nm-wy
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
1/124
Defending Life 2010
699
new MexiCOrAnKing: 37
nw mxic lacks ay c ss laws ad pciv gula-
is. F xapl, nw mxic ds adqualy pc h halh
ad safy f w skig abis bcaus i lacks a ifd
cs law, a fcabl paal ivlv law, cph-
siv gulais f faciliis pfig abis. I addii, nw mxic has addssd
pial abuss f bichlgy, icludig hua clig, dsuciv by sach, as-
sisd pduciv chlgis.
ABOrTiOn:
nw mxic ds hav a ifd cs law f abi.
nw mxic has acd a paal ic law ha is csiuially pblaic. th
sa Ay Gal has issud a pii ha h law ds pvid h csiu-
ially-quid judicial bypass pcdu ad is ufcabl.
th nw mxic Sup Cu has hld ha h equal righs Ad h sa
csiui pvids a bad igh abi ha h U.S. Csiui. Ud his
ulig, h cu has suck dw sicis h us f axpay fuds pay f
abis.
nw mxic pvids cu-dd mdicaid cvag f all dically cssay
abis.
nw mxic aiais gulais adaig ha abi cliics iiu
halh ad safy sadads, bu ly physicias licsd i nw mxic ay pf
abis.
nw mxic phibis paial-bih abi, bu ly af viabiliy.
nw mxic adas h pvisi f gcy cacpi i hspial g-
cy s. I addii, gcy cacpi is availabl dicly f phaaciss
wihu a pscipi.
th sa has a fcabl abi pig law, bu ds qui h pig
f ifai h Cs f Disas Cl ad Pvi (CDC). th asu
applis bh sugical ad sugical abis.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
2/124
700
Americans United for Life
Halh isuac plas ha pvid pscipi cvag us als pvid cvag
f cacpi. A xpi applis ligius plys.
LegAL reCOgniTiOn Of UnBOrn AnD newLY BOrn:
Cu nw mxic law ds cgiz a ub child as a pial vici fhicid assaul.
New Mexico denes criminal assaults on a pregnant woman that result in miscarriage,
sillbih, daag pgacy as hacd ffss f scig pupss.
th sa allws a wgful dah (civil) aci wh a viabl ub child is killd
hugh a glig ciial ac.
nw mxic ds qui ha a ifa wh suvivs a abi b giv apppi-
a dical ca.
nw mxic has a Baby mss law, sablishig a saf hav f hs lgally
lav hi ifas a dsigad placs ad suig h ifas civ apppia ca
ad pci.
BiOeTHiCS LAwS:
New Mexico bans live fetal experimentation. A fetus is dened as the product of
ccpi f h i f ccpi uil h xpulsi xaci f h p-
ig f h ui caviy. thus, i is ucla whh h sau applis cld huabys.
nw mxic has acd h Ubilical Cd Bld Bakig Ac, which quis phy-
sicias ad hspials if w hs f h pi da hi childs u-
bilical cd bld f sach.
nw mxic aiais laws gadig assisd pduciv chlgis.
enD Of Life LAwS:
I nw mxic, assisig a suicid is a fly.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
3/124
Defending Life 2010
701
HeALTHCAre
rigHTS Of COnSCienCe LAwS:
Patcpato Aboto:
A ps assciad wih, plyd by, h saff f a hspial wh bjcs li-gius al guds is quid paicipa i a abi.
A hspial is quid adi a wa f h pups f pfig a abi.
Patcpato rsach Hamul to Huma L:
nw mxic culy pvids pci f h ighs f halhca pvids wh
csciiusly bjc paicipai i hua clig, dsuciv by sach,
ad h fs f ial dical sach.
wHAT HAPPeneD in 2009:
nw mxic csidd ulipl asus ha wuld hav acd a sa Fd
f Chic Ac.
o h h had, h sa csidd a asu ha wuld hav quid paal -
tication before a minor could obtain an abortion.
nw mxic csidd asus qusig h cai f a sawid ask fc
assss ad ipv accss subsac abus a ad paal ca f pgawomen with substance abuse problems, as well as a bill providing for certicates of
sillbih.
nw mxic csidd asus allwig dsuciv by sach ad phibiig
clig--pduc-child.
nw mxic csidd lgislai allwig physicia-assisd suicid. I als csid-
d a csiuial ad pvidig h igh ak dcisis abu halh ca
ad baig aday halhca cvag.
th sa als csidd lgislai pcig h ighs f cscic f sachs.
The bill provided that an employee shall not be required to conduct scientic research,
xpiai, sudy ha ivlvs h cai us f p-iplaai bys
i lai hua byic s cll sach h x ha such sach c-
icts with the sincerely-held religious practices or beliefs of the employee.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
4/124
702
Americans United for Life
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
5/124
Defending Life 2010
703
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR NEw MEXICO
Sort-term
Priorities
Additional
Goals
ABORTION
Informed Consent
Comprehensive informed
consent
law with reection period
Parental Involvement Parental notice or consent
State Rights & PoliciesAmendment declaring no state
constitutional right to abortion
Abortion Funding Limits on use of state fundingfor abortions
Abortion Provider
RequirementsAbortion clinic regulations
Abortion Bans
Regulation of Abortifacients Regulation of RU-486
PCCs Support Direct funding of PCCs
Abortion Reporting
LEGAL RECOGNITION AND PROTECTION FOR UNBORN & NEwLy BORN
Fetal HomicideComprehensive unborn victims
of violence protection
Assault on Unborn
Prohibitions on WrongfulBirth & Wrongful Life
Lawsuits
Permit Wrongful Death
Lawsuits
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
6/124
704
Americans United for Life
Born-Alive Infant ProtectionLaw requiring care for infant
who survives an abortion
Abandoned Infant Protection
BIOEThICS
Human Cloning Ban on human cloning
DER Ban on DER
State Funding of DER
Ban on state funding of DER
and continued funding of ethical
alternatives
ART & IVF Any medically-appropriateregulation of ART
END OF LIFE
Assisted Suicide
Pain Management Education
RIGhTS OF CONSCIENCE
Protection for Individual
ProvidersComprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Institutions Comprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Payers Comprehensive ROC protection
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
7/124
Defending Life 2010
705
new YOrKrAnKing: 41
nw Yk lags fa bhid h sas i acig laws ha ad-
qualy pc h halh ad safy f a wa csidig
skig a abi. I ds hav ih a ifd cs
paal ivlv law, ds i pvid ffciv liis h
public fudig f abi.
ABOrTiOn:
nw Yk ds hav a ifd cs law f abi ad ds pc h
igh f pas b ivlvd i h abi dcisis f hi i daughs.
I Hope v. Perales, h du pcss pvisi f h nw Yk Csiui was i-
pd as pcig a was igh abi.
nw Yk axpays a quid fud dically cssay abis f w
civig public assisac.
New Yorks requirement that abortions after the rst trimester be performed in hospitals
is, ud cu fdal pcd, ufcabl. Hwv, h sa liis h pf-
ac f abis licsd physicias.
Hspials pvidig gcy ca f sxual assaul vicis us pvid gcy
cacpi.
nw Yk pvids fudig pgacy ca cs ad h abi alaivs.
th sa has a fcabl abi pig law, bu ds qui h pig
f ifai h Cs f Disas Cl ad Pvi (CDC). th asu
applis bh sugical ad sugical abis.
Halh plans ha provid prscripion covrag mus provid covrag for conracpion.
th provision includs an xmpion so narrow ha i xcluds h abiliy of mos m-
ployrs and insurrs wih moral or rligious objcions from xrcising h xmpion.
LegAL reCOgniTiOn Of UnBOrn AnD newLY BOrn:
Ud nw Yk law, h killig f a ub child af h 24h wk f pgacy is
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
8/124
706
Americans United for Life
dened as a homicide.
th sa allws wgful dah (civil) acis ly wh a ub child is b aliv
fllwig a glig ciial ac ad dis haf.
nw Yk law sas h ppuiy bai dical a f a ifa pau-ly b aliv i h cus f a abi shall b h sa as h ighs f a ifa b
spontaneously. Thus, the state has created a specic afrmative duty of physicians to
pvid dical ca ad a b-aliv ifas a ay sag f dvlp.
nw Yk has a Baby mss law, sablishig a saf hav f hs lgally lav
hi ifas a dsigad placs ad suig h ifas civ apppia ca ad
pci.
th sa fuds dug a pgas f pga w ad wbs.
BiOeTHiCS LAwS:
nw Yk aiais laws lad hua clig.
nw Yk aiais a isiu disbus sa is f dsuciv by -
sach.
Hwv, h sa ds facilia h dai f ubilical cd bld f s cll cl-
lci, psvai, ad sag f public piva us.
nw Yk gulas ccial sugacy, scig f s ds, ga dai,
ad isuac cvag f ifiliy.
enD Of Life LAwS:
nw Yk xpssly phibis assisd suicid. Ud a ciial sau, assisd suicid
is dened as a form of manslaughter. This prohibition has been upheld by the U.S. Su-
p Cu.
HeALTHCArerigHTS Of COnSCienCe LAwS:
Patcpato Aboto:
A ps wh bjcs i wiig ad h basis f ligius blifs cscic is
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
9/124
Defending Life 2010
707
quid pf assis i a abi.
Saff bs f h Sa Dpa f Scial Svics ay fus pvid faily
planning services if in conict with their cultural values, conscience, or religious convic-
is.
Patcpato rsach Hamul to Huma L:
nw Yk culy pvids pci f h ighs f halhca pvids wh
csciiusly bjc paicipai i hua clig, dsuciv by sach,
ad h fs f ial dical sach.
wHAT HAPPeneD in 2009:
nw Yk acd lgislai akig chical ccis pvisis dsigaig
suga dcisi-akig cis as guadias f ally-add pss f hpupss f halhca dcisis.
nw Yk csidd asus quiig ifd cs bf abi; quiig
w civ ifai abu fal pai; ad quiig paal ivlv. th
sa als csidd a ag f asus laig h ub ad wly b, f
unborn victims of violence measures, to the availability of stillbirth certicates, to ex-
pasi f h sas Baby mss law.
Cvsly, h sa csidd asus adaig isuac cvag f abi;
quiig sids civ dical aiig i cacpi ad abi, wihu x-cpi; ad ipsig buds gulais pgacy ca cs. nably, i
als dbad a sa Fd f Chic Ac.
nw Yk csidd asus pig h accssibiliy f gcy cacp-
i, adaig isuac cvag f cacpi, allwig uss ad phaaciss
disps gcy cacpi, ad pig gcy cacpi
nw Yk cllg capuss.
o h bihics f, h sa csidd lgislai pig dsuciv by
sach, baig clig f all pupss, ad gulaig assisd pduciv ch-lgis.
th sa csidd asus pig pp palliaiv ca ad pai aag
ad ducai.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
10/124
708
Americans United for Life
nw Yk csidd adig is xisig halhca ighs f cscic laws p-
hibi disciiai basd bjcis cai d-f-lif ca, lif-susaiig a-
, cacpi. Cvsly, h sa csidd lgislai quiig phaa-
cists and pharmacies to ll prescriptions without regard to religious or moral beliefs.
I Tummino v. Torti, h eas Disic f nw Yk uld ha Pla B (gcycacpi) shuld b ad availabl 17-ya-lds ad dicd h FDA c-
sid is plicis gadig is accss. th obaa Adiisai did appal
ad h FDA plas cply.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
11/124
Defending Life 2010
709
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR NEw yORK
Sort-term
Priorities
Additional
Goals
ABORTION
Informed Consent
Comprehensive informed
consent law with reection
period
Parental Involvement Parental notice or consent
State Rights & Policies
Amendment declaring no state
constitutional right to abortion;
continue to defend against state
FOCA
Abortion FundingLimits on use of state funding
for abortions
Abortion Provider
RequirementsAbortion clinic regulations
Abortion Bans
Regulation of Abortifacients Regulation of RU-486
PCCs Support Direct funding of PCCs
Abortion Reporting
LEGAL RECOGNITION AND PROTECTION FOR UNBORN & NEwLy BORN
Fetal HomicideComprehensive unborn victims
of violence protection
Assault on Unborn
Prohibitions on Wrongful
Birth & Wrongful Life
Lawsuits
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
12/124
710
Americans United for Life
Permit Wrongful Death
Lawsuits
Born-Alive Infant Protection
Abandoned Infant Protection
BIOEThICS
Human Cloning Ban on human cloning
DER Ban on DER
State Funding of DER Ban on state funding of DER
ART & IVFAny medically-appropriate
regulation of ART
END OF LIFE
Assisted Suicide
Pain Management Education
RIGhTS OF CONSCIENCE
Protection for Individual
ProvidersComprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Institutions Comprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Payers Comprehensive ROC protection
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
13/124
Defending Life 2010
711
nOrTH CArOLinArAnKing: 27
North Carolina lacks many common sense and life-afrming
laws. F xapl, nh Calia ds qui ifd
cs f abi ad ds pc ub vicis f
violence. Moreover, despite the signicant threats of abuse
ih i s bichlgis, nh Calia ds
gula dsuciv by sach, hua clig, assisd pduciv chlgis. Fi-
ally, nh Calia is f a sall ub f sas ha ds xpssly phibi assisd
suicid.
ABOrTiOn:
A physicia ay pf a abi a uacipad i ud h ag f
18 wihu h wi cs f pa a gadpa wih wh h i has
livd f a las six hs. A cu d ay b issud fgig h cs qui-
ment if the judge nds the minor is mature and well informed enough to make her own
dcisi, ha paal cs is i h bs is, ha sh is h vici f ap
flius ics.
nh Calia phibis public fudig f abi ulss h pgacy is h sul f
ap ics h was lif is a isk.
nh Calia has acd cphsiv gulais sablishig iiu halh ad
safy sadads f abi cliics. Ag h aas gulad a cliic adiisa-
tion, stafng, patient medical evaluations, and post-operative care.
oly physicias licsd pacic dici i nh Calia ay pf ab-
is.
th sa has a fcabl abi pig law, bu ds qui h pig
f ifai h Cs f Disas Cl ad Pvi (CDC). th asu
applis bh sugical ad sugical abis.
Halh isuac plas ha pvid pscipi cvag us als pvid cvag
f cacpi. th pvisi icluds a xpi s aw ha i xcluds h
abiliy f s plys ad isus wih al ligius bjcis f xcis-
ig h xpi.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
14/124
712
Americans United for Life
LegAL reCOgniTiOn Of UnBOrn AnD newLY BOrn:
Cu nh Calia law ds cgiz a ub child as a pial vici f
hicid assaul.
North Carolina denes criminal assaults on a pregnant woman that result in miscarriage,sillbih, daag pgacy as a hacd ffs f scig pupss.
th sa allws f wgful dah (civil) acis wh a viabl ub child is killd
hugh a glig ciial ac.
nh Calia ds qui ha ifas wh suviv a abi b giv apppi-
a dical ca.
nh Calia has a Baby mss law, sablishig a saf hav f hs lgally
lav hi ifas a dsigad placs ad suig h ifas civ apppia caad pci.
th sa fuds dug a pgas f pga w ad wbs.
BiOeTHiCS LAwS:
nh Calia aiais laws gadig hua clig, dsuciv by sach,
assisd pduciv chlgis.
nh Calia quis h Sa Dpa f Halh ad Hua Svics akpublicly availabl publicais ubilical cd s clls ad ubilical cd bld
bakig. th Dpa als cuags halhca pfssials pvid h pub-
licais hi pga pais.
enD Of Life LAwS:
nh Calias a f assisd suicid is ucla. Whil h sa has sauily
adpd h c law f cis, i has als ablishd h c law ci f sui-
cid. Assisd suicid ay sill b a c law ci.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
15/124
Defending Life 2010
713
HeALTHCAre
rigHTS Of COnSCienCe LAwS:
Patcpato Aboto:
A licsd physicia us wh bjcs ligius, al, hical guds is quid paicipa i abis.
A hspial h halhca isiui is quid pvid abis.
th sa pvids s pci f h civil ighs f phaaciss ad phaacis.
Patcpato rsach Hamul to Huma L:
nh Calia culy pvids pci f h ighs f halhca pvids
wh csciiusly bjc paicipai i hua clig, dsuciv by -sach, h fs f ial dical sach.
wHAT HAPPeneD in 2009:
nh Calia acd a law quiig h Sa Dpa f Halh ad Hua S-
vics ak publicly availabl publicais ubilical cd s clls ad ubilical
cd bld bakig.
North Carolina considered measures requiring informed consent with a 24 hour reec-
i pid, quiig aizd paal cs, quiig abi pvids pfulasuds, phibiig cvag f abi ud h sa halh pla, ad auhizig
Chs Lif lics plas.
The state also considered a measure dening a child born alive as a result of abortion as
a ps, as wll as a ub f asus pcig ub vicis f vilc.
nh Calia csidd a asu pvidig pci pss wh csci-
iusly bjc h pvisi f dugs dvics ha sul i abi.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
16/124
714
Americans United for Life
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
17/124
Defending Life 2010
715
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR NORTh CAROLINA
Sort-term
Priorities
Additional
Goals
ABORTION
Informed Consent
Comprehensive informed
consent law with reection
period
Parental Involvement
Parental consent enhancements
like notarized consent or
identication requirements
State Rights & Policies
Abortion FundingBan on use of state funding for
abortion counseling or referrals
Ban on use of state facilities for
abortion
Abortion Provider
Requirements
Abortion Bans
Regulation of Abortifacients Regulation of RU-486
PCCs Support Direct funding of PCCs
Abortion Reporting
LEGAL RECOGNITION AND PROTECTION FOR UNBORN & NEwLy BORN
Fetal HomicideComprehensive unborn victims
of violence protection
Assault on Unborn
Prohibitions on Wrongful
Birth & Wrongful Life
Lawsuits
Permit Wrongful Death
Lawsuits
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
18/124
716
Americans United for Life
Born-Alive Infant Protection
Abandoned Infant Protection
BIOEThICS
Human Cloning Ban on human cloning
DER Ban on DER
State Funding of DER Ban on state funding of DER
ART & IVFAny medically-appropriate
regulation of ART
END OF LIFE
Assisted SuicideStatutory prohibition on assisted
suicide
Pain Management Education
RIGhTS OF CONSCIENCE
Protection for Individual
ProvidersComprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Institutions Comprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Payers Comprehensive ROC protection
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
19/124
Defending Life 2010
717
nOrTH DAKOTArAnKing: 7
nh Daka has ak h lad i w ipa ad g-
ig aas: public fudig f abi alaivs ad aig-
ful gulai f bichlgis. nh Daka has allcad
hudds f husads f dllas i sa fuds gaizais
pig alaivs abi. I is als f ly a had-
ful f sas ha bas bh hua clig ad dsuciv by sach.
ABOrTiOn:
A physicia ay pf a abi a wa uil a las 24 hus af h
wa has b ifd f h dical isks assciad wih abi; h dical
isks f cayig h pgacy ; h pbabl gsaial ag f h ub child;
state assistance benets; the fathers legal obligations; the availability of state-prepared
ifai h dvlp f h ub child; ad a lis f agcis ha ff al-
ternatives to abortion. Women must be also be informed that "the abortion will terminate
h lif f a whl, spaa, uiqu, livig hua big.
Abi pvids us ff a wa h ppuiy viw a ulasud iag f
h ub child.
nh Daka phibis ay f ccig a wa i abi. Fuh, ic
us b psd a all abi faciliis saig ha ca fc a wa hav a
abi.
A physicia ay pf a abi a uaid i ud h ag f 18
wihu h wi cs f pa a cu d.
nh Daka phibis gaizais civig sa fuds f usig hs fuds
pvid abi cuslig ak fals f abi.
A abi ay b pfd i hspials wd pad by h sa, ulss h
abi is cssay psv h lif f h wa.
Sa halh isuac cacs, plicis, ad plas us xclud cvag f abi
ulss h abi is cssay psv h was lif. Piva isuac cpa-
is a als phibid f cvig abi xcp i cass f lif dag.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
20/124
718
Americans United for Life
oly physicias licsd by nh Daka pacic dici spahy -
plyd by h Uid Sas ay pf abis.
nh Daka has acd a asu baig abi shuld Roe v. Wade b v-
ud.
nh Daka phibis paial-bih abi.
nh Daka fuds gaizais ha p abi alaivs.
th sa has a fcabl abi pig law, bu ds qui h pig
f ifai h Cs f Disas Cl ad Pvi (CDC). th asu
applis bh sugical ad sugical abis.
th sa quis ha halh aiac gaizais cv pscipi cacp-
i faily plaig svics.
LegAL reCOgniTiOn Of UnBOrn AnD newLY BOrn:
Ud nh Daka ciial law, h killig f a ub child a ay sag f gsai
is dened as homicide.
North Dakota denes a nonfatal assault on an unborn child as a criminal offense.
The state has created a specic afrmative duty of physicians to provide medical care
ad a b-aliv ifas ly af viabiliy.
nh Daka quis halhca pfssials p suspcd paal dug xp-
su. I addii, halhca pfssials us s wbs f paal dug xp-
su wh h is adqua suspici f paal us by h h.
BiOeTHiCS LAwS:
nh Daka bas bh clig--pduc-child ad clig-f-bidical--
sach.
nh Daka bas fal xpiai.
nh Daka has acd a asu laig h ihiac ighs f child cad
hugh assisd pduciv chlgis.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
21/124
Defending Life 2010
719
enD Of Life LAwS:
I nh Daka, assisig a suicid is a fly.
HeALTHCAre
rigHTS Of COnSCienCe LAwS:
Patcpato Aboto:
A hspial, physicia, us, hspial ply, ay h ps is ud a lgal
duy cacual bligai paicipa i abis.
Patcpato rsach Hamul to Huma L:
nh Daka culy pvids pci f h ighs f halhca pvids wh
csciiusly bjc paicipai i hua clig, dsuciv by sach,ad h fs f ial dical sach.
wHAT HAPPeneD in 2009:
nh Daka acd a asu quiig ha a abi pvid ff a wa h
ppuiy viw a ulasud iag f h ub child.
th sa als acd a asu aid a pvig ccd abis, quiig ha
ic b psd a all abi faciliis saig ha ca fc a wa hav
a abi.
th sa add is ifd cs quis iclud a sa ha a
abi will ia h lif f a whl, spaa, uiqu, livig hua big.
nh Daka als acd lgislai pvidig dic fudig abi alaivs.
nh Daka acd a asu lad ihiac ighs f child cad hugh
assisd pduciv chlgis.
th sa als acd a asu caig a gisy f advac dicivs f halh-ca.
nh Daka did csid ay asus lad halhca ighs f cscic.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
22/124
720
Americans United for Life
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
23/124
Defending Life 2010
721
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR NORTh DAKOTA
Sort-term
Priorities
Additional
Goals
ABORTION
Informed Consent Counseling on fetal pain
Parental Involvement
Parental consent enhancements
like notarized consent or
identication requirements
State Rights & PoliciesResolution opposing federal
FOCA
Abortion Funding
Abortion Provider
Requirements
Comprehensive abortion clinic
regulations
Abortion Bans
Regulation of Abortifacients Regulation of RU-486
PCCs Support
Abortion Reporting
LEGAL RECOGNITION AND PROTECTION FOR UNBORN & NEwLy BORN
Fetal Homicide
Assault on Unborn
Prohibitions on WrongfulBirth & Wrongful Life
Lawsuits
Permit Wrongful Death
Lawsuits
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
24/124
722
Americans United for Life
Born-Alive Infant Protection
Abandoned Infant Protection
BIOEThICS
Human Cloning
DER
State Funding of DER Funding of ethical alternatives
ART & IVFAny medically-appropriate
regulation of ART
END OF LIFE
Assisted Suicide
Pain Management Education
RIGhTS OF CONSCIENCE
Protection for Individual
ProvidersComprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Institutions Comprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Payers Comprehensive ROC protection
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
25/124
Defending Life 2010
723
OHiOrAnKing: 17
ohi aiais faily cphsiv pcis f w ad h
ub, icludig a gulai quiig abi pvids abid by
h FDA-appvd pcl wh adiisig h dagus ab-
i dug, rU-486. Hwv, h sa has fall bhid i gula-
ig bichlgis, failig ba v gula dsuciv by
sach hua clig. ohi als fails pc halhca pvids wh csciiusly
bjc paicipaig i such ial sach.
ABOrTiOn:
A physicia ay pf a abi a wa uil a las 24 hus af h
physicia ifs h f h au f h ppsd abi pcdu ad is isks; h
pbabl gsaial ag f h ub child; ad h dical isks f cayig h pg-
acy . th physicia us als pvid sa-ppad aials dscibig h
dvlp f h ub child; public ad piva agcis pvidig assisac; sa
medical assistance benets; and the fathers legal obligations.
ohi quis abi pvids ff a wa h ppuiy viw a ulasud
ad bai a cpy f h iag wh a ulasud is pfd as pa f h ppaa-
i f a abi.
Abi faciliis us ps sigs ifig w ha ca fc h hav
abis. th law als icass h paly f dsic vilc if h ffd kw
h wa was pga, ad pis cvy f cpsay ad xplay da-
ags wh aday ps fail p suspcd abus.
A physicia ay pf a abi a uacipad i ud h ag f
18 uil civig h cs f pa guadia.
ohi phibis public fuds f big usd f abis ulss h pcdu is cs-
say psv h lif f h wa h pgacy is h sul f ap ics.
ohi phibis isuac cvag f abi f gv plys, h us f
public fuds f abi cuslig, ad h us f public faciliis pf ab-
is.
Sa ply halh isuac ay pvid cvag f abi ulss h ab-
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
26/124
724
Americans United for Life
i is cssay psv h was lif, h pgacy is h sul f ap
ics, a addiial piu is paid f a pial id.
ohi licss ad gulas abi cliics as a subs f abulay sugical cs.
All abi pvids us aiai adiig pivilgs.
ohi liis h pfac f abis licsd physicias.
ohi phibis paial-bih abi hughu pgacy ud a law which has b
liigad ad uphld i fdal cu.
I 2004, ohi acd a law gulaig h pvisi f rU-486 ad caig ciial
palis f pvidig h dug wihu fllwig FDA-appvd guidlis. th law
als quis abi pvids if h sa dical bad whv rU-486
lads sius cplicais. I July 2009, h Sixh Cicui Cu f Appals va-
cad a lw cu ijuci agais h law, allwig h law b fcd.
ohi pis iss pay a $30 f f Chs Lif spcialy lics plas, wih
$20 from the proceeds of each plate designated for non-prot groups that encourage
adpi. I 2007, h sa als allcad $150,000 v w yas a Chs Lif
fud.
th sa has a fcabl abi pig law, bu ds qui h pig f
ifai h Cs f Disas Cl ad Pvi (CDC). th asu ap-
plis bh sugical ad sugical abis ad quis abi pvids p
sh- cplicais.
th sa quis halh aiac gaizais cv pscipi cacpi
ad faily plaig svics.
LegAL reCOgniTiOn Of UnBOrn AnD newLY BOrn:
Ud ohi ciial law, h killig f a ub child a ay sag f gsai is hi-
cid.
Ohio denes a nonfatal assault on an unborn child as a crime.
ohi allws wgful dah (civil) acis wh a viabl ub child is killd hugh
glig ciial ac.
ohi has a Baby mss law, sablishig a saf hav f hs lgally lav hi
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
27/124
Defending Life 2010
725
ifas a dsigad placs ad suig h ifas civ apppia ca ad pc-
i.
th sa fuds dug a pgas f pga w ad wbs.
Under the Grieving Parents Act, the state requires a fetal death certicate and burialf h dah f a ub child.
BiOeTHiCS LAwS:
ohi aiais laws gadig hua clig dsuciv by sach, bu
bas fal xpiai.
ohi aiais iial guidac laig assisd pduciv chlgis (Art)
ad gulas isuac cvag f Art svics.
enD Of Life LAwS:
ohi has dclad ha assisd suicid is agais public plicy. Hwv, cu ohi
law does not specically criminalize assisted suicide. Under existing Ohio laws, an
ijuci ay b issud pv a halhca pfssial f paicipaig i a
suicid, ad assisig a suicid is guds f pfssial discipli.
HeALTHCAre
rigHTS Of COnSCienCe LAwS:
Patcpato Aboto:
n ps is quid paicipa i dical pcdus ha sul i abi.
A hspial is quid pi is faciliis b usd f abis.
Patcpato rsach Hamul to Huma L:
ohi culy pvids pci f h ighs f halhca pvids wh csci-
iusly bjc paicipai i hua clig, dsuciv by sach, hfs f ial dical sach.
wHAT HAPPeneD in 2009:
ohi acd lgislai quiig abi faciliis ps sigs ifig w ha
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
28/124
726
Americans United for Life
ca fc h hav abis. th asu als icass h paly f
dsic vilc if h ffd kw h wa was pga, ad pis cvy
f cpsay ad xplay daags wh aday ps fail p sus-
pcd abus.
th sa als csidd asus ppsig a fdal Fd f Chic Ac, as wllas lgislai lad paal cs.
ohi csidd lgislai suppig ubilical cd bld bakig ad dai.
th sa did csid ay asus lad halhca ighs f cscic.
th ohi Sup Cu uld ha is 2004 rU-486 law quis abi pvids
disps h dug accdig h dug labl ad ha i ca ly b dispsd w
through 49 days gestation. With that clarication in hand, the Sixth Circuit Court of Ap-
pals vacad a bad ijuci d by a lw cu i a fdal challg hlaw, allowing the law to nally be enforced.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
29/124
Defending Life 2010
727
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR OhIO
Sort-term
Priorities
Additional
Goals
ABORTION
Informed Consent Fetal pain counseling
Parental Involvement
Enhancements such as
notarized consent or
identication requirements
State Rights & Policies
Abortion Funding
Abortion Provider
Requirements
Abortion BansSex-selective ban or delayed
enforcement law
Regulation of Abortifacients
PCCs Support Continued funding of PCCs
Abortion ReportingMandatory reporting of abortion
complications
LEGAL RECOGNITION AND PROTECTION FOR UNBORN & NEwLy BORN
Fetal Homicide
Assault on Unborn
Prohibitions on WrongfulBirth & Wrongful Life
Lawsuits
Permit Wrongful Death
Lawsuits
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
30/124
728
Americans United for Life
Born-Alive Infant Protection
Abandoned Infant Protection
BIOEThICS
Human Cloning Ban on human cloning
DER Ban on DER
State Funding of DER Ban on state funding of DER
ART & IVFAny medically-appropriate
regulation of ART
END OF LIFE
Assisted SuicideStatutory prohibition on assisted
suicide
Pain Management Education
RIGhTS OF CONSCIENCE
Protection for Individual
ProvidersComprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Institutions Comprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Payers Comprehensive ROC protection
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
31/124
Defending Life 2010
729
OKLAHOMArAnKing: 2
I c yas, oklaha has ad ga sids i pc-
ing both women and the unborn. Among several life-afrm-
ig asus passd i 2009, bh huss f h oklaha
lgislau acd a AUL-dafd slui dclaig
hi ppsii h fdal Fd f Chic Ac.
ABOrTiOn:
oklaha quis ha, 24 hus bf a abi, a wa civ cuslig
h dical isks f abi ad pgacy, h a f h physicia pfig h
abi, ad h gsaial ag f h ub child. th wa us als civ
ifai aaical ad physilgical chaacisics f ub child a diff-
sags f dvlp ad h igh civ sa-ppad aials pial
government benets, child support, and a list of support agencies and their services.
oklaha has suppld is ifd cs quis, adaig ha w
skig abis a 20 wks gsai la civ ifai abu fal pai ad
quiig ha w b giv h ppuiy viw a ulasud pi udg-
ig abis.
A physicia ay pf a abi a uacipad i wihu h c-
s f a pa guadia. A pa guadia us sig a cs f ad pvid
photo identication, and the abortion provider must also sign a document attesting to
the quality of the identication provided. In a medical emergency, an abortion provider
us ify a pa guadia f h is abi lss ha 24 hus af h
pcdu, ulss h i bais a judicial waiv.
Oklahoma has amended its denition of abortion to include the use of abortifacients
(such as RU-486). It has also amended the denition of medical emergency as applied
all f is abi laws, awig h xcpi xclud al halh ad apply-
ig i ly cass wh a physical cdii culd caus aj ipai f a bdily
fuci dah.
oklaha axpays a quid fud abis xcp wh h abi is c-
ssay psv h was lif h pgacy is h sul f ap ics ha
has b pd h plic a cusl.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
32/124
730
Americans United for Life
oklaha phibis axpay fudig f ay iy assciad wih ah iy ha
pvids, cusls, fs f abi ad phibis halh isuac cvag f
lciv abis. th sa als sics h us f sa faciliis f h pfac
f abi.
oklaha law adas ha abi cliics iial halh ad safy sadads.th gulais pscib iiu sadads f h buildig faciliy, cliic adiis-
ai, ad pai dical valuais. A addiial qui ha abis af
the rst trimester be performed in a hospital has been ruled unconstitutional.
oly physicias licsd pacic dici i oklaha ay pf abis.
oklaha psssss a fcabl abi phibii shuld h U.S. Csiui b
amended or certain U.S. Supreme Court decisions be reversed or modied.
oklaha phibis paial-bih abis ad sx-slciv abis.
oklaha has dicd h Sa Dpa f Halh facilia fudig gv-
al iis ha pvid alaivs abi svics. th Sa has allcad
dic axpay fudig abi alaivs.
The state also offers Choose Life license plates, the proceeds of which benet preg-
acy ca cs ad/ h gaizais pvidig abi alaivs.
Abortion providers must report specic and detailed information, including information
h ub f w civig sa abi cuslig aials ad h ubf abis xpd f h cuslig qui bcaus f a dical -
gency. In addition, abortion providers must report specic and detailed information
gadig is abis, icludig whh physicias civd h aday pa-
al cs, whh is sugh judicial bypass, ad whh such bypass
was gad. th asu applis bh sugical ad sugical abis, bu i is
quid ha ay f his ifai b pd h Cs f Disas Cl
ad Pvi (CDC).
th sa quis halh aiac gaizais cv pscipi cacpi
faily plaig svics.
LegAL reCOgniTiOn Of UnBOrn AnD newLY BOrn:
oklaha ciializs h ulawful killig f a ub child f h f
ccpi.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
33/124
Defending Life 2010
731
oklaha als ciializs a faal assaul a ub child.
The states newly-enacted Pregnant Womans Protection Act provides an afrma-
iv dfs w wh us fc pc hi ub child f ciial
assauls.
oklaha allws wgful dah (civil) acis wh a viabl ub child is killd
hugh a glig ciial ac.
Ud oklaha law, h ighs dical a f a ifa pauly b
aliv i h cus f a abi shall b h sa as h ighs f a ifa f siila
medical status prematurely born. Thus, the state has created a specic afrmative duty
f physicias pvid dical ca ad a b-aliv ifas a ay sag f
dvlp.
oklaha has a Baby mss law, sablishig a saf hav f hs lgally
lav hi ifas a dsigad placs ad suig h ifas civ apppia ca
ad pci.
oklaha quis halhca pfssials p suspcd paal dug xpsu.
BiOeTHiCS LAwS:
oklaha bas dsuciv by sach ad hua clig f all pupss. th
sa als bas fal xpiai.
oklaha has cad a Advisy Cucil Cd Bld/S Cll Dais ad has
allcad fudig f a sa us fud hical fs f s cll sach.
oklaha gulas h dai ad asf f hua bys usd i assisd p-
duciv chlgis ad sablishs ha ds f bys liquish all paal ighs
wih spc h dai f ay sulig child.
enD Of Life LAwS:
I oklaha, assisig a suicid is a fly.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
34/124
732
Americans United for Life
HeALTHCAre
rigHTS Of COnSCienCe LAwS:
Patcpato Aboto:
n ps is quid paicipa i dical pcdus ha sul i a i ppaa-i f a abi xcp wh cssay psv a was lif.
A piva hspial is quid pi abis wihi is faciliis.
Patcpato rsach Hamul to Huma L:
oklaha culy pvids pci f h ighs f halhca pvids wh
csciiusly bjc paicipai i hua clig, dsuciv by sach,
ad h fs f ial dical sach. A 2008 law pvidig such pci is
culy i liigai.
wHAT HAPPeneD in 2009:
I a vy busy lgislaiv sssi, oklaha acd lgislai dclaig h lgisla-
us ppsii a fdal Fd f Chic Ac.
th sa acd h AUL-dafd Pga Was Pci Ac, which pvids
an afrmative defense to women who use force to protect their unborn children from
ciial assauls.
oklaha acd a asu phibiig sx-slciv abis. th asu als -
quis abi pvids p cai ifai abu ws ad is ab-
is f saisical pupss. this asu is i liigai.
th sa acd lgislai ha fuds abi alaivs.
o h bihics f, oklaha acd lgislai baig dsuciv by -
sach ad clig f all pupss. th sa als csidd asus fudig hical
alaivs, gulaig assisd pduciv chlgis, ad gulaig by da-
i ad adpi.
oklaha acd a asu caig a gisy f advac dicivs f halhca.
th sa als csidd a asu akig i ulawful pacic ivial pai
aag wihu licsig.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
35/124
Defending Life 2010
733
th sa csidd a dacia asu quiig ha pscipis f cacpivs
be lled without delay, as well as legislation requiring insurance coverage of contra -
cpivs.
I Augus 2009, a sa cu judg ivalidad a 2008 ibus pvisi quiig a
wa udg a ulasud pi abi; gulaig h pvisi f rU-486;quiig abi cliic psl hav a piva sssi wih is su dci-
sis a h sul f cci; phibiig ccd abis; ad allwig idi-
vidual halhca pvids ad idividual dical faciliis dcli paicipa i
abis, dsuciv bichlgis, ad assisd suicid basd al ligius
beliefs. However, the state ofcials intend to appeal the ruling to the Oklahoma Supreme
Cu.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
36/124
734
Americans United for Life
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
37/124
Defending Life 2010
735
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR OKLAhOMA
Sort-term
Priorities
Additional
Goals
ABORTION
Informed Consent
Parental Involvement Coerced abortion prevention
State Rights & Policies
Abortion Funding
Abortion Provider
Requirements
Abortion Bans
Regulation of Abortifacients
PCCs Support Continued funding of PCCs
Abortion Reporting
LEGAL RECOGNITION AND PROTECTION FOR UNBORN & NEwLy BORN
Fetal Homicide
Assault on Unborn
Prohibitions on Wrongful
Birth & Wrongful LifeLawsuits
Permit Wrongful Death
Lawsuits
Remove viability requirement
from wrongful death actions
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
38/124
736
Americans United for Life
Born-Alive Infant Protection
Abandoned Infant Protection
BIOEThICS
Human Cloning Ban on human cloning
DER Ban on DER
State Funding of DERContinued funding of ethical
alternatives
ART & IVFAny medically-appropriate
regulation of ART
END OF LIFE
Assisted Suicide
Pain Management Education
RIGhTS OF CONSCIENCE
Protection for Individual
ProvidersComprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Institutions Comprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Payers Comprehensive ROC protection
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
39/124
Defending Life 2010
737
OregOnrAnKing: 42
og has a disal cd f failig pc w, h u-
b, h sick, ad h dyig. F xapl, og ds a-
da ifd cs paal ivlv f abi, ds
cgiz a ub child as a pial vici f hicid
assaul, ad ds lii dsuciv by sach hua
clig. ms disubig is ogs law piig physicia-
assisd suicid.
ABOrTiOn:
og ds pvid v udiay pci f w csidig abis.
th sa ds hav a ifd cs law, a paal ivlv law f is
skig abis, abi cliic gulais, ulasud quis, a phibii
ay h ha a licsd physicia pfig a abi.
og axpays fud dically cssay abis f w ligibl f sa
dical assisac f gal ca.
og has sablishd h Sxual Assaul Vicis egcy mdical rsps
Fud, which pays f dical asssss ad h pvisi f gcy ca-
cpi vicis f sxual assaulicludig h pvisi f ad pscipi f
gcy cacpi is.
Hspials us pvid sxual assaul vicis wih ifai abu ad accss
gcy cacpi.
th sa has a fcabl abi pig law, bu ds qui h pig f
ifai h Cs f Disas Cl ad Pvi (CDC). th asu ap-
plis bh sugical ad sugical abis ad quis abi pvids p
sh- cplicais.
Halh plas ha pvid pscipi cvag us als cv pscipi cacp-
ivs. rligius plys ay fus cvag if hi piay pups is h iculca-
i f ligius valus, piaily ply ad sv ppl wih h sa valus, ad a
nonprot entities under federal law.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
40/124
738
Americans United for Life
LegAL reCOgniTiOn Of UnBOrn AnD newLY BOrn:
Cu og law ds cgiz a ub child as a pial vici f hicid
assaul.
th sa allws wgful dah (civil) acis wh a viabl ub child is killdhugh a glig ciial ac.
og ds qui ha a ifa wh suvivs a abi b giv apppia,
pially lif-savig dical ca.
og has a Baby mss law, sablishig a saf hav f hs lgally lav
hi ifas a dsigad placs ad suig h ifas civ apppia ca ad
pci.
th sa fuds dug a pgas f pga w ad wbs.
BiOeTHiCS LAwS:
og aiais laws gadig hua clig dsuciv by sach.
Oregon mandates that only physicians perform articial insemination procedures.
enD Of Life LAwS:
Oregon permits physician-assisted suicide under statutorily-specied circumstances.
HeALTHCAre
rigHTS Of COnSCienCe LAwS:
Patcpato Aboto:
A physicia is quid paicipa i giv advic abu abi if h sh
disclss his lci h pai.
A hspial ply dical saff b is quid paicipa i abisif he or she has notied the hospital of this election.
A piva hspial is quid adi a wa f a abi.
Dpa f Hua Svics plys wh bjc i wiig ay fus ff
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
41/124
Defending Life 2010
739
faily plaig ad bih cl svics.
Patcpato rsach Hamul to Huma L:
og culy pvids pci f h ighs f halhca pvids wh c-
sciiusly bjc paicipai i hua clig, dsuciv by sach, h fs f ial dical sach.
wHAT HAPPeneD in 2009:
og add is laws f advac dicivs, givig h halhca psaiv h
auhiy appv sh- hspializai f dia pais.
og csidd lgislai xpadig is hicid laws iclud h killig f a
ub child.
og csidd lgislai pig ad fudig dsuciv by sach. th
sa als csidd lgislai ha discuagd clig--pduc-child, as wll as
a asu quiig halh cvag f a f ifiliy.
th sa did csid ay lgislai lad halhca ighs f cscic.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
42/124
740
Americans United for Life
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
43/124
Defending Life 2010
741
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR OREGON
Sort-term
Priorities
Additional
Goals
ABORTION
Informed ConsentComprehensive informed
consent with reection period
Parental Involvement Parental notice or consent
State Rights & Policies
Abortion FundingLimits on state funding of
abortion
Abortion Provider
RequirementsAbortion clinic regulations
Abortion Bans
Regulation of Abortifacients Regulation of RU-486
PCCs Support
Abortion Reporting
LEGAL RECOGNITION AND PROTECTION FOR UNBORN & NEwLy BORN
Fetal HomicideComprehensive unborn victims
of violence protection
Assault on Unborn
Prohibitions on Wrongful
Birth & Wrongful LifeLawsuits
Permit Wrongful Death
Lawsuits
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
44/124
742
Americans United for Life
Born-Alive Infant Protection
Abandoned Infant Protection
BIOEThICS
Human Cloning Ban on human cloning
DER Ban on DER
State Funding of DER Ban on state funding of DER
ART & IVFAny medically-appropriate
regulation of ART
END OF LIFE
Assisted SuicideRepeal of law permitting
assisted suicide
Pain Management Education
RIGhTS OF CONSCIENCE
Protection for Individual
ProvidersComprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Institutions Comprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Payers Comprehensive ROC protection
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
45/124
Defending Life 2010
743
PennSYLvAniArAnKing: 3
Psylvaias ffs pc w f h gaiv cs-
qucs f abi hav b gud-bakig, as ializd i
h ladak casPlanned Parenthood v. Casey. Psylvaia has
ld h way f h sas by acig such asus as ifd
cs, paal cs, ad sa fudig f abi alaivs. Hwv, h has b
lil ff gula hua clig.
ABOrTiOn:
I h ladak cas, Planned Parenthood v. Casey, Psylvaias ifd cs
requirements, mandated 24-hour reection period prior to an abortion, and parental con-
s qui f a i skig a abi w uphld as csiuial by h
U.S. Sup Cu.
th sa quis abi pvids sa i hi pid aials ha i is illgal f
s cc a wa i havig a abi.
Psylvaia ds pvid public fudig public faciliis f a abi ulss
h abi is cssay psv h was lif h pgacy is h sul f
ap ics.
Halh plas fudd by h sa ay iclud cvag f abis ulss a ab-
i is cssay psv a was lif, h pgacy is h sul f ap ics
pd by h wa a law fc agcy, h is a fal abaliy.
Psylvaia phibis gaizais ha civ sa fuds f usig hs fuds
pvid abi cuslig ak fals f abi. th sa als sics h
us f s all sa faciliis f h pfac f abi.
Psylvaia adas iiu halh ad safy sadads f abi cliics. th
regulations prescribe minimum requirements for the building or facility, stafng, clinic
adiisai, pai dical valuais, ad ps-paiv ca. ths sadads
require a patient safety plan and the reporting of serious incidents (as dened in theablig lgislai). Abi pvids us als aiai hspial adiig pivi-
lgs.
oly physicias dcs f spahy licsd pacic dici i Psylvaia
ay pf abis.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
46/124
744
Americans United for Life
Psylvaia has allcad illis f dllas abi alaiv pgas. eiis
civig h fuds ca pf abis pvid abi cuslig.
Psylvaia ffs Chs Lif lics plas, h pcds f which a usd fud
adpi ad abi alaivs svics.
th sa has a fcabl abi pig law, bu ds qui h pig f
ifai h Cs f Disas Cl ad Pvi (CDC). th asu ap-
plis bh sugical ad sugical abis ad quis abi pvids p
sh- cplicais.
LegAL reCOgniTiOn Of UnBOrn AnD newLY BOrn:
Ud Psylvaia ciial law, h killig f a ub child a ay sag f gsai
is dened as homicide.
Pennsylvania denes a nonfatal assault on an unborn child as a criminal offense.
th sa allws wgful dah (civil) acis wh a viabl ub child is killd
hugh a glig ciial ac.
The state has created a specic afrmative duty for physicians to provide medical care
ad a b-aliv ifas a ay sag f dvlp.
Psylvaia fuds dug a pgas f pga w ad wbs.
Psylvaia law pvids f fal dah gisais.
BiOeTHiCS LAwS:
Psylvaia phibis haful xpiai ay ub child, which is d-
ned as an individual organism of the species homo sapiens f filizai uil liv
bih. th law ay b ipd als phibi haful xpiai cld
hua bys.
Psylvaia aiais faily cphsiv gulais f assisd pduciv ch-lgis (Art), icludig wh ay pacic ad paicipa i h svics, cd kp-
ig, ad sadads f aiac f cliical faciliis ivlvd i Art. I als quis
qualy ps f Art daa, icludig ub f ggs filizd, dsyd, dis-
cadd ad h ub f w iplad.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
47/124
Defending Life 2010
745
enD Of Life LAwS:
I Psylvaia, assisig a suicid is a fly.
HeALTHCAre
rigHTS Of COnSCienCe LAwS:
Patcpato Aboto:
If a bjci is ad i wiig ad is basd ligius, al, pfssial
guds, a physicia, us, saff b, h ply f a hspial halhca
faciliy is quid paicipa i abis ad ca b hld liabl f fusig
paicipa. mdical ad usig suds a als pcd.
excp f faciliis ha pf abis xclusivly, ach faciliy ha pfs ab-
is us pily ps a ic f h igh paicipa i abis.
A piva hspial h halhca faciliy is quid pf abis ad
ay b hld liabl f his fusal.
Psylvaia als pcs halhca pvids wh bjc pvidig abifacis.
Patcpato rsach Hamul to Huma L:
Psylvaia culy pvids pci f h ighs f halhca pvids wh
csciiusly bjc paicipai i hua clig, dsuciv by sach, h fs f ial dical sach.
wHAT HAPPeneD in 2009:
Psylvaia acd lgislai fudig abi alaivs ad pvidig f sill-
birth certicates.
Psylvaia csidd lgislai quiig halhca pvids p a
f a i wh is pga has a sxually asid disas psv vidc
agais sxual ffds. th sa als csidd lgislai quiig paal i-vlv f is skig cacpi ad asus pcig ub vicis f
vilc.
Cvsly, h sa csidd lgislai quiig hspials ad halhca faciliis
pvid ifai abu ad accss gcy cacpi, as wll as asus
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
48/124
746
Americans United for Life
quiig isuac cvag f abi.
Psylvaia csidd lgislai allwig physicia-assisd suicid, bu i als c-
sidd asus aid a ipvig h qualiy f ca f pais suffig pai.
Psylvaia did csid ay asus lad bihics halhca ighs fcscic.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
49/124
Defending Life 2010
747
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR PENNSyLVANIA
Sort-term
Priorities
Additional
Goals
ABORTION
Informed Consent
Enhancements such as
ultrasound requirement,
counseling on fetal pain, and/or
coerced abortion prevention
Parental Involvement
Enhancements such as
notarized consent or
identication requirements
State Rights & Policies
Abortion Funding
Abortion Provider
Requirements
Abortion Bans
Regulation of Abortifacients Regulation of RU-486
PCCs Support Continued funding of PCCs
Abortion Reporting
LEGAL RECOGNITION AND PROTECTION FOR UNBORN & NEwLy BORN
Fetal Homicide
Assault on Unborn
Prohibitions on Wrongful
Birth & Wrongful Life
Lawsuits
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
50/124
748
Americans United for Life
Permit Wrongful Death
Lawsuits
Born-Alive Infant Protection
Abandoned Infant Protection
BIOEThICS
Human Cloning Ban on human cloning
DER Ban on DER
State Funding of DER Ban on state funding of DER
ART & IVFAny medically-appropriate
regulation of ART
END OF LIFE
Assisted Suicide
Pain Management Education
RIGhTS OF CONSCIENCE
Protection for Individual
ProvidersComprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Institutions Comprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Payers Comprehensive ROC protection
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
51/124
Defending Life 2010
749
rHODe iSLAnDrAnKing: 28
Whil rhd Islad aiais s basic pci f w ad
is, i 2009, h sa csidd lgislai ha wuld hav -
dagd ha pci. F xapl, h sa csidd a sa
Fd f Chic Ac, which wuld hav ivalidad all xisig
abi-lad laws, ad a asu ha wuld hav allwd a physi-
cia psychiais uilaally cclud a i shuld b quid bai paal
cs bf abi, hus hwaig cu sa law.
ABOrTiOn:
A physicia ay pf a abi a wa uil h physicia h physi-
cias ag has ifd h f h pbabl gsaial ag f h ub child ad h
au ad isks f h ppsd abi pcdu. th wa us als sig a sa-
idicaig sh was ifd ha, if sh dcids cay h child , sh ay
b abl plac h child wih ih a laiv, wih ah faily hugh fs
ca adpi.
A physicia ay pf a abi a uacipad i ud h ag f
18 wihu h cs f pa a cu d.
rhd Islad axpays a quid fud abis xcp wh cssay p-
sv h was lif h pgacy is h sul f ap ics.
th sa halh isuac pla pvids abi cvag wh a was lif halh
is dagd i cass f ap, ics, fal abaliy.
rhd Islad has a cplx sys f abi cliic gulais ud which diff
sadads apply a diff sags f pgacy, ad diff faciliis ay b usd
pf abis a diff sags f gsai.
rhd Islad psssss a fcabl abi phibii shuld h U.S. Csiui
be amended or certain U.S. Supreme Court decisions be reversed or modied.
th sa has a fcabl abi pig law, bu ds qui h pig
f ifai h Cs f Disas Cl ad Pvi (CDC). th asu
applis bh sugical ad sugical abis.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
52/124
750
Americans United for Life
Halh isuac plas which pvid pscipi cvag a als quid pvid
cvag f cacpi. th pvisi icluds a xpi s aw ha i x-
cluds h abiliy f s plys ad isus wih al ligius bjcis f
xcisig h xpi.
LegAL reCOgniTiOn Of UnBOrn AnD newLY BOrn:
Ud rhd Islad law, h killig f a ub child af quickig (discibl
v i h wb) is hicid.
th sa allws wgful dah (civil) acis wh a viabl ub child is killd
hugh a glig ciial ac.
Ay physicia, us, h licsd dical ps wh kwigly ad ii-
ally fails pvid asabl dical ca ad a a ifa b aliv i h
cus f a abi, ad as a sul h ifa dis, shall b guily f h ci f a-slaughter. Thus, the state has created a specic afrmative duty to provide medical care
ad a b-aliv ifas a ay sag f dvlp.
The state denes substance abuse during pregnancy as child abuse under civil child-
wlfa saus. rhd Islad als quis halhca pfssials p suspcd
paal dug xpsu.
rhd Islad aiais a asu allwig a wa wh lss a child af 20 wks
gestation to obtain a certicate of birth resulting in still birth. The certicate is also led
wih h sa gisa.
BiOeTHiCS LAwS:
rhd Islad bas clig--pduc-child, hus akig i a cl-ad-kill sa.
rhd Islad bas haful xpiai a hua fus whh bf af
expulsion from its mothers womb. Fetus is dened to include an embryo.
th sa gulas isuac cvag f assisd pduciv chlgis.
enD Of Life LAwS:
Ud rhd Islad law, assisig a suicid is a fly.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
53/124
Defending Life 2010
751
HeALTHCAre
rigHTS Of COnSCienCe LAwS:
Patcpato Aboto:
A physicia h ps assciad wih, plyd by, h saff f a halhcafaciliy wh bjcs i wiig ad ligius ad/ al guds is quid
paicipa i abis.
Patcpato rsach Hamul to Huma L:
rhd Islad pvids pci f h ighs f halhca pvids wh csci-
iusly bjc paicipai i hua clig, dsuciv by sach, ad h
fs f ial dical sach.
wHAT HAPPeneD in 2009:
rhd Islad csidd lgislai quiig ifd cs bf abi; phib-
iig cci; quiig a ulasud bf abi; ad phibiig h us f public
faciliis, public plys, ad public fuds f h pups f pfig, assisig
i, cuagig a abi. th sa als csidd asus pcig ub
vicis f vilc.
Cvsly, h sa csidd a sa Fd f Chic Ac ad a asu dify-
ig h sas paal ivlv sau allw a physicia psychiais c-
clud a i shuld bai a abi wihu paal cs judicial auhiza-i.
th sa csidd halhca ighs f cscic lgislai pvidig cph-
siv pci f pvids, isiuis, ad pays, bu i als csidd a asu
quiig phaacis disps pscipi ad v-h-cu cacpivs wih-
u gad al ligius bjci.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
54/124
752
Americans United for Life
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
55/124
Defending Life 2010
753
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR RhODE ISLAND
Sort-term
Priorities
Additional
Goals
ABORTION
Informed Consent
Comprehensive informed
consent law with reection
period
Parental Involvement
State Rights & Policies
Abortion Funding Ban on use of state funding forabortion counseling or referrals
Ban on use of state facilities forabortion
Abortion Provider
Requirements
Abortion Bans
Regulation of Abortifacients Regulation of RU-486
PCCs Support Direct funding of PCCs
Abortion Reporting
LEGAL RECOGNITION AND PROTECTION FOR UNBORN & NEwLy BORN
Fetal HomicideProtection for unborn from
conception
Assault on Unborn
Prohibitions on WrongfulBirth & Wrongful Life
Lawsuits
Permit Wrongful Death
Lawsuits
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
56/124
754
Americans United for Life
Born-Alive Infant Protection
Abandoned Infant Protection
BIOEThICS
Human Cloning Ban on human cloning
DER Ban on DER
State Funding of DER Ban on state funding of DER
ART & IVFAny medically-appropriate
regulation of ART
END OF LIFE
Assisted Suicide
Pain Management Education
RIGhTS OF CONSCIENCE
Protection for Individual
ProvidersComprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Institutions Comprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Payers Comprehensive ROC protection
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
57/124
Defending Life 2010
755
SOUTH CArOLinArAnKing: 18
South Carolina maintains a number of life-afrming laws, includ-
ig cphsiv abi cliic gulais. Whil Suh Ca-
lia has acd c ss gulais pc w f
h gaiv csqucs f abi, i has faild discuag
ial ad dsuciv sach hua bys.
ABOrTiOn:
A physicia ay pf a abi a wa uil af sh is ifd f h
pbabl gsaial ag f h ub child; h abi pcdu b usd; ad
h availabiliy f sa-ppad, wi aials dscibig fal dvlp, lisig
agcis ffig alaivs abi, ad dscibig availabl dical assisac
benets.
If a wa chss viw h sa-ppad, wi aials, sh us b giv a
least a one-hour reection period before an abortion can be performed.
Suh Calia quis a wa b ffd a ulasud ad h ppuiy viw
h iag pi abi.
Ulss h pgacy is h sul f ics, a physicia ay pf a abi
a uacipad i ud h ag f 17 wihu h ifd, wi cs f
pa gadpa a cu d.
Suh Calia pis mdicaid fudig ly f abis cssay psv h
lif f a wa wh h pgacy is h sul f ap ics pd h p-
lic (ulss h wa is uabl p f physilgical psychlgical ass).
Sa axpay fuds apppiad h Sa Halh Isuac Pla ay b usd
pay f a abi xcp i cass f ap, ics, fal abaliy, psv a
wa's lif halh.
th Suh Calia Dpa f Halh ad evial Cl ad is plys
ay pvid fal svics cuslig f abi.
Suh Calia als phibis ay fuds apppiad ud h Suh Calia Bih
Dfcs Pga f big usd cusl f w f abis.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
58/124
756
Americans United for Life
Suh Calia has acd cphsiv halh ad safy gulais f abi
cliics. ths gulais a basd aial abi ca sadads ad cv such
aas as cliic adiisai, physical pla, saiai sadads, pai ca, ps-
paiv cvy, ad pp aiac f pai cds. Addiially, abi
pvids us aiai adiig pivilgs.
oly a physicia licsd pacic dici i Suh Calia ay pf a ab-
i.
Suh Calia phibis abis af 24 wks gsai ulss h adig physi-
cia ad ah idpd physicia cify i wiig ha h abi is cssay
psv h wa's lif halh. If bh physicias cify h abi is cssay
psv h was al halh, a idpd psychiais us als cify h
abi is cssay.
Suh Calia phibis paial-bih abi.
A Suh Calia law quis dical a f sxual assaul vicis iclud
dicai f pgacy pvi (i.e., gcy cacpi) if idicad ad
if dsid.
th sa has a fcabl abi pig law, bu ds qui h pig
f ifai h Cs f Disas Cl ad Pvi (CDC). th asu
applis bh sugical ad sugical abis.
LegAL reCOgniTiOn Of UnBOrn AnD newLY BOrn:
th Ub Vicis f Vilc Ac pvids ha h killig f a ub child a ay
sag f gsai ay b pscud as hicid. th Ac als ciializs a faal
assaul a ub child.
th sa allws wgful dah (civil) acis wh a viabl ub child is killd
hugh a glig ciial ac.
Suh Calia ds qui ifas wh suviv a abi b giv apppia
dical ca.
Suh Calia has a Baby mss law, sablishig a saf hav f hs lgally
lav hi ifas a dsigad placs ad suig h ifas civ apppia ca
ad pci.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
59/124
Defending Life 2010
757
The state denes substance abuse during pregnancy as child abuse under civil child-
wlfa saus.
BiOeTHiCS LAwS:
Suh Calia ds phibi hua clig dsuciv by sach.
Suh Calia ds gula h pvisi f assisd pduciv chlgis
h faciliis ha pvid i.
enD Of Life LAwS:
Assisd suicid is a fly i Suh Calia.
HeALTHCAre
rigHTS Of COnSCienCe LAwS:
Patcpato Abotos:
A physicia, us, chicia, h ply f a hspial, cliic, physicia wh
bjcs i wiig is quid cd, pf, assis i h pfac f
a abi.
A halhca pvids csciius bjci pfig assisig i abis
ay b h basis f liabiliy disciiai. A ps disciiad agais i
ply ay big a civil aci f daags ad isa.
excp i a gcy, a piva gval hspial cliic is quid
pi h us f is faciliis f h pfac f abis adi a wa
f a abi.
A hspials fusal pf pi h pfac f abis wihi is facil-
iy ay b h basis f civil liabiliy.
Patcpato rsach Hamul to Huma L
Suh Calia culy pvids pci f h ighs f halhca pvids
wh csciiusly bjc paicipai i hua clig, dsuciv by -
sach, ad h fs f ial dical sach.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
60/124
758
Americans United for Life
wHAT HAPPeneD in 2009:
Suh Calia csidd sghig is ifd cs qui by ad-
ig h -hu waiig pid 24 hus ad pvidig f a sa B Aliv Ifa
Pci Ac.
Suh Calia csidd lgislai pvidig ha h Sa Dpa f Halh ad
evial Cl ay v a sid f a cuiy sidial ca fa-
ciliy if h sid, h sids faily h sids halhca pw f ay,
h sids physicia, ad h faciliy ag h sids ciud say, ad h
faciliy is capabl f pvidig baiig cssay svics f h sid.
Suh Calia did csid ay asus lad bihics halhca ighs f
cscic.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
61/124
Defending Life 2010
759
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR SOUTh CAROLINA
Sort-term
Priorities
Additional
Goals
ABORTION
Informed Consent
Enhancements such as
counseling on fetal pain or
coercion
Parental Involvement
Enhancements such as
notarized consent or
identication requirements
State Rights & Policies
Abortion FundingBan on use of state funding for
abortion counseling or referrals
Ban on use of state facilities for
abortion
Abortion Provider
Requirements
Abortion Bans
Regulation of Abortifacients Regulation of RU-486
PCCs Support Direct funding of PCCs
Abortion Reporting
LEGAL RECOGNITION AND PROTECTION FOR UNBORN & NEwLy BORN
Fetal Homicide
Assault on Unborn
Prohibitions on Wrongful
Birth & Wrongful Life
Lawsuits
Permit Wrongful Death
Lawsuits
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
62/124
760
Americans United for Life
Born-Alive Infant ProtectionProtection for unborn who
survive abortion
Abandoned Infant Protection
BIOEThICS
Human Cloning Ban on human cloning
DER Ban on DER
State Funding of DER Ban on state funding of DER
ART & IVFAny medically-appropriate
regulation of ART
END OF LIFE
Assisted Suicide
Palliative Care & Pain
Management Education
RIGhTS OF CONSCIENCE
Protection for Individual
ProvidersComprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Institutions Comprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Payers Comprehensive ROC protection
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
63/124
Defending Life 2010
761
SOUTH DAKOTArAnKing: 6
Suh Daka has acd s f h s pciv, abi-
lad laws i h ai. I addii, h sa bas hua
clig ad dsuciv by sach. Hwv, Suh Da-
ka has y pvid cphsiv pci f halhca
pvids wh csciiusly bjc paicipaig i fa-
ciliaig pcdus ad as h ha abi.
ABOrTiOn:
A physicia ay pf a abi a wa uil a las 24 hus af sh has
b ifd f h pbabl gsaial ag f h ub child; h dical isks f
abi; h dical isks f cayig h pgacy ; ad h a f h physi-
cia wh will pf h abi. Sh us als b ifd abu availabl dical
assistance benets; the fathers legal responsibilities; and her right to review additional
information prepared by state health department ofcials.
I addii, Suh Daka quis a wa b ffd a ulasud ad h ppu-
iy viw h iag pi udgig a abi. th law als quis abi
pvids p h ub f w wh udg abis af chsig viw a
ulasud.
A physicia ay pf a abi a uacipad i ud h ag f
18 uil a las 48 hus af pvidig wi ic pa af baiig
a court order. South Dakota also requires parental notication within 24 hours after the
pfac f a gcy abi a i ad a xcpi h qui
is pid if a i idicas ha sh will sk a judicial bypass.
Suh Daka phibis public fudig f abi ulss h pcdu is cssay
psv h wa's lif.
Suh Daka quis ha all abi cliics i h sa iiu halh ad
safy sadads. A ali law quis scd-is abis (bgiig a 14
wks ad 6 days gsai) b pfd i a hspial, if is availabl, i a
licensed physicians medical clinic or ofce of practice subject to the requirements of
34-23A-6 [bld supply quis].
oly a physicia licsd by h sa a physicia pacicig dici spa-
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
64/124
762
Americans United for Life
hy ad plyd by h sa h Uid Sas ay pf a abi. Fuh,
sa dical bads phibi physicia assisas ad uss f ig i pacic
ags ud which hy ay pf abis.
South Dakota maintains a law that would "on the date that the states are given the ex-
clusive authority to regulate abortion" ban abortion throughout pregnancy except if nec-essary to preserve a woman's life. It specically applies both to surgical and chemical
abis ad applis a all sags f pgacy.
Suh Daka phibis paial-bih abi.
Suh Daka pvids ha abi ay b pfd af h 24h wk f pg-
acy ulss h pcdu is cssay psv h wa's lif halh.
The state offers Choose Life license plates, the proceeds of which benet pregnancy
ca cs ad/ h gaizais pvidig abi alaivs.
F ach abi pfd, a abi pvid us cpl a pig f a-
dad ad pvidd by h Suh Daka Dpa f Halh. th ifai ha
us b pd icluds: (1) h hd f abi; (2) h appxia gsaial
age of the fetus; (3) the specic reason for the abortion; (4) the entity, if any, that paid
f h abi; (5) a dscipi f ay cplicais f h abi; (6) h h-
d usd disps f fal issu; (7) h spcialy aa f h adig physicia; (8)
whh h adig physicia has b subjc lics vcai, suspsi,
h pfssial saci; (9) h ub f pvius abis h wa has had;
(10) h ub f pvius liv bihs f h wa; (11) whh h wa civdh rH s ad sd psiiv f h rH-gaiv fac; ad (12) h aial ad du-
caial saus ad ac f h wa. th pvisi applis bh sugical ad -
sugical abis, bu ds qui ha ay ifai b pd h Cs
f Disas Cl ad Pvi (CDC).
LegAL reCOgniTiOn Of UnBOrn AnD newLY BOrn:
Ud Suh Daka law, h killig f a ub child a ay sag f gsai is d-
ned as a form of homicide.
South Dakota denes a nonfatal assault on an unborn child as a crime.
th sa allws wgful dah (civil) acis wh a ub child a ay sag f
dvlp is killd hugh a glig ciial ac.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
65/124
Defending Life 2010
763
The state has created a specic afrmative duty for physicians to provide medical care
ad a a b-aliv ifa a ay sag f dvlp.
The state denes substance abuse during pregnancy as child abuse under civil child-
wlfa saus.
Suh Daka aiais a asu allwig a wa wh lss a child af 20 wks
gestation to obtain a certicate of birth resulting in a stillbirth.
BiOeTHiCS LAwS:
Suh Daka bas hua clig f ay pups, as wll as sach cld -
bys bys pducd hugh in vitro filizai.
Suh Daka pvids iial gulai f faciliis ffig assisd pduciv
technologies. Specically, the state regulates the use and treatment of gametes, neo-as, bys, ad fuss.
enD Of Life LAwS:
Assisig a suicid is a fly i Suh Daka.
HeALTHCAre
rigHTS Of COnSCienCe LAwS:
Patcpato Abotos:
Suh Daka law pcs h ighs f physicias, uss, cusls, scial wks,
ad h pss fus pf, assis i, pvid fals f, cusl ab-
is.
A halhca pvids csciius bjci pfig assisig i a abi
ay b a basis f liabiliy, disissal, h pjudicial acis by a hspial
medical facility with which the person is afliated or employed.
A counselor, social worker, or other person in a position to address "the abortion ques -tion . . . as part of [the] workday routine" who objects to providing abortion advice or
assisac ay b hld liabl ay ps subjc aliai by a isiui
with which the person is afliated or employed.
n hspial is quid adi a wa f h pups f abi. th fusal f a
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
66/124
764
Americans United for Life
hspial paicipa i abis ay b a basis f liabiliy.
A phaacis is quid disps dicai if h is as bliv h di-
cai wuld b usd caus a abi.
Patcpato rsach Hamul to Huma L
South Dakota currently provides no specic protection for the rights of healthcare pro-
vids wh csciiusly bjc paicipai i hua clig, dsuciv by
sach, h fs f ial dical sach.
wHAT HAPPeneD in 2009:
I sps abi pvids avlig i h sa f ighbig sas p-
f abis, Suh Daka csidd a bill quiig h physical psc f a
abi pvid i h cliic a las day pi pfig abis. I alscsidd lgislai quiig isuac cvag f cacpi.
Suh Daka did csid ay asus lad bihics, d-f-lif issus,
halhca ighs f cscic.
I Augus 2009, a fdal disic cu uphld a pvisi f Suh Daka law qui-
ig, pi a abi, a wa b ifd ha a abi ds h lif f a whl,
spaa, uiqu, livig hua big. Hwv, h cu siulausly suck dw
quis h wa b ifd ha abi icass h liklihd sh will la
ci suicid ad ha sh has a xisig laiship wih h ub child. thsuligs a appal h eighh Cicui Cu f Appals.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
67/124
Defending Life 2010
765
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR SOUTh DAKOTA
Sort-term
Priorities
Additional
Goals
ABORTION
Informed Consent
Enhancements such as
counseling on fetal pain or
coerced abortion prevention
Parental InvolvementAmend parental notice law to
require parental consent
State Rights & Policies
Abortion Funding Ban on use of state funding forabortion counseling or referrals
Ban on use of state facilities forabortion
Abortion Provider
Requirements
Abortion Bans
Regulation of Abortifacients Regulation of RU-486
PCCs Support Direct funding of PCCs
Abortion Reporting
LEGAL RECOGNITION AND PROTECTION FOR UNBORN & NEwLy BORN
Fetal Homicide
Assault on Unborn
Prohibitions on WrongfulBirth & Wrongful Life
Lawsuits
Permit Wrongful Death
Lawsuits
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
68/124
766
Americans United for Life
Born-Alive Infant Protection
Abandoned Infant Protection
BIOEThICS
Human Cloning
DER
State Funding of DER
ART & IVFAny medically-appropriate
regulation of ART
END OF LIFE
Assisted Suicide
Pain Management Education
RIGhTS OF CONSCIENCE
Protection for Individual
ProvidersComprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Institutions Comprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Payers Comprehensive ROC protection
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
69/124
Defending Life 2010
767
TenneSSeerAnKing: 30
tss is f 16 sas wih a cu-cad sa csiu-
ial igh abi; i fac, tsss cu-dclad igh is
f h bads i h ai. this dcisi has b usd
nullify the states informed consent law and mandatory reection
pid bf a abi.
ABOrTiOn:
A cu has jid h fc f tsss ifd cs law.
A physicia ay pf a abi a uacipad i ud h ag f
18 wihu h wi cs f pa a cu d. I 2001, h tss
Ay Gal issud a pii ha his qui als applis h us f if-
pis (rU-486).
th tss Sup Cu has aufacud a sa csiuial igh abi
i h sa csiui. this igh is dd b bad ha ha pvidd ud
h fdal csiui. Ud h auspics f his sa csiuial igh abi,
the Tennessee Supreme Court has invalidated a law requiring a three-day reection pe-
id ad ifd cs pi a abi.
tss pvids public fudig f abis wh h pcdu is cssay p-
sv h was lif wh h pgacy is a sul f ap ics.
A fdal disic cu has dclad tsss abi cliic gulais ucsiu-
ial (as applid h paicula abi pvid wh challgd h law).
Only a physician licensed or certied by the state may perform an abortion. Tennessee
law pvids ha us pacii physicia's assisa ay wi sig a p-
scipi, disps ay dug dicai, pf ay pcdu ivlvig a dug
dicai whs sl pups is caus a abi.
tss phibis paial-bih abi.
n abi ay b pfd af viabiliy ulss cssay psv h wa's
lif halh.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
70/124
768
Americans United for Life
tss pvids fudig pgacy ca cs hugh a Chs Lif spcialy
lics pla pga.
th sa has a fcabl abi pig law, bu ds qui h pig f
ifai h Cs f Disas Cl ad Pvi (CDC).
LegAL reCOgniTiOn Of UnBOrn AnD newLY BOrn:
Ud tss law, h killig f a viabl fus is a f f hicid.
th sa allws wgful dah (civil) acis ly wh a ub child is b aliv
fllwig a glig ciial ac ad dis haf.
The state has created a specic afrmative duty for physicians to provide medical care
ad a a b-aliv ifa a ay sag f dvlp.
tss has a Baby mss law, sablishig a saf hav f hs lgally
lav hi ifas a dsigad placs ad suig h ifas civ apppia ca
ad pci.
BiOeTHiCS LAwS:
Tennessee does not specically prohibit human cloning or destructive embryo research,
bu i ds ba fal xpiai.
tss ds gula assisd pduciv chlgis.
enD Of Life LAwS:
Assisig a suicid is a fly i tss.
HeALTHCAre
rigHTS Of COnSCienCe LAwS:
Patcpato Abotos:
A physicia is quid pf a abi ad ps ay b quid
paicipa i h pfac f a abi.
A hspial is quid pi h pfac f a abi wihi is faciliis.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
71/124
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
72/124
770
Americans United for Life
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
73/124
Defending Life 2010
771
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR TENNESSEE
Sort-term
Priorities
Additional
Goals
ABORTION
Informed ConsentComprehensive informed
consent with reection period
Parental Involvement
State Rights & PoliciesAmendment declaring no state
constitutional right to abortion
Abortion FundingBan on use of state funds for
abortion counseling or referrals
Ban on use of state facilities for
abortion
Abortion Provider
RequirementsAbortion clinic regulations
Abortion Bans
Regulation of Abortifacients
PCCs Support Direct funding of PCCs
Abortion Reporting
LEGAL RECOGNITION AND PROTECTION FOR UNBORN & NEwLy BORN
Fetal HomicideComprehensive unborn victims
of violence protection
Assault on Unborn
Prohibitions on Wrongful
Birth & Wrongful LifeLawsuits
Permit Wrongful Death
Lawsuits
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
74/124
772
Americans United for Life
Born-Alive Infant Protection
Abandoned Infant Protection
BIOEThICS
Human Cloning Ban on human cloning
DER Ban on DER
State Funding of DERBan on state funding of DER;
funding of ethical alternatives
ART & IVFAny medically-appropriate
regulation of ART
END OF LIFE
Assisted Suicide
Pain Management Education
RIGhTS OF CONSCIENCE
Protection for Individual
ProvidersComprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Institutions Comprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Payers Comprehensive ROC protection
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
75/124
Defending Life 2010
773
TexASrAnKing: 4
As a sul f aggssiv lgislaiv aci v h pas sval
yas, txas has bc f h s pciv sas i h
ai. I aiais faily cphsiv pcis f w
ad h ub ad has apppiad illis f dllas sup-
pig abi alaivs. Hwv, h sa has y ac
ba hua clig ad dsuciv by sach.
ABOrTiOn:
A physicia ay pf a abi a wa uil a las 24 hus af bai-
ig h ifd cs ad af ifig h f h au ad isks f h ppsd
abi pcdu, icludig h gsaial dvlp f h ub child ad avail-
abl assisac f bh public ad piva agcis.
th sa als xplicily quis a physicia if a wa skig abi f h
abi-bas cac lik.
txas phibis isuac cpais f saiig diaig a was abi
dcisi hugh fc by haig advs alai a isuac pla.
A physicia ay pf a abi a uacipad i ud h ag f
18 wihu h cs f pa a guadia scuig a cu d. I addii,
agcis ha civ sa fudig us bai paal cs bf pvidig is
wih cacpi.
th txas Sup Cu has uphld a law liiig axpay assisac f abi
cass wh h abi is cssay psv a was lif wh h pgacy
is h sul f ap ics.
txas phibis gaizais ha pf cusl bhalf f abi f civ-
ig sa fuds, ad gaizais civig sa faily plaig fuds us aiai
sic spaai f abi pvids. I addii, agcis ha civ sa fudig
us bai paal cs bf pvidig is wih cacpi.
txas has acd cphsiv halh ad safy gulais f abi cliics.
ths gulais a basd aial abi ca sadads ad cv such aas
as cliic adiisai, saiai sadads, pai ca, ps-paiv cvy, ad
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
76/124
774
Americans United for Life
pp aiac f pai cds. Fuh, abi pvids us aiai adi-
ig pivilgs.
oly a physicia licsd i txas ay pf a abi.
txas psssss a fcabl abi phibii shuld h U.S. Csiui bamended or certain U.S. Supreme Court decisions be reversed or modied.
A hid-is abi ay b pfd a viabl fus ulss cssay
psv h was lif pv a subsaial isk f sius ipai h
physical al halh, if h fus has a sv ad ivsibl abaliy. Ad-
diially, a scd law pvids ha a hid-is abi ay b pfd
a viabl fus ulss cssay pv sv, ivsibl bai daag h
wa, paalysis, if h fus has a sv ad ivsibl bai ipai.
txas cius allca illis f dllas h issi f pgacy ca csad hs pvidig abi alaivs.
th sa has a fcabl abi pig law, bu ds qui h pig
f ifai h Cs f Disas Cl ad Pvi (CDC). th asu
applis bh sugical ad sugical abis ad quis abi pvids
p dahs ha ccu i hi faciliis as a sul f abi as wll as sh-
cplicais.
LegAL reCOgniTiOn Of UnBOrn AnD newLY BOrn:
Under Texas law, the killing of an unborn child at any stage of gestation is dened as a
f f hicid.
Texas denes a nonfatal assault on an unborn child as a criminal offense.
txas allws pas ad h laivs big a wgful dah (civil) lawsui wh
a ub child a ay sag f dvlp is killd hugh h gligc ciial
ac f ah.
Ud txas law, a livig hua child b aliv af a abi pau bih isild h sa ighs, pws ad pivilgs as a gad by h laws f [txas]
ay h child b aliv af h al gsaial pid. thus, h sa has
created a specic afrmative duty of physicians to provide medical care and treatment to
b-aliv ifas a ay sag f dvlp.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
77/124
Defending Life 2010
775
The state denes substance abuse during pregnancy as child abuse under civil child-
wlfa saus. th sa has als cad a ask fc chagd, i pa, wih advisig
pial ciial liabiliy f a wa wh xpss h ub child clld
subsacs.
BiOeTHiCS LAwS:
txas ds phibi hua clig dsuciv by sach, bu i ds ba
fal xpiai.
txas cly apppiad $5 illi i sa fudig f adul s cll sach ad
als cuags sach usig ubilical cd bld.
txas quis faciliis pfig in vitro filizai iiu sadads ad
gulas isuac cvag f assisd pduciv chlgis. th sa icluds
embryo donation in its denition of assisted reproductive technology.
enD Of Life LAwS:
Assisig a suicid is a fly i txas.
HeALTHCAre
rigHTS Of COnSCienCe LAwS:
Patcpato Abotos:
A physicia, us, saff b, ply f a hspial wh bjcs paicipaig
dicly idicly i a abi ay b quid paicipa i a abi.
A halhca pvids csciius bjci paicipaig i abis ay b
a basis f disciiai i ply ducai. A ps whs ighs a vi-
lad ay big a aci f lif, icludig back pay ad isa.
A piva hspial halhca faciliy is quid ak is faciliis availabl f
h pfac f a abi ulss a physicia dis ha h was lif is
idialy dagd.
Patcpato rsach Hamul to Huma L
txas culy pvids pci f h ighs f halhca pvids wh csci-
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
78/124
776
Americans United for Life
iusly bjc paicipai i hua clig, dsuciv by sach, h
fs f ial dical sach.
wHAT HAPPeneD in 2009:
txas wd fudig f pgacy ca cs ad h abi alaivs ad abudgay id ha quis ha cipis f sa faily plaig fudig sgga
hi faily plaig svics f abi svics.
txas acd a asu caig a ask fc chagd, i pa, wih advisig pial
ciial liabiliy f w wh xps hi ub child clld subsacs.
th sa add is Halh ad Safy Cd allw f lcic sigaus ad-
vac dicivs ad pi aizai f d--suscia ds (as a ala-
iv w wisss). txas als adad licsig ad gulai f pai aag-
cliics.
txas csidd asus quiig a ulasud bf a abi; sghig
is ifd cs law by addig ifai cci; quiig cs ifai
b psd i abi cliics; caig Chs Lif lics plas; ad, i a uiqu
asu, quiig ifd cs f w baiig gcy cacpi.
I Fbuay 2009, txas Gv rick Py aucd h sa wuld pvid $5
illi i fudig f adul s cll sach.
Convrsly, h sa considrd lgislaion broadning xising xcpions o h informdconsn law, as wll as rgulaions which would hav rquird prgnancy car cnrs b
licnsd by h sa in ordr o rciv any funding. th sa also considrd lgislaion r-
quiring assaul vicims rciv informaion abou and accss o mrgncy conracpion.
Whil txas csidd lgislai quiig paal ivlv f is skig
cacpi, i als csidd lgislai xpadig isuac cvag f cacp-
i f is.
txas csidd sval asus which wuld hav phibid clig--pduc-
child, bu clig f all pupss. o h h had, h sa als csiddasus pig adul s cll sach ad phibiig h us f sa y
faciliis f dsuciv by sach.
th sa csidd a bad csiuial ad pcig fd f cscic,
icludig ha f halhca pvids.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
79/124
Defending Life 2010
777
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR TEXAS
Sort-term
Priorities
Additional
Goals
ABORTION
Informed Consent
Enhancements such as
ultrasound requirement or
counseling on fetal pain
Parental InvolvementEnhancements such as judicial
bypass standards
State Rights & Policies
Abortion Funding
Abortion Provider
Requirements
Abortion Bans Sex-selective abortion ban
Regulation of Abortifacients
PCCs Support
Continued funding of PCCs
including Choose Life licenseplates
Abortion Reporting
LEGAL RECOGNITION AND PROTECTION FOR UNBORN & NEwLy BORN
Fetal Homicide
Assault on Unborn
Prohibitions on Wrongful
Birth & Wrongful Life
Lawsuits
Permit Wrongful Death
Lawsuits
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
80/124
778
Americans United for Life
Born-Alive Infant Protection
Abandoned Infant Protection
BIOEThICS
Human Cloning Ban on human cloning
DER Ban on DER
State Funding of DERBan on state funding of DER;
funding of ethical alternatives
ART & IVFAny medically-appropriate
regulation of ART
END OF LIFE
Assisted Suicide
Pain Management Education
RIGhTS OF CONSCIENCE
Protection for Individual
ProvidersComprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Institutions Comprehensive ROC protection
Protection for Payers Comprehensive ROC protection
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
81/124
Defending Life 2010
779
UTAHrAnKing: 25
Uah pvids a asabl dg f pci f w, h ub,
ad wly b. Hwv, i ds phibi dsuciv by -
sach, hua clig, assisd suicid.
ABOrTiOn:
A physicia ay pf a abi a wa uil a las 24 hus af i-
fig h f h pbabl gsaial ag f h ub child; fal dvlp; h
au f, isks f, ad alaivs h ppsd abi pcdu; ha adpiv
pas ay lgally pay h css f paal ca; ad h dical isks f cayig h
pgacy .
Addiially, Uah quis ha a wa civ ifai ulasud svics ad
ha a wa skig abi a 20 wks gsai la us b ffd ashsia
f h ub child.
Uah phibis ad ciializs acs idd cc a wa i udgig a
abi. th sa als quis abi pvids sa i pid aials ha i is
illgal f s cc a wa i havig a abi.
A physicia ay pf a abi a i uil h physicia bais h c-
s f pa guadia a cu d.
The Utah legislature has resolved it is the nding and policy of the Legislature that
ub child hav ih ad ialiabl ighs ha a ild pci by h
sa f Uah pusua h pvisis f h Uah Csiui. th sa f Uah
has a cpllig is i h pci f h livs f ub child. I is h
i f h Lgislau pc ad guaa ub child hi ih ad
ialiabl igh lif.
mv, h lgislau has fud ad dclad i is h public plicy f his sa
cuag all pss spc h igh lif f all h pss, gadlss f ag,
dvlp, cdii dpdcy, icludig all ub pss.
Uah fuds abis wh cssay psv h was lif, h was physi-
cal halh is had by a ciud pgacy, h pgacy is h sul f ap
ics, i h cas f fal abaliis.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
82/124
780
Americans United for Life
Uah adas iiu halh ad safy quis f faciliis pfig ab-
tions after the rst trimester. The regulations prescribe minimum standards for the build-
ing or facility, stafng, clinic administration, and patient medical evaluations. Further,
abi pvids us aiai adiig pivilgs.
oly a physicia spahic physicia licsd by h sa pacic dici aypf a abi.
Uah phibis ps-viabiliy abis xcp i cass f lif dag, sius
isk f subsaial ad ivsibl ipai f a aj bdily fuci, sv fal
abnormality as certied by two physicians, or rape or incest reported to the police. Per-
fig a phibid abi is a fly.
Uah phibis paial-bih abi ud a law which has b liigad ad uphld i
fdal cu. Alhugh dlig h fdal ba, Uahs law pvids hash pal-
is.
th sa has a fcabl abi pig law, bu ds qui h pig
f ifai h Cs f Disas Cl ad Pvi (CDC). th asu
applis bh sugical ad sugical abis.
Uah quis halhca faciliis pvid ifai abu ad accss gcy
cacpi assaul vicis.
LegAL reCOgniTiOn Of UnBOrn AnD newLY BOrn:
Under Utah law, the killing of an unborn child at any stage of gestation is dened as a
f f hicid.
th sa allws wgful dah (civil) acis ly wh a ub child is b aliv
fllwig a glig ciial ac ad dis haf.
Uah has a Baby mss law, sablishig a saf hav f hs lgally lav hi
ifas a dsigad placs ad suig h ifas civ apppia ca ad pc-
i.
Uah quis subsac abus a pgas civig public fuds giv piiy
adissi pga w ad ags. th sa als quis halhca pfs-
sials p suspcd paal dug xpsu.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
83/124
Defending Life 2010
781
BiOeTHiCS LAwS:
Uah ds phibi hua clig dsuciv by sach, bu i ds ba
fal xpiai.
Uah ds gula assisd pduciv chlgis.
enD Of Life LAwS:
Utah does not have a specic statute criminalizing assisted suicide. Thus, the legal status
f assisd suicid i Uah is culy idiabl.
HeALTHCAre
rigHTS Of COnSCienCe LAwS:
Patcpato Abotos:
A physicia h ps assciad wih, plyd by, saff wih a hspial ha
bjcs ligius al guds is quid paicipa i abis.
A halhca pvids csciius bjci paicipaig i abi ay b a
basis f daags, discipliay aci, h ciiay aci.
mal ligius bjcis abi ay b a basis f disciiai i hi-
ig.
A piva diaial hspial is quid adi a wa f h pf-
ac f a abi.
Patcpato rsach Hamul to Huma L
Uah culy pvids pci f h ighs f halhca pvids wh csci-
iusly bjc paicipai i hua clig, dsuciv by sach, h
fs f ial dical sach.
wHAT HAPPeneD in 2009:
Uah acd lgislai baig ps-viabiliy abis. I als cad a us accu
f fuds b usd i dfdig p-lif saus wh challgs ais.
th sa als acd lgislai quiig a wa skig a abi a 20 wks
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
84/124
782
Americans United for Life
gsai la b ffd ashsia f h ub child.
Cvsly, h sa acd lgislai quiig halhca faciliis pvid ifa-
i abu ad accss gcy cacpi.
Uah add is Advac Halh Ca Diciv Ac xpad h lis f halhcapfssials auhizd di a pais dcisi-akig capaciy ad ffcu-
a a pais halhca diciv.
Uah did csid ay asus lad bihics halhca ighs f c-
scic.
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY
85/124
Defending Life 2010
783
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR UTAh
Sort-term
Priorities
Additional
Goals
ABORTION
Informed Consent
Parental Involvement
Enhancements such as
notarized consent or
identication requirements
State Rights & Policies
Abortion Funding Limits on use of state fundingfor abortion counseling or
referrals
Abortion Provider
Requirements
Abortion BansSex-selective abortion ban and
delayed enforcement law
Regulation of Abortifacients
PCCs Support Direct funding of PCCs
Abortion Reporting
LEGAL RECOGNITION AND PROTECTION FOR UNBORN & NEwLy BORN
Fetal Homicide
Assault on Unborn
Prohibitions on Wrongful
Birth & Wrongful Life
Lawsuits
Permit Wrongful Death
Lawsuits
-
8/8/2019 NM-WY