mrhdm: understanding sediment availability and … › ceer2014 › speaker presentations ›...

28
US Army Corps of Engineers BUILDING STRONG ® MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND DELIVERY FOR LAND BUILDING Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf

Upload: others

Post on 03-Jul-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

US Army Corps of Engineers BUILDING STRONG®

MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND DELIVERY FOR LAND BUILDING

Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf

Page 2: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

Geomorphic Assessment

Document the historic trends of the channel system Establish the current stability of the

channel system and identify the dominant processes and features within the system

Acknowledgement: Little & Biedenharn

2

Page 3: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

1960s to 1970s

3

Page 4: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

1970s to 1990s

4

Page 5: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

1990s to 2000s

5

Page 6: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

Future Without Project Acknowledgement: Brown (ERDC)

6

Much larger flow fraction diverted at Ft St Philip / Bohemia

Page 7: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG® 7

Acknowledgement: Heath & Thomas

Page 8: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

Page 9: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

BONNET CARRÉ – Delft3D Acknowledgement: Sadid et al

Page 10: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

Bathymetric change (FLOOD 2011) observation polygon A to I

Page 11: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

Bathymetric change (June 2011-June 2012)

Page 12: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

Volume of Erosion and Accretion

Page 13: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

2011 Flood Event-Sand Budget

29%

17%

8%

2%

Page 14: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

2011 Flood Event-Fine Sediment (Mud) Budget

4% -12%

0%

0%

Page 15: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

MODEL DOMAIN UPPER BRETON

SOUND

Page 16: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

Production run: 2 Simulation period: January 2008 – December 2010 Diversion Capacity 250k cfs Diversion is open for three years

Simulated Flow through the Diversion

Page 17: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

Production run: 2 Simulation period: January 2008 – December 2010 Sediment Water Ratio

SAND

Page 18: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

Production run: 2 Simulation period: January 2008 – December 2010 Sediment Water Ratio

Fine Sediment

Page 19: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

Production run: 2 Simulation period: January 2008 – December 2010 Erosion and Deposition volume in the river bed for operating the diversion continuously

Page 20: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

Myrtle grove and White Ditch Diversions

Model Domain: RM 76 – RM 56 Design Capacity for MG: 75,000 CFS Design Capacity for WD: 35,000 CFS

Page 21: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

MG+WD Model: Erosion and Deposition volume in the river bed for operating both the diversions continuously between 2008-2010

Page 22: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

WEST BAY DIVERSION Acknowledgement: Meselhe, Allison, Khadka & Deltares

To West Bay (Receiving Basin)

Page 23: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

2009-2011 volumes

Page 24: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

2009-2011 Land Building (~3 km2 /750 acres)

EFFECT OF SREDS

Page 25: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

Basin-side Analysis

Page 26: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

Objectives of Basin Wide Analysis Produce a validated model to simulate:

Morphological evolution processes during the creation of a new delta and wetland areas

Nutrient effects to the wetland vegetation, soil, and the estuarine primary producers of Breton Sound and Barataria Basin

Determine how diversions affect the distribution and biomass of fish and shellfish using a community modeling approach (Ecosim/TroSim)

Page 27: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

Estuarine Open Water transects

Page 28: MRHDM: UNDERSTANDING SEDIMENT AVAILABILITY AND … › CEER2014 › Speaker Presentations › J… · Ehab Meselhe, PhD, PE The Water Institute of the Gulf . BUILDING STRONG ® Geomorphic

BUILDING STRONG®

CLOSING REMARKS The synergy between Diversions and Dredging offers:

Diversions: Sustainable solution

Diversions: Significant new land building and preserve existing wetlands [fine material]

Dredging: Near term land building

Dredging; Reduced erosion

Dredging: Enhanced sediment retention

Combined: May reduce shoaling near the HOP

Impacts on Fisheries and Nutrients are being analyzed