networks and citizenship: using technology for civic innovation

62
Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy Trkar`m  Jgccrgy @br`mukl/ R`ttkrvgwr @ Rtrv c v 2400 @ut Iuvivwv Crwm Emmwie`viu `f Ueiv WUIla VgEnlkokay CkR EIsIE Illks@VIkl Lgvqkrhu `Lf eivizgLunit:

Upload: communications-and-society-program

Post on 05-Apr-2018

223 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 1/61

E k m m w l i e ` v i k l u ` l f U k e i g v y T r k a r ` m

 Jgccrgy @br`mukl/ R`ttkrvgwr 

@ Rtrv c v 2400 @ut Iuvivwv Crwm Emmwie`viu `f Ueiv

WUIla VgEnlkokay CkR EIsIE Illks@VIklLgvqkrhu `Lf eivizgLunit:

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 2/61

Lgvqkrhu `lf Eivizglunit:Wuila Vgenlkokay ckr Eisie Illks`vikl

@ Rgtkrv kc vng 2400 @utgl IluvivwvgCkrwm kl Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy 

Jgccrgy @br`mukl

R`ttkrvgwr 

Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy Trkar`mEn`rogu M, Cirguvklg

G~gewvisg FirgevkrQ`unilavkl/ F,E,

2402

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 3/61

0>37EUT+02-BH 

Vk twren`ug `ffivikl`o ektigu kc vniu rgtkrv/ tog`ug eklv`ev:

Vng @utgl Iluvivwvg

Twboie`viklu KcciegT,K, Bk~ 222

049 Nkwanvkl O`b O`lg

Pwggluvkql/ M`ryo`lf 2037>

Tnklg: .604) >24-7523

C`~: .604) >21-9016

G-m`io: twboie`vikluD`utgliluvivwvg,kra

Ckr `oo kvngr ilpwirigu/ tog`ug eklv`ev:Vng @utgl Iluvivwvg

Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy Trkar`m

Klg Fwtklv Eireog/ LQ

Uwivg 144

Q`unilavkl/ FE 24453

Tnklg: .242) 153-7>0>

C`~: .242) 631-4194

Ektyrianv © 2402 by Vng @utgl Iluvivwvg

Vniu qkrh iu oieglugf wlfgr vng Erg`visg Ekmmklu @vvribwvikl-

Lklekmmgrei`o 5,4 Wlivgf Uv`vgu Oieglug, Vk sigq ` ekty kc vniu

oieglug/ siuiv nvvt:++erg`visgekmmklu,kra+oieglugu+by-le+5,4+wu+  kr

uglf ` ogvvgr vk Erg`visg Ekmmklu/ 010 Ugeklf Uvrggv/ Uwivg 544/

U`l Cr`leiuek/ E`oickrli`/ 96047/ WU@,

Vng @utgl Iluvivwvg

Klg Fwtklv Eireog/ LQ

Uwivg 144

Q`unilavkl/ FE 24453

Twboiungf il vng Wlivgf Uv`vgu kc @mgrie` il 2402

by Vng @utgl Iluvivwvg

@oo rianvu rgugrsgf

Trilvgf il vng Wlivgf Uv`vgu kc @mgrie`

IUBL: 4->9>75-733->

02-441

En`rogu M, CirguvklgG~gewvisg Firgevkr 

T`vriei` H, Hgooy @uuiuv`lv Firgevkr 

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 4/61

Eklvglvu

Ckrgqkrf/ En`rogu M, Cirguvklg ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,s 

Lgvqkrhu `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay 

Ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL/  Jgccrgy @br`mukl

Fiaiv`o Fiurwtvikl `lf vng Ifg`ou kc Eivizglunit ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 5

Vng Fgcilila Cg`vwrgu kc vng Lgq Fiaiv`o O`lfue`tg ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, >

Tkoiey Ktviklu @ng`f: Rgekmmglf`viklu ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 05

Ak Oke`o: Illks`viklu il Eivizgl-vk-Eivizgl `lf 

Eivizgl-vk-Aksgrlmglv Ekmmwlie`viklu ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 07Ak Cr`lhoil: Aksgrlmglv-vk-Eivizgl Ekmmwlie`viklu ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 24

Ak M`fiukl ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 26

Ak Vrwvncwo `lf Vnkrkwan ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 23

Ak Glvgrv`ilila: Ekllgev Ukei`o Lgvqkrhila vk Brk`fe`uvila ,,,,, 21

Ak Aokb`o: Brifag Ewovwr o `lf Ut`vi`o Bkwlf`rigu ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 2>

Ekleowuikl ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 50

Lkvgu ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 52

`ttgLfi~ 

T`rvieit`lvu ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 51

@bkwv vng @wvnkr ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 60

Trgsikwu Twboie`viklu crkm vng Ckrwm ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 65

@bkwv vng Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy Trkar`m ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 61

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 5/61

Vniu rgtkrv iu qrivvgl crkm vng tgrutgevisg kc `l ilckrmgf kbugrsgr `v vng 

@utgl Iluvivwvg Ckrwm kl Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy,Wloguu `vvribwvgf vk ` t`rviewo`r tgrukl/ lklg kc vng ekmmglvu kr ifg`u eklv`ilgf 

il vniu rgtkrv unkwof bg v`hgl `u gmbkfyila vng sigqu kr e`rryila vng glfkrugmglv 

kc `ly utgeicie t`rvieit`lv `v vng Ckrwm,

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 6/61

Ckrgqkrf

Vng fsglv kc fiaiv`o ilckrm`vikl lf ekmmwlie`viklu vgenlkokaigu

.IEVu) n`u brkwanv fiurwtvikl vk lwmgrkwu ilfwuvrigu/ crkm mwuie/

twboiunila `lf lgqut`tgru vk m`lwc`evwrila `lf ugrsiegu, Vr`fivikl`o

iluvivwviklu n`sg uggl vngir m`rhgvu/ geklkmie mkfgou/ tkqgr rgo`vikl-

unitu `lf kvngr `utgevu kc bwuilguu wtglfgf by krfil`ry ekluwmgru

gmtkqgrgf by fiaiv`o vgenlkokaigu, Lgq vkkou ckr ug`renila/ erg`vila

`lf ekmmwlie`vila gl`bog ekluwmgru `lf bwuilguugu vk cilf g`enkvngr il vng aokb`o m`rhgvto`eg, Ckr ukmg ekmt`ligu/ vng vr`luivikl

crkm bwuilguu mkfgou il vng ilfwuvri`o ag vk vnkug il vng fiaiv`o gr` n`u

bggl ` unkeh-`lf-`qg g~tgrigleg/ `lf vngy n`sg bggl uokq vk `f`tv,

Bwv m`ly kvngru n`sg ugizgf vng kttkrvwlivigu `cckrfgf by IEVu `lf

vng ilngrglv tkqgr kc lgvqkrhu vk rgvnilh ekmt`ly bwuilguu mkfgou

`lf tr`eviegu/ og`fila vk brk`fgr t`rvieit`vikl `lf cwlf`mglv`ooy 

en`lagf rgo`viklunitu qivn ewuvkmgru `lf vng brk`fgr twboie,

Vng trgmiug kc vng 2400 Ckrwm kl Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy .CKE@U) iu vn`v vng fiaiv`o fiurwtvikl iu lkq ekmila vk fgmker`vie

iluvivwviklu `lf trkeguugu, Vng rkog kc eivizgl `lf vng g~greiug kc eivi-

zglunit n`sg arkql mkrg ekmtog~, Tgktog gla`ag il `lf `erkuu lgq

lgvqkrhu `lf twboie utngrgu lkv bkwlfgf by agkar`tny, Vngy kcvgl

bgokla vk mkrg vn`l klg lgvqkrh `v ` vimg, Vngug m`y ileowfg oke`o/

uv`vg `lf rgaikl`o ekmmwlivigu8 uksgrgial uv`vgu/ l`viklu `lf vribgu8

`lf gsgl vng aokb`o ekmmwlivy, Vng `bioivy vk qkrh qivnil `lf `erkuu

lgvqkrhu/ `lf vk ckrm lgq lgvqkrhu kc eivizglu/ iu `l ilerg`uilaoy imtkrv`lv uhioo ugv ckr eivizglu il vng 20uv eglvwry, Vgenlkokay erivie

`lf qrivgr Nkq`rf Rngilakof gmtn`uizgf vng erivie`o rkog kc lgvqkrhu

`u ng tkilvu kwv/ ‟Vng uvrwevwrg `lf fyl`mieu kc lgvqkrhu ilcowgleg

tkoivie`o crggfkm/ geklkmie qg`ovn erg`vikl `lf t`rvieit`vikl il vng

erg`vikl kc ewovwrg,”

Ekleglvr`vila kl vng eivizgl `u vng b`uie wliv il ` fgmker`ey/

CKE@U 2400 g~tokrgf vng t`r`oogou bgvqggl wugr-eglvrie ttoie`viklu il

vng bwuilguu qkrof `lf eivizgl-eglvrie fgmker`ey, Jwuv `u bwuilguu n`umksgf `q`y crkm vng vkt-fkql/ ekmm`lf-`lf-eklvrko gvnku/ uk vkk

iu vng fgmker`vie g~tgrigleg gskosila `u ` bkvvkm-wt `ttrk`en vk eisie

`lf tkoivie`o gla`agmglv, Vngrg `rg uialu vn`v vniu gskowvikl iu `org`fy 

 S 

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 7/61

 si Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

wlfgrq`y, Uimtoy okkh `v vng q`yu il qnien eivizglu `epwirg `lf un`rg

ilckrm`vikl `bkwv e`lfif`vgu `lf aksgrlmglv/ rgegisg ilckrm`vikl`lf ugrsiegu crkm vngir aksgrlmglvu/ t`rvieit`vg il e`mt`ialu `lf

gogeviklu `lf gla`ag il eisie oicg,

Vng @utgl Iluvivwvg Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy Trkar`m brkwanv

vkagvngr 65 fiuvilawiungf eivizglu qivn ekluifgr`bog g~tgrigleg qkrh-

ila il `lf `rkwlf vng iluvivwviklu kc fgmker`ey vk g~tokrg vngug iuuwgu,

@ cwoo oiuv kc t`rvieit`lvu `ttg`ru il vng @ttglfi~ kc vng rgtkrv, Vng

Ckrwm vkkh to`eg il @utgl/ Ekokr`fk/ @wawuv 0-6/ 2400,

Vng CKE@U t`rvieit`lvu ukwanv vk `ffrguu vqk b`uie pwguviklu:0) Qn`v fkgu eivizglunit okkh oihg il `l gr` kc fiaiv`o lgvqkrhu;

2) Qn`v `rg vng gmgraila rkogu kc ilfisifw`o eivizglu `lf iluvivwviklu

il vniu en`laila glsirklmglv; Qivn ` ekmmkl wlfgruv`lfila vn`v

eivizglunit iu gskosila/ t`rvieit`lvu vngl ugv kwv vk m`hg rgekmmglf`-

viklu ckr nkq vk twv vng tkqgr kc lgvqkrhu `lf fiaiv`o vgenlkokaigu `v

vng ugrsieg kc fgmker`vie eivizglunit,

Eklcgrgleg r`ttkrvgwr Jgccrgy @br`mukl n`u fgcvoy uwmm`rizgf

vngir iluianvu/ fiuewuuiklu `lf cilfilau, Il vng rgtkrv vn`v ckookqu/@br`mukl trguglvu ` fgv`iogf ugv kc rgekmmglf`viklu m`fg `v vng

eklcgrgleg ckr mksila vng eivizglunit g~tgrigleg ckrq`rf‖crkm vng

ifg`ou kc fgmker`vie eivizglunit vk tr`evieg il vng rg`o qkrof kc vng lgq

fiaiv`o o`lfue`tg,

@ Lgq Fiaiv`o O`lfue`tg, Vng ckookqila `rg `mkla vng hgy kbugr-

s`viklu m`fg fwrila vng Ckrwm .qivn utgei`o `ehlkqogfagmglv vk

@lfrgq MeO`wanoil/ qnk uwmm`rizgf vngug fgcilila cg`vwrgu kc vnglgq fiaiv`o o`lfue`tg `v vng eklcgrgleg):

• VngTwboie Utngrg, IEVu e`l `ovgr tkoivieu by gln`leila vng

twboie utngrg/ m`hila iv mkrg mwuewo`r `lf ga`oiv`ri`l, Vng

@r`b Utrila iu klg g~`mtog, Vng gmgragleg kc ukei`o lgvqkrh-

ila rgfwegu vng ekuvu kc ckrmila `lf m`ilv`ilila ekllgeviklu

qivnil `lf `mkla arkwtu vn`v m`y ckrm `rkwlf t`rviewo`r

ilvgrguvu kr rkwlf t`rviewo`r agkar`tny .oihg V`nrir Upw`rg),

• @eeguuvkIlckrm`vikl,@l g~tokuikl kc `eeguu vk nwag `mkwlvu

kc f`v` kl ktgl-ukwreg `lf ktgl-f`v` lgvqkrhu n`u fgmker`-

vizgf `eeguu vk ilckrm`vikl, Mkrg fgmker`vizgf `eeguu vk ilckr-

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 8/61

Ckrgqkrf sii 

m`vikl og`fu vk arg`vgr eisie gfwe`vikl/ qnien il vwrl og`fu vk

bgvvgr-ilckrmgf eivizglu `lf ekmmwlivigu, Nkqgsgr/ ilckrm`-vikl ksgrok`f `lf il`fgpw`vg ciovgrila `ifu erg`vg vng riuh kc eivi-

zglu frkqlila il uk mwen ilckrm`vikl vn`v iv bgekmgu ficciewov

vk m`hg uglug kc kr wug vng ilckrm`vikl gccgevisgoy, @lf qniog

vng ksgr`oo vrglf iu vkq`rf arg`vgr ga`oiv`ri`lium/ vng `bioivy vk

t`y ckr vng lgeguu`ry IEV vkkou `lf vr`ilila mg`lu vn`v ilekmg

iu uvioo ` ckrmif`bog b`rrigr vk gpw`o `eeguu vk ilckrm`vikl,

• Ekllgevisivy bgvqggl Eivizglu `lf Aksgrlmglv,Mkrg `lf

mkrg/ fiaiv`o vgenlkokay iu fgeglvr`oizila8 ukmg kc vng tkqgr

vn`v n`f rguifgf il vng n`lfu kc a`vghggtgru `lf ilvgrmgfi`r-

igu iu unicvila vk `sgr`ag wugru, Lkq vqk-q`y ekmmwlie`vikl

`lf ilckrm`vikl cokqu bgvqggl aksgrlmglv `lf eivizglu `lf

nkrizklv`o ekmmwlie`vikl `mkla eivizglu iu s`uv, IEVu n`sg

ilerg`ugf vng utggf kc ekmmwlie`vikl/ tgrmivvila eivizglu vk

ekmmwlie`vg qivn e`lfif`vgu `lf gogevgf kcciei`ou il rg`o vimg,

Vniu immgfi`ey e`l og`f vk arg`vgr imt`ev kl tkoiey fgeiuiklu

`lf `aiog rgutkluisglguu vk vng tkoivy/ bwv immgfi`ey `ouk e`r-rigu vng riuh kc okuila s`ow`bog vimg ckr rgcogevikl `lf e`rgcwo

fgoibgr`vikl,

• Aokb`oLgvqkrhu,Vng gmgragleg kc aokb`o `lf erkuu-bkrfgr

lgvqkrhu e`l ngot vk wlfgrmilg rgtrguuisg `lf `wvnkriv`visg

rgaimgu, Vng imt`ev kc ukei`o mgfi` il vng @r`b Utrila e`llkv

bg wlfgruv`vgf, Bwv gsgl bgckrg vn`v/ il 244>/ vng Wun`nifi

to`vckrm/ qnien gl`bogf vng mklivkrila kc tkuv-gogevikl sik-ogleg il Hgly`/ ogf vk imtrksgf fgmker`vie kwvekmgu il vn`v

ekwlvry, IEVu `ouk gl`bog `f nke lgvqkrhu vk ckrm vk `ffrguu

utgeicie/ v`ragvgf lggfu bgyklf gogevkr`o tkoivieu/ uwen `u vng

ekkrfil`vikl `lf fgoisgry kc `if vk g`rvnpw`hg-r`s`agf N`ivi,

.Qngl vng l`vikl’u glvirg ilcr`uvrwevwrg q`u okuv/ N`ivi`lu

vwrlgf vk Vqivvgr,)

• Nytgr-oke`oEivizglunit,IEVu e`l qkrh vk aokb`oizg `lf `oukvk oke`oizg eivizglunit, Nytgr-oke`o lgvqkrhu `rg hgy tkrv`ou

ckr brilaila tgktog ilvk eisie `cc`iru `lf ekllgevila tgktog vk

iuuwgu kc oke`o kr lgianbkrnkkf eklegrl,

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 9/61

 siii Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

• ErkqfUkwreila,Vng riug kc erkqf ukwreila vk v`t hlkqogfag

`lf vng v`oglvu kc vng twboie iu `lkvngr cg`vwrg kc `l IEV-gl`bogf eivizglunit, Vng mgvnkfu `lf vgenlipwgu kc erkqf

ukwreila ileowfg ugoc-ekrrgevila `lf ugoc-aksgrlila trkeguugu

il ekoogevila vng qiufkm kc vng m`ly,

Vng Ifg`ou kc Eivizglunit, Vng ckookqila oiuv/ v`hgl crkm @br`mukl’u

eklcgrgleg rgtkrv/ e`tvwrgu vng ifg`ou kc fgmker`vie eivizglunit vn`v

`ly g~tgrimglvu il fiaiv`o fgmker`ey unkwof uggh vk rg`oizg:

• Ilckrmgf eivizglunit: `eeguu vk ilfgtglfglv `lf `eewr`vgilckrm`vikl `bkwv vng fkilau kc aksgrlmglv `lf kvngr tkq-

grcwo iluvivwviklu, Lgivngr ilekmg lkr rwr`o oke`vikl unkwof

bg ` b`rrigr vk `eeguu vk vng ekrg ilckrm`vikl vn`v m`hgu ckr

ilckrmgf eivizglunit,

• T`rvieit`vkry eivizglunit: mg`lilacwo kttkrvwlivigu vk t`r-

vieit`vg `evisgoy il vng fgoibgr`visg trkeguugu kc aksgrlmglv

vnrkwan qnien twboie tkoiey iu m`fg,

• Gmtkqgrgfeivizglunit:aglwilg tkqgr/ il ekmbil`vikl qivn

kvngru/ vk `ccgev vng kwvekmg kc tkoiey fgb`vgu,

• Gfwe`vgf eivizglunit:  vng eisie gfwe`vikl/ sirvwg `lf utiriv iv

v`hgu vk gla`ag kvngru il twboie fi`okawg/ fgoibgr`vikl `lf

ktgl g~en`lag kc ifg`u `bkwv vng ekmmkl akkf,

• Mkbioizgfeivizglunit: vng t`rviu`l ifg`oium iv v`hgu vk jkil qivn

kvngru vk cianv ckr ` e`wug kr e`lfif`vg,

• Oke`oeivizglunit:vng lggf ckr twboie upw`rgu/ vkql ekmmklu/

vkql mggvilau `lf Utg`hgru’ Ekrlgru vk brila eivizglu kwv kc 

vngir nkmgu lf ilvk eklsgru`vikl lf ekoo`bkr`vikl qivn vngir

lgianbkru,

• Aokb`oeivizglunit: vng wlfgruv`lfila vn`v qg oisg il ` aokb`o

sioo`ag lf n`sg vng e`t`eivy vk fgoisgr nwm`liv`ri`l uuiuv`leg

`lf vk trkvgev nwm`l rianvu gsgryqngrg,

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 10/61

Ckrgqkrf i~ 

Hgy Rgekmmglf`viklu kc vng 2400 Ckrwm kl Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf

Ukeigvy, Vng 2400 CKE@U rgekmmglf`viklu trkmkvg IEV glsirkl-mglvu vn`v gln`leg rgo`viklunitu `mkla eivizglu/ bgvqggl eivizglu

`lf aksgrlmglvu `lf bgvqggl eivizglu `lf vng mgfi` il vng twboie

utngrg, Vng rgekmmglf`viklu c`oo wlfgr klg kc ui~ ng`filau: Ak Oke`o/

Ak Cr`lhoil/ Ak M`fiukl/ Ak Vrwvncwo `lf Vnkrkwan/ Ak Glvgrv`ilila 

`lf Ak Aokb`o , M`ly kc vngug rgekmmglf`viklu trktkug vk erg`vg lgq

`ttoie`viklu kl vkt kc g~iuvila kr lgq to`vckrmu vk imtrksg ilckrm`-

vikl cokq/ ekmmwlie`vikl `lf eivizgl ilvgr`evikl, G`en rgekmmglf`-

vikl gmtn`uizgu vng `bioivy kc lgvqkrhu vk uwttkrv eivizglu il o`rag eko-o`bkr`visg gcckrvu/ um`oogr-ue`og ekoo`bkr`viklu `lf ekoogevisg trkbogmu,

G`en rgekmmglf`vikl `ouk ckewugu kl bwiofila to`vckrmu ckr eivizglu

vk v`hg l evisg rkog r`vngr vn`l t`uuisg uv`leg, Vn`v iu/ vng imtkrv`lv

lg~wu kc IEVu `lf eivizglunit iu `bkwv eivizglu’ eklvrko `lf vngir og`f-

ila rkogu il aksgrl`leg/ lkv uimtoy mkrg gccieiglv fgoisgry kc aksgrl-

mglv ugrsiegu vk kvngrqiug t`uuisg eivizglu,

Il uwmm`ry/ vng 2400 CKE@U rgekmmglf`viklu `rg:

AkOke`o 

• Bwiofakkf-lgianbkr`ttuvkrwlklg~iuvilaukei`olgvqkrhu/

uk `u vk bwiof eivizglunit crkm vng oke`o ogsgo wt,

• Fguial vngug lgianbkr lgvqkrhu vk ogsgr`ag vng v`oglvu `lf

uhioou vn`v eivizglu `org`fy‖`lf `bwlf`lvoy‖tkuuguu,

• Mkvis`vgeivizgluvkt`rvieit`vgiltwboietkoieyfgb`vgubyrwl-lila trizg-qillila eklvguvu ckr trktku`ou vn`v a`rlgr vng mkuv

kloilg skvgu, Aisg vnkug eivizglu qivn ` qillila trktku`o c`eg

vimg bgckrg ` aksgrlmglv bkfy vn`v ekwof `evw`ooy gl`ev vng

uwaaguvikl,

• Fguialt`rvieit`vkryg~greiuguilqnieneivizglum`hgfgeiuiklu

vnrkwan kloilg rgcgrglf`,

• Wugvngtkilv-vk-tkilv`lffgeglvr`oizilatrktgrvigukcfiaiv o

vgenlkokay vk uwttkrv eivizgl-vk-eivizgl lf eivizgl-vk-aksgrl-

mglv ekmmwlie`viklu,

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 11/61

~ Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

AkCr`lhoil 

• Trkmkvgaksgrlmglv gcckrvu vk ‟akCr`lhoil”by fkilaqivnfiaiv`o ekmmwlie`vikl qn`v Bglj`mil Cr`lhoil fif il niu kql

vimg: uwttkrvila twboie ilsguvmglv il oibr`rigu kr il ckrmila

ekmmwlivy cirg bria`fgu,

• Erg`vg`tkoivie`osgruiklkcvng‟TriwuGccgev”byfguialila`l

kloilg f`unbk`rf fiuto`y vn`v siuw`ooy fgtievu nkq aksgrlmglv

`lf eivizglu `rg fkila‖ileowfila g`en arkwt’u `enigsgmglvu

`lf fiu`ttkilvmglvu,

AkM`fiukl 

• Eklsglg ` ckrmgr arkwt kc eklarguuikl`o rgtrguglv`visgu vk

mkfgo nkq tkoivie`o fgoibgr`vikl mianv v`hg to`eg `v vng ekm-

mwlivy ogsgo/ crgg crkm vng ilcowgleg kc mklgy lf vng trguuwrg

kc gogeviklu,

AkVrwvncwo`lfVnkrkwan 

• Uwttkrvmgfi`gcckrvuvkfguial lkloilg‟coitbk`rf”vn`vtwoou

vkagvngr ilckrm`vikl by uwbjgev, Wugru ekwof coit vnrkwan vng

lgqu/ ekmila `erkuu `rvieogu crkm mwovitog tkilvu kc sigq, @u

klg g~`mtog/ vng coitbk`rf ekwof ileowfg ‟c`ev-engeh” ugevikl

`lf ‟trk” `lf ‟ekl” bwvvklu vn`v og`f vk kt-gfu qivn eklvr`uv-

ila tgrutgevisgu kl vng u`mg vktie,

• Fguial`fkqlok`f`bog‟Qn`vivMg`luvkMg”qifagvvkaisgrg`fgru `l ifg` kc qny ` aisgl lgqu uvkry m`vvgru vk vngm‖

nkq ng`ovn rgckrm ccgevu vng sgr`ag eivizgl/ qngvngr uvimwowu

mklgy iu ekmila vk ykwr vkql/ qn`v vng Gwrktg`l fgbv eriuiu

mg`lu vk ykwr bkvvkm oilg,

• Fgsgokt`mgfi`c`ev-engehilae`t`bioivybyerg`vila`ttoie`-

viklu vk rwl kl g~iuvila brkqugru vn`v qkwof nianoianv rgoi`bog

`lf `eewr`vg uivgu kr ukwregu,

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 12/61

Ckrgqkrf ~i 

AkGlvgrv`ilila 

• Trkfweg`lfbrk`fe`uv`lglvgrv ililaqgbiukfgkrvgogsiuikla`mg unkq `rkwlf ` tkoivie`o vktie‖oihg nkq vk ukosg vng

eivy’u bwfagv eriuiu‖qivn ` qillgr fgeo`rgf vnrkwan kloilg

`wfigleg t`rvieit`vikl,

AkAokb`o 

• Uwttkrv aokb`o eivizglunit qivn `ttoie`viklu vn`v mklivkreglukrunit `lf glekwr`ag mkrg uwuv`ilgf `vvglvikl vk gsglvu

`brk`f,

@ehlkqogfamglvu 

Vng 2400 Ckrwm kl Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy mgv `v vng @utgl

Iluvivwvg il @utgl/ Ekokr`fk/ @wawuv 0-6/ 2400, Qg vn`lh kwr uglikrutklukr/ vng Jknl U, `lf J`mgu O, Hlianv Ckwlf`vikl/ ckr ivu og`fgr-

unit il fgsgoktila vniu Ckrwm, Qg qkwof `ouk oihg vk vn`lh kwr utg-

ei`o awguv/ Sieg Trguifglv @o Akrg/ ckr jkilila vng CKE@U uguuikl kl@wawuv 6 `lf un`rila niu ekluifgr`bog hlkqogfag `lf iluianv ilvk vng

l`vwrg kc lgvqkrhu lf fgmker`ey, Qg qkwof oihg vk vn`lh Oisguvrg`m/

OOE ckr kleg `a`il oisg-uvrg`mila vng CKE@U uguuiklu/ uk vn`v tgktog

`rkwlf vng qkrof ekwof bg ` t`rv kc vng g~tgrigleg, Qg aisg utgei`ovn`lhu vk r`ttkrvgwr Jgccrgy @br`mukl `lf vk Uglikr Trkjgev M`l`agr

Gril Uiooim`l/ @uuiuv`lv Firgevkr kc vng Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy 

Trkar`m Vriei` Hgooy `lf Firgevkr kc Jkwrl`oium Trkjgevu @my A`rmgr

ckr vngir qkrh il brilaila vniu rgtkrv vk crwivikl,

En`rogu M, CirguvklgG~gewvisg Firgevkr

Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy Trkar`mVng @utgl Iluvivwvg

M`ren 2402

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 13/61

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 14/61

Lgvqkrhu `Lf EivizgLunit:

WuiLa vgEnLkokay Ckr  

EisiE iLLks`vikL

 Jgccrgy @br mukl

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 15/61

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 16/61

5

Lgvqkrhu `lf Eivizglunit:

Wuila Vgenlkokay ckr Eisie Illks`vikl

@ Rgtkrv kc vng 2400 @utgl Iluvivwvg

Ckrwm kl Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy 

Fiaiv`o Fiurwtvikl `lf vng Ifg`ou kc EivizglunitIl `ly rkbwuv wlfgruv`lfila kc fgmker`ey/ eivizglunit iu ` erwei`o

ekmtklglv kc ugoc-aksgrlmglv, Il vwrl/ vng crgg cokq kc ilckrm`vikl/vng `eewr`ey kc vn`v ilckrm`vikl/ kttkrvwlivigu vk t`rvieit`vg il vng`cc`iru kc aksgrlmglv `lf ` uglug kc eisie gla`agmglv qivn kvngru `rgerwei`o ekmtklglvu kc eivizglunit, Il gs`ow`vila vngug ekmtklglvu/t`rvieit`lvu il vng 2400 @utgl Iluvivwvg Ckrwm kl Ekmmwlie`viklu`lf Ukeigvy .CKE@U) g~tokrgf nkq bguv vk v`hg eivizglunit fiaiv`o,T`rvieit`lvu a`vngrgf vk v`hg uvkeh kc illks`visg q`yu vn`v eivizglu e`l

wug ilckrm`vikl `lf ekmmwlie`vikl vgenlkokaigu .IEVu) vk bgvvgrtr`evieg vng ekrg‖bwv kcvgl wlrg`oizgf‖ifg`ou kc eivizgl t`rvieit`vikl`lf gmtkqgrmglv,

Vng `fsglv kc fiaiv`o IEVu n`u fiurwtvgf lwmgrkwu ilfwuvrigu,Crgg kloilg eklvglv wlfgrewvu rgekrf o`bgou `lf trilv twboie`viklu,Vgenlkokaigu vn`v ilerg`ug vng utggf kc ekmmwlie`vikl `ouk wlvgvngrm`lwc`evwrila `lf ugrsieg jkbu crkm agkar`tnie`o rguvrieviklu,

Vng trgmiug kc vng 2400 CKE@U iu vn`v vniu fiaiv`o fiurwtvikl n`u kr

qioo ekmg vk fgmker`vie iluvivwviklu `lf trkeguugu `u qgoo, Vng Ckrwmg~tokrgf vng uimio`rivigu lf ficcgrglegu bgvqggl eivizgl-eglvrie fgmke-r`ey lf wugr-eglvrie ttoie`viklu il vng qkrof kc bwuilguu, T`rvieit`lvuokkhgf utgeicie`ooy `v nkq eivizglu qioo `eeguu vng ilckrm`vikl lgeguu`ry vk aksgrl/ rgegisg ugrsiegu `lf ilckrm`vikl crkm vngir aksgrlmglvu/t`rvieit`vg il fgmker`vie trkeguugu `lf t`rvieit`vg il vng twboie utngrgkc vngir oke`oivy `lf vng brk`fgr qkrof, Qn`v `rg vng gmgraila rkogu kc ilfisifw`ou `lf iluvivwviklu il vniu en`laila glsirklmglv;

Il vng ewrrglv mgfi` glsirklmglv `u fgueribgf by T`wo` Hgragr/Trguifglv `lf EGK kc vng Twboie Brk`fe`uvila Ugrsieg/ tgktog uvioo q`venvgogsiuikl/ il c`ev mkrg vn`l gsgr, Tkoivie`o e`lfif`vgu eklvilwg vk utglfc`r mkrg mklgy kl vgogsiuikl `fsgrviuila vn`l `ly kvngr q`y kc rg`enila

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 17/61

6 Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

skvgru,0 Vngug rg`oivigu mg`l vn`v fiaiv`o IEV’u tkoivie`o rkog iu lkv oihgoy 

vk gmgrag il iuko`vikl kr il rgto`egmglv kc vr`fivikl`o mgfi`, R`vngr/iv qioo gskosg `u t`rv kc im`ail`visg mwovi-to`vckrm uivgu vn`v m`rry vngrg`en kc vgogsiuikl `lf vng ilsguvia`visg ilfgtglfgleg kc jkwrl`oiuvuqivn vng utggf/ ar`tnieu/ ilvgr`evisivy `lf ktgl ilckrm`vikl e`t`eivy kc IEV, Jk`pwil @os`r`fk/ Uglikr Sieg Trguifglv kc Fiaiv`o Illks`vikl `v@mgrie`l Twboie Mgfi`/ fgueribgf vng CKE@U miuuikl `u o`wlenila vnglg~v mwovimgfi` ‟G~vrgmg M`hgksgr: Vng Fgmker`ey Gfivikl,”

Eklcgrgleg t`rvieit`lvu `ttrk`engf vng vktie kc lgvqkrhu `lfeivizglunit crkm ` s`rigvy kc trkcguuikl`o tgrutgevisgu‖bwuilguu/vgenlkokay/ tkoivieu/ jkwrl`oium/ glvgrv`ilmglv/ tnio`lvnrkty `lf `e`-

fgmieu, Bwv vngrg q`u qifgutrg`f `arggmglvvn`v @mgrie`lu `rg fiuglen`lvgf qivn vngiraksgrlmglv `lf cggo rgo`visgoy tkqgroguu `ueivizglu vk fk mwen `bkwv iv, Ckrmgr Cgfgr`oEkmmwlie`viklu Ekmmiuuikl En`irm`lRggf Nwlfv fiuewuugf nkq fgutivg `oo vnglgq kttkrvwlivigu ckr eivizglu’ iltwv/ vngrg

uggmu vk bg oivvog imt`ev kl vng ewrrglv tkoiey t`r`oyuiu il Q`unilavkl, Lkrm`l Krluvgilkc vng @mgrie`l Glvgrtriug Iluvivwvg .@GI)g~to`ilgf vn`v t`rv kc vng trkbogm iu vn`v lgv-

qkrhu gl`bog ` um`oo `lf wlrgtrguglv`visg lwmbgr kc t`rviu`l `evisiuvuvk ilfwoag il fggt-rkkvgf t`vnkokaigu vn`v e`l wovim`vgoy glf il vnge`tvwrg `lf eklvrko kc vngir t`rvigu’ trim`rigu,

Aisgl vngug rg`o-qkrof gccgevu crkm ` sgry cgq fiueklvglvgf g~vrgm-

iuvu/ CKE@U t`rvieit`lvu ekluifgrgf qn`v IEV mianv fk vk m`hgeivizglunit mkrg mwuewo`r `lf fgmker`vie, Vnkwan vngy `ouk `ehlkqo-gfagf vn`v vgenlkokay `oklg `eekmtoiungu oivvog `lf mwuv bg `eekm-t`ligf by ewovwr`o `lf cil`lei`o uwttkrv ckr en`lag, Mien`go Krguhgu/Uglikr M`l`aila Gfivkr kc Vng @uukei`vgf Trguu .@,T,)/ rgm`rhgf vn`vmgfi` trkfwegru e`l `lf unkwof bwiof glvieila‖gsgl glvgrv`ilila‖to`vckrmu ckr `evisg eivizglunit .vng uwttoy uifg)/ bwv `v vng glf kc vngf`y ilfisifw`ou n`sg vk q`lv vk bg eivizglu .vng fgm`lf uifg),

Vk f`vg/ qg n`sg ygv vk ugg IEV fiurwtv tkoivieu vk vng g~vglv vn`vvng Ilvgrlgv n`u `org`fy fiurwtvgf vng mwuie/ mgfi` `lf twboiun-ila ilfwuvrigu/ `lf vr`luckrmgf `fsgrviuila/ m`rhgvila/ rgv`ioila/sifgk/ vgogtnklgu `lf gsgl kwr ukei`o oisgu, Aisgl vngug fiurwtviklu

Vgenlkokay `oklg

`eekmtoiunguoivvog bwv mwuv

bg `eekmt`ligf

by ewovwr`o `lfcil`lei`o uwttkrv

ckr en`lag,

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 18/61

Vng Rgtkrv 7 

gougqngrg/ Mkfgr`vkr `lf G~gewvisg Firgevkr kc vng @utgl Iluvivwvg

Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy Trkar`m En`rogu M, Cirguvklg `uhgfqny qg unkwof g~tgev aksgrlmglv vk rgm`il immwlg crkm vng fiaiv`okluo`wanv, @eekrfila vk F`ligo Qgivzlgr/ Fgtwvy Enigc Vgenlkokay Kcciegr ckr Ilvgrlgv Tkoiey `v vng Qnivg Nkwug/ vgl yg`ru t`uugf `cvgrtgrukl`o ekmtwvgru qgrg ilvrkfwegf ilvk vng qkrhto`eg bgckrg vngy aglgr`vgf ` riug il trkfwevisivy, Iv m`y qgoo bg vn`v qg `rg il ` uimio`rqilfkq/ q`ivila ckr tkoivie`o en`lag,

Egrv`iloy uialu kc vr`luckrm`vikl`rg `oo `rkwlf wu, Klg fkgu lkv n`sgvk vnilh vn`v IEV e`wugf  vng @r`bUtrila vk ergfiv ukei`o lgvqkrhilaqivn mkbioizila eivizglu `lf twmt-ila wt vngir tkqgr vk `ev firgevoy ileisio ukeigvy `lf kwvuifg vng bkwlfu kc vr`fivikl`o kra`liz`viklu, Lkr iu vniuekllgevikl bgvqggl ekmmwlie`viklen`lag `lf tkoivie`o rgckrm glvirgoy 

lgq, @u ckrmgr W,U, Ugergv`ry kc Uv`vgM`fgogilg @obrianv tkilvgf kwv/ vngukei`o lgvqkrhu il vng @r`b Utrilato`ygf ` uimio`r rkog vk vng e`uugvvgv`tgu vn`v qgrg umwaaogf by Tkoiun Ukoif`rivy mgmbgru ugghila vk fiu-vribwvg Ogen Q`ogu`’u utggengu, Kc ekwrug/ vkf`y/ IEV fiuvribwvgu ifg`umkrg pwiehoy/ oguu g~tgluisgoy/ vk mkrg tgktog/ crkm mkrg tgktog/ ilmkrg ktgl `lf ilvgr`evisg q`yu vn`l e`uugvvgu gsgr fif,

Aokb`ooy/ IEV tkrvglfu vng glf kc eglvgr-kwv eklvrko ksgr ifg`u `lfekmmwlie`viklu/ vnkwan bokqb`eh crkm vng ckregu kc eglukrunit iuoihgoy vk rgm`il ` ugrikwu vnrg`v vk tkoivie`o vr`lut`rgley/ `u KtglLgvIlivi`visg’u 2404 rgtkrv kl Ilvgrlgv eglukrunit `rkwlf vng qkrof m`hgueog`r,2 Ktgl-ukwreg to`vckrmu `lf ktgl f`v` m`hg ckr vng fgmker`vi-z`vikl kc ilckrm`vikl/ bwv vng b`vvog ksgr qngvngr ilckrm`vikl unkwofbg ktgl kr eokugf kl vng Ilvgrlgv iu c`r crkm ksgr, Qn`v iu eog`r iu vn`vfiaiv`o lgvqkrhu n`sg gmgragf `u ` fkmil`lv‖ic lkv vng fkmil`lv‖

kra`liz`vikl`o ckrm,5

 @renkl Cwla kc N`rs`rf’u Hgllgfy Uenkko kc Aksgrlmglv kbugrsgf

vn`v vng tkuuibioivigu ckr nkq fiaiv`o lgvqkrhu `lf IEV mianv vr`luckrmeivizglunit `rg `u lwmgrkwu `u vngy `rg ilfgvgrmil`vg, Eivizglu mianv

Mgfi` trkfwegru e`l `lf

unkwof bwiof glvieila/gsgl glvgrv`ilila 

to`vckrmu ckr `evisg

eivizglunit .vng uwttoy 

uifg) bwv `v vng glf kc vng f`y tgruklu n`sg vk

 q`lv vk bg eivizglu .vng

fgm`lf uifg),

Mien`go Krguhgu  

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 19/61

3 Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

lgvqkrh vk byt`uu vr`fivikl`o kra`liz`viklu uwen `u tkoivie`o t`rvigu

il c`skr kc brilaila twboie ktilikl firgevoy vk bg`r kl e`lfif`vgu `lfaksgrlmglv tkoieym`hgru,

Vngy mianv wug IEV vk iln`biv sirvw`o/ kloilg twboie upw`rgu vn`v `rg

ileowuisg `lf ga`oiv`ri`l `lf vn`v mkbioizg eivizglu vnrkwan lgq kra`-

liz`viklu/ uwen `u Mksgkl,kra kr CrggfkmQkrhu,kra, @ovgrl`visgoy/

IEV mianv uwttkrv rgcgrglf`-oihg g~greiugu

il firgev fgmker`ey/ qnien q`u vrigf il Bgok

Nkrizklvg/ Br`zio/ qngl skvgru qgrg gmtkq-

grgf vk `ooke`vg vglu kc miooiklu kc fkoo`ru kc vng eivy’u bwfagv,6 Vr`ey Qguvgl/ Ckwlfgr

`lf EGK kc vng Eglvgr ckr Aksgrlmglv

Uvwfigu/ lkvgf vn`v ` lwmbgr kc uv`vgu n`sg

`fktvgf kloilg skvgr-rgaiuvr`vikl uyuvgmu8 vng

u`mg vgenlkokaigu ekwof bg wugf ckr kloilg

b`ookv-ilivi`visg pw`oicie`vikl/ og`fila vk mkrg

firgev fgmker`ey, Kr tgrn`tu QihiOg`hu

mianv bg vng n`rbilagr kc eivizglu gmtkqgr-

ila vngmugosgu vnrkwan lgq ckrmu kc vrwvn-b`ugf `fske`ey, Qn`vgsgr

ckrm vng vr`luckrm`viklu v`hg/ g~iuvila tkoivie`o iluvivwviklu qioo egr-

v`iloy en`lag vk `eekmmkf`vg vng mksgmglv kc tkoivie`o `evisivy klvk

fiaiv`o lgvqkrhu,

Vniu iu lkv vk u`y vn`v fiaiv`o lgvqkrhu qioo n`sg gccgevu kl tkoivie`o

oicg t`r`oogo vk vngir gccgevu vk f`vg kl mgfi`/ ekmmgrei`o `lf ukei`o oicg,

Bgila ` eivizgl iu cwlf`mglv`ooy ficcgrglv crkm bgila ` ekluwmgr‖kr

gsgl ` C`egbkkh criglf, Eivizglu fk lkv wug ekmmwlie`vikl vgen-lkokaigu mgrgoy vk ug`ren kwv ` FSF8 vngy ug`ren ckr ifg`u, Eivizglu ak

kloilg lkv kloy vk g~trguu kr rgaiuvgr kr e`tiv`oizg kl vngir ilfisifw`o

ilvgrguvu8 vngy ekmmwlie`vg il t`rv vk fgb`vg qn`v vngir ilvgrguvu kwanv

vk bg il oianv kc vng fisgrug iuuwgu `rkwlf vngm, Eivizglu `eegtv `l gvnie

kc tgrukl`o rgutkluibioivy `u qgoo `u kc tgrukl`o oibgrvy8 vngy g~tgev vk

ugrsg `u qgoo `u vk bg ugrsgf, Eivizglu fk lkv n`bivw`ooy ekekkl vngm-

ugosgu il eokugf `lf ugoc-eklv`ilgf ukeigvigu8 vngir cr`vgrlivy mwuv bg

vkogr`lv kc lf eklsgru`lv qivn uvr`lagru lf criglfu `oihg, Vng CKE@U

fiuewuuiklu vngrgckrg vkkh lkvg kc vng lggf ckr lgvqkrhgf eivizglu vk

ekmmwlie`vg ktgloy `lf vr`lut`rglvoy il twboie ut`eg‖il vng sirvw`o

gpwis`oglv kc vng twboie upw`rg‖r`vngr vn`l il l`rrkq uioku,

Vng tkuuibioivigu

ckr nkq fiaiv`o

lgvqkrhu `lf IEVmianv vr`luckrm

eivizglunit `rg `u

lwmgrkwu `u vngy 

`rg ilfgvgrmil`vg,

@renkl Cwla  

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 20/61

Vng Rgtkrv 1 

Vng ckookqila oiuv e`tvwrgu vng ifg`ou kc fgmker`vie eivizglunit vn`v`ly g~tgrimglvu il fiaiv`o fgmker`ey unkwof uggh vk rg`oizg:

• Ilckrmgf eivizglunit: `eeguu vk ilfgtgl-fglv `lf `eewr`vg ilckrm`vikl `bkwvvng fkilau kc aksgrlmglv `lf kvngrtkqgrcwo iluvivwviklu, Lgivngr ilekmglkr rwr`o oke`vikl unkwof bg ` b`rrigrvk `eeguu vk vng ekrg ilckrm`vikl vn`vm`hgu ckr ilckrmgf eivizglunit,

• T`rvieit`vkry eivizglunit: mg`lilacwokttkrvwlivigu vk t`rvieit`vg `evisgoy il vng fgoibgr`visg trk-eguugu kc aksgrlmglv vnrkwan qnien twboie tkoiey iu m`fg,

• Gmtkqgrgf eivizglunit: aglwilg tkqgr/ il ekmbil`vikl qivnkvngru/ vk `ccgev vng kwvekmg kc tkoiey fgb`vgu,

• Gfwe`vgf eivizglunit: vng eisie gfwe`vikl/ sirvwg `lf utiriv iv

v`hgu vk gla`ag kvngru il twboie fi`okawg/ fgoibgr`vikl `lfktgl g~en`lag kc ifg`u `bkwv vng ekmmkl akkf,

• Mkbioizgf eivizglunit: vng t`rviu`l ifg`oium iv v`hgu vk jkil qivnkvngru vk cianv ckr ` e`wug kr e`lfif`vg,

• Oke`o eivizglunit: vng lggf ckr twboie upw`rgu/ vkql ekmmklu/vkql mggvilau `lf Utg`hgru’ Ekrlgru vk brila eivizglu kwv kc 

vngir nkmgu lf ilvk eklsgru`vikl lf ekoo`bkr`vikl qivn vngirlgianbkru,

• Aokb`o eivizglunit: vng wlfgruv`lfila vn`v qg oisg il ` aokb`osioo`ag lf n`sg vng e`t`eivy vk fgoisgr nwm`liv`ri`l uuiuv`leg`lf vk trkvgev nwm`l rianvu gsgryqngrg,

Vngug s`rikwu gogmglvu kc eivizglunit `rg lkv mgrg ue`vvgrgf glvrigukl ` o`wlfry oiuv, Vngy `ff wt vk klg ksgr`oo tkilv: eivizglu kc ekwrug

n`sg tris`vg lf t`rviu`l ilvgrguvu vk ugrsg/ bwv eivizglu ouk wlfgruv`lfvn`v fgmker`ey iu lkv `bkwv ugoc-ilvgrguv qriv o`rag `lf egrv`iloy lkv/ ilvng qkrfu kc tkoivie`o ueiglviuv Rkbgrv F`no/ `bkwv ‟74 tgreglv towu klgagvvila vngir q`y kl gsgry iuuwg,” Fgmker`ey iu aksgrlmglv `eekrf-

Bgila ` eivizgl iu

cwlf`mglv`ooy 

ficcgrglv crkmbgila ` ekluwmgr

kr gsgl `

C`egbkkh criglf,

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 21/61

> Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

ila vk ` ekmmkl akkf `lf `bkwv t`rvieit`vila il vng aisgu `lf vng

v`hgu/ vng ekmtrkmiugu `lf vng ek`oiviklu vn`v gl`bog ` fisgrug tgktogvk un`rg ` akkf oicg vkagvngr, G towribwu wlwm e`tvwrgu vniu siuikl kc 

erg`vila ` wlivy vn`v iu rgutgevcwo kc ficcgrgleg `u qgoo `u `ly uoka`l kc 

eivizglunit ekwof,

Vng Fgcilila Cg`vwrgu kc vng Lgq Fiaiv`o O`lfue`tgFwrila vng ciruv 24 yg`ru kc vng Ilvgrlgv/ eklvglv ilfwuvrigu uwen

`u mwuie `lf lgqut`tgru u`q r`fie`o fiurwtvikl il vngir vr`fivikl`o

mkfgou/ `lf ukeigvy iu ewrrglvoy il vng mifuv kc uialicie`lv en`lagu ilvgogtnkly/ sifgk/ `fsgrviuila/ m`rhgvila/ cil`leg `lf rgv`ioila, Qivn

vngug vgenlkokaigu e`wuila fiurwtvikl il bwuilguu iluvivwviklu lf mkf-

gou/ qny qkwof vng iluvivwviklu `lf mkfgou kc aksgrlila bg immwlg;

Egrv`iloy vng rkog kc ekmmwlie`viklu vkkou il vng rgskowviklu il vng

Miffog G`uv `lf tkoivie`o mksgmglvu gougqngrg uwaaguvu vn`v vng f`yu

kc eglvgr-kwv eklvrko `rg ksgr, Lgvqkrhu n`sg bgekmg vng fkmil`lv

kra`liz`vikl`o ckrm/ kccgrila lgq kttkrvwlivigu ckr vng ilfisifw`o,

Twboie Ktilikl, IEV e`l ovgr tkoivieu by gln`leila vng twboie utngrg/ m`hila iv mkrg mwuewo`r`lf ga`oiv`ri`l, Vng bguv rg`o-qkrof g~`mtog kc vniu m`y bg vng @r`b Utrila,

‖@renkl Cwla/ ‟Twboie Ktilikl/” ` trguglv`vikl vk vng 2400 @utgl Iluvivwvg Ckrwm klEkmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy .@wawuv 2/ 2400/ @utgl/ Ekokr`fk),

Twboie Utngrg+ 

Twboie Ktilikl

I   E  V   

    I   E    V

Eivizglu

Tkoiviei`lu # 

Twboie

 @agleigu

O`qu # 

Tkoieigu

Vr`fivikl`o

Kra`liz`viklu

Twboie @evikl

 

~  

Twboie Ktilikl

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 22/61

Vng Rgtkrv 9 

Kl vng vgenlkokay uifg/ qn`v `rg vng lksgo cg`vwrgu kc fiaiv`o ekm-

mwlie`viklu vn`v mianv glrien kr imtksgriun eivizglunit; @lfrgqMeO`wanoil/ G~gewvisg Firgevkr kc Eisie Ekmmklu `lf ckrmgr QnivgNkwug Fgtwvy Enigc Vgenlkokay Kcciegr kc vng Wlivgf Uv`vgu/ trguglvgf

CKE@U t`rvieit`lvu qivn vng mkuv u`oiglv cg`vwrgu kc vng lgq fiaiv`o

o`lfue`tg,

Vng gmgragleg kc ukei`o lgvqkrhila, Trku: ukei`o lgvqkrhila n`u fr`-m`vie`ooy okqgrgf vng ekuv kc arkwt ckrm`vikl/ `lf ukei`o lgvqkrhila

tgrmivu ilfisifw`ou vk oilh vkagvngr by t`uuikl `lf ilvgrguv/ `u qgoo `u

by agkar`tny,Eklu: vng sgry g`ug kc arkwt ckrm`vikl m`y m`hg vigu vk vnkug

arkwtu qg`h `lf ewrukry,

Vng g~tokuikl kc `eeguu vk nwag `mkwlvu kc ilckrm`vikl kl ktgl-ukwreg 

`lf ktgl-f`v` lgvqkrhu, Trku: vng `s`io`bioivy `lf `eeguu vk ilckrm`vikl

trkmiugu fgmker`viz`vikl kc ilckrm`vikl lf vrwg rgskowvikl il eisiegfwe`vikl, Ckr g~`mtog/ vng Rgeksgry,aks qgbuivg tgrmivu eklegrlgf

eivizglu vk vr`eh nkq uvimwowu mklgy iu bgila utglv wlfgr vng Rgeksgry 

@ev kc 2449/ vk boka `lf vqggv `bkwv iv/ vk g~en`lag sigqu/ vk rgtkrvcr`wf `lf `bwug `lf vk ug`ren ckr jkbu cwlfgf qivn uvimwowu mklgy,

Vngrg iu `ouk vng T`rvieit`vkry Ewovwrg Ckwlf`vikl’u ktgl-ilckrm`vikl

qkrh8 vng Ckwlf`vikl trksifgu kra`liz`viklu qkrofqifg qivn crgg `eeguuvk `l `rr`y kc sifgk vkkou ckr fiuvribwvila vngir mguu`agu,

Eklu: vng unggr skowmg kc ilckrm`vikl e`l ksgrqngom eivizglu qivn

qn`v Wlisgruivy kc Qiuekluil Trkcguukr Ogqiu Crigfo`lf e`oogf ‟ilckr-

m`vikl lkiug,”7 Vng Eglvgr ckr Aksgrlmglv Uvwfigu’ Qguvgl uv`vgf vn`v

kcvgl tgktog eklekev uvr`vgaigu vk l`sia`vg vnrkwan vng cokkf kc f`v` vk`skif frkqlila il wugoguu ilckrm`vikl, Ckr g~`mtog/ tgktog kcvgl qioo

eoila vk klg ekmmglv`vkr kr klg uv`vikl kr e`bog VS lgqu lgvqkrhvk tiokv vngm `lf vk trksifg u`cg n`rbkr il mg`lilacwo ilckrm`vikl,

Wlckrvwl`vgoy/ vniu uvr`vgay e`l og`f tgktog vk okeh klvk klg ci~gf uv`r

ckr vngir tkoivieu `lf vwlg kwv tkilvu kc sigq qivn qnien vngy fiu`argg,

L`ley V`vg/ G~gewvisg Firgevkr kc vng Og`awg kc Qkmgl Skvgru/g~trguugf vng trkbogm `u vng `bugleg kc `ly ‟eklvg~v ugvvgru” ckr

vng ilckrm`vikl, Wlisgruivy kc M`ryo`lf ekmtwvgr ueiglviuv BglUnlgifgrm`l genkgf vn`v vnkwanv by uwaaguvila vn`v ukeigvy lggfu lgq

ilvgrc`egu vk ngot mgfi`vg `oo vniu ilckrm`vikl il q`yu vn`v uwttkrv

ekoo`bkr`vikl kl ukei`o lgvqkrhu, @lf ckrmgr W,U, Ugergv`ry kc Uv`vg

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 23/61

04 Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

@obrianv g~trguugf eklegrl vn`v vng utrg`f kc ukmg ilckrm`vikl‖ckriluv`leg/ QihiOg`hu’ vrksg kc eo`uuicigf Uv`vg Fgt`rvmglv e`bogu‖e`ln`rm r`vngr vn`l ugrsg fgmker`ey by g~tkuila vng eklcifglvi`o en`l-lgou vnrkwan qnien fitokm`ey ukmgvimgu mwuv bg eklfwevgf,

Vng gpw`oizila kc `eeguu vk ilckrm`vikl, Trku: vng Ilvgrlgv e`l okqgrvng ekuv kc utrg`fila ilckrm`vikl/ `lf iv e`l trksifg iv il ktgl `lfcrgg ckrm`vu `lf qivnkwv eklvrko by vr`fivikl`o a`vg-hggtila `wvnkri-vigu, Jgf @otgrv/ EGK kc Mkbiog Ekmmklu/ lkvgf IEV’u e`t`eivy vk

rg`en niuvkrie`ooy wlfgrugrsgf ekmmwlivigu,Ng eivgf vng g~`mtog kc Rgckrm Immiar`viklil @mgrie`/ qnkug qgbuivg n`u ngotgf vkmkbioizg `lf ileowfg lgq arkwtu il tkoivieu,@lkvngr g~`mtog iu vng ileowuisg `lf ga`oi-v`ri`l gccgevu kc VngRkkv,ekm il guv`boiunila`l gogevrklie lgqu to`vckrm/ il ekoo`bkr`-vikl qivn Uo`vg,ekm/ ckr vng @crie`l-@mgrie`lekmmwlivy,

Eklu: bkvn Jglly Vkkmgy/ Uglikr Trkar`mKcciegr qivn vng Ckrf Ckwlf`vikl/ lf @lfrgqR`uigj/ Ckwlfgr kc vng Tgrukl`o Fgmker`ey Ckrwm/ gmtn`uizgf vn`v vng ekuv kc brk`f-b`lf n`u erg`vgf ` lgq ‟fiaiv`o fisifg” vn`vtrgsglvu vng gpw`oivy kc `eeguu vk vng Ilvgrlgv,

@eekrfila vk vng 2404 Tgq Eglvgr uwrsgy kc Ilvgrlgv wu`ag/ 20 tgreglvkc `fwovu fk lkv wug vng Ilvgrlgv `lf 55 tgreglv kc nkwugnkofu fk lkvn`sg brk`fb`lf Ilvgrlgv ekllgeviklu `v nkmg,3 

Fiaiv`o vgenlkokay iu fgeglvr`oizila, Trku: il vng brk`fe`uv gr`/ ekm-mwlie`vikl q`u eglvr`oizgf il vng n`lfu kc ` cgq tkqgrcwo `evkru `lfq`u trim`rioy m`uu-vk-tkilv, Eivizglu n`f oivvog kttkrvwlivy vk ekm-mwlie`vg b`eh vk aksgrlmglv `lf gsgl oguu kttkrvwlivy vk lgvqkrhqivn klg `lkvngr, Ekmt`rgf qivn brk`fe`uvila/ fiaiv`o vgenlkokay uwttkrvu tkilv-vk-tkilv ekmmwlie`viklu `lf gmtkqgru eivizglu vkm`hg vngir kql vgogsiuikl unkqu kr boka vngir kql lgqu,1 @eekrfilavk R`uigj/ eivizglu `lf lkv e`lfif`vgu trkfwegf lilg kc gsgry vgl kc vng

0,7 biooikl kloilg sifgku mglviklila B`r`eh Kb`m` kr Jknl MeE`ilfwrila vng 244> e`mt`ial, Fiaiv`o lgvqkrhu `ouk uwttkrv aglwilg vqk-q`y ekmmwlie`vikl bgvqggl eivizgl `lf aksgrlmglv/ `lf vngy tgrmivnkrizklv`o ekmmwlie`viklu `mkla eivizglu vngmugosgu,

Vng unicv crkm

c`ev vk ktilikl jkwrl oium og`sgu

eivizglu qivnkwv

vng hilf kc `eewr`ey engehu

lgqut`tgru `lf

brk`fe`uv mgfi`

vr`fivikl`ooy 

trksifgf,

Er`ia Lgqm`rh 

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 24/61

Vng Rgtkrv 00

Eklu: vng bkfy tkoivie e`l bgekmg utoilvgrgf/ cr`amglvgf/ tko`rizgf

kr b`oh`lizgf ic ekmmwlie`viklu `rg uk fgeglvr`oizgf vn`v wugru ciovgrkwv kttkuila ukwregu kc ilckrm`vikl `lf ng`r kloy crkm oihgmilfgftgktog iluifg qn`v Uvgsgl Eoicv/ Ckwlfgr `lf G~gewvisg Firgevkr kc G-Fgmker`ey,kra/ o`bgogf ‟a`vgf sirvw`o ekmmwlivigu,” @eekrfila vkJgccrgy Umwoy`l/ EGK kc GMMIU Ekmmwlie`viklu/ `lf F`sif Qguvil/Trguifglv `lf EGK kc vng Lgqu Oiegluila Arkwt `lf ckrmgr ng`f kc @BE Lgqu/ vng tko`riz`vikl iu t`rvoy cwgogf by vng geklkmie ileglvisgu,E`bog vgogsiuikl uv`viklu vn`v `ttg`o vk nianoy mkvis`vgf `wfiglegu/`ovnkwan um`oo/ e`l bg sgry trkciv`bog .Ck~ Lgqu `lf MULBE bgilaris`o g~`mtogu), Mkrgksgr/ `u kcvgl tkilvgf kwv by er`iauoiuv CkwlfgrEr`ia Lgqm`rh/ vng `eekmt`lyila unicv crkm c`ev vk ktilikl jkwrl`o-ium og`sgu eivizglu qivnkwv vng hilf kc `eewr`ey engehu lgqut`tgru `lfbrk`fe`uv mgfi` vr`fivikl`ooy trksifgf,

Vng ilerg`ugf utggf kc ekmmwlie`viklu/ tgrmivvila eivizglu vk ekmmw-lie`vg qivn e`lfif`vgu kr gogevgf kcciei`ou il rg`o vimg, Trku: rgtrguglv`visgu`rg g~tgevgf vk ugrsg vng ilvgrguvu kc vngir ekluvivwglvu `lf vng utggf kc ekmmwlie`viklu m`hgu iv cg`uibog vk hlkq vnkug sigqu il rg`o vimg,

IEVEivizgluTkoiviei`lu # 

Twboie

 @agleigu

O`qu # 

Tkoieigu

Vr`fivikl`o

Kra`liz`viklu

Twboie @evikl

 

Twboie Utngrg+ 

Twboie Ktilikl

Gogeviklu+ 

Okbbyila

Ekmmwlie`visg

Trguuwrg

Firgev Eivizgl-vk-Aksgrlmglv, Klg q`y vn`v vgenlkokay e`l en`lag tkoivieu iu by erg`vilafirgev oilhu bgvqggl eivizglu `lf aksgrlmglv, Vngug oilhu byt`uu kr uialicie`lvoy uwttogmglvilvgrmgfi`rigu uwen `u vng twboie utngrg `lf vr`fivikl`o kra`liz`viklu,

‖@renkl Cwla/ ‟Firgev Eivizgl-vk-Aksgrlmglv/” ` trguglv`vikl vk vng 2400 @utgl Iluvivwvg Ckrwm kl Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy .@wawuv 2/ 2400/ @utgl/ Ekokr`fk),

Firgev Eivizgl-vk-Aksgrlmglv

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 25/61

02 Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

Aogll Kviu Brkql kc Vqivvgr/ tkilvgf vk vng ilerg`ugf kttkrvwlivigu

vk eewr`vgoy mg`uwrg twboie uglvimglvu kl iuuwgu lf vk r`tifoy siuw`o-izg vn`v uglvimglv qivn ilck-ar`tnieu, @ffivikl`ooy/ utggfy ekmmwli-

e`vikl iu ngotcwo ic klg q`lvu vng oke`o aksgrlmglv vk ci~ ` tkvnkog, @Ugg-Eoieh-Ci~ uvyog kc gogevrklie to`vckrm qioo trguwm`boy n`uvgl vng

aksgrlmglv’u rgutklug vk ` eivizgl’u tkuv,

Eklu: bkvn eivizgl `lf gogevgf rgtrguglv`visg

ifg`ooy lggf vimg vk rgcogev kl `lf tkuuiboy en`lagvngir ktiliklu, Utggf/ il vng jwfamglv kc ckrmgr

Eklarguum`l Miehgy Gfq`rfu/ e`l bg `l glgmy kc vng n`bivu kc fgoibgr`vikl `lf rgcogevikl vn`v qgs`owg il kwr rgtrguglv`visgu, Qguvgl/ kc vng Eglvgr

ckr Aksgrlmglv Uvwfigu/ `ffgf vn`v utggf v`hguvng `bioivy vk eklvrko vng util kl klg’u mguu`ag

`q`y crkm e`lfif`vgu, Hlkqila vniu/ e`lfif`vgu hggt vngir rgm`rhu

bo`lf/ uk vn`v lkvnila u`if il Tgkri` qioo bg tkwlegf kl `u ilekluiuvglvqivn ukmgvnila u`if il Tnio`fgotni`,

Vng gmgragleg kc aokb`o kr erkuu-bkrfgr lgvqkrhu, Trku: IEV wlfgr-milgu vng `bioivy kc `wvnkriv`ri`l aksgrlmglvu vk eokug vngir bkrfgru vk

vng crgg cokq kc ilckrm`vikl, Ckr g~`mtog/ vng Wun`nifi to`vckrm/ ek-fgsgoktgf by Jwoi`l` Rkvien/ q`u `bog vk eklfwev ilvglug mklivkrila

kc tkuv-gogevikl sikogleg il Hgly` il 244>, B`ugf kl rgtkrvu uwbmivvgfby Wun`nifi wugru si` vng qgb `lf mkbiog tnklgu/ gsglvu vn`v `wvnkri-

vigu qiungf vk fgly bge`mg vr`lut`rglv vk vng qkrof, Il oianv kc ` oisg

brk`fe`uv b`l gl`evgf by vng aksgrlmglv/ vng Ilvgrlgv bge`mg ` siv`okwvogv vk unkq vng qkrof qn`v q`u n`ttglila il Hgly`, Eivizglu’ gygu

m`fg wt ckr vng o`eh kc jkwrl`oiuvu’ bkkvu kl vng arkwlf, Mg`lqniog/fwrila vng `cvgrm`vn kc vng 2404 g`rvnpw`hg il N`ivi/ Rglfkl Arkwt

EGK Jknl Rglfkl tkilvgf kwv/ tgktog lkv il g`rvnpw`hg-r`s`agf N`ivi

bwv ue`vvgrgf vnrkwankwv vng qkrof qgrg `bog vk erg`vg `l `f nke qgblgvqkrh `lf `l ilvgr`evisg m`t/ qnien qgrg uweeguucwo il fgvgrmilila

qnien fkevkru/ qivn qn`v utgei`ovigu/ qgrg il N`ivi `lf nkq vngy ekwofbg rgtkuiviklgf vk bgvvgr ugrsg mgfie`o lggfu,

Eklu: `u vgenlkokay qrivgr Gsagly Mkrkzks rgeglvoy `rawgf/ IEVekmt`ligu n`sg uwttoigf rgtrguuisg rgaimgu vnrkwankwv vng qkrof qivn

uwrsgioo`leg vgenlkokaigu vn`v ‟`aglvu kc vng G`uv Agrm`l Uv`ui ekwofkloy n`sg frg`mgf kc,”>

Utggf e`l bg

`l glgmy kc 

vng n`bivu kc 

fgoibgr`vikl`lf rgcogevikl,

Miehgy Gfq`rfu 

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 26/61

Vng Rgtkrv 05

Nytgr-oke`o lgvqkrhu, Trku: @v vng u`mg vimg u vngy rg aokb`o/ ukei`o

lgvqkrhu e`l bg nytgr-oke`o `lf e`l bg ` hgy tkrv`o ckr brilaila ilfi-sifw`ou ilvk tkoivieu by ekllgevila vngm vk vng eisie eklegrlu kc vngirlgianbkrnkkfu, Ckr iluv`leg/ u`if G-Fgmker`ey,kra’u Eoicv/ klg e`llkq rg`fioy rg`en kwv vk lgianbkru gogevrklie`ooy il Millg`tkoiu klto`vckrmu oihg niu qivn uimtog pwgrigu oihg ‟I’f oihg vk uv`rv ekmmwlivy a`rfgl” kr ‟I’f oihg vk uv`rv ` Ut`liun-Glaoiun to`y arkwt,”

Eklu: oke`o lgvqkrhu vn`v `rg lkv ilvgrekllgevgf kcvgl `rg ilsiuibogvk klg `lkvngr `lf o`eh vng e`t`eivy vk bwiof oilhu kr brifagu vk kvngroke`o lgvqkrhu’ mgmbgru qivn qnkm vngy unkwof bg v`ohila,

Vng riug kc erkqf ukwreila `u ` q`y kc fgmker`vie`ooy v`ttila ilvkvng hlkqogfag kr v`oglvu kc vng twboie, Trku: Wun`nifi’u qkrh il Hgly`fgtglfgf kl erkqf ukwreila, Qihitgfi` iu tgrn`tu vng mkuv qgoo-hlkql g~`mtog kc kwvukwreila qn`v wugf vk bg ` trkcguuikl`o v`uh.qrivila gleyeoktgfi` glvrigu) vk vng aglgr`o twboie‖`lf cilfila kwv ilvng trkeguu vn`v vngrg iu ugoc-aksgrlila lf ugoc-ekrrgevila uyuvgm vn`vuvgmu crkm vng ekoogevisg qiufkm kc vng m`ly, Vniu trkeguu iu ewrrglvoy bgila `f`tvgf ckr eisie `lf tkoivie`o twrtkugu,9 

Eklu: erkqf ukwreila e`l bg wugf il q`yu vn`v e`wug ukei`o n`rm,Ckr g~`mtog/ il 2400 Lkrvn Oklfkl rikvgru `tt`rglvoy wugf mkbiogtnklgu vk t`uu kl ilckrm`vikl il rg`o vimg `bkwv qngrg iv q`u u`cg vkokkv, Mkrgksgr/ vng `eewr`ey kc erkqf ukwreila e`l bg il fkwbv/ qnienq`u egrv`iloy vrwg kc m`ly g`roy glvrigu il Qihitgfi` .`lf uvioo vrwg kc m`ly ewrrglv glvrigu), Vng ukwregu kc ilckrm`vikl crkm vng erkqf `rglkv `oq`yu vr`lut`rglv kr wlbi`ugf vk wugru,

Wug kc ukei`o lgvqkrhila vk rgckrm e`mt`ial cil`leila, Trku: @GI’uKrluvgil tkilvgf vk B`r`eh Kb`m`’u uweeguu u trguifglvi`o e`lfif`vgil r`iuila o`rag `mkwlvu kc mklgy kl vng Ilvgrlgv crkm um`oo fklkrufwrila vng 244> e`mt`ial,

Eklu: Krluvgil q`u lkv uwrg vn`v vng Kb`m` lgvqkrh uwrsisgf vnge`mt`ial kr trksgf ugoc-uwuv`ilila/ `lf/ `v `ly r`vg/ ukei`o lgvqkrhilan`u lkv `ovgrgf vng rkog kc Bia Mklgy il e`mt`ialu,

Tkoiey Ktviklu @ng`f: Rgekmmglf`vikluEklcgrgleg t`rvieit`lvu ekluifgrgf lgq aksgrlmglv tkoieigu `lf`ttoie`viklu `v vng cgfgr`o/ uv`vg `lf oke`o ogsgou vk trkmkvg `l glsi-rklmglv vn`v glekwr`agu fgmker`vie illks`viklu m`fg tkuuibog crkmgmgraila fiaiv`o `lf lgvqkrh vgenlkokaigu,

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 27/61

06 Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

Il m`hila rgekmmglf`viklu/ t`rvieit`lvu qgrg awifgf by vqk tril-

eitogu gl`bogf by 20uv eglvwry ekmmwlie`vikl:0) Vng `bioivy kc lgvqkrhu vk uwttkrv eivizglu il mga`-ekoo`bk-r`vikl kl ekoogevisg trkbogmu,04 Bgl Unlgifgrm`l’u `rawmglv vn`vvng trktgr mgvrie ckr `uuguuila vng fgmker`vie e`t`eivy kc IEV il vnglgq ekmtwvila `ag q`u lk oklagr qn`v vng ekmtwvgr e`l fk kr qn`vvng e`t`eivy kc ` enit iu/ bwv qn`v  tgktog fk qivn ekmtwvgru, Okkhgf`v il vniu q`y/ Unlgifgrm`l uwaaguvgf/ vng bguv mg`uwrgmglv kc vngIlvgrlgv’u fgmker`vie wugu iu vng lwmbgr kc ‟ekoo`bu” kr ‟eklvribu”kl ` mga`-eklvribwvila/ mga`-ekoo`bkr`vila uivg uwen `u Qihitgfi`/Wun`nifi/ Vqivvgr/ C`egbkkh kr Oke`oker`ey,

2) Fiuvilawiun g-fgmker`ey crkm g-ugrsiegu .ukmgvimgu `ouk e`oogfg-aksgrlmglv)‖`lf ekleglvr`vg kl vng ckrmgr, N`rs`rf’u Cwlauwaaguvgf vniu fiuvilevikl bge`wug/ qivn g-ugrsiegu mkfgou/ ilfisifw-`ou `rg rgeitiglvu kc aksgrlmglv`o ugrsiegu/ vng fgoisgry kc qnien ium`fg mkrg gccieiglv by kloilg ekmmwlie`viklu,00 Bwv/ il g-fgmker`ey mkfgou/ ukmgvimgu `ouk rgcgrrgf vk `u g-aksgrl`leg/ ilfisifw`ou `rgvng ek-`wvnkru  kc vngir kql aksgrlmglv/ wuila vng lgq lgvqkrhilavgenlkokaigu vk t`rvieit`vg hlkqilaoy `lf `evisgoy il vng ckrm`vikl kc twboie tkoiey, T`rvieit`lvu’ eklegrl ckr eivizglunit `u `l `evisg r`vngrvn`l t`uuisg uv`leg ogf vngm vk ekleglvr`vg kl nkq vk bwiof rkbwuvg-fgmker`vie to`vckrmu ckr t`rvieit`vikl `lf fgoibgr`vikl,02 

Vk ` egrv`il g~vglv/ gogevgf kcciei`ou `lf `fmiliuvr`visg `agleigu`org`fy n`sg uwccieiglv tkoivie`o lf e`rggr ileglvisgu vk twruwg gccieiglvg-ugrsiegu fgoisgry vk ekluvivwglvu, Bwv vngy o`eh uimio`r ileglvisgu vkilsguv il g-fgmker`ey to`vckrmu/ uileg eivizglu e`l m`hg bkvn lga`-visg `lf tkuivisg ekmmglvu kl `ly kloilg eisie ckrwm vng aksgrlmglvmianv erg`vg, Vniu o`eh kc ` ‟tkoivie`o m`rhgv” ckr eivizgl-criglfoy wugukc IEV iu klg kc vng m`il rg`uklu arkwtu oihg CKE@U `rg vryila vk

 jwmt-uv`rv vng trkeguu,

Il m`hila rgekmmglf`viklu/ vng CKE@U t`rvieit`lvu fisifgf ilvkckwr qkrhila arkwtu/ g`en v`uhgf qivn br`iluvkrmila illks`viklu il `t`rviewo`r `rg` fgcilgf by ` t`rviewo`r ekmmwlie`vikl fyl`mie:

0) eivizgl-vk-eivizgl ekmmwlie`viklu il vng twboie utngrg2) eivizgl-vk-aksgrlmglv ilvgr`eviklu

5) aksgrlmglv-vk-eivizgl ekmmwlie`vikl

6) mgfi`-vk-eivizgl eklvglv `lf trkar`mmila

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 28/61

Vng Rgtkrv 07 

Il vng cil`o uguuiklu kc vng eklcgrgleg/ iv bge`mg `tt`rglv vn`v vngrg

q`u ekluifgr`bog ksgro`t `lf uylgray `mkla vng qkrhila arkwtu’ rge-kmmglf`viklu, Vngy `rg trguglvgf ngrg/ vngrgckrg/ `u klg m`uvgr oiuv

vn`v rgekmmglfu vng ckookqila `eviklu,

R gekmmglf`vikl 0,AkOke`o:Illks`vikluilEivizgl-vk-Eivizgl

`lfEivizgl-vk-AksgrlmglvEkmmwlie`viklu 

Ekmmwlivy kra`lizgru uileg U`wo @oiluhy n`sg uvrguugf vng lggf vk

uv`rv qivn qn`v tgktog q`lv, Il vniu utiriv/ eivizglunit unkwof bg bwiov

crkm vng lgianbkrnkkf kwv, Ckwr rg`uklu ekmbilg vk m`hg oke`o eivi-zglunit vng trgcgrrgf uv`rvila tkilv, Ciruv/ u unkql

by Eoicv’u qkrh il Millg`tkoiu .`v G-Fgmker`ey,

kra) kr Eklkr Qnivg-Uwoois`l’u qkrh il @mngruv/

M`uu`enwugvvu .`v Oke`oker`ey,ekm) kr Ar`n`mRien`rf’u vglwrg `u M`ykr kc Ckrv Q`ylg/ Ilfi`l`/

agkar`tnie`o trk~imivy e`rrigu qivn iv ` uvrkla

ileglvisg ckr lgianbkru vk ekoo`bkr`vg il ukos-

ila lgianbkrnkkf trkbogmu, Ugeklf/ oke`o iuuwgu`rg oihgoy vk bg eivizgl-m`l`ag`bog/ kr `v og`uv mkrg m`l`ag`bog/

vn`l rgaikl`o kr l`vikl`o trkbogmu, Vnirf/ `u unkql by vng qkrh kc 

Bglj`mil Riaby kl mierk-skowlvggrila .Ut`rhgf,ekm) kr kc EklkrQnivg-Uwoois`l kl oke`o aksgrlmglv/ eivizglu n`sg vng v`oglvu `lf

hlkqogfag iv v`hgu vk v`ehog oke`o trkbogmu/ `lf qg unkwof fgsgokt

to`vckrmu vn`v `rg qgoo-fguialgf vk ogsgr`ag g~iuvila eivizgl uhioou vkukosg g~iuvila trkbogmu, Ckwrvn/ ficcgrglv lgianbkrnkkfu `rg oihgoy 

vk un`rg vng u`mg trkbogmu/ qnien rgpwirgu vn`v vngy bg ekllgevgf ilkrfgr vk qkrh vkagvngr vk ukosg vngm8 ngleg/ oke`o lgvqkrhila utklv`-

lgkwuoy g~t`lfu vng nkrizklu kc akkf eivizglunit, Vngug ckwr rg`ukluckr m`hila oke`o eivizglunit uv`rvila tkilv n`sg trim`ry ak`o: vk cilf

oke`o illks`viklu e`t`bog kc bgekmila ‟oke`ooy gsgryqngrg” ukowviklu,

Vng uvgtu kc ‟akila oke`o” `rg `u ckookqu:

Rgekmmglf`vikl 0@: Fgsgokt ` Lgianbkru @tt

@ ‟Lgianbkru @tt” ekwof ktgr`vg kl vkt kc g~iuvila ukei`o lgvqkrhu.C`egbkkh/ Vqivvgr/ Akkaog( `lf vng oihg) `lf gl`bog lgianbkrnkkf-

ogsgo `evisivigu/ uwen `u fiuewuuikl kc oke`o trkbogmu/ un`rila kc vitu `lf

Eivizglunit

unkwof bg

bwiov crkm vng

lgianbkrnkkf

kwv,

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 29/61

03 Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

rgekmmglf`viklu/ to`llila kc lgianbkrnkkf ukei`o gsglvu `lf skowl-

vggrila evisivigu,@eekrfila vk 2404 rgtkrv crkm vng Tgq Ilvgrlgv lf @mgrie`l OicgTrkjgev/ 9 tgreglv kc `fwovu uwrsgygf g~en`lagf gm`iou qivn lgianbkru`bkwv ekmmwlivy iuuwgu/ 7 tgreglv `rg kl ` ekmmwlivy oiuvugrs `lf 6tgreglv n`sg jkilgf ` ukei`o-lgvqkrhila uivg ekllgevgf vk ekmmwlivy iuuwgu,05 Qivn `vvglvikl vk vng imtkrv`leg kc oke`o ekllgevisivy arkq-ila/ vngug tgreglv`agu unkwof fkwbog il vng lg~v cgq yg`ru,

Vng ilivi`o tiven vk jkil vng Lgianbkru @tt qkwof bg uimtog: agv vk

hlkq ykwr lgianbkru `lf v`oh `bkwv ykwr lgianbkrnkkf , Bwv vng tkvgl-vi`o ckr o`ragr-ue`og eisie `evikl `rkwlf tkoivie`o iuuwgu qkwof g~iuv kleglgianbkru lgvqkrhgf `lf bga`l vk ugg vng lggf ckr ekoogevisg `evikl vkukosg oke`o trkbogmu,

Uvgtngl B`oh`m/ Ckwlfgr `lf EGK kc vng C`mioy Kloilg U`cgvy Iluvivwvg/ trksifgf ` mksila g~`mtog kc nkq klg tgrukl qivn ` lggfun`rgf by m`ly bwiov ` tkqgrcwo lgvqkrh kc eivizglu vk mkvis`vg brk`fen`lag, Vng uvkry iu fr`ql crkm B`oh`m’u trgsikwu qkrh il vng Iuoilavkllgianbkrnkkfu kc Lkrvn Oklfkl, @v ciruv/ ` qkm`l t`r`oyzgf il `qnggoen`ir n`f ` twrgoy tgrukl`o lggf vk cilf vr`lutkrv, Uk ung uv`rvgf` Fi`o-`-Rifg ugrsieg `lf lgvqkrhgf qivn kvngru il lggf kc vr`lutkrv,Lg~v/ ung guv`boiungf ` lkltrkciv `lf/ qivn ` ar`lv crkm vng Iuoilavkloke`o ekwleio/ br`lengf kwv ilvk ` mkrg aglgr`o e`mt`ial vk ilerg`ugtwboie ilsguvmglv il m`uu vr`luiv, Wovim`vgoy/ ngr tiklggrila qkrh o`ifvng arkwlfqkrh ckr vng Eklaguvikl En`rag/ ` mwovi-yg`r twboie vr`lu-tkrv e`mt`ial vn`v/ `mkla kvngr vnilau/ lkq uweeguucwooy en`ragu `ly `wvkmkbiog frisila ilvk Eglvr`o Oklfkl fwrila tg`h nkwru,

Vk f`vg/ tgktog n`sg m`fg rgo`visgoy cgq `vvgmtvu vk ekllgev lgian-bkrnkkfu si` C`egbkkh `ttu, Ukmg lgq fguial kr e`mt`ial uggmulgeguu`ry vk mksg tgktog vk m`hg wug kc vng kttkrvwlivigu kwv vngrg,BgLgianbkru,kra iu klg g~`mtog kc ` trktkugf ‟oke`o gsgryqngrg”lgianbkrnkkf to`vckrm crkm G-Fgmker`ey,kra, Vng ilvwivisg fguialifg` iu vn`v tgktog unkwof bg `bog vk ugogev vngir kql ‟lgianbkrnkkfeireog” uizg/ `fjwuvila iv `u lggfgf fgtglfila kl vng iuuwg vn`v eklegrluvngm `lf fgvgrmilila qn`v ilckrm`vikl kr ekmmwlivy fiuewuuiklu

vngy q`lv vk jkil, Vniu `ookqu eivizglu vk un`rg ilckrm`vikl kloy vk vngirlg`rguv lgianbkru .g,a,/ ‟I q`u brkhgl ilvk o`uv lianv/ fif `lyklg ugg`lyvnila;”) kr vk vng glvirg eivy .g,a,/ ‟Jkil „EivyQ`ven’ vk frisg erimgkwv kc kwr ekmmwlivigu!”),

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 30/61

Vng Rgtkrv 01 

Rgekmmglf`vikl 0B: Oke`ou Kloilg‖Ug`ren/ Cilf `lf Jkil

Lgianbkrnkkf-vk-Lgianbkrnkkf Lgvqkrhu @u B`oh`m’u uvkry .`bkwv nkq klg qkm`l’u twruwiv ogf vk ` rittog

gccgev kl twboie vr`lutkrv`vikl `lf vr`ccie vnrkwankwv Oklfkl) ioowu-vr`vgu/ ilfisifw`ou lggf vk bg lgvqkrhgf vk lgianbkrnkkfu/ bwv lgian-bkrnkkfu `ouk lggf vk bg lgvqkrhgf vk g`en kvngr, Ewrrglvoy/ vnkw-u`lfu kc ilfgtglfglv/ ar`uurkkvu lgvqkrhu rgm`il o`ragoy ilsiuibog vkkwvuifgru, Ygv vng trgmiug kc vng arg`v @mgrie`l g~tgrimglv fgtglfukl brk`foy un`rgf twboie fiuekwrug, Ckr vn`v rg`ukl/ ` ugeklf uv`ag kc lgvqkrhila iu lgeguu`ry/ ag`rgf vk fiueksgrila/ brifaila `lf ekllgev-

ila nytgr-oke`o lgvqkrhu,

IEV lggfu vk bg mkrg siuibog `lf mkrg `eeguuibog vk `oo mgmbgru kc s`rikwu lgvqkrhu/ lkv jwuv vng nianoy gla`agf mgmbgru qnk rg org`fy 

ekllgevgf `lf qnk kcvgl ugrsg `u en`lag `aglvu, Vngrg iu rgug`renvk b`eh wt vng imtkrv`leg kc ilvgroilhila lgvqkrhu, MIV’u F`mklEglvko`/ ilsguvia`vila nkq ukei`o lgvqkrhu `ccgev vng utrg`f kc ng`ovn-rgo`vgf bgn`sikr/ ckwlf vn`v lgvqkrhu qivn m`ly oke`ooy rgfwlf`lvvigu rguwovgf il bgn`sikr`o en`lagu utrg`fila c`rvngr `lf c`uvgr vn`lbgn`sikr`o en`lagu qivnil r`lfkm lgvqkrhu, @u Eglvko` n`u qrivvgl/‟Qngrg`u oke`ooy eowuvgrgf vigu m`y bg rgfwlf`lv ckr uimtog eklv`-

aiklu/ oihg ilckrm`vikl kr fiug`ug/ vngy e`l bg nianoy gccieiglv ckr trk-mkvila bgn`sikr`o ficcwuikl,”06 By g~vgluikl/ iv m`y bg vn`v g~tkuwrgvk eisie gla`agmglv bgn`sikru qivnil lf erkuu lgqoy siuibog lgvqkrhum`y yigof mkrg uwen bgn`sikru `erkuu vng glvirg ekmmwlivy,

Vng rgekmmglf`vikl ngrg iu vk bwiof kl vng g~iuvila Oke`ou Kloilgekmmwlivigu qniog uvioo mksila vng cigof ckrq`rf by o`wlenila ` e`m-t`ial vn`v e`l ngot miooiklu kc @mgrie`lu cilf `lf oilh vngir oke`okloilg arkwtu, Uwen ` e`mt`ial qkwof uv`rv crkm g~iuvila lgianbkr-nkkf- kr t`rglv-gm`io oiuvu `lf bwiof kwvq`rf vnrkwan C`egbkkh krAkkaog( arkwtu vigf vk ` utgeicie agkar`tnie`o to`eg,

Rgekmmglf`vikl 0E: R`mt Wt G~iuvila Oke`o To`vckrmu ilvk Sirvw`o Twboie Upw`rgu E`t`bog kc Uwttkrvila Vqk-Q`y Eivizgl-vk-Aksgrlmglv 

Ekmmwlie`viklu G~iuvila oke`o to`vckrmu unkwof bg g~t`lfgf vk uwttkrv eivizgl t`r-

vieit`vikl il aksgrlmglv tkoieym`hila, To`vckrmu unkwof bg fguialgfvk uwttkrv lkv jwuv eivizgl-vk-eivizgl kr lgianbkr-vk-lgianbkr g~en`la-

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 31/61

0> Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

gu/ bwv eivizgl-vk-aksgrlmglv vqk-q`y fi`okawgu `u qgoo, Lgianbkr

`ttu ekwof bg r`mtgf wt ilvk sirvw`o twboie upw`rgu vnrkwan vng cko-okqila uvgtu:

• @ff `l ilckrm`viklhikuh iekl vn`v eivizglu e`l eoiehkl vk

rgvrigsg b`uie tkoivie`o ilckrm`vikl ue`ogf vk vngir ekmmwlivy/

uwen `u: ‟Qngrg fk I rgaiuvgr vk skvg;” kr ‟Qn`v iu vng m`ykr’u

tkuivikl kl bwiofila ` uko`r c`rm il vng kof o`lfcioo;” Wuila `

pwguvikl-`lf-`luqgr ckrm`v `ookqu eivizglu/ `u qgoo `u t`rviei-

t`vila kcciei`ou/ vk `luqgr tkuvgf pwguviklu `lf vk v`hg `fs`l-

v`ag kc erkqf ukwreila vk aglgr`vg `eewr`vg `luqgru,

• @ff ` sirvw`o twboie upw`rg qngrg eivizglu e`lm`hg tkoiey

uwaaguviklu `lf fgb`vg klg `lkvngr’u trktku`ou ckr ukosila

lgianbkrnkkf kr erkuu-lgianbkrnkkf eklegrlu, Vng sirvw`o

twboie upw`rg unkwof ileowfg ` vkko- `lf ktgl-f`v` ugv‖uwen

`u Fgmker`eym`t,kra‖vn`v qkwof ngot eivizglu vk oke`vg

vngir rgtrguglv`visgu `lf vk eklv`ev vngm by gm`io, Vng sirvw`o

upw`rg unkwof `ouk bg fguialgf uk vn`v eivizglu e`l ilvgr`e-visgoy fgb`vg `l iuuwg‖oihg bwiofila ` uko`r c`rm il vng kof

o`lfcioo, Tkuvgf trktku`ou qkwof bg uwbjgev vk fgb`vg/ `mglf-

mglv `lf skvila, Trktku`ou vn`v `enigsg uwccieiglv uwttkrv il

vng sirvw`o twboie upw`rg qkwof vngl bg v`hgl vk aksgrlmglv,

Aksgrlmglv kcciei`ou ekwof bg brkwanv ilvk vng sirvw`o twboie

upw`rg vk ekluifgr `ly tkoiey trktku`ou `enigsila egrv`il ogsgou

kc eivizgl uwttkrv `lf vk rgutklf vk vngm,

• Trksifg ileglvisgu ckr eivizglu vk t`rvieit`vg il vng sirvw o

twboie upw`rg `okla vng oilgu kc vng ^-Trizg kr En`ooglag,aks 

ekmtgviviklu, Eivizglu qnkug tkoiey trktku`ou qil vng mkuv

uwttkrv il `ly kloilg fgb`vg ekwof rgegisg rgq`rfu/ uwen `u

0) iluvivwvikl`o `lf cil`lei`o uwttkrv crkm vng utklukr kc vng

eklvguv vk ngot imtogmglv vng qillila tkoiey trktku`o8 2) `l

kttkrvwlivy vk mksg crkm t`rvieit`vila il vng sirvw`o fiuewu-

uikl vk agvvila c`eg vimg qivn oke`o rgtrguglv`visgu lf en`legvk trguglv ` lgianbkrnkkf arkwt’u eklugluwu rgekmmglf`-

vikl8 kr 5) c`eg vimg bgckrg vng ogaiuo`visg kr `fmiliuvr`visg

bkfy qivn vng utgeicie `wvnkrivy vk gl`ev vng qillila trktku`o,

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 32/61

Vng Rgtkrv 09 

• @ff sirvw`oskowlvggrilabkkvn/qngrgoke`oaksgrlmglvu lf

lkltrkciv kra`liz`viklu e`l mggv kloilg vk m`ven vngir lggfuqivn vng vimg `lf uhioou kc eivizgl skowlvggru, M`ly eivizglu

`org`fy n`sg vng v`oglv vk ukosg m`ly lgianbkrnkkf trkbogmu8

ekmmwlivigu unkwof bwiof to`vckrmu vn`v ogsgr`ag vnkug v`oglvu

`lf vn`v okqgr vng ekuvu kc ukowviklu vk trkbogmu `u eivizglu

crggoy eklvribwvg vngir vimg `lf g~tgrviug, Ckr iluv`leg/ m`ly 

ekmt`ligu `org`fy n`sg tkoieigu vk uwttkrv ekmmwlivy skowl-

vggrila by trksifila gmtokyggu qivn ileglvisgu vk agv ilskosgf,

Vngrg `rg gsgl bwuilguugu‖uwen `u Ut`rhgf,ekm‖vn`v qkrh

qivn ekmt`ligu vk erg`vg qgbuivgu vn`v uwttkrv vng ekmt`ligu’

skowlvggr trkar`mu,07

Rgekmmglf`vikl 0F: Gpw`oizg @eeguu vk Oke`o Lgvqkrhu `lf Ckrwmu 

Lgianbkrnkkf lgvqkrhu lf sirvw`o twboie upw`rgu/ u glsiuiklgf by 

t`rvieit`lvu/ qioo qkrh vk trkmkvg fgmker`ey kloy ic mkrg iu fklg vk

aisg eivizglu gpw`o `lf `cckrf`bog `eeguu vk Ilvgrlgv `lf mkbiog ekm-

mwlie`viklu, Vqk ifg`u fgugrsg ekluifgrgf uwttkrv:• Il 2447/ `v vng wraila kc M`ykr Ar`n`m Rien`rf/ Sgrizkl

ilsguvgf ksgr &044 miooikl vk bwiof kwv ` cibgr-vk-vng-nkmg

.CVVN) uyuvgm il Ckrv Q`ylg/ Ilfi`l`/ m`hila iv klg kc vng

ciruv eivigu vk gljky eivy-qifg cibgr-ktvie brk`fb`lf ugrsiegu.CIKU), Nkqgsgr/ vkf`y m`ly ekmmwlivigu fk lkv n`sg oke`o

trksifgru‖kr glvnwui`uvie m`ykru‖qiooila vk bwiof CVVN

uyuvgmu, M`ykr Rien`rf iu qkrhila kl twboie-tris`vg t`rvlgr-

unitu vk brila cibgr-ktvie e`bog vk rwr`o `lf kwvoyila `rg`u ewr-rglvoy wlfgrugrsgf by nian-utggf brk`fb`lf, Vng t`rvlgrunit

e`oou ckr mwlieit`oivigu vk iuuwg bklfu .Um`rv Eivy Bklfu) vk

cil`leg vng ekluvrwevikl/ bwv iv e`oou ckr tris`vg CVVN ktgr`-

vkru vk t`rvlgr qivn vng oke`o ekmmwlivy vk un`rg ukmg kc vng

riuh kc ktgr`vikl/ m`l`agmglv lf cil`leila, O`yila kc ktvie`o

cibgr lkv kloy ugrsgu vng Ilvgrlgv lggfu kc ` ekmmwlivy’u eivi-

zglu8 iv ouk erg`vgu lgq twboie akkfu/ uileg vng cibgr ilcr`uvrwe-

vwrg e`l bg wugf ckr um`rv ugqgr/ q`vgr `lf glgray uyuvgmu,

• Vng Ckrf Ckwlf`vikl’u Vkkmgy rgekmmglfgf uvwfyila vng

cg`uibioivy kc vng Klg Geklkmy Ekrtkr`vikl’u trktku`o vn`v

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 33/61

24 Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

lk twboie nkwuila bg bwiov kr uwbuv`lvi`ooy rglks`vgf qivnkwv

`ffila Ilvgrlgv ekllgevisivy, Fgsgoktgru qkwof rgegisg ` v`~qrivg-kcc vk fgcr`y vng ekuvu kc lgvqkrhila bwiofilau/ il vngu`mg q`y vngy `org`fy e`l qrivg kcc egrv`il m`ilvgl`leg `lfarkwlfu-hggtila g~tglugu,

R gekmmglf`vikl 2,AkCr`lhoil:Aksgrlmglv-vk-Eivizgl

Ekmmwlie`viklu 

IEV iu jwuv klg vkko ckr eivizgl eklarga`viklu vk wug il sirvw`o twboieupw`rg, Aksgrlmglv mwuv fk ivu t`rv vk m`hg eivizglunit t`rvieit`viklm`vvgr il vng `evw`o tkoieym`hila trkeguu, Wloguu eivizglu ugg vn`v t`r-vieit`vikl n`u eklugpwglegu/ vngy `rg wloihgoy vk uwuv`il vngir siuivu vkvng sirvw`o twboie upw`rg/ lk m`vvgr nkq qgoo-fguialgf iv iu,

Vng uoka`l ‟Ak Cr`lhoil” twvu vng e`oo kwv ckr ` mkfgrl-f`y Bglj`mil Cr`lhoil/ qnk qioo fk ckr aksgrlmglv vkf`y qn`v Cr`lhoilfif il niu vimg by uv`rvila oke`o cirg bria`fgu lf oibr`rigu, Aksgrlmglvu‟ak Cr`lhoil” qngl vngy wug IEV im`ail`visgoy vk: 0) ekmmwlie`vgqivn eivizglu8 2) gmtkqgr eivizglu vk `ffrguu twboie trkbogmu8 `lf 5)mggv vng lggfu kc vng ekmmwlivy, Vng ckookqila `rg uwaaguviklu ckrnkq aksgrlmglv e`l wug ivu rgukwregu lf wvnkrivy vk uwttkrv illks`-viklu il fiaiv`o eivizglunit,03

Rgekmmglf`vikl 2@: Vng Ukei`o Eklvr`ev Mggvu vng Ukei`o Lgvqkrh 

Il @br`n`m Oilekol’u 0>30 il`wawr`o `ffrguu/ ng bguggengf ` un`v-

vgrgf l`vikl kl vng brilh kc Eisio Q`r vk ogv ‟vng bgvvgr `lagou kc kwrl`vwrg” trgs`io/ vk ekmg vkagvngr `lf trgugrsg vng wlikl, @mgrie`luvkf`y c`eg lk uwen firg eriuiu `lf ygv fiuglen`lvmglv qivn aksgrlmglvfkgu jwuvicy ` rglgq`o kc vng ukei`o eklvr`ev, IEV unkwof ngot eklsglgvng tgktog il ` ekluvivwvikl`o ‟rg-ckwlfila” by `uhila ekrg pwguviklu`bkwv qn`v iv mg`lu ckr ‟Qg/ vng tgktog/ vk ckrm ` mkrg tgrcgev wlikl”:

• Unkwofaksgrlmglvfkvnilautgktoge`llkvfkklvngirkql.g,a,/ bwiof `lf m`ilv`il rk`fu/ brifagu/ m`uu vr`luiv uyuvgmu/

ugqgru);

• Unkwof aksgrlmglv erg`vg twboie akkfu .g,a,/ t`rhu/ twboieuqimmila tkkou/ twboie uenkkou);

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 34/61

Vng Rgtkrv 20

• Unkwofaksgrlmglverg`vg`u`cg`lfvrwuvgfglsirklmglvckr

`oo .g,a,/ tkoieg/ cirg cianvgru/ glsirklmglv`o trkvgevikl);

• Unkwof aksgrlmglv erg`vg ` u`cgvy lgv .g,a,/ Ukei`o Ugewrivy/wlgmtokymglv ekmtglu`vikl/ Mgfie`rg/ Mgfie`if);

@oo aksgrlmglv `agleigu il vng Wlivgf Uv`vgu ekwof `eekmtoiun vniuby wuila mwovitog to`vckrmu vk uwrsgy eivizglu il vngir jwriufieviklu`bkwv vng twrtkugu kc aksgrlmglv, Vng uwrsgy unkwof bg vng uv`rv kc `lklakila fi`okawg `bkwv qn`v ` ukei`o eklvr`ev unkwof trksifg,

Rgekmmglf`vikl 2B: Erg`vg ` F`unbk`rf vn`v Siuw`oizgu ‟Nkq Aksgrlmglv iu Fkila” `lf ‟Nkq Eivizglu `rg Fkila” 

Iv iu imtkrv`lv vk fguial `ly ukei`o-eklvr`ev uwrsgy uk vn`v iv fkgulkv uggm oihg jwuv ` vkhgl aguvwrg, Vk m`hg vng uwrsgy uwttkrvisg kc aglwilg vqk-q`y eklsgru`vikl/ Wun`nifi’u Rkvien uwaaguvgf `l `eekm-t`lyila siuw`o fiuto`y vn`v mg`uwrgu nkq aksgrlmglv iu `evw`ooy fkilail rgutklug vk cggfb`eh crkm vng ukei`o-eklvr`ev uwrsgy, Il `ly uwen

fiuto`y kr mgvgr/ eivizglu unkwof `ouk r`vg vngir kql tgrckrm`legu .`rgvngy `evisgoy gla`agf eivizglu;), @l gla`agmglv okkt bgvqggl eivizglu`lf aksgrlmglv qkrhu ` oivvog oihg vnkug co`unila utggfkmgvgr uialu il` uenkko zklg: qngl frisgru `rg m`fg `q`rg kc vngir utggf/ vngy kcvgl`fjwuv `eekrfilaoy, Vng aksgrlmglv aisgu ilckrm`vikl vk vng eivizgl/vng eivizgl `ovgru ngr `eviklu/ ekmmwlivigu `rg u`cgr `lf vng cggfb`ehokkt trksgu gccgevisg, Gsgryklg qilu, @lkvngr `l`okay mianv bg vng‟Triwu Gccgev/” il qnien Vkykv` Triwu frisgru n`sg ` utgei`o f`unbk`rf

cg`vwrg vn`v ogvu vngm hlkq nkq mwen a`u vngy `rg bwrlila vnrkwan kreklugrsila v ly aisgl mkmglv8 frisgru uk trkmtvgf kcvgl vqg`h vngirfrisila n`bivu il `l gcckrv vk eklugrsg mkrg cwgo, Guuglvi`ooy iv iu `bkwvilekrtkr`vila cggfb`eh okktu ilvk vng gla`agmglv bgvqggl eivizgl `lfaksgrlmglv, Vniu iu `l iluv`leg qngrg vgenlkokay e`l bg ` bia ngot,

Vng pwguvikl iu qngvngr l illks`vkr e`l fguial uimio`r siuw`o mkl-ivkr vn`v fiuto`yu nkq qgoo aksgrlmglv iu fkila, Vng kbsikwu kbuv`eogvk fguialila uwen ` mklivkr iu vn`v r`vilau kc aksgrlmglv tgrckrm`leg

`rg bkwlf vk bg c`r mkrg uwbjgevisg vn`l `rg r`vilau kc ` e`r’u cwgo tgr-ckrm`leg, Vng mg`uwrgmglv s`ri`bogu `rg mkrg lwmgrkwu `lf c`r mkrgekmtog~, Uvioo/ vngrg iu ukmgvnila ilutirila `bkwv `l kcciegnkofgr bkofoy ‟akila Cr`lhoil” `lf ilsivila kloilg eivizglu vk r`vg niu kr ngr tgrckr-

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 35/61

22 Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

m`leg, Oke`o eivizglu ekwof gsgl erg`vg vng fiuto`y uyuvgm vngmugosgu‖

mwen u uvwfglvu n`sg erg`vgf kloilg gs`ow`vikl uyuvgmu ckr vngir trkcgu-ukru, Ic vng mgrg fiuto`y kc a`u ekluwmtvikl e`wugu Vkykv` Triwu frisgruvk rgckrm vngir q`yu/ ` qgoo-fguialgf ‟nkq qgoo iu aksgrlmglv fkila;+

nkq qgoo `rg eivizglu fkila;” ar`tnie ekwof trkmtv `l`okakwu rgckrm`mkla bkvn vnkug tiokvila vng unit kc uv`vg `lf vnkug klbk`rf,

Rgekmmglf`vikl 2E: Rgerwiv Ekmmwlivigu Qiooila vk Ak Cr`lhoil

@eekrfila vk @mgrie`l Twboie Mgfi`’u @os`r`fk/ vng vgenlkokay 

vk uwttkrv aksgrlmglvu qiunila vk ‟ak Cr`lhoil” iu `org`fy kl vngungoc‖kr ekwof bg fguialgf qivnil ui~ mklvnu, Qn`v iu lggfgf iu `

um`oo lwmbgr kc oke`o aksgrlmglvu kr kra`liz`viklu qnk `rg g~eivgf`bkwv gmtkqgrila eivizglu lf qiooila vk rkoo kwv vng vgenlkokay, Ukmg

tkuuibog t`rvlgru ckr akila Cr`lhoil rg: 0) ilvgrguvgf m`ykru eklsglgfil eklegrv qivn vgenlkokay fguialgru8 2) Vng Og`awg kc Qkmgl Skvgru8

5) vng L`vikl`o Eklcgrgleg kc Eivigu8 6) twboie wlisgruivigu fguialilafgmker`ey-il-`evikl eo`uugu8 7) twboie oibr`rigu8 `lf 3) twboie brk`f-

e`uvila uv`viklu ilvgrguvgf il erg`vila ` vgogsiuikl unkq `rkwlf fgmke-r`ey il `evikl,

@ trkmiuila g~`mtog kc cilfila t`rvlgru qiooila vk ak Cr`lhoil q`u

kccgrgf il 2404 by Enie`ak @ofgrm`l Jkugtn Mkkrg, G`en eivy `ofgr-m`l vn`v yg`r q`u aisgl ` fiuergvikl`ry cwlf kc &0 miooikl vk utglf il

uwttkrv kc trkjgevu vn`v qkwof bg vk vng bglgciv kc rguifglvu il niu kr ngrq`rf, R`vngr vn`l m`hila vng fgeiuikl `oklg/ Mkkrg gmtkqgrgf vng

rguifglvu kc Q`rf 69 vk skvg kl vng bguv wugu ckr vng mklgy, Ng vwrlgf

vk g~iuvila to`vckrmu ckr kloilg t`rvieit`vkry bwfagvila g~greiugu vn`vn`f bggl fgsgoktgf il Br`zio `lf gougqngrg, Ng tgrmivvgf kloilg fiu-ewuuikl `lf skvila by `ly q`rf rguifglv ksgr 03/ rga`rfoguu kc eivizgl-

unit kr rgaiuvr`vikl uv`vwu, Mkrg vn`l 0/344 rguifglvu t`rvieit`vgf `lfvng qillila trkjgevu ileowfgf uifgq`ohu/ bihg o`lgu/ bihg r`ehu/ ekm-

mwlivy a`rfglu lf q`oo mwr`ou, Mkkrg qrkvg vn`v vng trkeguu lkv kloy rguwovgf il trkjgev rgekmmglf`viklu8 iv `ouk ngotgf vk bwiof ` uglug kc 

ekmmwlivy ilskosgmglv il vng q`rf vn`v qkwof rgm`il gsgl `cvgr vng

t`rviewo`r g~greiug q`u ksgr,01

Klg rgeglv g~`mtog kc aksgrlmglv akila Cr`lhoil/ fgueribgf by 

R`engo Uvgrlg/ Enigc Fiaiv`o Kcciegr ckr vng eivy kc Lgq Ykrh/ q`u vngrgeglv ‟N`eh`vnkl,” Vng ak`o q`u vk rgfguial vng eivy’u qgbuivg vk m`hg

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 36/61

Vng Rgtkrv 25

iv mkrg eivizgl-criglfoy, Lgq Ykrh Eivy ngof `l ktgl fguial eklvguv

qivn kluivg t`rvieit`lvu uwaaguvila illks`viklu, Vng Jwfag’u Trizg q`u`q`rfgf vk E`uukl Rkuglbo`vv/ M`vvngq Nkqgoo `lf Vkm Aibbklu ckrvngir ifg`: MyLYE,aks, Vng uivg brilau ‟a`mgicie`vikl” vk bgila akkfeivizgl/ `q`rfila tkilvu vk rguifglvu qnk rgtkrv trkbogmu/ uwen `u tkv-nkogu `lf fkqlgf vrggu, Eivizglu e`l vngl wug vnkug tkilvu vk ekmtgovng eivy vk m`hg um`oo ar`lvu vkq`rf ` oke`o e`wug,

Rgekmmglf`vikl 2F: Uvwfy Uweeguucwo G~`mtogu kc Akila Cr`lhoil

Aksgrlmglv e`l ak Cr`lhoil il q`yu vn`v ficcgr lkv kloy il vngirvgenlkokaie`o mg`lu bwv `ouk il vngir tkoivie`o glfu, Ckr g~`mtog/ vqkkc vng mkuv uweeguucwo g~`mtogu kc akila Cr`lhoil vk f`vg/ fgueribgfbgokq/ n`f sgry ficcgrglv tkoivie`o ifg`ou bgnilf vngir fguial,

Vng ciruv iu vng g~`mtog kc vng t`rvieit`vkry bwfagvila rkoogf kwvil Bgok Nkrizklvg/ Br`zio/ `lf by @ofgrm`l Mkkrg il Enie`ak’u 69vnQ`rf, Qivn t`rvieit`vkry bwfagvila/ IEV gmtkqgrgf eivizglu vk byt`uuvng vr`fivikl`o bwfagvila trkeguu il c`skr kc `ooke`vila mkligu vngm-

ugosgu, Vniu iu qn`v N`rs`rf’u Cwla fgueribgf `u vng ‟ngrg ekmgu gsgry-bkfy” mkfgo kc tkoivieu: wuila vng t`vnq`yu kc IEV vk tgrmiv eivizglu/il vng gpwis`oglv kc kloilg rgcgrglf`, Il kvngr qkrfu/ eivizglu fk lkv

 jwuv skvg ckr rgtrguglv`visgu qnk qioo vngl skvg kl bwfagvu/ bwv vngy byt`uu vng iluvivwviklu kc rgtrguglv`visg fgmker`ey `ovkagvngr `lf skvgkl vng bwfagvu firgevoy,

IEVEivizglu

Tkoiviei`lu # 

Twboie @agleiguO`qu # 

Tkoieigu

Vr`fivikl`o

Kra`liz`viklu

Twboie @evikl

 

~  

Ngrg Ekmgu Gsgrybkfy, @lkvngr q`y vn`v vgenlkokay e`l `ovgr tkoivieu iu by `ookqila eivizgluvk byt`uu `oo ilvgrmgfi`rigu uv`lfila bgvqggl vngm `lf ` fguirgf `evikl,

‖@renkl Cwla/ ‟Ngrg Ekmgu Gsgrybkfy” ` trguglv`vikl vk vng 2400 @utgl Iluvivwvg Ckrwm klEkmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy .@wawuv 2/ 2400/ @utgl/ Ekokr`fk),

Ngrg Ekmgu Gsgrybkfy

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 37/61

26 Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

@ ugeklf/ `lf eklegtvw`ooy ficcgrglv q`y ckr aksgrlmglv vk ak

Cr`lhoil qkwof bg vk ilsivg eivizglu vk t`rvieit`vg c`r mkrg `evisgoy il`lf vnrkwan vng guv`boiungf en`llgou kc rgtrguglv`visg fgmker`ey, @lilvriawila g~`mtog kc vniu `ttrk`en ekmgu crkm O`vsi`/ `u fgueribgf by 

@lfrgq MeO`wanoil, O`vsi`’u aksgrlmglv n`u gmbr`egf `l kloilg tgvi-viklu trkeguu fgsgoktgf by vng qgbuivg M`l` B`ouu .nvvt:++m`l`b`ouu,os),

Eivizglu `rg ilsivgf vk tkuv trktku`ou ckr t`roi`mglv`ry `evikl, Ilivi`ooy/kloy vng trktkuila eivizgl hlkqu vng WRO kc ngr trktku`o8 ngr miu-

uikl iu vk wug gm`io/ ngr boka/ Vqivvgr kr `ly kvngr mg`lu vk ilutirgngr cgookq O`vsi`lu vk siuiv vn`v t`ag `lf e`uv ` ‟skvg” il uwttkrv kc vng

trktku`o, Kleg vng trktku`o a`rlgru 0/444 uwttkrvgru/ vng t`ag mksguvk vng twboie tkrvikl kc vng M`l` B`ouu uivg/ qngrg `ly O`vsi`l e`l

rgsigq lf fgb`vg vng trktku`o/ uwaaguv imtrksgmglvu kr rgsiuiklu lftwboieoy uial`o uwttkrv, Ic ` trktku`o `vvr`evu 04/444 uwttkrvgru/ vngl

vng trktkuila eivizgl iu ilsivgf vk vng cokkr kc vng l`vikl`o ogaiuo`vwrgvk trguglv vng trktku`o ckr ekluifgr`vikl by vng gogevgf rgtrguglv`visgu,

Imtkrv`lvoy/ vng ogaiuo`vwrg iu wlfgr lk kboia`vikl vk aisg vngug

trktku`ou cwrvngr ng`rilau kr ` skvg/ bwv iv iu lkv`bog vn`v `v og`uv vqktrktku`ou n`sg/ il vng t`uv yg`r/ aklg crkm M`l` B`ouu vk vng cokkr kc 

vng t`roi`mglv vk cil`o `ttrks`o `u o`q, Vng O`vsi`l aksgrlmglv qglvCr`lhoil by ilsivila eivizgl t`rvieit`vikl il `lf vnrkwan guv`boiungf

en`llgou kc rgtrguglv`visg fgmker`ey‖r`vngr vn`l `rkwlf vngm,

@ly aksgrlmglvu qiunila vk ak Cr`lhoil mwuv g~to`il vk vgenlie`o`fsiukru g~`evoy qnien kc vng `bksg vqk mkfgou .kr kvngr mkfgou) ckr

eivizglunit t`rvieit`vikl vngy `rg ugghila vk ckookq,

R gekmmglf`vikl 5, AkM`fiukl 

Aksgrlmglv lggfu vk ‟ak M`fiukl” `u qgoo `u Cr`lhoil, Vng

M`fiukli`l bowgtrilv ckr akkf aksgrlmglv e`oou ckr trwfglv tkoivieu/crgg kc fgbioiv`vila ilvgrguvu `lf ifgkokaigu, @GI’u Krluvgil twv ckrq`rf

` eklergvg q`y vk ak M`fiukl: eklsglg `lf vgogsiug ` fgb`vg `mkla `bit`rviu`l arkwt kc  ckrmgr mgmbgru kc vng W,U, Nkwug kc Rgtrguglv`visgu

`lf Ugl`vg, Wlglewmbgrgf by vng immgfi`vg `lf tko`rizila fgm`lfu

kc mklgy `lf e`mt`ialu kr by vng o`ragr fisiuisg ewovwrg iluifgEklarguu/ ckrmgr eklarguuikl`o og`fgru ekwof fgb`vg eklvrksgrui`o iuuwgu

kl vng mgrivu, @ rgutgevgf lgqu trkar`m oihg ‟TBU LgquNkwr” ekwofngot fguial `lf `ir vng trkeggfilau/ qivn oke`o twboie brk`fe`uvila uv`-

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 38/61

Vng Rgtkrv 27 

viklu trkfweila ckookq-wtu kr nkuvila ekmt`likl unkqu qivn ckrmgr

m`ykru kr uv`vg rgtrguglv`visgu, Akila M`fiukl qkwof ileowfg IEV by fgoisgrila b`eharkwlf ilckrm`vikl vk eivizglu `bkwv vng tkoieigu vng ckr-mgr o`qm`hgru `rg fgb`vila `lf tgrmivvila eivizglu vk fgb`vg vng iuuwguqivn klg `lkvngr kloilg `lf vk t`rvieit`vg il vqk-q`y g~en`lagu qivnvng ckrmgr kcciei`ou‖ckr g~`mtog/ by wuila ukei`o mgfi` vk uwbmiv pwgu-viklu, Cwlfila ukwregu mwuv bg ckwlf vk ngot uwttkrv uwen `l glfg`skr/aisgl vng trguglv cil`lei`o trguuwrg kl twboie brk`fe`uvila,

Akila M`fiukl iu cog~ibog, Vng eklsglgf arkwt ekwof ileowfgrgtrguglv`vikl crkm eivizgl arkwtu/ `u qgoo `u ckrmgr mgmbgru kc aksgrlmglv crkm lkl-ogaiuo`visg br`lengu, Vngrg ekwof bg eivizgl

 jwrigu/ enkugl oihg `evw`o jwrigu vk bg rgtrguglv`visg kc vng ekmmwlivy/bgckrg qnkm vng e`ug ckr `lf `a`iluv ` aisgl trktku`o qioo bg vrigf,T`rvieit`lvu cwrvngr uwaaguvgf ` eklsglila kc ` bit`rviu`l arkwt kc ckrmgr m`ykru kr aksgrlkru vk ng`r nkq vngy qkwof v`ehog vng l`vikl`ogeklkmie eriuiu, Nkqgsgr uvrwevwrgf/ vng twrtkug kc vng g~greiug qkwofbg vk erg`vg ` to`vckrm ckr tkoivieu `u ekluifgrgf fgoibgr`vikl/ r`vngrvn`l ukwlf bivgu/ t`lfgrila kr sglkm,

Vng ak M`fiukl mkmglv keewru qngl eivizglu lf tkoiviei`lu gue`tgcrkm l`rrkq `lf tko`rizila genk en`mbgru `lf ng`r vng eo`rikl skiegukc ekmtrkmiug `lf ek`oivikl-bwiofila, Vk brila kwv vng M`fiukl ileivizglu/ N`rs`rf’u Cwla uwaaguvgf fguialila ` utgei`o qifagv vk uial`o` tkvglvi`ooy wlng`ovny ekluwmtvikl kc lgqu `lf ilckrm`vikl crkm `lksgroy l`rrkq uoieg kc vng tkoivie`o utgevrwm, Vng qifagv ekwof aokq bowgkr rgf/ ckr g~`mtog/ fgtglfila kl vng wugr’u lgqu ekluwmtvikl .i,g,/Fgmker`v kr Rgtwboie`l), @ uimio`r vgenlkokay iu `org`fy il fgsgokt-

mglv, ‟Vrwvn Akaaogu” rg vng erg`vikl kc MIV ar`fw`vg uvwfglv F`ligoUenwovz, Iv iu ` bkkhm`rhogv .` trkar`m vn`v u`sgu qgbuivg oilhu) vn`vekokr-ekficigu qrivvgl eklvglv kl vng qgb b`ugf kl ivu ogsgo kc vrwvn,Uk/ qngl vng akaaogu nianoianv vg~v qivn vng ekokr rgf/ vn`v ilfie`vgu `lglvirgoy c`oug uv`vgmglv8 qivn ygookq/ ` ukmgqn`v c`oug uv`vgmglv8 qivnbowg/ ukmgqn`v vrwg uv`vgmglv8 lf qivn arggl/ c`ev, Uenwovz uvrguuguvng ileitiglv l`vwrg kc Vrwvn Akaaogu/ bwv ivu tkvglvi`o iu kbsikwu, Qivncwrvngr uktniuvie`vikl kc vng ukcvq`rg/ vng akaaogu ekwof awifg lgqu

ekluwmgru kwv kc tko`rizila genk en`mbgru `lf vkq`rf ergfibog lgquukwregu, Qivn qifg glkwan `eegtv`leg/ uwen vgenlkokay ekwof gsglilutirg qrivgru vk `skif fiuvkrvila vng vrwvn il vng ciruv to`eg‖og`filavk ` rgl`iuu`leg kc `eewr`ey `lf vrwuv kl vng qgb,

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 39/61

23 Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

R gekmmglf`vikl 6,AkVrwvncwo`lfVnkrkwan 

Vng ckookqila `rg ` ugrigu kc fgsiegu fguialgf vk bwvvrguu kr rgto`egvng mgfi`’u niuvkrie a`vg-hggtila cwleviklu il trguglvila wlbi`ugf `lf`eewr`vg ilckrm`vikl vk eivizglu crkm ` s`rigvy kc ukwregu `lf ekmtgv-ila sigqu,

Rgekmmglf vikl 6@: Fguial ` Coitbk`rf vk Ngot Eivizglu L`sia`vg vnrkwan vng Cokkf kc Ilckrm`vikl

Lgqu kra`liz`viklu unkwof kccgr ekluwmgru ` oianv/ wugr-criglfoy 

coitbk`rf vn`v `aarga`vgu ilckrm`vikl by uwbjgev, Wugru ekwof coitvnrkwan vng lgqu il q`yu vn`v aw`r`lvggf vngy qkwof ekmg `erkuu`rvieogu kr ukwregu crkm mwovitog tkilvu kc sigq, Vng coitbk`rf ekwofileowfg ‟trk” `lf ‟ekl” bwvvklu: twunila vng ‟ekl” bwvvkl/ ckriluv`leg/ qkwof v`hg vng sigqgr vk `l `rvieog g~trguuila `l kttkuilatkilv kc sigq vk vn`v kc vng `eekwlv `org`fy rg`f, Vngrg ekwof bg `‟tkilv-kc-sigq” uoifgr vn`v `ookqu eivizglu vk oivgr`ooy fi`o ogcv/ rianv `lfeglvgr ckr ekmtgvila tkilvu kc sigq, Er`ia Fwbkq/ qnk `v vng vimg kc 

CKE@U q`u vng En`irm`l lf EGK kc A`llgvv Ek,/ g~trguugf vng nktgvn`v ` tkilv-kc-sigq uoifgr qkwof fgvgr bi`u il mgfi` eklvglv trkfwe-vikl,

Rgekmmglf`vikl 6B: Fguial ` ‟Qn`v iv Mg`lu vk Mg” Qifagv kr Ar`tnie vk Unkq Sigqgru Qny Lgqu M`vvgru 

Mien`go M`lguu kc vng Hlianv Ckwlf`vikl tkilvgf kwv vn`v vngrg iulkvnila oihg `l `ttrk`enila l`vwr`o fiu`uvgr vk ckewu ` tgrukl’u `vvgl-

vikl kl vng lgqu, Tgrn`tu fr`qila ` rg`fgr’u `vvglvikl vk vng oke`o krtgrukl`o gccgevu `lf imt`evu kc kvngr lgq cg`vwrgu qkwof ut`rh ilvgrguv`omkuv `u qgoo `u ` vkrl`fk q`rlila, Ckr iluv`leg/ `rvieogu kl vng Argghfgbv eriuiu ekwof bg `eekmt`ligf by ` ‟qn`v-iv-mg`lu-vk-mg” uifgb`rvn`v unkqu nkq W,U, nkmg mkrva`ag r`vgu kr ilsguvmglvu il aokb`obklf cwlfu mianv bg `ccgevgf by gsglvu `erkuu vng keg`l il Arggeg, Vnglkvikl iu lkv vn`v eivizglu unkwof l`rrkqoy lf ugogevisgoy ckewu kloy kllgqu vn`v `ccgevu vngm tgrukl`ooy8 bwv ` ‟qn`v-iv-mg`lu-vk-mg” qifagv

ekwof `mtoicy l`vwr`o ileglvisgu kc ugoc-ilvgrguv vk g~t`lf rg`fgru’`ttgvivgu ckr vng imtkrv`leg kc lgqu `rkwlf vng qkrof, @,T,’u Mien`goKrguhgu uwaaguvgf vn`v Vng @uukei`vgf Trguu mianv bg sgry ilvgrguvgf ilt`rvlgrila qivn kvngru kl ` ‟qn`v-iv-mg`lu-vk-mg” qifagv,

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 40/61

Vng Rgtkrv 21 

Rgekmmglf`vikl 6E: Rguvkrg vng Mgfi`’u Vr`fivikl`o C`ev-Engehila 

Rkog by Erg`vila Brkqugr Towa-Ilu vn`v Engeh ckr C`evw`o @eewr`ey Vng tgrtgvw`vikl kc c`evw`ooy il`eewr`vg ilckrm`vikl iu ` m`vvgr ckrfggt eisie eklegrl, Vk uwttkrv vng mgfi`’u vr`fivikl`o c`ev-engehilarkog/ Ilvgrlgv brkqugr-b`ugf `ttoie`viklu unkwof bg fguialgf vk nian-oianv ergfibog kr vrwuvqkrvny uivgu lf ukwregu kc ilckrm`vikl, Ekwlvoguu`ttoie`viklu n`sg `org`fy bggl fguialgf `lf bwiov ilvk Ilvgrlgv brkqu-gru‖oihg U`c`ri/ Mkzioo` Cirgck~ `lf Ilvgrlgv G~tokrgr‖vn`v tgrckrm

v`uhu uwen `u co`aaila qgbuivgu vn`v tkug ugewrivy riuhu vk vng wugr,Brkqugr-b`ugf `ttoie`viklu oihg vniu ekwof tgrckrm vng v`uh kc mg`uwr-ila vng `eewr`ey kc ` uivg’u ilckrm`vikl `u qgoo, @ c`ev-engehila qifagvekwof trksifg brkqugru qivn ` tkrv`o vnrkwan qnien `rvieogu mwuv t`uuil krfgr vk rgegisg c`evw`ooy vrwuvqkrvny lf wlbi`ugf r`vila, Vng CkrfCkwlf`vikl’u Vkkmgy lkvgf vn`v Tkoivic`ev,ekm’u ‟Vrwvn-K-Mgvgr” iueokug vk tgrckrmila `u ` c`ev-engehila tkrv`o `org`fy, @ uimio`r eklegtv

ekwof bg uoifgr kr mgvgr vn`v akgu crkm rgf vk ygookq vk arggl vk uial`ovng ergfibioivy kc ` uivg kr t`rviewo`r boka kr tkuv, Lgqm`rh kc er`iauoiuvvnkwanv vng vgenlkokay ekwof ak cwrvngr `lf fiuto`y vng `eewr`ey-engeh il rg`o vimg‖oihg qngl `l ilvgrsigqgg/ twlfiv kr nkuv kl e`bogvgogsiuikl q`u qrkla kl vng c`evu, Uwen ` rgekmmglf`vikl lggfu vk bgcilg-vwlgf `lf fgsgoktgf vk cwlevikl imt`rvi`ooy uk vn`v iv e`llkv bg

m`litwo`vgf vk ciovgr il kr kwv egrv`il tkilvu kc sigq, Bwv/ `u Vkkmgy tkilvgf kwv/ vn`v f`lagr iu `org`fy vng uv`vwu pwk,

R gekmmglf`vikl 7,AkGlvgrv`ilila:EkllgevUkei`oLgvqkrhila

vkBrk`fe`uvila Lgqu kra`liz`viklu unkwof fguial eklvglv trkfwevikl qivn glvgr-

v`ilila nkkhu, @u GMMIU’u Umwoy`l twv iv/ qg lggf vk unkq eivizgluvn`v ilckrmila vngmugosgu tkoivie`ooy e`l bg cwl,

Vk `eekmtoiun vniu/ erg`visg t`rvlgrunitu ekwof bg ckrmgf qivn uim-wo`vikl-a`mg erg`vkru/ brk`fe`uv kwvogvu `lf ukei`o-lgvqkrhila uivgu vk

fgsiug ` mwovi-to`vckrm vgogsiugf eisie-t`rvieit`vikl gsglv, .@mgrie`lTwboie Mgfi`’u @os`r`fk q`ul’v hiffila qngl ng u`if qg `rg `cvgr

‟G~vrgmg M`hgksgr: Vng Fgmker`ey Gfivikl,”)Lg`o Un`tirk/ Trguifglv `lf EGK kc QLGV/ uhgvengf kwv ` tkoivi-

e`o eklvguv/ qnien mianv ilvgrguv ` twboie-brk`fe`uvila kwvogv/ e`oogf‟YkwSioog”: ` bwfagvila a`mg il qnien eivizglu m`lgwsgr vk a`il

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 41/61

2> Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

uwttkrv ckr vngir trktkugf ukowviklu vk vngir eivy’u bwfagv`ry eriuiu/

rgtogvg qivn ` trguglv`vikl kc c`evw`o ilckrm`vikl/ ilvgrsigqu qivng~tgrvu `lf oke`o kcciei`ou `lf `wfigleg t`rvieit`vikl‖`oo ewomil`vilail `l ‟@mgrie`l Ifko”-oihg kloilg skvila trkeguu vk enkkug ` qillgr,0> Ckookqila wt kl vniu/ Umwoy`l im`ailgf vng nkkh: ‟Ekmg wt qivnvng rianv ukowvikl vk vng bwfagv eriuiu `lf qil &04 miooikl!” Bwv vngtrkbogm il fguialila ` c`ir tkoivie`o a`mg/ Un`tirk lkvgf/ iu vn`v t`r-viu`lunit oggengu ilvk uk m`ly erg`visg iuuwgu/ uv`rvila qivn qn`v f`v`t`rvieit`lvu lggf vk n`sg ic vngy `rg vk to`y vng bwfagvila a`mg qgoo,

Ugsgr`o t`rvieit`lvu g~trguugf ilvgrguv il twruwila vng glvgrv`il-mglv-unkq eklegtv bwv lkvgf vn`v vng arkwt o`ehgf `l g~tgriglegfa`mg fguialgr `lf qkwof n`sg vk uggh cwrvngr `fsieg bgckrg cwooy cogun-ila kwv vng eklegtv, Klg tkuuibog to`eg vk ak iu MIV’u Eglvgr ckr EisieMgfi`/ qnien n`u fgsgoktgf `l `wamglvgf rg`oivy a`mg kl vng iuuwg kc eoim`vg en`lag il ` uimwo`vgf tiskv`o gogevikl,09

Ukei`o a`mgu n`sg gmgragf `u ` m`jkr tnglkmglkl, EivySioog/C`egbkkh’u og`fila ukei`o a`mg/ n`f mkrg vn`l 17 miooikl wugru ilUgtvgmbgr 2400,24 Vng c`uvguv-arkqila a`mg/ vng Uimu Ukei`o/ n`fmkrg vn`l 33 miooikl wugru vn`v u`mg mklvn,20 Eog`roy/ vngrg iu `lkttkrvwlivy vk glvgr vng g~tokfila ukei`o-a`mg m`rhgv `lf erg`vg `a`mg ckr sirvw`o eivizglu,

R gekmmglf`vikl 3, AkAokb`o:BrifagEwovwr`o`lfUt`vi`oBkwlf`rigu 

Vng ciruv rgekmmglf`vikl q`u vk ‟ak oke`o,” Vng o`uv rgekmmglf`-

vikl iu vk ‟ak aokb`o” `u qgoo,CKE@U fgskvgf klg togl`ry uguuikl utgeicie`ooy vk aokb`o tkoivieu,

Ugsgr`o eklcgrgleg mgmbgru brkwanv ` s`uv g~tgrigleg qivn aokb`o`cc`iru vk vng v`bog/ ileowfila ckrmgr Ugergv`ry kc Uv`vg M`fgogilg@obrianv/ Wun`nifi’u Jwoi`l` Rkvien/ ilcowglvi`o Gaytvi`l jkwrl`oiuv `lfbokaagr Q`go @bb`u/ Uglikr @fsiukr vk vng Wlivgf L`viklu @ooi`legkc Eisioiz`viklu .WL@KE) Jg`l-Enriuvktng B`u/ vng Rglfkl Arkwt’uJknl Rglfkl/ vng Tgrukl`o Fgmker`ey Ckrwm’u @lfrgq R`uigj `lf @o

Akrg/ il ` awguv `ttg`r`leg,Wlvio vng o`uv n`oc kc vng o`uv eglvwry/ eivizglu mkuvoy o`ehgf vng `bioivy 

vk og`rl `bkwv l`vwr`o `lf tkoivie`o fiu`uvgru n`ttglila il fiuv`lv to`eguil rg`o vimg .`lf qngl vngy fif/ iv q`u kcvgl vnrkwan lgqu `lf qirg ugr-siegu/ lkv vnrkwan vng ewrrglv `rmy kc eivizgl jkwrl`oiuvu kloilg `lf kl

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 42/61

Vng Rgtkrv 29 

ukei`o-lgvqkrhila uivgu aisila gyg-qivlguu vguvimkly vk niuvkry)/ mwen

oguu vng e`t`eivy vk aisg immgfi`vg rgutklug `lf `if, IEV n`u g~tokfgfvimg/ ut`eg `lf fiuv`leg b`rrigru vk aokb`o ekmmwlie`viklu, Vng eireog`lf eklegrlu kc eivizglunit qioo‖`lf kwanv vk‖g~t`lf vk `ev klvng aokb`o hlkqogfag qg lkq n`sg kc gsgryvnila crkm g`rvnpw`hgu vkc`milg/ crkm rgtrguuikl vk rgbgooikl, @lf ygv/ `u Ut`rhgf,ekm’u Riaby rgm`rhgf/ vngrg iu ` t`r`fk~: rg-‟vrib`oiz`vikl” iu trkeggfila `t`eg qivnvng arkqvn kc vng aokb`o sioo`ag,

Rgekmmglf`vikl 3@: Glekwr`ag Ekoo`bkr`vikl lkv Eklcrklv`viklbgvqggl Eisio Ukeigvy `lf Ilvgrl`vikl`o Kra`liz`viklu 

Eisio ukeigvy’u rgutklug vk geklkmie `lf cil`lei`o aokb`oiz`vikln`u wlfgraklg uialicie`lv en`lagu uileg vng 0994u/ qngl mksgmglvu`fktvgf qn`v vng WL@KE’u B`u fgueribgf `u `l ‟`lvi” kr eklcrkl-v`vikl`o uv`leg, Vngrg n`sg bggl vng QkrofVr`fg Kra`liz`vikl trkvguvu il Ug`vvog il0999/ fgmkluvr`viklu `v vng Qkrof B`lh

`lf Ilvgrl`vikl`o Mklgv`ry Cwlf `llw`omggvilau il Tr`awg il 2444 `lf `vvgmtvu vkfiurwtv vng A> uwmmiv il Aglk` il 2440/`mkla kvngru,

B`u ergfivu ukei`o mgfi` `lf IEV qivntrkmkvila ekoo`bkr`vikl r`vngr vn`l ekl-crklv`vikl bgvqggl eisio ukeigvy `lf aokb`okra`liz`viklu, Vng lgq aokb`o eivizgl n`u

q`yu vk ilcowgleg ilvgrl`vikl`o tkoieym`hgruvn`v trgsikwu aglgr`viklu o`ehgf, Ckr g~`m-tog/ vniu lgq ekoo`bkr`visg uv`leg n`u v`hglun`tg qivn nwm`liv`ri`l `uuiuv`leg `cvgr vngg`rvnpw`hg il N`ivi `lf `cvgr vng Vuwl`mi ilJ`t`l8 vng VGF .Vgenlkokay/ Glvgrv`ilmglv/Fgsgoktmglv) eklcgrgleg’u kbjgevisg kc ‟ifg`u qkrvn utrg`fila” `lf ivu &044/444trizg vk uwttkrv `l g~vr`krfil`ry ilfisifw-`o’u ‟klg qiun vk en`lag vng qkrof”822 `lf vng@s``z,kra qgbuivg vn`v mkbioizgu ckwr vk cisg miooikl tgktog `erkuu vngqkrof kl ilvgrl`vikl`o e`mt`ialu .oihg crggzila fgtkugf Gaytvi`l rwogrNkuli Mwb`r`h’u `uugvu il Uqiuu b`lhu)/ vk l`mg ` cgq,

Ukei`o mgfi` `lf

IEV trkmkvg

ekoo`bkr`viklr`vngr vn`leklcrklv`vikl

bgvqggl eisio

ukeigvy `lf aokb`o

kra`liz`viklu,

Vng lgq aokb`o

eivizgl n`u q`yuvk ilcowglegilvgrl`vikl`o

tkoieym`hgru

vn`v trgsikwu

aglgr`viklu o`ehgf,

 Jg`l-Enriuvktng B`u 

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 43/61

54 Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

Rgekmmglf`vikl 3B: Glekwr`ag Mgfi` vk Eksgr Qkrof Gsglvu `u 

M`r`vnklu r`vngr vn`l `u Ckkvb`oo A`mgu Vng mgfi` qkwof bg ` bgvvgr criglf kc aokb`o eivizglunit ic iv uwu-v`ilgf kwr `vvglvikl vk ilvgrl`vikl`o gsglvu, Ugergv`ry @obrianv tkilvgf

kwv vn`v mkuv lgqu lgvqkrhu eksgrgf gsglvuil Gaytv `u ic vngy qgrg ` ckkvb`oo a`mg/qngl il c`ev vngy `rg mkrg `hil vk ` m`r`-vnkl, Vng lgqu eyeog fgeo`rgf ` qillgr ilGaytv `lf vngl mksgf kl vk vng lg~v uvkry,Oivvog `vvglvikl iu bgila aisgl vk vng ekl-vilwila m`r`vnkl‖vng uvrwaaog vk `enigsgfgmker`vie aksgrlmglvu il Gaytv/ Vwliui``lf kvngr @r`b Utrila l`viklu, Qn`v aokb`oeivizglunit rgpwirgu/ il @obrianv’u jwfamglv/iu ` oklagr `vvglvikl ut`l,

Rgekmmglf`vikl 3E: Fgsgokt @ttu vk Mklivkr Eglukrunit

Vgenlkokay e`l en`lag tkoivieu by erkqf-ukwreila gcckrvu vk mkli-vkr vng tkoivie`o trkeguu, Vng bguv rg`o qkrof g~`mtog kc vniu m`y bgWun`nifi/ ` vgenlkokay kriail`ooy wugf vk mklivkr gogevikl sikogleg ilHgly`,

Rgcogevila kl vngir g~tgriglegu il Hgly` `lf Gaytv rgutgevisgoy/Rkvien `lf @bb`u uvrguugf vng rkog IEV to`ygf qngl vngrg qgrg vkk cgq

 jkwrl`oiuvu kl vng arkwlf vk agv vng lgqu kwv, By uv`lfila q`ven/ aokb`oeivizglu e`l trksifg fiuuglvgru ukmg `mkwlv kc trkvgevikl uimtoy by 

unkqila kr vgooila vng qkrof qn`v iu keewrrila, By ktglila wt en`llgoukc ekmmwlie`vikl `brk`f `lf iluiuvila vn`v mwovil`vikl`o ekrtkr`viklulkv ekktgr`vg qivn `wvnkriv`ri`l rgaimgu’ gcckrvu vk eokug fkql Ilvgrlgv`eeguu qivnil vngir kql bkrfgru/ vng aokb`o eivizgl e`l wug IEV vk hggtbkrfgru ktgl vk vng crgg cokq kc ilckrm`vikl, Klg utgeicie rgekmmglf`-vikl iu vk fgsgokt kr uwttkrv g~iuvila ‟`ttu vk mklivkr eglukrunit”‖tgrn`tu fgsgoktila vngm `u mkbiog `ttu ckr vng aokb`o eivizgl,

Rgekmmglf`vikl 3F: Fgsgokt Trizg Eklvguvu ckr Ilvgrewovwr`o Illks`vikl@u qivn vng rgekmmglf`viklu ckr fkmguvie tkoivieu/ eklvguvu unkwof

bg utklukrgf ckr illks`viklu fguialgf vk ilerg`ug ilvgrl`vikl`owlfgruv`lfila, Unkrvoy ckookqila vng ekleowuikl kc CKE@U 2400/ B`u

Mkuv lgqu lgvqkrhu

eksgrgf gsglvu il

Gaytv `u ic vngy qgrg

` ckkvb`oo a`mg/

 qngl il c`ev vngy `rg mkrg `hil vk `

m`r`vnkl,

M`fgogilg @obrianv 

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 44/61

Vng Rgtkrv 50

ilckrmgf vng wvnkr kc vniu rgtkrv vn`v vng WL@KE n`f t`rvlgrgf qivn

BMQ vk kccgr ` mklgv`ry trizg ckr ilivi`visgu vn`v `fs`leg erkuu-ewo-vwr`o wlfgruv`lfilau, Il `ffivikl vk vng mklgy/ vng qillila illks`-vkru qioo rgegisg iluvivwvikl`o uwttkrv crkm vng WL@KE `lf ivu tris`vg

t`rvlgru vk ngot o`wlen vngir tkoiey trktku`ou,

EkleowuiklFgmker`eigu vnrisg qngl ` siv`o eisio ukeigvy kr twboie utngrg uv`lfu

bgvqggl `vkmizgf ilfisifw`ou `lf vng ekoogevisg tkqgr kc aksgrlmglv,

Eisio ukeigvy vr`fivikl`ooy keewtigf twboie `lf tnyuie`o ut`eg8 tgktog`uugmbogf `v Utg`hgru’ Ekrlgr il Oklfkl’u Nyfg T`rh kr il vkqlmggvilau vnrkwankwv vng Wlivgf Uv`vgu, Eisio ukeigvy vnrisgu il vng

mggvila n`oou kc `oo ukrvu kc skowlv`ry `uukei`viklu/ crkm vng Airo Uekwvukc @mgrie` vk Sgvgr`lu kc Ckrgial Q`ru vk o`bkr wliklu `lf crkm trk-

cguuikl`o kra`liz`viklu uwen `u vng @mgrie`l Mgfie`o @uukei`vikl vklkltrkciv `agleigu uwen `u E`vnkoie En`rivigu kr K~c`m,

Eisio ukeigvy iu ifg`ooy towr`oiuvie/ lkv mklkoivnie/ mksila lkv by 

ckreg kc klg `oo-glekmt`uuila m`jkrivy bwv vnrkwan vng tkqgr unicvilaek`oiviklu `lf ekmtrkmiugu `mkla ekmtgvila `uukei`viklu qkrhila

vk `enigsg vng ekmmkl akkf, Trgjwfieg `lf fiuerimil`vikl uhgq vngqkrhilau kc eisio ukeigvy qngl vngy g~eowfg egrv`il arkwtu, Owehioy/ vng

vr`jgevkry kc @mgrie`l niuvkry n`u bggl vk qkrh vkq`rf `l gsgr mkrgileowuisg `lf ga`oiv`ri`l twboie utngrg, Qnivg Nkwug Fgtwvy Enigc 

Vgenlkokay Kcciegr ckr Ilvgrlgv Tkoiey F`ligo Qgivzlgr v`ohgf `bkwvvng @mgrie`l gvnku kc skowlvggrium8 eisio ukeigvy iu vng twboie utngrg

kc eivizgl skowlvggru,Bwv u M`fiukl ttrgei`vgf gsgl il niu kql f`y/ ekllgeviklu mkla

eivizglu `rg ficciewov vk m`ilv`il il `l g~vglfgf rgtwboie, Vn`v iu qny 

vng Ckwlfgru qgrg uk q`ry kc eglvr`oizgf aksgrlmglv: cgfgr`oium`v og`uv trkmiugf vk fgeglvr`oizg tkqgr `lf vk aisg eivizglu aglwilg

kttkrvwlivigu vk ccgev aksgrlmglvu v oo ogsgou, Bwv vng ekuvu kc t`rviei-t`vikl/ gsgl `v vng oke`o ogsgo/ n`sg `oq`yu bggl nian/ `lf vkf`y vngrg

uggmu vk bg ` unrilhila .kr gsgl fgugrvgf) lwmbgr kc twboie ut`egu

qngrg ilfisifw`ou qivn ekmtgvila sigqu mggv‖gsgl ckr glvgrv`ilmglv`lf rgerg`vikl`o twrtkugu/ mwen oguu ckr tkoivie`o `lf ukei`o fgb`vg, @u@GI’u Krluvgil `rawgf/ brk`fe`uv vgogsiuikl ckr ` vimg a`sg wu `l goge-

vrklie twboie upw`rg il to`eg kc vng kof tnyuie`o klgu: vnrgg lgvqkrhu

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 45/61

52 Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

fgoisgrila b`uie`ooy vng u`mg un`rgf lgqu `lf c`evu vk `oo sigqgru, Vng

`bksg rgekmmglf`viklu vk v`hg fgmker`ey kloilg `rg `imgf `v rguvkr-ila ` ekmmkl b`ug `lf vng n`bivu kc ekoo`bkr`vikl vk kwr wlfgruv`lf-ila kc akkf eivizglunit,

Lklg kc vng rgekmmglf`viklu ngrgil uv`lf kl vgenlkokaie`oukowviklu `oklg, Nkqgsgr `oo kc vng rgekmmglf`viklu rgpwirg ` qgoo-fguialgf to`vckrm ckr eivizgl fgmker`ey‖` to`vckrm vn`v uwttkrvulwmgrkwu fisgrug arkwtu `v vng u`mg vimg/ ` to`vckrm vn`v rgq`rfuifg`u `lf trkmkvgu fgb`vgu vn`v trksg tgruw`uisg `erkuu fgmkar`tniefisifgu, Fiaiv`o eivizglunit mwuv trgugrsg qn`v n`u `oq`yu bggl vngmkr`o miuuikl kc akkf eivizglunit, Vng eivizgl tr`eviegu tkoivieu lkv `u` a`mg qivn qillgru `lf okugru/ bwv `u ugrsieg vk ` ekmmkl akkf vn`vm`hgu kwr oisgu vkagvngr bgvvgr,

Lkvgu

0, @unogy T`rhgr/ ‟Utglfila kl E`mt`ial VS @fu G~tgevgf vk Brg`h Rgekrf/” Vng Lgq Ykrh Vimgu  .Kevkbgr 3/ 2404), @s`io`bog `v: nvvt:++vnge`wewu,bokau,lyvimgu,ekm+2404+04+43+

vgogsiuikl-`f-utglfila-g~tgevgf-vk-brg`h-rgekrf,

2, KtglLgv Ilivi`visg/ ‟Vng Yg r il Rgsigq/” .2404), @s`io`bog `v: nvvt:++ktgllgv,lgv+`bkwv-ciovgrila+2404yg`rilrgsigq+,

5, @u kc @wawuv 23/ 2400/ 37 tgreglv kc `fwov Ilvgrlgv wugru rgtkrvgf wuila ` ukei`o-lgvqkrhilauivg, Ugg M`ry M`ffgl `lf H`vnryl Ziehwnr/ ‟Ukei`o Lgvqkrhila” ` Tgq Rgug`ren Eglvgr’uIlvgrlgv # @mgrie`l Oicg Trkjgev rgtkrv .@wawuv 23/ 2400), @s`io`bog `v: nvvt:++qqq,tgqil-

vgrlgv,kra+Rgtkrvu+2400+Ukei`o-Lgvqkrhila-Uivgu,`ut~, C`egbkkh eo`imu 174 miooikl wugruqkrofqifg/ 74 tgreglv kc qnkm oka il kl `ly t`rviewo`r f`y/ utglfila ` vkv`o kc 144 biooikl

milwvgu tgr mklvn kl vng uivg, Vng `sgr`ag wugr n`u 054 criglfu oiuvgf, Vqivvgr eo`imu 044miooikl mklvnoy `evisg wugru qkrofqifg/ 74 tgreglv kc qnkm oka il gsgry f`y/ aglgr`vila 254miooikl vqggvu ` f`y/ `eekrfila vk Aogll Kviu Brkql/ Firgevkr kc Bwuilguu Fgsgoktmglv `v

Vqivvgr,

6, Vi`ak Tgi~kvk/ ‟g-T rvieit`vkry Bwfagvila: g-Fgmker`ey crkm vngkry vk uweeguu;” g-Fgmke-r`ey Eglvrg .244>), @s`io`bog `v: nvvt:++qqq,gfgmker`eyeglvrg,en+illgr,tnt;ol`mg=Tw

boie`viklu#v`bog=Qkrhila[T`tgru#t`rglv[if=69#oilh[if=33#uwboilhl`mg=g-FE'24Qkrhila'24T`tgru,

7, Vng cgfgr`o aksgrlmglv `oklg m`ilv ilu mkrg vn`l 26/444 qgbuivgu, Il `llkwleila to`lu vkewv vn`v lwmbgr vk 2/444/ Trguifglv B`r`eh Kb`m` pwittgf vn`v vng aksgrlmglv fif lkv lggf` qgbuivg fgskvgf vk ‟ckrguvgru qnk ciffog,” Ugg M`ekl Tniooitu/ ‟VkkM`lyQgbuivgu,aks/” Vng 

Qnivg Nkwug Boka .Jwlg 05/ 2400), @s`io`bog `v: nvvt:++qqq,qnivgnkwug,aks+boka+2400+43+05+vkkm`lyqgbuivguaks,

3, @`rkl Umivn/ ‟Nkmg Brk`fb`lf 2404/” ` Tgq Rgug`ren Eglvgr’u Ilvgrlgv # @mgrie`l OicgTrkjgev rgtkrv .@wawuv 00/ 2404), @s`io`bog `v: nvvt:++tgqilvgrlgv,kra+Rgtkrvu+2404+Nkmg-

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 46/61

Vng Rgtkrv 55

Brk`fb`lf-2404,`ut~, @eekrfila vk ` Tgq vr`ehila uwrsgy/ ‟Nian-ilekmg `lf qgoo-gfwe`vgfilvgrlgv wugru `rg mwen mkrg oihgoy vk wug aksgrlmglv ugrsiegu `lf ilckrm`vikl kloilg,”

Mkrgksgr/ ‟Qnivgu `rg uialicie`lvoy mkrg oihgoy vn`l givngr @crie`l @mgrie`lu kr O`vilku vkt`rvieit`vg il vng kloilg fgb`vg `rkwlf aksgrlmglv iuuwgu kr tkoivieu/” qngrg`u r`ei`o fisgr-aglegu il vng wu`ag kc g-ugrsiegu qgbuivgu `rg c`r mkrg mkfguv, Ckr mkrg/ ugg @`rkl Umivn/‟Aksgrlmglv Kloilg/” ` Tgq Rgug`ren Eglvgr’u Ilvgrlgv # @mgrie`l Oicg Trkjgev rgtkrv.@trio 21/ 2404), @s`io`bog `v: nvvt:++tgqilvgrlgv,kra+|+mgfi`+Ciogu+,,,+TIT[Aksgrlmglv[Kloilg[2404,tfc,

1, @oklauifg vng vr`fivikl`o ckwrvn guv`vg/ bokaagru lkq ekmtriug qn`v Akkaog’u Grie Uenmifv`lf J`rgf Ekngl e`oo vng ‟ilvgrekllgevgf guv`vg,” Ugg Grie Uenmifv `lf J`rgf Ekngl/ ‟VngFiaiv`o Fiurwtvikl: Ekllgevisivy `lf vng Ficcwuikl kc Tkqgr/” Ckrgial @cc`iru >9/ lk, 3.Lksgmbgr-Fgegmbgr 2404), @s`io`bog `v: nvvt:+++qqq,ckrgial`cc`iru,ekm+`rvieogu+331>0+

grie-uenmifv-`lf-j`rgf-ekngl+vng-fiaiv`o-fiurwtvikl,

>, Gsagly Mkrkzks/ ‟Tkoivie`o Rgtrguuikl 2,4/” Vng Lgq Ykrh Vimgu .Ugtvgmbgr 2/ 2400): @-20,@s`io`bog `v: nvvt:++qqq,lyvimgu,ekm+2400+49+42+ktilikl+tkoivie`o-rgtrguuikl-2-4,nvmo,

9, Ugg Nkq`rf Rngilakof/ Um`rv Mkbu: Vng Lg~v Ukei`o Rgskowvikl .Lgq Ykrh: TgrugwuTwboiunila/ 2442)/ 034-036, Klg g~`mtog kc kloilg ekmmwlie`viklu v`ttila ilvk vng hlkqo-gfag b`ug kc vng eivizglry `v o`rag iu vng W,U, T`vglv `lf Vr`fgm`rh Kccieg’u .WUTVK) ‟Tggr-vk-T`vglv” rgsigq trkar`m/ il qnien t`vglv `ttoie`lvu skowlv`rioy uwbmiv vngir `ttoie`vikluckr rgsigq by ‟eivizgl-g~tgrvu” il vng aglgr`o twboie, Il vng qkrfu kc vng t`vglv kccieg/ ‟Vngtggr-vk-t`vglv uyuvgm erg`vgu ` cr`mgqkrh qnien m`hgu wug kc `l kl-oilg uyuvgm vk mgragvng vgenlkokaigu kc tggr-vk-tggr ekmmwlie`viklu/ lgvqkrhila `lf ekoo`bkr`visg ciovgrila vk

kccgr g~tgrviug il ifglvicyila rgogs`lv oivgr`vwrg qnien ilckrmu bkvn t`vglv `ttoie`lvu `lfvng WUTVK’u t`vglv g~`milgru,” Qnivg Nkwug Ktgl Aksgrlmglv Ilivi`visg/ ‟Tggr-vk-T`vglv:Bgvvgr Ilckrm`vikl ckr Bgvvgr T`vglvu/” .2441), @s`io`bog v: nvvt:++qqq,qnivgnkwug,aks+ktgl+illks`viklu+Tggr-vk-T`vglv,

04, Ugg Bgl Unlgifgrm`l/ Ogkl`rfk’u O`tvkt: Nwm`l Lggfu `lf vng Lgq Ekmtwvila Vgenlkokaigu  .E`mbrifag: MIV Trguu/ 2442)8 ugg `ouk Bgl Unlgifgrm`l/ Jgllicgr Trggeg/ Tgvgr Tirkooi/‟Rg`oizila Vng S`owg kc Ukei`o Mgfi` Rgpwirgu Illks`visg Ekmtwvila Rgug`ren/”Ekmmwlie`viklu kc vng @EM  76/ lk, 9 .Ugtvgmbgr 2400): 56-51, @s`io`bog `v: nvvt:++e`em,`em,kra+m`a`zilgu+2400+9+022197-rg`oizila-vng-s`owg-kc-ukei`o-mgfi`-rgpwirgu-illks`visg-ekmtwvila-rgug`ren+cwoovg~v,

00, Ckr ` uwmm`ry kc vng aksgrlmglv’u g-ugrsiegu trkar`mu/ ugg @`rkl Umivn/ ‟Vng ilvgrlgvaisgu eivizglu lgq t`vnu vk aksgrlmglv ugrsiegu `lf ilckrm`vikl/” Aksgrlmglv Kloilg/` Tgq Ilvgrlgv # @mgrie`l Oicg Trkjgev rgtkrv .@trio 21/ 2404), @s`io`bog `v: nvvt:++qqq,tgqilvgrlgv,kra++Rgtkrvu+2404+Aksgrlmglv-Kloilg+Uwmm`ry-kc-Cilfilau,`ut~, Vng rgtkrvckwlf vn`v >2 tgreglv kc Ilvgrlgv wugru .30 tgreglv kc `oo @mgrie`l `fwovu) n`sg okkhgf ckrilckrm`vikl kr ekmtogvgf ` vr`lu`evikl kl ` aksgrlmglv qgbuivg il vng 02 mklvnu trgegfilavng uwrsgy, @ rgeglv g~`mtog kc g-aksgrlmglv iu vng fgsgoktmglv kc ` mkbiog vgogtnklg `ttby vng Cgfgr`o Gmgragley M`l`agmglv @agley vk ngot tgktog kl vng G`uv Ek`uv trgt`rg ckr`lf rgeksgr crkm Nwrrie`lg Irglg il @wawuv 2400,

02, Vng G-Fgmker`ey Eglvrg/ `v vng Wlisgruivy kc Zwrien/ uwttkrvu rgug`ren kl g-fgmker`vieilivi`visgu vnrkwankwv vng qkrof, Ugg nvvt:++qqq,gfgmker`eyeglvrg,en+ilfg~,tnt, Ugg `oukKra`liz`vikl ckr Geklkmie Ekktgr`vikl `lf Fgsgoktmglv/ Trkmiug `lf Trkbogmu kc G-Fgmker`ey: En`ooglagu kc Kloilg Eisie Gla`agmglv  .T`riu: KEGF Twboiunila/ 2445),@s`io`bog `v: qqq,kgef,kra+f`v`kgef+9+00+5701352>,tfc, Cil`ooy/ Uvgsgl Eoicv m`y n`sgbggl vng ciruv tgrukl vk wug vng vgrm ‟g-fgmker`ey” qngl ng ckwlfgf G-fgmker`ey,kra ilMillgukv` il 0996,

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 47/61

56 Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

05, @`rkl Umivn/ ‟Lgianbkru Kloilg/” ` Tgq Ilvgrlgv # @mgrie`l Oicg Trkjgev rgtkrv .Jwlg 9/2404), @s`io`bog `v: nvvt:++qqq,tgqilvgrlgv,kra+Rgtkrvu+2404+Lgianbkru-Kloilg+T`rv-0,`ut~,

06, F`mkl Eglvko` gv `o,/ ‟Vng Utrg`f kc Bgn`sikr il `l Kloilg Ukei`o Lgvqkrh G~tgrimglv/”Ueigleg  529/ lk, 0096 .2404), @s`io`bog `v: nvvt:++feglvko`,ueritvu,miv,gfw+fkeu+Eglvko`'24Utrg`f'24kc'24Bgn`sikr,tfc,

07, Rgeglvoy/ Ut`rhgf,ekm `llkwlegf ` t`rvlgrunit qivn vng Tkilvu kc Oianv Iluvivwvg vk erg-`vg g~`evoy vniu ukrv kc skowlvggrila tkrv`o ckr vng eivy kc U`l Cr`leiuek, Vng to`vckrm qioom`ven eivizglu vk vng skowlvggrila lggfu kc oke`o bwuilguugu/ lkltrkcivu `lf eivy fgt`rvmglvu,Skowlvggrila e`l bg kloilg .‟fguhvkt skowlvggrila”) kr il-tgrukl, Vng trkjgev qioo g`rlmklgy ckr U`l Cr`leiuek vnrkwan ekrtkr`vg utklukrunitu `lf vnrkwan u`ogu kc vng to`vckrmvk o`rag ekrtkr`viklu il vng eivy/ qnien e`l wug vng uivg vk glekwr`ag vngir kql gmtokyggu vk

skowlvggr,

03, Ckr kloilg fiuewuuikl/ ugg Vqivvgr `v %akcr`lhoil,

01, Jkg Mkkrg/ ‟T`rvieit`vkry Bwfagvila: Ykw N`sg ` F`vg qivn Fgmker`ey‖Fgeifg Nkq YkwrV`~ Fkoo`ru Qioo Bg Utglv il vng 69vn Q`rf/” .2404), @s`io`bog `v: nvvt:++qqqq`rf69,ekm+t`rvieit`vkry-bwfagvila, Ugg `ouk vng T`rvieit`vkry Bwfagvila Trkjgev’u qgbuivg/ nvvt:++qqq,t`rvieit`vkrybwfagvila,kra/ ckr fgueritvikl kc eivizgl t`rvieit`vikl il bwfagvila il Lgq Ykrh`u qgoo `u il Enie`ak,

0>, Il 2449/ vng vkql kc Gs`luvkl/ Iooilkiu/ g~tgrimglvgf qivn ilsivila eivizglu vk trktkug q`yu kc eokuila ` &9,7 miooikl nkog il vng lg~v yg`r’u bwfagv, Trktku`ou qgrg tkuvgf ckr kloilg skvila

`lf twboie-`eeguu vgogsiuikl en`llgou brk`fe`uvgf ckwr bwfagv qkrhunktu, Lg`roy 0/444 rgui-fglvu skvgf kloilg, Ugg Mihg Ungfokeh/ ‟Gs`luvkl Iooilkiu Ukei`o G~tgrimglv vk Ukosg BwfagvFgcieiv/” Miun’u Aokb`o Geklkmie Vrglf @l`oyuiu  .Fgegmbgr 50/ 2449), @s`io`bog `v: nvvt:++aokb`ogeklkmie`l oyuiu,bokautkv,ekm+2449+20+gs`luvkl-iooilkiu-ukei`o-g~tgrimglv-vk,nvmo,

09, Grie Hoktcgr/ ‟Vimgo`b 2044/” MIV Eglvgr ckr Cwvwrg Eisie Mgfi` .244>), @s`io`bog `v: nvvt:++eisie,miv,gfw+trkjgevu+e6cem+vimgo`b-2044,

24, Jkg Kubkrlg/ ‟Vkt 27 C`egbkkh A`mgu‖Ugtvgmbgr 2400: Riug kc Vng Uimu Ukei`o/” A`mg Lgqu  .Ugtvgmbgr 3/ 2400), @s`io`bog `v nvvt:++boka,a`mgu,ekm+2400+49+43+vkt-27-c`egbkkh-a`mgu-ugtvgmbgr-2400-uimu-ukei`o+%4[wlfgcilgf/4[,

20, Ugvn Uenigugo/ ‟@ A`mg vk M`hg Zyal` Lgrskwu/” Vng Lgq Ykrh Vimgu  .Kevkbgr 1/ 2400),@s`io`bog `v: nvvt:++qqq,lyvimgu,ekm+2400+04+4>+`rvu+sifgk-a`mgu+uimu-ukei`o-iu-`l- uvkl-iunila-uweeguu-kl-c`egbkkh,nvmo, Vng `rvieog eivgu f`v` vn`v il klg mklvn vngrg qgrg 24 mio-oikl mkrg siuivu vk vng Uimu Ukei`o a`mg vn`l vngrg qgrg twren`ugu kc vng lksgo Vng E`vengr ilvng Ryg ksgr vng o`uv 34 yg`ru,

22, Ckr mkrg kl VGF/ ugg nvvtu:++qqq,vgf,ekm+t`agu+`bkwv,

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 48/61

`ttgLfi~ 

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 49/61

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 50/61

51

Lkvg: Vivogu `lf `ccioi`viklu `rg `u kc vng f`vg kc vng eklcgrgleg,

Q`go @bb`uGaytvi`l Jkwrl`oiuv/ Bokaagr `lfNwm`l Rianvu @evisiuv

Jgccrgy @br`muklTrkcguukr kc O`q `lfAksgrlmglv

Vng Wlisgruivy kc Vg~`u `v @wuvilUenkko kc O`q

M`fgogilg @obrianvEn`ir@obrianv Uvklgbrifag Arkwt

Jgf @otgrvEk-Ckwlfgr `lf Enigc G~gewvisgKcciegr

Mkbiog Ekmmklu/ Ile,Jk`pwil @os`r`fkUglikr Sieg TrguifglvFiaiv`o Illks`vikl@mgrie`l Twboie Mgfi`

Uvgtngl B`oh`mCkwlfgr `lf Enigc G~gewvisg

KcciegrC`mioy Kloilg U`cgvy Iluvivwvg

Jg`l-Enriuvktng B`uUglikr @fsiukrUvr`vgaie Fgsgoktmglv `lfT`rvlgrunitu

Wlivgf L`viklu @ooi`leg kc Eisioiz`viklu

Jknl Br`ehglFirgevkr kc Fiaiv`o Mgfi`Hlianv Ckwlf`vikl

Aogll Kviu BrkqlFirgevkr kc BwuilguuFgsgoktmglv

Vqivvgr

Fkll` Byrf

TwboiungrVngRkkv,ekm

Uvgsgl EoicvCkwlfgr `lf G~gewvisg FirgevkrG-Fgmker`ey,kra

Er`ia Fwbkq En`irm`l `lf Enigc G~gewvisg

KcciegrA`llgvv Ek,/ Ile,

@utgl Iluvivwvg Ckrwm kl Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy 

Lgvqkrhu`lfEivizglunit 

@utgl/ Ekokr`fk ± @wawuv 0-6/ 2400

T`rvieit`lvu

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 51/61

5> Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

Lkvg: Vivogu `lf `ccioi`viklu `rg `u kc vng f`vg kc vng eklcgrgleg,

Miehgy Gfq`rfu

Firgevkr@utgl Iluvivwvg-RkfgoCgookqunitu il Twboie Og`fgrunit

Vng @utgl Iluvivwvg

En`rogu M, CirguvklgG~gewvisg FirgevkrEkmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy Trkar`m

Vng @utgl Iluvivwvg

Ogqiu @, Crigfo`lfTrkcguukrUenkko kc Jkwrl`oium `lf M`uuEkmmwlie`vikl

Wlisgruivy kc Qiuekluil

@renkl Cwla 

Ckrf Ckwlf`vikl Trkcguukr kc Fgmker`ey `lf Eivizglunit

N`rs`rf Wlisgruivy 

Qioo AriccilTrguifglv `lf Enigc G~gewvisgKcciegr

Nit Nkt Kl Fgm`lf

Rggf NwlfvTrileit`oRGN @fsiukru

@obgrvk Ib`raÿglTrguifglvHlianv Ckwlf`vikl

Riuni J`ivoy 

Trkar`m Firgevkr/ FgvrkivHlianv Ckwlf`vikl

T`wo` Hgragr

Trguifglv `lf Enigc G~gewvisgKcciegrTwboie Brk`fe`uvila Ugrsieg

Mien`go M`lguuSieg Trguifglv kc Jkwrl`oium `lfMgfi` Illks`vikl

Hlianv Ckwlf`vikl

@lfrgq MeO`wanoilG~gewvisg FirgevkrEisie Ekmmklu

Er`ia Lgqm`rh Ckwlfgr `lf Ewuvkmgr UgrsiegRgtrguglv`visg

er`iauoiuv

Mien`go KrguhguUglikr M`l`aila GfivkrVng @uukei`vgf Trguu

Lkrm`l J, KrluvgilRguifglv Uenko`r@mgrie`l Glvgrtriug Iluvivwvg ckrTwboie Tkoiey Rgug`ren

@lfrgq R`uigjCkwlfgrTgrukl`o Fgmker`ey Ckrwm

Jknl Rglfkl

Trguifglv `lf Enigc G~gewvisgKcciegr

Vng Rglfkl Arkwt/ Ile,

Lienko`u RgsioogEk-Ckwlfgr `lf G~gewvisgFirgevkr

T`rvieit`vkry Ewovwrg Ckwlf`vikl

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 52/61

T`rvieit`lvu 59 

Lkvg: Vivogu `lf `ccioi`viklu `rg `u kc vng f`vg kc vng eklcgrgleg,

Ar`n`m Rien`rf

TrguifglvAr`n`m Rien`rf @uukei`vgu/ OOE/

`lf

Ek-Ckwlfgr

Tkrv`ou 6 Nian Tgrckrm`leg

Bgl Riaby 

Ek-Ckwlfgr `lf Enigc 

Vgenlkokay Kcciegr

Ut`rhgf,ekm

Jwoi`l` Rkvien

Ek-Ckwlfgr `lf G~gewvisg

Firgevkr

Wun`nifi Ile,

Jkrag Rgil` Uengmglv

Fg`lUenkko kc Ekmmwlie`vikl/

Ilckrm`vikl `lf Oibr`ry Uvwfigu

Rwvagru Wlisgruivy 

Lg`o Un`tirk

Trguifglv `lf Enigc G~gewvisg

Kcciegr

QLGV

Bgl Unlgifgrm`l

Ckwlfila Firgevkr

Nwm`l-Ekmtwvgr Ilvgr`evikl

O`bkr`vkry 

Wlisgruivy kc M`ryo`lf

Jgcc Umwoy`l

Enigc G~gewvisg KcciegrGMMIU Ekmmwlie`viklu

R`engo Uvgrlg

Enigc Fiaiv`o KcciegrM`ykr’u Kccieg kc Mgfi` #Glvgrv`ilmglv

Eivy kc Lgq Ykrh

L`ley V`vg

G~gewvisg FirgevkrOg`awg kc Qkmgl Skvgru

Jglly Vkkmgy Uglikr Trkar`m KcciegrVng Ckrf Ckwlf`vikl

F`ligo J, Qgivzlgr

Fgtwvy Enigc Vgenlkokay Kcciegrckr Ilvgrlgv Tkoiey 

G~gewvisg Kccieg kc vng TrguifglvVng Qnivg Nkwug

Vr`ey Qguvgl

@fjwlev TrkcguukrWlisgruivy kc Ukwvngrl E`oickrli`@llglbgra Uenkko kc Ekmmwlie`vikl/ `lf

Uglikr Rgug`ren CgookqEo`rgmklv Ar`fw`vg Wlisgruivy 

F`sif QguvilTrguifglv `lf Enigc G~gewvisgKcciegr

Lgqu Oiegluila Arkwt

Eklkr Qnivg-Uwoois`l

Enigc G~gewvisg KcciegrOke`oker`ey 

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 53/61

64 Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

Lkvg: Vivogu `lf `ccioi`viklu `rg `u kc vng f`vg kc vng eklcgrgleg,

Uv`cc: 

@my H, A`rmgrFirgevkr kc Jkwrl`oium TrkjgevuEkmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy Trkar`m

Vng @utgl Iluvivwvg

Gril Uiooim`lUglikr Trkjgev M`l`agr

Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy Trkar`mVng @utgl Iluvivwvg

Hi`nl` Qiooi`muUglikr Trkjgev M`l`agrEkmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy Trkar`m

Vng @utgl Iluvivwvg

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 54/61

60

@bkwv vng @wvnkr

Jgccrgy @br`mukl iu ` Trkcguukr kc O`q `lf Aksgrlmglv `lf Cgookqkc vng Cr`lh Grqil En`ir il Aksgrlmglv `v vng Wlisgruivy kc Vg~`u`v @wuvil/ qngrg ng vg`engu ekwrugu kl tkoivie`o vngkry/ ekluvivwvikl`oo`q `lf eisio oibgrvigu, Ng iu vng `wvnkr/ mkuv rgeglvoy/ kc  Milgrs`’u Kqo: Vng Vr`fivikl kc Qguvgrl Tkoivie`o Vnkwanv  .N`rs`rf/ 2449),Kvngr bkkhu ileowfg Qg/ vng Jwry: Vng Jwry `lf vng Ifg`o kc Fgmker`ey .N`rs`rf/ 2444) lf Vng Gogevrklie Ekmmklqg`ovn .B`uie Bkkhu/ 09>7),Trkcguukr @br`mukl n`u ugrsgf `u ` Utgei`o @uuiuv`lv @vvkrlgy Aglgr`oil M`uu`enwugvvu/ l @uuiuv`lv Fiuvriev @vvkrlgy lf u O`q Eogrh vk vngo`vg Enigc Jwuvieg Rkug Birf kc vng E`oickrli` Uwtrgmg Ekwrv,

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 55/61

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 56/61

65

Trgsikwu Twboie`viklu

crkm vng @utgl IluvivwvgCkrwm kl Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy 

Lgqu Eivigu: Vng Lg~v Aglgr`vikl kc Ng`ovny Ilckrmgf Ekmmwlivigu  .2404)

Rien`rf @fogr/ r`ttkrvgwr,Lgqu Eivigu  fgv`iou vng bguv `lf qkruv kc vimgu ckr vng lgqu bwui-

lguu, Vng bguv bgila vng s`uv g~t`lug kc kloilg ilckrm`vikl ukwregu/crkm wugr-aglgr`vgf eklvglv vk eivizgl jkwrl`oiuvu, Vng qkruv bgila vngfgvrimglv`o geklkmie vimgu, Il vniu rgtkrv/ @fogr ekleowfgu vn`v ukei-gvy lggfu vk glekwr`ag mkrg g~tgrimglv`vikl qivn lgq mkfgou vn`vtrksifg ergfibog ilckrm`vikl `lf glekwr`ag gla`agmglv/ oke`ooy `lfl`vikl`ooy8 gluwrg `eeguu vk brk`fb`lf ugrsiegu by `oo8 `lf m`hg egrv`iltgktog n`sg vng gfwe`vikl il vng mwovitog oivgr`eigu vngy lggf vk cwle-vikl cwooy `u eivizglu il vng 20uv eglvwry, 1> t`agu/ IUBL: 4->9>75-763-5/

&02,44,

Kc vng Trguu: Mkfgou ckr Vr`luckrmila @mgrie`l Jkwrl`oium .2449)

Mien`go R, C`lengr/ r`ttkrvgwr,Kc vng Trguu  v`hgu ` eokugr okkh `v q`yu vk u`sg @mgrie`l jkwrl`o-

ium `lf oke`o fgmker`vie aksgrl`leg il kwr ewrrglv cil`lei`o eriuiu,Qivn vng m`ly vgenlkokaie`o `lf bgn`sikr`o en`lagu v`hila to`eg/lgqu kra`liz`viklu c`eg unrilhila `wfiglegu `lf fgeoilila `fsgrviuila

rgsglwg, Kc vng Trguu kccgru ckwr `rg`u vk imtrksg: vr`luckrmila twboieugrsieg jkwrl`oium8 rgbwiofila twboie vrwuv il jkwrl`oium `lf jkwrl`o-iuvie kra`liz`viklu8 trkmkvila rgug`ren8 `lf twunila g~tgrimglv`vikl`lf ekoo`bkr`vikl, 34 t`agu/ IUBL: 4->9>65-720->/ &02,44,

Mgfi` `lf Fgmker`ey .244>)

Rien`rf T, @fogr/ r`ttkrvgwr,Mgfi` lf Fgmker`ey g~tokrgu vng rkog kc mgfi` il gln`leila ukei`o

e`tiv`o/ eisie gla`agmglv `lf fgmker`vie ilskosgmglv, Il `ffivikl vkg~`milila vng uv`vg kc lgqut`tgru lf jkwrl`oium `a`iluv vng b`ehfrktkc vng 244> trguifglvi`o gogevikl/ vng rgtkrv fiuewuugu trktkugf trkjgevu

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 57/61

66 Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

ckr n`rlguuila mgfi` vk utwr eisie `lf aokb`o gla`agmglv, @mkla vng

ifg`u bgila imtogmglvgf `rg vng Kloilg Tg`eg Ekrtu/ Arkwlfuqgoo`lf vng @mgrie`l Fi`okawg Ilivi`visg/ `u qgoo `u klakila qkrh by vngHlianv Ekmmiuuikl kl vng Ilckrm`vikl Lggfu kc Ekmmwlivigu il `Fgmker`ey/ qnien uvgmmgf crkm vng 2441 CKE@U, 7> t`agu/ IUBL:4->9>65-745-^/ &02,44,

Mgfi` `lf S`owgu: Iuuwgu kc Eklvglv/ Ekmmwlivy `lf Ilvgoogevw`o Trktgrvy .2441)

Rien`rf T, @fogr/ Frgq Eo`rh/ H`vnoggl Q`oom`l/ r`ttkrvgwru,Vniu rgtkrv g~`milgu nkq vng lgq mgfi` t`r`fiam ilvgrugevu iuuwgukc eklvglv s`owgu/ ilvgoogevw`o trktgrvy/ `lf oke`o ekmmwlivy, Cr`milavng fiuewuuiklu crkm CKE@U 2441/ Mgfi` `lf S`owgu  okkhu `v vktieuuwen `u kccgluisg eklvglv/ c`ir wug/ lgq bwuilguu mkfgou/ ilvgoogevw`otrktgrvy/ oke`o mgfi`/ `lf vng cwvwrg kc fgmker`ey, Vng rgtkrv `oukkccgru ekluvrwevisg uwaaguviklu ckr rgukosila ugsgr`o kc vng mkrg eklvgl-vikwu en`ooglagu vn`v n`sg eekmt`ligf fgsgoktmglvu il lgq mgfi`, 94t`agu/ IUBL: 4->9>65-6>>-2/ &02,44,

Lg~v-Aglgr`vikl Mgfi`: Vng Aokb`o Unicv .2443)

Rien`rf T, @fogr/ r`ttkrvgwr,Vniu rgtkrv g~`milgu vng arkqvn kc vng Ilvgrlgv `lf ivu gccgev kl ` r`t-

ifoy en`laila `rg`: vng imt`ev kc lgq mgfi` kl tkoivieu/ bwuilguu/ ukeigvy/ewovwrg/ `lf aksgrlmglvu vng qkrof ksgr, Vng rgtkrv `ouk ungfu oianv klnkq vr`fivikl`o mgfi` qioo lggf vk `f`tv vk c`eg vng ekmtgvivikl kc vnglg~v-aglgr`vikl mgfi`, 13 t`agu/ IUBL: 4->9>65-639-3/ &02,44,

Ukcv Tkqgr/ N`rf Iuuwgu .2447)

Un`lvni H`o`vnio/ r`ttkrvgwr,Il vniu ekmtio`vikl kc vqk rgtkrvu/ vng `wvnkr g~tokrgu vng arkqila

imtkrv`leg kc ukcv tkqgr by okkhila `v vqk erwei`o `rg`u kc ilvgrl`-vikl`o vgluikl: vng W,U, rkog il vng Miffog G`uv `lf Uilk-@mgrie`lrgo`viklu, Vng rkog kc ilckrm`vikl `lf ekmmwlie`viklu vgenlkokaiguil @mgrie`l twboie fitokm`ey il vng Miffog G`uv `lf @mgrie`l’u

rgo`viklu qivn Enil` iu ` eglvr`o vngmg il vng rgtkrvu, 14 t`agu/ IUBL:4->9>65-661-7/ &02,44,

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 58/61

Trgsikwu Twboie`viklu  67

Rgtkrvu e`l bg krfgrgf kloilg `v qqq,`utgliluvivwvg,kra kr by uglfila `lgm`io rgpwguv vk twboie vikluD`utgliluvivwvg,kra,

Ktglila vng Rg`om: Vng Rkog kc Ekmmwlie`viklu il Lgakvi`vila 

vng Vgluikl kc S`owgu il Aokb`oiz`vikl .2446)Mien`go Uwm`l/ r`ttkrvgwr, Vniu rgtkrv `ffrguugu nkq ekmmwlie`viklu mgfi` `lf ilckrm`vikl

vgenlkokaigu e`l bg wugf vk `mgoikr`vg kr g~`egrb`vg vng vgluiklu `mklavng s`owgu kc tg`eg/ trkutgrivy/ `lf akkf aksgrl`leg kr `mkla vng ckregukc ugewrivy/ e`tiv`oium/ `lf fgmker`ey, Vn`v iu/ e`l vng mgfi` ngot ` ukei-gvy a`il vng uimwov`lgkwu bglgciv kc `oo vnrgg s`owgu kr ckregu; Nkq fkguklg trikrivizg nkq vng mgfi` ak `bkwv fkila vn`v il ` crgg ukeigvy; Qn`viu vng rkog kc vng lgq mgfi`/ qnien n`u uk mwen trkmiug vk ilskosg vngilfisifw`o il lgq q`yu; 70 t`agu/ IUBL: 4->9>65-652-1/ &02,44,

Mgfi` Eklsgragleg/ Fisgruivy `lf Fgmker`ey .2445)Lgio Uniuvgr/ r`ttkrvgwr,Il vng uwmmgr kc 2442/ enigc g~gewvisg ogsgo og`fgru crkm vng twboie

`lf tris`vg ugevkru mgv `v vng @utgl Iluvivwvg vk `ffrguu vng wlfgroyilarkog kc mgfi` il ` fgmker`vie ukeigvy `lf tkoieigu vn`v m`y imtrksg vng`bioivy kc eivizglu vk g~greiug vngir rkogu `u ilckrmgf uksgrgialu il vn`v

ukeigvy, Vniu twboie`vikl/ `wvnkrgf by jkwrl`oiuv Lgio Uniuvgr/ g~`milguvng eklegrl kc m`ly ksgr vng unrilhila gogevkr`vg il @mgrie`l goge-viklu `lf vng tkuuibog rkog vng m`uu mgfi` to`y il vn`v vrglf/ vng fgb`vgksgr qngvngr eklukoif`vikl il kof `lf lgq mgfi` r`iugu ‟fgmker`vie”`u kttkugf vk `lvivrwuv eklegrlu/ `lf kttkrvwlivigu ckr lgq mgfi` vkgl`bog eivizglu vk ekmmwlie`vg‖bkvn il vgrmu kc a`ilila lgq ilckrm`-vikl `lf g~en`laila vngir kql ktiliklu qivn kvngru, Ng `ouk `ffrguuguvng eklegrl vn`v lgq mgfi` qioo bgekmg bkvvoglgehgf r`vngr vn`l ekl-

vilwg vng ktgl `renivgevwrg kc vng Ilvgrlgv, 73 t`agu/ IUBL: 4->9>65-516-3/ &02,44,

Il Ug`ren kc vng Twboie Ilvgrguv il vng Lgq Mgfi` Glsirklmglv .2440)F`sif Bkooigr/ r`ttkrvgwr,Vniu rgtkrv g~`milgu twboie ilvgrguv `lf vng rkog kc vng m`rhgvto`eg

il rgfgcilila vniu eklegtv qivn rgutgev vk gfwe`vikl`o `lf ewovwr`o ekl-vglv, Iv uwaaguvu ktviklu ckr cwlfila twboie ilvgrguv eklvglv qngl `oomgfi` `rg mksila vkq`rf fiaiv`o vr`lumiuuikl, Vng twboie`vikl `oukileowfgu `cvgrvnkwanvu crkm `l ilvgrl`vikl`o tgrutgevisg by Briviun niu-vkri`l @u` Briaau, 30 t`agu/ IUBL T`tgr: 4->9>65-555-9/ &02,44,

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 59/61

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 60/61

@bkwv vngEkmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy Trkar`mqqq,`utgliluvivwvg,kra+e#u 

Vng Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy Trkar`m iu `l `evisg sglwg ckraokb`o og`fgru `lf g~tgrvu vk g~en`lag lgq iluianvu kl vng ukeigv`o imt`evkc fiaiv`o vgenlkokay `lf lgvqkrh ekmmwlie`viklu, Vng Trkar`m `oukerg`vgu ` mwovi-fiueitoil`ry ut`eg il vng ekmmwlie`viklu tkoiey m`h-ila qkrof qngrg sgvgr`l `lf gmgraila fgeiuikl m`hgru e`l g~tokrg lgqeklegtvu/ cilf tgrukl`o arkqvn/ `lf fgsgokt lgq lgvqkrhu ckr vng bgv-vgrmglv kc ukeigvy,

Vng Trkar`m’u trkjgevu c`oo ilvk klg kr mkrg kc vnrgg e`vgakrigu:ekmmwlie`viklu `lf mgfi` tkoiey/ fiaiv`o vgenlkokaigu `lf fgmker`vies`owgu/ `lf lgvqkrh vgenlkokay `lf ukei`o en`lag, Klakila `evisivigu kc vng Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy Trkar`m ileowfg `llw`o rkwlfv`bogu

kl jkwrl`oium `lf ukeigvy .g,a,/ jkwrl`oium `lf l`vikl`o ugewrivy)/ ekm-mwlie`viklu tkoiey il eklsgragf qkrof .g,a,/ vng cwvwrg kc ilvgrl`vikl`ofiaiv`o geklkmy)/ vng imt`ev kc `fs`legu il ilckrm`vikl vgenlkokay .g,a,/ ‟qngl twun ekmgu vk twoo”)/ `lf ugrsila vng ilckrm`vikl lggfukc ekmmwlivigu, Ckr vng t`uv vnrgg yg`ru/ vng Trkar`m n`u v`hgl `fggtgr okkh `v ekmmwlivy ilckrm`vikl lggfu vnrkwan vng qkrh kc vngHlianv Ekmmiuuikl kl vng Ilckrm`vikl Lggfu kc Ekmmwlivigu il `Fgmker`ey/ ` trkjgev kc vng @utgl Iluvivwvg `lf vng Jknl U, `lf J`mgu

O, Hlianv Ckwlf`vikl, Vng Trkar`m `ouk eklsglgu vng @utgl IluvivwvgCkrwm kl Ekmmwlie`viklu `lf Ukeigvy/ il qnien enigc g~gewvisg-ogsgoog`fgru kc bwuilguu/ aksgrlmglv `lf vng lkl-trkciv ugevkr g~`milg iuuwgurgo`vila vk vng en`laila mgfi` `lf vgenlkokay glsirklmglv,

Mkuv eklcgrglegu wvioizg vng uial`vwrg @utgl Iluvivwvg ugmil`r ckrm`v:`ttrk~im`vgoy 27 og`fgru crkm ` s`rigvy kc fiueitoilgu `lf tgrutgevisgugla`ag il rkwlfv`bog fi`okawg/ mkfgr`vgf qivn vng kbjgevisg kc frisilavng `aglf` vk utgeicie ekleowuiklu `lf rgekmmglf`viklu,

Eklcgrgleg rgtkrvu `lf kvngr m`vgri`ou `rg fiuvribwvgf vk hgy tkoi-eym`hgru `lf ktilikl og`fgru qivnil vng Wlivgf Uv`vgu `lf `rkwlf vngqkrof, Vngy `rg `ouk `s`io`bog vk vng twboie `v o`rag vnrkwan vng QkrofQifg Qgb/ qqq,`utgliluvivwvg,kra+e#u,

61

7/31/2019 Networks and Citizenship: Using Technology for Civic Innovation

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/networks-and-citizenship-using-technology-for-civic-innovation 61/61

6> Lgvqkrhu  `Lf EivizgLunit: WuiLa vgEnLkokay  ckr EisiE iLLks`vikL 

Vng Trkar`m’u G~gewvisg Firgevkr iu En`rogu M, Cirguvklg/ qnk n`u

ugrsgf il vn`v e`t`eivy uileg 09>98 ng n`u `ouk ugrsgf `u G~gewvisg SiegTrguifglv kc vng @utgl Iluvivwvg, Ng iu ` ekmmwlie`viklu `vvkrlgy `lfo`q trkcguukr/ ckrmgroy Firgevkr kc vng WEO@ Ekmmwlie`viklu O`qTrkar`m/ ciruv Trguifglv kc vng Oku @lagogu Bk`rf kc Vgogekmmwlie`vikluEkmmiuuiklgru `lf `l @ttgoo`vg @vvkrlgy ckr vng W,U, Cgfgr`oEkmmwlie`viklu Ekmmiuuikl,