innovator vol. 39, fall 2008. literacies in the 21st century
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/14/2019 Innovator vol. 39, Fall 2008. Literacies in the 21st century
1/19
INNOVATORFALL 2008
LITERACIES
IN THE 21ST
CENTURY
-
8/14/2019 Innovator vol. 39, Fall 2008. Literacies in the 21st century
2/19
On the cover: An Ann Arbor third-grader records predicted
locations o animal habitats on a map o her schoolyard
by traditional methods: crayon and paper. Is a switch to
higher-tech methods such as GPS tracking in her uture?
Photo by Mike Gould
Deans note 1
Literacies
in the 21st century 2
Learning sciences creating FLow 6
experiences with games -
Barry Fishman
common myths aBout
21st-century Literacies 8
higher eDucation anD new
technoLogies - eric Dey 10
scaFFoLDing minDFuLness -
chris Quintana 12
preparing
tech-savvy teachers 14
aLumni
DaviD BranDon
(aBeD 74, certt 74) 16
aLumni
gwenDoLyn caLvert Baker
(Ba 64, ma 67, pD 72) 18
snapshots 20
awarDs
cLass notes 26
DeveLopment report 28
in thiS iSSue
2
6
16
20
-
8/14/2019 Innovator vol. 39, Fall 2008. Literacies in the 21st century
3/19
U N I V E R S I T Y O F M I C H I G A N S C H O O L O F E D U C A T I O N 1
When I began teaching elementary school more than 30
years ago, our working denition o literacy was simple.
I children could read and write basic texts, then we
considered them literate. oday things are dierent. In
order to be successul, students must command many
dierent aspects o literacy. Tey must do more than read
in the traditional sense, they must also be able to interpret
a vast array o text, images, and graphics.
odays young people are bombarded with inormation
everywhere they turn: books, graphic novels, websites,
television, blogs, newspapers, CD liner notes, text
messages, magazines, email, and instant messages. Te
list goes on and on. How do we prepare these children
to navigate this overwhelming quantity o inormation
and both ocus and interpret careully? How do children
manage the avalanche o words and data they encounter in
and out o school? How do they decide what is legitimate
and useul inormation?
Faculty and students at the University o Michigan School
o Education are exploring questions like these in eorts
to improve teaching and learning o literacy or the
twenty-rst century. We have an ongoing commitment to
understanding and ostering literacy, broadly dened, or
DeanS note
individuals o dierent backgrounds and capabilities. Our
research and teaching ocuses on students rom preschool
through college. It takes place both in and out o school and
it is motivated by a range o theoretical, methodological, and
practical perspectives. What ocuses our collective work is
the commitment to understandingand improvinghow
young people interpret and communicate meaning.
In addition, we are preparing tomorrows teachers with
the orientations and skills to be able to respond to and
deploy the ever-changing tools that may well become
requirements or modern education and which will enable
the creation o new educational methods. Our curriculum
evolves, as does the schools physical space. We are creating
an inrastructure or projects and curriculum that utilize
digital texts, graphics, video, animations, computer games,
and other high-tech tools to represent, study, and research
learning and instruction, as well as to engage in specially-
enabled orms o learning and teaching literacies.
Tis issue o Innovator, with its theme Literacies in the
wenty-First Century, explores what literacy means in a
quickly evolving, technology-reliant world, how meaning
is made and conveyed, and what teachers and students
need to thrive in this ever-changing landscape.
Deborah Loewenberg baLL
-
8/14/2019 Innovator vol. 39, Fall 2008. Literacies in the 21st century
4/19
-
8/14/2019 Innovator vol. 39, Fall 2008. Literacies in the 21st century
5/19
-
8/14/2019 Innovator vol. 39, Fall 2008. Literacies in the 21st century
6/19
w w w. S O E . U M I C H . E D U F A L L 2 0 0 8 U N I V E R S I T Y O F M I C H I G A N S C H O O L O F E D U C A T
messages, inomercials, and pseudo-acts. It is important
or young people (and their elders) to ask a series o hard
questions as they read or view:
Who created this message?
What creative techniques are used to attract
my attention?
How might dierent people understand this
message dierently?
What values, liestyles, and points o view are
represented in, or omitted rom, this message?
Why is this message being s ent?
(Center or Media Literacy, 2002/2008)
L Ss c Fl
exps gs - b Fs
Barry Fishman has words o warning or anyone considering
his upcoming undergraduate course on video games and
learning.
Students looking or a gut course might want to check out the
syllabus in advance, he says, because learning about games
isnt all un and games.
An associate proessor in the School o Education and School o
Inormation, Fishman taught a similar class at Harvard last year
when he was a visiting proessor there. People who take this
course either have an enthusiasm or video games and want to
legitimize that enthusiasm, he says, or have an enthusiasm
or learning, know that games are really popular, and want to
gure out how they can use that to help kids learn. Either way,
students learn about learning, motivation, teaching, and even a
bit about school reorm.
Learning sciences, Fishmans specialty, is a relatively new eld.
It draws rom education, cognitive science, computer science,
psychology, neuroscience, and anthropology to study learning
in real-world settings and, he says, bring together the best o
what we understand about learning and apply it to the design
and study o more eective learning environments.
One thing we understand clearly is that much learning occurs
through play in various orms, which makes studying video
games worthwhile. Its not about using games in school, or
turning ormal school learning into a video game. Its about
identiying eatures in good games that can be adopted
by educators.
Highlight
What isnt new? One o the challenges I think we need
to grapple with is dening what this new literacy is, what
makes it new, says Moje. Is it really new or do we just
think its new because the tool or communicating is
new? We have this notion that literacy is a linear process;
thats part o what makes old literacies old. Te question
about whats new is less about whether its more possible
to jump around and take a non-linear pathpeople can
skip around in books, toobut that its more accepted, and
even prompted, in and by these digital contexts. Tats the
dierence. What is new and dierent are our approaches
to texts, to inormation, and to interaction around texts
and inormation.
Te delivery systems notwithstanding, literacy is still
what society expects literate individuals to do, argue
researchers Donald Leu, Charles Kinzer, Julie Coiro, and
Dana Cammack in a chapter entitled oward a Teory
o New Literacies Emerging rom the Internet and Other
Inormation and Communication echnologies in
T eoretical Models and Processes o Reading (2004). But
power, identities, and agency crucially shape which literate
behaviors count. Individuals will need to be lighter on
their eet because social expectations can change as swily
and prooundly as the systems, but people cant dance
without a foor beneath them.
building on foundationS
Mojes comments suggest that learning how to lear
taking on even greater signicance. Leu, Kinzer, C
and Cammack also wrote new literacies almost a
build on oundational literacies rather than replace t
In act, it could be argued that they will become
more essential because reading and writing become
important in an inormation age. And, according t
National Council o eachers o English policy
Studies o workorce readiness show that employer
written and oral communication skills very highly
collaboration, work ethic, critical thinking , and leade
all rank higher than prociency in i normation techno
Continued on page 9
Were trying to understand how games, when theyre
successul, create true fow experiences, where learners are
optimally engaged in the task at hand, he says. When kids
play these games, theyre doing all the things we hope people
will do in a high-perormance learning environment. What i
school had those same qualities? Challenges that kids want to
engage with, challenges at just the right level or each learner,
and learning environments that teach you what you need to
know to succeed just when you need to know it? What can
we learn rom this to redesign the way school is put together,
so that kids come to school wanting to engage and nding it
to be a challenge that they choose to take on believing they
will succeed?
Im very interested on the whole in what makes learning
and reorm successul, he says. A huge part o what I do is
gure out how to design environments that use technology in
transormational ways, not just recreating what we already do.
A lot o people bring technology into schools and wonder why
scores dont improve. But i its just more o the same, theres
no reason to expect an improvement in outcomes.
-
8/14/2019 Innovator vol. 39, Fall 2008. Literacies in the 21st century
7/19
w w w. S O E . U M I C H . E D U F A L L 2 0 0 8 U N I V E R S I T Y O F M I C H I G A N S C H O O L O F E D U C A T
Te evidence that employing these tools in teaching strengthens the oundations required to take ull advantage o
is more than anecdotal. Gere and company tell us that research shows that digital technology enhances writin
interaction in several ways. K-12 students who write with computers produce compositions o greater length and h
quality and are more engaged with and motivated toward writing than their peers. College students who keep e-port
have a higher rate o academic achievement and a higher overall retention rate than their peers. Tey also demons
greater capacity or metacognition, refection, and audience awareness.
Te role o the teacher embodies both what changes and what doesnt. Te teacher still must be the classroom leade
acilitator and that now entails orchestrating complex contexts or literacy and learning, not just simple dispensing
Te good news is that the instructor need not be a geek to achieve this; in act, it can oster collaboration i the teacher
At the end o the day, modeling critical thinking and refection matter at least as much as technological expertise.
We try to emphasize that its okay to say to your students, I dont know, or Im not sure, Liz Keren-Kolb, doc
student in learning technologies, says o the course in classroom technology that she and Lecturer Je Stanzler teach
the next step is always to say, Lets nd out.
Tere are, to be sure, serpents in the garden.
Continued on page 11
1Myth
wenty-rst-century literacy is about technology only.
Reality
Although technology is important to literacy in the
new century, other dimensions o learning are essential.
Studies o workorce readiness show that employers
rate written and oral communication skills very highly,and collaboration, work ethic, critical thinking, and
leadership all rank higher than prociency in inormation
technology. Te Partnership or 21st-Century Skills
(www.21stcenturyskills.org) advocates or core academic
subjects, learning and innovation skills, and lie and
career skills, along with technology skills. Even a
standardized measure like the iSkills Inormation
and Communication echnology Literacy est gives
signicant attention to organization, evaluation,
critical thinking, and problem solving.
2Myth
Te digital divide is closed because schools provide
computer and Internet access.
Reality
Te digital dividethe gap in access to and quality otechnologystill exists. In 2005, nearly 100 p ercent o
public schools in the United States had access to the
Internet, but student-to-computer ratios and access to
broadband service vary widely across socio-economic
levels. Furthermore, available computers are oen not
used eectively or ully; the national average o students
school use o computers is 12 minutes per week.
3Myth
eachers who use technology in their personal lives will
use it in their classes.
Reality
Research shows that teachers who use word processing,
spreadsheets, presentation soware, and web browsers athome do not bring that knowledge into the classroom.
Furthermore, two-thirds o all teachers report eeling
under-prepared to use technology in teaching, even i
they use computers to plan lessons, access model lesson
plans, and create activities.
4Myth
eachers need to be experts in technology i n order to use
it eectively in instruction.
Reality
Research shows that eective teachers collaborate with
students to understand the inormation landscape
and think about its use. Since success with technology
depends largely upon critical thinking and refection,even teachers with relatively little technological skill
can provide useul instruction.
National Council of Teachers of English
Policy Research Brief
common mythSa 21s-c Ls
K-12 students who write with computers produce
compositions of greater length and higher quality and are
more engaged with and motivated toward writing than
their peers. Anne Ruggles Gere
Speed of access is a truly new component of new
literacies that puts an even higher premium on knowing
how to sort information, how to evaluate it, and how to
read it critically. Elizabeth Moje
-
8/14/2019 Innovator vol. 39, Fall 2008. Literacies in the 21st century
8/19
w w w. S O E . U M I C H . E D U F A L L 2 0 0 8 U N I V E R S I T Y O F M I C H I G A N S C H O O L O F E D U C A T
Its ironic, says Associate Proessor Eric Dey: A lot o theIts ironic, says Associate Proessor Eric Dey: A lot o the
technologies we think about deploying in educational settingstechnologies we think about deploying in educational settings
were invented in universities and at the same time college acultywere invented in universities and at the same time college aculty
re trying to gure out how to use them.re trying to gure out how to use them.
For all its shortcomings, the K-12 system has generally been anFor all its shortcomings, the K-12 system has generally been an
arlier adopter o those technologies than has higher education.arlier adopter o those technologies than has higher education.
Dey, whose research is concerned with the infuence thatDey, whose research is concerned with the infuence thatolleges and universities have on their students and aculty,olleges and universities have on their students and aculty,
points out an organizational reason or that:points out an organizational reason or that:
hh eed dd d nn ttlsls
-- ee D D
Highlight
For More Info
One thing thats very dierent in higher education is that thereOne thing thats very dierent in higher education is that there
isnt a traditional command-and-control structure, he says.isnt a traditional command-and-control structure, he says.
The organic experimentation o individual aculty membersThe organic experimentation o individual aculty members
drives this kind o innovation. In some cases this leads to adrives this kind o innovation. In some cases this leads to a
critical mass o adoption where suddenly everybodys doing it.critical mass o adoption where suddenly everybodys doing it.
That was the story with CTools, the University o Michigans web-That was the story with CTools, the University o Michigans web-
based environment or creating course and project websites. Itsbased environment or creating course and project websites. Itsgrowth has been almost viral.growth has been almost viral.
This was an initiative that hardly anyone used ve or six yearsThis was an initiative that hardly anyone used ve or six years
ago, says Dey, and literally almost everyone on campus usesago, says Dey, and literally almost everyone on campus uses
it now.it now.
Student resistance and the physical inrastructure o campusesStudent resistance and the physical inrastructure o campuses
have also militated against the incorporation o morehave also militated against the incorporation o more
technology, according to Dey. A lot o students want to usetechnology, according to Dey. A lot o students want to use
some technology, but they also want ace-to-ace contactsome technology, but they also want ace-to-ace contact
and traditional learning environments, in part because they areand traditional learning environments, in part because they are
amiliar with and successul in such settings, he says. So youamiliar with and successul in such settings, he says. So you
get some pushback.get some pushback.
Dey uses a quotation rom Winston Churchill, we shapeDey uses a quotation rom Winston Churchill, we shape
our buildings, and aterwards our buildings shape us, in theour buildings, and aterwards our buildings shape us, in the
syllabus or Ed 860, his course on how the use o technologysyllabus or Ed 860, his course on how the use o technology
aects stakeholders in the higher education enterprise.aects stakeholders in the higher education enterprise.
Especially in large universities or colleges that have a longEspecially in large universities or colleges that have a long
history, the hidden technology we have to deal with is thehistory, the hidden technology we have to deal with is the
classroom, he says. Lecture halls typically have xed seatingclassroom, he says. Lecture halls typically have xed seating
arrangements which encourage aculty lecturing, and i wearrangements which encourage aculty lecturing, and i we
dont have an available internet connection, were not going todont have an available internet connection, were not going to
be using computers, which also slows down aculty adoption.be using computers, which also slows down aculty adoption.
As or Deys own adoption rate, he used basically standardAs or Deys own adoption rate, he used basically standard
technology in Ed 860, principally CTools and sometechnology in Ed 860, principally CTools and some
videoconerencing. When I looked at my teaching evaluations,videoconerencing. When I looked at my teaching evaluations,
he says, I, ironically, got a ew dings or not doing morehe says, I, ironically, got a ew dings or not doing more
with technology.with technology.
Anne Ruggles geRes ReseARch
www-personal.umich.edu/~argere
BARRy FishmAns ReseARch
www-personal.umich.edu/~fshman
chRis QuintAnAs ReseARch
sitemaker.soe.umich.edu/soe/
aculty_introduction&mode=single
&recordID=50928
elizABeth mojes ReseARch
www-personal.umich.edu/~moje
no QuiCk fixeS to
aCCoMpanying pRobleMS
Almost every public school in the United States now
access to the Internet, but student-to-computer r
and access to broadband service vary widely a
socioeconomic levels, and inadequate or nonexistent a
to technology at home is just another orm o pover
disadvantaged youth. New literacies mean even gr
challenges or students who are already struggling
traditional orms. So-called monastic learners, those
t the stereotype o the solitary scholar ensconced i
library, will also have diculties. And it didnt take
or ChaCha, a cell-phone service launched last Ja
that promises to give ree answers to virtually any que
within minutes, to be used or cheating.
Tese problems are all too amiliar. rying to solve
is what the noblest educational enterprises have long
about: leveling the playing eld, disseminating a sh
intellectual and ethical oundation, insuring tha
students learn despite disparate gis, and preparing
or success in all their worlds. It behooves teachers to
up the powerul tools that are now at hand and reme
the ends that they serve.
Story by Jef Mortimer
Photos by Mike Gouldaa Cole is a graduate student in mathematics education at the School o Edcuation.
liz KolBs Toys To Tools: ConneCTing
sTudenT Cell Phones To eduCaTionwww.cellphonesinlearning.com
centeR FoRmediA liteRAcy
www.medialit.org
nAtionAl council oFteAcheRs
oF english sQuiRe oFFice oF
Policy ReseARch
www.ncte.org/edpolicy?source=gs
digitAl ideAKeePeR
www.hi-ce.org/digitalideakeep
Toward a Theory
of new liTeraCies
www.readingonline.org/
newliteracies/leu
inteRnAtionAl society FoR
technology in educAtion
www.iste.org
-
8/14/2019 Innovator vol. 39, Fall 2008. Literacies in the 21st century
9/19
w w w. S O E . U M I C H . E D U F A L L 2 0 0 8 U N I V E R S I T Y O F M I C H I G A N S C H O O L O F E D U C A T
Highlight
ldld dlss -dlss - ccs Qs Q Teachers provide scaolding all the time when dealing with Teachers provide scaolding all the time when dealing with
their students, says Assistant Proessor Chris Quintana. Whattheir students, says Assistant Proessor Chris Quintana. What
oes it mean to provide that kind o support in technology?oes it mean to provide that kind o support in technology?
How to design those kinds o technologies is what Ive beenHow to design those kinds o technologies is what Ive been
looking at.looking at.
Thats the overall ocus o Quintanas work, but the value oThats the overall ocus o Quintanas work, but the value o
ne project in particular will be instantly recognizable tone project in particular will be instantly recognizable to
nyone who has ever done research on the Web. Called thenyone who has ever done research on the Web. Called the
Digital IdeaKeeper, he describes it as a sotware environmentDigital IdeaKeeper, he describes it as a sotware environment
to help kids with online inquiry by providing them with toolsto help kids with online inquiry by providing them with tools
to help them locate, assess, and synthesize inormation onto help them locate, assess, and synthesize inormation on
the Internet.the Internet.
When he and his colleagues learned o the National ScienceWhen he and his colleagues learned o the National Science
Foundations interest in building a digital inrastructure or K-12Foundations interest in building a digital inrastructure or K-12
students, all o their ideas were either lets make it easier orstudents, all o their ideas were either lets make it easier or
kids to search digital libraries, or lets build specic librarykids to search digital libraries, or lets build specic library
collections that are aimed at kids, he says. But we thoughtcollections that are aimed at kids, he says. But we thought
that nding inormation on the Web was not necessarily thethat nding inormation on the Web was not necessarily the
problem. Once you nd the inormation, what do you do with it?problem. Once you nd the inormation, what do you do with it?
How do you make sense o it? How do you synthesize it?How do you make sense o it? How do you synthesize it?
Research shows that when most students use the InternetResearch shows that when most students use the Internet
to investigate a problem, they enter a ew words in a searchto investigate a problem, they enter a ew words in a search
engine, click on some o the websites displayed, scan orengine, click on some o the websites displayed, scan or
sentences that seem to t a potential answer, and copy andsentences that seem to t a potential answer, and copy and
paste. Its the sort o behavior that eeds the ears o technologypaste. Its the sort o behavior that eeds the ears o technology
skeptics, but technology can also solve the problem it seemsskeptics, but technology can also solve the problem it seems
to have created.to have created.
How can we develop tools to help kids put the brakes onHow can we develop tools to help kids put the brakes on
and be more mindul and read these things in more detail?and be more mindul and read these things in more detail?
says Quintana. Thats what we were aiming at with thesays Quintana. Thats what we were aiming at with the
IdeaKeepera sotware environment that would not just haveIdeaKeepera sotware environment that would not just have
access to search engines but would support phases o theaccess to search engines but would support phases o the
online inquiry process.online inquiry process.
Online inquiry is an important way o engaging learners inOnline inquiry is an important way o engaging learners in
inormation-rich activities using online inormation collectionsinormation-rich activities using online inormation collections
to explore questions in dierent elds, such as science. Onlineto explore questions in dierent elds, such as science. Online
inquiry involves a set o interrelated activities, such as planninginquiry involves a set o interrelated activities, such as planning
an investigation; seeking, analyzing, and making sense o onlinean investigation; seeking, analyzing, and making sense o online
inormation; and synthesizing inormation into a nal argument.inormation; and synthesizing inormation into a nal argument.
However, learners may encounter several obstacles inHowever, learners may encounter several obstacles in
trying to tackle an open-ended, complex process like onlinetrying to tackle an open-ended, complex process like online
inquiry. Many digital library services support inormation seekinginquiry. Many digital library services support inormation seeking
but they do not necessarily support the ull range o onlinebut they do not necessarily support the ull range o onlineinquiry activities.inquiry activities.
The IdeaKeeper extends digital library services by integratingThe IdeaKeeper extends digital library services by integrating
dierent tools and scaolding approaches to help learnersdierent tools and scaolding approaches to help learners
eectively engage in all the process o online inquiry. The maineectively engage in all the process o online inquiry. The main
IdeaKeeper screen illustrates student inquiry activities withIdeaKeeper screen illustrates student inquiry activities with
a sidebar o tasks in student language: Figuring out what Ia sidebar o tasks in student language: Figuring out what I
need, nding what I need, reading what I ound, and puttingneed, nding what I need, reading what I ound, and putting
it all together into a nal answer. IdeaKeeper also displaysit all together into a nal answer. IdeaKeeper also displays
ierent questions or students to think about and spaces orierent questions or students to think about and spaces or
responses: What is my driving question? What do I know aboutresponses: What is my driving question? What do I know about
this topic? What do I want to know about this topic? What arethis topic? What do I want to know about this topic? What are
some possible search keywords?some possible search keywords?
When students open an article retrieved rom the digitalWhen students open an article retrieved rom the digital
library, IdeaKeeper displays it in a browser window ramed bylibrary, IdeaKeeper displays it in a browser window ramed by
scaolded notepad that contains prompts and note-takingscaolded notepad that contains prompts and note-taking
reas or analysis. Students are asked to say something in theirreas or analysis. Students are asked to say something in their
wn words rather than copy and paste, Quintana says. Thatswn words rather than copy and paste, Quintana says. Thats
whats been lackingmindulness.whats been lackingmindulness.
The sotware was used by sixth and seventh graders and theThe sotware was used by sixth and seventh graders and the
results were encouraging. Kids that used IdeaKeeper wereresults were encouraging. Kids that used IdeaKeeper were
taking more notes than the kids who were not and looktaking more notes than the kids who were not and look
ewer websites but spending more time on each, which iewer websites but spending more time on each, which i
o what we were wanting to see, he says. It worked no what we were wanting to see, he says. It worked n
small sample.small sample.
Sadly, the NSF grant that supported the project has ruSadly, the NSF grant that supported the project has ru
Further study is needed may be a clich, but its rustraFurther study is needed may be a clich, but its rustra
true in this case.true in this case.
Id like to do a larger trial, say a hundred kids, says QuiId like to do a larger trial, say a hundred kids, says Qui
and wed have to make the sotware less brittle. Its techand wed have to make the sotware less brittle. Its tech
a little more complex when you want to scale it rom a ca little more complex when you want to scale it rom a c
o classrooms to hundreds o classrooms. But such so classrooms to hundreds o classrooms. But such s
requires another round o unding. Quintana is explorrequires another round o unding. Quintana is explor
variety o avenues to update and distribute the sotwarevariety o avenues to update and distribute the sotware
wider audience.wider audience.
The Digital IdeaKeeperThe Digital IdeaKeeper
includes dierentincludes dierent
upportive eaturesupportive eatures
or students who areor students who are
ngaging in onlinengaging in online
inquiry. For example,inquiry. For example,
hen students openhen students open
eb-based articles (sucheb-based articles (such
s this article rom thes this article rom the
Environmental ProtectionEnvironmental Protection
Agency), the IdeaKeeperAgency), the IdeaKeeper
onnects a scaoldedonnects a scaolded
notepad to the article tonotepad to the article to
uide students in readinguide students in reading
nd taking notes aboutnd taking notes about
the article. Not onlythe article. Not only
oes the notepad giveoes the notepad give
tudents a place to taketudents a place to take
notes about the article,notes about the article,
ut it includes dierentut it includes dierent
prompts to describe whatprompts to describe what
they should think aboutthey should think about
s they skim, read, ands they skim, read, and
ummarize the article.ummarize the article.
There are similarThere are similar
prompts and eatures inprompts and eatures in
IdeaKeeper to supportIdeaKeeper to supporttudents throughtudents through
ierent aspects o theierent aspects o the
nline inquiry processnline inquiry process
to make explicit theto make explicit the
act that online inquiryact that online inquiry
involves a wide range oinvolves a wide range o
onstructive, refective,onstructive, refective,
nd analytical activity.nd analytical activity.
-
8/14/2019 Innovator vol. 39, Fall 2008. Literacies in the 21st century
10/19
w w w. S O E . U M I C H . E D U F A L L 2 0 0 8 U N I V E R S I T Y O F M I C H I G A N S C H O O L O F E D U C A T
And even some twentysomething students in
technology course were as wary as their elders o K
Kolbs ideas.
Teyd say, What are you talking about, using
phones? says Stanzler. Tere was a lot o resistan
lot o conusion. Schools are only gradually seeing
possibilities and Liz is on the leading edge o that
whole question o whether blogs or cell phones h
place is an abstraction, but the experience o working
them helps our students get in touch with who they
teachers, whats important to them, and what experi
aspects they want to encourage.
So, given her views, why did Keren-Kolb produce a
instead o a digital stream? Because Im trying to
old-ashioned teachers, she says. You cant reach
through a cell phone.
Story by Jef Mortimer
Photos by Mike Gould
PreParing tech-
Savvy teacherSSd ms
as cf
P
Students in last years Secondary Master o Arts with
Certication program got technology coming and going.
Tey learned how to embed video and photos in text
to create multimedia papers. Tey used BlueStream, a
University o Michigan server designed or archiving and
sharing large les, or their classroom assignments. For the
rst time, under a pilot project sponsored by the eacher
Education Initiative, each student coming into the program
was equipped with a laptop computer, a video camera,
and audio-recording devices to chronicleand study and
analyze and sharetheir pre-service practice.
And going out to do that practice, they were urther
equipped with the ideas and insig hts they gained rom the
echnology in Education course taught by Je Stanzler
and Elizabeth Keren-Kolb.
In at least one important regard, the results are already in.
Teyve done really well getting teaching positions, says
Lecturer Deanna Birdyshaw, who led the pilot project along
with Clinical Proessor Charles Peters. Teir ability to
design learning experiences using instructional technology
became something that people interviewing them thought
would be important or their school districts. Te level
o their knowledge about technology was denitely
an advantage.
One o those students was Katie Z awacki, who now teaches
English at Stevenson High School in Lincolnshire, IL. My
mentor teacher was at the end o her career and basically
used next to n o technology, she says. I noticed the ways
that students reacted to my lessons in contrast to hers.
In teaching Pride and Prejudice, or example, she had
students create a Facebook page or a character o their
choosing and then write and post blog entries in the
guise o that character. I know how interesting things
like Facebook and MySpace are to students these days
so I wanted to integrate those into the classroom, Zawacki
says. Tat helped them be able to understand the
character better.
Tats exactly what the tech-
nology course is ocused on,
says Keren-Kolb: When you
walk into that classroom,
how are you going to use
technology to meet your cur-ricular goals?
As a high-school social stud-
ies teacher and technology
coordinator, Keren-Kolb was
among those who wanted to
keep personal digital devic-
es out o schools. Now, shes
the author o oys to ools:
Connecting Student Cell Phones
to Education, which will be
published this all.
I you have an overhead pro-
jector and thats it, she says,
turn to the students and
say, What do you have? Cell
phones, iPods, mp3 players
theyre not just great tools you can use to enhance learn-
ing, but also tools that will connect student learning in the
classroom with what theyre doing in their lives.
Students can be as oblivious as their teachers to these
technologies potential. Its not about teaching them how
to use the tool, Keren-Kolb says. Teyre already better
than we are. Its about showing them how to use the tool
eectively or their proessional growth instead o looking
at it as a toy.
-
8/14/2019 Innovator vol. 39, Fall 2008. Literacies in the 21st century
11/19
w w w. S O E . U M I C H . E D U F A L L 2 0 0 8 U N I V E R S I T Y O F M I C H I G A N S C H O O L O F E D U C A T
Sl ed Dls Sss Pzz-Dl ceo
Te best teachers are oen those who combine a knack or teaching with creative application
o their ormal training. David Brandon, who came to the University o Michigan on an
athletic scholarship, has truly pushed the envelope with his use o his School o Education
experiencehe entered the world o business. As CEO o Dominos Pizza, Inc., he leads over
145,000 team members in over 60 countries. And he credits much o his success to what he
learned at the School o Education.
Brandon came to the school intent on becoming a teacher. Besides his amily, he said, the
people who had made an impact on his lie had been teachers and coaches and he wanted
to have a similar infuence on other young people. In his senior year at SOE, he was student-
teaching at a local high school and was in discussions to continue at the school aer graduation.
Tats when opportunity knocked.
Actually, opportunity called on the telephone, and it was a
he and he w as a recruiter rom Procter & Gamble. Brandons
ootball coach, Bo Schembechler, had given the recruiter
Brandons name. Tinking it unlikely that hed be interested,
Brandon agreed nonetheless to meet with the recruiter, who
was hiring or the companys sales team in the Food Products
Division. As he learned about how Procter & Gambles sales
team worked and thought about his own abilities, he began to
eel that a position in the business world might make sense:
It wasnt as large a leap as some people might think, he said.
Many o the skills and much o the training I received at the
School o Education were really applicable to the jobs I have
had in the business world. My career has been spent teaching
and coaching people how to maximize their potential and
how to succeed in business.
When someone graduates rom the School o Education,theyve learned a lot about eective teaching and learning, the
dynamics o what occurs in a classroom, how to prepare a
curriculum, how to set objectives and measure perormance,
how to motivate people to want to learn, and how to make
learning a positive experience. All o those skills I learned at
the school are just as applicable in the world o business as
they are in the classroom.
DaviD branDon (abeD 74, certt 74)
aLumni Making a Difference Brandon later moved to Valassis Inserts, a company inthe sales promotion and coupon industries. Te companybecame Valassis Communications, Inc., aer Brandon led
the process o taking the company public. Over the course
o 20 years at Valassis, Brandon took it rom a company o 75
employees to a rm with 1,300 employees that was acclaimed
as one o the 100 Best Companies to Work or in America.
In 1998, he was elected to the universitys Board o Regents.
He says he was interested in this position so that he could
give back to the school that had played such a major, positive
role in his lie. He was recruited to his current position at
Dominos Pizza, Inc. the ollowing year.
Brandon and his wie Jan have recently ounded the Brandon
Proessional Resource Center and Archive at SOE. In his
experience, he said, or leaders to be successul, they need
appropriate resources that they can leverage to achieve
results. Te Brandon Center will house and oer access
to inormation, to resources that students need to be as
successul as they can be, in an ecient and technologically
advanced way.
Nearly our decades ago, Brandon came to SOE to learn how
to teach. Now, as CEO o the largest pizza delivery company
in the world, he says he continues to use his education:
Primarily what CEOs do is they teach and they coach.
I surround mysel with terric peoplea great team
and I coach them to be the best they can be. I teach and
communicate those things that I think are most important
or us to achieve as an organization. Te core skills that
I think are necessary to success I can trace back to my
education at the School o Education.
Story by Robert Brustman
The core skills that I think are necessary to
success I can trace back to my education at
the School of Education. David Brandon
UMPhotoServices,MartinVloet
UM Photo Services, Paul Jaronski
-
8/14/2019 Innovator vol. 39, Fall 2008. Literacies in the 21st century
12/19
-
8/14/2019 Innovator vol. 39, Fall 2008. Literacies in the 21st century
13/19
w w w. S O E . U M I C H . E D U F A L L 2 0 0 8 U N I V E R S I T Y O F M I C H I G A N S C H O O L O F E D U C A T
ypSilanti Middle SChool StudentS attend nanoSCienCe aCadeMy
For the third summer in a row, Ypsilanti sixth through eighth graders attended a two-week Nanoscience Academy designed by the or Highly Interactive Computing, Classrooms, and Curricula in Education on the University o Michigan campus. Te program intrstudents to the science o small. In the process, students conducted investigations, met practicing scientists who used nanoscience work, and toured university labs and acilities.
leadeRShip inStitute
For the second year, the Education Leadership Center held severalseminars on issues important to school leaders. Tis year, topicsincluded Current Legal and Political Issues and OrganizingSchools to Develop eaching Expertise.
aluMni CelebRate hoMeCoMing
On October 4, 2008, alumni enjoyed the chance to get reacqu
ed with each other and catch up with former t eachers and me
at Fall Gathering, the schools annual homecoming reunion lu
and football game.
inStitute paRtiCipantS CelebRate theMe, living Wide aWake
Participants in Oakland Writing Projects Invitational Summer Institute, a our-week, intensive, literacy-ocused workshop or excellent K-12teachers o all disciplines, were inspired to pose or a photograph by the institute theme Living Wide Awake. During June and July, teachersprobed their classroom practice and interior lives through writing, studying, and proessional inquiry. Te National Writing Project site iscosponsored by the U-M School o Education, Oakland Schools, and Adrian College.
SnaPShotS
eleMentaRy MatheMatiCS laboRatoRy addS neW tWiStS
In its second summer, the Elementary Mathematics Laboratory, a unique two-week program or Ypsilanti h graders taught by Dean DeborahLoewenberg Ball and documented extensively by multiple research teams, added several layers in 2008: a ull-day program or the childrenincluding arts-based work and a mathematics clinic, proessional development or Ypsilanti teachers, and a course or mathematics educatorstaught by National Medal o Science winner and SOE Proessor Hyman Bass.
-
8/14/2019 Innovator vol. 39, Fall 2008. Literacies in the 21st century
14/19
w w w. S O E . U M I C H . E D U F A L L 2 0 0 8 U N I V E R S I T Y O F M I C H I G A N S C H O O L O F E D U C A T
Over the last several years, important U-M programs with and
or members o the Chinese education community have eatured
participation rom the School o Education. Tere have been
both university-level orums as well as programs that originate
rom SOE.
Last May, the Michigan-China University Leadership Forum
included 23 educational and government leaders rom China and
took place on the campuses now considered part o the University
Research Corridor: University o Michigan, Michigan State
University, and Wayne State University. Te orum built on a history
o engagement that began with a 2005 visit to China by President
Mary Sue Coleman where she met with ocials rom the Chinese
Ministry o Education. Chinese leaders requested that t he University
o Michigan host a two-week orum or Chinese higher education
leaders on the management o world-class research universities. One
orum was held in 2006, ollowed by this years orum.
SOE aculty member Constance Cook, who is also Executive
Director o the U-M Center or Research on Learning and eaching
and Associate Vice Provost or Academic Aairs, directed this yearsorum. Nine students rom the Center or the Study o Higher and
Postsecondary Education (CSHPE) assisted with this orum as
translators, drivers, and event planners.
Challenges identied by Chinese leaders included problems that
emerge with rapid expansion o a higher education system: the
need to develop ethical codes, standards or teaching and learning,
and additional revenue streams besides government budget lines
and tuition.
SnaPShotS
idea inStitute opened and dediCated
Te IDEA Institute was dedicated on October 14, 2008, with an opening symposium and dedication ceremony. IDEA is a collabobetween the College o Literature, Science, and the Arts and the School o Education and ormalizes long-term interdisciplinary partnIt is ocused on the improvement o undergraduate science and mathematics instruction, the recruitment to K-12 science and mathteaching, the improvement o 7-12 science and mathematics education, and the development o uture aculty.
building RenovationS undeRWay
Renovations are underway in key spaces within the School o Education. Tese will improve the look o the school and its collaborativeand welcoming atmosphere. Above is a rendering o the Deans Conerence Room, renovations o which were made possible by a gegi rom Judith A. (ABED 62, CER 62) and Verne G. (AB 62, MBA 63) Istock. In addition to this space, planning is underwayBrandon Proessional Resource Center and Archive, a twenty-rst-century education library.
At the school-level, the School o Educations CSHPE, in an eort led
by aculty member Janet Lawrence, began oering intensive executive
education programs or Chinese higher education administrators in
the summer o 2000. Between 2000 - 2005, the provincial educational
department o ianjing sent 80 university administrators to
participate in 16-week executive education programs that included
lectures, discussions, and visits to postsecondary institutions in
Southeast Michigan.
Since 2006, CSHPE has oered a three-week executive education
program or higher education administrators rom Liaoning
province in China. Te content has been developed in collaboration
with provincial government personnel and is revised annually
based on evaluations by participants and input rom the provincial
government. Between 20-25 individuals come to Ann Arbor each
all or a program consisting o lectures, group exercises, and site
visits. Certain topics vary; or instance, last October the group
wanted inormation about the management o endowments and
about creating university oundations while continuing past
interest in sessions that establish a oundational knowledge o
U.S. higher education (e.g., organization and governance andacademic programming).
Te Liaoning provincial government also supports our individuals
each year who spend six months in residence as visiting scholars
with CSHPE. Tese visitors unction as members o our academic
community, attending classes, social and proessional events, and
meeting individually with aculty on research or administrative
issues. Te latest delegation, which arrived on October 13, 2008,
included 21 higher education administrators rom universities and
the provincial government department o education.
SChool of eduCation a key paRtiCipant in u-M RelationShipS With China
-
8/14/2019 Innovator vol. 39, Fall 2008. Literacies in the 21st century
15/19
-
8/14/2019 Innovator vol. 39, Fall 2008. Literacies in the 21st century
16/19
w w w. S O E . U M I C H . E D U F A L L 2 0 0 8 U N I V E R S I T Y O F M I C H I G A N S C H O O L O F E D U C A T
cLaSS noteS
stephen a. anDerson
(AB 71, CER EDUC 71) has received numerous
career awards including: International Educators to Japan
Fellowship (2008); Michigan Elementary Principal o the
Year (2008); membership in the Michigan Network o
Educators (2008); Michigan Science eachers Association
Administrator o the Year (2005); and National
Science eachers Association/Council or Elementary
Science International Award or Elementary Science
Administration Excellence (2004).
amy kLiJanowicz campBeLL
(ABED 99, CER 99) received her National Board
Certication as an early childhood generalist aer having
taught in Fairax County, VA, and then in Carteret
County, NC, most recently team teaching a rst/second
multi-age class there. She is currently in Newport, Rhode
Island, where she tutors privately. She and her husband,
roy, are expecting their second daughter this all.
kate (BuDzinski) Druchniak
(ABED 00, CER EDUC 00) just nished her
seventh year o teaching second and third grade. She is
looking orward to completing her masters in reading
in December. She married Eric Druchniak (another
teacher!) in 2003 and had a son in December 2006.
Josephine eLizaBeth Fermanian
(AB 94, CER EDUC 98) has developed a line o
organic products aimed at saeguarding childrens health.
As she tells her story: I never imagined that one day I
would be an inventor o organic/green goods. I launched
an organic cleaner, Germs Begone, in 2005 when I
reused to bring chemicals into our home or cleaning
because my son and I both have Multiple Chemical
Sensitivity. More recently, she worked with a group o
organic manuacturers and, aer two years o intense
product development, launched PediaOrganic, natures
oral electrolyte. Te product contains no articial colors,
no articial favors, and no preservatives. I simply reuse
to give up on an idea that can make a dierence in our
childrens health, says Fermanian.
nataLia Forrat
(MA 08) was the winner o the article competition or
young scholars in the journal Voprosy obrazovaniya
(Educational Issues), published by State University -
Higher School o Economics, Moscow, Russia.
BarBara kuhn heerman
(AB 69, CER EDUC 69) retired in June 2007 aer 37
years o teaching. She was the Social Science departmentchair at Maine East High School in Park Ridge, IL. Her
retirement plans include travel and supervising student
teachers or Northwestern University.
pauL krieger
(BS 86, CER EDUC 86) just published his second
book,A Visual Analogy Guide to Human Physiology.
Tis is a companion book to his rst national publication,
A Visual Analogy Guide to Human Anatomy. Both books
are unique stand-alone supplements or which Krieger
is both the author and illustrator. His rst book is now
sold throughout the U.S. and Canada and is one o his
publishers best selling titles. More inormation on both
books can be vi ewed at the Morton Publishing website:
www.morton-pub.com. Krieger has been teaching as a
proessor o biology at Grand Rapids Community College
or the past 16 years.
cLaire cameron ponitz
(AB 02, MS 05, PhD 07) received the American
Psychological Associations Educational Psychology Early
Career Research Award. Tis accomplishment is due in
large part to my wonderul training in CPEP!
waLLace c. schLoerke
(ABED 47, CER EDUC 47, MS 50, EdS 62, EdD 64)
is proessor emeritus at Iowa State University and was
inducted into the Michigan Interscholastic rack Coaches
Association Hall o Fame recently or his successul
coaching at Pontiac High Sc hool (47-56). In May 2008,
he was honored to be selected as Grand Marshall at the
State o Iowa Special Olympics Summer Games, where he
has volunteered or over 20 years.
wed love to hear rom you.
Send us nes about your
achievements and experiences.
Send us your comments and advice.
Our address is:
Ofce o Development & Alumni Relations
U-M School o Education
610 East University, Suite 1001
Ann Arbor, MI 48109-1259
email: b@.
seung-hee son
(AM 01, AM 03, PhD 06), now an assistant proess
at Purdue University, received the 2008 Outstanding
Dissertation Award in Human Development rom
American Educational Research Association Divisio
E. Her dissertation also won the 2007 Outstanding
Dissertation Award rom American Educational Res
Association Early Education Special Interest Group.
mengLi song anD tamara young
Mengli Song (AM 01, PhD 03) and amara Young
(AM 01, PhD 05) recently published a book, Readin
Politics, Policies, and Processes. Tis book is based on
graduate research with the School o Educations Rea
Policy Project lead by proessor emeritus and ormer
Cecil Miskel. In 2005, Song, along with Miskel,
won the University Council or EducationalAdministrations William J. Davis Award or most
outstanding article in Educational Administration
Quarterly. In 2006, amara Young was a nalist or
the Politics o Education Associations Outstanding
Dissertation Award. Song is a research s cientist at
American Institutes or Research in Washington, DC
and Young is an assistant proessor at North Carolina
State University in Raleigh, North Carolina.
Staying in touchhsin-yi chang
(PhD 07) is now an
assistant proessor at
the Graduate Institute
o Science Education
at National Kaohsiung
Normal University in
Kaohsiung, aiwan. She
received the Dimond
Outstanding Dissertation
Award or 2008.
Spotlight
-
8/14/2019 Innovator vol. 39, Fall 2008. Literacies in the 21st century
17/19
2 8 w w w . S O E . U M I C H . E D U F A L L 2 0 0 8
David Brandons (ABED 74 CER 74) prole on page16 and highlighted in the Fall 2007 issue oInnovator.
Te renovation o the Deans Conerence Room, made
possible by a gi rom Verne (AB 62, MBA 63) and Judy
Istock (ABED 62, CER 62), is underway as I write this.
Improvements to the technological capabilities and the
aesthetics and comort will enable productive meetings
and seminars.
Tese improvements are to shared spaces in which
members o the school community meet to work and thinkwith one another. As we have discussed and planned these
improvements, we have begun rethinking the ways in which
we interact with each other and we value the synthesis
that results rom the sharing o intellect and experience.
Were going to continue envisioning how we can best work
togetherand how our physical environment can nurture
productive collaboration.
Other school activities made possible by this campaign
include the signicant expansion o our K-12 summer
outreach activities, ellowship support, and gis or
the Center or the Study o Higher and Postsecondary
Education (which has again been rated the #1 higher
education program in the country).
Your gis, large and small, enable the school to continue
to lead the way in transorming educational practice and
policy in the state, the nation, and the world.
As always, i you are in the area, we encourage you to come
back and visit the school. See where youve been. And see
where were going. Well be happy to take you on a tour
and show you the exciting things happening at the Schoolo Education.
Tank you or all o your support.
Sincerely,
Michael S. Dubin
Director o Development and Alumni Relations
As the clocks tick down to midnight and reworksare launched to welcome the New Year, we will be drawing
the curtain on the Michigan Dierence Campaign. We
wont mark this conclusion with our own pyrotechnics, but
i we did shoot o a ew rockets or light a Roman Candle,
it would be entirely appropriatethis has been the
biggest, the best, and the most successul campaign in our
schools history.
Tis success is a result o the generosity and aith o you: our
loyal alumni and riends. You have been here. You know
that the schools work builds upon more than 125 years opreparing teachers, o pioneering research, and o working
with communities to persistently improve education and
meet new challenges.
Our goal or this eight-year campaign was to raise $30
million. Tanks to the enthusiastic support o our alumni
and riends, we have surpassed that goal and have raised
over $35 million.
More than 13 million o these dollars are designated or
student scholarships. Helping our students with the expense
o their education enables many bright and passionate
people to enter the teaching proession or improve their
abilities. While the university does its utmost to keep
tuition reasonable, it is still a signicant expense. Your
gis or tuition assistance help to remove the barriers that
might otherwise prevent gied students rom entering the
critical eld o education.
We have also received gis or use in improving our
physical resources. While our building is dear to us and
provides a meaningul heritage, its spaces need to evolve
to meet current and uture needs.
We are particularly grateul or the unding that enabled
us to renovate areas o our school. Improvements are quite
noticeable in the rst-foor public areas o our school with
brighter hallways and inspirational artwork.
Tis winter we plan to break ground on the Brandon
Proessional Resource Center and Archive, described in
DeveLoPmentrePort
-
8/14/2019 Innovator vol. 39, Fall 2008. Literacies in the 21st century
18/19
o blf f d, ff, d fl, ld l , t !
The most successul capital campaign in our schools history is approaching its conclusion and the benets o your
largesse are already being realized.
You have given over $13 million or scholarships and student support
You have provided unds to retain and recruit the nations leading education scholars
You have made possible physical improvements, including those to public spaces and conerence rooms, as well
as the creation o a new proessional resource center
You have supported academic programs and seminar series
w blf d bl d l f f
f , f ddl lf , f lbl , d f
f d d d . w l fl f .
t ts w h g S gsl
School of Education
-
8/14/2019 Innovator vol. 39, Fall 2008. Literacies in the 21st century
19/19
INNOVATORUniversity o Michigan School o Education
610 East University Avenue
Ann Arbor, MI 48109-1259
the regentS
oF the univerSity oF michigan
Julia Donovan Darlow, Ann ArborLaurence B. Deitch, Bingham Farms
Olivia P. Maynard, Goodrich
Rebecca McGowan, Ann Arbor
Andrea Fischer Newman, Ann Arbor
Andrew C. Richner, Grosse Pointe Park
S. Martin Taylor, Grosse Pointe Farms
Katherine E. White, Ann Arbor
Mary Sue Coleman, ex ofcio
nds Pl SThe University o Michigan, as an equal opportunity/afrmative action employer, complies
ith all applicable ederal and state las regarding nondiscrimination and afrmative action,including Title IX o the Education Amendments o 1972 and Section 504 o the Rehabilita-
tion Act o 1973. The University o Michigan is committed to a policy o nondiscrimination
and equal opportunity or all persons regardless o race, sex, color, religion, creed, national
origin or ancestry, age, marital status, sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression,
disability, or Vietnam-era veteran status in employment, educational programs and activities,
and admissions. Inquiries or complaints may be addressed to the Senior Director or
Institutional Equity and Title IX/Section 504 Coordinator, Ofce o Institutional Equity, 2072
Administrative Services Building, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109-1432, 734-763-0235, TTY
734-647-1388. For other University o Michigan inormation call 734-764-1817.
INNOVATOR is published by the
University o Michigan School o Education
Oce o Outreach and Communications
LeaDerShiP team
oF the SchooL oF eDucation
Deborah Loewenberg Ball, Dean
Joseph Krajcik, Associate Dean, Research
Annemarie Sullivan Palincsar, Associate Dean,
Academic Aairs
Henry Meares, Assistant Dean
communicationS team
oF the SchooL oF eDucation
Robert Brustman, Writer/Editor
Elena Godina, Designer
Mike Gould, Photographer
Je Mortimer, Writer
Yvonne Pappas, Designer/Art Director
Laura Roop, Writer/Editor
Kathryn Taylor, Interim Communications Director