landscape functions and people bangkok, cctober 2010 governing landscapes
Post on 20-Dec-2015
220 views
TRANSCRIPT
Mismatches in levels and scales
Bio-physical scales governance scales juridical scales
Individual
family
Community
Country
Region
Municipality
Local
provincial
National
International
Province/district
department
municipal
Governance in the landscape
which political body has responsibility over
the landscape?
who is responsible for landscape level
planning?
how can stakeholders be democratically
involved?
what is the legitimacy of any landscape plan?
whom to be held accountable?
according to whose legal system?
Mismatch between administrative levels and landscape level
Mismatch between democratic accountability mechanisms and landscapes
Institutional frameworks don't fit the landscape level planning process
New institutional arrangements are needed
Governance in the landscape
Albert Einstein: "we cannot solve problems using the same logic with which we created them..."
Governance in the landscape
Closed Invited Claimed
National
Local
International
Forms of power
Levels of power
Spaces of power
Forms of power
Visible
Invisible
Hidden
Mobilizing the power of stakeholders in the
landscape
Levels of power Mobilise capacities at all levels connect vertically by building alliances and networks
Spaces of power
connect horizontally by building chains of accountability Strengthen (in)formal institutions
Forms of power Address the hidden and invisible forms of power at all levels and spaces, and make them visible through lobby and advocacy
Where would we like to be?
Where are we now?
Vision
Plans
Where have we come from?
Past Present Future
Multi-stakeholder processMulti-stakeholder process
Multi-stakeholder process
Collaborative Action
Reflexive Monitoring
Adaptive Planning
Initiating
Stakeholder 3
Stakeholder 5
Stakeholder 7
Stakeholder 8
Stakeholder 6
Stakeholder 4
Stakeholder 2
Stakeholder 1
Multi-stakeholder process in the landscape
Stakeholder 3
Stakeholder 5
Stakeholder 7
Stakeholder 8
Stakeholder 6
Stakeholder 4
Stakeholder 2
Stakeholder 1
Multi-stakeholder process in a landscape
Stakeholder 3
Stakeholder 5
Stakeholder 7
Stakeholder 8
Stakeholder 6
Stakeholder 4
Stakeholder 2
Stakeholder 1
Are networks democratically representative?
Do they play an official role in decision making?
Can they be held accountable?
Stakeholder networks