national energy policy consultations · henry hub spot price is expected to average a slightly...
TRANSCRIPT
1
National Energy
Policy CONSULTATIONS
Re-fueling T&T’s economic engine: A new policy for energy, 2011-2015
NATURAL GAS UTILISATION AND PRICING
NATURAL GAS UTILISATION AND PRICING
_______________________________________________________________
2
Natural Gas Utilisation and Pricing
Preamble
Natural gas has dominated the energy landscape in Trinidad and Tobago over the last four decades and
will no doubt continue to play a pivotal role in the future growth and development of our national
economy. In particular, the natural gas industry has exhibited phenomenal growth over the last decade
with the establishment of successive natural gas liquefaction trains, which in tandem with our well
established and expanding ammonia and methanol export business, have accelerated natural gas
production levels and generated unprecedented levels of economic activity.
Global Context
Supply/Demand
Natural gas is the fastest growing primary energy source in both the industrialized and non-
industrialized world. It currently accounts for about 20 % of world energy consumption and is expected
to increase its share relative to crude oil over the next 20 years.
Natural gas is and will continue to be an important fuel for industrial and domestic applications and
particularly for electricity generation worldwide because it is inherently more energy efficient and less
carbon-intensive than other fossil fuels.
NATURAL GAS UTILISATION AND PRICING
_______________________________________________________________
3
In the medium to long term the largest projected increase in natural gas production is forecasted for the
non-OECD regions with the major increments coming from the Middle East (an increase of 16 trillion
cubic feet (Tcf) over the period 2007 to 2035), Africa (7 Tcf), and Russia and the other countries of non-
OECD Europe and Eurasia (6 Tcf).
World natural gas trade, both by pipeline and by shipment in the form of LNG, is poised to increase in
the future. Most of the projected increase in LNG supply comes from the Middle East and Australia,
where a number of new liquefaction projects are expected to become operational within the next
decade. World liquefaction capacity is forecasted to increase by about 2.4 times, from about 8 Tcf in
2007 to 19 Tcf in 2035. In addition, new pipelines that are currently under construction or planned will
increase natural gas exports from Africa to European markets and from Eurasia to China.
Price Outlook
The EIA forecasts that gas will be in oversupply globally for the next ten (10) years primarily due to the
emergence of Shale Gas in the US and the availability of additional LNG export capability. In 2011, the
Henry Hub spot price is expected to average a slightly lower US$4.31 per MMBtu, compared to US$4.35
per MMBtu in 2010.In Europe, natural gas prices are expected to continue to be disconnected from oil
prices and the outlook is for further erosion in the traditional oil-based formula gas pricing system.
In the medium to long term, the EIA sees US prices rising to about US$7.00 per MMBtu by 2015 with
European prices rising to around US$11.60 per MMBtu over the same period.
PIRA’s outlook for the Henry Hub price for natural gas is pegged at a more conservative US$4.00 per
MMBtu in 2011 with moderate growth expected in the medium term to long term.
NATURAL GAS UTILISATION AND PRICING
_______________________________________________________________
4
Based on historical price trends the picture for the other principal commodities produced by our natural
gas-based industries in Trinidad and Tobago is expected to be similar. Demand and market prices for
Ammonia, Urea, Methanol and Metals are therefore expected to exhibit similar modest growth in the
short to medium term. It should be noted that natural gas pricing for many domestic natural gas based
industries has traditionally been indexed to the international market prices of these and other
commodities.
Regional Market [Caribbean and Latin America]
Natural gas production in the region is currently estimated at 7.8 Tcf and is forecasted to
increase by approximately 20% over the next decade with Brazil, Venezuela and Colombia
expected to show significant growth in production capacity. At present, Trinidad & Tobago is
the main producer of LNG in the region and currently supplies volumes to such locations as
Argentina, Chile, Brazil, the Dominican Republic and Mexico.
There are several proposed projects within the region which seek to interconnect natural gas
supply with demand either directly via pipeline and LNG or CNG export or alternatively by
linkages through integrated electricity transmission and distribution systems. These projects
are viewed as critical to the economic development of several regional economies as they are
NATURAL GAS UTILISATION AND PRICING
_______________________________________________________________
5
expected to reduce the exposure to energy price volatility, improve the quality and reliability of
supplies and generally contribute to national and regional energy security.
Natural Gas Utilization
Natural Gas is utilized by a diverse mix of industrial facilities and our national infrastructure
includes the following:
1 Crude Oil Refinery
1 Gas Processing Facility (PPGPL)
4 LNG Trains
10 Ammonia Plants
1 Urea Plant
7 Methanol Plants
1 Methanol to Power facility
An A-U-M Complex that comprises of :
1 Ammonia plant
1 Urea plant
1 Nitric Acid Plant
1 Ammonia Nitrate plant
2 Melamine trains
4 Iron and Steel Plants
1 cement manufacturing plant
Over 100 Light Industrial Consumers & small gas consumers (air conditioning etc)
6 Power Generation Sites [Powergen (Pt. Lisas/Penal/POS), Trinity Power (Point Lisas),
TGU (Union Estate), Cove (Tobago)]
The relative gas utilisation of these sectors is observed in the pie chart below for the period January-October 2010.
NATURAL GAS UTILISATION AND PRICING
_______________________________________________________________
6
Given the export oriented nature of the country’s gas based facilities, their commercial performance is
directly affected by global trends and fluctuations in the respective markets. Products from Trinidad &
Tobago are exported to a variety of destinations. Trinidad and Tobago is currently the #1 exporter of
Ammonia and Methanol from a single site and, notwithstanding recent trends to diversify away from its
predominant position of supply of LNG to the US market is still the leading supplier of LNG to North
America. LNG, Methanol and Ammonia are exported to more than 20 countries in Europe, Asia, Africa
and the Americas.
Future Initiatives
Trinidad and Tobago has seen the creation of various highly successful gas based sub-sectors including
LNG, petrochemicals, metal processing and power generation. The next stage of value creation and
development of gas based industry would be built on the earlier accomplishments of the country, as
well as potentially attractive areas.
NATURAL GAS UTILISATION AND PRICING
_______________________________________________________________
7
With the right positioning, Trinidad can be the manufacturing base and the commercial, trans-
shipment and financial hub of the Caribbean and the Americas. Emphasis is therefore being placed on
expanding the country´s trade frontiers and promoting investment in human capital and infrastructure
with the aim of improving overall economic efficiency.
As an example, derivatives of methanol such as formaldehyde, vinyl acetate, methyl methacrylate and
dimethyl ether (DME) can be used to manufacture a host of finished products. Similarly, derivatives of
ammonia include melamine that is used in manufacture of laminates, wood adhesives, paper and
textiles, kitchenware, fire retardant, surface coatings, concrete plasticizers; and UAN used as a source
of fertilizers for plants.
Enhancement of the downstream demand would also be a driver for increased exploration and
production activity in the upstream sector. Conditions have been created whereby companies vie
(through the Competitive Bidding process) for the award of contracts to explore and produce from
hydrocarbon acreages. In evaluating the bids proposed, the Government considers what options will be
in the best overall interest of the country.
The Government has also pursued measures for the improvement of energy efficiency in the natural
gas based industries (with gas being used as both as fuel and feedstock). Having a structured approach
to incorporation of energy efficiency programs in gas based industrial plants will extract much greater
value for every unit of gas that is produced and utilized. In the 2011 Budget, provisions in the form of tax
allowances were made for incentives to companies which institute energy audits, as well as companies
which acquire energy efficient systems.
Encompassing the above energy efficiency programs and other considerations as to what sort of
industries would be the best options for the country, the Government has favoured the impetus for
the award of approvals for projects to be objective assessments using the following criteria:
Criteria for Evaluating Gas Based Projects
Degree of value added in the production process
Environmental impact
Capital expenditure
Early construction plan in terms of utilization of natural gas
Degree of local content
Projection of local content during construction and operation of the plant
Energy efficiency measures
Extent of variation between key terms and conditions of gas contract with NGC
Extent of variation between key terms and conditions of contracts for power and water
Extent of variation between key terms and conditions of estate and pier user contracts with
NEC
Additional benefits including Corporate Social Responsibility(CSR)
NATURAL GAS UTILISATION AND PRICING
_______________________________________________________________
8
The Government has also shown favourable interest in the development of industrial projects such as
the production of inorganic chemicals that have synergies with the local manufacturing sector.
The Carisal calcium chloride/sodium hydroxide project is scheduled to begin construction in 2011, with
an estimated capital cost of US$300 million, and is to be located at the Point Lisas South and East
Industrial Estate. Products from this project include calcium chloride, sodium hydroxide, sodium
hypochlorite, and hydrochloric acid.
The above project would use natural gas mainly as a fuel as opposed to a raw material and may have
relatively smaller requirements for such aspects as plant utilities and land use.
Other chemicals that may be considered for local manufacture include calcium hydroxide, magnesium
chloride, potassium nitrate, potassium chloride, ammonium sulphate, ammonium chloride, sulphuric
acid and hydrogen peroxide.
Local manufacture of these chemicals may provide some degree of stability to volatile global prices and
enable reliable and sustainable supplies for raw materials in the creation of new and innovative
industries for Trinidad and Tobago.
From time to time, the Government has brought together stakeholders providing wide and varied views
on energy related projects from the conceptual stages in order to clearly identify areas for
improvement and to highlight potential synergies that are available. Such stakeholders have been the
state companies for e.g. the National Energy Corporation (NEC), the Ministry of Trade and Industry,
manufacturing and trade associations, project investors, business groups, non-governmental
organisations and financing institutions.
The Government has initiated conferences and seminars with key stakeholders for further discussions
on development of targets markets for new products manufactured in Trinidad. A seminar was held in
November 2010 that brought together the private and public sectors, academia and international
agencies for discussions on the potential of maximizing the downstream utilisation of melamine.
Similar events are anticipated for other new downstream projects to increase awareness and facilitate
access to information and also to encourage potential activities along these new project lines.
The table below shows an analysis of the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats for the
country’s natural gas industry, with the focus on the development of the Downstream Gas Based
Sector.
NATURAL GAS UTILISATION AND PRICING
_______________________________________________________________
9
SWOT Analysis: Natural Gas Industry- development of Downstream Gas Based Sector
Strengths Weaknesses
Well educated and experienced labour force
Good transportation & communication links.
Strong legal system.
Regulated financial system.
Clear fiscal framework for the energy sector.
State agency (NGC) as an aggregator of gas for
supply and transmission.
Ample power generation capacity &
generation. Its proximity to industrial sites.
Existing and planned Ports and Industrial
Estates.
Capacity to produce downstream chemicals- such as 3rd stage chemicals (ammonium nitrate) and 4th stage chemicals (UAN, melamine).
Dependence of economy on energy (accounting for 50% of GDP, more than 80% of exports and about 60% of government revenues) renders the economy highly vulnerable to a downturn in international commodity prices.
Sufficiency of T&T reserves for meeting growing local and international demand for natural gas and gas based chemicals.
Suitable gas pricing along the value chain (e.g. margins, tariffs).
Limited access of third parties to liquefaction facilities.
Barriers to local energy participation (high risk and large capital requirements).
Opportunities Threats
Options for gas-based industries are diverse.
Possible participation of the State along the gas value chain.
Negotiations with Venezuela on development of cross-border fields.
Diversity of export of natural gas to Caribbean
Downturn in international commodity prices.
Potential for adverse gas quality from
increased numbers of gas suppliers.
Fall in upstream and downstream foreign
direct investment (FDI).
NATURAL GAS UTILISATION AND PRICING
_______________________________________________________________
10
and Latin America via pipeline, CNG, LNG or other suitable mechanisms.
Smaller gas-based industries with minimal impact on resources and infrastructure using output from primary chemical production facilities or by developing fully integrated processing plants.
Developing energy efficient industries will
optimize the use of our natural resources.
Expand to other higher value derivative
products such as plastics, iron and steel
products
The Potential for innovation, research and
development.
Increased security of supply of raw materials.
A larger and more diverse contribution to the
country’s GDP
Greater participation of more players in the
energy sector.
Regions with lower production costs of LNG and primary chemicals, e.g. Middle East, could make Trinidad less attractive.
Additional expansion in methanol and
ammonia could negatively impact our leading
position by further weakening the markets
with the addition of greater capacity.
Weaker gas import demand in the US, T&T’s
main LNG customer, owing to increased US
gas shale production.
NATURAL GAS UTILISATION AND PRICING
_______________________________________________________________
11
Questions for Comment/Discussion
The following questions are for consideration:
1. What should be the role of the government in support of programmes to encourage
research and development, technology transfer, skills development and business
incubation in the natural gas based sector?
How can we meet skills gaps?
2. What should be the role of the government in gas sector development?
3. What is the state’s role in mobilization of local financing in support of the natural gas
based industrial sector?
4. What are the clear and distinct roles and responsibilities that the MEEA, NEC and NGC
should have in the implementation of policies in the gas based industrial sector?
5. How should related party transactions, transfer pricing, conflicts of interest, potential
for abuse of monopoly power in the up-, mid- and downstream sectors be handled?
6. What is the current state of competition and opportunities within the country for:
Gas Supply
Gas Transportation
Natural Gas Liquids Extraction
LNG Production
Petrochemical Manufacture e.g. ammonia and methanol
Iron & Steel Manufacture
Power Generation
7. Is the structure of the fiscal system efficient and effective to allow for mechanisms to
encourage activities in the natural gas based sector, and how should the system be
reviewed to address changing external conditions?
8. What is the role, if any, of the reserve-to-production (R/P) ratio as a criterion in the
decision making process for gas allocation?
9. What are the key areas for future downstream development?
NATURAL GAS UTILISATION AND PRICING
_______________________________________________________________
12
10. How should the Criteria for Evaluating Gas Based Projects be weighted and should
there be differences in weighting for different industries?
11. Should there be specific requirements by Government for any Energy Efficiency and
Carbon Emissions Reduction activities/initiatives for the gas based industries?