national study on abs implementation in south africa · 2016-06-20 · national study on abs...

40
National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative in collaboration with the Government of South Africa April 2014

Upload: others

Post on 13-Apr-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa

Commissioned by

the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

in collaboration with

the Government of South Africa

April 2014

Page 2: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

The ABS Capacity Development Initiative, in collaboration with the Governments of Brazil, India and South Africa, commissioned national studies to review each country’s experienc-es with Access and Benefit Sharing. Lessons learned from these experiences will inform the global implementation of the Nagoya Protocol on Access to Genetic Resources and the Fair and Equitable Sharing of Benefits Arising from its Utilization (Nagoya Protocol). These studies were prepared to provide background information in preparation for the first Dia-logue on Practical Ways Forward for the Implementation of the Nagoya Protocol, hosted by the Government of South Africa on 30-31 January 2014 in Cape Town, South Africa and the second Dialogue on the same topic, co-organized with the Ministry of Environment and Forests of India, from 4-6 August 2014 in Goa, India. The study was carried out by Sustento.

Page 3: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

�-589A6/.1/7/8>=

� .?<��<G8IKD<EK�F=� EM@IFED<EK8C��==8@IJ��� �

• �I�(FJ:FN�(8ILDF

• '8:K@K@8�.J?@KN8DLCFDFE@

• �8I@E8�(8C?<I9<

• "I8:<�(9LC<

� .?<��<G8IKD<EK�F=��>I@:LCKLI<�!FI<JKJ�8E;�!@J?<I@<J����!!

• �I�%LC@8E�%8G?K8

� .?<��<G8IKD<EK�F=�-:@<E:<�8E;�.<:?EFCF>P���-.

• .FD�-L:?8E8E;8E

Page 4: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

�3=>�90��,,</@3+>398=

��- �::<JJ�8E;��<E<=@K�-?8I@E>

���- �@FGIFJG<:K@E>��::<JJ����<E<=@K�-?8I@E>

�-� �<E<=@K�-?8I@E>��>I<<D<EK

��� �FEM<EK@FE FE �@FCF>@:8C��@M<IJ@KP

�$. - �FEM<EK@FE� FE� $EK<IE8K@FE8C� .I8;<� @E� E;8E><I<;� -G<:@<J F=�N@C;� =CFI8� 8E;

=8LE8

��!! �<G8IKD<EK�F=��>I@:LCKLI<�!FI<JKIP�8E;�!@J?<I@<J

� � �<G8IKD<EK�F=� EM@IFED<EK8C �==8@IJ

�-. �<G8IKD<EK�F=�-:@<E:<�8E;�.<:?EFCF>P

�.$ �<G8IKD<EK�F=�.I8;<�8E;�$E;LJKIP

$�, $E;@><EFLJ��@FCF>@:8C�,<JFLI:<J

$&- $E;@><EFLJ�&EFNC<;><�-PJK<DJ

$.+",!� $EK<IE8K@FE8C�.I<8KP�FE�+C8EK�"<E<K@:�,<JFLI:<J�=FI�!FF;�8E;��>I@:LCKLI<

'((� '@B<�(@E;<;�(<>8��@M<IJ<��FLEKI@<J

(�. (LKL8CCP��>I<<;�.<IDJ

( � (<D9<I�F=� O<:LK@M<��FDD@KK<<

('- (LCK@C8K<I8C�-PJK<D

(.� (8K<I@8C�.I8EJ=<I��>I<<D<EK

) (� )8K@FE8C� EM@IFED<EK8C�(8E8><D<EK��:K

) (�� )8K@FE8C� EM@IFED<EK8C�(8E8><D<EK���@F;@M<IJ@KP��:K

+$� +I@FI�$E=FID<;��FEJ<EK

.& .I8;@K@FE8C�&EFNC<;><

.*+- .?I<8K<E<;�FI�+IFK<:K<;�-G<:@<J

Page 5: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

Table of Contents.89C<�F=��FEK<EKJ�������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

�� $).,*�/�.$*)��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

��� �8:B>IFLE; ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

� �%�! ����#���(!#� ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

� "#!'���#$�!���� �%���#�$!&#��$ ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

�� &$�#$�!���� �%���#�$!&#��$� ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

�� ��$���#���� %$ ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

� ��)���$$! $����# ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

�� , ! , )� - ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

�� �++ )�$2����+,*� --�!'*1��$�",�(- ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

�� �++ )�$2���� 2+'�)�.*,3�)*. �������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

Page 6: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

1. INTRODUCTION-FLK?��=I@:8� @J�I@:?�N@K?�E8KLI8C�I<JFLI:<J� @K�9<@E>�K?<�K?@I;���

I;�DFJK�9@FCF>@:8CCP�;@M<IJ<

:FLEKIP� =FCCFN@E>� $E;FE<J@8� 8E;� �I8Q@C N@K?� 8� ?@>?� @E:@;<E:<� F=� <E;<D@:� JG<:@<J 8E;� @J� 8

D<D9<I�F=�K?<�'@B<�(@E;<;�(<>8��@M<IJ<��FLEKI@<J��'((�� $K�I<GI<J<EKJ�89FLK����F=�K?<

NFIC;UJ�C8E;D8JJ�8E;�?8J�����F=�K?<�NFIC;UJ�GC8EKJ����F=�8CC�D8DD8CJ�9@I;J�8E;�I<GK@C<J

8E;�����F=�8CC�BEFNE�D8I@E<�JG<:@<J� $EK<IE8K@FE8C�8E;�CF:8C�KI8;<�@E�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J

?8J�C<;�KF�8E�@E:I<8J<�@E�K?<�LK@C@J8K@FE�F=�8�M8CL89C<�9LK�C@D@K<;�I<JFLI:<�@E�-FLK?��=I@:8���$E

8;;@K@FE�K?<I<�?8J�9<<E�8�>IFN@E> :FE:<IE�K?8K�?FC;<IJ�F=�K?<�KI8;@K@FE8C�BEFNC<;><�F=�K?<

LJ<=LC�GIFG<IK@<J�F=�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�8I<�EFK�I<:F>E@J<;�8E;�F=K<E�;F�EFK�9<E<=@K�=IFD

K?<� :FDD<I:@8C� LK@C@Q8K@FE� F=� JL:?� I<JFLI:<J�� � �J� 8� I<JLCK� 8� ELD9<I� F=� @EK<IE8K@FE8C� 8E;

E8K@FE8C� GFC@:@<J� C8NJ� 8E;� I<>LC8K@FEJ� ?8M<� 9<<E� @EKIF;L:<;� KF� I<;I<JJ� @E<HL8C@KP� @E� K?<

:FDD<I:@8C�LK@C@Q8K@FE�F=�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J���-FLK?��=I@:8�?8J�D8;<�J@>E@=@:8EK�GIF>I<JJ�@E

;<M<CFG@E>� K?<� GFC@:P� 8E;� C<>@JC8K@M<� @EJKILD<EKJ� E<:<JJ8IP� KF� >L@;<� 8E;� I<>LC8K<� K?<

:FDD<I:@8C� FI� @E;LJKI@8C� <OGCF@K8K@FE F=� @E;@><EFLJ� 9@FCF>@:8C ><E<K@:� I<JFLI:<J 8E; FI

8JJF:@8K<;�KI8;@K@FE8C�BEFNC<;><� =FI�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�8E; FI�9@FKI8;<� @E�K?<�:FLEKIP�9LK� @J

=8:<;�N@K?�:?8CC<E><J�N@K?�K?<�8GGC@:8K@FE�8E;�@DGC<D<EK8K@FE�F=�K?<J<�@EJKILD<EKJ�N?@C<

8K�K?<�J8D<�K@D<�JK@DLC8K@E>�K?<�>IFNK?�F=�K?@J�<:FEFD@:�JL9�J<:KFI�@E�K?<�:FLEKIP�

*E<�F=� K?<� @EK<IE8K@FE8C� @EJKILD<EKJ� KF� I<>LC8K<� K?<�LK@C@Q8K@FE�F=� ><E<K@:� I<JFLI:<� @J� K?<

)8>FP8� +IFKF:FC� FE� �::<JJ� KF� "<E<K@:� ,<JFLI:<J� 8E;� K?<� !8@I� 8E;� HL@K89C<� -?8I@E>� F=

�<E<=@KJ� �I@J@E>� =IFD� K?<@I� /K@C@Q8K@FE� KF� K?<� �FEM<EK@FE� FE� �@FCF>@:8C� �@M<IJ@KP� �@E� J?FIK

I<=<II<;�KF�8J�V.?<�)8>FP8�+IFKF:FC�FE���-W FI�VK?<�)8>FP8�+IFKF:FCW N?@:?�N8J�8;FGK<;

@E������8K� K?<���K?D<<K@E>�F=� K?<��FE=<I<E:<�F=� K?<�+8IK@<J� KF� K?<��FEM<EK@FE��@FCF>@:8C

�@M<IJ@KP� ������ $K� J<KJ� @E�GC8:<� 8� C<>8CCP�9@E;@E>� 8>I<<D<EK� JG<:@=@:� KF��::<JJ� 8E;��<E<=@K

-?8I@E>� ���-�� � -FLK?��=I@:8� @J� FE<� F=� K?<� :FEKI8:K@E>� G8IK@<J� KF� K?<� ���� 8E;� K?<�)8>FP8

+IFKF:FC� FE� ��- 8E;� ?8J� GIFDLC>8K<;� 8E;� @DGC<D<EK<;� C<>@JC8K@FE� KF� I<>LC8K<

9@FGIFJG<:K@E>� 8::<JJ� 8E;� 9<E<=@K�J?8I@E>� 8:K@M@K@<J <M<E 9<=FI<� K?<� 8;FGK@FE� F=� K?<

)8>FP8�+IFKF:FC�FE���-���@E�8::FI;8E:<�N@K? K?< F9C@>8K@FEJ 8J�GIFM@;<;�@E�K?<����� -FLK?

�=I@:8�I8K@=@<;�K?<�)8>FP8�+IFKF:FC�@E�%8EL8IP������

.?<� )8>FP8� +IFKF:FC ?8J J<K� FLK� :FI<� F9C@>8K@FEJ� =FI� @KJ� :FEKI8:K@E>� +8IK@<J� KF� K8B<

8GGIFGI@8K<� D<8JLI<J� I<C8K<;� KF� 8::<JJ� KF� ><E<K@:� I<JFLI:<J� 9<E<=@K�J?8I@E>� 8E;

Page 7: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

:FDGC@8E:<��(<8JLI<J�K?8K�FL>?K�KF�9<�GLK�@E�GC8:<�=FI�K?<�<==<:K@M<�@DGC<D<EK8K@FE�F=�K?@J

+IFKF:FC�@E:CL;<�8DFE>JK�FK?<IJ��<JK89C@J?@E>�:C<8I�ILC<J�8E;�GIF:<;LI<J�=FI�GI@FI�@E=FID<;

:FEJ<EK�8E;�DLKL8CCP�8>I<<;�K<IDJ�<EJLI@E>�K?8K�9<E<=@K�J?8I@E>�D<8JLI<J�GLK�@E�GC8:<�;F

GIFM@;<�=FI�K?<�=8@I�8E;�<HL@K89C<�J?8I@E>�F=�9<E<=@KJ�8I@J@E>�=IFD�K?<�LK@C@Q8K@FE�F=�><E<K@:

I<JFLI:<J� N@K?� K?<� :FEKI8:K@E>� G8IKP� GIFM@;@E>� ><E<K@:� I<JFLI:<J� 8E;� 8CJF� <EJLI@E>� K?8K

8GGIFGI@8K<�F9C@>8K@FEJ�K?8K�JLGGFIK�:FDGC@8E:<�N@K?�K?<�;FD<JK@:�C<>@JC8K@FE�FI�I<>LC8KFIP

I<HL@I<D<EKJ�F=�K?<�:FEKI8:K@E>�G8IKP�GIFM@;@E>�><E<K@:�I<JFLI:<J�8I<�JG<CK�FLK�

��� �����#!& �

.?< V��-� �8G8:@KP� �<M<CFGD<EK� $E@K@8K@M<W ?8J� @E@K@8K<;� JKL;@<J� KF� I<M@<N� K?<� E8K@FE8C

<OG<I@<E:<�F=��I8Q@C�$E;@8�8E;�-FLK?��=I@:8�I<JG<:K@M<CP�N@K?�I<JG<:K�KF���-�@DGC<D<EK8K@FE

@E� FI;<I� KF� ;I8N� C<JJFEJ� K?8K� :8E� @E=FID� K?<� ;<M<CFGD<EK� F=� E8K@FE8C� D<8JLI<J� @E

:FE=FID@KP N@K?�K?<�)8>FP8�+IFKF:FC�FE���-�

)8K@FE8C� JKL;@<J�8I<� KF�9<�:8II@<;�FLK�9P�E8K@FE8C� :FEJLCK8EKJ� @E�<8:?�:FLEKIP� @E�FI;<I� KF

<O8D@E<� N?8K� @J� K?<� ��-� =I8D<NFIB� @E� GC8:<� N?8K� N<I<� C<JJFEJ� C<8IE<;� =IFD� K?<@I

@DGC<D<EK8K@FE�8E;�?FN�K?<J<�C<JJFEJ�:8E�9<�K8B<E @EKF�8::FLEK�@E�K?<�@DGC<D<EK8K@FE�F=

K?<�)8>FP8�+IFKF:FC�FE���-� �� � 8:?�F=� K?<� K?I<<� JKL;@<J� @J� KF�GIFM@;<�8E�FM<IM@<N�F=� K?<

<O@JK@E>���-�=I8D<NFIBJ�@E�GC8:<�8K�K?<�:FLEKIP� C<M<C�8E;�K?@J�I<GFIK�J<<BJ�KF�8;;I<JJ�K?<

-FLK?��=I@:8E�G<IJG<:K@M<� @E� I<JGFEJ< KF� K?<�J<K�HL<JK@FEJ GIFM@;<;�9P K?< V��-��8G8:@KP

�<M<CFGD<EK�$E@K@8K@M<W�

Page 8: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

2. NATIONAL FRAMEWORK(29�+</�>2/

-97:/>/8>�8+>398+6

+?>29<3>3/=�

.?<�(@E@JK<I�F=�18K<I�8E;� EM@IFED<EK8C��==8@IJ�8E;�K?LJ�K?<�E8K@FE8C��<G8IKD<EK�F=� EM@IFED<EK8C��==8@IJ �� ��8J

K?<�<EM@IFED<EK8C�I<>LC8KFI�@E�K?<�:FLEKIP�@J�K?< :FDG<K<EK�E8K@FE8C�8LK?FI@KP�

.?<�(@E@JK<I�F=�18K<I�8E;� EM@IFED<EK8C��==8@IJ�@J�K?< @JJL@E>�8LK?FI@KP�=FI��8�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�G<ID@KJ�@E�K?<�:FLEKIP

8E;��9�@EK<>I8K<;�<OGFIK�8E;�9@FGIFJG<:K@E> G<ID@KJ�@=�K?<�@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�8I<�9<@E>�<OGFIK<;�=FI�K?<

GLIGFJ<J�F=�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�

.?<� I<JG<:K@M<� GIFM@E:@8C� (<D9<I� F=� O<:LK@M<� �FDD@KK<<� �( �� @J� K?<� @JJL@E>� 8LK?FI@KP� =FI� <OGFIK� G<ID@KJ F=

@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�=FI�GLIGFJ<J F=�I<J<8I:?�FK?<I�K?8E�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�

�=�>2/</�98/�9<

79</�

.?<�� ��@J�K?<�FECP�:FDG<K<EK�E8K@FE8C�8LK?FI@KP�

#FN<M<I� @K� @J� @DGFIK8EK� KF� EFK<� K?8K� 8::FI;@E>� KF� K?<� �FEJK@KLK@FE� F=� -FLK?� �=I@:8� E8KLI<� :FEJ<IM8K@FE� �<O:CL;@E>

E8K@FE8C�G8IBJ�E8K@FE8C 9FK8E@:8C�>8I;<EJ�8E;�D8I@E<�I<JFLI:<J�8I<�8�:FE:LII<EK�E8K@FE8C�8E;�GIFM@E:@8C�:FDG<K<E:<

@E� K?<�:FLEKIP��08I@FLJ�>FM<IED<EK�;<G8IKD<EKJ�8I<� @EMFCM<;� @E�8;D@E@JK<I@E>�G8IK@:LC8I� C8NJ�N?@:?� I<>LC8K<���-� @E

-FLK?��=I@:8��.?<��<G8IKD<EK�F=� EM@IFED<EK8C��==8@IJ�8E;�GIFM@E:@8C�<EM@IFED<EK�8E;�:FEJ<IM8K@FE�;<G8IKD<EKJ�8I<

K?<�I<JGFEJ@9C<�@EJK@KLK<J�=FI�I<>LC8K@FE�8E;�@DGC<D<EK8K@FE�F=�<EM@IFED<EK8C�C<>@JC8K@M<�@DG<I8K@M<J��.?<��<G8IKD<EK

F=�.I8;<�8E;� $E;LJKIP���.$� @J�K?<�I<JGFEJ@9C<� @EJK@KLK<�=FI�I<>LC8K@FE�8E;� @DGC<D<EK8K@FE�F=�K?<� @EK<CC<:KL8C�GIFG<IKP

I@>?KJ� C<>@JC8K@M<�@DG<I8K@M<J�8E;�K?<��<G8IKD<EK�F=�-:@<E:<�8E;�.<:?EFCF>P���-.� @J�K?<�I<JGFEJ@9C<� @EJK@KLK<�=FI�K?<

GIFK<:K@FE�GIFDFK@FE�;<M<CFGD<EK�8E;�D8E8><D<EK�F=�$E;@><EFLJ�&EFNC<;><�-PJK<DJ��$&-�K?IFL>?�K?<�$&-�+FC@:P�

�9A�A/</�>2/C

/=>+,63=2/.�

.?<�"FM<IED<EK� F=� -FLK?� �=I@:8� @J� 8� K?I<< R K@<I� JPJK<D� :FEJK@KLK@E>� F=� K?<�)8K@FE8C� +IFM@E:@8C� 8E;� 'F:8C� C<M<CJ� F=

"FM<IED<EK� 8CC� ?8M@E>� C<>@JC8K@M<� 8E;� <O<:LK@M<� 8LK?FI@KP� @E� K?<@I� JG?<I<J�� .?<� �FEJK@KLK@FE� F=� -FLK?� �=I@:8� ;<=@E<J

K?<D� 8J� 9<@E> �;@JK@E:K@M<� @EK<I;<G<E;<EK� 8E;� @EK<II<C8K<;�� 8E;� K?<� "FM<IED<EK� JPJK<D� I<:F>E@J<J� .I8;@K@FE8C

�LK?FI@K@<J�� �.?<�)8K@FE8C��FDG<K<EK��LK?FI@KP�N8J�<JK89C@J?<;�K?IFL>?�K?<�GIFDLC>8K@FE�F=�)8K@FE8C� EM@IFED<EK8C

(8E8><D<EK���@F;@M<IJ@KP��:K��) (���

Page 9: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

.?<� )8K@FE8C� "FM<IED<EK� F=� -FLK?� �=I@:8� @J� :FDGI@J<;� F=� +8IC@8D<EK� �89@E<K� 8E;� M8I@FLJ� �<G8IKD<EKJ�� .?<J<

:FDGFE<EKJ� :8IIP� FLK� =LE:K@FEJ� 8J� FLKC@E<;� @E� K?<� �FEJK@KLK@FE� 8E;� @E� C<>@JC8K@FE� <E8:K<;� 9P� +8IC@8D<EK�� .?<

�<G8IKD<EKJ� K?8K� D8B<� LG� K?<� E8K@FE8C� 8;D@E@JKI8K@FE� 8I<� :?8I><;� N@K?� @DGC<D<EK@E>� C<>@JC8K@FE� 8E;� GIFM@;@E>

J<IM@:<J�KF�K?<�GL9C@:�

(2+>�3=�>2/�=-9:/

90�>2/�7/+=?</=�38

:6+-/�

.?<� )8K@FE8C� EM@IFED<EK8C�(8E8><D<EK�� �@F;@M<IJ@KP� �:K� ����� ��:K� � )F�� ��� F=� ����� �) (��� N?@:? <E8:KJ K?<

1?@K<�+8G<I�FE�K?<��FEJ<IM8K@FE�8E;�-LJK8@E89C<�/J<�F=�-FLK?��=I@:8UJ��@FCF>@:8C��@M<IJ@KP�@J�K?<�C<>@JC8K@M<�@EJKILD<EK

N?@:?�>FM<IEJ�K?<�9@FGIFJG<:K@E> 8E;�K?<�LJ<�F=� @E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J� @E K?<�:FLEKIP�� � �.?<��:K <==<:K@M<CP

J<KJ�FLK�-FLK?��=I@:8UJ�;FD<JK@:�F9A<:K@M<J�KF�8;;I<JJ�K?< F9C@>8K@FEJ�F=�K?< �FEM<EK@FE�FE��@FCF>@:8C��@M<IJ@KP�����G8IK

=IFD�GIFM@;@E>�B<P�;<=@E@K@FEJ�F=�K?<�:FDGFE<EKJ�8;;I<JJ<;�9P�K?<��:K�@K�8CJF�GIFM@;<J�KNF�:IL:@8C��9LK�EFK�FECP�K?<J<

:FDGFE<EKJ� KF� K?<� 9@FGIFJG<:K@E>� J<:KFI� E8D<CP�� �@� K?8K� K?<� JK8K<� @J� K?<� KILJK<<� F=� K?<� 9@FCF>@:8C� ;@M<IJ@KP� � @E� K?<

:FLEKIP� N@K?� K?<� JK8K<� 8JJLD@E>� I<JGFEJ@9@C@KP� KF� D8E8><� :FEJ<IM<� 8E;� JLJK8@E� -FLK?� �=I@:8UJ� 9@F;@M<IJ@KP� 8E;� @KJ

:FDGFE<EKJ�8E;�><E<K@: I<JFLI:<J���@@�8E;�K?<���-�C<>8C�=I8D<NFIB�=FI�-FLK?��=I@:8�N?@:?�@J�:FEK8@E<;�@E��?8GK<I���F=

K?<��:K�N@K?�K?<�F9A<:K@M<��8�KF�I<>LC8K<�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�@EMFCM@E>�@E;@><EFLJ�><E<K@:�8E;��9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J����9�KF

I<>LC8K<�K?<�<OGFIK�=IFD�K?<�,<GL9C@:�F=�@E;@><EFLJ�><E<K@:�8E;�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�=FI�K?<�GLIGFJ<�F=�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>

FI�8EP�FK?<I�B@E;�F=�I<J<8I:?��8E;��:�KF�GIFM@;<�=FI�8�=8@I�8E;�<HL@K89C<�J?8I@E>�9P�JK8B<?FC;<IJ�@E�9<E<=@KJ�8I@J@E>�=IFD

9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�@EMFCM@E>�@E;@><EFLJ�><E<K@:�8E; 9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J��8E;��;�KF�<EJLI<�K?<�E8K@FEUJ�@E;@><EFLJ�><E<K@:

8E;� 9@FCF>@:8C� I<JFLI:<J� 8I<� ;<M<CFG<;� 8E;� LK@C@J<;� @E� 8� JLJK8@E89C<� D8EE<I� N?@C<� GIFDFK@E>� JF:@8C� 8E;� <:FEFD@:

;<M<CFGD<EK�@E�G8IK@:LC8I�@E�K?<�8I<8�N?<I<�K?<�@E;@><EFLJ�><E<K@:�FI�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<�8E;�KI8;@K@FE8C�BEFNC<;><�@J

8::<JJ<;�

(29�9A8=�1/8/>3-

</=9?<-/=�38�>2/

-9?8><C��(29�9A8=

,396913-+6

</=9?<-/=�

�<JG@K<�K?<�-K8K<�9<@E>�K?<�KILJK<<�F=�9@FCF>@:8C�;@M<IJ@KP�@E�K?<�:FLEKIP�C<>@JC8K@FE�;F<J�EFK�M<JK�FNE<IJ?@G�F=�><E<K@:

I<JFLI:<J�@E�K?<�JK8K<�LEC<JJ�K?<P�F::LI�FE�JK8K<�C8E;��.?<�C8E;FNE<I�@E�-FLK?��=I@:8�@E�K<IDJ�F=�:FDDFE�C8N�FNEJ

9FK?�K?<�9@FCF>@:8C�8E;�K?<�><E<K@:�I<JFLI:<J�FE�FI�LE;<I�?@J ?<I�GIFG<IKP�

�=�+--/==�>9�1/8/>3-

</=9?<-/=�9<

.?<��:K�FLKC@E<J�K?8K�K?<�:FDD<I:@8C@J8K@FE��G?8J<�F=�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�D8P�FECP�K8B<�GC8:<�JL9A<:K�KF�K?<�>I8EK@E>�F=�8

G<ID@K�N?@:?�N@CC�FECP�9<�>I8EK<;�@=�K?<�@EK<I<JKJ�8I<�GIFK<:K<;�F=���@ -K8B<?FC;<IJ�N?@:?�@J�GIFM@;@E>�FI�>@M@E>�8::<JJ

Page 10: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

?>363D+>398�90

1/8/>3-�</=9?<-/=

./038/.��(2+>

+->3@3>3/=�+</

-9@/</.�,C���$

</;?3</7/8>=�

KF�K?<�@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�KF�N?@:?�K?<�8GGC@:8K@FE�I<C8K<J��8E;��@@�8E�@E;@><EFLJ�:FDDLE@KP��FI�@E;@M@;L8CJ�

@��N?FJ<� KI8;@K@FE8C�LJ<J�F=� K?<� @E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C� I<JFLI:<J� KF�N?@:?� K?<�8GGC@:8K@FE�I<C8K<J�?8M<� @E@K@8K<;�FI�N@CC

:FEKI@9LK<�KF�FI�=FID�G8IK�F=�GIFGFJ<;�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>��FI�@@��N?FJ<�BEFNC<;><�F=�FI�;@J:FM<I@<J�89FLK�K?<�@E;@><EFLJ

9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�KF�N?@:?�K?<�8GGC@:8K@FE�I<C8K<J�8I<�KF�9<�LJ<;�=FI�K?<�GIFGFJ<;�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>� .?<��:K�D8E;8K<J

K?8K�8�G<ID@K�8GGC@:8EK�DLJK�;@J:CFJ<�8CC�D8K<I@8C�@E=FID8K@FE�8E;�F9K8@E�GI@FI @E=FID<; :FEJ<EK�=IFD�K?<�JK8B<?FC;<I

GIFM@;@E>�FI�>@M@E>�8::<JJ�KF�K?<�@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<��9LCC<K�8�89FM<�9P�<EK<I@E>�@EKF���8�8�D8K<I@8C�KI8EJ=<I

8>I<<D<EK��(.��K?8K�I<>LC8K<J�K?<�GIFM@J@FE�F=�FI�8::<JJ�KF�JL:?�I<JFLI:<J��8E;��9�8�9<E<=@K�J?8I@E>�8>I<<D<EK���-�

K?8K�GIFM@;<J�=FI�J?8I@E>�9P�K?<�JK8B<?FC;<I�@E�8EP�=LKLI<�9<E<=@KJ�K?8K�D8P�9<�;<I@M<;�=IFD�K?<�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>��$E�K?<

:8J<�F=�KI8;@K@FE8C�LJ<�BEFNC<;><�FI�;@J:FM<I@<J��9LCC<K�9�89FM<�K?<�G<ID@K�8GGC@:8K@FE�DLJK��8��;@J:CFJ<�8CC�D8K<I@8C

@E=FID8K@FE� 8E;� F9K8@E� � GI@FI� :FEJ<EK F=� K?<� @E;@><EFLJ� :FDDLE@KP� FI� @E;@M@;L8CJ� KF� LJ<� 8EP� F=� K?<@I� KI8;@K@FE8C

BEFNC<;><�F=�FI�;@J:FM<I@<J�89FLK K?<�@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�=FI�K?<�GIFGFJ<;�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>��9��<EK<I�@EKF�8

9<E<=@K�J?8I@E>� 8>I<<D<EK� ��-�� K?8K� GIFM@;<J� =FI� J?8I@E>� 9P� K?<� JK8B<?FC;<IJ� @E� 8EP� =LKLI<� 9<E<=@KJ� K?8K� D8P� 9<

;<I@M<;�=IFD�K?<�I<C<M8EK�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>���<E<=@K�J?8I@E> 8>I<<D<EKJ�DLJK�K?LJ�9<�<EK<I<;�@EKF�N@K?�9FK?�:8K<>FI@<J

F=�JK8B<?FC;<IJ�8E;�@E�8;;@K@FE�8�D8K<I@8C�KI8EJ=<I�8>I<<D<EK��(.��DLJK�9<�<EK<I<;�@EKF�N@K?�JK8B<?FC;<IJ�N?F�>@M<

8::<JJ� KF� K?<� @E;@><EFLJ� 9@FCF>@:8C� I<JFLI:<J�� .?<� �:K� 8CJF�D8E;8K<J� @E:CLJ@FEJ I<HL@I<;� @E� 9FK?� �-�J� 8E;�(.�J� @E

-FLK?��=I@:8��$=�@K�?8J�EFK�9<<E�GFJJ@9C<�KF�:FE:CL;<�JL:?�8>I<<D<EKJ�8�I<HL<JK�=FI�K?<�@EK<IM<EK@FE�F=�.?<�(@E@JK<I�=FI

K?<�GLIGFJ<J�F=�E<>FK@8K@E>�JL:?�8>I<<D<EKJ�@J�GIFG89C<�@E�8::FI;8E:<�N@K?�-<:K@FE����F=�K?<��:K��-<:K@FE����F=�K?<��:K

8CJF� FLKC@E<J� K?<� J<KK@E>� LG� F=� 8� �@FGIFJG<:K@E>� .ILJK� !LE;� @EKF�N?@:?� 9<E<=@K� J?8I@E>� 8>I<<D<EK�DFE<P�NFLC;� 9<

;<GFJ@K<;� =FI� G8PD<EK� KF� 8CC� 8GGIFGI@8K<� 9<E<=@:@8I@<J�� !@E8CCP� �?8GK<I� �� F=� K?<� �:K� FLKC@E<J� +<ID@K� GIF:<JJ<J� =FI

9@F;@M<IJ@KP�@E�K?<�:FLEKIP���::<JJ�8E;��<E<=@K�-?8I@E>����-�C<>@JC8K@FE�?8J�K?LJ�9<<E�CFE>�@E�FG<I8K@FE�@E�K?<�:FLEKIP

N@K?� K?<� B<P� F9A<:K@M<�F=� K?<� =8@I� 8E;� <HL@K89C<� J?8I@E>� 8DFE>� JK8B<?FC;<IJ� F=� 9<E<=@KJ� 8I@J@E>� =IFD�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>

@EMFCM@E> 8EP�@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C ><E<K@:�I<JFLI:< 8E; FI�8JJF:@8K<;�.I8;@K@FE8C�&EFNC<;><�

�9A�+</�38.31/89?=

+8.�69-+6

-977?83>3/=�+8.

><+.3>398+6

.?< ���-�,<>LC8K@FEJ�;<=@E<� @E;@><EFLJ�:FDDLE@KP�8J�8EP�:FDDLE@KP�F=�G<FGC<� C@M@E>�FI�?8M@E>�FI�?8M@E>� I@>?KJ FI

@EK<I<JKJ� @E�8�;@JK@E:K�><F>I8G?@:8C�8I<8�N@K?@E�K?<�,<GL9C@:�F=�-FLK?��=I@:8�N@K?�8� C<8;<IJ?@G�JKIL:KLI<�8E;��8�N?FJ<

KI8;@K@FE8C�LJ<�F=�K?<�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�KF�N?@:?�8E�8GGC@:8K@FE�=FI�8�G<ID@K�I<C8K<J�?8M<�@E@K@8K<;�FI�N@CC�:FEKI@9LK<

KF�FI�=FID�G8IK�F=�K?<�GIFGFJ<;�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>��FI��9�N?FJ<�BEFNC<;><�FI�;@J:FM<I@<J�89FLK�K?<�@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C

Page 11: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

589A6/.1/

./038/.�

I<JFLI:<J�KF�N?@:?�8E�8GGC@:8K@FE�=FI�8�G<ID@K�I<C8K<J�8I<�KF�9<�LJ<;�=FI�K?<�GIFGFJ<;�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>��.?@J� @J�=LIK?<I

GIFEFLE:<;� @E� K?<� +IFK<:K@FE� +IFDFK@FE� ;<M<CFGD<EK� 8E;�D8E8><D<EK� F=� @E;@><EFLJ� BEFNC<;><� JPJK<DJ� �@CC� 8J

@E;@><EFLJ�:FDDLE@K@<J�8I<�;<=@E<;�8J� :FDDLE@K@<J� @E� K?<�,<GL9C@:�F=� -FLK?��=I@:8�N?F�8I<� I<>8I;<;�8J��=I@:8E�FE

8::FLEK�F=�K?<@I�;<J:<EK�=IFD�GFGLC8K@FE�N?@:?�@E?89@K<;�K?< ,<GL9C@:�FI�K?<�><F>I8G?@:8C�I<>@FE�KF�N?@:?�K?<�,<GL9C@:

9<CFE><;�8K�K?<�K@D<�F=�:FCFE@J8K@FE�8E;�N?F�@II<JG<:K@M<�F=�K?<@I�C<>8C�JK8KLJ�I<K8@E�JFD<�FI�8CC�F=�K?<@I�FNE�JF:@8C

<:FEFD@:�:LCKLI8C�8E;�GFC@K@:8C�@EJK@KLK@FEJ�@E:CL;@E>�K?<��=I@:8E�?LD8E�GFGLC8K@FE�@E�8�;@JK@E:K�><F>I8G?@:8C�8I<8�N@K?

FNE<IJ?@G� FM<I� @KJ� @E;@><EFLJ� BEFNC<;><� >FM<IE<;� G8IK@8CCP� FI� :FDGC<K<CP� 9P� @KJ� FNE� :LJKFDJ� KI8;@K@FEJ� FI� C8NJ�

.I8;@K@FE8C�LJ<�FI�BEFNC<;><�8J�JK@GLC8K<;�@E�K?<����-�,<>LC8K@FEJ�I<=<IJ�KF�K?<�:LJKFD8IP�LK@C@J8K@FE�FI�BEFNC<;><�F=

@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C� I<JFLI:<J�9P� 8E� @E;@><EFLJ� :FDDLE@KP� @E� 8::FI;8E:<�N@K?�NI@KK<E�FI�LENI@KK<E� ILC<J� LJ8><J

:LJKFDJ� FI� GI8:K@:<J� KI8;@K@FE8CCP� F9J<IM<;� 8::<GK<;� 8E;� I<:F>E@J<;� 9P� K?<D� 8E� @E:CL;<J� ;@J:FM<I@<J� 89FLK� K?<

I<C<M8EK�@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�9P�K?8K�:FDDLE@KP�

(29�9A8=

><+.3>398+6

589A6/.1/���9A�3=

><+.3>398+6

589A6/.1/�09?8.�38

>2/�:?,63-�.97+38

�/�1��:?,63-+>398=�

+..</==/.�

$E;@><EFLJ�BEFNC<;><�?FC;<IJ�8E;�@E;@><EFLJ�BEFNC<;><�GI8:K@K@FE<IJ�8I<�K?<�:LJKF;@8EJ�F=�K?<�@E;@><EFLJ�I<JFLI:<J

@E�8::FI;8E:<�N@K?�:LJKFD8IP�C8N�8E;�GI8:K@:<J�F=�K?<@I�G8IK@:LC8I�:FDDLE@KP�FI�@E;@><EFLJ�:FDDLE@KP�8J�@E;@M@;L8CJ

=8D@C@<J� FI� JF:@<K8C� >IFLG� I<GI<J<EK8K@M<� F=� K?<� G8IK@:LC8I� :FDDLE@KP�� .I8;@K@FE8C� &EFNC<;><� @J� =FLE; @E� K?<� GL9C@:

;FD8@E�@E�M8I@FLJ�N8PJ��+<FGC<�:8E�9<�D8;<�8N8I<�M@8�9FFBJ�8IK@:C<J�D<;@8�FI�@EK<I8:K@FEJ�N@K?�:FDDLE@KP�D<D9<IJ

FI�JFD<K@D<J�K?<�BEFNC<;><�@J�:FDDFECP�BEFNE�FI�N@;<CP�J?8I<;�8DFE>�8�ELD9<I�F=�@E;@><EFLJ�:FDDLE@K@<J�8E;�@J

K?<I<=FI<� @E� K?< GL9C@:�;FD8@E��#FN<M<I� @E� K?<J<�:8J<J� @E;@><EFLJ�:FDDLE@K@<J� JK@CC�?8M<� I@>?KJ�FM<I� K?<� KI8;@K@FE8C

BEFNC<;><�9<:8LJ<�K?<I<�@J�:FDDFE�LE;<IJK8E;@E>�K?8K�8�JG<:@=@:�:FDDLE@KP�;@J:FM<I<;�FI�;<M<CFG<;�K?@J�BEFNC<;><�

*E�K?<�FK?<I�<E;�-� K?IFL>?�@KJ��<G8IKD<EK�F=�-:@<E:<�8E;�.<:?EFCF>P ?8J�;<M<CFG<;�K?<�)8K@FE8C�,<:FI;8C�-PJK<D

N?@:?�I<:FI;J�8E;�;F:LD<EKJ�@E;@><EFLJ�BEFNC<;><��F=�@E;@><EFLJ�8E;�CF:8C�:FDDLE@K@<J 8JJF:@8K<;�N@K?�@E;@><EFLJ

9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�

(2+>�>C:/=�90

7/+=?</=�A/</

+.9:>/.�+8.

37:6/7/8>/.�

"963-C��6/13=6+>398�

-FLK?� �=I@:8� ?8J� C<>@K@D@J<;� <EM@IFED<EK8C� GFC@:P� GI@E:@GC<J� K?IFL>?� K?<� GIFDLC>8K@FEJ� F=� 8� JL@K<� F=� <EM@IFED<EK8C

C<>@JC8K@FE�9<KN<<E������8E;��������.?<�)8K@FE8C� EM@IFED<EK8C�(8E8><D<EK��:K��������:K�)F������F=�������) (�

@J�:8K<>FI@J<;�8J K?< =I8D<NFIB�C<>@JC8K@FE�8J�@K�;<=@E<J�K?<�FM<I8I:?@E>�8E;�><E<I@:�GI@E:@GC<J�@E�N?@:?�<EM@IFED<EK8C

C<>@JC8K@FE� @E� -FLK?� �=I@:8� @J� <D9<;;<;�� .?<� FM<I8I:?@E>� F9A<:K@M<� F=� K?<� �:K� @J� KF� GIFM@;<� C<>8C� <==<:K� KF� K?<

Page 12: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

</1?6+>398=� <EM@IFED<EK8C I@>?KJ� <EJ?I@E<;� @E� -<:K@FE� ��� F=� K?<� �FEJK@KLK@FE� F=� K?<� :FLEKIP�� .?<� )8K@FE8C� EM@IFED<EK8C

(8E8><D<EK�� �@F;@M<IJ@KP� �:K� ����� ��:K� � )F�� ��� F=� ����� �) (��� N?@:?� C<>@K@D@J<J� K?<� 1?@K<� +8G<I� FE� K?<

�FEJ<IM8K@FE�8E;�-LJK8@E89C<�/J<�F=�-FLK?��=I@:8UJ��@FCF>@:8C��@M<IJ@KP�@J�K?<�C<>@JC8K@M<�@EJKILD<EK�N?@:?�>FM<IEJ�K?<

9@FGIFJG<:K@E>� � J<:KFI�F=� K?<� :FLEKIP�� .?<��:K� <==<:K@M<CP� J<KJ�FLK� -FLK?��=I@:8UJ� ;FD<JK@:�F9A<:K@M<J� KF� 8;;I<JJ� K?<

�FEM<EK@FE�FE��@FCF>@:8C��@M<IJ@KP��.?<��@FGIFJG<:K@E>��::<JJ����<E<=@K�-?8I@E>�����-�,<>LC8K@FEJ��)F��,����F=�����

:8D<� @EKF� =FI:<� FE� ���GI@C� �����N@K?� K?<� GLIGFJ<� F=� I<>LC8K@E>� K?<� 9@FGIFJG<:K@E> K?IFL>? G<ID@K� JPJK<D� @E� -FLK?

�=I@:8����.?<J<�I<>LC8K@FEJ�=LIK?<I�J<K�FLK�K?<�:FEK<EKJ�F= K?<�I<HL@I<D<EKJ�8E;�:I@K<I@8�=FI 9<E<=@K�J?8I@E>�8E;�D8K<I@8C

KI8EJ=<I�8>I<<D<EKJ�8E;�8CJF�>FM<IE�K?<�;@J:FM<IP�8E; FI�:FDD<I:@8C@J8K@FE�G?8J<�F=�8�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�GIFA<:K�8E;�K?<

<OGFIK�F=�8EP�$�,�=IFD�-FLK?��=I@:8�=FI�K?<�GLIGFJ<�F=�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�FI�8EP�FK?<I�B@E;�F=�I<J<8I:?���.?<P�GI<J:I@9<;

K?<� =FCCFN@E>� =FIDJ�� G<ID@K� 8GGC@:8K@FE� ��EE<OLI<� ���� ��� G<ID@KJ� ��EE<OLI<� � ��� ���(.�� ��EE<OLI<� �� 8E;��-�

��EE<OLI<� �� 8E; )FK@=@:8K@FE� =FID�� .?<� �<G8IKD<EK� F=� -:@<E:<� 8E;� .<:?EFCF>P� ��-.� ?8J� 8� GFC@:P� FE� @E;@><EFLJ

BEFNC<;>< JPJK<D���-.�?8J 8CJF�;<M<CFG<;� K?<��@CC�FE� K?<�+IFK<:K@FE�GIFDFK@FE�;<M<CFGD<EK�8E;�D8E8><D<EK�F=

@E;@><EFLJ�BEFNC<;><�JPJK<DJ�8E;�8CJF�<JK89C@J?<;�8�)8K@FE8C�,<:FI;8C�-PJK<D��.?<��<G8IKD<EK�F=�.I8;<�8E;�$E;LJKIP

��.$� ?8J� JL9J<HL<EKCP� GL9C@J?<;� K?<� +8K<EKJ� �D<E;D<EK� �:K� F=� �����N?@:?� C<>@K@D@J<J� K?<� >8GJ� @E� $&-� GIFK<:K@FE

?@>?C@>?K<;�@E�K?<�$&-�GFC@:P�F=��������.?@J�8D<E;D<EK�KF�K?<������+8K<EK��:K�?8J�K?<�B<P�GLIGFJ<�KF�D8E;8K<�K?8K�8E

8GGC@:8EK� =FI�8EP�G8K<EK� =LIE@J?� @E=FID8K@FE�FE�K?<�IFC<�GC8P<;�9P�8EP� @E;@><EFLJ 9@FCF>@:8C� I<JFLI:<�8E @E;@><EFLJ

><E<K@:� I<JFLI:<� FI� KI8;@K@FE8C� BEFNC<;><� FI� LJ<� @E� 8E� @EM<EK@FE� $E� 8;;@K@FE� .?<� $EK<CC<:KL8C� +IFG<IKP� '8NJ

�D<E;D<EK��@CC�N8J�@EKIF;L:<;�@E������KF�@E�G8IK�GIFM@;<�I<:F>E@K@FE�8E;�8==FI;�GIFK<:K@FE�KF�@E;@><EFLJ�BEFNC<;><

?<C;�9P�@E;@><EFLJ�:FDDLE@K@<J�

�9A�A/</�8+>398+6

?=/<=�90�1/8/>3-

</=9?<-/=

-98=3./</.��/�1�

</=/+<-2�38=>3>?>/=�

?83@/<=3>3/=��

.?<��<G8IKD<EK�F=� EM@IFED<EK8C��==8@IJ�?8J�:FE;L:K<;�J<M<I8C�NFIBJ?FGJ�J<D@E8IJ�:FE=<I<E:<J�D<;@8�<M<EKJ 8E;

@E=FID8K@FE�J?8I@E>�J<JJ@FEJ K?IFL>?FLK�K?<�:FLEKIP KF I8@J<�8N8I<E<JJ�FE��@FGIFJG<:K@E> �::<JJ�8E;��<E<=@K -?8I@E>

N?<I<9P�8CC JK8B<?FC;<IJ� @E:CLJ@M< F=� @E;@M@;L8CJ� I<J<8I:?� @EJK@KLK@FEJ� 8JJF:@8K@FEJ LE@M<IJ@K@<J�8E;� :FDG8E@<J�?8M<

9<<E�@EM@K<;�KF�G8IK@:@G8K<�8E;�<E>8><�@E�K?<�GIF:<JJ�

Page 13: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

(2+>�3=�>2/

:<9-/.?</�09<�"���

(2+>�+</�>2/�5/C

-98.3>398=�09<

9,>+38381�"��� (29

7+C�1<+8>�"���09<

?=/�90��#�+8.�%��

+I@FI� @E=FID<;� :FEJ<EK� @J� :FEJ@;<I<;� KF� 9<� 8E� 8GGIFM8C� @E� 8;M8E:<� =FI� K?<� LJ<� F=� 9@FCF>@:8C� I<JFLI:<J� 8E; FI� 8EP

8JJF:@8K<;�KI8;@K@FE8C�BEFNC<;><�98J<;�FE�8;<HL8K<�@E=FID8K@FE�;@J:CFJLI<����G<ID@K�8GGC@:8EK�@J�I<HL@I<;�KF�GIFM@;<

@E=FID8K@FE�8J�KF�N?8K�JK<GJ�N<I<�K8B<E�@E�@;<EK@=P@E>�K?<�I<C<M8EK�JK8B<?FC;<IJ�F=�N?@:?�K?<�G<ID@K�@JJL@E>�8LK?FI@KP

:FLC;� 8CJF� I<HL<JK� <OG<IK� 8;M@:<� N?@:?� N@CC� <E89C<� @K� KF� ;<K<ID@E<� N?<K?<I� K?<� :FII<:K� JK8B<?FC;<IJ� ?8M<� 9<<E

@;<EK@=@<;�8E;�GIFK<:K<;��.?<��@F;@M<IJ@KP��:K�;<8CJ�N@K?�+$��JK8K@E>�K?8K�GI@FI�KF�8�G<ID@K�9<@E>�@JJL<;�9P�K?<�8LK?FI@KP

K?<�=FCCFN@E>�DLJK�9<�@E�GC8:<���@ 8CC�I<C<M8EK�D8K<I@8C�?8J�9<<E�;@J:CFJ<;�KF�JK8B<?FC;<IJ�@E:CL;@E>�@E=FID8K@FE�89FLK

K?<�@EK<E;<;�<E;�I<JLCK��@@�K?<�JK8B<?FC;<IJ�?8M<�:FEJ<EK<;�KF�GIFM@;@E>�8::<JJ�FI�J?8I@E>�F=�BEFNC<;><��@@@�D8K<I@8C

KI8EJ=<I�8E;�9<E<=@K� J?8I@E>�8>I<<D<EKJ�?8M<�9<<E :FE:CL;<;�N@K?�K?FJ<�JK8B<?FC;<IJ�8E;� �@M� K?<�8>I<<D<EKJ�?8M<

9<<E�8GGIFM<;�9P�K?<�(@E@JK<I�N?F�DLJK�9<�J8K@J=@<;�K?8K��-�J�8I<�=8@I�8E;�<HL@K89C<�KF�8CC�G8IK@<J�

�=�>2/�:<9-/.?</

.300/</8>�A2/8��#

+</�+--/==/.�09<

,+=3-�</=/+<-2

:?<:9=/=�9<�09<

-977/<-3+63D+>398

:?<:9=/=�

+$�� GIF:<;LI<J� 8I<� ;@==<I<EK�� ,<J<8I:?� FK?<I� K?8E� :FDD<I:@8C@J8K@FE� :FE;L:K<;� @E� -FLK?� �=I@:8� ;F<J� EFK� E<<;� 8

9@FGIFJG<:K@E>� G<ID@K� 9LK� D8P� E<<;� 8� :FCC<:K@FE� 8E; FI� I<J<8I:?� G<ID@K� =IFD� K?<� I<C<M8EK GIFM@E:@8C 8LK?FI@KP�

,<J<8I:?�FK?<I�K?8E�:FDD<I:@8C@J8K@FE�KF�9<�:FE;L:K<;�FLKJ@;<�-FLK?��=I@:8�I<HL@I<J�8E�<OGFIK�G<ID@K�8E;�8GGC@:89C<

C8N� @J� K?8K� F=� K?<� �FEM<EK@FE� FE� $EK<IE8K@FE8C� .I8;<� @E� E;8E><I<;� -G<:@<J F= N@C; =8LE8� 8E;� =CFI8 ��$. - N?<I<

8GGC@:89C<� .?I<8K<E<;� FI� +IFK<:K<;� -G<:@<J� �.*+- N?<I<� 8GGC@:89C< ���-� ,<>LC8K@FEJ 8E;� GIFM@E:@8C� FI;@E8E:<J

N?<I<� 8GGC@:89C<� �::<JJ� KF� ><E<K@:� I<JFLI:<J� =FI� :FDD<I:@8C@J8K@FE� GLIGFJ<J� :FE;L:K<;� FLKJ@;<� -FLK?� �=I@:8� N@CC

I<HL@I<�8E�$EK<>I8K<;�<OGFIK�8E;�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�G<ID@K�@JJL<;�9P�K?<�(@E@JK<I� -<<��GG<E;@O��

�0�+�>A9�:2+=/

+::<9+-2�3=�38

:6+-/��:<[email protected]�"��

09<�</=/+<-2�+8.

</;?3<381�+�8/A�"��

09<

-977/<-3+63=+>398�

(2+>�3=�>2/�><311/<

09<�>2/�=/-98.

:2+=/���9<�/B+7:6/

$E�:@I:LDJK8E:<J�N?<I<9P�8�GIFA<:K�N@CC�K8B<�8�KNF�G?8J<�8GGIF8:?�K?8K�@J�I<J<8I:?��;@J:FM<IP�G?8J<�=FCCFN<;�9P�K?<

:FDD<I:@8C@J8K@FE�G?8J<�+$��@J�I<HL@I<;�=FI�K?<�I<J<8I:?�G?8J<�8E;�E<N�+$��DLJK�9<�F9K8@E<;�=FI�:FDD<I:@8C@J8K@FE��$K

@J�@DGFIK8EK�KF�EFK<�K?8K�9<E<=@KJ�N@CC�9<�;@==<I<EK�8K�;@==<I<EK�G?8J<J�F=�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>��+$��@E�K?<�I<J<8I:?�G?8J<�N@CC

I<JLCK�@E�8�(.��@E�GC8:<�N?@:?�D8P�9<�I<E<>FK@8K<;�@E�K?<�:FDD<I:@8C@J8K@FE�G?8J<�N?@:?�N@CC�I<JLCK�@E�8��-��@E�GC8:<�

.I@>><IJ� =FI� :FDD<I:@8C@J8K@FE� 8I<� ;<=@E<;� @E�) (��� 8E;�D8P� @E:CL;<� K?< =FCCFN@E>� 8:K@M@K@<J� @E� I<C8K@FE� KF� $�,�� �8

:FDD<E:@E>�GIF;L:K�;<M<CFGD<EK�@E:CL;@E>�K?<�:FE;L:K@E>�F=�D8IB<K�I<J<8I:? 8E;�J<<B@E>�GI<� D8IB<K�8GGIFM8C�=FI

K?<�J8C<�F=�I<JLCK@E>�GIF;L:KJ� �9 K?<�DLCK@GC@:8K@FE�F=�@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�K?IFL>? :LCK@M8K@FE GIFG8>8K@FE

:CFE@E>�FI�FK?<I�D<8EJ�KF�;<M<CFG�8E;�GIF;L:<�GIF;L:KJ�JL:?�8J ;IL>J�@E;LJKI@8C�<EQPD<J�=FF;�=C8MFLIJ�=I8>I8E:<J

:FJD<K@:J� <DLCJ@=@<IJ FC<FI<J@EJ� :FCFLIJ� <OKI8:KJ� 8E;� <JJ<EK@8C� F@CJ� �: KI8;@E>� @E� 8E;� <OGFIK@E>� F=� @E;@><EFLJ

Page 14: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

-6383-+6�><3+6=�

:+>/8>381�

9@FCF>@:8C� I<JFLI:<J� KF� ;<M<CFG� 8E; GIF;L:<� GIF;L:KJ� JL:?� 8J� ;IL>J� @E;LJKIP� <EQPD<J� =FF;� =C8MFLIJ� =I8>I8E:<J

:FJD<K@:J� <DLCJ@=@<IJ� FC<FI<J@EJ� :FCFLIJ� <OKI8:KJ� 8E;� <JJ<EK@8C� F@CJ� �; F9K8@E@E>� FI� KI8EJ=<II@E>� 8EP� @EK<CC<:KL8C

GIFG<IKP�I@>?KJ FI�FK?<I�I@>?KJ� �< K?<�=@C@E>�F=�8EP�:FDGC<K<�@EK<CC<:KL8C�GIFG<IKP�8GGC@:8K@FE�N?<K?<I�@E�-FLK? �=I@:8

FI�<CJ<N?<I<� �=�:FDD<I:@8C�<OGCF@K8K@FE� -<<��GG<E;@O��

�</�>2/</�.300/</8>

"���</;?3</7/8>=

09<�.300/</8>�>C:/=

90�1/8/>3-�</=9?<-/=

�/�1��7+<38/�

09</=>��

)FK�<OGC@:@KCP��.?<�(8I@E<�'@M@E>�,<JFLI:<J��:K��)F�����F=������GIFM@;<J�=FI�K?<�:FEJ<IM8K@FE�F=�D8I@E<�<:FJPJK<DJ

K?<� JLJK8@E89C<� LJ<� F=� D8I@E<� C@M@E>� I<JFLI:<J� 8E;� =FI� FI;<ICP� 8E;� <HL@K89C<� 8::<JJ� KF� JL:?� I<JFLI:<J�� ��-� @J� EFK

<OGC@:@KCP�:FM<I<;�9P�K?<��:K�9LK�<O@JK@E>�I<:I<8K@FE8C�G<ID@KJ�:FLC;�8CCFN�JL==@:@<EK�HL8EK@K@<J�KF�9<�C<>8CCP�I<DFM<;�=FI

8E8CPJ@J�� O<DGK@FEJ�8I<�>I8EK<;� =FI�8�ELD9<I�F=�8:K@M@K@<J� @E:CL;@E>� I<J<8I:?�8E;�:FLC;�9<�LJ<;� =FI�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>

GLIGFJ<J�� .?<� )8K@FE8C� !FI<JKJ� �:K� �)F�� ��� F=� ����� GLIGFJ<� @E:CL;<J� K?<� JLJK8@E89C<� LJ<� D8E8><D<EK� 8E;

;<M<CFGD<EK� F=� =FI<JKJ� K?<� I<JKIL:KLI@E>� F=� -K8K<� =FI<JKIP� K?<� GIFK<:K@FE� F=� :<IK8@E� =FI<JKJ� 8E;� KI<<J� :FDDLE@KP

G8IK@:@G8K@FE�<K:���<IK8@E�8:K@M@K@<J�D8P�9<�C@:<EJ<;�@E�-K8K< =FI<JKJ�@E:CL;@E>�K?<�:FCC<:K@FE�F=�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�

#FN<M<I�@E�K?<�:8J<�F=�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�8:K@M@K@<J�) (���8E;�K?<����-�,<>LC8K@FEJ�I<HL@I<D<EKJ�GI<M8@C�

(2+>�3=�>2/�+@/<+1/

./6+C�38�9,>+38381

"���0<97�>2/�>37/

+--/==�3=�9003-3+66C

</;?/=>/.�

*9K8@E@E>� :FEJ<EK� @J� EFK� 8� HL@:B� FE:<�F==� GIF:<JJ� 9LK� I8K?<I� @K<I8K@M<� 8E;� GIF>I<JJ@M<� 8J� @K� @J� 89FLK� 9L@C;@E>

I<C8K@FEJ?@GJ�8E;�KILJK�9<KN<<E�G8IK@<J���@I:LDJK8E:<J�D8P�;@==<I�=IFD�:8J<�KF�:8J<�N?@:?�D8P�@DG8:K�FE�K@D<�K8B<E�KF

F9K8@E�+$��9LK�GI@E:@GC<J�F= +$��8I<�EFE�E<>FK@89C<�

$E�K?<�:8J<�F=� @JJL8E:<�F=�G<ID@K� K?<�8M<I8><�K@D<�=I8D<� @J =FLI DFEK?J �)�� @=�G<ID@K�8GGC@:8K@FE�I<HL@I<D<EKJ�8I<

D<K�=FI�K?<��FDG<K<EK�)8K@FE8C��LK?FI@KP�KF�D8B<�8�=@E8C�;<:@J@FE� .?<����-�,<>LC8K@FEJ�I<=<I�KF�K@D<�G<I@F;J�8J 8

ELD9<I�F=�NFIB@E>�;8PJ�=IFD�(FE;8P�KF�!I@;8P�8E;�<O:CL;@E>�GL9C@:�?FC@;8PJ�=@IJK�;8P�EFK�9<@E>�8::FLEK<;�=FI�9LK�K?<

C8JK�;8P�9<@E>�@E:CL;<;�

�=�"���+A+<./.�09<�+

:+<>3-?6+<�:/<39.�90

>37/�

+$��@J�G8IK�F=�8�GIF:<JJ�F=�9L@C;@E>�KILJK�8E;�;<M<CFG@E>�I<C8K@FEJ?@GJ��$K�;F<J�EFK�?8GG<E�HL@:BCP��.?<�I<C8K@FEJ?@GJ�F=

KILJK�8I<�F=K<E�9L@CK�FM<I�8�ELD9<I�F=�P<8IJ� )<>FK@8K@E>�K?<�DLKL8CCP�8>I<<;�K<IDJ��(.��F=�LJ<�F=�K?<�@E=FID8K@FE�FI

I<JFLI:<�N@CC�;<K<ID@E<�?FN�+$��@J�>I8EK<;�

#FN<M<I�FE�@JJL8E:<�F=�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�G<ID@KJ�M8C@;@KP�F=�K?<�G<ID@K�@J�JK8K<; 8E;�@K�I8E><�=IFD���P<8IJ�KF�=@M<�P<8IJ�

Page 15: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

�=�+�:/<73>�3==?/.

A2/8�"���3=

1<+8>/.�

3<J� 8� G<ID@K� N@K?� FI� N@K?FLK� :FE;@K@FEJ�D8P� 9<� >I8EK<;� 9P� K?<�(@E@JK<I� .?<�(@E@JK<I� ?8J� <JK89C@J?<;� 8� )8K@FE8C

�@FGIFJG<:K@E>��;M@JFIP��FDD@KK<<� KF�GIFM@;<� K<:?E@:8C� @EGLK�;LI@E>� K?<�<M8CL8K@FE�F=�G<ID@K�8GGC@:8K@FEJ�8E;�8CJF

D8B<�I<:FDD<E;8K@FEJ�=FI�K?<�(@E@JK<I�KF�@JJL<�FI�I<A<:K�K?<�G<ID@K�8GGC@:8K@FE��.?<��;M@JFIP��FDD@KK<<�D<<KJ�=FLI

K@D<J 8�P<8I�KF�I<M@<N�G<ID@K�8GGC@:8K@FEJ���;�?F:�D<<K@E>J�8I<�8CJF�:FEM<E<;�N?<E�E<:<JJ8IP�

(2+>�3=�>2/

:<9-/.?</�38�:6+-/

09<�>2/�8/19>3+>398

90���%�

(LKL8CCP� 8>I<<;� K<IDJ� @J� 8E� 8>I<<D<EK� I<8:?<;� 9<KN<<E� K?<� GIFM@;<IJ� F=� K?<� ><E<K@:� I<JFLI:<J� 8E;� LJ<IJ� F=� K?<

I<JFLI:<J�FE�K?<�:FE;@K@FEJ�F=�8::<JJ�8E;�LJ<�F=�K?<�I<JFLI:<J�8E;�K?<�9<E<=@KJ�KF�9<�J?8I<;�9<KN<<E�9FK?�G8IK@<J���

D8K<I@8C� KI8EJ=<I� 8>I<<D<EK 8E; 8� 9<E<=@K� J?8I@E>� 8>I<<D<EK� 8I<� I<HL@I<;� N?<E� 8::<JJ� KF� @E;@><EFLJ� 9@FCF>@:8C

I<JFLI:<J� @J�E<<;<;��.?<J<� KNF�8>I<<D<EKJ�>F�?8E;�@E�?8E;�� $=�8::<JJ� KF� @E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C� I<JFLI:<J� @J� I<HL@I<;

;LI@E>�K?<�:FDD<I:@8C@J8K@FE�G?8J<�F=�8�GIFA<:K�8�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�G<ID@K�8GGC@:8K@FE�@J�KF�9< JL9D@KK<; KF�K?<�$JJL@E>

�LK?FI@KP�N?@:?�DLJK�9<�JLGGFIK<;�9P�8 D8K<I@8C�KI8EJ=<I�8>I<<D<EK��(.�� .?< (.��DLJK�9<�J@>E<;�9P�K?<�GIFM@;<I

8E;�K?<�LJ<I�F=�$�,���<IK8@E�@E=FID8K@FE�@J�KF�9<�GIFM@;<;�9P�K?<�LJ<I�KF�K?<�GIFM@;<I�9<=FI<�8E�(.��@J�:FEJ@;<I<;��$E

K?<�<M<EK�K?8K�K?<�LJ<I�N8EKJ�KF�GIFM@;<�K?<�$�,�KF�8�K?@I;�G8IKP�<>�8�I<J<8I:?�@EJK@KLK@FE�K?< GI@D8IP�GIFM@;<I�D8P�J<K

:FE;@K@FE�FE� JL:?� KI8EJ=<IJ� KF� K?@I;�G8IK@<J�<EJLI@E>� K?8K� K?@J� @J� JK8K<;� @E� K?<�(.��EFK@E>� K?8K� K?<� KI8EJ=<I� KF� K?@I;

G8IK@<J�@J�JL9A<:K�KF�NI@KK<E�:FEJ<EK�=IFD�K?<�(@E@JK<I��+IFM@;<I�F=�$�,�@J�KF�=LIE@J?�K?<�LJ<I�N@K?�8;<HL8K< @E=FID8K@FE

@E�FI;<I�=FI�K?<�LJ<I�KF�9<�89C<�KF�JL9D@K�8�G<ID@K�8GGC@:8K@FE�

�E�(.��8E;�8��-��8I<�I<HL@I<;�N?<E�K?<�9@FGIFJG<:KFI�E<<;J�8::<JJ�KF� $�,�8E;�.& D<8E@E>�K?8K�PFL�E<M<I�?8M<�8

(.��N@K?FLK�K?<��-���$=�GIFM@;<I�?8J�;<:@;<;�KF >@M< K?<�9@FGIFJG<:KFI�8::<JJ�KF�$�,�8E; FI�.&�K?<�GIFM@;<I�N@CC�8CJF

?8M<�KF�GIFM@;<�JFD<�@E=FID8K@FE�K?8K�K?<�LJ<I�N@CC�E<<;�@E�FI;<I�KF�=@CC�FLK�K?<�G<ID@K�8GGC@:8K@FE�8E;�K?@J�@E=FID8K@FE

@J�>@M<E�9P�K?<�GIFM@;<I�FE:<�?< J?<�?8J�;<:@;<;�KF�>@M<�8::<JJ�KF�K?<�LJ<I�KF�$�,�8E; FI�.&�

���-�,<>LC8K@FEJ��EE<OLI<���8E;���GIFM@;<�K<DGC8K<J�=FI�K?<�B@E;�F=�@E=FID8K@FE�K?8K�@J�I<HL@I<;�N?<E�:FE:CL;@E>�8

(.�� 8E;� �-��� $E=FID8K@FE� I<HL@I<; 8DFE>JK� FK?<IJ D8P� @E:CL;< E8D<� 8E;� :FEK8:K� ;<K8@CJ� 8E;� @=� 8GGC@:89C<� K?<

;<J@>E8K@FE� F=� K?<� G<IJFE� J@>E@E>� K?<� 8>I<<D<EK�� $=� GIFM@;<I� 8>I<<J� KF� J?8I<� $�,� 8E;� <EK<I� @EKF� 8� �-�� N@K?� LJ<I

GIFM@;<I�N@CC�?8M<�KF�:FDGC<K<�8�(.���$=�GIFM@;<I�?8J�8>I<<;�KF�J?8I<�.&�8E;�<EK<I�@EKF�8��-��N@K?�K?<�9@FGIFJG<:KFI

Page 16: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

K?<�GIFM@;<I�N@CC�?8M<�KF�J?8I<�K?<�BEFNC<;><�8E;�KI8;@K@FE8C�LJ<�8JJF:@8K<;�N@K?�K?<�$�,���CC� @E=FID8K@FE�@E:CL;<;�@E

9FK?� 8>I<<D<EKJ� N@CC� 9<� J?8I<;� N@K?� K?<� 9@FGIFJG<:KFI� � �� 8J� N<CC� 8J� K?<� � ��8GGF@EK<;� 8;M@JFIP� :FDD@KK<<� @E

:?8I><�F=�8E8CPJ@E>�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�G<ID@KJ�

$=� @K� @J� 8E� @E;@><EFLJ� :FDDLE@KP� K?8K� @J� GIFM@;@E>� 8::<JJ� KF� $�,� FI� @J� J?8I@E>� .&� N@K?� K?<� 9@FGIFJG<:KFI� K?8E

I<GI<J<EK8K@M< N@CC�?8M<�KF�GIFM@;<�8�;<J:I@GK@FE�F=�K?<�:FDDLE@KP�E8D<�8E;�:8G8:@KP�F=�K?<�@E;@M@;L8C I<GI<J<EK@E>

K?<�:FDDLE@KP�@E�K?<�E<>FK@8K@FEJ�8E;�:FEK8:K�;<K8@CJ�F=�K?8K�I<GI<J<EK8K@M<���E�@E;@><EFLJ�:FDDLE@KP�DLJK�8;FGK�8

I<JFCLK@FE� K?8K� :FE=@IDJ� K?8K� K?<� I<GI<J<EK8K@M<� @;<EK@=@<;� @E� K?<� 8>I<<D<EK� ?8J� K?<� 8LK?FI@KP� KF� <EK<I� @E� KF� JL:?

8>I<<D<EKJ�FE�9<?8C=�F=�K?<�:FDDLE@KP�8E;�K?<�I<JFCLK@FE�N@CC�?8M<�KF�JK8K<�K?8K�K?< :FDDLE@KP�@J�=LCCP�8N8I<�F=�K?<

9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�GIFA<:K�8E;�K?8K�@K�:FEJ<EKJ�KF�K?<��-��

.?<�GIFM@;<I�?8J�KF�;<:@;<�8E;�8>I<<�N@K?�K?<�LJ<I�FE�K?<�KPG<�F=�9<E<=@KJ�K?8K�?< J?< K?<P�NFLC;�C@B<�KF�I<:<@M<�8J

G8IK�F=�K?<��-��8E;�8�;<:@J@FE�DLJK�9<�K8B<E�AF@EKCP�N@K?�K?<�LJ<IJ�FE�?FN�F=K<E�K?<��-��@J�KF�9<�I<M@<N<;�N@K?�8�M@<N

KF� 8D<E;� K?<� 8>I<<D<EK� N?<I<� E<:<JJ8IP� *E<� DFEK?� 9<=FI<� K?<� I<M@<N� K?<� 9@FGIFJG<:KFI� @J� KF� JL9D@K� KF� K?<

GIFM@;<I� 8EP� E<N� D8K<I@8C� @E=FID8K@FE� 89FLK� K?<� 9@FGIFJG<:K@E>� JF� 8J� KF� 8CCFN� K?<� GIFM@;<I� K@D<� KF� =8D@C@8I@J<

K?<DJ<CM<J�N@K?�K?<�D8K<I@8C�9<=FI<�K?<�I<M@<N�

EK<I@E>� @EKF�8��-��N@K?�FE<�9@FGIFJG<:KFI�;F<J�EFK�GI<M<EK� K?<�GIFM@;<I� =IFD�<EK<I@E>� @EKF��-�J�N@K?�FK?<I�LJ<IJ

LEC<JJ�K?@J�@J�JG<:@=@<;�@E�K?<�8>I<<D<EK�

�</���%�+

-98.3>398 09<

9,>+38381�"���

�<=FI<�8::<JJ�KF�$�,�FI�KI8;@K@FE8C�BEFNC<;><�:8E�:FDD<E:<�K?<�+$��=IFD�FNE<IJ�F=�K?<�$�,�FI�.&�?FC;<IJ�@J�I<HL@I<;�

.?<� LJ<I� @J� <OG<:K<;� KF� =LCCP� ;@J:CFJ<� K?<� @EK<E;<;� LJ<� F=� K?<� I<JFLI:<� K?<�D<K?F;� F=� :FCC<:K@FE� 8E;� K?<� @EK<E;<;

FLK:FD<�F=�K?<�I<J<8I:?���CC�K?@J�N@CC�9<�98J<;�FE�(LKL8CCP��>I<<;�.<IDJ�N?@:?�@J�8�:FE;@K@FE�=FI�F9K8@E@E>�+$�� (�.

J<IM<� 8J� <M@;<E:<� =FI� >I8EK@E>� F=� +$�� 9P� K?<� I<C<M8EK� JK8B<?FC;<I�� .?<� (�.J� 8I<� E<>FK@8K<; 9P� 9FK?� G8IK@<J 8E;

JK@GLC8K<;�@E�K?<�(.� 8E;��-� =FI�8GGIFM8C�9P�K?<�(@E@JK<I�

�</�5/C�/6/7/8>=�90

��%�=/>�9?>

�-98>/8>

-K8E;8I;� =FIDJ =FI�(8K<I@8C�.I8EJ=<I��>I<<D<EKJ�8E;��<E<=@K� -?8I@E>��>I<<D<EKJ 8I<�GIFM@;<;� @E��EE<OLI<J KF K?<

���-� ,<>LC8K@FEJ�� .?@J� JK8E;8I;� =FID8K� DLJK� 9<� LJ<;� 8E;� 8;;@K@FE8C� K<IDJ� 8E;� :FE;@K@FEJ� :8E� 9<� @E:CL;<;� @E� K?<

Page 17: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

</;?3</7/8>=����=�+

>/7:6+>/�09<���%

+@+36+,6/�

JK8E;8I;�=FID�8>I<<D<EK�8J�8E�8EE<OLI<�@=�E<:<JJ8IP� (LKL8CCP��>I<<;�.<IDJ�@J�K?LJ�@E:FIGFI8K<;�@EKF�9FK?�K?<�(.�

8E;��-��8E;�EFK�JK@GLC8K<;�@E�8�J<G8I8K<�;F:LD<EK�

�</�=:/-303-

</;?3</7/8>=�38

:6+-/�09<�>2/

=2+<381�90�798/>+<C

+8.�898�798/>+<C

,/8/03>=�

.?<��@F;@M<IJ@KP��:K�JK@GLC8K<J�K?8K�>FM<IED<EK�DLJK�<JK89C@J?�8��@FGIFJG<:K@E>�.ILJK�!LE;�@EKF�N?@:?�8CC�DFE@<J�8I@J@E>

=IFD��-�J�DLJK�9<�G8@;� @EKF�8E;�K?<��@I<:KFI�"<E<I8C�F=� K?<��<G8IKD<EK�F=� EM@IFED<EK8C��==8@IJ� @J� I<JGFEJ@9C<�=FI

8;D@E@JK<I@E>�K?<�=LE;��.?<�!LE;� @J�D8E8><;� @E�8::FI;8E:<�N@K?�.I<8JLIP�,<>LC8K@FEJ� @E�K<IDJ�F=�K?<�+L9C@:�!@E8E:<

(8E8><D<EK��:K �������:K�)F���F=�������(FE<P�I<:<@M<;�9P�K?<�=LE;�@J�G8@;�FLK�8EEL8CCP�KF�K?<�9<E<=@:@8I@<J�LEC<JJ

K?<� �-�� JK@GLC8K<J� 8� ;@==<I<EK� K@D<� G<I@F;� =FI�D8B@E>� FLK� G8PD<EKJ��(FE<K8IP� G8PD<EKJ� ;F� EFK� >F� ;@I<:KCP� KF� K?<

GIFM@;<IJ �:FDDLE@KP =IFD�K?<�LJ<IJ�9LK�K?IFL>?�K?<�!LE;��$K�@J�9<@E>�<DG?8J@Q<;�K?8K�K?<��@FGIFJG<:K@E>�.ILJK�!LE;

@J�M<IP�;@==<I<EK�=IFD�8��FDDLE@KP�.ILJK�!LE;�K?8K�D8P�9<�<JK89C@J?<;�KF�;@JKI@9LK<�9<E<=@KJ�8K�:FDDLE@KP�C<M<C��)FE�

DFE<K8IP�9<E<=@KJ�D8P�:FD<�@E�D8EP�;@==<I<EK�=FIDJ�8E;�K?<��<G8IKD<EK�F=� EM@IFED<EK8C��==8@IJ�@J�8M8@C89C<�KF�8JJ@JK

9<E<=@:@8I@<J�@E�DFE@KFI@E>�K?<�8;D@E@JKI8K@FE�F=�JL:?�9<E<=@KJ�8K�:FDDLE@KP GIFM@;<I�C<M<C�

(2+>�>C:/=�90

-97:63+8-/

7/+=?</=�+</�38

:6+-/�38�9<./<�>9

/8=?</�>2+>�?=/<=

</=:/->���$

</;?3</7/8>=�38�>2/

-9?8><C�

.?<�)8K@FE8C� EM@IFED<EK8C�(8E8><D<EK���@F;@M<IJ@KP��:K��������:K��)F�����F=�������) (���N?@:?�C<>@K@D@J<J�K?<

1?@K<�+8G<I�FE�K?<��FEJ<IM8K@FE�8E;�-LJK8@E89C<�/J<�F=�-FLK?��=I@:8UJ��@FCF>@:8C��@M<IJ@KP�@J�K?<�C<>@JC8K@M<�@EJKILD<EK

N?@:?� >FM<IEJ� K?<� 9@FGIFJG<:K@E>� � J<:KFI� F=� K?<� :FLEKIP�� .?<� �@FGIFJG<:K@E>� �::<JJ� �� �<E<=@K� -?8I@E>� ����-

,<>LC8K@FEJ� �)F�� ,���� F=� ����� :8D<� @EKF� =FI:<� FE� �� �GI@C� �����N@K?� K?<� GLIGFJ<� F=� I<>LC8K@E>� K?<� 9@FGIFJG<:K@E>

G<ID@K�JPJK<D�@E�-FLK?��=I@:8������.?<�,<>LC8K@FEJ�JK@GLC8K<�K?8K�K?<�G<ID@K�?FC;<I�FE�8E 8EEL8C�98J@J�JL9D@K�8�JK8KLJ

I<GFIK� KF� K?<� (@E@JK<I� @E� 8� =FID8K� ;<K<ID@E<;� 9P� K?<� (@E@JK<I�� $K� @J� 8CJF� @DG<I8K@M<� KF� :C<8ICP� JK8K< K?8K @E� 8EP

8>I<<D<EK� ?FN�;@JGLK<J� 9<KN<<E�GIFM@;<I� 8E;� LJ<I�N@CC� 9<� I<JFCM<;��D<;@8K@FE�GI@FI� KF� 8I9@KI8K@FE� @J� :FEJ@;<I<;�8

9<KK<I FGK@FE���FJKJ�F=�D@K@>8K@E>�FI� I<D<;P@E>� K?<� @DG8:K�F=�K?<�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�FE�K?<�<EM@IFED<EK�N@CC�9<� =FI�K?<

G<ID@K�?FC;<I�� $K� @J�8E�F==<E:<� @=�8�EFE�G<ID@K�?FC;<I�� �8� �@LE;<IK8B<J�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>� @EMFCM@E>� @E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C

I<JFLI:<J� �@@� <OGFIKJ� =IFD� K?<� ,<GL9C@:� F=� -FLK?� �=I@:8� 8EP� @E;@><EFLJ� 9@FCF>@:8C� I<JFLI:<J� =FI� K?<� GLIGFJ<� F=

9@FGIFJG<:K@E>� FI� 8EP� FK?<I� I<J<8I:?� �9� G<I=FIDJ� K?<� 8:K@M@KP� =FI� N?@:?� K?<� G<ID@K� N8J� @JJL<;� FK?<IN@J<� K?8E� @E

8::FI;8E:<�N@K?�8EP�:FE;@K@FEJ�JL9A<:K�KF�N?@:?�8�G<ID@K�N8J�@JJL<;��:�G<ID@KJ�FI�8CCFN�8EP�FK?<I�G<IJFE�KF�FI�KF

FD@K�FI�KF�;F�8EPK?@E>�N?@:?�@J�8E�F==<E:<�@E�K<IDJ�F=�K?<����-�,<>LC8K@FEJ����G<IJFE�:FEM@:K<;�:FLC;�9<�C@89C<�KF�A8@C

K@D<� 8� =@E<� FI� 9FK?� .?<� =@E<� @J� LG� KF� ���D@CC@FE� 4�,� 8E;� @DGI@JFED<EK� EFK� <O:<<;@E>� ��� P<8IJ� FI� K?I<<� K@D<J� K?<

Page 18: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

:FDD<I:@8C�M8CL<�F=�K?<�8:K@M@KP�

$E�8;;@K@FE�=8@CLI<�KF�EFK@=P�K?<�(@E@JK<I 89FLK�K?<�;@J:FM<IP�G?8J<�F=�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�GIFA<:K @J�8CJF�8E�F==<E:<�C@89C<�KF

K?<�G<E8CK@<J�8J�JK8K<;�89FM<�

(29�+</�</6/@+8>

=>+5/296./<=�+>�>2/

8+>398+6�6/@/6��/�1�

</=/+<-2

-977?83>C�

?83@/<=3>3/=��/B�=3>?

-966/->398=�

38.31/89?=�+8.

69-+6�-977?83>3/=�

:<3@+>/�6+8.

9A8/<=��

�CC�F=�K?<�<O8DGC<J�JK8K<;�8I<�I<C<M8EK�JK8B<?FC;<IJ�

(2+>�3=�>2/

7/-2+83=7�90

37:6/7/8>+>398�90

>2/��8>/<8+>398+6

%</+>C�98�"6+8>

�/8/>3-�#/=9?<-/=

09<��99.�+8.

�1<3-?6>?</

��%"�#����

(2+>�3=�3>=

</6+>398=23:�A3>2

>2/���$

0<+7/A9<5�

-��@J�EFK +8IKP�KF�K?<�$.+",!���.?<I<�@J�EF�D<:?8E@JD�F=�@DGC<D<EK8K@FE�J<K�FLK�

.?<�D8@E�:FDGFE<EK�F=�K?<�$.+",!��@J�K?<�(LCK@C8K<I8C�-PJK<D��('-��$E�K?@J�:FEK<OK�", FE�K?<��EE<O���'@JK�F=�JG<:@<J

:LII<EKCP����=FI8><�JG<:@<J�=IFD����><E<I8�8E;�8E�LE;<=@E<; ELD9<I�F=�:IFG�JG<:@<J�=IFD����><E<I8��:FM<I@E>�K?<�M8JK

D8AFI@KP�F=�GC8EK�:IFGJ�:FEJLD<;�9P�?LD8EJ � 8I<�=I<<CP�8M8@C89C<�KF�GC8EK�9I<<;<IJ�=8ID<IJ�J:@<EK@JKJ�<K:��#FN<M<I

Page 19: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

GLKJ� @E� GC8:<� D<8JLI<J� KF� <EJLI<� I<:@G@<EKJ� J?8I<� 9<E<=@KJ� K?<P� ;<I@M<� =IFD� K?< LJ<� F=� ><E<K@:� D8K<I@8CJ� N@K?� K?<

:FLEKI@<J�N?<I<�K?<P�FI@>@E8K<;�

.?FJ<�N?F�8::<JJ�><E<K@:�D8K<I@8CJ�K?IFL>?�K?<�JPJK<D�8I<�I<HL@I<;�EFK�KF�:C8@D�8EP�I@>?KJ�K?8K��C@D@K�K?<�=8:@C@K8K<;

8::<JJ� KF� K?<� +",!�� FI� K?<@I� ><E<K@:� G8IKJ� FI� :FDGFE<EKJ� @E� K?<� =FID� I<:<@M<;�� ��IK@:C<� �����;�� $=� GC8EK� ><E<K@:

I<JFLI:<J�8::<JJ<;�=IFD�K?<�('-�8I<�:FDD<I:@8C@Q<;�K?<�I<:@G@<EK��J?8CC�G8P�8E�<HL@K89C<�J?8I<�F=�K?<�9<E<=@KJ�8I@J@E>

=IFD�K?<�:FDD<I:@8C@Q8K@FE�F=�K?8K�GIF;L:K�<O:<GK�N?<E<M<I�JL:?�8�GIF;L:K�@J�8M8@C89C<�N@K?FLK�I<JKI@:K@FE�KF�FK?<IJ

=FI�=LIK?<I�I<J<8I:?�8E;�9I<<;@E>� @E�N?@:?�:8J<�K?<�I<:@G@<EK�N?F�:FDD<I:@8C@Q<J�J?8CC�9<�<E:FLI8><;�KF�D8B<�JL:?

G8PD<EK����IK@:C<������;�@@����GI<�=@O<;�G<I:<EK8><�F=�K?<�9<E<=@KJ�=IFD�:FDD<I:@8C@Q8K@FE�=CFN�@EKF�8�:FDDFE�=LE;

K?8K� @J� LJ<;� KF� JLGGFIK� =LKLI<� I<J<8I:?� 9I<<;@E>� 8E;� KI8@E@E>� GIFA<:KJ�� .?<� JPJK<D� @J� FG<I8K@FE8C@J<;� K?IFL>?� K?<

JK8E;8I;�(.��

$E�K?<�:FEK<OK�F=�K?<���-�8E;�.&�=8ID<IJ��I@>?KJ�8J�:F;@=@<;�@E�K?<�$.+",!��;<8C�N@K?�9<E<=@K�J?8I@E>�9LK�EFK�N@K?�8::<JJ

8JG<:KJ�� �LI@E>� K?<� $.+",!�� E<>FK@8K@FEJ� @K�N8J� 8I>L<;�9P� JFD<� G8IK@<J� K?8K� =8ID<IJU� I@>?KJ� J?FLC;� 8CJF� :FM<I� =I<<

8::<JJ�KF�8E;�<O:?8E><�F=�$+�GIFK<:K<;�GC8EK�D8K<I@8C�8J�8:BEFNC<;><D<EK�F=�=8ID<IJ��:FEKI@9LK@FE�KF�K?<�:I<8K@FE�F=

K?<�<O@JK@E>�;@M<IJ@KP�F=�GC8EK�><E<K@:�D8K<I@8C�N@K?FLK�N?@:?�DF;<IE�GC8EK�9I<<;@E>�:FLC;�EFK�<O@JK��-L:?�@EK<I=<I<E:<

N@K?�K?<�$+�JPJK<D�N8J�EFK�8::<GK<;�9P�:FLEKI@<J�N@K?�JKIFE>�GC8EK�9I<<;<I�@EK<I<JKJ��.?<�$.+",!��=@E8CCP�N8J�<HL@GG<;

N@K?�8�GIFM@J@FE�@E��IK@:C<�����K?8K�K?<�E8K@FE8C�@DGC<D<EK8K@FE�F=�=8ID<IJ��I@>?KJ�J?8CC�EFK��C@D@K�8EP�I@>?KJ�K?8K�=8ID<IJ

?8M<�KF�J8M<�LJ<�<O:?8E><�8E;�J<CC�=8ID�J8M<;�J<<; GIFG8>8K@E>�D8K<I@8C�JL9A<:K�KF�E8K@FE8C�C8N�8E;�8J�8GGIFGI@8K<��

.?<�FECP�@EK<IE8K@FE8C�KI<8KP�K?8K�GIFM@;<J�=FI�JL:?�I@>?KJ�K?FL>?�FECP�FE�8�MFCLEK8IP�98J@J�@J�K?<�/+*0��FEM<EK@FE�

)<>FK@8K<;�GFJK�,@F�8�:FEJ:@FLJ�<==FIK�N8J�D8;<�KF�<EJLI<�K?8K�K?<�$.+",!��@J�=LCCP�:FEJ@JK<EK�N@K?�K?<�GIFM@J@FEJ�F=

K?<��������GIFM@J@FE�K?8K�@J�F=�I<C<M8E:<�@E�K?<���-�:FEK<OK�:8E�9<�=FLE;�@E��IK@:C<������?�N?@:?�J8PJ�K?8K��5N6@K?FLK

Page 20: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

�9A�+</ >2/�-<9:=

63=>/.�38��88/B���90

>2/��%"�#��

></+>/.�38�>2/

8+>398+6���$

GI<AL;@:<�KF�K?<�FK?<I�GIFM@J@FEJ�LE;<I�K?@J��IK@:C<�K?<��FEKI8:K@E>�+8IK@<J�8>I<<�K?8K�8::<JJ�KF�GC8EK�><E<K@:�I<JFLI:<J

=FI�=FF;�8E;�8>I@:LCKLI<�=FLE;�@E�@E�J@KL�:FE;@K@FEJ�N@CC�9<�GIFM@;<;�8::FI;@E>�KF�E8K@FE8C�C<>@JC8K@FE�FI�@E�K?<�89J<E:<

F=�JL:?�C<>@JC8K@FE�@E�8::FI;8E:<�N@K?�JL:?�JK8E;8I;J�8J�D8P�9<�J<K�9P�K?<�"FM<IE@E>��F;P����::FI;@E>�KF�K?<�;<=@E@K@FE

F=��@E�J@KL��>@M<E�9P�K?<�$.+",!��8J�N<CC�8J�9P�K?<�����K?@J�:8J<�NFLC;�:FM<I�K?FJ<�GC8EK�><E<K@:�I<JFLI:<J�@E�E8KLI8C

JLIIFLE;@E>J� 8J�N<CC� 8J�FE� =8ID<IJ�� =@<C;J� @=� K?<P� ?8M<� �;<M<CFG<;� K?<@I� ;@JK@E:K@M<�GIFG<IK@<J�� @E� K?<J<� CF:8K@FEJ�� $E

����� K?<� 8;� ?F:� �;M@JFIP� .<:?E@:8C� �FDD@KK<<� FE� K?<� -K8E;8I;�(8K<I@8C� .I8EJ=<I� �>I<<D<EK� 8E;� K?<�(LCK@C8K<I8C

-PJK<D�F=�K?<�$.+",!��JK8IK<;�@KJ�NFIB�FE�:FDG@C@E>�@E=FID8K@FE�8E;�M@<NJ�FE�JL:?�JK8E;8I;J��.?<��K?�8E;��K?�-<JJ@FE

F=�K?<�"FM<IE@E>��F;P�@E�(8I:?������8E;�-<GK<D9<I������I<JG<:K@M<CP�;@;�EFK�=LIK?<I�<C89FI8K<�FE�K?<�NFIB�KFN8I;J

8::<JJ�JK8E;8I;J�=FI�@E�J@KL�:FE;@K@FEJ�

.?<�)8>FP8�+IFKF:FC��)+�?8M@E>�9<<E�E<>FK@8K<;�8=K<I�K?<�$.+",!��?8J�8�GIFM@J@FE�K?8K�<EJLI<J�K?8K�K?<�C8KK<I�KI<8KP

�8E;� EFK� K?<� )+ ���� >FM<IEJ� GC8EK� ><E<K@:� I<JFLI:<J� =FI� =FF;� 8E;� 8>I@:LCKLI<� :FM<I<;� 9P� K?<� $.+",!�� =FI� K?FJ<

:FLEKI@<J� K?8K� ?8M<� I8K@=@<;� @K��/E;<I��IK@:C<� ���� F=� K?<�)+� V5N6?<I<� 8� JG<:@8C@Q<;� @EK<IE8K@FE8C� 8::<JJ� 8E;� 9<E<=@K�

J?8I@E>� @EJKILD<EK�8GGC@<J�K?8K� @J�:FEJ@JK<EK�N@K?�8E;�;F<J�EFK�ILE�:FLEK<I�KF�K?<�F9A<:K@M<J�F=�K?<��FEM<EK@FE�8E;

K?@J�+IFKF:FC�K?@J�+IFKF:FC�;F<J�EFK�8GGCP�=FI�K?<�+8IKP�FI�+8IK@<J�KF�K?<�JG<:@8C@Q<;�@EJKILD<EK�@E�I<JG<:K�F=�K?<�JG<:@=@:

><E<K@:�I<JFLI:<�:FM<I<;�9P�8E;�=FI�K?<�GLIGFJ<�F=�K?<�JG<:@8C@Q<;�@EJKILD<EKW�<O:<GK�8J�JK@GLC8K<;�@E��IK@:C<�����F=

K?<� )+� VN?<I<� K?<� <O<I:@J<� F= K?FJ<� I@>?KJ� 8E;� F9C@>8K@FEJ� NFLC;� :8LJ<� 8� J<I@FLJ� ;8D8><� FI� K?I<8K� KF� 9@FCF>@:8C

;@M<IJ@KP�W

.?<��EE<O���:IFGJ�8I<�:LII<EKCP�<O:CL;<;�=IFD�K?<�E8K@FE8C���-�=I8D<NFIB����JG<:@8C�J@KL8K@FE�D8P�<O@JK�?FN<M<I�=FI

:FLEKI@<J�K?8K�?8M<�EFK� KF�;8K<�9<:FD<�G8IKP�KF�K?<� $.+",!���-@E:<�-FLK?��=I@:8� @J�8�G8IKP�KF�K?<�����8E;�K?<�)+

-FLK?��=I@:8�NFLC;�9<�9FLE;�9P�K?<���-�GIFM@J@FEJ�@E�K?<�����FM<I�GC8EK�><E<K@:�I<JFLI:<J�8E;�K?<�GIFM@J@FEJ�F=�K?<

)+���J�K?<�$.+",!��@J�:FEJ@JK<EK�N@K?�K?<�����K?<I<�@J�EFK?@E>�GI<M<EK@E>�K?<�LJ<�F=�K?<�$.+",!��(.��=FI�KI8EJ=<I�F=

Page 21: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

0<+7/A9<5� GC8EK�><E<K@:�I<JFLI:<J�=FI�=FF;�8E;�8>I@:LCKLI<�KF�8�EFE�J@>E8KFIP�

3. PROVIDERS OF GENETIC RESOURCES(2/</�+</��#

79=>6C�,/381

+--/==/.�38�>2/

-9?8><C��A2/</�3=

>2/�1</+>/=>

./7+8.�09<�+--/==

>9��#����8 09</=>

+</+=��7+<38/�+</+=�

9>2/<�

-FLK?��=I@:8E�C8N�?8J�8�M<IP�N@;<�;<=@E@K@FE��N?@:?�;<=@E<J�T@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<U��$�,�KF�@E:CL;<�8EP�C@M@E>�FI

;<8;� FI>8E@JD� F=� 8E� @E;@><EFLJ� JG<:@<J� 8EP� ><E<K@:� D8K<I@8C� FI� ;<I@M8K@M<J� F=� JL:?� FI>8E@JDJ� FI� 8EP� :?<D@:8C

:FDGFLE;J� 8E;� GIF;L:KJ� F9K8@E<;� K?IFL>?� LJ<� F=� 9@FK<:?EFCF>P� K?8K� ?8M<� 9<<E� 8CK<I<;� N@K?� ><E<K@:� D8K<I@8C� FI

:?<D@:8C� :FDGFLE;J� =FLE;� @E� @E;@><EFLJ� JG<:@<J�� $K� <O:CL;<J� ><E<K@:�D8K<I@8C� F=� ?LD8E� FI@>@E� 8EP� <OFK@:� 8E@D8CJ

GC8EKJ� FI� FK?<I� FI>8E@JDJ� 8E;� @E;@><EFLJ� 9@FCF>@:8C� I<JFLI:<J� C@JK<;� @E� K<IDJ� F=� K?<� $EK<IE8K@FE8C� .I<8KP� FE� +C8EK

"<E<K@:�,<JFLI:<J�=FI�!FF;�8E;��>I@:LCKLI<��$E�I<C8K@FE�KF�K?<�G<ID@K�JPJK<D�K?8K�B<<GJ�I<:FI;J�F=�8CC�G<ID@KJ�8GGIFM<;

8E;�>I8EK<;�K?<�>I<8K<JK�;<D8E;�=FI�8::<JJ�KF�",�@J�@E�GC8EK�D8K<I@8C�9FK?�N@C;�?8IM<JK<;�8E;�:LCK@M8K<;�

�9�09</318/<=�-+<<C

9?>�,39:<9=:/->398

38�>2/�-9?8><C�9<�.9

>2/C�+--/==�1/8/>3-

</=9?<-/=�0<97

38>/<7/.3+<3/=��/�1�

/B�=3>?�-966/->398=�

?83@/<=3>3/=�9<

8+>398+6�</=/+<-2

38=>3>?>/=����8 9>2/<

A9<.=

+</��#�+--/==/.�38

=3>?�9<�/B�=3>?�,C

09</318/<=�

!FI<@>E�@E;@M@;L8CJ�8E;�<EK@K@<J�8I<�<OG<:K<;�KF�8GGCP�AF@EKCP�N@K?�-FLK?��=I@:8E�$E;@M@;L8CJ�FI�/E@M<IJ@K@<J�8E;�,<J<8I:?

@EJK@KLK<J =FI� 9@FGIFJG<:K@E>� FI� <OGFIK� G<ID@KJ� 8E;� @E� DFJK� :8J<J� ><E<K@:� I<JFLI:<J� 8I<� 8::<JJ<;� =IFD� <O� J@KL

:FCC<:K@FEJ�� $E�K<IDJ�F=�K?<��:K�8�G<ID@K�D8P�FECP�9<� @JJL<;�KF�� �8�8� ALI@JK@:�G<IJFE�I<>@JK<I<;� @E�K<IDJ�F=�K?<�-FLK?

�=I@:8E�'8N��9�8�E8KLI8C�G<IJFE�N?F� @J�8�-FLK?��=I@:8E�:@K@Q<E�FI�8�G<ID8E<EK�I<J@;<EK�F=�-FLK?��=I@:8� �:�8� ALI@JK@:

G<IJFE�K?8K�@J�EFK�I<>@JK<I<;�@E�K<IDJ�F=�K?<�-FLK?��=I@:8E�C8N�FI�8�E8KLI8C�G<IJFE�N?F�@J�EFK�8�-FLK?��=I@:8E�:@K@Q<E�FI�8

G<ID8E<EK� I<J@;<EK�F=�-FLK?��=I@:8� @=� K?8K� ALI@JK@:�G<IJFE�FI� =FI<@>E�E8K@FE8C�8GGC@<J� AF@EKCP�N@K?�8� ALI@JK@:�FI�E8KLI8C

G<IJFE� I<=<II<;� KF� 89FM<� .?<� D8AFI@KP� F=� =FI<@>E<IJ� 8::<JJ� ><E<K@:� I<JFLI:<J� =IFD� <O�J@KL� :FCC<:K@FEJ K?IFL>?

:FCC89FI8K@FE�N@CC�CF:8C�@EJK@KLK@FEJ�

�9�38>/<7/.3+<3/=

:6+C�+8�37:9<>+8>

<96/�09<���$�38�>2/

$EK<ID<;@8I@<J� C@B<� LE@M<IJ@K@<J� 8E;� I<J<8I:?� @EJK@KLK@FEJ� GC8P� 8E� @DGFIK8EK� IFC<� @E� ��-� @E� -FLK?� �=I@:8� 8J� K?<P� 8I<

8:K@M<CP� @EMFCM<;� @E� K?<� 9@FGIFJG<:K@E>� J<:KFI� K?IFL>?� :FE;L:K@E>� <OK<EJ@M<� I<J<8I:?� NFIB� GFJJ@9CP� G8IKE<I@E>� N@K?

9FK?� CF:8C�8E;� =FI<@>E� @EJK@KLK@FEJ�8E;� CF:8C� :FDDLE@K@<J�8E;�FI� @E;@M@;L8CJ��.?<P�D8P�8CJF� =FID� AF@EK�M<EKLI<J�N@K?

Page 22: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

-9?8><C��/�1�

?83@/<=3>3/=�

</=/+<-2

38=>3>?>/=��/B�=3>?

-966/->398=�

@EK<IE8K@FE8C�FI>8E@J8K@FEJ�=FI�I<8JFEJ�JK8K<;�89FM<�8E;�FK?<I�I<8JFEJ�K?8K�D8P�9<E<=@K�K?<�JF:@<KP�F=�-FLK?��=I@:8�

$E� 8;;@K@FE� @EK<ID<;@8I@<J� JL:?� 8J� 9@FKI8;<IJ� GC8P� 8E� @DGFIK8EK� IFC<� @E� =8:@C@K8K@E>� 8::<JJ� KF� -FLK?� �=I@:8UJ� I8N

D8K<I@8CJ�F=�@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�=FI�=LIK?<I�I<J<8I:?�8E;�;<M<CFGD<EK�@E�=FI<@>E�:FLEKI@<J�

(29�+</�>2/�7+38

:<9@3./<=�90��#

+--/==/. 38�=3>?�38

>2/�-9?8><C��>2/

$>+>/��"<3@+>/

6+8.9A8/<=�

�8.31/89?=�+8.

69-+6�-977?83>3/=�

-FLK?��=I@:8�GIFM@;<J�><E<K@:�I<JFLI:<J�8E;�K?<J<�8I<�F=K<E�JFLI:<;�=IFD�9@FKI8;<IJ�8E;�8CJF�;@I<:KCP�=IFD�@E;@><EFLJ

8E;� CF:8C� :FDDLE@K@<J�� �J� JK8K<;� 89FM<� ;<JG@K<� K?<� -K8K<� 9<@E>� K?<� KILJK<<� F=� 9@FCF>@:8C� ;@M<IJ@KP� @E� K?<� :FLEKIP

C<>@JC8K@FE�;F<J�EFK�M<JK�FNE<IJ?@G�F=�><E<K@:�I<JFLI:<J�@E�K?<�JK8K<�LEC<JJ�K?<P�F::LI�FE�JK8K<�C8E;��.?<�C8E;FNE<I�@E

-FLK?��=I@:8�@E�K<IDJ�F=�:FDDFE�C8N�FNEJ�9FK?�K?<�9@FCF>@:8C�8E;�K?<�><E<K@:�I<JFLI:<J�FE�FI�LE;<I�?@J ?<I�GIFG<IKP�

.?<I<=FI<�><E<K@:�I<JFLI:<J�8I<�8::<JJ<J�D8@ECP�=IFD�GI@M8K<�8E;�:FDDLE8C�C8E;�

4. USERS OF GENETIC RESOURCES:(29�+</�>2/�7+38

?=/<=�90�1/8/>3-

</=9?<-/=�38�>2/

-9?8><C��%2/

</=/+<-2

-977?83>C��>2/

:<3@+>/�=/->9<���9<

A2+>�:?<:9=/�.9

>2/C�+--/==��#�

�/�1��,+=3-�</=/+<-2�

-977/<-3+63D+>398��

�</�>2/C�79=>6C

09</318/<=�9<

8+>398+6=�

�FK?�K?<�I<J<8I:?�:FDDLE@KP�8E;�GI@M8K<�J<:KFI�8I<�LJ<IJ�F=�><E<K@:�I<JFLI:<J��$E�8::FI;8E:<�N@K?�K?<�I<:FI;J�@E�K?<

G<ID@K�JPJK<D -<M<EK<<E ��� G<ID@KJ�>I8EK<;�8I<�=FI�:FDD<I:@8C@J8K@FE�GIFA<:KJ�8E;�K?<J<�:FDGI@J<�F= J@OK<<E ���

CF:8C� :FDG8E@<J� 8E; FE<� �� =FI<@>E� <EK@KP�� -@E:<� K?<� @DGC<D<EK8K@FE� F=� ���-� ,<>LC8K@FEJ� K?<� �<G8IKD<EK� F=

EM@IFED<EK8C� �==8@IJ� ?8J� I<:<@M<;� @E� KFK8C J<M<EKP� J<M<E ��� G<ID@K� 8GGC@:8K@FEJ� =FI� :FDD<I:@8C@J8K@FE� G?8J<� F=

9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�F=�N?@:? J@OKP ��� 8I<�@E�K?<�I<M@<N�8E;�8GGIFM8C�G?8J<��� ��?8J�I<:<@M<; <@>?KP�FE< ��� EFK@=@:8K@FEJ

=FI�K?<�;@J:FM<IP�G?8J<� $K�DLJK�9<�EFK<;�K?8K�K?<��@F;@M<IJ@KP �:K�;@JK@E>L@J?<J�9<KN<<E�K?<�;@J:FM<IP�G?8J<�8E;�K?<

:FDD<I:@8C@J8K@FE�G?8J<�F=�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>��.?<�;@J:FM<IP�G?8J<� @J�N?<E�K?<�LJ<I� @J� KIP@E>� KF� =@E;�FLK� @=� K?<I<� @J�8EP

GFK<EK@8C� @E� K?<� $�,� K?8K� :FLC;� =LIK?<I� 9<� ;<M<CFG<;� @EKF� 8� :FDD<I:@8C� GIF;L:K� 8E;� K?<� :FDD<I:@8C@J8K@FE� G?8J<� @J

N?<E�JFD<K?@E>�N@K?�:FDD<I:@8C�GFK<EK@8C�?8J�8CI<8;P�9<<E�@;<EK@=@<;�@E�K?<�$�,�

�0��#�+</�+--/==/. .?<I<�?8J�9<<E�8�JLI><�@E�K?<�LJ<�F=�E8KLI8C�GIF;L:KJ� @E� @E;LJKI@<J�JL:?�8J�:FJD<K@:J ELKI8:<LK@:8CJ G?8ID8:<LK@:8C

Page 23: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

09<�-977/<-3+6

:?<:9=/=��A2+>

>C:/=�90�=/->9<=�+</

38>/</=>/.�38�>2/=/

�#

�/�1��:2+<7+�

-9=7/>3-=�

+1<3-?6>?</�

38.?=><3+6�,39>/-2��

8E;�9@FKI8;<IJ 8E;�><E<K@:�I<JFLI:<J�8I<�LK@C@J<;�=FI�9FK?�I<J<8I:?�8E;�:FDD<I:@8C@Q8K@FE�GLIGFJ<J� *=�K?< J<M<EK<<E

��� 8GGIFM<; 9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�G<ID@KJ E@E< ���8I<��@FKI8;<IJ�KNF��� 8I<�+?8ID8:<LK@:8C�FE<����@J �FJD<K@:�FE<���

)LKI8:<LK@:8C�FE<� ����>I@:LCKLI8C� �#<I9@:@;<J�8E;�8�+?8ID8:<LK@:8C�FE<� �� $EJ<:K� I<G<CC<EK�FE<� ��� ��FJD<K@: 8E;

�@FKI8;<I 8E;� FE<� �� +?8ID8:<LK@:8C 8E;� �@FKI8;<I� *=� K?<� G<ID@K� 8GGC@:8K@FEJ� G<E;@E>� 8GGIFM8C K?@IKP� ��� 8I<

+?8ID8:<LK@:8C�=FLIK<<E������@FKI8;<IJ�KNF����)LKI8:<LK@:8C�8E;�KN<CM<������FJD<K@:��FDG8E@<J�

�9/=�>2/�8+>398+6

��$�=C=>/7�38�:6+-/

+6=9�+..</==�>2/

9,631+>398�90�C9?<

-9?8><C�+=�?=/<�90

1/8/>3-�</=9?<-/=

+--/==/.�38�09</318

-9?8><3/=���8�9>2/<

A9<.=��+</

9,631+>398=�37:9=/.

98 ?=/<=�38�C9?<

4?<3=.3->398�A29

2+@/�+--/==/.��#�38

09</318�-9?8><3/=�>9

</=:/->���$

</;?3</7/8>=�90

09</318�-9?8><3/=�

�?8GK<I� �� 8E;� �� F=� ) (��� GIFM@;<J� 8� =I8D<NFIB� =FI� I<>LC8K@E>� 9@FGIFJG<:K@E>� @EMFCM@E>� @E;@><EFLJ� 9@FCF>@:8C

I<JFLI:<J� 8E; FI� 8JJF:@8K<;� KI8;@K@FE8C� BEFNC<;><�� .?<� ���-� ,<>LC8K@FEJ� GIFM@;<� ;<K8@CJ� FE� K?<� GIF:<JJ<;� 8E;

GIF:<;LI<J�=FI�<E>8>@E>� @E�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�8:K@M@K@<J� C<>8CCP����?FJK�F=�FK?<I� C8NJ�8;D@E@JK<I<;�9P�FK?<I�;<G8IKD<EKJ

8CJF� ?8M<� I<C<M8E:<� @E� K?<� <==<:K@M<� @DGC<D<EK8K@FE� F=� K?<� GIFM@J@FE� F=�) (��� 8E;� ���-� ,<>LC8K@FEJ�� �J� G8IK� F=� 8

GI<G8I8KFIP� GIF:<JJ� =FI� K?<� E8K@FE8C� @DGC<D<EK8K@FE� F=� K?<� )8>FP8� +IFKF:FC� FE� ��-� -FLK?� �=I@:8 @J� :FEK@ELFLJCP

<E>8>@E>�N@K?�I<C<M8EK�JK8B<?FC;<IJ�@E�G8IK@:LC8I�FE�K?<�E<N�F9C@>8K@FEJ�FLKC@E<;�@E�K?<�)8>FP8�+IFKF:FC�FE���-�N?@:?

8I<�EFK�:FM<I<;�@E�K?<�<O@JK@E>�E8K@FE8C�C<>@JC8K@FE�9LK�I<HL@I<J�8;D@E@JKI8K@M<�JPJK<DJ�KF�9<�GLK�@E�GC8:<�=FI�<==<:K@M<

@DGC<D<EK8K@FE� K?<I<F=�� -FLK?� �=I@:8� 9<@E>� 9FK?� 8� GIFM@;<I� 8E;� � 8� LJ<I� ?8J� <D98IB<;� FE� 8� E8K@FE8C� JK8B<?FC;<I

<E>8><D<EK�GIF:<JJ�KF�8;;I<JJ�K?<�@;<EK@=@<;�E<N�F9C@>8K@FEJ�F=�K?<�)8>FP8�+IFKF:FC�9<@E>���8��IK@:C<������FDGC@8E:<

N@K?��FD<JK@:�'<>@JC8K@FE�FI�,<>LC8KFIP�,<HL@I<D<EKJ�FE��::<JJ�8E;��<E<=@K�-?8I@E>�F=�K?<�GIFM@;<I�:FLEKIP�8E;��9

�IK@:C<� ���� (FE@KFI@E>� K?<� /K@C@Q8K@FE� F=� "<E<K@:� ,<JFLI:<J� �FE:FD@K8EK� KF� K?8K� @J� K?<� I<M@<N� F=� K?<� 8GGC@:89C<

C<>@JC8K@FE�N?@:?�N@CC�@E:FIGFI8K<�8CC�K?<�F9C@>8K@FEJ <D8E8K@E>�=IFD�K?<�)8>FP8�+IFKF:FC�

5. ABS AGREEMENTS�9A�7+8C���$

+1<//7/8>=�2+@/

-@E:<���-�8>I<<D<EKJ� @E�-FLK?��=I@:8�8I<�8E� @E?<I<EK�I<HL@I<D<EK�F=�K?<�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�G<ID@KK@E>�GIF:<JJ<J @E�K?<

:FLEKIP� K?<I<� 8I<� :LII<EKCP �� G<ID@KJ� @JJL<; �� (.�J� 8E; �� �-�J� 8GGIFM<;� 9P� K?<� (@E@JK<I� F=� 18K<I� 8E;

Page 24: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

,//8�-98-6?./.���=

>23=�3809<7+>398

</-9<./.���0�89>�

:6/+=/ :<9@3./�+8

38.3-+>398�

EM@IFED<EK8C��==8@IJ�8E;�8CC�K?<J<�8I<�B<GK�FE�I<:FI;�9P�K?<�E8K@FE8C��<G8IKD<EK�F=� EM@IFED<EK8C��==8@IJ�

(/</�>2/=/���$

+1<//7/8>=�09<

898�-977/<-3+6�9<

-977/<-3+6

?>363D+>398�90��#�

�CC�K?<�8GGIFM<;�8>I<<D<EKJ�8I<�=FI�K?<�:FDD<I:@8C@J8K@FE�G?8J<�F=�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�

(/</�+8C�,/8/03>=

./<3@/.�0<97�>2/=/

+1<//7/8>=�

3<J 9FK?�DFE<K8IP 8E; EFE�DFE<K8IP�9<E<=@KJ�?8M<�9<<E�;<I@M<; =IFD K?<J<�8>I<<D<EKJ� O8DGC<J�8I<�>@M<E�9<CFN�

(2+>�+</�>2/�>C:/=

90�,/8/03>=

1/8/<+>/.�0<97

>2/=/���$

+1<//7/8>=�

�98/>+<C��898�

798/>+<C�

�9A�+</�>2/C

=2+</.��(2+>�>C:/

90�=?::9<>��30�+8C��3=

:<9@3./.�>9

,/8/03-3+<3/=

</-/3@381�,/8/03>=

+<3=381�0<97���%

+8.���$

+1<//7/8>=�

.?<� KPG<J� F=� 9<E<=@KJ� ><E<I8K<;� =IFD� ��-� 8>I<<D<EKJ� K<E;� KF� M8IP� =IFD� :8J<� KF� :8J< 8E; 8I<� ;@M@;<;� @EKF� KNF

:8K<>FI@<J��DFE<K8IP� 8E;�EFE�DFE<K8IP�9<E<=@KJ�� .?<J<� :FLC;�<@K?<I�9<� J?FIK� K<ID�D<;@LD�K<ID�8E;� CFE>� K<ID�8J

JK@GLC8K<;�@E K?<����-�,<>LC8KFIP�!I8D<NFIB��.?<I<�8I<�D8EP�9<E<=@KJ�8M8@C89C<�KF�GIFM@;<IJ�KF�:?FFJ<�=IFD�;<G<E;@E>

FE�N?<K?<I�K?<�JK8B<?FC;<I� @J�GIFM@;@E>�8::<JJ�KF�K?<� @E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�FI� @J�8E� @E;@><EFLJ�:FDDLE@KP

8E;�EFE<�F=�K?<D�8I<�<O:CLJ@M<�����- ,<>LC8K@FEJ�GIFM@;<J�8�C@JK�F=�9<E<=@KJ�K?8K�8I<�DFI<�I<C<M8EK�@=�K?<�JK8B<?FC;<I�KF

K?<�8>I<<D<EK� @J�GIFM@;@E>�FI�>@M@E>�8::<JJ�KF�K?<� @E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�8E;�8�J<:FE;� C@JK�GIFM@;<;� @J�DFI<

I<C<M8EK�KF�@=�8�JK8B<?FC;<I�KF�K?<�8>I<<D<EK�@J�8E�@E;@><EFLJ�:FDDLE@KP���(FE<K8IP�9<E<=@KJ�8J�JK8K<;�89FM<�8I<�;<8CK

N@K?� K?IFL>?�8��@FGIFJG<:K@E>�.ILJK�!LE;�8E; @E:CLJ@M<�F= EFE�DFE<K8IP�9<E<=@KJ� K?<��<G8IKD<EK�F=� EM@IFED<EK8C

�==8@IJ�GC8PJ�8�JLGGFIK�IFC<�KF�9<E<=@:@8I@<J�K?IFL>?�DFE@KFI@E>�F= :FDGC@8E:< KF�8>I<<D<EKJ�9P�K?<�LJ<IJ�

Page 25: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

�B+7:6/=�90

37:6/7/8>/.���$

+1<//7/8>=

�������"��#����&%����$��"%)���%�������

%C:/�90�:/<73>� $EK<>I8K<;�<OGFIK�8E;��@FGIFJG<:K@E>�G<ID@K

�39:<9=:/->381�"<94/->�98 ��!'!/%0(�/*-/*.%0(

.?<� (@E@JK<I� F=� 18K<I� 8E;� EM@IFED<EK8C� �==8@IJ� @JJL<;� 8E� $EK<>I8K<;� OGFIK� 8E;� �@FGIFJG<:K@E>� G<ID@K� KF� #"#

+?8ID8:<LK@:8CJ��+KP�'K;�=FI�CF:8C�8E;�@EK<IE8K@FE8C�I<J<8I:?�FE�:LCK@M8K<;�GC8EK�D8K<I@8C�8E;�<OKI8:KJ�=IFD ����"�#�

"� "�!�#��:FDDFECP�I<=<II<;�KF�8J�&8EE8��?8EE8�FI�&FL>F<;8E;�KF :FDD<I:@8C@J<�K?<�GIF;L:K�

.?<�GIF;L:K�@J�:FDD<I:@8CCP�8M8@C89C<�@E�-FLK?��=I@:8�8J�4<D9I@E�

�<E<=@:@8I@<J��-FLK?��=I@:8E�)8K@FE8C�-8E��FLE:@C��-8E�+8LCJ?F<B�8E;�)FLI@M@<I �)8D8 :FDDLE@K@<J

�� ���%��%�!

�98/>+<C�

• #"#�+?8ID8:<LK@:8CJ�N@CC�G8P�K?< -FLK?��=I@:8E�-8E��FLE:@C�8E�8EEL8C�IFP8CKP�F=����G<I�8EELD�FE�K?<�E<K�GIF:<<;J

K?<P�I<:<@M<� =FI�K?<�=@IJK K?I<<�P<8IJ�IFP8CKP�N@CC�FECP 9<�G8P89C<�@E�I<JG<:K�F=�E<K�GIF:<<;J�I<:<@M<;�;LI@E>�<8:?

P<8I�@E�<O:<JJ�F=�,�D@CC@FE

• ����F=�IFP8CK@<J�I<:<@M<;�9P -8E�N@CC�9<�G8@;�KF�K?<�+8LCJ?F<B�8E;�)FLI@M@<I�:FDDLE@K@<J

• �EEL8C�G8PD<EK�F=����G<I�8EELD�FE�E<K�GIF:<<;J�F=�J8C<J�I<:<@M<;�=FI�<O:CLJ@M<�LJ<�F=�K?<�-8E�'F>F

• /G=IFEK�G8PD<EK N8J�G8@;�@EKF�K?<��@FGIFJG<:K@E>�.ILJK�=LE;�F=�K?<�-8E��FLE:@C�8E;�K?<�:FDDLE@K@<J�F=�+8LCJ?F<B

8E;�)FLI@M@<I

98�798/>+<C�

• .?<�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�GIFA<:K�:FEK@EL<J�KF�:FEKI@9LK<�KF�K?<�<E?8E:<D<EK�F=�J:@<EK@=@:�BEFNC<;><�F=�I<J<8I:?<IJ

<DGCFP<;�8K�K?<�-FLK?��=I@:8E�:FEJFIK@LD�#"#�+?8ID8:<LK@:8CJ

• �:BEFNC<;><D<EK�@J�>@M<E�KF�K?<�-8E�:FDDLE@KP�N?F�8I<�K?<�@E;@><EFLJ�BEFNC<;><�?FC;<IJ�K?IFL>?�K?<

<E;FIJ<D<EK�F=�K?<@I�CF>F�FE�K?<�GIF;L:K

Page 26: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

• %F9�:I<8K@FE�=IFD�K?<�:LCK@M8K@FE�F=�K?<�@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<

������� ���&%����&%���%#&$%������

%C:/�90 "/<73>� �@FGIFJG<:K@E>�G<ID@K

�&%����&%���%#&$%�"#!���%

.?<�(@E@JK<I�F=�18K<I�8E;� EM@IFED<EK8C��==8@IJ�?8J�8N8I;<;�8�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�G<ID@K�KF� ;8B<E@�(LK?@�!LK?@�.ILJK�=FI

K?<� :LCK@M8K@FE� GIF:<JJ@E>� 8E;� D8IB<K@E>� F=� ?<I98C� GIF;L:KJ� :FEK8@E@E>� 8:K@M<� @E>I<;@<EKJ� =IFD� J<M<EKP� <@>?K� ��

@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�

�<E<=@:@8I@<J�� ;8B<E@��FDDLE@KP�-<EQFBL?C<�!FF;�+IF;L:K@FE��FFG<I8K@M<�'K;�8E;� EQ8E>8B?F��FEJLCK8E:P�::

�� ���%��%�!

�98/>+<C�

X .?<�:FDDLE@KP�?8J�8�J?8I<�F=�LG�KF�����F=�8EP�GIF=@KJ�><E<I8K<;�9P�K?<�9LJ@E<JJ�@EKF�K?<�.ILJK

98�798/>+<C�

X -LJK8@E89C<�<DGCFPD<EK�=FI�LG�KF����ILI8C�NFD<E

X HL@GD<EK�8E;�@E=I8JKIL:KLI<�JLGGFIK�KF�K?<�:FDDLE@KP

X EM@IFED<EK8C�8E;�:FEJ<IM8K@FE�<;L:8K@FE

X .I8@E@E>�FE�8>IF�GIF:<JJ@E>

Page 27: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

� �!& �����!#�$��� %������ ��� �&$%#����#�$��#�����$�#�

%C:/�90�"/<73>� �@FGIFJG<:K@E>�G<ID@K

����� �� � ��� "#!���%

.?<�(@E@JK<I�F=�18K<I�8E;� EM@IFED<EK8C��==8@IJ�@JJL<;�8�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�G<ID@K�=FI�K?<�:LCK@M8K@FE�F= ��������$�����

K?<�;@JK@CC8K@FE�8E;�<OKI8:K@FE�F=�K?<�F@C�=FI�:FDD<I:@8C�GIF;L:K@FE�F=�DFJHL@KF�I<G<CC<EK�:8E;C<J�

�/8/03-3+<3/=� )8K@FE8C�.I8;@K@FE8C�#<8C<IJ��FDD@KK<<

�� ������%�!

98�798/>+<C���98/>+<C�+8.�E38�538.F�,/8/03>=�

• .?@J�@J�8�:FDDLE@KP�FNE<;�<EK<IGI@J<�GIFA<:K 8K�K?<�:LCK@M8K@FE�J@K<

• ���F=�K?<�D@C<JKFE<�G8PD<EK�FE�8CC�K?<�@E:FD<�I<:<@M<;�=IFD�C@:<EJ<

• DGCFPD<EKJ� F=� "@P8E@� :FDDLE@KP� ���� D<D9<IJ� F=� K?<� (8JN8E>8E@� 8E;� (89LE;8� :FDDLE@K@<J� D<D9<IJ� 8K

"@P8E@�!8:@C@KP�@E�K?<�:LCK@M8K@FE�?8IM<JK�;@JK@C�F@CJ�8E;�D8EL=8:KLI<�DFJHL@KF�I<G<CC<EK�:8E;C<J�

• .<:?EFCF>P�KI8EJ=<I

�� ��!"#!�&�%$

%C:/�90�:/<73>� $EK<>I8K<;�<OGFIK�8E;��@FGIFJG<:K@E>�G<ID@K

�39:<9=:/->381�"<94/->�98 �).*)%�� %#%/�/�

.?<�(@E@JK<I�F=�18K<I�8E;� EM@IFED<EK8C��==8@IJ�@JJL<;�8E�@EK<>I8K<;�<OGFIK�8E;�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�G<ID@K�KF� :F+IF;L:KJ�

"<94/->�>3>6/� .?<�D8@E�GLIGFJ<�F=�K?<�GIFA<:K�@J�KF�9LP�GIF;L:<�8E;�J<CC�98F989�J<<;�8E;�=IL@K�GFN;<I�KF�9<�LJ<;�8J

=FF;�8E;�:FJD<K@:�@E>I<;@<EKJ�

Page 28: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

�/8/03-3+<3/=� �<E<=@:@8IP�KF�K?<�GIFA<:K�@J�K?<�(LBFM?8N898C<�8E;�(LJNF;@��@G<E@��FDDLE@K@<J�I<GI<J<EK<;�9P��?@<=

'@E>8E@�&<EE<K?�)<K?<E>N<�8E;��?@<=�(@BFJ@� DD8EL<C�)<=FCFM?F;N<�I<JG<:K@M<CP�@E�0<E;8�'@DGFGF�+IFM@E:<�N?F

8I<�@EMFCM<;�@E�:FCC<:K@E>��F8989�=IL@KJ�

�� ���%��%�!

�98/>+<C�

• ,<@D9LIJ<D<EK�G<I�B@CF>I8D�F=�9F8989�=IL@K�FE�;<C@M<IP�8J�LG=IFEK�G8PD<EK�;<C@M<I<;�9P�K?<�:FDDLE@K@<J�KF

:F+IF;L:KJ�

98�798/>+<C

• .?<�C@M<C@?FF;J�F=�FM<I������D8I>@E8C@J<;�ILI8C�NFD<E�NFLC;�9<�JLGGFIK<;�

• *E�>F@E>�:FDDLE@:8K@FE�N@K?�K?<�:FDDLE@K@<J�

• /G�KF����G<FGC<�NFLC;�9<�G<ID8E<EKCP�<DGCFP<;�

• /G>I8;@E>�8E;�GIF:<JJ@E>�F=�CF:8C�GIF:<JJ@E>�=8:@C@KP�

• JK89C@J?D<EK�F=�CF:8C ELIJ<IP =FI�>IFN@E>�98F989�KI<<J�

• -@DGC@=@<;�8E;�GFGLC8I@J<;�GFJK<IJ�D8EL8CJ�G8DG?C<KJ�8E;�FK?<I�;F:LD<EK�KI8EJC8K<;�@EKF�CF:8C�C8E>L8><J�

• $E:CLJ@FE�F=�CF:8C�:FDDLE@K@<J�@E�K?<�I<J<8I:?�GIF>I8DD<J�8E;�GIFA<:KJ�

• ,<:F>E@K@FE�8E;�GIFDFK@FE�F=�KI8;@K@FE8C�BEFNC<;><�

• 'FE>�K<ID�I<J<8I:?�@EKF�K?<�<==<:K�F=�<EM@IFED<EK8C�:?8E><�FE��8F989�JLIM@M8C�8E;�I<:IL@KD<EK��8E;

• �<M<CFGD<EK�F=�D8K<I@8CJ�=FI��8F989�<EM@IFED<EK8C�<;L:8K@FE�=FI�J:?FFCJ�:FDDLE@K@<J�8E;

*K?<I� @DGC<D<EK<; ��-� <O8DGC<J� :8E� 9<� =FLE;� FE� K?<� � �� N<9J@K<� =FCCFN@E>� K?<� C@EB� 9<CFN�

NNN�<EM@IFED<EK�>FM�Q8 J@K<J ;<=8LCK =@C<J ;F:J G<ID@KJ78N8I;<;�G;=

�+@/�>2/=/���$

+1<//7/8>=

-98><3,?>/.�>9

-98=/<@+>398�+8.

�FEJ<IM8K@FE� 9<E<=@KJ� 8I<� @DG<I8K@M<� @E� FI;<I� KF� JLGGFIK� K?<� <:FJPJK<D� =IFD�N?<I<� K?<� I<JFLI:<�N8J� <OKI8:K<;� @E

FI;<I�KF�8MF@;�FM<I�<OGCF@K8K@FE�8E;�LEJLJK8@E89C<�LJ<�F=�K?<�I<JFLI:<���E�<O8DGC<�F=�EFK89C<�9<E<=@KJ�K?8K�?8M<�9<<E

@E:CL;<;�@E�JFD<�F=�K?<�8>I<<D<EKJ�@E:CL;<;�9LK�EFK�C@D@K<;�KF�

Page 29: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

=?=>+38+,6/�?=/�90

,396913-+6

.3@/<=3>C�38�C9?<

-9?8><C�

• "<E<K@:�@E=FID8K@FE�><E<I8K<;�K?IFL>?�K?@J�GIFA<:K�N@CC�:FEKI@9LK<�KF�-FLK?��=I@:8E�:FEJ<IM8K@FE�F9A<:K@M<J

@E:CL;@E>�K?<�GI<M<EK@FE�F=�><E<�GFCCLK@FE

• -LGGFIK�=FI�:FEJ<IM8K@FE K?IFL>?�9LIJ8I@<J

• .I8@E@E>�FE�JLJK8@E89C<�?8IM<JK@E>�D<K?F;J�F=�K?<�I<JFLI:<

• EM@IFED<EK8C�<;L:8K@FE

• EM@IFED<EK8C�8E;�:FEJ<IM8K@FE�<;L:8K@FE

• ,<JFLI:<��JJ<JJD<EK�8E;�I<>LC8K<;�HL8EK@KP�F=�8LK?FI@J<;�@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C��I<JFLI:<J�=FI�N@C;�:FCC<:K@FE

?8IM<JK@E>

• �@F;@M<IJ@KP�(8E8><D<EK�+C8E�=FI�-G<:@<J

$K� @J� @DG<I8K@M<� K?8K� K?<� G<ID@K� @JJL@E>� 8LK?FI@K@<J� <EJLI<� K?8K� K?<� I<C<M8EK� 8:K@M@KP� N@CC� EFK� ;<GC<K<� 8E� @E;@><EFLJ

9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<�9<PFE;�8�C<M<C N?<I<�@KJ�@EK<>I@KP�@J�A<FG8I;@J<;�8E;�K?8K�K?<�@DG8:K�F=�K?<�8:K@M@KP�N@CC�9<�E<>C@>@9C<

FI�N@CC�9<�D@E@D@J<;�8E;�I<D<;@<;�K?LJ�@E:CLJ@FE�F=�:FEJ<IM8K@FE�9<E<=@KJ�@E�8CC�8>I<<D<EKJ�

6. KEY LESSONS LEARNED(2+>�A366�C9?�.9

.300/</8>6C�38

0?>?</�

�FEK@ELFLJ� @DGIFM<D<EK� I<HL@I<J�8� :FDD@KD<EK� KF�;F@E>� K?@E>J�;@==<I<EKCP� 1<�8I<� C<8IE@E>� =IFD�G8JK�<OG<I@<E:<J

8E;�9L@C;@E>�FE�JL::<JJ<J�K?8K�N<�?8M<�8:?@<M<;���?8CC<E><J��8J� C@JK<;�9<CFN�K?8K�?8M<�9<<E�<E:FLEK<I<;�8I<�9<@E>

GI@FI@K@J<;�8E;�8;;I<JJ<;�KF�<EJLI<�K?8K�8�=LE:K@FE8C�8E;�J<8DC<JJ���-�JPJK<D�@J�8KK8@E<;�

�+=/.�98�C9?<

/B:/<3/8-/��A2+>

+</�5/C�/6/7/8>=

09<�+�0?8->398+6���$

=C=>/7�

�J� JK@GLC8K<;� @E� ) (��� B<P� <C<D<EKJ� F=� 8� =LE:K@FE8C� ��-� JPJK<D� DLJK� <EJLI<� K?<� =FCCFN@E>�� �8 9@FGIFJG<:K@E>

@EMFCM@E>�@E;@><EFLJ�><E<K@:�8E;�9@FCF>@:8C I<JFLI:<J�@J�I<>LC8K<;���9 K?<�<OGFIKJ =IFD�K?< -FLK?��=I@:8 F=�@E;@><EFLJ

><E<K@:�8E;�9@FCF>@:8C I<JFLI:<J�=FI�K?<�GLIGFJ<�F=�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�FI�8EP�FK?<I�B@E;�F=�I<J<8I:? 8I<�I<>LC8K<;���: 8�=8@I

8E;� <HL@K89C<� J?8I@E>� 9P� JK8B<?FC;<IJ� @E� 9<E<=@KJ� 8I@J@E> =IFD� 9@FGIFJG<:K@E>� @EMFCM@E>� @E;@><EFLJ� ><E<K@:� 8E;

9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J @J�GIFM@;<;�=FI�8E;���; K?8K�K?<�E8K@FE�J�@E;@><EFLJ�><E<K@:�8E;�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�8I< ;<M<CFG<;

8E;�LK@C@Q<;� @E�8E�<:FCF>@:8CCP�JLJK8@E89C<�D8EE<I�N?@C<�GIFDFK@E> JF:@8C�8E;�<:FEFD@:�;<M<CFGD<EK� @E�G8IK@:LC8I� @E

K?<�8I<8J�N?<I<�K?< @E;@><EFLJ�><E<K@:�FI�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�8E;�8JJF:@8K<;�KI8;@K@FE8C�BEFNC<;>< @J�8::<JJ<;� .?@J

Page 30: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

<EK8@CJ�K?<�=FCCFN@E>�

• �EPFE<� :8IIP@E>�FLK� 9@FGIFJG<:K@E>� @EMFCM@E>� $�,� 8E;� @=� 8GGC@:89C<� 8JJF:@8K<;� KI8;@K@FE8C� LJ<�FI� BEFNC<;><�DLJK

?8M<�8�G<ID@K�F9K8@E<;�=IFD�8�I<C<M8EK�@JJL@E>�8LK?FI@KP

• �EPFE<�<OGFIK@E>�$�,�=FI�K?<�GLIGFJ<J�F=�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�FI�FK?<I�I<J<8I:?�DLJK�F9K8@E�8�G<ID@K�F9K8@E<;�=IFD�8

I<C<M8EK�@JJL@E>�8LK?FI@KP

• )F�G<IJFE�D8P�N@K?FLK�=@IJK�EFK@=P@E>�K?<�(@E@JK<I�<E>8><�@E�K?<�;@J:FM<IP�G?8J<�F= 9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�@EMFCM@E>�8EP

@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�

• �FII<:K�JK8B<?FC;<IJ�@E�8�9<E<=@K�J?8I@E>�8>I<<D<EK�8I<�@;<EK@=@<;

• �<=FI<�8�G<ID@K @J�@JJL<; 8EP�@EK<I<JKJ�F=�JK8B<?FC;<IJ�8I<�GIFK<:K<;

• (.�J�8E;��-�J�8I<�@E�8�GI<J:I@9<;�=FID8K�8E;�<EK<I<;�@EKF�9P�8CC�G8IK@<J�@EMFCM<;

• ��D<:?8E@JD�KF�DFE@KFI�:FDGC@8E:<�KF�8>I<<D<EKJ�@J�@E�GC8:<

• ���@FGIFJG<:K@E>�.ILJK�!LE;�@J�<JK89C@J?<;�@EKF�N?@:?�8CC�DFE<PJ�8I@J@E>�=IFD��-�J�8E;�;L<�KF�JK8B<?FC;<IJ�DLJK�9<

G8@;�@EKF

�8�</6+>398�>9

:<9-/.?</=�09<�"��

• $;<EK@=P@E>�K?<�:FII<:K�:FDDLE@KP�KF�J<<B�+$��=IFD @J�F=�G8I8DFLEK�@DGFIK8E:<�;LI@E>�K?<�@E@K@8C�JK8><J

• $K�DLJK�9<�<EJLI<;� K?8K�8CC� I<C<M8EK�D8K<I@8C�?8J�9<<E�;@J:CFJ<;� KF� JK8B<?FC;<IJ� @E:CL;@E>� @E=FID8K@FE�89FLK� K?<

@EK<E;<; LJ< <E;�I<JLCK�8E;�D<K?F;�F=�:FCC<:K@FE

• .?<�JK8B<?FC;<IJ�DLJK�8>I<< KF�GIFM@;@E>�8::<JJ KF� $�, FI�J?8I@E> F=�.& GI@FI�KF�8EP�=LIK?<I�<E>8><D<EKJ�FE�K?<

@EK<E;<;�M<EKLI<

• �CC 8>I<<D<EKJ�DLJK�9<�:FE=@ID<;�8E;�;F:LD<EK<;�N@K? @JJL<J�I<C8K<;�KF�8::<JJ�KF�$�, .I8;@K@FE8C�&EFNC<;><

�8�</6+>398�>9�>2/

8/19>3+>398�90��%�

• (.� DLJK 9<�=@E8C@J<;�GI@FI�KF�JL9D@KK@E>�8�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�G<ID@K�8GGC@:8K@FE KF�K?<��FDG<K<EK�)8K@FE8C��LK?FI@KP

• (.��DLJK�9<�J@>E<;�9P 9FK?�K?< GIFM@;<I�8E;�LJ<I�F=�K?<�$�,�8E; FI�KI8;@K@FE8C�BEFNC<;><

• $=�LJ<I�@J�KF�GIFM@;<�$�, 8E; FI�KI8;@K@FE8C�BEFNC<;>< KF�8�K?@I;�G8IKP�GIFM@;<I DLJK J<K�:FE;@K@FEJ�FE�JL:?�KI8EJ=<I

8E;�@K�DLJK�9<�JK8K<;�@E�K?<�(.��8E; K?< �FDG<K<EK�)8K@FE8C��LK?FI@KP�DLJK 9<�EFK@=@<;

• +IFM@;<I�DLJK�GIFM@;<�I<C<M8EK�@E=FID8K@FE�KF�K?<�LJ<I�K?8K�N@CC�9<�E<<;<;�KF�:FDGC<K<�K?<�8GGC@:8K@FE�=FID

• -K8E;8I;�=FID8K�=FI�;I8=K@E>�F=�(.� DLJK 9<�D8;<�8M8@C89C<�KF�GIFM@;<I�8E;�LJ<I

Page 31: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

• .?<�(@E@JK<I�KF�8GGIFM<�8CC�(.�J�FI�8D<E;D<EKJ�KF�JL:?�8>I<<D<EKJ�

�8�</6+>398�>9�>2/

=2+<381�+8.

.3=><3,?>398�90

,/8/03>=

• .?<I<�J?FLC;�9<�8E�8>I<<D<EK�K?8K�FLKC@E<J�?FN�K?<�9<E<=@KJ�8I@J@E>�FLK�F=�8�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�GIFA<:K�N@CC�9<�J?8I<;

9<KN<<E�K?<�GIFM@;<I�8E;�K?<�LJ<I

• +IFM@;<I�J?FLC;�GIFM@;<�@E=FID8K@FE�KF�LJ<I K?8K�N@CC�9<�I<HL@I<;�@E�FI;<I�KF�=@CC�FLK�G<ID@K�8GGC@:8K@FE

• $E=FID8K@FE�I<HL@I<;�=FI�K?<�8>I<<D<EK�@J�G8IK@8CCP�J@D@C8I�8J�K?8K�E<<;<;�=FI�(.�

• .?<��-��DLJK�@E:CL;<�G<I@F;�F=�I<M@<N

• .?<�(@E@JK<I�8GGIFM<J�8CC��-�J�FI�8D<E;D<EKJ�KF�JL:?�8>I<<D<EKJ�

�8�</6+>398�>9

-97:63+8-/

• ��:C<8I�@E;@:8K@FE�F=�N?8K�:FEJK@KLK<J�8E�F==<E:<

• ��:C<8I�@E;@:8K@FE�F=�N?8K�G<E8CK@<J�8I<�@E�GC8:<�@=�LJ<I�@J�:FEM@:K<;

• /J<I�KF�I<GFIK�98:B�KF�K?<�(@E@JK<I�FE�8E�8EEL8C�98J@J�FE�GIFA<:K�GIF>I<JJ

�+=/.�98�C9?<

/B:/<3/8-/��A2+>

A/</�5/C�-2+66/81/=

0+-/.�A3>2

37:6/7/8>+>398�

�GGIFGI@8K<�N8PJ� KF� @;<EK@=P� 8E;� M<I@=P� ?FC;<IJ�F=� KI8;@K@FE8C� BEFNC<;><� KF� J<<B� +$�� 8E;�E<>FK@8K<�DLKL8CCP� 8>I<<;

K<IDJ� I<D8@E� LE:C<8I� @E� K?<� :FE:<GKJ� 8E;� K<IDJ� LJ<;� @E� ��-�D<8JLI<J�� !FI� <O8DGC<� 8� N@;<� M8I@<KP� F= K<IDJ� 8E;

;<=@E@K@FEJ� 8I<� LJ<;� 9P� ;@==<I<EK� J<:KFIJ� KF� ;<J:I@9<� ?FC;<IJ� F=� KI8;@K@FE8C� BEFNC<;><� 8JJF:@8K<;� N@K?� ><E<K@:� FI

9@FCF>@:8C� I<JFLI:<J�8E;�I<C8K<;�GIF;L:KJ�8E;�F=K<E�K?<�J8D<� C8E>L8><�D8P�9<�LJ<;�9P� KNF�G8IK@<J�KF�;<J:I@9<� KNF

;@==<I<EK�J@KL8K@FEJ��*K?<I�:?8CC<E><J�@E:CL;<

• $;<EK@=@:8K@FE�8E;�GIFK<:K@FE�F=�JK8B<?FC;<IJ�

• �::<JJ�KF�K?<�$�,�8E;�M<I@=@:8K@FE�F= KI8;@K@FE8C BEFNC<;><�FNE<IJ�

• �FCC<:K@FE�LJ<�GIFG8>8K@FE�:LCK@M8K@FE�FI�KI8;<�F=�$�,�=FI�;FD<JK@:�FI�JL9J@JK<E:<�GLIGFJ<J�

• ,<>LC8K@FE�F= K?<�M8I@FLJ�(LK?@�D8IB<KJ�8E;

• '8:B�F=�LE@=FID�JPJK<DJ�8GGC@<;�KF�;@==<I<EK�J<:KFIJ�@EMFCM<;�@E�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�8E;�9@FKI8;<

.?<�LGK8B<�F=�K?<�G<ID@KK@E>�8E;�K?<�LE;<ICP@E>���-�I<HL@I<D<EKJ�?8J�9<<E�JCFN�@E�K?<�:FLEKIP����LII<EK�@E;@:8K@FEJ

8I<�K?8K�C<JJ�K?8E�����JG<:@<J�?8M<�9<<E�I<HL<JK<;�@E�K?<�G<ID@K�8GGC@:8K@FE�GIF:<;LI<��EFK<�K?@J�;F<J�EFK�@DGCP����

G<ID@KJ�?8M<�9<<E�JL9D@KK<;�8J�FE<�G<ID@K�I<HL<JK�D8P�@E:CL;<�8GGC@:8K@FE�F=�8�ELD9<I�F=�JG<:@<J�8E;�FECP���

G<ID@KJ�?8M<�9<<E�8GGIFM<;�9P�K?<�(@E@JK<I�F=�18K<I�8E;� EM@IFED<EK8C��==8@IJ���.?<�JCFN�LGK8B<�F=�K?<�G<ID@KK@E>

GIF:<;LI<�@J�;L<�KF�8�ELD9<I�F=�:FEJKI8@EKJ�9<@E>�<OG<I@<E:<;�9P�K?<�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�J<:KFI�@E:CL;@E>�

• �<JG@K<�8�J<K�F=�>L@;<C@E<J�=FI�K?<�GIF:<JJ�K?<�HL8C@KP�F=�G<ID@K�8GGC@:8K@FE�;F:LD<EK8K@FE�I<:<@M<;�9P�� ��@J�GFFI

Page 32: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

N?@:?�;<C8PJ�K?<�GIF:<JJ@E>�F=�K?<�G<ID@K�8GGC@:8K@FEJ

• '8:B�F=�)8K@FE8C�-PJK<D�=FI�K?<�M<I@=@:8K@FE�F=�C<>@K@D8K< KI8;@K@FE8C BEFNC<;><�FNE<IJ ?FC;<IJ

• '8:B�F=�8::LI8K<�;8K8�FE�K?<�8DFLEK�F=�I8N�D8K<I@8CJ�<OGFIK<;�FLK�F= -FLK?��=I@:8�N?<K?<I�C<>8C�FI�@CC<>8C�8E;�K?<

8DFLEK�F=�I<M<EL<�><E<I8K<;�9P��@FKI8;<IJ�@J�LEBEFNE

• /E@M<IJ8CCP�8::<GK<;�D<8EJ�F=�@DGC<D<EK@E>�@EK<CC<:KL8C�GIFG<IKP�I<:F>E@K@FE�@J�P<K�KF�9<�=FIDLC8K<;

• '8:B�F=�?LD8E�I<JFLI:<�:8G8:@KP

• -FD<�E<>FK@8K@FEJ�F=��-�J�8I<�EFK�:FE;L:K<;�FE�<HL8C�=FFK@E>

• !FI<@>E�8E;�CF:8C�:FDG8E@<J�:FE;L:K@E>�LE8LK?FI@Q<;�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>��(FI<�<==FIKJ�I<HL@I<;�@E�<JK89C@J?@E>�E8K@FE8C

JPJK<D�KF�DFE@KFI�8E;�KI8:B�K?<�DFM<D<EK�F=�$�,J�KF�E8K@FE8C�8E;�=FI<@>E�,���:FDG8E@<J�=FI�:FDD<I:@8C GIF;L:KJ

;<M<CFGD<EK�

�8�>/<7=�90�:<9-/== �

:<9-/.?</=

/=>+,63=2/.�+8.

-98>/8> �/�1��>9

1+>2/<�=?::9<>�09<

>2/�=C=>/7�+>�>2/

8+>398+6�6/@/6��,C

@+<39?=

=>+5/296./<=��3�/�

A2+>�A/</�5/C

7/==+1/=�-98@/C/.

,C�=>+5/296./<=

</1+<.381�>2/

37:6/7/8>+>398�90

>2/ =C=>/7�

-<M<I8C� NFIBJ?FGJ� J<D@E8IJ� :FE=<I<E:<J 8E;� @E=FID8K@FE� J?8I@E>� J<JJ@FEJ 8I< :FEK@ELFLJCP :FE;L:K<; N@K?

JK8B<?FC;<IJ� K?IFL>?FLK� K?<� P<8I� @E� FI;<I KF I8@J<� 8N8I<E<JJ� FE� �@FGIFJG<:K@E> �::<JJ� 8E;� �<E<=@K� -?8I@E>�

/E8E@DFLJCP�JK8B<?FC;<IJ�?8M<�@E GI@E:@GC<�8>I<<;�8E;�8::<GK<;�K?<���-�JPJK<D���FDD<EKJ�K?8K�?8M<�9<<E�:FEM<P<;

I<>8I;@E>�K?<�JPJK<D�8I<�

• +IF:<JJ@E>�K@D<�=FI�8GGIFM8C�F=�G<ID@KJ�@J�KFF�CFE>�8E;�@J�?8M@E>�8�E<>8K@M<�<==<:K�FE�K?<@I�9LJ@E<JJ<J

• �GGC@:8K@FE�=FIDJ�=FI�G<ID@KJ�8I<�EFK�LJ<I�=I@<E;CP

• +<ID@K�=<<�JKIL:KLI<�J?FLC;�9<�:8K<>FI@J<;�@EJK<8;�F=�K?<�:LII<EK�JK8E;8I;�=<<�8GGC@:8K@FE�=FI�8CC

• ,<>LC8K@FEJ�DLJK�9<�JG<:@=@:�@E�:FEK<EK�

• $K�@J�8�JPJK<D�K?8K�N@CC�<EJLI<�=8@I�8E;�<HL@K89C<�J?8I<�F=�9<E<=@KJ�8DFE>JK�JK8B<?FC;<IJ

!>2/<�</6/@+8>

3==?/=

$E� <EJLI@E>� 8E� <==<:K@M<� 8E;� J<8DC<JJ� ��-� JPJK<D� @E� GC8:<� � �� ?8J� @DGC<D<EK<;� K?<� =FCCFN@E>�D<8JLI<J� 8DFE>JK

FK?<I�@E@K@8K@M<J�

Page 33: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

X .I8EJC8K<;�K?<����-�,<>LC8K@FEJ�8E;�����-�"L@;<C@E<J�@EKF�8CC��<C<M<E�-��F==@:@8C�C8E>L8><J

X JK89C@J?<;� 8E� @E=FID8K@FE� GFIK8C� ?FLJ<;� N@K?@E� K?<� � �� N<9J@K<� J<IM@E>� 8J� K?<� )8K@FE8C� ��-� �C<8I@E>� #FLJ<

(<:?8E@JD

X +L9C@J?@E> F= >L@;<C@E<J�<EK@KC<; ( �'!����� �!���"���������!!�����������"� �� �������#��"� &�� ���%� ����#�������!

�� � �$��� !���!� !��������#��"� !)�

X #���!���� �� ��� �!"� !��������"!������ ��#��"�&��!�����#�!"���!�������"!

X �<M<CFG<; 8E@D8K<;� M@;<F� :C@G� KF� I<C8P� @E� 8� J@DGC<� 8E;� 8GG<8C@E>�N8P� K?<���-� JPJK<D� � KF� JK8B<?FC;<IJ� 8E;� K?<

><E<I8C�GL9C@:

X -<M<I8C�NFIBJ?FGJ�J<D@E8IJ�:FE=<I<E:<�D<;@8�<M<EKJ�8E;�@E=FID8K@FE�J?8I@E>�J<JJ@FE�8I<�:FE;L:K<;�8EEL8CCP�KF

X I8@J<�8N8I<E<JJ�FE��@FGIFJG<:K@E> �::<JJ�8E;��<E<=@K�-?8I@E>�

Page 34: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

7. REFERENCES� �<G8IKD<EK� F=� EM@IFED<EK8C� �==8@IJ� ������� -FLK?��=I@:8UJ� �@FGIFJG<:K@E>� �::<JJ

8E;� �<E<YK�-?8I@E>� ,<>LC8KFIP� !I8D<NFIB�� "L@;<C@E<J� =FI� +IFM@;<IJ� /J<IJ� 8E;

,<>LC8KFIJ�

� �<G8IKD<EK� F=� EM@IFED<EK8C� �==8@IJ� 8E;� .FLI@JD� ������� 1?@K<� +8G<I� FE� K?<

�FEJ<IM8K@FE�8E;�-LJK8@E89C<�/J<�F=�-FLK?��=I@:8UJ��@FCF>@:8C��@M<IJ@KP��"FM<IED<EK

"8Q<KK<�����EF��������

� � �� ������� �� JKL;P� F=� K?<� J:FG< 8E;� <OK<EK� F=� K?<� LK@C@J8K@FE� F=� @E;@><EFLJ

I<JFLI:<J�9P�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�@E;LJKI@<J�@E�-FLK?��=I@:8���/EGL9C@J?<;�I<GFIK�

� &@;;�(���������� EM@IFED<EK8C�'8N���E; ;@K@FE�

� '8@I;� -�� �� 8E;� 1PE9<I>� ,� ������� �@FGIFJG<:K@E>� @E� -FLK?� �=I@:8�� KFN8I;J� K?<

;<M<CFGD<EK� F=� <HL@K89C<� G8IKE<IJ?@GJU�� $E� (L>89<� %�� �8I9<I� �0�� #<EE<� "�

"CFNB8� '�8E;���'8�0@E8� �<;J���::<JJ� KF�"<E<K@:�,<JFLI:<J�� -KI8K<>@<J� =FI�-?8I@E>

�<E<=@KJ��=I@:8E��<EKI<� =FI�.<:?EFCF>P�-KL;@<J�1FIC;�,<JFLI:<J� $EJK@KLK<�8E;�K?<

1FIC;��FEJ<IM8K@FE�/E@FE��&<EP8���.-�+I<JJ�

� (8E;<I�(��)KLC@�'���@<;<I@:?J�)��8E;�(8MLE;C8�&����LE;8K<;��� :FEFD@:J�F=�K?<

.I8;@K@FE8C� (<;@:@E<� .I8;<� @E� -FLK?� �=I@:8�� � 5*EC@E<6�� �M8@C89C<�

?KKG� NNN�?JK�FI>�Q8 LGCF8;J =@C<J :?8G��7���G;=

� (8E;<I�(��8E;�(:&<EQ@<�(���������-FLK?<IE��=I@:8E�KI8;<�;@I<:KFIP�F=�@E;@><EFLJ

E8KLI8C�GIF;L:KJ� ?KKG� NNN�:GN@C;�:F�Q8 �F:.I8;<�?KD

� (8E;<I�(�� 8E;� '<��I<KFE�"�� �������*M<IM@<N�F=� K?<�D<;@:@E8C� GC8EK� @E;LJKIP @E

-FLK?<IE� �=I@:8�� $E�� �@<;<I@:?J� )�� � ;��� �FDD<I:@8C@J@E> (<;@:@E8C� +C8EKJ�� �

-FLK?<IE��=I@:8E�"L@;<��-LE�+I<JJ�-K<CC<E9FJ:?�GG����R���

� -FLK?��=I@:8��������)8K@FE8C� EM@IFED<EK8C�(8E8><D<EK� �@F;@M<IJ@KP��:K�)F����F=

������"FM<IED<EK�+I@EK<IJ�+I<KFI@8�-FLK?��=I@:8�

�� -FLK?� �=I@:8� ������� )8K@FE8C� EM@IFED<EK8C� (8E8><D<EK� �:K� )F� ���� F=� �����

"FM<IED<EK�+I@EK<IJ�+I<KFI@8�-FLK?��=I@:8�

��1PE9<I>� ,� ������� �� I<M@<N� F=� 9<E<=@K�J?8I@E>� 8II8E><D<EKJ� =FI� 9@F;@M<IJ@KP

GIFJG<:K@E>�@E�-FLK?��=I@:8��$E���<M<CFG@E>��::<JJ�8E;��<E<=@K�-?8I@E>�'<>@JC8K@FE�@E

-FLK?��=I@:8���I<M@<N�F=�@EK<IE8K@FE8C�8E;�E8K@FE8C�<OG<I@<E:<J��$/�) +I<KFI@8�

GG����R���

��1PE9<I>� ,� 8E;��LI><E<I�(� ������� -L9D@JJ@FE� F=� :FDD<EKJ�FE� K?<��@F;@M<IJ@KP

�@CC�9P�K?<�$/�)�KF�K?<�+8IC@8D<EK8IP�+FIK=FC@F��FDD@KK<<�FE� EM@IFED<EK8C��==8@IJ

8E;�.FLI@JD������I@K@:8C�I<M@<N�F=�GIFM@J@FEJ�I<C8K@E>�KF�V9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�8::<JJ�8E;

9<E<=@K�J?8I@E>W�

�� ?KKG� NNN�89J�@E@K@8K@M<�@E=F LGCF8;J D<;@8 '8:K@[email protected]?@KN8DLCFDFE@7�7� �7�

7-FLK?7�=I@:87J7C<>@JC8K@M<7=I8D<NFIB�G;=

�� ?KKG� NNN�>FM�Q8 89FLK>FMK JKIL:KLI< JKIL:KLI<�?KD

�� �@FGIFJG<:K@E>��::<JJ�8E;��<E<=@K�-?8I@E>�,<>LC8K@FEJ�����

�� �FEJK@KLK@FE�F=�K?<�,<GL9C@:�F=�-FLK?��=I@:8��������:K�)F������F=�����

Page 35: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

8. APPENDIX 1: PROCESS FLOW DIAGRAMS�$! "'*2�$�-/��!'*2�.!/.�*0/���./!+��3�./!+�#0% !�"*-�/$!� ���+-*�!..�"*-�+-*1% !-.�*"������) ����

�%#0-!��� ��!..��) ��!)!"%/��$�-%)#��-*�!..��'*2��$�-/ �/�&!)�"-*(��� ������

Page 36: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

�$!�"'*2�$�-/��!'*2�.!/.�*0/���./!+��3�./!+�#0% ! *)�/$!��%*+-*.+!�/%)#�� ��!..��) ��!)!"%/��$�-%)#��-*�!..

*1!-1%!2�

�%#0-! � �%*+-*.+!�/%)#�� ��!..��) ��!)!"%/��$�-%)#��-*�!..�*1!-1%!2� �/�&!)�"-*(��� ������

Page 37: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

�$!� +-*�!..� "*-� /$!� �++'%��/%*)� +-*�!..� "*-� �� +!-(%/� %)� /$!� �*((!-�%�'%.�/%*)� +$�.!� *"� �%*+-*.+!�/%)#� %.

.$*2)�%)��%#0-! �!'*2�

�%#0-!�� �-*�!..�"*-�/$! �++'%��/%*)�+-*�!..�"*-���+!-(%/�%)�/$!��*((!-�%�'%.�/%*)�+$�.!�*"��%*+-*.+!�/%)#

�/�&!)�"-*(��� ������

Page 38: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

�%#0-!�� �!'*2�.$*2.�/$!��%*+-*.+!�/%)#�+!-(%/�-!,0%-!(!)/.��'*)#�/$!�1�'0!��$�%)�

�%#0-!�����%*+-*.+!�/%)#�1�'0!��$�%)�+!-(%//%)# -!,0%-!(!)/.��/�&!)�"-*(��� �����

Page 39: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

9. APPENDIX 2: EXPLANATORY NOTE�$!� �)/!''!�/0�'��-*+!-/3���2� (!) (!)/��%''� ����� ;<=@E<;� @E;@><EFLJ�:LCKLI8C�<OGI<JJ@FEJ�FI�BEFNC<;><

D<8EJ�8EP�=FID�K8E>@9C<�FI�@EK8E>@9C<�FI�8�:FD9@E8K@FE�K?<I<F=�@E�N?@:?�KI8;@K@FE8C�:LCKLI<�8E;�BEFNC<;><

8I<�<D9F;@<;�G8JJ<;�FE�9<KN<<E� ><E<I8K@FEJ� 8E;� K8E>@9C<�FI� @EK8E>@9C<� =FIDJ�F=� :I<8K@M@KP�F=� @E;@><EFLJ

:FDDLE@K@<J�@E:CL;@E>�9LK�EFK�C@D@K<;�KFS

�8�G?FE<K@:�FI�M<I98C�<OGI<JJ@FEJ�JL:?�8J�JKFI@<J�<G@:J�C<><E;J�GF<KIP�I@;;C<J�8E;�FK?<I�E8II8K@M<J�NFI;J

J@>EJ�E8D<J�FI�JPD9FCJ�

�9�DLJ@:8C� FI� JFLE;�<OGI<JJ@FEJ� JL:?�8J� JFE>J� I?PK?DJ�FI� @EJKILD<EK8C�DLJ@:� K?<� JFLE;J�N?@:?�8I<� K?<

<OGI<JJ@FE�F=�I@KL8CJ�

�:� <OGI<JJ@FEJ� 9P� 8:K@FE� JL:?� 8J� ;8E:<J� GC8PJ :<I<DFE@<J� I@KL8CJ� <OGI<JJ@FEJ� F=� JG@I@KL8C@KP� FI� I<C@>@FE

JGFIKJ�KI8;@K@FE8C�>8D<J�GLGG<K�G<I=FID8E:<J�8E;�FK?<I�G<I=FID8E:<J�N?<K?<I�=@O<;�FI�LE=@O<;��FI

�;� K8E>@9C<� <OGI<JJ@FEJ� JL:?� 8J� D8K<I@8C� <OGI<JJ@FEJ� F=� 8IK� ?8E;@:I8=KJ� 8I:?@K<:KLI<� FI K8E>@9C<� JG@I@KL8C

=FIDJ�FI�<OGI<JJ@FEJ�F=�J8:I<;�GC8:<J�

�%*+-*.+!�/%)# @J�;<=@E<;�@E�) (����������� �8E;�K?<�������D<E;D<EK�KF�K?<��:K� @E�I<C8K@FE�KF� @E;@><EFLJ

9@FCF>@:8C� I<JFLI:<J� D<8EJ� 8EP� I<J<8I:?� FE� FI� ;<M<CFGD<EK� FI� 8GGC@:8K@FE� F=� � @E;@><EFLJ 9@FCF>@:8C

I<JFLI:<J�=FI�:FDD<I:@8C�FI�@E;LJKI@8C�<OGCF@K8K@FE�8E;�@E:CL;<J�

�8�K?<�JPJK<D8K@:�J<8I:?�:FCC<:K@FE�FI�>8K?<I@E>�F=�JL:?�I<JFLI:<J�FI�D8B@E>�<OKI8:K@FEJ�=IFD�JL:?�I<JFLI:<J

=FI�GLIGFJ<J�F=�JL:?�I<J<8I:?�;<M<CFGD<EK�FI�8GGC@:8K@FE�

�9�K?< LK@C@J8K@FE�=FI�GLIGFJ<J�F=�JL:?�I<J<8I:?�FI�;<M<CFGD<EK�F=�8EP�@E=FID8K@FE�I<>8I;@E>�8EP�KI8;@K@FE8C

LJ<J�F=�@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�9P�@E;@><EFLJ�:FDDLE@K@<J�

�:�I<J<8I:?�FE�FI�K?<�8GGC@:8K@FE�;<M<CFGD<EK�FI�DF;@=@:8K@FE�F=�8EP�JL:?�KI8;@K@FE8C�LJ<J�=FI�:FDD<I:@8C

FI�@E;LJKI@8C�<OGCF@K8K@FE��FI

�;�.I8;@E>�@E�8E;�<OGFIK@E>�F=�@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�@E�FI;<I�KF�;<M<CFG�8E;�GIF;L:<�GIF;L:KJ�JL:?

8J� ;IL>J� @E;LJKI@8C� <EQPD<J� =FF;� =C8MFLIJ� =I8>I8E:<J� :FJD<K@:J� <DLCJ@=@<IJ� FC<FI<J@EJ� <OKI8:KJ� 8E;

<JJ<EK@8C�F@CJ

�%*'*#%��'� %1!-.%/3 FI �%* %1!-.%/3 @J�;<=@E<;�@E�) (�����������8J�K?<�M8I@89@C@KP�8DFE>�C@M@E>�FI>8E@JDJ�=IFD

8CC�JFLI:<J�@E:CL;@E>�K<II<JKI@8C�D8I@E<�8E;�FK?<I�8HL8K@:�<:FJPJK<DJ�8E;�K?<�<:FCF>@:8C�:FDGC<O<J�F=�N?@:?

K?<P�8I<�G8IK�8E;�8CJF�@E:CL;<J�;@M<IJ@KP�N@K?@E�JG<:@<J�9<KN<<E�JG<:@<J�8E;�F=�<:FJPJK<DJ�

�) %#!)*0.��%*'*#%��'� -!.*0-�!. 8I<�;<=@E<;� @E�) (������8�N?<E�LJ<;� @E�I<C8K@FE�KF�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�D<8EJ

8EP� @E;@><EFLJ� 9@FCF>@:8C� I<JFLI:<� 8J� ;<=@E<;� @E� J<:K@FE� ������ FI� �9� N?<E� LJ<;� @E� I<C8K@FE� KF� 8EP� FK?<I

D8KK<I�D<8EJ�8EP�I<JFLI:<�:FEJ@JK@E>�F=�

�@�8EP�C@M@E>�FI�;<8;�8E@D8C�GC8EK�FI�FK?<I�FI>8E@JD�F=�8E�@E;@><EFLJ

�@@�8EP�;<I@M8K@M<�F=�JL:?�8E@D8C�GC8EK�FI�FK?<I�FI>8E@JD��FI

�@@@�8EP�><E<K@:�D8K<I@8C F=�JL:?�8E@D8C�GC8EK�FI�FK?<I�FI>8E@JD�

�9�<O:CL;<J� �@�><E<K@:�D8K<I@8C�F=�?LD8E�FI@>@E���@@�8EP�<OFK@:�8E@D8CJ�GC8EKJ�FI�FK?<I�FI>8E@JDJ�FK?<I�K?8E

<OFK@:�8E@D8CJ� �@@@� @E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J� C@JK<;� @E�K<IDJ�F=�K?<�$EK<IE8K@FE8C�.I<8KP�GC8EKJ�FI�FK?<I

FI>8E@JDJ�I<=<II<;�KF�@E�G8I8>I8G?��L�@@@��8E;�FE�+C8EK�"<E<K@:�,<JFLI:<J�=FI�!FF;�8E;��>I@:LCKLI<�

�*((!-�%�'%.�/%*) @J�;<=@E<;�@E�) (������������8E;�K?<�������D<E;D<EK�KF�K?<��:K @E�I<C8K@FE�KF @E;@><EFLJ

9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�I<C8K<J KF�K?<�=FCCFN@E>�8:K@M@K@<J�

�8 !@C@E>�F=�8�:FDGC<K<�@EK<CC<:KL8C�GIFG<IKP�8GGC@:8K@FE�N?<K?<I�@E�-FLK?��=I@:8�FI�8EPN?<I<�<CJ<�

�9 *9K8@E@E>�FI�KI8EJ=<II@E>�8EP�@EK<CC<:KL8C�GIFG<IKP�I@>?K�FI�8EP�FK?<I�I@>?K�

�: �FDD<E:@E>� GIF;L:K� ;<M<CFGD<EK� @E:CL;@E>� K?<� :FE;L:K@E>� F=�D8IB<K� I<J<8I:?� 8E;� J<<B@E>� GI<�

D8IB<K�8GGIFM8C�=FI�K?<�J8C<�F=�I<JLCK@E>�GIF;L:KJ�

Page 40: National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa · 2016-06-20 · National Study on ABS Implementation in South Africa Commissioned by the ABS Capacity Development Initiative

��

�; .?<� DLCK@GC@:8K@FE� F=� @E;@><EFLJ� 9@FCF>@:8C� I<JFLI:<J� K?IFL>?� :LCK@M8K@FE� GIFG8>8K@FE� :CFE@E>� FI

FK?<I�D<8EJ� KF�GIF;L:K�8E;�;<M<CFG�GIF;L:KJ� JL:?�8J�;IL>J� @E;LJKI@8C�<EQPD<J� =FF;� =C8MFLIJ� =I8>I8E:<J

:FJD<K@:J�<DLCJ@=@<IJ�FC<FI<J@EJ�<OKI8:KJ�8E;�<JJ<EK@8C�F@CJ�

�< .I8;@E>�@E�8E;�<OGFIK@E>�F=�@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�KF�;<M<CFG�8E;�GIF;L:<�GIF;L:KJ�JL:?�8J

8J� ;IL>J� @E;LJKI@8C� <EQPD<J� =FF;� =C8MFLIJ� =I8>I8E:<J� :FJD<K@:J� <DLCJ@=@<IJ� FC<FI<J@EJ� <OKI8:KJ� 8E;

<JJ<EK@8C�F@CJ�

�= �FDD<I:@8C�<OGCF@K8K@FE

�) %#!)*0.� �*((0)%/3 8::FI;@E>� KF� K?<� $EK<CC<:KL8C� +IFG<IKP� '8N� �D<E;D<EK� � �@CC� ������ D<8EJ� 8EP

I<:F>E@J89C<�:FDDLE@KP�F=�G<FGC<�FI@>@E8K<;� @E�FI�?@JKFI@:8CCP� J<KKC<;� @E�8�><F>I8G?@:� 8I<8�FI�8I<8J� CF:8K<;

N@K?@E�K?<�9FI;<IJ�F=�K?<�,<GL9C@:�8J�JL:?�9FI;<IJ�<O@JK<;�8K�K?<�;8K<�F=�:FDD<E:<D<EK�F=�K?<�$EK<CC<:KL8C

+IFG<IKP� '8NJ� �D<E;D<EK� �@CC� ����� :?8I8:K<I@J<;� 9P� JF:@8C� :LCKLI8C� 8E; <:FEFD@:� :FE;@K@FEJ� N?@:?

;@JK@E>L@J?� K?<D� =IFD� FK?<I� J<:K@FEJ� F=� K?<� E8K@FE8C� :FDDLE@KP� 8E;� N?F� @;<EK@=P� K?<DJ<CM<J� 8E;� 8I<

I<:F>E@J<;�9P�FK?<I�>IFLGJ�8J�8�;@JK@E:K�:FCC<:K@M<�

�-� %/%*)�'�0.! FI &)*2'! #! 8::FI;@E>�KF����-�,<>LC8K@FEJ�I<=<IJ�KF�K?<�:LJKFD8IP�LK@C@J8K@FE�FI�BEFNC<;><

F=�@E;@><EFLJ�I<JFLI:<J�9P�8E�@E;@><EFLJ�:FDDLE@KP�@E�8::FI;8E:<�N@K?�NI@KK<E�FI�LENI@KK<E�ILC<J�LJ8><J

:LJKFDJ�FI�GI8:K@:<J�KI8;@K@FE8CCP�F9J<IM<;�8::<GK<;�8E;�I<:F>E@J<;�9P�K?<D�8E;�@E:CL;<J�;@J:FM<I@<J�89FLK

K?<�I<C<M8EK�@E;@><EFLJ�I<JFLI:<J�9P�K?<�:FDDLE@KP�

�/�&!$*' !-. @E�) (���

�8���G<IJFE�@E:CL;@E>�8EP�FI>8E�F=�JK8K<�FI�:FDDLE@KP�GIFM@;@E>�FI�>@M@E>�8::<JJ KF�K?<�@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C

I<JFLI:<J�KF�N?@:?�K?<�8GGC@:8K@FE�I<C8K<J��8E;

�9�8E�@E;@><EFLJ�:FDDLE@KP�FI�8�JG<:@=@:�@E;@M@;L8C�

�@�N?FJ<�KI8;@K@FE8C�LJ<J�F=�K?<�@E;@><EFLJ�9@FCF>@:8C�I<JFLI:<J�KF�N?@:?�K?< 8GGC@:8K@FE�I<C8K<J�?8M<�@E@K@8K<;

FI�N@CC�:FEKI@9LK<�KF�FI�=FID�G8IK�F=�K?< GIFGFJ<;�9@FGIFJG<:K@E>��FI

�@@� N?FJ<� BEFNC<;><� F=� FI� ;@J:FM<I@<J� 89FLK� K?<� @E;@><EFLJ� 9@FCF>@:8C I<JFLI:<J� KF� N?@:?� K?<� 8GGC@:8K@FE

I<C8K<J�8I<�KF�9<�LJ<;�=FI�K?<�GIFGFJ<; 9@FGIFJG<:K@E>�