kevin cuff, valeria romero, matthew a. cannady, rosalinda ......n e e e l her activism identity and...

1
In the course of conducting a study to assess the scalability of a university-based outreach program designed to increase clean energy-related STEM content understanding and awareness of associated career pathways, an important secondary line of research evolved. This particular research sought to examine the program’s guided environmental quality investigations and to assess their capacity to mobilize youth to become active in addressing issues related to their environments and/or communities. Findings to date indicate that students whose science identity increased through engagement in program activities also experienced an increase in interest and capacity to engage in environmental activism. Abstract Research Question Program Design: Connecting science learning experiences to students’ lived experiences and real-world issues is key to fostering student engagement and increasing their perception of the value of science. These findings illustrate the potential this programmatic approach can have on developing more “science minded” and environmentally conscious individuals. Policy: Findings suggest that it is important to integrate community-based research experiences in school-based science learning. This is a potential framework that can support teachers, schools, districts and communities. Research: Findings suggest that there is a potential relationship between fostering science identity and activism. Future research can aim to understand the role that community-based research plays in shifting students’ beliefs about and connections to social change Implications and Contributions The Clean Energy Literacy and Leadership (CELL) Pathways program was designed to Contact Kevin Cuff, Co-PI and Director, EBAYS: [email protected] Rena Dorph, PI: [email protected] Can the CELL Pathways program experience support students’ development of environmental activism identities? Kevin Cuff, Valeria Romero, Matthew A. Cannady, Rosalinda Nava and Rena Dorph Lawrence Hall of Science, University of California, Berkeley Fostering Environmental Activism through Community-Based Research Investigations Methods Activism Identity and Commitment Survey (Klar & Kassar, 2009; Cronbach’s α=.99). Science Identity Scale (activationlab.org) Program observations Student Interviews Activist Identity Being an activist is central to who I am; I am truly commitment to engage in activism; I identify myself as an activist; I make time for activism, even when I am busy; People who know me well would call me an activist Activist Commitment I go out of my way to engage in activism; Being an activist is an important reflection of who I am; I take the time I need to engage in activism. Figure 1. Activity Identity and Commitment, Klar & Kassar, 2009 Results There is no difference from Pre to Post, overall There is a statistically significant difference between girls and boys Gender Identity Differences Activism Identity & Commitment (N=413) Pre Post Female 2.97 2.95 Male 2.57 2.61 Interaction between Science Identity & Activism Identity and Commitment Students who reported a larger change in science identity were more likely to report an increase in activism identity and commitment “[CELL] did like, you know change how I thought of the world because you know, uhmm... like the more you know about something the more you see things differently. So I mean if you learn more about the place around you and how like it's being affected by what you're doing then uhmm... you're bound to make a change.”-- High school student This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant No.1433552. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation. Learning Environment CELL pathways programming was presented in both in-school and after school contexts as either an enhancement component of ongoing courses or as a stand alone set of experiences. Activities were presented by trained staff members during 60-90 minute sessions, 2- 3 times per week at participating program sites. Activities were arranged in modules that presented a combination of hands-on, inquiry-oriented skills development and action research activities. The following data sources were used in the study: 47% 49% Ma le Female They/Them Decline to State 129 128 120 8 4 129 18 172 17 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 Asian Black/African American Latino/Hispanic Indian/Middle Eastern Native American/Alaska-Native Wh ite Decline to state Multi-racial Other Activism Identity and Commitment 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 Activism Pre Activism Post Greater than the mean increase in Science Identity Less than or equal to the mean increase in Science Identity N Activism Pre Activism Post Students with greater than the mean increase in Science Identity 170 2.81 2.99 Students with less than or equal to the mean increase in Science Identity 258 2.82 2.69 © 2019 The Regents of the University of California provide high school aged youth with inquiry-oriented, STEM skills-building activities that foster working understandings of the relationship between various approaches to energy use and environmental impact. Developed and facilitated by the East Bay Academy for Young Scientists (EBAYS), based at U.C. Berkeley’s Lawrence Hall of Science, a key component of CELL is community-based research investigations aimed at assessing local air quality.

Upload: others

Post on 01-Oct-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Kevin Cuff, Valeria Romero, Matthew A. Cannady, Rosalinda ......n e e e l her Activism Identity and Commitment 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 Activism Pre Activism Post Greater than the

In the course of conducting a study to assess thescalability of a university-based outreach programdesigned to increase clean energy-related STEM contentunderstanding and awareness of associated careerpathways, an important secondary line of researchevolved. This particular research sought to examine theprogram’s guided environmental quality investigationsand to assess their capacity to mobilize youth to becomeactive in addressing issues related to their environmentsand/or communities. Findings to date indicate thatstudents whose science identity increased throughengagement in program activities also experienced anincrease in interest and capacity to engage inenvironmental activism.

Abstract Research Question

Program Design: Connecting science learning experiences to students’ lived experiences and real-world issues is key to fostering student engagement and increasing their perception of the value of science. These findings illustrate the potential this programmatic approach can have on developing more “science minded” and environmentally conscious individuals. Policy: Findings suggest that it is important to integrate community-based research experiences in school-based science learning. This is a potential framework that can support teachers, schools, districts and communities. Research: Findings suggest that there is a potential relationship between fostering science identity and activism. Future research can aim to understand the role that community-based research plays in shifting students’ beliefs about and connections to social change

Implications and Contributions

The Clean Energy Literacy andLeadership (CELL) Pathwaysprogram was designed to

ContactKevin Cuff, Co-PI and Director, EBAYS: [email protected] Dorph, PI: [email protected]

Can the CELL Pathways program experience support students’ development of environmental activism identities?

Kevin Cuff, Valeria Romero, Matthew A. Cannady, Rosalinda Nava and Rena DorphLawrence Hall of Science, University of California, Berkeley

Fostering Environmental Activism through Community-Based Research Investigations

Methods

❖ Activism Identity and Commitment Survey (Klar & Kassar, 2009; Cronbach’s α=.99).

❖ Science Identity Scale (activationlab.org)❖ Program observations❖ Student Interviews

ActivistIdentity

Being an activist is central to who I am; I amtruly commitment to engage in activism; Iidentify myself as an activist; I make time foractivism, even when I am busy; People whoknow me well would call me an activist

ActivistCommitment

I go out of my way to engage in activism;Being an activist is an important reflectionof who I am; I take the time I need toengage in activism.

Figure 1. Activity Identity and Commitment, Klar & Kassar,2009

Results

• There is no difference from Pre to Post, overall

• There is a statistically significant difference between girls and boys

Gender Identity Differences Activism Identity & Commitment (N=413)

Pre Post

Female 2.97 2.95

Male 2.57 2.61

Interaction between Science Identity &Activism Identity and Commitment

• Students who reported a larger change in science identity were more likely to report an increase in activism identity and commitment

“[CELL] did like, you know change how I thought of theworld because you know, uhmm... like the more youknow about something the more you see thingsdifferently. So I mean if you learn more about theplace around you and how like it's being affected bywhat you're doing then uhmm... you're bound to makea change.”-- High school student

This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant No.1433552. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.

Learning Environment

CELL pathways programming was presented in bothin-school and after school contexts as either anenhancement component of ongoing courses or as astand alone set of experiences. Activities were presentedby trained staff members during 60-90 minute sessions, 2-3 times per week at participating program sites. Activitieswere arranged in modules that presented a combinationof hands-on, inquiry-oriented skills development andaction research activities. The following data sources wereused in the study:

47%

49%

Male Female

They/Them Decline to State

129 128120

8 4

129

18

172

17

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

Asian

Black

/Africa

n Am

erican

Latin

o/Hispa

nic

Indian

/Middle Eas

tern

Native Am

erican

/Alask

a-Nat

ive

White

Dec

line

to sta

te

Multi-rac

ial

Oth

er

Activism Identity and Commitment

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

Activism Pre Activism Post

Greater than the mean increase in Science Identity

Less than or equal to the mean increase in Science Identity

NActivism

PreActivism

PostStudents with greater than the mean increase in Science Identity 170 2.81 2.99Students with less than or equal to the mean increase in Science Identity 258 2.82 2.69

© 2019 The Regents of the University of California

provide high school aged youth with inquiry-oriented,STEM skills-building activities that foster workingunderstandings of the relationship between variousapproaches to energy use and environmental impact.Developed and facilitated by the East Bay Academy forYoung Scientists (EBAYS), based at U.C. Berkeley’sLawrence Hall of Science, a key component of CELL iscommunity-based research investigations aimed atassessing local air quality.