kbc ioe webinar - shale or tight oil processing
TRANSCRIPT
© 2012 KBC Advanced Technologies plc. All Rights Reserved.
Scott Sayles, Executive Consultant
Shale or Tight Oil Processing
20 November 2012
Agenda > What is Shale or Tight Oil? > Market Drivers > Refinery Impacts, Experience > Plant Modification Implications > Conclusions
20 November 2012 PROPRIETARY INFORMATION 2
What is Shale or Tight Oil? > Shale or Tight Oil are terms for the geological formation where oil is found
– The name does not infer quality of the crude oil – Location of the deposit determines the qualities – Tight Oil can be found around the world – Focus here will be on North America production
Shale Oil Shale NGLs2012 AFPM FCCU Seminar Houston Texas
20 November 2012 PROPRIETARY INFORMATION 3
What is Shale or Tight Oil? > Current situation is the quality and volumes are variable
– API ranges from 20 to 55 – Sulfur generally low and nitrogen – Paraffin generally high – Heavy metals are low (Ni &V) – Alkaline metals are high – Lead, Arsenic and Barium are elevated – Filterable solids increases with decreasing API – Production chemicals add contaminents
20 November 2012 PROPRIETARY INFORMATION 4
Market Drivers > 65 to 70 refineries have access > Limited pipeline to local refineries > Rail in North America
– Reaches to the east coast – Train size becomes limiting
> Truck to distribution points and to local refineries – Cushing is reported to collect 36,000+ BPD (CVR Energy 2012) – Other locations are similar
> Other options being explored: – Barges on Mississippi – Saint Laurence Seaway shipments
PROPRIETARY INFORMATION 20 November 2012 5
Market Drivers > It’s not all oil. > Gas production is high for these fields > Cheap natural gas has changed the energy economics > SMR Hydrogen is low cost > Energy efficiency or savings projects have to be carefully
evaluated – Cost is lower – May allow internal production for improved refinery reliability
PROPRIETARY INFORMATION 20 November 2012 6
Overall Impact
Low Cost Natural Gas
Crude Feedstock
Coke
CrudeTower
NHTCatalytic
Reforming Unit
Gasoline Pool
Reformate
Hydrotreated Naphtha
Virgin Naphtha
Jet and Diesel Pool
KeroseneDHT
Kerosene HT Jet
DieselDHT
HT Diesel(ULSD)
Middle Distillate
Vacuum Tower
Atmospheric Resid
CokerVacuum Resid
Naphtha
GOHTor
HCU
ATM Gas Oils
SyntheticJet/Diesel
Naphtha
CFHT
FCCU
FCC Naphtha
FCC Gas Oil
Fuel Oil Pool
Cutter Stock forFuel Oil
Wild Naphtha
Alkylation
Alkylate
VacuumGas Oils
Naphtha
CokerC3s and C4s
Cok
er G
as O
ils
FCCC3s and C4s
Vacuum Resid
Wild Naphtha
UtilitiesUtilities to Units
Utilities from Suppliers
Oil
Mov
emen
t and
Sto
rage
(OM
S)
Vacuum Ohds
DesalterCrude
Waxy, Fouling
Problems with cold flow properties
Low Yields
Cracks well High olefins
Low Utilization
Lower octanes/yields
Low Rate
20 November 2012 PROPRIETARY INFORMATION 7
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
10095908580757065605550454035302520151050
Ble
ndin
g In
dex
Num
ber
Percent of Crude 'B' in Blend
Crude 'A' and Seven 'B' Crudes
Crude B1Crude B2Crude B3Crude B4Crude B5Crude B6Crude B7
Incompatible Region
Refinery Impacts, Experience > Tankage
– Incompatibility – Wax deposition
> Desalter – Wax causes stable emulsions – Fouling – Salt carry-over – High filterable solids
> Crude unit – Preheat fouling – Tray fouling in upper sections – Light ends lift limitations – Crude heater undersized
Operating GAP
Technology GAP
CurrentDesalter
inlet
outlet
mudwash
CER, Cold Eyes Review
KBC BenchmarkKerosene P/A
12
Reflux fromReflux Pumps
3456789
1011121314
151617
1920212223242526272828
18
32
293031
35363738394041
34
42
43
46
4445
474849505152
53
545556575859
Overhead Vapors to Overhead Condenser
Kerosene Vapor fromKerosene Stripper
Kerosene Draw toKerosene Stripper
Diesel Vapor fromDiesel Stripper
Kerosene Reflux fromKerosene Stripper
Diesel P/A
Diesel Draw toDiesel Stripper
Diesel Reflux fromDiesel Stripper
HGO Vapor fromHGO Stripper
HGO P/A
HGO Draw toHGO Stripper
HGO Reflux (Wash Oil) fromHGO Stripper
Overflash DrawCrude Feed from
Crude Heater
Overflash Return
Steam In
Bottoms toVacuum Heater
20 November 2012 PROPRIETARY INFORMATION 8
> Vacuum tower – Low yields – Waxy – Vacuum heater oversized
> FCCU (See 2012 AFPM FCCU Seminar) – Cracks well – Good selectivity – Lower octane – Lower slurry
> Olefins processing about the same – Conversion increase – Heat balance? – Atmospheric resid?
Refinery Impacts, Experience
CW
Condensate
Steam
FeedCoalescer
Contactor
Light Olefins
Mixed Butanes
Makeup Isobutane
Acid Settler
Fresh Acid
Spent Acid to AcidBlowdown Drum
FlashDrum
SuctionTrap
DepropanizerFeed Pumps
MixerMixer
Acid WashDrum
RefrigerantCompressor
Condenser
TotalCondenser
RefrigerantSeparator
Economizer
RefrigerantAccumulator
CW
CW
CausticWash Drum
Condensate
Steam
Depropanizer
Deisobutanizer
MixerOverheadCondenser
OverheadReceiver
Reflux/Product Pumps
CW
Propane Product
to Storage
Reboiler
ProductCooler
Reboiler
Reflux/Product Pumps
OverheadCondenser
CW
Bottoms Effluent to Debutanizer
Refrigerant Recycle
Feed/Bottoms
Exchangers
CW
DepropanizerBottoms Coolers
Isobutane
Net Effluent
Alkaline WaterWash Drum
Circulation Pumps
Circulation Pumps
Fresh AcidFresh
Caustic
Spent Caustic
Alkaline Water
Net Effluent fromSuction Trap Drum
Net Effluent toAcid Wash Drum
Feed/EffluentExchangers
WaterWash Drum
A
B
B A
CIsobutaneRecycle
IsobutaneTo
Storage
Recycle to Contactors C
OverheadReceiver Water
WaterWash Drum
20 November 2012 PROPRIETARY INFORMATION 9
Refinery Impacts, Experience > Hydroprocessing
– Low utilization – Increased run lengths
> Distillate (DHTU) – Cold flow properties are high – Dewaxing catalyst – Modification to fractionation cut
points > Gas Oil Hydrotreaters (GOHT)
– Treating severity potential to meet tier 3 sulfur
– Low sulfur in regenerator flue gas
PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
Stripper Tower
StabilizerTower
Reactor Effluent Cooler
Feed/Effluent
ExchangerFeedPumps
Fired Heater
Reactor(s)
Separator
Stripper Bottoms Pumps
H2 Rich Off GasHydrogen-rich Make-up Gas
Hydrotreated Distillate Product
Possible Light Liquid Overheads
to Fuel Gas
Kerosene Feed CW
CW
CW
CW
Overheads receiver
Wash Water Pump
Wash Water
Charge Pump
ReactorReactor
HC Feed
FiredHeater
Feed/Effluent
Exchanger
CW
Reactor Effluent Coolers
HP Separator
CW
HPHTOverhead
Cooler
HPLow TempSeparator
LPLow TempSeparator
LP Separator
H2-richOff-gas
Amine Absorber(with Trays and Packing)
Lean Amine
H2-rich Gas
Hydrogen Recycle
Compressor
H2-rich Makeup
Gas
H2-rich Purge
Stripper Tower(with Trays and Packing)
FiredHeater
Main Fractionator(with Trays and Packing)
Heavy Naphtha
Light Distillate
Heavy Distillate
Net Bottoms
Sour Vent Gas
Light HC Liquid(LPG/Naphtha)
Fat Amine
20 November 2012 10
Refinery Impacts, Experience > Naphtha Reformer
– Paraffinic low octane – Higher gas production
> Coker – Low VR yield – High API – Low CCR
> WWTP – Impacted by solids under-carry – Alkaline metals
Wet Gas
Coker Fractionator
Furnace
CokeDrum Offline Overhead
Condenser
RefluxPump
CokeDrum Online
CokeDrum Offline
CokeDrum Online
Recirculation
4-Way Valve
Velocity Medium
Fuel Gas/Fuel Oil
Overhead Trim Cooler
CWOverhead
Drum
Sour Water
Coker Naphtha
Heater Charge
Pump
Coke Drum
Vapors
Blowdown System
Off-gas
Light Slop Oil
Heavy Slop Oil
Recycle Water
Quench
Steam fromWater Quench
LCGO Stripper
LCGO Product
FeedVessel
Fresh FeedFeedPump
HCGO Product
Feed/LCGOExchanger
Feed/HCGOExchanger
P/A Exchanger
Steam Generator
P/APump
BFW
Steam
SteamHCGO
Stripper
Steam
4-Way Valve
1 2 3 4
fromOily Water System API
Separator
Sour Water
Desalter Water
Oil
Spent Caustic
Depurator
toIncinerator
Flow EQ
Spent Caustic
DAF Trains
OilSolids
Cationic and Anionic Polymers
Aeration Basin
Caustic
Cooling Tower Blowdown
Phosphoric Acid and Activated Charcoal
Biomass + Activated Sludge
Sump
Sulfuric Acid
Polishing Ponds
toRiver
Water Reuse Supply
Water Reuse Return
Reactor 3
Reactor 1
Reactor 2
Continuous Regenerator(for Reactor 4 only)
Heater 1 Heater 2 Heater 3 Heater 4
Reactor 4(tail position)
FeedRecycle Compressor
Feed/Effluent Exchanger
Separator
Unstabilized Reformate
Hydrogen-rich Gas
Charge Pump
Air Cooler
20 November 2012 PROPRIETARY INFORMATION 11
Plant Modification Implications > Most refineries can process some volume > Crude blending is the key
– Compatibility – Light Ends
> Changes to ensure piping and tankage sufficiently heated to overcome high pour points
> Consideration of dewaxing catalysts for pour control and fractionation changes
> Under running sulfur plants may require modifications to prevent fouling
> WWTP modifications
20 November 2012 PROPRIETARY INFORMATION 12
Conclusions > Tight Oil produced crudes are:
– Readily available and quantities are increasing – Waxy and low sulfur/nitrogen
> Experience has been generally favorable > Some issues are due to the waxy/paraffinic nature > Limited refinery investment modifications
PROPRIETARY INFORMATION 20 November 2012 13
Closing > Contact: Scott Sayles, Executive Consultant,
[email protected] > Questions? > Future webinar topics:
– Market conditions – Asset optimisation – Investment support – Sustainable workforce development
> We welcome suggestions for future topics – please email [email protected] > Thank you for joining us!
20 November 2012 PROPRIETARY INFORMATION 14