pgpf progress report

8/2/2019 PGPF Progress Report

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pgpf-progress-report 1/44

!"#"$%&'%!"#"$()*%

+),*-.#/)*%

!$)&$"((%$"!)$#0112%3%0144



!"#$%&'()

*+%,#-%./#01-2#3456'"47#745689":#;<'(9=>?7#@97=>A#=B>A1

A'":'7#4B(%5:B#>#=5((9=5A5<#6'&'A%,'6#C8#D%5"6>49%"#

:(>"4''#$%A5<C9>#+'>=B'(7#$%AA':'E#F>(49=9,>"47#>4#D%5"16>49%"#:(>"4''#G%C9A9H'I%(:?7#J'<%=(>=8#KIL#M>49%">A#

N%54B#35<<94#9"#$B9=>:%/#O0E#@%(<'(#$B>9(<>"#%@ #4B'#

D'6'(>A#-'7'(&'#F>5A#P%A=Q'(#9"#>#&96'%#,(',>('6#@%(#4B'#

D%5"6>49%"?7#KLRL#D97=>A#35<<94I

*3'=%"6#-%.#@(%<#+%,/#01-2#D%(<'(#!GS#J9('=4%(#;A9='#

-9&A9"#>4#4B'#D%5"6>49%"?7#KLRL#D97=>A#35<<94E#D%(<'(#

F('796'"4#S9AA#$A9"4%"#>4#4B'#D%5"6>49%"?7#KLRR#D97=>A#

35<<94E#F>(49=9,>"4#>4#D%5"6>49%"#:(>"4''#;<'(9=>1

3,'>Q7?#T!5(#S56:'4/#!5(#U=%"%<8V#'&'"4#9"#FB9A>6'A1,B9>E#M>49%">A#U=%"%<9=#$%5"=9A#J9('=4%(#W'"'#3,'(A9":#

>4#4B'#D%5"6>49%"?7#KLRR#D97=>A#35<<94I

*+B9(6#-%.#@(%<#+%,/#01-2#F>(49=9,>"47#>4#D%5"6>49%"#

:(>"4''#;<'(9=>3,'>Q7?#T!5(#S56:'4/#!5(#U=%"%<8V#

'&'"4#9"#F%(4A>"6/#!(':%"E#O<>:'#@(%<#>"#'65=>49%">A#

4'A'&979%"#>6#>9('6#C8#4B'#D%5"6>49%"#65(9":#>#M'.#

X><,7B9('#F('796'"49>A#J'C>4'E#FS3#7'"9%(#=%(('7,%"1

6'"4#Y568#Z%%6(5@@ #.94B#[I3I#3'">4%(7#3>\C8#$B><CA977/#G>(Q#Z>("'(/#G9Q'#$(>,%/#>"6#J9=Q#J5(C9"#>4#4B'#D%5"1

6>49%"?7#KLRR#D97=>A#35<<94I

*S%44%<#-%./#01-2#$S3?7#0'7A'8#34>BA/#@%(<'(#ZB94'#

X%57'#$B9'@#%@ #34>@@ #U(7Q9"'#S%.A'7/#>"6#@%(<'(#[I3I#

3'">4%(#;A>"#39<,7%"#>4#4B'#D%5"6>49%"?7#KLRL#D97=>A#

35<<94E#X%57'#S56:'4#$%<<944''#$B>9(<>"##F>5A#-8>"#

>4#4B'#D%5"6>49%"?7#KLRR#D97=>A#35<<94E#F>(49=9,>"4#>4#

D%5"6>49%"#:(>"4''#;<'(9=>3,'>Q7?#T!5(#S56:'4/#!5(#

U=%"%<8V#'&'"4#9"#FB9A>6'A,B9>I



!"#$%%$&"'&()"*+$",+-.&)-/" ! "

01&"'.23-4",+-44$/5$2"

-/6"01&"7.22.(/!! #

81.46./5",(/2$/212"(/"

9(4.3:";(41%.(/2

$%&'(&)&*!+%,)$-./0(12!/&3!(4PE152!

5%!/&26(1!57(!8)2$/,!$7/,,(&*(! 9

:,;(+1)&52!8%1!8)2$/,!/$5)%&!/$1%22!

57(!)3(%,%*)$/,!2+($51;.!! <#

/331(22)&*!57(!7(/,57!$/1(!$7/,,(&*(!! <=

/,)*&)&*!&/5)%&/,!2($;1)5-!6)57!($%&%.)$!2($;1)5-!! <>!

:;),3)&*!.%.(&5;.!8%1!+%,)$-!/$5)%&

)&!6/27)&*5%&!! "?

<613-%./5"-/6"!3%.=-%./5"

%+$"!)$&.3-/"91>4.3!

+1(2(&5)&*!57(!8/$52!/&3!

/&/,-@)&*!57(!%+5)%&2! ""

:;),3)&*!+;:,)$!/6/1(&(22!/:%;5!

%;1!8)2$/,!8;5;1(! "#!

1(/$7)&*!/;3)(&$(2!/$1%22!57(!$%;&51-! "=

:1)&*)&*!57(!+(%+,(A2!'%)$(!5%!57(!

:;3*(5!3(:/5(! ">

5(/$7)&*!-%;&*!/.(1)$/&2!/:%;5!

57()1!8)2$/,!8;5;1(! B?

(&*/*)&*!57(!&(45!*(&(1/5)%&! B"

!>(1%"%+$"'(1/6-%.(/

,)25)&*!%8!*1/&5((2! BC

8)&/&$)/,!%'(1')(6! B9

8%;&3/5)%&!,(/3(127)+!

/&3!/3')2%1-!:%/132! #?

+(5(1!*D!+(5(12%&!8%;&3/5)%&!

+1%*1(22!1(+%15!"??>!E!"?<<



?

/!,(55(1!81%.!57(!$7/)1./&

)AF!GHIJK!LMNJO!PQR!)!OJSTOJO!IG!MILUI!L!HGVKOLITGK!

HGSVMJO!GK!LOOUJMMTKW!/FJUTSLAM!XGKWYIJUF!HTMSLX!SQLXY

XJKWJMZ!PQTSQ!)!SGKMTOJU!L![UTFLUR!IQUJLI!IG!/FJUTSLAM!

JSGKGFTS! HVIVUJD! 5QJ! MTF[XJ! LKMPJU! TM! IQLIZ! TK! FR!

FTKOZ!)!QLO!KG!SQGTSJD!

/!HJP!RJLUM!LWGZ!)!HLSJO!IQJ!\VJMITGK!GH!PQLI!IG!OG!

PTIQ! IQJ! ]VXN! GH!FR! [JUMGKLX! HTKLKSTLX! UJMGVUSJMD! )!

NKJP!IQLI!)!QLO!FGUJ!IQLK!JKGVWQD!)!LXMG!HJXI!IQLI!IQJ!

/FJUTSLK! JSGKGFTS! MRMIJFZ!PQTSQ! QLO![UG^TOJO! MG!

FVSQ!G[[GUIVKTIR!IG!FJZ!PLM! TK![JUTXD!2NRUGSNJITKW!

XJ^JXM!GH![UG_JSIJO!XGKWYIJUF!OJ]I!KGI!GKXR!ULTMJO!IQJ!

UTMN!GH!L!HTKLKSTLX!SUTMTMZ!]VI!PJUJ!LXMG!IQUJLIJKTKW!IG!MITHXJ! JSGKGFTS! WUGPIQZ! SQGNJ! GHH! SUTITSLXXR! KJJOJO!

TK^JMIFJKIM! TK! JOVSLITGKZ! MNTXXM! IULTKTKWZ! TKHULMIUVSY

IVUJZ!LKO!TKKG^LITGKZ![LMM!GK!L!QVWJ!]VUOJK!GH!OJ]I!

IG![JG[XJ!TK!FR!KTKJ!WULKOSQTXOUJKAM!WJKJULITGKZ!LKO!

]LKNUV[I!IQJ!MGSTLX!MLHJIR!KJI![UGWULFM!IQLI!MG!FLKR!

UJXR! GKD! 8VUIQJUFGUJZ! IQJ! TKJ\VLXTIR! GH! TKSGFJ! TK!

IQJ!;D2D!QLO!UJLSQJO!IQJ!QTWQJMI!XJ^JXM!MTKSJ!<9">Z!

IQUJLIJKTKW!IQJ!TOJLX!GH!HLTUKJMM!LKO!G[[GUIVKTIR!HGU!

LXX!/FJUTSLKMD

5QJ!/FJUTSLK!3UJLF!TM!LK!TOJL!TKMITXXJO!TK!FJ!HUGF!

L!RGVKW!LWJD!.R![LUJKIM!PJUJ!*UJJN!TFFTWULKIM!PQG!

SLFJ!IG!IQTM!SGVKIUR!PTIQ!GKXR!L!IQTUOYWULOJ!JOVSLITGKZ!

]LUJXR!LKR!(KWXTMQZ!LKO!_VMI![JKKTJM!TK!IQJTU![GSNJIMD!

/HIJU!MJIIXTKW!TK!IQJ!MFLXX!IGPK!GH!0JLUKJRZ!&J]ULMNLZ!

IQJR!G[JKJO!IQJ!TKJ^TIL]XJ!*UJJN!OTKJUD!)I!PLM!SJUILTKXR!

KGI!OTMITKWVTMQJO!HGU!TIM!SVTMTKJZ!]VI!ULIQJU!HGU!IQJ!HLSI!

IQLI!TI!PLM!G[JK!"#!QGVUM!L!OLRZ!`!OLRM!L!PJJN!HGU!

"C!RJLUMD!.R![LUJKIM!PGUNJO!MG!QLUO!LXX!IQGMJ!RJLUM!

]JSLVMJ! IQJR!PLKIJO!FR!]UGIQJU!LKO!FJ!IG!WJI!IQJ!

]JMI!JOVSLITGK!LKO!QL^J!IQJ!G[[GUIVKTIR!IG![VUMVJ!IQJ!

/FJUTSLK!3UJLFD

)K!J^JUR!UJM[JSIZ!)!QL^J!]JJK!IQJ!XVSNTJMI!GH!/FJUTSLK!

3UJLFJUMD!8UGF!]VMTKJMM!IG!WG^JUKFJKI!IG!HTKLKSJZ!

)! QL^J! QLO! G[[GUIVKTITJM! IQLI! PJUJ! GKXR! L^LTXL]XJ!

TK!/FJUTSLD! /KO! )! PLKI! HVIVUJ! WJKJULITGKM! IG! QL J!

IQJ! G[[GUIVKTIR! IG! UJLXTaJ! IQJTU! GPK! ^JUMTGK! GH! IQJ!

/FJUTSLK!3UJLFD!

/M!)!MLP!GVU!KLITGKLX!XJLOJUM!WG!RJLU!LHIJU!RJLU!]XTIQJXR!

TWKGUTKW!GVU! XGGFTKW! XGKWYIJUF! OJHTSTIM! LKO! OJ]IZ! )!

NKJP!)!QLO!IG!OG!MGFJIQTKWD!)!SGVXOKAI!TFLWTKJ!PLNTKW!

/!XTHJITFJ!GH!G[[GUIVKTIR!TKM[TUJO!GVU!HGVKOJUAM!

FTMMTGK!IG![UJMJU^J!IQJ!/FJUTSLK!3UJLFD

+(5(1!*D!+(5(12%&



" @

V[!TK!<?!GU!"?!RJLUM!TK!L!PJLNJKJO!/FJUTSL!IQLI!QLO!

XGMI!IQJ!/FJUTSLK!3UJLFZ!LKO!KGI!QL^TKW!IUTJO!IG!OG!

MGFJIQTKW!L]GVI!TID!5QJ!PGUOM!GH!FR!HGUFJU![UGHJMMGU!

LI!IQJ!;KT^JUMTIR!GH!$QTSLWGZ!*JGUWJ!2ITWXJUZ!ULKW!TK!FR!JLUMb!c)H!GKJ!QLM!KG!LXIJUKLIT^JZ!GKJ!QLM!KG![UG]XJFDd!

2G!TK!UJLXTIRZ!)!QLO!KG!LXIJUKLIT^J!]VI!IG!IURD

)!MILUIJO!IQJ!+JIJU!*D!+JIJUMGK!8GVKOLITGK!IG!JKWLWJ!

PTIQ![JG[XJ!LXX!LSUGMM!/FJUTSL!E![GXTSRFLNJUMZ!]VOWJI!

Je[JUIMZ!]VMTKJMM!XJLOJUMZ!_GVUKLXTMIMZ!LSLOJFTSMZ!LKO!

STITaJKM!GH!J^JUR!WJKJULITGK!f!HULKNXRZ!LKRGKJ!PQG!PTXX!

XTMIJKD!6J!QL^J!QLO!IQJ!QJX[!GH!MGFJ!GVIMILKOTKW!TKOTY

^TOVLXMZ! TKSXVOTKW! GVU! HTUMI!$(%Z!HGUFJU! $GF[IUGXXJU!

*JKJULX!GH!IQJ!;KTIJO!2ILIJM!3L^TO!6LXNJUZ!PQG!QLM!

OJFGKMIULIJO!ITUJXJMM!OJOTSLITGK!IG!HTMSLX!TMMVJMD

:R! [V]XTSTaTKW! IQJ! OTMFLX! IUVIQM! L]GVI! /FJUTSLAM!

XGKWYIJUF!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJM!LKOZ!J^JK!FGUJ!TF[GUILKIY

XRZ!GHHJUTKW!L!QG[JHVXZ![GMTIT^J!^TMTGK!GH!LK!/FJUTSL!IQLI!

TM!HTMSLXXR!MGVKOZ!JSGKGFTSLXXR!MJSVUJZ!LKO!]UTFFTKW!

PTIQ! G[[GUIVKTIRZ!PJ!QG[J! IG! MITFVXLIJ![UGWUJMM! GK!

MGXVITGKM!LKO!JKMVUJ!IQLI!GVU!KLITGK!QLM!IQJ!UJMGVUSJM!

IG!]VTXO!LK!TK^JMIFJKI!LKO!TKKG^LITGK!JSGKGFR!IQLI!TM!

WXG]LXXR!SGF[JITIT^J!HGU!OJSLOJM!IG!SGFJD

5QJ!/FJUTSL!PJ!JK^TMTGK!QLM!L!MIUGKW!FTOOXJ!SXLMMZ!

GHHJUTKW!_G]M!LKO!PTOJXR!MQLUJO![UGM[JUTIR!LKO!WT^TKW!

LXX![JG[XJZ!KG!FLIIJU!PQJUJ!IQJR!MILUI!TK!XTHJZ!IQJ!G[[GUY

IVKTIR!IG!SXTF]!IQJ!XLOOJU!GH!JSGKGFTS!MVSSJMMD!/KO!

LM!PJ!FLNJ!IQJ!IGVWQ!SQGTSJM!UJ\VTUJO!IG!UJOVSJ!GVU!

XGKWYIJUF!OJ]I!IG!MVMILTKL]XJ!XJ^JXMZ!PJZ!IQJ!UTSQJMI!

GH!KLITGKMZ!FVMI!LXMG![UJMJU^J!IQJ!MLHJIR!KJI!HGU!IQJ!

^VXKJUL]XJD

5QJ!HTUMI! IQUJJ!RJLUM! GH!GVU!8GVKOLITGKAM!G[JULITGKM!

QL^J!]UGVWQI!FJ!WUJLI!MLITMHLSITGKD!%VU!KLITGKAM!HTMSLX!

[UG]XJFM!LUJ!MJUTGVMZ!]VI! )!LF!G[ITFTMITS!IQLI! IQJR!

SLK!]J!MGX^JOD!3JM[TIJ!HUJ\VJKI![GXTITSLX!PULKWXTKW!LKO!

MXGP![UGWUJMMZ!L!SGKMJKMVM!QLM!JFJUWJO!LSUGMM!IQJ!

KLITGK!LKO!LSUGMM!IQJ![GXTITSLX!M[JSIUVF!IQLI!PJ!SLK!

KG!XGKWJU!TWKGUJ!HTMSLX!UJLXTIRD!5QJ!/FJUTSLK![JG[XJ!QL^J!WUGPK!OJJ[XR!HUVMIULIJO!PTIQ!L!6LMQTKWIGK!IQLI!

GHIJK!MJJFM!IGG!HGSVMJO!GK!TOJGXGWR!LKO!VKPTXXTKW!IG!

UJLSQ!LSUGMM!IQJ!LTMXJD!5QJR!]JXTJ^J!PJ!FVMI!SQLKWJ!

SGVUMJ!LKO!IQJR!LUJ!JLWJU!HGU![GXTSRFLNJUM!IG!JKLSI!

MGXVITGKMD!6QTXJ!IQJ!TF[LSI!GH!GVU!HVKOLFJKILX!]VOWJI!

SQLXXJKWJM!PTXX!]J!HJXI!G^JU!IQJ!XGKW!IJUFZ!TI!TM!TF[JULY

IT^J!IQLI!PJ!]JWTK!IG!LOOUJMM!IQJMJ!SQLXXJKWJM!MGGKJU!

ULIQJU!IQLK!XLIJUD!5QJ!KJeI!HJP!RJLUM!PTXX!]J!OJSTMT^J!TK!

OJIJUFTKTKW!IQJ!XGKWYIJUF!HTMSLX!HVIVUJ!E!LKO!IQJUJHGUJ!

IQJ!JSGKGFTS!HVIVUJ!E!GH!GVU!KLITGKD

5QTM!UJ[GUI![UG^TOJM!LK!G^JU^TJP!GH!GVU!TKTITLIT^JM!LKO!

WULKIYFLNTKW!MTKSJ!GVU!XLVKSQ!TK!"??>D!)I!TM!IQJ!HTUMI!

SQL[IJU!TK!GVU!MIGUR!E!GKJ!IQLI!)!]JXTJ^J!PTXX!QL^J!L!

MVSSJMMHVX! SGKSXVMTGKD!6J! XGGN! HGUPLUO! IG! UJWVXLUXR!

V[OLITKW!RGV!GK!GVU![UGWUJMM!E!LKO!IG!QTWQXTWQITKW!QGP!

GVU!KLITGK!TM![UGWUJMMTKW!TK!SGKHUGKITKW!TIM!XGKWYIJUF!

HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJM!LKO![UJMJU^TKW!IQJ!/FJUTSLK!3UJLFD

+(5(!+(5(12%&

$QLTUFLK!LKO!$(%



A

/.(1)$/A2!($%&%.)$!/&3!8)2$/,!$7/,,(&*(

/!QJLXIQRZ! WUGPTKW!JSGKGFR! TM!SUTITSLX! IG! TF[UG^TKW!

GVU!\VLXTIR!GH!XTHJ!LKO!FLTKILTKTKW!IQJ!/FJUTSLK!3UJLF!

HGU!SVUUJKI!LKO!HVIVUJ!WJKJULITGKMD!5GOLRAM![UJMMTKW!

JSGKGFTS!SQLXXJKWJM!FVMI!]J!LOOUJMMJOZ!RJI!J^JK!XLUY!

WJU!XGKWYIJUF!JSGKGFTS!LKO!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJM!XTJ!LQJLOD

)K!GUOJU!HGU!GVU!JSGKGFR!IG! IQUT^J! TK!IQJ!HVIVUJZ!PJ!KJJO!IG!FLNJ!PTMJ!OJSTMTGKM! IGOLRD! )K!LKR! HTKLKSTLX!

GU! JSGKGFTS! LSIT TIRZ! L! [UGM[JUGVM! HVIVUJ! UJ\VTUJM!

[UVOJKI!TK^JMIFJKIM!IQLI!WJKJULIJ![UGOVSIT^J!UJIVUKMD!

5QJ! MVSSJMM! GH! GVU! JSGKGFR! UJMIM! TK! IQJ! QLKOM! GH!

/FJUTSLK!PGUNJUMZ!JKIUJ[UJKJVUMZ!LKO!]VMTKJMMJMZ!LXX!

GH!PQGF!KJJO!L!QJLXIQR!SXTFLIJ!TK!PQTSQ! IG!TK^JMIZ!

TKKG^LIJZ!LKO!]VTXOD!

5QJ!HJOJULX!WG^JUKFJKI!QLM!LK!TF[GUILKI!UGXJ!IG![XLR!

TK!FLTKILTKTKW!MVSQ!LK!JK^TUGKFJKID

7GPJ^JUZ! ]R!LKR! FJLMVUJ! E! SGKMJU^LIT^J! GU! XT]JULXZ!

1J[V]XTSLK! GU! 3JFGSULIZ! MV[[XRYMTOJU! GU! 0JRKJMTLK!

E!IQJ!HJOJULX!WG^JUKFJKIAM!SVUUJKI! XGKWYIJUF![LIQ! TM!

MTF[XR!VKMVMILTKL]XJD!

.LKR!QL^J!SLXXJO!IQTM!cIQJ!FGMI![UJOTSIL]XJ!JSGKGFTS!

SUTMTM! TK!QTMIGURDd! 5QLIAM! ]JSLVMJ! IQJ!HTMSLX! HVIVUJ!TM!SXGVOJO! ]R!L! [JUHJSI! MIGUF! GH!^JUR! [UJOTSIL]XJ!

OJFGWUL[QTS!HLSIGUM!IQLI![GMJ!L!MJUTGVM!SQLXXJKWJ!

IG! IQJ! XGKWYIJUF! ]VOWJI! GVIXGGNb! :L]R! :GGFJUM!

LUJ!]JWTKKTKW!IG!UJITUJZ!IQJ!JXOJUXR!LUJ!XT^TKW!FVSQ!

XGKWJU!TK!UJITUJFJKIZ!LKO!QJLXIQ!SLUJ!SGMIM!gPQTSQ!

UJ[UJMJKI!L! MTWKTHTSLKI!WG^JUKFJKI! G]XTWLITGKh! LUJ!

GK!L!OULFLITS!UTMJD!

)K!L!"?<?!8GVKOLITGK!MVU^JR!GH!HGUFJU!JSGKGFTS![GXTY

SRFLNJUM!HUGF!]GIQ![LUITJMZ!L!UJMGVKOTKW!<??![JUSJKI!

GH! 1J[V]XTSLK! LKO! 3JFGSULITS! UJM[GKOJKIM! LWUJJO!

IQLI!/FJUTSLAM!XGKWYIJUF!HTMSLX![LIQ!TM!VKMVMILTKL]XJZ!

LKO!>#![JUSJKI!LWUJJO!IQLI!L!HLTXVUJ!IG!LOOUJMM!IQJ!

SGVKIURAM!XGKWYIJUF!MIUVSIVULX!OJHTSTIM!PGVXO!XJLO!IG!

LKGIQJU!JSGKGFTS!SUTMTM!TK!IQJ!KJeI!IJK!RJLUMD

6QR!TM!IQJ!SGKSJUK!GH!Je[JUIM!MG!VKLKTFGVMi!2TF[XR!

[VIZ! IQJ! HJOJULX! WG^JUKFJKI! TM!GK! L![LIQ!IG! ]GUUGP!

FVSQ!FGUJ!FGKJR!IQLK!TI!SLK!LHHGUOD!

5QJUJ!LUJ!FLKR!PLRM!IG!FJLMVUJ!L!SGVKIURAM! HTMSLX!

QJLXIQZ! ]VI! IQJ! ]JMI! G^JULXX! WLVWJ! TM! HJOJULX! OJ]I!

UJXLIT^J!IG!IQJ!MTaJ!GH!GVU!JSGKGFR!gIQJ!ULITG!GH!HJOJULX!

OJ]IYIGYWUGMM! OGFJMITS! [UGOVSIZ! GU! OJ]IYIGY*3+hD!.LKR!JSGKGFTMIM!MVWWJMI!FLTKILTKTKW!L!OJ]IYIGY*3+!

5G!JKMVUJ!L!^T]ULKI!JSGKGFTS!HVIVUJZ!IQJ!;KTIJO!2ILIJM!FVMI!

ILSNXJ!TIM!XGKWYIJUF!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJMD!6J!NKGP!PQLI!KJJOM!

IG!]J!LOOUJMMJOZ!LKO!PJ!NKGP!IQJUJ!LUJ!FLKR![GIJKITLX!

MGXVITGKMD!&GP!PJ!KJJO!IG!]VTXO!MV[[GUI!HGU!]T[LUITMLK!LSITGKD!!

:-!.)$7/(,!/D!+(5(12%&Z!+1(2)3(&5!/&3!$%%

.)$7/(,!/D!+(5(12%&



" B

ULITG!GH!KG!FGUJ!IQLK!=?![JUSJKIZ!LKO!IQJR!PLUK!GH!

OLKWJU!TH!IQJ!ULITG!MILRM!L]G^J!9?![JUSJKID!

1TWQI!KGP!GVU![V]XTS!OJ]I!TM!`?![JUSJKI!GH!*3+D!5QLIAM!

LXUJLOR!^JUR!QTWQZ!]VI!IQJ!UJLX!IQUJLI!TM!TK!HUGKI!GH!VMb!

)H!SVUUJKI![GXTSTJM!SGKITKVJZ!IQJ!;D2D!OJ]IYIGY*3+!ULITG!

TM!GK!L!IUL_JSIGUR!IG!WUGP!IG!L!MILWWJUTKW!<>?![JUSJKI!

GH!*3+!PTIQTK!"C!RJLUMD

!,TNJ!LKR!]GUUGPTKWZ!WUGPTKW!HJOJULX!OJ]I!]UTKWM!FGUJ!TKIJUJMI!SGMIMD!5GOLR!PJ!LUJ!LXUJLOR!HGUSJO!IG!M[JKO!

j""?!]TXXTGK!JLSQ!RJLU!GK!TKIJUJMID!:VI!GK!GVU!SVUUJKI!

[LIQZ! TKIJUJMI! [LRFJKIM!PTXX! UJLSQ! L! MILWWJUTKW! j<!

IUTXXTGK![JU!RJLU!TK!L]GVI!<?!RJLUM!LKO!]R!"?B?!PGVXO!

]JSGFJ!IQJ!XLUWJMI!XTKJ!TIJF!TK!IQJ!HJOJULX!]VOWJID

)IAM!KGI!OTHHTSVXI!IG!VKOJUMILKO!PQR!OUGPKTKW!TK!MVSQ!

XLUWJ!TKIJUJMI![LRFJKIM!SGVXO!QVUI!LK!JSGKGFRZ!J^JK!

GKJ!LM!MVSSJMMHVX!LM!GVUMD!5QJMJ![LRFJKIM!FLNJ!TI!

^TUIVLXXR!TF[GMMT]XJ!HGU!VM!IG! TK JMI!LM!FVSQ!TK! GVU!HVIVUJZ! LKO!PTXX! TKSUJLMTKWXR! cSUGPO! GVId! JOVSLITGKZ!

MNTXXM!IULTKTKWZ!1k3Z! TKHULMIUVSIVUJZ!LKO!GIQJU![V]XTS!

LKO! [UT^LIJ! TK^JMIFJKIM! IQLI! FLNJ! GVU! JSGKGFR!

MIUGKW!LKO!GVU!KLITGK!SGF[JITIT^JD!/K!JSGKGFR!SLKKGI!

UJFLTK!QJLXIQR!LKO![UGOVSJ!WGGO!_G]M!LKO!PLWJM!TH!

PJ!LUJ!M[JKOTKW!FVSQ!FGUJ!GK!TKIJUJMI!IQLK!PJ!LUJ!

GK!TK^JMITKW!TK!GVU!HVIVUJD

/KO!IQJ!MGSTLX!MLHJIR!KJI!TIMJXH!SGVXO!]J!_JG[LUOTaJO!E!

[UGWULFM!XTNJ!2GSTLX!2JSVUTIR!LKO!.JOTSLUJ!LUJ!]GVKO!

IG!]J!SVI!PTIQGVI!SGF[LMMTGK!TK!L!HTMSLX!SUTMTMD!

*T^JK! IQJ! ^JUR! UJLX! TF[LSI!GH!GVU! KLITGKLX! OJ]I! GK!

GVU! JSGKGFR! LKO! GVU! [JG[XJZ! TF[UG TKW! /FJUTSLAM!

XGKWYIJUF!]VOWJI!GVIXGGN!FVMI!]J!LK!VUWJKI![UTGUTIR!

HGU!GVU!KLITGKD!

!"#$%&!'()*+*(,-./(+01(%.23-1445.2*6(78931+(",,5:1(;.23<=1-/(78931+("8+6..>'(?821(@ABB(*29(?821(@AACD(*29(+01(",,5:1(.,(E*2*31/12+(*29(78931+F(

=01(78931+(.,(+01(#25+19(!+*+14(G.H1-2/12+'(I54:*6(J1*-(@AB@F(I1K-8*-L(@ABBM(%./N5619(KL(OGOIM(P"=&'($1,61:+4(91K+(0169(KL(+01(N8K65:(+.(*66(,191-*6(

91K+(0169(KL(5295H598*64F(:.-N.-*+5.24F(4+*+1(.-(6.:*6(3.H1-2/12+4F(*29(,.-1532(12+5+514M(

5QJ!OJ]I!XJ^JXM![UG_JSIJO!TK!IQJ!KJLU!HVIVUJ!LUJ!VK[UJSJOJKIJOD!

PROJECTED

P E R C E N T A G E

O F

G D P

200

175

150

125

100

75

50

25

0

1995 2005 2015 2025 2035

177%ACTUAL



C

57(!2%,;5)%&2

5QJ! WGGO! KJPM! TM!IQLI!GVU! HTMSLX! SQLXXJKWJM! SLK! ]J!G^JUSGFJD!/!^LUTJIR!GH!TKTITLIT^JMZ!TKSXVOTKW!IQJ!2TF[Y

MGKY:GPXJM!SGFFTMMTGKZ! GIQJU!ILMN! HGUSJMZ! LKO!GVU!

HGVKOLITGKAM![GXTSR![UG_JSIMZ!QL^J!LXX!MQGPK!IQLI!IQTM!

[UG]XJF!SLK!]J!MGX^JOZ!LKO!IQLI!TH!PJ!OG!TI!MGGKZ!TI!SLK!

]J!OGKJ!PTIQ!HLTUKJMM!LKO!SGF[LMMTGKD

/!SUJOT]XJ!HTMSLX![XLK!FVMI![LMM!L!MTF[XJ!IJMIb!OGJM!

TI!MIL]TXTaJ!OJ]IYIGY*3+!LI!LK!LHHGUOL]XJ!XJ^JX!G^JU!IQJ!XGKW!IJUFi!'LUTGVM!HTMSLX!UJHGUFM!SLK!SXLTF!IG!UJOVSJ!

LKKVLX! OJHTSTIM!]R!SJUILTK!LFGVKIMZ!]VI! TK! GUOJU! IG!

[VI!IQJ!;D2D!GK!L!MVMILTKL]XJ![LIQ!PJ!FVMI!MIG[!IQJ!

WUGPIQ!TK!OJ]ID

5G! LSQTJ^J! IQTM! G]_JSIT^JZ! L! MVSSJMMHVX! HTMSLX! [XLK!

FVMI!]J!SGF[UJQJKMT^J!LKO!LOOUJMM!IQJ!HVKOLFJKILX!

OUT^JUM!GH!GVU!XGKWYIJUF!OJ]ID

%KJ!TM!QJLXIQ!SLUJD!:UTKWTKW!FGUJ! LXVJ!IG!QJLXIQ!SLUJ!

M[JKOTKW! TM! L]MGXVIJXR! JMMJKITLXZ! WT^JK! IQLI! QJLXIQ!

SLUJ! SGMIM! UJ[UJMJKI! L! FL_GU! MQLUJ! GH! TKSUJLMTKW!HJOJULX!Je[JKOTIVUJMD!5GOLRZ!PJ!M[JKO!IPTSJ!LM!FVSQ!

[JU!SL[TIL!LM!GIQJU!LO^LKSJO!KLITGKMZ!RJI!GVU!QJLXIQ!

GVISGFJM!LUJ!GHIJK!KG!]JIIJUD!.LNTKW!IQJ!G^JULXX!QJLXIQ!

SLUJ!MRMIJF!FGUJ!JHHTSTJKIZ!PQTXJ!FLNTKW!SQLKWJM!IG!

.JOTSLUJ!LKO!.JOTSLTOZ!TM!NJR!IG!GVU!JSGKGFTS!LKO!

HTMSLX! HVIVUJD! *ULOVLXXR! SQLKWTKW! GIQJU! JKITIXJFJKI!

[UGWULFM! XTNJ!2GSTLX!2JSVUTIR! IG!FLNJ!IQJF!MJSVUJ!

LKO! MGX JKI! HGU! IQJ! XGKW! IJUF! TM!LXMG! LK! TF[GUILKI!SGF[GKJKI!GH!HTMSLX!UJHGUFD!

3JHJKMJ! M[JKOTKW! KJJOM! MSUVITKRZ! IGGD! 5GOLRZ! PJ!

M[JKO!FGUJ! GK!OJHJKMJ! IQLK! IQJ! KJeI! <`!SGVKIUTJM!

SGF]TKJOD!6J! KJJO!IG!JKMVUJ! IQLI!PJ! HVXXR!LOOUJMM!

IQJ!IQUJLIM!GH!IQJ!"<MI!SJKIVURZ!PQTXJ!LSNKGPXJOWTKW!

IQLI!GVU!KLITGKLX!MJSVUTIR!TM!QTWQXR!OJ[JKOJKI!GK!GVU!

JSGKGFTS!MJSVUTIR!LKO!HTMSLX!QJLXIQD!

!.8-:14'()*+*(,-./(+01(",,5:1(.,(E*2*31/12+(*29(78931+F(78931+(.,(+01(#25+19(!+*+14(G.H1-2/12+'(IJ(@AB@F(I1KM(@ABBF(G*32.2(Q(R52+1-4:0S1531-F(

=01(G6.K*6("8+6..>(,.-(G.H1-2/12+()1K+(.H1-(+01(P1T+(@U(J1*-4'(V/N65:*+5.24(,.-(+01(&:.2./L(*29(O8K65:(O.65:LF(OVV&F(?821(@ABBM(%./N5619(KL(OGOIM(

:R!"?BCZ![UG_JSIJO!TKIJUJMI!SGMIM!GK!IQJ!OJ]I!PTXX!]J!FGUJ!IQLK!HGVU!ITFJM!PQLI!IQJ!HJOJULX!WG^JUKFJKI!

QLM!QTMIGUTSLXXR!M[JKI!GK!JOVSLITGKZ!UJMJLUSQ!LKO!OJ^JXG[FJKIZ!LKO!TKHULMIUVSIVUJ!SGF]TKJOD

P E R C E N T A G E

O F

G D P

13.2%

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

1960-2010 AVERAGE YEARLY R&D SPENDING INTEREST COST

2035

0.7%

Education

0.9%

Non-defense

Infrastructure

1.2%

Research and

Development

1.5%

2011

4.5%

2020



" D

/KO! LKR! [GXTITSLXXR! UJLXTMITS! LKO! XLMITKW! ]T[LUITMLK!

HTMSLX! MGXVITGK!PTXX! UJ\VTUJ! IQLI! UJ^JKVJM! ]J! GK! IQJ!

IL]XJ!E!LM!IQJ!:GPXJMY2TF[MGK!SGFFTMMTGK!LKO!GIQJUM!QL^J!UJSGFFJKOJOZ![LUTKW!]LSN!ILe!Je[JKOTIVUJM!SLK!

KGI!GKXR!SGKIUT]VIJ!IG!OJHTSTI!UJOVSITGKZ!]VI!SLK!FLNJ!

TI![GMMT]XJ!IG!XGPJU!ILe!ULIJM!LKO!SUJLIJ!L!MTF[XJU!ILe!

SGOJ!IQLI!TM!FGUJ!SGKOVST^J!IG!WUGPIQD

2GFJ!MLR!IQLI!KGP!TM!KGI!IQJ!ITFJ!IG!OJLX!PTIQ!GVU!

XGKWYIJUF!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJMZ!OVJ!IG!IQJ!SVUUJKI!HULWTXJ!

UJSG^JURD! :VI! IQTM! TM! KGI! LK! JTIQJUlGU! [UG[GMTITGKD!+VIITKW!L!XGKWYIJUF!HTMSLX![XLK!TK![XLSJ!IQLI!WGJM!TKIG!

JHHJSI!GKSJ!IQJ!JSGKGFR!UJSG^JUM!TM!L!MJKMT]XJ!PLR!IG!

OJLX!PTIQ!UJSG^JUR!LKO!MVMILTKL]TXTIR!LI!IQJ!MLFJ!ITFJD!

/KO!ILNTKW!IQTM!LSITGK!KGP!HGU!IQJ!XGKW!IJUF!SLK!LXMG!

MIUJKWIQJK! IGOLRAM! JSGKGFTS! UJSG^JUR! ]R! ]GGMITKW!

SGKHTOJKSJ!LI!QGFJ!LKO!L]UGLO!IQLI!IQJ!;D2D!TM!HTKLXXR!

WJIITKW!TIM!HTMSLX!QGVMJ!TK!GUOJUD!$GKHTOJKSJ!PGVXO!]J!

L!^LXVL]XJ!HGUF!GH!MITFVXVM!IQLI!GVU!JSGKGFR!KJJOMZ!]VI!QLMKAI!RJI!WLTKJOD

:R!SGFFTIITKW!GVUMJX^JM! IG! MIL]TXTaTKW! IQJ!OJ]IZ!PJ!

SLK! XLR! L! HGVKOLITGK! HGU! XGKWYIJUF! WUGPIQZ! WUJLIJU!

JSGKGFTS! TKOJ[JKOJKSJZ! LKO!J\VTIL]XJ! MGXVITGKM!IG!IQJ!JSGKGFTS!SQLXXJKWJM!HLSTKW!WJKJULITGKM!GH!/FJUTY

SLKMD!6J!SLK!MQL[J!L![GMTIT^J!^TMTGK!GH!GVU!KLITGKAM!

HVIVUJ!LKO!ILNJ!IQJ!MIJ[M!KJSJMMLUR!IG!UJLXTaJ!TID!

5QTM!TKLVWVULX!UJ[GUI!SQUGKTSXJM!GVU!JHHGUIM!IG!JOVSLIJ!

IQJ! [V]XTSZ! ]VTXO! SGKMJKMVM! TK! 6LMQTKWIGKZ! LKO!

FG]TXTaJ!/FJUTSLKM!IG!ILNJ!LSITGK!LKO!QJX[!XJLO!IQJ!

KLITGK!IGPLUO!L!MVMILTKL]XJ!HTMSLX!HVIVUJD!

!.8-:1'()*+*(,-./(+01(%.23-1445.2*6(78931+(",,5:1F(=01(;.23<=1-/(78931+("8+6..>'(?821(@ABAF(*6+1-2*+5H1M(%./N5619(KL(OGOIM(

P"=&'(WI191-*6(R1*6+0(%*-1(O-.3-*/4X(52:6891(E195:*-1F(E195:*59F(%RVOF(*29(1T:0*231(48K459514M

%;1!8)2$/,!$7/,,(&*(2!/&3!%;1!.)22)%&

5QJ![UG_JSIJO!FL_GU!OUT^JU!GH!HJOJULX!M[JKOTKW!G^JU!IQJ!KJeI!MJ^JULX!OJSLOJM!TM!IQJ!OULFLITS!UTMJ!

GH!M[JKOTKW!GK!QJLXIQ!SLUJD!

A S

A

P E R C E N

T A G E

O F

G D P

10.0

8.0

6.0

4.0

2.0

0.0

2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050

12.0

14.0MAJOR

HEALTH

SOCIALSECURITY

DEFENSE

DISCRETIONARY

NON-DEFENSE

DISCRETIONARY

OTHER

MANDATORY



:;),3)&*!$%&2(&2;2!! !%&!+%,)$-!2%,;5)%&2b1(/$7)&*!/*1((.(&5!

%&!8)2$/,!2%,;5)%&2!6),,!1(m;)1(!5%;*7!$7%)$(2!/&3!:%,3!:)+/15)2/&!

$%..)5.(&52D!571%;*7!(3;$/5)%&Z!/&/,-2)2Z!/&3!

/$5)%&!)&!6/27)&*5%&!/&3!:(-%&3Z!57(!8%;&3/5)%&!)2!6%10)&*!5%!:;),3!/!

:)+/15)2/&!$%&2(&2;2!/1%;&3!,%&*Y5(1.!8)2$/,!2;25/)&/:),)5-D



" E:;),3)&*!$%&2(&2;2!%&!+%,)$-!2%,;5)%&2

$%&'(&)&*!+%,)$-./0(12!/&3!(4+(152!

5%!/331(22!57(!8)2$/,!$7/,,(&*(

5QJ!"?<?!8TMSLX!2VFFTI!PLM!QJXO!L!OLR!LHIJU!IQJ!HTUMI!

FJJITKW!GH!IQJ!&LITGKLX!$GFFTMMTGK!GK!8TMSLX!1JM[GKY

MT]TXTIR!LKO!1JHGUFZ!LKO!TI!OJFGKMIULIJO!IQLI![GXTITSLX!

XJLOJUM!LKO!JSGKGFTMIM!GK!]GIQ!MTOJM!GH!IQJ![GXTITSLX!

LTMXJ!UJSGWKTaJ!IQJ!VUWJKSR!GH!GVU!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJMD

+LUITST[LKIM! TKSXVOJO! HGUFJU! +UJMTOJKI! :TXX! $XTKIGKZ!

HGUFJU!;D2D!2JKLIGU!nVOO!*UJWWZ! HGUFJU!3TUJSIGU!GH!

IQJ!%HHTSJ!GH!.LKLWJFJKI!LKO!:VOWJI!+JIJU!%UMaLWZ!

HGUFJU!2JSUJILUR!GH!IQJ!5UJLMVUR!1G]JUI!1V]TKZ!HGUFJU!

$QLTUFJK! GH! IQJ! 8JOJULX! 1JMJU^J! +LVX! 'GXSNJU! LKO!

/XLK!*UJJKM[LKZ!LKO!&LITGKLX!$GFFTMMTGK!GK!8TMSLX!

1JM[GKMT]TXTIR!LKO!1JHGUF! SGYSQLTUM!(UMNTKJ!:GPXJM!

LKO! HGUFJU! ;D2D!2JKLIGU! /XLK! 2TF[MGKD! 5QJUJ!PLM!

WJKJULX! LWUJJFJKI! IQLI! XGKWYIJUF! MIUVSIVULX! TF]LXY

LKSJM!LUJ!L!MJUTGVM!JSGKGFTS!IQUJLI!HLSTKW!IQJ!KLITGK!

LKO!IQLI!TI!TM!TF[JULIT^J!IG!LOOUJMM!IQJMJ!TF]LXLKSJM!

MGGKJU!ULIQJU!IQLK!XLIJUZ!PQTXJ!GVU!G[ITGKM!LUJ!FGUJ!

JSGKGFTSLXXR! LKO! [GXTITSLXXR! [LXLIL]XJD! $GKIUT]VYIGUM! TOJKITHTJO! UTMTKW! QJLXIQ! SLUJ! SGMIM! LM! IQJ!FGMI!

MTWKTHTSLKI!SGF[GKJKI!GH!XGKWYIJUF!MIUVSIVULX!OJHTSTIM!

LKO!VUWJO!UJHGUFM!IG!IQJ!SVUUJKI!MRMIJFD!5QJR!LXMG!

OTMSVMMJO! LXX! GH! IQJ! UJ^JKVJ! LKO! M[JKOTKW! G[ITGKM!

GK!IQJ! IL]XJZ! TKSXVOTKW! UJHGUFM! IG!JKITIXJFJKIMZ! ILe!

Je[JKOTIVUJMZ!LKO!OJHJKMJD

/M![LUI!GH!IQJ!2VFFTIZ!IQJ!8GVKOLITGK!UJXJLMJO!IQJ!UJMVXIM!GH!L!WUGVKO]UJLNTKW!MVU^JR!GH!MJKTGU!JSGKGFTS!

5QJ!+JIJUMGK!8GVKOLITGKAM!LKKVLX!8TMSLX!2VFFTIM!SGK^JKJ!

IQJ!KLITGKAM!IG[!XJLOJUM!LKO!Je[JUIM!IG!HTKO!SGFFGK!

WUGVKO!GK!MGXVITGKM!IG!/FJUTSLAM!XGKWYIJUF!HTMSLX!LKO!

JSGKGFTS!SQLXXJKWJMD!5QJ!SGK^JUMLITGK!]JWLK!TK!"?<?Z!

PQJK!PJ!HGSVMJO!GK!]VTXOTKW!LPLUJKJMM!L]GVI!IQJ!VUWJKSR!

GH!GVU!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJMZ!LKO!TI!SGKITKVJO!TK!"?<<Z!PQJK!GVU!

WULKIJJM!]UGVWQI!M[JSTHTS!MGXVITGKM!IG!IQJ!IL]XJD

g5%+Y:%55%.h!8%1.(1!67)5(!7%;2(!$7)(8!%8!25/88!

(120)&(!:%6,(2!/&3!8%1.(1!;D2D!2(&/5%1!/,/&!

2).+2%&!3)2$;22!57(!6%10!%8!57(!&/5)%&/,!$%..)22)%&!%&!8)2$/,!1(2+%&2):),)5-!/&3!1(8%1.D



FG

GHHTSTLXM! HUGF!IQJ![UJ^TGVM!JTWQI![UJMTOJKITLX!LOFTKY

TMIULITGKM! LKO! $GKWUJMMTGKLX! XJLOJUM! HUGF! IQJ! [LMI!

B?! RJLUMD! /K! LMIGVKOTKW! >#! [JUSJKI! GH! 1J[V]XTSLK!

LKO! 3JFGSULITS! UJM[GKOJKIM! LWUJJO! IQLI! L! HLTXVUJ!

IG!LOOUJMM!IQJ!SGVKIURAM!XGKWYIJUF!MIUVSIVULX!OJHTSTI!

SQLXXJKWJM!PGVXO!XJLO!IG!LKGIQJU!JSGKGFTS!SUTMTM!TK!

IQJ! KJeI! IJK! RJLUMD!2J^JKIRYHGVU! [JUSJKI! GH! UJM[GKY

OJKIM! LXMG! ]UGLOXR! LWUJJO! IQLI! MGXVITGKM! FVMI!

TKSXVOJ! ]GIQ! M[JKOTKW! SVIM! LKO! ILe! TKSUJLMJMZ! LKO!

>9![JUSJKI!]JXTJ^JO!IQLI!L![XLK!IG!LOOUJMM!XGKWYIJUF!

OJHTSTIM!MQGVXO!]J!LWUJJO!IG!PTIQTK!GKJ!IG!IPG!RJLUMD

%K!.LR!"CZ!"?<<Z!IQJ!+JIJUMGK!8GVKOLITGK!QGMIJO!TIM!

"?<<!8TMSLX!2VFFTIb!2GXVITGKM!HGU!/FJUTSLAM!8VIVUJZ!TK!

6LMQTKWIGKZ!3D$D!5QJ!HGUVF!HJLIVUJO!XJLOTKW!IQTKNJUM!

LKO! [GXTSRFLNJUMZ! TKSXVOTKW! %]LFL! LOFTKTMIULITGK!

GHHTSTLXMZ!FJF]JUM!GH!$GKWUJMMZ!]VOWJI!Je[JUIMZ!_GVUKLXY

TMIMZ!LKO!]VMTKJMM!XJLOJUMZ!PQG!GHHJUJO!L!ULKWJ!GH! TJPM!

L]GVI!MGX^TKW!IQJ!KLITGKAM!XGKWYIJUF!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJMD

5QJ!2VFFTI!PLM!IQJ!SVXFTKLITGK!GH! IQJ!8GVKOLITGKAM!

2GXVITGKM! )KTITLIT^JZ! L! WULKI! [UGWULF! MV[[GUITKW! MTe!

GUWLKTaLITGKM!LSUGMM!IQJ!TOJGXGWTSLX!LKO!WJKJULITGKLX!

M[JSIUVF!IG!OJ^JXG[![XLKM!PTIQ!M[JSTHTS!MGXVITGKM!IG!IQJ!

KLITGKAM![UG_JSIJO!XGKWYIJUF!OJ]I!LKO!OJHTSTIMD!)K!LOOTITGK!

IG!IQJ![XLK![UJMJKILITGKMZ![UGWULF!QTWQXTWQIM!TKSXVOJOb

Y! /!SGK^JUMLITGK!PTIQ!HGUFJU!+UJMTOJKI!:TXX!$XTKIGK!!! GK!IQJ![GMTIT^J!JSGKGFTS!JHHJSIM!GH!OJ]I!UJOVSITGK!!

! LKO!IQJ!KJJO!HGU!]GIQ![LUITJM!LKO!IQJTU!MV[[GUIJUM!!

! IG!MJUTGVMXR!SGKMTOJU!TOJLM!LO^LKSJO!]R!IQJ!GIQJUo

Y! )KIJU^TJPM!PTIQ!7GVMJ!:VOWJI!$GFFTIIJJ!

! $QLTUFLK!+LVX!1RLK!LKO!&LITGKLX!(SGKGFTS!!

! $GVKSTX!3TUJSIGU!*JKJ!2[JUXTKW!GK!IQJTU!^TMTGKM!GH!!

! UJHGUFZ![LUITSVXLUXR!TK!UJWLUO!IG!.JOTSLUJo

Y! /K!TKIJU^TJP!PTIQ!)KOTLKL!*G^JUKGU!.TISQ!3LKTJXM!!

! GK!XJMMGKM!QJ!XJLUKJO!TK!]VTXOTKW![V]XTS!MV[[GUI!IG!!

! LOOUJMM!OJHTSTIM!GK!L!MILIJ!XJ^JXo!

Y! /![LKJX!OTMSVMMTGK!PTIQ!;D2D!2JKLIGUM!2Le]R!!

! $QLF]XTMMZ!.TNJ!$UL[GZ!3TSN!3VU]TKZ!LKO!.LUN!!

! 6LUKJU!L]GVI!IQJTU!JHHGUIM!IG!SULHI!L!]T[LUITMLK!!

! [XLK!IG!LOOUJMM!GVU!XGKWYIJUF!SQLXXJKWJM!IQUGVWQ!!

! IQJ!c*LKW!GH!2Ted!LKO

Y! /!OTMSVMMTGK!GH!/FJUTSLKMA!LIITIVOJM!L]GVI!OJHTSTI

! UJOVSITGK!LKO!L[[JITIJ!HGU!SQLKWJ!PTIQ!HGUFJU!;D2D!!

! 2JKLIGU!/XLK!2TF[MGKZ!P1S(J.->(=5/14!SGXVFKTMI!!

! 3L^TO!:UGGNMZ!7GKJRPJXX!$(%!3L TO!$GIJZ!3JFGM!!

! 'TSJ!+UJMTOJKI!GH!+GXTSR!LKO!+UGWULFM!5LFLUL!!

! 3ULVIo!LKO!=01(Y+6*2+5:Z4!]VMTKJMM!LKO!JSGKGFTSM!!

! JOTIGU!.JWLK!.S/UOXJD

:GIQ!GH!IQJ!LKKVLX!8TMSLX!2VFFTIM!PJUJ!IJXJ^TMJO!^TL!

$Y2+/&!IG!L!KLITGKLX!LVOTJKSJ!GH![GXTITSLXXR!JKWLWJO!

/FJUTSLKMD! 5QJR! UJHXJSI! IQJ! 8GVKOLITGKAM! SGFFTIY

FJKI! IG!JKWLWTKW!L! ]UGLO! ULKWJ!GH!MILNJQGXOJUM!TK!

L![ULSITSLX!OTLXGWVJ!GK!IQJ!KLITGKAM!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJM!LKO!OUT^TKW!LSITGK!IG!UJMGX^J!IQJFD!

g,(85h!8%1.(1!%.:!3)1($5%1!+(5(1!%12@/*!1(2+%&32!5%!m;(25)%&2!/:%;5!7(/,57!$/1(A2!).+/$5!%&!

57(!&/5)%&A2!8)2$/,!2)5;/5)%&D!g1)*75h!8%1.(1!8(3(1/,!1(2(1'(!$7/)1./&!/,/&!*1((&2+/&!,/-2!%;5!

57(!(88($52!%8!)&$1(/2)&*!3(:5D!



" FF:;),3)&*!$%&2(&2;2!%&!+%,)$-!2%,;5)%&2

g5%+!,(85h!8%1.(1!$7/)1./&!%8!57(!8(3(1/,!1(2(1'(!+/;,!'%,$0(1!3)2$;22(2!57(!).+%15/&$(!

%8!8)&3)&*!,%&*Y5(1.!2%,;5)%&2!57/5!/331(22!:%57!2+(&3)&*!/&3!1('(&;(D!g5%+!1)*75h!8%1.(1!

2($1(5/1-!%8!57(!51(/2;1-!1%:(15!1;:)&!3(2$1):(2!57(!(88($52!%8!%;1!;&2;25/)&/:,(!3(8)$)52!/&3!

3(:5!%&!+;:,)$!/&3!+1)'/5(!)&'(25.(&5D!g:%55%.h!8%1.(1!%.:!3)1($5%1!/,)$(!1)',)&!/&3!($%&%.)$!

+%,)$-!)&25)5;5(!+1(2)3(&5!,/61(&$(!.)27(,!3)2$;22!+%5(&5)/,!2%,;5)%&2!5%!57(!&/5)%&A2!($%&%.)$!/&3!8)2$/,!$7/,,(&*(2D



F?

g5%+!,(85h!P&[(J"$\(=VE&!($%,;.&)25!3/')3!:1%%02!3)2$;22(2!57(!$;,5;1/,!/&3!+%,)5)$/,!

$7/,,(&*(2!%8!8)&3)&*!/!2%,;5)%&!5%!57(!3(:5D!g5%+!1)*75h!)&3)/&/!*%'(1&%1!.)5$7!3/&)(,2!

3)2$;22(2!7)2!(4+(1)(&$(!6)57!8)2$/,!1(8%1.!%&!/!25/5(!,('(,D!g:%55%.h!.%3(1/5%1!n;3-!6%%31;88!

3)2$;22(2!57(!3(8)$)5!1(3;$5)%&!(88%152!%8!57(!c*/&*!%8!2)4d!6)57!;D2D!2(&/5%12!2/4:-!$7/.:,)22Z!

./10!6/1&(1Z!.)0(!$1/+%Z!/&3!3)$0!3;1:)&D



" F@:;),3)&*!$%&2(&2;2!%&!+%,)$-!2%,;5)%&2

g5%+h!8%1.(1!+1(2)3(&5!:),,!$,)&5%&!3)2$;22(2!57(!).+%15/&$(!%8!8)2$/,!2;25/)&/:),)5-!5%!

/.(1)$/&!$%.+(5)5)'(&(22!)&!/&!)&5(1')(6!6)57!+:2A!*6(&!)8),,D!g:%55%.!,(85h!7%;2(!:;3*(5!

$%..)55((!$7/)1./&!+/;,!1-/&!,/-2!%;5!7)2!3(8)$)5!1(3;$5)%&!+,/&D!g:%55%.!1)*75h!&/5)%&/,!

($%&%.)$!$%;&$),!3)1($5%1!*(&(!2+(1,)&*!3)2$;22(2!57(!%:/./!/3.)&)251/5)%&A2!+(12+($5)'(!!

%&!8)2$/,!1(8%1.D



FA

:,;(+1)&52!8%1!8)2$/,!/$5)%&!81%.!/$1%22!

57(!)3(%,%*)$/,!2+($51;.

)K!nLKVLUR!"?<<Z!IQJ!+JIJUMGK!8GVKOLITGK!XLVKSQJO!IQJ!

2GXVITGKM!)KTITLIT^JZ!L!WULKI![UGWULF!IQLI!SGK^JKJO!MTe!

GUWLKTaLITGKM!HUGF!LSUGMM!IQJ!TOJGXGWTSLX!LKO!WJKJULYITGKLX! M[JSIUVF! IG!OJ^JXG[!MGXVITGKM!IG! IQJ!KLITGKAM!

[UG_JSIJO!XGKWYIJUF!OJ]I!LKO!OJHTSTIMD!

5QJ!8GVKOLITGK!LPLUOJO!WULKIM!IG!MTe!XJLOTKW![V]XTS!

[GXTSR! GUWLKTaLITGKM! E! IQJ! /FJUTSLK! (KIJU[UTMJ!

)KMITIVIJZ!IQJ!:T[LUITMLK!+GXTSR!$JKIJUZ!IQJ!$JKIJU!HGU!

/FJUTSLK! +UGWUJMMZ! IQJ! (SGKGFTS! +GXTSR! )KMITIVIJZ!

5QJ!7JUTILWJ!8GVKOLITGKZ!LKO!IQJ!1GGMJ^JXI!)KMITIVIJ!$LF[VM!&JIPGUN! E!LKO! LMNJO!IQJF!IG! OJ^JXG[!LKO!

[UJMJKI!IQJTU!^TMTGK!IG!LOOUJMM!GVU!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJMD!

5QJ!WUGV[M!PJUJ!WT^JK!TKOJ[JKOJKSJ!LKO!OTMSUJITGK!IG!

OJHTKJ!IQJ!HTMSLX!WGLXM!LKO!SULHI!SGF[UJQJKMT^J![XLKM!

IG!LSQTJ^J!IQJFD!6J!IQJK!LMNJO!IQJ!KGK[LUITMLK!5Le!

+GXTSR!$JKIJU!LKO!GIQJU!Je[JUIM!IG!MSGUJ!LKO!SGF[LUJ!

PQLI!IQJ!^LUTGVM![XLKM!PGVXO!LSQTJ^J!TK!"?"<!LKO!"?BCD

/HIJU! SGKMTOJUTKW! IQJ! FLKR! IULOJGHHM! IQLI! WG! TKIG!

[UGOVSTKW!L!]VOWJIZ!IQJ!GUWLKTaLITGKM![UGOVSJO![XLKM!

UJHXJSITKW! IQJTU! TKOT TOVLX! [QTXGMG[QTJMD! )F[GUILKIXRZ!

+01L( *66( 45325,5:*2+6L( -198:19( 91K+<+.<G)O ! [UG_JSITGKM!

PQJK!FJLMVUJO!LWLTKMI!LK! JeIJKOJO! ^JUMTGK!GH! IQJ!

$GKWUJMMTGKLX!:VOWJI!%HHTSJ!]LMJXTKJD!:R!"?BCZ! IQJ!

[XLKM!PGVXO!UJOVSJ!OJ]I!XJ^JXM!IG!]JIPJJK!B?!LKO!>?!

[JUSJKI!GH!*3+D

(^JK! IQGVWQ! IQJ! WULKIJJM! OJFGKMIULIJO! MTWKTHTSLKI!

OTHHJUJKSJM!G^JU!IQJ!MTaJ!LKO!UGXJ!GH!WG^JUKFJKIZ!IQJTU!

[XLKM! MQGPJO! L! UJFLUNL]XJ! SGKMJKMVM! GK! MJ JULX!

NJR! [UTGUTITJMD!.GMI! TF[GUILKIXRZ! LXX! GH! IQJ! WULKIJJM!

LSNKGPXJOWJO! IQLI! /FJUTSLAM! SVUUJKI! HTMSLX! [LIQ! TM!

VKMVMILTKL]XJ!LKO!UJSGFFJKOJO![GXTSTJM!IQLI!PGVXO!

UJOVSJ!IQJ![UG_JSIJO!HJOJULX!OJ]ID!/OOTITGKLXXRZ!IQJR!

LWUJJO! IQLI! PJ! FVMI! [UJMJU^J! L! MGSTLX! MLHJIR! KJI!HGU! IQGMJ!PQG!KJJO! TIZ! LKO! IQLI!PJ!SLKKGI!SGKITKVJ!

IG! MV]MTOTaJ! IQJ! PJXXYGHH! IQJ! PLR! PJ! SVUUJKIXR! OGD!

,LMIXRZ!IQJR!SGKSVUUJO!IQLI!MGYSLXXJO!ILe!Je[JKOTIVUJM!

E!ILe!OJOVSITGKMZ!JeSXVMTGKMZ!LKO!SUJOTIM!IQLI!LSI!LM!

OTMWVTMJO!M[JKOTKW!LKO!SGMI!IQJ! HJOJULX!WG^JUKFJKI!

j<DB!IUTXXTGK!JLSQ!RJLU!E!LUJ!HJUITXJ!WUGVKO!HGU!UJHGUF!

IQLI! WUJLIXR! MTF[XTHTJM! IQJ! MRMIJFZ! LKO! XGPJUM! ILe!

ULIJM!HGU!SGU[GULITGKM!LKO!TKOT^TOVLXMD

+ ( 1 $ ( & 5 / * (

% 8

* 3 +

2%,;5)%&2!)&)5)/5)'(!+1%n($5(3!3(:5!,('(,2

CBO Current

Policy Scenario

EPI

RooseveltAEICAP

HeritageBPC

175

150

125

100

75

50

25

2010 2015 2020 2025 20352030

6LMQTKWIGK!LKO!IQJ![V]XTS!WJKJULXXR!LSSJ[I!IQJ!KJJO!IG

UJOVSJ![UG_JSIJO!XGKWYIJUF!OJ]I!LKO!OJHTSTIM!E!IQJ!KJeI!MIJ[

TM!IG!OJ^JXG[!SUJOT]XJ![XLKM!HGU!UJLSQTKW!IQLI!WGLXD!5QJ

+JIJUMGK!8GVKOLITGKAM!2GXVITGKM!)KTITLIT^J![UG^TOJO!WULKIM!IG

MTe![V]XTS![GXTSR!UJMJLUSQ!GUWLKTaLITGKM!LSUGMM!IQJ!TOJGXGWTSLX

LKO!WJKJULITGKLX!M[JSIUVF!IG![UJMJKI!IQJTU!^TMTGK!GH!QGP!IG

[VI!/FJUTSL!GK!L!MVMILTKL]XJ!XGKWYIJUF!HTMSLX![LIQD



FC

/331(22)&*!57(!7(/,57!$/1(!$7/,,(&*(

)KOT^TOVLXM!LKO!Je[JUIM!HUGF!LSUGMM!IQJ![GXTITSLX!M[JSIUVF!

LWUJJ!IQLI!/FJUTSLAM!UL[TOXR!UTMTKW!QJLXIQ!SLUJ!SGMIM!LUJ!

VKMVMILTKL]XJD!5QJ!+JIJUMGK!8GVKOLITGK!TM!PGUNTKW!PTIQ!

GUWLKTaLITGKM!TKSXVOTKW!IQJ!)KMITIVIJ!GH!.JOTSTKJ!LKO!IQJ!$JKIJU!

HGU!/FJUTSLK!+UGWUJMM!IG!OUT^J!QJLXIQ!SLUJ!MGXVITGKM!IQLI!OJXT^JU!]JIIJU!^LXVJ!]R!TF[UG^TKW!\VLXTIR!LKO!XGPJUTKW!SGMIMD

/SSGUOTKW! IG! IQJ!$GKWUJMMTGKLX! :VOWJI!%HHTSJZ! IGILX!

[UT^LIJ!LKO![V]XTS!QJLXIQ!SLUJ!M[JKOTKW!TK!IQJ!;KTIJO!

2ILIJM! TM! [UG_JSIJO! IG! MGLU! FGUJ! IQLK! C?! [JUSJKI!

]R! "?BCZ! SGKMVFTKW! " ! [JUSJKI! GH! *3+D! 5QJ! ;D2D!

SVUUJKIXR!M[JKOM! IPTSJ!LM!FVSQ![JU!SL[TIL!LM!FGMI!

GIQJU!LO^LKSJO!KLITGKM!GK!QJLXIQ! SLUJD!:VI! OJM[TIJ!

IQJMJ! FLMMT^J! UJMGVUSJMZ! ;D2D! QJLXIQ! GVISGFJM!

LUJ! WJKJULXXR! KG!]JIIJU! LKO! MGFJITFJM! PGUMJ! IQLK!

GVISGFJM!TK!GIQJU!LO^LKSJO!SGVKIUTJMD!8GU!JeLF[XJZ!

IQJ! ;D2D! TM!B<MI! TK! TKHLKI!FGUILXTIR! LKO! " IQ! TK! XTHJ!

Je[JSILKSRD!&GI!GKXR!LUJ!PJ!HLTXTKW!IG! LSQTJ^J!WGGO!

UJMVXIMZ!]VI!GVU!QVWJ!XJ^JXM!GH!M[JKOTKW!IQUJLIJK!IQJ!

HTMSLX!MVMILTKL]TXTIR!GH!IQJ!KLITGKD!

)K! "??9Z! IQJ! +JIJUMGK! 8GVKOLITGK! _GTKJO! PTIQ! IQJ!

)KMITIVIJ!GH!.JOTSTKJ!g)%.h!IG!]UTKW!IGWJIQJU!FJOTSLX!

[UGHJMMTGKLXMZ! QGM[TILX! LOFTKTMIULIGUMZ! JSGKGFTMIMZ!

SGKMVFJU! UJ[UJMJKILIT^JMZ! LKO! TKMVUJUM! IG! TOJKITHR!

IQJ!JXJFJKIM!GH!IQJ!QJLXIQ!SLUJ!MRMIJF!IQLI![UG^TOJ!

IQJ!FGMI!^LXVJZ!UJOVSJ!TKJHHTSTJKSRZ!LKO!OJXT^JU![UG^JK!

SLUJD! /! UJMVXITKW! UJ[GUIZ! =01(R1*6+0:*-1( V/N1-*+5H1'(

;.S1-523( %.4+4( *29( V/N-.H523( "8+:./14Z! [UJMJKIM!G[ITGKM! HGU! UJOVSTKW! ;D2D! QJLXIQ! SLUJ! Je[JKMJM! ]R!

<?![JUSJKI! TK!<?! RJLUMZ!PQTXJ! TF[UG^TKW! IQJ!\VLXTIR!

GH! SLUJD! 2VWWJMIJO! MIULIJWTJM! TKSXVOJ! FLNTKW! IQJ!

QJLXIQ!SLUJ!MRMIJF!FGUJ![LITJKIYSJKIJUJOZ!UJHGUFTKW!

[LRFJKI! MRMIJFMZ! LKO! TKSUJLMTKW!IULKM[LUJKSR! LKO!

LSSGVKIL]TXTIRD! 5QJ! UJ[GUI! PLM! MQLUJO!PTIQ! XJLOTKW!

Je[JUIMZ! [ULSITITGKJUMZ! LKO! MILNJQGXOJUM! IQUGVWQGVI!

IQJ!QJLXIQ!SLUJ!MJSIGUD

5QJ!8GVKOLITGK!QLM!PGUNJO!JeIJKMT^JXR!PTIQ!L!KVF]JU!

GH!GIQJU!GUWLKTaLITGKM!IG!QJX[!TF[UG^J!IQJ!/FJUTSLK!

QJLXIQ!SLUJ!MRMIJFD!)K!&G^JF]JU!"??>Z!PJ!SGXXL]GY

ULIJO!PTIQ!(FGUR!;KT^JUMTIRAM!)KMITIVIJ!HGU!/O^LKSJO!

+GXTSR!2GXVITGKM!IG!JMIL]XTMQ!IQJ!$JKIJU!HGU!(KITIXJFJKI!

1JHGUFZ!SQLUWJO!PTIQ!GVIXTKTKW!IQJ!HLSIGUM!UJM[GKMT]XJ!

HGU! UTMTKW! JKITIXJFJKI! SGMIMD! )K! nVXR! "??9! LKO! .LR!

"?<?Z! IQJ!8GVKOLITGK! TMMVJO! WULKIM!IG! IQJ! )KMITIVIJ!

HGU!7JLXIQSLUJ!)F[UG^JFJKI!IG!M[GKMGU!MRF[GMTL!GK!

QJLXIQ!SLUJ!SGMIM!LKO!OJXT^JURD!

/! "?<?! WULKI! IG! IQJ! $JKIJU! HGU! /FJUTSLK! +UGWUJMM!

HVKOJO!LK!Je[XGULITGK!GH![LRFJKI!UJHGUFM!IG!UJOVSJ!

G^JULXX! QJLXIQ! SLUJ! SGMIM! ]R!MQTHITKW!LPLR! HUGF! IQJ!HJJYHGUYMJU^TSJ![LRFJKI!FGOJX!IQLI!JKSGVULWJM!G^JUY

SGKMVF[ITGK!GH!QJLXIQ!SLUJ!]R![LITJKIM!LKO!G^JUYIUJLIY

FJKI!]R!OGSIGUM!LKO!QGM[TILXMD!5QJ!8GVKOLITGK!LXMG!

PGUNJO!PTIQ!IQJ!$JKIJU!HGU!+ULSITSLX!:TGJIQTSM!IG!HGUF!

IQJ!$GLXTITGK!IG!5ULKMHGUF!/O^LKSJ! $LUJZ!L! SGKMGUY

ITVF! GH! XJLOTKW! GUWLKTaLITGKMZ! XJO! ]R! HGUFJU! //1+!

$(%!6TXXTLF!&G^JXXTZ!IQLI!JF[GPJUM![LITJKIM!LKO!IQJTU!

HLFTXTJM!LKO!JKWLWJM!QJLXIQ!SLUJ![UG^TOJUM!TK!JHHGUIM!IG!TF[UG^J!SLUJ!HGU![JG[XJ!PQG!LUJ!MJUTGVMXR!TXX!LKO!ORTKWD

7JLXIQ!SLUJ!PTXX!SGKITKVJ!IG!]J!L!SJKIULX!HGSVM!GH!IQJ!

8GVKOLITGKAM!PGUN!E!L!KJP!TKTITLIT^J!TM!]JTKW![XLKKJO!

IG! HGSVM! OTUJSIXR! GK! IQTM! NJR! JXJFJKI! GH! GVU! HTMSLX!

SQLXXJKWJD



" FD:;),3)&*!$%&2(&2;2!%&!+%,)$-!2%,;5)%&2:;),3)&*!$%&2(&2;2!%&!+%,)$-!2%,;5)%&2

!"#$%&'()*+*(,-./("&%)M(%./N5619(KL(OGOIM(P"=&'(O1-(:*N5+*(01*6+0(1TN1295+8-14(52(@AACF(826144(.+01-S541(2.+19M(%./N*-54.2(8414(O8-:0*4523(

O.S1-(O*-5+LF(S05:0(*9]84+4(1T:0*231(-*+14(+.(*448/1(5912+5:*6(N-5:1(.,(3..94(52(95,,1-12+(:.82+-514M(!"#$%&'()*+*(,-./(+01(%.23-1445.2*6(78931+(

",,5:1F(=01(;.23<=1-/(78931+("8+6..>'(?821(@ABAF(*6+1-2*+5H1(45/86*+5.2M(%./N5619(KL(OGOIM

P E R C E N T A G E O F G D

P

$2,878

$3,487 $3,445

$3,137

$3,722

$4,363 $4,218

$5,144

$3,978

$7,960

0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

7,000

8,000

9,000

SOCIAL SECURITY

MEDICARE, MEDICAID AND CHIP

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

2010 2020 2030 2040 2050 2060 2070 2080

FISCAL YEAR

5% of GDP

5.5% of GDP

19%of GDP 25%

of GDP

6%

of GDP

J A P A N

U K

A U S T R A L I A

I T A L Y

S W E D E N

C A N A D A

G

E R M A N Y

S W I T Z E R L A N D

F R A N C E

U S P

E R C A P I T A H E A L T H C A R E C O S T S

U . S . D

O L L A R S

$VUUJKIXRZ!/FJUTSLKM!M[JKO!L]GVI!IPTSJ!LM!FVSQ![JU!SL[TIL!GK!QJLXIQ!SLUJ!LM!GIQJU!%($3!SGVKIUTJM!PTIQ!

KG!L[[UJSTL]XJ!OTHHJUJKSJ!TK!QJLXIQ!GVISGFJMD

7JLXIQ!SLUJ!JKITIXJFJKI![UGWULFM!LUJ![UG_JSIJO!IG!FGUJ!IQLK!IUT[XJ!LM!L![JUSJKILWJ!GH!*3+!VKOJU!

SVUUJKI![GXTSTJMD



FH

/,)*&)&*!&/5)%&/,!2($;1)5-!6)57!($%&%.)$!2($;1)5-

3JHJKMJ!M[JKOTKW!LSSGVKIM!HGU!KJLUXR!"?![JUSJKI!GH!

IQJ!;D2D!]VOWJI!LKO!KJLUXR!HT J![JUSJKI!GH!IQJ!KLITGKAM!

WUGMM!OGFJMITS![UGOVSI!E!FGUJ!IQLK!IPTSJ!PQLI!FLKR!

GIQJU!LO^LKSJO!KLITGKM!M[JKO!LM!L![JUSJKILWJ!GH!*3+D!

)K!HLSIZ!IQJ!;KTIJO!2ILIJM!OJ^GIJM!FGUJ!UJMGVUSJM!IG!

OJHJKMJ! IQLK! IQJ! KJeI! <`! QTWQJMIYM[JKOTKW! KLITGKM!

:./K5219M

3JM[TIJ! IQJ! MTWKTHTSLKSJ! GH! IQJ! OJHJKMJ! ]VOWJIZ!

OJHJKMJ! M[JKOTKW! GHIJK! JMSL[JM! SXGMJ! HTMSLX! LKO!

MIULIJWTS! MSUVITKRD! +GXTSRFLNJUM! KJJO! IG! LMNb! /UJ!

IGOLRAM!M[JKOTKW![UTGUTITJM!L[[UG[UTLIJ!IG!IQJ!MJSVUTIR!

IQUJLIM!GH!IQJ!"<MI!SJKIVURi!5QJ!;KTIJO!2ILIJM!HLSJM!

L! XLKOMSL[J! GH! KJP! IQUJLIM! LKO! FJJITKW! IQJF! PTXX!UJ\VTUJ!L! SGF[UJQJKMT J! UJ^TJP! GH!KLITGKLX! MJSVUTIR!

IQLI!LOOUJMMJM!IGOLRAM!SQLXXJKWJMZ!KGI!RJMIJUOLRAMD

8VUIQJUFGUJZ! IG! FLUMQLX! IQJ! UJMGVUSJM! KJSJMMLUR!

IG! LOJ\VLIJXR! OJHJKO! /FJUTSLAM! KLITGKLX! TKIJUJMIM!

LKO! NJJ[! /FJUTSLKM! MLHJZ! GVU! KLITGK! FVMI! ]J! GK!

MGVKO!HTMSLX!LKO!JSGKGFTS!HGGITKWD!)K!IGOLRAM!WXG]LX!

JSGKGFRZ!GVU!KLITGKLX!MJSVUTIR! OJ[JKOM! OTUJSIXR! GK!GVU!JSGKGFTS!MJSVUTIRD!/OFTULX!.TNJ!.VXXJKZ!HGUFJU!

$QLTUFLK!GH!IQJ!nGTKI!$QTJHM!GH!2ILHHZ!QLM!MLTOZ!c5QJ!

MTKWXJ!WUJLIJMI!IQUJLI!IG!GVU!KLITGKLX!MJSVUTIR!TM!GVU!

OJ]IDd! 7J! LXMG! KGIJOZ! c5QJ! p+JKILWGKq! ]VOWJI! QLM!

]LMTSLXXR!OGV]XJO!TK!IQJ!XLMI!OJSLOJZ!LKO!TK!OGV]XTKWZ!

PJ!QL^J! XGMI! IQJ! L]TXTIR! IG! [UTGUTITaJZ! IG!FLNJ! QLUO!

OJSTMTGKMZ!IG!OG!IGVWQ!LKLXRMTMZ!IG!FLNJ!IULOJMDd!

7GP! SLK! /FJUTSL! KL^TWLIJ! IQJ! OVLX! SQLXXJKWJM! GH!

FTXTILUR![UJ[LUJOKJMM!LKOZ!LI!IQJ!MLFJ!ITFJZ!FL_GU!

HTMSLX!SGKMIULTKIMi!%KJ!SXJLU!LKMPJU!TM!HGU!GVU!KLITGK!

IG!HULFJ!L!KJP!KLITGKLX!MJSVUTIR!MIULIJWRD!5G!OG!MGZ!PJ!

KJJO!L!SXJLU!VKOJUMILKOTKW!GH!IQJ!UTMNM!HLSTKW!VM!TK!IQJ!

"<MI!SJKIVURD!6TIQ!IQJMJ!UTMNM!LKO!IQJ!UJXLIJO!SGMIM!

TK!FTKOZ!PJ!SLK!OJ^JXG[! IQJ! MIULIJWR!LKO!FTMMTGKM!

IG!SGVKIJU!LKO! UJOVSJ! IQJFD!/KO! PTIQ! IQJ! MIULIJWR!

TK!QLKOZ!PJ!SLK!]JWTK!IG!FLNJ!MJKMT]XJ!LKO!SGQJUJKI!

UJOVSITGKM!TK!IQJ!OJHJKMJ!]VOWJID!

6TIQ!IQTM!TK!FTKOZ!IQJ!+JIJUMGK!8GVKOLITGK!QLM!_GTKJO!

PTIQ! IQJ! 7JKUR! ,D! 2ITFMGK! $JKIJU! IG! WLIQJU! OTMITKY

WVTMQJO!KLITGKLX!MJSVUTIR!Je[JUIM!IG!]JWTK!PGUNTKW!GK!L!KJP!OJHJKMJ!MIULIJWR!HGU!IQJ!;D2D!:LUUR!:XJSQFLKZ!

SGYHGVKOJU!GH!2ITFMGKZ!TM!MJU^TKW!LM!+UG_JSI!3TUJSIGU!

LKO!,JMXTJ!*JX]Z!HGUFJU!/MMTMILKI!2JSUJILUR!GH!2ILIJ!HGU!

+GXTITSLX!LKO!.TXTILUR!/HHLTUM!LKO!+UJMTOJKI!(FJUTIVM!

GH!IQJ!$GVKSTX! GK!8GUJTWK!1JXLITGKMZ!TM! MJU^TKW!LM! L!

SGKMVXILKI!IG!IQJ!8GVKOLITGKD!5QJ![UG_JSI!PTXX![UGOVSJ!

L! UJ[GUI! IQLIZ!]LMJO!GK! IQJ! WUGV[AM! LMMJMMFJKI! GH!

SVUUJKI! TKIJUJMIM! LKO! IQUJLIMZ! GHHJUM! MIULIJWTJM! LKO!HGUSJ!MIUVSIVUJM!IG!NJJ[!/FJUTSL!MLHJZ!PQTXJ!LSNKGPXY

JOWTKW!IQLI!GVU!KLITGKLX!MJSVUTIR!UJ\VTUJM!VM!IG!]J!GK!

L!MVMILTKL]XJ!HTMSLX![LIQD

/!QJLXIQR!;D2D!JSGKGFR!TM!IQJ!HGVKOLITGK!GK!PQTSQ!

GVU!KLITGKLX!MJSVUTIR!TM!]VTXI!E!L!MVMILTKL]XJ!]VOWJI!LKO!

L!MIUGKW!OJHJKMJ!WG!QLKOYTKYQLKOD!5QJ!+JIJUMGK!

8GVKOLITGK!TM!SGK^JKTKW!IG[!OJHJKMJ!Je[JUIM!IG!LXTWK!IQJ!

;D2D!OJHJKMJ!]VOWJI!PTIQ!"<MI!SJKIVUR!KLITGKLX!MJSVUTIR!IQUJLIM!LKO!MIULIJWTJMD



" FE:;),3)&*!$%&2(&2;2!%&!+%,)$-!2%,;5)%&2

5QJ!;D2D!M[JKI!FGUJ!GK!OJHJKMJ!TK!"?<?!IQLK!IQJ!SGVKIUTJM!

PTIQ!IQJ!KJeI!<`!QTWQJMI!OJHJKMJ!]VOWJIM!SGF]TKJOD

!"#$%&'()*+*(,-./(!+.:>0.6/(V2+1-2*+5.2*6(O1*:1($141*-:0(V24+5+8+1F(!VO$V(E565+*-L(&TN1295+8-1()*+*K*41M(%./N5619(KL(OGOIM(

P"=&'().66*-(,538-14(*-1(52(K5665.24(.,(@ABA(:.24+*2+(#M!M(9.66*-4M(

600

500

0

700

400

300

200

100

TURKEY, UAE

SPAIN & ISRAEL

BRAZIL

SOUTH KOREA

AUSTRALIA

CANADA

ITALY

INDIA

GERMANY

JAPAN

RUSSIA

FRANCE

UK

CHINA

B I L L I O

N S

O F

D O L L A

R S

$691 BILLION

SAUDI ARABIA

800

USA

$698 BILLION



?G

:;),3)&*!.%.(&5;.!8%1!+%,)$-!/$5)%&!

6GUNTKW!PTIQ!NJR!6LMQTKWIGK!LO^GSLIJM!MVSQ!LM!IQJ!

$GFFTIIJJ!HGU!L!1JM[GKMT]XJ!8JOJULX!:VOWJIZ!IQJ!+JIJUMGK!

8GVKOLITGK!NJJ[M!IQJ![UJMMVUJ!GK!HGU!MVMILTKL]XJ!HTMSLX![GXTSR!

IQUGVWQ!SGXXL]GULIT^J![UG_JSIM!MVSQ!LM!5QJ!.GFJKI!GH!5UVIQ!

+UG_JSI!LKO!IQJ!+JIJUMGKY+JP!$GFFTMMTGK!GK!:VOWJI!1JHGUFD

2JJNTKW! IG! M[VU! LSITGK! GK! /FJUTSLAM! SQLXXJKWJM!

HGXXGPTKW! IQJTU! PGUN! GK! IQJ! +UJMTOJKIAM! &LITGKLX!

$GFFTMMTGK! GK! 8TMSLX! 1JM[GKMT]TXTIR! LKO! 1JHGUFZ!

SGYSQLTUM!(UMNTKJ!:GPXJM!LKO!/XLK!2TF[MGK!HGVKOJO!

5QJ!.GFJKI!GH!5UVIQ!+UG_JSI!TK!.LUSQ!"?<<D!:VTXOTKW!

GK!GVU!TKTITLX!MV[[GUI!GH!IQJ!$GFFTMMTGKAM!PGUNZ!IQJ!

+JIJUMGK!8GVKOLITGKZ!LXGKW!PTIQ!GIQJU!GUWLKTaLITGKMZ!

[UG^TOJO!HVKOTKW!HGU!5QJ!.GFJKI!GH!5UVIQD!

6QJK! L! ]T[LUITMLK!FL_GUTIRZ! TKSXVOTKW! MJ^JULX! JXJSIJO!

GHHTSTLXMZ!^GIJO!HGU!IQJ!8TMSLX!$GFFTMMTGKAM!HTKLX!UJ[GUI!

gJKITIXJO!=01(E./12+(.,(=-8+0hZ!TI!MJU^JO!LM!L!SXJLU!TKOTY

SLITGK! IQLI! ]T[LUITMLK!LWUJJFJKI! GK!L! SGF[UJQJKMT J!

XGKWYIJUF!OJHTSTI!UJOVSITGK! [XLK! TM![GMMT]XJD!.LNTKW! TI!

L! UJLXTIR! UJ\VTUJM! XJLOJUMQT[! LKO! IGVWQ! SQGTSJM! HUGF!

IQJ! +UJMTOJKI! LKO! FJF]JUM! GH! $GKWUJMMZ! LM! PJXX! LM!

SGKITKVJO!MV[[GUI!HGU!UJHGUFM!LFGKW!IQJ!^GITKW![V]XTSD

5QJ!.GFJKI!GH!5UVIQ!+UG_JSI!QLM!SGKITKVJO!IG!]VTXO!

FGFJKIVF! HGU! SGF[UJQJKMT^J! XGKWYIJUF! UJHGUFZ!

PTIQ! NJR! SGFFTMMTGKJUM! IJMITHRTKW! ]JHGUJ! $GKWUJMM!

LKO!JKWLWTKW!IQJ!+UJMTOJKIZ!LOFTKTMIULITGK!GHHTSTLXMZ!

LKO!$GKWUJMMTGKLX! XJLOJUMZ! TKSXVOTKW! IQJ!]T[LUITMLK!

WUGV[!GH!MTe!;D2D!MJKLIGUMZ!SGFFGKXR!UJHJUUJO!IG!LM!IQJ!c*LKW!GH!2TeDd!)F[GUILKIXRZ!IQJ!.GFJKI!GH!5UVIQ!

+UG_JSI!TM!M[JLNTKW!IG!IQJ![V]XTSZ!Je[XLTKTKW!IQJ!HLSIM!

L]GVI!GVU!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJMZ!LKMPJUTKW!\VJMITGKMZ!LKO!

XLRTKW!GVI!IQJ![GMMT]XJ![LIQM!IG!L!MGXVITGKD!

)K! LOOTITGKZ! IG! JKSGVULWJ! L! OJJ[JU! JeLFTKLITGK! GH!

QGP! IQJ! HJOJULX! ]VOWJI![UGSJMM! TF[LSIM! /FJUTSLAM!

HTMSLX!GVIXGGNZ!IQJ!8GVKOLITGKZ!TK!SGK_VKSITGK!PTIQ!IQJ!

+JP!$QLUTIL]XJ!5UVMIMZ![UG^TOJO!HVKOTKW!IG!JMIL]XTMQ!

IQJ! +JIJUMGKY+JP! $GFFTMMTGKD! 5QJ! $GFFTMMTGK!

SGK^JKJO! HJOJULX! ]VOWJI! LKO! HTMSLX! [GXTSR! Je[JUIMZ!

TKSXVOTKW! HGUFJU! OTUJSIGUM! GH! IQJ! $GKWUJMMTGKLX!

:VOWJI! %HHTSJ! LKO! IQJ! %HHTSJ! GH! .LKLWJFJKI! LKO!

:VOWJIZ!LKO!HGUFJU!SQLTUFJK!LKO!ULKNTKW!FJF]JUM!

GH!IQJ!7GVMJ!LKO!2JKLIJ!:VOWJI! $GFFTIIJJMD!5QJR!

UJXJLMJO! IPG! SGF[UJQJKMT^J! UJ[GUIMb! IQJ! HTUMIZ! $19(

V2>($54523F(GHHJUJO!L! MTeYMIJ[![XLK! HGU!MIL]TXTaTKW! GVU!

KLITGKLX! OJ]Io! IQJ! MJSGKOZ! G1++523( 7*:>( 52( 76*:>F!

[UG TOJO! L! MJI! GH! M[JSTHTSZ! OJILTXJO! UJHGUFM! IG! IQJ!

HJOJULX! ]VOWJI! [UGSJMMZ! TKSXVOTKW! LOG[ITKW! HTMSLX!

ILUWJIMZ!TKMITIVITKW!IUTWWJUM!TK!SLMJ!WGLXM!LUJ!KGI!FJIZ!

LKO!TKSUJLMTKW!IULKM[LUJKSRD!:GIQ!UJ[GUIM!QL^J!]JJK!

TKHXVJKITLX!TK![JUMVLOTKW![GXTSRFLNJUM!IG!HGSVM!GK!IQJ!

]TWWJU!]VOWJI![TSIVUJZ!TKSGU[GULITKW!TOJLM!HGU!MTWKTHTY

SLKI! ]VOWJI![UGSJMM! UJHGUFM! IG!]UTKW!MIL]TXTIR!LKO!

SUJOT]TXTIR!IG!IQJ!KLITGKAM!HTKLKSJMD

1JSGWKTaTKW!IQLI!MILIJ!]VOWJIM!LUJ!LXMG!HLSTKW!MJUTGVM!

SQLXXJKWJMZ! IQJ! +JIJUMGK! 8GVKOLITGK! MV[[GUIJO! IQJ!

XLVKSQ!GH!IQJ!2ILIJ!:VOWJI!$UTMTM!5LMN!8GUSJZ!XJO!]R!

HGUFJU!&JP!-GUN!XTJVIJKLKI!WG^JUKGU!1TSQLUO!1L^TISQ!

LKO!HGUFJU! 8JOJULX!1JMJU^J!$QLTUFLK!+LVX!'GXSNJUD!5QJ!WGLX!GH!IQJ!5LMN!8GUSJ!TM!IG!JKMVUJ!IQLI!MILIJ!MIUVSY

IVULX!]VOWJI!WL[M!LKO!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJM!LUJ!OTMSVMMJO!

[V]XTSXRZ!SG^JUJO!]R!IQJ!KLITGKLX!FJOTLZ!LKO!SGKMTOJUJO!

TK!]GIQ!MILIJ!LKO!HJOJULX!]VOWJI!OJ]LIJMD!5QJ!5LMN!8GUSJ!

TM!SGKOVSITKW!UJMJLUSQ!TK!HT^J!MIVOR!MILIJM!E!$LXTHGUY

KTLZ!)XXTKGTMZ!&JP!-GUNZ!5JeLMZ!LKO!'TUWTKTL!E!IG!LO^LKSJ!

VKOJUMILKOTKW!GH!IQJ!TMMVJM!TF[LSITKW!MILIJ!]VOWJIM!

LKO! QJX[! IG! TF[UG^J! ]VOWJITKW! LKO! IULKM[LUJKSRD



(3;$/5)&*!/&3!/$5)'/5)&*!57(!/.(1)$/&!+;:,)$b!1(/$7)&*!+%,)$-./0(12!

)2!%&,-!7/,8!57(!:/55,(D!(,($5(3!%88)$)/,2!/1(!.%5)'/5(3!:-!/.(1)$/&2!

3(./&3)&*!/$5)%&D!6(!/1(!$%..)55(3!5%!1/)2)&*!+;:,)$!/6/1(&(22!/:%;5!%;1!&/5)%&A2!,%&*Y5(1.!8)2$/,!$7/,,(&*(2!/&3!

(&(1*)@)&*!/.(1)$/&25%!n%)&!57(!.%'(.(&58%1!2%,;5)%&2D



!!

!"#$#%&'%()&*#)+,-&$),%.),%,/01'%()&*#)2!&'2%$

!"#$%&'&#$()$&"#$*+,(+-.$/,+'+0#.1 )34567)5898:68;)4<)=>9?)

@AABC)46):)D9:4<6DEF8<)G>4;8)7E) 7H8)38;85:9)GEI85<J

K8<7L6) 34<:<M86N)O64<G) 34G>586C) MH:576C):<;)G5:DH6C)

7H46):MM8664P98)58DE57) 8QD9:4<6)HER) 9E<GJ785K)675>MJ

7>5:9) ;834M476C) 86M:9:74<G) ;8P7) 98I896C) :<;) P>5G8E<J

4<G) 4<785867)D:?K8<76) DE68) :) 7H58:7) 7E)7H8) <:74E<L6)

8ME<EK4M) 3>7>58N) '<) :;;474E<) 7E) 9:?4<G) E>7) 7H8)

D5EP98KC)7H8)D>P94M:74E<)4;8<743486):58:6)7H:7)K>67)P8)

:;;58668;):6)DE94M?K:F856);8I89ED)6E9>74E<6N)

&H8)+E><;:74E<):96E)D>P946H86)<E<D:5746:<):<:9?686)

E3);8I89EDK8<76)589:78;)7E)P>;G87):<;)346M:9)DE94M?N)

$>PS8M76) E3) :<:9?646) 4<M9>;8T) UH478) *E>68) :<;)

-E<G58664E<:9)P>;G87)D5EDE6:96V)7H8)$EM4:9)$8M>547?)

:<;) W8;4M:58) &5>67886) 58DE576C) RH4MH) ;89I8) 4<7E)

7H8)6E9I8<M?)E3) 7H8)D5EG5:K6V) 58DE576)E<) 67:78):<;)

9EM:9)GEI85<K8<7)34<:<M86V):M:;8K4M)D>P94M:74E<6)E<)

H8:97H)M:58C)587458K8<7)583E5KC)6:I4<G6C):<;)4<MEK8)

;46D:547?V):<;) 8I:9>:74E<6)E3) 7H8) 346M:9)674K>9>6):<;)

KE<87:5?):M74E<6)7:F8<);>54<G)7H8)58M8664E<N)

'<):;;474E<)7E):<:9?646)E3)E<GE4<G)8I8<76C)7H8)+E><;:J

74E<):96E)D5E;>M86) 586E>5M86)3E5) M474X8<6)7E)P8):P98)

7E) ><;8567:<;C) 3E99ERC) :<;) ME<754P>78) 7E) 7H8) D>P94M)

;8P:78N) &H868) 7EE96) 4<M9>;8) 346M:9) 466>8) D54K856C)

MH:576C) :) G9E66:5?) E3) P>;G87) :<;) 8ME<EK4M) 785K6C)

6>KK:5486) E3) GEI85<K8<7) P>;G87) D5ES8M74E<6C) :<;)

94<F6) 7E)7H45;JD:57?):<:9?686N)&H868)D>P94M:74E<6):58)

:I:49:P98)E<)E>5)R8P6478):7)RRRNDGD3NE5GN

$4<M8)7H8)!5864;8<7L6)-EKK4664E<)E<)+46M:9)"86DE<J

64P4947?):<;)"83E5K)5898:68;)476)D9:<)4<).8M8KP85)E3)

@AYAC)K:<?)G5E>D6):<;)DE9474M4:<6)H:I8)E33858;)7H845)

ER<)I464E<6) E3) 346M:9) 583E5KC) :<;) 346M:9) 466>86)H:I8)

P8MEK8)4<M58:64<G9?)D5EK4<8<7)7ED4M6)4<)7H8)K8;4:N)

&H8)+E><;:74E<)H:6)D5EI4;8;):MM8664P98):<;)EPS8M74I8)

:<:9?646) E3) K:<?) E3) 7H8) D9:<6) 5898:68;C) 4<M9>;4<G)

6>KK:5486C) MEKD:546E<) 7:P986C) :<;)G5:DH6) 7E)H89D)

,K854M:<6):66866)7H8)MHE4M86)P83E58)>6N)

,6)D:57)E3)476)833E576)7E)5:468)7H8)98I89)E3)><;8567:<;4<G)

:PE>7)346M:9)MH:998<G86):<;)6E9>74E<6)4<)PE7H)U:6H4<G7E<)

:<;):M5E66),K854M:C)7H8)!87856E<)+E><;:74E<)58G>9:59?)

466>86)58DE576):<;):<:9?686C)4<M9>;4<G)7H8)$7:78)E3)7H8)

O<4E<L6)+4<:<M86N)&H868)D>P94M:74E<6)H:I8)867:P946H8;)

7H8)!87856E<)+E><;:74E<):6):)75>678;)6E>5M8)E3)><P4:68;C)

4<;8D8<;8<7)4<3E5K:74E<):PE>7)38;85:9)346M:9)DE94M?N

Z+,-'%()!,(#[)!,(#$)+"2W)&*#)+2O%.,&'2%L$)%!2!3$4/$!53$*6746-%$/762683% C),)(O'.#)&2)&*#)+#.#",/)

(2\#"%W#%&L$)+'%,%-#$C)'&$)/2%(J&#"W)+'$-,/)-*,//#%(#$C),%.)!2&#%&',/)$2/O&'2%$N



!"!"#$%&'()*%("*%$&'+%&'()*&,!*%-!.'$%(*/#01'$



?A

:;),3)&*!+;:,)$!/6/1(&(22!/:%;5!%;1!8)2$/,!8;5;1(

3JXT^JUTKW!L!SGF[JXXTKW!FJMMLWJ!UJ\VTUJM!MIULTWQI!HLSIM!LKO!L!QJLXIQR!OGMJ!GH!SUJLIT^TIRD!5QUGVWQ!IQJ!c%PJ&Gd!

SLF[LTWKZ!IQJ!MLITUTSLX!SLKOTOLSR!GH!7VWQ!nTOJIIJZ!LKO!

L!^LUTJIR!GH!LO^JUITMJFJKIMZ!IQJ!+JIJUMGK!8GVKOLITGK!TM!

JKWLWTKW!SGKSJUKJO!STITaJKM!LSUGMM!IQJ!KLITGKD

6QTXJ! OTMSVMMTGKM! L]GVI!/FJUTSLAM! HTMSLX! HVIVUJ! LUJ!

SGFFGK[XLSJ! TK! 6LMQTKWIGKZ!3D$DZ!PJ!LXMG!MJJN! IG!

TKM[TUJ!SGK^JUMLITGKM!LI!NTISQJK!IL]XJM!LSUGMM!/FJUTSLD!

5QLIAM!PQR!IQJ!+JIJUMGK!8GVKOLITGK!QLM!OJ^JXG[JO!L!

KVF]JU!GH![V]XTS!LPLUJKJMM!JHHGUIM! IG!SGKKJSI!PTIQ!

IQJ!/FJUTSLK![V]XTSD

)K!"?<?Z!IQJ!8GVKOLITGK!XLVKSQJO!L![V]XTS!LPLUJKJMM!SLF[LTWK!VKOJU!IQJ!]LKKJU!c%PJ&GDd!5QJ!SLF[LTWKAM!

WGLXM!LUJ!IG!198:*+1(/FJUTSLKM!L]GVI!IQJ!SGKMJ\VJKSY

JM!GH!GVU! MGLUTKW!OJ]I! LKO! OJHTSTIMZ!K8569(:.2412484!

LFGKW! SGKSJUKJO! STITaJKM! GH! LXX! [GXTITSLX! [JUMVLY

MTGKM!GK! IQJ!KJJO!HGU!MJKMT]XJ!MGXVITGKMZ! LKOZ!FGMI!

TF[GUILKIXRZ!123*31! [JG[XJ!LSUGMM! IQJ! SGVKIUR! TK!L!

FG^JFJKI!HGU!SQLKWJD!5QUGVWQ!TIM!SLF[LTWK!PJ]MTIJ!

LKO!MGSTLX!KJIPGUNTKW![UG[JUITJMZ!TI!GHHJUM!IGGXM!LKO!UJMGVUSJM!IG!QJX[!/FJUTSLKM!WJI!TK^GX^JO!PTIQ![VIITKW!

GVU!KLITGK!GK!L!FGUJ!MVMILTKL]XJ!HTMSLX![LIQD

5G!QJX[!SLILXRaJ![V]XTS!TKIJUJMIZ!IQJ!SLF[LTWK!HJLIVUJM!

L!MLITUTSLX![UJMTOJKITLX!SLKOTOLIJZ!7VWQ!nTOJIIJ!gL![XLR!

GK! IQJ! [QULMJ! c7VWJ! 3J]IdhZ! PQGMJ! L]MVUO! HTMSLX!

[XLIHGUF!TM!M[GIXTWQIJO!IQUGVWQ!L!QVFGUGVM!LO^JUITMTKW!

SLF[LTWK!IQLI!OUT^JM!QGFJ!L!MJUTGVM!FJMMLWJD!6QTXJ!QTM![GMTITGKM!MGVKO!MIULKWJ!LKO!VK]JXTJ^L]XJZ!VKHGUY

IVKLIJXR!LXX!GH!IQJ!HLSIM!LKO!HTWVUJM!IQLI!QJ!STIJM!LUJ!

JKITUJXR!IUVJ!E!]UTKWTKW!IG!XTWQI!GVU!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJM!LKO!

IQJ!IQUJLIM!IQJR![GMJ!IG!GVU!KLITGKAM!JSGKGFTS!HVIVUJD

5QUGVWQ!KVFJUGVM!GIQJU!LO^JUITMJFJKIMZ!IQJ!8GVKOLY

ITGK!QLM!QJX[JO!IG!HGSVM![GXTSRFLNJUM!LKO!IQJ![V]XTS!

GK!IQJ!KJJO!HGU!HTMSLX!LSITGKD!)K!"??>Z!IQJ!8GVKOLITGK!

ULK! FVXIT[XJ! LO^JUITMJFJKIM! SLXXTKW! GK! [UJMTOJKITLX!

SLKOTOLIJM!IG! UJSGWKTaJ! IQJ!VUWJKSR! GH!GVU!WUGPTKW!

OJ]I!LKO!OJ[JKOJKSJ!GK!HGUJTWK!XJKOJUMZ!LKO!FG^J!

OJSTMT JXR! IG! SGUUJSI! HTMSLX! TF]LXLKSJMD! 2V]MJ\VJKI!

LO^JUITMJFJKIM!QTWQXTWQIJO!IQJ!HLSIM!L]GVI!IQJ!VKMVMY

ILTKL]TXTIR!GH!WUGPTKW!UJITUJFJKI!LKO!QJLXIQ!SLUJ!G]XTY

WLITGKMZ! LM!PJXX! LM! IQJ! [V]XTSAM! HL^GUL]XJ! LIITIVOJM!

IGPLUO!L!]T[LUITMLK!HTMSLX!SGFFTMMTGKD!

)K!%SIG]JU!"?<<Z!IQJ!+JIJUMGK!8GVKOLITGK!MJU^JO!LM!

IQJ! GHHTSTLX! ]UGLOSLMI! M[GKMGU! GH!L!&JP! 7LF[MQTUJ!

[UJMTOJKITLX! [UTFLUR! OJ]LIJ! QGMIJO! ]R! :XGGF]JUW!

LKO! IQJ! [*40523+.2( O.4+( LI! 3LUIFGVIQ! $GXXJWJD! /M!

[LUI!GH!IQJ!M[GKMGUMQT[Z!IQJ!8GVKOLITGK!ULK!TKHGUFLY

ITGKLX!LO^JUITMJFJKIM!TK!PQTSQ!SQTXOUJKZ!PQGMJ!HVIVUJ!

TM!FGMI!LI!MILNJZ!GHHJU!HLSIM!L]GVI!/FJUTSLAM!OJ]I!LKO!OJHTSTIMD!5QJ!OJ]LIJ!PLM!IQJ!HTUMI!HGUVF!TK!IQJ!"?<"!

[UTFLUR! MJLMGK! IQLI! HGSVMJO! JeSXVMT^JXR! GK! HTMSLX!

LKO!JSGKGFTS!TMMVJMD!/M!MVSQZ!TI!MJU^JO!IG!LO^LKSJ!

IQJ!8GVKOLITGKAM!JOVSLITGKLX!FTMMTGK!LKO!QJX[!HGSVM!

LIIJKITGK!GK!QGP!GVU!KLITGKAM! XJLOJUM! LKO![GIJKITLX!

XJLOJUM! [XLK! IG![VI!/FJUTSL! GK!L!FGUJ!MVMILTKL]XJ!

HTMSLX![LIQD!

5QUGVWQ! IQJMJ! TKIJKMT J! JHHGUIM! IG! OULP! LIIJKITGK!

IG! IQJ! KLITGKAM! HTMSLX! SQLXXJKWJM! LKO! [V]XTSTaJ! IQJ!

WUGPTKW! L[[JITIJ! HGU! OJLXTKW! PTIQ! IQJFZ! IQJ! 8GVKY

OLITGK! TM!QJX[TKW! IG!]VTXO!FGFJKIVF! HGU! XGKWYIJUF!

MGXVITGKM!TK!6LMQTKWIGKD!



" ?B(3;$/5)&*!/&3!/$5)'/5)&*!57(!/.(1)$/&!+;:,)$

g$,%$06)2(h!)&8%1./5)%&/,!/3'(15)2)&*!;2(3!5%!7)*7,)*75!57(!&((3!8%1!8)2$/,!2;25/)&/:),)5-o!)./*(!

81%.!/&!(3;$/5)%&/,!5(,(')2)%&!/3!/)1(3!:-!57(!8%;&3/5)%&!3;1)&*!/!&(6!7/.+27)1(!+1(2)3(&5)/,!

3(:/5(o!7;*7!n)3(55(Z!/!2/5)1)$/,!+1(2)3(&5)/,!$/&3)3/5(!8(/5;1(3!)&!57(!c%6(&%d!$/.+/)*&D



?C

1(/$7)&*!/;3)(&$(2!/$1%22!57(!$%;&51-!

1JXJLMJO!TK!&G^JF]JU!"??>Z! VM"M#M!MYM!]UGVWQI!IQJ!

KLITGKAM! HTMSLX! SQLXXJKWJM! IG! XTHJ! TK! FGUJ! IQLK! B??!

IQJLIJUMZ! [UT^LIJ! MSUJJKTKWMZ!LKO!QGFJM!LSUGMM! IQJ!

SGVKIUR! LKO!SXLUTHTJO!SGF[XJe! IG[TSMZ! MVSQ!LM! OJ]IYIGY*3+! ULITGMZ!OJ]I!SJTXTKWMZ! IQJ!SGF[GMTITGK! GH!IQJ!

HJOJULX!]VOWJIZ!LKO!IQJ!FL_GU!OUT^JUM!GH!UTMTKW!OJ]ID!)K!

^T^TO!OJILTXZ!IQJ!SUTITSLXXR!LSSXLTFJO!HTXF!PJL^JM!TKIJUY

^TJPM!PTIQ!Je[JUIMZ!LKO!STITaJKM!LSUGMM!IQJ!SGVKIUR!PTIQ!

SGF[JXXTKW!JSGKGFTS!OLIL!IG!MQGP!QGP!GVU!WUGPTKW!

HTMSLX! [UG]XJFM! PTXX! LHHJSI! J^JUR! MTKWXJ! /FJUTSLK!

E! JM[JSTLXXR! IGOLRAM! RGVKW! [JG[XJ! LKO! IQJ! WJKJULY

ITGKM!IG!HGXXGPZ!PQGMJ!HVIVUJ!OJ[JKOM!GK!LOOUJMMTKW!IQJMJ![UJMMTKW!TMMVJMD!5QJ!IJMITFGKR!GH!STITaJKM!LKO!

PJXXYNKGPK! MV]_JSIM! MVSQ! LM!6LUUJK! :VHHJIZ! HGUFJU!

$QLTUFJK!GH!IQJ!8JOJULX!1JMJU^J!/XLK!*UJJKM[LK!LKO!

+LVX! 'GXSNJUZ! LKO! HGUFJU! 5UJLMVUR! 2JSUJILUTJM! +LVX!

%A&JTXX!LKO!1G]JUI!1V]TK!FLNJ!IQJ!HTXF!L!KGK[LUITMLK!

LKO![GTKIJOXR!IG[TSLX!KLUULIT^JD

)K! /[UTX! "?<?Z! IQJ! 8GVKOLITGK! UJXJLMJO! VM"M#M!MYM'(

!.68+5.24F! L! MJ\VJX! IG! IQJ! GUTWTKLX! OGSVFJKILURD!

:VTXOTKW!GK!IQJ!IGVWQ!\VJMITGKM!ULTMJO!TK!IQJ!HTUMI!HTXFZ!

!.68+5.24! GHHJUJO! L! [ULSITSLX! ]XVJ[UTKI! LKO! MJKMT]XJ!MIJ[M!IG!WJI!GVU!KLITGKAM!HTMSLX!QGVMJ!TK!GUOJUD!8GXXGPTKW!

IQJ! HTXFAM! $&&! [UJFTJUJZ! L! IJXJ^TMJO! [LKJX! OTMSVMY

MTGK!HJLIVUTKW!MJKTGU!8GVKOLITGK!XJLOJUM!]UGVWQI!GVU!

[JUM[JSIT^J!IG!J^JUROLR!/FJUTSLKM!GK!IQJ!TF[GUILKSJ!

GH!LSQTJ^TKW!XGKWYIJUF!HTMSLX!MVMILTKL]TXTIRD!.VSQ!XTNJ!

IQJ!GUTWTKLX!HTXFZ! VM"M#M!MYM'(!.68+5.24!JLUKJO!L!XLUWJ!

^TJPJUMQT[Z! KGI! GKXR! OVUTKW! TIM! IJXJ^TMJO! ]UGLOSLMIZ!

]VI!LXMG!GK!-GV5V]J!LKO!LSUGMM!IQJ!)KIJUKJID

8GU!LXX!/FJUTSLKM!E!J^JK!IQGMJ!PJXXY^JUMJO!TK!HTKLKSTLX!FLIIJUM!E!VKOJUMILKOTKW!IQJ!JKGUFTIR!GH!GVU!XGKWYIJUF!

HTMSLX!SUTMTM!SLK!]J!SQLXXJKWTKWD!6TIQ!IQTM!TK!FTKOZ!IQJ!

+JIJUMGK!8GVKOLITGK!M[GKMGUJO!IQJ!WUGVKO]UJLNTKW!HTXF!

VM"M#M!MYMZ!L!OGSVFJKILUR!IQLI![VIM!IQJ!MTaJ!LKO!MSG[J!

GH!GVU!KLITGKLX!OJ]I!LKO!OJHTSTIM!TK!LSSJMMT]XJ!IJUFM!HGU!

/FJUTSLKM!GH!LXX!LWJM!LKO!]LSNWUGVKOMD!

g8/$)&*!+/*(h!57(!.%')(!+%25(1!8%1! VM"M#M!MYMZ!57(!8%;&3/5)%&A2!$1)5)$/,,-!/$$,/).(3!3%$;.(&5/1-!

%&!/.(1)$/A2!8)2$/,!2)5;/5)%&D



" ?D(3;$/5)&*!/&3!/$5)'/5)&*!57(!/.(1)$/&!+;:,)$



?H

:1)&*)&*!57(!+(%+,(A2!'%)$(!5%!57(!:;3*(5!3(:/5(

5QJ! +JIJUMGK! 8GVKOLITGK! ]JXTJ^JM! IQLI! STITaJK!

JKWLWJFJKI! TM! SUTITSLX! IG! TIM! FTMMTGKD! 5G! JF[GPJU!

IQJ!/FJUTSLK![JG[XJ!IG! ILNJ!LSITGKZ! IQJ!8GVKOLITGK!

QLM!MV[[GUIJO!L!KVF]JU!GH!TKKG^LIT^J![LUIKJUMQT[MZ!

TKSXVOTKW! L! MTWKLIVUJ! JHHGUI! PTIQ! /FJUTSL2[JLNMZ!

L! KGK[LUITMLK! GUWLKTaLITGK! IQLI! PGUNM! IG! [UG TOJ!

STITaJKM!PTIQ!L!^GTSJ!GK!IQJ!FGMI!TF[GUILKI!OJSTMTGKM!

IQLI!TF[LSI!IQJTU!XT^JMD

)K! nVKJ! "?<?Z! /FJUTSL2[JLNM! ]UGVWQI! IGWJIQJU!

IQGVMLKOM!GH!/FJUTSLKM!TK!"?!STITJM!LSUGMM!IQJ!KLITGK!

IG! [LUITST[LIJ! TK! SGFFVKTIR! OTMSVMMTGKM! L]GVI! GVU!

HTMSLX! HVIVUJD! $TITaJKM! HUGF! LXX! PLXNM! GH! XTHJ! XJLUKJO!

L]GVI!HTMSLX!LKO!JSGKGFTS!TMMVJM!LKO!Je[UJMMJO!IQJTU!

[UJHJUJKSJM!HGU!]VOWJILUR! UJHGUFD!5QJ!HGUVFM!PJUJ!

QJXO!MTFVXILKJGVMXR! LKO! XTKNJO! IGWJIQJU! ]R!MLIJXXTIJ!

HGU!L!IUVXR!KLITGKLX!OTMSVMMTGKZ!LKO!GHHJUJO!/FJUTSLKM!

LK!G[[GUIVKTIR!IG!OTMSVMM!GVU!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJM!PTIQ!

IQJTU! HJXXGP!STITaJKMD!5QJ!UJMVXITKW!UJSGFFJKOLITGKM!

PJUJ!MQLUJO!PTIQ![GXTSRFLNJUM!LM!/FJUTSLAM!MGXVITGKM!

HGU!L!MVMILTKL]XJ!HTMSLX!HVIVUJD

5QJ!OTMSVMMTGKM!UJMVXIJO!TK!^LUTGVM!XJ^JXM!GH!MV[[GUI!

HGU! L! ULKWJ! GH! G[ITGKMZ! TKSXVOTKW! ULTMTKW! ILe! ULIJM!GK! SGU[GULITGKM! LKO! PJXXYGHH! TKOT TOVLXMZ! TKSUJLMTKW!

IQJ! LWJ! HGU! UJSJT^TKW! HVXX! 2GSTLX! 2JSVUTIR! ]JKJHTIMZ!

LKO! UJOVSTKW! OJHJKMJ! M[JKOTKW! ]R! <?Y<C! [JUSJKID!

+LUITST[LKIM! PJUJ! LXMG! LMNJO! IG! OJ^JXG[! FJMMLWJM!

IG! MJKO! IG! IQJTU! JXJSIJO! GHHTSTLXMD! /FGKW! IQJ! FGMI!

[G[VXLU!PLMZ!c+XJLMJ!HTKO!IQJ![GXTITSLX!PTXX!IG!VMJ!IQTM!

TK[VI!LM!TH!TI!PJUJ!SGFTKW!HUGF!L![GPJUHVX!XG]]RTKW!

WUGV[!E!]JSLVMJ!PJ!LUJDd!

8UGF!"??>!IQUGVWQ!"?<<Z! IQJ!8GVKOLITGK![LUIKJUJO!

PTIQ! 5QJ! $GKSGUO! $GLXTITGK! IG! MV[[GUI! TIM! 8TMSLX!

6LNJY;[!LKO!8TMSLX! 2GXVITGKM!5GVUZ!PQTSQ! JOVSLIJO!

/FJUTSLKM!L]GVI!GVU!KLITGKLX!]VOWJI!SQLXXJKWJM!LKO!

IQJ!SQGTSJM!TK^GX^JO!TK!LOOUJMMTKW!IQJFD!)K!HGVU!RJLUMZ!

IQJ!IGVU!MIG[[JO!TK!FGUJ!IQLK!`?!STITJMD!

6TIQ! HVKOTKW! MV[[GUI! HUGF! IQJ! +JIJUMGK! 8GVKOLY

ITGKZ! GVU! HGUFJU! $(%Z! 3L^TO! 6LXNJUZ! XLVKSQJO! IQJ!

c$GFJ]LSN!/FJUTSL!)KTITLIT^J!g$/)h!TK!"?<?Dd!1GGIJO!

TK! IQJ! UJSGFFJKOLITGKM! TKSXVOJO! TK! 3L TOAM! ]GGNZ!

%./1K*:>( Y/1-5:*F! $/)! JOVSLIJM! /FJUTSLKM! L]GVI!

GVU!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJM!LKO!GHHJUM!L!^LUTJIR!GH![UG[GMLXM!

IG! LOOUJMM! IQJFD!3L^TO! MJU^JM! LM! LK!JHHJSIT^J! LKO!

NKGPXJOWJL]XJ!LO^GSLIJ!HGU!HTMSLX!UJM[GKMT]TXTIR!E!QJ!

UJWVXLUXR!IUL^JXM! IQJ!SGVKIURZ!M[JLNTKW! IG!LVOTJKSJM!

GH!SGKSJUKJO!/FJUTSLKMZ!Je[XLTKTKW!IQJ!FLWKTIVOJ!GH!

GVU!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJM!LKO!GHHJUTKW!SGKSUJIJ!MGXVITGKMD

5QJ!/FJUTSLK![JG[XJ!MQGVXO!]J!LSIT^J![LUITST[LKIM!TK!LO^LKSTKW!MGXVITGKM!IG!GVU!KLITGKAM!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJMD!

5QLIAM!PQR!IQJ!+JIJUMGK!8GVKOLITGK!QLM![LUIKJUJO!PTIQ!

/FJUTSL2[JLNMZ!5QJ!$GKSGUO!$GLXTITGKZ!LKO!GIQJUM!IG!

JKMVUJ!IQJ![V]XTSAM!^GTSJ!TM!QJLUOD

g8/$)&*!+/*(h!+/15)$)+/&52!5/0(!+/15!)&!/.(1)$/2+(/02A!c%;1!:;3*(5Z!%;1!($%&%.-d!('(&5Z!67)$7!

$%&'(&(3!57%;2/&32!%8!/.(1)$/&2!)&!$)5)(2!/$1%22!57(!$%;&51-!5%!3)2$;22!7%6!57(!;D2D!27%;,3!

/$7)('(!8)2$/,!2;25/)&/:),)5-D!



" ?E(3;$/5)&*!/&3!/$5)'/5)&*!57(!/.(1)$/&!+;:,)$



@G

5(/$7)&*!-%;&*!/.(1)$/&2!/:%;5!57()1!8)2$/,!8;5;1(

8JP!XJMMGKM!LUJ!OJ^GIJO!IG!JSGKGFTS!LKO!HTMSLX![GXTSR!

TK!FGMI!MSQGGX!SVUUTSVXLD!/M!L!UJMVXIZ!MIVOJKIM!GHIJK!

WULOVLIJ!HUGF!QTWQ!MSQGGX!XLSNTKW!IQJ!LPLUJKJMM!LKO!

LKLXRITSLX!IGGXM!IG!VKOJUMILKO!LKO![LUITST[LIJ!FJLKY

TKWHVXXR! TK! OTMSVMMTGKM! L]GVI! IQJ! KLITGKAM! JSGKGFTS!

LKO!HTMSLX![UTGUTITJM!E!OTMSVMMTGKM!IQLI!OTUJSIXR!TF[LSI!IQJTU!HVIVUJD

5G!TF[UG^J!TKMIUVSITGK!GK!JSGKGFTS![GXTSR!TMMVJMZ!IQJ!

8GVKOLITGK![UG^TOJO!L!IQUJJYRJLU!WULKI! IG!$GXVF]TL!

;KT^JUMTIRAM!5JLSQJUM!$GXXJWJ!IG!OJ^JXG[!L!SGF[UJQJKY

MT^J!SVUUTSVXVF!HGU!SGVUMJM!TK!JSGKGFTSMZ!ST^TSMZ!;D2D!

QTMIGURZ!PGUXO!QTMIGUR!LKO!FLIQJFLITSMZ!QTWQXTWQITKW!

IQJ!KLITGKAM!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJMD!5QJ!SVUUTSVXVF!PTXX!]J!FLOJ!L^LTXL]XJ!HUJJ!GH!SQLUWJ!IG!J^JUR!QTWQ!MSQGGX!TK!

IQJ!SGVKIURD

5TIXJO!c;KOJUMILKOTKW!8TMSLX!1JM[GKMT]TXTIRb!/!$VUUTSY

VXVF!HGU!5JLSQTKW!/]GVI!IQJ!8JOJULX!:VOWJIZ!&LITGKLX!

3J]I!LKO!:VOWJI! 3JHTSTIZd! IQJ! KGK[LUITMLKZ! TK\VTURY

]LMJO!SVUUTSVXVF!PTXX!IJLSQ!MIVOJKIM!IQJ!HLSIM!L]GVI!

[V]XTS! [GXTSTJM! IQLI! QL^J! XJO! IG! [JUMTMIJKI! ]VOWJI!

OJHTSTIM!LKO!TOJKITHR!IQJ!MTWKTHTSLKI!SGKMJ\VJKSJM!GVU!

WUGPTKW!KLITGKLX!OJ]I!QLM!GK!IQJ!HVIVUJ!GH!IQJ!;KTIJO!

2ILIJM!LKO!TIM!STITaJKMD!/K!LO^TMGUR!]GLUO!GH!Je[JUIM!TK!

JSGKGFTSMZ!HTMSLX![GXTSRZ!LKO!JOVSLITGK!QLM!UJ^TJPJO!

IQJ! XJMMGKMD! 5QJ! SVUUTSVXVF! TKSGU[GULIJM! ]GGNMZ!

[UTFLUR! MGVUSJMZ! MTFVXLITGKMZ! LKO! GIQJU! ^TMVLX! LKO!

OTWTILX!FJOTLD!

/HIJU!HTJXOYIJMITKW!IQJ!SVUUTSVXVF!TK!C=!SXLMMUGGFM!TK!

5JeLMZ!+JKKMRX^LKTLZ!LKO!&JP!-GUNZ!IQJ!HTKLX!^JUMTGK!PTXX! ]J! OTMIUT]VIJO! KLITGKPTOJ! TK! "?<"D! $GXVF]TL!

5JLSQJUM! $GXXJWJ! QLM! SGFFTMMTGKJO! IQJ! &LITGKLX!

$JKIJU! HGU! 1JMIUVSIVUTKW! (OVSLITGKZ! 2SQGGXM! LKO!

5JLSQTKW! g&$1(25h! IG!SGKOVSI! LK!J^LXVLITGK! GH! IQJ!

UJMVXIM!GH!IQJ!SVUUTSVXVFD

5QJ!8GVKOLITGK!LXMG!LO^LKSJO!TIM!JOVSLITGKLX!FTMMTGK!

]R! [UG TOTKW! /FJUTSLAM! +UGFTMJ! /XXTLKSJ! E! L! [LUIYKJUMQT[!GH!FGUJ!IQLK!#??!GUWLKTaLITGKM!HGSVMJO!GK!

SQLKWTKW! GVISGFJM! HGU! SQTXOUJK! E! PTIQ! L! WULKI! IG!

Je[LKO!IQJ!IJLSQTKW!GH!HTKLKSTLX!XTIJULSR!IG!FTOOXJ!LKO!

QTWQ!MSQGGX!MIVOJKIM!LSUGMM!IQJ!SGVKIURD!

)K!LOOTITGKZ!IG!JKWLWJ!MIVOJKIM!TK!L!HVK!LKO!TKIJULSIT^J!

PLRZ! IQJ!8GVKOLITGK!LXMG![UG TOJO!L! WULKI!IG! MV[[GUI!

:VOWJI]LXXZ!LK!GVIOGGU!WLFJ!SUJLIJO!]R!IQJ!&LITGKLX!

/SLOJFR!GH!+V]XTS!/OFTKTMIULITGK!LKO!+LUMGKM!5QJ!&JP!

2SQGGX! HGU!3JMTWKZ!PQTSQ!SGF]TKJM![QRMTSLX!MNTXX!PTIQ!

HTMSLX!MIULIJWRD!5QJ!WLFJ!QLM!]JJK![XLRJO!GK!IQJ!KLITGKLX!

FLXX!TK!6LMQTKWIGKZ!3D$DZ!LKO!GK!SLF[VMJM!KLITGKPTOJD

5JLSQTKW!MIVOJKIM!L]GVI!HTMSLX![GXTSR!SLK!QJX[!IG!JMIL]XTMQL!HGVKOLITGK!HGU!HTKLKSTLX!XTIJULSR!LKO!LSIT^J!STITaJKMQT[D

5QJ!+JIJUMGK!8GVKOLITGK!TM!PGUNTKW!PTIQ!$GXVF]TL!5JLSQJUM!

$GXXJWJ!LKO!GIQJUM!IG!OJ^JXG[!JKWLWTKWZ!TKHGUFLIT^J!PLRM!

IG!TKSUJLMJ!VKOJUMILKOTKW!GH!HTMSLX!TMMVJM!LFGKW!RGVKW!

/FJUTSLKMD

g8/$)&*!+/*(h!7)*7!2$7%%,!25;3(&52!25;3-!57(!&/5)%&A2!8)2$/,!$7/,,(&*(2!571%;*7!/!$;11)$;,;.!

3('(,%+(3!:-!$%,;.:)/!5(/$7(12!$%,,(*(!6)57!/!*1/&5!81%.!57(!8%;&3/5)%&D!



" @F(3;$/5)&*!/&3!/$5)'/5)&*!57(!/.(1)$/&!+;:,)$



@?

(&*/*)&*!57(!&(45!*(&(1/5)%&

6QTXJ!HTMSLX![GXTSR!TM!KGI!JeLSIXR!IG[YGHYFTKO!HGU!FGMI!

IJJKM! LKO! SGXXJWJ! MIVOJKIMZ! IQJ! MILNJM! LUJ! IUJFJKY

OGVMD! %VU! MNRUGSNJITKW! OJ]IZ! OJHTSTIMZ! LKO! TKIJUJMI!

SGMIM! SGVXO! XJLO! IG! MQLU[! UJOVSITGKM! TK![V]XTS! LKO!

[UT^LIJ!TK^JMIFJKI!LKO!TKSUJLMJM!TK!ILeJM!IQLI!UJOVSJ!

IQJTU! MILKOLUO! GH! XT TKW! LKO! XTFTI! IQJ! G[[GUIVKTITJM!

L^LTXL]XJ!IG!IQJF!LM!LOVXIMD!

)K! "??9Z! IG! JOVSLIJ! RGVKW! /FJUTSLKM! L]GVI! IQJMJ!

[UJMMTKW!TMMVJM!LKO!IG!JF[GPJU!IQJF!IG!ILNJ!LSITGKZ!

IQJ! +JIJUMGK! 8GVKOLITGK! IJLFJO! V[! PTIQ! .5'AM!

SGXXJWJ!SLF[VM!KJIPGUNZ!FI^;Z!IG! XLVKSQ! )KOJ]IJOD!

2QGUI!HGU!cTKYOJ]I!JOVSLITGKZd!IQJ!)KOJ]IJO!SLF[LTWK!

SGFFVKTSLIJO!IQJ!UJLX!]VUOJK!GH!IQJ!OJ]I!IQLI!RGVKW!

/FJUTSLKM!PTXX!TKQJUTIZ!PTIQ!IQJ!WGLX!GH!QJX[TKW!SGXXJWJ!

MIVOJKIM! VKOJUMILKO! LKO! VXITFLIJXR! ILNJ! SQLUWJ! GH!IQJ!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJM!IQJR!PTXX! HLSJ!LHIJU! WULOVLITGKD!

)KOJ]IJO!OUG^J!QGFJ!IQJ!FJMMLWJ!IQLI!IQJ!FGKJR!GVU!

SGVKIUR!TM!]GUUGPTKW!IGOLR!PTXX!J^JKIVLXXR!]J![LTO!]LSN!

]R!IGOLRAM!RGVKW![JG[XJ!LKO!HVIVUJ!WJKJULITGKMD!5QJ!

SLF[LTWK!LXMG!JKSGVULWJO!MIVOJKIM!IG!ILNJ!SGKIUGX!GH!

IQJTU![JUMGKLX!HTKLKSJM!]R![XLKKTKW!HGU!IQJ!HVIVUJ!LKO!

ML^TKW!UJM[GKMT]XRD!

5QUGVWQ! IQJ! .5'! SLF[VM! KJIPGUNZ! IQJ! [UGWULF!

UJLSQJO! V[PLUOM! GH! 9! FTXXTGK! SGXXJWJ! MIVOJKIM! GK!

QVKOUJOM! GH! SGXXJWJ! SLF[VMJM! LSUGMM! IQJ! KLITGKD!

5QJ!SLF[LTWKAM!PJ]MTIJ! HJLIVUJO! TKHGUFLITGK! L]GVI!

UJM[GKMT]XJ!SUJOTI!SLUO!VMJ! LKO! TKSXVOJO!L![G[VXLU!

^TOJG! WLFJ! SLXXJO! 3J]I! 2NTZ! PQTSQ! TXXVMIULIJM! IQJ!

TF[GUILKSJ!GH!FLeTFTaTKW!ML^TKWMZ![LRTKW!HGU!KJSJMY

MTITJMZ! LKO! [UJ[LUTKW! HGU! VKJe[JSIJO! XTHJ! J^JKIMD!5QJ!XLIIJU!PLM!TKM[TUJO!]R!L!MIVOJKI![LUITST[LITKW!TK!

)KOJ]IJOAM!3TWTILX!$QLXXJKWJZ! PQTSQ! SLXXJO! GK!RGVKW!

[JG[XJ!HUGF!LSUGMM!IQJ!KLITGK!IG!OJ^JXG[!TKIJULSIT^J!

TOJLM!IG![UGFGIJ!IQJ!FJMMLWJ!GH!IQJ!SLF[LTWKD

5QJ!8GVKOLITGK!LXMG!PGUNJO!PTIQ!.G]TXTaJDGUW!IG!]UTKW!

IGWJIQJU! FJF]JUM! GH! IQJ! FTXXJKKTLX! WJKJULITGK! IG!

Je[XGUJ! IQJTU! UGXJ! TK!LOOUJMMTKW! IQJ! HTKLKSTLX! TMMVJM!

HLSTKW!IQJ!KLITGKD!6TIQ!8GVKOLITGK!HVKOTKWZ!.G]TXTaJDGUWSGK^JKJO! IQJ! &LITGKLX! -GVIQ! 2VFFTIZ! JKITIXJO!

c3JFGSULSR!"D?b!(e[XGUTKW!IQJ!.TXXJKKTLX!*JKJULITGKAM!

1JIVUK!GK!)K^JMIFJKIZd!PQTSQ!HGSVMJO!GK!MGXVITGKM!IQLI!

WG^JUKFJKI!LKO!IQJ![UT^LIJ!MJSIGU!SGVXO!TF[XJFJKI!TK!

HGVU!NJR!LUJLM!E!QJLXIQ!SLUJZ!ILeJMZ!JKITIXJFJKIMZ!LKO!

[JUMGKLX! HTKLKSTLX! UJM[GKMT]TXTIR! LKO! XTIJULSR! E! PTIQ!

LIIJKOJJM![UJMJKITKW!SGKSUJIJ![UG[GMLXM!IG!TF[UG^J!

IQJ!JSGKGFTS!QJLXIQ!GH!/FJUTSLAM!RGVKWJU!WJKJULITGKMD

)K! "?<?Z! IQJ! +JIJUMGK! 8GVKOLITGK! TKTITLIJO! IQJ! +JIJU!

*D!+JIJUMGK! 8GVKOLITGK! 8TMSLX! )KIJUKMQT[![UGWULF! IG!

JKL]XJ!VKOJUWULOVLIJ!LKO!WULOVLIJ!MIVOJKIM!IG!M[JKO!

MVFFJUM!TK!6LMQTKWIGKZ!3D$DZ!PGUNTKW!PTIQ! IG[!HTMSLX!

[GXTSR!Je[JUIM!LKO!MSQGXLUM!LI!XJLOTKW![GXTSR!UJMJLUSQ!

GUWLKTaLITGKMD! 5QTM! [UGWULFZ! PQTSQ! TM! LOFTKTMIJUJO!

IQUGVWQ! IQJ! $GKSGUO! $GLXTITGKZ! ]UTKWM! IQJ! MIVOJKIM!IGWJIQJU!TK!L!PJJNXR!MJFTKLU!LKO!WT^JM!IQJF!L!SXGMJYV[!

^TJP!GH!IQJ!TMMVJM!LKO!IQJ![GXTSR!OJ^JXG[FJKI![UGSJMMD!

5QJ!+JIJUMGK!8GVKOLITGK!PTXX! SGKITKVJ! IG!PGUN!PTIQ!

RGVIQYGUTJKIJO! GUWLKTaLITGKM! IG! JOVSLIJ! RGVKW!

/FJUTSLKM!L]GVI! IQJ! PLRM! TK! PQTSQ! XGKWYIJUF! OJ]I!

LKO!OJHTSTIM!TF[LSI!IQJTU!HVIVUJZ!PTIQ!IQJ!WGLX!GH!FGITY

^LITKW!IQJF!IG!MILR!TKHGUFJO!LKO!LSIT^JXR!PGUN!IGPLUO!MGXVITGKM!IG!IQJ!KLITGKAM!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJMD

5QJ!JSGKGFTS!LKO! HTMSLX!SQGTSJM!PJ!FLNJ! IGOLR!PTXX! QL^J![UGHGVKO!SGKMJ\VJKSJM!HGU!IQJ!KJeI!WJKJULITGKD!5QJ!+JIJUMGK!

8GVKOLITGK!QLM!PGUNJO!PTIQ!FI^;Z!.G]TXTaJDGUWZ!LKO!GIQJUM!

IG! UJLSQ! GVI! IG! /FJUTSLAM! KJeI! WJKJULITGK! GH! XJLOJUMZ!

OJFGKMIULITKW!PQR!HTMSLX![GXTSR!TM!MG!SUTITSLX!IG!IQJTU!HVIVUJD!



" @@(3;$/5)&*!/&3!/$5)'/5)&*!57(!/.(1)$/&!+;:,)$

25;3(&52!+/15)$)+/5)&*!)&!57(!)&3(:5(3!$/.+/)*&Z!/!$%,,/:%1/5)%&!:(56((&!57(!+(5(12%&!8%;&3/Y

5)%&!/&3!.5';!57/5!(3;$/5(3!/&3!(.+%6(1(3!$%,,(*(!25;3(&52!5%!5/0(!/!25/&3!%&!8)2$/,!)22;(2D



/:%;5!57(!8%;&3/5)%&b5%!,(/1&!.%1(!/:%;5!

57(!+(5(1!*D!+(5(12%&!

8%;&3/5)%&Z!/.(1)$/A2!8)2$/,!$7/,,(&*(2Z!

/&3!7%6!-%;!$/&!5/0(!

/$5)%&!5%!7(,+!2%,'(!57(.Z!+,(/2(!')2)5!%;1!

6(:2)5(Z!n%)&!;2!%&!8/$(:%%0Z!%1!$7($0!%;5!

%;1!-%;5;:(!+/*(

666D+*+8D%1*666D8/$(:%%0D$%.l+*+8%;&3/5)%&

666D-%;5;:(D$%.l+*+8%;&3/5)%&



" @B

57(!/,5/1;.!)&25)5;5(

5G!MV[[GUI!IQJ!nVKJ!"??9!SGKHJUJKSJ!HGU!MSQGXLUMZ!QJLXIQ![GXTSR!

Je[JUIMZ!LKO!FJOTL!IG!JeLFTKJ!LKO!TKSUJLMJ!LPLUJKJMM!GH !

NJR!QJLXIQ!SQLXXJKWJM!IQLI!LUJ!XTKNJO!IG!/FJUTSLAM!HTMSLX!SUTMTMD!

gjBCZ???h

/.(1)$/2+(/02

5G!MV[[GUI![UG^TOTKW!STITaJKM!PTIQ!L!WUJLIJU!G[[GUIVKTIR!HGU!

ST^TS!JKWLWJFJKI!LUGVKO!SUTITSLX!TMMVJM!LKO!OJXT]JULITGK!G^JU!

SGF[XJe!HTMSLX![GXTSR!TMMVJMD!gjC?Z???h

/.(1)$/A2!+1%.)2(!Y!57(!/,,)/&$(!8%1!-%;57

5G!MV[[GUI!IQJ!OJ^JXG[FJKI!GH !L!RGVIQ!SVUUTSVXVF!IG!Je[LKO!

IQJ!IJLSQTKW!GH !HTKLKSTLX!XTIJULSR!IG!FTOOXJ!LKO!QTWQ!MSQGGX!

MIVOJKIM!LSUGMM!IQJ!SGVKIURD!gj<Z???Z???h

:(!57(!$7/&*(Z!)&$D

5G!MV[[GUI!IQJ!2JU^TSJ&LITGK!+UJMTOJKITLX!$LKOTOLIJM!8GUVF!

LKO!2VFFTI!LKO!L!KLITGKLX!3LR!GH !/SITGK!IG!TKSUJLMJ!KLITGKLX!

MJU^TSJ!G[[GUIVKTITJM!LKO!MIUJKWIQJK!ST^TS!SVXIVUJD!gj"C?Z???h

57(!:1%%0)&*2!)&25)5;5)%&

5G!MV[[GUI!IQJ!:VOWJI!HGU!&LITGKLX!+UTGUTITJM!+UG_JSIZ!LK!

LSSJMMT]XJ!LKLXRMTM!GH !IQJ!SGVKIURAM!HTMSLX!MTIVLITGK!IQLI!

OGSVFJKIM!IQJ![UG]XJF!LKO!HJLIVUJM![GMMT]XJ!MGXVITGKMD!

gjC?Z???h

$(&5(1!8%1!57(!25;3-!%8!57(!+1(2)3(&$-

5G!MV[[GUI!L!SGF[UJQJKMT^J!KJI!LMMJMMFJKI!IG!QJX[!WVTOJ!IQJ!

KJP!+UJMTOJKI!TK!OJ^JXG[TKW!L!MIULIJWTS!UGLOFL[!HGU!LOOUJMMTKW!

LKO!SGKHUGKITKW!IQJ!KLITGKAM!FGMI!VUWJKI!SQLXXJKWJMD!

gj`??Z???h

$%..)55((!8%1!($%&%.)$!3('(,%+.(&5

5G!MV[[GUI!IQJ!JKXTMIFJKI!GH !MJKTGU!SGU[GULIJ!JeJSVIT^JM!LKO!

KJeI!WJKJULITGK!]VMTKJMM!XJLOJUM!TK!HTMSLX!UJHGUF!JHHGUIMZ!GKXTKJ!GVIUJLSQZ!LKO!J^JKIM!HGSVMJO!GK!XGKWYIJUF!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJMD!

gj<Z???Z???h

57(!$%..%&!*%%3!)&25)5;5(

5G!MV[[GUI!IQJ!OJ^JXG[FJKI!LKO!G[JULITGK!GH !LK!GKXTKJ!

[GXTSR!HGUVFZ!c&JP5LXNZd!IQLI!PTXX!JKL]XJ!Je[JUIM!IG!JKWLWJ!TK!

SGK^JUMLITGK!L]GVI!IQJ!FGMI![UJMMTKW!OGFJMITS!TMMVJM!HLSTKW!

/FJUTSLAM!HVIVUJZ!TKSXVOTKW!GVU!JSGKGFTS!LKO!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJMD!

gj#CZ???h

$%&$%13!$%/,)5)%&

5G!MV[[GUI!IQJ!8TMSLX!6LNJY;[!5GVUZ!L!MJUTJM!GH !IGPK!QLXX!

FJJITKWM!SGKOVSIJO!LSUGMM!IQJ!SGVKIUR!OJMTWKJO!IG!JKWLWJ!

LKO!JOVSLIJ!IQJ![V]XTS!GK!IQJ!KLITGKAM!XGKWYIJUF!HTMSLX!GVIXGGND!

gj<ZC??Z???h

(.%1-!;&)'(12)5-

5G!MV[[GUI!IQJ!SUJLITGK!GH !IQJ!$JKIJU!HGU!(KITIXJFJKI!1JHGUFZ!L!

UJMJLUSQ!SJKIJU!IQLI!LKLXRaJM!HLSIGUM!UJM[GKMT]XJ!HGU!TKSUJLMJO!

HJOJULX!JKITIXJFJKI!M[JKOTKW!LKO!HGUFVXLIJM!KJP!L[[UGLSQJM!

HGU!LSQTJ^TKW!]JIIJU!QJLXIQ!SLUJ!^LXVJD!gj=??Z???h

&/5)%&/,!/$/3(.-!%8!+;:,)$!/3.)&)251/5)%&

5G!MV[[GUI!IQJ!OJ^JXG[FJKI!GH !:VOWJI]LXXZ!L!cHTMSLX!M[GUId!HGU!

VMJ!TK![UGFGITKW!HTKLKSTLX!LKO!HTMSLX!XTIJULSR!LFGKW!SGXXJWJ!

MIVOJKIMD!gjB"CZ???h

5G!MV[[GUI!IQJ!TF[XJFJKILITGK!GH !:VOWJI]LXX!GK!SGXXJWJ!LKO!

VKT^JUMTIR!SLF[VMJM!LSUGMM!IQJ!;KTIJO!2ILIJM!LKO!L!"??9!

c:VOWJI]LXX!GK!IQJ!.LXXd!J^JKI!TK!6LMQTKWIGKZ!3D$D!gj#C>Z=`<h

&/5)%&/,!/$/3(.-!%8!2$)(&$(2

5G!MV[[GUI!IQJ!)KMITIVIJ!GH !.JOTSTKJAM!JHHGUIM!IG!OULP!LIIJKITGK!

IG!G[[GUIVKTITJM!IG!TF[UG^J!^LXVJ!LKO!UJOVSJ!IQJ!SGMIM!GH !

QJLXIQ!SLUJ!TK!IQJ!;KTIJO!2ILIJM!IQUGVWQ![V]XTS!FJJITKWM!LI!

IQJ!&LITGKLX!/SLOJFTJM!LKO!L![V]XTSLITGK!MVFFLUTaTKW!IQJTU!OTMSVMMTGK!LKO!HTKOTKWMD!gj9#CZ???h

&/5)%&/,!/$/3(.-!%8!2%$)/,!)&2;1/&$(

5G!MV[[GUI!L!KLITGKLX!SGKHJUJKSJ!IG![UGFGIJ!LKO!HLSTXTILIJ!

TF[UG^TKW!MGSTLX!TKMVULKSJ![UGWULFM!LKO!IQJ!QJLXIQ!SLUJ!

HTKLKSTKW!MRMIJF!LKO!JKSGVULWJ!HTMSLX!UJM[GKMT]TXTIR!LKO!

JSGKGFTS!WUGPIQD!gjBCZ???h

&(56%10!8%1!5(/$7)&*!(&51(+1(&(;127)+

5G!MV[[GUI!IQJ!OJ^JXG[FJKI!GH !SVUUTSVXL!HGU!JXJFJKILUR!LKO!MJSGKOLUR!MSQGGX!MIVOJKIM!TK!XGPYTKSGFJ!LUJLM!IG!TKSUJLMJ!

HTKLKSTLX!XTIJULSRD!gj"9CZ???h

&(6!/.(1)$/!8%;&3/5)%&

5G!MV[[GUI!IQJ!+JIJUMGKY+JP!$GFFTMMTGK!GK!:VOWJI!1JHGUF!

LI!IQJ!$GFFTIIJJ!HGU!L!1JM[GKMT]XJ!8JOJULX!:VOWJI!IG!J^LXVLIJ!

LKO!FLNJ!UJSGFFJKOLITGKM!IG!TF[UG^J!IQJ!HJOJULX!]VOWJI!

[UGSJMMD!gj<Z"C?Z???h

,)25!%8!*1/&5((2!

'.23-4"I$-&"?GGE"



36

NUCLEAR THREAT INITIATIVETo support the establishment of the World Institute for Nuclear

Security, a new international organization to help nuclear

security practitioners implement more effective and efficient

programs to secure nuclear materials. ($3,000,000)

PETERSON INSTITUTE FOR INTERNATIONAL ECONOMICS

To support a study and roundtable on the magnitude and

impact of growing global public debts and identify possible

implications for the world economy and the United States.

($100,000)

To support efforts to broaden public understanding of

globalization and the risks of short-sighted economic and fiscal

policies. ($50,000)

PROPUBLICA, INC.

To support the ProPublica Prizes for Investigative Governance,

honoring outstanding work in investigative reporting by

governmental bodies in the United States. ($49,000)

PUBLIC AGENDA FOUNDATION, INC.To support the expansion of “Students Face Up to the Nation’s

Finances,” an initiative designed to engage college students

across the nation on America’s fiscal challenges. ($500,000)

THE STATE OF THE USA, INC.

To support the development of measures for assessing key

fiscal conditions and trends in the United States that will allow

Americans to assess the nation’s progress on pressing issues.

($400,000)

TRANSATLANTIC FUTURES, INC.

To support the development of multimedia content designed

to provide innovative ways to address economic and social

challenges threatening America’s future. ($40,000)

AMERICASPEAKSTo support a national discussion on the fiscal future of the

United States in 20 cities across the nation and provide citizens

with an opportunity to consider options to address long-term

budget challenges. ($2,337,470)

AMERICAN SOCIETY FOR PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION

To support the 2009 ASPA Annual Conference to provide

participants an opportunity to learn about public

administration and recent developments in federal, state and

local fiscal affairs. ($15,000)

To support the 2010 ASPA Annual Conference to provide

participants an opportunity to learn about public

administration and recent developments in federal, state and

local fiscal affairs. ($30,000)

COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY

To support a one-year fellowship at the Columbia Journalism

Review to comment on the content and quality of media

coverage of fiscal issues. ($49,000)

COMMITTEE FOR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT

To support the enlistment of senior corporate executives and

next generation business leaders in fiscal reform efforts, online

outreach, and events focused on long-term fiscal challenges.

($603,616)

CONCORD COALITION

To support efforts to educate the public about the causes

and consequences of federal budget deficits, the long-term

challenges facing America’s unsustainable entitlementprograms, and how to build a sound foundation for economic

growth. ($1,337,428)

To support the Youth Action Conference to engage Millennials in

a discussion of fiscal issues. ($46,560)

HOPE STREET GROUP

To support the Bipartisan Working Group on Health Care

Reform to address health care policies and disseminate

findings in an effort to engage thought leaders in the areas ofhealth care policy and cost containment. ($10,000)

INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE IMPROVEMENT

To support the symposium, “How Do They Do That? Low-

Cost, High-Quality Health Care in America,” to learn from the

experiences of high-value health care systems. ($40,000)

Fiscal Year 2010



" @D

.%:),)@)&*!/.(1)$/A2!-%;57Z!)&$D5G!MV[[GUI!.G]TXTaJDGUWAM!3JFGSULSR!"D?!$LF[LTWK!LKO!

IQJ!"??9!c.TXXJKKTLX!1JIVUK!GK!)K^JMIFJKI!2VFFTIZd!PQTSQ!

Je[XGUJO!IQJ!KVFJUGVM!HTKLKSTLX!TMMVJM!HLSTKW!/FJUTSL!LKO!IQJ!

.TXXJKKTLX!*JKJULITGKAM!UGXJ!TK!LOOUJMMTKW!IQJFD!gj"#?Z???h

&/5)%&/,!/$/3(.-!%8!+;:,)$!/3.)&)251/5)%&

5G!MV[[GUI!IQJ!"?<?!c:VOWJI]LXX!GK!IQJ!.LXXd!J^JKI!TK!

6LMQTKWIGKZ!3D$D!IG![UGFGIJ!HTKLKSTLX!LKO!HTMSLX!XTIJULSR!LFGKW!

SGXXJWJ!MIVOJKIMD!gj""=Z="<h

+/15&(127)+!8%1!+;:,)$!2(1')$(

5G!MV[[GUI!L!SGKHJUJKSJ!Je[XGUTKW!IQJ!KJJO!HGU!_GTKI!JHHGUIM!]R!

WG^JUKFJKI!LKO!HGVKOLITGK!XJLOJUM!IG!TF[UG^J!IQJ!G[JULITGKLX!

SL[LSTIR!LKO!JHHJSIT^JKJMM!GH !WG^JUKFJKID!gjBCZ???h

+(5(12%&!)&25)5;5(!8%1!)&5(1&/5)%&/,!($%&%.)$2

5G!MV[[GUI!UJMJLUSQ!GK!IQJ!TKIJUKLITGKLX!OTFJKMTGKM!GH !IQJ!

HTMSLX!TF]LXLKSJM!GH !IQJ!;KTIJO!2ILIJMZ!TKSXVOTKW!LK!L[[ULTMLX!

GH !NJR!SUJOTIGU!SGVKIUTJMA!TKIJUKLITGKLX!JSGKGFTS![GMTITGKM!LKO!

[GXTSTJMD!gjB9?Z???h

5(/$7(12!$%,,(*(Z!$%,;.:)/!;&)'(12)5-

5G!MV[[GUI!IQJ!OJ^JXG[FJKI!GH !L!KJPZ!SGF[UJQJKMT J!MGSTLX!

MIVOTJM!LKO!FLIQJFLITSM!SVUUTSVXVF!IG!QJX[!QTWQ!MSQGGX!

MIVOJKIM!LSUGMM!IQJ!;KTIJO!2ILIJM!VKOJUMILKO!IQJ!HLSIMZ!

MTWKTHTSLKSJZ!LKO!SGKMJ\VJKSJM!GH !/FJUTSLAM!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJMD!

gj"Z##`ZC9=h

6&(5

5G!MV[[GUI!c%VU!;KMVMILTKL]XJ!8VIVUJZd!L!M[JSTLX!RJLUYXGKW!

FJOTL!TKTITLIT^J!IG!LOOUJMM!IQJ!SUTITSLX!HTMSLX!TMMVJM!IQLI!PTXX!OJIJUFTKJ!IQJ!GVISGFJ!GH !/FJUTSLAM!HVIVUJD!gj<Z???Z???h

/.(1)$/&!(&5(1+1)2(!)&25)5;5(5G!MV[[GUI!IQJ!OJ^JXG[FJKI!GH !SGF[UJQJKMT^J!LKO!M[JSTHTS!

MGXVITGKM!IG!LOOUJMM!IQJ!KLITGKAM!XGKWYIJUF!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJMZ!

LM![LUI!GH !IQJ!+JIJU!*D!+JIJUMGK!8GVKOLITGK!2GXVITGKM!)KTITLIT^JD!

gj"??Z???h

/.(1)$/&!2%$)(5-!8%1!+;:,)$!/3.)&)251/5)%&

5G!MV[[GUI!IQJ!"?<<!/2+/!/KKVLX!$GKHJUJKSJ!IG![UG^TOJ!

[LUITST[LKIM!LK!G[[GUIVKTIR!IG!XJLUK!L]GVI![V]XTS!

LOFTKTMIULITGK!LKO!UJSJKI!OJ^JXG[FJKIM!TK!HJOJULXZ!MILIJ!LKO!

XGSLX!HTMSLX!LHHLTUMD!gjB?Z???h

:)+/15)2/&!+%,)$-!$(&5(1

5G!MV[[GUI!IQJ!JMIL]XTMQFJKI!GH !IQJ!3J]I!1JOVSITGK!5LMN!8GUSJ!

IG!OJ^JXG[!L!XGKWYIJUF!]VOWJI![XLK!IG!UJOVSJ![UG_JSIJO!HJOJULX!

OJ]I!LKO![XLSJ!IQJ!;KTIJO!2ILIJM!GK!L!MVMILTKL]XJ!HTMSLX![LIQZ!

PQTSQ!PLM!TKSGU[GULIJO!TKIG!IQJ!+JIJU!*D!+JIJUMGK!8GVKOLITGK!

2GXVITGKM!)KTITLIT^JD!gj"??Z???h

5G!MV[[GUI![GMIYXLVKSQ!LSIT^TITJM!GH !IQJ!3J]I!1JOVSITGK!5LMN!

8GUSJAM!OJ^JXG[FJKI!LKO!OTMMJFTKLITGK!GH !TIM!XGKWYIJUF!]VOWJI!

[XLK!IG!UJOVSJ![UG_JSIJO!HJOJULX!OJ]ID!gj"??Z???h

$(&5(1!8%1!/.(1)$/&!+1%*1(22

5G!MV[[GUI!IQJ!OJ^JXG[FJKI!GH !SGF[UJQJKMT^J!LKO!M[JSTHTS!

MGXVITGKM!IG!LOOUJMM!IQJ!KLITGKAM!XGKWYIJUF!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJMZ!

LM![LUI!GH !IQJ!+JIJU!*D!+JIJUMGK!8GVKOLITGK!2GXVITGKM!)KTITLIT^JD!

gj"??Z???h

5G!MV[[GUI!MIVOTJM!GH !QJLXIQ!SLUJ!SGMI!SGKILTKFJKI!

MIULIJWTJMZ!TKSXVOTKW![LRFJKI!]VKOXTKW!LKO!LSSGVKIL]XJ!SLUJ!

GUWLKTaLITGKMD!gjBCCZ9<9h

$(&5(1!8%1!+1/$5)$/,!:)%(57)$2

5G!MV[[GUI!IQJ!OJ^JXG[FJKI!GH !L!]VMTKJMM![XLK!HGU!IQJ!$GLXTITGK!

IG!5ULKMHGUF!/O^LKSJO!$LUJ!g$Y5/$hZ!L!KJP!GUWLKTaLITGK!

HGSVMJO!GK!TF[UG^TKW!JKOYGHYXTHJ!SLUJD!gj""?Z???h

$%.(:/$0!/.(1)$/!)&)5)/5)'(

5G!MV[[GUI!L!KJP!TKTITLIT^J!G^JU!L!IQUJJYRJLU![JUTGO!IG!LOOUJMM!

HJOJULX!HTMSLX!TMMVJM!]R!JKWLWTKW!IQJ![V]XTS!LKO!LMMTMITKW!

[GXTSRFLNJUM!GK!L!KGK[LUITMLK!]LMTM!IG!QJX[!MGX^J!/FJUTSLAM!XGKWYIJUF!HTMSLX!SQLXXJKWJMD!gjBZ<??Z???h

$%&$%13!$%/,)5)%&!$%1+D

5G!MV[[GUI!JHHGUIM!IG!JOVSLIJ!IQJ![V]XTS!L]GVI!IQJ!SLVMJM!

LKO!SGKMJ\VJKSJM!GH !HJOJULX!]VOWJI!OJHTSTIMZ!IQJ!XGKWYIJUF!

SQLXXJKWJM!HLSTKW!/FJUTSLAM!VKMVMILTKL]XJ!JKITIXJFJKI!

[UGWULFMZ!LKO!QGP!IG!]VTXO!L!MGVKO!HGVKOLITGK!HGU!JSGKGFTS!

WUGPIQD!gj<Z#?>Z9??h

,)25!%8!*1/&5((2

'.23-4"I$-&"?GFF



38

CONCORD COALITION CORP.

To support the Fiscal Solutions Tour, a follow-up to the Fiscal

Wake-Up Tour that is designed to engage the public, the media,

and policymakers in dialogue about our nation’s future and

potential solutions to the current fiscal challenges that we face.

($75,000)

To support the creation of the Peter G. Peterson Foundation

Fiscal Internship Program, to establish and support an

internship program in 2010 for undergraduate and graduate

students. ($60,000)

To support the 2011 Peter G. Peterson Foundation Fiscal

Internship Program. ($47,000)

ECONOMIC POLICY INSTITUTE

To support the development of comprehensive and specific

solutions to address the nation’s long-term fiscal challenges,

as part of the Peter G. Peterson Foundation Solutions Initiative.

($200,000)

THE HERITAGE FOUNDATIONTo support the development of comprehensive and specific

solutions to address the nation’s long-term fiscal challenges,

as part of the Peter G. Peterson Foundation Solutions Initiative.

($200,000)

HOPE STREET GROUP

To support the Bipartisan Working Group on Health Care

Reform to address health care policies and disseminate

findings in an effort to engage thought leaders in the areas of

health care policy and cost containment. ($48,500)

INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE IMPROVEMENT

To support the “How Will We Do That?” symposium to examine

how to build low-cost, high-quality health care in communities

across the United States. ($269,371)

NABE FOUNDATION OF THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION

FOR BUSINESS ECONOMICS

To support the NABE Foundation’s work with NABE’s 2011

Economic Policy Conference, a national event addressing thenexus of economics, business, and policymaking. ($35,000)

NEW AMERICA FOUNDATION

To support the Peterson-Pew Commission on Budget Reform

at the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget to advance

responsible fiscal policy and budget process reform through

outreach and engagement toward policymakers, opinion

leaders, media, and the public. ($500,000)

To support the Moment of Truth Project at the Committee for a

Responsible Federal Budget to advance responsible fiscal policy

and budget process reform through outreach and engagement

efforts. ($300,000)

NUCLEAR THREAT INITIATIVE

To support the Connecting Organizations for Regional Disease

Surveillance (CORDS) initiative, which links regional disease

surveillance networks to improve global capacity to respond to

infectious diseases, and the Nuclear Materials Security Index, a

benchmarking project of nuclear materials security conditions

on a country-by-country basis. ($1,000,000)

PETERSON INSTITUTE FOR INTERNATIONAL ECONOMICS

To support research that examines global aggregate public debtprojections under likely scenarios through 2030, discusses

the implications of these issues for the United States, and

investigates the potential long-term impact across global

economies. ($225,000)

PROJECT HOPE

To support a Health Affairs conference and publication of case

studies on innovative projects addressing health care costs and

quality. ($50,000)

RICE UNIVERSITY

To support a conference examining the historical economic

effects of debt crises, the looming fiscal crisis in the United

States, and potential solutions. ($25,000)

THE FRANKLIN AND ELEANOR ROOSEVELT INSTITUTE

To support the Roosevelt Institute Campus Network’s

development of comprehensive and specific solutions to

address the nation’s long-term fiscal challenges, as part of the

Peter G. Peterson Foundation Solutions Initiative. ($200,000)

HENRY L. STIMSON CENTER

To support an analysis of alternative defense strategy and

mission choices as part of the Budgeting for Foreign Affairs and

Defense program. ($500,000)



" @E

8)&/&$)/,!%'(1')(6

)K! IQJ! 8GVKOLITGKAM! HTUMI! IQUJJ! RJLUM! GH! G[JULITGKMZ!

IGILX!Je[JKOTIVUJM!PJUJ!L[[UGeTFLIJXR!j=>D"!FTXXTGKZ!

TKSXVOTKW!jC#DC!FTXXTGK!TK![UGWULF!Je[JKOTIVUJM!LKO!

j<BD`!FTXXTGK!TK!MV[[GUITKW!MJU^TSJMD!/!]UJLNOGPK!GH !

[UGWULF!Je[JKOTIVUJM!TM!MQGPK!TK!IQJ!SQLUI!]JXGPD

5QJ! 8GVKOLITGKAM! IGILX! VKUJMIUTSIJO! LMMJIM! UJLSQJO!

j#`<D>! FTXXTGK!]R! IQJ! RJLU! JKOJO!.LUSQ!B<Z! "?<<!

OVJ! [UTFLUTXR! IG!SVFVXLIT J! HVKOTKW! GH! j#C>D?!FTXY

XTGK!HUGF!TIM! HGVKOJUD!5QJ!8GVKOLITGKAM!LKKVLX! HTKLKY

STLX!MILIJFJKIM!QL^J!]JJK!LVOTIJO!]R!.TISQJXX!k!5TIVMZ!

,,+Z!L!FJF]JU!HTUF!GH !(UKMI!k!-GVKW!*XG]LX!,TFTIJOD

jB"Z"<9Z???

*ULKIM!k!*ULKIFLNTKW

j>Z99>Z???

+V]XTS!/PLUJKJMM!k!(KWLWJFJKI

j<<Z"<9Z???

(OVSLITGK!k!%VIUJLSQ

j"Z?"=Z???

+GXTSR!1JMJLUSQ!k!/KLXRMTM

*(%-4"9&(5&-)"<JK$/6.%1&$2"L?GGHM?GFFN

jC#Z#="Z???



AG

8(-&6"(O"P.&$3%(&2

+(5(1!*D!+(5(12%&

$QLTUFLK!LKO!$QTJH !(eJSVIT J!%HHTSJU

.)$7/(,!/D!+(5(12%&

+UJMTOJKI!LKO!$QTJH !%[JULITKW!%HHTSJU

n%/&!*/&@!$%%&(-

3TUJSIGU

;$/.(&"#$-6$&2+.K

,%1(55/!;$(,,)

'TSJ!+UJMTOJKIZ!$GFFVKTSLITGKM!LKO!+V]XTS!/HHLTUM

2;2/&!5/&/0/

'TSJ!+UJMTOJKIZ!1JMJLUSQ

3%;*,/2!7/.),5%&

3TUJSIGUZ!1JMJLUSQ

+/;,!&(6./&

$QTJH !8TKLKSTLX!%HHTSJU

'(1/6-%.(/"!6=.2(&:"8(-&6"7$)>$&2

2($D!1%:(15!1;:)&Z!g$GY$QLTUFLKho!$GY$QLTUFLKZ!$GVKSTX!

GK!8GUJTWK!1JXLITGKMo!8GUFJU!;KTIJO!2ILIJM!2JSUJILUR!GH !IQJ!

5UJLMVUR!

2($D!*(%1*(!27;,5@Z!g$GY$QLTUFLKho!5QGFLM!6D!k!2VMLK!

:D!8GUO!3TMITKWVTMQJO!8JXXGPZ!7GG^JU!)KMITIVIJ!E!2ILKHGUO!

;KT^JUMTIRo!8GUFJU!;KTIJO!2ILIJM!2JSUJILUR!GH!2ILIJ!

3)/&/!/')'Z!+UJMTOJKI!LKO!$(%Z!)KOJ[JKOJKI!2JSIGU!

$1/)*!:/11(55Z!8GUFJU!$QLTUFLKZ!)KIJX!$GU[GULITGK!

1)$7/13!:(/55)(Z!$QLTUFLKZ!2TF[MGK!5QLSQJU!k!:LUIXJII!,,+!

2(&D!6),,)/.!:1/3,(-Z!.LKLWTKW!3TUJSIGUZ!/XXJK!

k!$GF[LKR!,,$o!8GUFJU!;KTIJO!2ILIJM!2JKLIGU!

2-,')/!./57(62!:;16(,,Z!+UJMTOJKIZ!

5QJ!6LXFLUI!8GVKOLITGK

*%'D!./1)%!$;%.%Z!%H!$GVKMJXZ!6TXXNTJ!8LUU!k!

*LXXLWQJU!,,+o!8GUFJU!*G^JUKGU!GH!&JP!-GUN!

:/11-!3),,(1Z!$QLTUFLK!LKO!$(%Z!)/$l)KIJU/SIT^J$GU[!

1%*(1!8(1*;2%&Z!n1DZ!+UJMTOJKI!LKO!$(%Z!5)//Y$UJH!

7/1'(-!8)&(:(1*Z!+UJMTOJKIZ!)KMITIVIJ!GH!.JOTSTKJ!

,(2,)(!*(,:Z!+UJMTOJKI!(FJUTIVMZ!$GVKSTX!GK!!

8GUJTWK!1JXLITGKM!

57%./2!./$0(,,Z!$QLTUFLKZ!;KTIJO!:JKJHTIM!! !LKO!+JKMTGK!2JU^TSJMZ!)KSD!

6),,)/.!&%'(,,)Z!+UGHJMMGUZ!*JGUWJIGPK!

;KT^JUMTIRo!8GUFJU!$(%!GH!//1+!

1)$7/13!+,(+,(1Z!$GY+UJMTOJKIZ!7GFJ!:Ge!%HHTSJ!

1)$7/13!2/,%.%&Z!.LKLWTKW!+LUIKJUZ!(LMI!(KO!/O^TMGUM!

27(1-,!2/&3:(1*Z!$%%Z!8LSJ]GGN!

2($D!3%&&/!27/,/,/Z!+UJMTOJKIZ!;KT^JUMTIR!

GH!.TLFTo!8GUFJU!;KTIJO!2ILIJM!2JSUJILUR!

GH!7JLXIQ!LKO!7VFLK!2JU^TSJM!

3/')3!:(/;.%&5!2.)57Z!(eJSVIT^J!3TUJSIGUZ!

&LITGKLX!$GKHJUJKSJ!GK!$TITaJKMQT[!

,(2,(-!25/7,Z!$GUUJM[GKOJKIZ!^A(E528+14(

+/;,!'%,$0(1Z!$QLTUFLKZ!(SGKGFTS!1JSG^JUR!/O^TMGUR!

:GLUOo!8GUFJU!$QLTUFLK!GH!IQJ!8JOJULX!1JMJU^J!

3/')3!.D!6/,0(1Z!+UJMTOJKI!LKO!$(%Z!

$GFJ]LSN!/FJUTSL!)KTITLIT^J

'(1/6-%.(/"Q/=$2%)$/%",()).%%$$

3D!1%&/,3!3/&)(,Z!g$QLTUFLKhZ!2JKTGU!+LUIKJU!(FJUTIVMZ!

.S0TKMJR!k!$GF[LKR

25(+7(&!1%:(15Z!$QLTUFLK!LKO!$GY$(%Z!2GVUSJ!GH !7G[J!

8GVKOLITGK

+(5(1!*D!+(5(12%&

.)$7/(,!/D!+(5(12%&

.)$7/(,!*D!./&/22(Z!$%%Z!+JIJUMGK!.LKLWJFJKIZ!,,$

8%;&3/5)%&!,(/3(127)+!/&3!/3')2%1-!:%/13



!"#$#%&'"(()*++,-.'/.0.1'&2'/.0.1345'6475890:45

;;;<='*:>-0-'"?.57.

@4A'BCDD

%.E'F41GH'%F'CIICJ

&)"%,'#%KL#)#*+

:5M7:1:.3NO>OP241>'

!*(#"'#%KL#)#*+

O1.33NO>OP241>

&*%*)"$'=Q!!*%,+'Q)'KL*+,#Q%+'

R4SS.503NO>OP241>'

/TQ,Q'=)*(#,+'U'"=V%QW$*(&*!*%,+

/9>.'XXY'#S9>.3'P14S'0-.'ZS0?L'#58.[0.8'=9SO9:>5\'73.8'

E:0-'O.1S:33:45'4P 'S0?L2']'^IIJ'!,_'%.0E41G32'"``'):>-03'

).3.1?.82'S0?L'958'9``'1.`90.8'0:0`.3H'R-919R0.13'958'`4>43'

91.'0198.S91G3'4E5.8'[a'!,_'%.0E41G3H'9'8:?:3:45'4P '

_:9R4S'#50.1590:459`'#5R2



!"#$%"#&$'()"#%*+'"(,$-.&*/&$0'/'+1$

2223454!3675

pgpf progress report

Documents