in the high court of south africa · 39. pinky r ramafu v raf 28233/14 40. lucas nkabinde v raf...
TRANSCRIPT
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA
GAUTENG DIVISION, PRETORIA
PRETORIA THIS 2ND DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2016
FRIDAY
CRIMINAL TRIALS
IN COURT GA AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JORDAAN
IN COURT GB AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MNGQIBISA THUSI
IN COURT GC AT 09:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TLHAPI CASE NO. CC 52/2015
THE STATE
AND
DIKELEDI SITHOLE + 1
Page 2 of 21
URGENT COURT
IN COURT A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE PRETORUIS IN COURT 6C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KOLLAPEN
FULL BENCH CRIMINAL APPEALS
IN COURT4A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOTHLE BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE HUGHES BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TWALA
Name of Advocate for the state : More/Leonard No. Case no. Name of appellant Jail/Bail
1. A250/15 D S Ngobese + 2 unknown
2. A783/15 D S Maluleke unknown
LAW SOCIETY MATTERS
IN COURT 4C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KHUMALO BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE SWARTZ
LAW SOCIETY VS BRADLEY JOHN SAUNDERSON 98684/15
Page 3 of 21
ADMISSIONS
IN COURT 4A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOTHLE BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE HUGHES
1. L. K MAKADESA ADV 54006/16
2. H.G RAMUKHESA ADV 55435/16
3. H. ELOFF ATT 56161/16
4. J. I ONI ATT 57741/16
IN COURT 4C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KHUMALO BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE SWARTZ
5. R. T RAMABULANA ADV 49020/16
6. A. E MUSEHANE ADV 51842/16
7. I. MABASO ADV 56846/16
8. R. MOKWENA ATT 54617/16
9. N. P RAMANALEDI ATT 40731/16
Page 4 of 21
UNOPPOSED MOTIONS
IN COURT 2A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RABIE IN COURT 2B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MBONGWE AJ IN COURT 2C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE NOBANDA AJ
OPPOSED MOTIONS
IN COURT4D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE FABRICIUS IN COURT 8B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JANSE VAN NIEWENHUIZEN IN COURT 8D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BASSON IN COURT8F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BUDLENDER AJ
JUDGMENTS
IN COURT 4D AT 11:30 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MALI J DE WEE VS RAF 71326/13
Page 5 of 21
IN COURT 2D AT 9:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TLHAPI CASE NO. 13901/2013 THE PRETORIA SOCIETY OF ADVOCATES AND MARGARET VAN ZYL
IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE
LEAVE TO APPEALS
IN COURT 4D AT 11:30 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MALI W VAN DER BURG VS D MOOSA +1 37238/14 IN COURT 8C AT 9;30 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE DAVIS AJ 1 M V J NHLAPO VS N F MARAIS 79904/15
PART HEARD MATTERS
IN COURT 4B AT 10:00 CIVIL TRIAL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE VAN DER WESTHUIZEN AJ
RTIES : JM FRICK VS DR SCHOLTZ
CASE NO : 16301/2014 Regards,
Page 6 of 21
SPECIAL CIVIL TRIALS
IN COURTC AT 10:00(22/08-02/090 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MURPHY IN COURT 6G AT 10:00(22/08-09/09) BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE DE VOS IN COURT 4E 10:00( 15/08-16/09) BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE FOURIE IN COURT 8C AT 10:00(22/08-02/09) BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RAUTENBACH
3RD
COURT MOTIONS
IN COURT 6F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEGODI IN COURT6B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RANCHOD
Page 7 of 21
CIVIL TRIALS ALLOCATION ONLY
IN COURT 8E AT 9;30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEDWABA, DJP AA CHAUKE N I VS RAF PP 30/08/16 67409/12
BB M A MASILO VS RAF PP 30/08/16 86105/14
CC C J W PRINSLOO VS RAF PP 23/08/16 26307/15
DD JR COETZEE VS RAF PP15/08/16 46034/12
EE J J CHUMA VS RAF 22/08/16 65681/14
FF P S MAHLANGU VS RAF 40635/14
CIVIL TRIALS DRAFT ORDERS ONLY
IN COURT 8E AT 9;30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEDWABA, DJP A V M HLAHLA VS RAF 32236/12
B M MSIMANGO VS RAF 39518/12
C A THULO VS RAF 58364/13
D T MBEDZI VS RAF 3184/15
E N MSASENI VS RAF 64678/15
F N V MLOZANA VS RAF 37518/13
G SNR SHEBE VS RAF 42408/13
H CELE M VS RAF 26820/15
I MOITSE M V VS RAF 12668/12
J T B LIFHIED VS RAF 14417/13
Page 8 of 21
K L MATOBAKO VS RAF 3859/13
L M NZIMNDE` VS RAF 73038/15
M TALA TR VS RAF 61754/13
N J MUSEKIWA VS RAF 7395/14
CIVIL TRIALS
IN COURT 8E AT 9;30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEDWABA, DJP 1A HM MATHEBULA VS RAF PREFDATE 9561/14 1B J MPHOSI VS MIN OF POLICE PREFDATE 63310/14
02 SEPTEMBER 2016
1. T CUPERTEA (V) V RAF 75942/15
2. AM MOLOTSANE V RAF 69942/15
3. GEORGE BALOYI V RAF 16915/15
4. MM RAMOKOPA V RAF 67097/15
5. MVUNYELA MBHUNGISWA V RAF 62334/15
6. JACK HENDRICK V RAF 45128/15
Page 9 of 21
7. ZVITO MAKAKATANWA V RAF 70357/14
8. JJ PC SWANEPOEL VS RAF 70748/14
9. MARIKA MONG V RAF 67662/10
10. DIBAKISO E KHAILE V RAF 2784/13
11. NELISWE K NZAMA V RAF 79417/14
12. LINDELWA SHUSHU V RAF 15211/14
13. MFAHADI LINAH TSOTETSI V RAF 82938/14
14. NEPHAWE N PAULINA V RAF 45620/13
15. NONTHENGISO E ZIMO V RAF 68567/14
16. E M NDLOVU V RAF 3898/14
Page 10 of 21
17. KEKANA K MAVIS V RAF 15129/15
18. LEKALAKALA O FREDERICK V RAF 6763/15
19. SAMUEL M MAKOETJE V RAF 73741/14
20. ARTHR COLIN AVENT V RAF 77171/10
21. AL NKOSI V RAF 87273/14
22. MDINGASE M MKABELA V RAF 51556/11
23. JPZ MABUZA obo MZIMBA V RAF 69890/13
24. NCUBE N obo S THOKOSANI V RAF 66654/15
25. KHATHILE C LETSIE V RAF 78487/15
26. TAUAHLAMA J BAPELA V RAF 57447/11
27. KOPEI PIET KGANG V RAF 55917/12
Page 11 of 21
28. K T GOLIATH V RAF 69592/13
29. D H HOMPA V RAF 57625/10
30. N E DUMA V RAF 39238/14
31. DESIRE A W obo V E FIELD V RAF 5966/15
32. F N NAHIMANA V RAF 27840/15
33. S M STOFFELS V RAF REMOVED 44168/15
34. DELLLAH VAN ROOYEN V RAF 23488/15
35. M DAVIDS V RAF 51691/15
36. KOBIE VAN NEEL V RAF 51181/15
37. LAZARUS T TSHILWANE V RAF REMOVED 16699/15
38. PETER M obo PETER JUNIOR ZINYEMBA V RAF 15027/13
Page 12 of 21
39. PINKY R RAMAFU V RAF 28233/14
40. LUCAS NKABINDE V RAF 16178/13
41. COETZER NANDI V RAF 78614/15
42. T MHLONGO V RAF 50419/14
43. N PHAAL V RAF 20902/15
44. M P MASEDI V RAF 18685/15
45. J P THERON V RAF 13747/15
46. T M MAKHALE V RAF 66242/14
47.
48. DENNIS MUDAU V RAF 51568/12
49. IDA SHIBURI obo K R MASAKA V RAF
38435/15
Page 13 of 21
50. MARIA P SAMBO V RAF 62469/13
51. MARCEL J BLIGNAUT V RAF 21943/15
52. LUZIBO MOYO V RAF NO FILE 61011/14
53. JOHANNES S ERLANK V RAF 32180/15
54. MARIA T NDLOVU V RAF 85991/15
55. GERT B MATAPENG V RAF 65610/14
56. LEAH E R obo MA RAATS V RAF 62945/15
57. MORONGWE R SELALA V RAF 58056/15
58. KOCH P J +1 V RAF 39773/15
59. TEREKI A M obo D A KOMANE obo RAF 60122/11
60. MMANARE LEAH MATJILA obo G M MATJILA V RAF 60123/11
61. BULK BRICK SUPPLIES CC V SHOTHA ENG CC 14989/15
62. R M PILANE V MIN OF POLICE 50735/13
Page 14 of 21
63. L J JORDAAN V MIN OF POLICE NO FILE 32259/14
64. WITBANK TIPPERS H/A SUNTRANS V MIN OF SAFETY 34295/07
65. ABSA BANK LTD V MIDDLESKY TRADING 243 CC REMOVED 70296/14
66. TOYOTA FIN SERVICES V FRANS M LEDWABA 31759/14
67. CHIEFTAIN REAL ESTATE INC V ENGADINI LANDSCAPING CC 43787/15
68. M L MATJILA VS RAF 60120/11
69. TSHOLOFELO MOLOKOMME V PRASA 9529/14
70. SIPHOKAZI N TSHAPA V PRASA 32811/11
71. ROSE M MANYIKI+1 V TRANSNET LTD 54978/08
72. MAREMANI NATURE RESERVEVS RICHMOND BOERDERY CC REMOVED 442/15
73. HAZEL GRACE SARAH V PREMILLA SEWPERSATH N.O 72122A/13
74. VIRGINIA M WOODSTOCK V MINISTER OF POLICE 71154/11
75. API PROPERTY GROUP CC V BETTA CORP RISK MANAGEMENT 29674/14
Page 15 of 21
76. TNA TRADING ENTER CC V CITY OF TSHWANE METRO NO FILE 7604/15
77. P M DE KOCK V FIRST DIAMONDS AND METAL SECURITIES FUND
54028/13
78. ABSA BANK V STEPHANUS H V DEVENTER 19458/12
79. ABSA BANK V VERA JENIFFER BOSCH 71859/13
80. MIDFIELD HOMEOWNERS ASS VSMOYA CANDLISH NAPE N.O NO FILE 83736/14
81. SIDNEY H CLARENCE V YOLANDI CLARENCE 69777/15
82. HENDRIK HEYNS SMITH V MARIA M SMITH 60681/15
83. CHANTELLE JONES V JOHN JONES 77998/15
84. MARK T HERMAN V MARE L HERMAN 10432/15
85. BEN MSHIGO V JOHANNA M MASHIGO 7243/15
86. SIKOE MALEPOTA PEARL V SIKOE A MPHO 51459/13
87. KEZANNE CONRADIE V MARUIS CONRADIE REMOVED 16546/15
Page 16 of 21
88. JOHANNA H A DU PLESSIS V LODEWICKUS G DU PLESSIS REMOVED 6872/15
89. DOCTOR NDLONDLO MSIBI V NTHATI S MSIBI 78632/15
90. RIAAN BESTER V CECILA BESTER NO FILE 85884/15
91. MOLAPO M N V RAF 41203/13
92. PHOKWANI T T V RAF NO FILE 71732/14
93. MOELA M M V RAF 56185/12
94. TSEKA L M V RAF 25206/14
95. PHIRI I M V RAF 37078/14
96. SHIBAMBO M R V RAF 51185/14
97. NDIMANDE P R V RAF 69732/13
98. MNTAMBO N C V RAF 46055/14
99. ZWANE N J V RAF 13346/14
100. MONOKETSAI L P L V RAF 83322/14
Page 17 of 21
101. DUBE A V RAF 18561/14
102. SANGWENI N M V RAF 49409/10
103. BREEDT L J obo TSHABALA NB RAF 62526/11
104. JIYANE M E RAF 37076/10
105. CASELINA MATSHIKA obo OFENTSE MATSHIKA V RAF 53104/13
106. NCUBUKA M J V RAF 38484/13
107. MAFAFO O O V RAF 20857/13
108. HLOHLOLO P E V RAF 4287/14
109. SEBOPETJA M J V RAF 63138/12
110. MOTHIBI N P V RAF NO FILE 387626/12
111. KS DLAMINI V RAF 45174/10
112. A B MAHLANGU V RAF 15758/12
113. I S MATEBESE V RAF REMOVED 73883/14
Page 18 of 21
114. S CHILOANE V RAF NO FILE 33282/08
115. S M METHULA V RAF 37818/14
116. BHATI; CALVIN V RAF 45679/10
116 REMOVED
117 H NLLABANE VS RAF REMOVED 20383/15
118 C F ZIKALALA VS RAF NO FILE 35840/11
119 TT MADONDELA VS RAF NO FILE 36946/13
120 MS MASHAPA VS RAF REMOVED 77016/15
121 N STRAUSS VS RAF 15081/13
122 C F ZIKALALA VS RAF REMOVED 36810/13
123 M R MOHAPI VS RAf 78268/14
124 J MABINANE VS RAF 42667/10
125 R W MOETJI VS RAF 71341/15
126 JS TSHATSHO VS RAF REMOVED 41310/12
127 C N MPONDOGO VS RAF READINES NO FILE 1046/13
128 MANAMELA M E VS RAF 23734/15
129 M M MABASO VS RAF 64194/15
130 B SIBONGILE VS RAF NO FILE 20803/12
131 M SAEED VS RAF 49416/14
Page 19 of 21
132 MAKWELA LP VS RAF 23626/15
133 M T MOPJELA VS RAF READY NO FILE 27781/14
133 S R RAMBAU VS RAF READY 30927/12
134 S L TEBEDI VS RAF READY 26285/13
135 GM MONAKHISI VS RAF NO FILE 7338/14
136 137 BHEMBE B VS RAF NO FILE 29682/14
138 BHEMBE B VS RAF 40315/13
139 ADV MONONYANE VS RAF NO FILE 48923/14
140 MZIMASI MAPAPU VS RAF 5512/15
141 M B ZOYA VS RAF 25557/15
142 MOGOLA L L VS RAF 11907/16
143 BANDA S F VS RAF 35406/14
144 RAMALATA L VS RAF 12364/14
145 R A MANANA vs RAF 62596/13
146 S M NKOSI VS RAF 25789/12
Page 20 of 21
147 E CHAUKE VS RAF 13639/13
148 P J MTHABINI VS RAF 58657/13
149 M F LEGODI VS RAF 68616/13
150 G B MABUZA VS RAF 20319/13
CIVIL TRIAL JUDGES
IN COURT 4G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE PRINSLOO IN COURT2D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TLHAPI IN COURT 4F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JW LOUW IN COURT 6D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TEFFO IN COURT 6A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOLAHLEHI IN COURT 8G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE SIWENDU AJ