May-2014159,900

May-2013141,250

%13

Change18,650

May-2013 vs May-2014: The median sold price is up 13%Median Sold Price by Month

Accurate Valuations Group

May-2013 vs. May-2014

William Cobb

Clarus MarketMetrics® 06/10/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

1/2

MLS: GBRAR Bedrooms:AllAll

Construction Type:All1 Year Monthly SqFt:

Bathrooms: Lot Size:All All Square FootagePeriod:All

County:Property Types: : Residential

LivingstonPrice:

Median Sold Price by MonthMay-2013 vs May-2014: The median sold price is up 13%

Accurate Valuations GroupWilliam Cobb

Sold Median Price Units Avg DOMTime Period

May-14 159,900 157 102

Apr-14 150,555 150 104

Mar-14 155,000 124 122

Feb-14 153,250 102 102

Jan-14 142,700 85 89

Dec-13 158,500 108 80

Nov-13 150,524 124 91

Oct-13 145,000 109 101

Sep-13 153,464 140 84

Aug-13 149,450 160 94

Jul-13 156,000 137 77

Jun-13 156,000 125 90

May-13 141,250 132 93

Clarus MarketMetrics® 06/10/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

22/

May-2013 vs May-2014: The median price of for sale properties is up 2% and the median price of sold properties is up 13%

Accurate Valuations Group

May-2013 vs. May-2014

157,900 2

William Cobb

161,750May-2014

Median For Sale vs Median Sold

ChangeMay-2013 %3,850

May-2013 May-2014 %141,250 13

May-2013 vs. May-2014

159,900Change18,650

Clarus MarketMetrics® 06/10/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

1/2

MLS: GBRAR Bedrooms:AllAll

Construction Type:All1 Year Monthly SqFt:

Bathrooms: Lot Size:All All Square FootagePeriod:All

County:Property Types: : Residential

LivingstonPrice:

Median For Sale vs Median SoldMay-2013 vs May-2014: The median price of for sale properties is up 2% and the median price of sold properties is up 13%

Accurate Valuations GroupWilliam Cobb

For SaleMedian SoldMedianFor Sale # Properties # PropertiesSold Price Difference

Time Period

May-14 938 157161,750 159,900 -1,850Apr-14 952 150162,000 150,555 -11,445Mar-14 948 124160,000 155,000 -5,000Feb-14 905 102159,900 153,250 -6,650Jan-14 890 85155,000 142,700 -12,300Dec-13 910 108155,132 158,500 3,368Nov-13 985 124156,500 150,524 -5,976Oct-13 1,045 109159,000 145,000 -14,000Sep-13 1,014 140159,000 153,464 -5,536Aug-13 1,012 160155,950 149,450 -6,500Jul-13 987 137156,500 156,000 -500Jun-13 964 125156,450 156,000 -450May-13 925 132157,900 141,250 -16,650

Clarus MarketMetrics®Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

06/10/201422/

May-2014157

May-2013132

%19

Change25

May-2013 vs May-2014: The number of Sold properties is up 19%Sold Properties by Month

Accurate Valuations Group

May-2013 vs. May-2014

William Cobb

Clarus MarketMetrics® 06/10/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

1/2

MLS: GBRAR Bedrooms:AllAll

Construction Type:All1 Year Monthly SqFt:

Bathrooms: Lot Size:All All Square FootagePeriod:All

County:Property Types: : Residential

LivingstonPrice:

Sold Properties by MonthMay-2013 vs May-2014: The number of Sold properties is up 19%

Accurate Valuations GroupWilliam Cobb

Time Period Units Median Price Avg DOM

May-14 159,900157 102Apr-14 150,555150 104Mar-14 155,000124 122Feb-14 153,250102 102Jan-14 142,70085 89Dec-13 158,500108 80Nov-13 150,524124 91Oct-13 145,000109 101Sep-13 153,464140 84Aug-13 149,450160 94Jul-13 156,000137 77Jun-13 156,000125 90May-13 141,250132 93

Clarus MarketMetrics® 06/10/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

22/

May-2014219

May-2013121

%81

Change98

May-2013 vs May-2014: The number of Under Contract properties is up 81%Under Contract Properties by Month

Accurate Valuations Group

May-2013 vs. May-2014

William Cobb

Clarus MarketMetrics® 06/10/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

1/2

AllBathrooms: SqFt:All

: Residential

All Square FootageConstruction Type: Lot Size:GBRAR

Livingston

Period: 1 Year MonthlyPrice:MLS:

All AllAll

Property Types:

Bedrooms:

County:

Under Contract Properties by MonthMay-2013 vs May-2014: The number of Under Contract properties is up 81%

Accurate Valuations GroupWilliam Cobb

Units Avg DOMMedian PriceTime PeriodMay-14 159,900219 80Apr-14 163,800185 99Mar-14 159,450164 91Feb-14 149,100113 121Jan-14 155,265113 118Dec-13 155,40086 99Nov-13 161,225112 77Oct-13 158,500124 94Sep-13 150,950108 102Aug-13 154,900145 75Jul-13 149,150126 80Jun-13 164,950126 93May-13 157,000121 89

Clarus MarketMetrics® 06/10/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

22/

May-2014233

May-2013202

%15

Change31

May-2013 vs May-2014: The number of New properties is up 15%New Properties by Month

Accurate Valuations Group

May-2013 vs. May-2014

William Cobb

Clarus MarketMetrics® 06/10/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

1/2

MLS: GBRAR Bedrooms:AllAll

Construction Type:All1 Year Monthly SqFt:

Bathrooms: Lot Size:All All Square FootagePeriod:All

County:Property Types: : Residential

LivingstonPrice:

New Properties by MonthMay-2013 vs May-2014: The number of New properties is up 15%

Accurate Valuations GroupWilliam Cobb

Units Median PriceTime PeriodMay-14 159,900233Apr-14 159,925226Mar-14 166,900215Feb-14 169,900188Jan-14 153,000145Dec-13 149,900113Nov-13 152,700140Oct-13 150,720203Sep-13 159,900212Aug-13 154,900215Jul-13 159,000207Jun-13 154,900219May-13 154,950202

Clarus MarketMetrics® 06/10/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

22/

May-2014938

May-2013925

%1

Change13

May-2013 vs May-2014: The number of For Sale properties is up 1%For Sale Properties by Month

Accurate Valuations Group

May-2013 vs. May-2014

William Cobb

Clarus MarketMetrics® 06/10/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

1/2

MLS: GBRAR Bedrooms:AllAll

Construction Type:All1 Year Monthly SqFt:

Bathrooms: Lot Size:All All Square FootagePeriod:All

County:Property Types: : Residential

LivingstonPrice:

For Sale Properties by MonthMay-2013 vs May-2014: The number of For Sale properties is up 1%

Accurate Valuations GroupWilliam Cobb

Units Avg DOMMedian PriceTime Period

May-14 161,750938 120Apr-14 162,000952 132Mar-14 160,000948 137Feb-14 159,900905 146Jan-14 155,000890 154Dec-13 155,132910 150Nov-13 156,500985 136Oct-13 159,0001,045 127Sep-13 159,0001,014 127Aug-13 155,9501,012 124Jul-13 156,500987 125Jun-13 156,450964 125May-13 157,900925 127

Clarus MarketMetrics® 06/10/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

22/

May-201449

May-201359

%-17

Change-10

May-2013 vs May-2014: The number of Expired properties is down -17%Expired Properties by Month

Accurate Valuations Group

May-2013 vs. May-2014

William Cobb

06/10/2014Clarus MarketMetrics® 1/2

MLS: GBRAR Bedrooms:AllAll

Construction Type:All1 Year Monthly SqFt:

Bathrooms: Lot Size:All All Square FootagePeriod:All

County:Property Types: : Residential

LivingstonPrice:

Expired Properties by MonthMay-2013 vs May-2014: The number of Expired properties is down -17%

Accurate Valuations GroupWilliam Cobb

Avg DOMUnits Median PriceMay-14 150,00049 167Apr-14 159,95062 270Mar-14 158,40058 173Feb-14 164,90059 194Jan-14 167,95060 196Dec-13 150,00079 177Nov-13 153,25076 178Oct-13 174,94976 157Sep-13 154,45064 173Aug-13 144,90065 167Jul-13 166,40064 201Jun-13 164,00058 168May-13 157,90059 159

Clarus MarketMetrics® 06/10/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

22/

May-2013 vs May-2014: The number of for sale properties is up 1% and the number of sold properties is up 19%

Accurate Valuations Group

May-2013 vs. May-2014

925 1

William Cobb

938May-2014

Supply & Demand by Month

ChangeMay-2013 %13

May-2013 May-2014 %132 19

May-2013 vs. May-2014

157Change

25

Clarus MarketMetrics® 06/10/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

1/2

MLS: GBRAR Bedrooms:AllAll

Construction Type:All1 Year Monthly SqFt:

Bathrooms: Lot Size:All All Square FootagePeriod:All

County:Property Types: : Residential

LivingstonPrice:

Supply & Demand by MonthMay-2013 vs May-2014: The number of for sale properties is up 1% and the number of sold properties is up 19%

William Cobb Accurate Valuations Group

For Sale Sold# Properties

Avg DOM Avg DOM# Properties

Time Period

May-14 120 102938 157Apr-14 132 104952 150Mar-14 137 122948 124Feb-14 146 102905 102Jan-14 154 89890 85Dec-13 150 80910 108Nov-13 136 91985 124Oct-13 127 1011,045 109Sep-13 127 841,014 140Aug-13 124 941,012 160Jul-13 125 77987 137Jun-13 125 90964 125May-13 127 93925 132

Clarus MarketMetrics® 06/10/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

22/

May-201480

May-201389

%-9

Change-8

May-2013 vs May-2014: The average days on market is down -9%The Average Days on Market by Month

Accurate Valuations Group

May-2013 vs. May-2014

William Cobb

LivingstonAll 1 Year Monthly

County:Period:Price:

Property Types: : Residential

06/10/20141/2Clarus MarketMetrics®

All Square FootageBedrooms: All AllSqFt:

All Lot Size:Bathrooms:AllConstruction Type:MLS: GBRAR

The Average Days on Market by MonthMay-2013 vs May-2014: The average days on market is down -9%

Accurate Valuations GroupWilliam Cobb

# UC UnitsAvg DOMTime PeriodMay-14 21980Apr-14 18599Mar-14 16491Feb-14 113121Jan-14 113118Dec-13 8699Nov-13 11277Oct-13 12494Sep-13 108102Aug-13 14575Jul-13 12680Jun-13 12693May-13 12189

Clarus MarketMetrics® 2/2 06/10/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

May-2013 vs May-2014: The average months supply of inventory is down -50%

Accurate Valuations Group

May-2013 vs. May-2014

6.2 -50

William Cobb

3.01May-2014

Months Supply of Inventory

ChangeMay-2013 %-3.01

Clarus MarketMetrics® 06/10/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

1/2

MLS: GBRAR Bedrooms:AllAll

Construction Type:All1 Year Monthly SqFt:

Bathrooms: Lot Size:All All Square FootagePeriod:All

County:Property Types: : Residential

LivingstonPrice:

Months Supply of InventoryMay-2013 vs May-2014: The average months supply of inventory is down -50%

William Cobb Accurate Valuations Group

During MonthLast Day of Month MSI# Units For Sale # UC Units

UC Avg DOMTime Period

May-14 219 80670 3.1Apr-14 185 99705 3.8Mar-14 164 91726 4.4Feb-14 113 121733 6.5Jan-14 113 118717 6.3Dec-13 86 99745 8.7Nov-13 112 77797 7.1Oct-13 124 94845 6.8Sep-13 108 102842 7.8Aug-13 145 75802 5.5Jul-13 126 80797 6.3Jun-13 126 93780 6.2May-13 121 89745 6.2

Clarus MarketMetrics® 06/10/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

22/