modeling work group staff report mwg meeting august 1, 2011 web meeting
TRANSCRIPT
Modeling Work GroupStaff Report
MWG MeetingAugust 1, 2011Web Meeting
2
• MWG analysis of high COI flows is ongoing• Past emphasis was on comparisons between
PROMOD and Gridview, which evolved into attempts to standardize the input and run assumptions.
• Currently, focus is on the differences in the generation commitment and dispatch.
COI Flow Analysis and Gridview Comparison
Result Comparison
Category2020 TEPPC PC0 -
COI984ipp 2020 Gridview PC0 Difference Diff %Conventional Hydro 246,723,896 246,809,200 85,304 0.035%Pumped Storage 2,942,544 2,962,073 19,529 0.664%Steam - Coal 296,325,674 278,831,582 (17,494,093) -5.904%Steam - Other 3,840,647 4,443,199 602,552 15.689%Nuclear 76,693,816 75,833,437 (860,379) -1.122%Combined Cycle 181,798,506 189,345,726 7,547,221 4.151%Combustion Turbine 13,068,291 17,535,122 4,466,830 34.181%Cogeneration 26,852,572 27,734,695 882,123 3.285%IC 338,701 364,828 26,127 7.714%Negative Bus Load 4,640,148 4,640,148 0 0.000%Biomass RPS 16,907,454 16,585,990 (321,463) -1.901%Geothermal 35,733,317 35,427,858 (305,459) -0.855%Small Hydro RPS 7,755,783 7,754,337 (1,446) -0.019%Solar 31,580,224 30,368,296 (1,211,928) -3.838%Wind 81,503,286 81,727,334 224,048 0.275%
Total 1,026,704,860 1,020,363,825 (6,341,035) -0.618%
Generation Results (MWh)
Comparison to new GV run by Sherman with loads reduced by 3.4% to back out transmission losses. Note large difference in coal generation.
Most Significant Gen Differences
(1,500)
(1,000)
(500)
-
500
1,000
1,500
GW
h
Difference (> 500 GWh) - Annual Generation GV-PM
Gridview Higher Than Promod
Gridview Lower Than Promod
Annual Energy Difference by Area
-4,000
-2,000
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000
16,000
GWh
Annual Energy Difference: 2020 TEPPC PC0 - COI984ipp vs. 2020 Gridview PC0
Hydro+PS Steam - Boiler Combined Cycle Combustion Turbine Cogeneration Renewable Other
In general, the trade-off is between coal and combined cycle generation, and appears to be caused by differences in the commitment and dispatch logic. Since the hurdle rates and tie limits effectively separate Alberta from other areas, initial analysis can focus there.
Difference in Alberta (MWh)
Category AlbertaConventional Hydro 63,420Pumped Storage 0Steam - Coal -3,227,128Steam - Other -2,794Nuclear 0Combined Cycle 1,237,317Combustion Turbine 1,916,084Cogeneration 157,767IC 389Biomass RPS -50,735Geothermal 0Small Hydro RPS 12Solar 0Wind 2,834
Total 97,168
Sample AESO Load/Gen (1)
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000
16,000
2/7/2020 2/8/2020 2/9/2020 2/10/2020 2/11/2020 2/12/2020 2/13/2020 2/14/2020 2/15/2020 2/16/2020
AESO Load/Gen Balance Snapshot - PC0-84COI+IPPnom
Combustion Turbine
Steam - Other
Combined Cycle
Other
Steam - Coal
Nuclear
Biomass RPS
Geothermal
Small Hydro RPS
Hydro+PS
Solar
Wind
Demand
Dump
Sample AESO Load/Gen (2)
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000
4/12/2020 4/13/2020 4/14/2020 4/15/2020 4/16/2020 4/17/2020 4/18/2020 4/19/2020 4/20/2020 4/21/2020
AESO Load/Gen Balance Snapshot - PC0-84COI+IPPnom
Combustion Turbine
Steam - Other
Combined Cycle
Other
Steam - Coal
Nuclear
Biomass RPS
Geothermal
Small Hydro RPS
Hydro+PS
Solar
Wind
Demand
Dump
Sample AESO Load/Gen (3)
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000
5/10/2020 5/11/2020 5/12/2020 5/13/2020 5/14/2020 5/15/2020 5/16/2020 5/17/2020 5/18/2020 5/19/2020
AESO Load/Gen Balance Snapshot - PC0-84COI+IPPnom
Combustion Turbine
Steam - Other
Combined Cycle
Other
Steam - Coal
Nuclear
Biomass RPS
Geothermal
Small Hydro RPS
Hydro+PS
Solar
Wind
Demand
Dump
Sample AESO Load/Gen (4)
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000
6/12/2020 6/13/2020 6/14/2020 6/15/2020 6/16/2020 6/17/2020 6/18/2020 6/19/2020 6/20/2020 6/21/2020
AESO Load/Gen Balance Snapshot - PC0-84COI+IPPnom
Combustion Turbine
Steam - Other
Combined Cycle
Other
Steam - Coal
Nuclear
Biomass RPS
Geothermal
Small Hydro RPS
Hydro+PS
Solar
Wind
Demand
Dump
Sample AESO Load/Gen (5)
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000
16,000
9/1/2020 9/2/2020 9/3/2020 9/4/2020 9/5/2020 9/6/2020 9/7/2020 9/8/2020 9/9/2020 9/10/2020
AESO Load/Gen Balance Snapshot - PC0-84COI+IPPnom
Combustion Turbine
Steam - Other
Combined Cycle
Other
Steam - Coal
Nuclear
Biomass RPS
Geothermal
Small Hydro RPS
Hydro+PS
Solar
Wind
Demand
Dump
Sample AESO Load/Gen (6)
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000
16,000
10/9/2020 10/10/2020 10/11/2020 10/12/2020 10/13/2020 10/14/2020 10/15/2020 10/16/2020 10/17/2020 10/18/2020
AESO Load/Gen Balance Snapshot - PC0-84COI+IPPnom
Combustion Turbine
Steam - Other
Combined Cycle
Other
Steam - Coal
Nuclear
Biomass RPS
Geothermal
Small Hydro RPS
Hydro+PS
Solar
Wind
Demand
Dump
Alberta Coal Dispatch - PromodAESO Coal Generation Results
Name
Num Starts
Num HoursOn
Num HoursOff
Percent TimeOn Max
Annual Energy (MWh)
BAT #5_5 14 7,897 887 89.9% 368 2,903,486 Genesee1 20 7,897 887 89.9% 384 3,029,377 Genesee2 21 7,897 887 89.9% 384 3,029,223 Genesee3 20 7,874 910 89.6% 450 3,539,940 HR_Milner_1 12 8,044 740 91.6% 143 1,150,234 Kephlls1 16 7,897 887 89.9% 411 3,243,037 Kephlls2 20 7,874 910 89.6% 411 3,232,925 Kephlls3 19 7,874 910 89.6% 450 3,509,615 Shernss1 17 7,897 887 89.9% 378 2,982,216 Shernss2 12 7,897 887 89.9% 378 2,983,043 Sundanc1 13 8,044 740 91.6% 280 2,250,763 Sundanc2 12 7,975 809 90.8% 280 2,231,555 Sundanc3 14 7,897 887 89.9% 353 2,786,084 Sundanc4 18 7,897 887 89.9% 406 3,203,226 Sundanc5 16 7,897 887 89.9% 406 3,202,976 Sundanc6 11 7,897 887 89.9% 399 3,149,194
14
• In PROMOD the hurdle rates represent a financial obstacle that must be overcome to allow economic interchange to occur.
• If the marginal price in SR A is $30 and the marginal price in SR B is $25 and the hurdle rate from B to A is $7, there would be no interchange.
Hurdle Rates
15
TEPPC Hurdle Rates for 2020
Forward Reverse$/MWh $/MWh
Alberta British Columbia $0.00 $48.00Alberta NWPP $0.00 $48.00AZNMNV RMPP $5.40 $2.60BASIN AZNMNV $5.40 $2.70BASIN CALIF_NORTH $5.40 $3.00BASIN CALIF_SOUTH $2.30 $2.30BASIN NWPP $5.40 $2.70BASIN RMPP $5.40 $2.70British Columbia NWPP $4.70 $2.80CALIF_NORTH CALIF_SOUTH $0.00 $0.00CALIF_NORTH NWPP $5.90 $6.10CALIF_SOUTH AZNMNV $2.60 $2.60NWPP CALIF_SOUTH $5.90 $7.70NWPP RMPP $7.30 $2.80
Region Connections
Study Year 2020
16
• Wrap-up• Next meeting
oNeed to set date (1st Monday is holiday)
• Note TAS meeting is August 8-9
Wrap-up and Next meeting
Questions?