nominating a winner: your package is your candidate
TRANSCRIPT
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
February 5-7, 2015 | Washington, DC
NOMINATING A WINNER: YOUR PACKAGE IS YOUR
CANDIDATE
Angela Barbee-Hatter
General Motors
BEYA Selection Committee
Chairperson
Ted Imes
Northrop Grumman
Sector Director
Talent Discovery
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Introductions
Angela Barbee-HatterDirector
Global Design Center Operations
General Motors
Ted ImesDirector
Talent Discovery
Northrop Grumman
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Nominating a Winner: Your Package is Your Candidate
3
Purpose of Awards To Recognize the Most Talented and Accomplished Leaders in STEM
At the end of workshop:
A
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Workshop Agenda
BEYA Selection Process 10 min
Award Category Descriptions 5 min
Nomination Package Preparation Tips 65 min– General logistics
– Nomination Form
– Bio, Resume, and Job Description
– Organization Chart
– Technical Papers / Journals / Articles
– Letter of Recommendation
– Other Supporting Material and CD
– Photo Requirement
Website
Summary / Q & A 10 min
4
A
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
BEYA Selection Process
5
Selection Committee
Identification
Form sub-committee teams based on award
categories
Award submission review by individual
committee members
Sub-committee members rate and rank
candidates
Top nominees discussed among sub-
committee teams examining subjective
and objective information
Sub-committee determines top 3
candidates by consensus
Top candidate presentation prepared
for entire selection committee
Sub-committee may make recommendation
for the Black Engineer of the Year Awardee, if
applicable
All recommendations are submitted to the
executive committee for final review
T
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
BEYA Selection Process
Unique; may be a pioneer in their
field.
Substantial Sphere of Influence,
including financial, managerial,
and cross-functional responsibility.
Respected within their
organization and has substantial
internal and external leadership
support.
Innovator in technology or
management of technology or
both.
Role Models; a leader working in
any area of science, engineering
and technology
Able to Excite Students, as well
as government, military, and
corporate communities
Individuals who have Overcome
Adversity and/or are the first (or
one of few) in their field
6
WHAT THE SELECTION PANEL LOOKS FOR IN EACH NOMINEE
A
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
BEYA Selection Process
7
Key Objectives: Highlight individual
achievement, celebrate personal excellence and
create role models.
Committee’s Goal: Select the best people for
every award
Note: Committee members may exclude themselves from the scoring
process of candidates from their own company or military branch to
ensure that there is no bias in the selection process.
INTEGRITY OF PROCESS
A
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Award Category
8
Candidate Submission Complexities
‒ Multiple Candidates Same Category
• Stellar candidate gets buried
• Appearance of “stacking the deck”
‒ Same Candidate Multiple Categories
• Appear indecisive
• Causes redundancy for Selection Committee
Internal Pre-screening
‒ Competitive Awards
• Focus on select few with greatest potential
• Consider internal recognition for candidates
not submitted
‒ Non-Competitive Recognition
• Ex: MDTL
• Limit number of submission
DESCRIPTIONS
A
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Nomination Package Preparation Tips: General Logistics – Overview
9
Step by Step Review of
Nomination Packet
Tips to Convey Candidate’s
Contributions, Talents, and
Overall Accomplishments
Package Submission
Checklist
Website
T
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Nomination Package Preparation Tips: General Logistics – How to Apply
10
How Do I Get Started?
• Embrace the nomination process as something
that is valuable
• Enlist senior executives and employee resource
groups
• Send out a call for nomination within your
organization
• Create an internal interview group to select
candidates from whom your organization will
submit nomination packages
A
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Nomination Package Preparation Tips: General Logistics – How to Apply
11
What is Required to Complete the
Nomination Package?
Timeline: Gathering the Nominee
Information
After Nomination
A
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Nomination Package Preparation Tips: General Logistics – Checklist
12
Checklist Cover Page
Table of Content
Cover letter / Reason for nomination
Nomination form
Current biography or resume
Full job description or curriculum vitae
Organizational Chart
Papers and articles by and / or about the nominee
Letters of recommendation
Other significant supporting materials
CD containing an electronic copy of the complete nomination package
Recent color photograph
A
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Nomination Package Preparation Tips: General Logistics – Checklist
13
Checklist Cover Page
Table of Content
Cover letter / Reason for nomination
Nomination form
Current biography or resume
Full job description or curriculum vitae
Organizational Chart
Papers and articles by and / or about the nominee
Letters of recommendation
Other significant supporting materials
CD containing an electronic copy of the complete nomination package
Recent color photograph
A
Complete Package
…Supporting Data
…Endorsements … Recognitions
What is
significantabout
accomplishments?
What’s your story? How is
it unique?Incomplete Packages Are
DisadvantagedAnd May Be
Rejected
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Nomination Package Preparation Tips: Nomination Form
14
Most Recent Nomination Form
Completeness of form
Missing information creates issue
Discrepancies between the form and
information in the detailed package
Importance of Nominator
‒ Relevance of position/level in the
organization/military branch
T
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Nomination Package Preparation Tips:Current Biography or Resume
15
Strongly recommend BOTH biography AND resume
‒ Biography should:
• Tell a story of your journey not just career but personal background
• Highlight what makes you unique; what will inspire
• Concise; to the point Recommended length = 2 pages or less
‒ Resume should:
• Include clear, comprehensive timeline of assignments explain gaps
• Indicate promotions or lateral move
• High-level description of responsibilities and what was accomplished
• Use general terminology, not internal corporate or military jargon
• Include education and training dates, school, degree(s) and/or certificate(s)
A
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Nomination Package Preparation Tips: Full Job Description or CV
Full job description or curriculum vitae (CV) of should include
details of current job assignment
‒ Specific responsibilities
‒ Budget
‒ Span of control
‒ Sphere of influence
‒ Indirect organization
‒ …etc.
Recommended length ~ two (2) to three (3) paragraphs
16
A
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Nomination Package Preparation Tips:Organizational Chart
The Content of this section should shows nominee’s
leadership chain of command.
The Organization Chart should show where the nominee is in
the overall organization.
Can show additional organization chart overall company
organization and the relation to the nominees organization.
17
T
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Nomination Package Preparation Tips: Organizational Chart
T
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Nomination Package Preparation Tips: Organizational Chart
19
The Organizational chart should show a
direct line from the CEO to where you
are in the organization
Pictures should be used
The Committee prefers to see this kind
of Org Chart.
President / CEO
(photo)
Senior Vice President
(photo)
You
(photo)
T
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Nomination Package Preparation Tips: Organizational Chart
20
Research &
Development
Finance Human Resources
OperationsProduct
Marketing
VP
Include the
Org Chart
that shows
your
organization.
T
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Nomination Package Preparation Tips: Papers and Articles
Papers/Journals/Patents/Articles by and/or about the nominee
‒ Include high-level summary or technical abstract
‒ Spell out acronyms
‒ Highlight candidates names in publication
‒ Think about relevance of publication as it relates to the award
• Quality over quantity
• More is not necessarily better
21
A
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Nomination Package Preparation Tips: Letter of Recommendation
• Create a LOR section
• Create a LOR table of contents
• Secure letters from various
levels of the organization
• Secure letters from external
customers and other
stakeholders (group the various
sources)
• Letter should be 1 page in length
• Letter must be signed
• Quality of content and
specifics of interactions with
candidate
• Quantify achievements
• Avoid “form” letters
• Use easy to read language
• Spell acronym on the first
usage
• Ensure the letter is address to
the proper committee and
identifies award category
22
Structure Content
T
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Nomination Package Preparation Tips: Letter of Recommendation
23
John Doe Chief Executive Officer
Jane Doe Senior Vice President, Engineering
Mary Doe Vice President, Human Resources
William Doe Director Supply Chain
Lynne Doe Manager, Engineering and Technology
Note: Individual letters should appears in the order of your table of contents.
T
Table of Contents:
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Nomination Package Preparation Tips: Other Supporting Material
Represent the nominee’s impact, influence and involvement in
the success of others and of their accomplishments.
Pictures of the nominee ‘in action’ i.e.: talking to employees,
students, with customers, staff, etc.
Award and Recognition
‒ Highlight the person receiving recognition
‒ Should be recent within past 5 years or so
‒ Picture of plaques, trophies, etc. or copies of certificates
24
A
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Nomination Package Preparation Tips: CD
CD containing an electronic copy of the complete nomination
package (including digital photograph in separate file)
25
A
CRITICAL REQUIREMENT
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Nomination Package Preparation Tips: Photograph
26
Professional photographs
Professional Attire should be worn
‒ Business attire for women
‒ Dark suit and tie for men
‒ Military service dress uniforms
Specifications for photographs:
– Include Color or B&W print (5”x7” – 8”x10”)
– Digital photographs
• High-resolution only (>300DPI)
• EPS, JPEG, or TIFF format.
Do not send Ink Jet Printouts
T
Delete
next
slide
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Nomination Package Preparation Tips: Photograph
Specifications for photographs:
– Color or black & white photographs – maximum size 8”x10”;
minimum size 5”x7”
– Digital photographs – High-resolution only. Minimum 300 dpi
resolution. EPS, JPEG, or TIFF format. Minimum size 5”x7”.
Please DO NOT send photos in Microsoft Word or in
PowerPoint. Save files as “firstname_lastname.filetype.” such as
John_Smith.jpg
– DO NOT send inkjet printouts of photos
27
T
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Website
28
Complete Nomination Package can be downloaded from CCG website :
A
NEW! Nomination Packet
Online Application
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Summary Your Package is:
Your Story Be complete
Your Reputation Be consistent
Your Brand – Be notable
Your Package is:
29
A
Your Candidate Be excellent!
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
30
Questions?
February 5-7, 2015
| Washington, DC
Workshop Agenda
BEYA Selection Process 10 min
Award Category Descriptions 5 min
Nomination Package Preparation Tips 65 min– General logistics (Angela)
– Nomination Form (Ted)
– Bio, Resume, and Job Description (Angela)
– Organization Chart (Ted)
– Technical Papers / Journals / Articles (Angela)
– Letter of Recommendation (Ted)
– Other Supporting Material and CD (Angela)
– Photo Requirement (Ted)
Website
Summary / Q & A 10 min
32
A