krajewski 11 november 2004 theme 1: radioactive release … · 1 2nd combined meetings of the iaea...

29
1 2nd Combined Meetings of the IAEA Programme on 2nd Combined Meetings of the IAEA Programme on Environmental Modelling for Environmental Modelling for RAdiation RAdiation Safety (EMRAS) Safety (EMRAS) 8 8 11 November 2004 11 November 2004 Paweł Krajewski (EMRAS Iodine Working Group Leader) Working Group 3 Working Group 3 The Chernobyl I-131 release: model validation and assessment of the countermeasure effectiveness working group THEME 1: Radioactive Release Assessment Central Laboratory for Radiological Protection Central Laboratory for Radiological Protection WARSAW WARSAW , POLAND , POLAND

Upload: dinhnga

Post on 01-Mar-2019

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

1

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

Paw

ełK

raje

wsk

i(E

MR

AS

Iodi

ne W

orki

ng G

roup

Lea

der)

Wor

kin

g G

rou

p 3

Wor

kin

g G

rou

p 3

The

Ch

ern

obyl

I-1

31

rel

ease

:m

odel

val

idat

ion

an

d as

sess

men

t of

th

e co

un

term

easu

re e

ffec

tive

nes

s w

orki

ng

grou

p

TH

EM

E 1

: Rad

ioac

tive

Rel

ease

Ass

essm

ent

Cen

tral

Lab

orat

ory

for

Rad

iolo

gica

l Pro

tect

ion

Cen

tral

Lab

orat

ory

for

Rad

iolo

gica

l Pro

tect

ion

WA

RSA

WW

AR

SAW

, PO

LAN

D, P

OLA

ND

2

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

IWG

con

tin

ues

som

e o

f th

e m

ore

tr

ad

itio

nal

wo

rk o

f th

e

pre

vio

us

inte

rnati

on

al

pro

gra

mm

es

that

have b

een

aim

ed

at

incr

easi

ng

co

nfi

den

ce

in

meth

od

san

d

mo

dels

fo

r th

e

ass

ess

men

t o

f ra

dia

tio

n

exp

osu

re

rela

ted

to

th

e

to

the

en

vir

on

men

tal

rele

ase

s.en

vir

on

men

tal

rele

ase

s.

the

IAEA

’sV

alid

atio

n o

f M

odel

Pre

dict

ion

s (V

AM

P)

the

IAEA

’sB

IOM

OV

S

the

BIO

MO

VS

II**

(Bio

sph

eric

Mod

el V

alid

atio

n S

tudy

)

the

IAEA

’s B

IOM

ASS

(B

IOsp

her

eM

odel

ling

and

ASS

essm

ent)

term

inat

ed in

20

01

**su

pport

ed b

y org

anis

atio

ns

from

Can

ada,

Spain

and

Sw

eden

.

Back

gro

un

d

EMR

AS

Iodi

ne

Wor

kin

g G

rou

p

3

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

act

ivit

y o

f th

e I

WG

act

ivit

y o

f th

e I

WG

Back

gro

un

d(c

on

t.)

EMR

AS

Iodi

ne

Wor

kin

g G

rou

p

•to

test

an

d c

om

pare

mo

dels

’ p

red

icti

on

s w

ith

real

en

vir

on

men

tal

data

•to

inte

rco

mp

are

mo

dellin

g a

pp

roach

es

an

d

mo

del

pre

dic

tio

ns

am

on

g s

evera

l ass

ess

ors

en

vir

on

men

tal

mo

dell

ing

exerc

ises

on

en

vir

on

men

tal

mo

dell

ing

exerc

ises

on

rad

ioio

din

era

dio

iod

ine

4

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

mmaain

targ

ets

of

IWG

in t

arg

ets

of

IWG

Back

gro

un

d(c

on

t.)

majo

r are

as

of

em

ph

asi

s:m

ajo

r are

as

of

em

ph

asi

s:

••im

pro

vem

en

t o

f m

od

els

pre

dic

tio

ns

acc

ura

cy b

y id

en

tifi

cati

on

im

pro

vem

en

t o

f m

od

els

pre

dic

tio

ns

acc

ura

cy b

y id

en

tifi

cati

on

th

e m

ost

im

po

rtan

t so

urc

es

of

bia

s an

d u

nce

rtain

tyth

e m

ost

im

po

rtan

t so

urc

es

of

bia

s an

d u

nce

rtain

ty

••im

ple

men

tati

on

of

new

mo

dellin

g p

roce

du

res

imp

lem

en

tati

on

of

new

mo

dellin

g p

roce

du

res

sup

po

rted

by

sup

po

rted

by

curr

en

t st

ate

of

kn

ow

led

ge a

bo

ut

pro

cess

es

an

d p

hen

om

en

acu

rren

t st

ate

of

kn

ow

led

ge a

bo

ut

pro

cess

es

an

d p

hen

om

en

a

EMR

AS

Iodi

ne

Wor

kin

g G

rou

p

••ch

eck

mo

dels

perf

orm

an

ce in

do

se r

eco

nst

ruct

ion

in

ch

eck

mo

dels

perf

orm

an

ce in

do

se r

eco

nst

ruct

ion

in

a

a c

ase

ca

se

wh

en

w

hen

13

71

37C

s (

Cs

(12

91

29I)

tra

cer

is u

sed

fo

r est

imati

on

of

I) t

race

r is

use

d f

or

est

imati

on

of

13

11

31I

dep

osi

tio

nI

dep

osi

tio

n

••ch

eck

mo

dels

ap

plica

bilit

y t

o c

ou

nte

rmeasu

re r

esp

on

sech

eck

mo

dels

ap

plica

bilit

y t

o c

ou

nte

rmeasu

re r

esp

on

se

••u

nce

rtain

tyu

nce

rtain

ty?,

l?,

lim

itati

on

imit

ati

on

?,

?,

req

uest

ed

in

pu

tre

qu

est

ed

in

pu

td

ata

?d

ata

?

5

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

EMR

AS

Iodi

ne

Wor

kin

g G

rou

p

nu

mero

us

rep

ort

s h

ave c

on

firm

ed

an

in

creasi

ng

nu

mb

er

of

case

s n

um

ero

us

rep

ort

s h

ave c

on

firm

ed

an

in

creasi

ng

nu

mb

er

of

case

s o

f th

yro

id c

an

cer,

part

icu

larl

y i

n t

he m

ost

heavily c

on

tam

inate

do

f th

yro

id c

an

cer,

part

icu

larl

y i

n t

he m

ost

heavily c

on

tam

inate

dre

gio

ns

of

Ukra

ine a

nd

Bela

rus,

bu

t als

o i

n R

uss

iare

gio

ns

of

Ukra

ine a

nd

Bela

rus,

bu

t als

o i

n R

uss

ia

Back

gro

un

d(c

on

t.)

the

conf

iden

t re

cons

truc

tion

of

the

aver

age

and

the

conf

iden

t re

cons

truc

tion

of

the

aver

age

and

pers

onal

thy

roid

dos

e in

aff

ecte

d ar

eas

is r

equi

red:

pers

onal

thy

roid

dos

e in

aff

ecte

d ar

eas

is r

equi

red:

••to

co

nfi

rm t

he s

peci

al m

ed

ical

aid

to

th

e p

op

ula

tio

n a

nd

to

co

nfi

rm t

he s

peci

al m

ed

ical

aid

to

th

e p

op

ula

tio

n a

nd

measu

res

of

soci

al

pro

tect

ion

measu

res

of

soci

al

pro

tect

ion

••tt o

pro

vid

e i

nfo

rmati

on

fo

r th

e p

ub

lic

an

d t

he a

uth

ori

ties

o p

rovid

e i

nfo

rmati

on

fo

r th

e p

ub

lic

an

d t

he a

uth

ori

ties

an

d e

nsu

re e

pid

em

iolo

gic

al in

vest

igati

on

s.an

d e

nsu

re e

pid

em

iolo

gic

al in

vest

igati

on

s.

AD

DIT

ION

AL A

SP

EC

T O

F I

WG

AC

TIV

ITY

AD

DIT

ION

AL A

SP

EC

T O

F I

WG

AC

TIV

ITY

6

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

••u

nce

rtain

tyu

nce

rtain

ty?,

l?,

lim

itati

on

imit

ati

on

??

the q

uan

tita

tive r

ela

tio

nsh

ip b

etw

een

rad

iati

on

do

se t

o t

he

the q

uan

tita

tive r

ela

tio

nsh

ip b

etw

een

rad

iati

on

do

se t

o t

he

thyro

id f

rom

Ch

ern

ob

yl

an

d t

he r

isk o

f th

yro

id c

an

cer.

thyro

id f

rom

Ch

ern

ob

yl

an

d t

he r

isk o

f th

yro

id c

an

cer.

tt he u

nce

rtain

ty c

om

bin

ed

wit

h i

nd

ivid

ual

est

imate

s o

f h

e u

nce

rtain

ty c

om

bin

ed

wit

h i

nd

ivid

ual

est

imate

s o

f ra

dia

tio

n d

ose

co

nst

itu

tes

a c

ruci

al p

oin

t in

est

ab

lish

ing

ra

dia

tio

n d

ose

co

nst

itu

tes

a c

ruci

al p

oin

t in

est

ab

lish

ing

th

is r

ela

tio

nsh

ip,

sin

ce,

an

y r

ele

ase

of

this

rela

tio

nsh

ip,

sin

ce,

an

y r

ele

ase

of

rad

ioio

din

era

dio

iod

ine

into

in

to

en

vir

on

men

t cr

eate

s w

ide r

an

ge o

f u

nce

rtain

ty f

or

en

vir

on

men

t cr

eate

s w

ide r

an

ge o

f u

nce

rtain

ty f

or

inte

rnal

do

se a

ssess

men

ts.

inte

rnal

do

se a

ssess

men

ts.

case

–con

trol

stu

dies

of

thyr

oid

canc

er

EMR

AS

Iodi

ne

Wor

kin

g G

rou

p

Back

gro

un

d(c

on

t.)

7

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

majo

r so

urc

es

of

the u

nce

rtain

tym

ajo

r so

urc

es

of

the u

nce

rtain

ty::

••sm

all

nu

mb

er

an

d p

oo

r q

uali

ty o

f th

yro

id m

easu

rem

en

ts

small

nu

mb

er

an

d p

oo

r q

uali

ty o

f th

yro

id m

easu

rem

en

ts

perf

orm

ed

aft

er

Ch

ern

ob

yl

acc

iden

tp

erf

orm

ed

aft

er

Ch

ern

ob

yl

acc

iden

t

••d

iffi

cult

ies

in e

valu

ati

on

an

d v

alid

ati

on

of

the d

yn

am

ic o

f th

e

dif

ficu

ltie

s in

evalu

ati

on

an

d v

alid

ati

on

of

the d

yn

am

ic o

f th

e

13

11

31I

inta

kes

fun

ctio

n in

to a

hu

man

bo

dy b

ase

d o

n s

pars

e

I in

takes

fun

ctio

n in

to a

hu

man

bo

dy b

ase

d o

n s

pars

e

(sin

gle

po

int)

in

div

idu

al

thyro

id m

easu

rem

en

ts a

nd

(sin

gle

po

int)

in

div

idu

al

thyro

id m

easu

rem

en

ts a

nd

lack

of

lack

of

mil

k

mil

k

sam

ple

s in

earl

y p

eri

od

s o

f acc

iden

tsa

mp

les

in e

arl

y p

eri

od

s o

f acc

iden

t ..

••la

rge v

ari

ety

in

in

hab

itan

ts b

eh

avio

ur

an

d a

gri

cult

ura

l la

rge v

ari

ety

in

in

hab

itan

ts b

eh

avio

ur

an

d a

gri

cult

ura

l

pra

ctic

es

(th

e t

ime w

hen

cow

s h

ad

been

pu

t o

n a

fre

sh

pra

ctic

es

(th

e t

ime w

hen

cow

s h

ad

been

pu

t o

n a

fre

sh

past

ure

) h

ave c

on

sid

era

ble

im

pact

on

do

ses

vari

ab

ilit

y.

past

ure

) h

ave c

on

sid

era

ble

im

pact

on

do

ses

vari

ab

ilit

y.

EMR

AS

Iodi

ne

Wor

kin

g G

rou

p

Back

gro

un

d(c

on

t.)

8

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

Th

e

Th

e 1

31

1

31

II--

scen

ari

os

pro

vid

e a

n e

xce

llen

t o

pp

ort

un

ity

scen

ari

os

pro

vid

e a

n e

xce

llen

t o

pp

ort

un

ity

to c

om

pare

a n

um

ber

of

mo

dell

ing

ap

pro

ach

es

to

to c

om

pare

a n

um

ber

of

mo

dell

ing

ap

pro

ach

es

to

a s

ing

le a

ssess

men

t p

rob

lem

, a s

ing

le a

ssess

men

t p

rob

lem

,

in a

do

se r

eco

nst

ruct

ion

co

nte

xt

in

a d

ose

reco

nst

ruct

ion

co

nte

xt

EMR

AS

Iodi

ne

Wor

kin

g G

rou

p

Back

gro

un

d(c

on

t.)

9

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

BIO

MA

SS

Them

e 2,

the

Dose

Rec

onst

ruct

ion

Work

ing G

roup

was

conce

rned

with t

he

eval

uat

ion o

f th

e re

liabili

ty o

f m

ethods

and

model

suse

d f

or

dose

rec

onst

ruct

ion f

or

spec

ific

indiv

idual

s an

d m

ember

s of

spec

ific

popula

tion

subgro

ups.

In t

he p

ast

en

vir

on

men

tal m

od

ellin

g e

xerc

ises,

on

ly t

wo

I-1

31

sce

nari

os

had

been

evalu

ate

d,

nam

ely

:

BR

EM

EN

SC

EN

AR

IOB

REM

EN

SC

EN

AR

IO(B

IOM

OV

S I

I)

HA

NFO

RD

SC

EN

AR

IOH

AN

FO

RD

SC

EN

AR

IO(B

IOM

AS

S)

HA

NFO

RD

SC

EN

AR

IO -

rele

ase

of

13

1I

fro

m t

he H

an

ford

Pu

rex

Ch

em

ical

Sep

ara

tio

ns

Pla

nt

in t

he

no

rth

west

ern

Un

ited

Sta

tes

in

Sep

tem

ber

19

63

Back

gro

un

d(c

on

t.)

EMR

AS

Iodi

ne

Wor

kin

g G

rou

p

10

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

Nece

ssit

y o

f p

erf

orm

ing

en

vir

on

men

tal m

od

ellin

g e

xerc

ises?

Nece

ssit

y o

f p

erf

orm

ing

en

vir

on

men

tal m

od

ellin

g e

xerc

ises?

Back

gro

un

d(c

on

t.)

Pre

dic

ted

th

yro

id d

ose

s to

th

e t

wo

Pre

dic

ted

th

yro

id d

ose

s to

th

e t

wo

child

ren

wit

h h

igh

milk c

on

sum

pti

on

ch

ild

ren

wit

h h

igh

milk c

on

sum

pti

on

ra

ng

ed

fro

m 0

.00

6 t

o 2

mS

vra

ng

ed

fro

m 0

.00

6 t

o 2

mS

v

Co

mp

en

sato

ry e

ffect

s (a

hig

h p

red

icti

on

in

on

e m

od

el co

mp

art

men

tC

om

pen

sato

ry e

ffect

s (a

hig

h p

red

icti

on

in

on

e m

od

el co

mp

art

men

tb

ein

g o

ffse

t b

y a

lo

wb

ein

g o

ffse

t b

y a

lo

wp

red

icti

on

in

an

oth

er

com

part

men

t) w

ere

qu

ite

pre

dic

tio

n i

n a

no

ther

com

part

men

t) w

ere

qu

ite

com

mo

n in

th

is t

est

exerc

ise.

com

mo

n in

th

is t

est

exerc

ise.

Majo

r so

urc

es

of

un

cert

ain

ty in

th

is e

xerc

ise in

clu

de

Majo

r so

urc

es

of

un

cert

ain

ty in

th

is e

xerc

ise in

clu

de

::

atm

osp

heri

c tr

an

spo

rt (

wh

ich

co

uld

co

ntr

ibu

te a

s m

uch

as

a f

act

oatm

osp

heri

c tr

an

spo

rt (

wh

ich

co

uld

co

ntr

ibu

te a

s m

uch

as

a f

act

or

of

r o

f 2

02

0-- 5

0),

50

),re

pre

sen

tati

ven

ess

rep

rese

nta

tiven

ess

of

availab

le m

easu

rem

en

ts,

iod

ine

of

availab

le m

easu

rem

en

ts,

iod

ine

speci

ati

on

, tr

eatm

en

t o

r n

eg

lect

of

speci

ati

on

, tr

eatm

en

t o

r n

eg

lect

of

terr

ain

eff

ect

s, a

ctu

al co

nsu

mp

tio

n

terr

ain

eff

ect

s, a

ctu

al co

nsu

mp

tio

n

an

d m

eta

bo

lic

rate

san

d m

eta

bo

lic

rate

s

Sele

cted

co

ncl

usi

on

s o

f H

AN

FO

RD

SC

EN

AR

IOS

ele

cted

co

ncl

usi

on

s o

f H

AN

FO

RD

SC

EN

AR

IO(B

IOM

AS

S):

11

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

MIL

ES

TO

NES

MIL

ES

TO

NES

EMR

AS

Iodi

ne

Wor

kin

g G

rou

p

11stst

EM

RA

S m

eeti

ng

(1

EM

RA

S m

eeti

ng

(1

-- 5 S

ep

tem

ber

20

03

)5

Sep

tem

ber

20

03

)

develo

pd

evelo

pin

gin

gap

pro

pri

ate

sce

nari

os

for

mo

del

vali

dati

on

ap

pro

pri

ate

sce

nari

os

for

mo

del

vali

dati

on

aan

dn

dco

llect

collect

ing

ing

measu

rem

en

t d

ata

sets

measu

rem

en

t d

ata

sets

qu

ali

tyq

uali

tych

eck

check

ing

ing

of

inp

ut

an

d m

easu

rem

en

t d

ata

o

f in

pu

t an

d m

easu

rem

en

t d

ata

bbefo

re

efo

re

11stst

EM

RA

S m

eeti

ng

(1

EM

RA

S m

eeti

ng

(1

-- 5 S

ep

tem

ber

20

03

)5

Sep

tem

ber

20

03

)

Qu

est

ion

nair

e

Qu

est

ion

nair

e

to

to i

den

tify

part

icip

an

ts o

f p

ote

nti

al

wo

rkin

g g

rou

pid

en

tify

part

icip

an

ts o

f p

ote

nti

al

wo

rkin

g g

rou

p

to

to i

den

tify

su

itab

le d

ata

sets

an

d m

od

els

fo

r te

stin

gid

en

tify

su

itab

le d

ata

sets

an

d m

od

els

fo

r te

stin

g

9 m

odel

lers

9 m

odel

lers

10 s

cena

rios

prop

osal

s10

sce

nario

s pr

opos

als

en

d o

f Ja

nu

ary

20

04

en

d o

f Ja

nu

ary

20

04

the S

cen

ari

oth

e S

cen

ari

oP

lavsk

Pla

vsk

was

evalu

ate

d a

nd

dis

trib

ute

d a

mo

ng

th

e

was

evalu

ate

d a

nd

dis

trib

ute

d a

mo

ng

th

e

part

icip

an

ts t

og

eth

er

wit

h p

red

icti

on

fo

rmu

lari

es

(in

Exce

l fi

lep

art

icip

an

ts t

og

eth

er

wit

h p

red

icti

on

fo

rmu

lari

es

(in

Exce

l fi

le))

Th

e S

cen

ari

o i

s als

o a

vail

ab

le o

n t

he E

MR

AS

WEB

SIT

E:

Th

e S

cen

ari

o i

s als

o a

vail

ab

le o

n t

he E

MR

AS

WEB

SIT

E:

http

://w

ww

http

://w

ww

-- ns.ns. ia

eaia

ea.o

rg/p

roje

cts/

.org

/pro

ject

s/em

ras

emra

s //em

ras

emra

s --io

dine

iodi

ne-- 1

31131 --

wg

wg ..

htm

htm

12

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

EMR

AS

Iodi

ne

Wor

kin

g G

rou

p

MIL

ES

TO

NES

MIL

ES

TO

NES

13

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

CO

NSID

ERED

FU

RTH

ER S

CEN

ARIO

CO

NSID

ERED

FU

RTH

ER S

CEN

ARIO

131

131

I

I W

AR

SA

W S

CE

NA

RIO

W

AR

SA

W S

CE

NA

RIO

(Cher

nobyl

)

in p

rep

ara

tio

n (

desc

rip

tio

n,

ele

ctro

nic

all

y a

vail

ab

le i

np

ut

data

)

ccru

cial

ruci

al

po

ints

fo

r m

od

el vali

dati

on

!p

oin

ts f

or

mo

del vali

dati

on

!

•eff

ect

iven

ess

of

thyro

id b

lock

ing

!

•in

ho

mo

gen

eo

us

13

1I

dep

osi

tio

n

en

d p

oin

ts c

on

sid

ere

d f

or

mo

del te

sten

d p

oin

ts c

on

sid

ere

d f

or

mo

del te

stin

gin

g::

•13

1I

con

cen

trati

on

in

milk

•13

1I

thyro

id b

urd

en

fo

r d

iffe

ren

t ag

e g

rou

ps

for

two

sp

eci

fied

lo

cati

on

cou

nte

rmeasu

res

cou

nte

rmeasu

res

•ad

min

istr

ati

on

of

stab

le i

od

ine s

olu

tio

n (

inte

rvie

ws

DB

),•

lim

itati

on

of

fresh

milk c

on

sum

pti

on

(u

nce

rtain

data

),

•re

stri

ctio

n o

f co

ws

past

uri

ng

(u

nce

rtain

data

)

14

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

PLA

VS

KP

LAV

SK

Sce

nari

oS

cena

rio

(Cher

nobyl

)Pr

imer

y pre

pare

d by

SEN

ES, (

desc

riptio

n, e

lectro

nicall

y ava

ilable

inpu

t dat

a)cu

stom

ised

for

IWG

by Ir

ina Z

wono

wa, P

aweł

Kraje

wski

•• mo

del

vali

dati

on

mo

del

vali

dati

on

pro

ble

mp

rob

lem

!!

reco

nst

ruct

ion

of

13

1I

dep

osi

tio

n u

sin

g 1

37C

s as

a t

race

r

•• sce

nari

o a

dvan

tag

es!

scen

ari

o a

dvan

tag

es!

nu

mero

us

measu

rem

en

ts o

f 1

31I

thyro

id c

on

ten

tsad

eq

uate

data

set

of

13

1I/

13

7C

s ra

tio

in

so

il (

28

May 1

98

6)

••a n

ew

su

bje

ct

a n

ew

su

bje

ct t

otob

e v

ali

date

d!

be v

ali

date

d!

13

1I

thyro

id b

urd

en

fo

r n

ew

bo

rn a

nd

<3

m:

pro

cess

-tr

an

sfer

fact

or

fro

m m

oth

er

bre

ast

to

mil

k

15

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

131

131

I P

LAV

SK

I P

LAV

SK

Sce

nari

oS

cena

rio

(Cher

nobyl

)

en

d p

oin

ts c

on

sid

ere

d f

or

mo

del

vali

dati

on

:en

d p

oin

ts c

on

sid

ere

d f

or

mo

del

vali

dati

on

:

••1

31

13

1I

dep

osi

tio

n (

soil c

on

cen

trati

on

)I

dep

osi

tio

n (

soil c

on

cen

trati

on

)

••a t

ime d

ep

en

den

t a t

ime d

ep

en

den

t 1

31

13

1I

con

cen

trati

on

in

milk

I co

nce

ntr

ati

on

in

milk

in t

he p

eri

od

27

Ap

ril

–3

0 M

ay 1

98

6 f

or

18

milk f

arm

an

d T

ow

n P

lavsk

situ

ate

d a

t d

iffe

ren

t 1

31I

dep

osi

tio

nd

en

sity

••13

11

31I

thyro

id b

urd

en

fo

r d

iffe

ren

t ag

e g

rou

ps:

I th

yro

id b

urd

en

fo

r d

iffe

ren

t ag

e g

rou

ps:

for

urb

an

po

pu

lati

on

(P

lavsk

tow

n):

new

bo

rn,

1-2

, 3

-7,

8-1

2,

13

-17

, ad

ult

for

speci

fied

ru

ral

loca

tio

ns:

new

bo

rn,

1-2

, 3

-7,

8-1

2,

13

-17

, ad

ult

en

d p

oin

ts c

on

sid

ere

d f

or

mo

del

inte

rco

mp

ari

son

:en

d p

oin

ts c

on

sid

ere

d f

or

mo

del

inte

rco

mp

ari

son

:co

mm

itte

d d

ose

s to

th

yro

id f

rom

in

gest

ion

reco

nst

ruct

ion

of

13

1I

air

co

nce

ntr

ati

on

fro

m d

ep

osi

tio

n

inh

ala

tio

n d

ose

co

ntr

ibu

tio

n t

o t

he t

ota

l d

ose

16

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

131

131

I P

LAV

SK

I P

LAV

SK

Sce

nari

oS

cena

rio

(Cher

nobyl

)

17

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

11K

rasn

og

or'

eK

rasn

og

or'

e22

Za M

irZ

a M

ir33

Im.

Safo

no

va

Im.

Safo

no

va

44P

lavsk

ijP

lavsk

ij55

Vp

ere

d k

ko

mm

un

izm

uV

pere

d k

ko

mm

un

izm

u66

Im.

Lu

k'j

an

ova

Im.

Lu

k'j

an

ova

77G

orb

ach

evsk

ijG

orb

ach

evsk

ij88

Tu

l'sk

aja

niv

a

Tu

l'sk

aja

niv

a

99Im

. K

. M

ark

saIm

. K

. M

ark

sa1

01

0R

oss

ija

Ro

ssij

a1

11

1K

oll

ekti

vis

tK

oll

ekti

vis

t1

21

2K

om

mu

nar

Ko

mm

un

ar

13

13

Dru

zhb

aD

ruzh

ba

14

14

im.X

XII

part

s'ezd

aim

.XX

II p

art

s'ezd

a1

51

5U

darn

ikU

darn

ik1

61

6O

l'h

iO

l'h

i1

71

7S

ko

rod

no

eS

ko

rod

no

e1

81

8N

ovo

Nik

ol'sk

ijN

ovo

Nik

ol'sk

ij

40

km

wid

th4

0 k

m w

idth

; ; 6

0 k

m h

igh

60

km

hig

h

>37

kBq/

m2

; 37

–185

kBq/

m2 ;

1

85–3

70kB

q/m

2 ;

370–

555

kBq/

m2 ;

>

555

kBq/

m2

>37

kBq/

m2

; 37

–185

kBq/

m2 ;

1

85–3

70kB

q/m

2 ;

370–

555

kBq/

m2 ;

>

555

kBq/

m2

18

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

MIL

ES

TO

NES

MIL

ES

TO

NES

(co

nt

(co

nt ))

EMR

AS

Iodi

ne

Wor

kin

g G

rou

p

2n

d M

eeti

ng

of

the

2n

d M

eeti

ng

of

the

IAEA

’sIA

EA

’sEM

RA

S

IWG

EM

RA

S

IWG

(h

eld

at

the C

IEM

AT,

Mad

rid

, S

pain

, 3

1 M

ay t

o(h

eld

at

the C

IEM

AT,

Mad

rid

, S

pain

, 3

1 M

ay t

o22

Jun

e 2

00

4)

Jun

e 2

00

4)

99p

art

icip

an

ts s

en

t re

sult

s, t

og

eth

er

wit

h q

uest

ion

nair

e

part

icip

an

ts s

en

t re

sult

s, t

og

eth

er

wit

h q

uest

ion

nair

e

sum

mari

zed

ass

um

pti

on

s an

d u

sed

para

mete

rs.

sum

mari

zed

ass

um

pti

on

s an

d u

sed

para

mete

rs.

bli

nd

test

exerc

ise

bli

nd

test

exerc

ise

(wh

en

measu

rem

en

ts r

esu

lts

rem

ain

ed

un

kn

ow

n t

o

part

icip

an

ts)

an

d s

en

t re

sult

s b

efo

re

fro

m F

eb

ruary

to

May 2

00

4fr

om

Feb

ruary

to

May 2

00

4

Irin

a Z

vo

now

aIr

ina Z

vo

now

ap

rovid

ed

th

e o

bse

rved

data

fo

r th

ep

rovid

ed

th

e o

bse

rved

data

fo

r th

eP

lavsk

Pla

vsk

reg

ion

.re

gio

n.

an

aly

sin

g p

red

icti

on

s vers

us

ob

serv

ed

data

an

aly

sin

g p

red

icti

on

s vers

us

ob

serv

ed

data

19

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

MIL

ES

TO

NES

MIL

ES

TO

NES

(co

nt

(co

nt ))

EMR

AS

Iodi

ne

Wor

kin

g G

rou

p

Th

e m

easu

rem

en

ts f

or

use

as

test

data

were

not

ideall

y s

uit

ed

fo

r m

od

el te

stin

g

pu

rpo

ses

(i.e

. m

ilk s

am

ple

s w

ere

no

t en

tire

ly r

ep

rese

nta

tive o

f th

e t

est

lo

cati

on

s

or

the t

hyro

id m

easu

rem

en

ts w

ere

in

com

ple

te).

Fo

r th

ese

reaso

ns,

th

e s

eco

nd

ru

n o

f p

red

icti

on

s w

as

pla

ned

wit

hre

sult

s to

be

sen

t b

efo

re t

he N

ovem

ber

20

04

.

Th

is e

xerc

ise w

ill

be s

till

rep

rese

nta

tive f

or

an

act

ual d

ose

reco

nst

ruct

ion

base

d o

n

exis

tin

g d

ata

, w

hate

ver

their

lim

itati

on

, an

d c

on

clu

sio

ns

stil

l b

e v

ali

d f

or

do

se

ass

ess

men

t p

urp

ose

s, e

speci

all

y i

f n

ot

mo

st d

ose

reco

nst

ruct

ion

sit

uati

on

s, t

he

data

availab

le a

re in

com

ple

te o

r im

perf

ect

.

2n

d M

eeti

ng

of

the

2n

d M

eeti

ng

of

the

IAEA

’sIA

EA

’sEM

RA

S

IWG

EM

RA

S

IWG

(h

eld

at

the C

IEM

AT,

Mad

rid

, S

pain

, 3

1 M

ay t

o(h

eld

at

the C

IEM

AT,

Mad

rid

, S

pain

, 3

1 M

ay t

o22

Jun

e 2

00

4)

Jun

e 2

00

4)

con

clu

sio

ns

con

clu

sio

ns

20

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

MIL

ES

TO

NES

MIL

ES

TO

NES

(co

nt

(co

nt ))

EMR

AS

Iodi

ne

Wor

kin

g G

rou

p

Jun

e

Jun

e ––

No

vem

ber

20

04

No

vem

ber

20

04

21

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

MIL

ES

TO

NES

MIL

ES

TO

NES

(co

nt

(co

nt ))

EMR

AS

Iodi

ne

Wor

kin

g G

rou

p

Jun

e

Jun

e ––

No

vem

ber

20

04

No

vem

ber

20

04

22

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

MIL

ES

TO

NES

MIL

ES

TO

NES

(co

nt

(co

nt ))

EMR

AS

Iodi

ne

Wor

kin

g G

rou

p

evalu

ati

on

an

d d

iscu

ssio

n o

f re

sult

s o

f se

con

d r

un

pre

dic

tio

ns

evalu

ati

on

an

d d

iscu

ssio

n o

f re

sult

s o

f se

con

d r

un

pre

dic

tio

ns

pre

para

tio

n o

f d

raft

Fin

al

pre

para

tio

n o

f d

raft

Fin

al

RRep

ort

ep

ort

intr

od

uct

ion

to

th

e W

ars

aw

sce

nari

oin

tro

du

ctio

n t

o t

he W

ars

aw

sce

nari

o

2n

d C

om

bin

ed

Meeti

ng

s o

f th

e I

AEA

2

nd

Co

mb

ined

Meeti

ng

s o

f th

e I

AEA

((EM

RA

S)

EM

RA

S)

88––

11

Novem

ber

20

04

11

Novem

ber

20

04

Th

e g

rou

p a

gre

ed

th

at

the f

irst

mo

del

vali

dati

on

an

d i

nte

rco

mp

ari

son

exerc

ise w

ill

be c

arr

ied

in

20

04

usi

ng

th

eP

lavsk

Sce

nari

o.

Calc

ula

tio

ns

for

the W

ars

aw

sce

nari

o w

ill

be d

ela

yed

un

til

aft

er

the

com

ple

tio

n o

f th

e G

rou

p’s

wo

rk o

n t

he

Pla

vsk

Sce

nari

o.

23

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

MIL

ES

TO

NES

(p

lan

ned

)M

ILES

TO

NES

(p

lan

ned

)

EMR

AS

Iodi

ne

Wor

kin

g G

rou

p

dis

trib

uti

on

of

dra

ft W

ars

aw

Sce

nari

od

istr

ibu

tio

n o

f d

raft

Wars

aw

Sce

nari

o

en

d o

f D

ece

mb

er

20

04

en

d o

f D

ece

mb

er

20

04

data

evalu

ati

on

, IW

G R

ep

ort

data

evalu

ati

on

, IW

G R

ep

ort

Jan

uary

20

05

Ja

nu

ary

20

05

--Ju

ne 2

00

5Ju

ne 2

00

5

IWG

mIW

G m

eeti

ng

eeti

ng

May

May

-- Ju

ly 2

00

5Ju

ly 2

00

5

pre

dic

tio

ns

for

Wars

aw

Sce

nari

op

red

icti

on

s fo

r W

ars

aw

Sce

nari

o

dis

clo

sin

g o

bse

rved

data

, evalu

ati

on

of

pre

dic

tio

ns

dis

clo

sin

g o

bse

rved

data

, evalu

ati

on

of

pre

dic

tio

ns

33rdrd

Co

mb

ined

EM

RA

S m

eeti

ng

Au

tum

n 2

00

5C

om

bin

ed

EM

RA

S m

eeti

ng

Au

tum

n 2

00

5

July

July

--O

cto

ber

20

05

Oct

ob

er

20

05

seco

nd

ru

n o

f p

red

icti

on

s se

con

d r

un

of

pre

dic

tio

ns

24

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

MO

DELS

MO

DELS

((9participants) Me

dical

Radio

logica

l Re

sear

chCe

nter

Ru

ssia

n

Ru

ssia

n

Fed

era

tio

nFed

era

tio

nO.

Vlas

ov (N

ew)

(New

)CL

IMRA

DCL

IMRA

D99

Food

Stan

dard

Age

ncy

UK

UK

Mr D

. Web

be-W

ood

(New

)(N

ew)

SPAD

ESP

ADE

V.6

V.6

88

Natio

nal C

ance

r Ins

titute

US

AU

SA

Mr S

. Sim

on (N

ew)

(New

)Pl

avsk

Dos

e Pl

avsk

Dos

e Ca

lculat

orCa

lculat

or77

Radia

tion &

Nuc

lear S

afety

Autho

rity (S

TUK)

Fin

lan

dFin

lan

dMr

M. A

mm

ann

(New

)(N

ew)

Ecos

ysEc

osys

-- 8787

66

Institu

tde R

adiop

rotec

tion e

t de

Sûre

té Nu

cléair

e(IR

SN)

Fra

nce

Fra

nce

Ms C

. Duf

fa(N

ew)

(New

)AS

TRAL

ASTR

AL55

Centr

al La

bora

tory f

or

Radio

logica

l Pro

tectio

nP

ola

nd

Po

lan

dMr

P. K

rajew

ski

(BIO

MASS

)(B

IOMA

SS)

CLRP

CLRP

44

Unive

rsity

of Ve

szpr

émDe

partm

ent o

f Rad

ioche

mistr

yH

un

gary

Hu

ng

ary

Mr B

.Kan

yár

(BIO

MASS

)(B

IOMA

SS)

UniV

esUn

iVes

33

Japa

n Atom

ic En

ergy

Re

sear

ch In

stitut

eJa

pan

Jap

an

Mr T

HOM

MA(B

IOMA

SS)

(BIO

MASS

)OS

CAAR

OSCA

AR22

Institu

te of

Phys

icsLit

hu

an

iaLit

hu

an

iaMs

T. N

edve

ckait

e (B

IOMA

SS)

(BIO

MASS

)LI

ETDO

SLI

ETDO

S11

Org

aniz

atio

nO

rgan

izat

ion

Cou

ntry

Cou

ntry

Part

icip

ant

Part

icip

ant

Nam

eN

ame

Mod

elM

odel

24

25

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

26

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

27

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

28

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04

29

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

2nd

Com

bine

d M

eetin

gs o

f the

IAE

A P

rogr

amm

e on

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

Env

iron

men

tal M

odel

ling

for

RA

diat

ion

RA

diat

ion

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

Safe

ty (E

MR

AS)

88 ––11

Nov

embe

r 20

0411

Nov

embe

r 20

04