__important_participation in climate change adapatation governance

8/10/2019 __important_participation in Climate Change Adapatation Governance

1/22

1

!"# %&'()#*+#,,- ./ 0123'('013'.+ '+ (4'513# ("1+6# 1*10313'.+ 6.7#2+1+(#

!" $%&' ()*&+,- ./&*% 012)3%44- 5+,&* 6*41*- &,7 8+9+&,& :3&*&

8+32.*9(3'.+

0'% ;%7 7+2%,3+1,3? 1@ =/+2&4% ='&,A% *%BC+*% *%4'+,>+,A '1< 41 !%34 A19%*,

%@@1*43 41%7 )*1!/%23- &3 7%@+,%7 !" F+44%/ &,7 E%!!%* GHIJKL-

=&,,14 !% 31/9%7 !" !*%&>+,A 4'%2 71&," &,7 51,1


2/22

2

&AA*%33+9%D 0'% %7,%33 1@ )&*4+=+)&4+1, +3 )&*4/" 4'% *%3C/4 1@ 4'% 9%*" )*1!/%2 4'&4

)*12)4%7 F+44%/ &,7 E'+4% GHIJKL 41


3/22

3

)*1=%33%3 +,A &,7 &=4+1,Q G)D bVLD 0'+3 7%@+,+4+1,

=12%3 71


4/22

4

&))/+%7 41 &))*1&='%3


5/22

5

%M)&,7 4'% %'1/7%* 1* )C!/+= )&*4+=+)&4+1,- 4'+3 )&)%*

=1,3+7%*3 )&*4+=+)&4+1, 1@ !14' 34&>%'1/7%*3 &,7 )C!/+=3 &3 =%,4*&/ 41 +,A 4'*1CA' 4'%

%7 7+2%,3+1,3 1@ )&*4+=+)&4+1,D

N, 4%*23 1@ )1/+4+=&/ )'+/131)'"- )&*4+=+)&4+1, +3 & =%,4*&/ =12)1,%,4 41

%,9+*1,2%,4&/ 7%21=*&="D R14+ %4 &/D GSTTfL &*AC% 4'&4 &==%33 41 +,@1*2&4+1,- )C!/+=

)&*4+=+)&4+1,- &,7 &==%33 41 \C34+=% &*% >%"3 41 21*% 4*&,3)&*%,4- +,=/C3+9%- &,7 &==1C,4&!/%

7%=+3+1,P2&>+,A +, 2&44%*3 &@@%=4+,A 4'% %,9+*1,2%,4D :3 & ,1*2&4+9% =1,=%)4-

)&*4+=+)&4+1, &3 )&*4 1@ 7%21=*&4+= *+A'43 G(4*+,A%*- X1CA+// %4 &/D STTVd F%%7 STTfL *%7C=%3

2&*A+,&/+U&4+1,- +,=*%&3%3 )C!/+= 4*C34- +,=*%&3%3 %2)1&," &,7 51%'1/7%*3 &*% +,91/9%7 G&/4'1CA' 4'% BC%34+1, 1@ %'1/7%*3 %7LD0'%3% *&4+1,&/%3 @1* )&*4+=+)&4+1, +, =/+2&4% ='&,A% &7&)4&4+1, A19%*,&,=% )*19+7%

& )'+/131)'+=&/ &,7 )*&=4+=&/ !&3+3 @1* 4'% +2)1*4&,=% 1@ )&*4+=+)&4+1, +, =/+2&4%

A19%*,&,=%D X%3)+4% 1C* !%/+%@ +, 4'% +2)1*4&,=% 1@ )&*4+=+)&4+1,- 1C* )&)%* *%9%&/3

@C,7&2%,4&/ &5"**,(-,/41 4'% 4'%1*" &,7 )*&=4+=% 1@ )&*4+=+)&4+1, 7C% 41 4'% ,&4C*% 1@

%7 )*1!/%23D 01 +7%,4+@" 4'%3% %7 7+2%,3+1,3 1@ )&*4+=+)&4+1,-


6/22

6

/+4%*&4C*% 1, =/+2&4% ='&,A% &7&)4&4+1, &,7 2C/4+P/%9%/ A19%*,&,=% &,7 4'%, @1=C3

3)%=+@+=&//" 1, =*+4+BC%3 1@ )&*4+=+)&4+1,D

;4'513# ("1+6# 1*10313'.+ 1+* 5943'%, &3 4'% 1,/" &=41*3 4'&4 =&, %@@%=4+9%/" 7%&/ %4 &/D GSTHTL 34*%33 4'% +2)1*4&,=% 1@ 4&>+,A &=4+1, &4 4'% &))*1)*+&4% /%9%/ 1@

3=&/% &,7 &*AC% 4'&4 !14412PC) &))*1&='%3 @+4 &7&)4&4+1, !%44%* 7C% 41 4'% %M+34%,=% 1@


7/22

7

2C/4+)/% 9&*+&!/%3- =1,4%M4 7%)%,7%,=+%3- &,7 =C/4C*&/ 3%44+,A3D e1!31, &,7 W+%2%"%*

GSTHHL C,7%*/+,% 4'% @&=4 4'&4 &7&)4&4+1, +3 & /1,A &,7 =1,4+,C1C3 )*1=%33 *%BC+*+,A =/13%

=11*7+,&4+1, %'1/7%*3 =&, !%

%,A&A%7 +, 7+*%=4 )&*4+=+)&4+1, +, 7%/+!%*&4+1, &,7 7%=+3+1, 2&>+,AD 0'+3 +3 +, /+,% %/" 41 @&+/D 0'% &C4'1*3 &*AC% 4'&4 4'%

]/&4%34 @&3'+1,Q 1@ 7%=%,4*&/+U&4+1, 1@ A19%*,2%,4 @C,=4+1,3 +3 C3C&//" \C34+@+%7 1, 4'*%%

A*1C,73Y A*%&4%* %@@+=+%,="- !*+,A+,A 7%=+3+1, 2&>+,A =/13%* 41 4'13% &@@%=4%7 !"

A19%*,&,=%- &,7 )*19+3+1, 1@ 21*% )*%=+3% >,1%*3D W%< '"!*+7

217%3 1@ A19%*,&,=% =*133=C44+,A 34&4%- 2&*>%4- &,7 =122C,+4" 3)'%*%3 &*% %2%*A+,AD

0'*%% !*1&7 =&4%A1*+%3 @1* 4'%3% ,%< +,,19&4+9% '"!*+7 A19%*,&,=% +,34*C2%,43 &*%

+7%,4+@+%7 !" 4'% &C4'1*3Y =1P2&,&A%2%,4 G!%4


8/22

8

:4 4'% /1=&/ /%9%/- )&*4+=+)&4+1, 1@4%, 2%&,3 7+*%=4 )&*4+=+)&4+1, !" 34&>%'1/7%*3 1*

2%2!%*3 1@ 4'% )C!/+= +, 7+&/1AC% &,7 7%/+!%*&4+1, 4'&4 +,@/C%,=% 7%=+3+1,P2&>+,AD [%4

%9%, &4 4'% /1=&/ /%9%/- )1%

1, )1


9/22

9

0'% +,=*%&3+,A )1)C/&*+4" 1@ 2&*>%4P &,7 +,=%,4+9%3P!&3%7 )1/+=" +,34*C2%,43 3C='

&3 %=1P4&M%3- 91/C,4&*" &A*%%2%,43- &,7 %=1P/&!%//+,A +, 7%9%/1)%7 - `C*,3 %4 &/D STHTL D 0'% *1/% 1@ 3C=' ;34&>%'1/7%*3?-

'1< &,7


10/22

10

@1*23d A19%*,+,A =/+2&4% ='&,A% &7&)4&4+1, *%BC+*%3 !14' 7+34*+!C4+9% \C34+=% G7+34*+!C4+1,

1@ =1343 &,7 !%,%@+43L &,7 )*1=%7C*&/ \C34+=% G%,=12)&33+,A *%=1A,+4+1,- )&*4+=+)&4+1, &,7

7+34*+!C4+1, 1@ )1,1


11/22


12/22


13/22

13

(% )/&=% +, ,1,P4*&,3)&*%,4-

&7 '1= &,7 =1,4%M4P7%)%,7%,4 %4 )1%3 =/%&*Y 1,/" +,=/C7+,A 4'13%


14/22

14

$q33r% GSTTJL- 4'% )134P%=1/1A+34 4*&,3@1*2&4+1, +2)/+%3 & ,&**1 )*17C=4+1, j 41 & 4%=',+=&/j@C,=4+1,&/+34+=

&))*1&=' *%34*+=4%7 1,/" 41 &, 1)4+2+U&4+1, 1@ *%31C*=%3 SL @*12 31=+&/ 21!+/+3&4+1, 4'&4

'+A'/+A'43 4'% 9&/C%P!&3%7 &,7 34*C=4C*&/ =1,@/+=43 +,A )&*&71M%3 3%*+1C3/" &,7

@+,7+,A


15/22

15

+@ !%44%* &,3


16/22

16

+@ 4'%" &*% 3%%, &3 !%+,A AC+7%7 !" )*%7%4%*2+,%7 1C4=12%3D :3 R%< %4 &/D GSTTJL &3>- ]N@

)C*3C+4 1@ &7&)4&4+1, 41 =/+2&4% ='&,A% +3 & )*%7%4%*2+,%7 A1&/- &,7 +@ 34&>%'1/7%*3 =&,,14

!% ;4*C34%7? 41 7%=+7% =1//%=4+9%/" 1, &, &7&)4+9% )&4' !%=&C3% 1@ =12)%4+,A )*+1*+4+%3 &,7

3'1*4P4%*2 +,4%*%343- +,A

7%=+3+1,3 41A%4'%* 312%4+2%3 /%&73 A*1C)3 41 &71)4 =1,3%,3C3P!&3%7 &))*1&='%3 =*+4+BC%7

!" )134P)1/+4+=&/ 3='1/&*3D E% *%\%=4 4'% ,14+1, 4'&4 & 219% 41 +,=/C7% )&*4+=+)&4+1, +,

2C/4+P/%9%/ A19%*,&,=% ,%=%33&*+/" +2)/+%3 =1,3%,3C3P!&3%7 &))*1&='%3- )&*4+=C/&*/" ,1


17/22

17

&!1C4 &A*%%2%,4 &!1C4 )13+4+1,3 &3 2C=' &3 +4 +3 &!1C4 C,7%*34&,7+,A 7+9%*3%

)%*3)%=4+9%3D W1*2&4+9% 2%4&P=1,3%,3C3- @1* %M&2)/%- 3CAA%343 4'&4 7+@@%*%,4 3+7%3 %,7 C)

&A*%%+,A 4'&4 14'%*3 '&9% /%A+4+2&4% 9&/C%3 %9%, +@ 4'%" 7+3&A*%% &!1C4 % =1,@/C%,=%- 4'+3 4")% 1@ =1,3%,3C3 ,%=%33&*+/"

*%BC+*%3 7+33%,4 &,7 7+9%*3% )%*3)%=4+9%3- !C4 +4 &44%2)43 41 @+,7 & & 6&0-/-#./ +$#*, 2#: ,#

+66"&// /2+"&6 4"#$%&'/8 @&, 1#=&".+.0& %+0>/ 0#6-)-&6 "*%&/ +.6 "&1*%+,-#./ ,2+,

6&)-.& .#"'/ #) 4+",-0-4+,-#.5 :2-02 0+. "&/*%, -. .A%-$&"+% +.6 0#"4#"+,& 0#A

#4,+,-#.8 RC,7&2%,4&//" 4'+3 +3 4'% )134P)1/+4+=&/ =1,=%*, 4'&4 +, 4'% &!3%,=% 1@ *1!C34

4'%1*" 1* ,1*23 A19%*,&,=% =&, !% =1P1)4%7 !" =1*)1*&4% +,4%*%343- 2&>+,A A19%*,&,=%

&,4+P7%21=*&4+= &,7 %,9+*1,2%,4&/+32 1,/" & 3&/%3 )+4='D R1//1


18/22

18

A19%*,&,=% +3 & 7%21=*&4+= *+A'4D N, 4'% +,4%*,&4+1,&/ =1,4%M4- )&*4+=+)&4+1, =&, !% 3%%, &3 &

@C,7&2%,4&/ 'C2&, *+A'4Z,14 \C34 & *+A'4 1@ =+4+U%,3'+) C,7%* & )&*4+=C/&* A19%*,2%,4D

>'()#* *'5#+,'.+, ./ &". 6#3, 3. 0123'('013#

69%, +@ &/ 6-"&0, 4+",-0-4+,-#. -'4"+0,-0+% -)

.#, -'4#//-$%&8 0'% ,&4C*% 1@ =/+2&4% ='&,A% &7&)4&4+1, *%BC+*%3 4'&4 ,14 %9%*" +,7+9+7C&/

1@ & *&,A% 1@ 7+@@%*%,4 ]'1/7%*3Q !&3%7 1, *+A'43- 3)&4+&/ /1=&4+1,- >,1%'1/7%* A*1C)3 &3 2C=' &3 2&,&A%*3D :4 4'+3 )1+,4- 4'%7%21=*&4+= &,7 )*&=4+=&/ \C34+@+=&4+1,3 1@ +,=/C7+,A /1=&/ )%*3)%=4+9%3 &,7 7+9%*3% 91+=%3

&*% C,7%*2+,%7 +@ )&*4+=+)&4+1, 1,/" +,=/C7%3 & 32&//- %34&!/+3'%7 A*1C) +,=/+,%7 41 3C))1*4

%M+34+,A )*&=4+=%3D

R+,&//"-4+",-0-4+.,/ ,&.6 ,# /&& 4"#$%&'/ #. + %&=&% $&%#: ,2&-" #:.8 G*, -) +

4"#$%&' -/ +,,+0>&6 #. ,## %#: + %&=&% ,2& /*00&// #) "&/#%*,-#. #) 2-12&" 4"#$%&'/ '+7


19/22

19

1# 6#:. 6*& ,# .&1+,-=& )&&6$+0> %##4/ 0+*/&6 $7 +66"&//-.1 %#:&" %&=&% 4"#$%&'/8

g19%3 41+,A 3'&)%D :3 X*"U%> GSTTTL 3CAA%343- %M)%*+2%,4+,A 4'&4 4'%3% 4'%1*%4+= 7+/%22&3 2&" !% 4'% 2134 %7

=1,7+4+1,3 4'&4 =1,@*1,4 C3Q G)DHVILD 0'% ,&4C*% 1@ )&*4+=+)&4+1, 2&>%3 +4 & %7

7+2%,3+1,Y 1, 1,% 3+7% )&*4+=+)&4+1, 2C34 !% & ,%=%33&*" =12)1,%,4 1@ &," =/+2&4% ='&,A%

&7&)4&4+1, A19%*,&,=%- 1, 4'% 14'%* 3+7% +4 @&=%3 4'% *+3> 1@ 4C*,+,A +43%/@ +,41 & ,&**1


20/22

20

)&*4+=+)&4+1, +, =/+2&4% ='&,A% &7&)4&4+1, 4'&4 %, 3%*+1C3/" ,14

%*&3%7D


21/22

21

>.2), ;'3#*

:7A%*- ED WD- X%33&+- (D- a1C/7%,- gD- eC/2%- gD- $1*%,U1,+- ND- W%/31,- XD FD- W&%33- $D hD- E1/@-

sD- &,7 E*%@1*7- :D GSTTIL O:*% 4'%*% 31=+&/ /+2+43 41 &7&)4&4+1, 41 =/+2&4% ='&,A%iO->*%+"$%& >5"(-,- IKYKK_D

Agarwal, B. (2001). "Participatory Exclusions, Community Forestry, and Gender: An Analysis

for South Asia and a Conceptual Framework." World Development 29(10): 1623-1648.Arnstein, S. R. (1969). "A ladder of citizen participation." Journal of the American Institute of

Planners 35: 216-224.Bauer, A., J. Feichtinger, et al. (2011). The governance of climate change adaptation in Ten

OECD countries: Challenges and approaches, Institute of Forest, Environmental, andNatural Resource Policy.

Biesbroek, G. R., R. J. Swart, et al. (2010). "Europe adapts to climate change: ComparingNational Adaptation Strategies." Global Environmental Change 20(3): 440-450.

Cleaver, F. (2001). Institutions, agency and the limitations of participatory approaches to

development Participation: The New Tyranny? B. Cooke and U. Kothari. London, ZedBooks.Collins, K. and R. Ison (2009). "Jumping off Arnstein's ladder: social learning as a new policy

paradigm for climate change adaptation." Environmental Policy and Governance 19(6):358-373.

Cooke, B. and U. Kothari (2001). Participtation: The New Tyranny? London, Zed Books.Ferkany, M. and K. Powys Whyte (2011). "The importance of Participatory virtues in the future

of environmental education." Journal of Environmental Ethics Published Online.Foti, J., L. de Silva, et al. (2008). Voice and Choice: opening the door to environmental

democracy, World Resources Institute.

Fung, A. (2006). "Varieties of Participation in Complex Governance." Public Administration andReview 66: 66-75.

Gaventa, J. (2004). Towards participatory governance: assessing the transformative possibilities.Participation: From Tyranny to Transformation? S. Hickey and G. Mohan. London, Zed

Books.Green, A. O. and L. Hunton-Clarke (2003). "A typology of stakeholder particiipation for

company environmental decision-making." Business Strategy and the Environment12(292-299).

Gualini, E. (2010). Governance, Space and Politics: Exploring the Governmentality of Planning.The Ashgate Research Companion to Planning Theory: Conceptual Challenges for

Spatial Planning. J. Hillier and P. Healey, Ashgate.Hickey, S. and G. Mohan, Eds. (2004). Participation: From Tyranny to Transformation? London,

Zed Books.Hickey, S. and G. Mohan (2004). Towards participation as transformation: critical themes and

challenges. Participation: From Tyranny to Transformation. S. Hickey and G. Mohan.London, Zed Books.

Hulme, M. (2009). Why we disagree about climate change: Understanding controversy, inactionand opportunity Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Larson, A. M. and F. Soto (2008). "Decentralization of Natural Resource Governance Regimes."Annual Review of Environment and Resources 33(1): 213-239.


22/22

Lemos, M. C. and A. Agrawal (2006). "Environmental Governance." Annual Review ofEnvironment and Resources 31: 297-325.

McGee, R. (2002). Participating in development. Development Theory and Practice: CriticalPerspectives. U. Kothari and M. Minogue. China, Palgrave.

Michener, V. J. (1998). "The participatory approach: Contradiction and co-option in Burkina

Faso." World Development26

(12): 2105-2118.Nikoloyuk, J., T. Burns, et al. (2010). "The promise and limitations of partnered governance: thecase of sustainable palm oil." Corporate Governance 10(1): 59-72.

Ostrom, E. (2010). "Beyond Markets and States: Polycentric Governance of Complex EconomicSystems." American Economic Review 100(3): 641-672.

Paavola, J. (2007). "Institutions and environmental governance: A reconceptualization."Ecological Economics 63(1): 93-103.

Paavola, J. and W. N. Adger (2006). "Fair adaptation to climate change." Ecological Economics

56(4): 594-609.

Reed, M. S. (2008). "Stakeholder participation for environmental management: A literaturereview." Biological Conservation 141: 2417-2431.

Rittel, H. W. J. and M. M. Webber (1973). "Dilemmas in a general theory of planning." PolicySciences 4(2): 155-169.

Schmitter, P. (2002). Participation in governance arrangements: is there any reason to expect itwill achieve 'sustainable and innovative policies in a multi-level context'? Participatory

Governance: Political and Societal Implications. J. R. Grote and B. Gbikpi. Opladen,Leske and Budrich.

Stringer, L. C., A. J. Dougill, et al. (2006). "Unpacking "participation" in the adaptivemanagement of social-ecological systems: a critical review." Ecology and Society 11(2):

39.Tebtebba (2009). Guide on climate chane and indigenous peoples. Philippines.

__important_participation in climate change adapatation governance

Documents