patrick discussant phd conference 2012

17

Click here to load reader

Upload: anucrawfordphd

Post on 14-May-2015

860 views

Category:

Documents


4 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Patrick discussant PhD Conference 2012

Comments on Yingying Lu’s Emissions intensitytargeting: From China’s 12th five year plan to its

Copenhagen commitment

Patrick [email protected]

PhD Candidate, Resource Management in Asia-Pacific & Environment and DevelopmentProgram, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University

November 27 2012,Canberra, Australia

Doupe - Discussant (Lu) (ANU) Emissions intensity targeting Crawford PhD Conference 2012 1 / 4

Page 2: Patrick discussant PhD Conference 2012

Why and what

This is a paper about the meeting environmental policy targets.

China (and others) are focusing on emissions intensity targeting

Intensity = Emissions LevelsIncome

Chinese climate policy is important

Enviro econ 101 focuses on levels

Finds that there is a set of emissions-growth trajectories that can achieveChina’s domestic and international commitments

Doupe - Discussant (Lu) (ANU) Emissions intensity targeting Crawford PhD Conference 2012 2 / 4

Page 3: Patrick discussant PhD Conference 2012

Why and what

This is a paper about the meeting environmental policy targets.

China (and others) are focusing on emissions intensity targeting

Intensity = Emissions LevelsIncome

Chinese climate policy is important

Enviro econ 101 focuses on levels

Finds that there is a set of emissions-growth trajectories that can achieveChina’s domestic and international commitments

Doupe - Discussant (Lu) (ANU) Emissions intensity targeting Crawford PhD Conference 2012 2 / 4

Page 4: Patrick discussant PhD Conference 2012

Why and what

This is a paper about the meeting environmental policy targets.

China (and others) are focusing on emissions intensity targeting

Intensity = Emissions LevelsIncome

Chinese climate policy is important

Enviro econ 101 focuses on levels

Finds that there is a set of emissions-growth trajectories that can achieveChina’s domestic and international commitments

Doupe - Discussant (Lu) (ANU) Emissions intensity targeting Crawford PhD Conference 2012 2 / 4

Page 5: Patrick discussant PhD Conference 2012

Why and what

This is a paper about the meeting environmental policy targets.

China (and others) are focusing on emissions intensity targeting

Intensity = Emissions LevelsIncome

Chinese climate policy is important

Enviro econ 101 focuses on levels

Finds that there is a set of emissions-growth trajectories that can achieveChina’s domestic and international commitments

Doupe - Discussant (Lu) (ANU) Emissions intensity targeting Crawford PhD Conference 2012 2 / 4

Page 6: Patrick discussant PhD Conference 2012

Why and what

This is a paper about the meeting environmental policy targets.

China (and others) are focusing on emissions intensity targeting

Intensity = Emissions LevelsIncome

Chinese climate policy is important

Enviro econ 101 focuses on levels

Finds that there is a set of emissions-growth trajectories that can achieveChina’s domestic and international commitments

Doupe - Discussant (Lu) (ANU) Emissions intensity targeting Crawford PhD Conference 2012 2 / 4

Page 7: Patrick discussant PhD Conference 2012

Why and what

This is a paper about the meeting environmental policy targets.

China (and others) are focusing on emissions intensity targeting

Intensity = Emissions LevelsIncome

Chinese climate policy is important

Enviro econ 101 focuses on levels

Finds that there is a set of emissions-growth trajectories that can achieveChina’s domestic and international commitments

Doupe - Discussant (Lu) (ANU) Emissions intensity targeting Crawford PhD Conference 2012 2 / 4

Page 8: Patrick discussant PhD Conference 2012

Levels, income and intensity

Emissions Levels(E )

Income(I )

E = Intensity0 × I

E = Intensity1 × I

Doupe - Discussant (Lu) (ANU) Emissions intensity targeting Crawford PhD Conference 2012 3 / 4

Page 9: Patrick discussant PhD Conference 2012

Levels, income and intensity

Emissions Levels(E )

Income(I )

E = Intensity0 × I

E = Intensity1 × I

Doupe - Discussant (Lu) (ANU) Emissions intensity targeting Crawford PhD Conference 2012 3 / 4

Page 10: Patrick discussant PhD Conference 2012

Comments

How is this modelled?

Technology change (AEEI) appears to be exogenousThere is a numerical algorithm from a previous paper

minTax Profile

Economic Loss subject to Intensity Target

So, what does this paper do that is novel?

Broader question

How does one design policy that achieves a medium term emissionsintensity target?

Doupe - Discussant (Lu) (ANU) Emissions intensity targeting Crawford PhD Conference 2012 4 / 4

Page 11: Patrick discussant PhD Conference 2012

Comments

How is this modelled?

Technology change (AEEI) appears to be exogenousThere is a numerical algorithm from a previous paper

minTax Profile

Economic Loss subject to Intensity Target

So, what does this paper do that is novel?

Broader question

How does one design policy that achieves a medium term emissionsintensity target?

Doupe - Discussant (Lu) (ANU) Emissions intensity targeting Crawford PhD Conference 2012 4 / 4

Page 12: Patrick discussant PhD Conference 2012

Comments

How is this modelled?

Technology change (AEEI) appears to be exogenous

There is a numerical algorithm from a previous paper

minTax Profile

Economic Loss subject to Intensity Target

So, what does this paper do that is novel?

Broader question

How does one design policy that achieves a medium term emissionsintensity target?

Doupe - Discussant (Lu) (ANU) Emissions intensity targeting Crawford PhD Conference 2012 4 / 4

Page 13: Patrick discussant PhD Conference 2012

Comments

How is this modelled?

Technology change (AEEI) appears to be exogenousThere is a numerical algorithm from a previous paper

minTax Profile

Economic Loss subject to Intensity Target

So, what does this paper do that is novel?

Broader question

How does one design policy that achieves a medium term emissionsintensity target?

Doupe - Discussant (Lu) (ANU) Emissions intensity targeting Crawford PhD Conference 2012 4 / 4

Page 14: Patrick discussant PhD Conference 2012

Comments

How is this modelled?

Technology change (AEEI) appears to be exogenousThere is a numerical algorithm from a previous paper

minTax Profile

Economic Loss subject to Intensity Target

So, what does this paper do that is novel?

Broader question

How does one design policy that achieves a medium term emissionsintensity target?

Doupe - Discussant (Lu) (ANU) Emissions intensity targeting Crawford PhD Conference 2012 4 / 4

Page 15: Patrick discussant PhD Conference 2012

Comments

How is this modelled?

Technology change (AEEI) appears to be exogenousThere is a numerical algorithm from a previous paper

minTax Profile

Economic Loss subject to Intensity Target

So, what does this paper do that is novel?

Broader question

How does one design policy that achieves a medium term emissionsintensity target?

Doupe - Discussant (Lu) (ANU) Emissions intensity targeting Crawford PhD Conference 2012 4 / 4

Page 16: Patrick discussant PhD Conference 2012

Comments

How is this modelled?

Technology change (AEEI) appears to be exogenousThere is a numerical algorithm from a previous paper

minTax Profile

Economic Loss subject to Intensity Target

So, what does this paper do that is novel?

Broader question

How does one design policy that achieves a medium term emissionsintensity target?

Doupe - Discussant (Lu) (ANU) Emissions intensity targeting Crawford PhD Conference 2012 4 / 4

Page 17: Patrick discussant PhD Conference 2012

Comments

How is this modelled?

Technology change (AEEI) appears to be exogenousThere is a numerical algorithm from a previous paper

minTax Profile

Economic Loss subject to Intensity Target

So, what does this paper do that is novel?

Broader question

How does one design policy that achieves a medium term emissionsintensity target?

Doupe - Discussant (Lu) (ANU) Emissions intensity targeting Crawford PhD Conference 2012 4 / 4