M, ZDw

ZZg~ eZ

ZDwZ0y

]tp

*/*

ZDwZ0y0yziZg]Zh!gZ( )#

2wZ-ZZDwgTel: [+92-42] 36314-510 [+92-42] 99203-573Fax: [+92-42] 3631-4496Email: info@iap.gov.pk

Website: www.allamaiqbal.com

ISBN 978-969-416-462-5

102Y 1 : TZw005 : ZXB052gz9 : 7{ : N?emZ

khalidfaisal@gmail.com

66g : -

z|:611.egzegy41275373

z

5 p11 1DZDw:M,52 2DZDw6~34 gw 3DZDwZzgG37 4DZDw@g

Z0zyZzgZ]41 IFEZggz~501 inqm]F`n^l]n 5D

ZsZg~711 6Zq*g{ _f^l]f^ 6D921 7DgzZ[~ZDw~Zzg/F]541 8DZDwF+g~:*)561 9DZDwfzy771 01DZDw~~egZ981 11DZDw791 21DZDwZzgZ{Z$Z112 tZzgZ, 31D

732 41DL!'csZZZqcC_

942 51DZDwZzg752 61DzcZ@i{

ZDwZq362 Zq~ D 71DZDw:Zzg,

pQgzW~ZD1]zr0ceZkNv

!VZDw!g}YVZYg;tZ

LZD1]gziZzVWz]q~!zZDw9VZzgzVa!X

ZDw~ZzgQyzu~k,ZqpZykzV_ZzgZy~Zzg/Zixgz6M{DgTXat]z

fi`ZkaZy~jZVZ{zg p}.MXptxjZC*yZKzgc]KXZka

sP]6ZyjZVZgg]*kXZk@;~Zq{mZxtHZDwg~xjZVBQyFZWb

XZwZDw6xg6ZkZoZx7HY@Txg~{QWCXZyp}~gZgFZWgzlZ(g

XQyxgMz{ZD1]DZZe{70NXtxFZW*qzlX

'p}~]q!zZqZg* ]f^`m6X&&ECkHYYZkg*(~zzttp}ZDwzK@VZka*kg6Zy~!bmX=Zk]6Zk{)_

gk,ZD1]z0_@gZgs T~.D]!g}~$4 MGn*eLVQ!gZk

inqm]F`n^l]n bikccX}ZDw6~ZsZg~ZDwF+~*)gzZ[~ZDw

~Zzg/F]hZDw6Zq*g{ZDw'ZzgZDwZzgZ{Z$ZXZ,]X}w~ZkZ7HXZDw

@g_~!gZ0zyZzgZ]41 IFE],yZDw@gBZyZiZ:HXZbZDwZzgZ,!g}~Z[JXZk~,!g}~!

q6 Zk Zscqg~!g}~!kx/]7gZg7M,/bwgZzg Z*yZk[~L

g8z Zk|Y^},uJZDwp inqm]F`n^l]n ~c7eXZbZp

!g}~pZkzg7Zzgs)bgBZs@g~g7XZ*yZk~Zqf:[XZtZzgzu}ItZD1]ZqDxM$4 MGV~t*q["xZzggZV7gX

Zq*aZk{ZicZ ]f^`m6a$4 MGZDwZ0y)g(DzZzgZDwk*[/r]ZgVQ,VZZLZZg}S_.~*qzVZDwVzWFJZxHX

ZZg~ eZ

7 p

ZDw:M,wMi~NNcNtQDg`fgZN

ZZ~ .Z[~~!@|C~tHzVZzgZi06]Z0ZWZ]%AKZazVZy

zgzV~HY@ZWZ0~Zg~gV~u6EquZW]Jz~Zi0~TqA]aZ6gZkVwu@g~fA~Zy_"Zzg7Vg6OWCZzgZz])

wZ(gg*x(}zVZL:bzg OWH~g~ZWZ0~VB@g~pg@|

o]~}Z0ZgZgOWZLzggZ~"ZgY*Zzg[y0xVa

]cgZ!*z){p0t~ZWZ]Zk}ic{k0ZzgtV zggkU"Dz~zZzgqF-VZI

6xZggbDZ~eZZL~gLL"0 EG0Zm~fg){eg{%Zzg"i!y-Vi!yj~XZ(}

x$zZVZfzZtzZZtBB ZZLzZzgzJOWHz~~pz

11 ZDw:M,

Zkz~Qyl))Y(g]Xfg)gKq(ZZzg(~qgNZzgZbp[iZzgip[3cYYZa~*~(}(}Qgz~M:0YC)zQx

(tf~~xz~T C1 gZg:LL~LLQxZ[~~HpZk~~g~ZWZ]{Z!VS6ZK$sZzg

xaZ3DZ%n}[DbZi0~ ~@|Zs~M` p C2 ZZzg@|,yHX

ExzZgz~ic{ZsZzgDBYY~'V ]z !zt!~Z~ggt@

ZxA]:~ ]Za@g ]7zu}(}ZBB~gMCG~Zz[

t) '03p*~ZZ,g}q'ZDwb9sV~LM, MX

ZDw -V*Z(}ZZLi06ZWZ0Zip,~~'R0uzyVZi06}ZWZ]

Z~Z~Zg qV %AKZzg)ZZHXZkVB*c[7c[zgZDwz@g(ZzgZ[67Vg6ZWZ]gh}Q,VQgz~~ZqZ+gzlZ(gTVwZk7Q,V~~@g]gi0Zzg~zVMt]Z0g6zWHQ,VQgz~Zkgfz{MH*i!V{~MnVQ,VQgzzw6w_"ZzgZg86Z1Z[zZbz{ZL

ZkzZka,dZ!Zzg BZq*Zzg*ZkRgzZc]~pZkZi066"azZZDw

ZDwM, 21

Qgz~]~ZqxpaZcZzg~seg)~Zzg@gzdBBZ2ZgbQ,V~,

]jZkb Zzgi0Zzgf!Zg~cVHZktZzgf[zV5gzxMnXQ,V~Z+wcZzgZ+wy"YyVwi0zVd

M~seX6Zk*]Q,VZK~~Hz{sQgz~77g~*Z[~nZDwZ[@g~h!gt7H~!Z]7ZZ~ZzgZi0

Zqzacfg=Zg uLD=zZqWfg='p~!zQ,V~zZzgQ|yX-VMHQQgz~~8Zq6pZsZsZgcYYXQy~ZBQgz~Zzg'RVZi0

~~ZzgQpVz*zqIz{Zq6p6{Zzg~ M'ZgQ,VQgz~zwZzgQ|[z Zq6M}

(longinus M}Zk~wH&-VZqzyY)(HXZkZgzZ[5X sublimity LLZg)

RVZq*@g]dZ*C!Zzg(gHQ,V Zzg'q~ ~ZqZ+d^nQ,VU"c)

dg%0t~z~7M$XQ,V dg ZqzWZzgqdZ!VZk/g ~DzBzocZzg)

B~~MDz.ygxy,!:g;X~~Xg!~L~XLQx:Zgcz{ ~r

a,~~~ZDw~~g5kXZDw~i!y!

~ZkZWZZcV7XZp*q~i!yupsHpqi!yg65Zs7XZDwi!y~~p=Vzg]ZkaZHXZzgZK~fg)ZqZ+~i!ywdZzgZ!zgVz{CZzg/Zp=VB

}$XZDwZKzg}Zzg*i]O'i!y~6gXZk5Z:i!y~C]Zzg])Z](BB{gYy7g~7g~&Zk!zti!y

qx(~~k]~ DzZ[*gzZc]8{7X)ZDwZW:g]~zggYYX

ZDwQgz~0t~xFZbZw~XXZDwZ:trwz{zu~x~Z0s?cXZpQgz

sV~]hgZzZ7 poem ZDwz~M_pZXZK4543 XGJGVTYC}{~%FIF

Dk5!Zzgz){Z%*zV~nZM!~zgZqZ,]hgdMZa poem ~Syx4543 XGJGVc

ZyV~ZZ7qZzgZk_!]zZ]nZZqZbZ~ZqZ+yZCzu]zgaZYCZ/'zzZZcc]ZysV

~7HYYXsV~n>>BCXZk~7Qgz ~]hcf!ggZZqZzgMiZu2VZ

[ikZx]hxzVeZZyxzV]hgDyT6lZ!qg]}~ZkzgzZVpqZzgMiZqCqw~]hZBzgtHY*ecXqZzgMiZ]hZkZZ/gcZkZZ/g~aizVF+~wH

'pZDw~Qgz*~ZqZz['0cXTb

ZDwM, 41

%iZQgzwM~zLHZbZDwQgz*0t~yzi!ycZkg*~Qgz

cZDw ZzgQyq7QgzZqq{Zzg;VUZg{Zzgg30XZDwzZ{Zzggqw

wZ_"Zzg{FgqwMHZzgZbZ/!GM Zg~BZ~cXZDwZqw{XZDwC

$zZqZ(0T~]z]FZ!VcXZDw)O\CuZzgM}nz`MHXZzg

Zqb$ EG0Mi(ZzgY2cQgz!gZDw;VZq*xCzu]g6zT~yZCzu]XZDwz{s{g`F)yZzg~ZzgzuJg~ZDwZ{g`BBZ4*MHZzgZZy~:VwHX%~~B

hZg7$XZbZDwZqZ(eHZpuJi05zVF) gzZefzVs@z{

&gZzgZq6Zkq'z{|&ZDwZBuZgQyZB=wL!6{DZyZp~y

HLLZk~Zm~]Zzgg/XZm~]%Zf!Zg7Zq*Zkz~:M@ZZDwf!ZgZzgZm~~Z2gs:DXZDwikZWQgzZq!Z!qg]Z(gXZzgg~qg'l'M!~j[ZM!~ZZZyZZzgZkzu}Z

YMX ;V%ZgNZzgZyg:^~ZDwZpa!hOkZ*qHptZDw>L{ZzgLZ{XZy=q!hOkZq]cXZ

51 ZDw:M,

wZzg{HZkaZq bZDwgf%zZzgg~wZ(gXcZDwQgz~Zq7g}

F0 cXZzgQgz@g6}ZzgzgkZWZ]%AKXp~wz)wZzgzpzg]ZZ`ZDwaZHZkZ+My:pZDwZWZ]Zk!z!ZzgZyZWZ]!~

TZDwizZg6Zq{y:cz:]h~6ZyZWZ]tHY,~Qgz~Zq5/zL{ZDw~BX

:ZDwQgzwT@g@g Z+}sZzg!GMZgXwTg'c]gg}y@g~zgJ*ZqZZzg~T~Zpig6!GMZgseqDZzgZqzu}BigV~}DXwZgezg'eZzgzZC=wF+

~~T~Zk*]Cqw~ Kg3Zk gTZqZZ~zL7Zq*Q|[aZ*)Z:&@XtZqZtZDww~ZZg6TZWJwHZkQ|[Zqii!yZr'^Zzgi!yCZ:]ZgZLZ*fztMMD

ZDwMi~ZLZ*{ycz~pQyZZBX6gzZwZzgZri!yg8cVZk|szgZg{CZDwi!ygzZvV5Z:gV~'pZ;V

ZrQ,Vi!y6CZ:q{zg5Zzgz{Zgwz(Zr~~gzZaZCZDw;VQ| spontaniety $Z>)

y6g]Z(gXpZDwt0:ic{:wZzgZq T$zQ,VQgzwZq*Z]oZq5z

ZDwM, 61

5 5XZk6Q|w~ZDwZZ&6VgZDwwxZgZ]Zzgiz:$wgcXwz

sztsZg{@55ZZ!VMsZg0XY{ wL~)(sZq*xZDww~G

qZy0]2sZzgZk BB)"!uXtL~z{MxZzgZ0MxzVh Vwp

*8XZzZu1~ ZZ@XtL~tZ*ZzgZsytzf[Zyg0VMZzgZ!Zk*]

q XzZu1_1JZzgzZDww)Zy$* EE0LXZDwwZq5'Z5*T

Bz{`bXt* zV~{Z0zz0iqZygixzX zZst*Zzg)

Z]zV~ZgCi!yOZqZ+i!y~M ZDww(wi!y progression sZzgwCwZk7)

*ZggVh~i!yZq*gHXZDww~Zp(OZp*xC7g concentrated centrality %6!GMZg~)

(Z~Zzg-VQgzwZzg~; progressive organic growth)*g/g'xMNXZDwQgzw@i~_"CZzg{gY]Zq5QgzwZLZg~eV$zZqM[0{ZzgT~Gz@{Zzg"t

sZ!7g;ZDw$zZqgcHz!TqxZ!VJcZzgQZq6~vcX )ZC(Z*kg6ZLaZq*Q|[~@

zZgZ]yn-V~~Zq6gZzg~ ! Zkp~Zq6KZ@Zzg)zV(~g

71 ZDw:M,

~p~Zzg~WJ~gz$w*7@XQgz~~Zzg~Qgz~ ZDwGZ(HQ,VZLa6Z2

%zZ2zgZ]wbSc'ZZDwZK~MiHQgz~qZzgMiZ$zZzg]I~~z~M_XZkgzZeM(JxM~zVZzgVM*Cz*'!]7XZkaZDwtzggT~i0(~(~ZMBYZzgZ:z

~eRYXZDwQgz~i!yzyZzgzZgcZk$z7g~Qgz~zV~MCZqz{ZDwZzgZqz{ZDwg]5kX

ZK]gVy ~$ ENg;Zka vV~CCXZ~MiZ6zZiz~MCZ

F0~7H (~ thought a~ZZV~)t : 1YXZzgZy~$ ENZ.lI XZzZk4Zqs

6izg:cYZk|T+~ic{77M$~ZqQ|[cyZzgpyZzgZkZ:~

+g7Zq]ZgzZcZZ%Zk|t~&G7Yy^Zzg~!wXqw,)xZi]zo(Zzg~LZq7tZzg!]*x~Zq(Zz:zwZk!zZ*(}zVc}tic{FWiUw7

ZZDw*z{Z"ZqZzgQ,Vg4Zzg_!E0xBk0HZkg] !gTb~

@Z[~s`,cZDwx7z;VMC)ZDwZzg,xV6pizgc('Z%

ZDwM, 81

'@ZDwZqStz{)ZDw(:ZgZzgZ7g}OgZZ0Zi~y67g~g]gnXZkt7Qy;VzZ7g}6{7z{ZeTzZ7g{ghgZZ0ZyZ(gfZzgZk!zZy;VeR'ZggS

XZDwZq(Zg*)tQ,VQgz~ZbZF0~] ]fg=cXW {ZHZzg$4-3 GGGMg& EHZp~~

Zzg{Zkp!ZDwzZqxZqxdzy]cX ZqZzgZqy,f!5ZzggDz+My~Zzg: Z@g

YZDw]h@g~ZqxNecXtZq*pZg|,f!5y+ZgZ@gz @g

i^m 'we-Zg.Vc 9po L:Xz{Z_54HGy\V]c:VZgzZVJg}

,~(ag7VJZZ0 ~7BZzgZK@ggZ0!Z0zy1Z#ZzggZ!xZy+Zzg!)4GEZ

q Zg@g~PZVZq7Y@ZkaZZDw)\V~7HY@Zk~]!]7xg6,f!gZK@c]f!@gJzgnZzgZLquzZLZkgz)GOZiDXpz{@c]f!@gJz7gY'Zy~VZg}E{7MXqw,~+~ZDwQiZqZqi~xXZkaQ,V]hZg

My~~HX*xF]g6TiZ7DXCZL]@*!*ZL7gzV]Zzg!h) O]g@XZ#yc*~PZq2VZc

fc(}ZZtCz{Z~ 'Z'XZa.q(}\V 6gZ}XZkZgZDwgG)

~*ecQ,VZq5Z435 EGGCZZHZzgZ@g~Lp~cLZ*!3 EGGZkgbz$i EByHXtIIZDwp~g7ptZq|ZDw

ZLZkp~cZ*!3 EGGg67gZpZkgMUgf!@g~.NzqYDXZ_543 FGEiZ

x !c= ZgZ{Z*!3 EGGsZg{@'}y=~z]ZyZbZgDyMsZgpf!Zk~ycgDyxZDwp~~CZbZDwZsgZ]jZi0Zzg]zqZzgZu`Z2Zg

q~ZqZ435 EGGCg6zgSZq Hz{Z)@XZLZm~h]~ZDw

U6MgizZDw7g~*VaZqZkZzgZ7cZyM,ZzgaZk(~]HQy

qVZzgZkZk0X )gzZV~Z ZDw~Z,Exz.yjZ!cX%)

i0=c7$,g}*hV~ZgZ1Z#!ic] NOZxJzZDwZii0o6MZzgxec

(Zzg| idealism }+B3 JEGGZqZ(u`aZHzgec)(ZqZiyZZ`7@XQ,V'Rd*~ realism I~)

MtZqs*zxwZZzgZUJZzgzu~s'}Vz;V$f EIZzg,JzWHZzgVa2ZZg

(ZH perspective C{Da)bzgsZqZ()Tgz~ZZzgZ)bic{MZzgZsBZzgYXZbQ,V;]~zZzgz@8-, EGE]xd*~gsZcZzgz]Z=qZzg=a6ozZgZ]%AKXQ,V

Z.}ig'7XnZDw]hZsZq5q~ZzgZjZVxc@z{p$3

GEgZzgZkgZLZ-uZVB'ZggXZDwZKg~fg)'RZsyZk*RZzgduZV%1oHZzgQgzzZ[~ZzgZM!K%Zizrms~Z!Zzg~gzZecQ,V

Z~ZqxFZsyzZgpZ[ZzgZkpZ[cZaZqZ(~c&ZkVZsy~ZzgRZk MMX

Z\V!)4GE McY@ZDwZZqyY: 9F+Z:t'Z'RV(ZzgZi0

xw s~ZDwZgt,z{9sV~Zqyx qZqxy ~ZC@g]ZgZZD3ZQ)

xbZKxf6_!C~Zzg Y:XQ,VZqVytHQyuzlV ZzgVCkHQy)b

]>cQyV~i0{gQ/ZgQCc ~_"wZg]Zg&"'ZzgZgZ}]Vi0~HpgB

: KZzgZZq7g~x XQ,VZK@|~XQ,VxZ7cz{zVZzg|IZ:X[f!Z~ZqMiZZsZ~Zq6Zsy

ZsxZXZDwZ7&~iZzbX g]5k~Zzg[f!Z~ZqMiZZsxQyz]sw~

ZsxzZu]ggZk|sZg{gZDw M'Zzg%AHZzg~Zzgg~zVV6Zq5Zs*~.e}ZzgzggkZWZ]qU"g;:

yBcygyDZg!0L*pg{gg@uZ!

ZDwM, 22

q~@g]qK~ZDwT]ZgHz{ )tZzgZxzxZZx Zy'Zzg$MiXz{2

Zg~ZzgMiZ~pZ;VXZpQyxKZzgz{Z~7g}tD@Qy,{mg6ZZgCZZxgZjZw6%iXQy~~,~ZzZbZ

Zk]6$GMMXz{ZZZxC6ZZxpB~Zg XMiZ~Cq~QZd'F~Zzg@g

ZZZk*]uZrMXZytg*)Zq7Q,V,~~Qgz~7g}ZZ]ZzgQjVF)ycXZkBtZq|Q,VZs*!

ZDw6~Qgz(}Zzg~ZDw7zX*Zs@q

Qgzc]ig&i}~zZuCZzg~~g1cZZDwMg~ZqzgZzg!gMzgg|cXZqZ!Z7ZzgW~g

wq~~gZKuzzgXzM6zZ[M*gY**kZkazu}!.yb~~q +C45GE

GJc/ZBCZkRszZuCcLL~~mg~ic{7$'ZaZDw~zZCZzgVqZZ`Q~ZzgTZzg_")zZzgZZLZ0g1q~MqxCX@Zk|Zg7HYY@g]ZgZDw~ZqzqzZuCZzg~~:mzggZzgtzz&6~gzWZbfs~MX6~Zq(~gzZeQgzZzgg~~~g]gZzgZDwZqQy~g~

TC@ZDw:st6~ZkxZygzZeg{7HZZLZqZzcX*zx

cVZyz'zgX7YYQ,VzZzg ~ Zzg]4n. IEGg~g~ HZWJwHpZ!]DQyz

en 7g~gzZe'Zbf[sVX~eZ{mQ,V ^8 Zzg, ++j ' ]mp

52 ZDw6~

:tHn*xxZy6~:]qZzgf gZzg. _"Zg*ggVzZ[zu~x.

Z0sz{Zy!g~gcXg~~gzZeVJg}]hFW~J~'~Zzg

w~t MZqzu}~)6(~{gg]ZzgwuZuZ~XZquJt!]gp!ZgpZKg'eZk)zZU"aXZk

3^Zzg e~ZqZzgZqipg3Y@g;XZzgz{t6~SZzg!GMZg~8g~CXZwX)Z(X~g'zZZZgeZzg#MxgZwtZqiZ][/ZzgZg~ZyZ0sZzgb~MgSnZ[~Zk6g

ZDw : $ ENZ.lI 7g~QFzZVB'ZzgZZkb7 EOZzgF00Z"cXt!]ZD1]CDY}ZDwV~wZy^M}~ZbZF0wgn

ZzgZyVM}Zz]'Z`ZzggXzu}/V~ZDws6~Jz7BZzg:wszZzZgZ]0wDXC7 EOtbz{Z0s~b7

XZkZg7YZDw~45454 XGJGGZLZ0g/7g~ygB'pqZwxZzg!"zu]ZzgYQZ0szs07$ZaZZDw6~_

:Z0sgCZzg:6~z{z Dg}7pWZzgDgizgc]aZCX

ZDwzZ6"Vwg]qZk]*Zg(}Z;VXZDwStz{zZ3^Zzg"!GM7*ZdgZ6~~tZqzgCkCz{

ZDwM, 62

Zz9Z{Cz{zX{c0xZy-VUZg~Zzgs~ZZbMDXeZL"0 EG0}Zz0~

~]ZqxzggcHp~z{ZqZzgZq!GM~MCXpzZtf[~eZZzgt~ZDwZ,2V{gYzZCy"g'eZzgs~ZHX

VZkZ%zszg~xC6~Myg~%ZH'!

IZb]Z~Zzg]6-ZDw/LM}]BZDwz+MCkDX* 7gXZ%bC

x(}Z7 EOtf~VZzggz;zVCkXZy7g~]A]Zkw@gZzg]wZ@gX!ZzghqiZb7X]ZgZDw6~z(}V~HYY:

1D]:c~ZzgM2DgzZ:CZzgegZ1D]:c~ZzgM

]ZL{gY]4 IJyZzgz~g'eBZDw~ ]ZzgbCzW:S7~MDc7~_z%ZcBMDk7@XZDwZA>VcQys:Qgzg>Zzg

c]]Cx6ZK)1CZzgz~g'eB{tZzg!]Zkg'ep'Z`Zzgi0Zzg]!g}~Zk1)$ EG0ZzgZk~ZgZg`@Xg6]!g}~ZDwgztzZ:Zzg:Zq]6

Zw7DZN!bX] bz{]C1.Zg&V~HX 6 !g}~Qyf

]XpZk*y~gZ 1D]I~2D]MZzg3DhgZ(gD ]& ZZkf6Zg_7

ZkgxtTZgZDwzZ~@X]z(}ZgbCXBZymgzZw

;h XgZzggX;h XgZKgf_ZZzg^!ZzggZKZqbp:zZzgZ!Zy]zZ

Z]MDgXZgn6zV]YZ;gbCy ZzgZy-VZyZuZg%ZzgZy610~VZ

psXg aZyzZzg*xz*.i0u*ZzgZgn7g~Zzg=}Zka

;]gZ ZyZgBZkmLLZXpC+ZVg6zV~HYYXZqz{LL);h XgI(ZzgZqz{LLd~gIzZXzZ[Zzg!.y~tzVbC]zZgZ](}u`XQgzZzgg~~g6ggc`iyZzg{zC]ic{zZ)ZqZgg(Zkic{#&ZzgwZ0XZzgg)Zqzu}C~Zzgs~](QgzZzgg~~](}~Xg~~~gzVfGX

pZ(dZzgp&76zgcE{'g~~~ZkzgcI~;Cz;]H$ZktZqZ_XpVJZDwfz~*]mz{ZkA~ZZeqXz{0ZzgMtgzVFGIDpg~Zyfz;h XgzVx@}ic{ZPZiq@Zka;h XgZy4q&C.3GGz#ZgZzgZKfZ]~p$3

GE#:

/ph{zaygZyi~ayl'~ZHz>yuZ

LZLM\~%6NhzVbi0xb:YZ!Zzg>"!uXZptZqZtpHtZtZDwZA!!g}~XZkzZ-V~]NiyZkZ*ZkaMc(wZzgZZZkMNazw

]!i~{X x@'tgc

92 ZDw6~

WzVC MC0~Z{C{{{ZC g]C M@

CCYZkZweiZ})w&F~MzZi

wMtgzVZ Z rMZiLg 5Gz{gV6VYcZ z{xT6Z

y;h Xg6 Q@Hg8p4ti{F}gg6

ZkMy~C@ZDwsg6pZDwZkfg)!ggzV*zwZqZ)

~ZqLZgg]Z(g: ]]p X!M^~gzi}!!gz% ;h XgT M[igZ(]Zigz;i*g7l M$zl Z}i0]zyZ*i| hFZ!My_Zi|Z,zgzgfz')4

GGp? ggZi0eg1

'vzZigxZ i0ZiyZ(;- FXGZM 0g6gZXZqgzigcI!X

-V&EOg,X}Z 0 's106QVZzg}(6N~Zzggf~My_ZicXp}0VyZ*izxcXg]}0VggZk~Ztzgt~Zzgt5HpgB?i0yZg]Xi0izy`zuZ*xXNhgcZk'ZzHZzgZk'~zZMs

}DZgzVgc}J~byXtyZ*iT?fgZ~+'ZLx*gZ+ZLM\

ZDwM, 03

M{7ZaZLvy6g;XZi!p~ NnyZ i0'Yp!6yZyzZg~zgZi2 y;z0g

ZWcMgy ik 4h4- XGG!6z@zyg

fgz>{ZZ "ygxZ Mi6zZo ZuZ 0

zZkzZ0z LL@^L(;- FXGZg t M[gZ'* gzzZ0g*g

i0ZLx6z0*xXczu}/V~p~!rYw*xXcVgIZzg}0Vi}~Xht&$4 MGZK2wzgVX~z0ZzgMVJVXVJp6z,}Z~MgZxHX~g~Y"yYCZ~~*g}>{D~MMVZuZg

(;- FXGMv~Z(z Zzg}yVMzZiFX~[ZkZzgCZ1X}w~Zzg~Mv'ZkMv60

*g7YXZkkJgCse ]]p !

ZgzZZz{C'!z{ZDw~~XNhzV ~gzV fZz{z0Z0Z_iZnZzggpZyfuu~

zu}0]zZ-VZzggzVZDw{pQgzZqX {p&

]MzZgZ#u%Z}Ze0gzV~

~X)gsy~/ q^m^ NhzVZzggzVoyzg('ZDw6 Z yZzg PZig;]CzZI

13 ZDw6~

ZqStZ,zZj[67g~qXMZzgc~a,zg~CZx~DZzgVZ"g'-z;VZqCqgbPzVZzgZqzgVk~Z

~e0Zqg-VyHX q^m^ aZX0.xZ0gZyr agZy'zg=Z0gzpgZlZr {gZZi-.

EGIwZrZr=zgZ$ZgMz| zz']4-B IEGEVg|

gz"M[ "s[ ; @& ELYgZ{-gZi+C

M[Z0gc @)ZizZzaKy n/n# gzj[Z0gZyzZ~gzZy

Hz``z`` gZ{ Qz-z 7]ZZ]Zk;h Xggxy)Zk%vMxNhZ~(ZqzZ~"gZzg"cz'vV60zV*xzVJ:XZkzZ~Ne0xXZkc~g`M\%YZkzZ~

~0g}Zq1!EMgXKV0~b.3CXZkgzZMz-'Z'XHZzg`g`Zzg.3C0~z{XZDw9zkZzgo%Zzg1JVXLgVFIZzgL+.ZyzkNZzg/seq@g~~

Zzggz.Xu`zZMZzZ%v 8 ~ZZzg~.Xgzci~

ZVJgZzgI~cZzgj[LZzg.3C!gz0~.X+.Zzg&B5 EGE]c]Zi:ZDwf6ZqSMZzgc~~ZgLXZDwZqZzgxf(~Zzgwi~BHX~L)~6ZzgZkp]fZkbD:

gwZzDZgZY:Za Zi%Zh[:cz{gnz#-C4 FGFGI Y{hxZiz{FZi;l':Mhg8z1 !{gZ;h XglXMZzZiZyyZ` Qz'Z` ui$4/GE

y i{'@Zi gc:EO{!iZy!TL6%Zh[:7'ZkJ~DZgzV*VyXZkgZ2V{gZ5$4 MG}7AZygZ2V`zn~xYCZkNhzVZ~u!~ZzgZ!l:Zk!

33 ZDw6~

g8z1z1ZgY3X)p(tui}Z+Zk'Z`gnXZkZwzVyZ`fXZkcV~!izV

l!FgTX!iXpsZzgi{'Z0ZxgTX(~gZDw images gzVzZhgZ])

ic{z]~@ZzgQZq{meZPZi@XNhzVZ~gkZy !z N)S NL!(5 LEX NL!uq%Z

4q*gSXQlZ!gz{zQ]V?Q%mYwZ~c6cVgZ0ggZz}Zz}YY))c' N?gMC!ZzgZkCCg`y

($ EG0tZqkX{ cinematography ukM)zZqT~lZ!gz:~%mZi~'fgZZzgdZYV(ZzgZyg8QY'kZzgzZZzgdF' N6MC3c&g`y'hgX!rzgZrZzg1Zgz!V0]~ NL!ZDw8[F+f6(c

(X image g)aVlZ!ixg!Z}Z*YYzY!0Z*Zi!'hgZz;h Xgz!'hiZ0p2\!&4- EGE

jy1Z Z+mk0 YGr

ZDwM, 43

z]6XL0gZysy n^ZKfZ]#XZ[ZqZyL!'TX

Ziwg)G My>Zx7Zi%z6zZ:&45 GFG

ZiwGU~ ~)!(z{>Vz6zZ:%Ziw!p3X!B ~ZDw!XL ^o^ '

L0Z~MCX e^qfm (identification ZDwr)t f t

egZCZkZgZ$4 MGZgZ2wV~Z}0Z{Vt{z#zg:^ I0#$4 MG^ I0#

gZzgz!rZDwzZMgzZVMCXtMgzZVZy~~MtgM[ZzgM(|gcZzgg

~sZqz(Zzgz{xg7 q^m^ Xgyp3'pp3MgzZVE{XZBV~LZqMgiz~ZDw])g"0cVpZZgDMD

XZk~egMgzZVk~s:V !0zVY+1LC}C}

0~s0kg;wdZ(;h Xgg{0`0QJQJ8Ml~i~cZ!{

QQh-V~0g;

53 ZDw6~

0gg N5@Ms8

0~Zzg;h Xggk\'T$ EG0Mi!Z~zZ0~XL*)ZyzV~C:

Z=u z{;k5 XGVQ+(}`3 Q7NhzVwot Zot

iC{6 ~gcZzggoz(QD'Zq q^m^ii6p3XgciC{'s7lNhzV gciC{Zzgzu}

CD: i0{gz zZT!g}~zMyZi'sZayZm My;k5 XGyMy"MDgZFgzZi'zy g$FLZzZky

wm g'ZZzj ZzgZ / `zz{y'z{Nh&x7McXz{TaV'sC~e0~ZmgxCZkZqVgT!ZkC

ic{MDg'Zkg~:QC:yMDXZk'Z`~Z(jyLiZb7@X

cZ1zaM"zZ% d'pzZQz/ zZ)'@gO QzqzZ)"g8z1

ikgcL[Mz czg WWuzZ0gzyuXzZyz% {;&zcyzu

gg}aZCBwcXchtZ0b3XZkgZ~Zq"g8z1zZ~XZ+zZ~T~@gVZqzu}nXZk%6czg{ WW7zq~X)A(e0nXg~QFMcX)QkzZ~~(NhgzG%XcVZzgQ}XZy~

ZDwM, 63

z%ZyZzg6.yMXZyo~p+uXp3XgT

)ZDw(P]aci0{cXZkyZL i0{gzM\b0@:

@i\:. XI"iYy Mhx:-C YEEgyy'zyygzy phx?hxipy_5 IEYy!wz6j[g8 gZgZyagxZi

(;54EXGEI%{'i 0{#Ciy N0ggpy digZZyqx0ZgxizggQz& py!pyZ0gU

$4 MGXz{Zp~y7YXZkpszb[:Y@X$4 MGHXZqgpy_mXZ(gTZ0g

yZzg!CyXZ~,ZDZzgQbg~)g~N(XZyWZzg60g}bXzVbMh3zZZypsV6%YDXy/zVi6Zqxajy7X9/9"3I^I^g~C)Zzgg'0C(p3Zqzu}BZgXZzgQV~Zq3gXZyVVl!ZkR%Z0Zi{YZDwZMsb

DZy0g{ggZ7@XtZzg!]gyZDwic{ZZbq7@XzzQy4q]cZYc%;k5 XG!V6gzZZzggVzZZghZDw~ic{7XZk:eXZDw4qtgmgpzZgZYDXgVDg~ZyZZ*sYCz{M

73 ZDw6~

PZV.7gTX@Z7g}Zzg]uJ`zgcZDwIh{]XqwZDw6~~]ZzgZkbCy{mZq]}$ EG0Mi}$ EG0Z!xZzg}gZw@i{x

9>c~zqC}' e^-] agZsZqz9XLg*~MiZkb@:

{Ms eg> yG0k MV!wtggZ]{l~ e0!Zkg{l~

g]Z{s '* gZg]Z{sCfuZ0g !

?Mu Zzg{(xZgBp objectivity CPZDwM{g)

Zk!zZDwTc1yDZk~ZqbZzgaZXZkbz{c1Zqi0{Zzgg|3

{mw*ecXzg:Z" 4XZZDwzYyzZCZLZi0{3DVX-VZDwxF~

MZzgc~MgZ3XpoZ,6~Zy6Og6*i$XZy~Po6]yHY@X

lCo {le0;h Xg!7l{l zZ~Zzl{lMl~ ]"l

myZxjV Z(j]\Vt"gZgzZV @gzVlgzZVg]%Z~c {lzzgc

)Zqx:gcm);w'v()g}6(

ZDwM, 83

zi0~V8g* FI0M[g0cVgzZV

Ziw%eu6z waDZgZq{icV

ucz$1VghGGV Z}g8'8

0uZ'+B5EE

GR6*V Z=3x gr

MvcSOIKj[QOHZkx*g}gzZV

( ) gc?$4 MGSugZ]" i

w~SuZCZ[j]ZZZM{gc3xZVtgcc%GLM[

pZg Zg}~Y@'pZ[ s}ZV~^

gZ]Z\V]MV~ZL[ r EMX Z

( ]V^ )

(:CZzgegZ situation 2DgzZ)(ZyzVy event (~pzZ) situation gzZ)

ag};V]ZbgZg']~eZzggzZe(|x)egZy~egZK] narration g )

Q@'tzf[W~~ZqpV%`g

93 ZDw6~

t~]cqg~zuZ*xC~xbz~d]btZqQg~p@ZkZg7HYYZ

(YZk~gzZ expression ~Cby'ZzgZg)(7Zko simple yZipY@XgzZL{)

~FbZgVZyZ~Dg(Y@XZk~Zgcek?g8 complex zZy%)

gznz{xZbZMYDgzZ~zyMXZDwgzZy6ZqcGZy6'!ZzggzZZ!kMD'VgzZ

ZqLxg45 XG'CZzg e^-] ZqVwc,'zZ~ egZy4+%:XZk~ZgzVZ]45 XG( ;CZaZ~XtgzZ~g6ZqZg)xg

zZhpzZZzgZgzVZqzu}z~zyU"D(T~ZqZzo5k grim 'gqw'@gZq)

)TZk6pZ&g(ZqzX:].'MiZqZzgzZZ)fZikzZs~LpX

g45 XGga6zgBg~M@

wxgV0 cZItZ0Z0:MUS

>zZk)]ewx*i'

cM{![gZy$z{zZ .VX0

ZDwM, 04

iD*iux6RgzZVgcpVPZ-VhF

M@gZk -4kJ"H]V #QJ$$M@!VZTCg3MXZzgQa

Z gc0 upZ[0ZZkM\V

gZ0QQVZzgg~wx-VDeec?:ZLlg%Z?Y*z^zgMgZcHt%ZZkge

=geZ}1tgZiMyg}i6

*xTgy('Z`cV'pZkzZ~ story ZkzZ~ce)

hZegZ7Zk%~Zgxgg45 XGZ0ZizZZgaZc justify 'g45 XGg~wxZqMy~ZLM\

'ZzgZkyHXpg-VZzoZZzgg~wxagqwp~ZZe7z{g45 XGZkegZ|xKg~gLXg45 XG,Z0ZWZzgk~ZDwz{

14 ZDw6~

-EEOw"ZEwKZqegZiXZkZzgc*u~ZDwxyz5wgqwZZzg/ZgLZgZ

'Zk c'ZzgZkx6a Nfg)'g45 XGZL}szZWzcX

gzZyZzgZgg~%Zg~ZDw>kuZqzZ '*g{Zjy'k ~ VwgBX}Z1ZY!O

(egZ1JVZzg%@ dimensional c.GLz){'ZDw6Zz~){gYg]5k~'Z]Zzg@WZ] Zu] z 'bCZgZzg

(ID detachment _mC'ZDwLZLaegZe)g (gSX involved pic{FZyfZ]gqw~7g~b)

qwse7g~bQYaz{}m7DXt{LZgzVi!y@ZzgLpY+dZzggpzB

Z,z ZN[M}Zzgikz/gzZ7gZ7gZBXg'zZ(Zzg:'nL6 tempo (Zzggg) mood Zj[MizZxe)

gTZzgz{Tq xZbZzZzgMMzZ*Cqw~ZDw7Zr eTic{ZzgTeTxfXZysV~z{L

ZzgZxs/zg]o('6~s@g~ZDw'%eZ'ZzgzzKZzgMMX

KKK

ZDwM, 24

gw G Zzg ZDw/!{ NEW%ELypgZ+!Zz

! 1;- XEZ x Z/Zz:g~)ZDw(

EL W]-ZvmzzbzzGNCr

az

z!X]6Z|] \W C4 YZzgz{Zzgz

ZsxZZ~;8 NELgwlZregZ&EYL~gz!gFZzgQgzic{FVdZ!ZzgRi!3g$ EGLg=weVwg~)ZzgQgz~(~~

fz

+Zt5ixZ*gO~{m,kZzgz{Dkq*g6Zq{mic@XeZrZoZxBCzu}}ZkDk

GpZDXguz]p~z{LLz{1V~g0zZzqDDkqWy~XQ{m%[

XZkFQywW@Zzgz{Z"Z(ggz7DXZbZ{C8 YCQyW@zg6Y'X

ZsxZzggZsxmZ}>zZ?xQyzZA:^ZVBQyZ~)~WNXZDwZCZg;ZzgZ'LzZZyZgz]u*Wy*ZzgmZ}>zZ?xXQy

T"0cVo] fZZ [ xZq5/{gZg@ZiILgwz{Zzg7HYYXZDwx

~GV_[zZtizuzgZzgTz]YOWCZDwfZCi0~Zy]z_!]%UZxfZzZ]Xto]cZyZg~Z7gZzgWZ0Zi~CZZDw'Y~Zzgzu}ZdgZZ~9}MDXgZx-ZvmzfZ]zZZzgZDwasZqfZCgDyc

7g~i06 sZqZN~X7ZqZkZzgQy0ZkZzgbeTX Zzgz{Zk_"7g~Q#

Za:/!{ NEW'ypgZ+!ZzZ/Zz:g~x1;- XEZ8~0Zzw~xz{5091YJZtx e^-]

~ZDw^EL-g\Zk8~01]~Zqw\Z(gwZg$ EG0Wi MM ZZDw~~Qy_!E0G

z{\:

ZDwM, 64

ZZ+yz*VZ}ZDwQhZ&A NEgsi}!8~0zx~5091Y8091YJi~ e^-]

!3 EEN]6Zpr0 GGT~ZDwB_!]!g7gZZ0Zi~C7'@m5091Y~^EL-g\Wi~d~i~ZqgcZq{

l!Z0Zi{YiILgw_/ZDwi0C%~Zqh~ZzgfZCseq_!CzZg6g;tZzgk

~ZYZv{V*xZzgQZg~ZZDwZZzgf6i0"_!C]~iILgw%~wzZatZqsZZDwsF+[YYZk

~ZDwZL^ZZ{ZjZw,)tQyx[b]g~%:(Xt7Ly21m5091Y7LyE}BZkb@:

Z[idW@Y@ZzgP[V~gZiyYX7L[gfztztZkzw~aZcZkZ*VHnzV'weLic]ZKW\VgzV:

Zvg}{0W'zpgZOu.

Z}[ui}!Igu!ZqT*zgzVgc1Zqda}ZY6HZ\V7|c{*dzy

!r5iVCV0kVzh5p C9 6gXCV5iVg!r!CwcZzgtA NF6zZ:

X?W{!Z}0uui}!z{(V!rpgH@k5YNGcCV!rw( FNVQy*&VWiZ}X}

74 gw ZDwZzgG

gVDZgzVlk$ EGILxAZzg~BENgzVDZgzVzCVZzgViW[&BENpg3Xl}$Zg{u}gefgzV~}!V~QhCQ}ZzgWzZg~i0@gqVg{!l~}ZV~NHYVZzg*xVWiZ~!\~PZZzg0VWV6zZ:@ZZk0uui+~YVV-V~ZfZw:WzZiX

C10 gZZDw ZiygQ21mZDwx~kzV~tic{ZkZZDwZ:

Zzg_!C4+%:ZgcYYZk~ZDwi0r_/NZDw NMWg~Zk@ ZkbFXLTb@

~~z{!gc&Qy~ MMXLZ}0uui}z{(V!rpgHXLl~}!V~NHYV'ZfZw:WzZi MZDwZkLZh:s

g}dc*WzZizV~ZkZzgZk/ZqiCcXZkA NFZDwZLZZz~WtcQ#~Z,_!]Zg`tZDwz

~~pZkzZ[ZDw~0gzV~g3YY'cQ#FI~ZzgZkZZegsLgzgnZyegZZzVZq{mqsB MM

XW}1: NE6sCk@Zkx6M~_!]zZ]Zqi'yzg;XaWy~)

sB(g:VZ! Z=

wzYy!Zep=pl-GEZks~ZgZ{'ZpZZg6gzZe6$GM

ZDwM, 84

gw~WzZV~QyQ|[Zy pSZzgszV~Y@:

Wx7ZV* ~QZ:wZg]w~/ZV* Y L' H L[~Zz

L~zZ Z}bV~gZZZzg& EYLlcZ Z}FZ. EGL~ze0e00ZgZZ Z}6$GMF};B[$ENg

u0tZ Vp p7{g;FZ6zV~0Z i &GL6 *i|! N.

T'!z{H %jxqH HVQ#Zi~ZDwz{Ti:

{Ng6QVz{)[~W$DZg!0 NE

tuJgzZ]6ZLLFc

94 gw ZDwZzgG

ZDwgtQyQz~mgBptxZDw~z]q1{Q,VZL%x~7HX

QyV~8091YZzg4291YgxyIQy~L{ e^-]6lxZqXLZqqYgZ5~'T~CZk

i^ELZ]z&

icVZ0Heu W{!t=Zzg@WWg"!u

Tzg~ZDw{ZzgZ{>Xz{*aZqKZzozZ_gi:ZDw*Zkgqw6!z"@[z"ZggTXZ{ZDwZ$

LzVjZZq'LLg[~'t!gt~~Zqg~yC)gW!G0Lg'~YD!gt~[HY@:

ZZi F~ !si gZ}2F~)@*i upYxwZ

6zZi 25agf *zV hZ Q!V'&EYL1Wcg}zZWHjWc?

lTz{i07Q g!C~W7QzT~1z{7Q DZgzV!z Ngc~qZk~~7Q 1~2gZuWcV

F~Q#W'zZk~Z$LzVZk~

LZ{!gZm~L{~yK]zZ]Z[ZDwiILgwZq7g7CXZk~}Zz&ELzksV[D'+ Gg~iz#bxFZgZnqziILg=w-Zvmz~:

GC-!}QY} C~Z\L

ZzzV~@+~LZ\LyZzg']E{H:

15 gw ZDwZzgG

:tYwF:C~V&4g GEO: m

t:Q:n:C~V&4g GEO: mZ#uZ*{Z*x"3EEELW{Z*x

;h Xg~yZy~ ~Zd~`Wl~y~u%Z!y~Zzg7{yZZy~

0ZZxtg{Z$JAA ^ gf

LZ{Z!xT6@z{ZMwZq$ EG0z`:z}tVqHbz}

),8191Y(ZDw e1p ),5191Y(Zzg ]]p~Zzg/ZzBgXzxZycVX~ZDwxZ]zZgqYZzg%1oZ0Zi~y'ZpZDwZyz

-VpQyi EE0p~Zzg]ZZ--V~XQy:'Zzgi EE0ZxZ]Zy-V~W^ZDwz{ZqZgZ-]=z

)BZ-~ZDwz{ 'z{cVX$zZDw'LgzZz[W,xT,~~$GLZsZZ~ZzgZi0

~Zqxp'0c'Zy-Vi~ZDw_!E08 NELgwap~ ]]p ~'hzZZzg~zs~zaZ'L

ZDwM, 25

ZPxcCZkaZk~ZkqjZ!sZq(e1

'{Zqg1XZkjZ! C12 |]Zx1x.G~ZDwpqd/ IG~}cXksV~R9EMZqd

]]%^o Zi%GLZWZ(gHz{'{LL~}931zZV: q^]foo]n

^$n&u$]f^o]q ]u$]$jou$j&BENpyg~Z@gZ)Zzg#|V W\-Zvmz(ZKQ#ZKZgrFuz@0z[yz gzi@gz

ZDwM, 85

EGLuZ+] Zi!0Z+]

ygZpZW! gy\. IL]Zz!(ZZ+uZW[z "Zi*1q~;*{;{ugZWx% @WZi L

Zi.zpW{ fg{Z. YGL$z{ZiZ[zZxk0 YIG08[F @%ZQ'gze'$ELG%Z. Z}~gZZ.Z$k5 EIEOpgZ fzh{Z,Z0gZgd.EGLWyZ z CZ Wc"

$ MZzg 8g FIL Z}zr-ELZgzgZ+!ygZi{gx0u 6*xeu

{i0pZ[Z}z{ gi0[W\ Z}z{W\!g{$zZgrZzgWyW\!1 i}W\

WZzg( ZW\zggzD)W\L ZW\ Fuz@0z[W\xX]%W\

*~i0lZrgzHW\ Zk](ZutXW\%Zk*W[z Lx(ZK" VuZg~2XW\

ZL$EMEML0u~WvgzZzg {6*xZzgq{XW\

{uWxcW\Zszc]fzV$z{ZYZz!3EOg6~ f{ZK|z]W{XZW\

=V!\ic{8['Z}1x.G~eg 7~W\zZXW\

&ANE'$EL>)%Z8XL~(HXW\&A NE

Z0fzhZka~ZKOq7T}ZZwZqWc"C)gz7(ZzgZ}ws)~~(~Z_ELWyZzgqZ}z{W\)wiVZzgW\8g F

ILIgu

95 gw ZDwZzgG

JzVNg'}*k6{euZzg&A NEZ,Zk!r)Q!GL0(0uX

2Zs@g~zR6z"uZqZq d

${GOs!qzZz\VIi0ZZ~U6Zzgzu}z{[qV~$GN*ExZaZZzg!syVmDZx6tzVV Nxzug}Zzg@gz6eZZzgZ")[rV

ghD(Zs$GLi0ZzgZsi~kXZk~Z(97Zka 7sZzgDZxszZgb

tzV"gzu~rVZzg{V~$4i EIEN@Zkg~%ZzZhV0Xp${ GOs"ggZ]zZLZ~1'g]${ GOsZzgDZxrV

WiVZzgmZ][]7Iz;V"3EEO]gztt[fgZKZp gZzg|

Zy[fgZM~5zqzZgZ]$45 GGGESgZaYYZke~#^E0@77g'85 FNE8ENV8ENV#^E0@ZsxZNZ][Zzg;C1VZqZ435 EGGCx~eJs

g t gZkxbZW`XLL| t LL|[;CZzgZN~z=Z0Zzgi EE0zu]

t LL| Z!Z|][Z+Z0Z!Z"g!Z0Z!XgZ+E~c~fg)Z*ZB5 EGZWJwDLSt7HXZkZyI#^E0Oy+~!ZZzgQyg$ NgZ+Zi~s$ NgZZkg

z=e~)!

ZkIt$ EG0(ZDwZ0Z!zc~A~Qy)Z0Z!( t LL| Z%]YV:V'

t=~}| ^5WDXZpZDwt]zg ZbZEw7pQ,VZke~ZL| t t gdcZk=YY'4q| t =%]H?ZkZwZ["u,ZzgZk*yZ

_uJZzVZkaZkgZgS%iZZgwZy]~: Zgfg)yHY@Qy~LLX

yu!G0LGNk WcGNk! '&BELZxzWi Z~!EN60Lipegf~gl pzZZ$p EI0uglilZzwgYxZg 9ELZky*xZg

!*i~;Z:t gli0L$45 GGGGLWtCf{ y%WZZ)$h EI"6{'bZv lgZ{ Z @%ENgWs

M !* i!&EL9)L}Z]INzi%GLy6zZUZz / Zz i*Yy-ZU{z{gpZx1 gZy]zgZiTz1hgWcp a8jEL8 GGG{Z0]g87 iWZuqZzWVO1 "3 EGEEz ~ iZ'Zuq

C14 qZgZZk! Zziq@gZZk{lzZOg ]z'Zgw~Zq|

Zg~ZkbyD: w w%iZd"@[Wy8XL*c[lcuXpg_5 IGLy@[

16 gw ZDwZzgG

ki+gW>ag8Z4~i+g7lZ[tgZzgZkzu}gZ]sZy ZDwL|

Zg~Zg{H:bZzZ2[45 YEELWg8}~x[LW[z{u~}gzrfgrc NW[

z}w% EGLz!mhZ)"[

tFZZ:~iZxs[ @ Zxs[Z

~*izV%Z0=#[z8o-B EGENGgzZCZ[

LLW[z{u~}gzrX MZDwt]Zzg!

z]ZyLLGgZJVY@Zk~Z|zaZY'XGZzgzkZaQ,VZsZEwH:

LG!{ NEW GG}ZgwG}Zx

Y C15 Z#^E0@'Zzg!

z{i0{gzg]~!k5 J0L{'.3 GGG6Bf:Z0Zi~IDWDZzgg{!zsDI:

zkz@ZeZZg9*GraZ

CMZZkz@ZeCk%ZZ2]Zzg@Ze%ZMzkz"3 EEO]Z2]{gY#Zzg@ZeX]

s~Wy~ ZXncznzq{Zzgf'ZzWt'g`9*GratZDw'h=_cD

ZZsDZkb'h=!i NIZkZg{7)Z,gZ'gy!i NIZ( NEc]7Nz~Z4 N \B NEEgZlF

Y@)WZilZ~Z(Zk6'`zZsZ0Zi~H:WyZi{'zhWgiz C|g&EYLz1c~iZ0g!{ NEWZ ci$EN!{ NEWZzgZ

V}?g8z1)LZkV(u)d'z{*T{uWgizQL?dcz{t@$ENg;c[[X

cZZkyl~XpZDwZkZ[7C'Zzgz{gh'`

7y:WyC*!{ NEWZ aLO Zi6p6yWyWhgz WcO~Z0gz

)Z}'`(~7VZp7t)@~7V(z{CT*x@Hz{W)(cz~ZCL

tZq Lz6}~C@?)Z*ZB5 EG4q|CLLZmg]~C@XZDwZgjZtZw7bg(ZkZwZ[~L'`ZqZzg6izgZ[)Z"ZDw

ZDwM, 46

]@g]ZgZy]@0g'`]m7cZi@0g'`Zy]}Zg7H('`H:

{Z pgZp{ &4FGILZz4>{ZiZZzWxzCZ Zi:

EXL!FZ {WxZziWxZxZ 8XLZz[ZYZ

'y; ; Z0gzzkZ: k; g] {h_5EYLZy { YZYjy {

uZ0ZOgZz q} v{!g&-

EYGZz"g8z1 CZzCZi{ {gZz { !ZZ"Z {

{baLOSZv W{ iaLO{ lFpZ${ Z[$zZz{

gZgz] { Pzb] {@:|Zi!3 MGG! aZi+z

} cX{ Qkti}ZCgZZkZLW\{!FZkaz{WxZzgCXZkC:!:Q'z{

kg]@ZkZ]0Ly~ WZzgWx7F{YZZzgYV*V)YyhzZ( zkZy~$wYDX{

Zzgq'Zk z{hZzg_5EYLZVXLZzgqZzg{C' auZ0ZOg'Zzgz{)TZOgHYg;({

ZZpZk ZzgC{XuZ0g8Zzgz{"g8z1X{gZi Z7X{zxg}zxZX{

Zk W{7X{ZZvZZzgA NF7XMS[ZZg{] { JgXZzgZZkic{?!]eL M:z{

|xzZ ]gZigzyXZk!zZyPzV TzX{)Z}W\7 ^nk]nk]#^ C7YZJ

56 gw ZDwZzgG

xF~~:X z{cVZg,Zvg~( g,: ZDwfzhZgVsZg{HX'`H ZkZ[

Zz'p$h4 GIGEygzZy hZWyMyiy p@ayZz!JZzYy gyi~aygwZzYy

ZzaLOZiZuZZz

:zkz { %W> iZQz%*; NXEZ,& M75 FGZi@Qz weiZZit-.

EGL0Qz

gWQzzZ{Z 0 LWlZrWzg{ZRR4Wh $EM'> 'lZ!{ NEW6zZU QRZiZ[U

l\.ILw'GLW[ Z fg{ QRZi&LhB@[

AZ(ZZqZ})-Zvmz(hZgzVZyh}cV)!V(~QkQ~gZ?QVbZzgNh V {

UzZ6zmcXZkxzZV](JcZzgXQk]C6Z(hcQkW gVuZg~

Zq@i{ygHXZkWx"5 FGL{~Zq5zbY7~'ZzgVQyWVz!g{yh1XZkggZ6Z*]W>zVZzg"zV]WiZ~)g(Qkt-. EGL0uaZ

jZ[Q;VEXqDZgzVlZrgzc ] ZXtZk

3Z6s6391Y~ZgZDw0w~Z{VpZ[~Q,VcZKFg~K!g}~g[~nzXtzcpZ[

~uZ{VZZz~gg[~ZqnZcwgXpZk~ZDwZKFg~ZjZwyZzgWgiz

6Q!GL0ZjZi1Vylxg3@VszZgDqcsYY:

zZg;yZ+xgZZiF%v Z}"egygZiz'v@i{~GgZ !]zoGgZ[!&EYLZfZy gfz ELZzYyg^IELZ06$ENgZiS[ izuzgZiZ[

xyZz{u }Z;74-EGGZiy

Z]IL] Nyz @}7qZcEL6zg0LZo Z+!Zi"0coxgZZg/LZ0g2g fLufztzuzg_Z0gCgZOz Z}xz2CgZCzZipZqZZ] w'GL]

Z}C{w'GLgyx /Zy~

gZ ga$ &=XL':yZzyFZ!igzglZ'm !6*gZZgxU

pgZg$ZiZg 6 Z}zgc%ZcZyc @i)Zv0ZgxZyqZgx*ZzwZ piIGL,L"qZ\ NL%GELZgy Zg7{Zi8g F

ILy

pgZp! Z}Z~ NgZ[

ZDwM, 86

Z}z{"egzVeg{iZzgO]XZkxp%v]W\6ZGV]zo]cZzg6Z**cVZzgZVfz*~W\iZzgW\ZfZyWzZiZ[izuzgg~'gZ]~S[gzY

)W\x]$z(:y)YgzV(ZC}Zc:~VZzgYzzVWuqcX:6ZGVW>}KX:] NyzZ

"0cVg~a ZsHptW\W\6zgZyXW\ffztzuzgutW\Q#ZZ

L~2ggXZ}z{W\CgZCz2wZzgxC)]W\Zs@~W\ w~W\w*

sZqZZ]pZ;VVW\p~C{{~Z!5GLxW\szhWcVXgzVaW\ic{Ns~W\VZzV'~gZgZ])Z0}(6*gzV)f[Zzgf[62V(kg;VZka}lZr~hZ%ZzgeZwa~ZvZZzgZy7gZkac=Zgc!Zp~/k"qgp}0kZqgKq&wZ~*zVg3ZZkaZk6W\h}\ NyZ}z{W\ NzV1Vic=ZLg~!Zyxy+bZZzZg~Zz&GLzZs~V

gXZDwgZ"3EGGLZkZ7gZxfZZ~ZXZqiQVt!

~;CZzg:]BLg0{fZzgNzZywX*VcH t7HXZDwZLx~!%(tgZx

Zy~PZqt:bZ2[W!G0L]!-

ELkc[C}Z0gz_w'GL]

{xz2CgZ{z[z!&EYLZfZV]q$L7 ELx8ELuaLSZvPzb]gZgz]Zg$ENgdW[

Gg9*Gr={?Z5454EEGOGE')-Zvmz(

ZDwZLWy~]~ZLRZx[cXZk~siQyiILgwZ~g;'z{0LWt[Zkx

: Zzg&BELgwWy~xxZka!g!g("Zzgg$o-+E

GZisiWh*h uzgC!iWh*hZ*gZiWh*h uWgziZ+M}siZzg!h5 NIEgZQZOWc z{)[zZ:Wc7?ui}

7?'ZkMiU/[ZzgZ*gZiW'c7'??z{^FccQ#'Zzgzu}ZgzqZ

Zk6ZZ[%iZZr:Wiy7ZxZYW!

VWizZxzVGz!i NgZqi0ZiZZ@Z'Q!GL0ZzgT!|. ENy s ~zVZzgZkZ&bzFzV~w M

7yz]Zzw6iIL)-Zvmz(g8zW,g;XZkGzIgu~H!g{Y@X

KKK

ZDwM, 07

jZm910212X egwlcK epF fZ! 1D

52X msZ 2D601701X m Zs 3D

i^t! 4DZm14)fZ!Z1ZEZYm011(X u^n( )Gyg7g~: 5D

)x845|(X ]]vj^o 6D!Zi*ZX ]f^^( 7D

^l]f^! 8Dz{wT=ZDwFwZLh]~YOdzV6Zzg 9DZsxdu`!g}~LqdZ]0X

gX593Z'5091Y7X ]f^ 01D!zZ[~yZy~|]y0U"Tic{ 11D]z=qBz{|Zx0G1x.G~xg6Zx1x.G~*xYYDJZw806|_.7ga3121Y^ZqNzm~aZM

g''Fr-

L&EM"EMG^ NZpzq@7H g }#~qZzgZCW]:sQscZKegZkLi:$h43GIEGEWit:

e^k^fo]njfjnj^mf

LL^ N)8/*x(7ENZZkW`ZwzVZk~ZwZk{~bTtZZ:HZzgz{izVZZXt{Czg

g;F!V~ZkFZWZzgF Zzw ~czsZzg-g\Fi!V~ZkFZWZzgXZkA~

JZzt V g!g[egz{Qy{0Zy~ge:DZggnZyh1QtegZ~Zzg#0kgV

~WXi0Z!]+ NW)zZ(YZ~Zi ! J#vZZ%ZYZ4

GG(ZZg|]/gztZq!gi

Zq@zbZq:LLZL!\p~iZgXZgG|]/:?Zcz{[ZkA NF?cz{Z!Xizq!z"uplZt3xp3'Z`TZZ0u!iu NIZzg}Zz&ELzkZzggzbZ6g6ZZygXi!\z{pZk

fZX zV>Zzg&YZzgzVZzg+>. EEG[.xX,76ziZg].2431X n^len 41D

z ju^ln ZyZq]zIte~Z>])} 51D(z{|]ZU!]**~>])!Z^[ ]^o]^]^

_HYYX ]m]^15D Universal Time.16D Temporal Time.17D Aboslute Time.18D Subjective.

KKK

ZDwM, 27

ZDw@g zyZzgZ]41 IFEZggz~ Z0

z]h+i EE0zesqgn'@g~Meaning in ) i^mn6` *&ELZgcXgwBZK@;

(~LL@gXg6pZL~*&ELZ[ Hisotry=(X@g])cZqw(YcWy~|x]7 )*.

C@gqcx7X@gZ:iaZZ:nXg!g}~t @ C1 ZkaSy@g]/'*x!g]X

$h40 EEGS]hZzgQyf6gz-V0@z~ ELM~xg6@g@g~zl gWDX*\VZzg+

{k5 EG:Zk!g}~uz2]Dg@g!g}~gw'@gs2C@g7JM'Z

|sZg{@@g~l* ELpwZq=tea@g55gZjZwaZCgSZkagz~qwcZLw!g}~7 N7cYYXZk=

s@g&ELZzg&EL=&ZzgZZq]1C@XZk~CqcC%ZKZVZK}g;z~zV~gw74n. EGFZy@g]!]!g}~HXLLp)(g~|K~7XZy'VZzgm

37 ZDw@g

ZzZgZZzgz)z(~ZygZY+ZzgK~7QXZk~7@gC~pZ+gz~*i0Zzg'V|x}nZWy7Axg6w1Y@Xz{+])~7D@gZq"pczZu]Z(gZg7}MX~s~g*:ZDw4q@gZq?|TZyJYZzg

seg~7X@g!g}~ZDwZgZq%1oi EE0@gwgnXZk~ZkZZZwZi EE0@gg~

ZqZ(x H%ZX$h40 EEGS{Zp~LLi EE0@g%Z@gT~ZqZuLQwfg)@g]zZu]zjZ_ZkbHYZzgQy~ZkbZqaZYZkZyzZu]zjZ_

C2 Wy~sVsgnXZf!+w@g]sLq^ INgSpZkw:cZsZgdcQyZggz7_/X@Zk~7f!@g~@g]$h40 EEGS]h~gztX-*y]hf!xzY@)qZ"Zsy]hf!dz(@g!g}~zZc:$ EG07Xp*-*gpV@g!g}~z{ZkaZZk@g!g}~*F+gZ]tWDZzgZka

Zkfg)iVZzg@g!g}~$GN*EVf6gzbDq(}ic{GL N history (Zzg@g) time @Z~-*EVz)

(pXz{@gxg6zZzgZzo cosmos (Zzg]) logos)5k~gZ]fg)BXi0Zzg]!g}~-*EV$ EG0tCqZ]}~wCXW}ZFZzgxp5k~]z@gZkg~}z{wXZ]41 IFETc]g}

ZDwM, 47

,c*i!g}~-*EVgZ]ZyZp~y@:LL)T%Z-*(d~@g)*xq7(tdszLqwhZzgZZkgBX*Z*p

zXtgztQ6jyzg WIs+@0.gpQy!7g~qg`XzezF4q@g*g}zZu]gkge@*g~!VcVfz*g6":Y2txg*Zlg~Dg:YNXzezFiFKgz!g}~x-*gZ]bZ]}g]~

@XZk4q@gZqZg~T~WQwZiyaZ@XZqZzg-*gceZek4q@gZk(]z4Z])JwS:]6FXaZ]p5k7Zka@g~5p~aZ7$XzZu]Tbz`XZbW{zVwbZ

7X2t@g~g65qzq5k7$XZ%Zq-*gc7!ZkZ(zgT;V@g~!h453

GGEGGgX7

!Zk4qzZuzxKjZ7s^gXcZkw~@g~ZqLZgzgX7!Zkw~@glgp5k~Zs@gX)(Zq)g}zu})g}sCgSZkaw!g}

~7Y$XZkazZu]tgw!g}~W7$X

]hf!zV~z{T@g~ZZgZ}(|xK suffering Zzg@g~Zg)

)0381Y(~@g!g}~ZL i^m_f^l X]Zzg@WZ],ByHXz{HZVz`z

57 ZDw@g

ZzgWz]qZzZgq-Zzg"t] izZwZZZzgZZxgz]Z0xZ]g}f~waZ@z{xpwXZ!RVQZkzZgzVg]~

wg}f~V~tsV~Q@pZV p5i0ZpQwQpZqg0Y@X@g]

gW@XO@g]ZzgZgu*Zk4qpZ_"ZzgZZgZ{XpLLZ@g%{g6T6ZZxz^pVZvVZ*ZzgZZ>V!yHY@g;

g}f~!tZwQ@WyWy~atxZy@gZq]1CHT~C C3 !*V7?

(ZLW\Zk universal idea qZku EL'WgZzgZqKw)]1Cfg)g;X!G0L@g{Zzgo@

z{T@ga@gzgZjZ!)Kw(7HXV@g!g}~ZqZzg$ EG0fp{:Xt$ EG0`,ZDwZ!@z~X,4qLL@gF+qXt0ta]@z]Xz{ZL*g] IZLZq)9ga2081Y(~qLLg6Tqx@{M

z{0-VZzggcVZqi'~zx-VZzg?:0YD gc zZ-V!Q7DVJz{(}

YD2VZk7|'Zzgz{ t XZkc[~z{qZkyzy:XZkxZy!~Z]Zzg73XZkq

HXLsQ,VL{Zg}chZka]q6}~Zq!gQ]"3IEeIZ:7@Tf6gig$h43 GIGGGZzgX8B5YMXzZ42. HJGghDZf!

@g@g~{~g'elX@f! +@g~Tic{ZDwzKzwHX`' +

(K]q Decline of the West) ]h Z]41IFET[

'VzZgm X"35 GEGGLf[f!dizZwgZzgZsx!g}~$WgZ'tZ+!'X$zZDwZ]41

IFEsic{zXWZZ]41

IFE)0881X2391Y(ZDw)'Zk!g}~tfz{`\VgzZc]'@!{c !]!

Z}gZ]41 IFEmXz{HtZqY1!](ZzZzZg expression-forms LL@g~LZg~eV)CZDgTXz{H ( type zZu]zZjZwZzgZmZEg6ZL)

living ) pLi0{gV "YyqzVgcMCZ2YY(fg)YYZa analogy) sZzgs/cx (forms

@gZk4qZkZgZDwzk]_ZBZzgQyWy~setDXZkw~i0]fg)

Mt]!'W$XZkZK[$ EELU{Zicd~:

LLZqz{@Txt@z{ZLZK]Zzg_.#i~}Zkz{Zk0keg0Lg7Xz{ZbTbz{W66gHXZ!syZka*z{kZkaZBaZtz{*ZkZX7ZZk)(pZKfZ]~gcHXtZq!gQZkZKfZ]!tZkZKZp~eRXtZk,|xZqZuL

(g]~eRXtZuLQwVJZk doctrine Qwco})pYZZzgZki0g] ZKfZ]mX*.

(Xt"3GGOGiZ@gcZ!G0LZgZzgZks identical)Zzg& Xz{xH::xZk(t!Cg{YD

zZgZ:ZzDXZ]41IFE"p:Vg'e=%]Zq(Zf{Z]41 IFE

Zk[CwZ09) ENVZkC9) EN %~wswZ0'ZzgCwXzsg@XZkhV~

Z C4 (yAzw space ZyDQX}z{Hky) MMXZLZgz C6 &i0*xCzx C5 iVylg

ZDwM, 87

]!g}~Z]41 IFEILL~ZL,Xz{H(~@g]7|Qwgc ]h LL~Zk[)

tY+dW{H7WzZX!

(ZgcXZk6WZzgz&;V]Zzg organicism)=qZf[Z]41

IFE]{z'ghcqw'Z]41

IFE_P]g~g6g}tWDz{t:~ZgcZgwtuJ Z]41 IFE@g D1

(destiny Zg~ZkaZk4q@gp'7lg)X@g'V)p:V(z`zizZwg]ZZqdz]PHg{QVZzgvVCZBZkZ!xdWY@XZ

(g8 analogy bz{ZqdZzgzu~dgxyx)pQyZggt7@X

Zpz{}}""/V~@gaZZzgZZgZ} D2 zgf)ZgZgXpZ"Zkxz]7

ZktWiZ~c)ZDwZq]~LZZ~p~!ZgaR7gXZkgZ]~'Zq6f{(}xdpc'Z`z66gX

9) EN~Zy@z{@g~!g ]h Z]41IFE 3D

@g]7|Qwz[g;XgwzBZp~'LLZkq[s~Z]t@g^&Zpzg]cZoZx

(~~ life-cycles !34 GGOE]IN{X@g]p:VZzZ%JL])'''!6Zzg9%Xa@g~:!h4 IGGLZm~g:ZyZgZ{Zka@g2wcZ77XZkxFzgfZk"e~X

Zsx!g}~Z]41 IFEIZsdzbX 4Dig$h43GIGGOGZzgX]4GOGbZzg"3IE"GOGg6Z2ZgXZDwaZ]41 IFEZk}~Zq_!Cf!dZK

!6ZZLizZwuzVgXpZDwa i C7 Z,c@gZ+Jw"uT~

ZDwM, 08

Z~Z*! Z C8 c@gZqZgwg6:ZzgT~7Kwt:HXqwZDw &6V@g*.

Z]41IFEE{ZLh]~HZzgZkZgW~$ EG0X

a\ inqm]F`n^l]n ZDw;VZ]41IFE*x

]Z>]'Zk\~z{k Zzg ~MTZy:Lp~zgjZZ]41 IFEfDZzgZsx!g}~ZkZqgZjZ!}ZkCg6{DOz{:

pQMy!g!gksZg{HXZkZ6g~Z]41IFEtwCHZsx ]h ec!

ZK+}tpXpW~WYXOZkZZyTqk64aZC'Zkk64$

EELfZ]7

6Z]41 IFEwXti0z{"0cVZzgGNg]'Zt7CZzgT$zZyZkzZCs1V'kg

C11 V!EyZZ[>~^zsgLXVtZw{ZZDwZ]41 IFETLC&gLZZy

Zscx/ZgcHZ]41 IFE;VtZbLZZycZZy!Zscx/?Z]41 IFE;VtZbi0RbC=Zq~gCCZ]41 IFEdcpZqC1ZzgZq*xCzu]

]zZg`C@*xCzu]cC n@ZzgZk1M!6Zzg9%'YZDwZk)Cc

(ZsBVZzg intuitional method C($GLgz]Z$GLg)ZkbZLZZypZgVX

inqm]F`n^l]n Z]41IFEg}-E{ZDw

0vV\LZspzb~HXZk\~!gZ]41 IFEfz{-*EVjZD:

Z]41IFEH-*EV6gXpQp7X

C12 QyfzpGNgC^zZzgZkZzguz~Z{g;XZk'@Zsdzp@g_ ELc

;

JwZgcXgc~ ZzgI~]g*Zzg*.tZk|sZg{@]sZqk|7Zqi|XZ]41 IFE]hgcZk{f[qZgcXZDwZk6{D:

Z]41IFE4qgcMCgf[{mqXz{H*

C14 dZksZg{7HXpzEHZZgZ`OT~e$w,XU"cZ]41 IFE C15 Z

C16 !X(O magnitude Zk~ZDw-*EVg)

(~$w~pZgiZzgZ`zE{DZ]41 IFEZq relation)LjZ!:

-*EVVgggXqZpZgi[zsx(JctgLgO~$wXQW^z

x@ZzgT C17 zZg6z{gH&Z]41 IFEL_54- EGEC20 svY@X C19 O@+ C18 gZfy

Z]41IFE'V'Z`K~zzZu])f{ZH

ZkZkz^GL]7gZ7gZo]MXZk'VZyExz.yQy]ZzgQyZg'efg)KZqZ3$GLggcHpx7ZsxZzgVZk`gcH6{lZsxZzg

V!g}~Zk{Zzg#/ JE{7XZDw!O'LLZsxZzgZsd!g}~Z]41 IFEX]

k~7Zs Z C21 ZgHZyzWaZqecX*dVZDwZ]41 IFE]zZggzkHXZzgZkLt]6dZ0Zi~{HXZDwZ]41 IFE$45 GGGEStHX-*

fdVbZDw d!g}~Zkc]*x.

38 ZDw@g

d{pZsd!g}~Zk}eZ{Zzg$W,ZgcXZ]41 IFE(ZdVt)TsZDwZg{*zg~7(z{'V*RgZCdZsZgZzg~jZ!bzg~7&W`J7g~f!*Wg

'V*xCg~Z]41 IFEdg6ik!Zy7q|Zk!'@X'V*xCzuVg6Z0Zi~

zy*t7XWy*~g> TZzAdZ0 ZsZZs~VLi0!g}~ZqzZZg{c:

^]q]qmj^^$mj t ]$]qZc )F(CQ#aZqzHgcOZQ#aI

HgWY( ZzWQ:Zq&FM@$Zzg:Zq&FM)z{zZDwZWeZ+wD:L)Zk(We6gZk

wZqm@g]XT~c(}:Z0Zi~tcQ&LZ_Z*d6*ecXZZk(~ZzgH$Wy0u~Z(w7i EE0@gu*0

zyLl)u@uZkzbg /|YZ0 q nMy$zZk~aZz{ZZxzZ5Z]zcb6@

C22 Zk~ic{FWy0uZ.{@Xzy(ZdZsz{@g_ ~Z0 gz@Zk4qZzg}7' a/Z*C&

ZzgZ!]tZZZb~ZzgIZKZq8/gBTWY*Zyae7@XZkuJtZsZzgWt

zyZK]Tx1ZzgttH 'pZk=~Z0LLTbZm~[Zq/Zzgz{ZqwCZbgczZq/C&LLZwIzi7YC

ZDwM, 48

zyVi06LLZq 0Z C23 LLe:'k*ecw,L8Z:tp|ttZq

dW@XW*t McCxazZqZ0Zi{IZcpWyZkZ0Zi}8QV}zoOLZq

ZzgLZqBzoHXVz`zZzoQyZqwzZhW*tgZkWe~zZg6:

e^$]#mn(]]^oFujoFmn]^e^]$)Zw:35( ]#nn

)F(ZzgtZkaZZvHg{yz{z{@ZQL7$mZJpZz{ZZZKq:$wBZzg)Zk

C24 a(Zv)(Zzg)(Y}XZktU"ZVz`zizZwQyZqwz5k@X

cZyZL!'W@ZkaZqwu*ZZ!@{gY]ZZx6!CfzZ!g7C)Cg6{g`

VgZ 7W@z{ZZxzZZ!{gYC('qwstIVa,LAgVZq*xCzuVg]

zyWicZ (Z]41IFEfZCZs7Z0 method ~u`)

zyZgZ.{:H! gZzgte7Z]41IFEZ0 &

Zsx!g}~Z]41IFE(Z$Z0eZ{yt

ZsxX8$g]z{Zi,f!d~-*+(gQz{sf!dg*)Zg anti-hellinistic)

5X2V-*y qZk$0{m~f[ZsExz.ygj*C]~Zqw]7HZzgExz.y~"Zzgx@}ZzZH-*g~u~x'g]~

Zsdx~!ExZ~Zzg-Vi0

58 ZDw@g

ZzgExz.yaZqZ(u`ZHZ"Lq]hd*ZkU"ZXpZ]41 IFEZsxZzgZsytZZiag7X

'VCZgp$3GE

Zg~Z]41 IFETbIEx1Zkn)ZDw4qz{U"n#L-*~

57XZsx6X8ZWZ]Zzgf!d f[ZzgdgP-*A~Z]41 IFE]zt]6ZDwWZqz

VHY@ZDwD: sZw!zZKZ7Z]41IFE~dZZK(6Zq8g EL*g*7}Zk

ai;YdZkdZknxcMym7XZ]41

IFE4qCdZCZq$ EG0@Zzgz{TZ$ EG0&zu~'VZZ7MXt

Te~Z]41 IFEZCZ[ZkuJ(|z{ZqzZzuZZzgZqzu~7@ZzgZkbzZu]ZzgZ]Zqg9Z

-*+zbZk @:btU"Yf!d#ZKf;-z-:ZyZWZ]eZkZsd

!gzbZzgH!Z]41 IFE4q H C25 JwKVYtd{X'Zyh]~!g!g M`LqgzlZ-*+

ZkZZgZZkz]LZsx EL-*s o ]h 1Z]41 IFEZk!]tY?YZtU"Yd

-*+zbsQyZWZ]ZkZK7gz)Zs( #dJwK'V!^WiZ~Zzg7ENZ:0Z]41

IFEq!YX~gZ~Z]41 IFEZCZ[z{ZLZk}:b9U"nZkZ%!ZZqpDqZkZsx

C26 (~ZzgVXZsx!g}~Z]41 IFEZy]g~g6ZqZZnaZ@Zz{f!d6ZsxZWZ]tKag7Zk

ZDwM, 68

4qCdZqp$3GE

zu*ZkZsx6X8ZWZ]YVt1XZkZZn]LO![ZktHxdZzg@g]Z@Zzg

1eZse*Z

ZDwZs2VWy*!G0LDKZzgQy^LQ,VZkZZ+ZsByHg6

VwXQ,VWy*4qD&(}fgZXZXZy "ZC!)=zZgZuzz]ZyZzg_!]zC]z){(2Xx@0L]cx@0L]Zzg3X@g'@gZq~fg$ G0DZgbZsxZq(Zdg*)Tgz7L7@,~~tZDwlg~z{VZzgd*@g!g}~ZsxZkZz[W,$ EG0sz,ZDwZke~7g~d:ENP]BWy

*@g{ZgXZkA~Z`zZ0tzy7gZ7gZZ.{HZDwZ(}yzVb ZzgZ0

ZyVg{!zVZg~ZyZbZlq EL]hZzgi0Zzg]wgZgcYnwZzg$. GEGOxgZ]ZyzV;VWDZDw4qZsxZ]XZk~

(ZzgZq6!X method zy@gg~~Zq6) 7Z0Zk@g/Z*]B%1oHZzgtzf[>Zk

zyZ !]6Zti EE0@gZzgL/Z*],Z0zy!G0L@g/xzwW*@gcZk= ZpZ0

zyl)Zzg ZsZg7cYYXpZDwZ(7HZ%Z0zy Zw~@gz/Z*]~g*0cY@2Z0 j^h]f

ZDwZk @gg~wz$. GEGOZ~Zk7zZgBBQZssZgcXZDwz ].

gZ]Mx]_5EYLZg1XzuJ])i0Zqu`aZLLZzg$

EELzZu{aZH)ZWy4:1(Zzg2X

it*Zzgi0t${ GOgz{ZqZzgxwg]X ZDwZkzu}Wg)i:Zzgi0ZEwzuZ*x(Z0

ZDwM, 88

zy@g~0DZka:zy!G0L@g~g~p%0Y@' igZ0

ZsdzyZLZgagZ3Z(gHZk6gtyxY@gggZqZzgw@i;Zq

zy!G0L@g Z0 Z,zwTg*kczyz{gZk$. GEGO![~H pZkzzZ0

tg(ZZYZkpt@gaZqwiZ0gZt'ixW@ZkZZ!X/Zpvtz{gZ37

Zkg 'ZkigTg8~HZk7'}V7gzzV~,X)27(

zyZZqZkaz{)y( ZDw4qZ0ZzggcT@gZqDwyzg]CkHZzg@gd)2uJ:(7)CPtZgZ]6

zy@g zyZzuZ:tZ0 (ZDwaZ0uJWy*gz~KX2Zk@g/ZZzg

;Cfg)KXZk;CjgsZsIf!>tH)ZDw\~6zWZ& EHwH

zy;CZg(}NXz{ZW`i0{@z@ XLLZ0egSz~ C28 ZIy8X ^a]lafoo+^+o 8-, EGE[

zy ZK[L@g[,~IZ!jZLLZ0l~!g@gZqZ, j^h]f ZKK@g

ZKxF+g*)fiyzky~HXzyZq@gZy(+Zy Z[~gHjZLLZ0

8XL/Z*]8XLZOc]ZzgZjZZZq!gqDXz{ZyZkaY'eLZkgz~ZyqwZzgwnX)

98 ZDw@g

zy(p~gZuyXz{ ZDwLL*Og6Zk)Z0HZ#ycZgTcZMZy~Zk.7Zk~

C29 YX ngzu}ZyfHXZyZkB*x71YzyZqZ3ZyXW^,~ Z1ihZZ)GE/zZ+Z0

Zkc)q]~i0Zk{0ZyZe C30 ~)Q0(mgZzg,~{~~ZeWZk

zy W!Z]ZzZb0vZzZzg[F+>mgnZ0zy Z]ZQ0~]zZzgz{Zo6^DgXZ0

/~~EZz!6,kqZzgZR'k/~!{zyi0ZxZVZzgZ%Z ZZCLLAZO)HgHXpZ0

g!gzV~g~ZkF^Kz{}czgZzgCXZkYZ?> ZiCZzgzu~ZgoV~gkbXz{{&!gC{~

HgH308|~ZkyZY+w~Zg5]Y@ZgZkZ0ZWZzgzY>OW

}6^g;'ZkZK Z?> zyZKz]JC{ ZXZ00LWt@gZzgl)HZ0s~d677|Zzg977|gxy

j^h]fm]]fj]]fo]m^]h]r [7gZ*x Xt[ZqlZzg]zV6 ]fe^p]_^]f

zyic{]q>gZ~ d*~LLl%0LZ0[Z,Zqgz7q7@tZqZ"

(ZkU"Zk sociology z{[]hi EE0@gZzg/Z*])zy!g@gZqLDZgcZzgZkDgC [~Z0

zyk!dZzgii0 Z2ZgKt[Z0 B ZjZw_2zW_Zzgx@}qXwZiZk[l)T~LL!ExZzgdxVc!{3EO]Z

ZDwM, 09

z8GLyZzgZ"EGLgZp$45 GGGESZLiZ"C31 ZzgCy"Zk'7YmX

'C32 zy*Z(~i!V~FZW` l)Zzg@gZ0zy&@c]ZzgX1DbZ_> l)Zzg@gz{Z0

2DZ4[3DZXzyZK[~@gcL@g xg6wHY@Z0

Z+p77TZk@g'ZgZZ0Zi{HYnZ%l)'Zzg@g~ZkdgztZ(gHZkZ0Zi{@z{@gzu}ExbZzg"Zzgx@}zo@Xp|t

zy;V@gZqYZzg%1ogzgXYz{ Z0 Zg@gYZzgp:zeptIh+ x

Zs7Zk;V@g%1og7XZ|Cz{b]hi EE0@gZzg@g/Zu`!ZgbY:@X

]] lZq`~@gZqzZpZzgz{tLLX ] i^mm]g]m^oF]u]]^nn]

@gZqz'tZZxZjZwZzg Y'ecZtzZ@X@gLLmZ)E

_0@gZzgDZZyZgbYM'Zt,CZyQg~VZquJYpZ~Y$}

zy@gDc 1DLLD@gZqzZzgZDXZ0Zg7cXZzg:ZkZZkbtHX

zy 2DLLtDZZZjZwzZtzZ@XZ0T@gZZxzZ5zZhHZzgCc@gZ&L

ZjZwzZt_*xX_54EGEzgcsvZjZwg]7t@gzWZzgdg*t7HX

3D@g|ttLXZq{ZsZbT%Z{mzZ!g}~t ELdct EL~7McuJ9gzZegZz-V*VZzgQyZpqXgzZe~

@g MZk| zy Vzzl*7{7Z0sZg{H@g~gzZeZZzggZz-Vp"HpgBX

4DLL@gmLZZXczZuZjZw@g 7 MMtZyZgqw_Xz{NVZ0 ]f]qj^]^o zy@g/Z*]B5'LL

(g sociology @g~/Z*]cDZZy) MZkD~'ZkwaZy_Zk~jwZzgCZjZw(t

4X zyg zt~HY*ec*Z"Z0zyZZ 5DLLZZgZL/ZyZXZZ0

L/ZyZZ:@LZZZbZ]h/Z*]!U"aXpZkLZZ6L/ZyZZzZcz{@gZyZgqw'Zzg7g~*Z]_

&XZktZg{Mz{@gZqcxJz7@Zgqw_ZsZg @gd

ZDwM, 29

zy4q@gZq ZkZg}~ZqZg{tVZ0(TmZyZzgCgqw general process)

@D@gZk4qZqZ(D{mcImq]zZy]6'hPgZ]Zc Z C34 zZu]cZgX

zy@gtWY@z{PgZ]t: YZ0zy@g~pZzgQwg 6D$. GEGOZzgQw:Z0

'QJdFZzg@gZgYtZqZz[W,gi0ZZ~cZc$. GEGO~Zzg}C~QwgpZ{tw7gc%ZXZkgu*$45 GGGES

Wy*tgZZxi0$. GEGOZ]zeggS6zZg6i]m$^]^en]$^ Zgc:

ZzgtZ&GO)z`zizZw(qZV)V(~SOQOQZDgT)LZqc~CZzgLzu}(XgW/ZytWeQyWc`~85 EEYLQu~VQy@3GLa*iwNXpQWc]~Wy*

ZCi EE0@gZzgVz`zizZwZ[zCZ)iybZkWc]~Wy*ZgL?*~Vaz`zizZwZ2ggX:*zZzgdZhP

cM*Vz`zizZwg6Zy C35 zZVZxHZzyQ$. GEGO@g Zq)z(BzoHXqwZ0

_ZuLQwZgcXzyZgZzgi EE0@g_ 7X@gZq%Zczg~:Z0

zy zZtZ~~uJhO+@gZ0(g] cyclic movement ) 4qZq!g!g%ZzZwczg~

c@gC!gZqZ]}@ZzgC6Z]}z

39 ZDw@g

zy4q@g8EL~7Zk *Z]}bCXZ0tZ~HYYz{7g~]Z~Zq~cZgwt7@XpZ(ZkZp~7ZkgZ]g@Xc

ZygZ]|x@Zk'V,LA!g}~7KXzy@gE7.0G Z0zi~ZzgZzi~:Z0 8D]

(gz[XZk@gZq%2 philosophy)ZkzZuZ[zCtBBZyzZu]zjZ_

7gZ*x)6 zy[ ]Z0zi~Zzg5k~x1Y*ecXZ0j^h]fm]]fj]]fo]m^]h]r [( Tg!~CcY

XZxgLL[ ]fe^p]_^]fzy@g~L Z.E*xcHX>wZ0

~ZqXz]hZqpW,[Xu~ZKzyg@g LZzgLZ&GOxZp~w~ZzgZ0 ~ C36

=ZzZpjZLL]Zzg]pzZccZZzZZxZjZwZ,}Z~*}Z~zZa

ZZ&b!0XxZp~ZGz MMXZ0zyzZu]Lq~78~~5ZqMgw8X

zy@gpZkZL Zk%70c~oZ0zy*x Zp~qY[,XL[Z.El)Xl%0Z0

WtZzgLz*]u*ZqZ+kzqZ& l7YYXZk7WiZq\@\Z0

zyZkbWxH:Z$ O'@gQy.y~gXx~xg67f7JCgSXZzg^J;Zk{'ZCXZxzxZkcgZ{~

ZDwM, 49

73DXZzgCuzZ'Zk~Z4k5 EGY

ZzggZgDXnfzxCz'Z'Zk~ZLf6Zty0DXYZ@gZqsC~*ZcxZzg.zpVq]g}tCZzgZcg}z%ENzgBZzgbbZZwzZVwz{7gXZzgg~~

qz6kHYtlxZzgCgZ5?YC38 }]7$X

zyg@g!g}~nHZZk6 T!~Z0lZzgl7ZyZ]gz~'P'hZgZ]

zy@gZKxzVZzguzBQt ZcYZ0WY@Xz{ZgZ]tM:

@gZq%DZzgMZ|ZZpl}X D1@gzZu]]~Z[zCgcZzgzZu].e"z D2I~bg]X3D@gzZu]Q|[DXZq{m@g]gqw~zZu]z

(QDZzgzq5kDtD style or manner q]cQ|[)Zk_@X

r Z[}DXg}DzZgZuR} 4DzZu]]!z~

YN'ZzgC~zZu]g~a@gD

Z)g(ZDzggzZzgzZR6W@XZkbzZu]QyZ[B5_*Z"ZqDgzgX

Fzu}ExzZ/ D 5D@gg~sg7ZqZ(@X

zZc]ZzgpZY@g7X g $zg 6D{]yZ]"!'Zzg:!V*x@gt*ZVZzgzDz]gpzZV7zWZzWZQwI|g>DXZkZ){Zx6Zq!gQZDwZpCZDLL'Zs

dzyZLZgagZ3Z(gHZk6gtyxY@gggZqZzgw@i;ZqZ,zwTg*kX

ZDwV. EGLgCQyBi0ZJgzVzbg

ZDwM, 69

gzZ((ZsZzg ELZszZg@g'ZzgVz`zizZw]zd~pZzgzZZk$z*kQy;V@g!g}~Zqmgz!GOaZYXZDwz~Qytgz!GOcZ0ZZ(%1ozZOg6Qy@gci EE0@g MMXZpQyi EE0@gic{FQyZ+gZ]g]

zy'Zzgf!gpV~Z]41 IFE Q,VuJZ`zZzguJZ0]zgZ]*D4KXZbZDw@gZqgZyiyzkVMTQ,VZLh]

~bz$i EBXZtYZDw!G0L@guJWy*@gz"Y:X@g!g}~Qy(ZtZ`Z(Z~W*Q@g!k543 GEEXZZ7S@g]ZZ`

(Zq ogical induction) MMXZxZ`Z (historical induction)ig]'eczV%ZtqZkb%AHYZzgQyZkbgz~YQyZ5Z`HYnXZk|sQ,VZq~zZZg{H:

~%~w~W$GILgCuZr

~xuV8o-B EGEN!VZk|sZg{)izV7Zz9gV~@g

ZDw%ZZs@gXZs@gi0{F~FZzgYzFZbZz$h5

GIGL$EMZDwf6Zzg_!Ci0~(~GOgXZDw

(tZqig]X historical induction ;V@g]Z`Z)@g~QyZ`Z$GLgZqi%:X2391Y 6 ZDw^

~ZQwa*yy{HQ,VZiFZzg6(sZgZ{1XZq~:LL~7g}Zi

79 ZDw@g

t C39 FZzg6(spgVXzZq{~6VYVX12#2391YXP{12Z~2391YQ,VZqZzg~:LLZZ[ZpXZyYZv1V*dVZzgQy

,VZkZgZ}iY)zcck~'}V5] Q C40 6VX(5]tCHX Massignon Q,VZ[$4h43 GGEV)

T1VZ6xHXZk5]ZxHXZDwZk5]~VZsx!g}~f!*$sgzbf

HVtH-g\6VZ*]ZDw6~zgiXzgiZjgcwVV!?(Zf{ZDwaS:XZjgcwz{ZkQ,V

!yWUgz!]pzg]%:0cXVz{\TxZyZzgWtKQywzr6}ZWZ]%AKXLK\

xZy!'Zk^zgZyZDw@g]g7g}xWXK z`6g;'ZzgZ`Z&gWiQ7g}ZZkic{ \!g}~Zzg6Q,V:LL~gZ~W`J

pzg]Zzg0ZgKgzi}67XZklN]WyZzgkZ C41 Zsx|x0~qz{pVzVq:eX"It is a commentary on the K\!g}~Q,VZq!g:

qwZs@gZDwa@g%: Quran written in stones"{m (@sV~ZDw@gse prototype)

~g6Qy@g+B3 GEGGZyiV6Z2ZgXpiz{Zq%ziV ZgwZgX@@gi~Zq!w

(ZZk6ZZp%ziV]~zZ passage of time)zZw] zZCwM~@pL]~zq5kZzg @g7@gZZqwaZCZzgZZqwZgZ}

ZDwM, 89

tZgZ{z W}gXZZgZ{Zzg@gZqZZzg!m|xD@gZ ZDw@gQyp~%1oDa

XZkaZgZ{Zm@g ZgZ}Zzg$z]~Z4C~gTZzggV~@gDV

(uZrMgYwcZ8w hero worship ZDwgYw64cZ64)(Xfg)Lp~7gZg@@ghV6ZW heroes)

Z0ZiDXQyZg@gJgzV$w:gZigZi%GLKz@iZgYDkgZiZg\.n. IIGL\gqZ0ZTwZg]ZiZgg_5GL!

tH[IMZzgZirLz{~%Z}ZrZgk}ZWzZi!

)zA'Zg6(@g~Zp~ZkzwZqZzg(ZDw

0gzZgcX0gzH?fzZz[!0gzH?I[!0gz7Zi00gz_5EYL{g{L*[!

)zh(ZDw4q@g~ZZzZZxf6i0z@

Zp@gg~ZgZ}7YZka@g~Z[zC

99 ZDw@g

qwggLp@g~zxZhYz{Zp~"C{Zk!zZDw@gZyV'ZzgZk"ZVs"GOGQitDZzg@gDxZp~ZzgzZq(Zfg=wD~~Qy@gZyZg~yZ:

Z*~ G0ZYU? 74i FGG@gZ}ip[UWgz%g{+ Z+FZZip$h4 GIGEW+

$ OGgZaZ[ZZ+ zbgZu@[ZZ+zlgWZ%zil ^ I0LZf{gilgzZiz~Z`z_Z Z5gZZ \. ILZzh

0gg9+

%1oV~z3GOGZkaZCXt]Zzgi268ELZgZ{Zy!3 EGOGZzgWiZ3GOGZZgCqw~Zse_mZzgZqZyWsZgCt%ziVC"Tz~zZu]zjZ_zgZwgB@g{%{~i0zIVg]XZk~ZZzg{gYZ]ZZzg

ZqgqwZZzZZxZg&"ZzgZy&h i s to r i ca l ) aZqZJy{0YC'@gZKezzx

(ZzgWiZ)gZ33C choice !zZp~ZN[) (determainationt@gZyZkZk*]gzkC@g%ziVZ|xZzgZqZ+pUg3 EGOGTJgZZykz!h4 IGOG0

g@ZzgZgZ{zx0XVi0!

mgBZZx!mi0ZkZgZzg!wfg)i~oCZzg@gZLW\ZZxZZqw'ZzgQy!Zqw

g]~CCZka@g|xZZxZi0u*ZzgZkCseZq7XZptLLZzZhp)!'gpzZZV$zZk~LLci0

5 ZZ4Z0Zi~g YC'@gtZz])7CZLZy!'WgZZzgZ435 EGGCZgZDw;V@g~0Zlg8 EGLA=

GXGX~(7XtqwZLw eternal recurrence (cZ$~Zgzg) regressioin)

~7gXi06Zk*]D'c@gycWy~Zxy7g*zZgZqZ(

(z~g;: perfection)t]Z*xh

WgxZ5 EGVc:

)wgr7~i WgZWZ[~! 7

KKK

jZ1D Carl Lowith, Meaning in History, p.191. 2D Carl Lowith, Meaning in History, Introduction.3D Lecture on the philosophy of History (trans) 1900, p.21.4D Cause and effect.5D Destiny.

ZDwM, 201

6D Organic Necessity in life.VZ]41

IFEwY@X 7D0vZV[W:2k*i~m302X inqm]F`n^l]n 8D

XInterpolation ZgZ` 9DTrignometrical function X 01D0vZV[W:2k*i~m502 inqm]F`n^l]n 11DXChronological Number _54-

EGE 21DXBeing y 31D

XBcoming @+ 41D0vZV[m502 inqm]F`n^l]n 51D

(ZEwHX5Xl) Mathemetical Z]41 IFEZk(t~gcMC) 61DX ]h

zuZ[W:2k*i~m561X661X inqm]F`n^l]n 71DzuZ[W:2k*i~m661X inqm]F`n^l]n 81D

VZ]41IFEwY@ 91D

0vZV[W:2k*i~m302X inqm]F`n^l]n 02DXInterpolation ZgZ` 12D

XTrignometrical Function 22D0vZV[W:2k*i~m502X inqm]F`n^l]n 32

Xchronological number _54-EGE 42D

XBeing y 52DXDecoming @+ 62D

0vZV[W:2k*i~m502X inqm]F`n^l]n 72Dm022 inqm]F`n^l]n 82DLLZspzbm212312X inqm]F`n^l]n 92D

(ZZg{pZs -]e )fZ! ]^]e *0z~X 03Dm9506X

2m66 iq^] *Z1ZxWiZ 13DZsd 23D

301 ZDw@g

0vZV[W:2k*i~m812912 inqm]F`n^l]n 33D0vZV[W:2k*i~m612712 inqm]F`n^l]n 43Dm62 inqm]F`n^l]n 53Dm612 inqm]F`n^l]n 63D

zyZ1ihZzZ+:237|&2331Y~Z~aZZZzg808|&6041Y Z0 73D~C{~]ZX

zyZwm605X X!LLZ0 ]^]n 83D2681Y~Zi!y~FH@gZq{HFZz| 1 y 93D

ZXg0191YQgzF ]e 0481Y~ZXQgzFZiZ@Z[M! i^m]e Zi{VZcQgzF ]e

ZieZeZvgX0691YX i^m]e 1091YQgzFTZZuzZC$3 GGG]C{X7591YZzwm162X 04D

ckZic`Zm05X ]e 14DZWyXgW/ZyXWe:731X 24D

43D Muhsin Mehdi: Ibn Khaldun's Philosophy of Histroy , London. 1957.QgzFZi*{V-;)Z](gZZ, ]e 44D

Zcm33XQgzFZi*{V-;)Z](gZZ, ]e 54D

Zcm93Xzzxm484X ]f^^ YZv%A 64Dzzxm022X ]f^^ YZv%A 74D

7491Ym34X ]f^12q]amc Z?: 84D

KKK

ZDwM, 401

inqm]F`n^l]n

ZsZg~ {Six Lectures On Reconstruction ~ )ZDw0LWth]Zm~

inqm ZyZzgZ[Qgz~ of Religious Thought In Islam}*xgLqZsZg*~ZqZV ]F`n^l]n

guwgnXZpZsZq{mU!g}~ZDw7gz*(LZxZzgLDZx*xZsx:zgzZeZzgZk~)b6zZ7`XpZyzV1V

mZsZ~\. MGXZsy:Zk*(qGZqZ+"&F-Vf6 ur]#]f^ 7XZk

Zzg~Zs~ZqZz!'. GO`ZzgZq6hwq|]{zZv~ZKZk$Z:"~Zsx/ZUVZ0=ZzgZs}~FZgZ]~p=Vzg]6izgcXtZq5FIZ:aThdizZwzZzo@gqgZ]

1'ptFIa+57!h* OZZzgRgzZc]zZ]gz~ZqZzo5ky}~ZqZ+p~xV:s+ZgzqZzgCx]dnZx]yQy*z~i04o6Z2ZgnX|]{zZvz{Zz[&GLW@+85 EEYLWiZ~)7581Y(ZzgFzuk]ZzgZ~*]~ZqwgZzgZWZ0Zi

501 :ZsZg~ inqm]Fn^`l]n

g;X@|]{zZv~*zgu!h* OZzg%zZ435 EGG]&Q,Vzu]ZgA IXZq]z{'fZCZq]fg)yHpZk$EMZsZ435 EGG]^$EM7ZsxCZzg/ZgZ]XtZzg!]|]{rkzVZq(ZzZys]6XZLq~]hZss

Yz{{rgZvm>]'W@XQy}]Zp*Vp~R6z{Zs}~6CZzg/ZZz[

(Zzgi!XZ human ZZzgsZq5'Zzgic{Z)R~ZsxzZg cz$ EG0Y*0w~'

ZbZ~{ &(}CyWDtwgZkZs(F socio-political thought) Z435 EGGCZzg:Zg(/ZZg

emotional z,XpZy7EO]zk]_!CB)(~Zq(~pZgZzgz{Zs}a content

U!] ZzgZsx$h EILU6pZ|]&CEOZ6Zq/ZJ'C:dZzg}# 'ZDwLLI

~cVg6xCWCXqw''R*0w@g~&>]CwZzggz7X|]ZU

Zzg)ZDwh] ur]#]f^ !]|]{zZv~"'ZktC7Zkg} inqm]F`n^l]n

~Zs!g}~s&xzZkg}~:xDZg,]ZsZzgZsgzZc]=zDz+~sVXZ,~~puZ{V&ZpZq{

T: N"GOGL|])ahW!~ wgn'W!~c@i{gBZs4+gzZc]Z}g;'z{W!~

Zi)Z/W!~( ^^ank^7 TZqi&ELZ") l)ZDwZqsJg'ZbZVgz,ZzgZ,~

ZDwM, 601

y~FZzg{yZzg2VZs+B GEOE'ZzgZkZy0 4+ZbZzFI~ZVg}]Zx~Vp'

V~ZsgzF+yX EL@i{W[zL[qD_f^l Zzg ur]#]f^ je^l]^e^o 3'&:

ZqzZg6 $EM 'ZyVo~Zsg*z^Zzg ]f^Zl 3XZzgz{SZs@g~ZZq*.

(wCX collective experience ZzZgZ])LhZDw'ZKz7gzx?~ZuJd

(ZkaZJZk~!o-) IG] undiscovered Zg*gc]IN{)(ogz~7mZk~~ZbZ thought contents)

7g~bgc7HYeZyh]~Lq~ZsxXzgVfMZyzgVZJQy7g}ZRZzgZ(tzt

Bt7HZJt7YeZyh]~ZbZZDw~BHg?ZzgHZ(gc7?z{dxZzg]XZ!]ZDwZs@g~l'H

dZzg 'h7?h]7gdttzf[:gzZc]~zZ/@2Zk!]W@

($ EG0 pragmatic value WyZDwZsYVZkxec&~)Ziuo*eTXH~jZVBZ(*ec7?Zzg

J (ZkxZx Zz{yZ_Zk')ZsBZkxec&~g67g~QFCVZyh]hzzZDw7'Zk~7th]g~ZV~

Zd!]~'pZZyh]Zs@g:~g:YZzg)q~VzgVBZkg:YZkse4+zg~gzggLX

701 :ZsZg~ inqm]Fn^`l]n

cZq6u8g* FI0 zZtth]Zs@g~Zq(wgnZyh]ZZsx source of inspiration y)

]hk]Zq~Zzgf6B#Zyh]{:gz7!zQOg6)q~Zq6DZx$ EG0MiYYZyh]ZV:Zg_ZzgQylz[afztztuXZyh]gDjZVfg)

'yzVZzgzVZzgAVZ,ZjZwzZZw 3X!g}~g~g6CkHYYZy~Zzg)q

F+rF+Z2~]Z0x'pZk t7ZDwf!ZzgZs~bz~c Nxl

tZy7Xz{Zyh]~ZzgF!Vz{t3*eT]!g}~Zy!~(f]']h435 EGG]QzZ6]'Zzg]h;Cgz~X2Zy]hFzgV'Zzg~)bgz~'Z

*gZhbzZ'Zke~f!Zzg'hQyzVnXZbz{Zs4+ZbZ

Zkb*eT'Zy~ZbZz{s~Z]ic{gz ^zq~)bZzgV!mi0 Xg)

Z'ZzgZi0~LLZZsQwcXZZytgO'WYYZyh]~ZDw)]

] X*VV'ZzgQyHgzh]~QyizgZy( induction) 6]h!b7gzZsxTZ`Z

j,ZZXzuZNt]h435 EGG]]~6[g~~Z[{Z+|7g;'Tfg)&4JGOE'

zqsV~TckzrZzg"xeZL!~'ZDwZkl!zZZaz{,\)H

zu}Zy}Ah}ic{ZuZzg]Z0XOZktg&QyZi{~,XmZyZ0gzi0X@-VZk~t&aZ@gw~n

C2 znZkt*hecX'z{)q~

}{6izg'csV~tZzgq77X CZDw4qz{W`yabizVZzg

2h]~Zzgc]pZDwZqd~w

Z Bycz{Zsx|I~{gY]BfZfDZL (g inductive (ZzgZ`Z) empirical) !

ZsExzV!

AExZZuzZ.}b7XOZDwZd~:ZJZ(u`o7Y@Xt_cHz]ZsxCZzg:ZzgV

IzZgZ]1X]hEx!

ZkZ*%~wqpZkZZe!syIzu]~F YIzZgZ]]hbZzgi!y~y6Zzgdw

Zs}q!Zzg{Xa,~~

,~{~ZZyh]~ZDwZ435 EGGCZgUZcV:@Q)

q~V(Z/ZZgcYYZ[Qytw)07CZ(Ck@p~;CZzgZ435 EGGC=%]Qy9Zg6YXpZZDwxec&~Y'ZLx:Z]!zp~,~VaZq{/ZcgZDw}LZ*Zzg9]'Zzg![:ZZsx'Zsy&Z

inductive gZ]zsDX1XWiZ)2XZ`Z)Zzg3XZa![~Zy&gZ]Z435 EGG]%A (empiricism

ZzgZkBLkZs|xzZXTqWiZ)gxZsx]!GM~gXZ`Z

ZDwM, 411

$ EG0!]Qy^Zzg^Qy@ZDw4qZsdZzAZzZgzzZ0zyZL

!G0L@g$zZzgZ0tZLZggZ]$zVd@g~"uZZDwZygZ]ZsyQww#g6&4GGIHXtQww'VZzgZZxi0{gBZDw4q"uZLiy:KxFlZkaVZq!gQi0QwzZhHYnXLh]0v,!['

@gVzZfD LLZspzb~ZDwDLL)@g(d_a(}zWZzg(}}"B

izg]z{Zi,i0Zzgi:!g}~ B(~=ZgZ].e9ZgZuXZYZke

C4 ~z(}gg}tWDXggZqZzg i D uJZ]Zzg2 zD Zzgtzg1

zu} xw'YgmbwZzg: zyiy6*DZDw VwXZ0

ZsdzyZLZgagZ3Z(gHZk6gtyxY@gggZqZzgw@i;

zy@g ZqZ,zwTg*kcZ0pZkzzZ0zyz{gZkp![~HXtg(ZZYVZkpt@gaZqwiZ0gZt'ixW@ZkZZ!X/Zpvtz{

zyZ435 EGG] w7TgZ3Z[ZpZ0p7z{g|Zk#!,!ZkigTg8~

C5 7HZk7Zkg'}V7gzzV~,XiZzgxwZgZzg'@gi~cpi!3E

GGZgzZ|xyZkwQyZZ~ZzgZ

511 :ZsZg~ inqm]Fn^`l]n

kaHg~f,ZzgZk|ZsBZgZu,@g3 EGGZq!'T%ZZqZ,w

: c%'&gLk7cn'ZDwCZk Zzg]:[etV[zZzg6W{HYn

q~ZsxZzgZsy/ZUVs ZgZyxgZ])gZUXLZZsx~Q,VZsx@g+B3 GEGGgz~yZsxzZgQwcZkeV~LZ

LgzZei0{HY@z{6i)b{'W[XZQy@WZ]sZquu~Y^{1YnZDwzVZi06%A3ZzgQy(Zzg/Zp=Vtg3

Z] Y*~~Zsx~zq5kN2]hd*gz~VsZsxZzgWy*=Zzg@V7g3Y7YY'ZDwh]]hZsc]@g~'ZqZhZq6![ZzgZqog0L$ENgwgnX

Zsx~EZsZrV~ZPxaZZZzgZsx$h EIL $zU62wVzZZzgdFWX

jZ

H

6Zq*g{ _f^l]f^ZDw0LWth]'LLgZkZZc]6%A

ZzggZkgW!)(ZzgZ|~bg]~!g0391Y(Y@g;X six lectures ~XZkztbh]XZkaZ)

Zyh]ZV[XLLH

gnZzg!kxgW!gZ'VZzgzVZYDXwggM!',~,ZwZ!x6g ]3

ZmZzgWy*Zm~Wge-u&- FGwgW!)(Yg~HXZzgzZkkXZkgMIs'R7XZ-g\ZiZzgZ%MJ;ZXZkaZk~

> zZkzV{mZqXtCgZ]hcCyfZzg gM!1391Y ]3 { F)yXhZDwik

~776386J;ZX}Z!x6{gZL7g}*xab6ge-u M.P. OZL*xZZwzs

&- FGw*xkw~ZZktk~Zg~7C {gpge-u&- FGwq]hZs*Qy}]7

ZZxXZk}ZFZgXZqthZDw6tZzB{TzZZq{dmgXzu}

t!3 EO']hZs*~pZqiwqZzgLq~Zsxdu~ZzgEZsZ~dwwg;X

ge-u&- FGw!g}~ZqZ!]tQ,VgZkQ^gZkZZc]6gZk~h]bT]6)

Cultural ZDwZLh]%AKX&- FGwiZ~WJZzg*xX&- FGwth]-Eg;Z| side of Islam

*xZyh]F i`mg]o yzC[~) [(W*WZzgZqw&- FGw!~Zzg

ZsBZy~zZZ0Zi{QyZLh]ZqZkHYYXZs]~W*ZzggZx-Zvmz%e!g}~z{:

Cz{&W*_X]t}W*

ZDwM, 811

ZyVaZkx]6VZk*ZzgWy]zV~x!qZy#bz%ZZ z{@X2tW*7

Z!6ZzgZWgZ\$XZVZ(i0cZ(g1xWZzgZt~6F7z{ &

&TuZrZs!CAXV) Zs Zq)xJwpZ{z{CQyFgZ5~qg`:W@#bzx!Qy:gDecXC*WMxWoZzg;)'hz

#V6x!gZDz}XVa)C1 ZsWMZ(g*ZLW\zg0Lh~eZX

nhZDwZzBZm~!3 EO'ge-u&- FGwpEZsZ@g~ZqiqXQy{)Zm~i!y~(ZyZpzq

: @XXp)ZDwZLh]dWiHZzgz{ZpW*ZqZ+[LO}L6izg-VS~gm)7 EGS(t&7Cz{ZqZ+]&ZLW\[:0DXZkm!mzZgZ]Zq~ZWg6@i{p~_[BT)!mzZgZ](6WygZZyzZg@Xz{Zi,]h)(ZyZLW\LCkpZ+F}ZZzgjZ_*

0gSX)t~~ypZsxZzg7ZiZLRzZgZZZzZg~zgQgZ(pZ+)!m(zZgZ]ZI7gcXz{)]hZy(ZyzZgZ]zzV8XY)d$ EG0(

C2 Zy~zzZkWxZk*]XZkZk!3 EO)&- FGw(ZC{zq@Xz{:-VuZDwbh]6Zkzg}7ZLdWiD

ph]ZqZkL~|LT6Wyizgc2tZkSI")!mzZgZ](QyZq]~yL]hZya&ELV!tZ+w7Y

911 6Zq*g{ _f^l]f^

Wyi!y)(egZ~zZXZzg')ZDw$ EG0(z{fZkn):Zq](]YXXZzg

uJgz)c(ZgcYYplL]hZVZeZkq)ZzgRz~(0uXpt|ZK(6Z,f~V)*~(7Z+ZBJw

ag7D]hZzgZtZq]~s:XZzgZ,fZ}VDZzgatZq}Zka)Z,

(ZgcY@XuZDwZ, elite f~VqV(v[cFcC)VJQyZKi!y~ZsxxauxgXZzgaQLZtZq]ZEw6GNg]q,Zkat!]DQ)ZDw(Z,VZZxWqXZk!]6]ZgK%7g{MWyZyV6Zyh]HZWZ2VZLH'!th]zZg67YaX.eZoZzggz

%FHYat)h](_mgZ]zFZIZkbZzgZ,cZZVg]X_(g_MXZyh]GQyk]Zzg]i{cX2VZgZkgW!)(ZzgZ|~XZk]iZzgjZk!$

"ZkgZgZ{~J)(uZDwZsx&4EGOEgzcX)p(tgZ.Xt|7uZDw

Zk'@Zyh]fg)Zsxz{4+}#uZx~X C3 W`yae$X)ZDw(]hZgHV

z'zQyZKi!y~'ZzgZk.3GOGBZy.3GOGb7U"3cZsxZ"Q)]hZgbZgzV(

ZkgZk!]69g;Wy*LOL6izgcpZDwZL~'~!o-) IG]y[gZb-

EEOc)Zq]gZ(ZEwC@ jargon dZq]a

Z0ZVg9tzgXZq]_mi!y(fDZ pervert (Zzg) bewildered sX)

{cZ~I7DZzgtplZ,XZzgfic{7XZzgZQyauZDwth]kKXZk}WiZbZp{W(kh]dgz7

q~Zsx(~Zzg4+}#Zg Zk@Zzgz{Z)ZsxzZ]hdi!y~yHYYZk9tcZ~gzKZDwic{f[{IX'ZzgLzf~Vs{|Zq]g}~Q{'qwg~g6t6W{h]fg)ZDw

q~(Zsx(~}#uZx~! ))s7)ZDwZzgHXz{Zsx]Z+Z!VtWqpVcQQZ0Zig3XZke~sZqVw6ZrDLL{?Z5454 EEGOGEZp)H?()-Zvmz(Wy~ZzggwXZkaZyxZ`Z$GL

(Yg~Zy_0]ZzgbC inductive method of reasoning)z){gY(6W{ZyLLZF6'ycXZk

zg~ aZ[ZkZA@Zezg]7gqZy

}9zVY@Zkh]ZDwsZ]K'ZzgZyZ]B{Z!x5kY@

ox@Zk6Zyh]!g}~ZDwZL]z]guZrcY'ZkZwZ[pZDw4qZyh]

x ZzB#ypZDwZp~t'ZLkz.8Zq[~ZDwZyh]!g}~5c8291Y:

'!g;zVF3xXtx*e7ZzgZi'zgXZyzV#ic{Fz{yf!OWZzgZk!]

pZi EE0Zsxi EE0]hZp~yHYZzgZ6Z{]~{xVZygHYXZxic{Fy~ZzgZky~$4 MGiEE0Zsx4+gzZc]{g3X1~w@VQgzpZV*hZyZ{:Y!VD~n17"zZc

C4 GzZqZk%eg{:XZkzZ@ZDw4q:1DZyh]#py2D@Z,yi EE0Zsxi EE0]hi!y~'eT3DZyh]Zq6ZIZg~Fz;X4DtZzg!]ZDw4qxQgzpZVZyh])cZyF3?(

ic{Z.{7YYZycg~!g}~n1z{)bW{X

ox@V }'hZ]7t]g!g}~ZDwZgpZDwi!y~7KYNXZDwtZgQy0v,\~XXTZy:LZsp

'Zk\Wi~ZDwt]ZzgzeZqiZ] C5 zbZ"gByK'Z~z{

ZZzg&45 ENEG~gZgpZko}=~Q,VZgcZz{LLo0Lt]pDgz7ZgXZkq6

qOz{D: ZDwt]"u*gZzg]Z0zLLZqZgt]p-VY$tzez{^T

(ZKuzziYCZzgQyV unitary experience ~zZgZZ)QgcZiuzbe&CZg]XcZmYfZ]~i0p%)Zp~(ZLpZqt~ez[Y@XZkaQZq@i{]ZzgizgQnXz{S@ZzgQi0

C6 55gZXZkbzsZDwzkZk.e|x~yDZzg

Z]ZqgZgptD%ZiZ%sczZg`geZk:Zzg$rYCXZkZ+wZ

ZzgLLZN[HYYXZk"u*iuZzg ~tt]LLeZZDw]hZyZqi~p!)Z`Zc!&g(:

~g[XZk{mb=D:ZkpY-VW9Zsx)-Zvmz(fZZ

w**Zzg]hgxyZqzZWX/ZgZLu8g* FI0zktX m**p/ZgZkzb*]h W\

z{@i{u`ZkW{ W\zi06Dzc_.XZZsxg6W^{pZ{&6U"cYZ`ZgXZsx~t]aZLcZwVXZZk{zg~'ZkstzZgZ!^

qwh(=ZzgxfZk6WiZ~BW,t]y1coSty1Z[Zk ZkaZ

h7(ZkDmatZ[]u`ZZkZixWCX

321 6Zq*g{ _f^l]f^

ZysZ]Vzg]ZkaCk8-)43EGLEE]

Zo}cXg!g}~ZDw=%]z]ZFZbZZq~tWZzgZyZi:Qk.eZ+gZuHYnge-u&- FGw}~MX&- FGwnCk@ZDw4q8-

EGL

t]estZyZK=zxnZzgZaZsxV~ZzgZ`Z$GLDzr[ZpZDw

Z+wZqbzGpZDwZ+wsD7Y@ZkaZtZ+wDcYZkig6tZ[Zy

t]gqzg]7ZK=Zzg"xhzg]XpZDwZ+w{Qz6Tg~KZ80GS

t]o} U"DZDwst7'Qy4qitZ[g}aZyzqzZgZ]Zkb9B NEOG

7Q+ZzgZk7zZZ66gVZka+ZzgZaF+F+Zgg}tW[

XZzgZ[Z!mfgZDq*ZkaZLW~gZgZzg^zggXZDwZkg~c~}t7

t]z~z{ Mgz{Wy~Zzgwgc Ht]xFZq@'hZDwt7z{Zkg ;CZzgUVcgTZzgZk~7Q,V!gZkg:Zzg@g]7Cqw~wZ0ZzgcCX

&- FGw}zuZzhZDwsZ]6X~ZDwZk!]zsWy@gZzggzZc]bJwHXZzgbyHXZke~ZDwL~ G0LWx{mjZ!c'O&- FGwZL}~:

W*~Zy@ZezgayQZ

ZDwM, 421

!Zzgzu~lk1V~g@g]c]ZWyZzg)3XZk|VCkH

:Zzg{muZDwNyQ,Vg~{zSOKzwVwg6:qwZ[*Y^{WxZq7FXg;tZ%ZkgzZeZgbZVZk,e7XZy%Ziu~

7MXgZkZZ(gXX$40 EGEZy"gZy*Vp=V:XZ%VJZkgzZe^m MMZk~zqzqZytpZxg

ZqZ,jw~Tz{*kT~]ZgiZVZzgFgcVxZzgVZkZCW\'Zggp~xx6gzIVo*7@ZKi1VqZzggZgnXz{Zk.7Z]h}Zi0!g}~ZkgmZqZ(tZ(g1T6ckZzgoXO*!.Zq~,)#(Zzgg|Zzgg]'%)#&EL(2gDXXVtIqZkZg{sX]ZzgX]ZqGzqZyZyZ`s%ziy0Zl~'p4ZkgzZeM

W4 ~yLaZgzZeDXsZwZZ0ZigZXZWZzgL*%0PgzZc]tZkZ%?W0uZkZzg'X

tZkZDw}\1XTZy:LLfZ]Zg'CZZm~QZk7H Zzg'|

'ptZkD7Y@Z~z{&]zKZDwWxzjZZzgWx!g}~WgzZe~7K)&- FGw}6ZkZ+gZu%1ogpaVZDwZyLX37D:

521 6Zq*g{ _f^l]f^

1DW*~ G0Wxi]Za,Zzgf7HXZbW*WxzjZOsLWxfHZzgWxmZy%Z7ZkwZqgX2DW~ G0WxzZZV~HZqz{T~s

"5 GEXW* LZg?IE{fWcZzgzu~z{T~Lo>ZZzgL$ NZg-yLWxZzgZk~zgcZzgQ,VNg|V\

1X*%0LP~4WxZzBk{uiZXZ!ywcZzg'hwZ~X3D*%0P~Wx`*6i}yIZcZWy4qi}Zy8ZzgOqTaZZv\]Zg*ecXW*}t7WxQgzVZE#XW0uZkgzZe~%ZZZZzgT~ZyZLjwZng7ZXZzgZyZK"rZzgq~q~

Zkg~XZysZ]!3 EOZq!gQh]Zzg]z,

sZ]7D:6gZLg~tzZzgsZ]7,@Zy

h]~ZEwYzZLL]hFZIzi!yZzgZkBBZyZkVVU"HYnX h]ZV&

JY!g}

tsZ]X!3 EOHh]ZyIt0X~ZDw]Zzgz)iyzkV(:KZzgZzgU"H]cC|7Ccz~WgXZk~ZDw]hbZzg!

dqz{,ZLg8~Zyxz7ZLg}W\g{Xz{=$45 GGOE]Xfg)ZZgZu@XOZq%Zg)gv|]!mh~

XikcZq%hg}x$ EG0F)t}(~p!Zqzz{Zs}ZzZkZ:XpZkZ[~i!yZpz{Zzgic{p&XcZzgZ[H

c]tw7fZ!g~\ ?Z[s}ZzXZBzqZzgT6cz{Z[zgg;XZq

C7 TZZ]~g3X: ZkZkBi%GL{ZLZ!x('Z!Zpt

uZDw)t([Zqmf)VZzgQyVaZq$+i!y~qK!ZkfDgX@t[Zk!],Zgz{xvZsxc]h,czV~pgnZk[_.egzpnB,XZks}~h]It&]6ic{&ELz:1Do0Lt]!g}~ZDw:Zzg;C]2DWxzjZ!g}~WgzZc]]

iyzky!g}~ZDw.erzZzg:Z+gZ]X 3D:h]t&Itbz~g67Kh]xF

It7g~b7DpZzg}ZKuzC&- FGwqwZ]aZItKX

ZphZDwZzB)ge-u&- FGwZyh]dgz7ZzgZDw}]2s3@Zk!]/W

CkHYYQZk!]ZhbZ0Zi{7ZZsZZzg]hZsZg7g~Zyh]HZqzZZk}

721 6Zq*g{ _f^l]f^

ZkgZk!]Z0Zi{Z(7&- FGw4qZsx]hi!y~7*f[mZzgzVaoczg~z:hZkPZVzg]:ZDwZLh]~Tz^GL_ZZzgZsZ435 EGG]!g}~]Z0]ZgHZzg]hZg)zZ/h]!3 EO)&- FGwZkdD37XZk!ztZqd{zgT~h]&ItjZ!cXZk}(~p!Zk@g+B3 GEGGXhZDw6ti!y~d{

T~g&GZzgZoBXZyh]dZzg:gz7tHXZzgLq~ZsxaZDwd}]AwZZsHX

jZ)ge-u&- FGwhgZkFZiZvZ*XZ}X i`mg]o 1D

inqm]F`n^l]n! p: 2D!3 EOZm~~ZEwHX 3D^ing]f^ 4D

The Spirit of Islamic Culture 5DFZi2k*i~X inqm]F`n^l]n( 6D

FZi Z[LLfZZgZzg| inqm]F`n^l]n( D72k*i~X

KKK

ZDwM, 821

gzZ[~ZDw~Zzg/F]ZKFZZ~S:]z{ZDwZKz^GL_~iZzgQy

_0~"u]ZzgzWz{QgzgZm~!Zzg`z{Fzu~i!VzZ[~Zzg/6~gnXQyfZs~,Vk{:TFKzWgZ~ZoZN[ZzgW~

( thought content) B Z[x~cZkaZDw~~(}*Xz{ZyyzzVqpV~(ZZzgWfg=wDXZke~QytgLLZqZzoIg'Zz{ZKxZZ6Z\VZi~YXZZzg5HzV

Dw4qgz7ZzgZe Z C1 ic{n{U"YXg D/}ic{Zk~ZbZZzgWZ]7

ec/pV GLDt9ecZZ~Zp~zZPxZzgZ~HZgZZYXzZ[

[aX A~QygzJwezzu}.)Wg^(Qy4q!Z]7XZzgLewfg=XZkaZ~Zzgs~d~Q,VZLZkZL

7HXf!i!V~Zm~Zzg`Zzgi!V~QgzgZzg!zZ[XQy_0Z[SzZ]'pgi!yZzgzZ[QyzgXz{Zzgi!y7XVJ!mXQgzgQyaZq"ugCZzgizVF+z_5 G0ZgXZzg

921 gzZ[~ZDw~Zzg/F]

z{i!yT~QyF+XZzgh4+'ZbZcy~thought WnXQpZk!]ZhbZ0Zi{Qy~)

]] (g~Z3GELyBic{W}X~ process~D: p

py~gz"]Z%g~,FZ

lg Z ELZi{{%0+C

EELg

Z06Zx 0gZigfgpg!Z06Zx

({m sublimity of thought Z06) Zk~Q,VZKgfw E{HZzghg~g EGLZ06QyZ

ZKsgXpQygzJwezg'g~(ZCzqgt q^m^ Z~Q,V*zxZCcz%Zzg)

HZzgpZzqZi~qZg!s~xg;gZg6~WLZuZp~Zic~ q cXZp

ZoV~vs~pq~!g}~ZDw$ EG0~Lp~7WXZzgZke~Q,Vmg]pZ;:gztLZ(g7HXz{q/wG2sXZK0191Y~zeZ]~'LZ

(LLZLyVbFZp~q 6.V~z{ZqZic ]p ] C2 $*

EE0,Zzgg~gzq+cXZ)5191Y(ZLZq[~q!g}~ZL$ EG0zsD:

pZzq~~2sVXZo{z(Z~W`JaZ7ZZzgaZ7XpTz{7"zZVw6g~*eT

ZDwM, 031

C3 z{Z]$zgz*ZVzZX($ EG0 craft and artistary) Zke~t!]Z/wZzg0

ZDwZ,r3GE

]ZzgahVXZzgt!]gzi'zizZCYgZDwaw)g(~qZzg~~*

%:)ew(ZKgwCW}ZzgZk~ zx.ic{ZWQ,VqZi~JwH'ZKdZcx~-g\~Q,VLtLL~Z(Ck@Vqzb~uZeXtz{wx`,F!gZLL-Z~CHXYZDwtZkZKd~,

g1XZzgVJp,mz{ZDw/8[zV~g;XqwZDwtgZ}q~~ZzgZk@|'zVZp~a] Nz)"p~z"(fg=XZkaZp~ZzgZqV}~:stzy7ggVXzZ+gZQ,VZ#y!g}~CZzgZkgZLzZ:71Xz{Z#y&zzyz+LZ#Z*xcDZDw;VAZg0c)ZgZiAZVZg(Qy4qqZzgZ#y]j*C'Z

*zx]wZzgZgZaZDw~ZgAZ.{*gzxHZzu}(}(}7HXpZDwZzg*zx~gV,y9Zk(tzt~qZi~

ZiZqxi0ZzgxE{zg~T U/Uui}*xZzgx]-Vgi!yzZ[Z~gzZVzZV|]~Zi~w~qzZzggzZ[)!

ZDwT* ZgzrgqZ.{H'ZzgtZka.ZLZ*)Dg~@Zkx~qZzgz}ic{~Zi~ZqIyz1*yF-VJ'

R~Zsyf6ZzgW[zg8H'ZzgW`~Z06[Iyz1*y~ wz+!h* OpZDwgf

ic{7$Iyz1*y'zz~ZZsyZkgZzgi0Yzhf{zg ZgzVZzg*VZzgzWZVZq.

(*zxx~QCX idealism Xpz{gecVqI~)gZ] Zk*~n{CZk~7~ZLiZ

(ZkI higher ethics) ~Zz9QyyDqZDZDw{K%~gZ]ic{Z.{7 p ec

H'Zi0zZzgzZgZzg)q~ZquZzgF5kZsy$h5

GIGL$ EG0z{*zx~Zzgc

~Zzg/Z]zWZ]Zag:XZk~7*zxTbi0Zzg:

QOg6Zzg,~~Zs !%1oHZk7yZZCZ[WzZiZzgZy!Zk*]#ZgcYY

pzZ]gZkzWz{Zq~cP-V7zZtQyF-V)s~zbZZqizZwi0ZZzgzgZi0ZqzgZp@ptzgZ

(Zqty7g~7g~&gB t r anscenden ta l i sm)'t')s~'Zq+? EL!OZ`TC`ZsyZgZVQ)~gVZCZzgZzZZ$~g6Zzg*c[ZVwX*zxZsC~ZbZZkb%AHZ"gg'Zzg

ZDwM, 231

9BBZZyzgZ5Dzg Z~%2V@g;z]b) ELZW'ZzgZZyzVgc'tz{z~S:]X~Lq~Z*zxqez{)ZDw2Vz]-V}

EL

iZsy%z~vV6~WDQy9V{Zzg%vWiZgcZzgf[~VZzg5!y$zg-V67gWDZsyZq*'%1o~xc&*zxZg!i7 MM@zV~uZzgWQZsc]@g~'2Zs7g@g~'zZq

ZqiCXgbZzV~z)$ ELY(lZkZqO

zzVZN[HeZZzg_5h42. IGFJG'Zk4q)f!(*~~Lz'ZyzV!g}~gbQ,V*z]h)\(*VZKZK$43GGV~1**eZZzg]h_5h42.

IGFJGXgqwxVB:*zxZzgZDw3Xz{Zsy~*z]h*VbZg'gbeZ

!g}~ZkZKxL"0 EG0Zm~~){~*(k{lC4 -Vi!y~X

Ztwg1YZkZ$5 EEt*zxZzgZDw6@'Zsy]-V*zxZzg'h]-VZDw~i!y~'tZqzWzgZzgZkZsyzu~xZyoVdZ!ZzgZg*Vgz7]*7'@ZyzVxzVZsdzZgZzgZsCZzg*xCB6ZuZgg3X

g~~~g~zzZg6ZZgzZtz0C

331 gzZ[~ZDw~Zzg/F]

3ZqgzZez{TuzZzgZ~~Z*ygzZeHYYZkgzZeZnqzZV~|]ZzZzu~gzZe:cg:~g~XT

ej^(+ uZzg OgpZk-VJzZz](%peo(eno%m^l^(vn](k

ZgzZez~g~ZkUZgzZe unl Zzgc]ZzgZ*V:Zzgg:)byfg=cZzg:~ai!yzyZzg]zZ7gZ]ZqzWzx%AHXZDwZKgc]~ZgzZeW(Jc'p/Zzg25]~z{*zxcz~D3ZuZp~Zzgg"p~!

ZkaZyw~wZqwIZzgQy~ZVpWZzgpsbCwZqFILyZxZDwf{qZzgQ,VZkFIZ~HL1

e^- ayZx@Zk;VwI~ZzgHHg':VXFV~wZg$pgx~wE{ ]Zq(7'Zk~7wZqZ(T;V:Zzgi0CU6YcZ3ZzgZ7gZCcZ~wI~pWp%Zg~Zzg1cC3 EGG"gZ+qg'ZDwfa"u!$XZzgNpwQ|~ZKxF~pV!zTbI~ZzgZtqz{ZDwa@k/gz7ZzgWy~g7YXZKZm~~cZV)Z6.V(~ZDwwZk.e

pzg]/cZ~d:4Z;gWf{U]({''y@$h-

EIEg&EYLgZ%iZQgzZzgg~~ZDwxzuZgQy

xZg!qZDwZZxZ:Z0Zi~ZtZzZg6Ck1ZDw~~KgZ2V6^gZzgZyQ|~gg6g&EYLMXZpW^

y~)zaZZkcz) ZDwZzgZ2ZZgVZq5se}~@ZDw0c/J

2sgXTQ,VZL:Z[~yZo]7Hzq^~Zy q^m^ a:L%iZ(Zkc e^-] )

BgXZ~Z%iZZzg,zZzgWE~xWCWzZV~QygZps7X

531 gzZ[~ZDw~Zzg/F]

W{Qa~~WgZy{z\~Z6.3 XEZpZ{ +

~Q,V'`Zzg>Z7C{Z+ZgzZZgc q^m^V0~gOYzZVF~ZDw$ EG0t 2

(~dZzg)yZo]ZkaZkgzb~Q,Vg6'`Zzg>Z7C{[H'Zyz~~ZZ~Z*WiZ~Zqg]'ZktZDwwb

~L q^m^ ~~Lp~gZ]ZzgZPZ*WgizWCX: ~ZjZw~ZDwz{0LWtwTi

WyZ4,gLZyZ4

i!yQyZk= i0{gz Zk![~ZDwe~ZgH:

g8 {z&5 ENE$ ~Z}*!7 E

YLH?

Z[~'z{z:Zzgt-.E

GLz~A@Wgiz)(g8WZzg>6Zqpzg]{:

C@*.IGLZzhx *0&ZiZ0z Zi~g8; ~Zi@|QzzZ

qZk]W] Z0gz%7]W"VgZiz W"ygZgjZiz

Cwg;~z 0ZZ+g8z1c'8Wci*g@~Zi

z{caZC'=Zk@|C(53~X~Zk

ZDwM, 631

@|VcZzgZg8Z1'Zk~%v7]tZqz~Vi0'Zzgz;V]XtZkbg8

gV1J'Zgj8'ZaZ@tz{g8"gu*'7Y}tg8z1xZzgV'Cwgz7

' ZgZk|6z{X;z@'Ocg8g8~YcZk"ggh}@NZktH?ZkMx~'ZDwZZzgg9*Gr=

ZF+Zzg6izgF+k]~' q^m^ 6Wtk?gHm ZkZwZ[~LW[z LBg9*Gr=

ZDw%izZc:Cu%0L1g9*Gra1

(ZDwZkw )V}Lbz1u)z;Vg9*Gr='he'g}@BZ[c

zkz@ZeZZg9*GraZ!

)'kZzg@Ze'LzZ%ZZZzgZyZg9*Gra(gZZkk:Zg=~z{c&LZpqzZkncY@'tc{ZL~Zzg*gjgxyp)ahW!~Zzg%iZZkc~1

'%iZZkcZLZqxZ+gZu)~(~'ZkkZgZ~a'p q^m^

Zk~Z,LZpqngic{zsB7D'Zkk~7}:

Z0&=XLvWh W$z{zZWh

731 gzZ[~ZDw~Zzg/F]

Z p&-C YEEz =Z0gZigz>z{{L]Tg`e0*g}aZbz{ezuZg`aZYpZigz'Zk~zZ7MXZyx!V!zZDwgx_t!]zZg6

CkY$Qy;Vg~ZWZ]Zic{ZzgZy~ZgcYnX zZ7Q)ZDw(WBs%

~ZzghZ+g:~~)Zqgz{:Zzgg:~~*zx7z'ZDw;VgE{P]6:g]~'ZDwgzc&Zg~sH'ZDwZ+Zzgg-y~&54 IGGgcXpgZDwzZic{U"7CtZzg!]

ZDw'gfzZzgBD'Z%ZqZ,zZDwiF+Z!Zzg~@z~3XZs*~'ZDw$ EG0zZzgz%~ZDwZqTZyLZDwZ|sZg{C:

zk~ztHt~ZJzzWl'`ptgzZeWySu%HgZp~l1]Zq{Wi~Dwt~^: e^qfm

Zd|]LZZ.0*g{i~zx3391Y~'~'ZgZkicg]XtPZ6.VX~Zqg}cz~ZkgzGcg~4K:

Zi[zgW* Zkfs~ZDwJdz{QgzB2VQgzw

ZDwM, 831

~)Z'3391Y( %p^ M}ZzgZkpcZ7ZzgLL

Zk~{ZZzg:~sZg{'pZ(Ck@{ZZzg:ZgZDw~'Z`ic{o97gn

ZDwaA NFic{wZ0X +]qm 'Z%]4n. IEG~ZzgzZzgs!g} ~: +] ]4n. IEG~ZKWt~

~+Cz~QVZ]Z[xg]~cZzgt~g|i EE0zu]ZZq='TZqitZk~~

QyZq])gzqZzgZ435 EGGC(_KXXC+csm7tz{]W^w~ZkI}'Zy~ZZ}0zzgg0yZ!]}g0

931 gzZ[~ZDw~Zzg/F]

Z[@e:2"i*gZpZ+=ZyC_XsDWDXtwZzgszVWi~]Z]2VwZzgszVF-VJZy]ZzgZyi]Zg3'Zzu]ZaZqWi~

]M'Zk@WZ]Zzgs~Z7ZDwZk*xZk +]qm ~7MZaQ,V

~LZ[XZzgZi~g]~zu]Z~:Z=zu]ZgA IXZzgZPZ*ZZ~$ EG0'ZDw]4n.IEG~yZo]7BBQy$ EG0zZg6Z%s

+] (~ ~ )]4n.IEG +] H'ZzgtZq|

)ZDw(~Z:yR}Zzg6X qmgzZ[~ZDwF]_ZgHYY

ZE{:'Z'cXZkZgYg&xZ*x{ZqzZzg/x'gt*iZsg~7@Z[~Z!

ZzE{Z}z{~L)zZgX~ZNd-EELkZzgZ*kX

Nd-EELkgZhx/)x

h ILgZhx/)xgZizk z

ZiZQzZ*kZtwzE{}7 pZqxgixgcy

XZZzg!

%1o7':Lx)Z435 EGGCZkZDwgc]~~Lx)d~7qZkd~aZizVX

z>'L"5FEL!i!+@ EF0pZzgLpg{Zkd~zg n^ Z%'g0*y)xz(Zzg\gZW)\g*)(gZDw!-B5

GEGOW7HxZgzVigZ435 EGG])gz

Wzml(ZDwZgic{o97gBXZaZ]ZkfZW%A7Hz{Zi,x xgZDwz6.

ZgzV-Z+B5GEGOTuXZDwZkic{p

7X*gixz)x~ZDwaic{wy7XZq q^m^ /x*xZDw;VsZq(MX

~%ZkE{Hz{g~Wg;:WgZhzay'pgi!zx

cZDwxLxZzgDZ#ui]~Y*ZzgZk~ZZZDwzb~A6PZVZ7HXZkZZZDw'RXgZZ~z{|]Zzn~TZ1Zzg5"~@ZzE{P]~'o]H:

g:Zzg~c!@i{z,$* EE0z

ZqzZgc^V$ZzE{}7XZ%Zgc$'ZzgZqQgz~Z7gyZo]7H

G:Q|~ZkWZzgZkLZ*+Zzgpp :|x~ZDwagz7qn~wZzgZ1

WQ{OWH'"~ZDwZq:_!CzZ

ZDwM, 241

(~Q,VZkgzZexH5 n^ ZKZqg)"~:"Zy~DygzZi{gny!CYDgzZi{ghVZgH}y~ic{qZzgyT

~"~ZLZZ^ q^m^ agzZi{HYXBZzk~3cZzgZki!y8 E0ZzgD6zg~

dZzgZk]'ZDwZKZqgQgzL[/Z*Zsx~"Zk$H:

"gz(*.FGLsygZh{Zlgz+8g FILilgZ

ZyZz{XZyTg~E{H'ZkZyZzg'R"ggZXZgz$ZDw;VQc:g]~ZyE{'QZy*VzZqZ0Zi{@

ZDwgzZ[_HzWZzgrZzgQg]Z~zZ[)&&'ZQsZqZ(5

gQ,VZk$c Q|[cz_Zg.ZZ,ZyHi0{X]gg~g,~~

Zq"uczspQyZqZDw_"Zzg+B5GEGOZ

Zq![Lg:ZyZk ]^ur^ OWH~7ZL_"ZzgQ|[ZgzZ0t'ptZDwCkgZ[zZz+ZmgZkC0g}w'Zzg]hZs*aZki0{i00LYzhc':

Z[34i XGGi%GLWyZil*iuF{Wh745 ENEGz!mhZk!

dZfZykzVZzgZy gZ,c~~M'X~0LWtZzg*xgpZDw

341 gzZ[~ZDw~Zzg/F]

~aqs*x7Xz{ZiZzd~ dL7D'QygxZZzg)ZZx.gVZzgg~xZ26'Qy/F]~zwgfBBy0g]Zzg"~0ZkZQ,V

0gw6~:x/)x$h Z {ih{

xn!y%Z!ZDw'gx'pZkBz{g~ZqZzgQy'ZgZc!ZW'g~W~&Zp x

Zq{ygzgBX

jZX7X 2j^o 1D

2D "In words like cut jewels, Hafiz put the sweet unconscious spirituality ofnightingale". Stray Reflections, p.152.

[x'gZzu6gQ3Z6s4191YX 3D4D "And so in this Dante, as we said , had later silent centuries, in a very

strang way, found a voice" Carlyle:: On Heroes and Heroworship.

KKK

ZDwM, 441

ZDwF+g~:*)'ZyZ*F*Zr'*x*'V

ZzgxZyVZPxZzgQy!4g GIxZgZZg}6X|][mZ?xzDZgwv[z4y^sdzy7Vyhzz|(Z%pMUgZkXX-VMUgCDz{gVxcDZzgxgVLL!CMg'Y@XgZ]~Zq6|]Z'ZmZ?xZq{mzZ~XcLL~ZzZqZ,

o~YQyo:Xz;VvQxBZzgeg'kJz;VZzgQy gX)aZ51:31(gZ]Zk7]Zt|]-

^~'ZzgZuZLBX^~ZuZLMgzZ`xZzgF-V`Mg;Xxg6!-)GOy^ZZszZ+$z~!

Zg6gXcZoZ#yZzgZgTxzVXZgZuzZZzg=z6M`ZZ*i$gzZc]]B7Xz{2VZZzggZ]Jgq

9QwHgKZzgi0 XgckZzgZkZDwgcHCp[z*p[6Yw)kZ#y('Zd6$Zr:Nn'tZ*gQZdZqgCZzg~z3cX**g}i0{t

gzZVZL0V6QVgBXtZq (X4y* slavery) C1 *k|&QkFcC'VxZZgzV}qX

ZsxzZkz7g~v[*~%`XZsxZk8c7HYZ(* (7 historical necessity @g]z[)(@ZkaZzgDg historical impossibility @g]g6*e)

QwZCcXVB'Z'~Zzg)zZ]|uZzg!]!]6VMiZS'ZkxF+Zz!ZZ]XZpZsxMzZFZzZgJgpZsxDgZZkbHVz@`ZzgExz.yzZg_cXtZsxx]ZWXn*CXZzgZ[Zv[*gZzg;^~

ZZzgZMZgzwzig 'Zag7XZ%]h*~(!4ZzgZEgeg]~5gcBqwc(ZZzZg~qbX

ZyZC'!ZV4+ZCb'!gXZ)

ZDwZyZp~yH:Zizb!@ Ziw'-. EGg$y

[Zz{*[ Zi c~g[ Zi

ZDwM, 641

Z+zMy!Z+zMyZ0g Zi)Igz!glay[L"Zx +gx Z MyPZ0g@CiyCgZg} gC!}ZiCl*Zgr Zi%hi*g

p$zl %"%vz gfztz>gZZlw~%Y@Zzgzba!ZVYCX~Z

Z-YD ~(J9$zg~hYCX~gYD X~~)YCZzgZZZqzu}'u

Xxxgz!]q"ZxYC>}~Zzgx~XnZZZqzu}DDgT'ZzgCw~Cz*aZ@gLX$z%h6i*g!0|

QkC"7Zg}XxgfztY@)Zk2]ZzgZ0Zi}YD(z{iC"Xz{%I

X %Y@ZzgZkbcZKZL+V6QV@g]ZgZDwZqxx~aZpQyzbZgZzg

Va(MiZ~wpZQy!(ZS*yRV Xz{MgizweTQgzi!yx~Zzg'

ZqMiZpZ[HXZ|IZ:Zzgbx1YM> CkHYYZDw~xF@gz7XVZZsx$h EI

RVa!

Yp~ZzgMiZ~Zq|z,XZG2@MZpMTV6ZuZ!

*Qi0{HXZkaZDwa qTH Zzg~ZgcXnt@Zzga%gzwe4g GIZ*

!GZ0'5Zzgz~: lhp~$( ego or self NzZ%M't;CZzgZ435 EGGCsV~p~)

Z7g}Zzg(sV~MiZ~zweZg}X-VZDwXZX!g6MiZ~zweeRCZZzg(Z]=%]

g6Xpg6MiZ~tg]XZzg!g}~ZKHX@zXq6 s ~!]Zq5/zw M

e B +]qm Q,VZq~LL*)"My~g-X r*)L*)'ZDwF+g~s861BZg6pZKZzg/pVZgZDwzu}0g}

(~zg MMp minor 7XZ"g!QQyZqn)ZZDw~~zxqQyzu~Zq

-g6XZk er YXL*)'7291Y~Z3391YXZyzV T q^m^ Z"Mt~

-V~g*s~T,M{Tg~yXL*)ZDwx(~ZzgZ-Vb)s~d~XhZkq6

Zzgq6'*~Zzgc~7XZkaZk~ZDwZq/g*)ZgbI:Xt~eg(}Z*])Z1Z[(6

;'

ZDwM, 841

1D*))(2Dg.3GE0y

y 3D

^ I0g^ I0 WZ0gZ5 EGWHgzgcyzl l7 WZizyg;!;iCgm g)glg;Z0gU

iz' N{$ENg uzi0{ .g >Zl0{8FNV'gzig g

qxg! plFZi)d-) GYVHZ}6zgg('ZqZ+ui}>;+[]{g{ggTwDVZ(~VZj;Ve7gCVZzgVDgCV'Zkui}~Z+xZzic5Z'z{Z+ZZ+a!%Z'Qkui}ZV~Wv?ugV?~>.3g;Z+Wv.3DNeg7lZzgWv)gzV6,Zqzu}uUV,X5ViCgkg;'Zzgz{WvZ+T?Mh3zZVbV'ui0{zZ'Zzg"$ENg{z@g?!)Z}}Z(Z,^IGL~wgx4'Zq)@gq(x!Zq/t

'./ GG er 6Qz6Tg~yZLL*)'7291Y~g6(YYt~7291Y~cZkI

ZDw~"z{QyxZy~ er XZzgq^m T!g}~wHY@z{&w~ q^m^

wZ2391YXcZkWi9291Yc8291Y~Z'VZq ^waZ@HteL*)gUZDw)g~~(

g~q q^m^ rzqH'?ZzgHte q^m^ZDw!-B5

GEGL*)Z5'?Zk~7Zqs

egZwZDww~zqXeZL"0 EG0Zm~

ZDwM, 051

ZqsZDwg~'YL*)tZDwCkZz{'L"0 EG0Zm~i6'Zzgzico6

q^m^ ZqegZZzg6~7g~g]gnXtZzg!]~ZzgzicoyZkb7TbL"0 EG0Zm~~M

/ZYL"0 EG0Zm~g6Z' q^m^ tIic{izV~ziccziqjwo'ZkaZk q^m^ z{Zi,

~yKzq^zgZy}LLgziczZ7Zk!z'ZqZ(ZzgL*)Zkg{!~ q^m^

xgZqN!]tL*)Zkziq~LLizg~Z+6%Zg7 q^m^ Z+'Z+fXp

@']I\@gOQzZZq?%Zg@Z% ELii6ZgzZgfW)}tzQ(p3~izgte)6Zg(3c

z{zL*)Zkxg' q^m^ 'p3'ZqyZq5y@X

@i\:. XI"iYy Whx&-C EYEEgy

gzy V'zyy phx?hxipy_5 IEYy!wz6[g8 gZgZyagxZi(;54EXGEI%{'i g0{#Ciy N0ggpy x0Z digZZyqgxizggZz& py!pyZ0gU

)Zk(~)Zk(y~7W$XQkpsYy"Zzg":Y@~H?~pyZqgZ(gT!~yZzgC~y)QkgZz6(Z~,ZkbZkg~Xz{,XW

Zzg!wz6e0~bXZkgTVbMh3zZ

151 ZDwF+g~:*)

XZkpsgcYgi6' N{7}g')g}>u7hXC{~:"yQk+? ELp3~C'VU{g'Zg~Zq3CWgX

Zyzo~tsZ)*)(mZqg{1x)ui}(Zqp3,y@ q^m^ gz{giZg(ZzuZ)

~Wv?Zzg@gOzu}~VgZzg"VI^I^aZzZ}~Wv?Mh3zZVb3Xzu}~VbMh3zZCc

XZ%,ZzgZyiCYWzVo~'Zq~Wva NqXzu}~gcp3a NqpsZzgXzV

(q'Zzg pictorial value i'y~ck~gz7)qsZkaZk~ Z q^m^ y?X)@a

g~ZzgzZg'}ic{(V.[:uZzgqg~~zu}![ZyLLg.3GE0yXT~ZDw

uZzgqg~jZV.[s~Z]cXXZg~ZysV~tZ*! C3 zgZ435 EGGC Z C2 ZDwZg~

3E

GG'ZgZZgXZzgZ435 EGGCZysV~Z*~}&3 EGGWiZ~*Zk!3 EGG~C@ZDwZzo5k C4 ZzgZkZqWiZ3GG

V.y%vWiZzgdwzuV.y]ZziBZk(X]IZ: normative e~Zy$ EG0zZg6gIZ:)

fg) (7'z{]zw19eT@Zy naturalistic)X Zzg}dqi0{gXz{)w~wWlzg~B

ZoTmZf{z{!HH

ZDwM, 251

"7{*~QC7~@7gzN9. XNEH

L*)~!gZDwVZzgV.[se6,B{HX~Z\V!g}~HCVX.yu@u%vVDX

p*Zi\ %v;Z0g.VZzgVV.y!}~ZyQy.yXi0

wZg]Zzg7 EOtgzg~DXZk![~uZyVfz6Zkb{D:

aZ$-Z] $* EE0Qz{Zi*]-8FNy3 EIZ;x 8FNyQz{jxfzZEOZ%zig ZiZfQzig

%qZZ0gQz Zi6QzWDgZgZQzZiyZgi%GNZ *ZyziZgi%GNZ

g]Zz' ZgZ+$* EE0]Zz'zVZW / xi0wZg]{@z{i0-Zg6c[

@Xx%Qkwb{z@gCXZbxQkb-@XQk9' N{wiY[XQZZOg7:Z%ziZkaEO]u*XQk!~zZZkgZiWDgZgXZki~Zq]

yCXZzgZL2i0ZzgZ*WiZ3 EGGgZ3DzY6C;WzZiY6V~fz]^` NYD

(iCY@Xg!CW@ death instinct cZy~85 EEOG%v)Z0g66gY@'ZzgZ0g'ZZzg7@XY{~LCz!ZqnzcXC!6Zzg!C6ZWZ0ZiXxu8g* FI0]{@:

ZiaLOYy*WZ![~ZDwVopVyZzg*gzxjZ

g]zpZqizu6ZqZ+gZuHVopVyD:

@'ZiwygZ !h"5 GNEz#Wgpwi !hy6zg{sgZbQzyZy Zi'ELQz>6zgyZyL0gz"wsgzhx ?guzZWyx

*ecXbHz@wV1Q@gn*ecV6zglHZXZ(Zkpy~Wv`Z(Zk?6zZymJcYnZzg{ZkzcYnXY}?'o~ZqxZ(@V%ZpxaZ@XL0gz!wsgzhx'*gzx^qZy7gZZqoY]zT~z{ZqZgi!y}Zz0\gpZD:

0gz"wsgzhx gZWyx yY }}Z#-) EE Z ')~(zbz{x3VZp%xgzGC Z}6zg

t*gzx"F+]F)yXZDwZk]M,oSZgcZk~~c@|Z,xVDVx"!3EOGLwsFZzl@Zq6ZDwZqZbZDwZk

ZDwM, 451

}6yz*yu{Ztyz*yu{yZ0XZ~uaZgXZDwZ6{

D:~ZHVTb]~yaZ}XZkMW~Qy'hZwHLLHW\z]zqw?ZkZ[~ZDwz{u!

)EM'ZgzWig~ g]~ Oyhx_}!]}Z0g$ gZg7G0Zk

x$zl % M}y7l z}7gzkZU *i&4/ EGEgg"ENG{U

Zz]INlZr WZ0g cZigc~ZrZr*6z@Zzmi YG `"Zi$* EE0[:^'!!c ZZipg{

g]~:Zk~LZ'Z:Wig~')Zk Zkb~]xg6t(Zq@g*gZ

L7~{&GXeZ,Zk 2j^o ZkaQ@W@GZDwZqCXQ,VZLZk*y~H

XtZDw7c6291YeZ,'ZtLZDw*)~'ZkZ0Zi{@ZDwq6Zk!zm!g}~ic{ic{]q~XZk~z{

C7 eZ,:LLeJ7r!Z?iZW\0kyz*qgzVkzVZZqzgzia%X~Z9eLVXZZ(:Pgzk

*xXZyBZy*y*zg~X~tx*eLVyz*qg!kxp}ZLaZN[DXXZjwzk*x{me454 XGGXZkz{VWg^6Z[z{BX

ZDwgXtXP0@z{t:

X x!K[_7H 1Dm6291YZDw)qgzV2Dz{zkBQy*yeTX@YyLLyz*qg

!kxp}ZLaZN[DX3DQ'R~qg~zVZ{VXXwZjwZzgh

Zjw%ggX@zV!Z0ZiZi:X4DZki~qg~i0{){yXwZjwXT{

zkZDw!

qg~LLNU]ZDwtWtz]XfQ,VL*)~HXN!]tZDwXLNU]

gzkZ:'XZjw fHQy~LL*i&4/ EGEgg"ENG{:'Zzg' ]xD'ZbLL_}!]}Z0g$XLL%

x$zlXZzgZcZigc~ZrZrWZ0g^GLZzlZr

Z,]Zya NZrp,zk~cYYXZp7~ZDw,d~b@$ Nx7 2j^o

1X-ZqgZicZz{'R]hqg~ZzgS~Zq9. XNEBBZo LL*gg*)ZgZzg,W~d

j,ZZgztZ(gDQyZLZp~:ZkZ%WUgcV[tZy9. XNEqZKf)Zg-V7gZZkg

XZz{i0Z"54i EGG,2wg;wZkZ[}e:'k/~ZkwHg8Z(g}ZzggZ6^XZk

~ZkpgpzZg}Z3XLZkFoiw6ZK,:7( 2j^o ) )gX

9. XNE!zZk7~ZDwZLg Zkd z{zZZp~Zk|ZyHZsxR@g~LLZ

yZ]'Zs.['uqg~uJ~'~igXzu}Zp~'ZDwZg*V

xFZkZqg~'ZzghZjwxqgZ:gzZc]Zsz') GOyF)y+~@bHXpZtYZsx~i*iZG{.y~ZDwuJ~1Z0Zi{@z{Zs.ya

"uVf~gXz:z{Vqg~7g}

ZDwM, 851

f}g:XYZkf6gzbM~Vqg~~!gCELgXL*)zT \ZhZZzg@`

~Q,VL:qg~]Y^{1'ZDw8j NEZzgZy.[ZbZWsZgZDwi EE0)1]z~Zk~Zk{6ic{ZgHY@XZL.yZzg{qzVz{"DDgZg'ZzgL"!g}~ZkaL$ EGILaZ*"uz{p~zgZzgZkaggQk/Z7ZxZkfztX

gDyzgZ5i0 gZg-i{Zi]+W!&4i JGG&4FGILZ gZZip'zy8h4 EGEZ'iY4 qiyZip$h4 GIGEgf4iZZ0gBwyu ZiggZ#u

zbZ~ "Zi {gz"gzi0"ZiCZ#Z,gZi

)"(]tgZDyZzgZV6eZeZmXZKfZ]!Cl*tZkae34/ XGGz{g}tVXZk)"2g(ZqxaZKfZ]g8C7Hg})ZgZ](j6L):](7}gZXZkz{7ZkWV~g9YNXZkaZkJ~yuw7

Xtb~I'"gZzg'ZLzbZ~x7WXi0)gZ(Zi%7'ptz{gZiZvYX

V

|ZDw

Zi;ZzWzg WzggZ+zLZgr %Z:zT

)ZyqgZ]yzZV(ZLW\ZLZ0g!CZzgZkbZKfZ]HZkbhZZqx~ZqcXZkyZC1)Z}#(pN)]zZg(qCZyg{NZzgy~Y@)gZ(ZL

sY@YZL;)ZyyZCbC'tzCZy %Z:Zzg Z0Zi{@(

zV|XZkwZDwZKZqW~CZc6zWqZ{V%jx

gZz~017391YZqxQ,Vzu}Zx[B)7 2j^o ZDw;VZg~ZkWuZkW~ZDw

ZzgL*)~yKZ]Z{HwgtQyz]sb{W:

yZ.[~~Zszb7WXZsyZ] tzZ~WCz{=Zzg}7WXZ%%-g\zZ36^YZtZZzgz;V*V'5XZyGzVBy!V"ENGX~)]z(ZqZ+yT~

OWZX]Zk|]/KZzgK]ZsxaZCZZ~K]Zsx%1ZW~6QkzZz{=Z[JcXx(gZzgf[zdX

ZYe;K~Z4iZZzVXpK]zw=Zkgz %[c=ZCtZqg]x:@Kzg6ZkbC8 VX }w~stZk~ZkK~i7".7 Y

ZkW~ZDwL@`6{D:K]ZsxZk~7WCXqgVbZk~]

161 ZDwF+g~:*)

C9 KWZzggZ]KaZiy@X*[ @L*)~ZDwL@`7gyZd7HZLLC

(ZgcZzg@`~ZgZZZqLZ$ the purest pearl)0{FX@ZDwZ]ic{GzZgZgcX

gZ!(y^0 NEGZ %ZyaLOpgZ&Z Gh;Ziz %Zy0uzg3ay0 G

)%ZV(@`y7HZCgZiWDgHczVVu G)%ZV(zkb0{Zzgg3XZzg)ZK( 6zcXG

z%%,'WXL*)ZDwF+~YZpzg]F+~

YnZkaZkZ"gZk~ZqZgiZzg6aZcZk~(ZZqitZk~ZzgdZ*7XtZkq6*zZuWiZ~Zzgweq6"g>V

?* XpVZzgxV;]ZyZzgZyIi0HCg0Z8 ZzgcZkqZkb7gZXuZ{VGL

~V;]6dcpZk;]Z]sZDwL*)~ZKpzg]Z:Z]B7H'!

7cXZk ZkZDwV

Va7gZZ0Zi~_!E0LF3QgZqt@xsV~6gZZk'@ZDwZgZCcZ-V|x@

z{uJZKpf)Zg ZxZKq$%[7@'@Zk~ZzgaZDw~Zzgh*IhZgYO@ZzgZk%~_/X

jZ!g}~ZsxZz[M,ZZ],a5uZ 1D

zXgx(,>F ^ln ) ^]e_^o {V"Z[g

expressionstic 2Dmetaphysical 3Dfree causality 4D

Zi6zWqZ{V r^l )ZDw;VZqx)ZDw,Zzg~( 5D81X

%eZzikWX f]u2j^oVnk] 6Dzx,]133233X ]f^^ 7D

Zi6zWqZ r^l )ZDw;VZqx)ZDw,Zzg~( 8D{V81XZs26X 9D

KKK

361 ZDwF+g~:*)

ZDwfzyCPZX}ZZV%9. XNEqWiZpgzgyLUq"{UZ

7 C "gzB{U;

~Z]'.[~ZDwzic{ysgX!

:uJZkZ]ZW~WYCX2aiVZzgkVBZyiZzgKg(Z1ZkaZDwOg6.[dzW~Zic{Z~XC-VCk@ZDwuZzgqg~

yic{ZwHpwZ(7XQy !g}~{Zzg WgZZ[Zzg~!g}~'ZkTic{.

se{q' $JLzz{yXnZDwfzy(ic{Z time (~iy) space ZpQyZg~kV)

qpZLZ435 EGGC~z{iyZzgkyZq|zUwD'ZzgW6cz~~iyZzgkyiVXkV

(6Zy space (Za]Zzgy~bCkV) time-space)si-VCD*kg6ZDw]z

yZDwZk~zZZq(Z:tZsy X(}'ZzgZky~ZzgZ435 EGGCZ(]gbw

\qZCZZzg@` ySpXZky*K ZDwZsy~Z+4543 XGJGVwz)wzV gKZzg

yXV[ y~ZDwZjZZs X~z{LcWvZzgLIKj[)siZd(z{V

e^-] gClDX xZyqgZ]ZzgZyy~Lg*~Zk_"ZgzZ1ZZg]~ZX

zl6ZLZV%zV-V!g W{!Kz{ygtZkuVg*y i0LgZ[y

ZL^ NO@{uZ{{u6V0VZ*{

h0L]yZZ]IL)VZZ pZ& EYVt2]ZW{!Zu'Xxut g*V1t{uzV0t854 EEEIL(V8g FILvg g zVy]W,Zk

ZDwM, 661

Z+*Zkk~ZF$7W&40 JGE0Lk~

Zk~ZDwg*'!g}~zr3GEZpZEwKy){(Zzg]W,'{Zzg]WZ,S:]

(Y@XtZ%U"{ZDw~Zg3 EGOG sublime &ZgcY)pZkBz{ B z (Zzg!Z*]Zgic{. sublimity)

BzoDZka{gYq]g} !Zg{gYjZ!gz-V6ZWZ0ZiDZagCqw~{gYq]gegDecZzgZy6ZLgoFDgxecXY!sytg@

ZK!3 EGG]ZzgZLZg$z{gYZ`$wYZzg$wXGt~tpZDwzZsZp~ZL~XZywZxZzoDgWfg{)"~(Z(gCZkxg)}(x2cV@:

2CZkxVCZZkxZCgWig~

Wig~L"~Zzgz LWig~'g=ZbCguZsZzgZDwZ*~EFu*Zg)ygZ'g]@('p/gZ]jZWig~']Z0SZzgZs'Zzg]))(ZDw4qZ*{XLZCZ^Tz{ZaOWZqz{zZxZg

]wpXzu}Qy~]x71X@[{lc~ Zk

]gerKyZCZxVgZ#u

;BsZ$etk

761 ZDwfzy

]WiZ9. XNE3 :%Z{q

g6!.yC,zZ)wCz!)zq(ZzgxZzgwz i]Zzgez[Z]ZgZ*Z

]F)y*ec'ZDwCqw~Zyp~)&.5 GGL({(BzZhXZkaQ,Vzu} ZzgQ"p~)

y!g}~7VZqX !.y!g}~z{Zg i ZpZDwZX}ZZwDpzya

p(|tZJgZZCZ[)!

fZDwZk~ZzgZLxZg~X Vt!]$45 GGGES.( motif ~QuZVc'W~!gu)

ZzZHXIcu%Zz{~_/Z){c(T6/eJZ2Zg@'z{Zi,Zk~ image g)

( end (BBZkecLq) cause L!)czgZyg7McZiZkg~]~gTXuZVc~ZDwTLI

(cuic{ZZgcXz{G']" motif)Vw-V~ZDwtU"H{gYZjZw$w'Zk|z{WiZZzgxV.yZizZD

yaZ![!0J' '*)~Q,VWiZVyZ)pV %ZWiZ('T~Q,VWiZV y )g

] ]ZsxZzg@`)1Cgz7Y^{1K BBKZsxVZzg@`Vy#:

WiZ%Zy/ qiy!gy+zZ`ZZg~ &zgZzg~Z+pgZ{Z0 pgZZip'zyWzg{Z0gzig}gZ7hZ0 _5{ZxcZ+g{

961 ZDwfzy

LLh~kag}VZ(gzZzgdWiZ%zV)/(bC'Q^ZzgZzg~g*

d'W@Z?~j,XQ,VZKfZ]g{ZkbHZLW\ZLW\!CWXZqzu}BZkbk3HiZqxB!0|c'Z,g{NZKfZ]~F@-VIecNZq6p~Z4')gZ!]t(sW@

;ZV!@'w~z6. XGL%Z:ZzgT't>{{)K(?:7g'gzb`Z:gcz'~ZLW\ZV)7g~b%Zg7(X~i0

aZC' gc07\'ZPxZzg6Z\k}cX}Z0gSOZv7'ZkaZ

>{ZkKcy7YX]ZsxE{XZDwtZg:sZy tZ+ZK

R0uzy~VIZsy6 =D'mZsy~ZDwX 4+}gzgnIWiZ%Zy/(ZfZ]p~ uZrcz{_!E0we)S:]'Zzg]!ZsxXz %Z:ZzgT ^Z$ey

\Zzgzu~ )]ZDw"uOWZy~ZqK]Zsx'yZKtZDwZKZ*)VZ K

p~Zs($zg3~Zzgz{ZyZ]CK%7g{n]ZsxZyZq~ZyZ]wyH: LK

%}"g~Z[H!MS[%{zZf{z"fz%

n yT 8g FIL]:Zci~V

ZDwM, 071

YVV:*F~^Z!5

ILiY`Zkz

F~ycVQiTr~c01ztZ[V}~z{wZg]z{Zi

"Az@gzV~[>ZzggzZfZV~:~:{ %~!8

HZgZNZ,V@VZkZ%=PZVq~7ZkKgZDwX

Z]zegz{gZVZZ*$zg~Zyfz%Qy!VxZPxZzgZkF)D

( anguish) ZkK!g}~ZDwgZqbxy'Zzggz5w\ZDwzizZiZZbzZPZi'Zzg g]'ZK

\ZDw Vw!g}~Zq6gcWHXzZtKB uU"T~ZDwi EE0]Zzg ZqZ+xZy

BVZ@g]eZzg)1CUW:Z}w\!GZz

GuZ0zZxT~7gz1] g8czTcwsz

70Lp%0Lp] L@wpyZizuzgzuz~cwzi~ZBiVgVZwz)w%}Z?Yzz{Yz

171 ZDwfzy

~0GZg}2V"gxZ~W+B5

EEG

}gz!x6zZ)Z^gZo{ YLLZWDg0LgZiZkVZkVZiZkZkxZkuzgZktZk*iZk*i0E0Zg!!T#GELwx%;Z0Vi~!GLzVZ~~n

V~Zzg7}! *xp%Z{xp%

\LIZDwGZgcT-Vg'$ KZq{m'p~g pZDw;VG

ZDw~ZgGT"@!zZCZ[izZi'Zzg ZVZKfZ]zV'Zzgi0'FWCXK \yZC(~ZDwZqZkwz)wWc'K

G \ZkaZDw4qyV%:ZqZku_/+%: zu}z{:sw:s)wZyVZZ`@F

']Z~ZDw4q0g}ZZtz{\ ('K objective correlative Z)!

\wz)wZZz{%}Zw: ZaK!GLzVZ~~n

V~Zzg7} \~cV zi~Zzgw'ZqZzgyZCSZDwK

WCX@`hygZS:]zzizZwX]Zsxf@`.5G[ L*)Z![~T~K

3X@`gZgi%GL" Wy*" q

qxWZiZ$0{F %%liWgzZy0{FgZ!(y^0 NEGZ iIL%Zya LLOpgZ&Zh;Ziz iIL%Zy0uzg3ay0

gZ6{g6{Zg iIL%Zy$ EGLp!ygZgZiPzayzy* 6. XGLZzWzV*

iZg*hiWhp"'> Zi;

ZqZk{Cd'ZzgZZ9sV~9e0~gZ]~d'Zk%%0ic{!ZzgZkhZqZ$eic{0GZg

wGgZiyH'cVZ )@`Hc(ZI'%zVG0ic{0uZzgg3XtGzo

>@X%zVG81VOqKXtG"s[@Zzg6{gZk)@`~(WV6}gXZkz{y~7W@')@`(GZL;ZL.V{!E0L![QVcX@`!g}~ZDw7g~~~Zq{Xphtt

{AZk}ic{ZzgwZ0'@`aZDw*[Z$ic{ $]ZEwz{&Zpg~%XC

371 ZDwfzy

0GZg6{gZzg6{Zg0uzg4z]Vg%G"[zZ@`'&ZqZgZq,~ zZZzg;

ZDw)0x1XZzgx!V(|XZDw4q@`setZkG{Zzg0{_"%g6C

y%:B XZkBBz{@`L%ZMiZ'yZC.yZDwtpg7Zy.e}fZC~*]ZzgfzyF)yX

Zy~~XqgZ]E{WcZzgZyXS:]6izgcXZzgZDw~!.yXZ`zoHZygz~

y ZDwy!g}~P}Z5Z`DYYtS:]Qy4qZZzgzg~:

grandeur 1DyZzgsublimity 2DgfZzg

3Dwz)wc_~ZzgC~ZZ`)_~"C~Yz~(4D]WiZ~)]WiZ9. XNE(

)pgZZip'zyWzg{Z0( self-ecpression 5DZfZ]cfz%Z}wx )qX@i{Z@i{%() motif 6DucI

\!GZz()qxWZiZ$0{F( relative eternity 7DzZxZzgZ$ey

ZCZ[ gZizZi self-consumation 8Dpq{Uq"{:Z7 )pgvzgy Zzg

p%(inspirational 9DwZzi~Zzgw

iIL%Zy0uzg4ay0( ) purity of feeling ]0ZzgC 01DZ11DZgZzgZ)gZ6{g6{Zg(

)%~{{HAhtwf![:( truth 21XZ

ZDwM, 471

-VC(}.[:ZzgZyg~eVy !g}~cZ)iZgwH'pcs

yZ ZUV07'ZatI7ZDw)1]ZzgZkg~ZzgVgZ]~zZ'ZZDwp

yZC1)1C{g*7@ZkHC'ZkhZZ0Zi{t ZyZg@X~Q,VLZ#u~sv q^m^

zP]g~'ZyugWyx wsz?{xzx*xi0{zZ*zcz gcyZi{;ZzWyZ0g'l q}Zi9zi{-Zgzgl+Z06gZpZgzi1V g EGLZz'FZiPzbyZi!5

ILkg WyzuzzWyg

ZgZifz%g&EYL Ciy'z'o@({'iigZZ Z,g!Z\yZ

ZZ0gyzl i %ELzk Ozl ; CsZg{fgZzW[Z0g !gZ0gZy/ZzZi1z6uZi` =z-ZgzZvZi`jgcyh!ig+$ Et 'z'(MyzUt

zZWZx gxV&4mk0 EEIG'Zzg&EYLig~WzZiZzgZL{x'Zzg~*xXZkx!g}~HYY

i0{zZ*ZzgK6ZiZzg XZk}M@gzDZ!0YDXtZqT-Zgzg9zi{VWVZk

ZKz~1Zk~zFZNzpZgzi1Vg{YD'z{ZkYwZzguzZzgg'~z{

kgbXZkYwZzgfz%!CZq*g8Z(gDXZYz~tZO?QOigg8uc~

571 ZDwfzy

$w['CsZg}CtDZzgzk60{i')6ZiXZkZzg6{~Zqg!gWgZ3Zkfg}W[ZKXZk

Zzg-Zg,Zzg2y`lZkZzg5Q`XZkgzVY+jg,#!0hXgxy~6ZzgZxyzzZsvXZkgZCy~~Zzggfic{Z~XC

tZq{m(tztzZzgZk!GM~zk!g}~V{]g@ZZZDwy~{]Zq%:Zg}1YZ(:'Zk

+C45GEJGqg]~ic{Zz1Zg,

qXZkNStZk'vzCZq*(gDZzgig,=~ucY@ZzggVt+Zzg1JC g8Z

Yg~gSXZDw~i'wKhtZz'ZqZzgIZZzkz,ZDwI7WYXg6tgHmqgZ])!

ZDw~~egZZDw!~ZqUtQy~~Zk!.y

xi0{ZzgZ*ZbZ'Zqzu]W}ZzgpZbZg]~'ZK3DXZpZDwegZ7ZkaZy~ZzgegZ~Cm37pZ'LzZtZDw~

9zegZ.y~zZ/ZzgzZx@X$GNV~ZzgtI~egZsb Z egZm*XKXZ

gSZzgegZ~s'833 GGGGZ7XtZzg!]f[Z!gzZc]~~ZzgegZ~F-VJ*kmg;ZkVwQgzZ[~l*"Zzg"'Zkag};V~

egZg"*i)ZzguJ"(g{ZKXZf[~egZ~zr!Zzg~egZ=q:kgZzgZyzV.y~czbz$ymg;Xg~~gzZc]~egZ4:'Z'Zk!zQgz~~egZuZr*Z(7Zk|tK%eg0Lg7~ZzgegZ/gzZ*_9sV~f!Z[jZHYYX

(c verse ZpZk|XZtD~s)fegZgzVZL~Zq izVZs7'p*9.

{mbZaZaxegZ$4-

g',] IgZg]h42.IFGJZ$j EEZzgg}~KZZ'

~ZzgegZ!bm(}g'kXWeyZzzeZzgzu}gZzu}xegZgzV

GL'Z~ZzgegZm

Zq!gQi0{cXZ!]t~ZzgegZ'zVZkZxF xZbZZzgZyF0QV6X~ZzgegZ'zVZpZy

egZZk (z;V speech ZkVBZEwDXVx)ZkaxZKL43 XGOG~#3EGeg~g6GzZc:zzTbegZV~pZ{z{~VcxZdgZ~ZbZYD,ZkbZhZzgZdgZ~)ez{

i!yZzgmgB(egZ8{7$XZkgqw4+Vw)ZDw~T~egZz)uJ&ELz'-V6ZZg{H~~egZVBCZiZzg(};VYC'}Zq{:

~ NHm]t&4g

GEOH!ZkZq~egZxFZbZ'Zgk?)ZzggLO(

(egZcV'g{~t situation ZzgcgzZ)xcZbZXZg)~Zzg(k?)~: NHm](Zzgcg)t+H('cgzZp~

'nZk{~egZ}xZix'pt'Zzg~~egZzu~VBZZzg)g~Zg~Y$ZZDw;VegZTzZZzgp&g]~WDZkZZkZzgZ~7HYYZDwZZL/a/gBZEwHX

Zk~7egZZ~TZzbwZzg

ZDwM, 871

WzmlegZ~VZzgyz{egZz{Zzg~C7$'pZkbz~ZzgZg~gVegZDXegZZ0Zpk?Zgg~VzZzg#~egZ

tz{ZbZZZ:~YN~~egZaZZzgt!]{]Z0Qgz~xegZ)cegZ(

(~Zzgi0{gzZex!zZDwZKZ:VaegZZyZbZic{x1egZ"Zq{m

Z0Zi~Z@gmJW}@W1Zzg#!bmkfg)WzZZgzV]ZzgQy!m,

Zs'z{S:]ZDweg&6VZzgZy&6V]Z0Zg67g~7g~gzeZrX

tZwZDwegZYV7Zk~{ZqZV6ZkZwZ[~YYZq{gY|&

g]Z0Zi7HYYtZDwtZnZzgegZi0{gzZe7Tx~z{egZZqdwWZzg!z*g6ZEwDXZgaZm~egZi0{gzZe7Zi-gzZnZzgegZZqzW:zgZq'ZDwaZc

gzZe:'Z'ZkZzgKmQgzZ[Bi0{gzZeg6L7g;Z-Z0gfHYzZtz{Z0gzZ

4egZgzZeTZZzgWy~g]WegZXTbe^ W7Y$)YUT e^e`^ Z*ZkZzg`

i W Ig3Z'ecX(Zbz{egZgzZeT$ EG0 e`^Z-Z0gZgcY@WegZVW7(|$Z!]Zke~tZDwCqw~ZqZzggxeT

'ZzgegZZkzJsf[q'h'WVZDwegZ6

971 ZDw~~egZ

Z435 EGGCZZ]X=fgZW^,'pZk!zegZ1%Zgg~~ZZZzgkCZ0Z

wZKY+zg'zzZyZZ Vp!ZyZ8~0Zw~Zig{ e^-] V~kCZ0ZyX

>ZkZ0ZiXZkZzAegZZq)ZZzgZqNhZzg*~ZqZzg~k6F'LL{uZgZpkC71egZ@W7gXegZ

: @WZkzu}zqY@Zzg$ EG0z`Y+bW@wY}= fgZ!

ZzgZk?egWZ}=Z}wuVgT??

ZkWyVgT?!z{]{UZ%zizZ?Zzg!

Zk]Z+)]ZzgLZgzZb!g}~Z]Zqs$ EG0z`6@:

W{z{g@gOHg?ciuZ0g??CzgZiZk45 YEELZV~?]Su8-5 FNEGZZV~?

L]Su8-5 FNEGZwZV~'ZkegZ$ EG0z`Zzg$ EG0Z!xXZb=zwZyZzg)g]GZzg]iZ@Zzgg0~Zq60{ZzgNZ^zgxFkC>XLgZ})Vi'egZ@Wq:

gZ})V!zY@V~W{ZkW!zkZ~

(egZ]&~Zqfg=X paradox W!zkZw)V~ZLM{ZgZ]]ZzgZZx e^-]

Zq tg3YegZseFUtWDXLZ&zV~HYY:

z:B{1rGL:B *g{gz@ZzgtH

\? MM:B ZV!GLZ i0{W[CoH>*g}

x[@Zg}zuZz:

EL+N!45 YEELQF 854 EEGELH i- t~Z}%}gcKcYV6zg -)zV_M

~!VVgZk"5 ELEVZ$0GZgZk!

egZyZqSZi:Zzg.zcZZ~seC@XZDwZkQ|[)/]B

Zzgzu~(~Vw{ZzgZ ZEwHTZqVwtLZ{XegZ.ZiyZZxZhQgz

1 fV8zZu ~~ZyVwZzg}:nXZyZzgzu~@.ZLZ0gz7g~ygZzgZkZ0Zy-*egZY~$wY@XLr0 GG)bkZ(Z|U"D:

gzZ[wwZ}hp'/!gz{W@"GELsi~'Zg

W'z W{!Z}Z!ggbZk0Z~

181 ZDw~~egZ

VZDwg0Z MegZwx1XLgZ]V~kCZg e^-] ZzgZqZzgg6kC'p

gZ{ic{ZXZpZyV~ZzgzV LZzgZzgL]Xfg)ZDwZLZgz]ZgH@ZyZgg~ZzgZgW~ZDw/]Z0Zi{zg@X

ZgZzgk?'egZzZ2yX|tZZg:k?z~7WY'ZggZegZga(ZDZkaZZgzV6Zk:zZu]9sV~o

7M'Z[ZfggHYZ0Zi{ZDw~pW,"gZgzVW!XstZqxtbZDwT

ZZg~$wXz{"YyqzV~e]uZrDZzgZy,XZk:tz{]

(gZgZkaZZfg}fg}~ finite egos pZ*V)ZzgZZeWUgWD]!]7Z)g6ZDw*

ZgzVegV~HYY1D~ZzgmC*Zg

}!Lg4L9%{F"z){2DZi0ZgXZi0ZgXZDw*~z{zjl~wg

ic{mgnZy~ZZgX3DZZg)zZ(

xg45 XGg0'`>Z7 ~ !O }zhzAC{sZY"~] Nyz){

4DZZg)+C45GEJG(

! }!!Zgy~)ZkZgmyz-(5Z[%wZzg%&40 EEGOX

ZDwM, 281

Zy~ZzgL%ic{Czq)ZZgzV~'ZDwZZgZ+Zy~~Zgz]Zga)ZgZZ@tI:ZDw~(ZegZZgZ+egZ~k?ZzgZgZq*xCzu]

zDXZgzVw]zZ]egZ%0@Zzgk?Zkse@XZgj]Zqpk$wXZkaZg{c|xCCXqwk~Z"gz

,egZg)c();CjgsZzg!gq|@ZDw>Zgg~Zzgk]ZgggzgBZzg

LszZ+~zVZgzV e^qfm xegZzWCXk?Z7gZzg'H)egZ~~ZkVw}Zzg7QXk]ZqZqzZgzV]Zzg,WsZgXWisZg@:

^kg8z1?ZwtZ0ZisaizVXL^kBszZ+

*g*gQ@XZzV!gk~8iEL%ZAgTZ+%zY'Z^kIssFZ

gCcXn go]XZkZqfg)Z+Zk^kFI~@WxZzgZkI7g~Z*y~Z+Z[Zq^q~ZzgZq^q~g8z1gZZZzgg~

Z[5: z'F~y~XZw:^kyg8z1!LLizizgzZrz[zWgz!

g s'hZzg{'ZKZkw~ZzghweLZ+Zk^kZKeZ!iWYZzgZK*gVZzgV0ZkaszuZZwt:

381 ZDw~~egZ

C{~Z#u6gS~WH7eZeZg?

Z+Z['-*Zzc@tzL*xF+Z;VW@:

W{Z}szZ7ZkgZiu^I^Z&Z[V~ge7e7

g{ltL"czkWy~{~Z+~gZzg9KgWc:

8igizyV83g;X~!Lx7bZv~ G0LWxg4?

Z+Zg~egZZk*]z{ZDwfZKY+qg'ZkZq:tg}+Zzg5!

Zm~6wg;6-VZ{z{ZCZZx!svXOZ+ZZs:

Z}}ZV:Wx4qzzgzkziz W{!z{i0Z

wZbg}te:;V1~!~:Z@

ZkZZs~Wx)$hE

LWx(@{|Zzg6?a^Tt>{0Zl~Z+}z0~zx*7ZXZ+Zw7YzgBBz{Wx$zg-V(Zg'kIZ'nZ+$h

ELWx>Y:sYZZk|]

BZk~ G0WxZpZ*g3eX)t%]ZDwZgg~QC(Zg;CV7gZgg~izZzgZDwZkULzVZz7'Z+ZZsmZVZzgZ+Zqk?Zq~Y@egZW

4+%:XmZVZw~ZzgZkZwZ[6Z+:ENxZgzZgX

6tgZi?Zg? mZV:'!Z}~izZ! Z+:

ZgczsXZzg Z['kZzg!@zsZIZ+(Z8ENyXZkZ[Z+c[7

VNt{H:]1t9B NEGZ

H~!h4 IGOG~:Z@}g;ZKWiZ~6g~*xZL^ I0iZVpHz

581 ZDw~~egZ

ZDwZ+ Z+E{{sg;pZk|sZg_a#g6ZEwHXt!]ZK(6ZZkZg~ZDw)/]x1'ZDw~~VZkZgWCzZdgZegZ~uZrMXLLZ+&CELg'ZkehZ

iZzgZy&gtW@X T~Z+ZzgZkvZ+Z*+pI~CZ"*i~ZzgZi05]

s*'Z+k]s~XZqz} ~ZkregZ"4+%:'}

t6Z*!t*zV)ZWVpVZk'!~?W`W{z{gi

TZk*xg3sz$ENVpZ[ CK ~c

~hZKzkzG\V~*ZgzV1c$k~cutZg~V

iZVu yYZkW>TuV~Z+gzVTVg~Wg~yYZk+C

EEL@uV

c}:%}^GLs~g8z1Hi~H$z)HW/NBZKW\Vtz[

~ZcZZ-g\

ZDwM, 681

ZZkQ#T{~Z[JZWgiz

ZgWt)WUg'ZgzV]'ZyCseZzgk6gZ:'Zk!]~'ZDZDwegZ.y~zZszZ7Zy}UV67g~,kqpZk!zZDwegZ7'chic{9!]t

Q,VegZrI7H'Zk/gzbmGZymBT=t7'Cz{c/ZypZsY'Zp~~T~p~WiZZ:g:ZDw4qg6.Fu'ZzgegZZDw~ZZgZzg*zV

p~@XYZZgZzg*zVegZg/!0*7@ZzgZKp~wc)p~Zg*7@XZq!

egZZK(6pZDwyZZzg$ EG0'egZD)'Zzg)D|Zg@'ZkLL1%c|d'ZZDwZ435 EGG]

~)xZgXZn6zZu]gz{CPzq5kgpLZZZyL|7'pZk!zZZgzVX!z)

ZgZzg* ZzgZqg]ptZ(ZfZCp~!6{ZzgL7@XegZXZZgZzg*zVLZkVZqL9; EXGL

nzx~Y@ZzgZkbZZgZzg*p~egZLnzxZgzVp~~YC'egZ6ZDwtWZqZgZDgzgB'*~ttZDw'ZzgsZDwm'Zk

ZzgwZ0bZgZDwZKZqLLF~H:F~p~gzFZw'GLz]HZuzgzizm]

781 ZDw~~egZ

F)z6z,ZxZgaZ}fZ]z]w*Zp~)fZvz!g{i0{:gz!]zo]

w:g] g;::p~:

Qy MYZZDwegZ@z{t~_5h42.IGFJGZzg,

$45IG:D!KKK

ZDwM, 881

ZDw+B5GEGO

(Zq]hZb auditory imagination ) ~W~+B5GEGO

&Zm~i!y*gZzgKZZZ:+B5GEGOZq{mU

zsazHZzgZ[]hWZZKgzi%{Zq]~Y@X 1Zk%Zt+B5

GEGOxg6y~czV'. GO`cH

gLX ZK!3 EGOG$z6ZgV~gz$w55g'z@ZZt Zb

+B5GEGOZqUz{TmWzZizVcZXZ

(f{@Z visual memories Tb+B5GEGO~y~czV)

(f{@T$z sound memories bZqCczV)+B5GEGOge(6ZZzg5WzZizV+B5

GEGO LL

+B5GEGO')0

Zk&ZL+B5GEGO'c+B5

GEGOL*xct]c&

x6ZWZ0ZiCYZ$z;V{mnDTZk~ZqZZ~ (aZ sound pattterns C)

tg]-Vg6gpTbZqx W}q@X~ZZe7gZbZk+B5

GEGOZk 'ZpZEw

s ~W}|~ZZgZZ7@X+B5GEGOtg~7 EO

(}Z;VcVZ0Zi~WC'Z+B5GEGO'htHY

verbal Zk~ZqZ+q~g6&zs{LL+B5GEGO)

(YY'TZ]cZxZzg7Zp6 imagination(~'ZzgZz]6 phrases @Zzg5FZI)

981 ZDw+B5GEGO

ZpZZq~g@'gHYCk+B5GEGO'y~Zzg

+B5GEGOuu6zZXY6ZpzFZIzZZq~ZpC

czVBB'ZprM~c,C'ZpQyCgz7$zQyg~gz7'ZzgZyzVzzcgn'ZqtZy+B5

GEGO~ZpZLxZBi0{

gTXZDw+B5GEGOig&~Qy!g*VzZzgB#

CZzgQy'5FZI|~Q'g]Zzgg]VwQyzx7gzzV'%iZwZzg%iZ~QX qZk&ENg]Zzgs~:VZgQgzZzggzVi!V ZDwFZI

~u!G0LZgZzg-C40YEEGE0LZg'ZyTg~gZZDwZZ]

sZqUc*&ZDw+B5GEGO MMZzgZk+B5

GEGO

sZqUg}7Tmg66ZpZXzZZqX

zZy:ziyzkV gQy

+B5GEGOzu}UVbZDw+B5

GEGOic{7gZ0Zi~

~CZYZk~ZDwegZZgzVa q^m^Z*xz7}XOZke~*xQLziyz

(E~(sa kVaz*))W^YCXZkzbiyzkVZDwLLigzZy*xciyzky

law of BZzgZzgs~Ug'+B5GEGO~iCQw)

(+B5GEGO~3 EGOGg6x@'pVZk!] association

*7Lig!yZzgLigyg] 40 NOGGS zszg~LgzZy'~gi!yZq*ig!yZzgigyL45 XEYL.5GZqZgcZzgigyZkpt:

ZDwM, 091

igyXm)$-

EEGiZzjgZ(*.FGL

gZ!x6't aL)ZEwHXpW^LH z z/i0{gzh}g)c ZyMXLLc

Zqw7@Ti: i0{gz (Zk6Z+z!}Z0!gZ{erEGLZ0!

q^m ZkwL)Q}7MZzg(tztC@Li0{gc X zZu1)$4GM(*x ^

xhZ:ZzgZ]~gcz#Zgc C2 zZgc 'cZDwpz)cgziyZgcY

(Xg}*5:Z[~5 alter-ego LigzZyZ*w)*VBLi0{ccLi0{hZMX}Zq|]ZYx

q^m^ YZDw C3 *xWy~Li0{hZMX*xZ(g~ZygzZc]g~c)~g6 ~ZLa

ZWJwHX@eZYzhZDwZkZqZzgyTZk:ZDw7 s~ZzgCz~ZZXZK"

zg'7~z{:*xQ,VW8gjZZLa85 FNEZk:t

ZDw`,(}ZbX,Wx]Zzgp Zsx6ZqxkZgZ{H "uOWXVJZk9

sZZeX":XZkZZc>ZyL~|]ZZzg|]W:~WzgZy,t]=e~W8gaL]W,W[UZEw@Tx*0-VZKWl~gZv\sY*XZDwt

7SZzgZk$]Zzg