11' 1 HL COL'\ IY COL R r OF \'JCTORl \

County Court Case :\o:C'R-12-01126

lnd1cu11cnl :--.o. C' I 0133516 AT f\1ELBOL RNE

fllE \1ATTER OF:

THE DIRECTOR or PUBLIC PROSl CL TI0'\5

\'.

DA \"ID\\ 11 L.IA\1 OSBOR'\F

l\OTICE Of E\ IDENCE

Pursuanl Ill Practice "lllh! 2-20 I 0. Paragraph 54

·1H15 1\1 \I I ER Jc:; LIS'I ED FOR ,\ 11 RS1 DIRl:.CTIO'\S Ii E1\Rl'\G 0'\;· "\I J ul~ 2012

fhc Prosecution pmpllscs w ac.ld111.e the foll0\\ ing C\ idem:c at tnnl:

Date ol Documcnl 24 July 2012

OPP.3026.001.0613_E_R

IN I Ill· ~1 \<.ii::- I Rr\ l I s <. c >UR I or \ J( I ORI.\ ,\I ~11 I BOL R'I CRl~ll~ \I J I Rl!-.Dlt 110~

IN I HI ~1 \I I I·R OJ S.:.:11011 C17of1h,· h tdcncc ,\.:1 200l\

f)I 11 C I l\'I sI :'\ICJR < o:--:s I \Bl f· ROii \;-,:BODS\\ llR 111

\.

()\\ID OSBCll{ \II·

'011( •.: I F:'\Dl''C \ J:\ IOE:\CT~

Datl· <lf lll1cumen1·

St:n cd 1•11 hdtalf of, DI 11 <. 11\ I sE>.!ll >R < <)'\\I \Bl I Kt II I \!\ BODS\\ OR 111

t> cpa1eJ h\

~ \flh..:1ll'f 1l1 l'ubh.: t>1 oscd1tions 56'" I onslh1lc Su eel

s.,Jidto1', l'nde: "'"9 I dt'phon. ( O' ) '"''I' ~ 666

Dm:.:1 1d!11!1IJ'!11

~klboumc \'1.: ~011!1 Rckn:nL c I 100' 111

REDACTED

No1kL' j, hcr.:h~ gi\Cll pursuant hl sQ7( I) of the I \id~·ncc \cl ~llllX 1"1lw \1:t'") 1hat

the l'w~cc111i1>n intend-.. t(I ;1dd111:e •·tt.·ndem:~ l'\ id.:nn~ ... 1ha1 i'. C\ 1d.:no.L' 111 thc ch.1mdl.:'t, 1 ql\11.111011 ,,, condu.:t 1•1 a 1wr~.111. or tcmkn. ~ Ihm .1 pu~nn h.1 ... l•r h.id Ill pnl\ c that :1 pcrs1111 ha-. 11r lwd a 1cndcnL~ 1 "h.:lhcr ix'l'lllt.,c ,11 1hc pcr-.nn ·" d1.11.1ckr 01 nthl'I\\ j,c) 111 .id 111 :1

parucular '\ .1~ l'r w h,1\c ,, p:irtit.'ul.11 ..,t.llc "' nund

h rndicatcd 111 I ahlc \ hd''". tlw ti:ndc111:~ .._., 1<lcn~c rdai..::- 111 1h.: IPllo\\ 1ng 1.ll'l(sl

Ill ''"lll! Ill I he pl ll~Ci:dmg..

I\ I \

OPP.3026.001.0614_E_R

l .thk \ Rd.:\ ant laclL8_ 111 1~sm:

fCH.\R<. 1~s _____ .. _. \( l(S) " ISSl E TO " lfl( II ·1111: I .. ,m_,n n 11>1'( 1-. RI• I.\ n:s _____ ~----r I. lndc.:cnl .1s-...1uh upon \\ hcthcr 1hc ,1ccuscd k1s~cd rho: ..:1•111plain.1111 1•n the nwuth

.1m.1lc :!. Indecent assault uron .1 m.alc ~ Indecent ,,s,,auh upon :tmak .t lndcn:nt ass.mil upon .1mak

\\ 111.:ther the ;1cc11scd 111.1sturh.1kd the compl.1in;1111's pents

I hl· ll'mlcnc) '11ught tu ht pr<'\cd 1~ 1h.;- lcndcnc) nl ll \\ID OSB< >RN! 10

(:1) ha\..:,, parllcul;tr stale nl msnd. n;und) In h<1H' .1 -..c\Ual 11111.:1.;st in 1hc Cl>mpl.1111.mt. and

I h 1 .1c1 111 ,, p.1rt1cul.1r "·•). 11.11111:1) to acl upon th.ti scxu.1l 1111crc~1 .111J t\l engage 111 '<e\ u;il .1.;1i' ll) ''uh th..: <.:('lllJ'l.1111mi1

~ \s mdtl"<llcd 111 l :1bk B hdm\. the O:l•nducl ''' "l11ch c\ 1tk·11c.: '' 111 h.: addu;;cd .• ind p.1r11..:ul.1rs nl the date. tun..:,\;: pl.11:c lll & 1hc cm;um,,1.111..:c" m '' lm:h th.11 c11nd11c1 t•ccurn:d. ,111d the n.un..- 1•1' cadi pcr-1m "ho sa\\. heard t•r 1•lhcrn 1sc pcr.:el\ .:d I hat 1.:11ntlt1l'I, .1rc.

I\ I\

OPP.3026.001.0615_E_R

I able B Particulars ofCt•ndud

DESCRIPI 10'\ OF CO'-OlCf I I h~ .1 ·.;11,,.:d \\ oul<l 1-iss th<.' c<'mrlam.1111 un th.: nwulh t c:lrnn::c I and uncharj!cd actq

2 I he :tl!l..'ll'ed \\ nuld h'mll.: Ill<.' CCllllJ)la1111111 ·s h:,1ick<.

(dllll1?l' :?.J nn<l unch11rgcd act\)

T l>\f'l:

Unl-110" 11

l'J lk\'Clllhcr 1%9 25 \I.iv I <>70

14 lkccmh~·r

1%9 25 \11) I lJ70

l<l Dcccmhcr I %9 25 \I.I) I <)70

N1dn

I rt. \CI:

hkn l\1rk Sah :111011 \ml\ 1101111!, \\ ISIO\\

i-

S\

l he Ba.,111. V1c.:1t1n.1

i he Tfasin. \ 1dnria

I he lt1sm. \ '1c.:111n.1

CIRC l \IS r \ W FS \\I f''-LSS(ES)

\\ h.:n It.: ·1:n11soled· me h.: \\nuld tdl Ill<.' that he Stcph.:n <rR \'.'\I \\11ul1l tak..: me (lUI nl thc1,• .1ml h.: \\ould 1h.:11 pull nw up harJ 11g.11nst 1h..: I runt of hi,., ho<l) 111 .1 11ght hug nnd J..:1,.,,., 111.: I h.: kiss \\as ,1 kmg tongu~· kiss I Ins \\ :t:. n.:arl) e'er) 111ght that I "oultl h;I\.: l<l

m.:l..'t him "h.:n 1 ''il' in the l'>n~ ·, ho_n_1c_. __ ~ • \\\:had the ·normal J,,j,s·. the lnng mouth 1.;,.,, and

then I don· 1 \\ h:ll .. 1.1rt.:d it hut m~ p) iamn pants \\ere uncln1w (drnree I)

C .1ptain < hh1m1e ''"" desc.:nh111g 1h.: dillercnl S1.:ph.:n <•R \NI p;trts 111 111~ genital' and '•l) ing lil,,e. •· llli" i-. the le,le,:·. I don· 1 l..110\\ hcl\\ lung he lotu:li.:<l m~ h,11ls fo1. ii \\1H1ld h,l\C been .1 shurl ''hile trhn~l' 2) It then happ~nl!d ag.1in. I can'1 s.I) ti it""' lht.> ncxt 111gh1 or .1 li11k \\ hilc I.lier h111 11 ''·'"the ,;ime thmg ;md I \\:is .. 1111 n;m c as t11 \\hat he ".1s dnrng \gain 11 \\ .1s 'iC\ .:cluca1111n .Uld that pan of Ill)

b1'd) . \gam he ''.ts h1lkhng me 111 his hand. hol<lmg mv l\."'ICs .111d I thinJ.; 1111 tl11s occas11'l1 th,·r..: \H ts nwre tuudm1g .111tl II \\ "" for longer It ha<l gunl" lrnm 1ust 111111 h11ld111!! 111) testes to 111111 londlmg Ill) penis until 11 hc..:mne h,ml (ch:tr:?l' J)

Stephen GR \~ I

Sl BSI \'-CF OF F\ IDE\CJ• !'.tgl..' 25.2il I IUll

Pau~· 21J llUB

1\ 1\

OPP.3026.001.0616_E_R

f){ "C Rll1 110:\ OF (0,IHCI'

1 I IH.' .11.:cuscd '' nuld 111a ... 111rh.11c the n1111plainant"' tcsuck,. (charge -4)

°' I h1.: .1ccu,c<l \\ nuld discui;., "il"\ual l·<luc.11ion and the .. 11mpl.1inant ·' 1c ... 1c' '' ith the <.: Olll pla 111.1111

D' n :

[I)

Dci:i.:mbcr I %9 ~5

\la;. I <no

It)

Dc<.:<:mhcr 1%l) 25 ~la;. pro

l'f\IE

:-.l1gh1

Pl \0

I he B;hm. \'11;tnna

rhc 0 ..... 111.

\ 1<.:lllrJll

cmn \ IST \ Cf s \\I l '\LS~ ( ES)

1 lus \\l'lll on ,1 le\\ llllll'l" 111m.:s on d1ffcrcnt mghls Sh:phcn CiR.\l\ I until ii <lidn'1 seem righl Ill me. I \\lHtl\I ~a~ 1ha1 lhcrl' ''a" .1hn111 tom dirti:rcnl 111gh1s 1ha1 he came in o.:fnrc I rca(i,l·J that\\ hath.: \\,IS doing \\a ... 11·t right. I didn·11111dcNanJ \\h) hl· kepi nn coming

-+--1n_1_0_1.:~·'pl.11111hau1art nl 1m hod-. On the lasl 111gh1 II happcued C .1p1ain Osh1,111c :--tq>heu <iR \NI ngmn came 11110 Ill) mom and "·" nu thc bed h• J;l\C me '"x cducalmn, \111 can rcmemb,·r 1s that he sat''" Ill) hc<l .1ga111

.md that m;. pants" ere open .111d lw ''.is t<1uching my pc111s aml '' ha1 I \\ uul<l ,·all 11xl.1;. ·m, .... 111rb;i1ing_: nw "uh tHll' of hi" h.md~ ( .1p1;1in < lshomc \\lls descrihiny thc dil lcr.:nt l':tns ol 111~ g.:ni1.1h and :>a) ini::. likl'. .. Thi' i-. the 1.: .. tc' ". I don 1 l..110\\ lum long Ill' touclw<l Ill) halls tnr. II \\ ould ha\ c been a :-ho11 I\ hik \g,un 11 I\ ,Ji, :>C\ c<lucal 1,111 .11nl 1ha1 p;irt ''' 111) bc•d~ ~g.un hl' \\ "" holdml! me 111 Im: ham!. hol<l111g Ill) tcslc.., an<l I lhmk on 1!11!'< Ol"Ca..,1011

there \\,ts morc loudung .111d 11\\<IS101 lonl!Cf I 1lid11'111nder;.1<111d \\h) hc l...:pt on coming in 10 .:\pl.1111 that p.1rt ol Ill) hod) I '' omkr.:<l h) :I. !rs c lsb1.11·11.: \\ ,1,n·l l"\plaining 'e' ..:d111.:.1liCl11 h• m.: ;md \\ h~ <.he \\.Ni' 1 around \\hen II \\ ..... happcnmg

• On the last 111ght 11 happened C.1p1.1111 llslwmc :igai11 .:;im~· tnh• my r<lom and ~ii <'n the h..:d to

Stcph..:n CiR \NI

-~------1

:--l llS I \\( l OF l·\ ll>E'\( l< P·tt!~ 'O Ill B

P.1gc 'O 111 B

l1.1gc 'o llUB

l'al!c 10 I IL B

Pagl.' '"Ill B

I\ I\

OPP.3026.001.0617_E_R