ninian smart’s sociological model of religion there is a relationship between the existence of...

23
Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion grown out of a response to the human need to understand the mystery around us? Has our failure to understand, or control forces beyond what we can explain, resulted in a tendency to worship? According to Ninian Smart’s theory, all world religions have the following elements which came into being due to our need to

Upload: marilyn-bridges

Post on 11-Jan-2016

227 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of ReligionThere is a relationship between the

existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion grown out of a response to the human need to understand the mystery around us? Has our failure to understand, or control forces beyond what we can explain, resulted in a tendency to worship? According to Ninian Smart’s theory, all world religions have the following elements which came into being due to our need to explain mystery.

Page 2: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

1. An Encounter with the Divine

• All religions begin with an experience of the divine. The “divine” is that which gives meaning to our existence. Someone has an experience of a greater reality which transforms that person and our understanding of reality. This person is the founder.

• Example: The disciples meet and follow Jesus.

Page 3: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

2. The MythThe encounter with the divine is remembered and retold, first in story form and then in writing. An attempt is made to communicate the experience. Sacred books (scriptures) tell the story of the founder’s religious experience.

Example: The disciples tell others about Jesus. These stories later become written down in the “gospels” or Bible.

Page 4: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

•3. Rituals (Cult)• Attempts are made to recreate the

encounter with the divine using ceremonies and celebrations.

• Example: For Catholics, the Mass is an attempt to recreate the experience of Jesus giving himself for us at the Last Supper and on the cross

Page 5: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

•4. Community• People come together who share a

common vision of the world based on their understanding of the divine. In most religions, branches or splits occur in the community as a result of a variation in experience, beliefs or world view.

• Example: The Catholic Church is made up of local church communities.

Page 6: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

•5. Morality (Code)•Members of the community share a common set of values which are rooted in the experience of the divine. These values determine right and wrong.

•Example: Two Great Commandments

Page 7: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

•6. Beliefs (Creed)•The community shares a common vision of what the world could be like based on the encounter with the divine.

•Example: The Christian vision of the Kingdom of God; The Apostle’s Creed

Page 8: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

Charting Ninian Smart’s Six Trait

Model of Religion:

Page 9: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

Religious Teaching or Doctrine (Creed)creeds, laws, articles of faith

Community of Faith

Leaders and followers

Morality (Code)Norms of behaviour, virtues, values, karma,

ethics

Page 10: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

Religious Experience

Divine HumanGod foundersgods mysticsSpirits prophetsangelsavatars

Demonic Heirophaniessatan Encounters with devils the sacredevil spirits

Theophanies Encounter with God

Page 11: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

Sacred Stories

Myths

Stories which explain sacred realities: hero, creation, divine, natural

Scriptures

Sacred Writings containing myths, history, law, wisdom, teachings, prophecy

Page 12: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

Sacred Symbols and Rituals(Cult)

Symbols (water)Objects (rosary)Places (shrines)

ClothingFood

PrayerLife-cycle rituals

Daily ritualsWeekly ritualsPilgrimages

Annual festivals

Page 13: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

Choice Self-test:1.St. Luke writing his gospel:a) religious experience b) myth c) ritual d) community e) beliefs f) code2.The Catholic Catechism’s teaching on pre-marital sex:a) religious experience b) myth c) ritual d) community e) beliefs f) code3.Mohammed receiving a vision from the Angel Gabriel:a) religious experience b) myth c) ritual d) community e) beliefs f) code

Page 14: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

4.Jewish wedding ceremony:a) religious experience b) myth c) ritual d) communitye) beliefs f) code5.Buddhistsa) religious experience b) myth c) ritual d) community e) beliefs f) code6.Jehovah’s witnesses state that only 144, 000 will be saved at the end of time:a) religious experience b) myth c) ritual d) community e) beliefs f) code7.The holy book of Islam called the Korana) religious experience b) myth c) ritual d) community e) beliefs f) code8. Face Mecca and pray five times a day:a) religious experience b) myth c) ritual d) community e) beliefs f) code

Page 15: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

Neanderthal Man

The Neanderthal, was a species that inhabited Europe and parts of western and central Asia.

Neanderthals had many adaptations to a cold climate, such as large braincase, short, robust builds, and rather large noses — traits selected by nature in cold climates

Their cranial capacity was larger than modern humans, indicating that their brains may have been larger, which may be due to their more robust build.

On average, Neanderthal males stood about 1.65 m tall (just under 5' 5") and were heavily built with robust bone structure.

Females were about 1.53 to 1.57 m tall (about 5'–5'2").

Page 16: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

Some physical characteristics Projecting mid-face Low, flat, elongated skull Prominent browridge Lack of a protruding chin Broad, projecting nose 1200-1750 cm³ skull

capacity (10% greater than modern human average)

Large round finger tips Barrel-shaped rib cage Large kneecaps Long collar bones Short, bowed shoulder

blades Thick, bowed shaft of the

thigh bones Short shinbones and calf

bones

Page 17: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

Culturally, Neanderthal was fully human He buried his dead.

He drew paintings on cave walls. He used fire and tools. He played the flute. He worshipped bears. He was cannibalistic. He cared for the injured and elderly. In essence he did the things that

other humans have done down through history.

Page 18: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

In summary Neanderthal was more muscular, more agile, and stronger with a greater bone density than modern humans.

He also had a bigger brain. He would easily overpower most modern day Homo sapiens. When archeologists describe Neanderthal they often use the word "robust."

This is a fancy way of saying bigger, thicker or larger.

Page 19: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

CRO-MAGNON MAN Cro-Magnon man an ancestor of modern

man, Homo Sapiens Sapiens, living during the last ice age in what is now Europe, most notably in the area of modern day France.

Cro-Magnons knew how to make many different tools and weapons, and wore sewn clothes decorated with bone and shell jewelry and ornaments.

They were taller and less muscular as their cousin subspecies the Neanderthals that originally habitated those colder regions.

Page 20: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

It is named after the cave of Crô-Magnon in southwest France, where the first specimen was found.

They had a balanced diet of meat, grain, wild carrot, beetroot, onion, turnip and other foods.

Surviving Cro-Magnon artifacts include huts, cave paintings, carvings and antler-tipped spears. The remains of tools suggest that they knew how to make woven clothing.

They had huts, constructed of rocks, clay, bones, branches, and animal hide/fur.

These early humans used manganese and iron oxides to paint pictures and may have created the first calendar around 15,000 years ago

Page 21: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

If Cro-Magnons buried their dead intentionally it suggests they had a knowledge of ritual, by burying their dead with necklaces and tools, or an idea of disease and that the bodies needed to be contained.

the humans of this time period led a physically difficult life

The Cro-Magnons lived in Europe between 35,000 and 10,000 years ago. They are virtually identical to modern man, being tall and muscular and slightly more robust on average than most modern humans.

They were skilled hunters, toolmakers and artists famous for the cave art

most modern Europeans are probably descended from them

Page 22: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

Biologically modern human beings (species Homo sapiens) first appear about 120,000 years ago.

implements for making clothing, engraving, and sculpting.

They produced fine artwork, in the form of decorated tools, beads, ivory carvings of humans and animals, shell jewelry, clay figurines, musical instruments, and polychrome cave paintings of exceptional vitality.

Page 23: Ninian Smart’s Sociological Model of Religion There is a relationship between the existence of religions and humankind’s need for meaning. Has religion

They were tall like modern humans, their skull had no brow ridges, was thin, rounded, with a high forehead, with a projecting chin.

Average brain size:about 1,350 milliliters (same as today).

As their oral anatomy were identical to modern humans, they could probably speak. They were our ancestor.