judd d. bowman arizona state university alan rogers mit/haystack observatory may 26, 2011

19
Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011 Experiment to Detect the Experiment to Detect the Global EoR Signature (EDGES) Global EoR Signature (EDGES)

Upload: henrik

Post on 09-Jan-2016

22 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Experiment to Detect the Global EoR Signature (EDGES). Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011. Outline. Brief motivation Instrument Overview Results Reionization Galactic synchrotron spectral index Radio Frequency Interference - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011

Judd D. BowmanArizona State University

Alan RogersMIT/Haystack Observatory

May 26, 2011

Experiment to Detect the Experiment to Detect the Global EoR Signature (EDGES)Global EoR Signature (EDGES)

Page 2: Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011

Outline

1. Brief motivation

2. Instrument Overview

3. Results

a. Reionization

b. Galactic synchrotron spectral index

c. Radio Frequency Interference

4. Looking ahead

Page 3: Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011

The global 21 cm signal

Pritchard & Loeb (2011)

Page 4: Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011

EDGES

Page 5: Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011

EDGES – Experiment to Detect the Global EoR Signature

CSIROsupport trailerAntenna

Murchison Radio-astronomy Observatory (MRO), Western Australia

Page 6: Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011

in from antenna

to 2nd stage

calibration source

2nd stage amp

dithering noise source

to digitizer

LNA

switch

Page 7: Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011

Technical challenges

• Cannot (easily) create external calibrator, difficult matching sky temperature across band

• Cannot fully characterize antenna in lab

– Beam pattern changes with frequency

– Antenna and LNA impedance change with frequency, in general poor match

– Receiver noise reflections

• Multi-path reflections

• Non-linear effects prevent ideal comparison-switch calibration

Page 8: Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011

EDGES measured spectrum

Murchison Radio-astronomy Observatory (MRO)

Aug 20 – Oct 20, 2009

1440 wall-clock hours on sky

500 hours after RFI cuts

50 hours eff. integration

+15 dB

Bowman & Rogers (Nature, 2010)

Page 9: Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011

EDGES parameter estimation

#1: 21 cm reionization model

#2: Foreground model

m

n

nnF zaT

0

)1(

Pritchard & Loeb (2010, submitted)

2 science parameters: z and zr 4-19 nuisance parameters: an (ACKK!!)

Page 10: Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011

EDGES lower limit on duration

Bowman & Rogers (Nature, 2010)

zr > 0.06 for 6 < zr < 13 (95% confidence)

Page 11: Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011

EDGES absolute calibration

Tgal = 237 10 K (3 sigma) @ 150 MHz

100-200 MHz: = 2.5 0.1 (3 sigma)

150-408 MHz: = 2.52 0.04 (3 sigma)

Rogers & Bowman 2008

Page 12: Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011

Integrated RFI(time excision only – by broadband power level in

FM, Orbcomm, DTV bands: 30% removal)

Note: shows every channel that ever had RFI over 3 months

Page 13: Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011
Page 14: Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011

Orbcomm LEO satellite constellation

Page 15: Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011

Outline

1. Brief motivation

2. Instrument Overview

3. Results

a. Galactic synchrotron spectral index

b. Reionization

c. Radio Frequency Interference

4. Looking ahead

Page 16: Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011

EDGES reionization forecast

Pritchard & Loeb (2010)

Page 17: Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011

EDGES reionization forecast

Morandi & Barkana (2011)

Page 18: Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011

Physical model templates

EOR absorption x 104

Data deviates from power law primarily due to the antenna mismatch factor 1 - |G|2

AEER

Page 19: Judd D. Bowman Arizona State University Alan Rogers MIT/Haystack Observatory May 26, 2011

Summary

• Identified key technical challenges and viable approaches– See AEER talk tomorrow morning– CoRE (RRI), Bighorns (Curtin University), DARE (U. Colorado), LWA cosmic

dawn, Peterson

• Beginning to rule out rapid reionization histories– z>0.06 between 6<z<13– First reionization science from any redshifted 21 cm experiment

• Ancillary science and supporting measurements– Galactic synchrotron spectral index– Deepest broadband spectrum ever acquired at 5 mK rms– RFI properties of remote sites in US and Australia (more to come)

• More compelling 21 cm science in the near future– Constrain derivative of neutral fraction for generic reionization histories– Attempt first detection of z=15-25 absorption feature to probe UV

emission from first stars and early IGM heating