�

>n�H i� *s%$I{Ys{,� OT] Ns$� e� Bjj�� �� *Ys8sjs� XeR�$8s�$t� ��t��s�$t� }s��$�$BtR BP {YsB�${ RkR��8R Ak ZtR�sAj�

}��$BI${ B�A$�R�" _YkR� i�%� e� Ed 1 dnxnTdnxE� w1(((D�

>nMH i� N� *s%$I{Ys{, stI Ns$� O$t�T]Y�t�� FZt� n� d���� e^{$�t� sj�B�$�Y8 PB� I���{�$t� ZtR�sAj� }��$BI${ B�A$�R $t

{YsB�${ RkR��8R� {YsBTIkt\��(E((�� ; }}�

>n�H _� 7{Y8�j{Y�� stI *$s,BtBR� 3� �� d��M� p�t��sj s}}�Bs{Y �B �Y� jB{sj$9s�$Bt BP ZtR�sAj� }��$BI${ B�A$�R $t {YsB�${

Ikts8${sj RkR��8R� _YkR� i�%� e x�wnDU1�n�T1�;E�

>;(H _� 7{Y8�j{Y�� stI *$s,BtBR� 3� �� d���� *���{�$t� =tR�sAj� _��$BI${ !�A$�R BP ]YsB�${ *kts8${sj 7kR��8R� _Yk�

i�%� N���� �Mw1xDU;�nnTE�

>;dH 3� �� *$s,BtBR� _� 7{Y8�j{Y��� stI $Ys8� !� d��M� 7kR��8s�${ ]B8}Z�s�$Bt BP �Y� N�sR� =tR�sAj� _��$BI${

!�A$�R $t ]YsB�${ V���s{�B�R� _YkR� i�%� N���� Mdw1(DU;n;�T;nx1�

>;1H _�]%$�stB%${� Xyt%s�$st� ��sRZ��8�t�R BP R��st�� R��R $t ���8R BP {k{j�R�" _YkR� i�%� N��� Ed� 1�1�T1�n1 wd�MMD�

>;nH _�]%$�stB%${� X_��$BI${ B�A$�R sR �Y� R,�j��Bt BP {jsRR${sj stI JZst�Z8 {YsBR�" _YkR${s * xd dnMTdxd wd��dD�

>;;H _� ]%$�stB%${� X*kts8${sj s%��s�$t� $t ���8R BP }��$BI${ B�A$�R�" _YkR${s * Mn� d(�Td1n wd��xD�

>;xH �� N�P�st{� _� pjB�$�Z-� 3� _s}B&� 3� �Bj�R�$� e� V�$8BtIB� _YkR� i�%� N���� �n dnE; wd��;D� p� BZjst�� 7�

$�jsbR,$� *� *��B9$��� �� N�P�st{� _YkR� i�%� e xx inM(d wd���D� p� BZjst�� �� N�P�st{� 7� $�jsbR,$� *� *��B9$���

_YkR� i�%� e xx x(M1 wd���D�

>;EH F� �Z��YR� ��� sj�� ]YsBR x� MM wd��xD� �� N�Y�8st stI V� � i�{Y�R���� _YkR� i�%� N���� �M� d wd���D� ]� 7� *sb���� sj�� _YkR� i�%� e x�� 1Mdd wd��MD� i� et�A���� ]� 7{Y�&{9k,� i� ��s8}�� F� �Z��YR� stI i� �j$��j� }}� 1�dT1M1

$t WBtj$t�s� q$8� 7��$�R VtsjkR$R BP _YkR$BjB�${sj *s�s w7}�$t���Tz��js�� <�$I�jA���� d��MD�

>;�H �� �$R{Ys$,Bb� ��� sj�� _YkR� i�%� N���� M1� dd;; wd���D�

>;MH e� Vj%s��9� V� 3��tstI�9� _� ps�{$s� F� F$8�t�9� V� �s�{stB� XW�b s}}�Bs{Y �B {YsB�${ �t{�k}�$Bt�" _YkR� N����

V 1En� n�n wd���D�

>;�H i� e� jsYZ�� _�$t{$}j�R stI _�s{�${� BP ytPB�8s�$Bt qY�B�k wVII$RBtTG�Rj�k� d�MMD�

>x(H G� _��RR� � 3jstt��k� 7� q�Z,BjR,k stI G� z�����j$t�� WZ8��${sj i�{$}�R $t ]� qY� V�� BP 7{$�t�$h{ ]B8}Z�$t��]s8A�$I�� =t$%��R$�k _��RR� W�b OB�,� wd�MMD�

>xdH e� Bjj�� X]B8A$ts�B�$sj ]Bt��Bj BP pjBAsj *kts8${R $t s ]YsB�${ *$&���t�$sj eJZs�$Bt�" �B s}}�s� yt���ts�$BtsjFBZ�tsj BP $PZ�{s�$Bt stI ]YsBR�

dE

Page 17: i %$ b BP ]YsBR ]B88Zt${s $Bt Ak IAs{3, ]Bt Bj BP 7k8ABj ...ebollt/papers/ieee-transactions-controlofsymboldynamics.pdf3 ((I (3 3 / / I $ Y stI R" ts $8$ j X Y t sI$ j Bj A 8 k R s

>x1H G� qZ{,��� XqY� NB��t9 s���s{�B� �-$R�R�" ]� i� V{sI� 7{$� _s�$R� �� n1M� 7�$� y� dd��Td1(1� d����

>xnH �� 3� <Z�{Y$tRBt� V]� q�stRs{�$BtR Bt �s�Y�8s�${sj 7BP�bs�� d1� dx( wd�MED�

d�