i....lockhart, roger jay lockhart, francis lockhart, emma a. barton, earl inman, alta barton, sandra...

83
BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD APPLICANT: CNX Gas Company LLC RELIEF SOUGHT: POOLING LOCATION: SEE EXHIBITS "A" AND "Al" UNIT NUMBER: R(-I) IN THE OAKWOOD COALBED METHANE GAS FIELD I BUCHANAN COUNTY, VIRGINIA DIVISION OF GAS AND OIL DOCKET NO.: VGOB 17-071$ -4134 HEARING DATE: July 18, 2017 APPLICATION I. Annlicant and its counsel: Applicant is CNX Gas Company LLC, 627 Claypool Hill Mall Road, Cedar Bluff, Virginia, 24609. Applicant's counsel is Mark A. Swattz, Hilliard & Swartz, LLP, 122 Capitol Street, FL 2, Charleston, WV 25301. 2. Relief souuht: Pooling under Oakwood Coalbed Methane Gas Field I. 3. Leual Authoritv: Va. Code Ann. $ 45.1-361.1 et seel. 4 VAC 25-160-10 et ~se . and relevant Virginia Gas and Oil Board Orders heretofore promulgated pursuant to law including OGCB 3-90; VGOB-91-1119-162; VGOB 92/02/16-0336; and VGOB 93/03/16-0349. 4. Tvne of well(sI: Coalbed methane, including increased density wells as required by mining plans. 5. Permit numbers. if anv: 6. Plat: Annexed hereto are Exhibit A and the Tract Identifications for Exhibit A. The Plat shows the size and shape of the unit and the boundaries of the tracts within the unit. The plat is certified by a licensed professional en(pneer and is attested by the undersigned on behalf of the applicant to be in conformity with existing orders issued by the Board. 7. Status of interests to be nooled/re-nooled and Annlicant'tandinu: The respondents whose interests are sought to be pooled/re-pooled by the Applicant are: Clyde Boyd, Arlene Decl, James Curtis Baldwin, Laura Virginia Manier, Henry IVathan Baldwin, Jr., Jody Baldwin, Lloyd. Michael Cook, Mark Anthony Cook, Daris Mesa Cook, Ercil Cook, Jr., Ursula Cook, Catherine Boyd, Betty Sturgeon Baker Boyd, James Bryant Boyd, Michael Leon Boyd, Darrell Gene Boyd, Bradley Dean Boyd, Bdcky Allen Boyd, Christine Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3 hereto which describes their interests/claims. The respondents and others, if any, whose interests are subject to escrow under $ 45.1-361.21.D. are identified at Exhibit E. The annexed Exhibit B-3 at pages 2 and 3 sets forth the total interest(s) held by Applicant in the unit. Page Number 1.

Upload: others

Post on 06-Aug-2020

6 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

APPLICANT: CNX Gas Company LLC

RELIEF SOUGHT: POOLING

LOCATION: SEE EXHIBITS "A" AND "Al"

UNIT NUMBER: R(-I)IN THE OAKWOOD COALBED METHANE GAS FIELD I

BUCHANAN COUNTY, VIRGINIA

DIVISION OF GAS AND OILDOCKET NO.: VGOB 17-071$-4134

HEARING DATE: July 18, 2017

APPLICATION

I. Annlicant and its counsel: Applicant is CNX Gas Company LLC, 627Claypool Hill Mall Road, Cedar Bluff, Virginia, 24609. Applicant's counsel is Mark A. Swattz,Hilliard & Swartz, LLP, 122 Capitol Street, FL 2, Charleston, WV 25301.

2. Relief souuht: Pooling under Oakwood Coalbed Methane Gas Field I.

3. Leual Authoritv: Va. Code Ann. $45.1-361.1et seel. 4 VAC 25-160-10 et ~se .and relevant Virginia Gas and Oil Board Orders heretofore promulgated pursuant to lawincluding OGCB 3-90; VGOB-91-1119-162;VGOB 92/02/16-0336; and VGOB 93/03/16-0349.

4. Tvne of well(sI: Coalbed methane, including increased density wells as requiredby mining plans.

5. Permit numbers. if anv:

6. Plat: Annexed hereto are Exhibit A and the Tract Identifications for Exhibit A.The Plat shows the size and shape of the unit and the boundaries of the tracts within the unit.The plat is certified by a licensed professional en(pneer and is attested by the undersigned onbehalf of the applicant to be in conformity with existing orders issued by the Board.

7. Status of interests to be nooled/re-nooled and Annlicant'tandinu: Therespondents whose interests are sought to be pooled/re-pooled by the Applicant are:

Clyde Boyd, Arlene Decl, James Curtis Baldwin, Laura Virginia Manier, HenryIVathan Baldwin, Jr., Jody Baldwin, Lloyd. Michael Cook, Mark Anthony Cook, Daris MesaCook, Ercil Cook, Jr., Ursula Cook, Catherine Boyd, Betty Sturgeon Baker Boyd, James BryantBoyd, Michael Leon Boyd, Darrell Gene Boyd, Bradley Dean Boyd, Bdcky Allen Boyd, ChristineLockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton,Sandra Barton Hibbi tts

Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3 hereto which describes their interests/claims. Therespondents and others, if any, whose interests are subject to escrow under $45.1-361.21.D.are identifiedat Exhibit E. The annexed Exhibit B-3 at pages 2 and 3 sets forth the total interest(s) held by Applicant inthe unit.

Page Number 1.

Page 2: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

VGOB 17-0718-4134Page 2 of 2

8. Formation(s) to be nroduced and estimates: All coal seams and associatedstrata below the Tiller seam of coal all as more particularly described in the annexed proposedorder. The estimated total production from subject unit is 125 to 550 MMCF. The estimatedamount of reserves from the subject drilling unit is 125 to 550 MMCF. These figures concerningestimated production and the amount of reserves are, however, estimates only that are not basedupon actual production and should not be relied upon for any purpose. It should not be assumedthat final production before plugging and abandonment will equal estimated reserves.

Estimate of allowable costs: $657,024.00 (Well R(-I) $317,581.00 & R(-1A)$339,443.00) Exhibit C which estimates/reports the costs associated with two fracwells. To the extent additional wells may be required by mine plans in theBuchanan No. I Mine, the costs of any such additional wells as may be permittedby the Division of Gas and Oil, in accordance with the provisions of tj45.1-361.20.C.,Code of Virginia, will not be allocated for frac well production to the

subject unit by the Operator.

10. Attestation: The foregoing application, to the best of my knowledge,information, and belief, is true and correct.

CNX GAS COMPANY LLCBY ITS PROFESSIONAL MANAGERCNX OMPANY L PETITIONER

ByD. Duty

Supervisor627 Claypool Hill Mall RoadCedar Bluff, Virginia 24609

Page Number 2.

Page 3: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

APPLICANT: CNX Gas Company LLC

RELIEF SOUGHT: POOLING

UNIT NUMBER: R(-1)

DIVISION OF GAS AND OILDOCKET NO. VGOB 17-0718-4134

NOTICE OF HEARING

HEARING DATE:PLACE:

TIME:

COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA:

July 18,2017Russell County Conference Center135 Highlands DriveLebanon, Virginia 242669:00 AM

To: Clyde Boyd, Arlene Decl, James Curtis Baldwin, Laura Virginia Manier, HenryNathan Baldwin, Jr., Jody Baldwin, Lloyd Michael Cook, Mark Anthony Cook, Daris MesaCook, Ercil Cook, Jr., Ursula Cook, Catherine Boyd, Betty Sturgeon Baker Boyd, James BryantBoyd, Michael Leon Boyd, Darrell Gene Boyd, Bradley Dean Boyd, Ricky Allen Boyd, ChristineLockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A, Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton,Sandra Barton Hibbitts

1. Anulicant and its counsel: Applicant is CNX Gas Company LLC, 627Claypool Hill Mall Road, Cedar Bluff, Virginia, 24609. Applicant's counsel is Mark A. Swartz,Hilliard & Swartz, LLP, 122 Capitol Street, FL 2, Charleston, WV 25301.

2. Relief sought: Pooling

3. Pronosed nrovlslons of order: (a) Pooling all the interests and estates of thepersons named above in coalbed methane in the unit in question; (b) Establishing a procedurewhereby each respondent shall have the right to make elections; (c) Providing that anyrespondent who does not make a timely election shall be deemed to have leased or assigned hiscoalbed methane gas interests to the applicant at a rate to be established by the Board; (d)Designating CNX Gas Company LLC as Unit Operator; (e) Making any necessary provisionsfor the escrow of fimds; (f) Granting such other relief as is merited by the evidence and is justand equitable, whether or not such relief has been specifically requested herein.

4. Legal Authorltv: Va. Code Ann. II45.1-361.1 et seq. 4 VAC 25-160-10 et seel.and relevant Virginia Gas and Oil Board Orders heretofore promulgated pursuant to lawincluding OGCB 3-90; VGOB-91-1119-162;VGOB 92/02/16-0336; and VGOB 93/03/16-0349.

5. Tvne of weII(s): Coalbed methane.

6. Plat: Annexed hereto are Exhibit A, Exhibit Al and the Tract Identifications forExhibit A. The Plat shows the size and shape of the unit and the boundaries of the tracts withintheunit. The Tract Identificationpageshows the percentage ofacreage in each tract. The plat iscertified by a licensed professional engineer and is attested by the undersigned on behalf of theapplicant to be in conformity with existing orders issued by the Board.

Page Number 3.

Page 4: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

VGOB 17-0718-4134Page 2 of 2

7. Your interest or claim sought to be nooled bv this Annlication nertains tocoalbed methane gas.

8. Formation(s) to be nroduced and estimates: All coal seams and associatedstrata below the Tiller seam of coal all as more particularly described in the annexed proposedorder. The estimated total production from subject unit is 125 to 550 MMCF. The estimatedamount of reserves from the subject drilling unit is 125 to 550 MMCF. These figures concerningestimated production and the amount of reserves are, however, estimates only that are not basedupon actual production and should not be relied upon for any purpose. It should not be assumedthat final production before plugging and abandonment will equal estimated reserves.

9. Estimate of allowable costs: $657,024.00 (Well R(-1) $317,581.00 Jk R(-1A)$339,443.00)

10. Attestation: The foregoing application to the best of my knowledge,information, and belief is true and correct.

NOTICE IS FURTHER GIVEN that this cause has been set for hearing and the takingof evidence before the Board at 9:00 AM, on July 18, 2017, at the Russell County GovernmentConference Center, 139 Highlands Drive, Lebanon, Virginia 24266, and that notice will bepublished as required by law and the Rules of the Board.

NOTICE IS FURTHER GIVEN that you may attend this hearing, with or without anattorney, and offer evidence or state any comments you have. For further information or a copyof the Application and Exhibits, either contact the Virginia Gas and Oil Board, State Oil and GasInspector, Department of Mines, Minerals and Energy, the Division of Gas and Oil, 135Highland Drive, Lebanon, Virginia 24266, 276/415-9650 or the Applicant at the address shownbelow.

DATED: 5 30 j7

CNX GAS COMPANY LLCBY ITS PROFESSCNX COMP

By:ita D. Duty

Po Supervisor627 Claypool Hill Mall RoadCedar Bluff, Virginia 24609

Page Number 4.

Page 5: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

PROPERTY LINES SHOWN ON THIS PLAT WERE PROVIDEDBY CNY GAS LLC AND WERE TAI(EN FROM DEED DESCRIPTIONSAND CHAIN QF TITLE OF RECORD IT DOES NOT REPRESENT A

C RREIIT BOUNDARY SURVEY. THE CERTIFICATION HEREQIICERTIFIES THE LOCATION OF THE PROPOSED WELL ONLY

N 336 825.86

IJNIT R —1

N 336 896 27 gE 940 757.66

3

L

~=CO R-'IA

N 335 029 02E 94o 687.oo XI

2

Q CDM WELL

G PROPOSED CRM WELL

Company CNX Gas Company LLC

Digitally signed by James R Dills

Jr.DN: c=us,o=ldenTrustACESBusiness Representative, ou=D. R.

PRICE ENGINEERING AND LAND

SURVEYING INC PC, en=James R

Dills Jr.,0.9.2342.19200300.100.1.1=A0109690000012E01701153000027EADate; 201 7.05.3010:24;41

-04'00'e

I I Name and

334 958 56E 942 553 64

//

//

/

EXHIBIT A

OAKWOOD FIELDUNIT R —

1

F RCE P QL INGVGQB —17—0718—4134

Tract No.

CQLInfy BUCHANAN

This plat is a new plat

ElevationOisti-jcf PRATER

an updated plat

Number UNIT R —1

Quadrangle PRATER

Scale: 1" = 400 Oafe

QI a final plat

Form OCO—CO —7

Rev. 9/91 Licensed Professional Engineer or Licensed Land Surveyor

(Affiy Seal)

Page Number 5.

Page 6: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

CNX Gas Company LLC

UNIT (1)Tract Identifications

1. Josephine Boyd Heirs, et al (105 Acre Tract) —MineralsIsland Creek Coal Company —Coal Below Tiller Seam Leased (94 4444%)Alpha Land and Reserves, LLC —Coal in Blair Seam and Above Leased (%a)

CNX Gas Company LLC —Oil, Gas and CBM Leased (84.2363%)Unknown Surface Owner20.84 Acres 26.0500%

2. Garden Realty Corporation (203.16Acre Tract) —MineralsIsland Creek Coal Company —Coal Below Tiller Seam LeasedAlpha Land and Reserves, LLC —All Coal Outcropping Above Water Level LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC —Oil, Gas and CBM LeasedDyno East Kentucky, Inc. —Surface29.66 Acres 37.0750%

3. Garden Realty Corporation (250.22 Acre Tract) —Coal and MetalsIsland Creek Coal Company —Coal Below Tiller Seam LeasedAlpha Land and Reserves, LLC —All Coal Outcropping Above Water Level LeasedJohn W. Pobst, Jr., et al —Oil, Gas and CBM

CNX Gas Company LLC —Oil, Gas and CBM Leased

Dyno East Kentucky, Inc. —Surface27.54 Acres 34.4250%

4. Levisa Coal Company Tract 20 (310.15Acre Tract) —All Coal except Coal Below Tiller SeamCONSOL Mining Company LLC —Coal Below Tiller SeamRevelation Energy, LLC —Above Drainage Coal LeasedJohn W. Pobst, Jr., et al —Oil and GasCNX Gas Company LLC —Oil, Gas and CBM LeasedUnknown surface owner1.96Acres 2.4500%

"This title block is for general informational purposes only and does not reflect an analysis of the severance deed and its effect upon coal bedmethane ownership and should not be relied upon for such purpose."

Page 1 of 1April 17, 2017

Page Number 6.

Page 7: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 60 NR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB tyU7(SN(34LltM 00 ICII I

A INN tU K

I COAL OWNURSNIP

7 St 20 St

20 84 26 0500N

fp ly FAIF 6 yd)(105A 7 0

(I I) D 10M GI tlt H,D

(I I 1) M 0 L M Gl thl H, D

(I 11N D IdM Gl thl

PCS *580L I,VA 24266

0 1240U168 t 20 84

0 1551N

(I 112) MNL MG)thl H,D

(I 1121) W y 7 Ib NB N,S1010 N M d I Rd

M 0 I SC 29835

0 041 3U504 t2084

0 0517N

(I 1122) J phJh LPd3123 P t kH yD Apt332F B*CI I,VA 22044

0 041 3U504 t2084

0 0517N

(I 1123) M DL I PPO 6 *188D YN B,MD 21035

0 041 3U504 t2084

0 0517N

(I 113) L IA MGIUI2859K IG pRd0 k W VA 24631

0 1240U168 t 20 84

0 1551N

(I 114) K 7 thy M Gl Ihl

2285 Cldb F RdH I,VA 24260

0 1240U168 t 20 84

0 1551N

(11) M 8 YdH,D

(111) L th 6 D IB ydH,D

(1111) KlbyB ydH D

(11111) J h YB ydH ,D

(«1«1) 3 vevd

(1111111)Clyd 6ydPO 6 *403CI I,VA 24226

(111112) L we Vd

(1111121)Clyd 6 yd

PO 6 *403CI I,VA 24226

C 7 d I 15/2/20111 I tt/t 128

0 0059U3528 t 20 84

C 7 d I 15/2/20111 I tt/t 128

0 0059U3528 t 20 84

0 Otl74N

0 Otl74N

(111113)M h IB vd

(1111131)Clyd 6 yd

PO 6 *403CI I,VA 24226

C 7 d I 15/2/20111 I tt/t 128

0 0059U3528 t 20 84

0 Otl74N

(I 1 I I 1 4) 8 tt 8 vd

(1111141)Clyd 6 yd

PO 6 *403CI I,VA 24226

C 7 d I 15/2/20111 I tt/t 128

0 0059U3528 t 20 84

0 Otl74N

(11113) Clyd 8 ydPO 6 *403

CI I VA 24226

0 0236U882 t 20 84

0 0295N

(1112) Jh yBydH,D

(11121) J yB yd

(I 1 I 2 I N clvd 6 vdPO 6 *403

CI I VA 24226

C y d I 15/2/20111 I tt/tl28

0 0118U1764 t2084

0 0148N

(11122) I 08 yd C y d I 15/2/20111 I tt/tl28

PS I 138 5/23/2017

Page Number 7.

Page 8: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlhlt 8U UR(1)

0 8 ttlVGOB IYGYISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 8

(11122H clvd 8 vdPO 6 *403

CI I VA 24226

0 0118U1764 t2084

0 0148N

(11123) M h IB yd

(I I I 2 3 H clvd 8 vdPO 6 *403

CI I VA 24226

C y d I 15/2/20111 I tt/ti28

0 0118U1764 t2084

0 0148N

(11124) S ttB yd

(11124H clvd 8 vdPO 6 *403

CI I VA 24226

C y d I 15/2/20111 I tt/ti28

0 0118U1764 t2084

0 0148N

(I I I 3) Clyd 6 yd

PO 6 *403CI I VA 24226

0 0473U441 t 20 84

0 0591N

(112) KlhyB ydH D

(1121) J h yB ydH,D

(11211) J yB yd

(112111) Clyd 8 yd

PO 6 *403CI I VA 24226

C y d I 15/2/20111 I tt/ti28

0 0118U1764 t2084

0 0148N

(I 1 2 I 2) I 8 8 yd

(112121) Clyd 8 yd

PO 6 *403CI I VA 24226

C y d I 15/2/20111 I tt/ti28

0 0118U1764 t2084

0 0148N

(11213) M h IB yd

(112131) Clyd 8 yd

PO 6 *403CI I VA 24226

C y d I 15/2/20111 I tt/ti28

0 0118U1764 t2084

0 0148N

(I 1 2 I 4) S tt 8 yd

(112141) Clyd 8 yd

PO 6 *403CI I VA 24226

C y d I 15/2/20111 I tt/ti28

0 0118U1764 t2084

0 0148N

(I 1 2 2) Clyd 6 yd

PO 6 *403CI I VA 24226

0 0473U441 t 20 84

0 0591N

(113) J h yBydH D

(1131)P I K 8vd

(11311)R IF 0

(113111)R thA F 0

(1131111)K gK

C y d I tl R IF 4 27372005 D861t/466

C 7 d I/15/1987 2/3/2005 DB 328/659

C 7 d3//5/19891 I I I ly I d d d d d I I 7 ft D83287659d /FMFSJ pl» 8 ydy I24 13D8350/310

C y d5/3/1990 4 I I I/ tl I 06360/679

(11311111)R thA F 5 t'P It C y ddOR002 4 I I II tl I 06547/239

(113111111)R IF 5 H,D

(1131111111)AI D

28131 D I H 7H y, VA 24256

0 094521441 t 20 84

0 11 SIN

(I 1 4) Clyd 6 yd

PO 8 *4tl3CI I,VA 24226

0 094521441 t 20 84

0 11 SIN

(12) H yB ydH,D

(121) D It 6 yd

(1211) H * IN I 7PO 6 *155D p 0, VA 24239

0 0473U441 t 20 84

0 0591N

(1212) J t M dd12260 5 D

F I It 5 NC 28303

(I 2 I 3) Sh I J tt J2371D 5RdH I VA 24260

0 0473U441 t 20 84

0 0473U441 t 20 84

0 0591N

0 0591N

(I 2 I 4) J dv 0 6 vd35tH 8 ydURdg Rd9 \, VA 24656

0 0473U441 t 20 84

0 0591N

Pg 2 138 5/23/2017

Page Number 8.

Page 9: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlhlt 50 UR(1)

0 k ttlVGQB ITGTISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 6

(I 2 I 5) R Iph 8 ydPD 6 *122M, VA 24628

0 0473U441 t 20 84

0 0591H

(I 2 I 6) 8 d D ly

12229 yd'dg RdV \, VA 24656

0 0473U441 t 20 84

0 0591H

(1217) E ly C I

PCS *97H y* VA 24256

0 0473U441 t 20 84

0 0591H

(I 2 I 8) L 3 D I H , D

(I 2 I 8 I) A 0 E D I H , D

(12181H L d C pt4240 R 09 I I 6 00 9, GA 30028

(121812) J DD328 U SI

BI I Id INV 24701

0 0047U4410 I 2tl 84

0 0047U4410 t2084

0 Otl59H

0 Otl59H

(121813) Shd yB I yPD 6 *957

L I,VA 24266

0 0047U4410 t2084

0 Otl59H

(121814) SI T03610 W dD I D

M, FL 32754

0 0047U4410 t2084

0 Otl59H

(121815) D 15DPD 6 *413

R 0 I,VA 24280

0 0047U4410 t2084

0 Otl59H

(121816) L MG y D

PCS *322D p 5 VA 24239

0 0047U4410 t2084

0 Otl59H

(121817) D 01 D

10276 DIDH y* VA 24256

(121818) 6 0 D I J15072 6 5 Rd9 t I,VA 242tl2

0 0047U4410 t2084

0 0047U4410 t2084

0 Otl59H

0 Otl59H

(121819) J y A D ITU H D

(1218191) Rh d R Ed133A I StH I,VA 24260

0 0016I H 3230 t 20 84

0 Otl20H

(1218192) K yM h 0 C 901161 k St9 0 9 MU, VA 24637

(I 2 I 8 1 9 3) S d M A dPQ 8 *2tl3R hf Id, QH 44286

0 0016I H 3230 t 20 84

0 0016I H 3230 t 20 84

0 Otl20H

0 Otl20H

(1218110) K yV D IH BD

(12181101) K yV D I,JPUB *8600 k d, VA 24631

0 0012U1 7640 I 2tl 84

0 0tH OH

(12181102) M I 0 J1229C pt *C 0 RdH I,VA 24260

0 0012U1 7640 I 2tl 84

0 0tH OH

(12181103) K t D2856 I RdJ I INV 24850

(12181104) K 5 0D10567H I H 0 H 7H I,VA 24260

0 0012U1 7640 I 2tl 84

0 0012U1 7640 I 2tl 84

0 0tH OH

0 0tH OH

(129) Alf dE 8 ydH,D

(1291) M 0 8 ydlNPCS *313D p 0, VA 24239(6 d Add )

Lf I I I/7 ff/441

(I 2 9 2) A I D D18030 R I V 0 YRdAM gd ,VA 24210

0 0095U2205 t 20 84

0 0118H

(I 2 9 3) T m 6 8 yd290 8 t D

AM gd ,VA 24210

(1294) L M St I y1813261 I H 0 Rd

AM gd ,VA 24210

0 0095U2205 t 20 84

0 0095U2205 t 20 84

0 0118H

0 0118H

Pg 3 138 512312017

Page Number 9.

Page 10: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 8U UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB IYUYISNI34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU h

N295) Jff YA0 BydPQ8 *313D p 6 VA 24239

(1296) L QD 8 yd

16507f! I yG pRdAN gd ,VA 24210

0 0095U2205 t 20 84

0 0095U2205 t 20 84

0 0118K

0 0118K

(13) J 6 ydO

(1311) R IF 0

N3111)RIhA Fg

C 7 d8/75/1978 0 I I 61 I I R IF 0 D8259/343

C 7 d81/t5/t987D8 328/659

C y d3/75/19891 I I I ly I d d d d d I I 7 ft D83287659d /FMFSJ pl» 8 ydy 124 13D8350/310

N3111NK gK C y d5/3/1990 ii I I II tl I DB360/679

(1311111)R thA F 0 (P tt ) C y 45//Ropy // I I ll tl I DB547/239

(13111111)R IF 0 H ,D

(131111111)Ad D

28131 D I H 7H y, VA 24256

0 4253U49 t2084

0 5316K

(14) Id 6 ydFI lb H,D

(141) 6 ItyFI th128101dG * C I RdH I,VA 24260

0 07tl9U294 I 2tl 84

0 0886K

N42) G QFI th5692 D I Rd9 \, VA 24656

0 07tl9U294 I 2tl 84

0 0886K

(143) J D(D y)FI Ih H,D

(1431) Gl d KyF)th8864 H I H d HW

H I,VA 24260

0 07tl9U294 I 2tl 84

0 0886K

(144) J dFI th496 H I W YAFI J206D It GA 30721

0 07tl9U294 I 2tl 84

0 0886K

N 4 5) 6 Ih I A SI19509EC 50 yDP 0 StL, FL 34983 4674

0 07tl9U294 I 2tl 84

0 0886K

(146) Cl5 I M k

4495 LP IDBl gt, IN 47404

(15) N yB ydJ k

(151) D IdM Gl thl H,D

0 07tl9U294 I 2tl 84

C 7 d9/77/1969

0 0886K

dbyh I 9 yd Ifh d fhf 0 Idbl Ql Ihl DS t93/125

(1511) M yL M Gl thl H D

(I 5 I I I) D Id A M Gl thl, JPQ8 *580L I,VA 24266

01063U196 I 2tl 84

0 1329K

(15112) M QL M Gl thl 8 0 H,D

(151121) W y T Ib NB N,S1010N M 0 \ RdM 0 I SC 29835

0 0354U588 t2084

0 0443K

N 5 I I 2 2) J PI J I L 2 43123 P t kH yD Apt332F B*CI I,VA 22044

0 03541/388 t2084

0 0443K

(151123) M QL I PPO 6 *188D Yd B,MD 21035

0 03541/388 t2084

0 0443K

(15113) L hA MG)thl2859K IG PRd0 k W VA 24631

01063I/196 t2084

0 1329K

N5114) K T thYMGItht2285 Cldb F RdH I,VA 24260

01063I/196 t2084

0 1329K

(16) M QB ydV

NSI) R IF

(1611)R thA F

(16111)K gK

(161111)R thA F~0 (P It

C y d I/15/1987 2/3/2005 DB 328/659

C 7 d3/75/19891 I I I ly I d d d d d I I 7 ft D83287659d /FMFSJ pl» 8 ydy 124 13D8350/310

C y d5/3/1990 ii I I ll tl I DB360/679

C y 45//Ropy // I I ll tl I DB547/239

N611111)R IF~0 H,D

Pg 4 138 5/23/2017

Page Number 10.

Page 11: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 6U UR(1)

0 k tbVGOB tyGYISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 8

(16111111)I I D

28131 D k H yH 7, VA 24256

0 4253U49 t2084

0 5316N

(17) St KBydH,D

(171) R byB ydP 41866LUI P t RdG dy, VA 24614

0 0851U2 45 t 20 84

0 1063N

N 7 2) Qp I 6 yd R d IU

(1721) D IdM Gl thl H,D

(17211) M CL M Gl thl H,D

(172111) D 14AMGIthI,JPCS *580L I,VA 24266

0 021 3 0 0266NU98tl I 2tl 84

N 72112) M DL M Gl thl 6 0 H,D

N 7 2 I I 2 I) W 7 7 Ib 6 6 0 , S1010N M 0 \ RdM 0 I SC 29835

0 0071U2940 I 2tl 84

0 0089N

(1 7 2 I 1 2 2) J ph J h I P3123 P t kH yD Apt332F B*CI I,VA 22044

0 0071U2940 I 2tl 84

0 0089N

(1721123) MDL LPHPO 6 *188D YU B,MD 21035

0 0071U2940 I 2tl 84

0 0089N

N72113) L IA MGIUI2859K IG pRd0 k M VA 24631

0 021 3U98tl I 2tl 84

0 0266N

(172114) K 7 thyM Gl Ihl

2285 Cldb F RdH I,VA 24260

0 021 3U98tl I 2tl 84

0 0266N

(173) N 8 yd C 7 d9/15/1970 I I 061 I I D M Gl thl D8 197/37

(1731) D IdM Gl thl H,D

(17311) M CL M Gl thl H,D

(173111) D 14AMGIthI,JPCS *580L I,VA 24266

0 021 3U98tl I 2tl 84

0 0266N

(173112) M QL M Gl thl 6 0 H,D

(1731121) W y 7 th 66 0 ,S1010N M 0 \ RdM 0 I SC 29835

0 0071U2940 I 2tl 84

0 0089N

N 7 3 I 1 2 2) J ph J h I P3123 P t kH yD Apt332F B*CI I,VA 22044

0 0071U2940 I 2tl 84

0 0089N

(1731123) MDL LPHPO 6 *188D YU B,MD 21035

0 0071U2940 I 2tl 84

0 0089N

(173113) L I A M GI 012859K IG PRd0 k M VA 24631

0 021 3U98tl I 2tl 84

0 0266N

N 73114) K 7 tIYM GI 012285 Cldb F RdH I,VA 24260

0 021 3U98tl I 2tl 84

0 0266N

(174) H 8 yd

N741) D 10MGItht H,D

N7411) MDLMGItht H,D

N7411N D 14AMGIthI,JPCS *580L I,VA 24266

0 021 3 0 0266NU98tl I 2tl 84

(174112) M QL M Gl thl 6 0 H,D

(1741121) W y 7 th 66 N,S1010N M 0 \ RdM 0 I SC 29835

0 0071U2940 I 2tl 84

0 0089N

(1741122) J phJ h I P3123 P t kH yD Apt332F B*CI I,VA 22044

0 0071U2940 I 2tl 84

0 0089N

90 5138 512312017

Page Number 11.

Page 12: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 80 UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB ITUTISH134LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 8

(1741123) M WL L P 4PO 8 *188D pd B,MD 21035

0 0071I/2940 I 2tl 84

0 0089K

(174113) L I A M GI 012859K IG pRd0 k W VA 24631

0 021 3I/98tl I 2tl 84

0 0266K

(174114) K T thyM Gl Ihl

2285 Cldb F RdH I,VA 24260

0 021 3I/98tl I 2tl 84

0 0266K

(175) L BydD

(1751) R IF~0

(17511)R IhA F 5

(175111)K gK

(1751111)RthA F0 IP5 )

C 7 d I/15/1987 2/3/2095 DB 328/659

C 7 d3//5/19891 I I I ly I d d d d d I I 7 ft D83257659d /FMFSJ pl» 8 ydy 123 13D8359/310

C y d5/3/1999 // I I ll tl I 00369/679

C y ddCR002 // I I II tl I 00547/239

(17511111)R IF 0 H ,D

(175111111)Ad D

28131 D I H 7H y, VA 24256

0 0851U2 45 t 20 84

0 1063K

(21)I Mydl Hl BydBldHD

(211) Mld dB ItH,D

(2 I I I) R I R 8 It H , D

(21 I I I) I M I W lt

2372Lb HyHB*S thRdL I,TN 37681

0 0322I/648 I 2tl 84

0 0402K

(2112) Rt St RH2304 Gl 0 k D

W I I, KS 67216

0 0161U1296 t2084

0 0201K

(2113) P St g1779 8 G

H I 9 I, MI 48030

0 0161U1296 t2084

0 0201K

(2114) L M h ISt U281588 I I DW, MI 48088

0 0161U1296 t2084

0 0201K

(2115) L M I W,lt

2372Lb HyHB*S thRdL I,TN 37681

0 0161U1296 t2084

0 0201K

(2 I 2) J 8 tt H , D

(2 I 2 I) J 8 Id

2212 M

R ! 10 k Ml 48067

(2 I 3) R g G I K dy Kl gPO 8 3550 I I U,PA 15324

(21 4) R kyg Id

2014 Hgh StC y hHI F 5,OH 44221

0 0965U216 t 20 84

0 0241I/864 I 2tl 84

0 0241I/864 I 2tl 84

0 1206K

0 0302K

0 0302K

Pg 6 138 5/23/2017

Page Number 12.

Page 13: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 8U UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB ITGTISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uk tU 5

(21 5) D 8 Id P755 F I D

W I * 3,QH 43953

(216) Wh E g 6 Id

3870511 R t 14R I I,OH 442729795

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0121U1728 t2084

0 0302H

0 01 51H

(217)A d Std St kpl2311St t R t 44Al t, OH 44201

0 0121U1728 t2084

0 01 51H

(22) W It F 8 yd

4055 L M *I D5 M VA 24656

0 2894IR2 I 2tl 84

0 3618H

(23) L hV 6 yd8 ld H,D

(231) V I M Ch2066 W tl StG dy, VA 24614

(232) Qp IM It H t

(2321) J 0 0 6 Id

1261 8 Id Rd5 M VA 24656

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302H

0 0302H

(233) P I 8 Id

59316 31 CtAI 0, VA 22303

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302H

(234) L I M M 0

(2341) J 0 0 6 Id

1261 8 Id Rd5 M VA 24656

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302H

(2 3 5) 6 I h D 8 yd

11248 I hL dRd5 M VA 24656

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302H

(2 3 6) L V g M

4022 L M *t D5 M VA 24656

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302H

(2 3 7) H O N th 6 Id ,J4036 5 DT * 3 VA 24651

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302H

(238) J dyEI I thH gyPO 6 *1045 \, VA 24656

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302H

(239) G OR y dB Id H,D

(2391) M yM RN tB Id C y d3/JR008 /tp p dy 766 3t9 gg g I d IVB24/3933,D629/5431 I 08 08781 J dye Id

(23911) 4&76 Id

341 P *yl A

8 I,VA 24153

0 0080U2592 t2084

0 0101H

(2 3 9 2) J dy 8 Id

341 P *yl A8 I,VA 24153

0 0161U1296 t2084

0 0201H

(231tR 8 dlyD Btd H D

f 0 I dLOH5/6/17)

(231tll) By 6 Id

4122 Cldt Gl d I Rd

Sp W b 61 SC 29307

(2 3 Itl 2) A b J158 0 RdJ I TN 39330

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302H

(2311) J C 0 8 Id

1261 8 10 Rd5 M VA 24656

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302H

(2312) 6 IM 6 10, H 4UD

(23121) S IM *8 Id

(231211) J C 0*8 Id

1261 6 Id Rd5 \, VA 24656

(2 3 12 2) 6 d 5 tt 8 Id

C y d3/JR008 // I I p P tl'

0080U2592 t2084

C y d9/JR007 // I I W P tl'

0101H

0 G C 0

(231221) CNXG 0 0 YLLCPQ 8 *643830Ptt b Gh, PA 15264 3830

0 0080 0 0101HU2592 t2084

Pg 7138 5/23/2017

Page Number 13.

Page 14: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 9U UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB ITOTISN134Lltrt 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 8

(23123) 6 rtl L 18 10 C y d9/JR007 3 I I 766319 gg 0 I 0 G C 0

(231231) CNXG 0 0 YLLCPQ 9 *643830Plt b rth, PA 15264 3830

(24)T I G UH,D

0 0080U2392 t2084

0 0101N

(241) M rt tShpl y46tlb 9 k D

H 0 \ U,MD 21074

0 1447U144 I 2tl 84

0 1809N

(2 4 2) R I 0 G 0, 612161N 01 4 CIH p \ U,MD 21074

(2 5) Ad N 0 St ~ H , D

0 1447U144 I 2tl 84

0 1809N

(2 5 I) 9 I G RRII 9 *4259 \,VA 24656

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0603N

(252) T CI917 R BF SR Rd

H ! I VA 24256

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0603N

(253) Slrtt MII

413891 gd I Rd6 t I,VA 242tl2

(254) 9 I 91637 D I*B I Rd9 \, VA 24656

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0603N

0 0603N

(2 5 5) T W 9 yd

16507f! 8 yG pRdAI gd, VA 24210

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0603N

(256) W y Stlt1586 D I*B I Rd9 \, VA 24656

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0603N

(26) M 8 yd853 JEE A

8 U 0, TN 37166

(2 7) J T 8 yd

1384D 1 8 I Rd9 rt VA 24656

0 2894ID2 I 2tl 84

0 2894ID2 I 2tl 84

0 3618N

0 3618N

(28) I FyB ydH,D

(281) H CG )8 yd

236 G A D

6 0 U, TN 37166

0 2894ID2 I 2tl 84

0 3618N

(29) Ch 4 Mlt 6 ydH,D

(291) A El 6 ydH D

(2911) L *t 6 Yd

6 *1829 rt VA 24656

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0603N

(2912) HI V I C I

4522 L G pRd9 rt VA 24656

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0603N

(2913) 8 5yP k

5632 L M *t D9 rt VA 24656

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0603N

(2914) P ggyC Td H D

(29141) J 8 YN IT0PCS *366H y, VA 24256

(29142) R A0 Td12tlg Sp & 8 Rd9 rt VA 24656

0 0080U2392 t2084

0 0080U2392 t2084

0 0101N

0 0101N

(2 9 I 4 3) Db Ly St4333 N Ah*1L I,VA 24266

0 0080U2392 t2084

0 0101N

(29144) F dd L Tb11tH R yB 0 H 0 Rd9 rt VA 24656

0 0080U2392 t2084

0 0101N

(2 9 I 4 5) GOD I T0PO 6 *1262G dy, VA 24614

0 0080U2392 t2084

0 0101N

(29146) M I K yM413 D IUD M L

L I,VA 24266

0 0080U2392 t2084

0 0101N

Pg 8 138 512312017

Page Number 14.

Page 15: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 8U UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB ITGTISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

(2915) J 6 8 vd4055 L M *I DV M VA 24656

A I Uh

0 0482U432 t2084

tU 8

0 0603N

(2916) 8 b E16859 I G A

H b 61 VA 228tH

(2 10) M D 6 yd C k H, D

(2101) Ed MR SC kH,D

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0603N

(21011) N y(Ed d)C k

1032 E 6 3 007 0 I M) 48220

0 0724U288 t2084

0 0905N

(2102) LI yd M h I C k

Itl316 k M IdDG dy, VA 24614

0 0724U288 t2084

0 0905N

(2103) E ID 0 I 8 H D

(21031) M kA th yC k,S H BD 0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

(210311) M kA th yC k,JAdd 0 I

(210312) D M C k

Add 0 I

(21032) E IC 3 J410T Gg Rd

Ag H ghte G 96910

(21033) U*I 0PQ 8 *11483VU, G 96929

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

0 0302N

(2104) WB MC k C I dhyd d IU33RSR0091 I 091089

(21041) S th R L

6228 EO AI V g NV 89110

0 0362U5 76 t 20 84

0 0452N

(21042) G UE 0966 Ch y Bl CtHGI I d*R 5 CO 80126

(2 I I) M R 6 yd, J H , D

0 0362U5 76 t 20 84

0 0452N

(2111) Lb M dh 6 ydH,D

(21111) S d 6 ydSSPO 8 5956 I,VA 24656

0 0724U288 t2084

0 0905N

(2 11 I 2) L ~ I 8 yd

PCS *2656 I,VA 24656

0 0724U288 t2084

0 0905N

(21113) Sh me vdgt vPCS *9806 I,VA 24656

0 0724U288 t2084

0 0905N

(21114) R d ye yd

21109P \ dD8 *t I VA 24202

0 0724U288 t2084

0 0905N

(212)AM G yB ydH,D

(2121) J 8 ydH,D

(21211) M *h 06 yd

3421 H ghg t RdR I UI, NC 27603

(2121 2) Th I 6 yd L

1012D t yRd80 R k VA 24603

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

0 0302N

Pg 9 138 512312017

Page Number 15.

Page 16: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlhlt 8U UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB ITUTISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 8

(21213) F 08 yd3117 L *I D9 \, VA 24656

0 0241I/864 I 2tl 84

0 03028

(21214) J HB yd

5810 D *3 *Rd9 \, VA 24656

0 0241I/864 I 2tl 84

0 03028

(21215)A L 8ydC5y3631M phl Rd9 \, VA 24656

0 0241I/864 I 2tl 84

0 03028

(21216) Et IP OB ydH,D

(212161) C th 8 yd11695 L

T H * 5,NC 28681

(2127) Ch 4 8 yd

RI I 8 *578A9 \, VA 24656

0 0241I/864 I 2tl 84

0 0241I/864 I 2tl 84

0 03028

0 03028

(2128) WS 8 yd

RI2 8 *4649 \,VA 24656

0 0241I/864 I 2tl 84

0 03028

(2129) D dG8 ydPCS 549 \, VA 24656

0 0241I/864 I 2tl 84

0 03028

(21210) St 8 yd

6211 L *t D9 \, VA 24656

0 0241I/864 I 2tl 84

0 03028

(21211) R 0 RB yd

Itl82Ad *J Rd9 \, VA 24656

0 0241I/864 I 2tl 84

0 03028

(212121) D IdCI g1365 D I*B I Rd9 \, VA 24656

0 0121U1728 t2084

0 01 518

(212122) R I RF I I CI 0 H D

(2121221) M OL CI gRI I 8 *5tl3A9 \, VA 24656

0 0121U1728 t2084

0 01 518

(3) LS J ph 8 ydH,D

(31) D ItB ydH,D

(311) M I T8ydPO 8 *1620 I,WV 24826

0 5789U36 t 20 84

0 72368

(32) H dy8 yd H D

(321) Al 5 8 yd2060 Ak W *t RdM 5 IS,OH 44903

0 5789U36 t 20 84

0 72368

(3 3) G g C 8 yd

(3 3 I) J t E F th I k J t 8 yd)

C y dt//3/2004hyd dt J 18 ydt k J IF th)D8586/374

07

(3311) J tB yd,T *t2520 51 I RI83MS I U,OH 44654

0 5789U36 t 20 84

0 72368

(34) F 8 ydH,D

(341) M OJ 8 yd

(3 4 I I) I *8 yd M g H , D

(34111) P I P SEpp d11360 GI 0 Rd

CI \ H'8 VA 23838

0 0289IR2tl I 2tl 84

0 03628

(34112) D P 08 37tl7A G pRd

M 0 8, TN 37354

0 0289IR2tl I 2tl 84

0 03628

(34113) PhdpM h IM g5732 0 I MU CtGl AB VA 23059

0 0289IR2tl I 2tl 84

0 03628

P 9 10 t 38 5/23/2017

Page Number 16.

Page 17: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 6U UR(1)

0 k tUVGOB ITUTISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 6

(34114) SI PI M M 01726 L A

P t b U,VA 23803

(34115) R 0 KEIW M g16655 6 I \ Rd9 0 I U,VA 23803

0 0289ID2tl I 2tl 84

0 0289ID2tl I 2tl 84

0 0362N

0 0362N

(3412) R b KC 0 6 yd

9611HtWI U t1959 b t, FL 32958

0 1447U144 I 2tl 84

0 1809N

(3413) Ed J PI T YI H,D

(3 4 I 3 I ) K 5 M J h *t45246 LUItl Rd9 Yp M MD 20674

(34132) K N IQ It

90106 dg ItL L 125L PI t,MD 20646

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

0 0302N

(3 4 I 3 3) K t El b th Q9010 6 dg ItL L 125L PI t, MD 20646

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

(34134) C I S I dQ90106 dg ItL L 125L PI t,MD 20646

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

(3 4 I 3 5) D 0 J StAdd 0 I

(34136) J h Th MlAdd 0 I

(3414) F T I g 8 yd,J50 K kl yPIF *\ VA 24551

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 1447U144 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

0 0302N

0 1809N

(3 5) F g 8 yd H D

(3 5 I) St 5 H 0 6 yd 0PCS *327S M*C k VA 24649

0 5789U36 t 20 84

0 7236N

(36) J ph D h gH,D

(36HRbdDhg

(3 6 I I) D It 8 yd H , D

C I dhyd d 12/30R003 DB 584 587

(3 6 I I I ) M I T 8 yd

PO 8 1620 I,WV 24826

0 5789U36 t 20 84

0 7236N

(4)ld C lb 6ydD Id A pl Gl fhl 8/19/1964

F kaydE I I II ftd ByddG CSth I d 7

(41) D 10 A M GI tht H, D

(411) M yL M Gl thl H D

(4111) D IdA M Gl thl,JPCS *580L I,VA 24266

0 8683 I 0854NU24 t 20 84

(4112) M OL MWI thl 6 0 H,D

(4 I I 2 I) W y T Ib 0 8 9 91010 N M 0 \ RdM 0 I SC 29835

0 2894ID2 I 2tl 84

0 3618N

(41122) J phJ h L P 03123P I kH OD Apt332F 5 Ch h,VA 22044

0 2894ID2 I 2tl 84

0 3618N

(4 I I 2 3) M O L L PPO 6 *188D pd B,MD 21035

0 2894ID2 I 2tl 84

0 3618N

(4133) L hA M Gl thl

2859K IG PRd0 k W VA 24631

0 8683U24 t 20 84

I 0854N

(41 14) K T thyM Gl thl

2285 Cldh F RdH I,VA 24260

0 8683U24 t 20 84

I 0854N

(5) FMFB ydH,D

(511) M dh 8 ydS dhM yPCS 35F I,KY 41528

0 3859U54 t 20 84

0 4824N

P g 11 1 38 512312017

Page Number 17.

Page 18: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 80 UR(1)

0 k t(IVGOB IYUYISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

(512) H It M Ch8 *44oV I,VA 24656

A I Uh

0 3859U54 t 20 84

tU 8

0 4824N

(51 3) D thy Hbbo5602 D I Rd0 M VA 24656

0 3859U54 t 20 84

0 4824N

(514) J g EeydH,D

(5 I 4 I) A d y D 8 yd

PCS 478 h p, VA 246tl4

0 3859U54 t 20 84

0 4824N

(515) K thl 8 ydL kh KH,D

(5 I 5 I) I D

(51511) CI \ L H 0PCS *2430 M VA 24656

0 0322U648 I 2tl 84

0 0402N

(51512) RMI J yL kh dPCS *9420 M VA 24656

0 0322U648 I 2tl 84

0 0402N

(51513) F L kh 6PCS *9420 M VA 24656

0 0322U648 I 2tl 84

0 0402N

(5152) Ch t L kh dPO 9 *2439 t, VA 24656

(5 1 5 3) R 0 J I L kh dFOB *9429 \, VA 24656

0 0965U216 I 2tl 84

0 0965U216 t 20 84

0 1206N

0 1206N

(5154) F L kh 0FOB *9429 \, VA 24656

0 0965U216 t 20 84

0 1206N

(51 6) Mydl 8 yd C y dtO/t8/t975 0 I I h I df FMFB yd J I D IdM Gl thl 09231/342

(5161) D IdA M Gl thl H,D

(51611)M OL M Gl thl H,D

(516111)D 15A M GI SI,JPO 8 580L I VA 24266

0 0965U216 t 20 84

0 1206N

(5 I 6 I I 2) M O L M gl thl 8 d H, D

(5 I 6 I I 2 I) W y 7 Ib 6 8 0 , S1010 N M 0 \ RdM 0 I SC 29835

0 0322U648 I 2tl 84

0 0402N

(5161122) J phJ h I P3123 P t kH yD Apt332F B*CI I,VA 22044

0 0322U648 I 2tl 84

0 0402N

(5161123) M OL L P 5PO 9 *188D Yd B,MD 21035

0 0322U648 I 2tl 84

0 0402N

(516133) L I A M GI 012859K IG 5RS0 k W VA 24631

0 0965U216 t 20 84

0 1206N

(516114) K 7 tIYM GI 012285 Cldb F RdH I,VA 24260

0 0965U216 t 20 84

0 1206N

(5 I 7) J *E N 9 yd OSG f 9 yd J I 0 Id A M gl thl

(5 I 7 I) D Id A M GI 8 I H , D

(51711)M OL M GI tlt H,D

(51 711 H D 15A M GI SI,JPO 8 580L I VA 24266

0 0965U216 t 20 84

0 1206N

(5 I 7 I I 2) M O L M gl thl 8 d H, D

(5 I 7 I I 2 I) W y 7 Ib 6 8 0 , S1010N M 0 \ RdM 0 I SC 29835

0 0322U648 I 2tl 84

0 0402N

(5171122) J phJ h I P3123 P t kH yD Apt332F B*CI I,VA 22044

0 0322U648 I 2tl 84

0 0402N

(5171123) MRL LP5PO 9 *188D Yd B,MD 21035

0 0322U648 I 2tl 84

0 0402N

Pg 12 138 5/23/2017

Page Number 18.

Page 19: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 6U UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB IYGYISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 8

(517133) L I A M GI 012859K IG pRd0 k W VA 24631

0 0965U216 t 20 84

0 1206H

(517114) K 7 thyM Gl Ihl

2285 Cldb F RdH I,VA 24260

0 0965U216 t 20 84

0 1206H

(5 I 8) H * I M d I 8 yd H , D

(5 I 8 I) M dh 8 yd S dh M IPCS 35F I,KY 41528

0 0551U378 t2084

0 0689H

(5182) H tt M Ch9 *4400 I,VA 24656

0 0551U378 t2084

0 0689H

(5183) D thyHbbB5602 D I Rd0 I,VA 24656

0 0551U378 t2084

0 0689H

(5184) J 0 E 8 ydH,D

(5 I 8 4 I ) A d Y D 8 ydPCS 478 h p VA 24604

0 0551U378 t2084

0 0689H

(5185) K thl 8 ydL kh AH D

(51851) I D

(518511) CIYU L Ih 0PQ8 *2439 M VA 24656

0 0046U4536 t2084

0 gtl57H

(518512) RW J yL kh 0PQ8 *9429 M VA 24656

0 0046U4536 t2084

0 gtl57H

(518513) F L kl 0PQ8 *9429 M VA 24656

0 0046U4536 t2084

0 gtl57H

(51852) CI \ L H 4PO 6 *2430 \, VA 24656

0 0138U1512 t2084

0 0172H

(51853) RWI J yL kh 0PUB *9420 \, VA 24656

0 0138U1512 t2084

0 0172H

(51854) F L kh 0PUB *9420 \, VA 24656

(5186) Mydl 6 ydH YW g H D

0 0138U1512 t2084

0 0172H

(51861) J OW g H,D

(518611) D YR YW 0

W Id, FL 32694

0 0184U1134 t2084

0 0230H

(5 I 8 6 I 2) L O W g833 K g*l yA0 0 P G FL 32073

(5 I 8 6 I 3) D y R y W g

W Id, FL 32694

0 0184U1134 t2084

0 0184U1134 t2084

0 0230U

0 0230H

(5187) J E tB YdH,D

(5 I 8 7 I) 6 Ity St M 8 k 8 yd29L yLF I,KY 41528

0 0092U2268 t 20 84

0 0115H

9 9 13 t 38 512312017

Page Number 19.

Page 20: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 50 UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB IYUYISHISJLltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU h

(51872)J BO tB ydIQB *960 I,VA 24656

0 0092U2258 t 20 84

0 0115H

(5 I 8 7 3) M h I L 8 yd

3574 LUI F *0 I D

0 I,VA 24656

0 0092U2258 t 20 84

0 0115H

(51874) D SG 8 yd

4562 M O by Rd0 I,VA 24656

0 0092U2258 t 20 84

0 0115H

(5 I 8 7 5) 6 dl I D 5 ydIQB *960 I,VA 24656

0 0092U2258 t 20 84

0 0115H

(51876) R kyAS 8 yd

444 F DCh t *b 01 VA 24073

0 0092U2258 t 20 84

0 0115H

(5 I 9) D d F 6 yd H D

(8 I 9 I) I D Cyd2/77/20171 / yf /ICI I LkhdRgJyLklddFL kid(51911) CI \ L H 0

PO 6 *2430 M VA 24656

0 0429U486 I 2tl 84

0 0536H

(51912) RNI J yL kh 0PCS *9420 M VA 24656

0 0429U486 I 2tl 84

0 0536H

(5 I 9 I 3) F L I 5 0PCS *9420 M VA 24656

0 0429U486 I 2tl 84

0 0536H

(5193) R g J yL kh 0PUB *9425 \, VA 24656

0 1286U162 t2084

0 1608H

(5194) F L kh 0PUB *9425 \, VA 24656

0 1286U162 t2084

0 1608H

(6)L hVt Bd

(6 I) D IdA M Gl thl H,D

(6 I 1) M 0 L M Gl thl H, D

(6 111) D Idh M Gl UI,JPO 8 580L I VA 24266

0 1240U168 t2084

0 1551H

(6 I I 2) M 7 L M gl thl 5 0 H, D

(6 I I 2 I) W I 7 Ib 0 5 0 , SIgltlN M G t RdM 0 I, SC 29835

0 041 3U504 I 2tl 84

0 0517H

(6 1122) J phJ h I P3123 P I kH OD Apt 332F 3 Ch h VA 22044

0 041 3U504 I 2tl 84

0 0517H

(6 1123) MOL LPHPO 8 188D 0 3 MD 21035

(6 133) L IA MGIUI2859 K I G p Rd0 k d, VA 24631

0 041 3U504 I 2tl 84

0 1240U168 t2084

0 0517H

0 1551H

(6 114) K 7 thy M Gl Ihl

2285 Cldt F RdH I, VA 24260

0 1240U168 t2084

0 1551H

(61)F MBA

(611) R IF 3

(6 I I I) R th A F 0

C y dt/49 7/fg/1976/ R IF 0 08239/549

C 7 d I/15/1987 DB 328/659

C y d 3/75/19891 I I I ly 08 350/310

(61111)K gK

(611111)R thA F~0 (P It

C y d5/3/1990 // I I ll tl I 08360/679

g

(6111111)R IF~0 H,D

(61111111)Al D

28131 D k H yH y, VA 24256

0 4253U49 t2084

0 5316H

(62) Alb KA 6 6 H D

(621)S hJBK ItL hCBH

Pg 14 t38 5/23/2017

Page Number 20.

Page 21: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlhlt 8U UR(1)

0 k tffVGGB ITUTISH134LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 8

(62111) H IB 0 H,D

(62111HH NM 8 d H,D

(6 2 I I I I I) E 8 8 0PDI *1655 I VA 24656

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 0133N

(6 2 I I I 2) M D C th I H D

(6 2 I I I 2 I) E 4 I

2926 51 D

8 *t I TN 24201

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 0133N

(6 2 I I I 3) L th M 8 0 H D

fd I I 0 I d 4/5/1 71

(6211131)Alt 6 61275 D

Y d t, VA 23692

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 0133N

(621114) H * U Sh1108 L I dcV g 8 h,VA 23464

(6 2 I I I 5) H It R th 8 0 T 5 H ,,D

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 0133N

(6 2 I I I 5 I) L h L T 0 H 6 D

(6 2 I I I 5 I I) M It G I Tff L *t1192A I RdR VA 24646

0 0027ID840 I 2tl 84

0 Otl33N

(62111512)St 8 dG NT01256A I RdR VA 24646

0 0027ID840 I 2tl 84

0 Otl33N

(62tt(SIS)RW GI K dySt18741 d G G pRd5 \, VA 24656

0 0027ID840 I 2tl 84

0 Otl33N

(62111514)M L T0210M Ik *0 I RdBl d, VA 24315

(621116) L NM dl SI 00 58919 P t kH yH 7PI 5 VA 23959

0 0027ID840 I 2tl 84

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 Otl33N

0 0133N

(6 2 I I I 7) V g I 8 0 J h

648 H IpLS 5 5 VA 24590

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 0133N

(621118) JCB 62469M 0 0 I RdG I 5 VA 24333

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 0133N

(6 2 I I I 9) Mt h 0 W 7 8 0186 R 5 gM d RdL I,VA 24266

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 0133N

(6211110)D C dyM C ph5PU8 776L I,VA 24266

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 0133N

(6212) J 0 8 d H,D

(62121) I 8 d H,D

(621211) V k 6 E ly

585201 0 50R I, VA 24018

0 0532U392 t 20 84

0 0665N

(6 2 I 2 I 2) T 6 M

2236 d5,Ch H 5 RdN Nhp 0, NY 11768

(6213) 0 de 6 H D

0 0532U392 t 20 84

0 0665N

9 9 15 t 38 512312017

Page Number 21.

Page 22: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 80 UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB IYUYISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I UU tU 8

(62131) S d 6 6 HbbtU4717 8 yd Rdg Rd0 I VA 24656

01063 0 13298U196 I 2tl 84

(6214) Elb AD 8 0 H,,D

(62141) D 0R 8 0

(62141 H CNXG 0 0 YLLCPO 8 643830Pll b gh PA 15264 3830

(62142) D IdP 6 6

(62142 H CNXG 0 0 YLLCPO 8 643830Pll b gh PA 15264 3830

(6 2 I 4 3) J L 8 0

0 0266ID84 I 2tl 84

0 0266ID84 I 2tl 84

0 03328

0 03328

(62143 H CNXG 0 0 YLLCPO 8 643830Pll b gh PA 15264 3830

(62144) D 8 d g

0 0266 0 03328ID84 I 2tl 84

(62144 H CNXG 0 0 YLLCPO 8 643830Pll b gh PA 15264 3830

0 0266ID84 I 2tl 84

0 03328

(6 3) J C 6 6 H D

(6 3 I) I 6 6 H , D

(6 3 I I) V k 8 E dy

5852 CI 0 0 0R I,VA 24018

0 2127U98 I 2tl 84

0 26588

(6312) 7 8 M

2236 dg,Ch H 0 RdN dhp 0, NY 11768

0 2127U98 I 2tl 84

0 26588

(64)6 hJBA H,D

(64HF MBA H,D

(6 4 I I) H I 6 6

(64111)0 IB 0 H,DC y dtt/t2/t9981 C /8 0 09485/422

(641111)S d 8 0 Hbbth4717 8 yd Rdg Rd0 I,VA 24656

01063U196 I 2tl 84

0 13298

(6 4 2) J *0 8 0 H , D

(6 4 2 I) V k E ly C y dtt/t2/t9981 C /8 0 09485/422

(64211) 0 IB 0 H,D

(642111) S d 8 0 Hbbth4717 8 yd Rdg Rd0 I,VA 24656

0 0532U392 t 20 84

0 06658

(6422) 7 M C y dtt/t2/t9981 C /8 0 09485/422

(64221) 0 IB 0 H,D

(642211) S d 8 0 Hbbth4717 8 yd Rdg Rd0 I,VA 24656

0 0532U392 t 20 84

0 06658

(6 4 3) 0 I 8 0 H , D

(6431) S d 8 0 Hbbd4717 8 yd Rdg Rd0 I,VA 24656

01063U196 I 2tl 84

0 13298

(644) E~ HD 8 0 H,D

(6 4 4 I) J L 8 0

(64411) 0 IB 0 H,DC y dtt/t2/t9981 C /8 0 09485/422

(64411 H S d 8 0 Hbbth4717 8 yd Rdg Rd0 I,VA 24656

0 0266 0 03328ID84 I 2tl 84

(6442)D IdB 8 0

(64421) 0 IB 0 H,DC y dtt/t2/t9981 C /8 0 09485/422

Pg 16 138 5/23/2017

Page Number 22.

Page 23: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlhlt 8U UR(1)

0 k ttlVGGB ITUTISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 8

(64421 H 6 0 8 0 HH»U4717 8 yd Rdg Rd6 I,VA 24656

0 0266 0 0332HIR84 I 2tl 84

(8443) D UR 8 0„(64431) 0 IB 0 H,D

C y dtt/t2/t9981 C /8 6 09485/422

(64431 H 6 0 8 0 HH»U4717 8 yd Rdg Rd6 I,VA 24656

0 0266IR84 I 2tl 84

0 0332H

(6444)DBBH8dg C y dtt/t2/t9981 C /8 6 09485/422

(64441) 0 IB 0 H,D

(64441 H 6 0 8 0 HH»U4717 8 yd Rdg Rd6 I,VA 24656

0 0266 0 0332HIR84 I 2tl 84

(65) Alh KA 8 6 H D

(651)S hJBK ItL hCBH

(65111) H IB 0 H,D

(65111HH NM 8 0 H,D

(6 5 I I I I I) E 6 8 0PDI *1656 I,VA 24656

0 0106f1960 I 2tl 84

0 0133U

(6 5 I I I 2) M D C th I H D

(6 5 I I I 2 I) E 4 I

2926 01 D

8 *t I TN 24201

0 0106f1960 I 2tl 84

0 0133U

(6 5 I I I 3) L th M 8 0 H D

fd I I 0 I d 4/5/1 71

(6511131)Alt 8 6127 V D

7 d t, VA 23692

0 0106f1960 I 2tl 84

0 0133U

(651114) H * U Sh1108 L I dcV g 8 h,VA 23464

(6 5 I I I 5) H It R th 8 0 T 0 H ,,D

(6 5 I I I 5 I) L h L T 0 H 8 D

0 0106f1960 I 2tl 84

0 0133U

(6 5 I I I 5 I I) M It G I Tff L *t1192A I RdR VA 24646

0 0027IR840 I 2tl 84

0 Otl33U

(65111512)St 8 dG GT01256A I RdR VA 24646

(ggtt(513)RW GI 5 dySt18741 d G G pRd5 \, VA 24656

0 0027IR840 I 2tl 84

0 0027IR840 I 2tl 84

0 Otl33U

0 Otl33U

(65111514)M L Tg210M Ik *0 I RdBl d, VA 24315

(651116) L NM dl SI pp 08919 P t kH yH 7PI 5 VA 23959

0 0027IR840 I 2tl 84

0 0106f1960 I 2tl 84

0 Otl33U

0 0133U

(6 5 I I I 7) V g I 8 0 J h

648 H IpLS 5 0 VA 24590

0 0106f1960 I 2tl 84

0 0133U

(651118)JCB 62469M 0 0 I RdG I 5 VA 24333

0 0106f1960 I 2tl 84

0 0133U

(6 5 I I I 9) Mt h 0 W 7 8 0186 R 0 gM d RdL I,VA 24266

0 0106f1960 I 2tl 84

0 0133U

9 9 17 t 38 5/23/2017

Page Number 23.

Page 24: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 80 UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB IYSYISH134LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 8

(6511110)D 0 dYM C PI dprt8 776L I,VA 24266

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 0133N

(e612IJ cert H 60,„8(65121) I 8 rt H,D

(651211) V k 8 E ly

585201 6 bcR I, VA 24018

0 0532U392 t 20 84

0 0665N

(6 5 I 2 I 2) 7 6 M

2238 dS,Ch H 0 RdN rthp rt, NY 11768

(8613) 0 de 0 H,D

0 0532U392 t 20 84

0 0665N

(65131) S d 8 rt HbbtU4717 8 yd Rdg Rd7 I VA 24656

01063 0 1329NU196 I 2tl 84

(6 5 I I 4) Elb rt D 8 rt H D

(e61141) 0 SR e 0

(6511411)CNXG 0 0 YLLCPO 8 643830Ptt b Gh, PA 15264 3830

0 0266 0 0332NIR84 I 2tl 84

(651142) D IdP 8 rt

(6511421) CNXG 0 0 YLLCPO 8 643830Ptt b Gh, PA 15264 3830

0 0266IR84 I 2tl 84

0 0332N

(6 5 I I 4 3) J L 8 rt

(6511431)CNXG 0 0 YLLCPQ 8 *643830Pll b gh PA 15264 3830

(651144) D 8 M g

0 0266 0 0332NIR84 I 2tl 84

(6511441) CNXG 0 0 YLLCPO 8 643830

Prt*b gh, PA 15264 3830

(66)C IBrt H D

0 0266 0 0332NIR84 I 2tl 84

(661) S d 8 rt Hebth4717 8 yd Rdg Rd0 M VA 24656

0 4253U49 t2084

0 5316N

(6 7) Elb rt D 8 rt H D

(6 7 I) 8 It V 8 rt

(6711) D dR 8 rt

(67111)CNXG C p yLLCPO 8 643830

Prt*b gh, PA 15264 3830

01063 0 1329NU196 I 2tl 84

(6712)D IdP 8 rt

(67121) CNXG C p yLLCPQ 8 *643830Pll b gh PA 15264 3830

(6713) J L 8 0

01063 0 1329NU196 I 2tl 84

(67131) CNXG C p yLLCPQ 8 *643830Pll b gh PA 15264 3830

01063 0 1329NU196 I 2tl 84

(6714) D 8 d g

(67141) CNXG C p yLLCPQ 8 *643830Pll b gh PA 15264 3830

7 52 ~ 2966

01063U196 I 2tl 84

0 1329N

N) G d R fly C p(20316A 7 01088 d yR d

M 0 Nc 28117

29 66 37 0750N

N) G d R fly C p(25022A 7 01088 d yR d

M 0 Nc 28117

27 54 34 4250N

P g 18 1 38 512312017

Page Number 24.

Page 25: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 80 UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB ITSTISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I UU tU K

7 S4 ~ 136

(I) L C IC p y T 2tl

(31015A 7 0UJhCI MggPK4710 H \ 00R I 0, TX 77406

I 96 2 4500N

OE 8 GAS OWNER SHU

7 St 29 St100 0000'5

20 84 26 0500N

fp ly FAIF 6 yd)(105A 7 0

(I I) D 10M GI tlt H,D

(I I 1) M 0 L M Gl thl H, D

(I 111) D IdM Gl thl

POB *580L I,VA 24266

0 1240U168 t 20 84

0 1551N

(I 112) M OL M Gl th) H,D

(I 1121) W y T Ib KB N,S1010 N M N I Rd

M 0 I BC 29835

0 041 3U504 t2084

0 0517N

(I 1122) J phJh LPd3123 P t kH yD Apt332F B*CI I,VA 22044

0 041 3U504 t2084

0 0517N

(I 1123) M DL I PPO 8 *188D YU B,MD 21035

0 041 3U504 t2084

0 0517N

(I 113) L IA MGIUI2859K IG pRd0 k W VA 24631

0 1240U168 t 20 84

0 1551N

(I 114) K T thy M Gl Ihl

2285 Cldb F RdH I,VA 24260

0 1240U168 t 20 84

0 1551N

(11) M 8 YdH,D

(111) L th 3 D Ie ydH,D

(1111) Klbye ydH D

(11111) J h YB ydH ,D

(«1«1) 3 vevd

(1111111)Clyd BydPO 8 *403CI I,VA 24226

(111112) L We vd

(1111121)Clyd 8 yd

PO 8 *403CI I,VA 24226

C I d I 15/2/20111 I tt/t 128

0 0059U3528 t 20 84

C I d I 15/2/20111 I tt/t 128

0 0059U3528 t 20 84

0 gtl74N

0 gtl74N

(111113)M h Ie vd

(1111131)Clyd 8 yd

PO 8 *403CI I,VA 24226

C I d I 15/2/20111 I tt/t 128

0 0059U3528 t 20 84

0 gtl74N

(I 1 I I 1 4) 6 tt e vd C I d I 15/2/20111 I tt/t 128

0 9 19 t 38 5/23/2017

Page Number 25.

Page 26: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlhlt 60 UR(1)

0 8 ttlVGOB tyGytSH(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 5

(1111141)Clyd 8 yd

PO 6 *403CI I,VA 24226

0 0059U3528 t 20 84

0 Otl74H

(11113) Clyd 8 yd

PO 6 *403CI I VA 24226

0 0236U882 t 20 84

0 0295H

(1112) Jh yBydH,D

(11121) J YB Yd

(111211) Clyd 8 yd

PO 6 *403CI I VA 24226

(11122) I RB Yd

(111221) Clyd 8 yd

PO 6 *403CI I VA 24226

C 7 d I 15/2/20111 I tt/t f28

0 0118U1764 t2084

C 7 d I 15/2/20111 I tt/t f28

0 0118U1764 t2084

0 0148H

0 0148H

(11123) M h IB yd

(111231) Clyd 8 yd

PO 6 *403CI I VA 24226

C 7 d I 15/2/20111 I tt/t f28

0 0118U1764 t2084

0 0148H

(11124) S ttB yd

(111241) Clyd 8 yd

PO 6 *403CI I VA 24226

C 7 d I 15/2/20111 I tt/t f28

0 0118U1764 t2084

0 0148H

(I I I 3) Clyd 6 vdPO 6 *403

CI I VA 24226

0 0473U441 t 20 84

0 0591H

(112) KlhyB ydH D

(1121) J h yB ydH,D

(11211) J yB yd

(112111) Clvd 8 vdPO 6 *403

CI I VA 24226

C y d I 15/2/20111 I tt/ti28

0 0118U1764 t2084

0 0148H

(I 1 2 I 2) I 0 8 yd

(112121) Clvd 8 vdPO 6 *403

CI I VA 24226

C y d I 15/2/20111 I tt/ti28

0 0118U1764 t2084

0 0148H

(11213) M h IB yd

(112131) Clvd 8 vdPO 6 *403

CI I VA 24226

C y d I 15/2/20111 I tt/ti28

0 0118U1764 t2084

0 0148H

(I 1 2 I 4) S tt 8 yd

(112141) Clvd 8 vdPO 6 *403

CI I VA 24226

C y d I 15/2/20111 I tt/ti28

0 0118U1764 t2084

0 0148H

(I 1 2 2) Clyd 8 yd

PO 6 *403CI I VA 24226

0 0473U441 t 20 84

0 0591H

(113) J h yBydH D

(1131)P I K 6yd

(11311)R IF 0

(113111)R thA F~0

C 7 d I tl R IF 5 27372005 D861t/466

C 7 d I/15/1987 2/3/2005 DB 328/659

C y d3/75/19891 I I I ly I d d d d d I I 7 ft D83257659d /FMFS J Fl» 8 yd7 f24 13D8 350/310

(1131111)K SK C y d5/3/1990 5 I I II tl I 09360/679

(11311111)R thA F 5 (P It C y 55V/7002 5 I I I/ tl I 09547/239

(113111111)R IF 5 H,D

(1131111111)AI D

28131 D I H 7H y, VA 24256

(I 1 4) Clyd 8 yd

PO 8 *4tl3CI I,VA 24226

0 094521441 t 20 84

0 094521441 t 20 84

0 1181H

0 1181H

(12) H YB YdH,D

(121) D It 8 yd

90 20 t38 5/23/2017

Page Number 26.

Page 27: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlhlt 50 UR(1)

0 k ttlVGQB ITGTISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 6

(1211) H * IN I 7PD 6 *155D p 0, VA 24239

0 0473U441 t 20 84

0 0591N

(1212) J t M dd12260 0 D

F I It 0 NC 28303

(I 2 I 3) Sh I J tt J2371D SRdH I VA 24260

0 0473U441 t 20 84

0 0473U441 t 20 84

0 0591N

0 0591N

(I 2 I 4) J dv 0 6 vd35tH 8 ydSRdg Rd0 \, VA 24656

0 0473U441 t 20 84

0 0591N

(I 2 I 5) R Iph 8 yd

PD 6 *122M, VA 24628

0 0473U441 t 20 84

0 0591N

(I 2 I 6) 8 d D ly

12226 yd'dg Rd0 \, VA 24656

0 0473U441 t 20 84

0 0591N

(1217) E lv 0 I

PCS *97H y* VA 24256

0 0473U441 t 20 84

0 0591N

(I 2 I 8)

(I 2 I 8 I

L OD IH,D

A 0 E D IH ,D

(121811) L d C pt

4240 R 09 I I 6 00 0, GA 30028

(121812) J DD328 U SI

BI I Id IUV 24701

0 0047U4410 t2084

0 0047U4410 t2084

0 Otl59N

0 Otl59N

(121813) Shd vS I vF0 6 *957

L I,VA 24266

0 0047U4410 t2084

0 Otl59N

(121814) SI T03610 W dD I D

M, FL 32754

0 0047U4410 t2084

0 Otl59N

(121815) D 10DPD 6 *413

R 0 I,VA 24280

0 0047U4410 t2084

0 Otl59N

(121816) L MG Y D

PCS *322D p 6 VA 24239

(121817) D gl D

1027 6 0 I D

H 7* VA 24256

0 0047U4410 t2084

0 0047U4410 t2084

0 Otl59N

0 Otl59N

(121818) 6 0 D I J15072 6 5 Rd6 t I,VA 242tl2

0 0047U4410 t2084

0 Otl59N

(121819) J 7 A D ITU H D

(1218191) Rh 0 R Ed133A I StH I,VA 24260

0 0016I H 3230 t 20 84

0 Otl20N

(1218192) K yM h 0 C 001161 k St9 0 0 MU, VA 24637

0 0016I H 3230 t 20 84

0 Otl20N

(I 2 I 8 1 9 3) S d M A dPQ 8 *2tl3R hf Id, QH 44286

0 0016I H 3230 t 20 84

0 Otl20N

(1218110) K YV D IH KD

(1218110H K YV D I,JPCS *8600 k d, VA 24631

0 0012U1 7640 I 2tl 84

0 0tH ON

(12181102) M I 0 J1229C pt *C 0 RdH I,VA 24260

0 0012U1 7640 I 2tl 84

0 0tH ON

(12181103) K t D2856 I RdJ I IUV 24850

0 0012U1 7640 I 2tl 84

0 0tH ON

Pg 21 138 512312017

Page Number 27.

Page 28: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlhlt 8U UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB 97OYISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 8

(12181104) K 4 SD10567H I H 0 H Y

H I,VA 24260

0 0012I/17640 I 2tl 84

0 0tH 5N

(129) Alf dE 8 ydH,D

(1291) M g 8 ydlNPUB *313D 0 0, VA 24239(8 d Add )

(I 2 9 2) A I D D18tl30 R h V 5 yRdAN gd ,VA 24210

Lf I I I/7 ff/441

0 0095N2205 t 20 84

0 0118N

(1293) 7 QB 8 yd

2905 tDAN gd ,VA 24210

0 0095N2205 t 20 84

0 0118N

(1294) L M St I y1813261 I H 0 Rd

AN gd ,VA 24210

0 0095N2205 t 20 84

0 0118N

(1295) J 6 YA0 8 Yd

PQ8 *313D 0 6 VA 24239

(1296) L QD 8 yd

16507f! I yG FRdAN gd ,VA 24210

0 0095N2205 t 20 84

0 0095N2205 t 20 84

0 0118N

0 0118N

(13) J 6 ydO

(1311) R IF 5

(13111)R IhA F 5

C 7 d8//5/1978 0 I I 61 I I R IF 0 D8259/343

C 7 d81/t5/t987D8 328/659

C y d3//5/19891 I I I ly I d d d d d I I 7 ft D83287659d /FMFSJ Fl» 8 ydy 124 13D8350/310

(13111HK gK C y d5/7/1990 // I I N tt I 06360/679

(1311111)R thA F 0 (P tt )

(13111111)R IF 0 H ,D

C y d5//R002 // I I I/ tt I 06547/239

(131111111)Ad D

28131 D I H 7H y, VA 24256

0 4253U49 t2084

0 5316N

(14) Id 6 ydFI lh H,D

(141) 6 ItyFI th128101dG * C I RdH I,VA 24260

0 07tl9U294 I 2tl 84

0 0886N

(142) G QFI th5692 D I Rd5 \, VA 24656

0 07tl9U294 I 2tl 84

0 0886N

(143) J D(D y)FI Ih H,D

(1431) Gl d KyFlth8864 H I H d Hm

H I ,VA 24260

0 07tl9U294 I 2tl 84

0 0886N

(144) J dFI th496 H I IN YAFI J206D It GA 30721

0 07tl9U294 I 2tl 84

0 0886N

(I 4 5) 6 Ih I A SI1950 SEC 50 yDP 0 StL, FL 34983 4674

0 07tl9U294 I 2tl 84

0 0886N

(146) 0151 M 94495 LP IDBl gt, IN 47404

(15) N yB ydJ k

(151) D IdM Gl thl H,D

0 07tl9U294 I 2tl 84

C 7 d9//7/1969

0 0886N

dhyd I 6 yd Ifh d fhf 0 Idhl Ql Ihl DS t93/125

(1511) M yL M Gl thl H D

(I 5 I I I) D Id A M Gl thl, JPQ8 *580L I,VA 24266

01063U196 I 2tl 84

0 1329N

(15112) M QL M Gl thl 8 0 H,D

Pg 22 138 5/23/2017

Page Number 28.

Page 29: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 5U UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB 37OTISHI34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Ub tU 5

N 51121) W y T Ib 08 K,S1010N M 0 \ RdM 0 I SC 29835

0 0354U588 t2084

0 0443N

(151122) J phJ h L P d

3123 P t kH yD Apt332F B*CI I,VA 22044

0 0354U588 t2084

0 0443N

(151123) M OL I PPO 5 *188D Yd B,MD 21035

0 0354U588 t2084

0 0443N

N5113) L hA MG)thl2859K IG pRd0 k W VA 24631

01063U196 t2084

0 1329N

(15114) K T thyM Gl thl

2285 Cldb F RdH I,VA 24260

01063U196 t2084

0 1329N

(16) M DB ydV

(I 6 I) R I F

N 611) R thA F 0

C 7 d8/75/1978 0 I I 61 I I R IF 0 DB 259/345

C 7 d I/15/1987 2/3/2005 DB 328/659

C y d3/75/19891 I I I ly I d d d d d I I 7 ft D83287659d /FMF8J pl» 8 ydy 124 13D8350/310

N6111) K 0K

(161111)R thA F~0 (P It

(1611111)R IF~0 H,D

C y d5/3/1990 0 I I N tl I D9360/679

C y 45//R007 // I I ll tl I D9547/239

(16111111)I I D

28131 D k H yH 7, VA 24256

0 4253U49 t2084

0 5316N

(17) St KBydH,D

(171) R byB ydP 41866LUI P t RdG dy, VA 24614

0 0851U2 45 t 20 84

0 1063N

N 7 2) Qp I 8 yd R d IU

(1721) D IdM Gl thl H,D

(17211) M DL M Gl thl H,D

(172111) D 14AMGIthI,JPCS *580L I,VA 24266

0 021 3U98tl I 2tl 84

0 0266N

N72112) MDL MG)thl Bd H,D

N 7 2 I I 2 I) W 7 T Ib 5 5 0 , S1010N M 0 \ RdM 0 I SC 29835

0 0071U2940 I 2tl 84

0 0089N

(1 7 2 I 1 2 2) J ph J h I P3123 P t kH yD Apt332F B*CI I,VA 22044

0 0071U2940 I 2tl 84

0 0089N

(1721123) MDL LPNPO 5 *188D Yd B,MD 21035

0 0071U2940 I 2tl 84

0 0089N

N72113) L IA MGI012859K IG pRd0 k W VA 24631

0 021 3U98tl I 2tl 84

0 0266N

(172114) K T thyM Gl Ihl

2285 Cldb F RdH I,VA 24260

0 021 3U98tl I 2tl 84

0 0266N

(173) N 8 yd C 7 d9/15/1970 I I 0 6 I I I D M Gl thl DB 197/37

(1731) D IdM Gl thl H,D

(17311) M DL M Gl thl H,D

(173111) D 14AMGIthI,JPCS *580L I,VA 24266

0 021 3U98tl I 2tl 84

0 0266N

(173112) M OL M Gl thl 6 0 H,D

(1731121) W y T Ib KB 0 ,S1010N M 0 \ RdM 0 I SC 29835

0 0071U2940 I 2tl 84

0 0089N

90 23 t38 5/23/2017

Page Number 29.

Page 30: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 60 UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB tyOYISN(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU h

(1 7 3 I 1 2 2) J ph J h I P3123 P t kH yD Apt332F B*CI I,VA 22044

0 0071I/2940 I 2tl 84

0 0089N

(1731123) M WL L P 4PO 8 *188D W B,MD 21035

0 0071I/2940 I 2tl 84

0 0089N

(173113) L I A M GI 012859K IG pRd0 k W VA 24631

0 021 3I/98tl I 2tl 84

0 0266N

(173114) K T thyM Gl Ihl

2285 Cldb F RdH I,VA 24260

0 021 3I/98tl I 2tl 84

0 0266N

(174) H 8 yd C 7 d9/15/1970 I I 0 6 I I I D M Gl thl DB 197/37

(1741) D IdM Gl thl H,D

(17411) MDLMGlthl H,D

(174111) D IUAMGIthI,JPOB *580L I,VA 24266

0 021 3 0 0266NI/98tl I 2tl 84

(174112) M WL M Gl thl 6 0 H,D

(1741121) W y T tb 68 A,S1010N M 0 \ RdM 0 I SC 29835

0 0071I/2940 I 2tl 84

0 0089N

(1741122) J phJ h I P3123 P t kH yD Apt332F B*CI I,VA 22044

0 0071I/2940 I 2tl 84

0 0089N

(1741123) M WL L P 4PO 8 *188D W B,MD 21035

0 0071I/2940 I 2tl 84

0 0089N

(174113) L I A M GI 012859K IG PRd0 k W VA 24631

0 021 3 0 0266NI/98tl I 2tl 84

(174114) K T tIYM GI 012285 Cldb F RdH I,VA 24260

0 021 3 0 0266NI/98tl I 2tl 84

(175) L 8ydD

(1751) R IF~0

(17511)R 15A F 0

(175111)K SK

(1751111)RthA F0 (P5 )

C y d I/15/1987 2/3/2095 DB 328/659

C 7 d3//5/19891 I I I ly I d d d d d I I 7 ft D83257659d IFMFSJ pl» 8 ydy 123 13D8359/310

C y d5/3/1999 // I I I/ tt I 06369/679

C y 55//R002 // I I I/ tt I 06547/239

(17511111)R IF 0 H ,D

(175111111)Ad D

28131 D I H 7H y, VA 24256

0 0851U2 45 t 20 84

0 1063N

(21) I Mydl H I 8 ydB Id H SD

(211) Mld dB ItH, D

(2 I I I) R y R 8 It H , D

(21 I I I) I M I W It

2372Lb NyHB*S thRdL I,TN 37681

0 0322I/648 I 2tl 84

0 0402N

(2112) Rt St RN2304 Gl 0 k D

W I I, KS 67216

0 0161U1296 t2084

0 0201N

(2113) P St 01779 5 G

H I 9 I, MI 48030

0 0161U1296 t2084

0 0201N

(2114) L M h ISt RN281583 I I DW, MI 48088

0 0161U1296 t2084

0 0201N

9 9 24 t 38 5/23/2017

Page Number 30.

Page 31: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 80 UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB 97UTISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 8

(2115) L M I Wtt2372Lb NyHS*S thRdL I,TN 37681

0 0161U1296 t2084

0 0201N

(2 I 2) J 8 tt H , D

(2 I 2 I) J 6 Id

2212 M

R 7 IO k M) 48067

0 0965U216 t 20 84

0 1206N

(2 I 3) R g G I K dy Kl gPO 8 3550 I I U,PA 15324

(214) R IYB Id

2014 Hgh StC y NNI F 5,QH 44221

(21 5) D 8 Id 9755 F I D

W I * 0,QH 43953

(216) Wh E g 6 Id

3870511 R t 14R I I,OH 442729795

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0121U1728 t2084

0 0302N

0 0302N

0 0302N

0 01 51N

(217)A d Std St kpl2311St t R t 44Al t, OH 44201

0 0121U1728 t2084

0 01 51N

(22) W It F 8 yd

4055 L M *I D5 M VA 24656

0 2894ID2 I 2tl 84

0 3618N

(23) L hV 6 yd8 ld H,D

(231) V I M Ch2066 W tl StG dy, VA 24614

(232) Qp IM It H t

(2321) J 0 0 6 Id

1261 8 Id Rd5 M VA 24656

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

0 0302N

(233) P I 8 Id

59316 kl CtAI 0, VA 22303

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

(234) L I M M 0

(2341) J 0 0 6 Id

1261 8 Id Rd5 M VA 24656

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

(2 3 5) 6 I h D 8 yd

11248 I hL dRd5 M VA 24656

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

(2 3 6) L V g M

4022 L M *t D5 M VA 24656

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

(2 3 7) H O N th 6 Id ,J4038 5 DT * 0 VA 24651

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

(238) J dyEI I thH gyPO 6 *1045 \, VA 24656

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

(239) G ORy dB Id H,D

(2391) M yM RM tB Id C y d3/JR008 ttp p dy 766 3t9 gg g I d IVB24/3933,D629/5431 I 0808781 J dyg Id

(23911) 4&76 Id

341 P *yl A

8 I,VA 24153

0 0080U2592 t2084

0 0101N

(2 3 9 2) J dy 8 Id

341 P *yl A8 I,VA 24153

0 0161U1296 t2084

0 0201N

(231tD 8 dlyD Btd H D

f 0 I dLOH5/3/17)

(231tll) By 6 Id

4122 Cldt Gl d I Rd

Sp G b 61 SC 29307

(2 3 Itl 2) A b J158 0 RdJ I TN 39330

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

Pg 25 t38 512312017

Page Number 31.

Page 32: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlhlt 8U UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB ITUTISH134Lltrt 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 8

(2311) J C 0 8 Id

1261 8 10 RdV rt VA 24656

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

(2312) 6 IM 8 10, H,,D

(23121) S IM *8 Id

(231211) J C H*B Id

1261 8 Id Rd5 \, VA 24656

(2 3 12 2) 8 d 5 tt 8 Id

(231221) CNXG 0 0 YLLCPQ 8 *643830Ptt 0 rth, PA 15264 3830

C y d3/JR008 3 I I p 5 0'

0080U2592 t2084

C y d9/JR007 3 I I WP 0'

0080U2592 t2084

0 0101N

0 0101N

0 G 0 0

(2 3 12 3) 9 rtl L I 8 Id

(231231) CNXG 0 0 YLLCPQ 8 *643830Ptt 0 rth, PA 15264 3830

(24)T I G UH,D

C y d9/JR007 3 I I 766319 gg 0 I

0 0080 0 0101NU2592 t2084

0 G 0 0

(241) M rt tShpl y46tls 8 k D

H 0 \ U,MD 21074

0 1447U144 I 2tl 84

0 1809N

(2 4 2) R I 0 G 6, 912161N 61 4 CIH p \ U,MD 21074

(2 5) Ad N 5 St ~ H , D

0 1447U144 I 2tl 84

0 1809N

(2 5 I) P I G RRII 8 *4255 \,VA 24656

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0603N

(252) T CI917 R BF SR Rd

H I I VA 24256

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0603N

(253) Slrtt MII

413881 gd I Rd8 t I,VA 242tl2

(254) V I 51637 D I*B I Rd5 \, VA 24656

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0603N

0 0603N

(2 5 5) T W 8 yd

16507f! 5 yG pRdAI gd, VA 24210

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0603N

(256) W y Stlt1586 D I*B I Rd5 \, VA 24656

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0603N

(26) M 8 yd853 JEE A

5 11 5, TN 37166

0 2894ID2 I 2tl 84

0 3618N

(2 7) J T 8 yd

1384D 1 8 I RdV rt VA 24656

0 2894ID2 I 2tl 84

0 3618N

(28) I FyB ydH,D

(281) H Cg )8 yd

236 G A D

9 0 8, TN 37166

0 2894ID2 I 2tl 84

0 3618N

(29) Ch 4 Mlt 8 ydH,D

(291) A El 8 ydH D

(2911) L *t 8 Yd

8 *182V rt VA 24656

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0603N

(2912) HI V I C I

4522 L G pRdV rt VA 24656

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0603N

(2913) 8 gyP k

5632 L M *t DV rt VA 24656

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0603N

(2914) P ggyC Tg H D

P g 26 1 38 512312017

Page Number 32.

Page 33: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 8U UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB ITUTISH134LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU h

(29141) J 8 YN IT0PCS *366H y, VA 24256

(29142) R A0 Tff12tlg 99 & 8 RdV M VA 24656

0 0080U2592 t2084

0 0080U2592 t2084

0 0101N

0 0101N

(2 9 I 4 3) D b Ly St4333 N Ah*1L I,VA 24266

0 0080U2592 t2084

0 0101N

(29144) F dd L Tb11tH R ye 0 H 0 RdV M VA 24656

0 0080U2592 t2084

0 0101N

(2 9 I 4 5) G O D I T 0

PO 6 *1262G dy, VA 24614

0 0080U2592 t2084

0 0101N

(29146) M I K yM413 D 10CM L

L I,VA 24266

0 0080U2592 t2084

0 0101N

(2918) J 6 8 vd4055 L M *I DV M VA 24656

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0603N

(2916) 8 b E16859 I G A

H b ffl VA 228tH

(2 10) M O 6 yd C k H, D

(2101) Ed MR 0C kH,D

0 0482U432 t2084

0 0603N

(21011) N y(Ed d)C k

1032 E 6 3 dgF 0 I MI 48220

0 0724U288 t2084

0 0905N

(2102) LI yd M h I C k

Itl316 k M IdDG dy, VA 24614

0 0724U288 t2084

0 0905N

(2103) E ID 0 I 8 H D

(21031) M kA th yC k,S H BD 0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

(210311) M kA th yC k,JAdd 0 I

(210312) D M C k

Add 0 I

(21032) E IC 3 J41ST Gg Rd

Ag H ghte G 96910

(21033) U*I 0PQ 8 *11483YU, G 96929

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

0 0302N

(2104) Wff MC k C I dhyd d IU33ROR0091 I 091089

(21041) S th R L

6228 EO AI V g NV 89110

0 0362U5 75 t 20 84

0 0452N

(21042) G UE 0966 Ch y Bl CtHGI I d*R 5 CO 80126

(2 1 I) M R 6 yd, J H , D

(2111) Lb M dh 6 ydH,D

0 0362U5 75 t 20 84

0 0452N

(21111) S d 6 ydS8PO 8 595V I,VA 24656

0 0724U288 t2084

0 0905N

(2 11 1 2) L ~ I 8 yd

PCS *265V I,VA 24656

0 0724U288 t2084

0 0905N

(21113) Sh me vdgt vPCS *980

V I,VA 24656

0 0724U288 t2084

0 0905N

(21114) R d ye yd

21109P \ dD8 *t I VA 24202

0 0724U288 t2084

0 0905N

(212)AM G yB ydH,D

(2121) J 8 ydH,D

Pg 27 t38 512312017

Page Number 33.

Page 34: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlhlt 86 UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB ITGTISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

A ION tU 8

(21211) M *h 56 yd3421 H ghg t RdR I 61, NC 27603

(2121 2) Th I 6 yd L

1012D t yRd86 R k VA 24603

(21213) F 08 yd

3117 L *I D9 \, VA 24656

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 03026

0 03026

0 03026

(2 12 I 4) J .H 8 yd5810 D *3 *Rd9 \, VA 24656

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 03026

(21215)A L 8ydC5y3631 M phy Rd9 \, VA 24656

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 03026

(21216) Et IP OB ydH,D

(212161) C th 8 yd

11605 LT H * 5,NC 28681

(2127) Ch 4 8 ydRI I 8 *578A9 \, VA 24656

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 03026

0 03026

(2128) WS 8 yd

RI2 8 *4649 \,VA 24656

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 03026

(2129) D dG8 yd

PCS 549 \, VA 24656

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 03026

(21210) St 8 yd6211 L *t D9 \, VA 24656

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 03026

(21211) R 0 dg yd

Itl82Ad *J Rd9 \, VA 24656

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 03026

(212121) D IdCI g1365 D I*B I Rd9 \, VA 24656

0 0121U1728 t2084

0 01 516

(212122) R I AF I I CI 0 H D

(2121221) M OL CI gRI I 8 *5tl3A9 \, VA 24656

0 0121U1728 t2084

0 01 516

(3) Ld J ph 8 ydH,D

(31) D ItB ydH,D

(31 I) M I T 6 yd

PO 6 *1620 I,WV 24826

0 5789U36 t 20 84

0 72366

(32) H dy6 yd H D

(321) Al 5 8 yd

2060 Ak W *t RdM 8 IS,OH 44903

0 5789U36 t 20 84

0 72366

(3 3) G 0 0 6 yd

(3 3 I) J t E F th ( k J t 6 yd) C 7 d4/16/20081 7 I h 7 I fth J IEB ydF lyT I dd I d5/24/2007

C y dt//3/2004hyd dt J 18 ydt k J IF fhlD8586/374

(3311) J tB yd,T *t2520 81 I RI83Mg I U,OH 44654

0 5789U36 t 20 84

0 72366

(34) F 8 ydH,D

(341) M OJ 6 yd C y dhyd dt h hid tp/20/2002D8 556/491

Pg 28 138 5/23/2017

Page Number 34.

Page 35: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 8U UR(1)

0 k tUVGOB IYUYISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 8

(3 4 I I) I *8 yd M g H , D

(34111) 9 I 9 5EPD 411360 GI 0 Rd

CI \ N'6 VA 23838

0 0289ID2tl I 2tl 84

0 0362N

(34112) D 9 08 87tl7A G pRd

M 0 8, TN 37354

0 0289ID2tl I 2tl 84

0 0362N

(34113) PhBpM h IM g5732 0 I MB CtGl AB VA 23059

0 0289ID2tl I 2tl 84

0 0362N

(34114) SI PI M M 01726 L A

P t b U,VA 23803

(34115) R 0 KEIW M g16655 6 I \ Rd9 0 I U,VA 23803

0 0289ID2tl I 2tl 84

0 0289ID2tl I 2tl 84

0 0362N

0 0362N

(3412) R b KC 0 8 yd

9611HYWI U t1959 b t, FL 32958

0 1447U144 I 2tl 84

0 1809N

(3413) Ed J PI T YI H,D

(3 4 I 3 I ) K 5 M J h *t45246 Lgltl Rd9 Yp M MD 20674

(34132) K N IQ It

90108 dg ItL L 125L PI t,MD 20646

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

0 0302N

(3 4 I 3 3) K t El b th Q9010 8 dg ItL L 125L PI t, MD 20646

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

(34134) C I S I dQ90108 dg ItL L 125L PI t,MD 20646

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

(3 4 I 3 5) D 0 J StAdd 0 I

(34136) J h Th MlAdd 0 I

(3414) F T I g 8 yd,J50 K kl yPIF *\ VA 24551

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 0241U864 I 2tl 84

0 1447U144 I 2tl 84

0 0302N

0 0302N

0 1809N

(3 5) F g 8 yd H D

(3 5 I) St 5 H 0 8 yd 0PCS *327S M*C k VA 24649

0 5789U36 t 20 84

0 7236N

(36) J ph D h gH,D

(36HRbdDhg

(3 6 I I) D It 8 yd H , D

C I dhyd d 12/30R003 Dg 584 587

(3 6 I I I ) M I T 8 yd

PO 8 1620 I,WV 24826

0 5789U36 t 20 84

0 7236N

(4)ld C lb 6ydD Id A hl Gl fhl 8/19/1964

F kaydE I I II ftd ByddG CSth I d 7

(41) D 14 A M GI tht H, D

(411) M yL M Gl thl H D

(4111) D IdA M Gl thl,JPCS *580L I,VA 24266

0 8683U24 t 20 84

I 0854N

(4112) M DL MWI thl 6 0 H,D

(4 I I 2 I) W y T Ib 0 8 9 91010 N M 0 \ RdM 0 I SC 29835

0 2894ID2 I 2tl 84

0 3618N

(41122) J phJ h L P 03123P I kH DD Apt332F 5 Ch h,VA 22044

0 2894ID2 I 2tl 84

0 3618N

Pg 29 t38 512312017

Page Number 35.

Page 36: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 6U UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB IFSFISH134LltM 00 ICII I

(4 I I 2 3) M O L L PPO 6 *188D 76 B,MD 21035

A I Uh

0 2894ID2 I 2tl 84

tU 6

0 3618H

(4133) L hA M Gl thl

2859K IG pRd0 k W VA 24631

0 8683U24 t 20 84

I 0854H

(41 14) K 7 thyM Gl thl

2285 Cldb F RdH I,VA 24260

0 8683U24 t 20 84

I 0854H

(5) FMFB ydH,D

(511) M Hh 8 ydg dhM yPCS 35F I,KY 41528

0 3859U54 t 20 84

0 4824H

(512) H It M Ch8 *4407 I,VA 24656

0 3859U54 t 20 84

0 4824H

(51 3) D thy HbbU5602 D I Rd9 M VA 24656

0 3859U54 t 20 84

0 4824H

(514) J g EgydH,D

(5 I 4 I) A d I D 8 ydPCS 479 h p, VA 246tl4

0 3859U54 t 20 84

0 4824H

(515) K thl 8 ydL kh AH,D

(6 I 6 I) I D

(51511) CI \ L H 0PCS *2439 M VA 24656

0 0322 0 0402HU648 I 2tl 84

(51512) RHI J yL kh 0PCS *9429 M VA 24656

0 0322 0 0402HU648 I 2tl 84

(51513) F L kh 0PCS *9429 M VA 24656

0 0322 0 0402HU648 I 2tl 84

(5152) Ch \ L kl 0PO 6 *2439 \, VA 24656

0 0965 0 1206HU216 t 20 84

(5153) R g J yL kh 0PUB *9429 \, VA 24656

0 0965 0 1206HU216 t 20 84

(5154) F L kh 0PUB *9429 \, VA 24656

0 0965 0 1206HU216 t 20 84

(51 6) Mydl 8 yd

(5161) D IdA M Gl thl H,DC y dtg/t8/t975 0 I I h I df FMFB yd J I D IdM Gl thl 08231/342

(51611)M OL M Gl thl H,D

(516111)D 15A M GI SI,JPO 8 580L I VA 24266

0 0965U216 t 20 84

0 1206H

(5 I 6 I I 2) M R L M gl thl 9 0 H D

(5 I 6 I I 2 I) W I 7 Ib 0 9 0 , S1010K M 0 \ RdM 0 I SC 29835

0 0322U648 I 2tl 84

0 0402H

(5161122) J phJ h I P3123 P t kH yD Apt332F B*CI I,VA 22044

0 0322U648 I 2tl 84

0 0402H

(5161123) M OL L P 5PO 6 *188D 76 B,MD 21035

0 0322U648 I 2tl 84

0 0402H

(516133) L I A M GI 012859K IG pRd0 k W VA 24631

0 0965U216 t 20 84

0 1206H

(516114) K 7 thyM Gl Ihl

2285 Cldb F RdH I,VA 24260

0 0965U216 t 20 84

0 1206H

(5 I 7) J *E H 8 yd C y d3/17/1988 0 I I I OSG I I df FMFB yd J I 0 IdA M gl thl

(5171) D IdA M Gl thl H,D

(51711)M OL M Gl thl H,D

Pg 30 t38 5/23/2017

Page Number 36.

Page 37: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 6U UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB IFSFISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 6

(517111)D 14A M GI UI,JPO 8 580L I VA 24266

0 0965U216 t 20 84

0 1206U

(5 I 7 I I 2) M O L M gl thl 6 0 H, D

(5 I 7 I I 2 I) W y 7 Ib 0 6 4 , S1010 H M 0 \ RdM 0 I SC 29835

0 0322U648 12tl 84

0 0402U

(5171122) J phJ h I P3123 P t kH yD Apt332F B*CI I,VA 22044

0 0322U648 12tl 84

0 0402U

(5171123) M OL L P 4PO 6 *188D 76 B,MD 21035

0 0322U648 12tl 84

0 0402U

(517133) L I A M GI 012859K IG 5Rd0 k W VA 24631

0 0965U216 t 20 84

0 1206U

(517114) K 7 tIYM GI 012285 Cldb F RdH I,VA 24260

(5 I 8) H * I M d I 6 yd H , D

0 0965U216 t 20 84

0 1206U

(5 I 8 I) M dh 6 yd S dh M yPCS 35F I,KY 41528

0 0551U378 t2084

0 0689U

(5182) H tt M Ch8 *4400 I,VA 24656

0 0551U378 t2084

0 0689U

(5183) D thyHbbB5602 D I Rd0 I VA 24656

0 0551U378 t2084

0 0689U

(5184) J g 6 8 ydH,D

(5 I 8 4 I ) A d y D 6 yd

PCS 478 5 0 VA 24604

0 0551U378 t2084

0 0689U

(5185) K thl 6 ydL kh KH D

(51851) I D Cyd2/77/20171101 IICI I LkhdRgJyLkldSFL kid(518511) Ch U L kh 0

PCS *2430 M VA 24656

0 0046U4536 t2084

0 gtl57U

(518512) RW J yL kh 0PCS *9420 M VA 24656

0 0046U4536 t2084

0 gtl57U

(518513) F L kl 0PCS *9420 M VA 24656

0 0046U4536 t2084

0 gtl57U

(51852) CI \ L H 4PO 6 *243V \, VA 24656

(51853) RHI J yL kh 0PUB *942V \, VA 24656

(51854) F L kh 0PUB *942V \, VA 24656

0 0138U1512 t2084

0 0138U1512 t2084

0 0138U1512 t2084

0 0172U

0 0172U

0 0172U

(5186) Mydl 6 ydH 4W g H D

(51861) J OW g H,D

(518611) D yR yW g

W Id, FL 32694

0 0184U1134 t2084

0 0230U

Pg 31 t38 512312017

Page Number 37.

Page 38: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 8U UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB IYUYISHI34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 8

(518612) L WW g833 K g*l yA0 g P S FL 32073

(5 I 8 6 I 3) D y R y W g

W Id, FL 32694

(5187) J 8 tB ydH,D

0 0184U1134 t2084

0 0184U1134 12tl84

0 0230U

0 0230U

(51871) 6 ItySt UN 8 k 8 yd

29L YLF I,KY 41528

0 0092U2268 t 20 84

0 0115U

(51872)J BO tB ydIQS *960 I,VA 24656

0 0092U2268 t 20 84

0 0115U

(5 I 8 7 3) M h I L 8 yd

3574 LIB F *0 I D

0 I,VA 24656

0 0092U2268 t 20 84

0 0115U

(51874) D SG 8 yd

4562 M Why Rd0 I,VA 24656

0 0092U2268 t 20 84

0 0115U

(5 I 8 7 5) 6 dl I D 8 Yd

IQS *960 I,VA 24656

0 0092U2268 t 20 84

0 0115U

(51876) R kyAS 8 yd

444 F DCh t *b 01 VA 24073

0 0092U2268 t 20 84

0 0115U

(5 I 9) D d F 6 yd H D

(5 I 9 I) I D Cyd2/77/2017110111CI I LkhdRgJyLk/HSFL kid(51911) CI \ L H 0

PO 6 *2430 M VA 24656

0 0429U486 I 2tl 84

0 0536H

(51912) RW J yL kh 0PQ8 *9420 M VA 24656

0 0429U486 I 2tl 84

0 0536H

(5 I 9 I 3) F L I 3 6PQ8 *9420 M VA 24656

0 0429U486 I 2tl 84

0 0536H

(5193) R g J yL kh 0PUB *9425 \, VA 24656

0 1286U162 t2084

0 1608U

(5194) F L kh 0PUB *9425 \, VA 24656

0 1286U162 t2084

0 1608U

(6)L hVt 80(6 I) D IdA M Gl thl H,D

(6 I 1) M 0 L M Gl thl H, D

(6 111) D Idh M Gl UI,JPO 8 580L I VA 24266

0 1240U168 t2084

0 1551U

(6 I I 2) M 7 L M gl thl 8 0 H, D

(6 I I 2 I) W I 7 Ib 6 8 0 , SIgltlN M G t RdM 0 I, SC 29835

0 041 3U504 I 2tl 84

0 0517U

(6 1122) J phJ h I P3123 P I kH OD Apt 332F 3 Ch h VA 22044

0 041 3U504 I 2tl 84

0 0517U

(6 1123) MOL LP0PO 8 188D 6 3 MD 21035

(6 133) L IA MGIUI2859 K I G p Rd0 k d, VA 24631

0 041 3U504 I 2tl 84

0 1240U168 t2084

0 0517U

0 1551U

(6 114) K 7 thy M Gl Ihl

2285 Cldt F RdH I, VA 24260

0 1240U168 t2084

0 1551U

(61)F M 6 K

(611) R IF 3

(6 I I I) R th A F 0

(61111)K gK

C y dt/49 7/10/19761 R IF 0 06239/549

C 7 d I/15/1987 DB 328/659

C y d 3/75/19891 I I I ly 06 350/310

C y d5/3/1990 // I I II tl I 06360/679

0 9 32 t 38 5/23/2017

Page Number 38.

Page 39: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 8U UR(1)

0 k tffVGGB ITUTISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 8

(611111)R thA F~0 (P It g

(6111111)R IF~0 H,D

(61111111)Al D

28131 D k H yH y, VA 24256

0 4253U49 t2084

0 53168

(62) Alb KA 8 6 H D

(621)S hJBd ItL hCBH

(62111) H IB 0 H,D

(62111HH NM 8 0 H,D

(6 2 I I I I I) E 8 8 0PDI *1655 I,VA 24656

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 01338

(6 2 I I I 2) M D C th 8 H D

(6 2 I I I 2 I) E 5 I

2926 01 D

8 *t I TN 24201

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 01338

(6 2 I I I 3) L th M 8 0 H D

fd I I 0 I d 4/5/1 71

(6211131)Alt 8 6127 V D

7 d t, VA 23692

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 01338

(621114) H * U Sh1108 L I dcV g 8 h,VA 23464

(6 2 I I I 5) H It R th 8 0 T 0 H ,,D

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 01338

(6 2 I I I 5 I) L h L T 0 H 8 D

(6 2 I I I 5 I I) M It G I Tff L *t1192A I RdR VA 24646

0 0027ID840 I 2tl 84

0 Otl338

(62111512)St 8 dG GT01256A I RdR VA 24646

0 0027ID840 I 2tl 84

0 Otl338

(62tt(513)RW GI 5 dySt18741 d G G pRd5 \, VA 24656

0 0027ID840 I 2tl 84

0 Otl338

(62111514)M L T0210M Ik *0 I RdBl d, VA 24315

(621116) L NM dl SI pp 58919 P t kH yH IPI KVA 23959

0 0027ID840 I 2tl 84

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 Otl338

0 01338

(6 2 I I I 7) V g I 8 0 J h

648 H IpLS 5 0 VA 24590

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 01338

(621118) JCB 62469M 0 0 I RdG I 5 VA 24333

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 01338

(6 2 I I I 9) Mt h 0 W I 8 0186 R 0 g M d RdL I ,VA 24266

(6 2 I I 1 10) D C dy M C pb 0 P 88 776L I,VA 24266

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 01338

0 01338

(6212) J 0 8 0 H,D

(62121) I 8 0 H,D

Pg 33 t38 512312017

Page Number 39.

Page 40: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 80 UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB IYUYISM(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I UU tU 8

(621211) V k 6 E ly

585201 6 50R I, VA 24018

0 0532U392 t 20 84

0 06658

(6 2 I 2 I 2) 7 6 M

2236 dg,Ch H 0 RdN dhp 0, NY 11768

(6213)C dB 6 H,D

0 0532U392 t 20 84

0 06658

(62131) S d 6 6 HbbtU4717 8 yd Rdg Rd0 I VA 24656

01063U196 I 2tl 84

0 13298

(6214) Elb AD 8 0 H,,D

(62141) D 0R 8 0

(62141 N CNXG 0 0 YLLCPO 8 643830Pll b gh PA 15264 3830

(62142) D IdP 6 6

(62142 N CNXG 0 0 YLLCPO 8 643830Pll b gh PA 15264 3830

(6 2 I 4 3) J L 8 0

0 0266 0 03328IR84 I 2tl 84

0 0266 0 03328IR84 I 2tl 84

(62143 N CNXG 0 0 YLLCPO 8 643830Pll b gh PA 15264 3830

(62144) D 8 d g

0 0266IR84 I 2tl 84

0 03328

(62144 N CNXG 0 0 YLLCPO 8 643830Pll b gh PA 15264 3830

0 0266IR84 I 2tl 84

0 03328

(6 3) J C 6 6 H D

(6 3 I) I 6 6 H , D

(6 3 I I) V k 8 E dy

5852 CI 0 0 0R I,VA 24018

0 2127U98 I 2tl 84

0 26588

(6312) 7 8 M

2236 dg,Ch H 0 RdN dhp 0, NY 11768

0 2127U98 I 2tl 84

0 26588

(64)8 hJBA H,D

(641)F MBA H,D

(6 4 I I) H I 6 6 C y dtt/t2/t9981 C /8 0 06485/422

(64111)0 IB 0 H,D

(641111)S d 8 0 Hbbth4717 8 yd Rdg Rd0 I,VA 24656

01063 0 13298U196 I 2tl 84

(6 4 2) J *0 8 0 H , D

(6 4 2 I) V k E ly

(6 4 2 I 1) 0 I 8 0 H , D

C y dtt/t2/t9981 C /8 0 06485/422

(642111) S d 8 0 Hbbth4717 8 yd Rdg Rd0 I,VA 24656

0 0532U392 t 20 84

0 06658

(6422) 7 M C y dtt/t2/t9981 C /8 0 06485/422

(64221) 0 IB 0 H,D

(642211) S d 8 0 Hbbth4717 8 yd Rdg Rd0 I,VA 24656

0 0532U392 t 20 84

0 06658

(6 4 3) 0 I 8 0 H , D

(6431) S d 8 0 Hbbd4717 8 yd Rdg Rd0 I,VA 24656

01063 0 13298U196 I 2tl 84

Pg 34 138 5/23/2017

Page Number 40.

Page 41: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 8U UR(1)

0 k ttlVGGB ITUTISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 8

(644) E~ rtD 8 rt H,D

(6 4 4 I) J L 8 rt C y dtt/t2/t9981 C /8 rt 09485/422

(64411) 0 IB rt H,D

(644111) S d 8 rt Hbbth4717 8 yd Rrtg Rd6 I,VA 24656

0 0266IR84 I 2tl 84

0 0332H

(8442) D tde e,rt

(64421) 0 IB rt H,DC y dtt/t2/t9981 C /8 rt 09485/422

(644211) S d 8 rt Hbbth4717 8 yd Rrtg Rd6 I,VA 24656

0 0266IR84 I 2tl 84

0 0332H

(8443) D UR 8 0 C y dtt/t2/t9981 C /8 rt 09485/422

(64431) 0 IB rt H,D

(644311) S d 8 rt Hbbth4717 8 yd Rrtg Rd6 I,VA 24656

0 0266 0 0332HIR84 I 2tl 84

(6444)DBBrt 8dg C y dtt/t2/t9981 C /8 rt 09485/422

(64441) 0 IB rt H,D

(644411) S d 8 rt Hbbth4717 8 yd Rrtg Rd6 I,VA 24656

0 0266IR84 I 2tl 84

0 0332H

(6 5) Alb rt A 8 rt H , D

(65HS hJBrt ItL hCBrt

(65111) H IB rt H,D

(651111)H GM 8 rt H,D

(6 5 I I I I I) E 6 8 rt

PDI *1656 I VA 24656

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 0133H

(6 5 I I I 2) M D C th I H D

(6 5 I I I 2 I) E 6 I

2926 01 D

8 *t I TN 24201

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 0133H

(6 5 I I I 3) L th M 8 rt H D

fd I I 0 I d 4/5/171

(6511131)Alt 8 rt

127 V D

Y d t, VA 23692

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 0133H

(651114) H * U Sh1108 L I dcV g 8 h,VA 23464

(6 5 I I I 5) H It R th 8 rt T 0 H ,,D

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 0133H

(6 5 I I I 5 I) L h L T 0 H 8 D

(6 5 I I I 5 I I) M It G I Td L *t1192A I RdR VA 24646

0 0027IR840 I 2tl 84

0 Otl33H

(65111512)St 8 dG GT01256A I RdR VA 24646

0 0027IR840 I 2tl 84

0 Otl33H

(65111513)RNI G I 5 dySt18741 d G G pRd5 \, VA 24656

0 0027IR840 I 2tl 84

0 Otl33H

(65111514)M L T0210 W Ik *0 I RdBl d, VA 24315

(651116) L hM rth Sh pp d8919P t kH YHMPI 5 VA 23959

0 0027IR840 I 2tl 84

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 Otl33H

0 0133H

(6 5 I I I 7) 6 0 I 8 rt J648 H IpLS 5 0 VA 24590

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 0133H

Pg 35 t38 5/23/2017

Page Number 41.

Page 42: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 8U UR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB IYSYISH(34LltM 00 ICII I

A I Uh tU 8

(651118)JCB rt

2469M 0 0 I RdG I 5 VA 24333

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 0133N

(6 5 I I I 9) Mt h 0 W y 8 rt

186 R 0 g M d RdL I ,VA 24266

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 0133N

(6511110)D 0 dYM C PI dprt8 776L I,VA 24266

0 0106U1 960 I 2tl 84

0 0133N

(eSISIJ cert H UD

(65121) I 8 rt H,D

(651211) V k 8 E ly

585201 6 bcR I, VA 24018

0 0532U392 t 20 84

0 0665N

(6 5 I 2 I 2) 7 6 M

2238 dS,Ch H 0 RdN rthp rt, NY 11768

(8613) 0 de 0 H,D

0 0532U392 t 20 84

0 0665N

(65131) S d 8 rt Hbbdrt4717 8 yd Rdg Rd5 I VA 24656

01063U196 I 2tl 84

0 1329N

(6 5 I I 4) Elb rt D 8 rt H D

(e61141) 0 SR e 0

(6511411)CNXG 0 0 YLLCPO 8 643830Pdt b Gh, PA 15264 3830

0 0266ID84 I 2tl 84

0 0332N

(651142) D Idg 8 rt

(6511421) CNXG 0 0 YLLCPO 8 643830Pdt b Gh, PA 15264 3830

0 0266 0 0332NID84 I 2tl 84

(6 5 I I 4 3) J L 8 rt

(6511431)CNXG 0 0 YLLCPQ 8 *643830Pll b gh PA 15264 3830

(651144) D 8 W g

0 0266 0 0332NID84 I 2tl 84

(6511441) CNXG 0 0 YLLCPO 8 643830

Pg*b gh, PA 15264 3830

(66)C IBrt H D

0 0266ID84 I 2tl 84

0 0332N

(661) S d 8 rt Hebth4717 8 yd Rdg RdV M VA 24656

0 4253U49 t2084

0 5316N

(6 7) Elb rt D 8 rt H D

(6 7 I) 8 It V 8 rt

(6 7 I I) D d R 8 rt

(67111)CNXG C p yLLCPO 8 643830

Pg*b gh, PA 15264 3830

01063 0 1329NU196 I 2tl 84

(6712)D IdP 8 rt

(67121) CNXG C p yLLCPQ 8 *643830Pll b gh PA 15264 3830

(6713) J L 8 0

01063U196 I 2tl 84

0 1329N

(67131) CNXG C p yLLCPQ 8 *643830Pll b gh PA 15264 3830

(6714) D 8 d g

01063U196 I 2tl 84

0 1329N

(67141) CNXG C p yLLCPQ 8 *643830Pll b gh PA 15264 3830

01063 0 1329NU196 I 2tl 84

Pg 36 138 512312017

Page Number 42.

Page 43: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlblt 80 NR(1)

0 k ttlVGOB ITOTISHI34LltM 00 ICII I

A INN tU h

(I) G d R byC p(20316A 7 01086 d yR d

M 1 Nc 28117

29 66 37 0750N

(I) JI WPI IJ(25022A 7 0

L tdPNhp'JhCIMUUPA

4710 H \ 00R I 0, TX 77406

G i DIPL,Lp'710

H \ 00R I 0, TX 77406

( i FH 0 b,hT,t „t,OT„,tPO 8 *841T 1, VA 24651

27 54

6 89U4 t2754

2 30U12 12754

2 30U12 12754

34 4250N

8 6063N

2 8688N

2 8688N

(d)MNI EcNB I FEd MltC126 W I M SIT 1, VA 24651

2 30U12 12754

2 8688N

IJI WPI IJ8 *86R, PA 18953

2 30U12 12754

2 8688N

(I) VN Lk'3248

tl 6 BRd0 0 I, WA 99037

2 30U12 12754

2 8688N

Sl)WK tPbtT

(gl)RhdKPbt'91N

I 0 D

0 N * 5,GA 30121

2 30U12 12754

2 8688N

(g2) C th P b t'Ly RO k

111 P *t II St t0 N * 5,GA 30120

2 30U12 12754

2 8688N

0)M dlhEJ g2418M *tL 0 60N I 5, TN 37212

4 59U6 t2754

5 7375N

'P I gpl tg d C* N 488.08A MW 100'5 1th CSM y lty

7 S4 ~ 196

(I) JI WPI IJ(31015A 7 0

L tdPN hpNJhCI MggPA4710 H \ 00R I 0, TX 77406

I 96

0 49U4 t196

2 4500N

0 6125N

il I DIPL, Lp4710 H \ 00R I 0, TX 77406

016U12 t196

0 2042N

( i FH 0 b,hT,t „t,OT„,tPO 8 *841T 1, VA 24651

016U12 t196

0 2042N

id)MNI EcNB I FEd MltC126 W I M SIT 1, VA 24651

016U12 t196

0 2042N

()JI WPI IJ8 *86R, PA 18953

016U12 t196

0 2042N

(0VDI L k

43248 tl 6 BRd0 0 I, WA 99037

016U12 t196

0 2042N

Sl)WK tPbtT

(01)RhdKPbt391NI 0 D

0 N * 5,GA 30121

016U12 t196

0 2042N

Pg 37 t38 512312017

Page Number 43.

Page 44: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

~*hlhlt 80 UR) I)

0 k ttlVGOS ITGTISN)34LltM 00 )CII I

A I UU tU h

(g2) C th P 0 t

U Ly RO k

111P *t 0 St t0 6 * I,GA 30120

016U12 t196

0 2042M

ih) M dlhE I g2418M *tL 0 ShN I I, TN 37212

0 33U6 1196

0 4083M

Pg 38 t38 612312017

Page Number 44.

Page 45: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Exhibit 6.3Unit R(-1)

DocketgVGOB 1707184134List of Unleassd Owners/Claimants

Acres In UnitPercentof Unit

COAL OWNERSHIP

7 Mal. 2nnri

Josephine Boyd Helm, Devisees,Successors or Assigns, st al.fmevmusly FMF Boyd)(105ricm yrecg

(1) Hester Boyd Heim, Dsvissss,Successols or Assrghs

(1.1) Marion Boyd Heim, Devisees.Successors or Assigns

20.84 acres

(1.1.1) Lath* A. Desi Boyd Ham, Dmnsees,Sucmsscmr or'ssrgrls

(1.1.1.1)Kilhy Boyd Heim, Dewsees,Successom or Assigns

(1.1.1.1.1)Johnny Boyd Heirs, Devaees,Successors or Assign!

(I 1 1.1.1.1)Jimmy Boyd

(1.1.1.1.1.1.1)Clyde BoydPO Box 403CBnchco, VA 24226

(1.1.1.11.2) Larry Boyd

(1.1.1.1.1.2I) Clyde BoydPO Box 403Clinchco. VA 24226

(1 1,1.11.3) Michael Boyd

(1.1.11.1,31) Clyde BoydPO Box 403Canchco, VA 24226

(1.1.1.1.14) Scog Boyd

(1.1.1.1.1.4.1)Clyde BoydPO Box 403Clinchco, VA 24226

(1.1.1.1.3)Clyde BoydPO Box 403

Clinches, VA 24226

Conveyed interest &2201I instr I I/I f28

0.DOSS acres1/3520 of 20.04 acres

Conveyedinleresl 52/2011 Instr 11/I f28

0 0050 acres1/3528 of 20.84 acres

conmyed interest szrzpf I Instr 11/1128

O DO50 scree1l3528 of 20 84 acres

Conmy d nleresl 52/2011 tnstr 11/1126

O.OOSS acres1OSZ0 ol Z0.84 sums

0.0236 acres1/002 of 20.04 acres

0.0074%

0.0074%

0.0074%

0.0074%

0 0205%

(1.1.1.2) Johnny Boyd Heim, Devissss,8uccessom or Assigns

(1.1.1.2.1)Jimmy Boyd

(1.1.1.2.1.1)Clyde BoydPO Box 403

Clinchco, VA 24220

Conveyed interest Smzgf I Inse. 11/1128

0.0110 acres1/1764 of20.04scres

0.0145%

(1 1.1.2.2) Lany Boyd

(1.1.1.2.2.1)Clyde BoydPO Box 403

Clinchco, VA 24226

Conveyed interest 52/Zpf1 Instr. 11/1128

0.0118 acres1/1 764 of 20.04 acres

0.0148%

(1.1.1.3) Clyde BoydPO Box 403

Cfnchco, VA 24226

0.0473 acres1/441 of 20.84 acres

0.0501%

(1.1.2) Kgby Boyd Heim. Dsvtsees,Successors or Assigns

(1.1.2.1)Johnny Boyd Heim, Devlsses,Successors m Assigns

(1.1.2.1.1)Jimmy Boyd

(1.I.2.1.1.1)Clyde BoydPO Box 403

Cfnchco, VA 24226

(1 1.2.1.2) Larry Boyd

(I 1.2.1.2.1) Clyde BoydPO Box 403

Clrnchco. VA 24226

Conmyed rnlerest 5/zr20fl Instr. 11/I 128

0 0118 acres1/1764 of2D.84 acres

Conmyed hlerest 5/2I7011 Ines. 11/1120

O.Oi18 acres1/1764 of 20.84 acres

0.0140%

0.014014

(1.1.2.13) Mnhael Boyd conveyed interest 5/zgof1 Instr. 11/1128Page 1 of 10 5I23/201 7

Page Number 45.

Page 46: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Exhibit 8-3Unit R(-1)

Docket 99008 17-0718<734Ust of Unleased OwnersIClalmants

Acres In UnitPercentof Unit

(1.1.2.1.3.1)Clyde BoydPO Box 403

Clinchco, VA 24226

0.0118acmeIII764 of 2D.84 acres

D.0148%

(1.1.2.1.4) Scott Boyd

(1.1.2.1.4.1)Clyde BoydPO Box 403

Clinchco, VA 24226

conveyed inleresl 6/27207 f Instr. f I/7 728

0.0118 acresIII 704 of 2D.84 acres

D.0148%

(1.1.2.2) Clyde BoydPO Box 403

Clinchco, VA 24226

0.0473 acresI/441 of 20.84 acres

D D591%

(1.1.3)Johnny Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(I I 3.1) Pamela Karen Boyd

(I 1.31.1) Ruat Fuber

(1.1.3.1.1I) Ruth Ann Fuller

(I 1.3.11.1.1)tang Koala. Inc.

(1.1.31.1.11.1) Ruth Ann Fuller (Potter)

(I I 3 1.1.1.1.1I) Ruat Fuller Heirs. Devisees,Successors Or Assfgns

Conveyed inleresl lo Ruat Fuller 2/&2005 DB 677/460

Conveyed I/75/1967 2/3/2005 DB 328/059

corweyed 326/7989 Irecls of coal only induded und 'dad Inlets el inTr 11 D8326859, lends of FAIF & Josephine Boyd Tr 12 & 13DB 350/370

Con eyed 53/7990 all rnleresls in sutyecl Irecls DB 3607879

Can eyed &rtt/002 all interests rn subject tracts DB 547/239

(1.1.31.1.11.1.1.1)Adsns Deal28131 Dicksnson Hwy

Haysi, VA 24250

(1.1.4) Clyde BoydPO Box 403

Clinchm, VA 24226

0.0945 acres2I441 of 20.84 acres

D.0945 acres7/441 of 20 04 acres

0.1181%

0 1161%

(1.3) Josie Boyd Owens

(1.3.1.1) Ruat Fuller

(1.3.1.1.1)Ruth Ann Fuller

(1.3.1.1.1.1)King Koch, Inc.

(1.3.1.1.1.1.1)Ruth Ann Fuller (Poker)

(1.31.1.1.1.1.1)Rust Fuller Heim, Dsvisees,Successors or Assighs

Con eyed 8//fyf 978 alii niwesl in 6 rnrcls to Real Fuller DB 259/343

Conmyed afire'198T DB 328/li59

Conveyed 3/250989 I eels of coal only included undivided inierssi in Tr 11 DBZZI7059,lands of FMF & Josephrne Bo)d Tr. 72 & 13DB 350/310

conmyed 50/felid ell inleresls in sub/eci frecle DB 360/079

Conve)ad 6/7/2002 elf inreresfs in sutyscl Iracls DB 547//3e

(1.3.1.1.1.1.1.1.1)Adene Deal28131 Dickenson Hwy

Haysl, VA 24256

0.4253 acresI/49 of 20.84 acres

0.5316%

(1.6) Mwyeoyduence

(1.6.1) Rust Fuller

(1.61.1) Ruth Ann Fuller

(1.61.1.1)King Koala, Inc.

(1.6.1.1.1.1)Ruth Ann Fuller (Potter)

(1.6.1.1.1I I) Ruat Fuller Heirs, Devitses,Successors or Assigns

conveyed 8/25/797e all interests H 6 tracts io Real Fuew DB 259/345

Conveyed I/15'19877/3/7005 DB 328/659

Conveyed 3/25'1989 Irects of coal only nciuded undvded interest irr Tr. 11 DB326059,lands of FMF & Josephine Boyd tr 12 & 13 DB 350070

Con eyed 50/1990 all inleresls in mbject tracts DB 360/679

Conveyed Er//2002 ail inieresls in sutyecl Irscts DB 547/)39

(1.6.1.11.1.1.1)Arlene Deal28131 Dlckenson Hwy

Heysi, VA 24256

0 4253 acres049 oleo.es swee

0.53161

(1.7) Stuart Boyd Heirs. Devisees,Successals m'ssigns

(1.7.5) laura Boyd Deal

(1.7.5.1)Ruat Fuller

(1.7.5.1I) Ruth Ann Fuller

(1.7.5.1.1.1)lung Koala, Inc.

(I 7.5.1.1.1.1)Ruth Ann Fuesr(Poker)

Conveyed 7/I 7/7975 interests in ell minerals she seemed by nherilance io Rual Fuller DB 229/371

Conveyed I/IIFI987 2/3/2005 DB 32e/859

Cori veyed 32MI 989 use m of coal only induded andi wded interest in Tr. 11 D8321M!59,lands of FMF & Josephine Boyd Tr. 12 & 13 DB 350/370

conveyed 53/1990 ell inmreslsin subject Irscls DB 360/879

con myed 5/I/2002 all inlaw sfs in succor Irscls DB 547//39

Page 2 of 10 5/23/2017

Page Number 46.

Page 47: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Exhihit 8-3Unit R(-1)

Docket mfGOB 1747184134Ust of Unleased Owners/Claimants

Acres In UnitPercentof Unit

(1.7.5.1.11.1.1)Rust Fuaer Heim, Dewsees,Successors or Assigns

(I 7.5.1 1.1.1.1.1)Arlene Deal28131 Dickeiison Hwy

Hayst VA 24256

(2) Manon Rendue Boyd Heirs, Deviance,Successom or Assigns

(2 3) Lash vemie Boyd Baldwin Hwni, Devisees,Successms or Assigns

O.D851 acresI/245 of 20 84 acr%i

0.1063%

(2.3.2) Opal Msttie Hunt conveyed 7/IS//0 f5 aa inleresr info lhe esieie of Lech ve nie se/dw/n to James curtis Be/dw/n

insir. 08-1469

(2.3.2.1) James Curtis Baldwin

1261 Baldwin RdVansanl, VA 24656

D.0241 SentsVaa4 of go.secures

O.D302%

(2.3.6) Laura viugnis Manier4022 Lee Master DrVansant, VA 24656

0.0241 acresI/884 of 20.84 acres

0.0302%

(2.3.7) Henry Nathan Baldwin, Jr403 Surface DrTezeweg, VA 24651

0.0241 acres1/864 of 20.84 acres

0.0302'/

(2.3.9) Gary Raymond Baidwfn Heks, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(2.3.9.1) Mary Margaret Baldvnn conveyed krdoooa 88propert «I 766 319agg/ega/e sc menloned in ivs 24/393 it Ds 29/543insir 08<878 lo Jody Baldwin

(?3.9.1.1) Jody Bakhvin

341 Pennsylvania AveSalem, VA 24153

D.OO5O acresI/2592 of 20 84 acres

0 DI DIN

(2.3.11)James Curtis Baldwin

1261 Balrhwn RdVansant, VA 24656

(2 10) Mary Boyd Cack Heim, Devisees,Successom or Assigns

0.0241 acresI/864 of 20 84 acres

0.0302%

(2.10.2) Uoyd Sachael Cook1031 Bakenrfield Dr

Grundy, VA 24614

(2 10 3) Eral Dariu Cook, Sr. Heirs, Devhees,Successors or Assigns

(2.103.1) Mark AnthonyCook, Sr. Heirs, DevlseesSuccessors of Assigns

(2.10.3.1.1) Mark Anthony Cook, JrAddress Unknown

0 D724 acresI/28a of 20.84 acres

0.0241 acresi/854 o/20.54ecres

0.0905%

0.0SD2%

(2.10.3.1.2) Daria Mesa CookAddress Unknown

(2.10.3.2) Ercil Cook, Jr410 Tel Glgec RdAgene Heights, Guam 96910

(2.10.3.3) Ursula CookPO Box 11483Yigo, Guam 98929

(2.12) /udue Guy Boyd Heks, Devisees,Succsssws or Asslghs

(2.12.1) Jane Boyd Heirs, Dswsees,Successom or Assigns

(2.12.1.6)Estel Peny Boyd Heirs. Dewsees,Successors or Assigns

(2.12.1.6.1)Cathenne Boyd116Villa Ln

Taylorsvale, NC 28681

0.0241 acresI/864 of 20.84 acres

0.0241 acresV854 ofgg.senores

0 0241 acresI/864 of 20.84 ames

0.0302%

0.0302%

0 0302%

(5) FMF Boyd Heirs, Demeans,Successors or Assigns

(5.1.8) Hazel Madeline Boyd Hens, Devisees,Successors CIAsslgils

(5.1.8.7) James Ernest Boyd Heirs, Devisees,SU c cess cia or Ass lg ha

Page 3 of 10 5/23/201 7

Page Number 47.

Page 48: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Exhibit 8-3Unit R(-I)

Docket 3V GOB 17-07IIce134List of Unleased Owners/Claimants

Acres In UnitPemmtof Unit

(5.1.8.7.1)Batty Sturgeon Baker Boyd29 Lany Ln

Frsebum, KY 41528

(5.1.8.7.2)James Bryant BoydPO Box 96

Vansant, VA 24656

0.0092 acresI/2268 of 20.84 acres

0.0092 acresI/2268 of 20 84 acres

O.ot IUD

O.ot ISIL

(5.1.8.7.3)Michael Leon Boyd3574 UIUe Fox Creak Dr

Vensant, VA 24656

(5.1.8.7.4)Derrsg Gens Boyd4562 Murphy RdVanssnt, VA 24658

O.OD92 acresI/2288 of 20 84 acres

O.D092 acresI/2268 of 20.84 acres

00115%

O.ot I5%

(5.1.8.7.5)Bradley Dean BoydPO Box 96

Vsnsant, VA 24656

D.0092 acresI/2268 of 2D.84 acres

O.ot I 5SL

(5.1.8.7.6)Ricky Allen Boyd444 Fsirvlew Dr

Chnstiensburg, VA 24073

(5.1.9) David F. Boyd Heirs, Devlsses,Successors or Assigns

0.0092 *creaI/2288 of 20.84 acres

0.0115%

(5.1.9.1)Irene Davis conveyed 2/277/of 7rntereara n a/I keels lo chrislme Lockhart, Roger Locknerf 5 Frands Locknart

(5.1 9.1.1) Chrtstins LockhartPO Box 243

Vansant, VA 24656

(5.1.91.2) Roger LockhartPO Box 942Vansant, VA 24656

O.O429 acresI/486 of 2D.84 acres

D.0429 acresI/486 of 20.84 acres

0.0536%

0.0536%

(51.9.1.3) Franco LockhartPO Box 942Vansant, VA 24656

(5.1.9.3) Roger LockhartPO Box 942Vsnsant, VA 24656

0 D429 acresUeee ofzEseacres

0.1258 a~resI/162 of 2D.84 acres

O.D536M

O.ISOSSL

(5.1.9.4) Francis LockhartPO Box 942Vansant, VA 24656

0.1286 screeI/162 of 20.84 acres

O. IUOBK

(6) Lash Victoria Bmton Hsiis, Dsvisees,SU cc assent or'ss I gris

(6.1) Francis M. Burton

(6.1.1) Rust FuUer

(6.1.1.1)Ruth Ann Fuller

(6.1.1.1.1)King Koala, Inc

(6.1.1.1.1.1)Ruth Ann Fuller (Poker)

(6.1.1.1.1.1.1)Ruel Fuller Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

Conmyed I/49 on 7/10/1978 lo Rual Fuser DB 235/549

Conveyed I/15rf 967 DB 32B859

Conveyed 3//5i1 989 Iree ts of coal only DB 350/310

Conveyed 5O/1 990 e/I interest in sub/ac I I acts 08 360/6/9

conveyed dr//2002 ac in/eras/ in sub/ecl ueds DB 5I/7/39

(6.1.1.1.1.1.1.1)Arlene Deal28131 Dicksnson HwyHaysi, v'A 24258

(62) AUmrtA. Barton Heim, Devoess,Successors or Assigns

(6 21) Sarah J Barton 5 Lash C. Barto

(6.E 1.1) Francis M. Barton Heim, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

0.4253 acresI/49 of 20.84 acres

Li/e Ea/e/e ex/inguiahsd

0.5316

'6.2

1.1 I) Haxel Barton Heim, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(6 2 I 1.1.1)Henry M. Barton Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(6.2.1.1.1.1I) Emma A. BartonPO box 165

Vsnsant, VA 24650

O.D106 amesI/1960 of 20.84 acres

0.01333k

(6.2.1.11.2) Mary Catherine Inman Have, Devlsses,Scccessols cr Assigns

Page 4 of 10 5/23/2017

Page Number 48.

Page 49: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Exhibit 6-3Unit R(-I)

Docket hVGOB 17-OT18W134Mat of Unleassd Owners/Claimants

Acres In UnitPercentof Unit

(6.2.1.1.1.2.1)Eert Inman

292 Begeheven Dr

Bristol, TN 24201

0.0106 acresI/1960 of 20.84 acres

0.0133'Ih

(6.2.1.1.1.3)Luther Marvin Barton Heirs. Dsvisess,Successors or Assigns(documenfadonmcuesred 45/17)

(6.2.1.1.1.3.1)Alta Barton127 Vine Dr

Yorktown, VA 23692

0.0106 acresI/1 960 of 20 84 acres

0.0133%

(6.5) Albert A. Barton Heirs, Devlsses,Successors or Assigns

(6.5.1) Sarah J. Barton 8 Lash C. Barton

(6.5.1.1)Francis M. Barton Heirs, Devlssss,Successors m Assigns

Lite Estate exiinguished

(6.5.1.1.1)Haxel Barton Hens, Dewsees,Successors or Assigns

(&5.1.1.1.1)Henry M Barton Heirs, Dsvhees,Successors or Assigns

(6.5.1.1.1.1.1)Emma A. BartonPO box 185

dansant, VA 24656

(6.5 1.1.12) Mary Calhenne Inman Heirs, Devisess,Successors or Asslgiis

(6 5.1.11.2.1) Earl Inman

292 Bsllehaven DrBristol, TN 24201

0.0106 acresI/1960 of 20.84 acres

0.0106 solesI/1960 of 20.84 acres

0.0133'/

0.0133%

(6.5.1 1.1.3) Luther Marvin Barton Heirs, Devisees,Successors m Ass I gila(documentsdon recuesfed 4/$ 17)

0.0106 acresI/1960 of 20.84 acres

0.0133%

(6.5.1.1.1.3.1)Ahe Barton127 Vine DrYorktown, VA 23692

(6.5.1.3)Carl Barton Hairs, Devlsses,Successors or Assigns

(6.5.1.3.1)Sandra Barton Hibbhls

4717 Boyds Ridge RdVensenl, VA 24656

0.1063 aurasI/196 of 20.84 acres

0.1329%

(6.7) Elbert D. Barton Hats, Dsvissss,Successors or Assigns

(6.7.1) Saute V. Benon

(6.7.1.1)David R. Barton

liTe Esfele exlinguished

Conveyed 11/4/i995 lo Buclianan Pmducim Company DB 442i504

(6.7.1.1.1)CNX Gas Company LLC

PO Box 643830Pittsburgh, PA I52648830

0 1063 acresI/196 of 20.84 acres

0.1329'/

(6.7.1.2) Donald P. Barton conveyed II/O/1 995 lo Buchanan producuon company DB 442'501

(6.7.1.2.1)CNX Gas Company LLCPO Box 643830Pittsburgh, PA 152648630

0.1063 acneUtea orZO.eoacms

0.1329'5

(6.7.1.3)James L Barton conmtwd 11/4/1995lo Buchanan producrmn company D8 442/498

(6 7.1.3I) CNX Gas Company LLCPO Box 643830Pittsburgh, PA 152640830

0 1063 acresU196 of 20.84 acres

0.1329%

(6.71 4) Donna Breeding Conveyed 11/I/f995 lo Buchanan Produciwn Company DB 442/424

(8.7 I 4.1) CNX Gas Company LLCPO Box 64383DPittsburgh, PA 152646830

OIL 8 GAS OWNERSHIP

7 mal-sued

0.1063 acresI/196 of 20.84 acres

0.1329%

Josephine Boyd Heirs, Dedsees,Successors or Assigns, st al.

(p eviously FMF Boyd)(105Acre Trecg

20 84 auras

Page 5 of 10

26.0500%

5I23/2017

Page Number 49.

Page 50: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Exhibit BGUnit R(-1)

Docket 0VGOB 17 07164134List of Unleased OwnersiClmmants

Acres in UnitPercentof Unit

(1) Hester Soyd Hats, Devlsses,Successom or Assigns

(1.1) Marion Boyd Heim, Devbees,Successors or Assigns

(1.1.1) Lathe A. Desi Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(1.1.1.1)Kilby Soyd Heirs, Oevtsses,Succsssws or Assigns

(1.1.1.1.1)Johnny Boyd Helm, Dsvlsees,Sucmissom cr Assigns

(1.1.1.1.1.1)Jimmy Boyd

(1.1.1.1.1.1.1)Clyde BoydPO Box 403Clinchco, VA 24220

Conmyed inlerssl 5/2 /011 Instr 11/1128

D.OOee acres1/3528 of 20.84 acres

04074%

(1.1.1.1.1.2)Lsny Boyd

(1.1.1.1.1451)Clyde BoydPO Box 403Clinchco, VA 24226

Conveyed interest 5/2/2011 Inslr. Ir/l128

0 D059 acres1/3520 of 2D.84 acres

0.00/4%

(1.1.1.1.1.31tachaei Boyd

(1.1.1.1.1.3.1)Clyde BoydPO Box 403Clinchco, VA 24226

Con eyed interest 5/2/2011 Instr. 11/1128

D.DD59 acres1/3528 of 20.84 acres

0.00740

(1.1.1.1.1.4)Scoh Boyd

(1.1.11.1.4.1) Clyde BoydPO Box 403Cgnchco, VA 24226

(1.1.1.13) Clyde BoydPO Box 403

Clinchco, VA 24226

Conveyed inmresl 5rgiggtf Instr. 1171128

0.0059 acres1/3528 of 20.84 ames

0.0230 acres1/882 of 2D.84 acme

0.0074%

0.0295%

(1.1.1.2) Johnny Boyd Heirs, Dsvlsees,Successors or Assigns

(1.1.1.2.1)Jimmy Boyd

(1.1.1.2.1.1)Clyde BoydPO Sox 403

Clinchco, VA 24226

Conveysdinleresf 5/2/2011 Instr 11/1128

D.D118 acrest/t/64 of 20.64 ecnn

0.0148/

(1.1.1.2.2) tany Boyd

(1.1.1.2.2.1)Clyde BoydPO Box 4D3

Clinchco, VA 24226

Conveyedinlwesf &2/2011 Instr 11/1126

D.0118 annie1/1 764 of 20.84 acres

D.0148 /

(1.1.1.3) Clyde BoydPO Box 403

Clinchco, VA 24226

0 0473 acres1/441 of 20.84 acres

0.0591%

(1.1 2) Kilby Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Succssson! Or Assigns

(1.1.2.1)Johnny Boyd Heirs, Devnsss.Successom or Assigns

(1.1.2.1.1)Jimmy Boyd

(1.1.2.1.1.1)Clyde BoydPO Box 403

Cinchco, VA 24226

Conveyed inlwesl 5%2011 Instr. 17/1126

D.D118 sents1/1 764 of 20 84 acres

0.0148'5

(1.1.2.1.2) Lany Boyd

(1.1.2.1.21)Clyde BoydPO Box 403

Cinchco, VA 24226

Conveyed nleresl 5/22071 insc. 1171128

D.0118 acres1/1 764 of 20.84 acres

D.0148%

(1.1.2.1.3)Michael Boyd

(1.1.2.1.3.1)Clyde BoydPO Box 403

Cgnchco, VA 24226

(1.1.2.1.4) Scog Boyd

conveyed nferesi 5/32011 Instr. 11/1 120

D.0118 acres1/1764 of 2D.04 acres

Conmyedintersst 5/2/2011 Instr. 1171128

0.0148%

Page 6 or 10 5I23/2017

Page Number 50.

Page 51: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Exhibit 8.3Unit R(-I)

Docket ¹V GOB 174718-4134Ust of Unleased Owners/Claimants

Acres in UnitPsrcsritof Unit

(I 1.2.1.4.1) Clyde BoydPO Box 403

Clinchco, VA 24226

(1.1.2.2) Clyde BoydPO Box 403

Clinchco, VA 24226

D D118 acres1/1 764 of 20.84 acres

0.0473 acresI/441 of 20.84 acne

0.0148%

0.0591%

(1.1.3)Johnny Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(1.1.3.1)Pamela Karen Boyd

(1.1.3.1.1)Ruat Fuller

(1.1.3.1I I) Ruth Ann Fuller

(1.1.3.11.1.1)King Koala, Inc.

(I.I.S1.1.1.1.1)Ruth Ann Fuller (Poher)

(1.1.31.1.1.1.1.1)Ruat Fuller Heirs. Devisees,Succ88sofs or Assigils

ccnveied lnlaresl lo Rual Fu/le 28//005 DB el I/466

Con eyed I/75/7987 2/372005 DB 32ly659

Conveyed 3/25'1989 Irecls of coal onlyincluded undivnled inta ssl n Tr. 17 08326/550,lends of FMF 5 Josephine Soyd Tr. 12 6 13 DS 350/370

Conveyed &377000 all interests in sub/em Iracta DB 350/870

conveyed 57/2002 au inlaresls m subject Irects DB 54//239

(1.13.1.1.1.1.1.1.1)Arlens Deal28131 Dickenson Hwy

Haysi, VA 24256

(114) ClydeBoydPO Box 403

Clinchco, VA 24226

0.0945 acres2/441 of 20.84 acres

0.0045 acres2t441 of 20.64 ames

0.1181%

0.1181%

(1.3) Josie Boyd Owens

(1.3.1.1) Rust Fuller

(1.3.1.1.1)Ruth Ann Fuller

(1.3.1.1.1.1)King Koala, Inc.

(1.3.1.1.1.1.1)Ruth Ann Fuller (Potter)

(1.3.1.1.1.11.1) Ruat Fuller Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

Conveyed 8/25'l9/8 ea mleresl m 6 I eels io Rual Fuller DB 250843

Conveyed 81/15'198T DB 32IV659

conmyed 3/25/t989 Irects of coal only mctuded uncividedinlerest m Tr 71 D89287659,lands clFMF8 JosspMne Boyd Tr 128 73DB 3SI/310

Conveyed 53/7990 80 ioleresis in subject bscts DB 360/679

Conveyed 57//002 all iruerests in sulpicl tracts DB 547//39

(1.3.1.1.1.1.1.1.1)Arlene Deal28131 Dickenson Hwy

Heysi, VA 24256

0.4253 8CfSSI/49 of 20.84 sciiis

0.5316%

(1.6) Mary Boyd Vance

(I 61) Ruat Fuller

(I 6.1.1) Ruth Ann Fuller

(1.6.11.1) King Koala, inc.

(1.6.1.1.1.1)Ruth Ann Fuller (Poker)

(1.6.11.1.1.1)Ruat Fuller Heirs, Devuses,Successors or Assighs

Conveyed 825'1978 ad interests m 6 Irecbr to Rual Fuller DB 250346

Conveyed I/rMI0872/320D5 DB 32iu659

Contwyed 3/257090 Iracls of coal only mciuded undi dod interest in Tr 11 08328659,lands of FMF 5 Josephine Boyd Tr. 72 & 13 DB 350 370

conmyed 5'371990a¹ inlweats in subiecl Iracls DB 3tmdi70

Con eyed 5/7/2002 sll interests in subj ecl uur/s DB 547 230

(1 6.1.1.11.1.1)Arlsns Deal28131 Dlcltensmi HuyHeysi, VA 24256

0.4253 Bcn!sI /40 of 20 84 acres

0 5316%

(1.7) Slush Boyd Heirs, Dswsees.Successors or Assigns

(1.7.5) Laura Boyd Deal

(1.7.5.1)Ruat Fuller

(I 7.5.1.1)Ruth Ann Fuller

(I 7.5.1.1.1)tgng Koala, inc

(I 7.5.1.1.1.1)Ruth Ann Fuller (Potter)

(1.7.5.1.1.1.1.1)Ruat Fuller Hmm, Dsvhees,Successors or Assighs

conveyed 7/77/7 975 interests in ab minerals she accuimd by innanlance lo Rual Fuller DB 229/3/I

Conveyed 1/15719ey SO/2005 DB 328559

Conveyed 3/2577989 Iracls of coal only induded undnidsd inlerestin Tr 11 D8328859,lands of FMF 8 Josepl ne Boyd Tr. 12 5 13 DB 350/310

ccnvefed 50/7990 e¹ inlsresls er sub)ac/ I acts DB 3M/679

Conveyed 59/2002 an interests in suifecf Ira cia DB 54 7/239

(1.7.5.1.1.1.1.1.1)Arlene Deal26131 Dickenson Hwy

Haysi, VA 24256

D.0857 acresI/245 of2D84acres

0.1063%

Page 7 of 10 5/23/2D17

Page Number 51.

Page 52: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Exhibit 8.3Unit R(-I)

Docket 8VGOB tymyta<134Ust of Unlsased Owners/Claimants

Acres In UnitPercentof Unit

(2) Madon Rendus Boyd Heirs, Devbees,Successors or Assigns

(2.3) Lech Vemie Boyd Baldwin Heirs, Deviseas,Successors or Assigns

(2.3.2) Opal Mania Hunt Conveyed 7/I 5i7015 eii in/wesi into Ihe estele of Lech Vernis Bet/win lo James CurtB Be/dwinInstr 08-l469

(2.3.2.1) James Curtis Baldwin1261 Baldwin RdVansant, VA 24656

0.0241 acresI/864 of 20.84 acres

0.0302%

(2.3.6) Laura I/irgnia Manier4022 Lee Master DrVansant, VA 24656

0.0241 acresI/864 of 2D.84 acres

0 D302%

(23 7) Harm/Nathan Bakfwin, Jr403 Surface Dr

Tazswea. VA 24651

0.0241 acresI/864 of 20.84 acres

0.0302%

(2.3.9) Gary Raymond Baldwin Hezs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(2 3.0.1) Mary Margaret Baldwin con eyed 3/J/yopa a// prcperty n 766 310 eggrega/e ec. menlionsd in IvB 24/393 & DB 29/543Insu 08-0878 to Jody Ba/dwin

(2.3.01.1) Jody Baldwin

341 Pennsylmnis AveSalem, VA 24153

(2.3.11) James Curtis Balrhnn1261 Baldwin RdVansant, VA 24656

O.0050 acresI/2592 of 20.84 acres

D D241 screeI/864 of 20.!!4acres

0.0101'7

0.0302 /

(2.10) Mary Boyd Cook Heim. Dswsees.Successom or Assigns

(2.10.2) Uoyd Michael Cook1031 Bakemfield DrGrundy, VA 24614

(2.10.3) Emg Dmius Cook, Sr. Heirs, Deviance,Successom nr Assigns

0.0724 acresI/288 of 20.84 acres

(2.10.3.1) Mark Anthony Cook, Sr. Heim, DewseesSuccessors or Assigns

0.0241 acres1/854 ofgE84scres

0.0302%

(2 10.3.1.1) Mark Anthony Cook, JrAddress Unknown

(2.10.31.2) DanaMesaCookAddress Unknown

(21D.3.2) Eral Cook, Jr410 Tai Gigao RdAgana Heights, Guam 96910

(2.10 3 3) Ursula CookPO Box 11483Yigo, Guam 96929

(2.12) Ardue Guy Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(2.12.1) Jane Boyd Hebe. Devisees,Successors or AssEns

(2.12.16) Estsl PenyBoyd Helm, Dewsees,Successom or Assigns

0.0241 acresI/864 of 20.84 acres

D.0241 acresI/864 oigE84ecres

0.0302%

0.0302'4

(2.12.1.6I) Cathmine Boyd116 Villa Ln

Taylorsville, NC 28681

(5) FMF Boyd Hers, Dewsses,Successors or Assigns

(5.1.8) Hazel Madeline Boyd Heirs, Devlsses,Successors or Assigns

(5.1.8.7) James Emesl Boyd Heirs, Deviance,Successom or Assigns

(5.1.8.7.1)Betty Sturgeon Baker Boyd29 Lany Ln

Freebum, KY 41528

0.0241 acresI/864 of2D 84 acres

0.0D92 acresI/2268 of 20 84 Bcres

0.0300.

0 0115%

Page 8 of 10 5/23/2D17

Page Number 52.

Page 53: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Exhibit 8-3Unit R(-I)

Docket gdGOB I/myta<tsaUst of Unleased Owners/Claimants

Acres In UnitPercentof Unit

(5.1.872) JamesgryanlBoydPO Box 96

Vansant, VA 2465S

0.0092 acresI/2268 of 20.64 acres

0.0115'8

(5 I 8.7.3) Michael Leon Boyd35/4 Lri8e Fox Creek DrVansant, VA 24656

0.0092 *creaI/2268 of 20 84 acres

0.0115M

(5 \.8.7.4) Darre8 Gene Boyd4562 Murphy RdVansant, VA 24656

0.0092 acresI/2268 of 20.84 acres

0.0115'h

(5.1.8.7.5)Bradley Dean BoydPO Box 98

Vansant, VA 24I56

(5.1.87.6) Ricky Alhn Boyd444 Fairview Dr

Chrishansburg, VA 24073

(5.1.9) Dawd F. Boyd Hmrs, Deviance,Successors or Assigns

0.0092 acresU2268 of 20.84 acres

0.0092 acresI/2268 of 20.84 acres

0.0115'/

00115%

(5.1.9.1)Irene Dsvh con eyed 2 27/201 7 inlemsls in sll sects lo chnslms Lockhsrl, Roger Leckherl & Francis Lockhrvr

(5.1.9.1.1)Christine LockhartPO Box 243

Vansant, VA 24656

0.OS29 acresI/488 of 20.64 acres

0.0536%

(5.1.9.1.2) Roger LockhartPO Box 942Vansant, VA 24656

(5.1.9.1.3)Francis LockhartPO Box 942Vsnsanl, VA 24656

0.0429 acresI/486 of 20.84 acres

0 0429 acresI/486 of 20.84 acres

0.0536li

0.0536/

(5.1.9.3) Roger LockhartPO Box 942Vensanl, VA 24656

(5.1.94) Francis LockhartPO Box 942Vansant, VA 24658

0.1286 acresI/162 of2084acres

0.1286 acresI/162 of 20.84 acn:s

0.1608%

0.160S'y.

(6) Lash Vmtona Barton Heim, Devisees,Successots or Assigns

(6.1) Franca M. Button

(6.1 I) Rust Fuller

(6.1.1.1)Ruth Ann Fuller

(6.1.1.1.1)King Koala, Inc

(6.1.1.1.1.1)Ruth Ann Fuller (Potter)

(6.1.1.1.1.1.1)Ruat Fuller Heirs, Devlsees,Successors m Assigns

Conveyed I/49 on 7/10/19/8 lo Rusl Foyer CB 23!F549

Conveyed 1/1 S'I 987 DB 328/659

Conveyed 325/1989 I eels of coal on/y DB 359/3rd

conveprd 5/3/1990 aa inlerest in sub/eel I eels DB 36DS/9

Conveyed 57/2002 ad infsresl in svh/ecl tracts CS 547'239

(6.1.1.1.1.1.1.1)Ariene Deal28131 Dickenson Hwy

Haysi, VA 24256

(6.2) Albert A. Sarton Heirs, Dsvissss,Successom or Assigns

04253 sc/eiiI/49 of 20.84 acres

0 5316%

(6.2.1) Sarah J. Barion & Lash C. Barton

(6.2.1.1)Francis M. Barton Heirs, Devlsees,Successors or Assigns

Lr/e Eslsle exknguished

(6.2.1.1.1)Haxel Barton Heirs, Devlsees,Successom or Assigns

(6.2.1.1.1.1)Henry M. Barton Hmm, Devoees,Successors or Assigns

(6.2.1.1.1.1.1)Emma A. BartonPO box 165

Vansant, VA 24555

0 0106 acresI/1960 of 20 84 acres

0.0133%

(6.2 I 1.1.2) Mary Catherine Inman Heim, Dsvlsees,Successom or Assigns

(6.2.1.1.1.2.1)Eari Inman292 Belehavsn Dr

Bnstol, TN 24201

0.0106 acresI/1980 of 20.84 acres

0.01331k

Page 9 of 10 5/23/2017

Page Number 53.

Page 54: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Exhibit BGUnit R(-1)

Docket CVG OS 1747184134Ust of Unleased Owners/Claimants

Acres fn UnitPermntof Unrt

(6 2 1.1 I 3) Luther Mannn Barton Heirs, Oevnees,Successors of Asslgl»(documenleecn nmues/sd 4 517)

0 OIO8 soresI/1 960 of 20.84 acres

0.013311

(6.2.1.1.1.3.1)Alta Barton127 Vine DrYorktown, VA 23692

(6.5) AlbertA Barton Heirs, Dewsees,Successom or Assigns

(6 5.1) Sarah 4 Baton 3 Lash C. Barton Life Es/e/e exflnguisned

(6.5 1.1) France M. Barton Heirs, Devisees,Successo/s Dr Asslglls

(6.5.1.1.1)Haxel Barton Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(6.5.1.1.1.1)Henry M. Barton Heim, Dewsees,Succsltso/s Dr Assigns

(6.5.1.1.1.1.1)Emma A. BartonPO box 105

Vansant, VA 24650

0.0106 acresI/1960 of 20.84 acres

D.D133'I

(6.5.1.1.1.2)Mary Catherine Inmen Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Ass/gns

(6.5.1.1.1.2.1)Earl Inman292 Bellehaven DrBristol, TN 24201

0.0106 acresI/1960 of 20.84 acres

0.0133SL

(6.5.1.1.1.3)Luther Mannn Barton Heirs, Devissss,Successors or AssSnsfdocumenlaf ion reouesled 4'5'f 7)

0.0100 acresI/1 900 of 20.84 acres

0.0133'6.5.1

I I 3 1) Alla Barton127vme OrYorktown, VA 23692

(6 5 1 3) Catt Barton Heirs, Oevisees,Successom or Assigns

(6 5 1.3.1)Sandra Barton Hibbtts4717 Boyne Ridge RdVensant, VA 24656

0 1063 acresI/196 of 20.84 acres

D.1329R

Acreage in Unit UnleasedPercentage of Un/t Unleased

2.64723.309tl4

Page 10 of 10 5/23/2017

Page Number 54.

Page 55: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Company: CNX Gas Company LLC

Virginia Gss And Oil Template —Estimated Authorization For Expenditure (AFE)

AFE ¹Welt Name:

Locatlan:

Expected Pay Zonesr

Proposed Work:

N/A P opens¹ N/A

R(-1) Fleidi Oakwood

Buchanan County Operator: CNX Gss Company LLC

mal seams below Tgler incl. Poca 3 and Squire Estimated Total Depth: 1,900

To drill. complete. end produce Parlicioandsb N/A

Version ¹Completed Bv: R E Staton

Dater Mav 2S.20'l

AAPG Class: CBM

W.t

Sub Description Casing Pmnt Completion Tolal Cost

N

TA

N

G

BL

E8

T

A

N

G

BL

E6

Code Code

Leasehold Costs

Permit I Tiye Opfnmn I Survey / Insurance

Biiildihg Locafioh

Roads / Stone / Culverts

Sudsce Camenae

Drilling - Footage

DrEling - Mobgiza5on

Dnmg - Davrate

Mud & Chemicals (Drisfnp)

Fuel

Cement Surface casino

Cement Intermediate casino

Open Hole Logging li Testing

Trucking /Dozer (Dnding)

Rental Tools & Equmment (Drlf linc)

Orylirlg Bits

Techniml Supervision (Drflynrn

Fresh Water Hauling tDrif ling)

Overhead Rate

Misc. & Continglndes

Loca(ion RdslStone/Culverls

Truckino / Dmer (Completionl

Technical Supervision (Comolefionl

Cased Hole Loan na / Perhrating

Symulalion/Fracturina

Comp(agon Rig

Redalmation 6 DammesHaul Pit Water / Disposal

Cement Producgon Casing

Renfel Tools 8 Eaulpment (Completion)

Fresh Water Hauling (Complebon)

Roustabout Labor

TOTAL INTANGIBLES

13 3/8 Condumor

9 5/8" 26 IblR LS Surface CsgI" 19 Ib/E LS Intermediate Csg

4F; 0 5 Ib/R M-65 Prodummn Csq

4(P 10.5 Ib/It M-65 Produmion Csg

2O/8 "4.7 lb/fl J55 Erd Pnxluction T bine

Wellhead Equipment / Fhgngs

Tank 6alterv

Separator I Heater I Treater

Gas Lyt Eiluioment

Rods I Stuflinlr Box

Downhole Pump

Pum pine Unit / Motor

SS EQT-Packer,PF,FC,NIO

Valves & Finnss

Flow Une labor/material

Sales line labor/mat/row

TOTAL TANGIBLES

75 Ft

0 Ft

300 Ft

1,800 Fl,

20 Ft

1,600 Ft

So$5.300

$40,000$34,000

$0$45,DOO

$0

$0

$0

$0

$2,000

$6,000

$3,900

$0$0$0$0$0$0$0$0

$0

$0

$0

$0

$0

$0$0$0$0$0So

$136,200

Canine Point

$7.500$0

$3,540

$13,500$1,200

$0

$0

$0$0

$0

$0$0

$0So

$0

$0

$0$25,749

$0$0$0

$0

$0$0

$0

$0

$0

$0$0$0So

$0

$0

$0$0$0$0

$3.000$D

So

$0$0

$82,000$0

$o

$0

$0

$0$0

$3,800Nte,800

Comp(assn

$D

$0

$0

$0

$0

$11,632$6,200

SD

$15,000$0

$13,000So

$11.000$0$0

$5,000$5,000

$66,832

$0$5,300

$40,000

$34,000

$0

$45,000

$0

$0$0$0

$2,000

$6.000$3,900

$0$0$o$0$0

$0

$3,000$0

$0

tg$0

$82,000

$0

$0

$D

$0$0$0

$3,800$225,000

Total Coal

$7,500$o

$3,549

$13,500$ 1,200

$11,632$6,200

$0

$15.000$0

$13.000$0

$11,000$0

$D

$5,000$5,000

$92.551

I GRAND TOTAL WELL COST $161,949 I $165,632

153 I MS I plugging&Abandonment $25.0OO I

Produmion Costs: $317,581 I Dry Hole Costs:

Sat v,sai I

$166.SM I

THIS IS AH ESTIMATE Or PROJECTED WELL DRILLING. COMPLEimn. EOUIFMnir Ann Pin SE ESTIMATES RE PROJECTIONS OHLYAHO ACTUAL

eittEO COSTS MAY VARY FROM WELL ro WEU. OEFEHOJHG UPON ACTUAL FINAL DEPTH Axo OTHER FACTORS JHCLUOIHG, SOT HOT UMITEO To, SEASOHAU

MATERIAL COST6. WEATHER COHO ITIOHS. AHO UNFORESEEN RJGHTEF-WAY FIIOSLEMS

Page Number 55.

Page 56: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Company: CNX Gas Company LLC

Virginia Gas And Og Template —Estimated Aulhorizagon For Expenditure (AFE)

AFE 8Well Name:

Locatlohi

Expected Pav Zohes:

Prollosed Worki

Rl-IA)

coal seams below Tiller incl Poca 3 and Squire

To dna, complete, end produce

Prop rty9 N/A

Field: Oakwood

Operaton CNX Gas Company LLC

Estimated Total Oepthi 2,40D

Parlicipands): N/A

Version 9Completed By: R.E Staton

Data: May 25, 20'

AAPG Class:

W.I.

CBM

Gen Sub Oescripoon Casing Point Conmleaon Total Cost

N

7A

N

G

8L

E

5

7A

N

G

I

8L

E

8

Coda Code

Leasehold Casts

permit / Title Dp iniori / Survey / Insurance

Bui1ding Location

Roader Stone/Cutvens

Surface nemesesDnafng - FootageDnSing - Mobilization

Drlqinrl - Dayrate

Mud & Chemicals (Ddalnq)

Fuel

Cement Surface casimCement Intermediate casfne

Open Hole Loaaina & Testing

Trucking I Dozer (Driling)

Rental Tools & Equipmsnt IDdllmg)

Ddlllng - Bits

Technbal Supenrisfon IDrilling)

Fresh Water Haulirra tDrialna)

D ed sad Rate

Misc. & Continaindes

Locatnn Rds/Stone/Culverls

Trucking I Dozer (Comp ladon)Technical Supervision tcompletion)

Cased Hole Logging I per(oragng

Stlmulabon /Fracturing

Completion Rig

Redaimagonii Damaaes

Haul Pit Water I Disposal

Cement Producgon Casiriq

Rental Toots Ii Eauipmsnt (Completionl

Fresh Water Hauling (completion)

Rouslabout LaborTOTAL INTANGIBLES

13 3/6" Condumor

9 5/8'6 Ib/lt LS Sum ce Csg7" 19 Ib/ft LS Intermediate Csq

4VP 9.5 Ib/lt M-65 Pnxlucgon Cso4M'0.5 Ib/ft M-85 Production Cm2-3/5 '.7 Ib/fl 355 SW ProducUon Tubinq

Wellhead Erluipment/ FINngs

Tank Batlerv

Separator / Heater ITreater

Gas Lift Equip ent

Rods I &fuOing BoxDownhole Pump

Pumping unit / Motor

SS EGT-Packer,PF,FC,Nip

Valves & Fillings

Flow tine labor/material

Sales line ISDor/msyrow

TOTAL TANGISLES

T5 Ft

0 Fl

300 Ft

2,400 Ft

20 Ft2,2M Ft

$0$5,300

$43,000

$34,000$0

$55,000

$0

$0

$0$0

$2,0M$6,000$3,900

$0$0

$0

$0

$0

$0$0

$0$0

$0

$0

$0

$0

$0

$0

$0

$0

$0

$0$149,200

Casing I'oint

$7,500

So

$3,549$13,0M

$1.200$D

$0

$D

$0

$0

$0So

$0

$0

$0

$0

$0

$30,249

$0$0$0SoSo

So

$0$0

$0

$0$0$0

$0$0$0$0$0$0

$0$3,000

$030$0$o

$62,000

$0

$0

$0

So

$0

$0

$3,800$68,800

Cmnplatlon

$0$0$0$0$0

$15.994$6,200

$0$15.000

$0

$13,0M

$0$11,000

$0

$0$5,000$5,000

$71.194

$0

$5,300$43.000$34,000

$o$55,DOO

$D

$0

$D

$0

$2.000Se.ooo$3,900

$0

$0

$0$0

$0

$0

$3,0DD

$0

$0

$0

$0

$82,000

$0

So

$0

$0

$D

$0$3,600

$236,000

Total Cost

$7,500

$0

$3,549

$13,000$1,200

$15,994$6,2DO

$0$15.000

SD

$13 ODD

$0$11,000

$0

$056,000

$5,000$101,443

GRANO TOTAL WELL COST $179,449 I $159,994

153 I 115 I Pluaaina & Abandonment Szs,ooo I

I Production Costs: $339,443 I Ory Hole Coals;

Prepared by M&i46PT

$339,443 I

Szo4/Ma I

THIS IS AH ESTIMATE DF PRO/ ECTEO WELL DRIILING. COMPLEiiON, COUIFIIENT AND PIPELINE COSTS. THESE ESTIMATES ARE yaoJECTIONS ONLY ANO ACTUAL

GILLED COSTS MAY VARY FROM WELL TO WEIL DEPENDING UPON ACTUAL FINAL DEFIH AND OTiiER FACTORS INCLUDING, GUT NOT LIMITED TO, SEASONAL

Page Number 56.

Page 57: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Exhibit EUnit R(-1)

Docket ¹VGOB 17-0718-4134List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants that require escrow

Acres in Unit

Percentof Unit

Trent ¹1.20.84 acres

Escrow due to Unknown/Unfocat¹Me

COAL OWNERSHIP

Josephine Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns, et al.(previously FMF Boyd)(105Acre Tract)

20.84 acres 26.05000/D

(1) Hester Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(1.2) Henry Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(1.2.9) Alfred E. Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(1.2.9.1) Margie Boyd WannerPO Box 313Davenport, VA 24239

(Bad Address)

Life estate in 1/3 of 1/441

(2) Marion Rendue Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(2.3) Leah Vemie Boyd Baldwin Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(2.3.10) Bradley Dean Baldwin Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns(requested LOH SB/1 7)

0.0241 acres1/864 of 20.84 acres

0 0302%

(2.3.10.1) Bryan Baldwin4122 Clifton Glendale RdSpartsnburg, SC 29307

(2.3.10.2) Amber Justus158 Orr RdJackson, TN 39330

(2.10) Mary Boyd Cook Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(2.10.3) Ercil Darius Cook, Sr. Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(2.10.3.1) Mark Anthony Cook, Sr. Heirs, DeviseesSuccessors or Assigns

0.0241 acres1/864 of 20.84 acres

0 0302%

(2.10.3.1.1) Mark Anthony Cook, JrAddress Unknown

(210.3.1.2) Daria Mesa CookAddress Unknown

(3) Lillie Josephine Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(3.4) Frazier Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(3.4.1) Mary Jane Boyd Conveyed by deed 10I20I2002 DB 556/491

(3.4.1.3) Ellen Josephine Taylor Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(3.4.1.3.5)David James StrattonAddress Unknown

0.0241 acres1/864 of20.84acres

Page 1 of 4

0.0302%

5/23/2017

Page Number 57.

Page 58: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Exhibit EUnit R(-1)

Docket 6VGOB 17-0718-4134List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants that require escrow

Acres in UnitPercentof Unit

(3.4.1.3.6)John Thomas MajorAddress Unknown

0.0241 acres1/864 of 20.84 acres

0.0302%

(6) Lech Victoria Barton Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(6.2) Albert A. Bahon Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(6.2.1) Sarah J. Barton & Leah C. Barton Life Estate exlingu/shad

(6.2.1.1)Francis M. Barton Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(6.2.1.1.1)Hazel Barton Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(6.2.1.1.1.3)Luther Marvin Badon Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns(documenlstion requested 4/5/I 7)

0.0106 acres1/1960 of 20.84 acres

0.0133%

(6.2.1.1.1.3.1)Alta Barton127 Vine DrYorktown, VA 23692

(6.5) Albert A. Barton Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(6.5.1) Sarah J. Barlon & Leah C. Barton Lde Estate extinguished

(6.5.1 1) Francis M. Barton Heirs, Deviance,Successors or Assigns

(6.5.1.1.1)Hazel Barton Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(6.5.1.1.1.3)Luther Marvin Barton Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns(documentalion requested 4/&rf 7)

0.0106 acres1/1960 of 20.84 acres

0.0133%

(6.5.1.1.13.1) Alta Barton127 Vine Dr

Yorktown, VA 23692

OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP

Josephine Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns, et al./previously FMF Boydj(105Acre Tract)

20.84 acres 26.0500%

(1) Hester Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(1.2) Henry Boyd Heirs, Dewsees,Successors or Assigns

(1.2.9) Alfred E. Boyd Heirs, Devrsees,Successors or Assigns

(1.2.9.1) Margie Boyd WannerPO Box 313Davenport, VA 24239(Bad Address)

Life esfate in 1/3 of 1/441

(2) Marion Rendue Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(2.3) Lsah Vemie Boyd Baldwin Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

Page 2 of 4 5/23/2017

Page Number 58.

Page 59: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Exhibit EUnit R(-1)

Docket ¹VG OB 17-0718%134List of Confgcting Owners/Claimants that require escrow

Acres in Unit

Percentof Unit

(2.3.10) Bradley Dean Baldwin Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns(requesled LOH &8/17)

0.0241 acres1/864 of 20.84 acres

0 0302o/

(2.3.10.1) Bryan Baldwin

4122 Cldton G/endale Rd

Spartanburg, SC 29307

(2.3.10.2) Amber Justus158 Orr RdJackson, TN 39330

(2.10) Mary Boyd Cook Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(2.10.3) Ercil Darius Cook, Sr. Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(2.10.3.1) Mark Anthony Cook, Sr. Heirs, DeviseesSuccessors or Assigns

0.0241 acres1/864 of 20.84 acres

0.0302%

(2.10.3.1.1) Mark Anthony Cook, JrAddress Unknown

(2.10.3.1.2) Daria Mesa CookAddress Unknown

(3) Lillie Josephine Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(3.4) Frazier Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(3.4.1) Mary Jane Boyd Conveyed by deed 10/20/2002 05 555491

(3.4.1.3) Ellen Josephine Taylor Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(3.4.1.3.5)David James StrattonAddress Unknown

(3.4.1.3.6)John Thomas MajorAddress tfnknown

0.0241 acres1/864 of 20.84 acres

0.0241 acres1/864 of 20.84 acres

0.0302%

0.0302%

(6) Leah Victoria Barton Heirs, Devisees,Successors orAssigns

(6.2) Albert A. Banon Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(6.2.1) Sarah J. Barton & Leah C. Banon Life Estate ex//nguished

(6.2.1.1)Francis M. Barton Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(6.2.1.1.1)Hazel Barton Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(6.2.1.1.1.3)Luther Marv/n Barton Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns(documen/a//on requested 4/5/1 7/

0.0106 acres1/1 960 of 20.84 acres

0.01331o

(6.2.1.1.1.3.1)Alta Barton127 Vine Dr

Yorktown, VA 23692

(6.5) Albert A. Barton Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(6.5.1) Sarah J. Barton & Leah C. Barton Life Esiale extinguished

Page 3 of 4 5/23/2017

Page Number 59.

Page 60: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Exhibit EUnit R(-t)

Docket gVGOB 17-07184134List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants that require escrow

Acres In UnitPercentof Unit

(6.5.1.1)Francis M. Barton Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(6.5.1.1.1)Hazel Barton Heirs, Devisees,Successo/s ol'ssigns

(6.5.1.11.3) Luther Marvin Barton Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns(documenie/ion reeves/ed ar5/1 7)

0.0106 acres1/1960 of 20.84 acres

0.0133%

(6.5.1.1.1.3.1)Alta Barton127 Vine Dr

Yorktown, VA 23692

Acreage in UnitPercentage of Unit

0.11770.1472%

Page 4 of 4 5/23/2017

Page Number 60.

Page 61: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Exhibit EEUnit R(-1)

Docket ¹VGOB 17-0718-4134List of ag Owners/Claimants with Royalty Splits/Court Orders/H 82058

Acres in UnitPercentof Unit

Tract 8.'I .27 54 ecms

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Garden Realty Corporetion

(250.22 Acre Trsclj108 Bexley RoadMoorssvige, NC 28117

27.54 acres 34 4250o%%d

OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP

(1) John W. Pobst, Jr., et al.(250.22 Acre Tracg

(a) Fairview Limited Partnership"do John C. Irvin, Managing Partner4710 Huntenvood CircleRichmond, TX 77406

27.54 acres

6.89 acres1/4 of 27.54 acres

34.4250%

8.6063'/

(b) DIPL, LP*

4710 Hunterwood Circle

Richmond, TX 77406

(c) F.H. Combs, II TestamentaryTrust'o

TrusteesP O. Box 841Tazeweg, VA 24651

(d) Martha E. Combs*r/o Benjamin F. Edwards & Co.126 West Main StTazeweg, VA 24651

(e) John W. Pobst, Jr *

Box 86Revere, PA 18953

2.30 sc/851/12 of 27.54 acres

2.30 acres1/12 of 27.54 acres

2.30 acres1/12 of 27.54 acres

2.30 acres1/12 of 27.54 acres

2.8688%

2.8688o/

2.8688%

2.8688%

(f) Vtrgima Lmwrck

4324 South Ball RdVeradale, WA 99037

(g) W. Kent Pobst Trust

(g.1) Richard K.Pobst'9

Waterside Dr.Cartersvige, GA 30121

2.30 8c/851/12 of 27.54 acres

2.30 acres1/1 2 of 27.54 acres

2.8688%

2 8688o%%d

(g.2) Catherine Pobst'o

Lynn R. Quick111 Postelle SkeetCartersvige, GA 30120

(j) Meredith E. Jennings*2418 West Linden StreetNashville, TN 37212

2.30 acres1/12 of 27.54 acres

4.59 acres1/6 of 27.54 acres

2.8688%

5.7375'Y

*Prevailing plant/If under Case No. 486-08Awarded 100%of the CBM royalty.

Acreage in TractPercentage of Tract

27.540034.4250%

Trent ¹4. 1 aa sores

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Levisa Coal Company, Tr. 20(310.15Acre Tracljc/o John C. Irvin, Managing Partner4710 Hunterwood CircleRichmond, TX 77406

Pags1of2

1.96 ac/85 24500%

5/23/2017

Page Number 61.

Page 62: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Exhibit EEUnit R(-1)

Docket SVGOB 17-0718-4134List of ag Owners/Claimants with Royalty Splits/Court Orders/HB2058

Acres in Unit

Percentof Unit

OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP

(1) John W. Pobst, Jr., et al.(310.15Acre Tree//

(a) Fairview Limited Partnershipc/o John C. Irvin, Managing Partner4710 Hunterwood CircleRichmond, TX 77406

(b) DIPL, LP4710 Hunterwood CircleRichmond, TX 77406

(c) F.H. Combs, II Testamentary Trustc/o TrusteesP.O. Box 841Tazewell, VA 24651

1.96 acres

0.49 acres1/4 of 1.96acres

0.16 acres1/12 of 1.96acres

0.16 acres1/12 of 1.96acres

2.4500'/0

0.6125%

0 2042o/

0.2042'/o

(d) Martha E. Combsr/o Benjamin F. Edwards 8 Co.126 West Main StTazewe8, VA 24651

(e) John W. Pobst, Jr.Box 86Revere, PA 18953

(f) Virginia Linwick

4324 South Bail Rd

Veradsle, WA 99037

(g) W. Kent Pobst Trust

(g.1) Richard K. Pobst39 Waterside Dr.

Cartersvias, GA 30121

0.16 acres1/12 of 1.96acres

0.16 acresI/12 of 1.96acres

0.16 sums1/12 of 1.96acres

0.16 acres1/12 of 1.96acres

0.2042oa

0.2042%

0.2042%

0.2042'/

(g.2) Catherine Pobstr/o Lynn R. Quick111 Posts8e StreetCartersvi8e, GA 30120

(h) Meredith E. Jennings2418 West Linden StreetNashville, TN 37212

0.16 acres1/12 of 1.96acres

0.33 acresI/6 of 1.96acres

0.2042'/

0.4083%

Acreage in TractPercentage of Tract

1.96002A500%

Total Acreage In UnitTotal Percentage of Unit

29.500036.8750%

Page 2 of 2 5/23/2017

Page Number 62.

Page 63: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

J.Scott Sexton

(540) 983-9379

~deke.corn

GENTRY LOCKERAKES 6 MQDREuin

Attorneys Fammiis 540.983 9400

Post Oflice Sox 40013

Roanoke, Virginia 24022-001 3

December 16, 2011

Via certified mail tl 7005 1820 0002 5514 1579

David G. Altizer, Esq.Altizer Walk tk WhiteP,O. Box 30Tazewell, Virginia 24651

Re: Richard K. Pobst, et al. v. Garden Realty CorporationBuchanan County Circuit Court; Case No. 486-08

Dear David:

Enclosed is a certified copy of the Final Order entered by Judge Williams on December 7. I amdelivering this to you as agent for CNX. Please note that this Order resolves the conflict betweenGarden Realty Corporation (the coal owner) and Richard K. Pobst, et al., (the gas owners) onOakwood Units O(-1), O(-2), P(-1), P(-2), P(-3), Q(-1), Q(-2), R(-I) and R(-2). A general mapof the acreage at issue is attached as Exhibit I to the Order.

The Court has ordered that the Plaintiffs are to receive their proportionate share of royaltiesassociated with gas (including CBM) production from these units. I understand that some or allof these royalties may have been held in suspense or escrow by CNX. To the extent that CNXhas done so, this Order requires CNX to pay such amounts to the Plaintiffs within 30 days ofreceipt of the Order.

Please call me should you have any questions.

Very truly yours,

JSS/lavEnclosurecc: John Irvin

GENTRY LOCKE RAKES k. MOORE, LLP

ott Sexton

10 Franklin Road SE, Suite 800 4 Roanoke, VA 2401 1O Toil Free. 866-983-0866www.gentrrlocke.corn

i 5088/4/8710988vi

Page Number 63.

Page 64: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

VIRGINIA:

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT FOR THE COUNTY OF BUCHANAN

RICHARD K. POBST,NANCY C. POBST,JOHN W. POBST, JR.,VIRGINIA LEE LINWICK,MEREDITH ELLIS JENNINGS,FREDERICK HARMON COMBS II TESTAMENTARYTRUST, AMY COMBS AND ERIC COMBS,CO-TRUSTEESCAROL C. IRVIN,MARTHA E. COMBS,aildFAIRVIEW LIMITED PARTNERSHIP,

Plaintiffs,

GARDEN REALTY CORPORATION,

Defendant.

)))))))))))))))) Case No. 486-08

))))

FINAL ORIJER

This matter came before the Court on the Plaintiffs'or Summary Judgment,

whereupon the Court received the papers submitted by the parties and heard oral argument of

counsel on February 23, 2011. By letter dated May 2, 2011, the Court indicated its ruling,

granting Plaintiffs'otion. Defendant filed a Motion to Reconsider on May 18, 2011, The

issue presented by the Plaintiffs'omplaint and its Motion for Summary Judgement is

whether the Plaintiff oil and gas owners or the defendant coal owner owns the coalbed

methane ("CBM")underlying a certain tract of land in Buchanan County containing 250.22

acres, and generally depicted on the attached Exhibit 1. For good cause shown and for the

reasons stated in the Court's letter of May 2, 2011, which is incorporated by reference as

15088/4/5505099vi

Page Number 64.

Page 65: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Exhibit 2, the Court finds that there are no material facts in dispute which would prevent a

ruling as a matter of law in this case, and, accordingly, hereby FINDS AND ORDERS as

follows:

1. Because there are no issues of material fact in dispute regarding the ownership

of the CBM at issue, the Court grants Plaintiffs'otion for Summary Judgment, finding that

the Plaintiffs own the rights to the CBM in that certain tract of land consisting of 250.22

acres, conveyed to Pobst and Combs as Tract 30 in the deed of December 4, 1937,of which

the coal, metals and timber were conveyed as Tract 30 to Levisa by the 1937 Deed and

subsequently conveyed by Levisa to Garden Realty Corporation as Tract 2 in the Garden

Realty Deed. This finding resolves all dispute as to the conflict of ownership of CBM within

such tract and particularly within the portions o'f the units designated under the Oakwood

Field Rules as O(-I), O(-2), P(-1), P(-2), P(-3), Q(-1), Q(-2), R(-I) and R(-2), the "Conflict

Units", that contain portions of such tract.

2. The Court ORDERS that the Plaintiffs shall receive their proportionate share

of royalties associated with gas (including CBM) production from the 250.22 acre tract,

including those now in escrow (including present and future conflicts between Plaintiffs and

Garden Realty Corporation as to the Conflict Units); and that CNX Gas Company, LLC, the

operator of the gas wells in these Conflict Units, is required within thirty days of notification

of this Court's decision to file with the Virginia Gas and Oil Board a petition to disburse from

escrow account to Plaintiffs all principal and accrued interest associated with the gas

(including CBM) produced from or attributed to the 250.22 acre tract at issue. To the extent

that CNX Gas Company, LLC has not escrowed royalties associated with Plaintiffs'nterests

15088/4/5505099vl

Page Number 65.

Page 66: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

in these Conflict Units but has instead otherwise paid them or placed them in some other

suspense account, CNX Gas Company, LLC is ordered to pay such amounts to Plaintiffs

within thirty days of receipt of this Order.

3. The Motion to Reconsider by Garden Realty Corporation is denied for the

reasons stated in this Court's letter of October 20, 2011, which is incorporated by reference as

Exhibit 3. The issues raised in such motion relate largely to a claim of trespass which is not

presented by Plaintiffs'otion or by any counterclaim by Defendant. Objections to CBM

wells by coal owners are governed by Va. Code 5 45.1-361.1,et seq., and the procedures and

regulations promulgated thereunder. The validity of any objection by the coal owner to well

permits or pooling orders does not alter the determination of ownership as between identified

conflicting claimants.

4. The Court retains jurisdiction over this matter until Plaintiffs'ave received all

escrowed, suspended, or unpaid but earned royalties as ordered herein.

5. The Clerk is directed to forward attested copies of this Order to all counsel of

record.

Entered this ~day of~~2011.j

15088/4/5505099v1

Page Number 66.

Page 67: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

We ask for entry of this Order.

f. S ott sexton(VSB No.'29284) y

NTRY LOCKE RAKES k. MOORE, LLP10 Franklin Road, S.E.P. O. Box 40013Roanoke, VA 24022(540) 983-9379(540) 983-9400 (facsimile)

Counsel for plainttffs

Seen and objected to by the Defendant, Garden Realty Corporation for the reasons set forth inits Answer to Plaintiffs'omplaint, written responses to Plaintiffs'otion for SummaryJudgment, oral argument, and the objections and exceptions of Garden Realty Corporation tothe Order granting Plaintiffs'otion for Summary Judgment and Order denying

Defendants'otion

for Reconsideration hereto attached, consisting of 20 separate paragraphs found upon

Eric D. Whitesell, Esq. (VSB No, 176311)Gillespie, Hart, Altizer & Whitesell, P.C.126 East Main StreetP. O. Box 718Tazewell, VA 24651

Blair M. Gardner, Esq. (WV DN8807)Jackson Kelly, PLLC500 Lee Street, East, Suite 1600Charleston, WV 25301

Counsel for Garden Realty Corporation

A CeovTee',e: " i:e!yS.Tiller. Clerk

15088/4/5505099v1

Deruty iie/k

Page Number 67.

Page 68: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Objections of Garden Realty Corporation to the Order GrantingPlaintiffs'otion for Summary Judgment and Order

Denying Defendant*s Motion for Reconsideration

I. Garden Realty objects to g 2 of the Order which directs the distribution of royalties now

escrowed with the Virginia Gas and Oil Board prior to the date on which the Defendant is

entitled to file a notice of appeal with the Virginia Supreme Court.

2. Garden Realty objects to the Order*s conclusion that the Pobst - Levisa Coal and Levisa

Coal - Garden Realty deeds which contained inconsistent grants and were executed by

the same individuals who were or controlled the grantors in both deeds were found not to

create an ambiguity.

3. Garden Realty objects to the Order's conclusion that the grantors under the Pobst - Levisa

Coal deed retained the coalbed methane (CBM) when they deeded the coal and others

substances to Levisa Coal.

4. Garden Realty objects to the Order's conclusion that the grantors under the Pobst-

Levisa Coal and Levisa Coal —Garden Realty deeds, who were shown to be sophisticated

lawyers and businessmen in their era, intentionally retained CBM under their deed to

. Levisa Coal when the CBM was known to be a hazard and liability.

5. Garden Realty objects to the Order's conclusion that the grantors under the Pobst-

Levisa Coal and Levisa Coal —Garden Realty deeds, who were shown to be sophisticated

lawyers and businessmen in their era, intentionally retained CBM under their deed to

Levisa Coal when the common law and statutes in effect at that time imposed upon

owners of coal and operators of coal mines the duty to ventilate mines of unsafe gasses.

Page Number 68.

Page 69: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

6. Garden Realty objects to the Order's conclusion that the facts presented in the case of

Harrison-8'yatt, LLC v. Ratlig; 267 Va. 549, 593 S.E.2d234 (2004) are similar to those

of the present case.

7. Garden Realty objects to the Order's conclusion that the Plaintiffs were deemed to

authorize another person, CNX Gas which operates the CBM wells at issue in the case, to

fracture Garden Realty's coal seam without establishing the legal source of that right.

8. Garden Realty objects to the Order's conclusion that the Plaintiffs were deemed to

authorize another person, CNX Gas which operates the CBM wells at issue in the case, to

invade and occupy Garden Realty's coal seam without establishing the legal source of

that right.

9. Garden Realty objects to the Order's conclusion that the entry and occupation by CNX

Gas into Garden Realty's unmined coal seam authorized by the Plaintiffs does not

constitute a trespass.

10.Garden Realty objects to the conclusion that the Court relied upon language found in its

opinion and order in Harrison-Wyatt regarding a surface owner's right only to recover

CBM which had separated from the coal when the uncontroverted evidence in the case is

that CNX has fractured Garden Realty's unmined coal seam in order to recover CBM.

11.Garden Realty objects to the conclusion that the Court relied upon language found in its

opinion and order in Harrison- W'yart denying a surface owner's right to fracture a coal

seam to recover CBM when the uncontroverted evidence in the case is that CNX has

fractured Garden Realty's unmined coal seam in order to recover CBM.

12. Garden Realty objects to the conclusion that the Court relied upon language found in its

opinion and order in Harrison-Syatr regarding a surface owner's right only to recover

Page Number 69.

Page 70: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

CBM which remained in the mine void upon the conclusion of coal mining when the

uncontroverted evidence in the case is that CNX has fractured Garden Realty's unmined

coal seam in order to recover CBM.

13.Garden Realty objects to the conclusion that the Court reached in its opinion to Garden

Realty's motion for reconsideration that the Supreme Court's 2004 decision in Harrisan-

Wyatt determined ownership of CBM as a matter of law,

14.Garden Realty objects to the conclusion that the Court reached in its opinion to Garden

Realty*s motion for reconsideration that a trespass upon Garden Realty's coal seam is

"collateral" to the issue of ownership of the CBM and royalties derived theretrom,

15. Garden Realty objects to the conclusion of the Court that ownership of the CBM can be

determined without finding that the owner also possesses the right to enter the coal seam

owned by another for the purpose of drilling wells, occupying the coal seam for an

indefinite time, &acturing the coal seam and recovering CBM or for having the legal right

to lease those rights to another person.

16.Garden Realty objects to the conclusion of the Court in its opinion to Garden Realty's

motion for reconsideration that an application ofActs 2010, April 13, 2010, which

amended Va. Code 45.1 —361.21.1,does not act as a retroactive application of that

provision of law to deeds executed between 1937 and 1941.

17. Garden Realty objects to the conclusion of the Court that the inclusion of the foregoing

issues as atfirmative defenses as part of Garden Realty's answer did not create a dispute

ofmaterial facts which foreclosed the entry of summary judgment in favor of the

Plaintiffs.

Page Number 70.

Page 71: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

18. Garden Realty objects to the Court's conclusion that the Plaintiffs have produced

sufficient evidence to demonstrate that it meets the definition of a "gas or oil owner" and

the definition of a "royalty owner" found in Section 45.1-361.1in order to entitle it to

payment of escrowed royalties under the provisions of Section 45.1-361.1.22.5.

19.Garden Realty objects to the conclusion of the Court that Garden Realty is entitled to no

compensation under the terms and provisions of its lease with the gas well operator given

under the provisions of Section 45.1-361.1.29-F.2.

20. The Court's opinion snd Order fails to acknowledge, or in any way deal with or rule

upon, the Defendant's first affirmative defense, second affirmative defense, third

affumative defense, fourth affirmative defense, and fifth affirmative defense set forth in it

answer to the Plaintiffs'omplaint for Declaratory Judgment.

Page Number 71.

Page 72: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

}

...}INIIUDHNNNYF}UNYbOU}h.t}0R 6/21/2007 8P/2:OS /}EE

THIS IHFORMATION IS GEINS PROVIDED AS A 8USI%55 OR PIKSESSHNALCOUIITESY. CNX GAS COM'AIF/ LLC ITS SINSIOIHIIES AND AFFILIAIES

MLLECTING CNX NINE NO RESPAESEIOATIONS ON NARIWIYIESGF AHV KINO OA UIARAcma CISNSHNINO THE CINPLNIKNESS CN

ACCURACY OF THIS INFOWATIQH ANI ASSUMES N! RESPONSISILITYQN LIAIILI Y IK AIG'INO FOR SUUI INFORMATION. THE RECIPIENT OF TH15

ACHKMLEQGES ANO ASUIIKS AIL NISH OF THE USE IK SUCH INFOINNTIONIN CONSIOEUATIOR OF CNX PNOVI!IHIC TIIIS INFOAINTUN THE RECIPIEIIT

FINEVER NAIVES IUID RELEASES ANY HID /ILL CLAIMS OR CAUSES OF ACTINI THERECIPIENT HAY EVER IIAK AGAINST CNX ITS OFFICEA5 DIRECTORS

CN AGENTS RELATttlG Tc CR AESULTUtG Glt ARISUN FROIt ITS USE OF TNEINFIXUMTIOH. ACCEPTHICE OF IRIS IHFMWATIOH SY TH SECH IENT

CON57ITUTES GAEENKNt NIIN ALL IHE TEAMS ANO CCNOITIt!NSCOMTANIED IN THIS HGIICE.

Page Number 72.

Page 73: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

(i43 IIIIIII43)mt)Eyeball(L 43 II Vita <I'tl)II'ta

CIRCUIT COURT JUDGES:

PATRICK R. JOHNSONBuchanan eaunty Ouurtuxx,n

P.O. Box 1995Grundy, VA 24614

(276) 935-2451(276) 935-8516 Fax

KEARY R. WILUAMS (Retired)P.O. Box 849Grundy. VA 24614

(276) 935-2451(276) 935-8516 Fax May 2, 2011

Blair M. Garduer, Esq.Jackson Kelly, PLLC500 Lee Street, East, Suite 1600Charleston, West Virginia 25301

TWENTY-NlNTli JiJVIGA). QR('UlT

COUNTIES OF BUCHANAN, OICKENSON, AU83ELL ANO TAZEWELL

MICHAEL L. MOORERusset County uaursrauseP.O. Box 435Lebanon, VA 24266

(276) 889-8049(276) 889-8090 Fax

HENRYA. VANOVER

rudansan Caunly Caurlhausa

PO. Box 190Clintwoad, VA 24228

(276) 926-1685(276) 926-5580 Fax

TERESA M. CHAFIN

Tstsnell County CaurlhaussP.O. Box 968Taxewell. VA 24651 .

(276) 988-1230(276) 988-3081 Fax

J. Scott Sexton, Esq.Gentry Locke Rakes & Moore, LLP10 Franklin Road, S.E.P.O. Box 40013

. Roanoke, Virginia 24022

Eric D. Whitesell, Esq.Gillespie, Hart, Altizer & Whitesell, P.C.P.O. Box 718Tazewell, Virginia 24651

Re: Richard K. Pohyt, et al. v Garden Realty Corporation, Case No J 486-08

Dear Counsel,

The above-styled case is now before the Court on the PlaintiQ'8 Motion forSummary Judgment. Richard K. Pobst, et al. (Plaintiffs) filed a Complaint forDeclaratory Judgment against Garden Realty Corporation, CNX Gas Company, LLC, End

Island Creek Coal Company to determine the ownership of coalbed methane gas (CBM).Subsequent to the filing of the Complaint, CNX Gas Company, LLC and Island CreekCoal Company were dismissed as parties, leaving Garden Realty Corporation(Defendant) as the sole Defendant. On March 2, 2011, this Court conducted a bearing onthe Plaintiff'8 Motion for Summary Judgment. After thorough review of the court file,submitted briefs, evidence, and oral arguments presented at the February 23, 2011

Page Number 73.

Page 74: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Blair M. Gardner, Esq.J. Scott Sexton, Esq.Eric D. Whitesell, Esq.5/2/2011Page2 of 7hearing, the Court now makes the following ruling on the Plaintiff s Motion for Summary

Judgment.

L Facts

The current dispute is the result of the extraction of CBM from a 250.22-acre tractof land (Subject Property). The Defendant in this case owns the coal estate. ThePlaintiffs in this case assert that they are the owners of all oil and gas located in or uponthe Subject Property. Prior to this action, the coal estate of the Subject Property wassevered and conveyed to the Defendant by deed.

Pursuant to separate agreements with the Plaintiffs and the Defendant, CNX Gas,LLC is extracting CBM &om the Subject Property. As part of this proces, CNX Gas hasphysically stimulated the coal seam by a method known as factoring. Fracturing of thecoal seam results in CBM collecting within gas wells. CNX Gas has declared that thereare conflicting ownership claims to the CBM located under the Subject Property, andtherefore, to the gas royalties generated by the wells. These royalties have beendeposited into an escrow account, in accordance with Virginia law, until the ownershipissue is resolved.

A. The Deeds

There are three consecutive severance deeds, all involving the Subject Property,that are pertinent to the present case. First, a deed executed on December 4, 1937(Prater-Pobst Deed), in which the Prater Land Company conveyed certain property rightsto F H. Combs and JL Claude Pobst. (Ex. C to Compl.). Second, a deed executed onDecember 28, 1937(Pobst-Levisa Deed), in which H. Claude Pobst, Mary Alice Pobst,F.H. Combs, and Harriet R. Combs conveyed certain pmperty rights to Levisa CoalCorporation. (Ex.D to Compl.). Third, a deed executed on January 8, 1941 (Levisa-Garden Deed), in which Levisa Coal conveyed certain property rights to the Defendant.

(Ex.E to Compl.). An analysis of the explicit language contained within these threeseverance deeds is necessary to determine the ultimate outcome of this case.

The language of the Prater-Pobst Deed grants and conveys to F.H. Combs and H.Claude Pobst, "all of the coal, oil, and gas as well as all such other minerals, metal and

timber as the party of the first part may own or be entitled to in or upon the landshereinafter identified." (Ex. C to Compl.). The Prater-Pobst Deed subsequently identifiesthe Subject Property. Id.

The language of the Pobst-Levisa Deed grants and conveys to Levisa Coal, "all ofthe coal, metals, and timbers, together with all rights, pfivileges and easements incidentthereto, in, or under the following described parcels of land...." (Ex. D to Compl.). ThePobst-Levisa Deed subsequently describes the Subject Property. Id.

Page Number 74.

Page 75: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Blair M. Gardner, Esq.J. Scott Sexton, Esq.Eric D. Whitesell, Esq.5/2/2011Page 3 of7

The language of Deed C grants and conveys to the Defendant, "all of the coal,metals, and timber and other substances snd all rights, privileges and easements... on orunder" the Subject Property. (Ex. E to Compl.).

In sum, the Prater-Pobst Deed explicitly conveys the rights to coal, oil, gas,minerals, metals, and timber in or upon the Subject Property. The Pobst-Levisa Deedexplicitly conveys the rights to coal, metals, and timber in or under the Subject Property.The Levisa-Garden Deed explicitly conveys the rights to coal, metals, and timber andother substances on or under the Subject Property.

Accordingly, when the Pobst-Levisa Deed was executed, it did not include therights to oil, gas, or minerals, as the Prater-Pobst Deed had explicitly included. Indeed,the Pobst-Levisa Deed contains a narrower conveyance than the Prater-Pobst Deed.

B. The Pobst and Combs Transfers

By deed dated April 23, 1947, H. Claude Pobst and Mary Alice Pobst conveyed"all of the oil and gas in, on and under" their undivided one-half interest in the SubjectProperty to their children, John W. Pobst, Nancy S.Ellis and W. Kent Pobst. (Ex. F toCompl.). The Plaintiffs, Richard K. Pobst, Nancy C. Pobst, John W. Pobst, Jr., VirginiaLee Linwick, and Meredith Ellis Jennings are the heirs and successors of the children ofH. Claude Pobst and Mary Alice Pobst.

F.H. Combs died in 1956, leaving two descendents, C.H. Combs and HelenCombs Johnson. The will of F.H. Combs is recorded in the Clerk's ofhce of the CircuitCourt of Buchanan County at Will Book 2, Page 554. C.H. Combs and Helen CombsJohnson each inherited a one-half interest ofF.H. Combs one.half interest in the SubjectProperty. The Plaintillh, Caml C. Irvin, Ma'itha E. Combs, Frederick Harmon Combs H

Testamentary Trust, Ke'lly Combs Necessary., Trustee, and Fairview Limited Partnershipare the heirs and successors of the children of F.H. Comb and Harriet R. Combs.

Accordingly, each Plaintiff asserts the fbllowing ownership interest in the gas andoil rights of the Subject Property:

1. Richard K. Pobst- 8.33%2. Nancy C. Pobst- 8.33%3. John W. Pobst- 8.33%4. Virginia Lee Linswick- 8.33%5. Meredith Ellis Jennings- 8.33%6. Frederick Harmon Combs II Testamentary Trust, Kelly Combs Necessary,

Trustee- 8.33%7. Carol C. Irvin- 8.33%8. Martha E Combs- 8.33%9. Fairview Limited Partnership- 25%

Page Number 75.

Page 76: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Blair lvl. Gardner, Esq.I Scott Sexton, Esq.Eric D. Whitesell, Esq.5/2/2011Page4of7

This ownership ratio of tbe gas and oil rights of the Subject Property is not indispute. (Def.'s Answer 14-15).

II. Applicable Law

A. Harrison-Wyatt

In Harnson-Wyatt v Ratltff, 267 Va. 549 S.E.2d 234 (2004), the Supreme Court ofVirginia heard an appeal of a Buchanan County Circuit Court ruling involving a similarset of facts as those in the present case. In that case, Ratliff and others ovmed the surfaceand all minerals located upon and within the relevant property, except the coal. Id. at550. Through a series 'of severance deeds, Harrison-Wyatt, LLC became the eventualowner of the coal estate. Id. The issue in Harrison- Wyatt was whether title to the CBMpassed with the severance of the coal estate. Id. Harrison-Wyatt contended that theowner of the coal estate was also the owner of the CBM. Id. The surface owners filedfor declaratory judgment asking the Court to determine the owner of the CBM. Id. TbeCircuit Court entered judgment in favor of the surface owner and the Supreme Court ofVirginia affirmed. Id. at 557.

In deciding Harrison-Wyatt, the Circuit Court examined the language of theconcerned severance deeds and the definition of coal at the relevant time period. Id. at553. From this examination, the Circuit Court determined that CBM is not a chemicalconstituent of coal and is a severable estate. Id. Accordingly, the Circuit Courtdetermined that, "the grant of coal rights does not include rights to CBM absent anexpress grant of coalbed methane, natural gas, or minerals in general." Id. Therefore, inthe event that a grantor executes a severance deed conveying the coal estate to a grantee,the grantor retains the CBM absent an express grant of CBM, natural gas, or minerals ingeneraL

B. Virginia Code tj 45.1-361.21:1.

Subsequent to the Supreme Court of Virginia's decision in Harnson-Wyatt, theVirginia Legislature enacted Virginia Code $ 45.1-361,21:1.This portion of the Codeserves to codify the decision of Harrison-Wyatt and states, in part, "a conveyance,reservation, or exception of coal shall not be deemed to include coalbed methane gas...."Va. Code Ann. ti 45.1-361.21:1.

HI. Discussion

A. PlamtifPs Argument

In resolving the ultimate issue of this case, the Plaintiffs would have the courtadopt tbe following reasoning: (I) the Pobst-Levisa Deed did not make an express grant

Page Number 76.

Page 77: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Blair M. Gardner, Esq.I. Scott Sexton, Esq.Eric D. Whiteseil, Esq.5/2/2011Page 5 of 7of coalbed methane, natural gas, or minerals in general; (2) without such an expressgrant, the rights to CBM did not pass to Levisa Coal through the execution of the Pobst-Levisa Deed; {3)therefore, Levisa Coal could not subsequently convey the CBM to theDefendant in the Levisa-Garden Deed; and (4) consequently, the named heirs andsuccessors of H. Claude Pobst and F.H. Combs own the CBM.

B. Defendant's Argument

The Defendant objects to this line of reasoning on two grounds.

First, the Defendant proposes that Harrison- Wyatt does not result in the inflexiblerule that a grant of coal rights does not include rights to CBIvl absent express language inthe conveyance. Rather, the Defendant views Harrison-Wyatt as a guide for Courts toexamine what has been conveyed in a deed. Specifically, the Defendant notes that in theCircuit Court's Letter Opinion, when interpreting the terms of the severance deedsspecific to Harrison- Wyatt, it stated, "the Court is left with no alternative but to examinethe terms used in light of the common understandings, along with other facts andcircumstances, during that time period.*'Op. at 5) In light of this statement, theDefendant argues that it was the intent of the parties to include a conveyance of the CBMupon the execution of the Levisa-Garden Deed.

In support of this, the Defendant points to the words "other substances" found inthe Levisa-Garden Deed. {Ex.E to Compl.). In oral argument, Counsel for theDefendant asserted that the term "other substances" includes CBM. In his written brief,Counsel for Defendant presents several well-conceived reasons as to why "othersubstances*'as intended to include CBM.

However, this argument cannot overcome fact that a grantor cannot convey whattbe grantor does not own. The Supreme Court of Virginia has held, when construing theterms of a deed:

where the language in the deed... is clear, unambiguous, andexplicit... a court called upon to construe such a deed should look nofurther than the four corners of the instrument under review.Furthermore, if the language is explicit and the intention is therebyfiee fiom doubt, such intention is controlling, if not contrary to law orto public policy, and auxiliary rules of construction should not bcused.

Irby v Roberts, 256 Va. 324, 329 (1998).

Page Number 77.

Page 78: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Blair M. Gardner, Esq.J. Scott Sexton, Esq.Eric D. Whitesell, Esq.5/2/2011Page 6 of 7

The Pobst-Levisa Deed, which was executed in 1937,does not contain an express

grant of coalbed methane, natural gas, or minerals in general. (Ex. D to Compl.)Furthermore, this Court finds that the language used in Pobst-Levisa Deed is clear,

unambiguous, and explicit. As is such, Levisa Coal did not obtain the rights to.the CBMfrom H. Claude Pobst, F.H. Combs, Mary Alice Pobst, and Harriet R Combs.

Consequently, it was impossible for Levisa Coal to subsequently convey those rights tothe Defendant in the Levisa-Garden Deed.

In addition, the Defendant argues that if the Court were to rule in favor of thePlaintiffs, it would be permitting a trespass upon the Defendant's coal seam. This Courtrejects this argument as it did in Harrison-Wyatt. As previously stated:

the surface owner need not trespass on the coal estate to retrieve theCBM because the Court holds that the surface owners'ight to theCBM only extends to that which has separated from the coal. TheCourt does not hold that the surface owners have the right to free thecoal in order to retrieve the CBM...Once the coal is removed, thesurface owners retain the ownership of the resulting void and havefull rights to retrieve the CBM left behind, as well as the rights toprofit f'rom CBM captured during the venting process.

(Op. at 7-8).

IV. Conclusion

Rule I:11of the Supreme Court ofVirginia promulgates the standard forsummary judgment. In part, Rule I:11states, "it must appear from the pleadings, an

order made at a pretrial conference, or an admission in the proceedings, or after the court

has sustained a motion to strike the evidence, that the movant is entitled to judgment.'* ACourt may not grant summary judgment if any material fact is genuiriely in dispute,

Carrrile v Richmond ¹wspapers, 196 Va. I (1954). Furthermore, all reasonable

inferences must be drawn in favor on the non-moving party. Andrews v Ring, 266 Va.311 (2003).

The language of the Pobst-Levisa Deed is clear and unambiguous. It does notcontain an express grant of the gas estate to Levisa Coal. Rather, the Pobst-Levisa Deed

conveys to Levisa Coal, "all the coal, metals, and timber," (Ex. D to Compl.). Stated

earlier, CBM is not conveyed with the coal estate absent express language. Harrison-

Wyatt, 267 Va. at 553. Therefore, H. Claude Pobst, F.H. Combs, Mary Alice Pobst, and

Harriet R. Combs retained ownership of the CBM when they executed the severance deed

to Levisa CoaL As Levisa Coal did not acquire the rights to the CBM in 1937, it was

Page Number 78.

Page 79: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Blair M. Gardner, Esq.J. Scott Sexton, Esq.Eric D. Whitesell, Esq.5/2/2011Page7of7impossible for Levisa Coal to convey the CBM to the Defendant in the subsequent

Levisa-Garden Deed.

There is no genuine issue of material fact before the Court at this time. The soleissue presently before the Court is the application of law to the language of the relevantseverance deeds. As such, after drawing all reasonable inferences in favor of theDefendant, it appears to this Court that the Plaintiff is entitled to summary judgment.The Plaintiffs, in accordance with the interest ratio stated above, are the owners of theCBM located in or upon the Subject Property.

Mr. Sexton is directed to prepare an Order reflecting the findings of this Courtand to forward the same to Mr. Whitesell and Mr. Gardner for endorsement and then tothe Court for entry.

KRW/cmb

Page Number 79.

Page 80: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

(i43 IIIIII)43)I)We+a(tL 43 ( VIIII'Ef'}'Im)IIB)

CIRCUIT COURT JUDGES:

PATRICK R. JOHNSONBuchanan County Courthouse

P.O. Box 1995Grundy, VA 24614

{276)935-2451(276) 935-8516 Fax

KEARY R. WILLIAMS {Retired)P.O. Box 849Grundy, VA 2461 4

(276) 935-2451(276) 935-8516 Fax October 20, 2011

Blair M. Gardner, Esq.Jackson Kelly, PLLC500 Lee Street, East, Suite 1600Charleston, West Virginia 25301

TWENTY-NINTH JUDIGAI. GRCUITCOUNTIES OF BUCHANAN, DICKENSON, RUSSELL AND TAZEWELL

MICHAEL L. MOORERussell Conroy Courthouse

P.O. Box 435Lebanon, VA 24266

(276) 889-8049(276) 889-8090 Fax

HENRYA.VANOVERDlckenson County CourthouseP.O. Box 1SOCllntwood, VA 24228

(276) 926-1635(276) S26-5580 Fax

TERESA M. CHAFIN

Tszewell County CourthouseP.O. Box 968Tazewell, VA 24651

(276) 988-1230(276) 988-3081 Fax

J. Scott Sexton, Esq.Gentry Locke Rakes & Moore, LLP10 Franklin Road, S.E.P.O. Box 40013Roanoke, Virginia 24022

Eric D. Whitesell, Esq.Gillespie, Hart, Altizer & Whitesell, P.C.P.O. Box 718Tazewell, Virginia 24651

Re: 'ichard K. Pabst, et al. V. Garden Realty Corporation, Case Noc 486-08

Dear Counsel:

The above-styled case is now before the Court on the Defendant Garden RealtyCorporation's Motion and Memorandum for Reconsideration. Specifically, the Motionseeks reconsideration of the Court's May 2, 2011 letter opinion granting the

Plaintiffs'otion

for Summary Judgment. After thorough review of the Court's file, submittedbriefs, and oral arguments presented at the June 16, 2011 hearing, the Court now makesthe foHowing iuling on the Defendant's Motion for

Reconsideration.'he

Court acknowledges the long delay from the June 16, 2011 hearing to the date of this letter. Thedelay is attributed to this Court*s desire to review the most recent decision in Addison v. CNX Gas Co.,ELC, 2011 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 50276 (W.D. Va. May 10, 2011).

Page Number 80.

Page 81: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Blair M. Gardner, Es<

J. Scott Sexton, Esq.Eric D. Whitesell, Esq.10/20/2011Page 2 of3

L Facts and Procedural History

On August 19, 2008, the Plaintiffs filed a Complaint for Declaratory Judgment

pursuant to Va. Code Ann. tj 8.01-184.In the Complaint, the Plaintiffs seek thedetermination of ownership over Coalbed Methane Gas (CBM) located within a certaintract of property in Buchanan County, Virginia (Subject Property). On November 29,2010, the Plaintiffs filed a Motion for Summary Judgment. On March 2, 2011 the Courtheld a hearing on the Motion for Summary Judgment and heard Counsel's oralarguments. On May 2, 2011, the Court issued a letter opinion outlining a ruling thatgranted the Plaintiffs'otion for Summary Judgment and directed Counsel for thePlaintiffs to prepare and present an order refiecting the findings of the Court. Before suchan order was presented to the Court, the Defendant filed this Motion for Reconsiderationon May 19, 2011.

In the May 2, 2011 letter opinion, the Court concluded that no genuine issue ofmaterial fact existed as to tbe issue of ownership over the CBM located within theSubject Property and granted the Plaintiffs'otion for Summary Judgment. In arriving atthis conclusion, the Court's main focus was upon the application of relevant law to thelanguage of three sequential deeds involving the Subject Property. The Court determinedfrom the language of the deeds that the Plaintiffs owned the CBM located within theSubject Property.

II. Motion to Reconsider

In Harrison-Wyatt v, Ratltff, 267 Va. 549 (Va. 2004), the Supreme Court ofVirginia stated, "the grant of coal rights does not include rights to CBM absent an expressgrant of coalbed methane, natural gas, or minerals in general." This rule was latercodified by Va. Code Ann. tj 45.1-361.21:1and states, in part, "aconveyance,reservation, or exception of coal shall not be deemed to include coalbed methane gas...."

In the Motion to Reconsider, the Defendant asserts that the Court misapprehends

the precedent set forth in Harrison- Wyatt and broadens the scope of the Supreme Court

of Virginia's decision by: (1) deciding the ownership of the CBM as a matter of law; and

(2) allowing Plaintiffs to trespass on the Defendant's property rights.

First, the Court disagrees that it should reconsider the May 2, 2011 letter opinion

ruling based upon the fact that it decided ownership as a matter of law. Va. Sup. Ct, R.3:20 provides the standard for granting Summary Judgment and allows for such a ruling

only when there is no genuine dispute concerning any material fact. The relevant deeds in

this matter are clear and final on the issue of ownership over the CBM located within theSubject Property. The Plaintiffs own the CBM. Because there is no genuine disputeconcerning the issue of ownership in this declaratory judgment proceeding, summaryjudgment is appropriate.

Page Number 81.

Page 82: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

Blair M. Gardner, Esq.J. Scott Sexton, Esq.Eric D. Whitesell, Esq.10I20/2011Page 3 of 3

Second, the Court disagrees that it should reconsider its decision based upon theDefendant's claim that the Court is permitting a trespass on the Defendant's propertyrights. The Defendant vigorously contends that by awarding the Plaintiffs ownership ofthe CBM, the Court is allowing the Plaintiffs to invade the coal seam, property of theDefendant, and is in effect permitting a trespass. The Court's ruling in this matter isconfined to the sole issue of ownership over the CBM located within the SubjectProperty. Any issue of trespass in this matter, while possibly meritorious, is collateral tothe issue of ownership. The law in Virginia is settled on the issue of CBM ownershipwhen there is a conveyance, reservation, or exception of coal. Again, Va. Code Ann. tj

45.1-361.21:Istates, in part, "a conveyance, reservation, or exception of coal shall not bedeemed to include coalbed methane gas...."After applying this rule of law to the relevantdeeds, it is patent that the plaintiffs own the CBM located within the Subject property.

III, Conclusion

It is unequivocally clear from the relevant deeds that the Defendant neverreceived an express grant of coalbed methane, natural gas, or minerals in general in theSubject Property. The Defendant did receive an interest in the coal located within theSubject Property. Consequently, the Plaintiffs own the CBM located in the SubjectProperty. The Complaint for Declaratory Judgment filed in this case seeks to have theCourt determine the ownership of CBM located within the Subject Property. The Courthas determined that the Plaintiffs're the owners of the CBM located within the SubjectProperty. Consequently, the Defendant Garden Realty Corporation's Motion andMemorandum for Reconsideration is denied.

Mr. Sexton is directed to circulate the prepared Order refiecting the findings ofthis Court's letter opinion dated May 2, 2011 to Mr. Whitesell and Mr. Gardner forendorsement and then to the Court for entry.

Page Number 82.

Page 83: I....Lockhart, Roger Jay Lockhart, Francis Lockhart, Emma A. Barton, Earl Inman, Alta Barton, Sandra Barton Hibbi tts Further, said respondents are listed in Exhibit B-3hereto which

I

i 1

~4

Ir:

(~

ePage Number 83.