namdeo dhasal - poet and panther - hovell - ocrring
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/10/2019 Namdeo Dhasal - Poet and Panther - Hovell - OCRRING
1/19
NAMDEO DHASAL: POET AND PANTHERAuthor(s): Laurie HovellSource: Journal of South Asian Literature, Vol. 24, No. 2, MISCELLANY (Summer, Fall 1989),pp. 65-82Published by: Asian Studies Center, Michigan State UniversityStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/40873091.
Accessed: 26/12/2014 12:30
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at.http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].
.
Asian Studies Center, Michigan State Universityis collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend
access toJournal of South Asian Literature.
http://www.jstor.org
This content downloaded from 2.27.80.189 on Fri, 26 Dec 2014 12:30:44 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=asiamsuhttp://www.jstor.org/stable/40873091?origin=JSTOR-pdfhttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/stable/40873091?origin=JSTOR-pdfhttp://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=asiamsu -
8/10/2019 Namdeo Dhasal - Poet and Panther - Hovell - OCRRING
2/19
NAMDEO
DHASAL: POET AND
PANTHER
Laurie
Hovell
To read
NamdeoDhasal's
poetry
s
to
step
nto the
slums
nd
streetsf
Bombay;
t
s toenternto centuries-old
istory
f
both
overty
and
vitality.
Dhasal was born
Mahar,
n Untouchable
n
Hindu ndia.
But Dhasal and millions f
Maharswill not die Hindus. Since
1956,
Dhasal
and an estimated ix millionUntouchables ave converted o
Buddhism
s a result f the fermenttarted
y
Dr. Bhimrao
Ramji
Ambedkar
1892-1956).
Dhasal
is both
poet
and a Panther.
His activities eflect he
political,
ocial and
literary
imensionsf the
arger
Dalit movement.*
In
1972,
Dhasal foundedhe Dalit
Panthers,"
political roup
oncerned
with he
rights
f
India's Scheduled astes nd soon he burst
n to the
Marathi
iterary
cene withhis book of
poems,
Golpitha, shocking
depiction
f
Bombay's
lums nd brothels.
"Dalit" means
ppressed,
owntrodden.
hasal's
poetry,
s
that
of the argerDalit movement,annot e separated rom tshistorical,
political,
nd social
ontext.Dalit
poems
have
purpose;
he
oets peak
about
nd
for
community.
omeof these
oets
ay
that
f
their
olitical
and social
goals
were met
tomorrow,
hey
ould
stop
shouting,
nd
writing.
The
following oems
re from
hasal's
Thi
ytt
Kanchi Thi
lytt
What
GradeAre You
n,
What
Grade?)
published
n
1982. Here
we find
him n
a
reflective ood.
By
this
ime,
he
Dalit
Panthers ad
already ndergoneeveralncarnationsndsplitsndDhasal's healthwas
bad. His
anger
nd
rebellion ad
reached
peak
n
Golpitha.
The later
book,
What
Grade,
findsDhasal
stepping
ack.
In
the
poems
n
this
volume,
Dhasal
meditates n how
far
the Dalits
have come
since the
Buddhist
onversion.
He reflects
pon
Ambedkar'
position
nd his
influence
n
the
ommunity
n
contemporary
ndia.
He
considerswhere
theDalit
community-united
r
divided-might
e
heading.
*For a study f Ambedkar nd theDalit movement,ee Eleanor
Zelliot,
"Dalit-New
CulturalContext
for an
Old Marathi
Word,"
Contributionso
Asian
Studies,
Vol.
XI,
1975.
65
This content downloaded from 2.27.80.189 on Fri, 26 Dec 2014 12:30:44 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
8/10/2019 Namdeo Dhasal - Poet and Panther - Hovell - OCRRING
3/19
SOME
BACKGROUNDN
AMBEDKAR
Dhasal and
Ambedkarwere born
Mahars,
members f
an
Untouchableubgrouphose ccupation as the isposal fdead nimals.
Traditionally,
ntouchables
erenot llowed
oenter
emples
r use wells
used
by
caste
Hindus. Their hildren ould not
enter choolsbut were
forced
o isten o the
essons rom utside. Untouchables
ould not
ive
inside he
village
with aste
Hindus. Their
very
ouchwas
considered
ritually
olluting;enerations
go,
f
n Untouchable's
hadow
assed
ver
a caste
Hindu,
he aste
Hindu
equired
series f
purifying
ituals.
This
had been theUntouchable's
eritage
or
many
enturies.
But
Bhimrao mbedkar
anaged
o
acquire
n
education
hroughthe
upport
f
private
cholarships.
mbedkar ent o
study
tColumbia
University
s
well as
in
London nd
in
Bonn.
Finally,
he returned
o
India
n
1923 as a
barrister,
eterminedo achieve
political
nd
social
rights
or ndia's Untouchables.
Ambedkar ecame
a
prominent
olitician
nd
helpedpass
laws
which
made
untouchability
nd ts
practice
llegal.
He obtained
rom he
Indian
government
quota
system
or Scheduled
Castes
for
filling
government
ositions,
heUntouchables
omprising
hemain
egment
f
this lassification.ut fter ears fstruggle,mbedkarinallyaveup
any
hope
of
changing
he
Untouchables'
osition
within he Hindu
hierarchy.
e
rejected
induism,
religion
hich e felt ad
oppressed
his
people
for enturies.
n
October
f
1956,
ust
twomonths
efore is
death,
Dr.
Ambedkar
ed a
mass conversion
f ex-Untouchables
o
Buddhism,
conversion
n
which
alf million
eople
took
hevows
to
become
Buddhist
aypersons.
Since
then,
n estimated
ix
million x-
Untouchables
aveconverted
o Buddhism.
66
This content downloaded from 2.27.80.189 on Fri, 26 Dec 2014 12:30:44 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
8/10/2019 Namdeo Dhasal - Poet and Panther - Hovell - OCRRING
4/19
AMBEDKAR: 1978
EQUALITY
FOR
ALL
OR
DEATH
FOR INDIA
After his
I'm
not
going
o write
nything
btuse
Poetic wists nd counter-twists
are not llowed
5 Don't misfire:
the arth
might
e there r not
Straightuickgrab
t
by
theroot
This
country
rows
ike castor il
plant
10 We love its worthlesseaveswithouteason
We havebeen
drooling
We
play
with
a strand f
spit
They
don't
ccept
ur
gift
f ove
15
Theybetray
hemselves--
as
if
you
could
carve
lump
utof
your
wn
flesh
and
eave
t
festering
n
a thick
loody
tream
They
re
fired
p
with heir
wn
egotism
They
re
possessed
y
neuroses
20
Killing,
iolence,
loodshed
They
re
polluted
y
this ottentench
They
make
veryone
nto n
Oedipus
They
want
artition
They
want iots
25
They
want o turn
umans
ntodemons
Theywant oseehumanityestroyednemore ime
Ashes
nd
skeletons
Their
ongs
f
death
Their
body/their
rain/theirss
30
their
rief/their
lood
Are
they
he
nly
nes born f
mothers'
ombs?
The rest
re from
atsand
dogs
What n
illusion
hey
ive
n
They re slaves otheirmotions
35
Lust and
thirst
Their
dreamy
mind-chariot
alls
part
They
deny
he
cceptance
f
ife
67
This content downloaded from 2.27.80.189 on Fri, 26 Dec 2014 12:30:44 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
8/10/2019 Namdeo Dhasal - Poet and Panther - Hovell - OCRRING
5/19
They
ift heir
aces nd
spit
t
the
ky
Do
they
hink
hey
ould
pollute
he
ky?
40 Theirfaces
re blackwith
hame
Does
condemning
omeone lse's
sanctitytake
way
theirwnsins?
They
hould
top
now
They
hould
hange
ow
45
Instead f
ooking
or he
plinter
n
somebody
lse's
eye
They
hould
et
theboulder
utof
their wn
You've
gone
beyond
the
power
n
your
tatue
You're evenbiggerhan hename f the ountry
50
You werenever
stiff
aying
en
The stream f
your
houghts
transformed
ur ives
How could
we
ignore
he
ruth?
We
want o become
ikethem-those
hosewisdom
lluminates
55
We want o be
like them-those
ho
rest
n
the
deep
shade
of a
tree
The inner
oice s
honest
You
weren't
bigot
You bent
he imes o
your
will
What
eemed
mpossible
60
you
dropped
n
our
aps
You stand adiant
efore
s
You neverhida
secret
My
lifewas
clear s a
crystal
that
lashed
eyond
eath
65
You became
he entral
igure
or ll
Dalits
Those
who
spoke
gainst
ou
those
who ridiculed
our
work-
you
didn't
et
ngry
with
hem
You
planted
our
eet
n the
wild-spinning
arth
70
and stood
ikea rock
against
heir
mistaken
eliefs
The harshwords
hat ame
outof
your
mouth-
their
urpose
was
liberation
In
your
heart
ou
storedolerance
75
In
the
ameheart
tirred
volcano
f
revolt
Your
revoltwas
notblind
nd
dumb:
68
This content downloaded from 2.27.80.189 on Fri, 26 Dec 2014 12:30:44 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
8/10/2019 Namdeo Dhasal - Poet and Panther - Hovell - OCRRING
6/19
to
change
yourself
as
to
change
he
world
New
eyes,
new
heart
Your
faith
was
in
awakening,
ot
revenge
80
awakening
orn
f
study,
f
duty
Your
reputation
asn't
false
You
grabbed
he
banyan
ree
y
the
roots
Weapons
You
didn't
ake
hem
ut
ust
to
fill
your
elly
85
You
unleashed
hem
gainst
njustice
You
did
a
post-mortem
n
the
gods
Satvi,
that
ate-reckoning
oddess,
you
cut
off
her
nose,
snubbed
t
You threwhebarrenalesofheaven ndhell
90
into
he
gutter
You
fucked
he
33
crores
f
cocksuckers
ithout
aring
You
set
the
water
n
fire
The
sky
ame
storming
own
at
your
ommand
95
and
the
easons
walked
heir
way
threaded
ith
old
You
took
n
the
world
You
played
with
ire
You playedusmusic nthe torm
Suffering
100
the
root
f
suffering
freedom
rom
uffering
the
path
f
freedom
You
warmed
o
the
ursed
arth
to
meet
with ow
ones
105
to
part
rom
oved
ones
tofeelunfillableesires
the
meaning
f
all
this
s
suffering
the
meaning
f
birth
s
suffering
the
meaning
f
old
age
is
suffering
1
10
the
meaning
f disease
s
suffering
the
meaning
f death
s
suffering
O heir
f
conflict
The
man
who
gives
good
to the
ong
nd
short
you
made
him
ransparent
115
We see
through
nd
beyond
very
man
69
This content downloaded from 2.27.80.189 on Fri, 26 Dec 2014 12:30:44 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
8/10/2019 Namdeo Dhasal - Poet and Panther - Hovell - OCRRING
7/19
They
believe
people
re
absolutely
lind
They
believe
people
re ow
They
believe
eople
re slaves
They
fearhuman
hadows
120
They
wear rmor eadto toe
They
et
anthills ise
up
around hem
till
hey
mother,eethe,
nd
spitup poison
After
his
nothing
bscure
s to be
written
Plow thewhole
hing
with
donkey's
low
125
EQUALITY
FOR
ALL
OR
DEATHFOR INDIA
and
on theheart
arved
AMBEDKAR:
1978
Translated
y
Laurie
Hovell
and Asha
Mundlay,
with
Jayant
arve
NOTES
The
"we" and
"they"
n
the
poemmight
e
thought
f as
we,
the
Dalits,
the
oppressed,
nd
they,
he aste
Hindus.
28-29:
This s a reference
o theBuddhist
deal of
enlightenment.
82: The
Buddha ttained
nlightenment
nder
banyan
ree.
87:
Satvi s a
Hindu
goddess
who,
in
the
mythology,
isits
newborn
childrenndwritesheir ate cross heir oreheads.
91 The number
f
Hindu
ods
s sometimes
etermined
s
33 crore.
(A
crore
s 10
million.)
99-102:
Dhasal s
speaking
f Buddhism's
our
Noble
Truths:
1)
Suffering
s
inherent
n
existence.
2)
The root
f
suffering
s
greed,
hatred,
nd
delusion.
3)
Freedom
rom
uffering
s
possible.
4)
The
way
to
freedom
s
the
ight-foldath.
124:
A
donkey's
low
is
particularly
nauspicious.
A
cow's
plow
is
auspicious.
70
This content downloaded from 2.27.80.189 on Fri, 26 Dec 2014 12:30:44 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
8/10/2019 Namdeo Dhasal - Poet and Panther - Hovell - OCRRING
8/19
AMBEDKAR:
79
Your followersct
ike false
gurus
Theyuse a loinclothor tieand babble
Their
heritage
s
mother-fucking
Like Yama fucked
ami,
they
uck
heir
isters
5 These
mpotent rjuns
f countless
enerations-
all
they
an do is
pop
some
virgin's
herry,
he
un
n
their
lood
This
bubbling
mass
who
will
pop
it with
pin
This sad lonesome
ain,
where s it
going?
10 Won't
somebody
etthis
ity
n fire?
Your death s
consideredmonumental
I
saw it from he
yes
of a
commonman
Therewas no
oy
in
your
eath,
o
sorrow
The real man
ivesbefore eath
15 The rest s
simply
ust,
wirling
ust
In
place
of death
'm
trying
o establish
Beauty
This s the
proclamation
f bread
This s the
parliament's
rothel
20
This
country
e call Mother
sleeps
with he
god
of wealth
and
time s
becoming
more
rthodox
The
life
n
my
heart
ecomesworthless
s dust
Green
reams ade
before
my
yes
25 Now whocan weworship?
Translated
y
Laurie Hovell
and Asha
Mundlay,
with
Jayant
arve
NOTES
1-2: Dr. Ambedkarsuallywore western-styleuit ndnever dopted
the
khadi
homespun
otton)
ress f
the
ndian
National
ongress.
The
lines
mply
hat is
followers
ttempt
o
mitate is
dress
but
don't
get
t
quite
right.
71
This content downloaded from 2.27.80.189 on Fri, 26 Dec 2014 12:30:44 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
8/10/2019 Namdeo Dhasal - Poet and Panther - Hovell - OCRRING
9/19
4:
In
the
Vedas, Yama,
the
god
of
death,
nd Yami are brother
nd
sister.
gnorant
f
the aws
ofthemortal
orld,
ami wants o
sleep
with
her
brother.
He banishes
er,
but she
repents,
nd he takes
her back.
This s the
rigin
f the
Diwali
Festival
f
Lights)
oliday:
n thefourth
day
ofthefestivalrothersonor heiristers.
5:
In
the
Mahbhrat,
he
hero
Arjun
as to ive for
year
s a
eunuch,
whilehis
wife erves
he
king
s
a maidservant.
72
This content downloaded from 2.27.80.189 on Fri, 26 Dec 2014 12:30:44 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
8/10/2019 Namdeo Dhasal - Poet and Panther - Hovell - OCRRING
10/19
AMBEDKAR:
1980
1
You
died
butdidn't
nd
Like
us,
you
slept
with
your
wife
You
had
children,
ut
hey
idn't
lap
n
thebreeze
We
grew
up
like
this,
ike
that
5
butour children
ouldnever
gnore
our
ffection
Academician/
echnician/
olitician/
cientist
Philosopher
These
mendefine
ou
some
way
or
another
You lived ike a man
10
No
acting
n
it
no dramatics
no
imitation,
o
imitators
Now
this s old stuff:
they
wouldn't
ouch s when
hey
ave
us
water
15 Now
this s old stuff:
theymadeus sitoutside he chool n theveranda
Now this
s
old:
they
wouldn't et us see
theblack nd
white eet f
Vithoba
20 Now
they
nd we are the
ame
This
world's ocialism
This world's
ommunism
And
your
deas-
we've
put
hem o the est
25 The implications this:
our shadow an cover
ur feet
2
We curse
you
too,
but
you
gave
us
the
ongue
We even sink
you
n
the
water,
ut
30 yougaveus thewater
We've
done
things
o
you,
but
anything
an
be doneto
you
73
This content downloaded from 2.27.80.189 on Fri, 26 Dec 2014 12:30:44 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
8/10/2019 Namdeo Dhasal - Poet and Panther - Hovell - OCRRING
11/19
Yet the
uestion
f
my oyalty,
myhonesty
35
still
emains
Whoare
you?
Who were
you?
Whose re
you?
3
The times re
yours
40
but
your
eople
till
uffer
A mendicantan be primeministerere
but
Mang
can't,
nor
Bhangi
In
front f
the
hair,
he
parliament's
rice
s less
In
front
f the
aw,
the
prostitute's
rice
s
less
45
I
saw
one
thing
n
all
this:
the
wheel f
the easons
omes
o us
equally
You,
like the
wheel,
were
qual
to all
4
It was a
Friday
An
arithmetic
ook,
slate,
50 and
one
piece
of
chalk-
Mama
got
them
rom
hebazaar
She
was tired
hat
ay
In
the
ight
f the
brass
antern
she
had me
massage
erfeet
55 Then hesaid
'Baba-until
fall
sleep
take
look
at this
ook
I
never earned
but
you
do one
thing
60
Start
our
ducation
and
trace
'B'
for
Babasaheb
Mostkids
tart
ith he
etter
orGanesh
but
Babasaheb
was
more eautiful
than hat odwith nelephant'sace
65 So don't
race
ShriGanesh
The lord
of the
people
s
never
gly
74
This content downloaded from 2.27.80.189 on Fri, 26 Dec 2014 12:30:44 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
8/10/2019 Namdeo Dhasal - Poet and Panther - Hovell - OCRRING
12/19
He
comes
from
mong
men
True
Holy
Beautiful
70
True,
holy,
nd
beautiful
this
s
Babasaheb
Ambedkar
orelsetherest fthis ookmeans
nothing
5
While
was
writing
his
3
o'clock
struck
75
I
know
need
drink
but
don't
feel
ike
having
ne
I
only
want osleeppeacefully
to
wake
up
in
the
morning
nd
see
no
varnas,
o castes
Translated
by
Laurie
Hovell
and
Asha
Mundlay,
with
Jayant
arve
NOTES
14:
If
a caste
Hindu
gave
water
o an
Untouchable,
hey
would
pour
t
from
bove
and
be careful
otto
touch
himfor
fear f
ritual
ollution.
Even
the
ouch
f
an Untouchable's
essel
was considered
olluting.
16:
Untouchables
ere
not
llowed
nside
chools
ut
had
to isten
o
the
lessonsfromhe choolveranda.
19:
Vithoba
s
the
god
of
the
mportant
hakti
devotional eligion)
ect
of
Maharashtra.
ntouchables
umbered
mong
he
pilgrims
f
the
ect
and
were
aint-singers
n
the
00
year
ld
tradition,
ut
until
ndependence
in
1947,
they
were
never
allowed
inside
Vithoba'
chief
temple
n
Pandharput.
note
by
Eleanor
elliot)
21-23:
Dhasal
in
his
maverick
olitical
areer
has
joined
both
the
communistsndthe ocialists,s wellas theCongress arty.He implies
here
hat ll
these
political
roups
till
hold the
now
ex-Untouchable
s
defiling.
Zelliot)
75
This content downloaded from 2.27.80.189 on Fri, 26 Dec 2014 12:30:44 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
8/10/2019 Namdeo Dhasal - Poet and Panther - Hovell - OCRRING
13/19
26:
In
the
ast,
Untouchables
eremade
o iveoutside
he
illage
walls.
As an Untouchable's
hadowwas
heldto be
polluting,
e
was
normally
not llowed
o enter
he
village.
But t
high
noon,
when he
hadowwas
covered
y
the
feet,
n Untouchableould
enter he
village. (Zelliot)
27-30:
The
speaker
cknowledges
hat
mbedkar
mpowered
heDalits--
without
mbedkar,
hey
wouldnot
havebeen onscious
f their
osition.
Ambedkar
ought
or
heir
ights
o
enter
emples
nd
to
get
water rom
public
wells.
Any
power
hey
ave
to
speak
gainst
im
now
s
power
that
e
gave
them.
42:
Mang
and
Bangi
are subcastes
ithin heUntouchable
ommunity.
Mangs
traditionally
ade
ropes,
nd
Bhangis
leaned
atrines.
60:
Traditionally
he
first
yllable
hat
hildren
earn s
"shri,"
which
means
"honorable"
nd refers o
the
Hindu
god
Ganesh,
or
Ganpati.
Ganesh
s an incarnation
f Shiva:
he has the
body
f a
man
nd
thehead
of an
elephant.
Ganesh
s a
particularly
opular
od
n
Maharashtra.
78:
Varna eferso
the lassical
our-foldivision
f
Hindu
ociety.
The
Manusmriti
peaks
of four
varnas: the
Brahmins
the
priests),
the
kshatriyas
the
oldiers
nd
rulers),
he
vaishyas
the
merchants),
nd the
shudras themenialworkers).Traditionally,ntouchablesre seen as
adishudras;
hey
re
so low that
hey
re
noteven
ncluded
within he
varna
ystem.
76
This content downloaded from 2.27.80.189 on Fri, 26 Dec 2014 12:30:44 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
8/10/2019 Namdeo Dhasal - Poet and Panther - Hovell - OCRRING
14/19
WHAT
GRADE
ARE YOU
IN,
WHAT
GRADE?
Whatgrade reyou n,
what
grade?
Have
you
rough-housed
made
t bounce
5
sunk
even
hands
eep
tell
oh
tell
If
you're
hungry:
at
husk.
For
sleeping:
rock
Done
that?
Have
you
fucked
menstruating
oman?
Fucked
her?
10 Dragged
round
hedead
cattle?
Dead
cow?
Rubbed
he
grindstone?
rindstone?
Know
what
hayale
s? Cow
gut?
Saved
stale
bread?
Ate t?
Sucked
he
marrow?
Marrow?
15
Fried
he
gibblets?
Gibblets?
Have
you
fondled
ny
breasts?
Breasts?
Kissed?
Kissed?
Filled
thehole?
The
hole?
Made
your
ockswell? Yourcock?
20
Knocked
nyone
p?
Knocked
er
up?
Done
it from
he
back?
The back?
Done
it
twice
n
one
night?
Twice?
You
have
otsof
gaps
What
grade
re
you
n?
25
What
grade?
Translated
by
Laurie
Hovell and
Asha
Mundlay,
with
Jayant
arve
NOTES
This s the itle oem fDhasal's1982 ollection. hasal'sexplicitexual
references
re
shocking
n
a
society
n
which,
p
until
few
years
go,
cinema
ouples
were
not
even
allowed
to
kiss
on screen.
Most
of the
things
hat he
peaker
sks
about
would
be
especially
aboo for
caste
77
This content downloaded from 2.27.80.189 on Fri, 26 Dec 2014 12:30:44 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
8/10/2019 Namdeo Dhasal - Poet and Panther - Hovell - OCRRING
15/19
Hindu: for
example,
having
ntercourse
ith
menstruating
oman s
considered
olluting.
In
Brahmin
omes,
menstruating
omen re not
allowed
n
thekitchenr
near he
odhouse.)
Eating
eef s also taboo
for
caste
Hindus.
The
speaker,articularly
n
the ections n
beef-eating,
ells
about heDalits'
heritage
f
poverty.
9: Hindus onsider
menstruating
oman
itually
olluting.
10:
Traditionally,
ahars
isposed
fthe
arcasses fdeadanimals.
The
cow,
though
acred
o Hinduswhile t s
alive,
s
impure
hen ead.
The
Mahars ometimes
tethemeat
rom he ead
attle,
ndtheir ontact
ith
dead cows both
reated nd
perpetuated
heirUntouchable
tatus. The
Mahar's
poverty
ssured heuse of
every
art
f the ow.
12:
Hayale
s the
arge
ntestinef a cow.
78
This content downloaded from 2.27.80.189 on Fri, 26 Dec 2014 12:30:44 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
8/10/2019 Namdeo Dhasal - Poet and Panther - Hovell - OCRRING
16/19
JUST
A
BIT MORE
TIME
Just
bit
more
ime,
my
darling
Just bitmore ime
Hold
on somehow
Suppliesmay
ome,
they
may
not
5
They
have
captured
ur
bodies
They
have
captured
ur
breath
But the
antern
n
our
hearts-how
an
we
blow
t out?
Injustice
oes
notfall
with
heharvest
Or come
pouring
own
n
season
10
These
days
will
pass
Just
s summers
ass,
rainy
easons
ass
Hear-in
thedistance
Revolution
umbles
verywhere
You
hear t?
Translated
y
Laurie
Hovell and
Jayant
Karve
79
This content downloaded from 2.27.80.189 on Fri, 26 Dec 2014 12:30:44 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
8/10/2019 Namdeo Dhasal - Poet and Panther - Hovell - OCRRING
17/19
ABOUT
SATAN
These
days
certainly
don'tgo aroundwith cross roundmyneck
I
said
to
her
Why
don't
you
write
couple
ines
bout atan n
the
house
5
about
he
ruel
ittle
ames
he
plays
with
your
ife
how
he
carries n
noisy
nd
naked
how
he
gets
hard-on/
oses t
and
finally
alls
down
ired,
uiet
n
his own
house
When
he
feels
should alk
f the
carlet
mohur
n
bloom
10 aboutus
walking
and nhand nthe ands f the ea
fondling
he
waves
that re
white irds
stealing
corner
f
privacy
nside
he
house/
utside
to
merge
with
ne
another
. .
These
days
can't
do
this.
I
am
like
Satan.
15
For
my
Satanic
port
I
need
thousandsf
witnesses
I minglewith hem,mixwith hem, ecome ike them
If I
can,
caress heir
leasures
nd
pains
If
possible
even
sharewith
hem
20 If
nothing's
ossible
dance ike
bearon a
leash
These
days,
very ay,
she
tunes he
ambourand
sings
like
a
ruffled en
before
acrifice
Eggs
with
lack
beauty
pots
Bread
madefrom
craps
25 Thefirstraughtfhomebrewna cup
Hot
blood
for
condiment
Narcotic
itten
ongue
Can
Satan
verbe
too
ntimate ith
umans?
I
am
intimate ith
er
30
Does
a devil
ver
isten o
the tereo
Watch
TV?
Spiff p
his
house? Need
privacy
Satan
fears
ight
I mergewithight
After
ark
my
oul s
restless
35
Satan
grabs
hold
of
her,
rushes
er
ips
rapes
her
80
This content downloaded from 2.27.80.189 on Fri, 26 Dec 2014 12:30:44 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
8/10/2019 Namdeo Dhasal - Poet and Panther - Hovell - OCRRING
18/19
I
said
to
her,
write bout
his emon
n
the
house
And that
he
could
notdo
Now
Satan's
turn
as come
40 surrender ind, oul,
body
and
put
cross
round
is
neck
Translated
by
Laurie
Hovell
and Asha
Mundlay,
with
Jayant
arve
NOTES
All
italicized
words
ppeared
n
English
n
the
riginal.
Dhasal
uses the
English
word
Satan"
n
his
poem.
To
an
American,
he
term
resonates
with
meanings
rom
he Christian
radition.
But to a
Marathi-speakerhewordmust oundfresh, oreign.Dhasal livesin a
part
f
Bombay
where
Buddhists
ive next
o Hindusnext
o Christians
next o
Muslims;
hristian
mages,
uch
s
crosses,
re
part
f
hiscultural
milieu.
In
the
poem
Dhasal
also talksof
other
foreign
hings sing
English
words:
tereo, V,
privacy.
Again,
hese re words
amiliar
n
our
culture,
ut
to
a
Marathi-speaker
hey
might
ound
cosmopolitan,
modern.
3-4: Dhasal's
wife,
MalikaAmar
hekh,
s
also a
poet.
Her
father as
thewell-known ommunistolk inger, mar hekh.
9: The
mohur ree s a conventional
omantic
mage.
15-20: Dhasal has
acquired reputation
or
his
public
ntics. Before is
health
ailed,
Dhasal
made namefor
himselfs a
drinker,
man-about-
town,
nd
political
maverick.
21:
A
tambouras a
four-stringed
nstrument,
trummed ithout
rets
s
a
backgroundccompaniment
o voice or other nstruments.
23:
Probably
metaphor
or woman's reasts.
81
This content downloaded from 2.27.80.189 on Fri, 26 Dec 2014 12:30:44 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
8/10/2019 Namdeo Dhasal - Poet and Panther - Hovell - OCRRING
19/19
24:
In
Marathi,
he
phrase
s
"seven-grained
read."
In
American
English
his ounds ike
health
ood,
ut
n
Marathit
connotes
overty:
there sn't
enough
f one kind f
flour;
he
remains f sevendifferent
kinds f flourmust e mixed.
27:
Literally
a chandol-bitten
ongue."
The chandol
s a
bird;
here he
image mplies drug-induced
tate.
82