open2012 technology-innovations-disabilities-goldberg
TRANSCRIPT
Department of Veterans AffairsTechnology Innovations for Persons with Disabilities (TIPeD)
Department of Veterans Affairs
Mary Goldberg, MEd
Jon Pearlman, PhD
Education & Outreach Coordinator
Assistant Professor, RST, SHRS
Department of Rehabilitation Science and TechnologySchool of Health and Rehabilitation SciencesHuman Engineering Research Laboratories
Department of Veterans Affairs
Talk outline
• Program overview & plan• 1st cohort results• Program replication• Feedback and questions
Department of Veterans Affairs
Departmental structure
• Rehabilitation Science & Technology
• Human Engineering Research Laboratories
• Veterans Affairs• QoLT• Intern programs
Department of Veterans Affairs
TIPeD Program• Product development program funded
by NCIIA• Augment ASPIRE & QoLT REU
programs
Department of Veterans Affairs
Background
• Assistive technology & participation in society
• Inappropriate designs• Design shortcomings• Improve independence and safety
of users
Department of Veterans Affairs
Background
• AT market• 3rd party payers• Performance & safety
requirements• Academic institutions• Valley of death
Department of Veterans Affairs
Technology transfer
• SBIR and STTR programs• Technology transfer offices within
universities• Interdisciplinary programs
Department of Veterans Affairs
HERL technology development• Commercialized 5 products• 3 patents awarded; 9 pending• Research & user-driven
innovations • Business partners• Multidisciplinary faculty, students,
& staff
Department of Veterans Affairs
HERL technology development• Design & fabrication facilities• Funding streams• SBIR/STTR involvement
Department of Veterans Affairs
Department of Veterans Affairs
Design Series
Department of Veterans Affairs
NCIIA funding
• Requested support for multidisciplinary teams
• Workshops on innovation & entrepreneurship
• Tours of local companies• Collaborative program facilitation
Department of Veterans Affairs
Evidence-based program model• Experiential learning• Solving problems of social
relevance
Department of Veterans Affairs
Program structure
• Interdisciplinary leadership team• Solicited ideas from faculty• Project mission• Commercial potential• Feasible 10-week objectives• Result in SBIR proposal
Department of Veterans Affairs
Participants
• Funding challenge• 1 engineering & 1 business student• Law student to investigate
intellectual property
Department of Veterans Affairs
Students’ tasks
• Technology design, development, and evaluation
• SBIR proposal instead of technical paper
Department of Veterans Affairs
Learning objectives
Department of Veterans Affairs
Department of Veterans Affairs
Activities
• Enhanced cohort– ELeVATE
– REU
– Bridge
• Talks
Department of Veterans Affairs
Weekly meetings
• Elevator pitch• Tasks completed• Next steps• Archives & team websites
Department of Veterans Affairs
SBIR Proposal• Technology
– Research and development efforts
– Technical merit
– Feasibility
• Commercialization– Market description
– IP protection
– Finance plan
– Marketing plan
– Revenue stream
Department of Veterans Affairs
Other deliverables
• Poster• Oral presentation• Participation in comprehensive
symposium
Department of Veterans Affairs
Evaluation and sustainability plan• 50% success rate on securing seed
funding within 12 months of starting summer project
• 25% success rate on establishing an operating company, measured by actual sales within two years of starting summer project
Department of Veterans Affairs
Evaluation and sustainability plan• At least one nationally-advertised
design award, per year (RESNA, Lemmelson)
• Obtain additional funding for TIPeD from federal agency or foundation within the first 12 months of program
Department of Veterans Affairs
1st cohort-summer 2011
• 6 primary students• Bus Buddy• Low-cost footwear• Smart controller
Department of Veterans Affairs
Bus Buddy
• Novel self-administered containment system
Department of Veterans Affairs
Bus Buddy
• Reduced:– System Weight by ~30%
– Upright Weight by ~60%
– Upright Width by ~40%
– Lateral Arm Weight by ~10%
– Cost ~70%
• Increased:– Upright Strength
– Efficiency of the Lifting Mechanism
Department of Veterans Affairs
FINANCES• Price: $1,000/unit• Sales in Units:
Year 1: 30 units Year 2: 150 units Year 3: 1,000 units Year 4: 2,000 units Year 5: 3,000 units• Cost: $750 Years
1 and 2; $650 each year after
• Financing: $500k• Break Even: Year 3
STRATEGY #1• Contract with
Manufacturers for Device Components
• In-House Marketing
1 2 3 4 5
($1,000,000)
($500,000)
$0
$500,000
$1,000,000
$1,500,000
$2,000,000
$2,500,000
$3,000,000
$3,500,000 Revenue
Gross Margin
Operating Income
Year
U.S
. Dol
lars
Forecasted Revenue, Gross Margin, and Operating Income
Production Strategy
Department of Veterans Affairs
Low-Cost Basic Custom Fit Footwear
• Diabetic footwear• Ordering and distribution system• Sandals with assembly instructions• Business plan for establishing
footwear microenterprises to sell both custom and regular sandals
Department of Veterans Affairs
Low-Cost Basic Custom Fit Footwear
Department of Veterans Affairs
Production & Marketing
Leather
Step 1. MaterialsStep 2. Draw and Cut Step 3. Packing with Instruction
Step 4. EntrepreneurStep 5. Selling
Rubber
• Final production will be done by entrepreneurs• 90 to 160 entrepreneurs can sell the shoes from 2012 to 2016
Department of Veterans Affairs
Finance plan
Y1 Y2 Y3 Y4 Y5
Target Market
AshantiUpper East
Western
AshantiUpper East
Western
GhanaAmericas(33%)
GhanaAmericas(66%)
Cote D'ivoreTogo
GhanaAmericas(100%)
Cote D'ivoreTogo
Sales 29,102 53,023 1,479,333 2,851,528 4,168,453
Revenue 87,305 169,675 15,832,557 35,580,305 57,797,959
COGS 81,779 153,198 6,352,339 15,553,388 27,361,363
Gross Margin 5,526 16,478 9,480,218 20,026,917 30,436,597
Operating Expenses 127,101 208,986 3,809,013 7,926,456 11,642,263
Income Before Taxes (121,575) (192,508) 5,671,206 12,100,460 18,794,333
Net Income (123,705) (215,471) 3,520,609 7,247,513 11,268,637
Sponsor Money 30,000 55,000 370,000 430,000 450,000
• Initial Investment : $100,000
• Financing : $200,000 at Y1 for operating expense
Department of Veterans Affairs
Powered Mobility Controller Platform• Smart controller for Personal
Mobility and Manipulation Appliance (PerMMA)Gen I as PerMMA I Controller Gen II as PerMMA II Controller
Department of Veterans Affairs
Top View of Smart Controller
Amplifiers to control driving wheels
Customized PCB board.Interface btw sensors, encoders and PC
Kill Switch for Safety PC – Single Board Embedded Cobra
10.5”
5.25”
10.00”
Input Command,i.e, joystick
Display from PC
Two fans to Cool System Down
Power Switch
Ethernet Connection to communicate with another computer
Smart Controller Design
Department of Veterans Affairs
Market Research• Potential users and market size
– Powered mobility device users
• Market size:
– 1.4-2.1 million (represents 61-91% of all wc users)
– Persons 65+: by 2030, 75% of 69 million people will be 65+
– 40% increased users based on prescriptions
– Powered mobility devices suppliers or manufacturers
• Invacare, Permobil, Pride Mobility, etc
– Powered mobility research
• 200+ enttities
– Higher education: estimated 5,700
– Wheelchair clinics: estimated 15,000
Department of Veterans Affairs
Commercialization factors• Promising preliminary data
– Safe and reliable
– Improving the driving performance
– Used for multiple research projects
• Platform technology– Used on three EPWs already
– Conduct some clinical studies
• FDA approval– Will not be a big issue
– hardware and software design are according to FDA requirements
– Previous experiences on similar products
Department of Veterans Affairs
Evaluation
• 100% recommend program• 78% suggest interest in
entrepreneurship increase– Independent thinking skills
Department of Veterans Affairs
Evaluation
Department of Veterans Affairs
Evaluation
Department of Veterans Affairs
Challenges
• Student funding• Mentorship commitment variability• Faculty familiarity with technology
transfer
Department of Veterans Affairs
Changes
• Templates• Training• Basecamp• MS Engineering/MBA student
involvement
Department of Veterans Affairs
Program Outcomes
• Big Idea Competition• LINC Designs• 1 SBIR submitted• Grants in review
Department of Veterans Affairs
Create your own program
• $80k/year including admin, student stipends, project supplies, travel expenses
• 10% supported by NCIIA– Supplies
– Admin support
– Travel to design competitions & entrepreneurship conferences
Department of Veterans Affairs
Create your own program
• Multidisciplinary partnerships across university departments
• Project based courses– e.g. RST design series
• Independent study courses
Department of Veterans Affairs
Create your own program
• Workshops– Concept generation
– Prototyping
– Patents
– Intellectual property
– Product development economics
– Managing projects
Department of Veterans Affairs
Acknowledgements • Funding: National Collegiate Innovators &
Inventors Alliance Grant #7563-10, National Science Foundation Grants EEC0540866 & EEC0849878, Berg Center for Ethics & Leadership
• Mentors: Mary Jo Geyer, Dennis Janisse, Linda van Roosmalen, Eric Porach, Honwu Wang,Rory Cooper
• Students: Melvin McElrath, Max Gruder, Kira Eckstein, Jonathan Valz, Rob Fillippi, Joe Trebitz, QoLT Foundry Interns
Department of Veterans Affairs
References*• Ansi/Resna. “American National Standard for Wheechairs-- Volume 1-19 Wheelchairs used as seats in
motor vehicles.” Rehabilitation Engineering and Assistive Technology Society of North America: Virginia (2000).
• Auerswald, P.E. and L.M. Branscomb. “Valleys of Death and Darwinian Seas: Financing
• the Invention to Innovation Transition in the United States.” The Journal of Technology Transfer, 28 (2003): 227-239.
• Hawtrey, K. "Using Experiential Learning Techniques." Journal of Economic Education, 38 (2007): 143-152.
• Kirby, R.L. and D.A. MacLeod. "Wheelchair-related injuries reported to the National Electronic Injury Surveillance System: an update." RESNA 2001 Annual Conference: Reno, NV (2001).
• Knotts, T.L. "The SBDC in the Classroom: Providing Experiential Learning Opportunities at Different Entrepreneurial Stages." Journal of Entrepreneurship Education, 14 (2011): 25-38.
• Kolb, D. “Experiential Learning Theory: Previous Research and New Directions” In R. J. Sternberg and L. F. Zhang (Eds.), Perspectives on cognitive, learning, and thinking styles. NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, (2000).
• Kolb, D. Experiential learning. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall (1984).
• Legs to Stand On. http://www.legstostandon.org (2011)
• McCarthy, P.R. & H.M. McCarthy. "Why Case Studies are not Enough: Integrating Experiential Learning into Business Curricula." Journal of Education for Business 81 (2009): 201-204.
• Phillips, B. and H. Zhao. "Predictors of Assistive Technology Abandonment." Assistive Technology, 5 (1993): 36-45.
*Additional project references (i.e. from Bus Buddy, Low-Cost Footwear, Smart Controller projects) available upon request.
Department of Veterans Affairs
Contact informationMary R. GoldbergUniversity of PittsburghSchool of Health and Rehabilitation SciencesRehabilitation Science and Technology6425 Penn AvePittsburgh, PA 15206mrh35@pitt.eduwww.herl.pitt.eduwww.qolt.pitt.edu412-822-3700