modul selektif 567
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
1/53
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
2/53
Maret 2011Interkoneksi
Semester Genap 2010-20112
Unbundling refers to the provision of components on a stand-alonebasis. Therefore, interconnecting carriers can obtain access to single
unbundled component without an obligation to buy other components
as part of an interconnection package
is the mandatory offering by network operators of specific
elements of their network to other operators, on terms approved by aregulator or sanctioned by a court
Unbundling of network elements allows competing operators to enter the
market and roll out services with considerably less sunk investment in some or
all components of a competing network. For example:
A new entrant might initially install switches in central business districts only, and
lease those components of the incumbent carriers network needed to directly servecustomers in other areas, or
An entrant might lease just those network elements needed to offer competing
retail services (such as DSL services). In this way the entrant can offer competing
services to customers without duplicating all components of the incumbent carriers
infrastructure, and without simply reselling the incumbents service offering
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
3/53
Some inputs are available only from certain network operators, and cannot
easily be duplicated. Unless those inputs are available at appropriate prices,
competition in downstream telecommunications markets would be difficult or
impossible
The emergence of competition from alternative technologiessuch as
wireless, cable telephony, and VoIPis eroding this rationale for mandatoryunbundling
Unbundling can be an enormous task for regulators. The administrative costs
of defining, and setting prices for, a range of network elements can be high. In
addition, unbundling can impose high compliance costs on incumbent carriers.
Regulators should carefully consider the merits of unbundling on a case-by-
case basis, with a thorough assessment of the likely costs and benefits
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
3
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
4/53
Some Possible Unbundled NetworkComponent and Service
Network access line (local loop and related functions)
Local switching function
Tandem switching functions
Inter-exchange transmission
Access to STP (Signaling Transfer Point )
Access to call-related databases
Central office codes
Subscriber listing
Operators Services
Directory assistance functions Operating Support Systems
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
4
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
5/53
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
5
1. Full Unbundling-Local Loop
2. Full Unbundling-Two Local Loop
3. Shared Use of Copper Local Using Splitter
4. Provision of High Speed Bit Stream Access
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
6/53
Types of Local Loop Unbundling
1. Full Unbundling-Local Loop
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
6
MDFIncumbentLocal Switch
PSTN
To NewEntrantsSwitch
PSTN
Link re-routed from incumbentsswitch to new entrants
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
7/53
2. Full Unbundling-Two Local Loop
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
7
MDF
Incumbent
Local SwitchPSTN
New
EntrantsDSL Access
MUX
NewEntrant
XDSLModem
PC or other
CustomerEquipment.
FirstLocal Loop
SecondLocal Loop
Types of Local Loop Unbundling
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
8/53
3. Shared Use of Copper Local Using Splitter
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
8
M
DF
Incumbent
Local Switch PSTN
DSLAccessMUX
NewEntrant
ADSLModem
PC or OtherCustomerEquipment.
Local Loop
Data
Tel
Splitter
Types of Local Loop Unbundling
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
9/53
4. Provision of High Speed Bit Stream Access
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
9
MDF
PSTN
DSL AccessMUX OperatedBy Incumbent
High SpeedBit stream
serviceprovided to
One Or moreNew Entrants
Local Loop Splitter
Customer ofIncumbent
DataService
Customer ofNew entrant
DataService
Local Loop
Types of Local Loop Unbundling
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
10/53
The magnitude of these costs and benefits will vary depending on:
The form of unbundling, and
Whether regulated prices for unbundled network elements reflect economic costs
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
10
Benefits Costs Increases, and brings forward, entry by
reducing entry costs
Increases competition in the provision
of services supported by the existing
network
Can bring forward the introduction of
new services that rely on the
incumbents network technology (such
as DSL services) and competition in
those services
Potentially high administrative and
compliance costs (costs increase with the
extent of unbundling)
May reduce incentives for incumbents to
invest in new infrastructure. Enables
incumbents to obtain legislative andregulatory relief, by making investment in next
generation networks contingent on such relief
May reduce incentives for entrants to invest in
new infrastructure. Entrants may focus on
reselling the incumbents services, instead of
designing innovative new service offerings
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
11/53
INTERNET INTERCONNECTION
I
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
11
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
12/53
The Internet is a world-wide collection of interconnected networks. It is
capable of switching, routing, and transmitting digital packets of information
corresponding to a variety of voice, data, text, audio, and video services.
The Internet allows any computer (or other device) with an Internet connection
to communicate with any other device that is connected to the Internet
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
12
Internet
Network Surfer Digital Subscriber Link, Cable Modem, orWireless Network
ISP
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
13/53
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
13
Internet Exchange Point (IXP): Point that interconnect ISP with each
other and with Internet Backbone Provider and some times call asNetwork Access Points (NAPs)
IXPs provide Switching and Routers that permit interconnection of variousinternet networks
Due to the rapid development of internet provider, IXPs provide also :Collocation services, providing services as well as equipment for internet
routing, transmission, web hosting and other service. Each ISP pays for its own cost of transmission, routing, and other
equipment, or shares the cost on a negotiates basis
Larger ISP orInternet Backbone
Provider
IXP
ISPISP
ISP
ISP
ISP
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
14/53
Internet Service Providers (ISPs) use different
models for interconnection pricing, depending on
the specific characteristics of the ISPs concerned.
Broadly, ISPs can either: Enter into arrangements, or
Enter into a arrangement
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
14
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
15/53
Peering, also known as Sender Keep All or Bill and Keep, is a zerocompensation arrangement by which two ISPs agree to exchange
traffic at no charge.
This kind of arrangement makes sense where the two ISPs have
roughly the same characteristics and traffic volumes, such that net
financial burden from traffic flows between them is likely to be small
The process by which an ISP qualifies for peering remains private. ISPs
negotiate terms and conditions privately. They only rarely publicly
disclose the criteria they use to qualify for peering.
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
15
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
16/53
Transit is an arrangement in which larger ISPs sell access to their networks,
their customers, and other ISP networks with which they had negotiated accessagreements.
Under a transit arrangement, the sender pays the full cost of interconnection.
Transit charges are set by commercial negotiation, and are generally not
disclosed.
Internet transit access arrangements provide a much greater geographical
access than telecommunications transit arrangements. In telecommunications,
transit arrangements typically secure an indirect link to one carrier in one
location (primarily because a small carrier is unable to secure a direct link).
Internet transit arrangements typically provide access to a vast array of
networks, not limited to one country.
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
16
Large ISP IXP Small ISP
Charges
Pays
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
17/53
Internet interconnection charges are typically based on one or more of
the following variables:
Traffics flow or usage, based on the increasing capacity of internet routers
and other equipment to measure traffic
Imbalance of traffic flows between ISPs
Distance or geographical coverage
Number of point of interconnection; and
Other cost-based interconnection charges
The trend toward cost-based interconnection charges is consistent with
development in other telecommunication services
US is the leader of internet industry, so many ISPs in other countryhave paid US ISPs for transportation to and from the US to their home
country
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
17
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
18/53
Noting the rapid growth of internet and internet protocol-based
international services : It is recommended that administrationsinvolved in the provision of international internet connection negotiate
and agree bilateral commercial arrangements applying to direct
international internet connections where each administration will be
compensated for the cost that it incurs in carrying traffic that is
generated by the other administration. (Rec. D.iii adopted by ITU SG 3)
The recommendation has been opposed by the US and Canada. They
argue that the North American bias of Internet routing will decrease
over time, as competition and market development reduce costs andincrease Internet facilities in other regions.
Local Interconnection charges are also important to the viability (able
to exist) of ISPs, Local internet access providers will be principal
beneficiaries of the move to unbundling of local loop
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
18
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
19/53
Mobile Interconnection
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
20/53
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
20
In many countries, mobile interconnection is regulated and
priced differently, depending on the form of
interconnection.
There are three broad forms of mobile interconnection:
A mobile network terminates a
call from a fixed network. The call might originate from a local
fixed operator, a domestic long-distance operator, or an
international operator
A mobile operator interconnects
with a fixed network in order to complete calls for the mobile
operator's customers. Again, the fixed network might be owned by
a local fixed operator, a domestic long-distance operator, or an
international operator
A mobile operator interconnects
with another mobile operator
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
21/53
Mobile Termination Rates (MTR) are the fees charged
when you call a friend on a different mobile network, or
call their mobile from your landline. In doing so, the other
mobile network charges your operator a fee for carrying
the call.
There is no a unique treatment of mobile termination
charges among countries:
Some countries only regulate mobile termination charges for fixed-
to-mobile calls.
In other countries, mobile networks are required to apply a singleregulated termination charge regardless of where the call
originates.
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
21
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
22/53
Under Calling Party Pays (CPP) the calling party, or the calling party'snetwork, pays for the call. The recipient of the call pays nothing.
CPP is used in many countries to structure interconnection payments
for fixed-to-mobile calls. Under the "old" CPP model, the mobile
operator sets a fixed-to-mobile tariff. The fixed operator deducts
specified charges from this fee (such as an origination charge, andbilling and collection charges), and passes the balance of the call
revenue to the mobile operator.
In recent years, some regulators have decided to regulate fixed-to-
mobile tariffs, rather than leaving this to the mobile operator to
determine. This generally reflects concerns that fixed-to-mobile tariffsare too high. This concern has also led regulators to control mobile
termination charges
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
22
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
23/53
A minority of countries, predominately developed countries such as the United
States, use a system of receiving party pays or mobile party pays for
interconnection with mobile operators.
Under this system, the mobile user pays airtime on received calls as well as
calls that user has initiated. This reduces the problem of setting
interconnection charges to defining the costs of just the link between twonetworks, which generally is low and easily defined. Thus, countries using
receiving party pays have largely avoided the problem of high mobile
termination charges.
This is a definite advantage of the receiving party pays system. Since a
receiving party pays system requires the mobile user to pay directly for
network usage on the mobile network, its main disadvantage is that it makes
it difficult commercially to extend service to mobile users with very low income
levels, precisely where the calling party pays system has been most
successful.
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
23
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
24/53
Structure of a GSM Mobile System
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
24
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
25/53
Roaming is the term used to describe the situation when a subscriber of one
mobile operators service travels outside that service area and obtains
connectivity and service from another operator. Roaming can take place withina country or between countries, as long as it involves a customer of one
operator being connected to the mobile network of another operator.
Conceptually, roaming is similar to a call forwarding arrangement. Callers use
the customers usual mobile phone number. The home network hands the call
over to the host network, which passes the call to the customers mobile
phone
Roaming charges are generally much higher than termination charges within
the home area. Customers often pay a monthly fee to be able to roam plus
usage charges, the combination of which can be quite expensive
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
25
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
26/53
VoIP Interconnection
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
27/53
Internet telephony, or Voice over the Internet Protocol (VoIP), is a category of
services that enable users to make real time voice calls, transmitted over theInternet (rather than using traditional circuit switched telephone networks).
VoIP enables network operators, service providers, and consumers make
significant savings, by:
Reducing the underlying costs of a telephone call. VoIP uses network resources
much more efficiently than conventional telephone service, reducing the costs of
providing a call (albeit with the loss of some call quality and service features)
Creating opportunities for regulatory arbitrage that enable service providers and
consumers to reduce or avoid call charges and/or regulatory fees
Currently the volume of voice telephony traffic is small compared to
traditional, dial up, circuit-switched telephone services. However, the very real
potential exists for packet switched, Internet Protocol networking to become
the primary medium for most voice and data services. Should this occur,
information services (including VoIP) will become the primary end user service
provided by telecommunications networks
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
27
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
28/53
VoIP services differ depending on whether:
The service provides a competitive alternative to conventional
telephone services
A conventional telephone can transmit and receive calls
Subscribers need to acquire and install additional equipment on
their premises Traffic routes into or from the PSTN
Users pay for service
1. Internet telephony via computer;
2. Internet telephony that is partially accessible from and to the
PSTN; and
3. Internet telephony that is fully accessible from and to the PSTN.
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
28
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
29/53
Internet telephony via personal computer has several drawbacks:
Typically, calls do not access the PSTN (unless one of the computers accesses the
Internet via a modem and conventional dial-up telephone line)
Subscribers must log onto the service in order to make and receive calls
The service does not provide caller identification and location information needed in
emergencies The service does not offer the same sound quality and reliability as conventional
circuit switched telephony
For these reasons, most countries treat Internet telephony via computer as an
unregulated information service, largely free of traditional telephone carrier
responsibilities
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
29
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
30/53
This category of VoIP calls includes:
Long distance telephone calls originated by subscribers of incumbent carriers,
and by users of calling cards who call from payphones and mobile phones
Internal corporate VoIP traffic that originates and terminates over an
enterprise network. Some enterprise networks can route traffic into the PSTN
VoIP services that enable customers to make calls over the Internet
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
30
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
31/53
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
31
The Internet and conventional circuit switched telephone numbering systems
use different addressing systems. Thus VoIP services in this category mustprovide call processing software that can map Internet Protocol addresses to
call recipients with conventional telephone numbers.
The software routes the call as far as possible through Internet networks, to a
gateway or point of presence as close as possible to the intended call
recipient. At that point, the service converts the call to telephony traffic and
hands it off to a conventional telephone network.
To access this category of VoIP services, users need:
A subscription to a VoIP service
Broadband Internet access
A modem
An Analog Terminal Adapter, to configure VoIP onto the users DSL or cable modemlink
The ability of subscribers to access service from conventional telephones, or
alternatively to call conventional telephone numbers, makes this form of
Internet telephony more attractive to customers (and therefore more
commercially attractive) than Internet telephony via computer
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
32/53
Many telephone companies already use Internet carriage to handle longdistance calls. The customer making the call may not even be aware of this
Most current VoIP services do not use the PSTN for both call origination and
termination.
In the future, almost all VoIP services will require a broadband, digital Internet
access link. Telephone companies and cable television companies will replace copper
networks with optical fibre. This will enable voice services to ride over a
ubiquitous broadband digital network as a software application
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
32
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
33/53
Wireless networks will have a substantial impact on VoIP service development,
particularly in developing countries As wireless and VoIP traffic increase, differences in the terms and conditions
under which wireline, wireless and VoIP operators interconnect networks will
create opportunities for arbitrage, and distort markets
Differences in call termination rates and interconnection arrangements can
cause operators to adjust traffic flows to obtain the lowest possible rate, and
to minimize regulatory fees
Incumbent operators may seek to exploit bottlenecks and essential facilities,
by imposing above cost termination charges to deliver calls to wireless
subscribers, or to deliver wireless traffic to wireline subscribers.
This may encourage wireless carriers and VoIP providers to avoid the
incumbents network by seeking cheaper alternatives for originating andterminating traffic
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
33
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
34/53
These promise to have sufficient bandwidth
and operating standards to support high speed data services, presumably
including VoIP
Wi-Fi can also support voice telephone calls.
Wi-Fi is generally provided as unlicensed broadband network access, on an
stand-alone basis at homes, offices and public hot spots such as airport
lounges and coffee shops
VoWiFi can integrate Wi-Fi access with licensed thirdgeneration mobile services. With seamless roaming between the two
networks, subscribers could use voice over a WiFi network (where available)
and mobile connections where WiFi is missing, or outside a WiFi network.
VoWiFi has the potential to allow VoIP providers to completely bypass the
PSTN
WiMax is a wireless
broadband technology, which has a range of up to 30 miles and can be used
for wireless networking like Wi-Fi, but at higher data rates over longer
distances
Maret 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
34
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
35/53
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
36/53
Bagi operator baru, dapat memperoleh interkoneksi
merupakan hal penting bagi kemampuannya dalam
kompetisi dengan operator incumbent.
Bagi penyedia interkoneksi (biasanya incumbent), harga
interkoneksi merupakan hal penting untuk memperoleh
return on investmentdari pembangunan fasilitastelekomunikasi.
Penentuan harga interkoneksi tidak hanya merupakan isu
teknis, tapi juga politis, sehingga penentuan kriteria yang
betul-betul obyektif untuk menentukan harga interkoneksiyang tepat tidak mungkin/sulit dilakukan.
April 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
36
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
37/53
Regulasi pembebanan interkoneksi bertujuan untuk mendorongterjadinya dengan menjamin new entrants
dapat mengakses fasilitas jaringan yang ada, yang memungkinkan
mereka dapat berkompetisi dengan existing operators.
Pembebanan interkoneksi yang tinggi memungkinkan return on
investmentyang tinggi. Hal ini menguntungkan bagi operatorincumbent tertentu yang telah menginvestasikan biaya yang lebih besar
dalam membangun fasilitas, dan memperoleh net paymentyang cukup
dari operator lain yang menggunakan fasilitas tersebut
Di lain pihak, tarif interkoneksi yang terlalu rendah dapat
mengakibatkan berkurangnya minat untuk investasi fasilitas jaringan.Hal ini dapat memperlambat .
April 2011 InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
37
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
38/53
Dalam menentukan besarnya beban interkoneksi tidak adapendekatan yang tepat, namun berdasarkan konsensus para ahli
disepakati bahwa yang yang paling baik adalah pendekatan cost-
based. Walaupun demikian terdapat pendekatan lain yang dianggap
cocok untuk kondisi tertentu.
Pendekatan yang banyak digunakan dalam menentukan bebaninterkoneksi adalah
o Forward Looking Incremental Cost
o Historical Accounting Cost
o Sender Keep All (SKA) atau Bill and Keep
o Revenue Sharing
o Interconnect Charge based on Retail Price
o Other Negotiated Interconnect Charge
April 2011 38InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
39/53
Besarnya pembebanan didasarkan atas forward-looking costs darifasilitas dan layanan yang diberikan kepada operator yangmemperoleh interkoneksi
o Biasanya diestimasikan untuk long run, misalnya dengan metoda LongRun Incremental Costs (LRIC)
Contoh
o Australia, Canada, Hong Kong, Chile, dan operator lokal di Amerika Serikat
Variasi metoda LRIC meliputi Long Run Average Incremental Costs(LRAIC), Total Service Long Run Incremental Costs (TSLRIC) dan TotalElement Long Run Incremental Costs (TELRIC)
o Perbedaan dari tiap pendekatan tersebut adalah dalam memasukkanelemen dari fixed costs dan common costs (mis. overheads dan fixed-
service costs) yang tidak ada dalam analisis LRIC yang tradisional
o Variasi-variasi tersebut berkembang dan diterima sebagai best practice
April 2011 39InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
40/53
Secara umum diterima sebagai best practice
Mencerminkan harga yang paling efisien, karena perhitungan berdasarkanteknologi yang digunakan saat itu (bukan sekedar dari nilai buku asset yangsudah lalu)
Merupakan perkiraan biaya yang paling mendekati dalam pasar yang sudahfully competitive
Perlu melakukan study serta estimasi cost dan demand
Biasanya pendekatan ini menghasilkan tarif interkoneksi yang rendah
o Pendekatan ini mendorong kompetisi, tapi menyebabkan pendapatan yang rendahbagi incumbent.
Secara substansial perhitungan ini bisa tidak sejalan dengan perhitungan
berdasarkan nilai buku dari incumbent yang inefisien
Pendekatan ini akan tidak tepat apabila harga yang ditetapkan kepada end-user tidak balans (misalnya di bawah costatau di bawah interconnectioncharge)
April 2011 40InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
41/53
Nilai pembebanan berdasarkan catatan akuntansi darioperator yang memberikan fasilitas dan layanan
interkoneksi
Perhitungan umumnya mencakup biaya langsung dan
biaya umum yang dicatat dalam pembukuan
Contoh
o UK, Jepang pada sistem yang digunakan tahun 1995, dan Swedia
April 2011 41InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
42/53
Merupakan pendekatan umum, namun tidak disukai oleh regulatordan para ahli saat ini.
Kurang efisien dibandingkan dengan perhitungan berdasarkanteknologi yang digunakan pada situasi operasi yang sedang berjalan.
Catatan akuntansi sering tidak menggambarkan nilai aset yang riil,karena kebijakan akuntansi yang subyektif, serta keputusan politismengenai investasi
Biasanya memerlukan studi untuk menetapkan/ mengalokasikan
nilai buku dari fasilitas dan layanan interkoneksi yang diberikan
April 2011 42InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
43/53
Tidak ada pembayaran yang dilakukan antar operator
yang saling berinterkoneksi untuk penyaluran trafik
Umumnya masing-masing operator menanggung biaya
untuk fasilitas miliknya sampai ke titik interkoneksi,
ditambah dengan biaya lain yang timbul untuk
mengakomodasikan trafiknya.
Contoh
o
India, operator lokal di AS and Canada, dan operator regional diIndonesia
April 2011 43InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
44/53
Cocok apabila dua operator yang saling berinterkoneksi memiliki
situasi yang sama dan mempertukarkan trafik yang seimbang
(misalnya interkoneksi antar operator lokal)
Dapat ditentukan beban tambahan untuk kompensasi trafik yang
tidak seimbang
Tanpa biaya tambahan tersebut SKA dapat menghambatpembangunan di daerah (rural) atau layanan lain, yang trafiknya tidak
seimbang (misalnya lebih banyak incoming)
Dulu digunakan sebagai model yang banyak dipakai untuk
interkoneksi antar ISP, tetapi sekarang sudah berubah karena ISP
yang memiliki jaringan backbone dengan jangkauan yang luas lama
kelamaan akan mengubah perlakuannya terhadap operator yang kecil
dari menjadi .
April 2011 44InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
45/53
Pada dasarnya, operator baru membayarkan kepada operatorincumbent sebagian pendapatan dari layanan yang melalui
interkoneksi (atau semua layanan)
Pada beberapa ketentuan revenue-sharing, tidak ada beban
tambahan yang harus dibayar antar operator yang berinterkoneksi
untuk menyampaikan trafiknya masing-masing. Namun yang lain, adayang menentukan pembayaran tambahan untuk biaya interkoneksi
langsung (misalnya link transmisi atau interface interkoneksi lainnya)
Contoh
o Thailand, Indonesia, dan China
April 2011 45InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
46/53
Pendekatan ini cukup sederhana, tidak perlu melakukan studi
mengenai costuntuk menentukan pembebanan interkoneksi
Umumnya dianggap tidak transparan
Berpotensi untuk tidak efisien dan anti-kompetitif (apabila terjadipembagian revenue yang tidak proporsional/ kelebihan)
Kadang-kadang dianjurkan oleh pemerintah sebagai satu-satunya
dasar perhitungan interkoneksi yang diperbolehkan pada situasi
pasar tertutup, dan dianggap sebagai taxuntuk penyelenggaraan
bisnis Dapat dijadikan langkah transisi menuju pendekatan yang lebih
efisien
April 2011 46InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
47/53
Biaya interkoneksi berdasarkan harga retail yang
dikenakan kepada end users
Kadang-kadang ditetapkan diskon untuk pembebanan
antar operator, yang diestimasikan berdasarkan biaya
yang tidak perlu dikenakan kepada operator pemberi
interkoneksi (mis. billing, marketing)
Contoh
o Harga resale lokal di AS, Jepang (sebelum 1995).
April 2011 47InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
48/53
Sulit mengestimasi diskon, dapat menyebabkan inefisiensi
o Diskon yang terlalu tinggi menyebabkan keengganan untuk
membangun fasilitas di area yang kompetitifo Diskon yang terlalu rendah menyebabkan menurunnya
kemampuan untuk berkompetisi
Pendekatan ini ditolak di beberapa negara (mis.
Hongkong, China yang membedakan carrier-to-carrier
charge dengan tarif retail)
April 2011 48InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
49/53
Besarnya beban interkoneksi dinegosiasikan antara
operator berdasarkan pendekatan-pendekatan lainSome principled, many arbitrary
Contoh
o Internasional accounting rates, beberapa reseller agreement
April 2011 49InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
50/53
Efisiensi pembebanan tergantung seberapa dekat
perkiraan biaya terhadap nilai yang efisien
o Dalam perhitungan biaya yang dinegosiasikan sering secara
implisit termasuk subsidi antara operator dengan customer
Hasil negosiasi tergantung tingkat kekuatan tawar
(bargaining power) dari masing-masing operator
April 2011 50InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
51/53
Pembebanan interkoneksi harus cost-based
o idealnya berbasis long-run average incremental costs
o termasuk cost of capital
o ditambah dengan mark-up yang wajar untuk mengcover forward-looking joint andcommon costs
Costs harus berdasarkan current replacement costs of assets
o dikurangkan pada sisa usia dari layanan
o untuk menghitung cost ini dapat digunakan depreciated book value of assets
Pembebanan interkoneksi harus cukup unbundled agar operator yangmemerlukan interkoneksi hanya membayar biaya untuk komponen ataulayanan sesuai yang diminta/diperlukan
Jika biaya komponen tertentu berbeda secara signifikan pada lokasi yangberbeda-beda, pembebanan interkoneksinya agar tidak di-aggregated
o Misalnya biaya jaringan akses di daerah rural yang mungkin lebih tinggidibandingkan dengan di perkotaan (karena biasanya lebih panjang)
April 2011 51InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
52/53
Pembebanan tidak memasukkan subsidi silang (secara tersembunyi)
Misalnya harga jaringan yang termasuk komponen monopoli agar tidak
dinaikkan diatas cost, dengan maksud untuk membiayai komponen
kompetitif yang dijual dibawah cost
Prinsip ini diadopsi dalam WTO Regulation Reference Paper.
Struktur pembebanan interconnection harus merefleksikan costs yang
mendasarinya
Fixed costs dicover dengan fixed charges, variable costs dengan variable
charges
peak and off-peak charges ditentukan apabila terdapat perbedaan cost
yang signifikan
April 2011 52InterkoneksiSemester Genap 2010-2011
-
7/30/2019 Modul Selektif 567
53/53
THANK YOU
Arigato
Matur Suwun
Nuhun