philip w. madson president cincinnati, ohio u s a
TRANSCRIPT
Philip W. MadsonPresident
Cincinnati, Ohio U S A
THE FUTURE OFTHE FUTURE OFFUEL ETHANOLFUEL ETHANOLTHE FUTURE OFTHE FUTURE OFFUEL ETHANOLFUEL ETHANOL
Small Grains and Cattle Small Grains and Cattle Leading the Way!Leading the Way!
Small Grains and Cattle Small Grains and Cattle Leading the Way!Leading the Way!
MORE THAN 6,000MORE THAN 6,000ETHANOL PLANTSETHANOL PLANTS
WORLDWIDEWORLDWIDESOURCE: DR. JOHN MURTAGHSOURCE: DR. JOHN MURTAGH
RANGE OF RANGE OF TECHNOLOGIES TECHNOLOGIES
EMPLOYEDEMPLOYED
Bioagra
DO SMALL GRAINSDO SMALL GRAINSWORKWORK
FOR ETHANOL?FOR ETHANOL?
Abengoa BioenergyAbengoa BioenergyNetherlandsNetherlands
OsageOsage
ENSUSENSUS
ENSUSENSUS
MAX. HOURLY WIND PRESSURE
BIOETANOL GALICIABIOETANOL GALICIA
CASTILLA y LEONCASTILLA y LEONCASTILLA y LEONCASTILLA y LEON
Agrana
TARKIMTARKIM
POUNDMAKERPOUNDMAKER
NORTH WEST TERMINALNORTH WEST TERMINALUNITY, SASKATCHEWANUNITY, SASKATCHEWAN
HUSKYHUSKYENERGYENERGYHUSKYHUSKY
ENERGYENERGY
Minnedosa, ManitobaMinnedosa, ManitobaMinnedosa, ManitobaMinnedosa, Manitoba
Lloydminster, SaskatchewanLloydminster, SaskatchewanLloydminster, SaskatchewanLloydminster, Saskatchewan
PERSPECTIVEPERSPECTIVE AGRICULTURAL INTEGRATIONAGRICULTURAL INTEGRATION FUTURE FEEDSTOCKSFUTURE FEEDSTOCKS TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENTTECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT HOW CAN MONTANA WIN?HOW CAN MONTANA WIN?
AGENDAAGENDAAGENDAAGENDA
TODAY IN USATODAY IN USA
““SQUARE BOXSQUARE BOX IN A CORNFIELD”IN A CORNFIELD”
TODAY IN USATODAY IN USA
““SQUARE BOXSQUARE BOX IN A CORNFIELD”IN A CORNFIELD”
Natural gas
THE “SQUARE BOX” THE “SQUARE BOX” RISKRISK
THE “SQUARE BOX” THE “SQUARE BOX” RISKRISK
- COMMODITY CYCLESCOMMODITY CYCLES- COMMODITY CYCLESCOMMODITY CYCLES
WORLD COMMODITY PRICESWORLD COMMODITY PRICESWORLD COMMODITY PRICESWORLD COMMODITY PRICES
??
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
1800
2000
91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99
YEAR
MIL
LIO
N G
AL
LO
NS
"Square Boxes"
Wet Mills and Others
U.S. FUEL ETHANOL PRODUCTIONU.S. FUEL ETHANOL PRODUCTION- Second Cycle - 1991-1999- Second Cycle - 1991-1999
CAN THE COMMODITYCAN THE COMMODITYRISK BE MITIGATEDRISK BE MITIGATED
????
CAN THE COMMODITYCAN THE COMMODITYRISK BE MITIGATEDRISK BE MITIGATED
????
MULTIPLE FEEDSTOCKSMULTIPLE FEEDSTOCKSMULTIPLE FEEDSTOCKSMULTIPLE FEEDSTOCKS
• WHEATWHEAT• BARLEYBARLEY• CORNCORN• MILOMILO• TRITICALETRITICALE
• WHEATWHEAT• BARLEYBARLEY• CORNCORN• MILOMILO• TRITICALETRITICALE
HUSKYHUSKYENERGYENERGYHUSKYHUSKY
ENERGYENERGY
Minnedosa, ManitobaMinnedosa, ManitobaMinnedosa, ManitobaMinnedosa, Manitoba
Lloydminster, SaskatchewanLloydminster, SaskatchewanLloydminster, SaskatchewanLloydminster, Saskatchewan
TARKIMTARKIM
CASTILLA y LEONCASTILLA y LEONCASTILLA y LEONCASTILLA y LEON
WHEAT, BARLEY, AND WHEAT, BARLEY, AND OTHER GRAINS YIELD OTHER GRAINS YIELD
PROPORTIONAL TO PROPORTIONAL TO STARCH CONTENTSTARCH CONTENT
EXAMPLEEXAMPLE20 MM GPY PLANT20 MM GPY PLANT
EXAMPLEEXAMPLE20 MM GPY PLANT20 MM GPY PLANT
FEEDSTOCKTon/Yr
WHEATWHEAT
BARLEYBARLEY
210,000 (+8%)
CORN CORN (base)(base)
DDGSTon/Yr
70,000 (+26%)
234,000 (+21%) 98,000 (+77%)
194,000 55,500
EXAMPLEEXAMPLE20 MM GPY PLANT20 MM GPY PLANT
EXAMPLEEXAMPLE20 MM GPY PLANT20 MM GPY PLANT
FEEDSTOCKTon/Yr
WHEATWHEAT
BARLEYBARLEY
210,000 (+8%)
CORN CORN (base)(base)
DDGSTon/Yr
70,000 (+26%)
234,000 (+21%) 98,000 (+77%)
194,000 55,500
Know your livestock!
INTEGRATED AGRICULTUREINTEGRATED AGRICULTUREFOOD, FEED, FUELFOOD, FEED, FUEL
InternalAnimal Feeds
Electricity and boiler
Renewable "Green" Grid
Electricity
Ethanol (Fuel Grade)
W D G(Wet Distillers
Grain)Anaerobic Digester
Waste
Beef Facility
BeefMilk
NitrogenBioFertilizers
as N-P-K
DDG Export(Dried Distillers Grain)
Dairy Facility
Ethanol Plant
WaterWaste
Waste and
solubles
Steam and Electricity
EE33
REEVEREEVEAGRI-ENERGYAGRI-ENERGY
POUNDMAKERPOUNDMAKER
Animal Feed CoproductsAnimal Feed CoproductsThe Forgotten ValueThe Forgotten Value
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
120%
140%
Ideal Ration General Ration Poor Ration Current MarketPrice
Per
cen
t C
orn
Val
ue
Animal Feed Coproducts ValueAnimal Feed Coproducts Value
Value ofValue ofCornCorn
Consequences of Industry PracticeConsequences of Industry Practicere: Animal Feed Coproductsre: Animal Feed Coproducts
• If agriculture system is viewed as a whole, If agriculture system is viewed as a whole, the livestock industry captures the the livestock industry captures the differential. Therefore, the value-added differential. Therefore, the value-added money remains in the ag community.money remains in the ag community.
• If export, the differential value-added If export, the differential value-added potential is lost to USA agriculture.potential is lost to USA agriculture.
Barley
ETHANOLETHANOL
Osage Bio EnergyOsage Bio EnergyDEHULLEDDEHULLED
BARLEYBARLEY(91-93%)(91-93%)
STEAMSTEAM
BarleyDehulling
EthanolPlant
BiomassBoiler
BARLEY BARLEY PROTEIN MEALPROTEIN MEAL
RENEWABLERENEWABLEFUEL PELLETSFUEL PELLETS
HULLSHULLS(7-9%)(7-9%)
SO…SO…IS THEREIS THERE
MORE THANMORE THANJUST CORN?JUST CORN?
SO…SO…IS THEREIS THERE
MORE THANMORE THANJUST CORN?JUST CORN?
SO…SO…IS THEREIS THERE
MORE THANMORE THANJUST CORN?JUST CORN?
YES!YES!
SO…SO…IS THEREIS THERE
MORE THANMORE THANJUST CORN?JUST CORN?
YES!YES!
GENERATION 1.5GENERATION 1.5GENERATION 1.5GENERATION 1.5
LETLET““MOTHER NATURE”MOTHER NATURE”
HELPHELP
LETLET““MOTHER NATURE”MOTHER NATURE”
HELPHELP
““Wheat”Wheat”““Energy Wheat”Energy Wheat”““Wild Wheat”Wild Wheat”
““High Protein”High Protein”
““High Starch”High Starch”
ENERGY WHEATENERGY WHEATAND BARLEYAND BARLEY
Biomass Fuel
TECHNOLOGYTECHNOLOGYASSESSMENTASSESSMENTTECHNOLOGYTECHNOLOGYASSESSMENTASSESSMENT
Is Corn the Bridge toIs Corn the Bridge toCellulose Ethanol?Cellulose Ethanol?
Is Corn the Bridge toIs Corn the Bridge toCellulose Ethanol?Cellulose Ethanol?
Commodity CyclesCommodity CyclesInvestment ManiaInvestment Mania
BankruptciesBankruptciesPremature AnnouncementsPremature Announcements
Funky ScienceFunky Science
Commodity CyclesCommodity CyclesInvestment ManiaInvestment Mania
BankruptciesBankruptciesPremature AnnouncementsPremature Announcements
Funky ScienceFunky Science
Is Corn the Bridge toIs Corn the Bridge toCellulose Ethanol?Cellulose Ethanol?
Is Corn the Bridge toIs Corn the Bridge toCellulose Ethanol?Cellulose Ethanol?
Is Corn the Bridge toIs Corn the Bridge toCellulose Ethanol?Cellulose Ethanol?Or Has the BridgeOr Has the Bridge
Been Blown?Been Blown?
Is Corn the Bridge toIs Corn the Bridge toCellulose Ethanol?Cellulose Ethanol?Or Has the BridgeOr Has the Bridge
Been Blown?Been Blown?
Do we needDo we needa new paradigm?a new paradigm?
Do we needDo we needa new paradigm?a new paradigm?
•Purpose-grown small grains
•Biomass-fueled boilers
•Livestock integration
Generation 1.5Generation 1.5
Is Corn ReallyIs Corn Reallythe Bridge tothe Bridge toSmall GrainsSmall GrainsFeedstocks?Feedstocks?
Is Corn ReallyIs Corn Reallythe Bridge tothe Bridge toSmall GrainsSmall GrainsFeedstocks?Feedstocks?
We mustWe mustalways remember…always remember…
We mustWe mustalways remember…always remember…
“ “ ALCOHOLISM ”ALCOHOLISM ” IS A DISEASE IS A DISEASE
“ “ VALUE - ADDED PROCESSING ”VALUE - ADDED PROCESSING ”
IS A BUSINESS IS A BUSINESS
“ “ ALCOHOLISM ”ALCOHOLISM ” IS A DISEASE IS A DISEASE
“ “ VALUE - ADDED PROCESSING ”VALUE - ADDED PROCESSING ”
IS A BUSINESS IS A BUSINESS