latest publication may 2011
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/6/2019 Latest Publication May 2011
1/19
Chemical Weathering of the Indo-Gangetic Alluvium with SpecialReference to Release of Fluoride in the Groundwater,
Unnao District, Uttar Pradesh
S. KUMAR and A. SAXENA+
Centre of Advanced Study in Geology, University of Lucknow, Lucknow - 226 007+Present Address: SMEC India Pvt. Ltd., Gurgaon - 122 002
Email: [email protected]
Abstract: In the central part of Indo-Gangetic alluvium in the Unnao district, Uttar Pradesh there are many pockets
where groundwater shows high fluoride content. Drinking of fluorinated ground water has effected a large populationand in many villages more than 80% of the population is suffering from fluorosis. The source of this fluoride appears
to be the alluvial sediments deposited in the geological past as no hard rock terrain is present in the nearby areas. The
area is dominantly made up of mud with pockets of sand. The sand fraction is made up of quartz, plagioclase, microcline,
muscovite and biotite along with some accessory minerals like garnet, epidote, chlorite, tourmaline, hornblende, kyanite
and a few opaque minerals. Moreover, the fluoride content in the groundwater varies both spatially and with depth
indicating a sporadic occurrence. The surface water is devoid of high content of fluoride but is reported in hand pumps
and in the dug wells. This paper deals with the geochemical study of the sediments up to a depth of 45m as most of the
hand pumps are up to this depth to understand the source of fluoride. 14C dates of calcretes have suggested that the
45 m thick succession must have been formed in about 45000 years.
Two different location sites were selected; one showing higher concentration of fluoride (Marksnagar village) while
at other site which is about 4 km east of Marksnagar, the fluoride content was minimal (Durgajkhera village). Major
elements and 24 trace elements were determined using XRF and it was found that when major elements are normalized
with respect to upper continental crust (UCC) there is an enrichment of Si in all the samples. Na shows depletion whereas Ti and K show enrichment. Fe and Mn show enrichment probably due to the formation of clay minerals. Si, and K
enrichment is due to weathering of feldspar while Mg, Fe and K may have been released by the weathering of biotite.
The CIA for the ancient sediments ranges from 54 64 while for the modern sediments of the Ganga River it varies from
50 64 indicating that there is no change in the rate of weathering in both modern and ancient sediments. The rate of
weathering at all the sample locations was compared with that of UCC. The CIA values also suggest that there is an
incipient weathering and indicate that the weathering of biotite is more progressive than muscovite. There is also a
positive correlation between CIA values and the fluoride content in the ground water. Higher percentage of biotite and
chlorite (altered biotite) was found at Marksnagar in comparison to Durgajkhera. It appears that the fluoride content in
the ground water is due to dissociation/alteration of mica minerals mainly biotite.
Keywords: Groundwater, Chemical weathering, Fluoride, Uttar Pradesh.
In the Indo-Gangetic alluvium the groundwater is mainly
used for drinking purposes. In last one to two decades, some
water related problems are encountered in this region. It is
noted that in many areas of the Gangetic alluvial tract, a
large population is suffering from fluorosis, a deadly
incurable disease caused due to high intake of fluoride
(Pandey, 2001) from dugwells and hand pumps mainly in
rural areas. It is also reported by various government
agencies (CGWB, 1999) that this problem is spreading in
other areas also.
The cause of fluorosis is mainly due to the drinking of
INTRODUCTION
The Indo-Gangetic alluvial plain covers an area of about
700,000 km2 and separates the Peninsular India (Indian
Shield) from the Himalayas (Fig.1). It represents deposits
of an active foreland basin formed as a result of continent-
continent collision of the Indian plate with the Asian plate
(Singh, 1996). The rivers originating from the Himalaya
deposit their load in the alluvial plain constituting the worlds
largest alluvial tract (Singh, 1996). The alluvium represents
Quaternary and Recent deposits comprising mud, sand and
clays and devoid of any hard rocks.
JOURNAL GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF INDIA
Vol.77, May 2011, pp.459-477
0016-7622/2011-77-5-459/$ 1.00 GEOL. SOC. INDIA
-
8/6/2019 Latest Publication May 2011
2/19
JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.77, MAY 2011
460 S. KUMAR AND A. SAXENA
fluoride contaminated groundwater. It has been now
confirmed that the villagers are drawing water from the
dugwells and the shallow hand pumps for their drinking
purposes and other domestic uses (Mukherjee et al. 1995).
These wells and hand pumps show a very high concentration
of fluoride in their water. In the year 1995 Mukherjee et al.
(1995) have identified that the Marksnagar village is the
most adversely affected area. At that time the value of
fluoride concentration in the dugwell measured 6.3 ppm andabout 50% of the population were reportedly suffering from
the fluorosis which was more pronounced in the children
below 20 years of age group (as per BIS 1991 norms the
permissible limit for fluoride in drinking water is 1.2 ppm).
They further added that the dental fluorosis was prevalent
in this area for the last 15-20 years. In a recent survey the
Marksnagar village of Unnao district, U.P. shows the
maximum of 9 ppm of fluoride in the dugwell (Saxena,
2005). This value shows a monthly fluctuation between 7 to
9 ppm throughout the year and in absence of any other
alternative source the villagers are forced to use this water
for the drinking and their domestic purposes. About 90% of
the population was found to be adversely affected by the
fluorosis in this village.
In the absence of any industrial effluents in the nearby
areas, the release of fluoride in the groundwater is definitely
due to the weathering of sediments. Since Marksnagar has
already been identified for the high fluoride contamination
in the groundwater, as confirmed by various other agencies
(Mukherjee et al. 1995; Rai, 1997; CGWB, 1999), this areawas selected for the detailed study of the weathering
processes active in the region for finding out any probable
source and mechanism for the release of fluoride in
groundwater.
GEOLOGICAL AND HYDROLOGICAL SETTING
The area under study forms a part of the Central Ganga
plain (Pathak, 1982 in Khanna, 1992). The alluvial sediments
of Ganga Basin have been classified as Older Alluvium and
Newer Alluvium; the former consists of sediments which
Fig.1. Geological setting of the study area (depicted by dot) (afterSingh, 1992).
-
8/6/2019 Latest Publication May 2011
3/19
JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.77, MAY 2011
CHEMICAL WEATHERING OF THE INDO-GANGETIC ALLUVIUM, U.P. 461
were formed in distant past and are partly undergoing
denudation, while the latter is under its process of formation
(Khanna, 1992). The Older Alluvium is made up of massive
beds of clay of a pale reddish brown colour, very often
yellowish with kanker (calcrete) present in between the clay
layers. The Newer Alluvium is light coloured and poor in
calcareous matter. The major part of the Central Ganga plain
is composed of Older Alluvium (Khanna, 1992). The area
in the Unnao district is a flat alluvial tract with soil exhibiting
a wide variance; sandy on the elevated locations, clayey in
the topographical lows and loamy on the flat surfaces. Figure
2 gives the location map of the study area.
The area is mud (silt + clay) dominated and thus leads
to water logged conditions which are supposed to be
responsible for the sodic soil present in the area. The Ganga
and Sai are the main rivers of the area and are responsiblefor many paleo-channels and ox-bow lakes. The general
trend of both the rivers is northwest to southeast. The study
area falls in doab of the rivers Ganga and Gomati, intersected
by Sai River and many other streamlets. The area shows
low regional surface gradient from northeast to southwest,
varying from 10 to 30 cm/km (Rai, 1997). The upper layer
of alluvium is composed of sandy loam and clayey loam.
The main source for irrigation in the area is Sharda canal
and shallow tubewells bored in the fields generally at about
45 m depth. The aquifer material is fine to medium grained
sand and generally micaceous in nature with calcrete. The
chemical analysis of groundwater (Rai, 1997) of Unnao
district indicates that both good and moderate/bad quality
groundwater found in the sand dominated areas and
moderate to bad quality groundwater occurs in clay
dominated areas under confined and semi-confined
conditions. The bad quality water is mostly found in
waterlogged areas and shows an increasing trend of
groundwater salinity/alkalinity. The problem of leaching of
fluoride in groundwater is more confined to this zone
and had effected the local population adversely. The
high fluoride content is found in well water which
intersects clay dominated sediments and the water table isvery shallow due to excess recharge from canals. Rai (1997)
suggested that since these soils are sodic the groundwater
contaminated with high fluoride is also alkaline with high
sodium bicarbonate and sulphates. Thus, the fluoride in
groundwater of Unnao district is closely related with soil/
groundwater alkalinity under waterlogged conditions.
The climate of the area falls under the warm temperate
type with dry winters (Cwg type) or C1 type of climate i.e.,
dry sub-humid type of climate (Ahmad, 1999). The climate
can be broadly divided into summer, monsoon and
winter. The average annual rainfall of the district is 837.80
millimeter (http://cgwblucknow.up.nic.in/hydro/dist36.pdf).
Almost 90% of the annual precipitation is received during
the period from June to September.
SAMPLING AND ANALYTICAL METHODS
As mentioned earlier, for understanding the weathering
process involved in the release of fluoride, two areas were
selected; one is Marksnagar village where excess fluoride
is reported in the groundwater and another is nearby village
Durgajkhera from where no such excess is known.
Six piezometers were installed in the study area in order
to get a representative water samples at various depths for
the water quality analysis as well as to get the vertical
sediment samples at uniform depth interval; four piezometers
were installed at Marksnagar (at depth intervals of 8, 21, 33and 45 m) and two at Durgajkhera (at 12 and 33 m of depth).
The piezometers were installed with the help of an augur by
rotary method and the sediment samples were collected
during the installation of the piezometers.
In all 26 sediment samples were collected at depth
interval of 3 m up to a depth of 45 m below ground level at
Marksnagar and up to a depth of 33 m at Durgajkhera. On
the basis of grain size analysis of the sediment samples, the
strata chart was also prepared representing the vertical
variation in the lithology of the selected sites. The vertical
variation in the sediments in Marksnagar and Durgajkhera
are shown in Fig.3. In addition to the above sediments, the
recent sand and mud samples were also collected from the
left bank of Ganga River at Bithur and Kanpur (Jajmau
Bridge) for the comparative study with older sediments.
There is some basic difference in the nature of sediments at
Marksnagar and Durgajkhera. The sediments of Marksnagar
are generally mud dominated with few regular patches of
calcrete while that of Durgajkhera are sand dominated with
kanker formation invariably at a depth below 18 m. The
basic mineralogy of the sand fraction confirmed the
dominant presence of quartz, muscovite, feldspar and biotite
as major minerals with hornblende, garnet, tourmaline,kyanite and epidote present in minor amount. Two samples
of calcrete collected at a depth of 7 m and 30 m were dated
by 14C method in the laboratory of the Birbal Sahani Institute
of Paleobotany, Lucknow (pers. commn. Dr. G. Rajgopalan)
to have an idea about the approximate age of the calcrete
bearing horizons. The radiometric dates of calcretes at
the depth of 7 and 30 m are 3060140 years B.P. and
276701490 years B.P. On this basis it can be inferred that
ca. 23 m thick succession was deposit in ca. 24000 years. It
can be presumed that about 1 m was deposited in ca. 1000
years. Thus, the total profile of 45 m thick succession must
-
8/6/2019 Latest Publication May 2011
4/19
JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.77, MAY 2011
462 S. KUMAR AND A. SAXENA
have been deposited in ca. 45000 years B.P., this is not an
absolute age of the sediments but an approximation for the
deposition of the sediments of about 45 m thick profile.
The chemical analysis of sediments was done by X-ray
Fluorescence Spectrometry (XRF) at the laboratory of the
Institute of Geology and Mineralogy, University of Erlangen-
Nurenberg, Erlangen, Germany. Philips PW 2400 X-Ray
fluorescence spectrophotometer was used for the
determination of major and trace elements.
Loss of Ignition (LOI)
The dry weight of the porcelain crucible was noted and
2 gm of the bulk sample was weighed in the crucible and
again the weight was noted. These crucibles were kept in
the furnace for 24 hours at about 1000oC. After 24 hours
these crucibles were cooled in an exsiccator and wereweighed again.
Calculation of the LOI
LOI = (Empty crucible weight + weight of sample before
heating) (weight after heating/ weight of sample before
tempering) X 100 [%]
Tablet Preparation: About 1.0000.0005 gm of the
samples were taken in bigger crucibles and were mixed
thoroughly with 4.830 gm of Li3B
2O
7. This mixture was
then kept in the platinum crucible and was melted. All the
five burners were used starting from the extreme left. The
crucibles were left over at each burner for 5 10 minutes.
In front of the last one laid the form for the tablets. After
10 - 20 minutes on the last burner the liquefied material was
poured in the tablet holder and was kept for cooling. The
samples are labeled as required. Then after melting these
crucibles were kept in a plasticbox with 25% HCl and was
processed in the ultrasonic bath for 10 minutes. Finally
douched them with normal water and aqua dest and dried
with paper.
The precision and accuracy of the preparation and the
instrumental performance of the XRF was checked using
the international reference samples. With few exceptions,
there were no discrepancies between the analytical data
obtained and the consensus data in the international reference
samples.
RESULTS
The grain size analysis was done for the sediment
samples collected during the installation of piezometers.
The piezometers were installed for two villages; one is
Marksnagar where maximum number of fluorosis patients
were recorded and the other is a near by village Durgajkhera,
where only about 10% patients were noted. Durgajkhera is
about 3 km east of Marksnagar (Fig. 2). Mud is the dominant
fraction in both the villages. In Marksnagar mud is about
Fig.2. Location map of the study area, Unnao district, Uttar Pradesh
-
8/6/2019 Latest Publication May 2011
5/19
JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.77, MAY 2011
CHEMICAL WEATHERING OF THE INDO-GANGETIC ALLUVIUM, U.P. 463
76% while in Durgajkhera it is 57%. Besides mud, the
variation in the content of sand and calcretes was also noted
up to the maximum depth of 45m below the ground surface.
At Durgajkhera more calcrete was found. The sediment
samples at Marksnagar generally show moderate sorting
while the samples collected at Durgajkhera the sorting lies
between moderately well sorted to well sorted. The samples
were found to be very coarse skewed for Marksnagar and
very coarse skewed to fine skewed for Durgajkhera.
Mineralogically, the sand fraction is dominantly composedof quartz, plagioclase, microcline, muscovite and biotite
along with some accessory minerals like garnet, epidote,
chlorite, tourmaline, hornblende, kyanite and a few opaque
minerals. It was noted that the minerals identified at
Marksnagar were found in more altered form as compared
to Durgajkhera. The minerals dominantly identified in their
altered form were plagioclase and biotite. In the silt fraction
quartz, albite, microcline, muscovite and biotite were
identified where as in the clay fraction the minerals of mica
(illite and muscovite), smectite (sauconite and
montmorillonite), chlorite (vermiculite and clinochlore) and
kaolinite (kaoline and amesite) groups were found (Saxena,
2005).
The geochemical analysis for these sediments was done
for all the ten major elements viz. Si, Ti, Al, Fe, Mn, Mg,
Ca, Na, K, P were determined and analyzed in their oxide
form. 24 trace elements viz. As, Ba, Bi, Ce, Co, Cr, Cu, Ga,
Hf, La, Mo, Nb, Ni, Pb, Rb, Sr, Ta, Th, U, V, W, Y, Zn, Zr
were also analyzed along with the major elements. Table 1
gives the concentration of the major elements for all the
sediment samples and Table 2 gives the concentration of
the trace elements. The correlation coefficients between
each pair of elements were calculated in order to search for
the inter-elemental relationship. The results are further
compared with the data of Upper Continental Crust (UCC)
sediments for better understanding of the chemical maturity
of the sediments. Furthermore, an attempt was also made tostudy the enrichment and depletion of the elements along
with the depth. We also tried to establish the relationship
between the CIA values of the sediment samples with the
fluoride content in the groundwater at the respective depth
of the sediment sample.
Major Elements
Major element composition of the bulk sediments of
Marksnagar and Durgajkhera indicates that these sediments
mainly consist of three elements; Si, Al and Ca. Silica is the
dominant major component in the sediments of the two
sites as well as in the recent sediments of Ganga River. The
greater amount of Al2O
3was found at Marksnagar where it
was about 12% while CaO was only about 8%. But at
Durgajkhera the average percentage of CaO is marginally
higher than Al2O
3; here CaO is about 11.2% where as Al
2O
3
is just about 10%. The relatively high percentage of Ca in
these bulk sediments is due to the extensive calcrete
formation. The average concentration of Al2O
3and CaO in
the recent sediments was 11% and 1.5 % respectively. The
other dominant major elements are Fe2O
3, K
2O and Na
2O.
Not much variation was noted for the average concentration
of MgO in these villages and it ranges between 2.6% to 3%.Marginally higher concentration of K
2O was found for
Marksnagar compared to Durgajkhera, and this difference
in the concentration of K2O may be due to the difference in
the altered feldspar present in the sediments. The high
content of clay was found at Marksnagar which is indicated
by the relatively higher percentage of Al2O
3, Fe
2O
3and K
2O.
Relative Mobility of Elements with Respect to Al2O
3
Elemental Ratio for Major Elements
The chemical composition of the sediments is expected
Fig.3. Strata charts for the piezometers installed at the selected
sites of Nawabganj Block, Unnao District, U.P.
-
8/6/2019 Latest Publication May 2011
6/19
JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.77, MAY 2011
464 S. KUMAR AND A. SAXENA
to demonstrate well established concepts on the mobility of
various elements during the weathering (Berner and Berner,
1996). The elemental ratio refers to the relative enrichment
or depletion of the element with respect to the least mobile
element, Al. It is given by dividing the ratio of the elementX and Al
2O
3of the sediment sample with the ratio of the
same element content in the UCC. i.e.
Element Ratio (X) =[X/ Al
2O
3(sediment sample)]
[ X/ Al2O
3(UCC)]
X > 1 indicates enrichment
X < 1 indicates depletion
X = 1 indicate no change in relative abundance of the
element.
Figures 4a and b display the elemental ratios of the major
elements of the sediments of Marksnagar (where M1 to M15
are sampling codes number each representing a sample of 3
m depth; M1 ranges from 0-3 m while M15 increases to
depth range of 42-45 m) and Durgajkhera (D1 to D11 are
sampling codes number each representing a sample of 3 mdepth; D1 ranges from 0-3 m while D11 increases to depth
range of 33-36 m).
As demonstrated in Figs. 4a and b, the SiO2
content in
the sediments of all the sites is found to be enriched. TiO2
is
considered relatively immobile and thus remains enriched
in all the samples. Whereas Na2O, which is highly mobile
(Singh et al. 2004) shows a relative depletion. Though CaO
is also very mobile in nature but due to secondary formation
of calcrete a relative enrichment is seen for the calcium.
Potassium is considered to be less mobile than Na and thus
generally shows enrichment. Mg also shows a relative
Table 1. Chemical composition of the major elements
SiO2
TiO2
Al2O
3Fe
2O
3MnO MgO CaO Na
2O K
2O P
2O
5LOI SUM
% % % % % % % % % % % %
Marksnagar
M1 59.5 0.63 12.39 4.76 0.095 3.08 6.36 1.47 2.75 0.158 9.26 100.4
M2 54.6 0.63 12.57 5 0.079 3.99 7.36 1.35 3.12 0.162 10.66 99.6
M3 54 0.67 13.97 5.7 0.092 4 7.2 1.41 3.47 0.13 9.73 100.4
M4 57.3 0.71 13.62 5.56 0.084 3.1 6.08 1.32 3.14 0.133 8.69 99.7
M5 57.2 0.68 12.34 5.04 0.093 2.94 7.7 1.37 2.6 0.123 9.92 100.1
M6 51.8 0.62 11.36 4.59 0.093 2.81 11.99 1.22 2.44 0.114 12.97 100
M7 57.2 0.68 12.79 5.08 0.081 3.06 7.1 1.38 2.84 0.131 11.29 101.7
M8 52.8 0.62 12.49 4.82 0.081 4.64 8.26 1.38 3.06 0.129 11.49 99.7
M9 58.4 0.69 12.74 5.03 0.082 2.8 7 1.38 2.76 0.137 9.11 100.1
M10 67.4 0.56 9.84 3.05 0.056 2.28 6.01 1.73 2.08 0.152 6.67 99.9
M11 53.4 0.6 11.55 4.55 0.098 2.79 11.19 1.15 2.52 0.121 12.59 100.6
M12 63.3 0.53 10.48 3.39 0.074 2.64 7.09 1.58 2.41 0.137 8.19 99.8
M13 61.3 0.64 11.29 4.03 0.081 2.54 7.15 1.54 2.52 0.144 8.38 99.6
M14 58.4 0.64 11.61 4.37 0.093 2.58 8.48 1.47 2.66 0.143 9.5 99.9
M15 58.4 0.56 10.9 4.02 0.124 2.15 9.65 1.43 2.55 0.13 9.96 99.8
Durgajkhera
D1 35.9 0.33 6.52 2.61 0.139 2.6 26.57 0.8 1.6 0.075 23.45 100.6
D2 56.8 0.47 8.87 3.07 0.088 2.43 12.54 1.22 2.13 0.107 12.38 100.2
D3 74.9 0.38 9.16 2.5 0.049 1.59 3.59 1.63 2.22 0.103 3.94 100.1
D4 73.5 0.41 9.83 2.86 0.046 1.85 3.39 1.6 2.45 0.094 4.05 100.1
D5 59.3 0.52 10.52 4 0.097 2.81 8.54 1.27 2.54 0.1 10.15 99.8
D6 50.8 0.62 11.99 4.93 0.081 3.89 10.9 1.15 2.68 0.121 13.26 100.5
D7 49.8 0.55 11.06 4.55 0.137 3.65 12.44 1.18 2.54 0.116 13.87 99.9
D8 57.4 0.54 10.28 3.94 0.105 3.1 9.52 1.1 2.38 0.104 11.42 99.9
D9 53.7 0.56 10.52 4.07 0.094 2.77 12.08 1.08 2.3 0.11 13.12 100.4
D10 52.4 0.54 10.9 4.29 0.084 3.98 11.08 1.1 2.45 0.082 13.51 100.4
D 11 48.6 0.56 10.99 4.56 0.119 3.67 12.92 1 2.61 0.109 11.2 99.8
Recent sediments (of Ganga at Kanpur and Bithur)
Bit1 82.1 0.3 8.29 2.11 0.04 0.94 1.07 1.64 1.97 0.067 1.37 99.8
Bit2 73 0.59 11.14 3.94 0.06 1.94 1.68 1.41 2.5 0.108 3.92 100.3
Kan1 82.9 0.23 8.23 1.69 0.029 0.77 0.8 1.7 2.04 0.052 1.21 99.6
Kan2 62.7 0.74 15.11 5.95 0.097 2.83 1.91 1.11 3.3 0.13 5.57 99.5
Kan3 63.7 0.66 12.84 5.02 0.079 2.49 1.91 1.24 2.94 0.118 5.58 96.5
-
8/6/2019 Latest Publication May 2011
7/19
JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA
,VOL.77,MAY2011
Table 2. Concentration of trace elements (in ppm)
As Ba Bi Ce Co Cr Cu Ga Hf La Mo Nb Ni Pb Rb Sr Ta Th
Marksnagar
M1 8 501 0 93 17 80 16 17 4 36 1 11 34 29 135 321 3 16M2 11 499 2 69 18 73 18 18 4 40 0 10 37 28 161 394 3 10
M3 15 560 0 66 14 73 18 18 5 35 0 11 36 30 185 252 0 12
M4 11 530 0 99 17 86 21 19 5 40 2 11 40 28 168 182 3 16
M5 8 466 1 99 14 83 18 15 5 40 2 13 46 25 133 316 0 16
M6 4 421 1 83 17 69 10 15 4 24 2 9 33 26 127 297 0 15
M7 9 499 0 96 19 80 16 18 5 32 0 13 40 27 149 241 0 14
M8 4 516 0 85 17 74 7 17 5 372 2 11 21 24 163 396 0 14
M9 7 441 1 95 14 82 17 18 5 33 3 11 41 29 143 221 0 21
M10 4 377 3 107 8 56 12 12 3 27 2 12 21 22 102 162 1 22
M11 10 456 0 77 15 63 20 16 3 29 0 11 32 25 139 183 0 12
M12 2 469 2 95 8 55 2 14 4 23 2 11 11 24 124 191 1 17
M13 7 534 1 116 11 65 12 15 5 31 2 13 23 27 127 165 1 23
M14 8 564 1 107 17 67 12 16 5 36 1 13 29 31 141 163 0 25
M15 8 561 2 118 18 54 14 14 3 34 0 12 28 38 138 154 0 18
Durgajkhera
D1 0 312 2 54 16 23 7 11 0 13 0 8 7 29 93 139 0 11
D2 3 373 2 115 11 38 5 14 3 23 1 9 11 21 114 150 0 18
D3 0 359 4 72 5 34 5 11 3 18 2 9 13 26 110 113 0 18
D4 3 385 3 71 10 37 0 13 3 18 2 9 11 22 126 116 0 13
D5 6 482 2 72 13 55 9 15 3 30 2 11 25 33 132 228 2 12
D6 11 463 2 70 13 71 21 18 4 30 0 10 37 23 145 396 0 12
D7 9 576 2 107 21 58 14 16 2 29 0 10 30 34 142 435 1 15
D8 5 523 1 97 16 52 7 15 3 28 1 10 21 33 124 307 0 21
D9 5 458 0 100 14 56 10 15 3 28 2 9 23 31 123 279 0 17
D10 7 433 0 96 15 49 13 16 3 34 2 8 20 33 135 219 2 17
D11 6 495 0 93 16 61 10 16 3 29 1 7 28 33 139 282 0 14
Recent sediments (of Ganga at Kanpur and Bithur)
Bit1 1 311 5 63 6 25
-
8/6/2019 Latest Publication May 2011
8/19
JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.77, MAY 2011
466 S. KUMAR AND A. SAXENA
enrichment trend because of incipient weathering in the area.
Thus, both Mg and K are preferentially adsorbed and tightly
incorporated in clay minerals of the sediments (Singh et al.
2005). It can also be seen that there is a remarkable
enrichment of both Fe2O
3and MnO. This is probably due to
the formation of clay minerals. During the mineral
weathering in the area the SiO2, Na and K originate by
incongruent dissolution of feldspar while the magnesium,
iron and potassium may be released from the biotite and
ferromagnesium minerals. Calcium may be derived from
the dissolution of calcretes
Inter-Element Relationship Between Major Elements
The inter-element relationships were plotted on the
variation diagram considering Al2O
3(Singh et al. 2005) and
TiO2
(Sharma and Rajamani, 2000) as relatively stable
phases. Figure 5 shows the relationship of Al2O
3,Fe
2O
3and
K2O with TiO2 for the sediments of Marksnagar andDurgajkhera.
There is a very good positive correlation between Al2O
3,
Fe2O
3and K
2O with TiO
2with correlation coefficient of 0.9,
0.95 and 0.79 respectively at Durgajkhera whereas at
Marksnagar this correlation coefficient value for Al2O
3,
Fe2O
3and K
2O with TiO
2was 0.84, 0.85 and 0.6 respectively
(Table 3). The positive trend of Al2O
3,Fe
2O
3and K
2O
with
TiO2
indicates the enrichment of these elements as the
concentration of TiO2increases. This is due to the formation
of secondary clay minerals such as illite, which is the result
of the weathering of mica and feldspar (Wilson, 1987). Some
amount of iron may also have been released from heavy
minerals. A more positive correlation of these elements is
seen at Marksnagar as compared to Durgajkhera.
The interrelationship of TiO2
with Na2O, SiO
2and CaO
is given in Fig.6. A poor negative trend of Na2O and SiO
2
with TiO2
was found with average correlation coefficient of
about -0.40 and -0.23, at Marksnagar and Durgajkhera
respectively (Table 3). Both Na2O and SiO
2are mobile
elements and thus are lost due to their dissolution in the
water while TiO2being the least mobile element remains in
the sediments. This negative correlation is better seen for
Marksnagar indicating a comparatively higher rate of
weathering in the area. According to Middelberg et al. (1988)
both Na and Ca (in silicate form) decrease more rapidly
than K and thus are depleted more than K. The negative
trend of Na2O and CaO and positive trend of K2O with TiO2result from the greater alteration rate of plagioclase as
compared to that of K feldspar. However, CaO does not
show a good negative trend due to its secondary precipitation
in the form of calcrete in Durgajkhera thus it is not lost due
to dissolution in water while remains in the sediments as
calcrete. In general the relationship between TiO2
and CaO
gives a strong negative trend on weathering and could be
seen in Marksnagar.
Inter elemental relationship between Al2O
3with MgO,
Fe2O
3and K
2O is given in Fig.7. There exists a very strong
positive correlation between Al2
O3
with MgO, Fe2
O3
and
K2O which is 0.66, 0.97 and 0.91 respectively for the
sediments of Marksnagar and 0.62, 0.86 and 0.96
respectively for Durgajkhera. The positive correlation
between K2O with Al
2O
3is indicative of the feldspar and
mica weathering that may lead to the formation of illite,
which is the dominant clay mineral in these sediments and
controls the concentration of Al and K. The weathering/
alteration of biotite may be responsible for the presence of
MgO in the sediments.
As compared to Na2O and CaO, K
2O and MgO are less
mobile and remain in the sediments during the incipient
weathering and only become mobile in the solution duringthe latter stage of weathering. A positive correlation between
Al2O
3with Fe
2O
3indicates that their source of origin could
be the alteration of biotite into aluminosilicates and Fe (III)
oxides due to biotite weathering (Appelo and Postma, 1993)
as per the following equation:
2K[Mg2Fe][AlSi
3]O
10(OH)
2+10H+.5O
2+7H
2O
Al2Si
2O
5(OH)
4+2K++4Mg2++2Fe(OH)
3+4H
4SiO
4
Figure 8 shows a strong negative correlation of SiO2
with the major elements; MgO, Fe2O
3and Al
2O
3with
correlation coefficient of -0.6, -0.7 and -0.6 respectively
Fig.4. Relative abundance of the elements at (a) Marksnagar.
(b) Durgajkhera.
-
8/6/2019 Latest Publication May 2011
9/19
JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.77, MAY 2011
CHEMICAL WEATHERING OF THE INDO-GANGETIC ALLUVIUM, U.P. 467
for Marksnagar. This indicates the grain size control on the
geochemistry of the sediments; with higher grain size higher
is the silica content. This silica dilution effect lowers the
concentration of other major and trace element. At
Marksnagar the negative correlation between SiO2is better
seen with MgO, Fe2O
3and Al
2O
3.
Chemical Maturity of the Sediments
A-CN-K Diagram and Chemical Index of Alteration
To ascertain the chemical maturity of the sediments the
CIA value scheme has been selected.
Nasbitt and Young (1982) proposed the quantification
of chemical weathering intensity as the Chemical Index of
Alteration (CIA) where:CIA = [ Al
2O
3/ (Al
2O
3+ CaO+ Na
2O + K
2O)] X 100
CaO : CaO in silicate form only (Nesbit et al. 1997).
Here the molecular proportions of the above elements
are used for the calculation of CIA of the samples. In case
CaO in silicate form is not available then it is assumed to be
equivalent to Na2O because Ca is lost more rapidly than
Na during weathering and it will give lesser CIA values
than that of Na (Singh, 2004). Since the study area
dominantly contains calcrete in abundance therefore the
values of CaO is invariably greater than that of Na2O.
Because of this the values of CaO were assumed to be
equivalent to Na2
O. A CIA value of 100 indicates intense
chemical weathering where all the alkali and alkaline earth
elements are leached out of the system whereas CIA values
of 45 55 indicate virtually no weathering . The fresh
granodiorite composition is also considered to be very close
to UCC and gives the CIA value of 47~50. With the initiation
of weathering Ca and Na component of the sediments starts
leaching out first, as both of these are highly mobile in nature
and the trend of the weathering is seen parallel to A-CN line
of the A-CN-K diagram. During the intermediate phase of
weathering when the above trend reaches close to the
formation of illite, K which was stable in the incipient
phase of weathering also becomes mobile and the weatheringtrend starts moving towards the apex i.e., A corner of the
A-CN-K diagram.
The CIA values of the sediment samples of Marksnagar
and Durgajkhera are given in Table 4. In Marksnagar the
CIA value ranges from 54.4 to 63.2 while in Durgajkhera
this value ranges from 53.2 to 63.6. It is indicative of the
fact that at both the places the rate of weathering is almost
same. In addition to this the bank sediments of Ganga River
were also analysed and CIA values are calculated. The CIA
value for Ganga River sediments ranges between 50.9 to
63.6. Singh et al. (2005) have done the geochemical analysis
Table 3. Inter elemental relationship between the major elements
SiO2
TiO2
Al2O
3Fe
2O
3MnO MgO CaO Na
2O K
2O P
2O
5
Marksnagar
SiO2 1TiO
2-0.39 1
Al2O
3-0.59 0.843 1
Fe2O
3-0.72 0.851 0.971 1
MnO -0.47 0.02 0.143 0.2695 1
MgO -0.61 0.331 0.659 0.6103 -0.14 1
CaO -0.60 -0.26 -0.24 -0.043 0.556 -0.119 1
Na2O 0.89 -0.41 -0.49 -0.651 -0.50 -0.305 -0.648 1
K2O -0.59 0.611 0.916 0.8534 0.143 0.793 -0.236 -0.37 1
P2O
50.52 -0.13 -0.1 -0.234 -0.40 0.0295 -0.65 0.586 0.0224 1
(CI) -0.63 -0.24 0.037 0.1361 0.525 0.2687 0.7239 -0.49 0.166 -0.62
Durgajkhera
SiO2
1
TiO2 -0.20 1Al
2O
30.147 0.9 1
Fe2O
3-0.38 0.953 0.858 1
MnO -0.87 0.163 -0.14 0.3402 1
MgO -0.64 0.78 0.615 0.8985 0.524 1
CaO -0.92 -0.18 -0.52 -0.014 0.795 0.2959 1
Na2O 0.963 -0.25 0.135 -0.377 -0.84 -0.619 -0.878 1
K2O 0.296 0.789 0.961 0.7497 -0.23 0.4823 -0.636 0.294 1
P2O
50.156 0.662 0.663 0.5456 -0.04 0.2302 -0.379 0.186 0.6355 1
(CI) -0.93 -0.08 0.44 0.0785 0.812 0.3688 0.9704 -0.91 -0.56 -0.36
-
8/6/2019 Latest Publication May 2011
10/19
JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.77, MAY 2011
468 S. KUMAR AND A. SAXENA
Fig.6. Relationship of TiO2 with SiO2 , Na2O and CaO.
Fig.5. Relationship of Al2O
3,Fe
2O
3and K
2O with TiO
2
-
8/6/2019 Latest Publication May 2011
11/19
JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.77, MAY 2011
CHEMICAL WEATHERING OF THE INDO-GANGETIC ALLUVIUM, U.P. 469
Fig.7. Relationship between Al2O
3with MgO, Fe
2O
3and K
2O.
Fig.8. Relationship between SiO2 with MgO, Fe2O3 and Al2O3
-
8/6/2019 Latest Publication May 2011
12/19
JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.77, MAY 2011
470 S. KUMAR AND A. SAXENA
for the channel sediments, flood sediments and suspended
sediments of Gomati River which is about 80 km east of
Ganga River, where the CIA value ranges between 53 to 68
with an average value of 60. The comparison of CIA values
of the recent sediments of Ganga and Gomati Rivers (Table
5) suggests that the rate of weathering is more or less same
for the sediments of both the rivers. However, Gomati River
sediments show maximum value of CIA as 68 where as it is
only 63.6 for Ganga River. This difference is due to the fact
that the Gomati River is a ground water fed river and the
sediments it carries are second cycle sediments (Kumar and
Singh, 1978).
In Marksnagar the minimum value of CIA was found to
be 54.4 at the depth of around 30 m i.e., at this level there
was virtually no weathering while the sediment at 33 m depth
shows the maximum weathering with CIA value at 63.3
which is of incipient nature. The sediment samples of the
Durgajkhera show lower CIA values up to a depth of 15 m
with the minimum of 53.23 value at the depth of 9 m. After
15m the CIA values increase and reach maximum around
64 up to the depth of 33 m. To illustrate these results the
ternary variation A-CN-K diagram was plotted for both thevillages (see Figs. 10 and 11). This clearly indicates that the
rate of weathering is not the prime factor for the release of
fluoride in the groundwater rather it is the different minera-
logical composition which is playing a key role in the release
of fluoride. The detailed geochemical analysis of the sedi-ments also shows more presence of mica minerals (especially
biotite) at Marksnagar as compared to Durgajkhera.
There is a loss of the most mobile elements i.e., Na and
Ca in the sediments as compared to the UCC (Fig.11). The
weathering trend was found running parallel to A CN line.
As the chemical weathering progresses, the clay minerals
are produced due to dissociation of primary minerals into
secondary clay minerals. During the incipient weathering
Na and Ca are rapidly lost to the weathering solution and
thus are not retained by the clay minerals while K due to its
nature of being adsorbed by the clay minerals retained as
the weathering product. This is due to the specific size and
charge characteristic of K that leads it to retain in the layer
position of 2:1 type clay mineral i.e. illite thus making it
present in the sediments till the weathering of illite also
initiates. Thus, K is stable during the incipient and moderate
weathering and is mobile at higher degree of weathering.
The retention of K and loss of Na and Ca with the progress
Table 4. CIA values of Marksnagar (M1 to M15) and Durgajkhera (D1 to
D11)
Sl. No. CIA Sl. No. CIA Sl. No. CIA
M1 60.634 Ganga B1 50.86 D1 59.15
M2 60.9496 Ganga B2 56.03 D2 57.595M3 61.79 Ganga K1 51.93 D3 53.23
M4 63.08 Ganga K2 63.55 D4 54.54
M5 62.012 Ganga K3 59.12 D5 59.54246
M6 62.327 Mean 56.298 D6 63.52664
M7 61.955 D7 61.80034
M8 60.68 D8 61.68221
M9 62.124 D9 62.8052
M10 54.413 D10 62.78137
M11 63.29 D11 63.60445
M12 56.465 Mean 60.02342
M13 58.34
M14 59.292
M15 58.56
Mean 60.39411
Fig.9. Comparison between the CIA values of recent and ancient
sediments.
Table 5. Range of CIA values for sediments of Gomati River, Ganga
River, Marksnagar and Durgajkhera
Location sites CIA values
Min. Max. Avg.
Recent sediments (Gomati River, after 53.0 68.0 60.1
Singh et al. 2004)
Recent sediments (Ganga River) 50.9 63.6 56.3
Ancient sediments I (Marksnagar village) 54.4 63.2 60.4
Ancient sediments II (Durgajkher village) 53.2 63.6 60.0 Fig.10. A CN K diagram for Marksnagar.
-
8/6/2019 Latest Publication May 2011
13/19
JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.77, MAY 2011
CHEMICAL WEATHERING OF THE INDO-GANGETIC ALLUVIUM, U.P. 471
of chemical weathering leads to the general trend of A CN
parallel weathering for both the sites. A-CN-K diagram was
also plotted for the recent sediments collected from the bank
of Ganga River at Kanpur and Bithur. This ternary variation
diagram for the recent sediments is shown in Fig 12. There
is a similar trend of weathering parallel to A-CN line for the
recent sediments also.
It is inferred that the weathering pattern is same on the
surface sediments of Ganga River as well as for the ancient
sediments of Marksnagar and Durgajkhera. Since the
approximate age of the sediments as revealed by the carbon
dating should be around 45,000 years at the depth of 45 m,
it is suggested that there is no remarkable change in the
weathering pattern since last 40 - 50,000 years. Moreover
it is clear from the A-CN-K diagram for both ancient
sediments and recent sediments that the weathering trend
active in the area is A-CN parallel.
Trace Elements
Trace element behavior in the sediments is influenced
by weathering, diagenesis, sediment sorting and hydro-
geochemistry. Tables 2 give the concentration of the trace
elements. Zirconium is known to be least mobile and
insoluble thus it remains in sediments. The higher
concentration of Zr at Marksnagar is probably due to the
higher degree of chemical weathering. Since the sediments
of Marksnagar are mud dominated while that of Durgajkhera
contains higher amount of sand so a general trend of higher
concentration of trace elements is noted in Marksnagar in
comparison to Durgajkhera indicating a marginal higher
rate of weathering at Marksnagar. Fritz (1988) had stated
that biotite and perthetic microcline are the important phases
of fresh rocks which are enriched in Ba and Rb. He furtheradded that the alteration of biotite results in the loss of Ba
and enrichment of Rb. The average concentration of Ba in
Marksnagar and Durgajkhera is 482 ppm and 441 ppm
respectively while Rb is 135 ppm at Marksnagar and at
Durgajkhera it is 125 ppm. Thus, the comparatively higher
content of Ba and Rb at Marksnagar supports the higher
amount of biotite and high rate of weathering. The relative
higher average concentration of Cr and Ni suggests the
higher content of clay in Marksnagar samples thereby giving
a direct evidence of higher degree of weathering (Sharma
and Rajamani, 2001). Slightly higher concentration of Sr at
Durgajkhera confirms the formation of calcrete, which could
act as barrier for the release of fluoride in the groundwater
of Durgajkhera.
Chemical Mobility of Elements with respect to
Weathering
Weathering involves redistribution of the major and
trace elements present in the parent rock material. This
mobilization and redistribution is facilitated by the process
of dissolution of primary minerals, formation of secondary
minerals, transportation of materials and its co-precipitation.
According to Nesbitt (1979), titanium is relatively immobileduring weathering and thus could be used for the calcu-
lation of the chemical mobility of the major and trace
elements. The chemical mobility of an element is determined
by plotting the CIA values against the percentage change
of the element with respect to TiO2. The percentage change
is calculated in terms of percentage increase or decrease
of the element X (of samples) with respect to X in
UCC.
Percentage change =(X/ TiO
2)
sample x 100(X/ TiO
2)
UCC 1}
Fig.11. A CN K diagram for Durgajkhera.
Fig.12. A-CN-K diagram for the recent sediments.
-
8/6/2019 Latest Publication May 2011
14/19
JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.77, MAY 2011
472 S. KUMAR AND A. SAXENA
The increasing or decreasing trend of the variation
diagrams plotted for percentage change of element X against
its CIA value indicates the increase or decrease of chemical
mobility of that element. The chemical mobility of the major
elements of the sediments of the Marksnagar, and
Durgajkhera is given in Fig. 13 (a and b). From Fig.13a it is
clear that during the chemical weathering there is a definite
mobility in the major element concentrations. The significant
increasing trend of chemical mobility of Fe and Mg prove
the instability of the biotite and muscovite content of the
sediments as these two minerals are the most important host
for Fe and Mg present in these sediments. This dissociation
of biotite and muscovite is due to the weathering process
active in the area. The increasing trend of CaO depicts that
as the weathering progresses, the chemical mobility of Ca
increases. This may be due to aqueous dissociation and co-precipitation of the calcrete during weathering.
Al2O
3gives neither decreasing nor increasing trend,
rather it is parallel to CIA and indicates that it is
comparatively very stable during weathering (Fig.13b).
Silicon, sodium and potassium showed a decreasing trend
of chemical mobility. The mobility of SiO2is very important
for understanding the weathering process as it plays an
important role in soil formation. It can also be concluded
that sodium decreases more rapidly than potassium. This is
due to the greater alteration of plagioclase as compared to
K feldspar, which is also shown in the A-CN-K diagram.
Another reason for this could be that K is more preferentially
adsorbed in the clay minerals and could also be incorporated
with the silicate minerals.
Distribution of Major Elements with Depth
The variation in the concentration of major elements
with the depth was plotted on the logarithmic variation
diagrams. The value of the major elements is in percentage.
However, the average concentration of fluoride (in ppm)for two years at the respective depth was also depicted in
the graph to search for any correlation between the fluoride
in the groundwater and the concentration of major elements
in the sediments.
Fig.13a. Chemical mobility of the major elements during the weathering process.
-
8/6/2019 Latest Publication May 2011
15/19
JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.77, MAY 2011
CHEMICAL WEATHERING OF THE INDO-GANGETIC ALLUVIUM, U.P. 473
The scatter plot shows (Fig.14) that pair SiO2
and CaO
and TiO2
and Na2O
3are inversely proportional to each other.
In Marksnagar as the SiO2
decreases with the depth there is
an increase in CaO and simultaneously the fluoride content
in the water of that depth zone (M2, M6, M11 and M15 at 6
m, 18 m, 33 m and 4 5m bgl respectively) also increases.
While with the increase in SiO2
content there is a decrease
of CaO and the fluoride content in the water in those depth
zones also decreases (i.e. at M3 and M10, which are in the
depth zone of 6-9 m and 27-30 m respectively). A positive
correlation in the variation of the concentration of Al2O3,
Fe2O
3, MgO and K
2O along with the depth suggests that the
concentration of all these elements is controlled by the
variation in grain size characteristic of the sediments and
the change in the rate of weathering. Moreover, the increase
in the content of Fe and Mg in the sediments indicates the
higher content of biotite which is also probably releasing
the fluoride in the ground water due to its alteration. The
source of K and Al may be K feldspar or any other alumino-
silicate. The positive correlation of fluoride with the variation
of these elements confirms its release from the biotite, as
fluoride is present in the lattice of biotite and could be
Fig.13b. Chemical mobility of the major elements during the weathering process.
-
8/6/2019 Latest Publication May 2011
16/19
JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.77, MAY 2011
474 S. KUMAR AND A. SAXENA
released during the weathering of this mineral. There is a
general trend of decrease in the concentration of all the major
elements except for SiO2
and Na2O at the depth interval of
27-30 m (M10) suggesting a comparative dominance of
SiO2. This zone also coincides with the low value of fluoridein the water. However, at depth interval of 30-33 m (M11)
there is a remarkable decrease of SiO2
and increase of other
major elements. The CIA value of M10 is 54 while that of
M11 is 63 indicating the incipient weathering phenomenon
in the depth zone M11 while this phenomenon is inactive
in M10 resulting in much lower values of fluoride in the
water at 27-30 m (M10) of depth as compared to the water
at 30-33 m of depth. The TiO2
and Na2O gives a negative
correlation as TiO2
is most immobile in nature while Na is
very mobile, both of these elements vary with the depth as
is shown in Fig.12.
The above finding were also confirmed when the fluoride
concentration in the water was plotted against the trace
elements like Ba, Ga and Rb (see Fig.15). From the above
figure it can be seen that in Marksnagar as the concentration
of Ba, Rb and Ga varies with the depth there is a variationin the fluoride content in the water. There exists a positive
trend between the two. The variation in the concentration
of Ba and Rb coincides with the variation in the biotite
content of the sediments suggesting their source of origin to
be biotite. This finding further supports the fact that the
source of release of fluoride in the water is mainly due to
the alteration of biotite.
The variation in the concentration of major elements as
well as the trace elements, along with the depth was also
plotted for Durgajkhera and the similar trend was noted as
it was seen for Marksnagar (Fig.14).
Fig.14. Variation of major elements with depth.
-
8/6/2019 Latest Publication May 2011
17/19
JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.77, MAY 2011
CHEMICAL WEATHERING OF THE INDO-GANGETIC ALLUVIUM, U.P. 475
Weathering and Release of Fluoride in Groundwater
The concentration and mobility of both the major
elements and the trace elements are controlled by the
weathering processes. This is because these elements areeither the primary products or the secondary products of
the weathering. So, an attempt was made to correlate the
fluoride content in the ground water with the CIA value at
that depth for the samples of Marksnagar.
Shaji et al. (2007) suggests that high fluoride in
groundwater is mainly derived from the hornblende biotite
gneiss. The fluoride released into the groundwater could be
the weathering product of mica minerals, probably of
muscovite or biotite or both. It is also known that biotite is
an alumino-silicate mineral containing magnesium, iron and
potassium; thus the enrichment of these elements also
suggests the active weathering of biotite.
The chemical mobility and enrichment of Fe and Mg
and enrichment of Al in the sediments indicates that the
weathering of the mica minerals is still active. So, in order
to understand the mobility of fluoride in the ground water
with the changing trend of the chemical weathering intensity
i.e. the CIA values, a graph is plotted (Fig. 16) and the
correlation was established where the groundwater samples
were available at the respective sediment sample depth. As
the CIA value increases the fluoride content of the ground
water also increases indicating the positive correlation
between the two. The correlation coefficient between thefluoride content in the ground water and the CIA value at
that depth zone for Marksnagar was about 0.8. The maximum
fluoride was released at 30-33 m (M11) of depth and the
CIA value was also found maximum for this sample. The
minimum fluoride was released at the depth interval of 27-
30 m (M10) which also coincides with the minimum CIA
values. However, at the depth interval of 6-9 meters (M3)
the fluoride content decreases with some increase in CIA.
This might be due to difference in lithological character of
the sediments at that depth. The CIA value at this depth
interval also coincides with the sediment age of 20 to 30
thousand of years as revealed by the carbon dating. Moreover
this period also happened to be the last event of global
glaciations. So, the role of the last event of global glaciations
in the weathering and ultimately in the release of fluoride
could not be ruled out.
CONCLUSION
The geochemical data indicates the dominant presence
of quartz, feldspar and mica in the sediments of Marksnagar
and Durgajkhera. The high percentage of CaO suggests the
secondary formation of the calcium in the form of calcrete.The enrichment of Fe
2O
3and MgO in the sediments indicates
the presence of high content of biotite and the clay minerals
like vermiculite and smectite (Murphy, 1998). The presence
of Na in sediments is mainly due to the plagioclase (albite).
The depletion of Na2O with loss of SiO
2indicates the
preferential disappearance of plagioclase as weathering
proceeds (Weijden and Weijden, 1995). The depletion of
Na corresponds to the extensive weathering of plagioclase
(albite) in the area (White et al. 1998) while the some
depletion and some enrichment of K suggests that the active
weathering of K-feldspar (microcline) is not very
Fig.15. Variation of trace element distribution and the fluoride content with the depth.
Fig.16. Relationship between F and CIA with the variation in depth
at Marksnagar.
-
8/6/2019 Latest Publication May 2011
18/19
JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.77, MAY 2011
476 S. KUMAR AND A. SAXENA
progressive. The presence of TiO2
confirms the presence of
biotite as Murphy et al. (1998) suggest that Ti is the part of
biotite and the trace elements Ni & Cr confirm the presence
of vermiculite (Ramesam, 1979). Na, Ca and K are mainly
concentrated in feldspar and the significant decreasing trend
of Na and some depletion of K, therefore reflects the
alteration of feldspar (Middelburg et al. 1988). Since Na
decreases more rapidly than K, greater alteration rate of
plagioclase than K-feldspar is suspected. Ca (in silicate form)
is also present in feldspar and normally gets depleted along
with Na. But in the present case due to its secondary pre-
cipitation as calcrete, enrichment of Ca is noted. The trace
element Rb is known to be more contained in K-feldspar
than biotite and is expected to be less depleted than K
(Middleburg et al. 1988). In, Marksnagar some depletion
of Rb was noted, confirming some alteration of K-feldspar.Since, according to Goldich cycle of weathering, K-feldspar
is more resistant of weathering than biotite, so its alteration
confirms the weathering of biotite. The CIA value also
suggests the incipient weathering of the sediments in the
area and support the weathering of biotite [K (Mg,
Fe)3(AlSi
3) O
10(OH, F)
2] to be more progressive than
muscovite [KAl2(AlSi
3)O
10(OH, F)
2].
A positive correlation between the CIA value and the
fluoride content in the ground water was also noted. Thus,
the rate of weathering active in the area is incipient in
nature, suggesting more prominent weathering of Na
feldspar and biotite. Probable reason for the high content
of fluoride in the groundwater of the study area is mainly
due to the dissociation/alteration of mica minerals, mainly
biotite.
Acknowledgement: We are thankful to the UP Council
of Agricultural Research for the financial support in the form
a research project, to Dr. Anupam Sharma for his help during
the course of investigation and to Dr. A.K. Jauhri for
extending working facilities in the Geology Dept., University
of Lucknow, India. S. Kumar is indebted to the Alexandervon Humboldt Foundation, Germany for the grant of a
fellowship to work in the University of Erlangen, Germany.
Authors are indebted to Prof. H.J. Tobschall for extending
working facility to S. Kumar at the Institute of Geology and
Mineralogy, University of Erlangen-Nurenberg and to Ms.
M. Drr for the analytical assistance in XRF analysis.
References
AHMAD, A. (1999) India A General Geography, NCERT, 162p.
APPELE, C.A.I. and POSTMA, D. (1993) Geochemistry Groundwaterand Pollution. A.A. Balkema, Chapter VI, pp.202-238.
BERNER, E.K. and BERNER, R.A. (1996) Global Environment: Water,
Air and Geochemical Cycles. Prentice Hall, Inc., Upper Saddle
River, NJ, 376p.
CGWB (1999) High fluoride groundwater in India occurrences,
genesis and remedies. Ministry of Water Resources,
Government of India, 29p.
FRITZ, S.J. (1988) A comparative study of a gabbro and granite
wethering. Chem. Geol.,v.6, pp. 275-290.
Khanna, S.P. (1992) Hydrogeology of Central Ganga Plain, U. P.
Gangetic Plain. Tera Incognita, pp.23-27.
KUMAR, S. and SINGH, I.B. (1978) Sedimentological study of
Gomati River sediments, Uttar Pradesh, India. Example of a
river in alluvial plain. Senkenbergiana marit., v.10, No.4/6,
pp.145-211.
MIDDELBURG, J.J., CORHELIS, H. VANDER, W. and JOOST, R.W.W.
(1988) Chemical process affecting the mobility of major, minor
and trace elements during weathering of granitic rocks. Chem.
Geol., v.68, pp.253-273.
MUKHERJEE, S., PAL, O.P. and PANDEY, A.K. (1995) Case studies
on sporadic fluoride contamination in groundwater, District
Unnao, U.P. Bhu Jal News, v.10, pp.1-6.
MURPHY, S.F., BRANTLEY, S.L., BLUM, A.E., WHITE, A.F. and DONG,
H. (1998) Chemical weathering in a tropical watershed,
Luguillo mountains, Puerto Rica: II. Rate and mechasism of
biotite weathering. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, v.62(2),
pp.227-243.NESBITT, H.W. (1979) Mobility and fraction of rare earth elements
during weathering of a granodiorite. Science, v.279, pp.206-
210
NESBITT, H.W. and YOUNG, G.M. (1982) Early proterozoic climates
and plate motions inferred from major element chemistry of
lutites. Nature, v.299, pp.715-717.
NESBITT, H.W., FEDO, C.M. and YOUNG, G.M. (1997) Quartz and
feldspar stability, steady and non-steady state weathering and
petrogenesis of siliciclastic sands and muds. Jour. Geol., v.105,
pp.173-191.
PANDEY, A.K. (2001) A report on study of fluoride contamination
in ground water in parts of Unnao district, U. P. (Annual Action
Plan: 1996-97). Central Ground Water Board, Ministry of
Water Resources, Govt. of India, 45p.
RAI , D. (1997) Geochemistry of fluoride enrichment in
groundwater Unnao district, Uttar Pradesh. Geol. Surv. India,
Spec. Publ., v.48(2), pp.169-172.
RAMESAM, V. (1979) Chemistry and mineralogy of
-
8/6/2019 Latest Publication May 2011
19/19
JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.77, MAY 2011
CHEMICAL WEATHERING OF THE INDO-GANGETIC ALLUVIUM, U.P. 477
SHAJI, E., BINDU, VIJU, J. and THAMBI, D.S. (2007) High fluoride
in groundwater of Palghat District, Kerala. Curr. Sci., v.92(2),
pp.240-245.
SHARMA, A. and RAJAMANI, V. (2000) Weathering of gneissic rocks
in the upper reaches of the Cauvery river, Southern India:implications to neotectonics of the region. Chem. Geol., v.
166, pp. 203-223.
SHARMA, A. and RAJAMANI, V. (2001) Weathering of charnokites
and sediment production in the catchment area of the
Cauvery river, Southern India. Sedi. Geol., v.143, pp.169-
184.
SINGH, I.B. (1992) Geological evolution of Gangetic Plain: Present
Status. Gangetic Plain. Tera Incognita, pp.1-14.
SINGH, I.B. (1996) Geological Evolution of Ganga Plain- An
Overview. Jour. Palaeont. Soc. India,v.41, pp.99-137.
SINGH, I.B. (2004) Late quaternary history of the ganga plain. Jour.
Geol. Soc. India, v. 64, pp. 431-454.
SINGH, M., SHARMA, M. and TOBSCHALL, H. J. (2005) Weathering
of the Ganga alluvial plain, Northern India: Implication from
fluvial geochemistry of the Gomati river. Appl. Geochem., v.20,
pp.1-21.
WEIJDEN, C.H.V. and WEIJDEN, R.D.V. (1995) Mobility of major,minor and some redox-sensitive trace elements and rare-earth
elements during weathering of four granitoids in central
Portugal. Chem. Geol., v.125, pp.149-167.
WHITE, A.F., BLUM, A.E., SCHULZ, M.S., VIVIT, D.V., STONESTROM,
D.A., LARSEN, M., MURPHY, S.F. and EBERL, D. (1998)
Chemical weathering in a tropical watershed, Luguillo
mountains, Puerto Rica: Long term versus short term
weathering fluxes. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, v.62(2),
pp.209-226.
WILSON, H.J. (1987) A handbook of determinative methods in clay
mineralogy. X-Ray powder diffraction methods. Pub. Chapman
and Hall, New York, Chapter II, pp.26-98.
(Received:23 March 210; Revised form accepted: 21 September 2010)