inhibitory effect of disodium edta upon growthof ...aac.asm.org/content/32/11/1627.full.pdf ·...

5
Vol. 32, No. 11 Inhibitory Effect of Disodium EDTA upon the Growth of Staphylococcus epidermidis In Vitro: Relation to Infection Prophylaxis of Hickman Catheters JENNIFER L. ROOT,' 0. ROSS McINTYRE,l 2* NICHOLAS J. JACOBS,3 AND CHARLES P. DAGHLIAN4 Department of Medicine' and Department of Microbiology,3 Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center, and Julius A. Rippel Electron Microscope Facility,4 Dartmouth College, and The Norris Cotton Cancer Center,2 Hanover, New Hampshire 03756 Received 17 August 1987/Accepted 23 August 1988 Granulocytopenic patients with an intravascular catheter are at increased risk for infection with Staphylo- coccus epidermidis. During the intervals when the catheters are not being used for infusions, it is customary to maintain patency of the catheter lumen with a solution containing heparin. We show that heparin does not inhibit the growth of S. epiderinidis isolated from the catheter of an infected patient. A 20-mg/ml solution of disodium EDTA, a chelating agent which effectively anticoagulates blood at this concentration, was shown to be bactericidal for an initial inoculum of 103 CFU of staphylococci per ml in 24 h. Vancomycin, an antibiotic which is often employed to treat Staphylococcus infections, was also bactericidal for initial inocula of 103 CFU/ ml at doses of 6.7 ,ug/ml, a drug concentration in the therapeutic range. When 103 staphylococci per ml were cultured in the presence of catheter segments and disodium EDTA or vancomycin, subcultures of the catheters showed minimal or no growth, respectively. In contrast, when cultured with heparin alone, subcultures showed abundant growth. In view of its low cost, effectiveness as an anticoagulant, and bactericidal activity, EDTA should be studied as a replacement for heparin solutions for the maintenance of intravenous catheters in granulocytopenic patients. Hickman and Broviac catheters offer long-term venous access for the treatment of patients who are seriously ill (2, 7). They are typically maintained by twice-daily injections of a heparin flushing solution. Reports of complications asso- ciated with the use of these catheters focus on thrombosis and infection (9, 10, 16). Among the latter, Staphylococcus epidermidis has emerged as the most significant opportunis- tic pathogen, especially in patients who are granulocytope- nic (1, 19). Christensen et al. have shown that microbial colonization of Hickman lines is dependent upon the pro- duction of a slime coat by the bacteria (3). Recent studies suggest that this glycocalyx contributes to S. epidermidis virulence by protecting the organism from the bactericidal effects of empiric antibiotic therapy (4, 5). Numerous approaches to infection prophylaxis have yielded inconclusive results. Pizzo and Schimpff report that total protected isolation of granulocytopenic patients re- duces but does not eliminate completely the incidence of catheter-related sepsis (11). Similarly, the efficacy of sys- temic antimicrobial prophylaxis or selective suppression of alimentary flora is counterbalanced by the emergence of resistant bacteria, fungal superinfections, and drug-induced organ toxicity (11). We address the issue of infection prophylaxis from the standpoint that bacterial adherence and colonization of Hickman catheters are prerequisite to S. epidermidis septi- cemia. Our model is based upon disodium EDTA, a chemical well known for its chelating properties in vivo and which has been used as an anticoagulant in vitro. EDTA has also been used as a topical antiseptic in gram-negative infections and more recently, in combination with other agents, for gram- positive infections (6). In this report, we investigate the antibacterial action of disodium EDTA against a catheter- * Corresponding author. associated S. epidermidis isolate, comparing its efficacy with those of heparin alone and a vancomycin-heparin prepara- tion in vitro. MATERIALS AND METHODS Chemical agents. All agents were obtained commercially: vancomycin hydrochloride (Eli Lilly Industries, Inc., Indi- anapolis, Ind.); disodium EDTA (Fischer Scientific Co., New Lawn, N.J.); heparin sodium injection, B.P., bacteri- cide free (Weddel Pharmaceuticals, Ltd., Wrexham, United Kingdom); heparin sodium injection, USP, preservative free (Squibb-Marsam, Inc., Cherry Hill, N.J.). A concentration of 6.7 jig/ml was selected for all in vitro testing of vancomycin for two reasons. One, the desired trough level of vancomycin in serum for effective antibacte- rial action is 5 to 10 ;ig/ml (15). Two, this concentration is 1.5 times the MBC for the strain utilized, to ensure complete bactericidal activity. A concentration of 20 mg/ml was selected for the in vitro testing of disodium EDTA because in preliminary experi- ments, this concentration was effective in preventing the growth of three noncatheter-related coagulase-negative staphylococcal blood isolates, one of which was methicillin resistant. In addition, this concentration was considered to be adequate for anticoagulating a Hickman catheter since standard phlebotomy Vacutainers (Becton Dickinson & Co., Lincoln Park, N.J.) contain 1.5 mg of EDTA per ml of whole blood. Organism. S. epidermidis was isolated from the Hickman catheter of a septic bone marrow transplant recipient at the Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center, Hanover, N.H. The organism was identified to species by the New Hampshire Public Health Laboratory in Concord. Antibiotic suscepti- bility was determined by standard clinical microdilution test panels (MicroScan). 1627 ANTIMICROBIAL AGENTS AND CHEMOTHERAPY, Nov. 1988, p. 1627-1631 0066-4804/88/111627-05$02.00/0 Copyright © 1988, American Society for Microbiology on April 17, 2018 by guest http://aac.asm.org/ Downloaded from

Upload: hoangtuyen

Post on 31-Jan-2018

221 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Inhibitory Effect of Disodium EDTA upon Growthof ...aac.asm.org/content/32/11/1627.full.pdf · Inhibitory Effect ofDisodiumEDTAuponthe Growthof Staphylococcus epidermidis In Vitro:

Vol. 32, No. 11

Inhibitory Effect of Disodium EDTA upon the Growth ofStaphylococcus epidermidis In Vitro: Relation to Infection

Prophylaxis of Hickman CathetersJENNIFER L. ROOT,' 0. ROSS McINTYRE,l 2* NICHOLAS J. JACOBS,3 AND CHARLES P. DAGHLIAN4

Department of Medicine' and Department of Microbiology,3 Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center, andJulius A. Rippel Electron Microscope Facility,4 Dartmouth College, and The Norris Cotton Cancer Center,2

Hanover, New Hampshire 03756

Received 17 August 1987/Accepted 23 August 1988

Granulocytopenic patients with an intravascular catheter are at increased risk for infection with Staphylo-coccus epidermidis. During the intervals when the catheters are not being used for infusions, it is customary tomaintain patency of the catheter lumen with a solution containing heparin. We show that heparin does notinhibit the growth of S. epiderinidis isolated from the catheter of an infected patient. A 20-mg/ml solution ofdisodium EDTA, a chelating agent which effectively anticoagulates blood at this concentration, was shown tobe bactericidal for an initial inoculum of 103 CFU of staphylococci per ml in 24 h. Vancomycin, an antibioticwhich is often employed to treat Staphylococcus infections, was also bactericidal for initial inocula of 103 CFU/ml at doses of 6.7 ,ug/ml, a drug concentration in the therapeutic range. When 103 staphylococci per ml werecultured in the presence of catheter segments and disodium EDTA or vancomycin, subcultures of the cathetersshowed minimal or no growth, respectively. In contrast, when cultured with heparin alone, subcultures showedabundant growth. In view of its low cost, effectiveness as an anticoagulant, and bactericidal activity, EDTAshould be studied as a replacement for heparin solutions for the maintenance of intravenous catheters ingranulocytopenic patients.

Hickman and Broviac catheters offer long-term venousaccess for the treatment of patients who are seriously ill (2,7). They are typically maintained by twice-daily injections ofa heparin flushing solution. Reports of complications asso-ciated with the use of these catheters focus on thrombosisand infection (9, 10, 16). Among the latter, Staphylococcusepidermidis has emerged as the most significant opportunis-tic pathogen, especially in patients who are granulocytope-nic (1, 19). Christensen et al. have shown that microbialcolonization of Hickman lines is dependent upon the pro-duction of a slime coat by the bacteria (3). Recent studiessuggest that this glycocalyx contributes to S. epidermidisvirulence by protecting the organism from the bactericidaleffects of empiric antibiotic therapy (4, 5).Numerous approaches to infection prophylaxis have

yielded inconclusive results. Pizzo and Schimpff report thattotal protected isolation of granulocytopenic patients re-duces but does not eliminate completely the incidence ofcatheter-related sepsis (11). Similarly, the efficacy of sys-temic antimicrobial prophylaxis or selective suppression ofalimentary flora is counterbalanced by the emergence ofresistant bacteria, fungal superinfections, and drug-inducedorgan toxicity (11).We address the issue of infection prophylaxis from the

standpoint that bacterial adherence and colonization ofHickman catheters are prerequisite to S. epidermidis septi-cemia. Our model is based upon disodium EDTA, a chemicalwell known for its chelating properties in vivo and which hasbeen used as an anticoagulant in vitro. EDTA has also beenused as a topical antiseptic in gram-negative infections andmore recently, in combination with other agents, for gram-positive infections (6). In this report, we investigate theantibacterial action of disodium EDTA against a catheter-

* Corresponding author.

associated S. epidermidis isolate, comparing its efficacy withthose of heparin alone and a vancomycin-heparin prepara-tion in vitro.

MATERIALS AND METHODSChemical agents. All agents were obtained commercially:

vancomycin hydrochloride (Eli Lilly Industries, Inc., Indi-anapolis, Ind.); disodium EDTA (Fischer Scientific Co.,New Lawn, N.J.); heparin sodium injection, B.P., bacteri-cide free (Weddel Pharmaceuticals, Ltd., Wrexham, UnitedKingdom); heparin sodium injection, USP, preservative free(Squibb-Marsam, Inc., Cherry Hill, N.J.).A concentration of 6.7 jig/ml was selected for all in vitro

testing of vancomycin for two reasons. One, the desiredtrough level of vancomycin in serum for effective antibacte-rial action is 5 to 10 ;ig/ml (15). Two, this concentration is 1.5times the MBC for the strain utilized, to ensure completebactericidal activity.A concentration of 20 mg/ml was selected for the in vitro

testing of disodium EDTA because in preliminary experi-ments, this concentration was effective in preventing thegrowth of three noncatheter-related coagulase-negativestaphylococcal blood isolates, one of which was methicillinresistant. In addition, this concentration was considered tobe adequate for anticoagulating a Hickman catheter sincestandard phlebotomy Vacutainers (Becton Dickinson & Co.,Lincoln Park, N.J.) contain 1.5 mg ofEDTA per ml of wholeblood.

Organism. S. epidermidis was isolated from the Hickmancatheter of a septic bone marrow transplant recipient at theDartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center, Hanover, N.H. Theorganism was identified to species by the New HampshirePublic Health Laboratory in Concord. Antibiotic suscepti-bility was determined by standard clinical microdilution testpanels (MicroScan).

1627

ANTIMICROBIAL AGENTS AND CHEMOTHERAPY, Nov. 1988, p. 1627-16310066-4804/88/111627-05$02.00/0Copyright © 1988, American Society for Microbiology

on April 17, 2018 by guest

http://aac.asm.org/

Dow

nloaded from

Page 2: Inhibitory Effect of Disodium EDTA upon Growthof ...aac.asm.org/content/32/11/1627.full.pdf · Inhibitory Effect ofDisodiumEDTAuponthe Growthof Staphylococcus epidermidis In Vitro:

ANTIMICROB. AGENTS CHEMOTHER.

A technique described by Christensen et al. was used todetermine slime production (3). Briefly, a colony of organ-isms from a blood agar plate was inoculated into 5 ml ofTrypticase soy broth (TSB) and incubated at 37°C for 48 h.The vial contents were poured off, and the tubes werestained with 6 ml of 3%t safranine. A positive slime test wasestablished by demonstration of a safranine-stained filmalong the tube walls. A negative test was indicated byformation of a ring of film only at the liquid-air interface orno staining at all.SEM. For scanning electron microscopy (SEM), the pa-

tient's catheter was bisected and fixed in 4% glutaraldehydein sodium cacodylate buffer (742 mosM; pH 7.3) for 24 h. Itwas postfixed in 2% osmium tetroxide, dehydrated in etha-nol, air dried, coated with gold palladium (150 A; 15 nm), andexamined in an AMR 1000 scanning electron microscope at20 kV.To study the effect of EDTA upon bacterial cell morphol-

ogy, an inoculum of 103 CFU of S. epidermidis in TSB waspipetted into sterile polystyrene test tubes containing diso-dium EDTA at a final concentration of 20 mg/ml. The tubeswere placed in a 37°C incubator. At 0, 10, and 24 h, the vialcontents were transferred to sterile Eppendorf tubes andpelleted by centrifugation at 12,800 x g for 20 min (Brink-mann Eppendorf Centrifuge 5412). The supernatant wasdiscarded, and the bacteria were suspended in 100 ,ll of 4%glutaraldehyde in 1,4-piperazinediethanesulfonic acid buffer(0.1 M; pH 7.3). The samples were rinsed in sodium cacody-late buffer (0.1 M; pH 7.4) and vacuum filtered on 13-mm,0.45-p,m-pore-size membrane filters (Millipore) with addi-tional buffer. The moist samples were then postfixed on thefilters with 1% osmium tetroxide in sodium cacodylatebuffer. The samples underwent serial ethanol dehydration(75 to 95%), followed by immersion in trichorotrifloroethane(Freon 113) and rapid air drying. The bacteria were mountedon stubs, coated with gold palladium (15 nm), and examinedin an AMR 10000 scanning electron microscope at 20 kV.

In vitro susceptibility and time-kill curve studies. A 24-hculture of S. epidermidis in TSB was serially diluted toapproximately 103 CFU/ml. One milliliter of each bacteria-broth mixture was inoculated into sterile polystyrene testtubes previously ifiled with vancomycin hydrochloride andheparin sodium injection (B.P.), ultimately bringing thelatter two concentrations to 6.7 p.g/ml and 10 U/ml, respec-tively. Tubes were incubated at 37°C. At 0, 12, and 24 h, theculture tubes were analyzed for viable organisms afterresidual antibacterial agents were washed away by thefollowing procedures. The tube contents were vortexed, andthe solutions were transferred by sterile pipette to Corexcentrifuge tubes. The bacteria were pelleted by centrifuga-tion at 10,000 x g for 25 min (Sorvall SS-34 RC2-B Auto-matic Refrigerated Centrifuge). The supernatant was dis-carded, and 3 ml of TSB was added to each vial. The tubeswere again centrifuged at 10,000 x g for 25 min. Thiswashing procedure was carried out twice before the bacteriawere suspended in sterile TSB at their original volumes.Then, three replicate samples of 0.1 ml of the test solutionswere transferred by sterile pipette to three blood agar plates(Scott Laboratories, Inc., Fiskeville, R.I.) and spread with awire loop. Colony counts and culture turbidity changes weredetermined by visual inspection. This experiment was re-peated three times and the data were pooled.The same protocol as described above was used to test

disodium EDTA. One milliliter of TSB containing 103 CFU/ml was added to filter-purified disodium EDTA at a finalconcentration of 20 mg/ml. Incubation at 37°C for 24 h was

interrupted at identical times as listed above for TSB washesand blood agar plating. This experiment was repeated threetimes and the data were pooled.

Quantitative recovery of bacteria using the above centrif-ugation and wash procedure was studied in control experi-ments not employing antibacterial agents.

Assays of affinity for catheters. (i) Experiment 1. An over-night culture of S. epidermidis in TSB was serially diluted to103 CFU/ml. Into sterile polystyrene test tubes were placed1 ml of microorganisms and the following chemical agents atthe respective final concentrations given: disodium EDTA,20 mg/ml; vancomycin, 6.7 ,ug/ml; heparin, 10 U/ml; vanco-mycin-heparin solution, 6.7 ,ug/ml-10 U/ml. One 1-cm seg-ment from a sterile triple lumen right atrial catheter (QuintonInstrument Co., Seattle, Wash.) was immersed in eachbacteria-antiseptic solution. The test vials were vortexed,and uniform intralumenal contact with the fluid was ensuredby pipette suctioning of the catheter segment. After incuba-tion (37°C; 24 h), the following procedure was used todetermine the quantity of viable bacteria adherent to thecatheter segment. The catheter piece was removed from thetest solution and immersed in 3 ml of sterile TSB. Thebacteria were removed from the catheter surfaces by vor-texing, extralumenal scraping with a wire loop, and intralu-menal scraping with an inoculating needle. The cathetersegments were discarded, and the test solutions were cen-trifuged at 10,000 x g for 25 min to separate any viablebacteria from tracps of antibacterial agents which mightinterfere with subsequent growth. After removal of thesupernatant, 3 ml of TSB was introduced and the vialsunderwent a second centrifugation. This wash procedurewas repeated twice, and the bacteria were suspended in 0.5ml of TSB. By sterile pipette, three replicates of 0.1 ml ofeach test culture were transferred to three blood agar platesand spread with a wire loop. The colonies were counted, andthe data were expressed as CFU per milliliter of TSB inwhich the bacteria were suspended. This experiment wasrepeated three times.

(ui) Experinent 2. A second experiment was conducted totest the effect of various concentrations of EDTA on theadherence of viable staphylococci to catheter segments.Serial dilutions of an overnight culture of S. epidermidiswere carried out to a final concentration of 103 CFU/ml inTSB. Samples (1 ml) of this broth were then transferred bysterile pipette to polystyrene test tubes containing variousdilutions of disodium EDTA. The final concentrations ofEDTA were 0.1, 5, 10, and 20 mg/ml. Into each vial was alsoplaced one 1-cm segment of the triple lumen right atrialcatheter. The tubes were vortexed, and the catheter tipswere pipetted. After 24 h of incubation at 37°C, the samemethods of TSB washings and agar plating as describedabove in Experiment 2 were performed. In addition, tworeplicates of 0.1 ml of the culture solutions in which thecatheters had been incubated for 24 h were transferred bysterile pipette to two agar plates and spread with a wire loop.Colony counts of the media were compared with those foundupon scraping of the catheter surfaces.

This experiment was repeated using an initial bacterialinoculum of 105 CFU/ml and disodium EDTA at final con-centrations of 10, 20, 30, and 50 mg/ml.

Coagulation assay. The partial thromboplastin and pro-thrombin times of heparin-vancomycin mixed (10 U/ml-6.7p.g/ml) and heparin alone were determined by routine clinicallaboratory methods. An Electra 700 Automatic CoagulationTimer was employed.

1628 ROOT ET AL.

on April 17, 2018 by guest

http://aac.asm.org/

Dow

nloaded from

Page 3: Inhibitory Effect of Disodium EDTA upon Growthof ...aac.asm.org/content/32/11/1627.full.pdf · Inhibitory Effect ofDisodiumEDTAuponthe Growthof Staphylococcus epidermidis In Vitro:

DISODIUM EDTA KILLING OF S. EPIDERMIDIS 1629

FIG. 1. S. epidermidis colonization of catheter removed from patient. (A) Lumen surface with abundant slime coat and debris;magnification, x 1,920; bar, 10 ,um. (B) Enlargement of a small cluster of S. epidermidis seen in slime coat; magnification x7,800; bar, 5 ,um.

RESULTS

Characteristics of the organism. For this strain of S.epidermidis, the MICs of five antimicrobial agents were as

follows: oxacillin, 1 ,ug/ml; vancomycin, <2 ,ug/ml; tetracy-cline, <1 ,ug/ml; amikacin, 4 p,g/ml; nitrofurantoin, l16 ,ug/ml. The MBC of vancomycin was determined to be 4.0 ,ug/ml. The organism was resistant to erythromycin, ampicillin,penicillin, gentamicin, clindamycin, and chloramphenicol.The slime coat test was positive.SEM. Bacterial colonization of both the lumenal and

external surfaces of our patient's catheter was verified bySEM (Fig. 1).The effect of EDTA on S. epidermidis morphology after

incubation for 10 and 24 h was also studied. SEM revealedno distinct morphologic changes in cell surfaces. No cellularballooning, distinct breaks in cell wall integrity, or scatteredcellular debris were observed. The bacteria were indistin-guishable from those in Fig. 1.

Time-kill studies. The killing curve of vancomycin-heparin

Incubation Time (hr)

FIG. 2. Bactericidal effect of disodium EDTA and vancomycin-heparin against a strain of S. epidermidis. Data represent mean ofthree experiments with three replicate samples analyzed for eachtime interval. Symbols: *, EDTA at 20 mg/ml (range at 24 h, 0 to 1.9log1o CFU/ml); 0, vancomycin (6.7 ,ug/ml) plus heparin (10 U/ml)(range at 24 h, 0 to 1.0 log1o CFU/ml).

against 103 CFU/ml is shown in Fig. 2. Vancomycin reducedan initial bacterial concentration of 3.0 log1o CFU/ml to 0.3log1o CFU/ml in 24 h, with a range of 0 to 1.0 log1o CFU/ml.No vial content turbidity or slime coat production wasevident.Disodium EDTA exhibited a similar but lower rate of

bactericidal activity for 103 CFU of S. epidermidis per ml(Fig. 2). An initial inoculum of 3.0 log1o CFU/ml was reducedto a mean of 1.4 log1o CFU/ml after 24 h of incubation, witha wide range of 0 colonies to 1.9 log1o CFU/ml surviving. Noculture turbidity or slime coat production was detected inany of the cultures.

Separate studies confirmed that the centrifugation tech-nique used for washing away residual antibacterial agentswas sufficient to pellet the S. epidermidis and minimizebacterial loss in the supernatant. Using the protocol de-scribed in Materials and Methods, an initial inoculum of 2.90log1o CFU/ml was determined to be 2.92 log1o CFU/ml aftermultiple washes and centrifugations in TSB alone. Thus,there is no possibility that the results shown in Fig. 2 werecaused by a residual carryover of inhibitory agents to theagar plates used to determine viable cell counts.

Influence of catheter presence. The antimicrobial effect ofdisodium EDTA against 3.0 log1o CFU/ml was not altered bythe presence of catheter segments in vitro (Table 1). After 24

TABLE 1. Effects of EDTA, heparin, vancomycin, andvancomycin-heparin on adherence and growth of 103 CFU ofS. epidermidis along catheter surfaces after 24 h of incubation

Mean (range) of

Agent (concn) viable bacteriaAgent(concn) ~~~(logl0 CFU/ml)after 24 ha

Disodium EDTA (20 mg/ml)............................... 1.0 (0-1.6)Heparin (10 U/ml) ............................... >8.0Vancomycin (6.7 ,ug/ml) ................................ 0Vancomycin (6.7 ,ug/ml)-heparin (10 U/ml) ............. 0

a Pooled data from three experiments.

VOL. 32, 1988

on April 17, 2018 by guest

http://aac.asm.org/

Dow

nloaded from

Page 4: Inhibitory Effect of Disodium EDTA upon Growthof ...aac.asm.org/content/32/11/1627.full.pdf · Inhibitory Effect ofDisodiumEDTAuponthe Growthof Staphylococcus epidermidis In Vitro:

ANTIMICROB. AGENTS CHEMOTHER.

TABLE 2. Dose-response relationship between 103 CFU ofS. epidermidis per ml and various concentrations of

disodium EDTA'

Mean (range) of viable bacteriaEDTA concn (loglo CFU/mi) after 24 h in:

(mg/ml)Catheter Medium

20 0 0.7 (0-1.0)10 1.4 (1.3-1.5) 1.5 (1.3-1.7)5 1.4 (1.3-1.6) 1.5 (1.3-1.6)0.1 >8.0 >8.0

a Bacterial counts isolated from the catheter surfaces are compared withthose found in the culture medium after 24 h of incubation.

h of incubation, 1.0 log1o CFU/ml remained. It could not bedefinitively ascertained whether this concentration of surviv-ing bacteria represented adherent colonies upon the cathetersurface or free-floating bacteria which were picked up withsmall droplets of culture mhedia when the catheter tip wasinitially transferred to 3 ml of sterile TSB. SEM of thelumnenal and external surfaces of a second catheter segmentincubated for 24 h in the presence of 103 CFU/ml and EDTAat a final concentration of 20 mg/ml failed to reveal anyadherent bacteria.

Catheters cultured in vancomycin and the vancomycin-heparin solution showed no growth after 24 h of incubation.In sharp contrast, catheter segments which were incubatedwith heparin alone had >8 log1o CFU/ml at 24 h. These lattertest solutions were also the only ones which became turbidwith incubation. This experiment was repeated three times.

Dose-response study. The dose-response relationship be-tween various concentrations of S. epidermidis and diso-dium EDTA incubated in the presence of catheter segmentsis shown in Tables 2 and 3. In this experiment, 20 mg ofEDTA per ml maintained the sterility of the catheter seg-ment against an initial inoculum of 103 CFU/ml but did notkill all the bacteria in the surrounding culture medium, whichcontained 0.7 log1o CFU/ml at 24 h. As the concentration ofEDTA was decreased from 20 mg/ml, the number of surviv-ing bacteria rose both in the culture medium and along thecatheter surfaces. However, even at 5 mg/ml, EDTA wasable to induce a 1.5-log reduction in the initial inoculum of3.0 log1o CFU/ml. EDTA had no detectable antibacterialeffect at 0.1 mg/ml.EDTA was unable to maintain the catheter's sterility when

faced with a 105-CFU/ml challenge. At very high concentra-tions, EDTA effected approximately a 3-log reduction in thenumber of viable bacteria. However, 1.5 log1o CFU/mlcontinued to thrive on the catheter surfaces after 24 h ofincubation with 50 mg of EDTA per ml.

TABLE 3. Dose-response relationship between 10' CFU ofS. epidermidis per ml and various concentrations of

disodium EDTAI

Mean (range) of viable bacteriaEDTA concn (log1o CFU/mi) after 24 h in:

(mg/ml)Catheter Medium

50 1.5 1.8 (1.5-2.0)30 1.1 (1.0-1.3) 1.9 (1.7-2.0)20 1.8 (1.6-1.9) 2.310 2.3 (2.0-2.5) 2.5 (2.4-2.5)

a Bacterial counts isolated from the catheter surfaces are compared withthose found in the culture medium after 24 h of incubation.

Coagulation asay. The anticoagulant action of heparinwas not changed significantly by the presence of vancomy-cin. The partial thromboplastin/prothrombin times for hepa-rin alone and heparin plus vancomycin were 13.8 s/>120 sand 12.9 s/>120 s, respectively.

DISCUSSIONThese studies show that disodium EDTA, in a concentra-

tion sufficient to serve as an effective anticoagulant, preventsthe growth of S. epidermidis and causes at least a 1.5-logreduction in viable organisms even in the presence of cath-eter segments. Heparin showed no similar bactericidal orbacteriostatic action.The clinical significance of these findings rests upon

elucidation of the mechanism of bacterial colonization ofcentral venous catheters. If infectious complications aresecondary to intralumenal colonization, as proposed in arecent study by Tenney et al. (18), EDTA as both ananticoagulant and antiseptic agent would have far-reachingimpact. However, if extralumenal colonization along theintercutaneous catheter tract is the primary route, the role ofEDTA would be of less importance and systemic antibiotictherapy would be necessary.The mechanism of Staphylococcus killing by EDTA also

awaits further exploration. The chelator forms extremelyfirm soluble complexes with divalent and trivalent metals(13), and it is most likely that in our experiments theconcentration of one or more metal ions necessary forbacterial growth was reduced to below a critical level. Overthe past 20 years, microbiologists have been studying theantibacterial action of disodium EDTA against gram-nega-tive organisms. They have determined that in some gram-negative organisms, specifically Pseudomonas aeruginosaand Salmonella typhimurium, EDTA appears to attack thecell wall membrane by chelating cations, especially Mg2",and thereby disrupting cellular integrity (8, 14). In otherbacteria, most notably Escherichia coli, the mechanism ofEDTA action is at a nuclear level and has been suggested toinvolve RNA transcription and synthesis (12). The SEMstudy described in this paper failed to reveal any morpho-logic evidence of enhanced cell wall fragility in the S.epidermidis under EDTA effect. This suggests that themechanism of EDTA against gram-positive bacteria may beintracellular in origin, although definitive proof awaits fur-ther investigation.When administered by rapid intravenous injection, diso-

dium EDTA causes a prompt decline in the ionized calciumconcentration in serum, and tetany results. Slow intravenousinjection, however, is unassociated with significant hypocal-cemia. For instance, Spencer (17) has studied serum andurinary calcium levels in four normocalcemic human sub-jects for 24 h following the intravenous administration of 4 gof disodium EDTA over a 4-h period. Slight and temporaryreductions of serum calcium were noted, and urinary cal-cium excretion increased from 4- to 20-fold. The calciumexcretion induced by the drug is offset by liberation ofcalcium from the large bone storage pool. Usual care for thecatheter includes twice-daily flushes with 2.5 ml of heparinsolution. If this volume were replaced with 20 mg of EDTAper ml, the daily dose of EDTA would amount to 100 mg.Thus, the amount of disodium EDTA which might reason-ably be required to anticoagulate blood for 24 h in standardintravenous catheters is 1/40 of that given acutely in the 4-hinfusions performed by Spencer. On these grounds it ispossible that EDTA could prove to be a safe, inexpensive,and effective means of catheter maintenance.

1630 ROOT ET AL.

on April 17, 2018 by guest

http://aac.asm.org/

Dow

nloaded from

Page 5: Inhibitory Effect of Disodium EDTA upon Growthof ...aac.asm.org/content/32/11/1627.full.pdf · Inhibitory Effect ofDisodiumEDTAuponthe Growthof Staphylococcus epidermidis In Vitro:

DISODIUM EDTA KILLING OF S. EPIDERMIDIS 1631

ACKNOWLEDGMENTSThis work was supported by Public Health Service Cancer

Education Program Grant CA19379-11 and by Public Health Servicecore grant CA23108-09 at the Norris Cotton Cancer Center.We thank Brenda Berube and Mona Dutile for their assistance in

the preparation of the manuscript.

LITERATURE CITED1. Blacklock, H. S., M. V. Pillai, R. S. Hill, J. F. Matthews, A. G.

Clarke, and J. F. Wade. 1980. Use of modified subcutaneousright-atrial catheter for venous access in leukemic patients.Lancet i:993-994.

2. Broviac, J. W., J. J. Cole, and B. H. Scribner. 1973. A siliconerubber atrial catheter for prolonged parenteral nutrition. Surg.Gynecol. Obstet. 136:602-606.

3. Christensen, G. D., J. T. Parisi, A. L. Bisno, W. A. Simpson, andE. H. Beachey. 1983. Characterization of clinically significantstrains of coagulase-negative staphylococci. J. Clin. Microbiol.18:258-269.

4. Costerton, J. W., K. J. Cheng, G. G. Geesey, T. I. Ladd, J. C.Nickel, M. Dasgupta, and T. J. Marrie. 1987. Bacterial biofilmsin nature and disease. Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 41:435-464.

5. Davenport, D. S., R. M. Massanari, M. A. Pfafler, J. J. Bale,S. A. Streed, and W. J. Hierholzer, Jr. 1986. Usefulness of a testfor slime production as a marker for clinically significant infec-tions with coagulase-negative staphylococci. J. Infect. Dis. 153:332-339.

6. Harper, W. E., and J. A. Epis. 1987. Effect of chlorhexidine/EDTA/Tris against bacterial isolates from clinical specimens.Microbios 51:107-112.

7. Hickman, R. O., C. D. Buckner, R. A. Clift, J. E. Sanders, P.Stewart, and E. D. Thomas. 1979. A modified right atrial cath-eter for access to the venous system in marrow transplantrecipients. Surg. Gynecol. Obstet. 148:871-875.

8. Hukari, R., I. M. Helander, and M. Vaara. 1986. Chain lengthheterogeneity of lipopolysaccharide released from Salmonellatyphimurium by ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid or polycations.

Eur. J. Biochem. 154:673-676.9. Jacobs, M. B., and M. Yeager. 1984. Thrombotic and infectious

complications of Hickman-Broviac catheters. Arch. Intern.Med. 144:1597-1599.

10. Peters, G., R. Locci, and G. Pulverer. 1982. Adherence andgrowth of coagulase-negative staphylococci on surfaces of in-travenous catheters. J. Infect. Dis. 146:479-482.

11. Pizzo, P. A., and S. C. Schimpff. 1983. Strategies for theprevention of infection in the myelosuppressed or immunosup-pressed cancer patient. Cancer Treat. Rep. 67:223-234.

12. Prasad, K. S., and S. N. Chitnis. 1986. Transcription but nottranslation is required for EDTA-induced autolysis in Esche-richia coli. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 134:338-343.

13. Russell, A. D. 1971. Ethylenediaminetetra-acetic acid, p. 209-224. In W. B. Hugo (ed.), Inhibition and destruction of themicrobial cell. Academic Press, Inc., San Diego, Calif.

14. Said, A. A., D. M. Livermore, and R. J. Williams. 1987.Expression of Hi outer-membrane protein of Pseudomonasaeruginosa in relation to sensitivity to EDTA and polymyxin B.J. Med. Microbiol. 24:267-274.

15. Sanford, J. 1988. 1988 guide to antimicrobial therapy. Antimi-crobial Therapy, Inc., San Antonio, Texas.

16. Schuman, E. S., V. Winters, G. F. Gross, and J. F. Hayes. 1985.Management of Hickman catheter sepsis. Am. J. Surg. 149:627-628.

17. Spencer, H. 1960. Studies of the effect of chelating agents inman. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 88:435-449.

18. Tenney, J. H., M. R. Moody, K. A. Newman, S. C. Schimpff,J. C. Wade, J. W. Costerton, and W. P. Reed. 1986. Adherentmicroorganisms on lumenal surfaces of long-term intravenouscatheters. Importance of Staphylococcus epidermidis in pa-tients with cancer. Arch. Intern. Med. 146:1949-1954.

19. Wade, J. C., S. C. Schimpff, K. A. Newman, and P. H. Wiernik.1982. Staphylococcus epidermidis: an increasing cause of infec-tion in patients with granulocytopenia. Ann. Intern. Med. 97:503-508.

VOL. 32, 1988

on April 17, 2018 by guest

http://aac.asm.org/

Dow

nloaded from